Mobile View

Main Search Advanced Search Disclaimer

Cites 3 docs
The Code Of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Act, 1956
The Information Technolo! Act, "###
The Indian Penal Code
Get this document in PDF

Print it on a f ile/printer
User Queries
macp
voluntar retirement
macp scheme
recommendation of pa commission doctpes! pun"ab#harana
seniorit fromdate!$%$%&'$( todate!($%$&%&'$(
)privile*e pass)
up*radation
pa commission
voluntar retirement
+th pa commission
,th pa commission
+th pa commission
mathew
voluntar retirement fromdate!$%$%&'$( todate!($%$&%&'$(
G-AD. PA/
recommendation of pa commission doctpes!cat#erna0ulam
runnin* allowance
central administrative tribunal fromdate!$%$%&'$( to!$,1'2&'$(
up*radation
recommendation of pa commission
Central Administrative Tribunal - Ernakulam
M.Hussain vs Union Of India And Another on 2 August 2!"#



CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ERNAKULAM BENCH
O.A.No.581/12
Friday !i" !# 2$d day o% A&'&" 2(1)
C O R A M *
HON+BLE Mr.,EOR,E -ARACKEN. /UDICIAL MEMBER
1. M.H&""ai$.
S/o.Moid##$ K&y.
R#d. A""i"a$ ,&ard/So&!#r$ Rai01ay/
Erod# Rai01ay Saio$.
R#"idi$' a -#riya2ada3 Ho&"#.
T!a$a4#. O0a4a55od#. -a0a55ad.
2. M.S&6ra3a$ia$.
S/o.M.Kri"!$a$.
R#d. A""i"a$ ,&ard/So&!#r$ Rai01ay/
Erod# Rai01ay Saio$.
R#"idi$' a Ma$i7!i T!odiyi0 Ho&"#.
Ma$$a$&r -.O.. -a0a55ad D. ...A220i7a$"
8By Ad4o7a# Mr.T.C.,o4i$da"1a3y9
V # r " & "
1. U$io$ o% I$dia r#2r#"#$#d 6y !# ,#$#ra0 Ma$a'#r.
So&!#r$ Rai01ay. H#ad:&ar#r" O%%i7#.
-ar5 To1$ -.O.. C!#$$ai ; <(( (().
2. T!# Di4i"io$a0 -#r"o$$#0 O%%i7#r.
So&!#r$ Rai01ay. Sa0#3 Di4i"io$.
Sa0#3 ; <)< ((1. ...R#"2o$d#$"
8By Ad4o7a# Mr.T!o3a" Ma!#1 N#00i3ooi09
T!i" a220i7aio$ !a4i$' 6##$ !#ard o$ )1" /&0y 2(1) !i" Tri6&$a0 o$
2$d A&'&" 2(1) d#0i4#r#d !# %o00o1i$' *;
O R D E R
HON'BLE Mr.GEORGE PARACKEN, JUDICIAL MEMBER The contention of the
!!"icnt# in thi# c#e i# tht the$ re entit"e% for &ir#t C"## Po#t'Retire(ent
Co(!"i(entr$ P## # !ro)i%e% *n%er R*"e + of the Ri",$ -er)nt# .P##/ R*"e#,
01+2, 3*t it h# not 3een cce!te% 3$ the re#!on%ent#. Hence, thi# Ori4in" A!!"iction.
5. The 3rief fct# of the c#e re tht the !!"icnt# re retire% A##i#tnt G*r%# of
-o*thern Ri",$ 3e"on4in4 to the cte4or$ of Trffic R*nnin4 -tff. Accor%in4 to the
r*"e# !!"ic3"e to the(, the$ re entit"e% to h)e 678 of their !$ trete% # !$ for ""
(teri" !*r!o#e#, inc"*%in4 for the !*r!o#e of %eter(inin4 the e9*tion of their 4r%e#
)i#'')i# the non r*nnin4 #tff. The Ri",$ Bor%, )i%e or%er 3erin4 RBE No.5:; of
0111 %te% 0.07.0111, re)ie,e% the e9*i)"ence of 4r%e# in the "i4ht of the )rio*#
#c"e# of !$ intro%*ce% 3#e% on the reco((en%tion# of the :th Centr" P$
Co((i##ion n% %eci%e% to e9*te the 4r%e# of r*nnin4 #tff ,ith tho#e of the
#ttionr$ #tff. Accor%in4"$ the cte4or$ of r*nnin4 #tff in the !o#t of -enior A##i#tnt
G*r% in the #c"e of !$ of R#.;777'2777<' h# 3een e9*te% ,ith the #c"e of !$ of
R#.:777'+777<' of the #ttionr$ !o#t#. -i(i"r"$, the !o#t of A##i#tnt G*r% in the
#c"e of !$ of R#.67:7';:17 h# 3een e9*te% to the #c"e of !$ of R#.;777'2777<' of
the #ttionr$ !o#t#. -i(i"r"$, fter cce!tin4 the 2th Centr" P$ Co((i##ion
reco((en%tion# 3$ the Go)ern(ent, the Ri",$ Bor% i##*e% Anne=*re A'6 or%er
3erin4 RBE No.6 of 5700 %te% 2.0.5700 re)i#in4 the e=i#tin4 entit"e(ent# of
P##e#<PTO# to the Ri",$ -er)nt# .P##/ R*"e#, 01+2 n% %eci%e% tht the
entit"e(ent# of P##e#<PTO# in re#!ect of Ri",$ -er)nt# %r,in4 !$ in the Ri",$
-er)ice# .Re)i#e% P$/ R*"e#, 577+ #h"" 3e inter'"i # *n%er >'
S.No. Ca#'ory Ty2# o% -ri4i0#'# Ty2# o% D&y
-a"" = -ri4i0#'# -a""
Ti75# Ord#r
,ro&2 +A+ = ,ro&2 +B+ I" C0a"" +A+ -a"" I" C0a"" +A+ -a""
1 8,a>##d9
2 No$;,a>##d #320oy##"
8i9 I$ ,rad# -ay R".?2((/; I" C0a"" -a"" I" C0a"" -a""
a$d a6o4#
.ii/ In Gr%e P$ R#.5+77<' IIn% C"## 'A' P## IIn% C"## 'A' P##
6. A4in, the Ri",$ Bor%, )i%e it# or%er 3erin4 RBE No.;? of 5705 %te% 5.;.5705,
the i##*e of rec@onin4 of r*nnin4 ""o,nce for the !*r!o#e of re)i#e% entit"e(ent of
P##e#<PTO# ,# con#i%ere% n% %eci%e% to ""ot e9*i)"ent 4r%e !$ to r*nnin4 #tff
for the !*r!o#e of entit"e(ent of P##e#<PTO# # *n%er >'
Po#t Ath CPC AIth CPC A""otte% e9*i)"ent 2th P$ -c"e Gr%e P$ CPC P$
Bn%<Gr%e P$ fter rec@onin4 R*nnin4 A""o,nce P$ Bn% Gr%e P$
ALP<Br@e#(n 67:7';:17 0177 PB0 5;77 -r.ALP<Loco Pi"ot .-hnt4/ ;777'2777 PB0
-r.Br@e#(n 5;77 ;577 Goo%# G*r% ;:77'?777 5+77 PB5 ;577
-r.LP.#t4/<LP.Goo%#/< :777'+777 PB5 -r.Goo%# G*r%<P## G*r% ;577 ;277
-r.LP.Goo%#/<LP.P#/ ::77'1777 PB5 -r.P## G*r%<Mi" G*r% ;577 ;277
-r.LP.P##/<LP.M<E/ 2777'1+77 ;577 PB5 ;277 In the fore#i% or%er, Br@e#(n
refer# to the c%re of A##i#tnt G*r%# ,hich i# their !re#ent %e#i4ntion.
;. The !!"icnt# re A##i#tnt G*r%# ,ho ,ere in PB'0 !"*# GP of R#.5;77<' # on the
%te of their )o"*ntr$ retire(ent on ;.1.577+. The$ ,ere 4rnte% the 3o)e PB !"*# GP
)i%e Office Or%er %te% 5:.:.5700 i##*e% 3$ the 5n% re#!on%ent. The fore#i% or%er
re%# # *n%er >'
-OUTHERN RAILBAC O.O.No.;2<OPTG.A%(n<5700 -*3 > &innci" *! 4r%tion
*n%er MACP -che(e, 577+ ' O!t4. De!rt(ent.
Ref > Ri",$ Bor%'# Lr. No.PC'A<5771<ACP<5 %t.07.72.5771.
In ter(# of Ri",$ Bor%'# "etter 9*ote% 3o)e, h)in4 co(!"ete% 07<57<67 $er# of
re4*"r #er)ice<h)in4 #!ent 07 $er# contin*o*#"$ in the #(e 4r%e !$ n% fo*n%
#*it3"e 3$ the co((ittee no(inte% for the !*r!o#e, the *n%er (entione% #tff of
-r.DOM<O<-A re con#i%ere% for &innci" U! 4r%tion n% !"ce% in the i((e%ite
ne=t hi4her Gr%e P$ # in%icte% 4in#t ech.
-". N(e, Dte of Pre#ent E"i4i3i"it$ of MACP n% U!4r%e% No. De#i4ntion, entr$ into
P$, P$ P$, P$ Bn% n% GP ,ith effect P& No. D re4*"r Bn% D fro( -ttion.-<-hri.
#er)ice Gr%e P$ I MACP II MACP III MACP # on .
M.H&""ai$. R".11)@(. ; R".11@@(. R".121A(.
(251<8)?. 52((;2(2(( 52((;2(2(( 52((;2(2((
A"". ,&ard ED B 1A(( ,-. B 2((( ,-. B 2?(( ,-.
8VR 1#% )1.(8.2((8 (1.(A.2((8 (1.(A.2((8
1 (?.A.2((89 (1/1(/@5
M.S&6ra3a$ia$ R".1(81(. ; R".112((. R".11<((.
(251<81(. 52((;2(2(( 52((;2(2(( 52((;2(2((
A"". ,&ard ED B 1A(( ,-. B 2((( ,- B 2?(( ,-
8VR 1#% )1.(8.2((8 (1.(A.2((8 (1.(A.2((8
2 (?.A.2((89 (1/1(/@5
The 3o)e *! 4r%tion i# #*3Eect to "" the ter(# n% con%ition# re "i% %o,n in
Bor%'# "etter cite%, #*ch #,
0. The$ re free fro( DAR<-PE<Ai4i"nce c#e# !en%in4<initite%<conte(!"te 4in#t
the(.
5. It ,i"" not confer on the( n$ #eniorit$ 3enefit#. Their n(e ,i"" 3e contin*e% to 3e
(intine% in the ori4in" #eniorit$ "i#t of re4*"r c!cit$ n% the$ ,i"" 3e con#i%ere%
for !ro(otion on re4*"r 3#i# in the nor(" chnne" on"$.
6. There #h"" 3e no chn4e in the %e#i4ntion, c"##ifiction or hi4her #tt*#. Ho,e)er,
finnci" n% certin other 3enefit# ,hich re "in@e% to the !$ %r,n 3$ the e(!"o$ee
#*ch # HBA, ""ot(ent of Ri",$ cco((o%tion #h"" 3e !er(itte%.
;. The$ ($ e=erci#e o!tion for fi=tion.
./ Of !$ *n%er R*"e 0606.0/./.I/ of the In%in Ri",$ E#t3"i#h(ent Co%e Ao"*(e II
.AI E%ition 01+? ' 5n% re!rint 577:/ &R 55 .0/./.I/ to 4et their !$ fi=e% in the
!o#t<Gr%e P$ either fro( the %te of hi# !ro(otion<*! 4r%tion.
.3/ &ro( the %te of hi# ne=t incre(ent fro( 0#t J*"$ of the $er. The !$ n% the %te
of incre(ent ,o*"% 3e fi=e% in ccor%nce ,ith c"rifiction No.5 of Ri",$ Bor%'#
"etter No.PC'AI<577+<I<R-RP<0 %te% 5:.71.577+ .PC'AI<55, RBE No.065<5771/.
In c#e n e(!"o$ee %oe# not e=erci#e n$ o!tion ,ithin one (onth fro( the %te of
i##*e of thi# O.O. It ($ 3e note% tht hi#<her !$ ,i"" 3e fi=e% # ;./ 3o)e.
Thi# h# the !!ro)" of ADRM<-A.
Di4i"io$a0 O%%i7#. 8M.-ra5a"!9
-#r"o$$#0 Bra$7!. A""i"a$ -#r"o$$#0 O%%i7#/T
Sa0#3 %or D-O/SA
No.SA/-.52?/II/O2'/MAC-S/,&ard" Da#d 25.(5.2(11
Co2y o * Sr.DOM/SA.Sr.DFM/SA.CSCI/SA.OS/Bi00"
OS/-a"".S#0#3#$ OS/O2'.TI/SA
CMR/ED/SA/DS/SRMU/DREU.
AISC/ST.AIOBC/SA
I$di4id&a0".
:. Accor%in4 to the(, in the 3o)e circ*(#tnce#, in ter(# of the fore#i% or%er# of the
Ri",$ Bor% re% ,ith Ri",$ -er)nt# .P##/ R*"e#, 01+2, the$ re entit"e% to 3e
4rnte% the 3enefit# of &ir#t C"## Po#t Retire(ent Co(!"i(entr$ P##e#.
2. -ince the$ h)e not 3een 4i)en the #i% fci"it$ the$ (%e in%i)i%*" re!re#enttion#
to the 5n% re#!on%ent. The 0#t !!"icnt (%e the Anne=*re A': re!re#enttion %te%
6.1.5700 n% 5n% !!"icnt (%e the Anne=*re A'2 re!re#enttion %te% 57.07.5700
re9*e#tin4 the re#!on%ent# to 4rnt the( the fci"it$ of &ir#t C"## Po#t Retire(ent
Co(!"i(entr$ P##e#. A# no re!"$ ,# forthco(in4, the$ (%e re!re#enttion %te%
50.00.5700 *n%er the Ri4ht to Infor(tion Act, 577:, to 4et infor(tion # to ,ht
ction the re#!on%ent# h)e t@en on their Anne=*re A': n% Anne=*re A'2
re!re#enttion#. In re#!on#e to the #i% re!re#enttion %te% 50.00.5700 the re#!on%ent#
h)e i##*e% the i(!*4ne% Anne=*re
A'0 "etter %te% :.05.5700 #ttin4 tht the !##e# h)e to 3e i##*e% to the e(!"o$ee#
,ho#e 4r%e !$ i# R#.;577<' n% 3o)e. The contention of the !!"icnt# i# tht ,hi"e
i##*in4 the fore#i% i(!*4ne% or%er the re#!on%ent# h)e i4nore% the fct tht the$
re to 3e e9*te% to !er#on# ho"%in4 the 4r%e !$ of R#.;577<' in ter(# of the
fore#i% Anne=*re A'5, Anne=*re A'6 n% Anne=*re A'; in#tr*ction# of the Ri",$
Bor%. Accor%in4 to the(, if the$ ,ere in #er)ice on cco*nt of the fct tht PB'0 !"*#
GP of R#.5;77<' i# e9*te% to PB'5 !"*# GP of R#.;577<', the$ ,o*"% h)e 4ot the
3enefit of the &ir#t C"## Po#t Retire(ent Co(!"i(entr$ P##e#. The$ h)e "#o #tte%
tht -enior Die#e" A##i#tnt# ,ho re "#o in the )er$ #(e PB'0 !"*# GP of R#.5;77<'
re 4rnte% &ir#t C"## Po#t Retire(ent Co(!"i(entr$ P## on the 4ro*n% tht their
#c"e of !$ i# e9*i)"ent to PB'5 !"*# GP of R#.;577<'.
?. Lerne% co*n#e" for the !!"icnt, -hri.T.C.Go)in%#,($, h# "#o #*3(itte% tht
#i(i"r c#e ,# fi"e% 3$ -hri.P.T.-#i%hrn )i%e O.A.?11<05 3efore thi# Tri3*n". The
#i% -hri.P.T.-#i%hrn ,# retire% Goo%# G*r% of -o*thern Ri",$, P"@@%
Di)i#ion. He ,# 44rie)e% 3$ the or%er# 3$ ,hich he ,# %enie% the 3enefit of &ir#t
C"## Po#t Retire(ent Co(!"i(entr$ P## !ro)i%e% for *n%er R*"e + of the Ri",$
-er)nt# .P##/ R*"e#, 01+2. The re#!on%ent# reEecte% hi# re9*e#t for 4rntin4 the &ir#t
C"## Po#t Retire(ent Co(!"i(entr$ P## #ttin4 tht the e"i4i3i"it$ for the t$!e of !##
i# 3#e% on the 4r%e !$ # !er Ri",$ Bor%'# "etter %te% 2.0.5700. Ho,e)er,
#*3#e9*ent"$ in !r 2 of the re!"$ #tte(ent fi"e% 3$ the( 3efore thi# Tri3*n" the$
h)e #tte% # *n%er >'
Fthe !!"icnt h)in4 retire% # r*nnin4 #tff, in or%er to %eci%e e"i4i3i"it$ for &ir#t
C"## P##, n e"e(ent of 678 i# to 3e %%e% to hi# 3#ic !$. Accor%in4"$, hi# !$ ,o*"%
3e R#.266?<' ,hich i# 3o)e the e"i4i3i"it$ criteri of R#.:6?:<' for 4rnt of &ir#t C"##
P##. Hence the !!"icnt ,i"" 3e i##*e% the Po#t Retire(ent Co(!"i(entr$ P## in
&ir#t C"## # n% ,hen he !refer# re9*e#t.F
+. On the 3#i# of the fore#i% re!"$ #tte(ent, thi# Tri3*n" he"% tht the 4rie)nce of
the !!"icnt therein #too% re%re##e% n% the O.A ,# c"o#e%.
1. The re#!on%ent# in their re!"$ #tte(ent h# #i(!"$ reiterte% their #tn% t@en 3$
the( in the i(!*4ne% Anne=*re A'0 "etter %te% :.05.5700. The$ h)e f*rther #*3(itte%
tht the !!"icnt# ,ere ,or@in4 # A##i#tnt G*r%# t the ti(e of their )o"*ntr$
retire(ent fro( #er)ice n% ,ere in #c"e R#.67:7';:17 # !re#cri3e% 3$ the :th
Centr" P$ Co((i##ion. B*t !*r#*nt to the reco((en%tion# of the 2th Centr" P$
Co((i##ion their !$ ,# re)i#e% n% the 0#t !!"icnt, -hri.M.H*##in ,ho ,#
%r,in4 R#.;+67<' # hi# 3#ic !$ in #c"e R#.67:7';:17 ,# refi=e% n% #*3#e9*ent"$
he ,# %r,in4 R#.006?7<' G 4r%e !$ R#.0177<' # on ;.1.577+. The 5n% !!"icnt,
-hri.M.-*3r(nin, ,# %r,in4 R#.;:17<' # hi# 3#ic !$ in #c"e R#.67:7';:17
n% hi# !$ ,# refi=e% n% #*3#e9*ent"$ he ,# %r,in4 R#.07+07 G 4r%e !$
R#.0177<' # on ;.1.577+. Both of the( )o"*ntri"$ retire% fro( #er)ice on ;.1.577+.
The$ h)e "#o #tte% tht the 0#t !!"icnt in hi# entire #er)ice h% 4ot three
!ro(otion# fro( Trffic Porter, Point#(n'B, Point#(n'A n% A##i#tnt G*r%.
Ho,e)er, # !er the reco((en%tion# of the 2th Centr" P$ Co((i##ion, #o(e of the
:th Centr" P$ Co((i##ion #c"e# ,ere (er4e% n% co((on 4r%e !$ ,ere
intro%*ce%. D*e to the (er4er of #c"e# of
Trffic Porter n% Point#(n'B in 4r%e !$ R#.0+77<' n% Point#(n'A n% A##i#tnt
G*r% in 4r%e !$ R#.0177<' # !er 2th Centr" P$ Co((i##ion reco((en%tion#,
the three !ro(otion# he 4ot ,ere trete% # on"$ one !ro(otion ie. fro( 4r%e !$
R#.0+77<' to R#.0177<' %*rin4 hi# entire #er)ice ,hich i# (ore thn 67 $er#. Hence he
,# e"i4i3"e for the 5n% n% 6r% finnci" *!4r%tion *n%er MACP fro( 0.1.577+ n%
ccor%in4"$ hi# !$ ,# fi=e% # R#.00??7 G 5777 n% # R#.05017 G 5;77 ,ith effect
fro( 0.1.577+. -i(i"r"$, in the c#e of the 5n% !!"icnt "#o the$ h)e #*3(itte% tht
he ,# "#o e"i4i3"e for the 5n% n% 6r% finnci" *!4r%tion *n%er MACP -che(e
fro( 0.1.577+ n% ccor%in4"$ hi# !$ ,# fi=e% # R#.00577 G 5777 n% # R#.00277 G
5;77 ,ith effect fro( 0.1.577+. A4in, ccor%in4 to the(, # !er the reco((en%tion#
of the :th Centr" P$ Co((i##ion, the fo""o,in4 Gro*! 'C' e(!"o$ee# re entit"e% for
&ir#t C"## Pri)i"e4e P##<PTO# n% D*t$ P##e# >'
0. Tho#e ,ho ,ere !!ointe% !rior to 0.+.0121 %r,in4 !$ of R#.;177<' or 3o)e
!ro)i%e% the e(!"o$ee# re in #c"e the (=i(*( of ,hich i# R#.2777<' or 3o)e.
5. Tho#e ,ho ,ere !!ointe% %*rin4 the !erio% fro( 0.+.0121 to 07.00.01+? n% %r,in4
!$ of R#.:6?:<' or 3o)e, !ro)i%e% the$ re in #c"e the (=i(*( of ,hich i#
R#.?777<' or 3o)e.
6. Tho#e ,ho ,ere !!ointe% %*rin4 the !erio% fro( 07.00.01+? to 0.5.0111 n% %r,in4
!$ of R#.?5:7<' or 3o)e or tho#e ,ho re in #c"e the (ini(*( of ,hich i#
R#.2:77<'.
;. Tho#e ,ho re !!ointe% fter 0.5.0111 n% ,ho re in !$ #c"e (ini(*( of ,hich i#
R#.2:77<' or 3o)e or ,ho re %r,in4 !$ of R#.?277<' or 3o)e.
07. The re#!on%ent# h)e "#o #*3(itte% tht t the ti(e of their )o"*ntri"$ retire(ent
the$ ,ere not in the !$ #c"e the (=i(*( of ,hich i# R#.?777<' or 3o)e. Their 3#ic
!$ # on the %te of their retire(ent on ;.1.577+ ,# R#.;2?7 G 0;70 H 27?0<' .%%in4
678 of !$ # r*nnin4 e"e(ent/ n% R#.;+67 G 0;;1 H 2761 re#!ecti)e"$ in #c"e
R#.67:7';:17. A# !er Anne=*re R'6 circ*"r %te% 0.07.0111 the (=i(*( of the
e9*te% #c"e i# R#.2777<' ,hich i# "e## thn R#.?777<'. Hence the$ re entit"e% for
-econ% C"## P## on"$. A4in, ccor%in4 to the re#!on%ent#, the Ri",$ Bor% h#
i##*e% re)i#e% !$ "i(it# for entit"e(ent of P##<PTO# on the 3#i# of !$ %r,n in the
Ri",$ -er)ice .Re)i#e% P$/ R*"e#, 577+ )i%e Anne=*re R'; "etter %te% 2.0.5700,
ccor%in4 to ,hich, tho#e Non' GIette% e(!"o$ee# in 4r%e !$ of R#.;577<' n%
3o)e re on"$ entit"e% to &ir#t C"## Pri)i"e4e P## D Pri)i"e4e Tic@et Or%er n% D*t$
P##e#.
00. I h)e her% "erne% co*n#e" for the !!"icnt, -hri.T.C.Go)in%#,($ n% "erne%
co*n#e" for the re#!on%ent#, -hri.Ar4he#e on 3eh"f of -hri.Tho(# Mthe,
Ne""i(ootti". In ($ con#i%ere% )ie,, it i# not nece##r$ to 4o into the %i#!*te% !o#ition
ri#e% 3$ the !rtie# in thi# c#e n$ (ore. In #i(i"r c#e ' O.A.?11<05 '
P.T.-#i%hrn A#. Union of In%i n% nother, the re#!on%ent# the(#e")e# h)e
%(itte% tht in or%er to %eci%e e"i4i3i"it$ for &ir#t C"## Po#t Retire(ent
Co(!"i(entr$ P##, n e"e(ent of 678 i# to 3e %%e% to the 3#ic !$. Accor%in4"$, the
!$ of the !!"icnt therein ,or@e% o*t to 3e R#.266?<' ,hich i# 3o)e the e"i4i3i"it$
criteri of R#.:6?:<' for 4rnt of &ir#t C"## P##. In the !re#ent c#e "#o, it i# #een tht
3$ %%in4 the e"e(ent of 678, the !$ of 3oth the !!"icnt# ,i"" 3e 3o)e the e"i4i3i"it$
criteri.
05. In the 3o)e fct# n% circ*(#tnce#, I ""o, thi# O.A n% 9*#h n% #et #i%e
Anne=*re A'0 "etter %te% :.05.5700. I "#o %ec"re tht the !!"icnt# re entit"e% to 3e
4rnte% the 3enefit of &ir#t C"## Po#t Retire(ent Co(!"i(entr$ P##e# ,ith ""
con#e9*enti" 3enefit# ri#in4 therefro(. Accor%in4"$, I %irect the 5n% re#!on%ent to
!## nece##r$ or%er# for 4rnt of the fore#i% 3enefit to the !!"icnt# ,ithin !erio%
of t,o (onth# fro( the %te of recei!t of co!$ of thi# or%er.
06. Un%er the circ*(#tnce#, there #h"" 3e no or%er # to co#t#.
.Dte% thi# the 5n% %$ of A*4*#t 5706/ GEORGE PARACKEN JUDICIAL MEMBER
#!