You are on page 1of 5

COMMENTS BY PTSC ENGINEERING TEAMS

Book 1 of 12: Part 1 Structural steel calculation (02ME-5400) C03-001 Structural design calculation (02ME-5400) Wrong content, Vendor to update approved one Lifting calculation section can be excluded

PLEASE FIND ATTACHED FILE FOR REPLACEMENT. Structural steel calculation (01ME-5300) C03-002 Structural design calculation (01ME-5300) Wrong content, Vendor to update approved one Lifting calculation section can be excluded

PLEASE FIND ATTACHED FILE FOR REPLACEMENT Doc C06-001 Vessel Design Calculation (02ME-5400) Design calculation for Utility Gas Scrubber (02V-5420) Design calculation for Utility Gas Filter/ Coalescer (02V-5430A) Design calculation for Utility Gas Filter/ Coalescer (02V-5430B) Doc No.: DC12118-08 Design calculation for Instrument Gas Filter (02V-5440) Design calculation for Fuel Gas Heater (01H-5310)

THESE DOCUMENTS ARE ALREADY APPROVED (CODE 1) by MES. THERE SHOULD NOT BE ANY CHANGES/REVISE ON THESE DOCUMENTS. AND ALSO, THESE DESIGN DOCUMENTS ARE REVIEWD BY APPLIED ENGINEERING QC AND BV MALAYSIA. Book 2 of 12: Doc C06-001 Vessel Design Calculation (01ME-5300) Design calculation for Fuel Gas Scrubber (01V-5320) Design calculation for Fuel Gas Filter (01V-5330A) Design calculation for Fuel Gas Filter (01V-5330B)

SAME AS ABOVE REPLY.

Page 1 of 5

Doc C06-003 Instrument Gas Cooler Design Calculation (02ME-5400) SAME AS ABOVE REPLY.

Doc C13-001 HST&HSD Equipment Sizing Calculation (01ME-5300 & 02ME-5400) Heater datasheet: vendor to attach in Mechanical equipment datasheet (G08-001)

PLEASE FIND ATTACHED. Book 7 of 12: Section P: Part 7 Site acceptance test (SAT) and offshore commissioning procedures/ HST 01ME-5300 It is SAT report. Vendor to attach cover page to sign Vendor to attach SAT procedure separately

PLEASE FIND ATTACHED 02ME-5400 It is SAT report. Vendor to attach cover page to sign Vendor to attach SAT procedure separately

PLEASE FIND ATTACHED Part 13: Vessel detail drawing (02ME-5400) Vendor to refer comment on Book 11 of 12 (Section P: Manufacturers data report by Applied Eng). These drawings shall be same

THESE DRAWINGS ARE FABRICATION SHOP DRAWINGS; THEY ARE USED FOR FABRICATION AND AS-BUILT ENDORESED BY APPLIED ENGINEERING. THESE DRAWINGS CANNOT BE THE SAME AS FINAL CODE 1 APPROVAL DRAWINGS. Part 14: Vessel detail drawing (01ME-5300 instead of 02ME-5300) Vendor to refer comment on Book 9, 10 of 12 (Section P: Manufacturers data report by Applied Eng). These drawings shall be same

THESE DRAWINGS ARE FABRICATION SHOP DRAWINGS; THEY ARE USED FOR FABRICATION AND AS-BUILT ENDORESED BY APPLIED ENGINEERING. THESE DRAWINGS CANNOT BE THE SAME AS FINAL CODE 1 APPROVAL DRAWINGS.

Page 2 of 5

Book 8 of 12: D29-002 Valve list It is not approved document. Vendor to attach approved one

PLEASE FIND ATTACHED. G15-002 HSD Instrument Datasheet Wrong content (Instrument list?)

XXXX M01-001 Operation and Maintenance manual (01ME-5300) Vendor to revise as per comment on document No.M01-001 Rev A

PLEASE FIND ATTACHED. M01-002 Operation and Maintenance manual (02ME-5400) Vendor to revise as per comment on document No.M01-002 Rev A

PLEASE FIND ATTACHED. Book 9 of 12: Section P: Manufacturers data report by Applied Eng Fuel Gas Scrubber 01V-5320 Refer to C06-001 (Heat treatment requirement for head (Doc No.: DC12118-02 Page No.13). Vendor to revise drawing IA-1202-FGC-ME-VSD-201 (Vessel detail, nameplate drawing) to reflect Heat treatment requirement for HEAD.

THERE IS NO HEAT TREATMENT REQUIREMENT ON DC12118-02 PAGE 13 PLEASE VERIFY. Book 10 of 12: Section P: Manufacturers data report by Applied Eng Fuel Gas Filter/ Coalescer 01V-5330A

THESE DRAWINGS ARE FABRICATION SHOP DRAWINGS; THEY ARE USED FOR FABRICATION AND AS-BUILT ENDORESED BY APPLIED ENGINEERING. THESE DRAWINGS CANNOT BE THE SAME AS FINAL CODE 1 APPROVAL DRAWINGS. Fuel Gas Filter/ Coalescer 01V-5330B

THESE DRAWINGS ARE FABRICATION SHOP DRAWINGS; THEY ARE USED FOR FABRICATION AND AS-BUILT ENDORESED BY APPLIED ENGINEERING. Page 3 of 5

THESE DRAWINGS CANNOT BE THE SAME AS FINAL CODE 1 APPROVAL DRAWINGS. Fuel Gas Heater 01H-5310

THESE DRAWINGS ARE FABRICATION SHOP DRAWINGS; THEY ARE USED FOR FABRICATION AND AS-BUILT ENDORESED BY APPLIED ENGINEERING. THESE DRAWINGS CANNOT BE THE SAME AS FINAL CODE 1 APPROVAL DRAWINGS.

Book 11 of 12: Section P: Manufacturers data report by Applied Eng Utility Gas Scrubber 02V-5420 Vessel detail drawing is not approved drawing as Document D20-001. Vendor to replace approved one.

THESE DRAWINGS ARE FABRICATION SHOP DRAWINGS; THEY ARE USED FOR FABRICATION AND AS-BUILT ENDORESED BY APPLIED ENGINEERING. THESE DRAWINGS CANNOT BE THE SAME AS FINAL CODE 1 APPROVAL DRAWINGS. Refer to C06-001 (Heat treatment requirement for head ((Doc No.: DC12118-06 Page No.13). Vendor to revise drawing IA-1201-FGC-ME-VSD-101 (Vessel detail, nameplate drawing) to reflect Heat treatment requirement for HEAD.

THERE IS NO HEAT TREATMENT REQUIREMENT ON DC12118-02 PAGE 13 PLEASE VERIFY.

Material name [Normalized] SA516 70 for Cylinder (Doc No.: DC12118-06 Page No.05)? No Normalized mil cert for item 21 in Material verification records 02V-5420? Vendor to correct all effected document if any (MDR, Material verification record, drawing)

THESE DOCUMENTS ARE ALREADY APPROVED (CODE 1). THERE SHOULD NOT BE ANY CHANGES/REVISE ON THESE DOCUMENTS.

Utility Gas Filter 02V-5430A Page 4 of 5

Vessel detail drawing is not approved drawing as Document D20-001 RevI. Vendor to replace approved one.

PLEASE FIND ATTACHED.

Material name [Normalized] SA516 70 for Cylinder (Doc No.: DC12118-07 Page No.05)???. No Normalized mil cert for item 14 in Material verification records 02V5430A? Vendor to correct all effected document if any (MDR, Material verification record, drawing)

SAME AS PREVIOUS REPLY.

Refer to C06-001 (Heat treatment requirement for head (Doc No.: DC12118-07 Page No.12). Vendor to revise drawing IA-1201-FGC-ME-VSD-102 (Vessel detail, nameplate drawing) to reflect Heat treatment requirement for HEAD.

SAME AS ABOVE FEEDBACK. Book 12 of 12: Section P: Manufacturers data report by Applied Eng (continue) Utility Gas Filter 02V-5430B Same comment as 02V-5430A

SAME AS ABOVE FEEDBACK

Instrument Gas Filter/ Coalescer 02V-5440 In drawing IA-Y1201-FGC-ME-VSD-104 (SHT 1 OF 4): Vendor to update elevation for nozzle K1B 75mm as approved vessel detail drawing D20-001 Rev I

THIS DOCUMENT IS ALREADY CODE-1 APPROVAL AND ITS ACCORDING TO AS-BUILT.

Page 5 of 5

You might also like