Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Technology
(Prepared for CALFIRE 3-28-11)
Agenda
Concluding Points
2
29.8.3.4(5))
Which is better?
10
11
12
14
http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/fire09/PDF/f09006.pdf
http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/fire09/PDF/f09007.pdf
15
16
17
Conclusions
19
Conclusions
Conclusions
Conclusions
NFPA 72 -2010
22
Other Reports
Norway report
23
Other Reports
England Study
Kennedy et al
Did not use smoke alarms
Did not provide correlation between sensor
measurements and actual smoke alarms
24
Escape Scenarios
25
Escape Scenarios
Escape Scenarios
Calculating Tenability
Calculating Tenability
C
Kitchen
BR 1
BR 3
Living
Room
START
A
BR 2
B
D
F
END
smoke alarm response
primary gas analysis
temperature
smoke obscuration
path of occupant where FED was calculated
Exit
BR 1
BR 3
Living
Room
START
START
BR 2
F
END
Exit
30
BR 2
C
Kitchen
BR 1
BR 3
Living
Room
START
F
smoke alarm response
primary gas analysis
temperature
smoke obscuration
path of occupant where FED was calculated
A
BR 2
START
BR 1
BR 3
Living
Room
B
D
F
END
Exit
31
Calculating Tenability
32
Calculating Tenability
33
Calculating Tenability
34
Calculating Tenability
Calculating Tenability
36
Calculating Tenability
Results of evaluations
37
Heat
Gas
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
Door open
SDC 5
SDC 7
SDC 38
SDC 392
Table 2.1b Living Room and Kitchen Fires, Direct Escape Scenarios from Bedroom 2
Direct Escape
Flaming
Smoldering
door closed
SDC 141
ION
PHOTO
SDC 341
SDC 2
door closed
SDC 9
SDC 36
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
SDC 10
SDC 12
Smoldering
SDC 13
door open
SDC 4
ION
PHOTO
SDC 6
ION
PHOTO
SDC 8
ION
PHOTO
SDC 37
3
SDC 40
Y
Y
N
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
SDC 15
Y
Y
SDC 33
Y
Y
SDC 35
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
Heat
Gas
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
Flaming
Flaming
1
Smoke
SDC 41
1
ION
PHOTO
38
Calculating Tenability
Results of evaluations
Calculating Tenability
Results of evaluations
40
Calculating Tenability
Results of evaluations
41
Calculating Tenability
Results of evaluations
42
Table 2.2b Living Room and Kitchen Fires, Indirect Escape Scenarios from Bedroom 2
Indirect Escape
Smoke
Heat
Gas
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
Door open
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
Smoldering
door closed
1
SDC 14
ION
PHOTO
N
Y
SDC 341
N
Y
SDC 2
door closed
SDC 9
ION
PHOTO
SDC 36
Y
N
Y
SDC 10
ION
PHOTO
SDC 12
Smoldering
SDC 13
door open
SDC 4
ION
PHOTO
SDC 6
ION
PHOTO
SDC 8
SDC 37
SDC 403
Heat
Gas
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO1
ION
Flaming
Flaming
1
Smoke
N
Y
N
N
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
Y
PHOTO
ION
PHOTO
ION
SDC 33
ION
PHOTO
SDC 15
SDC 35
SDC 41
1
PHOTO1
ION
PHOTO
43
Calculating Tenability
Results of evaluations
44
Calculating Tenability
Results of evaluations
Calculating Tenability
Results of evaluations
46
Calculating Tenability
Results of evaluations
Calculating Tenability
Results of evaluations
TG majority consensus
48
Calculating Tenability
Results of evaluations
TG minority opinion
49
Concluding Points
50
Concluding Points
51
Concluding Points
Concluding Points
Thank you
54