Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Faculty Team
Robert L. Cross
Gayle R. Erwin
Cynthia Fraser
William J. Kehoe
Jennifer M. Knippen
Michael G. Morris
Marcia L. Pentz
Area
OB
Finance
QA
Marketing
Strategy
IT
Communicatio
n
Office
379
308
352
381
398
338
320
Telephone
924-6475
924-7552
924-4921
924-7045
243-4241
924-0776
924-6169
E-mail address
robcross@virginia.edu
ge2a@virginia.edu
cfg8q@virginia.edu
wjk@virginia.edu
knippen@virginia.edu
mmorris@virginia.edu
mlp6h@virginia.edu
ALCOA: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/home.asp
Alcoa Annual Report: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/investment/info_page/annual_report.asp
Alcoa Financial Information: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/investment/stock_chart.asp
Alcoa Operating Locations: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/about_alcoa/map/globalmap.asp
Alcoa Investor Relations: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/investment/info_page/home.asp
Alcoa Shareholder Information: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/investment/info_page/shareholder_info.asp
Alcoa Corporate Governance: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/about_alcoa/corp_gov/info_page/corp_gov.asp
Alcoa Values: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/about_alcoa/corp_gov/info_page/values_at_alcoa.asp
Alcoa Ethics, Business Conduct, Compliance:
http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/about_alcoa/corp_gov/ethics_compliance/info_page/business_conduct.asp
Alcoa Regional Presidents: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/investment/regional_presidents.asp
Alcoa Business Units: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/investment/bu_presidents.asp
Alcoa Corporate Officers: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/investment/officers.asp
Alcoa Markets and Products: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/products/overview.asp
Alcoa Innovation: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/innovation/info_page/home.asp
Alcoa Innovation Center (virtual tour): http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/innovation/tour/default.asp
Alcoa Innovation Case Studies:
http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/innovation/breakthroughs/technology_breakthroughs.asp
Alcoa Millennium Development Goals:
http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/about_alcoa/millennium_dev_goals_report.asp
Alcoa Sustainability: http://www.alcoa.com/sustainability/en/home.asp#
Alcoas NEWT System:
http://www.alcoa.com/sustainability/en/case_studies/2011_innovative_wts_reduces_reuses.asp?
initCountry=26&initYear=0&initCategory=1000
Alcoa Environmental Science and Sustainable Technology:
http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/community/foundation/board/Parks.asp
Alcoa Foundation: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/community/foundation/info_page/about_overview.asp
Alcoa WebCams: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/eco_alcoa/info_page/webcams.asp
Alcoa Careers: http://www.alcoa.com/global/en/careers/welcome.asp?lc=2
Culture
&
Values
Resources
People
Architecture
Processes
External
ExternalStakeholders
Stakeholders
Outputs
Outputsof
of
The
TheFirm
Firm
Block 8
Block 7
Caitlin Henry (Head Mentor)
Nailini Agrawal
Julian El-Abidin
Joanna Fowler
Ellie Goodman
Courtney Lester
Emily Macon
Adrian To (Intl and Transfer Students)
Shawn Vo
Andre Whye
McIntire School Mentor Program Leaders:
Course Pack Title: COMM 3010 Strategy & Systems, Blocks 7&8, Knippen and Morris, (McGrawHill Custom Publishing)
Munter, M. (2012). Guide to Managerial Communication: Effective Business Writing and Speaking,
9th Ed. Prentice Hall (Pearson), (ISBN-0-13-214771-8).
ICE Fall 2012: Communication Readings. Readings (an unbound packet) are available at the UVA
Bookstore.
Ross, Westerfield, and Jaffe: Corporate Finance, 9th edition, with Connect access, McGraw-Hill
Irwin, ISBN-0077684222. The textbook will be available at the UVA Bookstore.
ICE Finance Course Packet (Erwin - Blocks 7&8) that includes the following reading: Financial
Statement Analysis Review and three cases: The Case of the Unidentified Industries, Clarkson
Lumber, and The Super Project.
ICE - Marketing, COMM 3020, Blocks 7 and 8, Kehoe. ISBN13: 978-1-121-55301-9. This is a paper
format Custom Book available at UVA Bookstore. This book also is available in an eBook format.
To access the eBook format, go to the McGrawHill Bookstore at: http://create.mcgraw-hill.com/shop/. In the dialogue box
under the words Looking for new materials? enter the following ISBN: 9781121557451. The book will appear in a dropdown menu under the dialogue box. Click on the ebooks title and you will be taken to the ICE-Marketing eBook page. You
may add the eBook to your Shopping Cart. You will be offered the choice of downloading the eBook to your desktop or
viewing the eBook online via a browser. At Check Out you will be asked if you have an account. Click on Register Now
to create an account. (ICE-Marketing, COMM 3020, Blocks 7 and 8 eBook: ISBN13: 9781121557451).
Fraser, Cynthia, Business Statistics for Competitive Advantage with Excel 2010: Basics, Model
Building, Simulation and Cases, Preliminary Third Edition, McGraw Hill, 2012, ISBN 0078047838.
(Note that this edition is updated and includes two new chapters not in the edition used last year.)
Revitalizing Dell, Harvard Business School case #: 710442-PDF-ENG (Available on line.).
COMM 3020 Blocks 7 and 8. Rob Cross. Fall 2012.
Additional OB materials include the Myers-Briggs (MBTI), Survival Exercise, Thomas-Kilman
Conflict Mode Instrument, and Career Card Sort. Materials in this category will be distributed in
class. You must purchase a voucher for these materials in the Textbook Office at the UVA Bookstore.
Please go to the Textbook Office as soon as possible and ask for a voucher for your Block. Take the
voucher to the Bookstore cashier, who will stamp the voucher when you pay. It is VERY important
that you bring the stamped voucher to class on September 4th in order to be given the first survey
(MBTI) which is due in Professor Crosss mailbox by 5:00 p.m. on September 14th.
Public folders in Outlook, Collab, and Blackboard Course Sites.
To introduce and to integrate the basic concepts of strategic management and a systems/process view of
business organizations.
To cultivate an appreciation of the dynamic and complex conditions, the challenging questions, and the
conflicting responsibilities facing business leaders.
To enhance individual and team analytical, communication, and decision making skills when addressing
integrative, strategic, and global issues.
To develop skills in process analysis and reengineering of business processes.
To understand major trends in information technology, types of information systems, and the role they play in
the success of contemporary business organizations.
To provide an analytical approach for the organization and its external environment, particularly with respect to
its competitive and global context.
To create an awareness of communication channels and choices and the need to develop communication
strategies.
To understand business writing standards and how to increase the clarity and power of your writing.
To teach students how to think like top executives, i.e. like executives at the strategy level.
After a broad foundation is established in Strategy and Systems, the focus of ICE is narrowed to
develop personal skills and analytical tools needed in business. Organizational Behavior,
Marketing, and Communication will include the following objectives:
Analytical and Tactical Issues concentrate on finance and the quantitative methods and theories
underlying financial and marketing techniques. Specific objectives include:
To develop the students proficiency in using standard analytical financial techniques. Key concepts and
techniques to be covered are: financial statement analysis; valuation of future cash flows; and long-term
investment decisions.
To develop the students understanding of why value maximization provides a coherent framework for the
firms financial decisions.
To further expand students capabilities in analyzing financial problems and developing reports, figures, and
exhibits.
To demonstrate the wide range of situations in which quantitative analysis improves decision making and
creates competitive advantage.
To develop mastery of quantitative analysis with Excel and communication of results to improve decision
making.
To develop students analytical thinking processes.
COURSE REQUIREMENTS:
Class meetings are built around a specific topic and focus on a set of current readings, classic
readings, and/or cases. All students are required to read all materials, to prepare all discussion
questions and cases, to participate during class, and to complete all assignments. To help you
succeed in the course, you are assigned to an ICE Group - a study group. ICE Groups are
encouraged to meet prior to class to review the readings and to prepare the discussion questions
for each class meeting. Study groups also are used during class, so you should sit in the
classroom with your study group. A seating chart will be provided.
Given the credit hours and schedule for ICE, the pace and workload can be challenging and
intense. If you are having difficulty, please contact the ICE faculty, Dean Rebecca Leonard in the
Office of Student Services, your mentor, or Counseling and Psychological Services (CAPS) at
UVA Student Health (924-5556). It is better to seek help sooner in the semester rather than later.
5
2
1
0
-1
Criteria
Exceptional
contribution to
class discussion
and learning
Positive
contribution to
class discussion
Attentive but did
not participate
meaningfully
Unprepared
attendance or
excused absence
Negative
behavior or
unexcused
absence
Example(s)
These are insightful comments or questions that go
beyond the readings, cases, or class discussion and
demonstrate new ideas. They move the class thinking to
a higher level or require the student to take a real risk
(e.g., student speaks up to persuasively and respectfully
disagree when there seems to be consensus in the
room, does an effective job of responding to a cold-call,
is willing to ask the stupid question, etc.).
Comments or questions that demonstrate thoughtful
preparation and attention to the readings, cases, or
class discussion and move the class forward.
Paid attention and politely listened to others but did not
engage in the discussion or made repetitive comments
that did not add to the discussion.
Unprepared for cold-call, inattentive, or absent from
class with prior approval.
Inappropriate, disruptive, disrespectful, or distracting
behavior or comments; late arrival, leaving early, or
absence from class without prior approval.
Meaningful, high impact contributions to the discussion via insightful comments and questions
are most valued, while frequent, irrelevant, repetitive comments receive little value. You are
expected to conduct yourself at all times in a professional manner by showing respect toward
others as well as by showing regard toward the classrooms and meeting spaces in our building.
Participation evaluation and subsequent point allocation is completely up to the
instructors. Obviously, some degree of subjectivity is involved, but every effort is made by the
instructors to arrive at a fair and consistent standard.
If participation is uncomfortable for you, please discuss this problem with the faculty early in the
session so that we can identify approaches to help you learn and practice this important skill to
increase your class contribution and comfort. The earlier in the semester you begin, the more it
will help your learning. If English is your second language, we want to use this class to help you
develop your comfort and facility in English discussions.
Attendance is Essential and Required -- Attendance is essential and required since you cannot
participate if you are not present. If you find that you are unable to attend class, you must notify
your instructors in advance and then it is up to the instructor to determine whether the absence
will be excused or not. If the absence is excused, please note that you will receive a 0 for class
participation for that day because you are unable to participate and contribute to the class
discussion and learning. If you attend class and demonstrate that you are unprepared for class or
are inattentive, then you will also receive a class participation grade of 0 for the day. If you fail
to attend class without an excused absence, you will receive a -1 for the day. Inappropriate
web-surfing, e-mailing and/or instant messaging during class is distracting and inconsiderate and
will result in a class participation grade of -1 for the day. Also, arriving late and leaving
early is unacceptable and will lower your participation grade. Excessive absences will result in
a significantly lower grade and could result in an F grade for the affected course(s).
Participation -- Participation, or speaking out loud in class, is important because:
Discussion or debate about a business situation is much more fruitful when multiple perspectives are included,
which can only happen through participation in the discussion by many people.
Others will hear your perspective and will analyze how it is different from their own, and will learn from that
analysis. Be an active listener and you will learn more from others participation.
When you are working in an organization, you will be expected to participate constructively in business
meetings. The McIntire School classroom is an excellent place to learn and practice these skills.
Articulating your thoughts out loud demands that you be clear and precise, and to speak so that others
understand. This discipline will help your learning.
You will learn more and will clarify your own thoughts better by teaching others.
Instructors grade class participation at the end of each class and summarize patterns of
participation over the course. Quality of participation is more important than quantity, but
speaking frequently (unless comments detract from the class) is also helpful. High quality
participation demonstrates good preparation before class; active listening to contributions of
others during class is encouraged and moves the class discussion in a constructive direction.
During class discussion, questions often may be as useful as statements.
Contribution to Class Learning -- Helping your classmates learn is important because the
business environment is constantly changing, and no one person will always have all the best
ideas. The most successful businesses are those whose employees help each other learn about
7
new things as they arise and cooperate to solve problems and implement solutions. This is a very
different approach to learning than most students have experienced in the past, but it will be
critical to your successful transition to the post-UVA world. The McIntire School environment is
an excellent place to learn and practice cooperative learning.
There are many ways you can contribute to class learning, in the classroom itself, as well as in
the McIntire School and University of Virginia communities. For example, you can:
Assist classmates in solving homework problems and assignments (unless they are designated individual
effort by the instructor).
Play needed roles in your study group: help lead, keep people on track, keep people organized, prepare
your parts especially well, and help others synthesize their parts, etc.
Most instructors grade contribution to class learning by observing students activities in class,
and watching how students interact. You may be surveyed in a Peer Evaluation towards the end
of the semester and asked to identify others in the class that contributed to your learning, as well
as to identify how you contributed to others learning. Patterns in these activities are analyzed to
obtain a grade.
Please remember that Participation/Contribution to Class Learning is designed to capture
active and cooperative learning. This type of learning is critical to your success as a leader, so it
is a central part of McIntire Schools program. Your thoughtful contributions will help make
everyones learning more effective. Your grade for participation/contribution to class learning
varies over the ICE components as is described under the Grading Framework presented later in
the syllabus.
Group Work:
Most organizational tasks are accomplished by groups or teams, so learning to be a good team
member, and a good team leader, is an important part of your business education. In the ICE
program, you will be in a team that will work together for the full semester on a project too large
and complex for one person to do. Your success on the project will be determined, in part, by
how well you work together as a team.
To help your team perform well, ICE includes a team-building program to systematically
develop group knowledge and skills. This will be important to you, because your performance in
the different subject areas of ICE, and on the project, will require effective team effort. During
the semester, your team will engage in exercises to teach you about groups, and more
importantly, help you diagnose and correct team performance problems in your ongoing ICE
team. Here are answers to frequently asked questions about the ICE team-building component:
How will the teams be assigned? Eight teams will be formed in each block, making team size five or six persons.
Assignment to teams is initially random, with adjustments made ensure diversity. You will be assigned to a team
during your first week, and will start working together almost immediately.
What if I dont like my group? Can I switch with someone on a different team? Once the teams are assigned
there will be no switching. Some difficulties working together are par for the course, and are opportunities for
learning.
How does grading for the team-building program work? There is no grading for the group work involved in
completing the activities in the Team Building component, although failure to complete the exercises adequately
could harm your OB participation grade. The payoff for good performance in this part of ICE is that your work in
other segments will go better. In addition, your fellow team members will evaluate your work as a team member,
and that will be factored into the participation component of your OB grade through a peer evaluation survey sent
out with the final.
What if my group is having problems? It is not unusual for groups to have problems for which outside assistance
will be required. Effective groups are not so much the ones without problems, but those that deal with their
problems in a timely way, and learn in the process. If you see problems that are going unresolved you should feel
more than comfortable seeking out any members of the ICE faculty who will help you and your group to resolve the
issues and get back on track. Dont wait for difficulties to turn into big problems before seeking assistance.
Remember, getting help is not a sign of weakness, but rather an opportunity for learning and improvement.
Do we still have to do all this if our group is getting along really well? The short answer is, yes. A group is not
necessarily doing well just because everyone gets along, is having fun, or has no evident problems. Its about
performance, and that includes learning skills and attitudes that will be useful in your career.
Alcoa ICE Seminar - Introduction & Overview with Alcoa Executives: September 25, 2012 (Note: This
ICE Seminar likely will be moved to an in-class session on October 3.)
Alcoa IIP Strategic Opportunity Analysis Report (SOAR) : Due on or before October 25, 20112
Alcoa ICE Seminar - Conference with Alcoa executives: October 30, 2012
Alcoa IIP Final Report - Marketing & Financial Plan: Due on or before November 30, 2012
Alcoa IIP Presentation: December 5/6, 2012 (randomly assigned)
Alcoa Release: As part of the Alcoa Interdisciplinary ICE Project, each student will sign an
Alcoa Release form to accompany submission of the Alcoa Interdisciplinary ICE Project. A
copy of the Alcoa Release form will be distributed in class for your signature.
Peer Evaluations
At the end of the semester you will be required to fill out a peer evaluation form indicating your
contribution to the project as well as that of your group members. Evidence of exemplary
contributions may be rewarded, while evidence of free loading will be investigated and may
result in a grade penalty. The faculty reserves the right to adjust your project and course grades
based on peer evaluation results.
Final Examination:
The comprehensive, integrated ICE final examination is an INDIVIDUAL exam. You are
expected to work alone on all aspects of the exam. The exam will be distributed at 1:00pm
on Monday, December 10, 2012. The examination is DUE by 1:00pm on Saturday,
December 15, 2012. The format of the final exam will be discussed in class later in the semester.
Institutional Review Board requirements for university studies, it is possible to earn research
participation credit through alternate work. While we encourage you to participate in research in
order to enhance your own learning experience, this alternate route is available at no penalty.
Questions about the research requirement, including details on the alternate credit route, should
be directed to Mr. Baglioni (ajb2t@virginia.edu).
Important Policies:
Cell Phones, Smart Phones, Laptops, Netbooks, Tablets, Pagers, etc.: Upon entering the
classroom, please turn off - not set to silent or vibrate - all cell phones, smart phones, laptops,
netbooks, tablets, pagers, etc. Use of computers in the classroom is at the discretion of the
instructor and is allowed only for designated class purposes. Please keep computers off your
desks at all other times. When computers are allowed for class purposes, inappropriate Websurfing, emailing, instant messaging, twittering, blogging, or the like is distracting, inconsiderate,
and will result in a -1 for an offenders daily class participation grade. (UVA Student Council
adopted the following resolution on January 14, 2003: "Student Council endorses a policy in
which professors inform students at the beginning of each semester at least on written syllabi that
they must turn off their cell phones before entering class.")
Audio and Video Recording to Meet Course Learning Objectives: We will make audio and
video recordings of presentations for instructional purposes related to our course. The recordings
may not be used for any purpose except to meet the learning objectives of our course. The
recordings may not be shared with or distributed to any other individual or groups without the
expressed written permission of the instructor and the recorded students.
McIntire Policy on Audio and Video Taping and Distribution of Class Materials : Audio and
video recording are only allowed under special circumstances (e.g., students with documented
disabilities) and only with the prior written permission of the instructor. Any audio or video
recording or all other class materials handed out in class or posted to websites such as
Blackboard or COLLAB may not be exchanged or distributed for commercial purposes, for
compensation, or for any other purpose other than study by students enrolled in the class. Public
distribution of such materials may constitute copyright infringement. Unauthorized use of class
notes or recordings may subject an individual to University Honor, Judicial charges, and/or legal
action.
Respect for Others and for the McIntire School Facility: As a McIntire student and future
business professional, you are expected to conduct yourself in a professional manner by showing
respect toward others as well as by showing regard toward the classrooms and meeting spaces in
our building.
11
12
Weight
5%
15%
S/NS
S/NS
S/NS
S/NS
15%
15%
15%
10%
10%
15%
100%
13
Weight
15%
30%
22%
25%
100%
Before you write, read the chapters & articles suggested on the assignment sheet and for our
class on 8/29. Then, as you brainstorm ideas, keep the following basic questions in mind:
What do you want to know about the industry in which Alcoa competes?
What do you want to know about the challenges and opportunities Alcoa faces?
In this assignment, and in all writing you do for ICE, use your strongest writing
skills.
Use VIRGOs commerce focused databases to research and reference at least
three articles about Alcoa to support the nature and content of your questions.
Again, do not actually send the questions to an Alcoa executive; your email
should be sent to Prof. Pentz.
Do not attach a Word document to your email; begin the email with a salutation
and direct address to a specific top Alcoa executive. Include your contentand
questionsin the body of the email.
Send Prof. Pentz your Alcoa email no later than 9:00pm Tuesday August 28th
14
Assignment Made - MBTI Survey: Go to the Textbook Office of the University Bookstore as
soon as possible and ask for a voucher for your Block. Take the voucher to the Bookstore cashier
who will stamp the voucher when you pay. You MUST bring the stamped voucher to class on
August 29th in order to be given the MBTI survey for OB. Feedback from the survey will be used
in class on October 2nd. This survey is due in Professor Crosss mailbox by September 14th.
September 3, Monday
Topic: Communication--Moving from Academic to Business WritingDesign, Purpose & Audience
(Pentz)
Readings/Cases:
GMC: Writing: Macro Issues pp. 53-70.
16
September 4, Tuesday
Topic: Organizational Behavior 1 - Team Development (Cross)
Readings:
Elite Teams Get the Job Done
A Note on Team Process
Discussion: Be prepared to discuss the following questions:
What great teams have you seen, and what made them great?
What prevents a team from becoming great?
Think about your ICE team as you read. What are the relevant
lessons?
Topic: Organizational Behavior 2 - Team Performance (Cross)
Readings:
17
Note: Tuesday evening is the Block7/Block 8 ICE Seminar evening. Please keep Tuesday
evening free on your calendar for ICE Seminars and other ICE academic activities.
September 5, Wednesday
Topic: Strategy & Systems - Strategy and Process Fit
Overview:
Todays session explores how strategy and process models fit with the
external environment. To do this, we will examine the sustainability of
competitive advantage in different contexts. In addition, we will study
how one company was able to integrate new business strategies and
business processes in order to become more competitive.
Readings/Cases:
ECCO A/S Global Value Chain Management
Wal-mart Stores: Every Day Low Prices in China
Discussion Questions:
1. What are ECCOs sources of competitive advantage and what is their
position in the market? What challenges do they face in managing their
global supply chain and what role does (or should) IT play?
2. Why is Wal-Mart successful in the US? Can Wal-Mart build the same
competitive advantage in China through its successful business model?
September 6, Thursday
Topic: Strategy & Systems - Environmental Analysis
Overview:
In prior sessions, we have discussed the formulation of strategy and
pursuit of competitive advantage. Such activities are not possible
without understanding the companys context. The book chapter and
lecture will explain a tool used to make sense of the world surrounding
the company.
Readings/Cases:
HBS, SWOT Analysis I
Porter, Understanding Industry Structure
Eisenmann, Satellite Radio
18
Discussion Questions:
1. Why is the analysis of the external environment critical to a firms
ability to identify and colonize a distinct strategic position?
2. How does industry (5-Forces) analysis help you to identify profitability
of an industry?
3. What are the strategies to influence industry profitability?
Assignment Made: Strategy/Communication Memo assignment made:
Strat/Comm Analysis memo due by 4:00pm for Prof. Knippen
Wednesday September 12th.
Workshoped Revision of Strat/Comm Analysis memo due to Prof.
Pentz by 4:00pm on Saturday, September 15th.
business intelligence using a case from the health and tourism industry
as context for our discussion.
Applegate, Canyon Ranch
McKinsey Big Data
Readings/Cases:
Discussion Questions:
1.
What are the drivers behind the move to analytics and big data?
What is this trend so hot in all industries right now?
2. What is the difference between data and information and how
does technology enable companies to utilize each effectively?
3. How did Canyon Ranch use data analytic capabilities strategically and
what key changes did they introduce as a result?
21
ASSIGNMENT DUE: MBTI Survey is due today, September 14: The completed MBTI
survey must be submitted to Professor Cross mailbox today. The results of the MBTI survey will
be presented in class on October 2.
Discussion Questions:
1. Why is a dollar today worth more than a dollar tomorrow?
2. What is the difference between the APR (or SAIR), EAR, and the effective
rate per compounding period?
3. How do you convert the APR (sometimes referred to as r in RWJ but I will refer to
it as r/m) into the effective rate per compounding period (sometimes referred to
as r/m in RWJ but I will refer to it as r)?
4. How are interest rates typically quoted?
5. What is the rate that should be used to discount future cash flows?
Homework Problems: RWJ Chapter 4: 1-3, 6, 9, 11, 13, 26, 29, 46
25
Assignment DUE: Place a hard copy of your final COMM 3010 case analysis in Prof. Knippen,
Prof. Morris, and Prof. Pentzs mailboxes by 5:00 p.m.
ICE Seminar - Introduction & Overview with Alcoa Executives: September 25, 2012 (Note: This ICE
seminar likely will be moved to an in-class session on October 3.)
IIP Strategic Opportunity Analysis Report (SOAR): Due on or before October 25, 20112
ICE Seminar - Conference with Alcoa executives: October 30, 2012
IIP Final Report - Marketing & Financial Plan: Due on or before November 30, 2012
IIP Presentation: December 5/6 (randomly assigned)
Alcoa Release: As part of the Alcoa Interdisciplinary ICE Project, each student will sign an
Alcoa Release form to accompany submission of the Alcoa Interdisciplinary ICE Project. A
copy of the Alcoa Release form will be distributed in class for your signature.
Reading Assignments: The readings listed below are assigned for four marketing classes: M-1,
M-2, M-3, and M-4. Please complete the readings as soon as possible to be prepared for class
discussion, beginning particularly during the M-2 class session.
For each of the assigned readings, I suggest that you please prepare a set of brief notes (one or
two pages) in bullet-point format (or in another format comfortable for you) of the key
takeaways from each reading.
Managerial Takeaways: What are the most important takeaways for a manager?
26
Personal Takeaways: What are the most important takeaways for you?
Project Takeaways: What are takeaways for the Interdisciplinary ICE Project?
(Bring your note pages to class for use during class discussion and as a study guide for use during the
marketing examination later in the semester. The note pages are to enhance your learning experience. I will
not be collecting the note pages.)
Readings from the Textbook: All the readings for the marketing sessions are in the marketing
custom textbook, except for the Value Added Readings:
Read: The Theory of the Business, Peter F. Drucker, HBR, pp. 3-12
Read: Developing Marketing Strategies and a Marketing Plan, pp. 14-33
Read: Note on Marketing Strategy, Robert J. Dolan, HBS, pp. 34-50
Read: Strategies to Crack Well-Guarded Markets, David J. Bryce and Jeffrey H. Dyer,
HBR, pp. 53-63
Read: Evaluate your Company with Marketing Due Diligence, Mark N. Clemente and
David S. Greenspan, HBR, pp. 69-71
Value Added Readings: In addition to readings from the textbook, Value Added Readings of
articles and reports from leading consulting companies such as Bain & Company (www.bain.com),
Booz, Allen and Hamilton (www.boozallen.com), the Boston Consulting Group (www.bcg.com),
McKinsey & Company (www.mckinseyquarterly.com), and other sources, will enlarge your
understanding of marketing and marketing strategy. My expectations of you for the Value Added
Readings are as follows:
Please read some if not all of the Value Added Readings: For some classes, there are many Value Added
Readings assigned. I realize that you might not have the inclination or the time to complete all the Value
Added readings before every class. That is OK. As the semester progresses, please try to find time to
complete all of the readings. In fact, as we get deeper into the semester, many of the Value Added Readings
may have greater meaning for you.
Please read the Value Added Readings online: There is no need for you to download and print out any of
the Value Added Readings. Rather, please read online, make a few notes if you desire, and bring your
computer or tablet to class to access the readings during class. Again, do not download/print any of the
Value Added Readings. Please save expense and paper - do not download/print the Value Added Readings.
File not found: All the Value Added Readings were available on line when the syllabus was prepared.
There may be an occasional reading for which you receive a file not found message. That happens - it is
the ephemeral nature of Internet postings. If that happens for one of the listed readings, simply see if you
can find another article on the same or similar topic while on line.
Read: The 21st Century Organization, McKinsey Quarterly. This article builds on Druckers
concepts. . (Note: This article is not in the marketing custom textbook. Go to: www.mckinseyquarterly.com and
use the Search Function to access the article. You will need to register for an account for which there is no
charge. While on the McKinsey website, please familiarize yourself with its content. Look particularly at the
content under Functions and under Big Ideas.)
Search for Other Articles/Reports: In addition to the assigned articles, please search on the
Internet for other interesting articles and reports about marketing and marketing strategy.
Topic: Introduction to Alcoa - Overview/Key Issues (Alcoa Executives and ICE Faculty).
ICE Seminar introducing Alcoa, the Corporate Sponsor for Blocks 7 and 8. During the seminar you will receive an
overview about Alcoa as well as discussion of a few key issues being considered by management. The information
discussed this evening will be useful for generating ideas for the Interdisciplinary ICE Project. Additionally, you
may receive information about possible career and/or internship opportunities at Alcoa. Attendance is required.
(NOTE: This ICE Seminar is tentative. It may be moved to an in-class session on October 3. You will be
notified in class whether this ICE Seminar will occur on September 25 or on October 3 as an in-class session.)
Discussion Questions:
1. What are the differences in the finance and accounting perspectives?
2. What are the timing differences between Income Statements and Balance Sheets?
3. What are sources/uses of cash?
4. How does the Statement of Cash Flows differ from the sources/uses statement?
5. Why is the change from the ending and beginning balance of balance sheet items
used for sources/uses of cash and the Statement of Cash Flows?
Homework Problems: RWJ Chapter 2: 1-4, 7, 13 & you should prepare a Statement of
Cash Flows, label the sources/uses, and analyze each of the firms financial health using
the excel template and data posted for you on the ICE Blackboard site (be sure to go to
the firms web site and find its mission statement and the fundamental business). You will
need to turn-in a landscaped and formatted exhibit of your Statements of Cash Flows
using the example posted on the ICE Blackboard site. On this assignment you may work
alone, with one other individual from your block, or in your assigned group.
October 1, Monday
Topic: Finance 5---Working with Financial Statements
Topics Covered: Ratio Analysis
Reading Assignment: RWJ Chapter 3.1-3.3 (skip 3.4-3.6) & Financial Statement
Analysis Review (This reading is in the finance course packet. For today read through the sections on
Common Size Financial Statements and Ratio Analysis on pp. 10-18 and Appendix A pp. 29-30.)
Discussion Questions:
1. What are reasons for performing ratio analysis?
2. What are some key drawbacks of ratio analysis?
Homework Problems: RWJ Chapter 3: 1-3, 6 and using the excel template and the data
posted for you on the ICE Blackboard site, calculate the ratios (as defined in Appendix A
of the Financial Statement Analysis Review reading). Be prepared to discuss the strengths
and weaknesses of each firm and the similarities and differences across the firms. You
will need to print out landscaped and formatted exhibits. On this assignment you may
work alone, with one other individual from your block, or in your assigned group.
Topic: Finance 6---Financial Statement Analysis in Practice
Topics Covered: Example of Financial Statement Analysis
Reading Assignment: The Case of the Unidentified Industries (in the finance course packet)
Case Assignment:
1. Working in your assigned group, try to match the 14 firms with the 14 industries
listed in the case using the data provided in Exhibit 1 and any approach you find
appropriate.
2. Prepare a brief group write-up that includes justification for why you matched
each of the 14 firms to a particular industry. Group write-up (not to exceed two typed
pages using 12-point font) and exhibits (no limit) due at the beginning of class.
October 2, Tuesday
Topic: Organizational Behavior 3 - Finding your Individual Myers-Briggs Type Indicator
MBTI (Cross)
Reading Assignment for Class: How (Un)Ethical Are You?
Discussion: Be prepared to discuss the following questions:
29
October 3, Wednesday
Note: Please see the entry for the ICE Seminar at September 25. Alcoa executives likely will
be attending class today (instead of the September 25 ICE Seminar). The Alcoa presentation will
be incorporated within M-3 and M-4 class sessions. It is anticipated that the Alcoa executives
will attend Block 7 at 11:00 a.m. to 12:15 p.m. and will attend Block 8 at 2:00 p.m. to 3:15 p.m.
To facilitate the Alcoa executives, we will combine the M-3 and M-4 assignment materials.
Topic: M-3, Marketing - Concepts, Strategies, & Theories (Kehoe)
Activity for class: In this M-3 class session, we will continue discussion of the reading assigned
under the M-1 class session. Also, we will discuss your IIP ideas during todays class.
Assignments:
Read and make discussion notes on the readings assigned under M-1 above
To begin planning for the marketing aspects of the Interdisciplinary ICE Project, please be
prepared to discuss your project ideas during class discussion. Present your ideas in well
conceptualized and well-written paragraphs describing each idea. Turn in your in your
project idea after todays class. Your paragraphs will be evaluated as part of your individual
Class Participation grade.
Topic: M-4, Marketing - Concepts, Strategies & Theories (Kehoe)
Assignments: See M-1 for reading assignments for todays class
Discussion and/or Activities: During the M4 class session, we will continue with discussion of
marketing concepts, strategies, and theories. Please be sure to have completed and made
30
discussion notes for all the assigned readings listed in the syllabus under marketing class session
M-1 above.
October 4, Thursday
Topic: Finance 7---Financial Forecasting and Planning
Topics Covered: Examples of financial forecasting - Using Excel
Reading Assignment: RWJ Chapter 3.4-3.6 & Financial Statement Analysis Review
(This reading is in the finance course packet. For today read through The Basics of Financial Forecasting
& Proforma Analysis section on pp. 19-25.)
Discussion Questions:
1. What are the basics for the status-quo (constant % of sales) forecasting technique?
2. What does the status-quo forecasting technique imply about the firms operating
policies?
3. What is EFN?
4. What are some key drawbacks of the status-quo forecasting technique?
5. What recommendations do you have to address these drawbacks?
Homework Problems: Chapter 3: 8, 19-22 & Supplemental Proforma Assignment
posted on the ICE Blackboard site
Topic: Finance 8---Financial Statement Analysis and Forecasting In Practice
Topics Covered: Example of financial statement analysis and forecasting in Excel
In-class Example: Bring laptop computers to build a proforma worksheet
Assignment DUE: Group Speaking self assessment memo due to Prof. Pentzs mailbox by
5:00 p.m. Thursday, Oct. 4th, 2012.
31
Read: The Consumers Voice: Can Your Company Hear It? Boston Consulting Group
(Note: Read pages 4 & 5 and 11 & 12 of this report)
Read: Capitalizing on Customer Insight, McKinsey Quarterly
Read: What Strategists Can Learn from Sartre, Strategy+Business. (This article presents a
different view of VALS.)
Ford Motor Companys experiment in social media marketing, Ford Takes Online
Gamble with New Fiesta, WSJ, 4/8/2009. (Ford lent Fiesta automobiles to 100 young consumers
who posted You Tube videos about the car over which Ford had no control. See You Tube Ford Fiesta
Movement.)
The BzzAgent concept on page 87, word-of-mouth marketing, social media marketing,
and crowdsourcing.
The concept of sociocultural influences on consumer behavior on pp. 86-92.
Interdisciplinary ICE Project: For discussion within your ICE Group:
Narrow down and decide on an idea or an approach for your project
32
Explain the issue or problem you will be addressing. Describe how you will address the
issue or problem - that is, what specifically is being proposed to address the issue or
problem?
Define the primary target market for the idea indicating the demographic characteristics
of the primary target market. Are there other characteristics (e.g., lifestyle, etc.)? What
problem does your proposed project solve for the primary target market? What are the
main points of difference of your proposed project idea? That is, how will this idea
differentiate Alcoa, add revenue, and create value?
October 10, Wednesday, 5:00 -7:00 p.m. - Robertson 123 at 5:00 p.m.
Topic: Careers in Marketing 101 series - Sales and Retailing. Information about the Careers in
Marketing 101 series will be sent to you by Commerce Career Services.
33
4. If sales growth continued along the same path in the 1997, what would be you estimate of
loan requirements in this year (1997)?
5. What advice do you have for Mr. Clarkson, and if you were a banker would you approve
his loan request?
Note: Trade notes payable are accounts payable with interest charged since they are overdue.
They should be considered as part of the accounts payable total balance in doing
analyses from year to year.
Be sure to bring your laptops to class with your case solutions for an in-class analysis.
Read two articles about giving the poor access to a firms products/services:
Using the Internet, select a consumer-product firm or a service firm that you believe has
done a good job of market segmentation. Explain why their segmentation approach is
laudable. Be prepared to share with the class information about the firms segmentation
approach. My selection of a firm with a laudable segmentation approach is Marriott
Corporation www.marriott.com.
Interdisciplinary ICE Project:
34
Who is your primary client, what are her/his needs in terms of your project, and why is
your project idea the best option to satisfy those needs? Is there a way to segment your
potential market? Is it intended for all of the market (undifferentiated) or for parts of the
market (segmented)?
Develop a positioning statement for your project idea (see page 99 for suggested format of a
positioning statement). To what segments will your appeal? Is there a primary customer or
segment? What are the needs that your project idea satisfies? Why is the project idea the
best option to satisfy needs of the market segment(s)? Will the project idea require to be
customized in approaching individual market segments?
Topic: M-7,Segmentation of Markets (continued) and begin Analytical Aspects of Marketing Market Research/Scenario Planning (Kehoe)
Assignments:
Complete the reading assigned under M-6 for Segmentation of Markets
Readings from the Textbook for M7:
Read: Note on Market Research, Stanford Graduate School of Business, beginning on page
101in the Marketing text
Read: A Note on Scenario Planning, HBSC, beginning on page 112 in the Marketing text
Value Added Readings:
Read: Tim Laseter, Casey Lichtendahl and Yael Grushka-Cockayne, Cleaning the Crystal
Ball: How Intelligent Forecasting Can Lead to Better Decision Making, Strategy+Business,
Summer 2010, pp. 26-31. (Use factiva to locate this article. See McIntire resources at:
http://guides.lib.virginia.edu/commerce.)
Read: How to Test your Decision-Making Instincts, McKinsey Quarterly.
Discussion Questions:
1. What are some key drawbacks of the IRR, payback period, and profitability
index?
2. In what cases may IRR lead you to a different answer than NPV?
36
Assignment Due: Revised Alcoa emailone email per group-- with 4-5 proposed
questions your group would like to propose for discussion during our conference with Alcoa on
October 30th.
Send your groups revised, group-authored, email to Prof. Pentz today (10/22) by 12:00pm
(Noon). Please make sure to put: Block # - Group # --- Alcoa/UVA Conference in the subject
line of the email.
Topics Covered: Relevant (incremental) free cash flows, opportunity costs, externalities,
sunk costs, fixed overhead expenses, financing costs, operating net working capital,
depreciation, capital expenditures, terminal value, liquidation/ salvage value
Reading Assignment: Financial Statement Analysis (p. 25-28 in the finance case packet)
RWJ, Chapter 6
Discussion Questions:
1. Why are sunk costs considered irrelevant to the evaluation of long-term
investments if cash outflows are involved?
2. What is one opportunity cost you may currently be facing?
3. Can you think of any potential side effects associated with your proposed project?
Homework Problems: RWJ Chapter 6: 1, 2, 4, 6, 10, 12, 14, 19-21, 24
Topic: Finance 16---Analyzing Capital Budgeting Projects
Topics Covered: Capital rationing, project ranking, unequal lives, risk analysis, options
Reading Assignment: RWJ, Chapter 6 (continued) and Chapter 7
Homework Problems: Supplemental Homework Problems
What are the relevant cash flows for General Foods to use in evaluating the Super
Project? In particular, how should management deal with the following 4 issues:
Test market expenses
Overhead expenses
Erosion of Jell-O
Allocation of charges for the use of excess agglomerator capacity
2 Based on what you decide in 1, compute the NPV of the Super Project using a 15%
discount rate. How attractive is Super based on financial terms? How sensitive is
Supers attractiveness based on what you decided in question 1?
(Note: To compute the NPV, you need to read carefully the assumptions associated with
exhibit 6. The exhibit is an analysis of ROFE or basically an average accounting rate
of return. Your mission is to re-arrange the basic flows into an NPV analysis. For
example, in line item 13, the exhibit gives the cumulative depreciation associated with
the time zero capital expenditure of $200 (thousand). Thus, the depreciation expense for
year 2, for example, would be the difference in the cumulative depreciation between year
one and year two).
3 How attractive is the Super Project in strategic and competitive terms? What potential
risks and benefits does General Foods incur by either accepting or rejecting the project?
4 Should General Foods proceed with Super? Why or why not?
Additional information that you may find helpful:
An excel file that contains the data from Exhibits 1, 2, 3 & 6 will be posted to the ICE
Blackboard site. If you believe the Jello equipment & building costs of $453,000 is
applicable, use the depreciation schedule that is also provided in the spreadsheet. If you
believe the overhead expenses are relevant, the amount to be allocated beginning in year
5 is provided on page 15 (the difference between the facilities-used profit before taxes
and the fully-allocated profit before taxes of $211-$157 is the 10-year average expense
and you may use this to get the total expense to be allocated from year 5 to year 10).
Assume the tax rate is 52%.
Use a 15% discount rate for calculating NPV (you may want to compare that to the IRR).
All numbers should be in $thousands (Exhibit 5 reports $millions but they should be $thousands).
39
October 30, Tuesday, 5:00 p.m. 7:00 p.m. - (Special Session/Room 120)
Topic: Conference with Alcoa Executives.
Everyone is expected to attend this important ICE Seminar with executives from our ICE Corporate Sponsor. Active
participation in this seminar is critically important for your Interdisciplinary ICE Project. Be prepared to ask the
Alcoa executives questions about Alcoa and about your project. Everyone is expected to bring several written
questions to the conference. Each ICE group should meet before the conference and develop questions about your
project. Please dress modestly. Attendance is required.
November 2, Friday
Assignment DUE: Team Analysis Paper is due today to Professor Crosss mailbox (refer to
assignment distributed on October 10 and assignment requirements and description
in opening pages of the syllabus).
November 5, Monday
Topic: Finance 21---Risk & the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC)
41
Topics Covered:
Reading Assignment: RWJ Chapter 13 & CAPM reading
Discussion Questions:
1. How is the CAPM estimated using real-world data?
2. How does leverage affect the risk and cost of equity? Beta?
3. How does leverage affect the risk of the firm, WACC, and firm value?
4. How is WACC used in practice?
Homework Problems: RWJ Chapter 11: 2, 18-19, 24, 32-33
Topic: Finance 22---Enterprise Valuation & WACC
Topics Covered: Baxter Valuation Example Using Excel
Reading Assignment: RWJ Chapter 11 & 13
Homework Problems: Assignment posted on ICE Blackboard site
Bring laptop computers to download Valuation Worksheet
November 6, Tuesday
Topic: Organizational Behavior 9 - Career Development (Cross)
Readings: Managing Your Career
How To Stay Stuck in the Wrong Career
Kevin Williams (Orientation)
Activity: Career Value Card Sort (Done in class)
Discussion: Be prepared to discuss the following questions:
What are some of the things you need to keep in mind as you manage a career? What
are some of the things you should be doing even now?
Why do people get trapped in less-than-optimal career and life situations? How do
you avoid getting trapped and what should you be thinking about even now to avoid
it?
What should Kevin do?
Topic: M-9, Marketing - Advertising & Corporate Communication (Kehoe and Pentz)
Assignment Due - During Class: Second Individual Advertisement/Brand Speaking
Assignment in class. Recording will be done in 2 locations - see assignment document for details.
November 7, Wednesday
Topic: Finance 23---WACC & Capital Structure Theory
Reading Assignment: RWJ Chapter 16
Discussion Questions:
1. How does leverage affect risk and the cost of equity? Beta?
2. How does leverage affect the risk, WACC, and firm value?
3. How is WACC used in practice?
Homework Problems: RWJ Chapter 16: 4, 9, 13, 20, 25
Topic: M-10 (Marketing)/QA-7 Joint Session
CASE 7-1 Segmentation and Forecasting in the Preemie Diaper Market (Fraser/Kehoe)
(Class meets in the classroom.)
Objectives:
Discuss Monte Carlo simulation implications for pricing a new product
Discuss the implications of segments responses for promotion and positioning of a new product
Experience making a PowerPoint presentation of statistical results to decision makers
42
November 8, Thursday
Topic: QA 8: Multiple regression analysis (Fraser)
Objectives: Learn how to account for joint influences with multiple regression
Learn how to recognize and account for multicollinearity
Readings & Cases: BSCAIII Ch. 10
Assignment: Homework 4 10-1 Chasing Whole Foods DUE Tuesday, November 14
This is an individual, pledged assignment.
W. B. Doner Advertising (An optional case that may be developed in class - not in Course Pack)
Value Added Readings:
Read: The Future of Advertising: Implications for Marketing and Media,
Booz/Allen/Hamilton www.boozallen.com
Read: Marketing in a Post-TiVo World, McKinsey Quarterly www.mckinseyquarterly.com
44
Read: Left Behind, the Clunky TV Remote, WSJ, 10/26/2010. (Discusses the changes in the
way we consumer media and programming.)
Read: The Most Powerful Manipulative Messages are Hiding in Plain Sight, John A.
Bargh, The Chronicle of Higher Education, 1/29/1999. (Examines advertising manipulation,
subliminal advertising, and priming. Use Google or factiva to locate the article. May be difficult to find the
article.)
Topic: M-13, Managing the Marketing Function - Advertising & Corporate Communication,
continued (Kehoe)
Assignments: Please see M-12 above for assignments.
Activity: We will continue our discussion of advertising and corporate communication.
What are the primary obstacles to benefitting from feedback? How do you handle
this for yourself?
What do you perceive as your personal strengths? How might you get feedback
from others to confirm or disconfirm your own perceptions of your strengths?
What one or two implications does the idea of playing to your strengths hold for
you as you think about next steps in your careers?
Assignment: CASE 11-1 Revitalizing Dell Memo DUE Tuesday, November 20th
This is a small team assignment. You may work with 1 or 2 classmates.
Topic: M-15, Marketing (Kehoe)
Activities: The activity planned for this class session is to catch up on any materials remaining
from prior classes.
Interdisciplinary ICE Project: If time is available, ICE Groups will work in this class session
on the IIP. Professor Kehoe will be available in class for consultation concerning the project.
Read: Winning in Turbulence: Price for Today and Tomorrow, Bain & Company
Read: Alcoa Pinched by Low Prices, Wall Street Journal, 7/10/2012, B2.
46
Interdisciplinary ICE Project: How does pricing strategy relate to your project? What about an
overall marketing strategy? For example, what is the proposed marketing strategy for your
projects roll-out; that is, will you recommend your project be placed in all areas, placed only in
a particular region, placed in several regions, or placed only in a few test areas? Explain why you
elected a particular roll-out strategy; that is, justify your roll-out strategy. What is your
segmentation and positioning strategy? What is your the advertising, communication, public
relations strategy? And, as asked above, what is your pricing strategy, if pricing is appropriate for
your project? Critically examine all of these strategic decision areas.
Read: Ethics & Social Responsibility in Marketing, Chapter 4 beginning on page 209 in the Marketing text
Read: James Bandler with Doris Burke, Can Alcoa Fight off the Feds? Fortune, 8/13/2102
Read: Ashby Jones and Nathan Koppel, Ethical Lapses Felled Long List of Company Executives, Wall Street
Journal, 8/7/2010
Read: Richard Alsop, Right and Wrong: Can Business Schools Teach Students to Be Virtuous? Wall Street
Journal, 9/17/2003
Review your OB reading from earlier in the semester, How (un)Ethical are you? and review the in-class case,
A Matter of Ethics
Discussion: What makes up corporate, rather than personal, ethics? Where do the two merge?
What examples of corporate ethics or lack of ethics has been in the news in the past year? How,
and by whom, are corporate ethics defined? What lessons are learned from the assigned reading
listed above?
47
December 3, Monday
Topic: Communication - Handling Q&A with Your Presentation (Pentz)
Discussion and/or Activities:
What have been your best practices in the past for handling Q&A?
How might you prepare support materials in order to answer questions fully?
Review: Final presentation slide design; having the last word after Q&A.
December 4, Tuesday
Topic: Finance 25 -Review & Recap
NOTE: Well pick finance right up where we leave off starting in January 2013 at the
beginning of COMM 3040 !!! You will want to review over break.
Topic: M-23, Marketing - Marketing Review (Kehoe)
Assignment: Review of marketing topics in preparation for the final examination.
Discussion and/or Activities: Please bring your semesters notes to class. We will review
marketing topics in preparation for the ICE final examination.
IIP: Lets try to make time available today for ICE Groups to work in class on developing their
IIP presentation. Professors Kehoe will be available in class for consultation concerning the final
presentation.
December 5, Wednesday
ICE Project Presentations: Attendance is required at all presentations.
49
December 6, Thursday
ICE Project Presentations: Attendance is required at all presentations.
50