You are on page 1of 48

3.

Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

47


*


1

,

,
1 ,

BlackRock2
PSI3.
.
; ,
.



,
,

. ,

,
.

,
.


(negative externalities),4

. ,
,
.
-


(financial safety net),
,

.
, .


.
, (leverage) (cap*
.
1
3864/2010
.
2 BlackRock
.
3 PSI Private Sector Involvement

.
4
(. Brunnermeir et al., 2009): (1) ,

, (2) , (3)
, (4)
(liquidity spiral),
, (5) ,
.

(1) ,
(2) (3)
.
.

36

2012

47

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

48

ital buffer)
.



.



,

.
.

,
, . 2 3
,
. 4

,
5, 6 7

,
.
, 8

. ,
.

Miller-Modigliani (MM)


. (1),
,
,

(irrelevance theorem).


,
.

,
,

(tax shield). (2)
()

.
,
.
,

2

.
,

.5
,

, ROE.
/ ,
.

.
-

48

36

2012

5 : () (off-balance sheet leverage),


.. SPV SIV,
/ , , () ,
. , (operating leverage)

.

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

49

.
,


.

.
,
(.. )
.



.


.

,
.


,
, .
,


,
. ,
,
.

, .

3 -

3.1

80



.

(Basel Committee on Banking
Supervision BCBS),

(Bank of International
Settlements). ,
- .
,
,
.
1988

(Basel Capital
Accord, 1988),
.



.
(risk weighting)

.
,

8%
36

2012

49

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

50

.6 1996
.


.

.
,
.
,

,
.. . (.. )
(regulatory arbitrage).
.



. , 1999,
: (A New
Capital Adequacy Framework ),
2004

2008.
,


(one size fits
all),



. ,
2007-08.

50

36

2012

2007 ,

. .
,
, , . ,

, , ,
(shadow banking),
, ,
, . ,

, ,
, . ,
, .
,
. ,

,
.

: , .
6 8%
.

.

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

51

,

,
,
,
,

,

.
,


. ,


( ESRB
Dodd-Frank
),

.
,


,

. ,
.


(lagging indicators).
, , 2009
, ,
..,
.



2019.


.
3.2
:
:
.
: .
:

.


(stakeholders).
: , , , .

, ,
,
.
,

,
,

. ,
36

2012

51

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

52

,


.


.
,
.
,

. ,
.
,
.
.
,

. ,

.


.
,

:
) (held to
maturity HTM)
) (loans and receivables L&R)
) (fair value through profit and loss
FVTPL)
) (available for sale
AFS).

.

HTM, ,
.. L&R.
,

.
() .7

3.3

,
,
.

(), , , .


. ,

52

36

2012

7 ,

(impairment test),
(incurred losses). ,

( )
.
, .
,
,
, .
.

(.. / 2442/1998, )

(. 1).
(expected
loss) (. 4.1).

. ,
.

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

53


(FVTPL) ,

(held for trading HFT) , , .8
.
,
(AFS)

,
,
.
,

.9
3.4

,
(available capital) (required
capital).

,

.
,
.


.
.
)
,

:
(permanence),

.
, ,
,
.
,
( )
(.. ), ,
.
, ,
.10
(flexibility),


( )

8
(in an arms length
transaction).
(market value) (model value).
,
.
9

.

AFS .
, AFS
HTM, .
. (PSI) ,

.
(
. ESMA, Public Statement, Sovereign Debt
in IFRS Statements, 25 2011, ESMA/211/397).
10 (subordination)
. .
,
,
. ,

.

36

2012

53

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

54

.

,
,

. ,
.
( l os s
absorption),
(going concern)
(gone concern).
,
,

. ,
,
,
,
.

,
, (Tier 1),
(Tier 2)
(Tier
3).
(upper) (lower) . 1
.
)

, .11
, -

54

36

2012

,

. ,
.
,
,
.
(.. )

(.. ).


.
, ,
.12
1 1 .

.
.

.
12 .
(step-up), ,
(call option),
.

.
( 10 ) .
. (going concern)
. (gone concern)
,
, .
,

.
. 3723/2008
,
( ) 10%.

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

55

1 1

(Tier 1)

-
-

-
-

(Tier 2)

- 50%



- 50%

,
10%

- 50%



- 50%

,
10%



,

20%




(Tier 3)

1 .
/ 2610/29.10.2010.

,

,
15%
. 2007-08
.
)
, -



. ,

,

,
0,6% .
(IRB)
(. 1),
.
36

2012

55

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

56

)
,

.
, , ,

,
,

. ,

(.. ).
,
,
, ,
.
, , 45%,
. (. ),


, .13

.
, ,

.


:


50% 50%
.
( )
, 10%

56

36

2012

, 50%
50% .
(double gearing), , ,

, .

,
20% .
)


.14 ,
50%
.
(cliff-effect), ,

50%, ( )
. .


.

.

1 3
.
, (
regulatory filters)
(unrealised losses) .
1 4 ,
. ,

.

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

57

)

(CAR) :
CAR =

AC
! 8%
Credit risk + Market risk + Operational risk

!
:

.
, (risk weighting) (RW)
(RWA)16 :

CAR: ( )
,
C: ()
(available capital),

!
:
C: ,

Credit risk: ,

RWA: ,

Market risk: ,

A: ,

Operational risk:
.

RW: .

CAR 8%, ,15


,

.

,
, ,

.
:
Tier 1 capital
Tier 1 ratio =
! 4%
Credit risk + Market risk + Operational risk

, 4%.


8. 5, 6 7

CAR =

AC
=
Credit risk + Market risk + Operational risk

AC
AC
=
! 8%
RWAcredit + RWAmarket + RWAoperational RWA

!
,


. , CAR 8%,

15 , CAR .
Dexia,

94 . ,
, (. De Groen,
W.P, A closer look at Dexia: The case of misleading capital
ratios, 19 2011, CEPS Cmmentary).
16 ,
, () 12,5.
8% ( 1/0,08=12,5).

36

2012

57

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

58

.
.

RC (required capital) :
, 100 .
RW=50%, :
= 100 50% 8% =
4 . .
, , 4
. . ,

.
:
, (
) ( RW). ,


.

.
,


(ROE).17

4
4.1



.

. -

58

36

2012

,
(,
)
.
. ,


, ,
,
,
. , .

,
. (
)
.


, ) , .


) , .
.

.


(PDF)

. ,
,
1 7
(tail risk), .
Perotti et al. (2011).

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

59


,


.. ,
,

,
, .
(expected loss),


(unexpected loss),
(stressed loss).



.
,


. , -

,
(fat tails).
, (stress testing) ,18 .

,
:
.
.
.
.

18 . (2011).

36

2012

59

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

60

,
, ,



.

,
1.

. .
,
, .



.
4.2

:
I.

, .
II.

,
.
III.

.

60

36

2012

,


. ,



.
,
.
,
,
, ,
.


,
.
,
:
1:


.
(concentration risk), (country risk), (residual
risk) (securitisation risk).
2:

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

61

.
(interest rate risk on
banking book), (liquidity risk), (business risk) (strategic risk).
3:


.
, (systemic risk).
4:

.
(.
E 3).
(SRP),


(ICAAP) (SREP).
. ,

.


:
.




.
.



,

.

.




.
.




.

5
5.1

.

, 36

2012

61

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

62


,
, .. . ,
, ,

.

,
(default
risk), (exposure risk)
(recovery risk).

,

.
. ,

. ,

. .

, .
, ,

:

(Probability of Default, PD),


.
.

62

36

2012

(Loss Given Default, LGD),



.

, .
(Exposure
at Default, EAD),

.

.
,
.

,
.
(default models)
.
(migration models)
,
.
,


! EL p = ! EL = ! (EADi " PDi " LGDi )


i

. :
,
LGD, :

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

#
UL p = %
%$

09-05-12

13:44

63

1/ 2

" " ! UL UL
ij

&
(
('

!UL = EL(LGD ! EL)

5.2

,



,
(RW).

,

.
(complete markets) ex ante

.

,
, ,
.
, .
,

.

/ (..
)
.
,

. ; ex ante
, .


(credit rating)



(credit mitigation). , .
( standardised approach)
(.. Moodys, S&P ..).


( IRB).
.
1
2 .

(STANDARDISED APPROACH)
, (.. Moodys, S&P ..). 36

2012

63

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

64

0%

20%

50%

100%

100%

150%

100%

20%

50%

100%

100%

150%

150%

100%

75%

35%

. (RW)
.
.
, .
(CRD) ,
.
.
.
, . , , 35% 75% .
, :
, .
(.. ), . , (
)
. . .

.
. .

64

36

2012

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

65

(IRB APPROACH)

.
.
.
:
,

.
, o 1. ,
.
,
.
, .
, ,
-. ,
. , (F-IRB), , , PD,
LGD=45%.1 . , (A-IRB),
. .
,
.
(experience test).

-

1 LGD . ,
(cash flow lending), LGD=45%
, (collateral lending) . ,
LGD 45%
(. S&P, 2004).

36

2012

65

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

66

. ,

(use test).
,
, , , ..,
.


,
. :
)

(lagging indicators) .
(forward looking),

(.
1) . ,

,
.19
)
, , .20

2007-08,
.
, ,
. ,

66

36

2012


. ,
, .



. ,
.
, , 1 9 Enron,
,
.
2 0 2008 IOSCO
. , .
, . , , . .
,
, ,
.
, (NRSROs)
(SEC)
. SEC IOSCO.
,
, 16 2009, ( 1060/2009), , , , .
(ESM)

2011.

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

67


.

.

)
) Dodd-Frank


,
,
. ,
,
,

. 21

150% 100% (. 1).

Dodd-Frank,22
, ,
(Section
939A).

.


23
.

)

(delegated monitoring),

.



.


.
,
.


. -

)
(sovereign risk)



.



21 . Saunders and Allen (2010).
22 . Tobias, A. (2011), Dodd-Frank One Year On: Implications
for Shadow Banking, Federal Reserve Bank of New York Staff
Reports 533.
23
(Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking - ANPR)

(.
http://www.occ.gov/news-issuances/bulletins/2010/bulletin-201032.html).
: (1)
G-20, IMF, (2) (1) , (3)
(4) .

36

2012

67

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

68

. ,


.

,

, 0%

.24 ,
- .
,

,
/ .

,
,25
.
,26

.
5.3
4.1
,
1,
. O

.
(second

68

36

2012

best), . , ,
,
.

(model risk),
,

.
,
Asymptotic
Single Risk Factor (ASRF)
VaR .
,
,
, ,
,
2 4

. (IRB)

(low default
portfolios) .
0% . .


25%
( ).
2 5 . CGFS Papers (2011).

too-big-to-fail,
too-important-to-fail toomany-to-fail.
2 6
, (incremental risk charge). ,
(. 8.4),
,

.

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

69

. ,
. ,
,
,
, ,
(.. CreditMetrix).27 ,

,
.


(concentration risk),
.
,

.



,
(portfolio invariant).28


,
-. ,

(rating-based),
(PD, LGD EAD)
. ,


.
29

99,9%, :

CaR: Capital at Risk (


),
VaR(99,9%): 99,9%,
PDA: ,
adj: ,30
PD LGD , PDA, .31 PDA
Vasicek, ( 3
):

!
PD:
,

: ,
G: ,
27 ASRF
CAPM . .
28 . BCBS (2005) Gordy (2003).
29 .

,

.
30 Vasicek (. 3)
.

. , :

31 ! LGD
, LGD (downturn LGD).

36

2012

69

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

70

R: ,
PDA: .
R


( )

(beta) CAPM
. , R
,

PD
12% 24%. :

R
PD



,
.

VASICEK
Vasicek Merton. Merton (call option) (.. Black-Scholes)
(distance to default). ,
100 , 80
20 , (DD) DD=(100-80)/10=2 , 95% 2,5%. (-1 G) DD. , .
Saunders and Allen (2010), 4.
, Vasicek (. Vasicek, 2002),
y
e . w1,
w2 , :
!

y ,
.

!
,

70

36

2012

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

71

PD ,

, 99,9%,
!, R,

w1 = R w2 = 1R , PDA :

6
6.1


,
, , (
) .

,
(trading)

(hedging). ,
, , ,
.


:
(position risk)
(specific position risk),

,
.
(general position
risk),
,
.

(foreign exchange risk)
.

(counterparty
risk)


.
/
(settlement risk)

36

2012

71

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

72


.

(DVP transactions). (incomplete transactions risk)

(non-DVP
transactions).
(MXA)
(large exposures from trading positions)

.
6.2
, ,
:
= VaR + SR,
:
= VaR + SR + sVaR
+IRC.

.
)
,

.


(

72

36

2012

standardised approach)
( internal model
approach).

. ,

(VaR model, .
2), Ct
k ( min k=3,
- backtesting) :

!
(VaR)




. .
10 , 99%
250 .


,

.
VaR, , .
, VaR
Stressed Value-at-Risk (sVaR)

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

73


. sVaR
(10 , 99,9%)
12 . C t
:

risk) (migration risk).


To IRC

99,9%,
.

#
1
C t = max % VaRt (10) , k1
60
$

60

" VaR
i=1

(10)
t!i

&
( + max
'

#
1
(10)
% sVaRt , k 2 60
$

60

" sVaR
i=1

(10)
t!i

&
(
'


VaR

.

. ,
, ,
.
. ,
, , .
, (model risk).
)
,

. (SR)

( standardised
approach)
VaR (
internal model approach).
VaR

.

(Incremental Risk
Charge, IRC)
(default

, .


,
(OTC)
(SFTs).
, ,
,
, ,
. ,


(potential future exposure).

, .
.


2007-08 .
. :
wrong-way risk
Wrong-way risk
36

2012

73

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

74

(PD EAD
). ,
, .
Credit Valuation Adjustment (CVA)
To CVA
(spread risk).

.



.
6.3
(non-trading book, )

.
, . .
:

74


(basis risk).

(yield curve risk).
(trading risk).



.

(repricing gap)
(duration gap).
(RGAP-repricing gap)
(RSA) (RSL) ()
:

RGAP = RSA ! RSL


NII = RGAP " #r

r: .
(DGAP duration gap)

(DA)
(DL)
() :

!DGAP = DA ! "DL
#E = DGAP $ A $

#r
1+ r

: ,



(repricing risk).

: .

36

2012

7
7.1

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

75


(cost of doing business), ex post
ex ante .
,
,
, .

,
. ,

.


.
, , .



.
,
,
.
, , . .

. (1)
, (2) ,

(3)
, (4) ,
, (5)
, (6)

(7) ,
.
, :
(high frequency, low impact)
(low frequency, high impact).


,

.
, , , ,
,

, , .
,
,
,
, , , (KRIs)
,


.
36

2012

75

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

76

7.2


.
:
(Basic
Indicator Approach),
(Standardised
Approach),

(Advanced Measurement Approach).



,
.


.
4.


(15%) (
alpha factor) . , , .
. ( beta factor) . :
(Corporate Finance)

18%

(Trading and Sales)

18%

(Retail Banking)

12%

(Commercial Banking)

15%

(Payment & Settlement)

18%

(Agency Services)

15%

(Asset Management)

12%

(Retail Brokerage)

12%

,

-

76

36

2012

.
( 4 key elements):

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

77

.
.
.

/
.

,
.
, VaR,

(Loss Distribution Approach LDA). ,

. (Monte
Carlo simulations Copulas).
LDA
,


.

8 :

8.1

. , 2007-08


, .
,

.
,

.


. ,

.
,

,


.
,

,
.
, Bayes

,
. ,

.
36

2012

77

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

78


B
(Common Equity Tier 1 ratio)


(Tier 1 ratio)

4,5%

6%

8,0%


(conservation buffer)

2,5%

7,0%

8,5%

10,5%


(counter-cyclical buffer)

0 2,5%


. ,

, .
, ,
.
( 12,5
)
.
,
,

.
2
,
12.9.2010.32

,

(core Tier 1)
4,5%. , (Tier 1 ratio) 6%,
(CAR)
8%. ,
(conservation
buffer) 2,5%
(counter-cycli-

78

36

2012

cal buffer) 0%-2,5%,


. o 5%
33
. ,

1.1.2019. 2.
8.2

,
,
,

3 2 . BSBC, Group of Governors and Head of Supervision
announces higher global minimum standards, Press release,
12/9/2010.
3 3
. ,
2007:Q32009:Q4 5,4% , 3,2% . (.. 20002002, 1988-1993 ..)
4%-5%
,
1%-2%. , (survivorship bias)
, 2,5%-5% (. BCBS, 2010).

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

79

,
. , .
Tier 1/RWA

(Tier 1 + Tier 2)/RWA.
, Tier 1

,
,
.

:
(common equity
Tier 1),
(additional
Tier 1)
(Tier 2).
,
(Tier 3),


.
. ( ), :
(i)
(. 2),
(ii) ( ),34
-


,
(iii) .


(going concern)
(gone concern).
,
. ,
,

15% . ,
,
.




.

, () 35 (CoCos Con34
, . , .
35 Lloyds
Bank 2009, 7,5 .
Tier 1
5%. Rabobank
2 .
300%
Tier 1 8%. ,
1.300 .
Tier 1 5%
.

36

2012

79

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

80

tingent Convertible Bonds),



.36

.

,
. ,
, , ,
.

.
,
,
,

.
,
,
. , ,

.
,
,
.
,

. , )
, )
)

. (..
) ,
(lagging indicator of risk)

, . (.. -

80

36

2012

)
.
,
.
,
.
8.3
2,

,
(capital buffer)
(. 5).
, ,
,
(procyclicality)37

.
38
.
,
.
3 6 catastrophe bonds (cat
bonds) .
(.. , ) , ,
,
.
3 7 procyclicality - -. InterActive
Terminology for Europe - - ( pro- )
, (. http://iate.europa.eu,
procyclicality).
3 8 . ,
, 2009,
.

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

81


,
.
: ,

. ,


.
,
.
,

. , .


(. 1).



. ,39 .
,
.
(bottom of the cycle calibration),
.
,
2,5% ,


.


, ,
.

, . ,

0%-2,5% .

, ,40
.


. ,
/ (.. bonus)
,
.

,
. ,
.

.

39 . CEBS (2009).
40 GAP=(CREDIT/GDP)x100 TREND,
TREND HodrickPrescott. GAP<2,
GAP>10, 2,5% .
GAP [(0,25 GAP 0,5)/100 ] x RWA.

36

2012

81

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

82

,
, ,
, ,
.



.41
,
.

.
.

, , .


,
.

,

. ,
,

.
4 1 (core Tier 1) 4,5%-5,125%,
100% (. Basel III,
http://www.bis.org/publ/bcbs189.pdf).
, ,


,
.
. ,
.



,
.
. xi
.

i,
.
.

(safety first), , h (tolerable threshold). Pr(K<h)<c, h c.

82

36

2012

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

83

Pr(K<h)<c, Tchebyshev.
KN(,2), Pr(K<h)<c
, k=.

!
h=k

!

h .
8.4

How the banks played the leverage game,42




. 2007-08, ,
,

, ...

, ,

. ,
:
=

3%



,

, ,

3%. , ,
1.1.2018 1.

, (model risk)
. ,
,
. ,



.

.
, , , .
,

42 . Acharya and Richardson (2009), Chapter 2.

36

2012

83

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

84

.
.

.43
, .

, . 15


. ,
.

9


, .

.

,
,
2007-08. : )
, , ..
,

(..
), )

84

36

2012

, ,

.
,



(first best solution),

.

.
4 3
.

, 2013.
,
.

( 20%),

.

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

85

2,
:

,

.

, ,


, .
,
.

,
.


(PIT point-in-time)

(TTC throughthe-cycle). PIT

,

. , TTC .
-

.
(credit rating) (credit scoring) ,
, . :
(application scoring),

,

(behavioural scoring),


.

(judgmental), (quantitative) .*

,
.
,
.
,



. (1)
* de Larosire (. The de Larosire Group (25.2.2009),
High level group on financial supervision in EU)
2007/08,
,
.
Fed, Alan Greenspan,
.
,
(. Alan Greenspan, We will never have a perfect
model of risk, Financial Times, 16.3.2008).

36

2012

85

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

86

(discriminant analysis),
,

, (2)
(logistic regression),


.
(structural models),

Merton
, (intensity-based models),


.

PDt =

(t-1) (t)
(t-1)

:
(t-1) (t):


(t-1):

,

.


(low default portfolios).


,


.
,
(shadow rating system),
(obligor mapping) (grade mapping).

.


.


, -

,

-




(Probability of Default, PD),
(Loss Given Default,
LGD)
(Exposure at Default, EAD).
)

:

86

. (PD)
(EDF)

. , :

36

2012

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

87

. ,
(logit model),
X1 , X2 , XN,

!Z = a 0 + a1 X1 + a 2 X 2 + ... + a n X n ,

F(z) =

1
1 + e !Z

)

(LGD)
, .



. LGD
:

!LGD = 1 ! d
d= .


. LGD
, . :

Pt ! C t

LGD = 1 !

" (1 + r)

EAD

!
P:
( , ),
C:
r: .


LGD
PD,
.
PD
LGD ( )
PD LGD ( ). LGD
PD.
,
LGD ( ), ,
.
) (EAD)
(EAD)


.


(credit conversion factor), , .

.
.


.
.
,


.
36

2012

87

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

88

,

. :
EAD = x
EPE = expected positive exposure ( )
. ,


()
(
).
=1,4.

(validation)
.

.

. ,
(backtesting)
(benchmarking).
,



.

) (calibration):


PD, LGD
EAD, .

.


. , ,

(noise) . ,
,
PD PD . L1
(L1-optimisation),
() .

88

36

2012

Gini

,
.
CAP Cumulative Accuracy Profile
( 3)
( 3).

( 3), ( ). O
(accuracy ratio) Gini

AR= ,

=
=
. AR1,

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

89

.

(backtesting) ()
().
, (mean
).
squared error), MSE=E (

,
.


(benchmarking).

36

2012

89

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

90

2

(VaR)

W t = ! Ai pi,t
i=1


.

. ,

VaR=60.000 95%
, 95%, 60.000 .
5%
60.000 .
10
10 x 60.000
= 189.736,66 95%.

99%,


2,33 / 1,65 x 60.000 = 84.727,27 .
10
10 x 84.727,27 =
267.931,15 .

! i



.
, ,
, ,

(, ).

VaRzero = E(Wt+1) W* = WtR*

. t+1 (
)
,
:
n

W t +1 = ! Ai pi,t +1 " #W = ! Ai #pi


i=1

i=1

!
,
R , , :
Wt+1 = Wt (1+R).
W* t+1. :
W* = Wt (1+R*).
VaR
,
VaRmean = E(Wt+1)W*= Wt (R*)
,
=0,

VaR W* . f(w) , c

w<W*, W* :
+$

Pr(w >W ! ) = c " 1# p =

% f (w)dw ,

w!



n , t (
) pi,t i=1,...n.
:

90

36

2012

w!

Pr(w >W ! ) = 1# c " p =

% f (w)dw
#$

! W*
f(w).

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

91



f(w) ()
~(0,1). W*, R*. R*
R*.

>0, :


.
,
.

:

= (R* )/

!

1c.
w#

1! c =

! R#

!a

$ f (w)dw = $ f (r)dr = $ %(& )d&


!"

!"

!!

2=

!"

!
2=

VaR
R*.
2=
R*= +
:

VaRmean=E(Wt+1)W*=Wt(R*)=Wt t

VaRzero=E(Wt+1)W*=WtR*=Wt( tt)

!! !
!

i:
Ri:
i:

i,j: i j.

36

2012

91

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

92

Acharya, V. and M. Richardson (2009), Restoring financial stability: How to repair a failed system, John Wiley and Sons Inc.
Acharya, V., H. Mehran, T. Schuermann and A. Thakor (2011), Robust Capital Regulation,
Federal Reserve Bank of New York, Staff Report o. 490.
Admati, A, P. DeMarzo, M. Hellwig, and P. Pfleiderer (2010), Fallacies, Irrelevant Facts, and
Myths in the Discussion of Capital Regulation: Why Bank Equity is Not Expensive, Stanford
University Working Paper No. 86.
Akerlof, G. and R. J. Shiller (2009), Animal Spirits: How Human Psychology Drives the Economy, and Why It Matters for Global Capitalism, Princeton University Press.
BCBS (2005), An Explanatory Note on the Basel II IRB Risk Weight Functions.
BCBS (2010), Calibrating regulatory minimum capital requirements and capital buffers: a topdown approach.
Blundell-Wignall, A. and P. Atkinson (2010), Thinking beyond Basel III: Necessary solutions
for capital and liquidity, OECD Journal: Financial Market Trends, Vol. 2010/1.
Bolton, P. and O. Jeanne (2011), Sovereign default risk and bank fragility in financially integrated economies, NBER Working Papers, No 16899, March.
Brunnermeier, M., A. Crockett, C. Goodhart, A.D. Persaud and H. Shin (2009), The Fundamental Principles of Financial Regulation, ICMB and CEPR.
X., (2011), : H
, . . (.),
, , .
CEBS (2009), Position paper on a countercyclical capital buffer.
CGFS Papers (2011), The impact of sovereign credit risk on bank funding conditions, No. 43.
De Weert, F. (2011), Bank and Insurance Capital Management, Wiley Finance.
Drehmann M., C. Borio and K. Tsatsaronis (2011), Anchoring countercyclical capital buffers:
the role of credit aggregates, BIS Working Papers, No. 355.
Engelmann, B. and R. Rauhmeier (2011), The Basel II Risk Parameters: Estimation, Validation
and Stress Testing, Springer.
European Parliament, Directorate General for Internal Policies, Policy Department, Economic
and Monetary Affairs (2010), The interaction between sovereign debt and risk weighting under
the Capital Requirements Directive (CRD) as an incentive to limit government exposures.
Gordy, M.B. (2003), A risk-factor model foundation for ratings-based bank capital rules, Journal of Financial Intermediation, 12, 199-232.
Gregory, J. (2010), Counterparty credit risk: The new challenge for global financial markets, Wiley
Finance.
Gregoriou, G. (2009), Operational Risk toward Basel III: Best Practices and Issues in Modeling, Management, and Regulation, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Hildebrand, P.M. (2008), Is Basel II Enough? The Benefits of a Leverage Ratio, Financial Markets Group Lecture, London School of Economics, London, December 15.
Hugh, T. and Z. Wang (2005), Interpreting the internal ratings-based capital requirements
in Basel II, Journal of Banking Regulation, 6, 274-289.
, . (2006), ( )
, , 47, .
, . (2011),
(stress tests) , , , 35, .

92

36

2012

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

09-05-12

13:44

93

Kashyap, A. K. and J. Stein (2004), Cyclical Implications of the Basel II Capital Standards.,
Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, Economic Perspectives, vol. 28, Q1, 18-31.
Matten, C. (2003), Managing Bank Capital Capital Allocation and Performance Measurement,
John Wiley & Sons.
Miles, D., J. Yang and G. Marcheggiano (2011), Optimal bank capital, Bank of England Discussion Paper No. 31.
Morrison, A.D. and L. White (2009), Level Playing Fields in International Financial Regulation, Journal of Finance, LXIV, no. 3, 1099-42.
Perotti, E., L. Ratnovski and R. Vlahu (2011), Capital regulation and tail risk, International
Journal of Central Banking, December.
Rafael, R. and J. Saurina (2011), The countercyclical capital buffer of Basel III: A critical assessment, CEPR Discussion Paper No. 8304.
Saunders, A. and L. Allen (2010), Credit Risk Measurement In and Out of the Financial Crisis:
New Approaches to Value at Risk and Other Paradigms, Third Edition, John Wiley & Sons,
Inc.
S&P (2004), Risk Solutions: Recovery rates for European SMEs, June.
VanHoose, D. (2007), Theories of bank behavior under capital regulation, Journal of Banking and Finance, 31, 3680-3697.
Vasicek, O. (2002), Loan portfolio value, RISK, December, 160-162.

36

2012

93

3.Meleti Kalfaoglou:

94

09-05-12

36

2012

13:44

94

You might also like