Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ALAN R. GURD
FAT
and
From
EMBOLISM
R. I. WILsoN,
Victoria
SYNDROME
BELFAST,
Hospital,
NORTHERN
Belfast
IRELAND
the Royal
The undiagnosed.
of skin
fat
and
embolism The
mucosa
syndrome, classical
is not
often
seen.
frequently and
passes petechiae
picture
always fat
of cerebral between
embolism
A distinction
pathologically. trauma (Sevitt 1957,
must
Post-mortem,
be made
the
and
fat
deaths
demonstrated
causes other than
is often
clinical emboli
1962, Bergentz 1968). It is also found evidence of the syndrome (Warren 1946, Scully is of doubtful significance in cases where the clinical
in deaths following fracture without 1956). The finding of pulmonary fat features of the syndrome are absent.
TABLE
DIAGNOSIS OF THE FAT
I
EMBOLISM SYNDROME
period
featuresfeaturesfeatures-I) I) Respiratory
involvement;
insufficiency;
3) Petechial rash
2) Cerebral
Laboratory
2)
Thrombocytopenia;
erythrocyte
macroglobulaemia
sedimentation
rate;
4) Fat
In this
series
100 cases
of the
syndrome
seen
over
a period
of four
years
are
analysed.
Certain clinical features were looked for in suspected cases (Table I) and in addition blood samples were checked for pathological fat globules. A positive diagnosis was made on finding at least one major feature, four minor features, and fat macroglobulaemia (Gurd 1970). The assessment of pathological fat globulaemia has been criticised by Nolte, Olofsson, Schersten and Lewis (1974), who report finding large fat globules as often in normal patients and in patients with fractures as in proven cases of fat embolism syndrome. In the original description of the test it was pointed It was merely out that pathological fat was blood globules number seen, often in considerable quantities, after fractures. feature was not onset found necessary the demonstration to assess of fat values but daily because the important the finding of either a recent or a change in their
of fat macroglobulaemia,
or an increase
in the
of globules,
appearance associated with the onset of the clinical As with the post-mortem finding of pulmonary in the asymptomatic patient is probably irrelevant. finding which is specific in fat embolism is one of of the condition under discussion here is made association with accepted clinical features. The embolism syndrome rather than the misleading embolism
408
condition. fat emboli, so, too, fat macroglobulaemia Bergentz (1968) asserts that the only intravascular fat droplets. The diagnosis when fat macroglobulaemia is found in condition is then referred to as the fat term fat embolism, which denotes the of their
THE JOURNAL
of fat droplets
with
or without
clinical
evidence
presence.
OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY
THE
SYNDROME STUDY
409
Of males
the ranged
100
from
patients fourteen
seventy-seven to ninety-one
were years
male
and (average
twenty-three thirty-three)
female. and
The
of the
ages
females
of the
from
sixteen half
to sixty-six
years
(average
The
mean
average
age
was
years. Forty-nine cases followed multiple (Table II). Thirty followed femoral shaft
In seven cases
with two or more long ten tibial fracture and four either
11
IN
the
syndrome
followed
injury
minor
bone
injury
or no demonstrable
NATURE
OF FAT
THE
INJURY
100
CASES
OF
EMBOLISM
SYNDROME
Injury Multiple
Femoral Tibial Pelvic Trauma: Trauma:
Number
.
fractures
shaft fracture fracture minor no fracture
.
49 30
10
4 4
fracture
.
fracture
fracture.
Thus
two
patients
fell
from
step
ladders,
both
sustaining
soft-tissue
injury
and
A girl
was
lay
hypothermia, after he
stairs died
was chest
bruised; later; no
Two evident
days
a classical
syndrome
abdomen,
had
sustained
arms
PRESENTATION
In all cases
varied latent from period four of
there
hours fifteen
was
days
a latent
in one
period
days, case with may
between
an average
injury
time
the
onset
of symptoms.
hours. The
This
recorded
to fifteen
of forty-six
patient fifteen
two
days
after
of onset
clinical
presentation.
In thirty-four
symptoms
tachycardia
first in
were
twenty
usually drowsiness and pyrexia heralded more patients with dyspnoea, in only seventeen
CLINICAL
rash
was
the
presenting
sign
cases.
FEATURES
was with
had was
and The
NO.
moist tension
even
arterial oxygen
1974
56B.
A. R. GURD
AND
R. I. WILSON
of mercury; in seventeen cases
was
less
than
50 millimetres
it
81. chest.
the
films
patchy areas of consolidation (Fig. normal radiographs, two had a p02 level of under 80 millimetres with clinically normal lungs had moderate radiological changes. twenty-two There patients. was some cerebral involvement and and in eighty patients,
patients with Two patients occurred in had of associated these nine the peak of
of whom
FIG.
An
antero-posterior
radiograph
of the
typically rash
first at times
seen
over
the be more
and
axillary
It was also
in the buccal
mucosa
it could or and
Pyrexia
noted
or exudates
above and
and
tachycardia
was recorded
per
minute in seven,
in eighty-three
Ophthalmoscopy
in sixty-three
patients
was
normal
Retinal
haemorrhages
were
fat
droplets always
seventeen
in the subsided
became
Five renal
anuric
oliguric,
one
became
incontinent.
LABORATORY INVESTIGATIONS
than
were recorded in sixty-eight patients, the maximum fall were monitored in only
THE
in sixteen
Daily
counts
a drop
SURGERY
of
JOURNAL
THE
FAT EMBOLISM
SYNDROME
50 per
cent
or more
was
found
in twenty-three,
with
minimum
cubic
millimetre in twelve patients. In eighty-seven cases the erythrocyte sedimentation rate was raised, with values of 30 to 50 millimetres in sixteen cases, 51 to 70 millimetres in seventeen cases, and over 71 millimetres in fifty-four cases. Fat globules larger than 8 microns were found circulating in all cases. The amount of circulating fat did not appear to correlate with the clinical severity of the condition.
..
FIG.
A photograph
showing COURSE
of petechiae.
Thirty-six patients recovered without any treatment. In the remaining cases treatment was directed towards: 1) the restoration of circulating volume with fresh blood or a physiological substitute; 2) the correction of acidosis; and 3) immobilisation of the affected part. Additional treatment was primarily concerned with respiratory support. In twenty cases routine
required
ward full
care
with
chest
care
physiotherapy
and
oxygen
by mask
was
sufficient.
respiratory
endotracheal require
with twenty-six
and 40 per cent oxygen, Ten comatose patients patient. or severe tachycardia, lung four
Digoxin
required
units
for
intravenously
three 3, to six
AUGUST
days.
1974
56B,
NO.
A. R. GURD
AND
R. I. WILSON
with
patients recovered fully, seven recovered with scotomata and five with personality severe pulmonary causes. insufficiency
100 cases
of
the
fat embolism
syndrome, findings
the
diagnosis
was
made
from
plus the demonstration of circulating has been shown to occur after minor (Bryans relationship obscure, for and Eiseman 1955: of these large fat we more have than found a century. by the
minor
Castelli,
trauma
Kropp
in a variety
Tedeschi
of 1968).
globules
to
the
of
clinical
Basically two concepts have evolved, the theory it is alleged that fat is liberated
an increase of intramedullary pressure and transmitted via the draining veins to the pulmonary capillaries, where it lodges. The metabolic theory suggests that emboli arise in the plasma from conglomeration and fusion ofa pre-existing physiological suspension oftiny chylomicrons (usually less than one micron), possibly due to some biochemical change initiated by injury. Other changes occur which augment the embolic effect of the large fat globules, such as agglutination of the formed elements of blood-particularly platelets and red cells-and an increase in the viscosity of plasma and whole blood (Bergentz, Gelin, Rudenstam and Zederfeldt 1961). Aggregation of platelets, chylomicrons and red cells can be produced by injection of thromboplastic substances, which also cause the formation of fat droplets (Bergentz 1961, Adkins, Foster and OSaile 1962). The pathological sequence of events is not yet proven, but the triggering mechanism appears to be an over-compensation in response to injury, haemorrhage, decreased venous return and increased cardiac output (Fig. 3). Reactive vasoconstriction
follows, causing local tissue hypoxia; carbohydrate metabolism is altered and there is an
post-traumatic
activation
of
the
coagulation
(disseminated intravascular and the metabolic acidosis. vasoactive polypeptides, of post-traumatic shock.
facet of the post-traumatic
them the
syndrome.
the fat
is probably
An association between pulmonary fat embolism and intravascular coagulation has frequently been reported (Bradford, Foster and Nossel 1970; Saldeen 1970; Soloway and Robinson 1972). It has been said that fat embolism potentiates shock (Porter 1917), but in reality the reverse applies (Peltier 1965, Volz 1966). It is our impression that the clinical syndrome is not uncommon: it occurred in 19 per cent
Over
of
the
a third
remained
Pulmonary
admitted
cases were
to
so the
had
was in
they diffuse
diagnosis
the Royal Victoria Hospital, Belfast, with major trauma. mild that no treatment was required, and these might have not been screened both clinically and for fat macroglobules.
most and common for feature, usually with tachypnoea, dyspnoea
and
proved
evidence
valuable
of had arterial
bilateral
both
oedema.
monitoring
Arterial
treatment.
oxygen
tension
Almost half
estimation
of those
investigated a lowered
normal or Defective
minimum
PO2 pCO2. transfer
values in injured
across
50 millimetres is diagnostic
of mercury. when
membrane
Ross
(1970)
believes with
the severe
found
in conjunction
is caused by
reduced gas
alveolar/arteriolar
degree
of alveolar
oedema
that
develops
in this
syndrome.
THE
Carbon
JOURNAL OF
dioxide
BONE AND
is not
JOINT
retained
SURGERY
SYNDROME
at a much faster rate than does oxygen. shunting plays an important role (Sproule, the significant congested positive features hilar shadows other features pulmonary
dilatation of the right heart. Radiographs also help to exclude such as pneumothorax (Fig. 4). The importance of arterial hypoxia in producing the cerebral syndrome has cases reported There and
cerebral appear
been here
stressed confusion,
and by Ross (1970). In most to follow the onset of hypoxia. who became
fat
were in whom
ten
patients,
predominate occasionally.
orientated minimal
common
deeply
comatose where
but does
respiratory
involvement
is less
Systemic
fat embolism
embolism,
features to occur
Haemorrhage
j
ReactIve Vasoconstriction
Activation
\
Tissue kCI Activation Hypoxia D0]
of Proteases + Release of
Polypeptides
Vasoactive
(Kinins)
SHOCK
I
LFAT
A suggested scheme EMBOLISM
and
SYNDROME
FIG.
of the rationale
syndrome.
on
in 1911,
they occur
are
across
a classical finding, usually the front of the chest, of the mouth and were even noted on and is (1965) cases white 1948, of
very and
easily Bergentz
overlooked (1968)
unless
quote
the 20 per
is studied the on
may last only a few days every day. Both Peltier of petechiae Classically, are found in diagnosed multiple (Newman
changes streaks
may
be
fluffy Kearns
of haemorrhage
macular
1956, Adams 1971). Scotomata may occur and usually resolve completely (Duke-Elder 1954). Oliguria is not uncommon and complete anuria does occur. Renal involvement is so frequent in fat embolism that Sevitt (1960) has suggested needle biopsy of the kidney as an aid to the diagnosis of obscure cases. Adebahr (1957) believes the sudden drop in the haemoglobin value, occurring even after adequate blood replacement at the time of injury, is due to pulmonary
VOL.
haemorrhage.
NO.
It
1974
is much
more
likely
that
this
anaemia
follows
an
increased
56B,
3,
AUGUST
A. R. GURD followed
AND by
cells
(Gelin
1956). of the fat embolism not been a routine syndrome in fact means to give fracture patients the prevention prophylactic of shock. treatment In many of shock
of transfusions, sedatives, analgesics or general anaesthesia (Bergentz 1968). This why fracture patients subjected to immediate internal fixation appear to develop syndrome less often than patients treated conservatively (Saikku 1954, Liljedahl 1967). Adequate volume substitution is essential, solutions or Fonkalsrud, showed that can
. 1
Westermark
________________
------
w-
result
in fat attempts
haematocrit
embolism. to
(1968)
traumatic
which
capacity
gives much
satisfactory
blood
of the
without is also
too
with
acidosis
flow.
Correction
necessary,
of
as
metabolic
early
immobilisation in the
by the
of the production
study. naturally
of proteases
is currently inhibition
under
occurring
used in
enzyme
thirty patients.
Trasylol as part
has
Unfortunately
been
it was trial
not and
given statistical
conclusions
yet be drawn. It is difficult specific treatment amongst measures spontaneous given to each recovery patient occurs
An the
FI;. 4 antcro-postcrior radiograph of the lung fields typical diffuse patchy appearances, complicated left side by a pneumothorax.
can
thirty-three
treatment
for whom
available,
and
a second g
rou
of sixt y
-seven
cases
routine 15 per
In the syndrome,
first
where protease lnhIbltlOn therapy was available but only given to thirty when group 60 per cent recovered fully and while in the second group recovery (1972), and was in the III). shock Zimmerman lung syndrome
full in 85 per cent and the mortality only 5 per cent (Table controlled trials with protease inhibition in patients with the
fat embolism syndrome, has reduced the mortality from almost 70 per cent with routine therapy alone to 39 per cent when using Trasylol in addition. Three cases in this present study died of massive pulmonary embolism whilst on protease inhibition treatment. In retrospect we noted that Trasylol was not commenced until the pCO2 had begun prophylactically to rise, which is a bad and therefore given prognostic as early sign. Protease as possible. This, inhibition of course, ought makes to be used evaluation that side-
as so many cases recover spontaneously. It is our clinical impression with Trasylol has a place in the treatment of this syndrome. No
in the thirty cases treated.
THE JOURNAL OF BONE AND JOINT
SURGERY
415
P#{176}2 Besides
the
unit.
correction
Antibiotics
and
the
for
lowering and
all patients
of blood such
with
viscosity, patients
respiratory ought
respiratory
care
may intensive
moderate
or severe
involvement.
be for
required
or in any
right that
and can
hypocalcaemia.
hypocalcaemia of these
A summary
TABLE
RESULTS IIEFORE AND
ADVENT
OF
TRASYLOL
Mortality Group Number of cases 33 67 Trasylol Partial recovery 4 3 Full recovery 20(60#{176}c) 57(835#{176}) Overall 9 7 Fat embolism syndrome
5(15#{176},)
A B
0 30
3(45#{176},,)
TABLE
SCHEME OF
IV
TREATMENT
Shock
of normal
I) Maintenance 2) Care
of normal
arterial
patient
P#{176}2
3) Non-specific
SUMMARY
1.
A distinction
must
be made
between
the which
entity,
fat
following years
include
cases
and
syndrome
fat
encountered
criteria have
a period
defined.
been
major
studied feature,
diagnostic
been
one
macroglobulaemia.
3.
eight
Sixteen The
of the
other
patients
traumatic
from
severe
insufficiency of the
of the syndrome.
4. the 5.
prevention in the
of shock production
of proteases
of shock
of protease
inhibition
syndrome are briefly discussed. For the established case the aim
of treatment
is to ensure
an adequate
oxygen.
VOL.
56
B,
NO.
3,
AUGUST
1974
416
A. R. GURD
AND
R. I. WILSON to study Respiratory patients under their care, and Dr R. C. Intensive Care Unit, Royal Victoria
We wish to thank our orthopaedic colleagues for permission Gray, Dr D. L. Coppel and Dr W. F. K. Morrow of the Hospital. Belfast, for their invaluable help. REFERENCES
ADAMS,
ADEBAHR,
C. B. T. (1971):
G R.
.
The
retinal
( I 957)
: Blutungen J. 156,
bei
Injury, 2, 221-224. Zentralblatt fir ailgemeine study Blutungen fat embolism. of the genesis
Pathokgie
iu,d
pathologisclze
ADKINS,
Anatomie,
FOSTER,
96, 267-274.
B., G
H., and
515-527.
D. (1962):
A,znals
BENESTAD.
of Surgen,
.
( I 91 1 ) : Drei 112,
in der Haut.
Ada
fir
BERGENTZ,
194-205.
Supplementum
BERGENTZ, BERGENTZ,
(1961): 282.
(1968):
GELIN,
on the genesis
Progress
chirurgica
embolism.
RUDENSTAM,
Surgerj, and
6, 85-120.
B. (1961): Indications for the use of low dextran in surgery. Acta chirurgica Scandinavica, 122, 343-357. BRADFORD, D. S., FOSTER, R. R., and NOSSEL, H. L. (1970): Coagulation alterations, hypoxemia, and fat embolism in fracture patients. Journal ofTrauma, 10, 307-321. BRYANS, W., and EISEMAN, B. (1955): The incidence of fat globulemia following soft tissue and orthopedic operations. Surgical Forum, 6, 28-32. DUKE-ELDER, Sir W. S. (1954): Textbook ofOphthalmology. Volume VI. Injuries. London: Henry Kimpton. GEuN, L.-E. (1956): Studies in anemia ofinjury. Acta chfrurgica Scandinavica, Supplementum 210. GURD, A. R. (1970): Fat embolism: an aid to diagnosis. JournalofBone andJoint Surgery, 52-B, 732-737. KEARNS, T. P. ( I 956) : Fat embolism of the retina : demonstrated by flat retinal preparation. America,z Journal C.-M.,
ZEDERFELDT,
viscous
of Ophthalmology,
LIUEDAHL,
41
1-2.
S.-O.,
and
11,
WESTERMARK,
L. (1967):
Aetiology
and treatment
MALONEY,
of fat embolism.
Acta
anaesthesiologica associated
Surgery,
Scandinaica,
MILLER,
177-194.
J. A., extracorporeal
P. 290-297.
FONKALSRUD,
circulation
H. (1948): The
J. V. F. (1962):
51, 448-451. Journal
Fat embolism
and Joint of the
with
30-B,
NEWMAN,
diagnosis
of Bone Evaluation
W. J., OLOF5SON, T., SCHERSTEN, T., and LEWIS, D. H. (1974): embolism. Journal of Boze and Joint Surgery, 56-B, 417-420. PELTIER, L. F. (1965): The diagnosis of fat embolism. Surgery, Gynecology
NOLTE,
Gurd
121,
test
371-379.
for
fat
and Obstetrics,
and Surgical
PORTER,
W. A.
T. (1917):
Fat
embolism.
A cause
of shock.
Boston
Medical
Journal,
176,
248.
The fat embolism syndrome: with special reference to the importance of hypoxia in the syndrome. Aiiizals f the Royal College of Surgeons of England, 46, 159-171. SAIKKU, L. A. (1954): Fat embolism in connection with treatment of fractures. Acta chiriirgica Scandiizarica, 108, 275-282. SALDEEN, T. (1970): Fat embolism and signs of intravascular coagulation in post-traumatic autopsy material. Journal of Trauma, 10, 273-286. SCULLY, R. E. (1956): Fat embolism in Korean battle casualties. American Journal of Pathology, 32, 379-403. SEVIrr, S. (1957): Burns. Pathology and Therapeutic Applications. London: Butterworth & Co. (Publishers) Ltd. SEvrrr, S. (1960): The significance and classification of fat-embolism. Lancea, 2, 825-828. SEVITT, S. (1962): Fat Embolism. London: Butterworths. SOLOWAY, H. B., and ROBINsON, E. F. (1972): The coagulation mechanism in experimental pulmonary fat embolism. Journal of Trauma, 12, 630-631. SPROULE, B. J., BRADY, J. L., and GILBERT, J. A. L. (1964): Studies on the syndrome of fat embolization. Canadian Medical Associatio,z Journal, 90, 1243-1247. TEDESCHI. C. G., CA5TELLI, W., KROPP, G., and TEDESCHI, L. G. (1968): Fat macroglobulinemia and fat embolism. Surgery, Gynecology and Obstetrics, 126, 83-90. VOLZ, R. G. (1966): Current concepts of fat embolism. Rocky Mountain Medical Journal, 63, 39-43. WARREN, S. (1946): Fat embolism. America,, Journal of Pathology, 22, 69-88. WERTZBERGER, J. J. T., and PELTIER, L. F. (1968): Fat embolism: the importance of arterial hypoxia. Surgeri, 63, 626-629. ZIMMERMAN, W. E. (1972): Paper read at a symposium on shock held at Buenos Aires, South America in
Ross,
P. J. (1970):
October
1972.
THE
JOURNAL
OF
BONE
AND
JOINT
SURGERY