Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(. . )
(. . )
ISBN : 974-86986-4-5
(= )
(=- -)
-
-
-
.....
......................................................................................................
..........................
......................................................................................
...........................................
) ..................................................................
) - ...........................................................................
...............................................................................
......................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................
: ...............
...................................................................................
.....................................................................
.............................................................
............................................................................................
..............................................................................................
............................................
: ..................
: .....................................
: ............................
: ........................................
...................................
- ...................
- ..............................................
.....................................................................................................
......
.........................................................................................
.................................................
..................................................
...........................................
............................................................
.....
.........................................................................
....................................................................
......................................................
............................................
...............................................
..............
..............................
..........................
..................................................
..........................................................
............................
.............................
................................
) ...................................................
) - ............................................................
......................................................................
: PALI TEXT SOCIETY ?
....................................
......................................
...............................
PALI TEXT SOCIETY
......................
: - .......
.................................................
.......................
...........................................
...............................................
..................................
....................................................................
..................................................................
.............................................
.......................
................................................................
........................
.................................................
..............................
............................................
..........................................................
.........................................................
...................................................
............................
...................................................
...................................
....................................................................
............................................
..............................................................
...............................................
............................
.............................................
..................
................................................
..............................................................
........................................................................
.......................................................
......................................................
...........................................................................
...................................................................
.....................
...................................................
........................................
......................................................................
........................
..............................................................
..................................................
.....................................
................................................
..................................
.................................................................................
................................................
..............
................................................................
...................................
............................................................
................................................................
.................................................
...............................................
..............................................................
............................
...........................
.........................................................................
....................................................
.....................................................................
...................................................
........................................................................
.............................................................
.............................................................
...................................................
........................................................
.........................................................
..................................................
....................................................................
.......................................
....................................................
.........................................................................
...............................................
.....................................
............................................................
......................................................................
...............................................
...........................................
..........................
........................................................................
...............................................................
.........................................
- -
................................................
......................................................................
: ......................................
. ...................................................................
. / ..........................................
....................................
.................................................................................
.......................................................................................
...........................................................................
...................................................................................
- ..............
..............................................................................
.........................................................
....................................................................
..............................................................................
..........................................................................
.....................................................................
(. . )
(. . )
. . .
( )
(. . )
. . .
(. . )
( )
.
.
.
(. . )
,
(..//)
(. . )
(. . )
Professor Soothill
. . .
(
) .
()
; . . .
Professor Mizuno
William Edward Soothill and Levis Hodous, A Dictionary of Chinese Buddhist Terms
(London: Kegan Paul, Trench, Trubner & Co., Ltd., 1934), p.83.
(. . )
T. O. Ling Dictionary
Christmas Humphreys
Kogen
Dr. Mizuno
.
()
. . .
Dr. Mizuno
Mizuno, p. 129.
(. . )
. . .
()
()
()
; ()
()
()
Ibid., p.32.
..
( )
(. . )
..
..
The Stra of
Forty-two Sections
..
..
.. ..
..
..
-
(King Munjong, .. -)
.. ..
(. . )
( .. )
( .. )
()
( )
..
(. . )
..
..
..
!
!
(. . )
..
(. . )
(. . )
. ()
. ()
. ( )
. ()
(.. //; .. //)
( .
(.
/)
--
(. . )
//)
( ..//; ../; . /)
.
. ()
. ( )
.
( )
(.. /)
(../)
(
) (
)
...
()
(. /)
( )
(
)
(. . )
. ()
. ()
. ()
. ()
. ()
. ()
. ()
. ()
(
)
. ()
. ()
. ()
. ( )
. ()
. ()
. ()
. ()
(.//)
. ()
. ()
. ()
. ()
. ()
. ()
. ()
(
(.. //)
)
(. . )
..
()
()
()
..
..
,
()
(
)
(=)
= + +
..
..
( )
( )
(=)
( )
( = + )
( )
(. . )
..
( Peshawar
Patna , ..)
..
()
(
)
(
.. ;
)
Professor Mizuno
(. . )
(
)
. (
)
.
. . .
( )
.
)
)
)
..
(. . )
(. . )
:
)
)
:
:
Pali Text Society ?
:
-
)
.
(
)
. . .
(
)
(. . )
?
?
?
,
?
.
= ( )
.
= ( )
(
)
(
)
(
)
(. . )
()
()
(
)
-
..?..
/
/ (= + = )
(. . )
) -
( ..
.. ) (
)
(
)
- )
(sense experience)
(idea)
empiricist ()
(myth of the cave)
Politeia ( The Republic)
( sun
)
(. . )
empiricist
myth of the cave Politeia
Politeia
(sense experience)
(idea)
.
sense
experience idea (
The Republic)
.
(
)
.
(
.
(
)
.
( The Republic
)
Politeia
(. . )
.
.
(
)
.
.
()
(Pali Text Society)
. Pali Text Society
Pali Text Society
?
( ) . . .
. . .
(Pali Text Society)
(. . )
. . Professor
T.W. Rhys Davids
(
)
.
.
-
Pali Text Society
(. . )
Pali Text Society
( )
-- Pali Text
Society
Pali Text Society
Pali Text Society
( )
()
Pali Text Society
Pali Text Society
Pali Text Society
(. . )
(Jtaka)
Pali Text Society
Pali Text Society
Pali Text
Society
.
Pali Text
Society
(. . )
Pali Text Society
( )
(.. )
Pali Text Society
Pali-English Dictionary .. (.. ;
.. )
(. . )
Pali Text Society
Lord Chalmers
Miss I. B. Horner
Nyanatiloka
Nyanaponika
amoli
Pali Text Society
(. . )
amoli
Mrs. Rhys Davids
.. . . . Miss I. B. Horner
.. - . . . Christmas
Humphreys . . .
( )
(. . )
(. . )
Max Muller
Mrs. C.A.F. Rhys
Davids Miss I. B. Horner
Miss I. B. Horner
Coomaraswamy (
) The Living Thought of Gotama the Buddha
Self (/)
I. B. Horner Coomaraswamy /
I. B. Horner Coomaraswamy
. . .
The Self is lord of the self . . .
Self S self s
(..//)
/
//
/
Self
(. . )
. . .
Encyclopaedia
Britannica
(
)
The approaches to the divine or sacred are various rather
than uniform . . . , it moves toward the ultimate goal: the
annihilation of the
self, . . . , Nirva (the state of bliss) in
Buddhism, . . .
.. )
. . .
, . . . ,
() , . . . ,"
(. . )
I. B. Horner
Walpola Rahula, What the Buddha Taught (New York: Grove Press, 1974),
p.130.
Professer Richard Gombrich
Nyanatiloka ()
Buddhist Dictionary
Nibbna
. . . the Buddha is known as the Anatta-vdi . . . the
truth of Anatt (q.v.), the egolessness and insubstantiality of
all forms of existence. Without such an understanding, one
will necessarily misconceive Nibbnaaccording to ones
either materialistic or metaphysical leaningseither as
annihilation of an ego, or as an eteral state of existence
into
which an Ego or Self enters or with which it merges.
...
()
Anatt
(. . )
( )
( ;
)
Ibid., p.13.
Richard Gombrich
Mrs. Rhys Davids
Richard Gombrich
Richard Gombrich
(. . )
Richard Gombrich
Theravada Buddhism
Many scholars of Buddhism, both Western and Hindu, have
tried to prove that the Buddha himself did not preach the doctrine
of no-soul as it has been understood in the Theravadin tradition . .
. This amounts to a claim that this great religious
teacher has been
completely misunderstood by his followers . . .
. . .
Richard Gombrich
Gombrich
Endless misunderstanding has been caused by
Western writers, who have assumed that Nibbana is the
blowing out of the personal soul . . . there is no soul or self as
a separate entity, for such terms as soul, self, individual etc.,
are mere conventional terms . . . there can be no question
of
getting rid of a soul because one has never had one . . .
. . .
. . .
Richard Gombrich
Ibid., p. 63.
(. . )
.
.
Richard Gombrich
.
.
Richard Gombrich
. . .
.
.
.
. (.. //)
metaphysics
metaphysics
metaphysics
(
)
()
(. . )
()
(/)
/
(
)
. . .
()
. . .
? . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . .
(. . )
? (/)
() (
) (
) . . .
(../-/-)
. . .
- -
. /
.
(. . )
..
(.. )
(.. )
(.. )
(. . )
(
)
. . .
, ;
.
,
; .
,
; .
(.. // . //)
. . .
.
()
(. . )
.
(
)
.
:
(..)
( )
() ()
()
/
/
/
(
/)
(/)
.
(. . )
)
( )
)
.
/ (
) / ( )
/
/
/
/
/ /
/
// //
//
/
//
/ /
/
//
/
/
/
()
()
/
(/
/
/
)
()
(. . )
()
()
()
- - (
= )
/
/
/
/
()
()
/
/
(. . )
/
/
()/
.
/
()
[
]
- - - - - -
(= )
(. . )
.
(
)
/
, ,
: , , . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
( . . . . . . . . . . . .)
. . .
: , , .
(..//)
, ,
/ . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . . (...
:
/
:
. . .
(. . )
/ /
/
/
...
... ... ()
/
/
()
( )
() (
)
/
()
,
/
/ /
/
/
/ / /
(
)
, , .
, , .
,
. , .
(..//)
: (
) / ?
(
) / ()
?
,
,
(
) ?
(. . )
/
(
- - - - - -)
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . .
, ,
, .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
(
) /
. . .
( / )
/
;
(=
) ( )
( - ../)
( )
/ (
)
(=)
/
(.. //)
: ()
(. . )
()
() /
/
. ?
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
(.. //)
: (
)
. ()
.
.
.
.
(
)
( .. //; .. //; .. //)
""
()
(. . )
.
( . )
(
( )
(= ) (=
) ""
(
)
[ ../; ../; ..; ../ -
, ..//]
)
?
.
?
.
(../-/-)
(/)
(. . )
?
( )
( )
(/)
?
(/
)
?
()
( )
( /
)
?
/
(. . )
.
(, )
.
(, )
.
(/, )
/
(=)
..// ../,
(=
) /
(..//)
: ()/
()
()
/
/
(. . )
(
)
(.. //)
( )
( )
( )
()/
/
( )
/
//
.
-
-
-
()
(. . )
.
(= + )
- =
- =
-
(
)
/ = / =
( ..//; /; /
..// )
()
(/)
(. //)
,
.
(. . )
.
( /)
(-)
(=)
(
)
( ..//; =
. )
. . .
(.. //)
.
: ( )
()
. . .
()
(../)
. . .
(. . )
(. //)
...
. ,
. .
(.. /)
(/ )
()
()
...
:
.
,
(.. /)
.
(.. /)
(
)
(
)
.
-
)
(../)
)
.
(.. / .. /)
(. . )
)
(.. /)
: ()
)
.
(.. /)
: ()
() ()
)
.
.
(../)
: -
...
(. . )
.
( ;
)
(
)
( .. //)
(.. /)
(.. //; .. //)
.
(.. /)
: ()
(
)
(/ )
(.. /)
:
(. . )
(
)
,
,
( )
(. . )
.
.
(=/
)
()
(= )
/
(
/ )
(/ ) (+/
)
( ) ( )
( +)
. . .
(. . )
,
,
,
= ( /)
= ( /)
= ( + )
()
()
(. . )
(.. /)
(. /)
/
/
. . .
...
()
(../ )
(. /
../)
(
)
(..)
,
.
(..//)
(. . )
.
( =
)
.
. (
) =
,
,
(..//)
,
.
= = =
= =
/
/
( )
/ ( , ..
//; / = = , .. /; / =
= , .. /; / =
, ..)
/
( / /
)
/
//
(. . )
( )
(
)
(. . )
(. . )
( ..//)
. . . . . .
(.. //)
(. . )
( -)
.
. ()
. ( )
.
. - -
. -
.
(
)
(. . )
( .//)
.
.
()
(. . )
(. . )
()
(..//)
.
)
)
.
(. . )
(. . )
)
(
)
)
(. . )
(. . )
(
)
/
()
/
()
/ (
)
/
()
/
(. . )
()
/
( )
(. . )
(. . )
)
( )
.
..
)
(. . )
.
( )
()
)
) ... ()
(. . )
(../-/-)
(./-/-)
.
()
.
()
.
(
)
.
()
(. . )
(
)
(. . )
..
,
( "Education, History of," Encyclopaedia Britannica (1965), VII, 1010)
( -
)
(
)
(..//)
( . . . . . .
. . .
.//)
)
)
) (
)
(. . )
( -)
(. . )
() ()
() ()
: ,
; , ;
, ;
. . .
. . .
. . .
.
. . .
:
()
() . . .
(. . )
:
. . .
. . .
,
;
. . . ,
(
) ()
?
(.. //)
.
. .
(../)
: -
(. . )
(. . )
()
. . .
(..//)
( )
()
.
, ; , . . .
(.. //)
(. . )
()
(..//)
. . .
. . .
(..//)
(. . )
(
)
( . /)
()
. . . . . .
. . . .
(..)
: ()
(. . )
.
) -
)
)
.
) ( + )
) ( + + )
)
)
)
( )
(
)
(
)
(
)
(. . )
..
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . . . . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
()
,
, ,
,
(
)
. . . .
. . . (
-, -, -,
-, - )
(. . )
. . .
(
)
) - = =
. ()
. ()
/
.
/ ()
.
/
.
/ ()
. ()
/
.
/ ()
. ()
/
) - = = =
.
/[]()
. ()
/
.
/
.
/
.
/
.
/
.
/
(. . )
.
/
.
/
.
/
( )
. . .
, ., ..
(
)
.
)
//
(. . )
(
)
)
( = ..)
/
()
() [ ..; . /]
../
(. . )
()
(
../)
.
(. /)
.
.
(. /)
(. . )
/
()
/
,
, . . .
(.. )
, .
;
()
: ()
/()
/()
(); ()
()
() ( )
()
( )
(. . )
.
()
.
/
.
//
()
(. . )
-
. . .
()
. . .
()
. . .
(..)
(. /)
()
( ../) ( ../)
( ../) ( ../)
( ..) (
../) ( ../)
( ../) ( .. /)
()
. . . (
) . . .
( .. /)
(. . )
( )
()
() ()
() ()
()
( ../)
( -)
(
)
()
(. . )
. . .
(.. //)
()
()
/
. . .
. . .
. . .
(= ) (=)
(= ) (=
) (= )
(=
(=)
)
(= . . . --------)
(.)
(. . )
(. . )
. . .
(. . )
)
Professor Richard Gombrich
(
)
(. . )
. . .
(,,)
,,
,,
. . .
. . .
. . .
(. . )
. . .
(
)
(),
.. , -.
(
)
(, ..//)
(..//)
(. . )
( ) ( )
( )
(
)
, .
. (..)
: ,
(. . )
(.. //; .. //)
(..//)
(..//)
( )
+
=
= =
(+) = ,
(+) = ,
(+) = , (+) =
(. . )
(.//; ..//)
. . .
()
()
()
()
(. . )
() ( ) ( ) ()
() ()
() () (
)
() ()
(. . )
)
( )
.
.
(
)
(. . )
( )
()
( )
()
(
)
(. . )
.
.
..
(. . )
.
.
(. . )
.
.
(
)
()
(. . )
(. . )
..
. . .
. . .
. . .
. . .
()
(. . )
( . . .
)
-
. .
(
.. , )
(. . )
,
..
(. . )
(. . )
.
.
(. . )
(. . )
(. . )
.
.
(. . )
( ..//)
. . ..
(. . )
(. . )
.
.
(. . )
( -)
Mrs. Rhys Davids ..
- [Steven Collins, Selfless Person; Imagery and thought in
Theravada Buddhism, (Cambridge; University Press, 1997), p.7],
Miss I.B.Horner ..
- [Peter Harvey, The selfless Mind, (Curzon Press, 1995), p.17.]
(Pali Text
Society)
(. . )
( )
( .;
)
( )
( )
( )
...
( )
...
()
()
...?
(. . )
Doctor Candidate (Buddhist Studies)
Dip. in Chinese : Dip. in Japanese
(
)
. ( )
. ( )
. ( )
(.. //)
.
.
(. . )
(.. //)
)
( )
)
() ()
()
)
) :
(. . )
) :
--
--
--
(. . )
() (
)
() ()
(..//)
(. . )
(=/)
(=/)
.
(
)
(
)
(. . )
( ) /
/
(
) (
)
(.. //)
;
. . . . . .
( )
()
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. ()
.
.
.
(..//)
(. . )
() ()
(..//)
: ()
(. . )
.
.
.
(. . )
(../) (../) (../ )
()
(
)
(. . )
()
(/)
()
(..//)
( )
( = )
(. . )
,
(
) (
)
()
(..//)
. . .
()
//; /
(. . )
. (
) = /
.
(
) = /
(
) = /
.
[ --]
(
) =
(. . )
(
)
()
(=)
()
()
()
Wendy Doniger O'Flaherty,
;
..
(. . )
( .. -)
. . .
. . .
( ..)
. . . . . .
. . .
. . .
()
()
() ()
. . .
()
() . . .
(
.. -)
(. . )
(= + =) (= +
=)
(
../)
(..//)
( .. )
()
(. . )
..
(. . )
. . .
. . .
, (: , .. ),
( -)
(. . )
.
.
.
()
()
()
()
( )
(. . )
( )
( )
. / ( )
. /
.
.
.
(. . )
()
.
()
.
()
: /
(. )
:
(. )
,
.
(../; ..; .)
()
.
)
(. . )
.
)
)
. ()
()
)
)
(
)
)
(../; .,)
(. . )
)
)
.
) ---
)
)
.
) ()
()
) ()
()
()
()
(. . )
()
()
()
()
(. . )
(. . )
( )
. :
.
( .. /)
( .; . /)
.
.
(. . )
.
.
(. . )
. . .
. . .
. . . . . . . . .
(../-/)
( = ) (
= )
(. . )
()
()
(
)
(, , , ) +
(, , )
..//
..//
(. . )
()
()
() ( )
(. . )
() ?
(.//)
...
()
(.. //; /)
(. . )
( )
.
)
(=)
)
( )
[
Lalmani Joshi, Studies in the Buddhistic Culture of
India (Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1987), pp.340, 348, 367]
()
.
(
)
) //
( )
)
(
)
( )
, ../-/-; , ..//
(. . )
(
)
.
(
, /
/ )
.
(..//)
(..//)
.
.
(. . )
()
()
( = )
( )
(.. /)
( )
( ..//; ../-/;
..//; ..//)
()
( ) ()
() () ()
(. . )
nonviolence
pacifism
( )
(..//)
: ()
(..//)
: ()
(, ..//)
( ) ..//
; ..//; ..//.
../-/
(. . )
(//)
(= /)
. . .
(..//)
emotion
..
(. . )
. . .
, .. (
)
(. . )
. . .
. . .
( )
(. . )
) (
) (
)
(,
) (
) (
)
.
.
()
(../)
.
(. . )
()
() + (
)
(
..; ..; ..; . /)
(. . )
. (
)
. ( )
. (
)
()
(..//;
../)
( )
( )
( )
( )
.
.
.
() (-
(. . )
) ()
.
.
.
..-; ../-
(. . )
(. . )
(.. //)
()
()
(. . )
( )
(..//)
- -
.
.
() ()
(. . )
()
(. . )
(
)
(
emotion )
(
)
-
(. . )
(. . )
.
.
()
(. . )
.
(
)
() (
)
(. . )
(
, ..)
(
, ../)
.
(
)
.
(
)
.
(
)
.
(
)
...
(../)
(. . )
(= )
(= )
(
)
()
. (
)
.
-
. /
(. . )
()
() (
//
/)
.
()
(
)
( , ../-/-)
.
()
()
() /
/
/
(
) /
/
//
//
(//
)
(. . )
//
//
//
(. . )
(
)
(. . )
(. . )
.
() - -
.
(. . )
:
, ,
?
:
: ?
:
(. . )
:
-
:
:
:
-
-
: ?
:
:
(. . )
:
Giza
:
:
(
)
, (
)
: ?
:
Seven Modern Wonders
: ?
(. . )
: . . . . .
. () . -
:
:
,
,
:
:
(. . )
?
:
:
Borobudur
()
(. . )
(Borobudur)
:
?
:
Borobudur
Borobudur
.. -
- ..
..
(. . )
: ?
:
?
:
:
:
(. . )
:
?
:
: ?
:
-
: ?
:
(. . )
:
?
:
: ?
:
()
: ?
:
-
(. . )
()
: ?
:
(/ )
: ?
:
: ?
:
.
. x
( x . ;
)
:
?
:
,
. . .
. . .
(.//)
,
;
,
(. . )
(..//)
:
?
:
()
.
,
.
:
:
( = /)
:
(. . )
?
:
: ?
:
(
)
:
?
:
(. . )
:
:
(. . )
: ?
:
( )
(. . )
:
:
:
?
:
(. . )
:
?
:
: ?
:
(. . )
:
?
:
: ?
:
: ?
:
(. . )
: ?
:
:
:
:
:
: ?
:
(. . )
-
()
:
?
:
:
?
:
(. . )