Professional Documents
Culture Documents
L-edges K-edge
1s
2s
2p
3s
3p 3d
continuum
EXAFS (extended x-ray absorption fine structure) Pre-edge and Edge (XANES)
Geometric Information
XAS or XAFS
Fast data acquisition time and high signal-to-noise ratio. Can be measured at room temperature without depreciation of data quality. The pre-edge region can be used to estimate: !! Ligand-field !! Spin-State !! Centrosymmetry The rising-edge region can be used to estimate: !! Geometric Structure !! Metal-Ligand overlap via Shakedown transitions !! Ligand arrangement in certain cases !! Charge on the metal center
!!
!!
Qualitatively !! Uses edges as a fingerprint of the electronic structure !! Compare to known model complexes !! Use in PCA analysis Molecular Orbital-Based Approach !! Obtain a more quantitative description !! Understand energy and intensity distributions using LF theory !! Works well for bound state transitions !! Fails for rising-edge and beyond. Multiple Scattering-Based Approach !! Required to simulate rising edge !! FEFF, MXAN !! Difficult to relate back to an MO-based picture Band Structure Approach !! Density of States
!!
!!
!!
M 4p edge M 3d L 3p energy edge pre-edge pre-edge M 1s Metal K-pre-edge absorptions arise due to a quadrupole-allowed dipole-forbidden 1s 3d excitation (!l = 2) - weak Metal K-rising edge absorptions are electric dipole allowed (!l = 1)- Intense
!! !!
The rising-edge and the edge maxima shift to higher energy as the oxidation state increases. Important consideration similar ligand system.
!!
!!
Both Ni samples. What oxidation states do they represent? Ni is special case with little change upon oxidation!
!!
Normalized Absorption
Coordination no:
z
2 Cu
3 Cu
4 Cu
0.8
y
0.4
x Energy
pz px,y 4px,y,z
px
Py,z
px,y,z
0.0
!! !!
Rising edge has strong contribution from the 1s to 4p transition. In special cases where the 4p orbital is low-lying, the energy and intensity of the edge transition can be used to estimate coordination number/geometry
M 4p M 4p M 3d M 3d L 3p
Normalized Absorption
0.8
0.4
Shakedown
M 1s M 1s
0.0
8980
9000 Energy ( eV )
9020
!! !!
Energy and intensity can be correlated with metal-ligand overlap using the VBCI model. In comparable systems: Intensity Covalency Energy 1/Covalency
0.8
O
0.4
N N N N N Fe N N N
N N
Fe
N N
N N
Fe O
0.0
7110
7130 Energy ( eV )
7150
7109
7111
7113
7115
Energy ( eV )
!! !!
Pre-edge intensity
Pre-edge intensity pattern is dependent on: Spin-State b) Oxidation-State c) Ligand-Field splitting d) Multiplet-Effects Pre-edge intensity-weighted average energy is modulated by Ligand-Field strength
!!
intensity
Fe
Sq-py
Normalized Absorption
>
Fe
Td
>
Fe
Sq-Py*
>
Fe
Oh
1.2
Td Oh
0.8
Td 4p orbitals : t2 symmetry 3d orbitals: t2 and e symmetry Mixing = Intense pre-edge Oh 4p orbitals : t1u symmetry 3d orbitals: t2g and eg symmetry No Mixing = Weak pre-edge
0.4
7112 7116
0.0
7110
7130 Energy ( eV )
7150
1.2
Cu 3dx2-y2
0.8
energy
Zeff 2p
0.4
8976 8978 8980 8982
0.0
8980
9000 Energy ( eV )
9020
1s
!!
Pre-edge intensity-weighted average energy is modulated by Ligand-Field strength Zeff or charge on the metal affects the energy of all energy levels equally, therefore has minimal effect on pre-edge energy position
!!
1.5
Normalized Absorption
Me-Cbl H2O-Cbl
k3 * EXAFS
1.0
0.5
7708
7712
7716
10
15
0.0
7750 Energy ( eV )
7850
Near-edge data were used to show a) crystal structure was erroneous b) determine the Me-Co distance to atomic resolution.
1 billion tonnes of methane is generated annually by MCR. Active site contains a Ni-tetrapyrrolic cofactor called F430. Enzymatic activity is observed only in its fully reduced state - Ni(I)
!! !!
!! !! !!
Do Not confirm Ni(III) state. Do Not show the presence of a Me group in the axial position. Do show increase in coordination #.
Very little shift in edge energies ~0.5 eV shift in pre-edge energy Ni(I) > Ni(II) > Ni(III)
Ni(I) Ni(II) Ni(III)-Me
Normalized Absorption
0.2
0.1
0.1
0.0
8330
8334 Energy ( eV )
8338
!!
Normalized Absorption
0.08
0.04
!! !! !!
The high intensity only occurs in the case of a Ni-Me coordination. The energy of the transition is only achieved in the case on Ni(III). The intensity and energy are in the right place when a trans-axial ligand is present.
EXAFS data not available to high k due to very low concentrations? EXAFS data too weak beyond k ~ 10 -1 ? Sample undergoes beam-damage too fast to obtain good quality data? Comparison of data at different temperatures is required? Micro-XANES data with low signal/noise ratio? Near-edge XAS has interesting features, but EXAFS are plain ?
Full multiple-scattering Theory. The potential is generated using the Muffin-tin approach.
EXAFS: SERIES Solution MXAN: EXACT Solution
Method can be applied to dilute samples. ( k =6-7 -1) A full multiple-scattering analysis gives important angular information. Can be applied to higher temperature samples. Since MXAN obtains an exact solution using all possible MS components the bond-distance resolution is infinite.
Fits are performed on data set : -10 eV to ~200 eV (0 eV = Edge Inflection) Initial structural parameters added as Cartesian or polar coordinates for all the atoms of a model of choice. The structural and non-structural parameters are varied iteratively (shown to have very low interdependence).
z
!!
R ! "
R sq = ! {[ y (..rn , $n ,..) #y
i =1
th . i
exp . 2 i
] / " }w i / ! w i
i =1
2 i
Sepctroscopic studies on the wild-type and the mutant (N694C) protein show that N694C has a distorted active site. However no information is available on whether the S is bound
!!
(Ile)O (His)N
N(His)
Structural Possibilities
(Cys)S O O N(His)
Fe
(Gln)
N(His)
N(His)
F=0.138
!!
The EXAFS fits show that the data are consistent with several different structural models (different coordinations at the Fe site)
F=3.71
F=3.91
F=0.95
!!
MXAN Fits using different models gave error values that were distinctly different to differentiate between the possible local structures. The data reveal that the geometric structure is best described as a 5+1 coordinate structure with 1 long Fe-O(H2O) bond.
!!
The edge-region of an XAS spectrum provides a powerful spectroscopic tool for geometric and electronic structure elucidation. Information related to: Oxidation State Spin State Covalency Site-symmetry Ligand Field Local Structure A lot is still not known about the rising-edge and near-edge region. Theoretical advances will unlock this region and help us better understand our data in the future.
!!
!!
Acknowledements
A special thanks to all authors of the articles, which were presented in this talk. SSRL DOE, Office of Basic Energy Sciences SMB program supported by the NIH, NCRR, Biomedical Technology Program, and the DOE, BER.
References
Metal K- pre-edge intensity R. G. Shulman et al., Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci., 1976, 73, 1384. T. Westre et al., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1997, 119, 6297-6314. J.E. Penner-Hahn et al., Chem. Phys. Lett. 1982, 88, 595598. Metal K- pre-edge energy R. Sarangi et. al. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2006, 128, 82868296. Rising edge-intensities in Cu(I) complexes L.S. Kau et al., J. Am. Chem. Soc., 1987, 109, 6433. Covalency from the rising edge J.L. DuBois et al., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2000, 122, 5775-5787. Pre-edge EXAMPLE 1 H. A. Hassanin, et al., Dalton Trans., 2010, 39, 10626-10630 Pre-edge EXAMPLE 2 R. Sarangi, et al. Biochemistry 2009, 48, 31463156. MXAN and EXAMPLE http://www.esrf.eu/computing/scientific/MXAN/ R. Sarangi et al., Inorg. Chem., 2008, 47,11543