Toronto City Council: Gardiner East Debate

Vote/Support PROJECTION
Based on public statements/voting history. Subject to change. And then change again. For novelty purposes only.
Got a tip or correction?
Email matt.elliott@metronews.ca or get me at @GraphicMatt.
2015-06-10

Member of Council

John Tory
01
Mayor of Toronto

Team Tory
Percentage

Notes

Dec 2014 - Apr 2015

PROJECTION
Maintain/Modify

100.00% Publicly stated his support

Maintain/Modify

100.00% Support for Maintain/Modify here: http://carmichaelgreb.com/can-

Unknown

100.00% No definitive statement.

Maintain/Modify

100.00% Not 100% confirmed but supported maintaining Leslie stub in

Denzil Minnan-Wong
05
Ward 34 Don Valley East

Maintain/Modify

100.00% 100% Maintain/Modify. Supported removing east-of-DVP spur in

Frances Nunziata
06
Ward 11 York South-Weston

Maintain/Modify

100.00% No public statement, but very likely to vote with mayor. Supported

Jaye Robinson
07
Ward 25 Don Valley West

Unknown

100.00% No definitive statement.

02

Christin Carmichael Greb

Ward 16 Eglinton-Lawrence

Preferred option for

Gardiner Expressway
between Jarvis St. and
Don Valley Parkway

Stephen Holyday
03
Ward 3 Etobicoke Centre
04

Norman Kelly
Ward 40 Scarborough-Agincourt

Gary Crawford

toronto-afford-to-remove-the-gardiner-expressway-east/

1999. Likely Maintain/Modify.

1999.

removing east-of-DVP spur in 1999.

Maintain/Modify

93.75% Statement isn't definitive, but reads like Maintain/Modify support:

Cesar Palacio
Ward 17 Davenport

Maintain/Modify

http://www.councillorcrawford.ca/councillor-crawford-response-ongardiner-options/2015/04/20
93.75% No public statement, but very likely to vote with mayor.

David Shiner

Maintain/Modify

92.31% No public statement, but very likely to vote with mayor. Supported the

08 Ward 36 Scarborough Southwest

09

13

John Campbell
Ward 4 Etobicoke Centre

Unknown

Spadina Expressway growing up. Supported removing east-of-DVP

spur in 1999.
91.67% No public statement, likely to vote with mayor or maybe not.
Supported replacing the Gardiner with public garden in 2010 mayoral
campaign. Supported removing east-of-DVP spur in 1999.
91.67% Has talked about tolling non-residents to pay for Maintain/Modify
option. Unclear if he'd support Hybrid cost without tolls. Still, a likely
Maintain/Modify vote.
87.50% Wildcard. Has also talked about road tolls.

14

Raymond Cho
Ward 42 Scarborough-Rouge River

Unknown

87.50% No public statement. Supported removing east-of-DVP spur in

Maintain/Modify

86.67% No public statement, but very likely to vote with mayor.

10 Ward 24 Willowdale

Giorgio Mammoliti

Maintain/Modify

11 Ward 7 York West

James Pasternak

Maintain/Modify

12 Ward 10 York Centre

Jon Burnside
15
Ward 26 Don Valley West

1999.

16

Jim Karygiannis
Ward 39 Scarborough-Agincourt

Maintain/Modify

86.67% Wildcard, but likely to vote with mayor.

17

Vincent Crisanti
Ward 1 Etobicoke North

Maintain/Modify

85.71% No public statement, but very likely to vote with mayor.

18

Ron Moeser
Ward 44 Scarborough East

Unknown

85.71% No public statement. Asked about ramifications of deferral at PWIC.

19

Rob Ford
Ward 2 Etobicoke North

Maintain/Modify

81.82% Bit of a wildcard, but steadfast in belief that Gardiner must stay up.

20

Mark Grimes
Ward 6 Etobicoke-Lakeshore

Maintain/Modify

81.25% No public statement, but very likely to vote with mayor.

21

Josh Matlow
Ward 22 St. Paul's

Unknown

81.25% Undecided.

22

Josh Colle
Ward 15 Eglinton-Lawrence

Maintain/Modify

80.00% No public statement, but very likely to vote with mayor.

23

Justin Di Ciano
Ward 5 Etobicoke-Lakeshore

Unknown

80.00% Has also mused about road tolls to pay for maintaining, but no

Maintain/Modify

80.00% No public statement, but very likely to vote with mayor.

Frank Di Giorgio
24
Ward 12 York South-Weston

definitive statement

25

Michelle Berardinetti
Ward 35 Scarborough Southwest

Maintain/Modify

76.92% No public statement, but very likely to vote with mayor.

26

Michael Thompson
Ward 37 Scarborough Centre

Unknown

76.92% No public statement.

27

Paul Ainslie
Ward 43 Scarborough East

Boulevard

68.75% Not definitive, but tweets seem to lean heavily toward Boulevard e.g.:

Glenn De Baeremaeker
28 Ward 38 Scarborough Centre

Unknown

68.75% Seems to argue he'd only support Hybrid if paid for with tolls here:

29

Ana Bailo
Ward 18 Davenport

Unknown

John Filion

Unknown

https://twitter.com/cllrainslie/status/595755399208370176

http://www.thestar.com/news/city_hall/2015/04/26/battle-shaping-upover-east-gardiner-options.html
60.00% Seems undecided. Running a survey here:
http://www.anabailao.com/tags/gardiner_east

53.33% Seems undecided. Running a survey here:

http://survey.constantcontact.com/survey/a07eb1pw6pji9ymsj2o/start
; Supported removing east-of-DVP spur in 1999.
53.33% Seems undecided: https://chinlee41.wordpress.com/tag/gardinerexpressway/

30 Ward 23 Willowdale
31

Chin Lee
Ward 41 Scarborough-Rouge River

Unknown

32

Mary-Margaret McMahon
Ward 32 Beaches-East York

Unknown

50.00% Publicly stated she leans toward Boulevard.

33

Shelley Carroll
Ward 33 Don Valley East

Boulevard

43.75% Publicly stated she supports Boulevard.

34

Anthony Perruzza
Ward 8 York-West

Unknown

42.86% Wildcard.

35

Joe Mihevc
Ward 21 St. Paul's

Boulevard

40.00% Publicly stated he supports Boulevard. Supported removing east-of-

Pam McConnell
36
Ward 28 Toronto Centre-Rosedale

Boulevard

37.50% Supports Boulevard. Supported removing east-of-DVP spur in

Maria Augimeri
37
Ward 9 York Centre

Unknown

33.33% Leans toward Boulevard, but undecided.Supported removing east-

Mary Fragedakis
38
Ward 29 Toronto-Danforth

Unknown

33.33% More likely to support Boulevard.

DVP spur in 1999.

1999.

of-DVP spur in 1999.

39

Sarah Doucette
Ward 13 Parkdale-High Park

Boulevard

31.25% Supports Boulevard. http://www.ward13.ca

40

Kristyn Wong-Tam
Ward 27 Toronto Centre-Rosedale

Boulevard

21.43% Supports Boulevard.

41

Mike Layton
Ward 19 Trinity-Spadina

Boulevard

20.00% Supports Boulevard.

42

Paula Fletcher
Ward 30 Toronto-Danforth

Boulevard

18.75% Supports Boulevard.

43

Joe Cressy
Ward 20 Trinity-Spadina

Boulevard

13.33% Supports Boulevard.

44

Janet Davis
Ward 31 Beaches-East York

Boulevard

12.50% Supports Boulevard.

45

Gord Perks
Ward 14 Parkdale-High Park

Boulevard

12.50% Supports Boulevard.

Projected Result
Total Maintain/Modify
Total Boulevard
Total Unknown

Maintain/Modify
18
11
16

Version 2: May 27, 2015