lJ1'I'YI 5

.,.,

f1l'l1~m1fl~ mn1fl~U

lJlJ1~mflUiiu~u
y

neu 1J111IOlfll1lHoU' fl~lIff1'l~ f1l'll~ UUi 1111

,

fl1 'l ~1'W fl1*Vi U" ~I'VIl1 U 1" 1j (~1'W~1'W) 'l~~ 'IJoMUl1'ti f UlIfff)'H1illl

f1iUffl111'l

(l

«~u ~t"Wl1lJ

1. f11111~~ 'H 1I1lJ'Ufl~m 'll'i)lJ

""'"

2. U'i~'lnm 3.

fl~:milflrh~
J! A '" '" ~I'" ",,,

4. m 'l ff"J1'llfll"fl 'llJfll\Ol f11f11J{)11~ 5.

tq U ~Hm1'l«fl

~u 'IJ 'LJ1IOlfllflUij,j~

6. fliiU'llUfI"

1. 1~fl «1' 1~U1111 110lfllfl U f1lHlum*'VU1~~I'VIfl1u

A

iiU~U"ZI111'U1'IlOlfl'fl'U m llJ!oU'11110 ~ lIf1'l'l~ on 11"1

y ,

11lJU

1~u (HlJ~TW) oMUlJ1WlJffmnilli

."
ft

1
d J!

2. l'YW'H 1f,)Wfll'n'U rJ ~u 'IJ'UTil fl1fllJ{)'U9I mt~ II11111'1 IOlfl'fl'U'VI 'UU fI'"J1'l

I"" "'''''

.1

U 'l~'lf1 n 'l 1tJuiJ ff'l ftf11hJ It!eru

"'.,.

n(i fJU'lflU'JlIlJlJfffl'l!liil-n
SI ~

1 fllfl

is lJU Vi
I

I iIms
0

fff11:l12546

fN 1'lJflW::fl'l
I

'j'lJ mr fll'lflmn'IJU
.,.

Viu! 1U 1Ul'U9In'lt:i1lfl61 U U U l'llfJiU

1u 1'j'~I~ lJU oO~'H1 tl1'U 'VI 1 iii ii

• •

'jfJUfHllJ

'JI 'JI fl'1'l~ rnn 'j'£J'W~ fl1 'l 'l1'Um '" 'If'Wlm~11'1 1 1 '" (~1'U'U1U) 'i1 lU 552 flU 'ill fl'i11UltJ fl 'U flU TW

h~l1£J'U8 h'l

74

• u u

fl~lJ~1Vcil':)

d'hnim1£JU'l1,.,lJ'IirJ1JfffllJlil-Yi

1 tl1fll1rJ,.,-Yi 1 ilfl1JfffllJl
•

2546

iJ ,:)11rJUff,:) ti ~rlT.r

fH 1U fl W~ fln lJ f11~ fl1 J fffllJ loUU Vl'UJ 1,., 1'U1'Il\9l ih!tll1 i'U 'U 'U l-:i1 fi,:)

mu .ij':)111~

1,.,

q~'UVl{ ~1i111m~U'U fl~lJffl~~fi1~11tf'Urf11H1'U'fJ1'11~Ua~IVlfl

I'Uia~

(,:)1,.,U'1'U) ~1'U1'U 70 fl'U

• J,lI]'lJ ~ ... 'Olfl'iJ1'U1'U i'"HI'H.I'U 3 i H~':) ~<f11J1i <f1U11if11JlaefUl1J'lH'iJ1~'iJ':) (Purposive Sampling)

Ifl~e ':):U'fJii f~l~;j'U f ( ':)1'U'Uru) VI~1'iJVti~1~'IllHhl1

iI

dj 'U1I1J1J1<f11lfltJij,j'9i t
Q.I' QI ~ : Q,I'

fl~ll ff1~::;:mr -l1'U61;~ II a~t'Yl i1..l I 1:1~ fl

~

.d jJ.QQ.I

~1J'tJ ru~V'U 'I:f'UlJ 'jilllJ I'Ifl1:l1 11 1 'ill'U TW 2 'I:f'tJ f1 'fJ < fl

0 ~ ~

iJd

1. 11'U'U1<f1 tl1fltJ iju9i ntill rn ~:; 011,:) l'U'fl1'11~ U1:I::::1 I I (-:J 1J,y l1J) ~11J 11J Vlfl u 1:1~ 1

Q'U'UVl 3 l-:itH fl1~Hllu8N1 'i!,j'U~

... .,;.A

...

'lJ

4 I~V,:j fll1Gtf6lJWlfmA'f1N'1 (fl1l'ihm1Jl1\J)

'"

'i!,j'1J~ 5 1~6-:Jf11nh::fl6'U6l11ld
I

'" 'lJ 1 '" 2. U1J1JVll9lff61J1191 fl111J1'1.11'iJfl ~ 1Jff11~ f11~I-:iV'tJ'lJ fl T:i,:)11J61'1:f'Vtlla~ I'VIl 1 1 '" 't f 'U 1:1 (I

(~1'U1J1'tJ) ~':)IU'UU1J1Jl1\91ff'fJ'UU1J1Jm8fl91tl'U 'b"\.J\9I 4 9l11'fltlfl Ul'UTW 30 '1Jfl 'ilTW1'U 1 'i!'U'U

'lJ

.!?I

...

'"

01'"

y..

...

'" 1. fll'l'Vl\9laV'IflHl1 '"

f1.ijtfl~\11U1J'U1<f1illfl'11fi,j'9Hiff~1-l~'tJ11-l

""

5 11,j'U i'l.J'VII9I'fl6~1<&'ti'Ufl~1J~1t1dH 20 fllfl11lJ!~11~1J'lJfI,:)aff{jIfl911-H

flU'W1Naf1n1'fl~'1IlJ11Ifl-:i1~li'111~ltil'U1'iJ~1I1Uml1~rJ-:i1£Joifti fl~U'U1J 2 flU 'il10111J'U1<f1.f11flUfitl~liff~1-:J~'lJ ff1'11i~i1,:)ii 1. ~ltiTlJ1'il~lU'Ufl

."

"

~ 1tilU 1 'il ~1111Jni R~ (I'j 1 fJ.jf-rJ 'tJ6,:jU1J11')19I illfl'11ij,j'9i 111:1:: ,L. Sabers '11-:i1l {]"hfhvl'U D f 1'il~111 flIQ 'U

. 1 fl 'U1191.fJ1 i:hl~V oifv'1.1 ':)111J fl'11fi,j'~u9ia::

I'flVl ~q91 'j

D.R. Whitney 'inJ'U ~ ~,:)i1

"

75
, ,
Q.i ~ d I 0 0 ~

..
'j}
QJ

U'l1'IJofll ~fhr:iTlJl,",~lUt! flIll~U:i1fJ,yil~'mW

..

0.000 n~ 1.000
t

1l'IJ'IJ'YI lJflltJ1t!l'O'OlUl.!nm~W'nU'lItl91~Wll 2 d. d. 9)!, U'IJ'IJ'YI3 lJtntl1Ul'O'OlUUnm'fllI'JlfJ'lItl91~!19'1

Q;I

0.000 m
4

l.000

1l'IJ'IJ'YI lJfl1t11t.ll'il'Oluunm 4
Q;.I' ~ ~

-QI

£:i

U'IJ'lJl'I 5 lJmtl1lJl'il'OlUUflI'il'fl1I'J1U'llil\9l~U\9l 0.000 fI~ 1.000

• A ~ "Q.I 9'" 1 G1 V 1 ~ ~ 2. f11f111lJ1'lftllJ u 'lIil'if;;!Il' m'fl mfl~ u uu 2 fll.! flU ~'lf~91 'J11i111Il'lJu 'J:-Il'1'I1i U'lJ ~ U

. .

..::t

too

00

mJ'J1U'llil\9l~U91 0.000 fI~ 0.935

~

."

0.000 tN 1.000
~

SI

9J

QJ.

..

Q;I.

!Viu1ff'lJ ll'J1nt]ilijfh~~uw

..

q..::t,

4l.I'

...

2. nl'Jl'1f1'fltl-JflHl'I
~'" "o]'lIo

0.629 ..... U~ 0.974 "" 2

OJ

fj1'il U !flU 111 1f11l1flut]'lJ91 'YI 1'J1~'lIU'YI'i5 U'lJ'lJ'VIu'J'lJtJ ~~Ufl !'lI'ill nmrns 'flil~ uu 1
'lI
'" I

AI""''''''''.,l

.x!

'"

d.I'"

'lIlI!

fl1-Jlll

th ill'YI~H'I8~fl1'ii1
,
'j/

iJ

2 fl'lJfl~lJ~1ildl~

~1l.!1t! 20 fit! ;:ihJCJ11ti'Wfl'UmilJ'VIflatl~;:i''l1'

fjIl'~Ifl \91 l1f1:-Ut! t! 2 fl U ~'flu'J 1fl{]lI-JU 1. filii lUl'O ~'uru fl th

'lI ""

AI

01

""

..
11'ltI1 'lfil!'fI'J
..:i'

r:i lU l'il\i 111 fllU ~ U'JlU1Ytl'lIil~ U'lJ'lJ1101 'W m

ua:- D.L. Sabers 1l'Jlfl{]11thr:iTtJl'il~lUUfll\l

Q,I' ~

UUtJVI 1 lJfl1tJ1U l'il'illU'Wfl!U'flV'J1lI'lIfI'fI'iU\9I 00400 iH 1.000 U'lJ'lJl'1 2 lJfl181Ul'il'illUl.!fl!'ila[l'JlfJ'lItl91~U'fl 0.400 iH 0.965 d .:t. c ~ iJ t U'lJ'lJVI3 ummurauuru flI'il'flV'J1U'lItI'fI-JU'fI 0.305 fH 0.965
G.f 0 (II ~ Q

.
,

~U'JlfJ1I6'l1il~UtJU11011l1flllfi'l1~u\9i'fl:-u'l1'lJ ijfil~-JU
g

fltJfi'l19i

D.R. Whitney

r"
I

£:i

...
, ,

..

iI

QI

II!{

:9J

CL.I'

..

,.:f

U'lJU'VI4 lJfl1tJ1t!1'il'illUUfl!'il'flV'J1U'IJtl'fl~IWI 00400 t;N 0.965 d d 9J t 4 'ilU'IJ'YI5 lJfl101l.!1'il'illUUflI'il'flfJ'JltJ'lI691-JU'fI 0.305 fI-J 0.600
g,;
Q

-Q;.I'

,t!i

rJI

(II

gJ

Q;I.

..

UIl'I01-Jl1filiillJl'il\ilu'Wm'ilit{l'J1U~il'IJtl-JUU'lJ1I'lillmJfi,r9h1'i 2. f1111H'lfillJlJ 'lItN f;;!Il' 1fl'1l 'H f1:::Ul.! 2 fI t! ~ U

'j/

...

..

..

5 irU'lJ ijRlr:ilUl'il~lUt!fl

'"

'lI '"

N'flfll'J 111'1::: l1fllf111lJ1 'If'tllJtA tAfll 'J ~l1f1:::UtAU'IJil-Jf;;! 1:'1' ~! !11i'I:-U1J t! 2 n fl91
OJ

"'"

",

A':'

nu il'lu 1 'lf~91'J1~111fflJ1h 3.

:::ff'VI1lU uudil V1fftA ilnfl{]11ijth~ .. , ... "" fll'Jl'I91 'fltl-Jfl HVI 3

..

"I

'j/

'j/

"I 'lI

-JU~ 0.572 n-J 0.933

flf~~ 3
fllf111lJ!

f1~ mrlflillflll fJ'IhU

ij'l19i,"~ 5 n 'l1'1J'Yllli'lJ1l~'i'illflf11'JVl91'flil~f11-Jn 2 111'Vl fI'flil-J

j/.

Sf

~ltA1U 30 flU ~-J!rh..lnQlJt!flI~U'lJ~1:JJlii'lJfi'IJfl~ml11a8~~'~'YIl1a'tl~i'lf-J~

1 , 2 !~fl'H1

fJWil1~~-J'i!

'lJ'1JI !~1'1l1~afll'JVlfI'flil'ilJl11fl'Jl:--H111~1Il'n~nitl~~'tJ
1Ufl1'J111 ~q1l1~~~d

ththl.!l'i1 \ilU u flIU~ fJJ1fJ<{Ifl

~'tI tu

'lIfl-J~ff ~! rm 1 lffl:::u UU 2 flll ~1 f111lJ! ~6tt! 'Ufl-JU'UU111n 1tlll

fi,j~ U'fl:::

tlli'111lJfl'flll'l!fl~fl'WlJl91'J~lU

76

..
-ff-l!fl¥l'rffl~U'U'U 2 fl'UiJthvY1~1111-lfmJ~:::

'Olflm'J'V1~lH)-lfl:i,rn 3 'UtFlUU'lrJ~iI1fltlfili~ 59.33 (i-l 76.17

,

5 l1li'IJU11fl{Jthm~~'lHl-l~

um: 64.67 O-l 78.17 mlJih~1J

l!ff~-l'hufU5(J'U1ifl11lJffl'JU

'U'J:1iURtl'U,rl-l~-l

'fhudj~-lIU'UlJ1\91'J~l'U'UtJ.:JUU'lJ-ff-llfl\¥l iJRl9l-lU91

..

2.32 (i.:J 2.87 Uri: 2.75 fi-l 3.48 ¥I1lJ~1~U Uff~.:J11UfU5UU~fl11lJff1lJ110hjU¥lfl~1-lft'U 2. fl1V1U 1'0'0111'1..1 fl
I. 0

1111'h81'U1'0~1U'UfU'ilatJ'lJtl.:JUUU1~ fl1f1Unli~~ Rl9l-l U~ 0.509 O-l 0.861 I!ft~-l

..

'hI!UU 1~ mfluij,j~l1.:J

..

5 'illiu ftllJ 110 ~lU 'Ufl,r

A .:..
O!

f11'1 rJ'UmilJ"l-lurl~

fl~ lJ~1

1 ~~ ih
0.867

3. 1'111111 'lI'V11'U 'UtJ-lU 11'lH'!'~I fl ¥I ,

111f111111oJ1mJ'U'lJ UUU -ff l!fl¥lU'J1fl{J11ilfi l~-lU ~ 0.592 fl.:J Uftfl-l11U'lJU1~.flltlUfili91'fh'UlJ1flilRltl11lJl~fl1i''UUl'lJfllt1-l 4. f111lJ!']ftJ11U'lJfl-l~ft~lfl¥l !l1fl~U'U'U 2 tl'U
A~
~O!

..

9~

iJfi 1\?1~1!~ 0.822

..

..

'I11fl11lJI'l1tJlJ'U

A':",

umr i~ 'lffl:U

'1..1 'lJ'lJfl-lljff un \¥I 'lftl: II'UU 2 flU lJ11 fl{J11

J!O!
I

1~

.1

ih
~..,

0.932 Uff~-l11U 'lJU l'flfl1f1t1nli91~ fI11lJ!~'U

I

111:1 :lJfl1111 fffl ~ fI IIV-lnu 1:l111-l

111,r rJ'lJfl-l1f1 ~ rnr irf fI:U W i~ ~., ,~ fllHI 'J1 '0 l1tlg:u UU'lJtl-l ~ff -l1fl¥l 2 nu1'1 flU'lJ1-l,p
lit) U

'1..1 U

5. tl11lJfI m1Hfl

Ai

mm!l'U

U f1111~

....

~ R1tl11lJtllt l~ltl~V'UlJ 11911 i'U rm 1~tI 'J1fl {J11il fi19r-lu9i 1.005 tH '11'lJ 1.626 11ff~-l ':hfil 1'1 11lJ fI m~ltl~VUlJ 1'f1 1'11'lJiU rm

1'~,rlJ V ..

"""~ .., ~ 2. NlI f11111m l:l1'lJVl,j tl '01nu'tJ'IJ'\'l \9lfftlU1 ~ fl11lJ1 'Uli'0

2.1 f11S'V1~fttl'UtlH'V1 1

fhfll'U 1'O~lU'Ufln(J~v1111 f1tJ1n'lJtNI UHJ'U v U (Brennan) ilfi 1~ eu~ -0.250 ~ iHO.730

2.2 fl1'J'V1~fftlt1tlH'VI 2 R181'U1'O~lU'Ufln(J~Vl111fltJ111'lJf.Nlll'JUUtl'lJ ~

O!

.. .
..

(Brennan) 1iR1~.:JU\9l -0.130

..

0.810

2.3 m'J'YI~f1'VllflH'YI 3 2.3.1 Rl ftfl91,.(U! lU 1llVlnR 1m ~ tJ !I~g:{h'U,rl U-lI'IJ'UlJ1I91'J11..1 lf111lJfW lf1 -'I fi Ifl~t1'U u 191 'U1 'U f11'Ji~ tI'J1 fl{J-:h fill 'ji1 19.76 mu: Ui:I:ff1U1tJU-lI1JUlJ1I91'J!lUlJfl1
, ..:!II ~

'"

.. ..,

\1, ~
r

~'Utl-lf1:U U'U'U8-lUUU 'Vl'f'l neu l''f'Itl11lJ1.;j11 'Oil fil 5.990 (Brennan) nfil

2.3.2 filfllUl'il~lU'Uf1ntJ.fi't1l111flU1i'll8-l11J'.i'U'UtI'U ~ I'l-llll'l 0.220 fN 1.000

."

..

77

2.3.3 ti lf111lJ !~~~hl 'U~ ~11 Ul'llilff~U 11ilf1,)11H 11'il111ililtJiti'U fN 1 ~ ~U11?l (Lovett)

ntil

0.865
, A 2.3.4 fl1f111lJf1tnlillf1fl~'UlJ1m~1'U
v ,

1'" "" ..1 " hlfll'nl9l 1IiltJ1" 'l:l't1I?l'i'IJ~~fTfll"l~'J1il

•

i!fl':il~-H~fll.dfl'[Jlfifil'J'YIlilff~Uf1f~ti

3 Nm.hlflt:r:h

tilf111lJf1allillf1ii~hllJ1\91'J~lhll

ufil'J11il

"" lJf11 2.201

Ni:1 'ii ~tJf1l'~ ff1lJ rmuen ~fhJntJ Na~~ m il 1. til~lhll'il~lUhlfl 1.1 ril~lhll'[J~1111.lfl!n~V'i1V';t1
tJ
ill
I

il

m~tJ ';;'I11filt11'l.l1'il~lU1.lmU~V'ilU,r8'IJ8~U'UU
II

..

1Iilmflt1iju~i'vi~
ill
t

5 nuulh1fl{J';hfil'il'lf1i:lil~f1i'~Vi1

VlIil tl ~f1f ~Vi 2 fi lr11t11'U1'il~111 fUn tJ'i1 V,ril 'l'i'l 5 n uuii a 'U
ill
Q.I

aI""

iifh ~~U~ 0.000 ~~ 1.000 IUl~'[Jlfim'J

rl191~
(II

0.305 n~ 1.000
d
I

'illfifl1'i'YlWmNflH'Yl 1 Ui:l~ 2 'U1.lUfflil'l11f1161U1'[J'illU'Ufl!ni:ltJnV'IJil'IJ3~UU'U,)Wfl1f1 1.1 ij u~,f~ 5 n UU I'i~U ~1~~ ffllJ 1'JflU£JfiflQlJ \!~'tl8 fl'illfi

lid

iJI
Q;.I' ,

'0

g,I

Q,oI

..

fffl~~ Ulll UU11111101111 fluiju9iVifi

,

1?l1lJIflWeflVinl'111J1il Nflms i~ tJ;h~'lrl.i ff~lilfl~~~f1UNi:l m'i~WJ'U1UUU1Iilfl1fl1_Jfiu1ii'tf1'lh'lft1UlJ ('lf0 159) 'tI'tl'l 1I'Vf'J')'Vl'iq'1'Vf'l'I!J(2539 : 83-86) YllJfll61'Ul'i1'illl1'U flI'iH'IlJntJ'lJtll?l~UI?l 0.234
4
if

i~ ifill'i1 !rJ'U1'Vf'J 11u Ullil~ ~~ 1~ ~ U ~1~ ~lfJUi:l:: n~lJ ~ 18 th'lih111lJ ffllJ1Hl U~1'Wn 11 il0119i'Ill.!
fl ~ u~1

..

~Q'

"Q,.oI'

..

T(;ttJ

fl~ 1.000

\'l''1n uU'U 't) 'Ill UUlf1.fllflU ij u~ fI1flDii;r9i 11Jfl1'JVllilflil'lflf~~

..

1.2 ft1ih1.l1'[J~lU1.lfUD~lJ~"D'l1u

. .. filD 5 n UU lh 1n lJ11~'lfi1 11lt11'U I'll~ 111 fUn a v'l'i'lD U U'U~ eu 'UU11il

m~vl~111fil~'I:I'i1~hIJ1'11~lU1.l
'IJ

..

glJ'i1V~6

3 ~fhi'lU~

0.509 n'l 0.861 ~'1ijftl11.l'J::v1'U~lJ1flli16'1'il1fi~

In WeflfllI?l611t11'J1lff1~U U 'IJ 'U~~UUU 11il111fltJfiti91~ otl'lill ~ '1ffllJ 1'Jn~1111.lmr n I~ lJU fl Q lJ \!'111 'il1.l a:: fl~ lJ~ 166

n 'ill fl flU 1 ~'1 rrtllil fl1I6'1nu ms ~~

~ w ~

rrr l'1UUU'YI1il nau

I 0 0

l'flfl1flDijU'9li

'tn~ l1J '111'1 'W~ 1'W ~

I

cd..::! J~ a..t ('1013) 'tI8~1'i::'I:I'V fl''ilJ'Iflfl (2540 : 85) 'YllJfI1t1l'IJ1\l\llU1.lfUnaV'VI'lUuul?l'lUI?l

0.719 \l~ 0.893

2.

A':" "... ~ ...ijl, lfllf111lJl 'I:I''tllJU'Uti~ I::J 1'1' '1tfl91 A':" X..., m llJl'lf~ uU 'tI6'1err ~tfll?l1" 'I1f1~U'IJ'IJ 2 flU ~1'[J V 1il'M

1lf f1~U'IJ'IJ 2 flU 'U6'1U11Uilil mml ij'l1~ ~ 'I 5 D'l1u ilil V1 .fI\1I?l'JflJD 'i:: ff'YI ul'UUl ~ V 1ff''IJ '[J nm 'i f f 1 'Yllilfl6'1flH'Yl 1 tN 3 lJ'JlfilJ11lJfl1'11'1U'1I 0.572 U'I 0.933, 0.952 '1I1lJih~u ~1flfl1 ~'VI a8'1~'1 ~ 3 fI 'I'iI~llhr;h
...,,c:t

.. .

.... 1

.QI

Q,I"

..

0.594

fl'I

0.942

I1n~ 0.822 O,:j

IIUU llil.fl1mJ fi,j91~

ij100m:d'l'1 ~U '1fl'i!'UU
'iI ~ 1 V lJ 'IJff 'I ~

"" A~ tJ' ~ ... hi"",..,.,. ... ""ljI d ... 'jI"I' lJf111lJl'lf'tllJ'IJ VI~'IJ 1~1'U'WlVln:: II1111 ~ mnu {JU'1IlJtflU! C)Il fl1 ~ l'l1f1::U'W 'tflill'II 1J'tll'IJl 'till ~ ' ') 'W'VI

~I?l~') 'il1lf fl::U 'IJllflfl,)llJ I~'tl,r II ua::;~ ~

m llJlrt 'IJU'JU tJ1 ms m ') 'ill ~fl~U 'IJ

~'1 fftllil fI~6'1 fl11

78

flTn:rf1~U'U'U1'1OI1l1fliJil'lJ'9ii'll'1i'1fllJYi1!~-eJ{~'W~l'W'l1'Wlh::t1UffmntlVl
• I ~

""

. 6 ~-eJ~ ff~l'W
O~ 0.999

111 (2542
I

'U'VIftlOleifl)tl1fl11lJl.J1mJ'W~V~~ff~!fl~1t¥f1::U'I.rw

2 m,lljfhw~ulPi

0.994

I1tl::~~Vl

'Vl1~f \9l 'Vl1i'\9ltf ! ~lff'W -eJ 1 U'U'Un ~ ff6'U~lJfl11lJl;j'WiJ 1 i'1::U'W'Wff~ ('Vl1'l'j"\9l'W'VI1~~U. 3. f111U 1
t

11

~,rmr ~~::ljti 1f1111Jl~-eJ

..

Q:J"

AQI

"

ii'u~fl ~~~ ~1'l '1,r "

~5

~~)lr 'U'U1~ ij'lJ'9i ~l.o rJ'I11fl11lJ1~mt'WU1J'U1101fl1fliJii'jj~~ 'W~V~ rnml

II
JI

2530:

330)

'il -U'U11!~ ~ 1 nmrn m'Ul 'I

fI i' ~ ~

11~::iJi''U iJ1 ~lJ 1uti' 1 ~ 1fl,r 'W iJ'VllOl fl~ f1f ~Vi 3 iJ'llfl{] 1 1 f111lJ 'Ill! ~ 'II::1'HU1111'U'U1~ 1l1f1iJ{J'U\9llJfI1f111lJl 'll't1lJ'Wtil '1 ltHHm
Q'
QJ .Q 41q-=

'JJ

l'll'tllJ'Wm {I tllJ i'11\9l II 11 0.592 ~

.d.::t.

~,

n ~ 0.867

~1 flU'U'U11'lfllfliJ ij-u9ilJfl11lJ ff::1OI1fl1'W01~1 <N V 1'WUti'11.,r11~ ~lVlJfl11U 1.,r11~ \9ll'l nUl! ~:: fl~lJW 1 ' tl ~1~lifl11lJ 'fI'llJ 1~ t1~ '11'Wfl1 ~iJijU91 \9l1Ul1 -eJ 1'11'1 W ~ '11 mn fl1f111lJl'll'fllJ'W~fHU1J1J19il11~~::'il'IJ'lJ1.l'l~1rJ (2538
1lJ' •

".

Vl fhlf'W~
Q,.-

tI~ ft'iJ S:: nnu I'H rlTUn JiUn11'1l1'

AQI Q q

"

CJ

q;'

iI.do

!lJ1{jffBlOImW~fl'IJr-mfl1~1'i1V~tI~ l'WrJS~~'J ~i:lfl'll

,..

f/

.:!

: 'U'VI1~ tltI) 11f11~::11 11~ .705 t1~ .840 f 4. tilffii9ildfl~9i''W 'il1flfl1HI9il~fl~f1f{j~ 3 ~t1{jmJ'lJ1~fllfliJfi,j9hf{j

..c:t,

. i1tl1m~rJ~tI~fl::II'W'W~fHU'lJ1J1~f11fliJfi'll91mfl~ff'l1fl~
15.53 111:1:: 13.33
I ~

,t¥f1::U'W'U 2 f1'Wijtlwi'~u9i

"

5 mltJiJnfl{l 11.87 U{j

I"llmll~1J"h'WlrlV'I!1J'W1I1~S~1'U~tl~U1JtJ'VI~ff-eJ'lJmi'1iJfiu9ilJtl1;~ 11 '1 $0 1111 2.32 t1'l 2.87 1m:: 2.75 0'1 2.86\9l1lJf11~'IJ Ufl::flllVrJf1::'Utl~fl::U'W'U~fl~~ff'l1fl'1l lffl::U'W'W 2
~ 0
Q,.I'

n~15.66
~

f1UlJfllVl'lUlI

Qf

Q:.oI

"

59.33

O~ 76.17

U~:: 67.67

iN 78.18 mUf11101'IJff11'H~'Y1f11mf1t1~fNfl::Ul-fW~-eJ~

00

q,.r

~I

fJ} ~

... '1 !II Uuun 'l1fl1"l lffl ::U'W'W2 flU

r

• !II ueem ~atlf1::~tl

~fl ::UU 'W'Utl'lUU'IJff ~!fl\11 '11 fI::U 'U'W2 flU \1'1 Uf1::fI1
0,.

,!II

ff1'W1'IJrJ~ltJ'U lJ 19'1S!ll'W 6 ~ ~'WS::~'IJ 'VI 'I111'l11~ n~lJ ~16rh ~ fl111Jfflm:l

.d

'9

... .d,}!'o]P 'J1 I~l

61'illlJ'WI'YfS1:: 1I'IJ'IJ1~mfllJ

~I

0,.

.1'" "'... dJ1.......

UtJ~ 'VI~1UtlffS 1~~'W~ lfl1l-.1 tI

~.1

,1

1~nil iiU91U 1U~ I'll 'Wlnl'lfl11lJ'l11'W 1'qj '11~ -eJ 1 'illtJ 'W~ ~1I1 'II 1fl n~ U1'i16 ~l{jn 6 01 'Wfl1SiJ~U9i'l1'W 1.l'l ~ {j'th'-H' rrun Sf1U~,j~{j11J 1 ~llJ1flW ~~ n I'll 'W I{ ~
5. f111lJfll11~ IfI~6'Wm ~ S! 1U' 'Ufl1 ~ 1 ~ lrl VVI~ lSW 1ri1fl11lJfll11~If1g6'W 1J1\Ol S~'11.-1
fI ~ -eJ 'Wm91:l~l'W

1'Wfl1 S l'~ ~u'.jf'i!91~ -eJ n1'1'rla{\OI il~ U 11t1lfl11)J flm~1 1 S~ 1fl f1f{j~ 3 flti19Y{jU9i 1.005 ffllJ SO'lJV~il' rJ'U flI~ 'VI~5

1'Wrnr 1101'Wfl1 ~ 'VI 1'1eJI 1 ~ -'

il~1.626
I

U'fl'~~i1U'lJ'lJ1~mfluijuii~~.olJfff1~~'Uff1)J1~01I01mllJ ff1U 1~0 ~ 1111'~ ~ ~ 'Uv~,r

A ,....

1fi'lml'lfi rJ~ftUfl11lJ

flI1 £11.-1 ffll119,]~111JU 1~m

I ~

fliJfiU91
I ....

",,1 !II. I " a rJl~lJ'W1.-1 fl11lJ 1lJ~:: ff'IJ f11:1W fl11lJ

su

..,.d~..,

.1 '" 'IJ'YI 1 ~ tlffdl~'lJ'WlJmfl11lJfl ~

~

m~lfl1'16'W

snm ~11.-11.-1 fl1S1101f1fl'W 1~1.-16J -eJ ~11'f'J1~ tl~)J ~ 1 'tJ r1

n

!II

fl::U 'W'U'VI\01 ns::'il 1Utl'WU Btl !lJ1 {j'fl'V~fla tI ~ nu Nfl m:iff'J1'l1fl Stl~lJ fl1 ~'Y1 fl'll::lJ{J'lJ \Ol1'l111'Y1 rJ1ff1ff'1lS (110l)
~V{j 'tl1'Uff'l 1\9l'111:itl~nN (2532

";1~

.., ~

'"

minr

(l

'I •

~....

..... !lJIWIf1111~fl'Um fl 11a::lJ'" rns ~ nuI'" (."..1Ut11 <'I r-.l {}'lJ91)J 11 'iFl'VI1 '11
$0

0' ~
"

'"

"'....

nl"" .........

...

: 68) lJfI191~U\9l 0.52 t1'l 1.49 Uf1::r-mf11:1'VlWl'W1UU'IJ

~ 'QI "

l..:t

Q:.I

1~mfliJiju9i1'111'Jh~ftlfJmatl

.,.

('110159) 'lJfl~ U'WS1'WS

q:1'VNfi'

(2539

: 92)

nti11'i~U~

"

1.397

O~

1.646

79

6. f'H'I fll ~11f1n~l1'\1tl\;lCl'il1flU'U'UYl~tl'6'U1~f111lJ 1'\11 'il

"" "'>I ... '>I

6.1 fll~'YI~tI'tl'UfI1' -1fi I ft161'U1'j)~lUtA fl SlVofi'tl 'H 11 ~u11hm~ 1'IJStAUtn.. ~1 fl!]11 nl lJfl1tl1U1'il'il1u'Um1U'\.Itl\9l~U\91 -0.25 1'li'11'ilrl6 U 'li'1-1~
~I 0 00 ,..
Q,.I

'"

..

(J~

0.730 Ufffl~11f11tl1tA1'il'il1UtAfl'\.l6-1U'U'U'¥IWlff6'U1'ilfl11lJ

I.

II)

00

-QI

mu 1~ (J IWflU m~uu fl ~ lJ Ifl-166 fl'il1 flU flI'7 U1..l ti 6U fl~lJ

111 i uu

1-1~6li fh 6 1tA1'il

~ 111 'Ufl~~Hlll ~ -111:1 'Url16 1'Urn~111tlflm ~fl'U'li'llJ U flI'7UtAflQlJ~ 6 tJ '1~f1 ~ 11 lJlfl fl11U flI5 U'Ufl ~ lJ 'UtJ Iri-111:1'U'Ii'tl~i,*hj'1~~-1'Il9i\9l~-1 ~i1'UitJ'Ii'6 4 'li'tl31lifh61tJl\lUlutJmlu,j'tll'l'htl'U 0.00 ~-1'1li

nun S (J ~ 11!'Ufl'I.!fll'7 u'U fl ~lJ1ri-16 6 f1\l1n U fll1ut..!m11J66 'U'1~1I ff¥l-111U flI5 ut..!flqlJ 10-1'1~f1:11 U 'UIvll nllu flI1 U'Ufl ~ 1Jri tl'U 11 'lu 'I.J -1,j'6li fh 6 l'U 1'il~ 111 CI: 1 'Ufl1lin-11 n Wcri' fi6 0.20 ~ -1'"1fll ~ 11 '\IU l'inl ~~ ~'1 6.2 fll~Yl¥l tl'tlUflS -1fi 2 fh61'U 1'0U1UUm 1ulItl1111 WlUn'\l6~''U HI UtlU

'"

ilfi16 1'U1'il~1I1lJ rn ltl.fj'tl9i'lU~ -0.130 n-1 0.810 IIfffl~ 111'1161'14 l'i1U111lJfI nu'li' 6'\.16-111 I11'f1<fl 1 neu 1<flfl11lJ11111'illi ft 16 1'Ul'iliilU 'U fl fi 61..l111-1~ffl1J 15 mwm! fl1'7U'U10-1tl6 fl '01flU fl11 UUti61..l '1~Ufl11't-I

..

ilrm {J 11

1 tI'U1-1116~fi

161U l'D-U 'Wf1~ <flClU~ ~I1:Iufi 16 It-11'OUlUtAf191 titA 111 S~

.fhm! flL'1 uu B6 tA '1~ 'W'WlJ 1fl f1:U

fl11U flI1 UtJlri~ ~-1ff.:jN~ i'lffi161U l'O~ lU 'Wfl~ fl ~'U fi.:jf1ri11 ff1'U i'W 1.:j,j't)'fi16 ltAl'Oiilll 'Wfl1,J n.:j 'U

lfIwen

flt) 0 .20 ~.:j'ti1 mnl i''IJ tl~ '1u~l '\I 6.3 fllSYl<flfftl'UflH'fI
oJ

.. .
'"

3
~d '"
'>I

6.3.1 ffO\9l'V'l1..lj}lU fl mms fffJ'Uf]J -1Yl3 '\J tJ ~u 11111'1191 'ill fff.l'U11911111Jl 'til 'il f

.,..,.,1

U J 1fl!]11 fi 11'il~ O'\l'tHfI:U

'Ut-I'\Itl-1Ull'lJ'YI\9l fff)'U1flfl11W.,j' 1'l'Of) 1'W '.i~~lltl1'W fl CIl-1il'fi 11vll ti''lJ 5.990

19.76 1:Y1UlflU~I'IJuu 191~! 1'W'\IJ'Ili 'lJ'UYlfltttl 'I.J 'ilfl11lJl ,j'11 'Oliflllv11nll t 1

vm fl1SYI<fln f.l'I
' It tt¥l '111

f1#.:j~ 3 '\Itl'lU uun <flff0'Ul'flfl11lJl,j'1 i'O'O:n1u 11 U flL'1 U'W 'W m:u U flI1 fl'Wlif1111J m inHI i 'W ff1 i u 5 :fl'U1J1'W fl ~ 1'1 CJI"'1ilJ 0'W'Ol5W l1J~:
-rv
d. d 1
Q)

... _I

.ol ""

_I

..., d d"", -'! neu fl'Uff1'UI'U fl~''U1..llJl91~! 1'W'YI1Jfllfl6'W"ul~lJlfl

'WflIr rJ1..l1Jfl111JffllJ 15 (J U91fl911'1mnnn 6.3.2 rl161t11'O~ 111 'Wns lU,j'tn111 flU1i'll8~1'U ~1..ltA8'Utl 5 1fl{)11ii fl16 ltA 1'il '0111t1mlU'lltl~'1I1'11 0.220
r;)

91

t.

-4

(J'I

1.000 lJ1'WtJ'I'U1'1'\10'YllJf1lf.ll1..l1'il'il111l..lfllYllnll 1.000 IIff~H11m

..:t

.,;:t

iJ

.d-=

00

Q;oI'

6 1'W 1'il~lU ufl 'llf)'1I1'U'UYI~fftlll 1'~ fl11lJ ,.fill 'iltl 11m'll 'i11flm5Yl~ff0'I.Jflf-1~

y1tALflW ~mlJ1:
Ii..;

fflJ ~'11n'U NnlJl'illfl fl1Juf 'Utl~-1

Vi111th61'U1'il~111'Wflil'fil~-1I1~ 0.35
I

,"

1, 2 ~'1ff6~f1~f)'1n'UN~fllsl.ijU'\l8'1lJ1'W:

1I,j~ff (2536 : 'UYlfi~tJ6)

,

ih
0

0.3 8 IIn~fff)flfl~t)'1nll

NnnWWl'lIlJ llfl18~,j61'flfllf1tl 6 '\16'1 'Wi:1ffl~ f

!V ~

ijtl~ fl'1W~
tid

rm n fin 0 -1116-111f -1 mjlJfffHlff11Jth:ff'U f

(2539 : 126-127)
C]f '1lflfll81'W

fl1JW~1'11 oMUtl5:: olJfffl'l:niJii

~ 1 ~ t ~

.J

-0

1'il'01U'WfllJfI191.:jIl\91 0.210 \1'1 0.667 11 :n't)llflCl t)'1 nu J;J

mw tl)'l YI

INOti 1'lfuft'S Im:f1tAt'W

a ~1 'U1flW
'01fltlul~~

cn~Uff~-1 i 'If'lt'U 1111ll'UYl~ff6'I.J ffllJl'H1UUflU

'1 (2523 : 9) ~1~'H'!-:hftlV1'Wl'il~1IltAfli'lll9'i

fl ijuu fl ~1J Ifl~IIa:u

.20 ~'WltJ 8611

flI1U1..l ~lJ~ 0 'Wf) 0 tl fl

80

6.3.3 fl ltll1111~'eJ J WU6'1!! 1JUVlI"Iff'eJ1111"1 fll1lJl (Lovett) 1.1nn{J 11 fll tll1lJ1~6J'Wijfl

11"1 fll1l1!~1
A

ill 1 111111 1"1 iii'll 6'11 flll91 v

~6 J'W 'II 'eJ'I 1111111'1"1 1

11'l'il fl11 O.865 11~a{f'Wlf111flltllTW

rreu

1 11~
0

~i') ff~ 1'1~'W ljfll fllll1 v

'"

l~tllt"W ~ 'I U ff~ '11lfl{f'W 111111111'1I"Ift'eJ1111"1 tll1

w.iJ 1111ijfll111
I I

?'I un.uI'"\.I eu fl:.:1"11UlJ 5 l

O11ff11'1n1lJ1:':ffl1flfiEl
A

v",";

,.:"" v '" v.,j-'t W:':'YIOW1Jl'lfU'W11f111lJff6W1f1f16'1fiUN'ft O11ffl1'1lf116'1lJfl

1
-A Q. -Q,I

11lfll1lJffllJ1HlI'11'W'IltH'l:f6lJ

...

fll1lJl'i1fJiT'W'lJfJ'IH'lJU'VIllfffJ'lJ1\91fllllJl~1

11

1 ,: y .... f111:':ltJfl'lI9l'W'U6'1ul'j')j'119l1Jl1111~ "

1 11ijfi1~'1ulii. 73

.r:::..

(2531 : 'HI) 'VI~11l1fll

(j'l .75 1m:.: fffJl"lflll'eJ'Ifl'lJNfI fl1{:i~[J'lJ6'1

til W fl~
llftwi'lUIli f11fll1lJl
v'JJ
f

"

1\91'l:fI~fJ fl 'I (2532 : '11

u'VIti~ ~6)
iJ

~ ~'lJ11 ftl tl11lJl ~f.lJ'W 'U6'1U 'lJ1J'VII"If6111~ fl11lJl ~1 f nllfln~

~.

.71 0'1 .78 UfI:':ff6I"1flti'fl,n11Jfmfl111')U'lJ6'1

4~ ~ 'l:ffllJU 'UfJ'11111111'11"1 fffJ1J'lflfl'lllJ
q
Q I

...fl~11:.:
~

111

(2539 : 135) 1l'Ym11

.d ~

nn ~ 11lJfI1l9l'1U \91 0.641

[1'I

0.860 9f '16111 I'U 8'1lJ 1111 n

~ '1~ 'I n fill f111i1!fl~ 6 'W
... ,

~I'Ulff81JlJ

""0

11 'l'WlJ 1 tl'IJU 'VIl 11011 lU

J.

1v

J v, A~ n 1:':111 tnn tl'lJ 'W "" • "I~11f11f1'lllJ1'l:f6lJ'W lJ J:-.lfl'VIl

6.3.4 fllfl 'J llJfl fIlli1l fl ~ tI uin 911~1'W 1'U tlll11il

lJ 1911 ilt.l1

f1')(l11 lfllfll1lJfl
~

1 t.l t111V1Ii1ff611fl1 'IVI 3

....1

u f) 1 1 l1il11il £I1 <W,,911'lJ6'1 fl f1~ fJ';lilt! 1 1 tl{J 11ft "I . s3JI

lfl11lJfl

a lli1lfl~
QGJ

6 'UlJ191 'j ~1'W 1'Wn 11 11"1

.yj 1flfl ftllnl f11J 2.201 'Vi'loU61111~ 'WI'n 1 1:': tl~tJ9i 1'eJ~1'111~'U ~TlJ f111lJ
'II

lJ1:.:ff1Jfi11W

fll1lJffllJTHl

'4lI.4 P IlJUl9ltlI9l1'1fi'U 9f'lff'eJli1flt16'1fi1J'Ilt.l111£J'UfJ'I~'Ytlm

1 Q.I

IlJ'I61'Yt'U

(2533 : 1.52 0'1

, U'YIti li1utJ) 111 ~ ffrl'lU

1J1JVlIi1fffJ11 1~ fI11lJ

IoU 1111mml ij1J'Vi1 'l:flfi1'j ~ £1111lf1 2 ijftll9l'lU9i

ff~11:.:

"

1.64 UlI:':fftJlilfllltJ'If11JNflml1~t1'U6'1
lJ1\911~1'U 1'Ufill11i19l'lUIli

vmflfi~r

(2539 : 125-126) ijftlfl11lJflm~lfl~tJt.l

"

1.035 0'1 2.143

"I'JJ -'t <!I w AI"""""'" <!I v... ,V """" "" 1.1 1 'U011 I'lflfl1'eJ 'IlJfJ 1IilfllfllJ!l1JI9lU 'Ufll 1 I flfJ fi~ff '11fi'fl llfiZ II 'U'U VI11fl11lJ tl Z 16 £I1il

..

'j tJ1Jfl'Cl1J 1'"

,,(1.1'
0

~ nn )!f 'I t n'fll 'VitJ11:':'I'JJ flfI rm "IV fI 1191 111fl:':U",

'U'fl'j'l flUfl11lJ
r4

'"

~ff 'II nW11 'W91fJ'Iflfl1l11 11iI ffZli1l

9J

n(UCfI m 1 'If fl:': II'W'W111 fi'O lJ6tJ

rI"

1'"

,1;'61"'."'" rrum (J"UtJ'IIJU U11\JIm

,t!i I

fl'VI-q'il Ut'l:.:

(ll'lm:m

o.q J £IflflfJ'W mr f1llU 'U n11'1owt) fl11lJ

n l'U rnr 1 t>I:.:u'U'U If

1.2 'Ufi1nll1f1~ tJ 'IijtJ1IilfllfltJ~1J'Vi1 .. U~tl:':f11'1 lown:':1l:':'l'l11lfff''1Ifil9lfl1111ij1J'91'l1'U'UtJ'IU 1.3 1 'Um1t'hlfl~fJ

1fl'j'6'1lJt) 1ffIPJ
A ......

111'* 1~fll1

1'*ff' 'Ilfl\JIU m~ t1'WIfl'U

,

15 fl'U 1 'W

m~t1'U 1;t~n10'l 1 tll '* ~~ 11 z'll11 111.w~fJ

'Ili61'i1f1ltl11ijliVi

,uhi1'10 'Ifl11lJfi

f6lJ'UtJ'I

" I" ~I .s A 1v A <!I d Qum(U UfI:':1.Jflfl1mllJ'Wfllf1qJ '" lfit) 1t'I'I 'JJ" I 1" 'l11I"1U1:': £J'l:f'U111flfl11 'l:flmtJ'IlJt)mfi'YIlfli1

v 2. 'U 61 rru 6 11'UZ 1 m 1 ""'" u 1 'iW

81