..

""
.
.
..
..

'

1
.
.
.

.,(
),

2
.
)
)
.,,
.

3
B'
,
',''

.
.
.
.
.
)
)
)

.
)

4
)'.
'

)'.
'

.
.
.'(381)


5
.'

.
,
1) Filioque
2) Filioque

.
.
..
.1984/93
...

""
.
.
.

.
,'
,'
.''
'
,
.
'2.
'..
'..
'

.
'
,
.
,

,.
.
,,
,.

,
,
,,
.

.
,
,.,
,,
,.
'

,,
.

.,

.
.

..,
.
,
.
.

...
.

....,
,.
.

.
,
.

1
1:

.
.
.
.,(
),
.
.

'

.
.
,

.
.

,'

,
.
,
.
,
.

.,,

.
,
.
,
,
.
,

.
,,
,
,
.

,
.
',

,
.
,,

.
1)

,,,
,2)
,
,

,.
,

.
.

,,
.

,
.
'1)
,,
,,,2)
,,
,,,,,,
...

.,
,
,,
.
,
,
.
1)
2),
.
',''.
',,
'.

',',','.
,
',
',879,'',
869,.21
.
,,,
'

.
11
Filioque

''..3

10

14
,
,,
,
.

'

,
.
.
,,
,
,,,
.

.
,

,
,
,
.,
,
,

.
,,,
,
,
.,

,
.
,

.
.

11


,
,
,

,
.
,
,
,",,,,
.,,,
,',,'.,
,,
,.
,.;
,
,
,.,,
,.;,
,,
,,,,
,.,
;,'
,,,
,,
(),,
,',
".1
,,,
".
.,,
,.,
,
,,,
,,,,
.,,
,,,,
.,,
,,,
,...,
;"2

",
,,".
""
,,.
,
.

12

',
,,
,.

,
,,
,,,,.
,,
,
,
,

,"
,,
,,,,
.,,
,,,
,,,,
,',
,,,
,,,
,,,,
,
,,." 3
",,
,,,
,,,,
,,.,
,,,,
.,
,,,,
,,
,,
.
,
,,
,,'
,,,,
,.
,....,
,.
,
,,
,."4
,
,.,
,,
,,
,,

13

.
,,,
,
.
,,,,,

,'

.5

,
.

,.
',

,'
.

,,
,,
,

.
,
,
,
,
,

,,,
,
,
',
,,,

,
,,
,,,,,
...
,.

,
,
,.

14

,
,
,,

,,
,
,

.,

'

,,

.
,,,

.1
',
.

,
,.3

.
,
,.4

,
,
14,
'.5
,
,
,'

15

,
.6

.7

.
'',
,
.
1439
'
.

1821,

,
.
,
'""

'
"",
,

,
,,.

,
,
.

,,
,
.

16

,.

.
1314

,
.

.8
,,
,

,.

,
,
,
,,

,.

''

,)
,

11

.,),
,
.9

17


1821.
,'

,,'
.879,'.

.
,,
.

.10
,

..
,,
,,
,
..
,,
.

'(
),

,
.
.

.'.(381)
.
.

18

'(431),
,,,
.
'
.,
.
,1,
,
.
, 2
,,

.
,
.

'.
.
,3
,,
,,.
,4,,

,
.,
.

5
.6
,,
7

.,
,.8
,
.
,
''
,
.',
,
,
.

19


,
...
.,
,
,
,.
,
,
,
,,.9
,
529
(Orange).2
5.12:"Per
unumhominempeccatumintravitinmundum[mundo],etperpeccatummors,etitain
omneshomines[mors]pertransiit,inquoomnespeccaverunt".
'.

.
,,

.
',
.'
,
.

','

,
.
'

,
.7
,
.10
.11
,'
,12
.13
.
,7,
,
,
,
.14

20

,Filioque,
,
,
"","",
,.
8,Filioque
,
,,
.15
808'
,,809,
,Filioque
.
.
,

,,,
.

.
.

.Filioque
,
'.
,,,
.
,,Filioque
,
""(Contra
erroresGraecorum)9.16
,
Filioque,

.
,
,

.17

,18
,
.

21

'.879,
Filioque'.
.19

,
.
'

,,.

,
,
8.
,

,,'..
,
,
,
.
,
,
,
.
'.
1009
'
'
(),()
.20
8671009
.867
',

22

962963

81009,

.21

811'

,
.,,,

'.

,,,
,.

,
1009,
(.)"
".[22]

,
.[23]
,
.
,

,
,
,,,.

11
.

(,
,,),

.24

23

.
1011,
,1500

,
,
.25
,'
,

.26

,
10(920)
,27
,
.

.
()

.
1075'
,
,
.
,1071

.
.,

'
.

24

',11,
,
.

,.
,
.

.
.
,

.
.

.
.
,
,

.12
'.. 29
'.872Filioque
.
'.
,
Filioque,
,
'879
869,
'.. 30

Filioque.

"",
Filioque.

1009
.

.31

25

.12
'.
.

11,.

.
,
,89,
Filioque.
,,
,
,,
,
,

.
,
,

.
'
.
,
,,
..
,.
,
.

,
Filioque,

. 33

26

'

,
'
(
).

.
'
,,

,
.

,
.

111

,
,,""""
9,
Filioque.2

.'
.3

'.4
'

,,,
',

.5
9,1011

,
,,

,
1009.6

27

,)
,

.
,,
.
.

Filioque'..

,Filioque'
..8
1009
,

'.Filioque,9
,

.10

,
.
Filioque'.
,'
,
,,,
,. 12

, 13'
''
,
.14
'867

',14()

962315
1009().

28

1054,,
,
Filioque
,,.16
,
1054

.17,
,

.18
.

, 19
.201054

'.21

722
. 23

,',
.

,"'
".24

.
,",
,
,,
".25
'
'
1009.26
,"
,
.
,'.27
',.
28
',

29


Filioque.29
,
.30
,"
.
,,
,
;"31
,"
,".32

1054

Filioque.33
Filioque'.
,",,...
,".34
1054

.
1054
1009
Filioque.
1009Filioque,
,
'.Filioque.

1054,Filioque
.

,
,.

1),2)'.
,3)Filioque,4)
Filioque5)9"
"(ContraerroresGraecorum),35,
8,.
,
,

30

,
,.

,
,
.
,
,
.
,,
,
(
).,

,
.
.
.
.
,1821.
.
.

,
,
.
,

,
,
.

,,

,
,
,.
,

31


"".

,,

,
.

,
,(..Toynbee)
,
.

,
,
()
,
.

,,
.

,.
1)
))
,
.,,

.
2)
,

'

32

3)

.
4).
5)
,

.,

.
,

;
(),
,,,...,
'.
,
,

,
,,,,,,...
.
,
,
;
,

.
,
;
;
,;,;
,;,;
,;
.

,
.'
,.
,

33

.'""
,
.
,
.
'.

.
,
.,,

.
"
".

,
,
))
)
,,

(1)(,
,)

,
(2)

(2)(1),
,
"",
"".

.,
.

)
,)
.
,

,
.

34

,
.

.
.

,
.36

.
.
,
,,,
,

'

.'

,,
,
.
,''
,
.,

.
,
.

,
,'.

35

,
,'
,

,
.

,,

,
,"
,,
,
,
,
".1

,
"".

,,
",
".,

.,,
.
.

.
,",
,,
,,,
;,
,,;;.
,,(
)
,,,,

36

,,
,
,;" 2
,
.
.

,
,",,
,;,,
,,
,,,.,
,3,,,'.
,,,,
,,
,4'.,()
,,'
,,,. 5,
','
,,,
.,,
,,,6
.7,
.,,
,,
,,,
".8
""
'

."'
.........
",,
.

,,
..
,
.
,
.
,'"
()......"
,.
.

37

1)
'
.
,,...
.'

,
.
2),,,
,
,
.
,',
,.

:
1).
2),.
3)'
.
4)
.
5)
,.

,
,.

,.
,
.226342,
,"
,;;
;,;"9
,
.
.

,"
,,,,,
,,

38

,
.
,,
.,.
,,
,"10

,,
.

,.12

,
,.

..13

.
"","
,,.
',,
,,". 14

,
.

,",,,,
'(),15,,
,.
,,,,".16
,
,,
'
.
;
;
.
.
.

39

.
,,"
".

.
,,,,
.
,
.,
,
.
,,,
,
,
,18
.
,,'
..
,"
,
;,
,,,
,,
"""',
".19"",'
,,,
,
',,"",,
,'",
",,
,
"",.,
,,
".20

'."
,'
,,
'
,'

".21

40

,
,,.
"",",
.,
,,'
,,
,,
.
.,;'
',
,'.
,.,
,
,,,
',',
,".22
"
,,,,,
',
',,'
.,23
,
,
,,,,
,
.
,,.
,
,,,
,,
,.
,
,,.

,,''".24

.
,
,
,'
,
.

,,,,
,
,
.
,

41

,
,'
.

,'.
.
1),,,,
,.
2),
,.
3)
.
4)
'.
5),

,.
6)
,,,
,,
.
7),
,
.

.
8)

,
.
9)
,
,
.
)
,
),,)
,
.

42

)
,)

,,)

,.
,
,
.
24
"",
,,
,2526
.
"
;.
,.
'.
.
,
.
,
,.
,,
,,

.
,,
.,
,,,
,
.
,
,
.,,,.
;,,27
".28
",",",
,,,,
.
,
,
,
."29
,
,
.29

43

,
.,"
'"30,"
'","
,,(
31),,
,,,,,,
(,",...,
"32),,,,
,,,,,
,,,,,,
,,,.
,,,,,,
,,,,,
,,
,,
,,,,
,,,,,
,,
,,
,
."33

44

2
.
.
.
.,,
.

'
)
,

,
'
.

1)2)
.
1)

2)

45

'

,
,,
.

.
,
.
.

,
.
,,,
,,
,

,
,

.
,
,
,.
,
,,

,,
,.

,
.

.,
.

,()

()

46

,,

.
1)

2)
3)
.

.
,,

,",
'...".1

,
,

.
,

,.2

'
3.

."
"

47

",,".
.

,
.
Filioque
'..

,,,

.
,

',
,'
.

,
,

.
. 4

13
.

.5

.
,
,,
,,
.6
,
,

'.
,
,,
.

529

48

,7.

,,.8

.,
,,

.9
'
,

.10
14
,.11
.12
,433
7.
,,
.13

,
,
,
.

,
.14,.15

,
Filioque,

'..
393
12
'.
.
.
1),
,
.

49

,'.

"".
,,16
""
"".17
""
"",
"".18
,,,,
,"".19
""
"",'.,
,,
,,
.20
,
,21,
,.22
,,,,,,,
,,,,,,...

.23
.24
2)
'.
,
."".25,,
'.,,
.26
, 27
.

""
.28

,.,
,,
""
.
'
.
,

.29
,,
,,

50

,
,

'..30
31
,,

.32
,47,'.
,
.
"".,

Filioque,
.38
,
,,40,41
,42
.43,,
,
,44,.
,
.,
,
,. 45,
.46
,'
,
.

. 47
.
Filioque,
.
,,()
'
.48
.
(
)

.,,
,
,";
,,
,

51

".49'
,
.50

,,
,,
,
.

,
,,
,,

.Filioque
,
,
'..
,
,
Filioque.51
,,
,
,52,
,
,
.53
,,
.54
1054
,""
Filioque.55

'
,,56
,
,'
,
,
.
,
,,,
,.

,57,

52

.
.,
.
,
.

().
,,
.

,
,'
..
,

.
.
,,
,,
,.
,
'

,
,.

.58

,""
,'
,.59
,

.60

.
,
,'
,

.61,
,,
,
"",.62'
,,

53

,"ContraAcademicos",
.63
,
,
,64

,65
,66
,67
,68
1341,1347
1351.69

.70
,,
,.71
,

,72
,
,
'.73

,
DanteJohnMilton.
,
.74
,,
,
,,
.
,

,,

,,75
,
.76

,,77
'
,.78

54


,. 79

,
'
80

81

.82

,
.
,
,
.83
,,

.
1)

,
'
,2),

,3),

),
,),
)
. 84

55

.85
,

.86
,
,
.
,,
.87

,,,,
,

,'
.
,
,
,
.
,

.88

.
,89,90.

,
,,
,.
'

.,

.
,
,
'

56

,
,
'
,.'

,'
.

',,
'
,
.

,
,.
,1)
,2),3)
,.
1).

,,
.
2)
,
,,

,
.

,,
,,
,.
.

,'
.
.1
,
.2
,

57

.3
,
.4

,,,
.5

,6

.
3),
,
,
.,

,
.7
,
.
,,

,
,
.8
,
,
,
.

,,'
.

.
.

.
,
,
,
,
,
.9

,
'
,

58

,
.10,,
,
,11,
,
.
,12,13,
,'

.14
.15

,,
,'
.
.
,,
.
,
.16
,
,
),
,)
,.
),
,17
1)

,,,2)
,

.
18,
,,
,
.19,

.
,
,.

...
)

)
,,
,,'

59

,20,
,,
,
,,
,...,

.'

.21

14,2526:16,1213
)"
")
"")
"

",

.22
,

,"
,",
,,'
,"23.,"
,',,,
,"24].,"
,,
,,,
".,
,,
,,
,
,'".

.
,
.
16
,
.
1)
,
,2)

60


,
.'

,
.
.
,,26

.
.

.
,"
',
,,,
',".
""
,

,'
,,,
,
,
,
.

,,

,.

."
",
.

61


,,
809Filioque,
,
.

,.
,
;

,
.
,
,
.

"
","","","","
",Filioque...
,.
.
,'
,,

,
,.
(,)

,,,
,
,,,
,.
,,
.

,
'
.
,
,,,,

,
.
,

62

,,

.,,
,

,
,,
,,

.
,,.

.
,,
,.

,,,
,
,
'"",
,
.

.'
,"()
,
,
,()
".

,,
.
,,.
'
.
,.

63

,,
,',
,'
,

.,
,
',

"".
,
,

'.

,1)2)
.

.
'
,
,
.
,
,
,
,.

,
,.

.
,
,,
,,
,
,
.
,

,
.

64


(
),
.
.
,,.

.
'

,
.

,
.
,,
'

.
'
,.
.
,
,
.

,,
,,
.
,
,

,
,,
,,
,
.

65

,,
.

.",
,,
,
.,,
',
,".

,,
.

.
"
...".
.

,
,",
,,
,,
,,
,,,
,,
".
)
,,

..
.",.
,,
.
.,
,,
".

.,,,
.
,
,
,,"
,,,

66

,...".46

.47,
,
.48
.
,
,
,
.49

,
.

,
'

,,
,,
,
,

.50

.51

'
,,
.,

,,,

,,
.

,,'
'
,
.

67

,
,'
,,
.
',
,
,,
,,
,.
,,
,,,
.56

,,
.
.
,
.
.

,".
,,',
".58

.59
,
,
,,
.

,
.

,
.60

68

,
,
.
,,

.
,.61
,

.62
,"
,,
,,,,,
,,,
,
.,,
,,,
".63
""
"","""",
""""

.
,"""",64

""65""66""67
"
".68
,
,
.69
""

,,
.70

,
",
".71
,
",,
,
,,,
,,,
,

69

,,,
,".72

,.

,",'
,
(
),,

.,
,
.'
"", 73
,
,'
,,
'
,
,'

,
,""
"", 74.
,.
""75
.,
,,

,,,"

"".76
,
,
,

(!!!)
.

,,,,
.77
,,
',
,

70

.
',

.78,,
,
,

,,
.

,79
,

,
.80

.
,,.

.81
,
.

.
'

,,

.
,

.
.,

71

,
,.

,.

,
,,
,,
,,
.
.
.
,

,
,'
.

'

.82
,
'.83
.,,'
,

,
,,

,
,.

,",
,,
,'
,
,,
...

72

,,

,''
,,
,,
,...".89
,

.85,
,
,
,
()
,
.86

,.
,
,.

,
,
.,

()
.

,
,'
,
.

,
,1)
,2)

'.

73

,
.,
,
,"
,...
,
.,',
,,,
,.
".87

,,
.'

88
,89
.
"
,,
".90'
,91,
,
,
,
,.
,'
,
.
,,
.

..
,
,

.
,,
,
.

.
.

,."
,,

74

.,
,".92

,'
,
,.
,

.
,"

'

".93

,
,94
,95,
,,,
',','
,,','
,,
,"".

.96

,
,,
,
,,

,
.97

75

,
,
.
'
,
.

.
,'
.98
,99

,.

.
.

,,'
,

,,
,,
,'
.
,
,,,
,

,
,.

,
,
.
,
.

76


,,

.
,,
.
,"
,
,,".
'
,
,
,
.

.:1)
"
",1002)"
",1013)
(,
,,,'
).102,
,,
,

.103

.104

.105

,
,
,"""
".
,
,

77

',
,,.

.,
,,,

,
.
.

,,
,,,
,,,

,,,
,,...,
.
,
,,
,
.

,...
,,

.
,

,
.

,
.

78

,
,.106
,
,

,
,,
,
,
.
,
,
,
.[107]
,

,.
,
'
,

,.108
,'

,
,
,

'
,
,',
,,,,
.
,,
,,
...109,,
'
,,
.

79

,
.

1821,

.
,

.
,

,
.,,,
,,,.

.,

'.
,
,

,,,

,,.

,.
,.

80

,.

,,

,"
".110
""
.

,,,,

.
.

,
.

,
.
'
'
.
,

,.

81

,.

,,
,.
'
.

,
,,
.

,,,

.1
'

.
1)2)
,3)
,

,,,

82

',
,
,

.2
,
,
419.385

.485
3605
.85,
,,67
8.
'(6912),
,9,
.
.
419.

,
.,
,

,,
,,,
85.

,,"
,,
,,,,,,
.,.
,,,
,,,
,,,,
,..,
,,,,
,.
,,,,,,
,,,,
.,,
,,
,,,'
,".10

83

,"'
,(),
,
,
,,,,,
.,,
,
,,
,,
,
".11

,",,,
,,,
,,
,,,.
,,
()".12
"
',,
..."85
.13
85

,,
,"',,
".14

,",
,..;
,,,
,'.,
,'".15
,

,
,",
".16

,.
,',

,,

84

.
,
.
.

,'
'.
.
,
,
.
,
,,,...

,'
,

,
,
,
.

,
,
.

,
,,,,
',

.17

85

,
.
.
,,

,
.

,,

,
.18
,

,
,

.
,
.
,
,
,

,
.

,
,
"""".

,,

86

,
.
,
'.

.
"",
,

,
,,
,
,
,,"
.
"",,
,
,
,
".",

,,,
,
.,
()
,,.
,
".19

.
'

,(
),
'.

',

87

,,

.
,',
,,
,.
.
,

.
.
;
.
;

,,

.
,.
,
'
,
,
,,
..
.
.

"",
.
..

,.
,
,
,,,

"",

.
,
,

88

,
,

.
.20,
.
.21

.22
,"()
(),
,
,,
,.
',
,'
,
,
,,
',
,
,
,
.
'',
,',

.,
;
,

.,'
(.)

.
,;
,

.
...
.
,
,

.
.
,
,
.,
.;
.,

89

,',;
.
.;

,'
,......,
,
.
,
,,,,,
,;',(
),,'
.,

,
.

,
.

;;
,
;
,
,

;
;(,
;)"23
",
,
".
,
'.
,
'.
,.
,
"
,,
,...

.,
,

'
.

90

,'

,
.
'
(
),
,
.
,
,,.
,,
'
'

,
,
;

.
,
.
;
,
,

,.

',
,
.
'
,'
,

.
,

".24
,
'381,

1316.

91


.
,,,
.

.
,,
.
1)
14 ,
2)""

1316,
.

.
,,

,,
,...,,
'.

,,
.'
"..."25'"
',
,
,
". 26
,"
...".27
'(691/2)

,",

92

,,
,

,
,
".28

93

3
B'
,
',''
.
.
.
.
.
)
)
)
.
)

'

,,
.
,'.
''
,
,,,
,,,,,,
,...

,.
,",
,
".1
,"
,,".2
"

94

,,
,.
,,,
.,,
,".3

,.

,
,.

1),"
,
",42)

,,
.5

,"
,,
,,,,
,
,,.,
.,,,
;,,
'.,,
'.,,
.,',
,;,
;;
,'
".6
.

.'
,,,
,
,,.
,
,
,,
,

.
"
'.,.'

95

".7

.
,"".8

,8
.9

'

,.

.6',
."
,,,
;;,
,
,,
(.6,910).
."1
',"
,,
.
,,
,
,,,
,.,
,.,,,
,
".2

3
,
.

,
,"
,
,()
,,
,
,,
,.
,
.(28,2528).,,

96

,,,,',
,,
,,,".5

,",
,.,
;,
,".6

,
.
.

.,"
,,
,
,,
,,
".7

.
,8,9
1011.12
13

.
,,
,,
",
,.,,
.,
;"14

,
.15
,16
17
,
.

4:3,5,16

97

,",.
".18

.
,,
,.

,
.
,
,,
....
,,
.19
'

,21
.22

.23

.
,.11:27,.10:22,
,
,
.,
,,
,"
,",
,,
".34,
,
,';",
,", 35,
,
,',36
,(),37,38
,39,,
,40.41

."42
,"...".43

,
...

98

.
,44,45.46,
,
.
,

,
.
.

,,
,
,.
,
.
,
,
.

.,,
,.

,'
.47
.[48]

.
,
.
'"
","","","","",...49
'',
,
,
'.

,.

,
,.
'

,,

.1

99


,
,
.

.,
,,
.,
,,.

.
,.
..
,'
.,
,,'
,.

,
.
,

.2",

"3'

,
,
.4

,",,
.
,,,
,
,,
,,
,
,
,,
,,
,,
".5
,",
,,
.,,'

100

,'
,,
,',,
,,
,',
,,

,,
,,
,',,
,",,
,,
,"6...
,.;
,",,,
."7...
,.8',
,,
,.,
,,
,',
,
,9,
,,
,,
.,
.'
,
,,'
,,
,
,,
,,
,,,
,
,,
,
.,
,
,,,
;,,,
,,,
'.
,
,,
,,'
,,
....,'
,;
',
,,,'
;,,

101

,",,
,".10'
,
,'
;,"
,,',
".11,',
;;';"12

.
.

.226342.
,

.
,,
,
.,
,
.
,

,
.
",
".142,11
"""
","
".15
9,1""
"",",
".16
.
"",
"".
.16,28,.9,1,.9,27
.1718
,,",
".19
,"
"20,"
,".21

102

14,.22

,
,
.
,
.'

.
,

.
,

,
,,,
.

.
,,
,,,
.,,

()
.

W.KMMEL,VERHEISSUNGUNDERFLLUNG(
),23

.
,
,
'
.

,,,
,
,

103

.,,
,,

.
,

.
W.G.KMMEL
.
."",
,
;
W.G.KMMEL
'.16,28,.
9,1,.9,27,
'
.
H.RIESENFELD
,

'

,
.

.25

.
.
,

,
,,,
,
.

,
,
.

104

'

,
.,,

,
,

.
,
,
.

.
,
.

,
,,
,.
12
.3,

,.4
,

.5

.6.7
. 8
""9""10""11
"".12

,
,13
.14

.''
.
.

105

",...
,,
...
......
..."15

,.16

,
,
.
,
'
,
.
,

,,
.

,,,
,.17

.
.
.

.,
.

,1)2),1)
2)3).
1)
2)
,.

.
1)
2)3)

.,
,
,'

106


.
,
,
.

.
,

.
,

,
. 18,
,,
,
,,,.

.
"......,,'
,,'". 19
,",
,...
,,,
,."20
,

,
,"".21
,
.
,,,
,,,,
,...
,
,
.

134041,"

,'

,,
,.',
'
,,
,
,",",22,
''

107

.',
,
,,,,,
,,
,
,.
,
,,
,
.
,
,,

,,

'

".23

.
,

.24

.
.

',
.,

,,

108

,
.

,
.
'',
,,,,
,,,
,,...

,.

'

,,...

,,

.
,
.
,,
.
,
,
,

.
,
,

109

'
.
',
,,,
,,,
,,

.
'.
'

.1
,
.

,
.

.
.2

,
.,
,
,'.3'

,,.4

1)2)
.

.
,

5."
;,...,;

110

,.,'
,".6
,
."
".7
,
.8
1)
2)
,

,"
.,,
;,,
;...
,;,
,,
,,',
,.,
,,,
,.,
,,
..
.,,
;,
,,
.,,
;,,
,
,,;,
,,,
"9
'

,,"
,,,
,,
,,,."10

,
.
,
,,
.,

111


,
,

'.

',
'.

,
.

.
,
,,
()(
).11

,
,'
.

,,
,
,'
.
.
,
,.

,,
,,
,
.
()
.12
,
.13

112


,
,

,.14

',,,...'.
',,
,.15

,
.
)
,
.
1)
1)
2),
,,,.16
.17
.
,
,.18
'.19
362,.20

()().
2),
SUBSTANTIAESSENTIA

.21

. 22
,TRES
SUBSTATIAE.TRESSUBSISTENTIAE
.23
3)

.24

113

.25
,,
.
26

.,
..
.
.
..
,',
....

.
.
,
,
,
,.

.
.

,,

.'.
,,

;.

.27

,
,
,.28
,SUBORDINATIONISTS,
.

,
,
.
,
.,

,.

,...29

114

4)

.30,
,,
.
,,
().

,
,
.31
,,

.
,
,,
,
.
.,

.
'.
8,22"
"
.
,,.

,
,

'

,
.

,
1)2)
,3)'.
,

115

.
,,.
.
,,
.
,
,
.
,

''
,
'.[1]

'.,
'
.

.
,

.
,'
.
',
,
,
,,,
.2

,,
.
,. 3
,,,

116

,
''.
.
,
,
.

,.
,,
,
,.
,,
,
.

.
,
,
.

,
,
.

.4,
,

,.4

,5,6
,
,,
.
,
7.8
,
,9,

,
,

117


,,
,
""
.10

,",
,,
,
,.
,
,',,
.
,,',
.,
,",
,,"11
,
,',',"
",,
,,',
.12,
,.
,','
,"," 13,
,"",14
.,
,15
,16,
,,,
,",
,",17,
,
,18,
,,19,
.20...
,,
,,
,,
,....
21,,
,,
.,,
,.
.,
,,,
,,,
,,,
,,,,,

118

,,.
,,,
'.
,,,
,22.23
,,.
,,24,25
,26,27
,28,,
,,
.,,
,,
,,
,,.29',,
.,.
, 30'.31
,,,'.
,,
,,,
,.,,,
,,,,
',,,,
,".32

""
.""
.
,"'
,",,'
,,."'
,.
,
.,'
,.
,,'
,,
,.

,
.
.",,,,',
,".'
,
,'.
,",,
,
"33',"
."34,
,",
',"35,",
."36,

119

..."37
,
,,
,".
",,
.
,,
,,
.
,
,,'
.'
,,.
,.

,,
,
.'
,
,,
.,
,
,
,,
,,
,
'...
,,
,'.
,,,
,,
',
.,
,,
(),
.
.
,'".38

,
'
39,",,"",
,","",
,,"",."
,,,,
,"."
,'.,
"."40
,,",

120

,".,
".40

,.41

.42

,,

.
,
,43.44
,,
. 45
,

14,.226342'.

."
,,
,
,,
.
,". 46
'
47

.48

.49

,50

.51'
.52
"
".53
.
.54

,,

121

.55

,
,'.56

57
,
.'
. 58
,

.59
.
,
,'
.

.
,
.60
,
61
",,
,
,,,
'
,."6263

.1)
642)
",
,".65
,

.",
,", 66,"
,,
,,,,,
,
;
.
,
,,
,,,
,
".67
.

122

.
.,
,
,.
"
"
,

"...'
......()...'
....",,,
68.69

,,"
,,
,
,
,,
,,
,,
,
'".70

,"...,
,
,,".71

,,

'.72

.73

,'.74
"...'
,'".75
,",;
,,;
,,",
",,;"76

123

,",,,
;
,
;,,.77
,
.
,.78
,.,
,,,79',
.80;,
;81
,
,
.
,'.
,
,,,
,82',
.83,
,.84,
.,
,,
,.
,,
,."85

.
,"

";86

.
,
,,,
,,,,,...
,
,
,,,
,,,
.

,
,
.,

124

,
,1415

.,

,
,,
,

,,
.
.

.'
.
,"
;
.",
,",
,,,
."87
,88,89
,90;,

,
,
;,
;'
,,
''
,,.
,,,
,,
".91,
,,,
',.
.
,
.9293',
9495
....'
;',
,
".96

,
,'
.,

125

,,
,"',,
,,

.
,"",
,,',
',
,".97

,
,
.98
,
,,
.99
'
,'.100
,,

,
,",

;
,"'"100
',,""
"",101,

,
,,
,,
.,
,()',
',
.
,',
,
...'
;
;,,';
"."
,"," 102
.;,
.,
,,,,;
',,,,
,'.'
,',,
.
';'

126

,
,,
'.;
;,,
,;
,,,',

,,,
,,',,
.''
,
,,
."103

127

4
)'.'

)'.
'
.
.
.'(381)

)'.'

,
,
,.1

.,,
,
.

,
,'
,.

.
,
,2,3

.4

128


'
.

,.5

,,.6

,
.
,''.7

.8
.
,

,'.

,
,

Filioque
.
,
,

."'
."9
'
'.Filioque.

,
''.,
Filioque
.

,"

.,
,",
".10,'

129

,'
,
,'
.
."11

,
,
.. 12
13,,

'',
''.

,
.

,
.
.

.14

.,
".,
,,
;"
".,
.
,,.
,,".15
,",
,,,
,."16
,",
,,
;
,
,

130

,,,
,;"17
,"
,,
,,
"..."18
,
,
,
,'
.19'
'.20
,21
.
,
,,
.22
264269
,1)
,2)
()3)'(
').23

.24
',,
,.25
.26

','
'.27'
'.
. 28

,
.29
.1)

.1)
,2)'
,3)
.

131

,
'.30
,,
.31
, 32
,,
,
,
.33
,
,,
.34

.
,

.35
""
"".
,,.36
,
,
,
,.37
,,,,...,
.
,,,,,...
,
.
,'.
,.
.38

,
'.'
',
,,
.39
','.
.

132

.40

.41
,,
'',
.
,"
,,,
,,
,.
;
,.
,
.,
,,
,,
,,
.,
,,.
,,
,,,
,
,;,,
.
,.
,
,.
;,
,
".42

''.,43
.
,,"
('
,,,
)44,
,
".45
,"'
,,;
,,,,
,.46
,,,
,
,',.

133

,,
.,
.
,,
,,
,.
,
,.
".[47]

,'
'.
.
'

,
,
,,,,,,
,...
,
.
,"
,...
,,
,,...
,
,,,','
;,';...
;...,,
,;,
,,,
.,,,
,...'
,

,,
,,
,".48
1),2),
3).1),.2)
,
,,3).
.
,"
,,,",
.49

134

,,,
,
."
".50
,"',
,,,,
,.,,
,,,,,
,,.,
,',
,.;
,,.
.,;
,.,;
".51

.
,,
,
.

.
,,
.
,,,
,,,
,,
.
,
.52
,,...
,
.53

,
,.
,
..
,
,
,
..

,
,.54,

,,
.

135

()
.,

.
,,

,'
.
,

,,
.55
,
.56

,
,
.57

,,
.
.
,",,
;,,
;,
,,
,,
,,58,
,,59,
,,.60
,,,
,,,61,
.62.,
;63,;,
.',
,',
,,'
,". 64

136


)'.
'

,,
,
,

,.
.66

.
,
,
.
.
.
.,,

.67
,
,
,,.

.,
,
,.68

,
.

.69
,
'..

.'
.70

137

,,
,,,
.
,.
(.)(.
)
,
.71
"",
"",
',
,
.72
,"
,
,,
,','
,,
.,
,,,
,
.
,.'
,,,
...
,;" 73
'
.74

.
'

,,
.
1),2)
,

.75
.

.76

,
.
J.N.D.KELLY

138

,,
.77.

,
,
"". 78

,
,,,...
,
.

,
,
.79

.,
.

.,,
,
.80,
,
.81

.
,.82
.
'
.
.

.
'
,
.

.
.83

139


,''
,
',,,,,...
.
,
,

,.84
,,

,',
,,,,
,,
,.85

,'
,
.
,
,
'
.
."
,,
,,
,
",.86
"
".87.
1,1.4,2,"
;,,,
,,
.,,
,...
,,
,88.
,;
;"89

.90
.
,"
".91

.92

140

.92
362,
.93362
..94

,,
,
.95

..96

."'
,
,.
,.,
',,(),
(),'(),
.,
,,
".97
,"
,,
',,,
.
,,,
.,
.,
,,
...
,
...,,,,
.'
,
.
,,,
,.
,.,
,,
.,
.
,',
...,;
',
',,
,,,
',,
".98

141

'
,,
.99
.
,,,
.100
,"
,,,,
,,
,."
,
,
,'.
,
....
',...
,.,
',,
;,
,,
...
,,
.,
,,
.,
,,
,".101
.
.'

.
.

,
.

,,",
;,,,
,.,
,,,
,,,'
,,.
,.
,,,
,,,
,,
.',
."102

142

,
,
'.
.,"
,
,,
,,,
.,
,,
,
,
.,
.,
.,
,,
,.
,.
,,
,,...
,,
,'
.
,,,
,
,,
".103

",
".
.
.

.",
".104
,,
.
,
,.

.
.

,
.
,"
,',,,"
.,
,
.104

143

,.
,.
.105
106,

.
,,
.

,"
,,

,,
,
,,
.'
,'
".107

.
.,
,.
,",,
...,
,,,,
,".108"...
,
.
,,,,,
'".109

,,

.
,

.111

.
.
.,

144

,
.

.112
,
,

'.113
,114'..
,.
'..

,
.
',,
,
,
,,.

.
,,
.
.115

''(381)

Filioque,
,

,
,

.
1
"",
.2
,,,
.

145


''.

.
.
,,,,,,,,
,,,,,
,,...
.,,1),,
,2),,,3)
,,,
,,4),
,,5)
,,,,
,,.
.
,'
.
'.
'
Filioque8
9.

.
3
,"
.,
,,,
,'',,
,(,),

".4
",,
,...,
,,
,".5

,",
,,,,,
,,,
,,,,'

146

,
...(),
,,,,
,,
.,,,,.
,,,.
,,,.,
,,,',
,,,
,;,,
,,,,
,,,,
.,,,
.,,
.,
,.,,
..,
,"6
"""
",
;
,"
,,
.',,,
().,
,,,
.,',
.,
,,,,
,,,
.,,,
,,
,,,,,,
.
,,.
,,'
,,.,
.,
,.
,,,.,,
,,.,
,,
.,,,,,,,
,.,,
,.,
,,''.
".7
',,

"

147

""".
."""
","".

,
,
,
.8
,,

1439,""""

,
.9
,

''..

'.,"
,
,
,,'
,
,,.
,,
.
,,
,,,.
,,
,,
,,
,,,,
,.
,,
'.,
,,
.,,
.
,',,,
,
,,
,',
,
,
,,
...',
".10

148


,
,""",
'".

,
.
,

,,
.'.
,
.

'..,

.12
,Filioque
,
.13'

',,
.

.'
,
,
,,,,
,...
8.
,"
,,
,,
,,
,,
(,
,),,,
,,
,
.,
,,
.
,
,,
,,,
',(

149


),'
,
,,,,,
.,
,'
,(),
',,
.'
,',
,,
,,'
,,".14
""
,,
,'..
,"
,,,,
,".15
,"
,',,
.,
,,'

.,
,'
,.
,,,
,,
,,,
.
,
,',

.
,,
...".16

,
,'
.

.
,"
,
,,,
,,,
'
...,'

150

,,,
(),
,,
,.
,'',
,
,,
.,
,,,
,.

,'
,
,
,,,,
,,
,
.'
,
,,
,
,,
,
,
,
...'
,,,

,,
.
,
,,
".17

,;
,.

;
.",
,
".,
,
;
""
.

,9"ContraerroresGraecorum"
,
7,
,

151

,
.

,
",,,'
,(,',
),;
,,
,
,
,.
,,,
,'
,...
.,
,,",
.
,',
.,,
,.,
,
,
,
,,,
,
...,'
,
,.
,,.,
.
;,,'.
,.,
,,,'
.,
,,.
,,
,',,,
".18

,
'..
,
".,,
,,,,
.',.

152

,,',,
.,,'
,".20
'"",,

,"""".
,.

,
,",.
',.
,,,
,,,,,,
',...
,,,
,". 21
,
.
.",
,.,
.,.,,
,.,.
,,,,
.,,,,"22
23,

.
.

.24
1),2)
,3),
,254)

,255),'.

430(
Filioque),
.26

,27
.'
.
'

153

..,
..
,",
,
,
,,.
,,,,
,;
,,,
,',,
',,',
.,,
.;
,,
,...
,,;,.
,,,',
,.
,,'
.,.'
,,,
,,,,,
,',,
.
(),',,(
),',,,
,".28

,
,
."',
".",
,,".
,'

.",,
...,,
.,,;"29

.
",,,...
,...",
,,
,
,,.
,"
,;"30"
,,".31
,"
,,

154

,,',
.
,
,
,,". 32
.
.

.
.

,,
.
,
,,,
.

.
'

'.."
""",
.
,
,
.
,
,
,.
'.
'
.10382,
".
,,,
,,,
,,
,,
,,,
,,,
,,".
'.
,
."'
,,
,
"33,"'()
(),,
".34

155

"
.35
"". 36
.
""
.,
,
"()
,,
,
,,,
,".37

.38
.39
.40"","
,,
,".41
"".
,

,.42
.16,15,Filioque.
,"
,,,,
,,". 43,
"(,
,',','
,'),
.
,,,".44
.,
,"
,,
,
".45",
,,
,,,
,,".46
.
'.
''.
Filioque.
'.

156

'.
,,,
'..
12
.
',
""
"".
',"
,',
',
,".48
',"
,,,
,,','
,.
,,.
,,
".49
,",
,
.
,',
.,
.,".50

'.12
,51
,"
,,
,,".52

,"(.)
.,
.'
,',
".53

433,54'.
()

.
449''.
,'..
'.

157

,
. 55

,
'..
,'.
,
.
,

,
.
.
'.

.
,

,
'..1)
,2)
,
.
.

Filioque
.

649.
,",
,,,
.,,,,
.',
,.,
,,
,,
,
,,
,'',
".56

158

5
.'

.,

1)Filioque
2)Filioque

'.'

Filioque
J.N.D.Kelly,"
,
,.
Hatfield(),680
,
649
Filioque."1
649

,(1437
1439),2
.3Kelly

.'.

.
'
. 4
'
Filioque,
.
'
.
,Filioque
.Filioque
,
,

159

'.

,
,,
.
'
,,
,
.
.Filioque.
Filioque.
1)
Filioque
,2)'.
,
,"'()
,',
.
,
,"',,
,'."5
,,
,;,",

."6',
;,
",".7'
,
;"8
,,

,
,,....9

,.10
Filioque
.11

'
,.
''Filioque
,',,
.
Filioque
.12
808

160

.()
.13'
.14809
,
780Filioque
..
'
Filioque."
'...".15809
,
.
,
,16
,

.17
.

.
,,.

..18

.19
794
'.,'
Filioque
,
'.20
800
',.21
.22
,,
. 23
799.
.800
..24

23,
.25,
,,
,"ImperatorRomanorum""
",(.

161

Imperator,.
).
,
,
"".26.
"""
".,
,.26
""
.,
,
""
.,
"".
.'
"""
"."
",,
.,
"".

"ImperatorRomanorum""ImperatorGraecorum".27
"ImperatorRomanorum"
,. 28

'
""
,.

,
'""
,.',
,
.

"".
Filioque.
9"
",
,
'.
Filioque;

9,1011
.

162


,,
.

'.
,,"
"
()
.28

"""".

''.
,.29
'
,.30
,

.31
'.

,
'
.
,'

,,
,
''.

Filioque.
Filioque,
.

.
.

,...

393

163

,,321)
2)
.

Filioque
.

.,",
,,
.(,,
').,
,''
,
.'
,,
,,
,.',
,
,',

,...
.
.',
,,
,,,'
,,
,.
,".33

,,,,
,...
,,,
,4.

.
,
",
,,",
,,
.,,.
,
".34
,
.
,
,

.
''.

164


"".

,",,,,
,,,('
,)'.''
,,,
,,''
,,
".35
"...
,;",",,
,',
,".36
,"
',,
,;"
,",,
,'',,,
,,
,';
,,.,
,.,,
,
,".37
,
",,
".
,",',','
,,...
,',
,,
',
".38
,"
,,
',,

,''
',',
,'
,,,,
,". 39
,",'
,,',',(
,',,)

165

,,
".40
,",
',;'
;','
,;"
,",,
,".41
,",,
,,,
,',
',,,".42

.
Filioque,",
,,
,;,
;"43
""
.44

,,"...
,,,
,,,
,,
,,,
,',
,,,
,".45
Filioque'."'
"
393
,'
.

,
,.
'.
.
,
Filioque,
Filioque.
,Filioque

166


.,.

;46
:
",,,
.,,,'
,',,
,"47"""
"
,

,.
,,
.
Filioque
589,

',
'
,
A.E.Burn1908.48
649

,
.

Filioque.,

.,"
,,,',
,;,'
".[49]'
,,,
.
(855858),
'(855858),
,',
'',",,
,
,,,
,,
94,6".50.
(10071072)

167

Filioque,",
,
,,,
,
".51

,1160
,",
,,
,''
."",
,".",
,,
...,
".52

(10791142),"
,
,,''
'."
,","."
,
,...,...".53
'
,"""
".54

..55

'
Filioque,",'
',,,
","","...,
',","
,",",
,,
,","'
,,,
,',
".
'
(
)

168

Filioque,"
".

,,.
'

855858
'(858867),
'(867872),'(872882).878,

.
,,
'
Filioque.
Filioque
'
.,',
Filioque,
,
.
,.
Filioque
,:1)
""2)

.
Filioque
',
...'
'.(879)Filioque,

Filioque,
'(876)'(881),
Filioque.
Filioque
.

Filioque
""
.

',"
,

169

,,,
,,'
,
,,
,,
,,
,,'
,,
".56
'
',

,.
..,''
,"
,,
",57",
,
".58
,
',
Filioque.

869.

Filioque.
'
Filioque'.,,
',59
.60'
,
,"...
,,
,
,
,.
,(
,
'),
,,
,',
,,
.
,',,
.'',
(.)
,.
,,

170

;
,,
,
".61
',
",,
,
,,
',

.
,'
,
.
,,
".62

,
1)Filioque,2)

3)Filioque
.

867
.,

.
'
'

Filioque.

',
,14,
,,
879,
,
.
,",,
,,,
,,,
'.,
,,
,.
,'.
,',
,,
,,
.'

171

,,
,,
,
.'',,
,.
,
',()
,,,
,,
.,
,',
,,
,
,,,
,,
,,
,,
,,
,,
.,,
,,
.,
,,
.,
',
,,
.
,',','
,,
,.
,
',.
','
,',
,,,
".63
'.
.'.1)
'.2),
,
.

.
Filioque.
'
Filioque,,
,
.

172

Filioque,
",
',
".64

'.
.

,
,"
".
'.

,
,

,
.
'.

.'

"",
.
768
772
,
.65
.
'
'66(882824).
""''
(884885).65
.
'.68
,".!
,'
".69

.
,,'

,,

173


. 70
,

,71
,.

""
.
'.,

.
'.
.
'

"",
.

,""
.72

"",

.(
)
,

,,,.

,,,
,,
,,"",
.

"ContraerroresGraecorum"
Grec,,",
".73
,
,"
"
.
,

174

,
.

'.
,
,,

.
Filioque.

,
,
,
.1'
.
',,
,.2

,.3,

.
Filioque
.

.Filioque

,
,.
,
.
,Filioque.

.4

,5'DeTrinitate
13

175

.6
Filioque,
.7

.8

.
,

,.

,.

,.
,

,
,,,9
.
,. 10

,,
,
.

,
,
.
Filioque,

.11

,
.12
Filioque1)2),.1)
,
,,
,
.2),
,.

176

1)Filioque

,.13

.14
,
,.
,
,
.

.
.

,
.

..."
,.
,,,
...".15

.
,
;

.16.
,
,,.
.5,26"..."
,.
',

.'
,
.5,26""
,"',,
,,
,"","".

',
,,,
...,
,".16

177

,",
,:
,.
,","',
,.,,
,,".17
,

.
,

,
,.
;
,

.
.

.'DeTrinitate
,
. 18'
"...
".19

''.,"'

,',
,
,'
,
,',
".20
,,

.21,',

.
,;

,,
;23

178

,',
.
.
,.

,.24

.'
,
.25
,
.26,1),2),3),
4).

.
.
1)2)
.1),
2),
,.

.27

.
,
1)
2),
.
,
.,"
,,
,,
,.,
,
".28

,29(
),30,
,
,
,'.31
,

.32

179


,,
,,
.33
'DeTrinitate
'.
,
,.
.34

,35
.
,,36,
.
.37
.
,
,
.
.
.38

,,
,.
,
,38,

,.39,
,
,.
,
,,
,.
.

2)Filioque
Filioque
40.41
Filioque
"

".40""
.41

180

.
. 42
(),",
,,,
,",
,,',
".,",
.,.
,,
,,,"
.,',
"...
,,,'.
",.
,,"
",
,",...",
.,,,
...".43

"".
,
"Retractationum".
.44

,.

.45
,,
.
,,
.

.
,
.

Filioque.

,
.

.,,"
,(),,
,,.
,,
',".46
,

.,

181

(amans,quodamatur,amor).47
,.48
,,,
.
,,,
,(esse,nosse,velle).49

.
,
(mens,notitia,amor).50
.,
.
,(memoria,
intelligentia,voluntas).51
.

,,

,
.52
,
,
,
. 53
,
,
.

.54
.55

.56
,
',
.57
Filioque
.
Filioque
'.58
,,
.
,,Filioque
"".Filioque
'

182

.
1955
,,
Filioque
.Filioque,
'
,
.Filioque

,
.

.59
,,Filioque

,.
,
,
,
,
.

Filioque.
,.
,

.
Filioque
.

,
.

,
.

,,
.

,,

.
'
.

183

""Filioque.

184

.
.
..
.1984/93
...
""
.
.
.

.(.120)
..
,

"".
.(.2026)

...
"...,
,,".

,'381
'879.
.

.
'.
1.19831984/93.
"
".2
.,.
.

185

',
,
.,.

.
,.,
1)","2)
""
3)"...,,
,."
.
2...

.
'
...
,""
""

''.
3..,
'""!
;.
"".3
4.
"""
"
""...
",.
,',,".4

.
,,,.
,
.
.
,.
""

.",.
,',,".5

186

'..
5..
..

,",;
;;
,;"61983.
493941984/93
283,"
,.
".7""
.
6...
""
.1983
.951984/93.84"...""""'
...

,".,.
.,

Franks,Romans,FeudalismandDoctrine1981,
,.,"
",,
""
..'

.
7.)""
","","'
.."
",..
",".
90.61983.81.51984/93,'
.
).
""""
"."
,,.
,
..
""
.
.
"".
,"".
""
"".

187

).27
'.'
8,
25
.
""
...
"""
".
,
"",
.

.""
,.
.

'.,,
""
.
""""",""
""'""".
""
,,
.
).

"".
""""
""..90921983.79811984/93
.""

.1983.90

"''
"..
,1984/93.81,.5.
""
.
,"",
..
8).,J.N.D.Kelly
,
.,
,
,
..,..',
,
..

188

.
'
,.

..""
"","""".

'.1984/93
9).1984.
..78
.1(1)."",(2)"
",.425(3)"Franks,Romans,Feudalism
andDoctrine",.77.
.77,
.8788.
"".,
,,,
,,"",
.
.
.

'...
""9
10.)19571987
,",
;;
;,;"10
)..93(.4)1983
.83.21984/93..
,,

,..
11.)
.
.

."".
""

.,

.
..

189


.
"
""".
).,"
,
,,'
,
...
,,
,.,
',
.,,

,'.,
,.'
,,,
,,.
,
,,
.,.
,',,
".11
)
.,,
/
"".,"",
,,.
,.
28.""
""..

.
).""
."

,(
,)."...
,,
."." 12
.
,.
).
17).921983.7981
1984/93,23(16.).
.
.

..22.

190

12.''"
"(1957/1989).""

.
,.
,,

.
.
13.
(;),
,
.

.
14..

""
.
.
""
"".
..
Migne,P.G.,45,325C,,
Migne,45,297BC.
"".
.
.,,
..

'.
15.
."".
16."
""".
.'
.
151154"'
''
,
,',

191

.'
,
,
,
,
,,
,'
,'
,
,,
.
C,

,
,
,
,
."(Migne,P.G.,45,
297A,B,C.)13
17..Migne,P.G.,45,297(.
931421983.831271984/93),297C(.1421983
.1271984/93).2971983
1984/93'.'.
297297C,
..
297'297297C

..
.
297
:"'
''

,,'
,

.'
,
,,"
18.""
..
"""
".
""

."
".
""
"",

.,

192

.
'.,,
,,,
,'
,.

Kelly.
,.
19."
".31
''
379.'
380'
..
"".
20.:1)

.2)"
",,
.3),
,.
4),,
.5)
,,
,.6)

.7)

.8)
.
21..,

.
.
""
,297
.
22.).
'
..

,
.
Migne,P.G.,45,294BC.
294294C294.
Migne,P.G.,45,
325C1983.90.

193

.1984/93.8182

"""".
1973
1981,
.

.9092
1984/93.81.5.
)1983.,"
,"'
'"".
1984/93.
..

,",
;'
'".14
,,

..

""""
.
""!
"''
","'""
".
.
,,
,."
"""''
.
23..
.:"
,
,,'
,
...
,,
,.,
',
.,,

,'.,
,.'
,,,
,,.
,
,,
.,.

194

,',,
".15
24.
,.
"","",
"".
""
""..

.
"".
"".
"",,

.
25...
""...

"",'
..
""
.,.
"""""
",""
"".'"
",."
",1."
".(1983,.165174:1984/1993,.148158)..
25
.

22.
""
"".
""
"".
.

.16
..172.11983.156.21984/93
.17

."".
,"",
Migne,P.G.,459091122,973.
,

.
"",Migne,P.G.,45,297,,

195

..
Migne,45,297,.'.1."
"297C
.'2.."".,
,Migne,45,297.
'"",."
",1."
".
,
.',,
.
""',
V.Lossky,J.Danielou,I.Theil,A.Schindler
;
26.
,

18,,.
.

.19
27....
.
,,
"...,
,,
".,
""
.
,

'
'.20
28.""

.....
29...,..
..141992
...
.8""
.286(1983).'
.9,.

196

.
30)..,..
..18810
1994
.23
...

..141992.

.
31.141992
,,
,.
.
.

<<...>>.
.
32.,"
,,
<<
,'
.
,>>

".
33.

.
34.
,,,
,,
"....(
)<<,
'.
,
>>..."
35.
,"...."
<<
>>...
.
.

197

,",,
..
.
"...","
".
:.
."..."(.2)
"..."(.3)"
,".
""
;,
.,"
",;,
.
;
,,
.'

,
."
36.39
,"...

".

,""
,
.
,,
.,,

,'
.
37.'
,
.
.9,

Filioque

(14381442).
38.,
.
,
,.
""
;

';
'

198

.'
,''
'.
1),2)
,1)2),
.
39.
(.286(1983).65
..
.

.
.'

,,.
,.
,
..
.

..
Migne,P.G.,94,824
.
'

..
.

;;
;

"",
."'
",
.

;
40.",
,,",

,,
.
41.
.
.
..141992
..101994.

199

""

,.

..
42.,.

.
,
.268.366,

.""
Filioque,
.21

.
43...,
,,.
.....

.155141992.

,..,.

,
.
44.

.,,..
.
..(
).1)
(),2),3)
,4)5)
.
,,
.,

'
17.

200

45.
,
.

.
,,
,1)"
",2)
3)"...,
,,".

,"",
"",""('.13:8)"
"()""""('.13:9)
""('.13:12).

.
,
.

,
.
46.

.
47.
,
,

,
,.
,,
,
."".
48.,

.
.
.
49.
.
,
.

201

"
".
,
().
50.,

,,
,.'
,

.22
23.24
"".

'

.
.
51.
,

.
,
.
.
"".'

.
52.,
..,
.
.
,"
".

('.12:26).25
,
,
,.
53.
,"
,.
,
,.
"('.11:2830).

202


,
,"",.
('.11:27).
""""
"()"('.11:30),
.,
.(
).
('.11:2122,34)"(
),,,
"('.11:3132).

.
'.1215:11.

203