You are on page 1of 11

Definition: Employee satisfaction is the terminology used to describe whether employees are happy and contented and fulfilling

their desires and needs at work. Many measures purport that employee satisfaction is a factor in employee motivation, employee goal achievement, and positive employee morale in the workplace. Employee satisfaction, while generally a positive in your organization, can also be a downer if mediocre employees stay because they are satisfied with your work environment. Factors contributing to employee satisfaction include treating employees with respect, providing regular employee recognition, empowering employees, offering above industry-average benefits and compensation, providing employee perks and company activities, and positive management within a success framework of goals, measurements, and expectations. Employee satisfaction is often measured by anonymous employee satisfaction surveys administered periodically that gauge employee satisfaction. (I do not support these.) Employee satisfaction is looked at in areas such as:

management, understanding of mission and vision, empowerment, teamwork, communication, and coworker interaction.

The facets of employee satisfaction measured vary from company to company. A second method used to measure employee satisfaction is meeting with small groups of employees and asking the same questions verbally. Depending on the culture of the company, either method can contribute knowledge about employee satisfaction to managers and employees. Exit interviews are another way to assess employee satisfaction in that satisfied employees rarely leave companies.

Before you can improve employee satisfaction and employee engagement, you need to know what to improve. The annual Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) 2011 Employee Job Satisfaction and Engagement Survey identifies the factors that are important in employee job satisfaction and employee engagement as perceived by employees. The surveys purpose is to assist employers to develop the right programs and practices when they seek to have an impact on these two factors that are critical to employee morale and motivation. Understanding employee preferences provides guidance for the knowledgeable allocation of resources. The survey explored 35 aspects of employee job satisfaction, divided into four topic areascareer development, relationship with management, compensation and benefits, and work environment. Added in 2011, the survey also explored employee engagement. Satisfaction Survey Results

According to this study, 83% of U.S. employees reported overall satisfaction with their current job, with 41% of employees indicating they were very satisfied and 42% somewhat satisfied. Despite this high percentage of satisfied employees, the level of overall satisfaction has been trending downward since 2009. Employees in organizations that had fewer than 100 employees expressed satisfaction more frequently than employers in larger organizations with 2500 or more employees. SHRM found no significant differences in overall job satisfaction by employee industry, job tenure, race or gender. Engagement, however, is a different story. The U.S. has a problem with employee engagement. In this years SHRM survey, employees were only moderately engaged (3.6) on a scale of 1 to 5, where 5 is highly engaged. Findings by the Gallup organization about disengaged employees were highlighted in the Wall Street Journal. Gallup found 19% of 1,000 people interviewed "actively disengaged" at work. These workers complain that they don't have the tools they need to do their jobs. They don't know what is expected of them. Their bosses don't listen to them. Top 10 Contributors to Employee Job Satisfaction Employees identified these factors as their top 10 most important contributors to their job satisfaction.

Job security: 63%, for the fourth consecutive year, as the top most important determinant of job satisfaction. (67% of employees are very satisfied or satisfied with their job security.) Opportunities to Use Skills and Abilities: 62%. (74% are satisfied or very satisfied in their workplace.) Organizations Financial Stability: 55%. (63% are satisfied or very satisfied.) Relationship with Immediate Supervisor: 55%. (73% are satisfied or very satisfied.) Compensation: 54%. (61% are satisfied or very satisfied.) Benefits: 53%. (65% are satisfied or very satisfied.) Communication between Employees and Senior Management: 53% (54% are satisfied or very satisfied.) The Work Itself: 53%. (76% are satisfied or very satisfied.) Autonomy and independence: 52%. (69% are satisfied or very satisfied.) Managements Recognition of Employee Performance: 49%. (57% are satisfied or very satisfied.) Feeling Safe at Work: 48%. (78% are satisfied or very satisfied.) Overall Corporate Culture: 46%. (60% are satisfied or very satisfied.) Flexibility for Work-Life Balance: 38%. (65% are satisfied or very satisfied.) Relationships with Coworkers: 38%. (76% are satisfied or very satisfied.)

SHRM Reports that Benefits which had been in the top two contributors to job satisfaction since 2002, slipped to fifth place. Relationship with immediate supervisor is new this year to the list of top five most important job satisfaction contributors. Among SHRMs other results: Chance for career advancement (36%) has been declining since 2002. Coaching, mentoring, and succession planning are less important in companies with less than 100 employees. 18 Employee Engagement Conditions Employee engagement, according to the SHRM report, is more likely to occur when certain conditions exist. Employers can maximize employee engagement via improving these factors. The percentages indicate the overall satisfaction of employees with the listed condition of engagement. The items are listed in order from the employee survey results: most satisfied to least satisfied with the condition in their organization.

The work itself: 76% Relationships with co-workers: 76% Opportunities to use skills and abilities: 74% Relationship with immediate supervisor: 73% Contribution of work to organizations business goals: 71% Autonomy and independence: 69% Meaningfulness of job: 69% Variety of work: 68% Organizations financial stability: 63% Overall corporate culture: 60% Managements recognition of employee job performance: 57% Job-specific training: 55% Communication between employees and senior management: 54% Organizations commitment to professional development: 54% Networking: 49% Organizations commitment to corporate social responsibility: 49% Career development opportunities: 48% Career advancement opportunities: 42%

With the percentages noted in both the satisfaction portion of the survey results and the engagement aspects of the survey, employers have some work to do to fully satisfy and, especially, engage employees. Note that four aspects of employee career and professional development fall in the bottom seven for employee satisfaction:

Job-specific training Organization's committment to professional development Career development opportunities Career advancement opportunities

Members of SHRM can download the whole report at no cost. How to Improve Employee Satisfaction and Engagement Are you interested in how your organization can improve your employee engagement and employee satisfaction? Take a look at these additional resources.

Keys to Employee Satisfaction: What You Can Do to Increase Employee Satisfaction Employee Engagement: Create a Work Environment That Encourages Employee Engagement Management Matters Most in Motivation 7 Ways to Foster Employee Motivation - Today How Managers Motivate Employees

Employee Satisfaction gift 400 368 - 31k - jpg cartoonstock.com

Employee Job Satisfaction 660 492 - 37k - gif callcentercomics.com

an employee satisfaction 650 492 - 28k - jpg qualtrics.com

and employee satisfaction. 324 305 - 24k - jpg joe.org

Employee Satisfaction gift 328 400 - 30k - jpg cartoonstock.com

Build a employee satisfaction 285 195 - 53k - jpg alphameasure.com

Employee Satisfaction Employee Satisfaction 425 282 - 134k - jpg Survey employeesurveys.com 300 449 - 77k - jpg lrims.com

Employee satisfaction is very Employee Satisfaction employee satisfaction 400 282 - 105k - gif 560 470 - 10k - png 300 300 - 10k - jpg mgmt280.blogspot.com analysesurvey.com enteryourhours.com

Employee Satisfaction 362 362 - 161k - jpg preres.com

from employee Employee Satisfaction employee survey and satisfaction customer 480 371 - 51k - png 554 400 - 140k - jpg 435 388 - 15k - gif finntrack.co.uk davidzinger.wordpress.com quantisoft.com

EMPLOYEE SATISFACTION 471 330 - 31k - jpg valcon.in

Employee Satisfaction 310 240 - 101k - png highestpayingjobsguide...

Employee satisfaction surveys 576 341 - 22k - jpg lrims.com

Employee Satisfaction employee satisfaction and 357 333 - 20k - jpeg 432 411 - 20k - gif nz.nielsen.com quantisoft.com

The Importance of Employee Satisfaction


Kristen Gregory Introduction Employee satisfaction is essential to the success of any business. A high rate of employee contentedness is directly related to a lower turnover rate. Thus, keeping employees satisfied with their careers should be a major priority for every employer. While this is a well known fact in management practices, economic downturns like the current one seem to cause employers to ignore it. There are numerous reasons why employees can become discouraged with their jobs and resign, including high stress, lack of communication within the company, lack of recognition, or limited opportunity for growth. Management should actively seek to improve these factors if they hope to lower their turnover rate. Even in an economic downturn, turnover is an expense best avoided. The Starting Point An employee who has no interest in his or her field, or the position in which he or she begins in a job, may initially put forth his or her best effort. However, this employee will often become bored with the work because there is no intrinsic motivation to succeed. Finding the daily job mundane reduces the individuals desire to show up to work and to do the job well. In this case, the employee may continue to come to work, but his or her efforts will be minimal. In contrast, an employee may be entirely too overwhelmed to handle the position; the responsibilities may prove to be too demanding. In an instance like this, the employee will search for another position that offers the financial security he or she needs with job characteristics that challenge them appropriately; thus increasing the initial companys turnover rate (Koslowsky & Krausz, 2002). The Sources and Effect of Stress Stress is one of the leading causes of employees discontentment with their job. Branham (2005) asserts that, it seems clear that one quarter to one half of all workers are feeling some level of dysfunction due to stress, which is undoubtedly having a negative impact on their productivity and the probability that they will stay with their employers. Stress can have many causes, including when companies cannot, or will not, supply the tools necessary to produce or work efficiently while on the job. This produces higher stress levels because these workers are expected to perform at certain rates, yet they are unable to do so. This results in lower productivity and higher turnover because quotas cannot be met by the employees on staff. Knowing that management is able to provide the tools essential for the position is crucial to the employee trusting the intentions of their employer.

Another source of stress is the now common practice of employers which attempts to cut costs by eliminating positions and disbursing the workload to other employees. The issue that arises is that tasks will not be performed effectively or efficiently because the employees become more concerned with having an overbearing workload. Consequently, the efforts of these employees fail to reach their own, or their employers, standards. These actions, and employee responses to them, result in employees who attempt to finish incomplete work assignments during personal time, such as lunch breaks, in an effort to keep their jobs (Branham, 2005). When a company expects their employees to perform outside normal working hours, it detracts from those employees relaxation time. Personal time is essential in maintaining relationships, personal wellbeing, and sanity. The extra strain of needing to finish an unreasonable amount of work to keep the job dramatically increases
30 31

employee anxiety. Employees that struggle to finish their tasks become less likely to attempt advancement and more likely to begin the search for a new job elsewhere. Those who do not attempt to complete all of the assignments are eventually terminated. The termination of some employees also causes stress to the remaining employees. Those remaining begin to wonder whether they are going to be the next people on the chopping block. The excessive strain can have a very detrimental effect. Employers that are untrustworthy are a burden to their employees and may cause stress. Distrust can result from a variety of situations (Branham, 2005). Harassment, in any form, may cause a new level of stress for the employee. It becomes increasingly difficult to do a respectable job at work when one is consistently faced with an uncomfortable working environment. This anxiety is caused by trying to avoid troublesome confrontations and situations. Workers may agonize about the consequences they would face if the harassment were to be reported, as well as the repercussions of not reporting it. Other Sources of Employee Dissatisfaction Dissatisfaction with the job may come from sources other than stress or poor fit between employee and job. Employers that are deemed unethical by their workers may be viewed as such because they appear to care exclusively about company revenues, rather than the employees that are working for them. This perception of an employer may lead to job dissatisfaction, and raise the companys turnover rate. Dissatisfaction may also arise, with the same result in turnover, when the work environment fails to have any flexibility or any source of amusement for the employees; the tone of the business will become stressful or tedious (Kaye & Jordan-Evans, 1999). Lack of communication in the workforce is a major contributor to dissatisfaction. This is usually the result of managerial staff that is isolated and does not know how to relate to their employees on a personal or professional level (Branham, 2005). Bad communication leaves employees feeling disconnected from the organization. This is
32

detrimental to the wellbeing of the company because when an employee feels neglected, he or she will tend to perform at a lower level. This employee becomes unsure of his or her position within the company, and wonders what his or her purpose is within the workplace. Employees may be unaware of how their performance measures up to that of their co-workers and have no sense of how they can improve. Without communication, it becomes difficult for employees to make any progress in their efficiency. Employees want to know that their employers recognize their achievements in the workplace. They need to feel appreciated, as

workers and as people (Branham, 2005). Often companies become more focused on production and revenues, rather than with their own employees, or even their customers. In the case of employees, the employees may rarely be praised for the quality of their performance. If a company does performance appraisals, the results may be given in such a harsh tone that, rather than motivating an employee, it intimidates and an employee may feel uncomfortable in the workplace, rather than encouraged to achieve more. It may be common for upper management in some workplaces, to take the ideas of lower level employees lightly, which leaves these employees feeling neglected and worthless. It becomes difficult for workers to see a bright future while working for the company. If an employee fails to see a future with the company, why would they work to produce results? Those employees who do work well to support the company may not be compensated for their efforts. Employers that choose to under-compensate know that these employees will work hard for minimal pay, and these employers will compensate accordingly (Timpe, 1986). At the same time, the same employers will pay more to other employees who are not willing to work for minimal compensation. This compensation disparity leads to dissatisfaction because eventually the hard worker will notice that he or she is not being compensated fairly for the amount of work they are doing, and will begin searching for another company that will appreciate his or her labor.
33

Finally, failure to provide employees with opportunities to grow within the company results in employee frustration. Barriers within the company may prevent some employees from reaching their full potential (Branham, 2005). Such barriers may include favoritism of certain employees or company policies requiring hiring from outside the company. Glass ceilings for minority employees may also cause difficulty in advancement. Organizations that do not provide sufficient training opportunities for employees are also doing themselves a disservice. These organizations are missing out on employees that are dedicated to their companies and knowledgeable in their fields, and with sufficient training, have the potential to do well in higher positions. Why Should an Employer Care? It is important that employers care about the happiness of their employees. Recent statistics show that throughout their careers, American workers hold an average of eight jobs (Rudman, 2003). The rate of turnover because employees are unhappy is alarming. Even is an economic downturn, employers must spend an enormous amount of money recruiting new employees, going through the hiring process, and finally training new employees. Dissatisfaction has many negative side effects for the company, while satisfaction results in a much better retention rate. The effects of dissatisfaction that results in an employees withdrawal from job and company can range from mild to severe. Tardiness, in showing up for work and coming back from breaks, shows a lack of interest by the employee for his or her responsibilities. This may escalate to the employee not showing up to work entirely. Some less obvious signs of withdrawal from the job include: taking care of personal matters while at work, playing games, engaging in non-work related talk, spending time on social networks, and diminishing job performance. These withdrawal behaviors, when evidence of dissatisfaction, may end with an employee leaving the workplace; the heuristic model posits that thinking of quitting is the most probable
34

outcome of job dissatisfaction ( Koslowsky & Krausz, 2002). Therefore, withdrawal will lead either to the employee voluntarily leaving the organization or being terminated for unprofessional behavior.

Happiness in the workplace leads to much higher levels of productivity. It increases employee morale; therefore employees are more willing to work harder to improve the company and its goals. According to Branham (2005), Gallup studies show that businesses with higher employee satisfaction also have: 86% higher customer ratings 76% more success in lowering turnover 70% higher profitability 44% higher profitability 78% better safety records. Companies need good, knowledgeable employees. If these employees are not treated fairly, they are going to take advantage of other job offers that will provide more stability, more benefits, and more compensation. What Should the Employer Do? The employer has a responsibility to ensure the satisfaction of all of its employees. There are many precautions that managers can take to make certain that they are meeting the working needs of their employees. Employers also should be more cautious during the hiring process. Having multiple people interviewing final candidates will help ensure that the employee will work well with the company. During interviews, employers should ask questions relating to the type of work that the potential employee enjoys doing. It is imperative to match the personal characteristics and values of the employee with the organization. Employers should prepare for the interview by doing a job assessment to see what skills are necessary for the position, then testing applicants to see if they have the ability to be trained to the position and have the skills and knowledge that correspond with the job description (Kaye & Jordan-Evans, 1999). It is critical that during this phase, the employer give an accurate description of the job to candidates so they can prepare for the challenges ahead. Managers must learn to communicate better with lower level employees. Connection to the company gives staff a better feeling of belonging and worth. Supervisors should set an example by promoting friendly relationships with the staff so the work environment is healthier (Kaye & Jordan-Evans, 1999). They need to learn to listen to the employees when they have a concern or a question about the work that they are doing or the direction that the company is taking. It is imperative that managers show respect for all employees, their opinions, and their work. Managers need to convey a good understanding of the mission and goals that the company is trying to attain so that the staff recognizes what the organization is working toward. Clarification, of the expectations associated with different positions, assists employees in comprehending their direct relationship with the company and how their work affects that of others. Performance reviews are a good managerial tool because they give administrators an idea of those employees that are contributing to the organizations success and those who need to work harder (Branham, 2005). It also offers employees the ability to gauge their performance. Often, employees will think that they are performing better or worse than their managers perceive their work to be. The performance review presents the perfect time to bring together these different perspectives, to correct negative behavior, and to reward productivity. Providing employees with the opportunity for growth is also a major contributor to satisfaction. Because performing the same job becomes uninteresting, it is important to challenge employees with work that they can accomplish but stretches their abilities (Timpe, 1986). It is a good opportunity to see the abilities of lower level employees. Giving employees new projects or goals allows them to become creative and skilled in new areas. This broadens their knowledge while they become a more valuable asset to the company. Lateral movement does not change the status of the employee, but helps

them learn more about different aspects of the company. Doing another job entirely gives the employee a change of pace and direction. The
35

employee may find that they enjoy a different branch of the workforce better than the one previously held. Recognition of an employees hard work is essential to his or her satisfaction in the workplace (Kaye & Jordan-Evans, 1999). Letting employees in on the decision making processes gives those employees a feeling that their opinions are respected and that they hold a place of importance within the company. Pay is a huge motivator for many employees. Making the connection between money and performance motivates employees to be more productive and to go the extra mile (Timpe, 1986). Caring about employees on a personal level is important as well. Let them know that the work that they do, the lives that they lead, also are of benefit to the company. The employer can make sure that employees are aware of their achievements. These employers can show appreciation for those achievements. Conversely, employers should take notice when employees become overwhelmed and attempt to alleviate the daily burden by adding more help when it is obviously needed. Conclusion Management should have a positive effect on, and seek to support the happiness of, the firms employees. Reasons for this are not solely to benefit the employees as companies also stand to gain from employee satisfaction. In an economic environment like the current one, employers often disregard the costs associated with unhappy employees, seemingly believing that these employees are stuck in their current positions and will tolerate unpleasant working environments. This, however, is not the case. Many reasons for employee dissatisfaction are well within the control of the firm and good management practices will enable a company to diminish, or remove, those reasons. Satisfied employees will work harder for the company and plan to stay at the company, ultimately reducing that companys labor costs.
36 37

References
Branham, L. (2005). The 7 hidden reasons employees leave: How to recognize the subtle signs and act before its too late. New York, NY: Amacom. Clutterbuck, David. (2007). Coaching the team at work. London: Nicholas Brealey International. Kaye, B. & Jordan-Evans, S. (1999). Loveem or loseem. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler Publishers. Koslowsky, M. & Krausz, M. (2002). Voluntary employee withdrawal and inattendance. New York: Plenum Publishers. Rudman, R. (2003). Performance planning & review: 2nd edition. Sydney, Australia: Allen and Unwin Academic. Timpe, A. D. (1986). Motivation of personnel: The art and science of management. New York: Facts on File Publications..

Please rate your responses [on a scale of one to 10]. Feel free to use the back of these sheets for additional comments. 1. How happy are you with your job overall? [1 = Not happy at all/10 = Ecstatic] 8. Allow alternative work schedules for salaried workers, like a 4 day work week with 10-hour shifts. 2. How do you feel about your benefits at Wild Oats? [1 = Terrible/10 = Great] 7. Love the profit sharing -- real incentive! How about more "carrots" to keep people more long term -retirement benefit?

3. How do you feel about the pay levels at Wild Oats as compared to similar employers? [1 = Worse than most/10 = Better than most] 7. Not having such a low ceiling for hourly workers. 4. How do you feel about the employee-review system at Wild Oats? [1 = Hate it /10 = Love it] 4. Need retroactive pay when managers are late getting reviews done! 5. How is the overall morale in your store? [1 = Awful/10 = Wonderful] 7 6. How do you feel about the responsibilities of your job? [1 = Too little/10 = Too much] 6 7. How effective is your store manager? [1 = Very poor/10 = Very good] 6 8. How effective is your department manager? [1 = Remarkably bad/10 = Terrific] 8. Easy to talk to, open to suggestions. 9. Why do you come to work every day? [1 = Have to/10 = Want to] 1. I didn't win the lottery! 10. How does Wild Oats compare with your previous employers? [1 = Worse/5 = Same/10 = Much better] 8. Like overall store concept -- ethics, consciousness, attitude. 11. What department do you work in? (optional) Deli 12. How long have you worked for Wild Oats? 4 months 13. How do you feel about the training and orientation program you experiences when you started? Do you feel you understand the procedures, policies, and responsibilities that are part of your job? How would you change things? Should be more standardized so all employees learn the job the same way. 14. What do you like least about you job and/or the company? Please explain. Not enough time to do the job. 15. What do you like most about the job and/or the company? Please explain. People, atmosphere. 16. What would you change if you were the owner? Use more local vendors! Give good support to general managers. Michael Gilliland explains how the system keeps the owners in touch: *** 1. I'm looking for an overall mood. Some employees circle a very high grade, then rag on you on 20 different points. Maybe they haven't thought their responses through very thoroughly. 2. Even now that we've added the wellness benefit, health insurance is still an issue we hear about. Because of the response to this question, this year we're going to increase the company's contribution from 50% to 94% for employees with at least one year's service. 3. We used to ask, "What do you think about your pay?" but, of course, the response was

always bad. The new phrasing helps us make adjustments based on employee feedback comparing our pay with industry averages. 4. Since we started this, the number one complaint was that reviews weren't done on time, so we've made raises retroactive. And people want their managers to spend some time with them on reviews, instead of just grabbing them in the aisle and saying, "You're doing OK." So in the last six months we've hired three full-time training and review people. 5. If the person is happy (#1) but reports low store morale, it could be that the store is understaffed. Some of our managers get overzealous in cutting costs for the profit-sharing program. 8. In our large stores, responsibility is decentralized, and a department manager can have more effect on an employee than a store manager might. We can learn a lot, especially if the employee answers question #11. 9. Once a person answered, "Greed." Another wrote, "To meet women." This is a mood indicator -- I want to see that I've created a fun place to come to. If everyone answers, "To get a paycheck," I'll know there's a problem. 10. This is the first section I go to, because I want to make sure we're being competitive. I want people to be happier at Wild Oats than at other places they've worked, and most have worked at other grocery stores. 12. I'm most interested in new people's impressions and their fresh look at the company. I figure the people who've been here for years are probably pretty much satisfied. 16. I like to see two pages of suggestions. I'm looking for thoughtful responses and a keen eye for retail -- half a dozen suggestions says this person really has a future with Wild Oats, and this kind of person usually volunteers his or her name on the survey. I don't mind seeing criticism, either.

ss

You might also like