IN THE HIGH COURT OF MALAYA AT KUALA LUMPUR (COMMERCIAL DIVISION) civiL suit No: OF 2010 BETWEEN SIME DARBY BERHAD. SIME DARBY ENGINEERING SDN BHD. SIME DARBY ENERGY SDN BHD SIME DARBY MARINE SDN BHD. SIME DARBY MARINE (HONG KONG) PTE. LTD. PLAINTIFFS. AND DATO" SERI AHMAD ZUBAIR @ AHMAD ZUBIR BIN HJ MURSHID DATO MOHAMAD SHUKRI BIN BAHAROM ABDUL RAHIM BIN ISMAIL ABDUL KADIR ALIAS MOHD. ZAKI BIN OTHMAN DEFENDANTSCONTENTS A. PARTIES (Plaintiffs (i) Defendants 8. QATAR PETROLEUM PROJECT (Background (i) The Bid for the AP Project (il) Entering into the QP Contract knowing that QP had rejected IOEC as the T & | sub- contractor and failing to make alternative appointment (iv) Failure to Properly DocumentRecord QP's alleged promises to compensate Sime Darby Engineering (¥) Deliberate withholding or concealment of critleal information (vi) Manipulation and Deliberate Concealment of Information in relation to cost overrun (vii) Wrongful appointment of Consultants (vii) Incompetent Implementation of the QP Project Pages 5-6 6-18 17-19 19-23 24 24-26 26-29 20-33 33-38 38-39c. a Ww iit) ww) o wi (wiy wit) ww Co) «xi (xii) xii) MAERSK OIL QATAR PROJECT Background Beyond the Competence or Capacity of Sime Darby Engineering to property carry out and complete the MOQ Project within time Appointment of RNZ Integrated (M) Sda Bhd as Designers for the MOQ Project Waiver of RN2's Performance Bond Incomplete and Poor Quality Design by RNZ Zero-Zero Settlement between Sime Darby Engineering and RNZ Release of Retention and other Monies to RNZ Dishonest Misrepresentation made by Shukri as to RNZ Transportation and Installation Construetion Hook-up and Commissioning Incompetent Choice of Sub-Contractors Consultants 40-42 43-44 45-46 46-47 47-48 48-49 49-51 51-82 52-58 56-87 87 58-50 59-62