Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Kai Wang - Hidden Symmetries and Their Implications
Kai Wang - Hidden Symmetries and Their Implications
Kai Wang
arXiv:hep-ph/0407234
Any additional (Hidden) Symmetry? Counting Degrees of Freedom in the avor independent Non-SUSY SM
Yukawa
= Quc H + Qdc H + ec H
Trace Anomaly (Gravitational) Cubic Anomaly Mixed Anomalies Between Abelian Symmetries
LBNL 4D Seminar, UC Berkeley, Oct 6th , 2004
U (1)Y is uniquely determined (except for its overall Normalization). A[SU (3)C ]2 U (1)Y A[SU (2)L ]2 U (1)Y TrU(1)Y Yukawa Ng = (2q + u + d) = 0 2 Ng = (3q + ) = 0 2 = Ng (6q + 3u + 3d + 2 + e) = 0 : q + u + h = 0, q + d h = 0, + e h = 0
No extra Unbroken U (1) Gauge Symmetry Hypercharge normalization from new physics like Grand Unication
Theories (GUTs)
LBNL 4D Seminar, UC Berkeley, Oct 6th , 2004
Remarks
uc 1/3
0
dc 1/3
0
ec
0
c
0
H
0 0
Early attempts to gauge Baryon number U (1)B requires fourth generation Carone &
Murayama, 2002
A self-consistent ultimate theory which contains gravity must be a true gauge theory (at MGravity ) Spontaneously symmetry breaking wont induce gauge anomalies
Where do global symmetries arise from a full gauge theory? How can global symmetries survive down to low energy? Arising as accidental symmetries: Results from gauge symmetry and
particle content
Baryon number and Lepton number: violation from New Physics SM: low energy effective theory. New physics corrections come as Non-renormalizable couplings suppressed by cutoff scales. Quantum Gravity Induced Violations
2 L HH/MPl + QQQ/MPl + ...
Lepton number violation (LNV) L = 2 Neutrinos have masses m 105 eV Baryon number violation (BNV) B = 1, L = 1 Proton decay p 1045 yrs
LBNL 4D Seminar, UC Berkeley, Oct 6th , 2004
m 1010 GeV
()0
p e+ 0 (Gauge mediated): P > 5 1033 yrs p K + (Higgsino exchange): P > 1.6 1033 yrs
Grand Unication proton decay: (For example p e+ 0 )
MPl O(1019 GeV) and L B MGUT O(1016 GeV) and L B MPQ O(1011 GeV) (Strong CP & invisible QCD axion) PQ MSUSY O(103 GeV)
Physics Scale in SM
t Hooft Electroweak Instanton Processes t Hooft, 1976 Sphaleron Processes: High Temperature Dreiner & Ross, 1993
Existence of Three Generation : B
3
= 3 mod 3
(uL dL dL L )i
i=1
Proton life time is way beyond the experiment reach Cosmology Implication
LBNL 4D Seminar, UC Berkeley, Oct 6th , 2004
Field regularization in lattice gauge theories Weger; Bakker, et al Relics of high dimensional gauge symmetries in string theory
Green, Schwarz & Witten, 1987
Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking and Its Discrete Subgroups Non-chiral Higgs Example scalar elds with charge under a U (1) gauge symmetry:
: 1, Higgs
ZN left unbroken; No gauge particle associated (Decoupled) Q eiq(x) Q, uc eiu(x) uc , H eiN (x) H,
at U (1) level, q
: 3 of SU (3)
Outline
Baryon Parity Non-SUSY avor-independent SM with seesaw mechanism at Renormalizable level has a discrete Z6 gauge symmetry.
Babu, Gogoladze, KW, 2003
Q uc Z6 Z3 Z2
Mixed Anomalies
dc
1 1 1
2 2 2
ec
5 2 1
c
3 3 1
H
1 1 1
6 3 2
5 2 1
A3 A2
Anomaly free due to Ng
= 3Ng = Ng
: Z3 is broken to nothing when electroweak gauge symmetry is broken. : Domain Wall near MEW << MInation
SM is inconsistent with cosmology? The answer is No!
He Z9 of Baryon Number
i 2 (1) i 2 (3) 3 N
Z3 U (1)2Y B+3L No Single Proton decay, No H H Oscillation In the Non-SUSY case, d = 15 Effective Operators
5 4 2 3 2 Q4 dc ec , Q5 uc dc , Q5 dc , Q6 uc dc ec , Q7 dc , Q8 dc ec ppp e+ + + + + ; pnn e+ + 0 ; ppn e+ + + nnn + 0 3 1033 yrs
Discrete Gauge Symmetries Gauge Symmetries in the bulk but broken on Distant Branes Arkani-Hamed &
Dimopolous, 2001
uc
4
dc
4
ec
3
H
0
S
1
can modify the big-bang nucleosynthesis processes but not signicant as Majoron will decouple before the electro-weak phase transition.
1023 mS : 10 sec
Gauging U (1)BL without c via Green-Schwarz Mechanism (Anomalous 5 U (1)A ) by adding 5 + of SU (5)
LBNL 4D Seminar, UC Berkeley, Oct 6th , 2004
+ Li + Lj 2Lk
di c = (1, 1, 1), i c = (3, 3, 3) , H = 1 Z6
Higgs elds has the charge of 6 under U (1) and breaks U (1) Allows all Quark Mixing but Lepton mixing( from neutrino sector)
LL=2
Remarks
Automatic anomaly free: No extra particles imposed (except for c ) Requires three generations (or six, nine, ...) Gauged B 3L U (1) symmetry (Ma 1998)
Solving Proton decay problem in Large extra dimension models Baryogenesis (new selection rule in Leptogenesis Baryogenesis?)
3 U (1) Realization as IR + Li + Lj 2Lk may imply SU (3)H
symmetry
Gauged R-parity The -term D-term Splitting Stabilizing the Axion solutions
W& = ec + Qdc + Hu + uc dc dc R Small Neutrino Mass from loop Effects(L) B Proton Decay ( ) How to distinguish from Hd in non-SO(10)(see also term)
Conventional Z2 R-parity: Gauge Origin? LSP as dark matter candidate (SUSY non-SUSY)
uc
1
dc
1
ec
1
c
1
Hu
1
Hd
1
3 Z2 subgroup of IR
Field U(1)BL
Q 1
uc 5
dc 5
ec 1 3
c 1 3
Hu 0 0
Hd 0 0
Z6
WMSSM Hu Hd Lsoft BHu Hd + h.c. = 0 : massless charged fermion (Higgsino) = MPl : Higgs Decoupled 102 GeV( MSUSY ) Hu + Hd Can NOT be vectorial
A3
3 = 3 + (2(q ) + (u ) + (d )) 2 3 = 3 (hu + hd ) 2 q + u + hu = 2, q + d + hd = 2
Induce mixed QCD anomaly A[SU (3)C ]2 G The symmetry that ensures the absence of bare -term in the superpotential carries mixed QCD anomaly and is broken explicityly by anomaly thus a Goldstone.
LBNL 4D Seminar, UC Berkeley, Oct 6th , 2004
U (1) : Extra Z , extra quark like particle (exotic) Cvetic & Langacker, 1994
MPQ (fa ) 1011 GeV Kim & Nilles, 1984; Babu, Gogoladze, KW 2003
MEW
2 MPQ MPl
Anomalous U (1)A Symmetry and Green-Schwarz Mechanism Cancellation of anomalies by the modied transformation law of p-form potential in Chern-Simons terms
Lkinetic = (x)
ki Fi2 + i(x)
i i
ki Fi Fi
(x): string dilaton eld; (x): axionic partner ki : KacMoody levels where i: SU (3)C , SU (2)L or U (1)Y
VA VA + (x) : (x) (x) (x)GS
A2 A1 AGravity A3 = = = U (1) version : = GS k3 k2 k1 24 A3 + mN/2 A2 + m N/2 Discrete version : = k3 k2 An : mixed anomalies of [SU (n)]2 U (1)A Kac-Moody level ki Z + for non-Abelian Group k1 positive rational number
c b a [Tm , Tn ] = if abc Tm+n + dab k j mnj
m, N Z +
d4 Hu Hd Z /MPl FZ /MPl
R-symmetry: gaugino being charged to distinguish the superpotential from Kalher potential.
Z4
Assignment
q
1
u
1
d
1
l
1
e
1
n
1
h
0
h
0
(A2 , A3 )
(3, 1)
WDFSZ = Hu Hd S 2 /MPl
Explanation of and B Axion: the Strong CP problem and Dark matter candidate
Questions needed to be addressed
How to naturally generate MPQ : Dynamical or Higgs A Complete Model with the appropriate symmetry Phenomenology Implication
LBNL 4D Seminar, UC Berkeley, Oct 6th , 2004
WDFSZ
|S S|2 (S S)2 2 2 2 2 2 2) V = (2 C + h.c) + mS |S| + mS |S| + 42 2 (|S| + |S| MPl MPl C C 2 12mS 2 2 MPl :fa = |S| = |S| MPl MSUSY 1011 GeV fa = 122
6 5 3 4 2 3 2 2
4 3 3
Uij
Lij
= 5 3 4 = 3 3
2 Hu , Dij = 3 1 2 p D 1 Hd , ij = 1
p 2 2 Hd , 1 1 a 1 1 1 Hu , 1 1
Yukawa Couplings
10 10Hu
+ 10 5Hd + 5 1Hu
LBNL 4D Seminar, UC Berkeley, Oct 6th , 2004
Z14
Qi
0,2,6 4,6,10 6,8,12
uc i
1,3,7 13,1,5 5,7,11
dc i
3,5,5 11,13,13 1,3,3
Li
4,6,6 6,8,8 0,2,2
ec i
13,1,5 9,11,1 7,9,13
c i
Hu
1 13 9
Hd
13 1 5
7 7 7
S
2 2 2
A2
6 13 13
A3
13 13 6
SU (5) compatibility and -term, Doublet-triplet splitting D-term Splitting and SUSY Flavor
LBNL 4D Seminar, UC Berkeley, Oct 6th , 2004
LQCD
2 gs G G = K 2 64
: = + arg(detMU detMD )
CP can be violated in QCD. However, No Evidence.
LBNL 4D Seminar, UC Berkeley, Oct 6th , 2004
Experimental Constraints
+ Br( + )th 1.8 102 2 Br( + )exp < 1.5 103 : < 103
i Neutron Electric Dipole Moment(EDM) 2 dn n 5 nF
mu = 0;
Peccei-Quinn Symmetry and the Axions Solution A Global U (1) with QCD anomaly Dynamical eld a-axion:
a/fa
i(x)
S = |S|e
fa ia(x)/fa e 2
a 1 L = Ga Ga fa 32 2
so the QCD Lagrangian depends on the combination
+ a(x)/fa
= 2 /fa QCD
2. DineFischlerSrednickiZhitnitskii (DFSZ): Invisible and Harmless 3. KimShifmanVainshteinZakharov (KSVZ): Invisible and Harmless
Astrophysical Constraints
fa < 1010 GeV leads to rapid cooling of stars and supernovae fa > 1012 GeV may exceed the limit of energy density of the universe : Axion mass ma 2 /fa 104 eV QCD
LBNL 4D Seminar, UC Berkeley, Oct 6th , 2004
Problem with Axion Solution PQ : Global symmetry, Gravity Induced Violation Non-renormalizable coupling
Sn MPl n4
Inducing
n fa n4 4 MPl QCD
where V VEVs.
U (1)A = P Q + B P Q carries QCD anomaly and B has SU (2) anomaly. A3 3 [SU (3)] U (1)A = 2
2
LBNL 4D Seminar, UC Berkeley, Oct 6th , 2004
A2
GSM
A2 A3 = : = k2 /(3k3 ) k3 k3 1 k2 B U (1)A = P Q 3 k3
uc 1
0 2 2 2
dc 1 1
4 4 4
L
0 0 4 4 4
ec
0
c
0 0 0 0 0
Hu
0 1
Hd
0 0
S
0
1
2 2 2
1/2
5 5 5
4
7 8
6
5 6
L = S + h.c.
: SU (3)C Triplet
= =
n=2 For b
b k3 /k2 = (1, 2, 3, 1/2, 1/3, 2/3, 3/2): (Z9 , Z21 , Z33 , Z6 , Z3 , Z15 , Z30 )
Conclusions
The Standard Model, by its construction, has a independent discrete gauge symmetry in addition to SU (3)C SU (2)L U (1)Y
Approximate Baryon number and Suppressing Proton decay
3 U (1) embedding implicates avor IR + Li + Lj 2Lk
Z4 from anomalous U (1)A as one -term solution DFSZ axion solution to the -term Discrete avor gauge symmetries Stabilizing the invisible axion solutions: DFSZ & KSVZ
LBNL 4D Seminar, UC Berkeley, Oct 6th , 2004