Chapter # 2
The Analysis of Some Major
Administrative Reforms in Pakistan
Chapter Two of the study provides details on some of the Major Administrative Reforms
in Pakistan. The government of Pakistan has introduced numerous administrative reforms
but for the sack of convenience and keeping in view the relevaricy of the reforms with the
present study, only four initiatives have been selected for discussion. These are: (1) the
separation of judiciary from the executive, (2) the establishment of Ombudsman office
(3) the Devolution of Power Plan, a scheme of local government and (4) the introduction
and establishment of the National Accountability Bureau.
2.1 Introduction
Administrative reforms have existed ever since men conceived better ways of organizing
their social activities. Yet the phenomenon has not received any systematic analysis. In
the twentieth century almost all the countries witnessed a change from laissez-faire to
regulation, from individualism to collectivism and from a state with limited powers to
welfare and service state. Now the expectation, of its people, from the government is not
only to protect them from external aggression and internal disturbances but the demand
of the people is that the government must solve their problems rather than merely define
their rights. It is also expected from the goverment to take care of its citizens from
cradle to grave Therefore the development of administrative process has become the
essential element of the modern political philosaphy
The need for administrative reforms was felt because the increase in state functions
further widened the gap between a government official and a private citizen, Prof Massey
(1995: 365) has very truly observed the prevailing situation. He says, “Any good system
of administration, in the ultimate analysis, hias to be responsible and responsive to the
103people. But history bears witness to the fact that more often the impersonal bureaucratic
system advertently or inadvertently tries to overwhelm the ‘little man’.
The people of the sub-continent had shown their interest to establish a friendly
administration but this dream could never come true till the creation of independent
States in the sub-continent, After independence the need for administrative reforms was
felt much strongly than before because the independence raised the expectations and
hopes of the people for a better standard of living. The people of newly created State saw
the answer to the problem of inefficiency in the public sector in the process of
administrative reforms. According to Dr Shah, administrative reform is considered to be
an essential ingredient of development in any country, irrespective of the speed and
direction of change, simply because administrative capability becomes increasingly
important in the implementation of new policies, plans and ideas. (Shab,
www intanbk intan.my dated 15-10-03)
Since independence till the day, the Government of Pakistan has made several attempts to
reform its administrative organ. This chapter deals, only, with the reforms that are closely
related with the present study because it is not possible to discuss all the initiated reforms
or successfully completed reforms. The reforms selected for discussion are the following
* Separation of judicial and executive powers
The establishment of Ombudsman office
* National Accountability Bureau and
* The Devolution of Power Pian
2.2 Admini:
ative Reforms and the Impediments
Since the inception of Pakistan, the necessity and urgency of redesigning the bureaucratic
structure have persistently and constantly been felt. The paramount objective of the
colonial bureaucratic structure, which we inherited from the British was predominantly
designed for conventional administration, ie. the maintenance of internal law and order
situation and the collection of revenue. Independence shifted the focus from conventional
104to Development Administration. It was therefore considered and desired to design a
rationalized structure of public administration, having a pragmatic approach, progressive
out-look and whole-bearted dedication to the development of the country and to the
service of the people
The review of literature on the subject in hand reveals that the government on a piece-
meal basis conducted most of the administrative reform programmes. This can be
attributed to tack of expertise or due to involvement of huge expenditure for carrying
such a massive and complicated exercise or there must be some problem in practically
implementing the said programme
For the last three decades, the political regimes of Pakistan have done more harm than
good to the over all situation of the country in general and the administrative sector has
been affected in particular, Not only have they encouraged partisan feelings and
corruption but due te political interference incompetent people were promoted and posted
at important places as well. So it can be said, without any hesitation, that the country has
suffered setbacks in different sectors due to many reasons. But two of the chief culprits in
the poor situation in the country were and are political interference and bureaucratic
bungling. However, steps are being taken presently to make the administrative sector
transparent and efficient. It is, in fact the public administration infrastructure that greatly
influences the quality and outcome of national activities in economic and social
development, (Khan, Afiab wow jang.com )
The administrative sector of Pakistan is faced with a number of problems;
Dr Haider (1979: 142-147) has pointed out some elements that have impeded the process
of improvement in the public administration, “over-emphasis on authority in
administration has impaired productivity and stifled dynamism of the subordinate public
service”. This emphasis on authority is the first element that has discouraged the effective
participation of employees at all level in government departments