BT /o08, TH ah. | Document Title: Suban Condensate Tank Project Technical Bid Evaluation for Pipe COPI Doc No.: — ID-N-SB-LLO-TBE-ST-00-0010 Originator: PT Wijaya Karya (Persero) Tbk. COPI Group Owner: U0 = Frasak Area: SB - Suban Location: ST- Stati System: 00 - General System Document Type: ‘TBE-Technical Bid Evaluati Discipline / Subdiscipline: LL - Piping / LO - Piping General Old COPI Document No: - o | Tees 1 FEB 2013 : | 1 | FU | 06022013 | issued for Use AGN | -MERHS | SH 08 | IFA | 21-01-2089 | teeued or Approval AGN | MERHS | 0 OA | IFC | 26-17-2012 | Ieeued for Comment | AR 7 nen | MERMS | AB ‘OEE/ Prepared | Checked | Approved £1 | untowner Rev Staus | Issue Date | Reason for isue Wed | Project Conitacor Approvale | COPI Rpprovale Printed initials in the approval boxes confirm that the document has been signed. The originals are held within Document Management.Technical Bid Evaluation for Pipe ‘Suban Condensate Storage Tank ConocoPhillips (Grissik) Ltd. ID-N-SB-LLO-TBE-ST-00-0010 Rev 4 Page 2 of 6 ] ee: ConocoPh ps Revision Sheet ConocoPhillips (Grissik) Ltd. | 1 REVISION DATE DESCRIPTION OF CHANGE | 0A 2641-12 [issued forComment 08 21-01-13 | Issued for Approval 1 06-02-13 | Issued for Use | l Additional Approvers (If Applicable) Name Designation Signature DateTechnical Bid Evaluation for Pipe ID-N-SB-LLO-TBE-ST-00-0010 Rev 1 Suban Condensate Storage Tank ConocoPhillips (Grissik) Ltd. Page 3 of 6 Contents Contents 3 1 General ass 4 2 Scope of Material Evaluated .. 4 3 Evaluation Criteria 0 4 4 Technical Analysis... 4 41 Sumitomo, V&M, Nippon, Tena 4 42 Tennaris, Sumitomo (PT. Gamako Mandiri). 4 43 Sumitomo (PT Paradise Perkasa). 5 44 Van Leeuwen (PT Van Leeuwen) 5 45 ARCELLOR MITTAL, SUMITOMO, V&M (PT Tunas Cipta Manunggal).... 5 5 Technical Evaluation Summary. 5 6 Qualification and Recomendation. 5 Appendix A — TBE for Carbon Steels Pipes.. ‘Acrobat Document‘Technical Bid Evaluation for Pipe ID-N-SB-LLO-TBE-ST-00-0010 Rev 1 Suban Condensate Storage Tank ConocoPhil 8 (Grissik) Ltd. Page 4 of 6 1 41 42 General CONTRACTOR is planning to purchase Pipe, which consist of Normal Carbon Steels Pipe. CONTRACTOR already issued requisition Carbon Steels Pipe for inquiry to Vendor and Manufacture which listed in COP! Preferred Manufacturers-Fabricators List Document No. ID- G-BU-GGO-AML-GN-00-0001 Rev. 3 5 (five) Vendor have submitted the proposal and evaluated. Clarification has been made to the all supplier including technical and commercial aspect, This Technical Evaluation of the VENDOR's proposal based on Datasheet pipe CS Pipe no ID-N-SB-LLO-DSR-ST-13-0001 Scope of Material Evaluated This evaluation covers CS Pipe fabrication and supply, Equipment Manufactures, Document and Data requirement, and Work Experiences as per Pipe Datasheet. Evaluation Criteria ‘The evaluation criteria are the requisition as follow: Compliance to the requisition and project requirement Completeness supply of Material to be Purchased Technical Specification Requirement Manufacture Documentation Manufacture Data Capacity Marking, Shipping Preperation and Delivery Quality System and Control Procedure Previous Experience © @NARAONG Document and Data Record 10. Deviation and/or Alternative 11. Number and Type of Inspection and Testing. 12. Delivery Term and Condition Technical Analysis In general all VENDORs proposal deviated from requirement as noted. CONTRACTOR has conducted clarification to settle this issue, and also perform evaluation with result as follows Sumitomo, V&M, Nippon, Tenaris, Benteller, Mittal (PT Alvindo Catur Sentosa) Sumitomo, V&M, Nippon, Tenaris, Benteller, Mittal are pipe manufacture for CS Pipe, which is listed in COP! PMFL. CONTRACTOR considers Sumitomo, V&M, Nippon, Tenaris, Benteller, Mittal Pipe ‘supplied by PT Alfindo Catur Sentosa is Technically Acceptable. Tennaris, Sumitomo (PT. Gamako Mandiri) Tenanaris is the one of pipe manufacture for Carbon Steel Pipe, which is listed in COP! PMFL. Vendor has capability to supply Carbon Steels Pipes without any deviation with 6 weeks delivered, which is still under time frame schedule. CONTRACTOR considers Tennaris supplied by PT. Gamako Mandiri is Technically Acceptable.Technical Bid Evaluation for Pipe ID-N-SB-LLO-TBE-ST-00-0010 Rev 1 ‘Suban Condensate Storage Tank ConocoPhillips (Grissik) Ltd. Page 6 of 6 43 44 45 ‘Sumitomo (PT Paradise Perkasa) ‘Sumitomo is the one of pipe manufacture for Carbon Steels Pipe, which listed in COPI PMFL. Carbon Steels Pipe to be supplied from PT Paradise Perkasa CONTRACTOR considers Sumitomo pipe supplied by PT Paradise Perkasa is Technically Acceptable Tennaris (PT Van Leeuwen) Tennaris is the one of pipe manufacture for Carbon Steels Pipe, which is listed in COP! PMFL. CONTRACTOR considers Tennaris pipe supplied by PT Van Leeuwen Technically Acceptable. ARCELLOR MITTAL, SUMITOMO, V&M (PT Tunas Cipta Manunggal) Arcelor mittal, sumitomo, V&M is the one of pipe manufacture for Carbon Steels Pipe, which listed in COPI PMFL. CONTRACTOR considers Arcellor mittal, sumitomo, V&M supplied by PT Tunas Cipta Manunggal is Technically Acceptable. Technical Evaluation Summary The submitted bids were evaluated and clarified with the bidders. The result are tabulated in Appendix-A Qualification and Recomendation Based on VENDOR Quotation CONTRACTOR recommends the Qualified VENDORs as supplier Carbon Steels Pipe based on Datasheet Carbon Steels Pipe no ID-N-SB-LLO-DSR- ST-13-0001 5 (five) VENDOR's are recommended for technical and schedule meet project requirement: © Acceptable 1, Sumitomo, which supplied “PT. Paradise Perkasa”. 2, Sumitomo, V&M, Nippon, Tenaris, Benteller, Mittal, which supplied Alvindo Catur Sentosa”. 3. Tennaris,Sumitimo which supplied “PT. Gamako Mandiri” 4, Sumitomo,Tennaris, Ulma, And Benkan which supplied “PT. Van Leeuwen”. 5. Arcellor mittal, sumitomo, V&M which supplied “ which supplied PT. Tunas Cipta Manunggal.Technical Bid Evaluation for Pipe ID-N-SB-LLO-TBE-ST-00-0010 Rev 1 ‘Suban Condensate Storage Tank ConocoPhillips (Grissik) Ltd. Page 6 of 6 Appendix A — TBE for Carbon Steels Pipes = ‘Acrobat Document