Table 3 Comparison of Improved Simplex Algorithm with other Optimization Algorithms

Optimization
Function

De Jong
De Jong with moved
axis
Quadruple
Powell
Moved axis parallel
hyper-ellipsoid
Zarakav
Schwefel
Sum of different
power
Step
Rosenbrock
Biggs Exp6
Colvitte
Wood

GA

DE

Success
rate
44%
60%

Comp.
time(s)
153.435
152.184

Success
rate
100%
100%

100%
Failure
Failure

46.6543 80%
10%
85%

Failure
Failure
100%

Failure
Failure
141.422 Failure

35%
Failure
Failure
Failure
Failure

166.335 95%
Failure
10%
Failure
Failure

PSO

SIMI

Comp.
time(s)
111.45
122.30

Success Comp.
rate
time(s)
96%
5.5137
Failure

Success
rate
100%
100%

Comp.
time(s)
0.3450
0.4450

117.85
173.76
123.50

100%
100%
96%

0.0840
4.5735
9.7553

100%
100%
100%

0.2541
1.1455
0.7254

96%
32%
100%

5.2152 100%
89.9445 100%
0.06425 100%

1.1444
0.9587
1.7978

80%
Failure
4%
Failure
Failure

23.1161 100%
54%
126.276 27%
40%
44%

0.3992
10.107
9.0644
5.6746
7.7333

121.09
160.05