ASSOCIATION for ISRAEL STUDIES 17th Annual Meeting May 15-17, 2001 (Tuesday - Thursday) Hosted by the Center for Israel Studies, American University, Washingion D.C. CALLFOR SESSION ORGANU tee invites sears to pr Please el your sugzetions oe coment mene Tie theme falls between oo area plese sea your opal od Bais: Dent Pais and ‘is Rho: shy an Ress oe Mig ese Pals ea ets ‘i Lain: red Ged, Revel Sone: Ftsipn Pa. ad Vint. Sem, Cla td Nain, ron Shae Sx, eign al te tp Deane: Decraber 18, 2000 (a frida eet ui ce Conference Prgen Commi on Sh Dap Sigs, Uisrty of Cabs, Sango ‘al ruses Gat Baits, agin of Plies Science, Te Ass Uses ‘al: gripe aca ‘sina Khan, Depa Siig. Unveryof ani Las As Jost Misa, Beano ot Piz Svs Unie of Wagon, Sl inal mplaluwatingioness Cy Labo, Deputies af Leste Cs. TL A ey “cn tapes i uss Sins Bop of Say Ar ‘ed Vind Sercune, rent Soizy a atop ‘ait mois macchho¢ HOUSING: Dorin oom ss) wl Re ea Be Ae Use eampun Thetoom ais poe S72 loshin eve nt isi fn Georgio) agen. S148 Essays “A First Step ina Difficult and Sensitive Road:” Preliminary Observations on Qaadan v. Katzir' Alexandre (Sandy) Kedar Haifa University Iniodocton Th Sus rl allt ano sh et Agen in dee esis Kaa Tis so eed “communi sons ‘ee fxndein 182i Wai ra Saba Er) ein 985, the Gat 2 Palesinias ss ani anette ed te Kati edo d so. Use Soren Cour Qua ota econ Arb eld ot qe le a he teed of ramen is kind exiting a. A sonisicned ‘Semin cet, ivlvng te Se he ew sh Saton Fond NF, He ha Lied Admission (ILA). ie Jesh ‘enc, al Comey Coepatnes gusaiee hecho til pry af ee stlements In Ostaber 198, he Assis Tinot Gig in el (ACR wichepesented Oe Quads deitone the Supreme Cour. Chet se Aon Bua cm (red? The Coun de many stent cmie te pest nda uo ou slo, ial afer fie jars fed {eps afer toon moyen oer athe Qala Cit Sune Bark ia ued atthe gens ote acorn selene th bas oF owe non ws (har 0)” Noting this snl ler dss peti pst ‘ashe Imes nse So conder sera he asf Vega peg an nn nme for "conceing een Age an he emis paee feet We Rate comm seen 0) Ta ayo ‘innate vedere, le pure eg the eens sence f ho eases being, athe words ofthe Cou" fic an see od ‘ats ie gcc of hs rd and whee wont? ook at sinoreld nd ‘on bana Rept orem en The ine he tia temp tases te impoo of the ison yon Woe Sackett ge How will he ews, Zia Deno ica ee How ni Hence set ole apy? Te sein, the normative perigee ta ask er bison aie ace iat ‘st Th tr a ater understand th “ine” Ing of onion, ha iio one pnton dso ‘dle fe Cau have dus os cuent pesictions on Qaafoe inpc Neveeleswillastes shor ths gustan econo, Astodte romaine nis te ins sigan of Queda? soni anesthe Cars pot Is {Neston fom acoleciveandteting” into moe talib” uriaence Nevereles, ncaa ‘rnin bate i ep. a he Tews” toward he *Deroriigig" poe within te “ewih Deroraie Staple Mesos Bosnia eas ein preset ‘hens tod nner pe paces wheat Ing" ist spin find somite rs Ta a sic reo embsis const ossand sige eran ‘lnk rie athe the eb, Promies on he Roe: Interne wih cries shthenettautasiegnngs ISRAEL STUDVES BURLETIN = Fall S000 ISRAEL STUDIES BULLETIN = Fall 2000eS EEE to promote te Zit projec iy As oven Witch ha argued, sly Yo hr wl st, ‘sel sted econpreisnie land an selene pee TS fy reed on ew power eit raened se ons emtenip ita Jewetvae ans Is paso ahah her won spss 1 Nsonizaon opted ‘Aubland 2) Sct alloation of foes sd 2s iin fhetewsh yoplaton This dscns inporunesnse Quan heed nthe ator comporsn. Artie eof te ae Wa of aepenfesce. bn ofl owned bythe State and Jeri in unlsa tgniztins ‘round oso 125% ofthe sae eon Tofu he 2 ‘eit projet of ding te and. a shed ton teathot indie apa 2nds)stenaiealy exposing ei in is contol By the 9K apeouraty 9 of eh Teor came tts nei conta ofp ad evist Fntuone aged together it ee Lands (lar ‘ll Tela exonalraion ok gic cosmo chan ‘sk 1 National of Paesinan an thgh he mia sate adel veri goers fae The pon) ‘tthe Palestina lugs, wa aly wasted pbuh ‘ees fade, Plessis ater esr = ‘Rleiteens Tost appeonmsiely $0 of heady haps. ‘ved! 2) Fama egisttionoall Bish Mena’ he ‘Si of oa une Nuh fe ui of dans eset fo Ske-onneip rng is ees ad ihr ban exp ter btinied gall blogedot Ste, Howe icon Taed was eter ro Ava and Bedi roi a © re at change nan possesion rey ts com ering “Meat (deat land) nd adverse possesion Ths Patestnanfand eve asa major succes malig eh ‘and gime “The creion ote hl epine ote Belo aon of pon (teen) orahol Ue inne ‘loping to iat Land The poses of is obi gH bln unfeed t) neaaese seo Sree sgetements™ Wel ws sappy ‘Sknbtam ade bine fered Shae om tscoer end copes axon sem" Ader ‘Presto a pneu tgio lini sine ‘Chg emer piled ellen of ro (yaec estan) musing seu fe, (nthe bss of tists developed ering sae iptore new semen gp, Be Mien Leck). Arar tnvag veo thes oft Mises he eto Tudeh Gale, This ein was peed ce ‘Sans erro hes Sas he ighroposion of ‘Rebveciding nie ressod is ecu e Nomen bs, “ee Magi wer enable in saeie eats in ede to om vit pecan eel ete Aas ‘er ol ll Such clement lee gh gay “ua ‘oie nso ps loa Jon mae he {Cake Te bltpthen esprit on eh pis ciiseaw gpctuteetr stnekenar Comma Se nen Rais eed in soe wa ae eel indy Art an dig 17 rc Asputoft proces fests communi eee oven spied ye ego exe ADS E88 tesive bli fede by cog ld acon ‘Seat whl sete! ad assigned ough & Sueno are Be pyle Acco oisarasge ‘ete pare sn end alan conrac: AVILA tc pb unoer aan The esish Agesy and C) ‘eden element acl gale ong Aho Icrdert seul a suszed pie ad som tees feof hare edi plo Flan in sch» ee tet, afenon ra bess asa meer of cooperative that incor al eds fh cent. The seperate (oF teens arson of ie en Agee) athe oe f= Ievon od pil eta poser cer scence Ts celepton (sae pve hema cn of wth et ede Abs fom acest in sever sminesay to pseve be il aca hres ote element Tiss bon he 9) tomate sr he Godard, With Qn ds et sucht be sue at inno sh ws i eedind pen, cameeay ine feed wie aloo pr Te ou ed hat ver ese, ‘seer sean. od ttn bene oer Uerahtuldhistoein te Kesreoamnty seer a "3 Mb ltt tom Gata, poner te Sina Tenish natn! xan sc thee Agee} an te INF ‘Shot es 009i te peal eae” Aid interpretation ofthe ensh ins Sate tne Lan isis side cei ian Pale iano denier wel af Libero and Zoe olgis. ‘Wile te Supene Cour enna othe formation of he ta dep, when ote and sts usally Cece to avoid idee guage” Tic ean be expand in {felting son he Greed oe thn ‘Sisal profesional ale abchstengened einen hat it inpemene e a” “TeQondo pin bred si ao amenbisieCen ses op! ees? While Coun depres nn rasa ose nly ea Zils sen is {ctetey en pb preptin a Lil wr peer he Count soi tect Lal and Zot ion. ‘ebing ntaial stig Zien evs Agen, co teapot sd pt by sing ry pores tee ecs inte expmert agen anes tp nase ais wlastepne wher ees fea s ‘pune (Pr 0, Buskeciemte cht ee calling ‘hoi nth ese o pve de “bated ‘Semen (seupomisn fr Ara 26d npn Aly, ‘etude od erg” ‘Yet, swithtandng the penne of sts isin pant gigi emergence ofa dew soe, which 0 hss se version of Zim sdaeng toads ib a Transat, Avorn 6 Qo wih Ze ie Se ne to wo mje: Alp aigtaon of Seve to el henna nus he es. ‘Theres ofthe Fesish Poole tts homer stems Irth vals offal aa Jenshand aDemowaie ‘Sit From thse sn sve! encasions ate diac. ha Hees wl bes pop language snd oa leigh wan i eons a et ia conponee offset’) din. Bat fom the ‘bef fae aa esha Dense Sate does ote ta thatthe ssl scout between [sce Jews and 0a Jows tae have egal in ‘ight and dos Pa 31, se so pu 19,3836, aly ‘ns ep and sranbiganas pogoecenet ate Fo to ube sal can ne site dssninton a om devslveseqaliy soa overlie pipe atts inst cnc evn he Sates ew shes. Ths pououceneats {idotely mie rnvation ste pos seal oa aut ch Cau eonstce espe on {eae ih extn o ernie ls rd races roma fnglenit eppopston of rd.” Furbetoor wb tht Isn0 Guesion that te Ire Supreme Co shige cis ji regen any res the Cer diet fl is jutpudence ithe sz foc aero Dou” Foca bi Coo pe ‘ee ie juepdence minty ss ls he ews“ Teed pub sms Parisi nth eve ese ‘vost toe see ting Zn, mh scar a and fctement the Cour eva the al el ipleomenton fs {iui jrigodnce on Jews Race, he Cat Shoe eer! tp ina donee wae Ta, alae 8 eat igo th Cou ily owe frie deci agile more tan eda, cua Be Tasiono edie bse by elas ring ardor the tun fl sles ‘Qa pe fis pater. Exec afer he el) conn Revlon 1992. he Coa began dep she doce uly” However td vt apply nthe some foe to Pasian Qandah Court ace an ages ema Unitary rated pston of ACR, ha toce- ‘i eer ort te porto an pay the Rey ps of np [reciente renin i joigrerceto eno re fA land hs” Aer atemsing terete dvs for “Sst esa he Cou sed to bl po sei ‘sly jnspcenve sd exten to Palestine ae. The Cnc mane at ahi ty ‘he cision on ewe Euiyafunhewal va ofthe Stoffel ach Ips eesy in tan aoe a the Se of "el seers mi emplyees = ms act eqaly be ‘ween sift nd nthe te TheSbe' “toatl eed ali actions Kappes fecal tote alton of She od et 31.2), In ening is cay span, thal Coo, 8 cours een a oped viene eon wi he Isptinaey fp precedes, To 6th Cau rid on poe ‘ete aking gulf women of banter ie ‘ston wih bate, a rues (Par 21.20) The maze ‘eine te hve recedes the sense eof at "eatin o Arty aon that th Co's egy rep ‘nes fer Jen ony. Ts a San me ee rer aso” he Cours pogesiveunsraare seems Irene wth Discrnintory mechs The fur uation f Ganda sits wanking and ee ano ern pees sin te pt ise ap ratte dscamint Bre I eine, Sine Hae sae Chee gh istry sat Soene Cour in es ‘see and sats heh Conese bese Coot ‘tester acne rd pane charcerztion Th Coane iene cesetn of tis nope Lez sue gnea High Coup, play asec bin ceasg and lpia sets hd epics” “pias ei coast wothe es and sys an ara ‘ase an esis tt rt eno tt Go a TSRAEL STUDIES BULLETIN - Fall 2000 ISRAEL STUDIES BULLETIN = Fall 2009LE ES pe overs fate cites Fomine: Tngtrlinsshgtinseion Roel pada nseree. nicied witha hen ef cl demise tingage ad cd cece he len emog wie tug of vay in os. ductor non ‘ner sroupean itu nels naedy De cecion Sitcningly“owea ong wc ch or fetal and etc pop. Te kl pst fe eps insranunabe psec dpe tes enoe "Tus fo fecunely limig an posting tad tah, Cour es does lie tet poses {he aiinsuatvesvotcs with spl pow sop ts tieing ser sae opin Sn sd. Fortermore tr chnoelogof the asic es et poceucesene eo el presumption wks & pose tollcp mos of cscs ou pble ss ie he {epinisan ef lnd apse tafe on casing Bovton Theos iow spe feet tena watct siting dmg sn. Tay son te ange ‘Seite pl les whe ean ean oe fg Te conned aplcnto hse oes sence he Tindanenl qucsons mh fondatn a tse mato, Suns tot senna nrc of Gs an ‘Slime as wil ge eos eontin of Condon Toe tenn fresno one (hugh ala exe nek. tise nish are welt pit tie ma {Ehuboe the Cou eed wi ese dni dvs ‘he wse ct pose aes bean tae duane gon bare tp “The ach ea sem He reese, con slr estas nperae Anolis rca [ena iw ecoed oped aalcomine encom toy ceplinchrer? mck ager tenet AD temesens torre rend Quan epee ‘rena ous si pce ada tea Tey aqurdsrworeay bene wrod theca Pa 8), he! Tose Rl nae espe Sep Tn td ie aes aie ene fore hilefora qe one ents fe om lycopeaie the peo os tory He ace te See mash toque woul eben he rons a ltd htretomera (at Db “Te Supteme Cot as oo tne dered 0 xine trsivedstton pening tthe ch lad epee” Duting the rtoalietin of Ara ad it consmed mnstatve freon ays fal eee aor wh ape powers ox opt Arb an witout ierence = Te Qaan Barhinereet bth cron and dee ot Seco for rininte os allacton of Paberms, te Sse uo iene fen hi ty by ig ahd odyebenif asthe eu gene (Par 38.38) Inte st te ac upc Cot fen ngs be Bu 9 6f pati ys te Arc ens od en” ‘A sobsalcontbaion of Ganda t seared spn. fet anemps wn the fg ie Te eve psc fe Surges ate esa of he ese) Cet Jase Banke Thestortave ngrgo Brin Ns pein pat eh aed e eto rote ar of own a sy feel mt is fn Kater mee ecu ae Ab a "tems, Bark rar eles qscton thal Soe ‘severely atthe Quatre sale ge dink, ait ll State al alrted re Jwish ageey fed ‘nabs, Whilets nanan cecton ase epttones. isimateously puta song spi ox sino) ant aeons, Fashmo, Cou ile ta any eal etme ch bass ign or sats spe! nd pi ie ‘hina, eens at rm not ie To rove 8 Gilet atiudeom ee ston tos, and ene SS the Sta prove at tha iene jute (ar 20)" ‘Pas om ey wih Qa, spe oneal rks do anecoopeive sa hare ADS td Jens cou Ie ogee Chi hse Baal le theron Be ‘pendent oe hate wale fee beeen te {wo ssasof Kane Te Ste en at te dpe sr feed bac rasacopenve Ot wspnden, elas Be Katie Consany Cope ad he Jesh Ager ain the Comm Cooersne ed sce i erste put a be "uf kd dss pocne lac eps erie ex ‘pc and sane Ar woot te slo pata urate thar, Beets meee Hee fede ao fel eves Ben reed ie ‘te duting the ees inthe Cry Cope thea ae vo Blot Fm hrm ti ee ‘i Ras jes te vison i eng paps” P26, $i, Heed at fo. he eCopt open a Sesh sl tre oven pat of eet be ela cept a eBsty Mc seve» ‘ha mse a dati trie’ 3). ‘TeCoutalo ase an stent inode beeps ual dt ergot ates sth Cour aad ‘spun mon rain pe Bown Borda Barn tuiahoon ictal pound Danang be el ini, Bask pained tatty Sh l als nd ulisey ndonConpeite ements Thee e nn poly ee dy frat. Pa 30) Stumbling Blocks on the Rot Wile Quodor dob coos emensoas hye Inake Course Cau ed ever suring bls, ‘tih itor oem te i's po a oud [Kat aioe constiedectone Tae mor bce te (Couns rec tole ath ps Ser das cate, nde intense escpe mechan, olaing the Cve:Aorvard ooking” and Iisa ‘ection ‘Quadon rams ne Te pat oe ei scan tooched an nen, Monash sy fhe Qa Indromthi alien ad needaasPaesiin izes lie, Iiwonhuietcosist eCourse ne pst ‘tera cong aegis oer sti sats. ‘Cr couns neers sak fh a ei past id ‘in Ths te Anan Super: Cat, wih te as de ese reopens ef aboriginal ‘sae the leg an pil denne by ney dowe ae Matos Queond 992 an ik: Quran (998) Be ‘or. InBate Cou ced ees dan otra ais ‘ichozeore Autiaas nem inn, andi riz Agia le "Te rata 2 we nel ein int ised te ian scnos pent a det om hse pt noses expsne he Coun Smits eanbecaredn igh cout of er ster sects sch ss New Zealand 3 CCatnda Netw te iia feel dees” ‘rears he ho fret s“Culjc event Atl ‘Selon’ erases la Jigar ep “hsgacl ends snenguig apo elas) shone cspanexrsaing stl aig cutee eh {dcinsins es hope poses ol cng com rrevand qutbeuuein ase eds, ‘Tstoes ining foe Gad Cs se Bara cea ‘he eons orn" ews clones eyo fhe Ste offre or sete toy ofl Te peta ‘err lokng” (Pa 7 ne he ol sry pe tee ‘sth Zt mana. Kae al et pty od ‘resol one yale Bu he naan ie of the vc land eae to ony utah bt alo ut. Farts te ou dco old busted ing ledion sibel Thats anos reading of ve ese ‘Mectdemstexisd eit Onn Inde a 9 {yorthepagasisiasreng tesco vt Qs sesso aval Kaithi” atte oes ania hand wt te Kr nid rum of he ion Dut same ext he amin ofthe Fein the Quai” ase seated fom th ean ie bp and acts alsin iets Thy sll ‘tata, ih desied olen place nie i feet guia ean velo ethene thoes "hotest ese to onsos cl ed wir urges tit ing pce in eal xin lela ysl secure at ban pal weakening nS i ‘Tas gas! ah ans wh reas othe ageless sont with eam glans he il teat con eer deers rai a pu” ‘This gent overeat ise ine I a flee well rm the ey 1990's the El id ep is ‘enuntrsin prsoun (tlc) patitn” Ti ‘ay eo ant meron over mow vale iit slo ese seat of ov soy, Smataneil tismpucet tose eoneuet consol sed esl earet a ton pine ines years soy a exp finn a ceasing een of open ps, Wes Fst od ‘asasonalsed aig he Sue ove pit ces nal anes of poner ene. Tf oe onc ‘Secs td estonia, propery pi bs te ‘usianetdse tae Base Lar an renin Spee Cot settaon Ths, Qandon ead rere tng ts ees fore sem, eragly Her aida ety Sse Yrs ew em, when oes nt ch vgn at ial, rorpon the cols eso ells ld be pred move tat epi o sfeusis [roen Beline ent power savers” Te (uate cuz ho undeandwcomrting ne seme 0 {stlzaonan van wile anit pve ste ‘us of re ce al heeping ose Psi ie ‘Sel poses postin Awol rame fi Pein lan be tet bey an ay ess hy llaeue a ‘Kui ad Most nd evil eld oc ty Po uri Max Ba Pesan wl rein Psere in ie owes pition nal space asset" Moin ining cape ea devices ‘Wie te Cour amanda some te sees shat penis sate dination Pans inte ton > Tins ono wth final ts e paste Cae ane wt se ional eis Ft Ur cyrstewtcfony aeons ong $issctecets Pr 87) Secon Court vetl fared ‘lnc, afer ony Se nd ingens ing ISRAEL STUDIES BULLETIN = Fal 2000 ISRAEL STUDIFS BULLETIN ~ Fal 2000)