Professional Documents
Culture Documents
अनुभूति और ज्ञान का द्वन्द
अनुभूति और ज्ञान का द्वन्द
qxd
27/11/2010
11:28 PM
Page 1
fbff-E-ffSX
Af
fb
fifQ ffff
BdfWXff
SXf
dU
d fZWXffaAffZfZ
Qdfffff
IY
AfffSX fSX fWXb f ffSX AffZ eUf IZY ffSXZ fZa fff
fiff dIYff f fIYff WX` ffSX ffff fWX WX` dIY
IZYff Bfe IZY AfffSX fSX fdf, Uf ASX dfffff
fSX AfffdSXf fff IY fVfY fbffe fWXea Qe f
fZOXIYSX fZ QVfIY fWXfZ IYWXf ff
fIYfe ffdWXSX W`X, fWXfa fffUfQ ASX AfbfcdfUfQ
dIY WXf Afe EIY SXfMX fWXea ff
IZY fef AafdUSXf JOXf WX fff WX` fWX AafdUSXf
ffE WX`a fWX fff CXWXafZ ffffdIY
Vfff IZY UYf IY fZIYSX WX` fffUfQ fZa Vfff
fffUZVf IZY faQf fZ IYWXe fe
IZY dUdff fiIYfSXa IYe fff WX` fZdIYf fiff: QZJfZ
ffffdIY fffUZVf ff WX`, dIYf Yf fZa
fZa fWXe Afff WX` dIY Vfff IZY dUdff fiIYfSX IYe
WX dIY WXf EIY SXfMX IZY Yf fZa CXfSX
fff IZY ffUcQ, Vfff IZY EIY WXe UYf IY
fIZY, Bf fSX fff dUffdffa fZ IYfRYe
fWXU dffff SXWXf WX` BfdfE Vfff IZY dJffRY
IbYL IYWXf ASX dfJf WX` fSX WXff IZY
EIY WXe fSXWX IYe fOXfB fOXe ffe SXWXe WX` faff
Uf fZa ffffdIY fffUZVf IYf fiVf
Vfff IZY dUdff fiIYfSX IZY dJffRY f WXIYSX EIYfafe
ff WX fff WX`, ff QcfSXZ VfQa fZa IYWXZa f fbf
SXWX ffff W`X ffefff, fWXb f ffSXZ Vfdff Uf Bf
CXffZ IYWXea AffZ fff fff WX` fbf fWX WX fff
fOXfB fZ ff f AffZ IY Vffdff fWXea IYSX fffZ ff
WX` dIY ffffdIY fffUZVf fSX IYf ff fIYff WX`
fOXfB IZY UYf IY fff WXe fWXea fffZ WXa`
ff BfIYe faIYfff IYSX fIYff WX`
fe fef, AfbfcdfUfQ EIY fVfY fbffe fZVf
ffdWXf IZY fff-fff fWX fiVf fff dUfff fZ
IYSXfZ WXEb Affe EIY dUdVf fWX fffff WX`
fe fbOXf WXA
b f WX` IYf ffffdIY fffUZVf IZY fbZ IY
Bf fSXWX Qfa Aff-Aff Vfff IZY fiIYfSX IY
CXNXf fIYfZ WX,a` fWX EIY fWXb f WXe ffSXfdff fiVf WX,`
ffffZ WXEb Aff-Aff fSXWX fZ fbffe fZVf IYSXfZ
dIY fff IZY fYf fZ fafadff WX` dIYfIZY fff UWX
WXa` BfIZY RYfUYf Q ffefZ QZJfZ IY dfffZ WXa`
fff WX fIYff WX,` ffffdIY fffUZVf IYe fff IYSX
fWXff fdSXfff fffUfQ fZ fafadff
fIZY ff CXfIYe AUffSXff
dUIYdff IYSX fIZY
fWXbf-fe faIYfffEa fff IZY IYfSX ffIYa IZY ffSXZ fZa WX` fWX EIY ffUfdfIY fff ASX
fUfffe faff IZY Yf fZa IYfSX
fWXfa Bf ffff IY CXNXffZ IYf
EIY Jff faQf W`X EIY fB ffSXf fZ IYe ffe SXWXe WX`a fZdIYf UZX fiff: CXfIZY UffdUIY eUf fOXfZ ffff WX` QcfSXf fdSXfff
f dfff WX` dfIY AffbfcdfIY fZ AfdSXdff, fOXe-fSXOXe fB fffB ASX faIbYdff QdMX AfbfcdfUfQ IZY UYf IY fZIYSX WX`
fff IYf fff dQff f fIYff WX` IZY AfffSX fSX IYe ffe SXWXe WX`a IYfSX ffIYa IYe fSXRY AfbfcdfUfQ IY WXe Aadff fff fZfZ
IZY RYfUYf BfIYf ffIYeIYSXf
AffbfcdfIY fff fZ ffff fWX WX` dIY
fZ fe AfUf AfB WX`, CXfZ Aff WXe SXJf fff WX` WX fff WX` ffff fWX WX` dIY AfSX
df ffbQffa fZ ffffdIY IiYSc XffEa
Vfff IYe fidIiYff fZa fWXffdfff WXe
fZfe WX,a` CXfIYf ffdSXff ffffdIY
`
fff IYf CXf ASX Adffdf IYf AdfIYfSXe WXff
fffUZVf ff ffffdfIY fdSXUff `fZ fbZ fSX fWXb f fidIiYff IYf dWXff ff IYSXYWXe CXfZ fOXf f fIYff WX?
XfSX-AffbdfIY ffffZ WXa` dIY fbfffe WXff ASX W`X, f fWXb f ffSXZ Vfdff Uf IYf Afff AfffWXUfcf WX fff WX` fWX fbf EIY ASX fiVf IY f
CXf feOXf IYe Adffdf, Qf Q dfdfffa W`X Aff AfbfUffIY fff WXff BfdfE UZ Afff
QZff WX` Bf QdMX IY fff IYf EIY fWXUfcf CXf
AfSX fff IYf IYB Uf dIYfe fe fSXWX IZY CXfeOX f dfUWXf IYSXfZ ff Affe dQVff fbffZ IZY dfE Ufaf
ffff ffE ff EIYfff fff?
CXQfSXUfdQfa fZ Bf fSX EIY Aff WXe YJ fZ fbSXf WX` f dffaQWZ X CXf feOXf IZY DYfSX CXfIYf WXa fZ fWX Ufafff fffcdWXIY f WXIYSXYAff-Aff
Afffff WX` CXfIYf fffff WX` dIY ffSXf fZa UfdfU WX` fZdIYf BfIYf fWX ffff IYfB fWXea WX` WXfe BffZ Vfdff Uf IZY fef EIYff IZY fifffa
AffbfcdfIY fff IYe fSXa fSXf IY IYfbdfMX ffdMX fa fZ dIY UWXe CXfIYf fZJIY WX fIYff WX` dfRY feOXf IY f fIYf ffZff ASX Bf EIYff IZY AffU fZa
AfSXff IY ffff QZIYSX ffWXe fSX fSX WXe fWXe, UWXf IYSXfZ fZ IYB CXfIYf fZJIY fWXea WX fff fffffSXe Uf IY WXe RYffQf fWbXafZff
Af: fffUfQ ASX AfbfcdfUfQ fZa Q faVfffa
feIYfSX dIYff WX` UZ IYWXfZ W`X dIY IYfbdfMX ffdMX f fcda IY feOXf IY fedOXf fff fZ dfdff fWXea dIYff WX,`
fZ AfafZOXIYSX ASX RbYfZ IY BfdfE Afffff WX` dfRY fbfff WX,` BfdfE BfIYf fZJIY dfRY UWXe fWXea fSX SX dQff f fIYff WX` ASX dQff fff ffdWXE
ffdIY CXfIZY SXffedfIY dWXf ff fIZY QcfSXZ VfQa WX fIYff fWX fZf ffIZY dfE Jbff WX` IYWXfZ IYf fWXff faVfff AffbfcdfIY fff IZY fWXU IY fZIYSX
fZ,a CXQfSXUfdQfa IYe fffZ fOXe dfaff fWX WX` dIY ffff WX` dIY fedOXf Uf feOXf fSX IYB fe dfJ WX` fffUfQ fZa AfbfcdfUfQ IY CXdff ASX ffff
AfbfcdfYAfffdSXf ffffff ASX BfIY WXe fff fff fIYff WX` Emff fZJf IYB fe IYSmX, CXf fZJf IY, fff dffff ffdWXE BffZ fffUfQ AdfIY
fZff CXf ffa IZY ffQff IY dfIY fff QZff, QZdSXQf IZY VfQa fZ,a dUJadOXf dIYff f fIYff WX` Bf fffdfIY ASX QZVff ff fZ faff WXff QcfSX,Z
dfIZY fff f f AffbfcdfIY fff WX` ASX f WXe UZ fSXWX CXfSX-AffbdfIY dUffSXIY dIYfe fe feOXf IYf faff IYf QffSXf CXf fZf fZa fe fPXZ ff Afe fIY
fSXIYfSX IYe dIYfe fedf IYf RYffQf CXNXf fIYfZ WXa` dWXff WXfZ IYe fidIiYff fZa Vffdff WXfZ IYe Vff IY BffZ AfLbE SXWXZ WXa` QcfSXf faVfff AfbfcdfUfQ IY
IbYf dfff IYSX, CXQfSXUfdQfa fZ AffbfcdfIY fff ASX fWXe ffffZ fZdIYf ffff fWX W`X dIY CXfSX- fZIYSX WX` AffbfcdfIY fff IY fWXU QZff BfIYf
Bf fSX AfffdSXf dIYfe fe fedf IYf dUSXf dIYff WX` AffbdfIYff ffffdIY fdSXUff IZY fbZ IY WXe MXff fffZ fOXf ffQff SXWXf WX` fZdIYf AffbfcdfIY fff
CXQfSXUfdQfa IYf dUVfff SXWXf WX` dIY faffAa IY QZfe WX,` Bf fWXf IYf fiffdfIY dfaQb WX` AfSX IZY fWXU IYeYfWX feOXf IYf dWXff SXWXZ WXfZ IYe Vff
fMXf SXJ IYSX WXe ffffdIY fffUZVf IZY ff IY ffffdIY fdSXUff IYf ffff WXe ffff ff ff WX faff IY IYfSX IYSXZ fe fWX Vff feOXf IYe dUdff
WXfdff dIYff f fIYff WX` ffdIY faffAa IY fE, dIY CXfSX-AffbdfIYff fZa UfffdUIY WXe WX Afbfcdffa IYf UfeIYSXf IYSX QZfe BffZa fWX dff fe
AffbfcdfIY fff IZY fWXfSXZ IYfe fe fMXf fWXea SXJf fff WX,` f dRYSX dIYfe fe fSXWX IZY fff IYe fff f`Qf WX fIYfe WX` dIY fWX Afbfcdf Af Afbfcdf fZ
AdfIY fcffff ff fiffadfIY W`X Emfe dfdf Aaff:
f fIYff fZdIYf CXQfSXUfdQfa IYe fffZ fOXe fff IZY Vfdff Uf IZY dfE fZfffe WX`
Bf faQf fZ QcfSXe fidfdIiYff fffUfdQfa IYe Vfdff Uf IZY EIYeIYSXf IZY SXffZ fZa YIYfUMX WXe fWXea
dUOXa fff fWX SXWXe WX` dIY UZ faffAa ASX fff IYe
fSXa fSXfAa IY fe AffUVfIY Yf fZ Ufaf ffffZ ASX fZ AfB WX` CXfIZY AfbffSX AffbfcdfIY fff IZY ffZfe, fdIY BfIYe CXfeQ fe Jf IYSX fIYfe WX`
ffaff SXff
faQf
Afa