ABN AMROs North American operations. While typically standing for ABN AMRO North America, it can also stand for ALCO Analytics for a New Age. The latter embodies the notion that leading- edge analytical tools are requisite for the management of interest rate risk in a balance sheet with high levels of complexity.
ABN AMRO currently ranks as the 6 th largest mortgage originator and 9 th largest mortgage servicer in the world. In addition, its holdings of mortgage loans and mortgage- backed securities are sizable. Its ability to monitor the liquidity, accounting, and option risk associated with those mortgages is therefore crucial to the success of its business.
ABN AMRO selected BancWares Convergence solution to successfully capture and assess many of those risks using advanced analytics.
At its Chicago headquarters, ABN AMRO North America manages risk on approximately $90 billion in retail and commercial banking assets through SunGard Trading and Risk Systems BancWare solution. ABN AMRO, a long- time user of BancWare for asset/ liability management (ALM), added advanced analytics to the solution early in 1999. These include: option- adjusted valuation (OAV) modeling through the Hull and White term- structure model, pre- payment modeling that incorporates the Andrew Davidson (ADCO) prepayment model, and commercial mortgage obligation (CMO) cash flows based on CMO data from Intex.
C C a a s s e e S S t t u u d d y y A A A BN A A A MRON N or r r thA A A mer r r ica
As one of the top ten US banks in mortgage originations, ABN AMRO realized that incorporating pre- payment modeling and the stochastic simulations of OAV were imperative for deriving interest rate risk exposures of its balance sheet. BancWares advanced analytical models more accurately capture interest rate risk because they consider optionalities inherent in mortgages, loans and other balance sheet items. ABN AMRO worked closely with BancWare to direct the development of models such as OAV and the prepayment model.
The Importance of Product Scalability
ABN AMRO installed BancWares Convergence in 1993. BancWare Convergence is an integrated planning, reporting, and analysis tool that supports asset/ liability management, forecasting, and budgeting. As ABN AMROs modeling and business requirements grew, BancWares advanced analytics were added. David Ide, first vice president and deputy director of ABN AMRO North America, explained, We added to our base functionality as our needs changed. Our decision to purchase Convergence pre- payment, term structure, and valuation modules was driven by the long, successful relationship we have had with BancWare. These modules give us the capability to model the earnings and market value sensitivities associated with a wide variety of highly complex financial instruments.
ABN AMRO North America was looking for a total software solution that had the ability to accurately model the options embedded in its balance sheet. After careful evaluation, BancWare was selected. Some of the reasons ABN AMRO cites for choosing BancWare include its: B B N N
M M R R O O No o t t h h m m e e i i c c a a
ABN AMROs Addition of BancWare Advanced Analytics Including OAV Takes Interest Rate Risk Management at ABN AMRO North America to New Heights. 1
! Prepayment modeling capabilities which include the four traditional factors as well as up to four additional factors ! Overall scalability, flexibility and ease of use ! Capability to easily customize reports to current processes and management requirements ! Ability to integrate measurement of off balance sheet risks into its ALM process
! Commitment to continual development of advanced analytics, complex scenario modeling and risk management
Carl Tannenbaum, senior vice president and director of treasury research for ABN AMRO North America, added, We are a huge mortgage bank. Without OAV for valuing assets with embedded options we would have a blind spot that would be 25 to 30 percent of total assets our mortgage loan portfolio alone represents roughly $10 billion in assets we would not be accurately valuing.
To take an accurate measure of interest rate risk in todays market, an institution requires the ability to measure the impact of embedded options. Tannenbaum noted that mortgage refinancing, one example of an embedded option, is beginning to take foot globally in Europe and also in Australia. Embedded options, he said, are becoming more important factors for the risk position of banks globally.
BancWares combination of prepayment and term structure modules evaluate the options embedded in ABN AMROs balance sheet calibrated to market conditions for statistically rigorous option valuation.
Because our balance sheet is loaded with embedded options from mortgage- backed securities and a large mortgage origination
business, we are very risk sensitive. OAV enables us to actively manage the risks in our balance sheet, said Tannenbaum.
BancWare Used to Manage Near- term Business Positions ABN AMRO uses the risk numbers derived from BancWare Convergence to actively manage the interest rate risk of its balance sheet, said Ide. ABN AMRO does this by closely examining its risk positions. This extends to our risk managers, Ide explained, who tend to think in terms of duration and market value sensitivity. ABN AMROs managers can get a better handle on duration and sensitivity through the risk numbers Convergence produces. We are a huge mortgage bank. Without OAV for valuing assets with embedded options we would have a blind spot that would be 25 to 30 percent of total assets mortgage loan portfolio alone represents roughly $10 billion in assets we would not be accurately valuing.
our
After determining duration, ABN AMRO also uses BancWare to examine how rate changes affect duration.
Ide explained, Curves of exposures generated for market value risks are just derivatives of market value risk. So, we look at the market value of the bank under these scenarios and calculate a localized duration. Essentially, we look at the change in market value, up and down 10 basis points, and then measure that up and down the spectrum. Not only did BancWare allow us to see the market value of the impact to changes in interest rates, it has allowed us to communicate these changes, as well the rate of change, to our managers, noted Ide. This type of modeling indicates that as interest rates increase, the duration of equity increases, and assets extend. At the same time, liabilities shorten; and duration extends. For instance, when rates fall, the model shows a dramatic decline in the duration of equity.
For the first time, our managers could actually see that and use that to manage their positions, Ide said.
The risk managers requested modeling that was outside of the realm of standard policy and reporting functions. On a daily basis, the managers think about near- term market movements and ask, What is my exposure for a 10 or 25 basis point move, - - not 200 points. They wanted modeling that would help them manage near- term positions, Ide said. To give the managers the modeling they desired, ABN AMRO added BancWares OAV, Intex and Behavior modules to Convergence in April of 1999. 2
Convergence as a strategic planning tool in acquisitions
ABN AMRO also employs BancWare as a tool to evaluate acquisitions. It does not utilize Convergence in every deal, but more often, BancWare is called upon to acquisitions where a balance sheet does not present needed granularity.
In these cases, ABN AMRO uses BancWare to test:
1. Whether there is risk in the balance sheet that it might not want to pay for, or that might be an issue for discussion.
2. Whether there would be costs to fix the banks position or, conversely, money to be made by adjusting the position.
Ide says that Convergence has become a real strategic tool for acquisitions. It is such an effective simulation tool that it can be used to either confirm or produce run- rate net interest income which can be useful for pricing decisions. Particularly useful [ for this kind of assignment] is the speed that comes with the Excel interface, which allows for a quick structuring of a new balance sheet. For every prospect that we eventually acquire, the integration is very clean because we have already done some initial set- up and analysis on BancWare, Ide said.
Also notable are the acquisitions that ABN AMRO did not make after an evaluation using BancWare. Among these was a bank that presented a weak GAP report and a sizeable portfolio of purchased funds made up of callable debt. We used Convergence and the (BancWare) behavior model to build a model that predicted the callable behavior of those advances over different rate environments. We ran the numbers and saw a horrendous risk position, Ide said. These results convinced management not to bid for the bank. Although Mr. Ide noted that the bank could have come to this conclusion through a more arduous route, It was nice to have the ease and reliability of Convergence for this evaluation.
Modeling Originations and Servicing Relationships
ABN AMRO also uses BancWare to rigorously model the natural hedge between its mortgage origination business and its mortgage servicing business. ABN AMRO has a huge - - over $100
billion dollar - - mortgage servicing business. ABN AMRO pays up- front for the right to service mortgages. These rights have a considerable adverse option position tied to mortgage prepayment. In particular, if the mortgages are refinanced, the value of the servicing rights evaporates. This business carries a substantial amount of financial risk. Ide noted. But at the same time the value of the servicing rights evaporates, income from the mortgage origination business begins to pick up steam. Determining how much mortgage origination offsets this risk exposure is extremely important to the bank. Ide continued, We wanted this relationship to be part of our earnings risk analysis. We also wanted it to be part of our market value analysis. Although it does not have a line on our balance sheet, it has a market value. We had to determine the extent to which banks make a mistake if they assume that originations and servicing are complete natural offsets to each other. The offset is there in economic terms but not entirely for reported earnings. There is a timing problem and BancWare is critical to our measurement of these differences, said Ide.
Between the economics and the accounting, ABN AMRO discovered this difference through innovative modeling within BancWare, particularly the behavior and ADCO prepayment models. Through the BancWare platform and pre- payment modeling, ABN AMRO modeled an interest rate exposure for the entire bank and determined the worth of mortgage originations when interest rates dropped. The modeling showed that the bank could make significantly more income in a falling rate environment than previously estimated.
To arrive at the mortgage origination sensitivities ABN AMRO easily built a model into Convergence. First Mr. Tannenbaums group built a summarized database in Convergence of the $5 trillion mortgage market in the US and called this the mortgage universe. Due to the flexibility and ease of Convergence we can use pre- payment modeling to project the behavior of the mortgage universe. The adds in the model represent the production volume for the entire industry, said Ide.
3 Market Value of Origination Business -300 -200 -100 0 100 200 300 Rate movements (bps) $
m illio n s
Next, working with assumptions on ABN AMROs market share and profit spreads (which is related to volume because of fixed costs), the model projects the fee income the bank expects to earn. This fee income stream can be calculated under numerous alternative interest rate scenarios and incorporated into the banks earnings- at- risk and market value risk positions. Because the model is so fast- - it takes just seconds to run each deterministic rate scenario- - we could actually go in and run scenarios in 10 basis point increments, from up 300 basis points, to down 300 basis points, said Ide. The result was a graph with a lot of detail and some intuitive results.
The shape of the market value sensitivity, not coincidentally, closely resembles the typical shape of a prepayment curve. The slope of the curve flattens both when the refinance incentive is significantly out- of- the- money and when it is significantly in- the- money. When the refinance incentive is at- the- money or modestly in- the- money, the slope becomes very steep, implying a large positive duration for the origination business.
Streamlined ALM Process
At about the same time that ABN AMRO implemented BancWares advanced modules the bank also consolidated the ALCO committees from its three major US banks. Now it has one consolidated ALCO and its entire interest- rate risk modeling is loaded onto one BancWare platform. This streamlined ALM process yielded immediate benefits. We saw significant time savings, To run stochastic scenarios, with 20 starting points and 200 paths, it takes just a few hours for each of the banks, Ide noted.
Mr. Tannenbaum zeroed in on two factors that have positively impacted turn- around time: 1. BancWares incorporation of ADCO prepayment assumptions data, eliminating the need for the bank to develop its own set of prepayment assumptions 2. BancWares ability to run deterministic valuations for simple assets and the more complex OAV simulations for assets with embedded options
We can run one scenario right after another, without a hitch. The process is streamlined, commented Mr. Tannenbaum.
Convergence, along with the behavior, term structure and valuation models, gives us the capability to model the earnings and market value sensitivities associated with a wide variety of highly complex financial instruments. Convergence is an extremely effective simulation tool in conjunction with OAV to manage market rate risk, commented Ide. The flexible architecture of Convergence loaded with the advanced analytics of OAV, Intex, ADCO and the BancWare behavior model, enables ABN AMRO to analyze market values and income simulations within an integrated and consistent framework. This allows ABN AMRO to deliver the market values that it uses to manage its complex balance sheet. Ide concluded: We are always trying to position ourselves based on the risk numbers we get from the model. Whether that translates into a hedge or position adjustment, BancWare modeling impacts the decision. In an age where markets are volatile, consumers are savvy, and the demand for up- to- date risk analytics is never ending, BancWares Convergence software has played an invaluable role. We saw significant time savings. To run stochastic scenarios, with 20 starting points and 200 paths, it takes just a few hours for each of the banks.
SunGard Trading and Risk Systems Contact: Kim Ferranti, Marketing Director Phone: 617- 542- 2800 x 337 Fax: 617- 542- 2100 bancware.marketing@risk.sungard.com http:/ / www.risk.sungard.com