"

30

_________________________________

' " ,

?
,
,
,

,

.

, :

"

30
, ' "

.-: ,
Our Rabbis taught: Simeon haPakuli23 arranged the eighteen
benedictions in order before
Rabban Gamaliel in Jabneh.
Said Rabban Gamaliel to the
Sages: Can anyone among you
frame a benediction relating to
the Minim? Samuel the Lesser
arose and composed it. The
next year he forgot it [29a] and
he tried for two or three hours
to recall it, and they did not
remove him.

_________________________________

"




"


,

"

30

_________________________________

' " ,

,.
?

.

.

"

30

_________________________________

!?

.

!?

( )

,
,.

' " ,

,.

"

30

_________________________________

!?

"

' " ,

,.

"

30

_________________________________

' " ,

,.

?



?

"

30
, ' "

_________________________________

p. 1
1. How would you interpret

?
p. 2
2. What is ? Who composed it? What happened?
p. 3
3. What is asked? What is offered?
p. 4
4. What is asked? What does offer?
5. What does the raise on ?What does it offer?
p. 5
6. What does the raise?
7. What are the facts of and s ?
p. 6
8. Why is there no problem for ?
9. What is the problem for ?
10. What is s theory?
11. How will explain the case of ?
12. Has your interpretation of

changed? Do tell.