Meta-Reflection: When I first started this class I knew little about all the complexities of schooling in the United States. My first draft and final draft are similar in that they both share the idea that the purpose of schooling in the United States is to help children learn grow, promote tolerance, and pursue their dreams. My final draft went into more detail about how I believe the current purpose of schooling has gone off course of what is really important. The main difference between the two papers relates to schooling and the existing order. In the first paper I did not think about the negative effects of schools continuing the existing order. My final paper looks much deeper into these ideas, and then gives solutions to transforming the existing order. I believe that my final paper has a more critical view of our education system, but this is extremely important for entering teaching as it will help me be a better teacher and understand the issues around my job and how I can tackle these issues to better educate my students.
Education is, in my opinion, the most important aspect of our society. In theory it should allow everyone an equal opportunity to achieve upward mobility and to pursue whatever it is that they desire. Horace Mann, an education reformist, envisioned public schools as places where students of all backgrounds come together to share fair and equal opportunities for success in the education system and, as a consequence, fair and equal chances in life (Oaks, Rogers, 1). However, this idealistic expectation of schooling in the United States is far from what we see today. While there are several factors that play into creating an unequal education system, many of which teachers can do little about, we can, as teachers, do everything in our power to promote equality, instill proper values in our students, and help them be successful in life. This paper will explore the purpose of schooling, how teachers fulfill that purpose, and how schooling not only continues the existing order but also transforms the existing order. What is the purpose of schooling in the United States? Depending on whom you ask, you will surely get differing answers every time. I believe that the purpose of schooling is all about the development of the student. Students should develop socially, emotionally, and cognitively. Schools should provide a safe environment where students feel comfortable to learn and to be themselves. Schools should teach children how to work with others, how to better themselves, and what their interests are so that they can pursue whatever it is that will provide them with happiness. Schools should be ground zero for where children learn about acceptance, diversity, kindness, and gain a general knowledge of the world they live in. Lastly, schools should promote critical and divergent thinking in order to prepare students to enter the global marketplace. I believe that if schools ensured that all of this was not only an important aspect of education, but
also the purpose of education, then we would see a more productive, equal, open-minded society. As a whole, the purpose of schooling today has a more narrow approach. With No Child Left Behind and the Race to the Top, schools seem to be narrowly focused on standardized testing and the math and sciences. There is less emphasis on the humanities, art, and musicall a critical piece of childrens education. I feel like the current purpose of schooling in the United States is only concerned with our global competitiveness, and what we can do to be the number one country economically, technologically, scientifically, and more. So much is left out when our education system is focused on this. It ignores the individual and what can be done to give everyone a fair and equal chance to achieve happiness. It ignores teaching wisdom. John Miller, author of Education for Wisdom, describes wisdom as, It is not the collection of information but a deeper knowing that is characterized by insight, humility, and love (Miller, 262). I truly believe this should be a purpose and needs to be taught in our schools. As a teacher I will play a significant role I achieving all the purposes mentioned above. With the current state of our education system being centered on standardized testing, I will have a duty to ensure that my students perform to the best of their ability, but I also have a duty in fulfilling the purposes that I find extremely important. I believe that the best teachers are the ones that are passionate, caring, and relate to their students. I know that if my students are aware of how much I want them to succeed and care about their future, then they will respond well and hopefully see that education is the key to success. It is my duty to be open, kind, and promote acceptance and diversity in the classroom. These are important qualities that can be best learned and practiced at school. It is also important that I reach out to every student and their different learning needs in
order to help everyone achieve. Everyone learns differently, and to maximize success in my classroom it will be important that I cater to every students learning styles. I hope to inspire my students to yearn for more knowledge and discover their interests so that they can achieve their goals and be happy in lifebecause I think that is the most important thing. Schools are one of the largest institutions in the United States, so it is no surprise that they are crucial in continuing the existing order. It is where we learn cultural norms, social behaviors, democratic practices and the basics of our economy. Students can take this knowledge and apply it to real-world situations, allowing for our society to prosper. Without learning this it would be hard for our society to maintain order and to continue evolving. However, this continuation of the existing order is not always a good thing. Our education system has a long history of deculturalization and promotion of white Anglo-Saxon superiority. Joel Spring, author of Deculturalization and the Struggle for Equality, reveals how policies within our educational system targeted African Americans, Asian Americas, Hispanic/Latino Americans, and Native Americans in an effort to assimilate these groups into what we saw as the dominant and superior European culture. Spring describes the methods of deculturalization as, segregation and isolation, forced change of language, curriculum content that reflects culture of dominant group, textbooks that reflect culture of dominant group, denial of cultural and religious expression by dominated groups, use of teachers from dominant group (Spring, 105). Unfortunately, these methods of deculturalization are still continued today, unintentionally or not. Schools are still largely segregated by race, immigrants are expected to speak English, and our curriculum mostly focuses on the experiences of mainstream Americans. This
has major consequences for majority and minority groups and perpetuates racism. James A. Banks writes that, A mainstream-centric curriculum is one major way in which racism and ethnocentrism are reinforced and perpetuated in the schools, in colleges and universities, and in society at large (Banks, 225). Here we see how schools continue the existing order and contribute to the current social, political, and cultural order of racism in our society. Fortunately, schools have the ability to transform this. As our society evolves so will our education system, and through this system we can transform the existing order to make our society better. The aforementioned issue of racism in our society, which is perpetuated in our education system, can be addressed and transformed through a series of actions. Doing so will have a lasting effect on our existing order by helping to eradicate racism at all levelsindividual, societal, institutional, and civilizational. The problem with racism in our society is that we no longer understand the definition of it. We are taught that racism is an act of overt discrimination. Issues like slavery, legal discrimination, violence against minorities; these are the things we associate racism with. We dont learn about covert racism, or how it is embedded at all levels of our society due to our history. The good news is schools can change this. One way is through culturally responsive teaching. Our population is becoming more diverse every year, so it is important that we understand and respect how all cultures contribute to the uniqueness of our society. A pedagogy that responds to, respects, and celebrates all cultures provides an equitable education to students of all backgrounds (Lab at Brown, 1). We must develop cultural sensitivity, which in turn will promote acceptance (Huerta, 235). If we do this in our schools, then it will spread out into our communities, and help to promote acceptance, diversity, and an
overall respect of all culturesnot just the normal cultures. Teachers must also do their part to bring cultures together and to be culturally responsive. The Lab at Brown reading suggests that characteristics of culturally responsive teachers are: positive perspectives on parents and families, communication of high expectations, learning within the context of culture, student-centered instruction, culturally mediated instruction, reshaping the curriculum, and the teacher as a facilitator. Another way schools can transform racism is through critical multicultural education. Race and the idea of colorblindness in our schools deprive our students from learning about the diverse world that they will soon be a part of. Some may use the term colorblindness to mean they are nondiscriminatory, but it may also be seen as refusing to accept differences and therefore accepting the dominant culture as the norm, as Nieto and Bode put it in Culture, Identity, and Learning. Students will not get the whole picture, or truly understand the world live in, if race is edited out. For students to thrive in our multicultural world then they must be taught to understand, accept, and celebrate all cultures. By doing so, I believe that racism will slowly begin to break down at all the levels. These are just a few ways in which our education has the power to transform the existing order and create a more equal, prosperous society for all. Schooling in the United States was created to produce a productive society and allow everyone an equal chance to learn and provide a better life for him or herself. While I sometimes think we have lost what was core to education at the beginning, it is still the most important aspect of society. As a future teacher I will take all that I have learned to help every student and use my job as a way to transform the existing order to create a better society for us.
Works Cited: Banks, James, and Cherry Banks. Approaches to Multicultural Curriculum Reform. Reprint. Bode, Sonia, and Patty Bode. "Culture, Identity, and Learning." Affirming Diversity: The Sociopolitical Context of Multicultural Education. : Print. "Culturally Relevant Teaching." Lab at Brown: Print. Huerta, Grace. Educational foundations: diverse histories, diverse perspectives. Instructor's ed. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 2009. Print. Miller, John. "Educating for Wisdom." Spirituality, Religion, and Peace Education. Print. Oaks, Jeannie, and John Rogers. "Unjust Schools." From Learning Power: Organizing for Education and Justice. Reprint. New York: Teachers College Press. Print. Spring, Joel H. Deculturalization and the struggle for equality: a brief history of the education of dominated cultures in the United States. 7th ed. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 2013. Print.