AIR FIN COOLER OUTLET

SUPPORT MODIFICATION
RESULT OF ANALYSIS FOR STRUCTURE RESULT OF ANALYSIS FOR STRUCTURE RESULT OF ANALYSIS FOR STRUCTURE RESULT OF ANALYSIS FOR STRUCTURE
Nov. 15, 2013
INTERGEN ACS PROJECT
ENGINEERING TEAM ENGINEERING TEAM
P f th M difi ti P f th M difi ti
AIR FIN COOLER OUTLET SUPPORT MODIFICATION
Purpose of the Modification Purpose of the Modification
Foundations for the Air Fin Cooler Out Foundations for the Air Fin Cooler Out--Let supports were located at incorrect Let supports were located at incorrect
location. (They located 200mm Southwards compare with correct location) location. (They located 200mm Southwards compare with correct location) ( y p ) ( y p )
To avoid the interference between the Air Fin Cooler Out To avoid the interference between the Air Fin Cooler Out--Let support Let support
Structure & Piping caused by these incorrect location, structural modification Structure & Piping caused by these incorrect location, structural modification
work can provide most economic & optimized result work can provide most economic & optimized result work can provide most economic & optimized result. work can provide most economic & optimized result.
Therefore, contractor propose the modification work regarding these support Therefore, contractor propose the modification work regarding these support
structures to solve these problems structures to solve these problems structures to solve these problems. structures to solve these problems.
Thesefoundationswerelocatedincorrectly.
(Located 200mm so th ards)
2
(Located200mmsouthwards)
M difi d M difi d D i 2586 D i 2586 22 AR AR DW DW 372 R 3A 372 R 3A
AIR FIN COOLER OUTLET SUPPORT MODIFICATION
Modified Modified Drawing 2586 Drawing 2586--22--AR AR--DW DW--372_Rev.3A 372_Rev.3A
Overall Drawing Overall Drawing
3
M difi ti D t il M difi ti D t il
AIR FIN COOLER OUTLET SUPPORT MODIFICATION
Modification Details Modification Details
Comparison between Elevations in 2586 Comparison between Elevations in 2586- -22--AR AR--DW DW--372_Rev.3 & Rev.3A 372_Rev.3 & Rev.3A
Original (Rev.3) Original (Rev.3) Modified (Rev.3A) Modified (Rev.3A)
St t b EL+1 990 t i ht(N th) id 300 St t b EL+1 990 t i ht(N th) id 300 Structures above EL+1,990 move to right(North) side as 300mm. Structures above EL+1,990 move to right(North) side as 300mm.
(By cutting the column at EL+1990) (By cutting the column at EL+1990)
T l ti f t t ill b l d 100 T l ti f t t ill b l d 100
4
Top elevation of structure will be lowered as 100mm. Top elevation of structure will be lowered as 100mm.
AIR FIN COOLER OUTLET SUPPORT MODIFICATION
M difi ti D t il M difi ti D t il
Comparison between Details in 2586 Comparison between Details in 2586--22--AR AR--DW DW- -372_Rev.3 & Rev.3A 372_Rev.3 & Rev.3A
Modification Details Modification Details
Original (Status in Rev.3) Original (Status in Rev.3)
Modified (Rev 3A) Modified (Rev 3A)
5
Original (Status in Rev.3) Original (Status in Rev.3)
*Erection drawing SE *Erection drawing SE- -AFCS AFCS--004 004--Rev2 Rev2
Modified (Rev.3A) Modified (Rev.3A)
AIR FIN COOLER OUTLET SUPPORT MODIFICATION
M difi ti D t il M difi ti D t il
Shape of Structure Shape of Structure
Modification Details Modification Details
Additional
members
6
St t l A l i R lt St t l A l i R lt
AIR FIN COOLER OUTLET SUPPORT MODIFICATION
Structural Analysis Result Structural Analysis Result
Overall Stress Ratio Result Overall Stress Ratio Result
1) 1) Stress Ratio of member can be Stress Ratio of member can be
used as evaluation standard of used as evaluation standard of
member stability. member stability.
1
2
2) 2) Structural Analysis Tool Structural Analysis Tool
: STAAD V8i : STAAD V8i
2
2
3) Structural Rule regarding 3) Structural Rule regarding
Stress Ratio Stress Ratio
: Stress Ratio < 0 8 (80%) : Stress Ratio < 0 8 (80%) : Stress Ratio < 0.8 (80%) : Stress Ratio < 0.8 (80%)
(Spare safety factor is 20%. (Spare safety factor is 20%.
If Stress Ratio > 0.8 , Member If Stress Ratio > 0.8 , Member
can be failed by chance) can be failed by chance)
4
can be failed by chance) can be failed by chance)
4) Indicated Members have 4) Indicated Members have
relatively high ratio comparing relatively high ratio comparing
7
relatively high ratio comparing relatively high ratio comparing
with other members. with other members.
St t l A l i R lt St t l A l i R lt
AIR FIN COOLER OUTLET SUPPORT MODIFICATION
Structural Analysis Result Structural Analysis Result
Girder Member Girder Member 1
MemberStressAnalysis
Result is PASS
MemberStressAnalysis
Result is PASS Resultis PASS Resultis PASS
8
St t l A l i R lt St t l A l i R lt
AIR FIN COOLER OUTLET SUPPORT MODIFICATION
Structural Analysis Result Structural Analysis Result
Girder Member Girder Member 2
MemberStressAnalysis
Result is PASS
MemberStressAnalysis
Result is PASS Resultis PASS Resultis PASS
9
St t l A l i R lt St t l A l i R lt
AIR FIN COOLER OUTLET SUPPORT MODIFICATION
Structural Analysis Result Structural Analysis Result
Girder Member Girder Member 3
MemberStressAnalysis
Result is PASS
MemberStressAnalysis
Result is PASS Resultis PASS Resultis PASS
10
St t l A l i R lt St t l A l i R lt
AIR FIN COOLER OUTLET SUPPORT MODIFICATION
Structural Analysis Result Structural Analysis Result
Girder Member Girder Member 4
MemberStressAnalysis
Result is PASS
MemberStressAnalysis
Result is PASS Resultis PASS Resultis PASS
11
C l i C l i
AIR FIN COOLER OUTLET SUPPORT MODIFICATION
Conclusion Conclusion
1 By this modification Air Fin Cooler Support Structure can avoid 1. By this modification, Air Fin Cooler Support Structure can avoid
any interference with Pipes or other structures.
(Dimensions for Modification were provided by Piping Engineering ( e s o s o od cat o e e p o ded by p g g ee g
Department)
2. The constructability for the piping installation works can be
improved by these modification works,
3. Stress Analysis results show that proposed structural modification
works can be proceeded without any technical problem.
12
We pledge to foster a trusted long We pledge to foster a trusted long--term partnership term partnership We pledge to foster a trusted long We pledge to foster a trusted long--term partnership term partnership
realizing significant value addition for mutual prosperity. realizing significant value addition for mutual prosperity.
Thank you Thank you
13