p**

et ]
Y 2012
]*
!gzZ]Zg :

Z6,
Y/Z eZZ eZgpWz6,:

'

mSZ0*
,
s M ^kXZ :
]
L

y 0*
D !*
M xsZ D~ pZ 8 1
051D8438391D 3 :
051D8438390 :

x Z

ips@ips.net.pk

y
c
~ Z
tgzu
-

vZyZ :
!*
M xsZ Di
+R,:
9zg 250&D :

ISBN

978-969-448-103-3

001Y 4
Zgp
]!*
gzZ]ZgD
Y 2012 m,
SZ0*
s W^kXZ : !*
WxsZ
m 112
]z}pD
Z e Z D 1
Z e Z6,
Y/ D II
yZ D III

X @*
Z
Z,jwg Z: Z Zi Mam,
SZ0*
s M ^kXZ
X 7~gzt Z{gZ Z]K7~[

]!*
gzZ]Zg
ZgpWz6,
ZZ e
Z6,
Y/Z e

!*
WxsZ D m,
SZ0*
s W^kXZ


z
5

g{

sg

ZgpWz6,

sZ

23

ZgpWz6,

Zt zt (~

37

ZZ e

65

ZZ e

{6,
[

89

Z6,
Y/Z e

q
-Z6,
yZdC1 @

w Z
m,
SZ0*
s W^kXZ} D y 0*
s WM : ZgpWz6,

!*
WxsZ
,
k
!*
WxsZ ;gE- sZ Z ZeZgzZ *Z . :
$E
!*
WxsZ
0G
LC
L

ZZ e

sZ^kXZR,
hZ a^g sZg ^
,Zzi
+Z :

Z6,
Y/Z e

7 Cze
{ OE

sg

sg
@*
[ | 7,] gzZ p
/Z
ag iW
~h R,
g !*
(Zt X @*
/3 Z q
-Z xi~ yZy
v Z ~ qzq z Zz% e8
-gZaI8
-Zg e
!*
^~
X CkC
LZ F,
{ c*
imX
0Q] Z ~ f Vzg iW
X @*
/Zz **
x igzZ W**
Z kZgzZ e
$sx
9
L o yZygzZ qL Zg C

z!*
|kZ +
$Y ~uz
X
M
h
a q
-ZC


, ZgQX C ]gz
M F,
S
X CY| (
,
{ c*
iZ Zg>g /~, Z
Za
M F,
Vzg 6 ~ m,
S Z 0*
s W^k XZ
gzZ ] !*
z aKZ >~XX
CY g m
F, zBVzg
[ Z
wZb!*
~ VByZX
DWBViW6,] Z x
X @*
Yy W'V!*

{6,
[ } CYW6,
k Q6%Um{] zZ
@*
X {)z] Zg~
C!Zjx 6,qm{
X
D] !*
gzZ] ZgF,
{ c*
ig"W
5

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

kZ6,Rz~% X F
F6,Vz Zzg VBP +Zk
,
i
Ta{ .Z F,WzZ [ Z7e
$ Z kZ @*

HHx Z
)
Z
$U*
"
_ Vzk
,
yZa g Vzg 6 yZX ;g Y c*
Zz
S X ;g Y H7~ i Z0
+ZWB+ zD
+ VWyZX
BDIZ OK[ ogzZo1%6,
q
M F,

kZX 4'q
-Z V- g Z Zz ZjkZ~VB Zz
~ eg Z~ KkZ 2 j{2gzZ Z a 7~ ^{
)i Z
X
b]Sh
+zYx6,
x ZugZ]V

g{

Y 2012ag J

sZ

OLsZ
ZgpWz6,
yZw ] ZgX @*
W~ z b gzZ D
g
C]
c*
D(Information)] t y ZgzZmCz[Z*Zzg6,
{@x/=yZ]
.z ~ T ) x Z ~ zg y.z xEyZX
k
b
*ZzZ ] wZQ
yZX @*
Y c*
VZ (

& gzZ
-: } f
J
w x Z`
Z kZgzZ ] X
D Y
QX
DW,O kZ {zgzZ CVy
KZJ
-UC
0
+
igzZ RgzZ
0*
._ yZgzZ ])b)]**
kZ z bz ]c*
Z
X
UZ
tX Lg ~g YCZg ZZ~0
+
igzZ
~g ~ X
H ~ e
$ZzggzZ d
$ V Z
ggzZ v gz +Zq q
-Z V; V p
,q
vZ |V h
I +X )J
-hl h {zX 7~
~ T

Zg7 t ~ kZ
z @*
wEZ \vZ e
$Z@ ~
C
gzZ]}im} V
KZ}uzm}vZm}
/

%m{q
-ZBB yYgzZ lg ~xsZX @*

t
] !*
t g0
+Z sZ X l h
/
%tgzZ ZZ a

rgwVzi !*
gzZVN*
akZgzZz Z Z (,kZt
7}
7

] !*
gz Z] ZgD

h(Value Framework)J e g ZZ {zgzZ r zw kZp

X **
cg yZgzZ bx ZuV@~g ~zgho ng ZhyT
 U X
U Z &i Z
Cx] !*
t D
yZX 'Y w] {z u~g C
gzZ~ [y
*Zz 2Z }g Q Z m yZgzZ : yZ~ + Y (facts)
X
D 0*
zy.zxEx gzZ
x*
*tX
C y.zxEgzZ D ] ~ c*
^D% Zuz
yZgzZ
Kc*
g \ W
q\W] 
]!*
kZ
o1%7Z
Wt \ W (Relationships)Zj c*
]
X J e~gYYq
-Z

Z% kZ X (Applied Research) :Z UZ
2Z yZ 2Z *ZzZ mkZBD x D]
X YqyZgzZE

:t~ C
(Paradigm)aVD! fgzZsZ
p q }c*
} q
-ZgzZ
rg ww x {~ ^] D
*ZwZ kZX
DA
$%~ ^Do1%q
-Z] \ WZ
#
d
$g ZZZ
+\WV
D W+
$Y VUe
$ Z kZgzZg {],Z
@*
qz **
7,
6,xE W,
Z g ZZ DgzZ @*
Y qzg Zq
-Z ]c*
gzZ a
mYgzZ
KZQ c*
~ }g !*
mC c*
~ }g !*
m8{z {Zp
aVc*
%VD!fgzZ}g VX ,: c*
,t Z D ~}g !*
*ZzZ ] V Zj] zyZ
t t
{zgzZ @*
YWt
~
C~
8

sZ

{z c*
Z
Ug ZZgzZ ]c*
~ kZ
{ c*
i Z6,|
# ggzZ }kZ

){z

0t pbzg q
-ZgzZX
i Z0
+Zc*

D
: Z
Zx d
$m{ e
$K m kZ Zi W g ZZ
X YH:N kZ <

V X N~
Ct
~KV)gzZV
Y Zg f ~ b 8
CW V; [fIZ g ZZ
t I
yZ~ }gzZbyZ X
zg :yZ {zpX { c*
i ~ ]*
KZgzZ
b )gzZ zc)q
-Z {z bkZX: ?kZ
C
-Z (Relationship) V Zj

Dtt yX
D >X\I
q
7~ t p @*
6,mC(gzZ m} ] z
yZ
)t ~ { yZ X @*
g0
+Z VU VyZ g ZZgzZ Dd
$
}}D
tgzZ ,7Z Zg Zi{z
YtgzZ Yc*
g ZZ
Y c*
:zg :g ZZ
It >yX mc*
!Zj C(gzZ g
g ZZ

M
h6,\W)g fkZY { c*
ig T tX Y ~ qzZ
c*
~
g ) c*
kZt z H~ ~c*
^D
U x t ?
H0*
~ i Z0
+Z ~) c*
~ ?x) c*
x~
$tEyZ
70 Dg ZZgzZ]c*
0 G


Dt vp
M
h
E
$ x { q
sZ p D
C
) !*
V! gzZ ) X 0 G
-Z
6,gzc @*
YHlmggzZ }kZs: V;zY:
+'
h
X @*
YmkZgzZ CYqZ {z
6
bkZX @*
Y Hy @*
Y 7c*
Z t ( g ZZ RF,Wz kZ
t
9

] !*
gz Z] ZgD

X gzZU!{ c*
i (Paradigm of Knowledge) DVDV;V
Z~(, q
-Z~ yZ
t |X [fIZ uZg Z |kZ
g0
+Z ]
( B wV ]
/Z )
] !*
t  V yZ
*ZgzZ Hg Z kZ Hi Z0
+Zs: g Zg ZZgzZ ] c*

]L8X O%Zgq
-Z3,
z',dX C 7k
,
% kZgzZ H
6,m}g Z ]
~The Whale of Economics [KZ
A
$X **
VkZ
# }6,q
-Z] c*
gzZg ZZ OzgZgp
|g X
M
ht g 9gzZk
,
~g7 ]
X U:Z

t~xEY gzZxEA
{gHgzZ { * AX { c*
i +
M 7~2Z A

Y
X ]ZgzZ s ZZ 2Z yZ V;zp Cx ._VZ
x ]ZtgzZ
2Z LZkZ%Z s ZZ y Ax t {)z y!i
Zz  2Z Cz [Z @*
t U (Zq
-ZpX ;g7y
UC
gzZqC
@',}gzZ ~ ]
]!*
{z gzZ YY H7
Ds ZZgzZ m,
/

2Z V $
Y 7= i Z0
+Z q
-Z
g
CsZ 6 W6,ZX igzZ =yZ Z
-Z swVkZ X { c*
q
i }U q V;z mxEYJ
-V p
(observer) @

X
D Z Z wBgzZ~ * A
$
Y ~ ]!*

q Zz Y {@xZz {@xX
,q Zz (Observed) gzZ

wBC
W,Z }@x kZgzZ Y_ kZ Z \ W LZ
10

sZ

-Z [ ]^ Y ~g ^q
q
-Z6,
g wVX @*
7,
76,
[
7(Z ,g ^a \ W
/ZpY ug {z Y6,A m{

KZ X Y up (^) wB \W Y ug {z Y [ ]

gz2Z x * kZXN 0*
q~kZ,gA\W6,UYgzZ
t
~
Ct~ AgzZ ]] *
KZX
7{ b * A{zp
~ ZgzZ @*
4 VjZgzZ ]c*
t ( d
$g ZZ p ZX
{z x {T V;zX 7Z (Motivation)q
-~ * A
zz q
-gzZ q Z q
-Z q
-~zu
KZp}x ._ Z
X
D Yw$
+!*
bggzZ
-Z :
U &

t {z
D Wt ]  c !*
q
zgq
c*
ggzZ X **
D UZgzZ^c*
~ DZuz w]

g} Z { c*
iD:Z~Z8 WX a%$
+0*
gzZ ~
Y t X $
7{u\WLZ ~
C0*
:Z
t |p
t X @*
7,**

{ kZ p,: n{ c*
i kZ

X x Zg %kZ zb
~gz

/ZzX ,
ki
q {zce**
t \ W U ZgzZ q
-Z ~ e
7+ F,
{ i @*
kZ Vgx \ W~ yZygzZTD W {q


HW[ c(Z ] gzZD` WX ~gz'YZgzZ **
{ W g
zz ,
MZgzZR,
V [ ZX
H **
q Z Dx0 q
4$ Wq
Za
[
7\W6,+hR,
{z7lOG
t
11

] !*
gz Z] ZgD

]
gP ~ Vzq
gzZ i W~(, q
-Zt
z

X **
[ NZ
} { 7 CI [Z
Zg

[NZ

X g ZZa[NZX
H[NZ ~D[
7 [ Z
~}g !*
qJ
-Z
# X Y ZhgqgzZ Y 1q
Lgt
V~(,
\ WX 6,
Z',c*
YZ
gkZ\ W
:1Z\W
~
Cz q
-Z i Z kZ Vgx \ W~ yZyTa kZX
M
h
ZbTN Y~f\WbhZ {z
B| 7,bkZ\ W
VU ZkZ g ZZ kZ g ZzuDmLZ \ W
/ZX @*
YH
7X ~[ NZgzZD\WQ N Y%ZzbhZ }p ZgzZ
~
/
% [ \ WX g 7~gza \W 7,/ V1 5gzZ g
&0 G
/G
$E
nTgzZ  Zhz6,kZ
Hc*
CZg iH G
gzZw ~
/
%y*
V Zzpgx~yZykZgzZ x ui *
*tpXw ~kZce\Wq
\W X @*
YzZd kZ '',: [NZ ~ kZ {z
ce
HgzZ
g { e H\ W
B \ WQkZ  B: {z
T e
~A [X CW7zc~%kZp x t X 7
; `ZgzZce**
Z Wz~}g !*
D Zg f Xce **
I zc
tY HwEZ HY Hg Y ~ F,
pXce **
%Zz
X6,
[
7ZzCZt \W
/ZXce**
ZzCZt \W
12

sZ

\Wx CZ6,ggzZnY;ggzgT x ZX7\WQ

\ W6,g ZzpX N*
ggzZ Y Z (, x X YZ Z gt
~kZ
Zg f Ha]yZ
]tt }
ce **
t
/Z ?qHgzZ 9qH
g {e 6,q\W ? Hwg+F,

{ i @*
D
kZgzZ kZ t \ W~x }g7 kZ
,q x t
gZ\W bT
g \W Zaw
X
B
bgwKi gzZ
~O 8

Zz+
0i

kZVgx ~T\W
tV\W{gtZ
~
C6,xsZ
t h
+'
X , x Zux LZ x Z}g7
GLG

dZ1Z~ekZXgt \ W ~
CxsZ
@*
B| 7,
r
# ?bZ X [ Y ~(, yWZ L L{;@*
~z
{
a.yW
~zg Z yW
',
+L Lk& ZZ}Z **
D
gzZ yWZsg L L
3gzZ f N
,_yZ bhZB[: )E
/Z\ WX

0
+
i ~g  YgU!q
-Zax ~C
\W N FLZ
tsZ L Lq
-Z ~ yZ
g ~uz &z {z kZ X Wx \W
B| 7, gZ \W
/Z
[ Z +Z q
-Z {z A
$% ~ ]
~ kzg ]c*
gzZ sZ \W{zvZ

yZ BgzZ
[y WC
]hX ]hL L[ ~z**
kZX }
fbzggzZ+ p 6,]h- bt V{0
+Zp **
gzZ
d{ c*
i Zg f ]L L[gzZq
-Z ~z**
X q~
C~(,ad
13

] !*
gz Z] ZgD

X ~gzgzZaV Zz x z d[t p 6,]

z kZ6,gm{X Z ~ KkZ #
Z ] L L (**

~DgzZ ,v0*
a QX @*
YWt y
KZuZg7 ] Vz
D~kZ q {aV Zzpg tzf m{gzZ t Zp

}pg e &~ kZ **
X
] 5 kZgzZ kz xZ
Xz Z Z(,kZ~ZsZp
~}g !*
VUP0
+
iZ
$E
{z ~z**

{gtZaVzg 6 q0 G
sZ
6,k Q Di Wc ZsZg {g Z Z VrZ B| 7,gzk
,

X
=TgzZ ~ zg Z {f Z (,
+ E y!*
i !
"7,ZsZXce _ 9
L okZ ]gzgzZ
T
t q
-Z
Z ,qz~KkZX N f CZ~}g !*
6,gm{
t ?
H]c*
Z@ z x Z sZ ~}g !*
qkZ
gx \W6,q
x V1h
+]
.6,]yZgzZ V1 }Z <
L z yW
\W
9<V Zzx Dg<Luq Z ~uz Y
X ~gzui Z **
q
bC
nX ~ y!*
i ~ m,ZgzZ zg Z Zh
+]
.gzZ *~ ekZ
\WgzZ $
e
$Z@ 6,ZC
\ W 6,wCzM c*
R~
CX @*
Y Z
~gzakZ<Lu6,Rz
Gc*
6,
gp
M
hVZ {Z
+ kZ
myZ DLuBB ]c*
Z@ myZ**
x {WVX

x Z Z x Z Xn xi igzZ o ^Z b)~ zg <LugzZ
14

sZ

Hx Z
Z F~ * ` WX Z ~ekZx vZ z {

gzZ ?

&x { i @*
Xf LE
jvZ] Z egzZ ~zZ-)~X
(Points of ] ~
CzV x Zz x ~ Z 8 W

Cc*
gzZ R Z xsZ
t q
-Z Xce**
%Zz bhZ reference)
GL!ZgzZ y 0*
LZ c*
~g Z p 0
:Zuz X **
N ~
/
% CZ g0
+Z 0*
g ZZ
tp~g ZpX 7G * p~g ZpX **

C g Z6,bz
yZgzZ N Vzq J
-yZ N VZ {Z
+ yZX V: ` ZVzuz \W


CZ \W1ngzZ 0
+
iQ c*
~n Cg {z e X ,wEZ Vzq
qakZgzZ}:kZqX
C\ W
]
V` ZVzuz\W
/ZXk0*
\W{zce~k, \Wp
yZ VJ
-V


tpq
-Z ^] o ]
X M
h7 ^] o
Tce
A & {z~
t p Y ] KZ J
G$
E
GG33 pX } e
(Self Sufficiency)
$ZgzZ LZ
Y ~g Z p X ~gz(Self Reliance) ~g Z pp 7e
DZ~ kZ ._ ]c*
gzgzZ ]qgzZgg Z0
+Y q
-Zt 7g
X ~gzxg

Z~A
&

E
+G
B
{
O
ykZ ~g {],
Z LZ LZ n
pgt ] ~
C

+Z`
Z
z bgd , :9z6, V1s~ekZgzZ Za
kZX C

~ bg d+ F,
+]
h
.YN ] KZ_
Xce**
VZ {Z
+,
MZ {z
15

] !*
gz Z] ZgD

N ] KZa kZ b x Zu\ Wx 
~Vs Y A
$B **
hzZ CZkZ B~g 6,
zZ LZx kZ
t | (,
H r Z6,{g Z
/sgzZ 1 y Wx \W
/ZX
M
hqCZ\W
x ~g
D ~z**
W~Z
# X Y07x kZ
7%~g kZXg ~x ;]Zpz ] ]_z
$
OZ Z Za Zg0
+Z \ WgT~ x X 7q tY
'iz0
+Zx \WZ Z
/ZgzZiz0
+Z x \ WgzZ (,
p~a y*q
-ZX W7u\ W%K lVzq 5$Q
V;
@*
kZt=Z
# gzZV@*
lVzqVLgVZ
/
uy x**

@*
Y X V q~ kZ
q ,q ]gz ~
g S. T. Coleridge
_ ~ kZ {z 7@*
iZ q
-Z
~ygzZ W~r kZ~Dt

g ZkZ0y{D
t0LZp
X c*
v6,kZ
~ w }p t (
D W

 q hZ Zg X Dg yZ c*

wD Z
X @*
~ ]gk
,
g Z kZQ g0
+Z,\ W{z CY
Xcexgt Ut~
7\Wq  X ,:
\ WLZ
Z ] !*
t
~', 'Y:q X ,IkZX 7B p~ tkZ CW
X)**
g Z \W **
ug Z D
+ kZgzZ ]!*
~',**
: s Z Z kZ 7]!*
7q x C
akZX Y7x C
{z
ce 'y
KZ
16

sZ

{z kZ Xce gzZ Z Y Hx  p
V xk!*
Y D@',V; }g
t {z -~ V; [fIZ q q
-Z
W6,kZ t Z] Z c*

Z xL L ~q q
-Z *Z
/Z
@*
tn
} (,

~ ~ [fp &Q KZ *Z
8Zg c*
**

Z',
[p
D7~g
q {zLZQ
]Wz6,} (,
t X
D 4Z~ zg kZ
DwJ lp Z {z CW
~g Z~ , y
KZ kZ Xz Z(, kZ ~ gzZ Z
t UkZX CZa vgzgzZ ~gzZ @*
Za yi Z gzZ/_
.
X ]gzpg

j
~
Cp qWz q
-Zp]Z &
+t mg T J
-V
ZuzgzZ (Inductive Method)iZ`Zq
-ZX
g T } (,
z6,
g
(Deductive Method)iY Z 5Z

X **
Z6, g Z | / p /KZi Z`Z
V1 AZ 4 Z (,q
-Z ~g ikZa X x{ c*
igzZ **
Z6,{ c*
iiYZ 5Z
DF,
',kZ6,
g~kZ CYqq
-Z)g f F,
',
DV;z
;g
aVZXi~!*
tX @*
YH~VgDc*
ib)i
kZQgzZ N q
-Z {z
t S VE**
- ~ zg
~kZ @*
YHg, UT
tTg Z6,
gwVX N YwZ
q
-ZgzZq
-Z ~q
-Z
/Z
w kZX, gzZLOg
{zgzZ
ZUz
tce
8
z{ c*
ik
HMh Z kZq
-Zce
8q
-Z
zAY
17

] !*
gz Z] ZgD

yZizZZ , qz ~
H7/kZ LkZpX w+Z [

Y
4G
5X 7c*
5G
gzN*
kZ H G
@*
t

z~ yZ
V@N V
]Zz) CMc*
g 7t
{z~ yZ
Zx 9yZizZ Zz Y6,#
Os W
ImI
H1 7~ we Tg Z y L
t zz kZ X @*

q
t ]!*
NX
g
7~gz X i[q
-ZiYZ 5Z
$ZVgX C7V7 ZVZ]ggzZ%
t Tg Z

/YL !7E
$ZyZ6,
gik QLpVc*
z k QX
D
D }@xgzZ"c*
Wp
g {@xgzZ/ y
KZ
Dx2Z gzZZ *ZzwZ TYc*
W ~^+Z q
Y Z`Z ~g i b VrZ
)**
g V t X : Ut
G

&
5. gY Z`Z 7Y Z`Z s ` Z 5ZgzZ HZ
Zg Z
`
# ~[fD ` Z 5Z LG

"
5E
% ix yZgzZ EG
m{c*
W[zZ 5~ V Y Z`Z VMW,
ZLG

Laws of

HE B; Z (,~ T) zg ~ ,z19gzZ , z18 g

c*
=
wC
T c*
* ,@*
2Z gzZCz[Z * ~g7( Motion
J
"
5Z
9
F
# X c*
WgZg F6,

CZ $
Y Zzc*
w~uz G

0;XE

HwZ kZpZyZ Z (,{z Hy t {

!*
Z
Fx
5J"
V! ZZ~ Zz
kZ @*
0*
7f Z}
.~x }g v~ F
 ft6, jZ`ZOX @*
7kC]gz =
w
X YZ 5ZgzZ Z`Z
Vztjszc` Wc*
0*
zg ~ b $
a
KZ ~ jYZ 5Z
Dc*
] q )g fkzgzZ $
Zz
18

sZ

HHwEZ6,e } (,jYZ 5Z ~} V; V X $

6,g wVX
HHwEZ jYZ 5Z s
7
g ]!*
tp
q
-Z
/Z ( iYZ 5Z
 ) k

t p( b Z 4}) yIZ
O o ^Z m{ q
-Z X Y Y c*
s k ;g Y
])
KZgzZ/
KZ ~
# qz ]gz n
pgt rgzZ <Lu
YZ 5ZgzZ Z`Z 7iYZ 5Z sV; }g ZX Y Y c*
6,
C
g0
+Z A~ i W~ [fX
g 6,g g i~
CVz
X ~ zZ ~xEY~ ~,z19p
HHwEZ { c*
iiZ`Z
s bxEAgzZwo

Ht Z
# c*
W{z
zq
-Z
$E
X 0 G
x {q
-Ztpt :Z yZ
a *ZzZ 
]gz
_ Z (,

a]~ 6,

C jZ`Z%]c*
zg ZZ
g ] CZg Z Z ~Classicism kZ X yZd Y 1929
:%YgzZ q
-Z x ~g ZtugzZ Zi W 8{ x4,
X c*
W~ z
~rgzZg ZVgzZ ~ 7,[q
-Z6,kZQ ` WX c*
WZg
X g Y]!*


jYZ 5ZgzZ Z`Z6,g~
Cp
g ih
+'

t g iYZ 5Z6,
gm{
VztX @*
YH
Zc*
vZ k0*
}g
akZX ~gz aV p Z a
/KW y Z p 6,|
CT y q
-Z
Y : ]g Z
/ZX ~ g6,t WzZgzZ% V V
G
4]g zZ u 0*
gzZ x Z sq
-Z zmvZ -wg
LE
W

YY
19

] !*
gz Z] ZgD

t |X
(Methodology) g iq
-Z {zBB
g
~ ] 5gzZ }g Z ZgzZ 2Z g ZZ Z
+u 0*
yW


E
{zBBkZp @*
2J
- **
q]g gzZ **
B; g }O !
yZ g @*
VKgzZ"7,]iq
-Z g[|Zq
-Z W
<
L nX @*
2iI \WLZp% $ wZziz `z
CX g Z
/0
+
i{g~XI~} zu{zsq
-Z~<
L

Bp $
0b H5VUqzggzZ Z0
+
iZ ~ ZZ

Hc*

~ ]5gzZ b)6 ] c*
zg ZZ
t {zgzZ c*
g iq
-Z <
L
-ZtVX t
q
H m}gzZmg ZZ~yZgzZ
M
hY J
-V7Z
Y H_<
L UkZ
/ZX YY H Z]
.yZ V ?

k~}uz
V 6,T g i{z X M (Methodology)g i*!*
-Z
q
t~g
$u VrZ Z
# X * 5!*
-Z~ yZy gzZ
q
]Z W,ZgzZ ] yZ Vk1 ~ a
VrZ  ` gzZ Zz n%C

J 7,
kZ **
pp ZyW


Hc*
CtyZZ
# X 1w` kZgzZ Hl
~ kZ a g zg t6 zg zg "
$a
t sX 7,

C ~d~g7 q
-Z bkZO **
Y c*
5]Zg f gzZ ~0
+e
x Vzq bkZOX :
L BZ'D 7,zgi
]!*
0
C
+
i VrZ Zc6,T g i{z gzZ BV q
-q
-Z xE
$Z@ yW
e

t yZd )Z $
+X , x Zu] }
.Vc*
~
g iq
-Z<
L gzZ yW
p Z"gzZnZ~}g !*

Xcegt X
, ZUtX
wy

20

sZ

E
t] !*
~
C
0kZ m]g 'ZgzZk
,
E
L J
-V

E
,
k
E
L

~
C~
A & kZ 7q ~t X C C
y
KZ wg !*
g !*


X $
0*
F,

A & , gzZ\W
/Zp @*
{ \vZz
\W D dZ0
+
i \ W m \vZX=g f Kq
-Z

~gz '] !*
tpX
A &kZ ZzgzZ ~g Z z
p Z ._] x **
[ ZY @*
7,
OakZX 7yW
p Z gzZ ]
/Z gzZ [ Z dZt
9~ p ZgzZ ]
/Z D g Z
@*

M F,~(,y
KZ~ pkZX Cq $
+~(,q
-Z {z V: o1%"Z
E
45J" ~(,yZizZnZgzZ }Wq
**

C
p
q E
-Z CZ kZ

G3H
-Z y!*
q
iX F, qt y
KZ *ZiZgzZ_X 7~gz
4k
,
KZX 4 Z (,
~Iy!*
i
)  CWG
g q 
,X p9p Z\ W
@*
wEZg !*
g !*
~ea
q ]g 'X
M
h4k
,
\ W gzZ DN ZC
LZ
8 W
yZ= X ] OZ CZg Z Z}uzgzZ CZ f KZq
-ZX
)g f z

( Y 2008',
Z 16)

21

X ( vZY

yZ ) YVzyZ~Z

 Z t zt (~

Zt zt (~
ZgpWz6,
7~0
+
iY q Z Z Contextc*
t (~x
: R
gzZ ( dm{ q
-Zk
,
kZy
s !*
gzZ yVQa y
KZX $
Y ~g Z
/
+Zt zt (akZX Ck?
[s:gzZ [i Z0
zzX Y}7x Zu i Z0
+ZZx CZ Zzx ~yZy
u 0*
W
c*
x Zux C n
pgt t ( LZ x Zm
CZ

g~}g !*
kZ +X [!*
Zg7 q
-Z wz4,
Z~K
[Zt @*
0Zm{kZ e
$Z@ {z yW
 7t pwz4,
[ Z
Z ~ ]q s$
+ t QgzZ  ~Kt (ZkZ
X YYHx gzZ]
q
-Z~ yZ q Z ,q a7~i Z0
+Z W,
]!*
KZ
#\ W
/ZX Hg b \WX  DwEZ y!*
i \Wt
kZgzZ0 kZRd#@',
kZ }W,
Z CZ] !*
\ W ,i Z0
+Z
z kZX CY| (, e

$ Z ]!*
\W Vt \ WgZ p
@gzZ D  Z Z(KZ VgzZ  t ( n&t }g
~X, ZUg " ~ * ` WpUq
-ZC
~yZX t (
t ( @gzZ @ D t ( X  D i Z0
+Z W,
Z6,}uz q
-Zt
23

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

t ZzgzZ b!*
gzZ o1%gzZ hZz [ zZ C gzZ Z ` W
~ LZg gzZ [i Z0
+ZVzq yZX Lg bZ
X Y7q!x
E
$ Z0 t (
-Z V Zz W6,Vz
q
CCc*
t 0G
Z kZ~ wqZzg Z] ]5
KZYce**

/
%gzZg"m
-Z
q
Cq
-Zg"q
-Za
C
k
,
c*
k
,
X 7bX y
KZX
X
/
%

$E
xgtgzZ Lg6,m kZ g"kZ J
-u ~(,g Z 0G


u N.gzZ ~ \WQ Y 1z J
-u Z\ WLZ
/ZpXce
~gz **
J (,
gzZ b zg {],
ZgzZ _ LZ a kZX g 7t
~
pg*g Vz #gzZ
zttzg igzZw Z~}g !*
kZX
p"Z \W
/ZX Y 3 Zgq
-ZaJ
-yZKyZ
] E
C
#
Z kZ vZYce '(Z \ WgzZ D BZ
L 8
Z0
+
iX ~gzyTgzZ
zaZq
-ZakZX c*
g Z
y
KZ
GLE
4]: **
:gzZ Y m
CZ
YzJ
-gzZ b `g {~V {gzZV
&\ Wq
: VY {z e =ggLE
-ZC
akZX Yg Z Zq
-Z

a kZ Yzg {],
Z \ W Y c*
`g {kZ
/ZX
-ZX ~gz 'kZX 7~gz IXce pgZg
q
X @*
7L !% @*
n%Z eX @*
tzg Z e q
-Ztzg Z
Z Z e **
g ~wkZgzZyYkZ **
X !%
A ] !*

Zg b!*
Xce **
#
ce ) J
-
Z X
24

 Z t zt (~

LZgzZgzZ
z\W7tpkZX e g N 5 ZgV5gzZ
$E
D7#V Zzpg0G
Z LZ \ W
/ZpX , :~)gzZ
Y~ WzgzZV]]!*
tC7 V\ WJ
-yZ

/Z # ? ~ 8
-g ? Hy%ZX o V
a kZX @*
**
LOg ._kZQ ~gz '
t ?
ug0
+ZkZ , qt D@c*
{z {Zp (Context)t ( \W
-Z g0
q
+Z ` Z'
kZ Xce g yi Z f CZ \ WpX  B
bg w
(,sgzZ b & Z C0*
W 7{gzZ ` Z'

y
KZ ]X @*
Za wZZ
:
HHybkZ~u 0*
yW
& q{zX @*
Y0\W
n e $] ^ u*] j $^e  ] n $ ] v] ji

DOPVkE

XZn u XZo $^* XZ ] n e

d ?+4 z nk Q~$
+?X 7V7 ~$
+gzZ n)
( X
H0
z ~{z~ 7,]zZTB}g v
6,
RzC
gzZ ~gzaq
-ZC
~ VJ
-
gzZ
A ]!*
Zg Z
X ~VZggzZ ~x d Z
0
+
i CWt |t Y ~:g @*
/Zt ( {

t\vZ y-X ]g LOgq

-Z~ gzZ F,
kZgzZ
Vz 4gzZ ]vgzZWN !*
N Z {z 3g
gJ
-$
+Z wi Z zggzZ ~
Cq
-ZtZgX Y
{z
HyV- wD Zy*ZX

25

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

iz%Z @*
wi Z ; g g { U
n
-;X1 Z ~
E
Zl

kZpU (gzZ Dp R
Z } Ug " kZ

7q Zz XUc*
t q Cc*
q
-Z ~tX Z { c*
iV U~
Z F,
gzZ ]~ 0
+
i VgzZ Y g Z +4 V6& y
KZX
]gzZ o zZQ x c*

{z}: kZ gzZ ]g
X @*
Yy'
6,
5 Zg
~}Lq
-Z
q x 0*
gzZ} 0*
-[ Z y 0*
J
x
gzZ ZZ ~~ V yZ YY H Z ~gzZ
wZ{zt?}g (Z c H{WtgzZgzZ ? ZZ H~X ~
wq]g ? Y Hg Z Zg ~ kZce 9 gzZce **
g6,T
X
!fQgzZ ]g uyZk
,
Z y j
jZ a y 0*~
( ]g @*
R
5Z' t X  q Z Z zgzZ Z
A Vz g @*
gzZBZ'~ T m(ZtgzZ g ZC
gzZ
'7(Z X  gg Z Zg Z CZ w V Z ~(, VzgzZ 
7tgzq
-Z g @*
gzZBZ'X  c*
'{Zptce
i Z0
+Z Vz yZ g @*
gzZBZ'a kZ n
pg w ] 
g ~ 0
+
i
{z:"Zz g @*
KZx gzZ# z qax q
-Z g @*
Xce **
7
, Z q
-Z h5~g $
+X Y xz z q LZ # kZ
GGB&
(zzce gt ]!*
kZEG4O i Z pX g ezgzZyJZ
26

 Z t zt (~

BZ' B: wzK+
$Y KZz~g yZN ZgzZy]Zb)
*
z kZp
/ZXg
/
% z{z q w~
CgzZ CZk
,
z,
H g @*
gzZ
CZgzZ yZdkZ#
Z yZtvZp ~
q~(,
tXcexgt }g XZ *BByZkZX } Z Zg Z
XZ V X  7]uz 5Z' c*
Cq
-Z sy |q
-Z
{0
+
i {z ]uz 5Z' c*
(C\WLZ VrZ Z
# t
kZ J
-uTgzZ Z
# @', kZgzZ  n {g 7] 
g p g
]z <
L w
gvZgzZ [ \vZg"R
gzZ Z Cc*
#
Z
%N} E
%N
(nt
z kZX ^z5 0
+
i ~]q} E
g ZLZ z!*
q ?
t ~ !*
WgzZ Z 5Z'bz ~ Zi W
Xce**
q~A kZgzZyiz"} (,
yg ZcgzW,ZgzZ
~ !*
WZ V ~* ~g7tN Zq
-Z~Kt (
[
/
%ZuzgzZ @*
WJ
-8
- gzZ Z Vz Z%
/
%q
-ZX 
/Z%} (,z
~ !*
WV Z VzgzZ Z ! fOX J
- kz&
+Z @~ Z
~
/
%q
-ZwqZ
rgw~
/
%q
-Zy 0*
~yZX D 0*
gZ

/
%
g Z x yZ D F,
Y (gzZ F,
bZwz ugzZ q w
vgzZ ,g (Z V0*
9  M
h Z Zg Z~
Cq
-Z
X N YKg Z2Z] ~
g
) Z VzgzZ * [ yZk
,
Z y j
jZ ~ V- Z ~}g
}g7kZyZ kZgzZZ8 W Zp~gzZqZ
kz&
+Z @BB kZX}x gzZg ] 9~}g !*

27

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

 J e d~ Y 1971 $
+X Y H:i Z0
+Z yZ D **
z',.5
[Zp Zg pyvw~~g ~
/Z%yZ~ !*
WV
X N W kZ)g f]Cc*
& (
w$
+uR
gzZ ( * t N+F, Z 0 t ( @
kZ c*
g]
z
H0]
%q
-Z  gt~ iq
-ZX ;g
YE
~(,apg !*
]
kZxL 58E~uzX YY3g
V6,` ZcLZ[Z g @*
 c*
J
-V V Zz
/',Z-gzZ
gzZ (Individualism)~Ie
$ ZZ[ZX h7^z~(,kZ[ZgzZ _
m ]!*
t 1X gl y
KZ gzZ gz (Capitalism) ~g Ztu
~! bh
+'
gzZ  $
+] q b~ V  B
bg
VX%Z q
-Z
z H~ ~p **
{ i Z0
+ZtX  gsp
E+G
t _ L g @*
X q d
$z g @*
~A wZziz `z
z| l,
e d
$


z LZ d
$
y**
-  CWt |
l0*
l0*
B Zxzg~ ~q
-ZgzZ ` ZcKZt~w
~gzZo zZ wg ZD
q
-ZkZp
@~wz xzgX
+]
h
.gzZV2c*
g Z ZbkZgzZ t Y~~, ,,gzZ}g
/
gzi Z
z ~ g @*
yZ  am{t vZ 6,V X Zg \gQwZziX 7k
,5
+o zZ6,
gL{z p ZwZzip
/Z
X x **
8{o zZ @*
ykZ 6U*
>
KgzZh
+Y Z
6,
i W~, Xgz ~p~(,
t Zzt~]q{
$
! fg ZC
d
D(~~,z19 @*
xBZ ei !*

28

 Z t zt (~

~ yZy

(gzZ ] Y ({z ~ ~ ,X g ~

+X g ]Z W,
Z} (,
y ZgzZ g <zZBB1g

YE
~g7 yZd R
tQX ~ qz]!*
wZzi[f Ug xL 58E
~% { c*
it [Z1g C ~ kZp ;g g0
+Z ~,
\WLZ\g- p
/ZV &t ~ HggzZ J 7, ~J
-VX [4Z
~ yZyC
u
(F,d
$
Q g !*
-ZgzZ ;g ~ {z
q
/5
wZzigz M%Z1 ;gg V 0*
B; aY KZ M%ZgzZ ;gZ
Z hg Z@ LZ {z ykZ Zg7 ]!*
kZgzZ 7 Y Z

OE
+
VM%Z VzgzZM%Z! ZgzZ }pg {0
+
ip~g Z Z',

/KZ {g !*
zVyZ[ZaM%ZttCZ Zp} Z { c*
i

W,
q
-Z \g- J
-] q
-Z ~
/Z% DQ
X 7e**
~
uX @*
{ i Z0
+Z g f(,zg- gzZ C
/Z e 6 g !*
w
~Z sgzZ: ZI DV0*
q }kggz { c*
i
~gz }g7 kZ
G
)V;z
/Z D~wk {W @*
kC(ZgzZ ;gx 6,i
L . 7
CQ]g p
/ZXg Z Z kZ D @*
7zgyZdzg0
+Z
{ c*
i ] %Z zg0
+Z } Cg p ;g Wt w

*gzZ u , Z Zg Z 9CZ *gzZ y 0*
/ZX M

hY 7!*
J
-
X Yw$
+
u ~,Zyzz Z
D Wt }g wZ gPax 6,R@gzZ
:sfzgq{z
g {],
Z LZ Og: zJ
- I KZ c*
LZ s\WLZ
29

(1

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

X , zykZ
, c _gzZ aKZgH]F,
KZ6,R@gzZ

(2

X ,w] ._kZgzZ
7N@\WLZL
]5gzZ pM
h7Z E
(3
GL.7: ZW **
]F,~g a kZ X 7i
4 @ i Z0
+Z
H7i Z0
+Z6,gq
-Z ~yZpe @gzZ K
M n!*
X YY
~X~sfe
$K~wVp 6,gm{

(4

U ;~* ~g7Oq
-Z yZ0
+{[ zZ r Z]
454Xe gt 0
G
X G

[Z zwZ
\W~ V=p@gzZ 5Z'Zz ~ w :wZ
? wy *
0

6,] !*
kZg Z kZpVLe9 gzZ V8 ~ w~ :[ Z
 t {z K y.6,J= q X  DXa
!- gzZ - q
-Z X CW7~ OZp x ~ y 0*
g vZ t \vZV]q a ZX V6&
g Z gvZ- gzZ DQOV]E ] u ]_iX V: k- L
V
rg hZs:v]~g0
+Z]q+ F,
+akZX c*
$
g Z
( )
zt ] ~ ekZXBu yZd kZV
rg ]gzZ x t
30

 Z t zt (~

X Dg ~g bg fzg]uZz
_ V Z KZ g Z j
+ZgzZ #d
$Z
# gz {z 0
+
i O$q
-Z
G-W!
-ZzmvZ -u 0*
q
g( ?W
vZ )vZ  w
gZgzZ
VV ZzyZZ~V?q Z<
?HD ts
]gq
-ZZ
# Wy {z! n Z}
.D 
+
$Y~uzgzZ
HZ eo J
-Vzg W
G
c*
1kZS 7{ ZgzZ }^J
-]|l E
L#

$ H ! t ( HDYWV;z
kZzmvZ -u 0*
gp! H !L F

zmvZ-\ W~g N ]ZzZuzX D yZ H

z
1Z **
) y
KZ gyZ F,
gzZ ~) ]gvZX {C
} ]g t
Kt \
W 0Zu~ ]qyZX 7ByQ ( Z&

& \ WX N WB; }g v;  g
/G
: Z9 HgzZ xH G
X ]
k- akZV e] qV]uZzztt T
~I| ~gztBBkZpX @*
7Za wZ % Z e4gzZ
y 0*
V &~6,gX 7
otzg
YZ
LX Y c*
CZ
aZgzZ Za ~VyZX **
F,
zgkZX u @*
w
**
Z
/
% z~g ~g gzZ Wi ~p , Z Z n
CZ
/ZX **
x
X ce
y*
!iX ,guyxg}g gzZu :wZ
7m{ $
+ Y Vz IZgzZ t
} ] yxg}g gzZ * ! fX
31

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

?h
M^7[fgzZyH D *
*[IZ yZ

x " _
.C(C
yX V4]q ~ [fvZ Y 0
yZ :[ Z
V;g7" _
.: Z0
]!*
t ~X 7] !*
tgzZg
Y
58E~uz
kZ]~ ! f V ZTgzZg gTxL E
y~ \g- X V zg ]Z W,
ZkZ Z 
g \vZa
: yZ6,] !*
p g ~ V&yZ D\g- gzZ Z Z
V 7(Z }i  t wg
z kZ pX ',Z',
sZ [f~ d
$
w~ z!*
kZp: Zf(,V
*gzZ uV8 gzt ~pX ;gN 7 Z R
c*
(B *
g gzZ =ga}uz q
-ZgzZ  U yzb!*
{ z Zyxg
 y~ uX ]gz~g ayZgzZ ]gzyZa}g
C
c*
{ i Z0
+Z J
- hz!{gG 0*
p 7D0 Z 9 yZgzZ
W,
O{zzz~p5Z'p e
$Z[Z~yF,
X @*
Y
y Z0
+{ Zg7 q
-Z ~VZ0
+{&#( 56) V;zX  g
g Z ~c*
( {zX  y~ VFv
X Z3gg Z
',
CZV V;zpn
pg7] { c*
i
$
Z Zg Z Z { c*
i CWg ZG 0*
{ c*
i
g * B u
kC] !*
t ~ 0V X $

) !*
e
$}uz q
-ZgzZ
E
E
3O!
V;zgzZg Z { c*
iX  {z V V ~ Z [p
/Z
uJ
-[Z: i+ZapDi Z0
+Z W,
Z6,
(zu
* ! fgzZ u6,b kZX g Z!*
x Cc*
!*
W0*
32

 Z t zt (~

gzZg X a,_pv\ W~ }g !*
kZ pX @*
Wt
Zz
X ,
kZB
ks ~/
c H Y]*
!t( { :wZ
M%Z/
Zt Zuz ?z t ( { *
c _ `g { t (
?wH B
ks ~/
c *
@,
k+
5 wZzi

:q
-Z ~
/c 7k
B s ~
/c |gt :[ Z
LgzZ x]Z W,Z LZ ~ * ._"gzZ 'LZM%Z Zg T
s ~
/cX YW: gzZ 0*
^7: t
/ZX Le **

~
/c z Z k
B uX Z ~g EZ M%Z k
B
t V|DRizZ Y +Zr Z Zg f ZZ Xz kZ k

B s
n zz q
-Z ~ { ~ k
B s ~
/cX =g f w Z 4Z
Y [t Y ]gzZ
# gzZ Y3g {0
+
i ]gzJ
-Z
# &
GL.7mt~Vz t ZgzZyj
V p gx **
i
jZ ;g WtC
X
kzg t {z
) !*
.6,a }]*
! p
z Z ~
3
9gzZ 7@W~g
/Z pN Y :Zz yj
jZ eM%ZgzZ
tXgg
/~]Z W,
Z$kZ~]g: D7g (Z V0*
^7{ c*
ik
B t!*
X ]Z W,
ZyZ b x W}g
GL.7 m zz q
} zu [ ZM%ZX m 7[x i
-Z kZX $

GL.7t gt~ !*
3Zzg7[xi
W7060~yZg W
~ t ZM%Z Zz x tp;g7]!*
Zzq
-ZC
Z~}g !*

g7 Z ~(,q
-ZyZdZzW~M%Z
zkZX ~yj
jZgzZ ;gx **
33

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

yZdkZM%Zt{i Z0
+Z Z~}g !*
]qJ
-[ ZX
p gzZ 7 ] Z W,
Z ( 7 {zX [ 7 ~g p
M%ZgzZ V W,O kZ gzZ X 7 gz gzZ ~ OZ
{W ;@ M%Zt aKZ ~X,W,Oci7 gzZ @
X } 7,6,k
B s ~
/c
zk Q W,
Z ~ kZX W,
O {~wk
si Zz 0
+F,
{ i @*
{i Z0
+Z kZ ;g Y c*
{ i Z0
+Z ] YZy
Z k
B kZ
H
4]Z
.H
(The Three Trillion Dollar War) [ (Joseph Stiglitz) E
k
B s ~
/c kZ ~ kZC
x **
[ 6X @*

GDP M%Z
z kZX c*
CizIZ e gR,3(] YZy
ZZzgzZZ !*

t+
$Y ~uzX  M
h { i Z0
+Z ]YZy
Zk
B \W ZX Z egR,11
&
*~V
/
X  *[gzZuZ egR,
{g
Ht /GG

q Zg f LZyZt ~g tu~M%Z {80 Vx

ZQ , qz ~g tuKZM%Z * [gzZ u
/Z ` WX Z7
t VUx yZX W q
-ZskZ Z W **

Z g^
zkZ~^Tk
B s ~
/c YYn
pg
X aM%Z **
`J
-E
g * Zj B
k s ~/
c

:wZ

tgzZ}g kZX *
c Wt ~ ^ @ qZ
DIZ : ;gZ : [Zt UtqZX  U
k*
0 T ;gKz *yX:gzZ
\W0Pgz ~ @ kZX *
@ M%Z *
c tz
b\WwkZgzZ i W kZ ? Zg H
34

 Z t zt (~

?

gzZz!*
kZ k0*
}J
-Zt] !*
EgzZ HwZp Z :[ Z
~ HtkZgzZ e A0kZ ~pX 7[Z bg ez
] [ftUX UVzgzZg0
+ZkZV6,kZ
Y ( ZkZt[ Z[fX [~g ~(,q
-Z6,kZ /$
+gzZ
)g
KZ~TM
h 5 Zg, ZgzZ Y3g {z z!*
y zi mgzZ F,
F,
x
**
gzZ w
D Zj 6f [fbTXn: q Vzuz {z Z Z]~g
[f~yZy}uzq
-Z Z'
~ twZ H ~
z
[ ez t ]!*
g.
X [
',i q
-Z 6,"$
+gzZ XkZ
Z'
X Z'
{z 
g q kZ6,sgzZ bZ c*
6,?gzZ
X Zq
-Zt?Y~Ei6,
%gzZ?VHC
bkZH^
p B}uz q
-Z ,q Vzt ~ kZ _0k
,

z kZX
KZ]
.yZ y ]gtXV ZgztgzZ YYH{u{uyZ
X Z'
0E
!_
. {z gzZzg { c*
iq ~U}g kZpX 7{g e%
R
~ , : o1% s sZ'
kZ  t x Zg
&
X N W x s kZ g ; igzZ bz Zg f (
g Z/GG
xg ZgzZ g {z
c*
s g Z{zX ggzZ g
kZX ggzZ ;gB Z a Vz yZwEZkZgzZg ZXce
X **
Z Zi W zkZ
Hc*
~^zq
-Z
z
X  Z ~{ ~UZVztp
ce **
7i Z0
+ZkZ Kzzq
-Z wEZ ]yZgzZ'

35

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

~pkZB ~!*
{z ] x ce
g ZgzZ
~gz[_
.g0
+Z LZ 7ZgzZ g~Zg yZa kZX}
)g f wEZ ]gzZ
Z Z (Zg !*
g !*
7g !*
-Z~ g @*
q
X
Vrx yZX
HH[_
.g0
+Z x 6 KkZ ~pp W~p
CZ Vz
/yZ kZX
Hc*
z x sp~ ` Vz
/~
6 {z
WKZz L)q
-Z {z kZ O ~ wgzZ c*
Z Z g Z
X 0zq
-Z x
]tDgzZ ~( c*
$g~:WV@W~yj
"
jZZg
sg _
OZo {z/
t ~gz ~y
WLZ tK Z
FZ kZp
7{@{@ZY] !*
X 7=g f ~pgzZ
a wV! zZ \W~ T { @ {za kZX .
g
/ZX ZX @*

Y s m: {}{z ,: x gzZ J e
{z **
Y 7~ ` gzZ 'Y 0 ` 5q
-Z '@Wx CY ~p
$
+p Z (Z ~ v *gzZ ~],Z4Z X 'Y 0z }
]gzKA kZ c*
WakZf ]!*
kZVX Z7(ZV; }g
~ Z'
X ]gz ZzgzZ g Z kZa {WgzZ
$
G
.
/Zp UVz gzZ twEZ]
tgzZ Y LGU

( Y 2008',
Z 16)

X ikZvZY 0
yZ Y(
,jU

36

^
ZZ e
0
C
+
i d
y
KZV &t gzZ V @*
gD
q
-Zp~
z DJ
-V X ~I*:C
0
+
i kZ @*
ce 6g ~%
~zzK
-kZgzZD{z @*
] !*
kZ C
xsZ m_
GL!OQ ZjkZXg J
+ YgzZ Zz+ Y
C
0
-]~y
W0
+
i KZ
gz& q
-Z
' 7{z 'gz kZ Le 'Y
Wx pX
rg
GL!OQ>X  $
VM ~VyZ0
[ (professional)
$ g f c*
kZ {z6,g 7~ Vst& X c*
g izg 0G
& CZz D
kZ F
F6,{z Y c*
J
-Vzuz ]!*
T DwJ~g Z)f
9
g VzgzZ Y J e} ._ kZ
t
X Yc*
x Zu

E
+G
B
{
gzZ qd
x ?, ~ yZyKZgzZ 7,H m ]!*
kZ J
-V
Y1KZ6,
gwVX D
C6,
Rq
-Z ]!*
}@x
 _(,WV
V
X  D Y J 7,}pk JWJ
-
) ) ,v0*

D Y\W~f
$zZX CYf(,Z~yQgzZ CY C Z}p
37

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

CY C F,
Zt YWh
+'
X  CY {gz 3!*
igzZ & }p
G
E
+

Zz "7,q
-Z bS X  D Ws {Bq
-Z gzZ
cg {z ece Wz
Ck Q Le **
c*

rgy~
X ~gz_ Rq
-ZakZX c*
]L8X ] ((L8X

}) Le**
7Zz] q Z ~
CxEY{zt
/Z+ L q
-Z
(xsZ {z%Z ( X 7g zu Q kZ H (positivism)
M XZt

KZ + L {z~}TakZX $
7e]!*
t Le **
W6,x
gzZ}m{k QJ
-Z
# Le J e}._kZgzZ Le I]!*
L8X q
-Z ]!*
X Y 7[ x ~LZ {z 7]Zg Zg ~ kZ
;g {g {z~}Tp ]yZy kZp
/ZX 6,]
]!*
kZQ ;g {e J e ._]ZgLZ {z}TgzZ ;g
H{z ? Y HZzg } kZ ? H {tce W
pgtzgg ZE J
n
-u~A Z
+LZ {zgzZ ? H yZ ?n
pg {o
7p<
yZ V!*
yZ ] L8X
/Z ?JgzZ E " c*
?

xEY+ L q
-Z bT x **
bZ {z 7Zz yQ c*
Le 'Y
LZ {z @*
~gz_a >ZX Y
) !*
: { W
G
E
+
X %m{q
-Z CZgzZ {B CZ yZ k QX N W 6,Rdm{q
-Z\W
V- ZX Vg~f LZ] 6,gBBkZp
o ~op CI**
zI  D] p KZq
-Z

yZ ? g<
- ~7 H~Vo) ( ? ;gH6,R@~b Zz
/
ZX CZa ]g0
+
~kZ] gzZ C]gzkZ **
{ W
38

]6,g wVX Og ] R\ W ~gza \W

4X3 b Zz
0 ] G
5E
/LZ c*
xsZ g @*

( (anthropology) ]*
KZ

K]5V~ 9gzZ
g ] tgzZe D
bg] ~
C
G
E
+
t Xc e
8 {Bq
-ZBBkZX VQa\W~
Da kZX ] !*
R 0C
c*
qq
-ZC
 7 e

Xqg6,qC
{z 7eta~* kZgzZ Wze
$.*
E
+G
B
{
kZgzZ Y 3g kZ Rq
-Z c*
X ~gz O
G
E+G
E
B+
]zZg~f ]!*
tDg (Z {BX Y1g (Z {B
E
E
+G
+G
B
B
{
{
LZib)}g * {zgzZ ( one-sided) {q
-y
KZ

: b)g "y 0*
Y Y7 + L
/Z }X Le
q
-Zq
- 4,
k Q ? HiyQ b) ZgzZ ~ OZ( Y~ kZ
kZXN Yib)}g N Yg 6, ~i
/Zv}g  N
]5Y4 !*
y
/Z {zY Y7wZ Vz
/Z@',
X 0*
gZ
iZC
e
$g/q
- 4,
yZ+(I e
$g/XN Y
g
C ~
/c4g J e ~ OZgzZ o ]c*
OZL8X
G
E
!
g}g J ]%Z LZb) * (specialist) {BC

v !*
X
G
E
!
$E
g0G
q
-Z ZgzZ x **
7{B Z 0
+
iX Le **

G
E
+
**
iZC
* {B LZ LZ sX H0
+
ice
86,
G
E
+
{BakZX 7~iZ]zZgzZ @*
"
$U*
]zZ
G
E
+
{B \ W}XceD
bgp }pd
$
d
$
BkZgzZcexg
| 7,, p ]( (XZa p ] ((p ]c*
OZ
39

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

G
E
B+ t{Z

zz{
+kZXgm [ Zz p

}g !*
xEgzZ 0
+
i [
/ZtnX g7{z @*
60
+Z Za 6{q
G
E
+
$E
X "
$U*
akZ~kZ {B kZ g0G
q
-Z~

$ gfgy*
D0G
!i
Z 3!*
i~ VY9yZgzZ  VH9FwD~ * ` W
J
-u gzZ  DZz G y!*
i ~g KZ ~ V !*
i yZX  q
gzZ N ~ m,Z Z
! ~ V !*
i Zv *1 n
pg W V !*
i
G
E
+
6,V !*
iv g Z ]gzgzZ {B LZ LZ X  3!*
i ~uz
t
/ZXce g ~g J
-yZgzZce qk,
Y| (,7W{z%zg QgzZ ~ m,Z G Le **
~}g !*
]g o
g6,V !*
igzZce Zl
7I3!*
iX I H J~y {z
/ZgzZ
Xce**

t 4{ c*
i ?N Y -J
-u3!*
it {z @*
W~f
wZ Z
kZgzZV}Yy!*
i ~g KZ~ YY7
/
tbTXqg6,y!*
C
i
9 Z \Wa+ YV7 eX VZz V7
gzZ C a \Wy!*
i ~g xk!*
p} 7,**
q
g ] gzZ ,7,
]5gzZ ~g N YJ3!*
iJ
-ukZ
/ZX BgzZ YZ\ Wg
YY c*
%Z kZ {i Z0
+Z Z Iy!*
iX  $
Z Zg Z4{t ~K
3!*
ig e i Z \W CY ~ ot ~ ]Yxk!*
~ V
g dZ 
!
1 m,
( M c Gi l l w c*
D;gE- G
SZ sZ s W^3Z = X V Y
40

&X 5 Y University)
V !*
ig e D
C
V;z t ]!*
f LE
V;z }Y ~ m,
ZgzZ
HR',{z
/Z ~ wkZ D
C
X Zz
/ZX ( CY 1y!*

i~wc*
Y ) ~ qz Gy!*
iZ
kZ Y
} 7,]gzIy!*
i F,
Z 0 Y uF,
! kZgzZ }Y zg Q {z
7]!*
t aDL X3Z~ * ! fX  C7,G7Z 3!*
ig e {
1 X
rg

A &kZz~
.Z~yZgzZ}Y3!*
i]b
z Wq
-Z
V !*
iyZ H{E
+J
-V !*
igzZ~CVs LZ VX
Y Z  M
h~
.Z kZ YZM
h| 7,
 YJ
-ukZ
V !*
iX  M
hy ~ kZ YgkZgzZ  M
h w1 Zzg
3!*
i @*
X a\ W Z3Y\W3!*
i J
-uTtn
[NZ kZgzZ @*
[NZ Z CZ Zg { {z ~ y!*
iTBB+ Y
X DwEZV !*
i J
-uc*
~ m,Zzg Qxk!*
a
$ g fgy*
g Z 0G
!i
~g J
-uq
-Z g Zt |g  Dg Z
)g f y!*
i
&
kZ kZ k
,
~y!*
i KYKI
/ZX @*
g Zz~wJLE
kZ X }g s~uz VQ Q _7,s Z
/Zc q
-Z 7,k
,

&J
~g x
ce wJLE
-ukZ y!*
i kZ 
 ~gza
$**
'~i Z0
+Z: ZC
 @*
7g izg 0EE

zLZ ~g x q
-Z Zg XnW,
M
Z ~kZZzy!*
i kZ
rg '{z i Z p6,y!*
i
]gzKZ {z **
t' c*
[q
-ZX Y H O9p ZV: o Z
$ g f CZ y!*
LZ c*
**
g Z 0G
i T B kZ pY 3!*
i ._
41

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

kZ q~ zg Q {z
/Z Xce **
g q
-Z y!*
i~ kZ V **
]
INgzZ ~y!*
t 6,g~g 7g rLag kZgzZce G
0kb
i

zg Q + L q
-Z :
L HX Y J 7, !*
V Zz zg Qce
akZX7, t Z Wx  @*
0*
7Za e {z~k
,
KZ Y
gzZ zZp ~ !*
c*
g]
.ZVrZX S7,y!*
i g - i L LVrZ
E
E
!
{
43
~zg Q ` WgLX H7_ ~gLZ
w={ c*
i EG
7+
[|ZgzZg Z yQBB Z ~
CyZ ~ q=yZ H
|g Y
KZgzZi Z0
+Z [|Z k
,
yZ,t Z ]!*
kZ\ W ?
t akZXg ZzBBZzDyQ~ w=yZ
c*
](( g @*
g rLgzZV{ W [|Zy!*
ikZ Y~y!*
iT
4X3
X g _7,V' Zy!*
ikZ6,gY
KZgzZ[ Zy!*
is?
] G
5E
E
.-|Z g ZX M
vx mJ
-V G
h;6,~ m,
Z\W]!*
Z
?ce **
4bg Zt pM
hy CZ]zZfgzZagzZ
~z K y ? ~ m,
Z 9] Zg Z y ? qhZ y~ m,
ZakZ
E4F
7
'!*
~g t ? yy Zz w= ` W ? CY 1 ~ m,
Z hZ6,E5G
&Ly!*
X N Y Dg E
iKZ @*
ceg yZn
pg7
G
G
E
E
+
+
-Z >t xd
~ {BX {BkZ ce Rdq
kZX Og }p}uza Za yi Z ~ kZ V: /q
3!*
ice **
gJ
-ukZ6,y!*
igzZ gg6,V !*
iBB
p ~ kZ Zz"7,y!*
i kZgzZ
M f Y~k
,
~g , .
J
-ukZ i Z
X}kC
42

gx~yZy
CZzDa0
+
i .Zz
/Z ?Y H bx tt wZ[Z
Hy~ gzZ qZg ce
8t  **
hzZgzZ yZy
y
KZ Y W[ zZ (Z X  $
w$
+V ]!*
Zt ?

BV +ZX Y `6,c }uz {zgzZ Y {g ~O ~O
M F,
X e(ZX c*
W`~
( c*
[ Z DDx ~q
-Z V
-V1 ~
J
CkZ
7,H Dt Z
# @*
q c*
kZ @*
ce
8| 7,._
KZ 7Z gzZce g
+F,{ i @*
{z gzZ YZ { Zp{ ~ ] ~g Zj~ }g !*
? 7F,
Z ygzZ F,
Z y ? 7 Z y c*
Zq yX N Y
c*
CY J 7,~ ;gE- C

[q
-Z c*
D ~g {~}g !*
kZ
g| 7, pZ v ]o]!*
kZ **
+
g !*
g !*
X C +
g !*
g*
!

ce**
{ WkZ\W 0\Wt
/ZX [ w=q
-ZtgzZ
kZ\ Wt
o{ c*
i 7
8| 7,sZXce
8| 7, S gzZ
Bzg} / Z Y S7,[
~Y ZZgzZ BF
ZgzZB| 7, yEZII\W[ ~
Cq
-Z
/ZXce 7, yEZ
TAz @*
YX i * " \ W V1 Vpt |g B
54X~ i
e q
-Z {zgzZ @*
c*
Zj {{z {~ E
5G4G
NN 7Z~ H{zyP X CY Z
Z~]g
kZX V 8F
5C
 3g| 7, jiZ ZV1 ~
C6,qLZ kZ t :
L
] !*
t X 7c*
]!*
5~ kZ @*
YxZ Z
/tgz [
43

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

$$
kZ:gz X  C (original) G
+c*
5 |g Y

gzZ i Z0
+Z C 7q 5{ c*
i 6,}i kZ gzZn yWkZ ~ ]
hZ ~
C
/ZX @*
Yc*
y~Zc6 q
-Z]!*
Z6,gzZ @*
*[|Q
g BBkZX
~"7, !*
V S7, b
X 7kZ
{ c*
i
8 Z c*

8F~ K 0_ [Y Hf  6
-Z X YY ~ s ZZ [a h
q
e FX igzZ
o
N
yZp $
Y : Zt ZgzZ yZX Y **
wEZ t ZgzZ i
ce
8 Z ZY ZWg gzZ)gzZce xg n
p6,gzZ hY zV
X F:
) !*
.6,
a\Wg mZV~ @*

x X Y c*
qzx 6,kZ a qq
-Z t g ia
]!*
Y 7
VyQt gq
-Z ?Y H t gzZce **
VY
gzZ~K
M F,
m{q
-Z Yq
-] t]qakZX Y
X @*
Yx q
-Z bkZX N Y ~ J
-V7~y!*
i
o
$%Fg7gx t ~ Z 8 WXce **
A
Y Hx t 6,Rq
-ZgzZ x dq
-Z t
v
te
$ Z x kZX @*
YH~]gpg6,Z
+Z`
zbggzZ
yZ **
_ qC
Zz +
0LZgzZ  gg Z
/0
+
i sz^
CYZa WayQ~]gA
$%{)zFg7g@*
7ea
-Z c*
q
t pX x t q
-Z X  M
h{ .Z yZ ~
z v {zgzZ
44

\ W qt {z **

/Z x Zg F,
', kZX x Zg
Za w _0 qm{q
-Z~f\Wzz X B
N VZ. @*
CZ \ Wt Z Z
W~ {],
Z \Wqt
/ZX Y
{z
/ZpX **
x ~zb
s\WgzZ{ W ]c*
IkZ\W yZy
E
+G
B
{
\Wqt e } 7,**
i ~(,\WQ ?
\Wq
Xg @*
W: VYg !*
g !*
~f
~kZ\ Wce 9 **
x \W6,qkZf
et\WZ
#
G
.2E$~ kZ H 7Z
CZ f \ W~ kS H ? M
hLG
/Z ? M
hZ
"7,
p YYHZ 7 ~kZ 4C
]zZ?7c*
z
&~ kZ @*
7,}g ~ ]g+Z X 7e**
Z wJLE
kZ
CZ F
g '!*
V~ W {%izg_t X Bz _LZ
$E
7Zd6,
qVzkCt
/Z~X YDZz0G
kZ K6,qTBgg t ak
,

/ZX @*
VQ76,kZ~ Y
V: VYxP{z eVWR{
Dc*
g {
D~
v gzce r\W G (Z
/Z X: VY 5 c*
oo Z
g rLgzZ ~gz_\WaXce
8z _LZZ
X 7~J
-/_

ww
( 46,w ) perfectionism**
kZ c*
**
J
-u wx C

X { q
-Z t B B kZ gzZ hZ q
-Z 6,g LZ
45

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

7t c*
,
k
KZ :
L ]zZ vb perfectionism
:!ZjV#c*
[ V#J
-Z
# 6,qkZ @*
t I yZ6,gwVX D
&th
wJLE
++
g46,wXN Zz7 +
y*CZY
&gzZ
/Z H\ Wx
X
K q M

z~ kZp] !*
pLE
gzgJ
-w{gG c*
kZ e7k c*
0*
gzZ }  c*
} {z
{g { c*

x Z
e
$ Z~ kZ
/ZX 7
o
V Zz yzo Z
Z~A kZ ZXB Zg7 Zz W\WZ
?7e6,VgzZ YYHM6,
]!*
Xce
8 Za yi Z yxg

x Fz
hx F
M
z vX K ` Z'
nZV
KZ \vZ
/ZX  Dg ZyZyq

-Zv ] zZgzZ M
h a6,V UF
yxg
/Zp J
-0*
~ i Z0
+ZiZ Q N Y 6,q q
-Z {z
k,
c*
D 0*
7x {zc*
gzZ *
@Y',g{zyZ Yc*
x gzZ ~
Fc*
W q
-Z {z *
*p0LZCt X  D Y ua
F
z Xx ._
KZ%ZkZX Yx 6,VU
~
z q
-Z
/ZpX 7YZ ~(,gzZ 7Z',
8x
x F A s Z
z ~ kZ
z!*
kZ ;gx 6,}p qZ Z
Z Zuz Zuz x q
-Zt y WX ~ }vP
E
$ L L~ ]g Z Z ~ +

0G
$Y Z 8 WX6,` Z'
\ Wst X
43X ~ kZX *
[ Z ] ((
zq
-Z 6, ] G
@Y 0*
Y
5E
46

E+G
CY } qC
J
-Vzk,
yZ ] z L g @*
Y !*
Z zq
-Z
bkZ J
-uq
-Zf LZ~ *
@Ya kZh
++
x Zg t
z pX
-Z_ Zg t wqpX V_ g @*
q
V| 7,[ ZV Y
G
E
+
X
V {OBq
-Zp kZgzZ g0
+Zg0
+ZR',q Zm{

[NZ
 M
hx 6,VU Fc*
 n
pgf {q
- \ Wh
e t
` Z'
gzZ Vgzg6,Z\ WZ
# X N Y4Z ~% Z
a g kZX Bg
zhZ q
-Z6,qkZ Vg
k0*
}D
q
-ZZ
# X *Z \ Wp/CZ \ WX YYc*
7wZ {
VH Y~{Zxk!*
~ @*
Wag 6,qm{
7**
C Z ~
z!*
kZp $
Wx kZ [ V#V}Y ~q
-Z {z ] zZ X }l[ p {z Y ~ {  t zz kZ X Le
q
~Q c*
~uzkZX 7x kZt kCQQ VQ[
Xk,
c*
Q~hZZ F
F6,gzZ$
- ;f kZt[ ZX VQ
gzZ HyizkZ ? ~
T# g DT!*
tg rL
 g[ q
-ZgzZ *
@Y~{{ zZ
# V &t~? +
jX{z
kZyZkZ[ {z i Z 7akZgzZ 76,qkZt
kZ {z ]gz Z LZ
# gzZ  D YW~fkZ ] YgqkZ '
a kZX Za /Zz V1 {z bkZX }YJ
-u: [
y Y ` @*
C /Zg BB
zXce gZg V {
47

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

GW8
kZN Y +
$O h~ t \ W - X 6,q}g [
EE{!
EE{!
7]gz
/
"7,EG43 ?7 ygzZ 4 EG43 y6,q
C
n Xg z 6,x **
i .w~ y 0*
? k,
/**

7,gzZ
%NV**
J
-ukZ , _yZp7~F
V1yZX 
t~ yZp c*
VZ F,~g Z VrZ YY Zg Z
/]yZ
byQ Z $
Y 7{ c*
i yQ~ekZX CY 0*
7Z
E
E
{!
ce hZg 0 EG43 ZbZXce **
7,7~6
C7,]gzt ] zZ
z D GL^zX 7gzZ Y J 7,
(bibliographies) } ;
zhZ6,] x z ~ * d` WX

z #\ W
/Z X  CY i
zx : t
/Z X  [
7
F,
a \ W~ [ NZ [ {z YWx (annotated bibliography)
%N yZLLX $
ekZX @*
7g0
+Z[ p @*
F
"
$U*
Xc e
8g Z6,
kZgzZ Cg ~g
z#~
hZ x 6,qk Qt
o ,_a Z
# nZ
V16,qk Qiq
-Z z y k X N Y N
z
[p [p\W kZXN
V6, \ WgzZ Y yT F,
gzZ q
-ZQ 6, [q
-Z 6,x xsZ [ q
-Z6,g wVX N Y

z!*
+ Y 
_tkZ Y | 7,6,g @*
c*
6,](([
-ZY t r
q
/ZX '0*
7Y q
-] ~g 6,qq
-Z
VF,
Z
{z~ V1[
7gzZ [
7~
z q
-Z6,q
_X W~ Zg _ yQX V7 \W
48

X7ZZ~yZFLZ bS X Ytg T q
-Z

)OGzg Z
V; gzZ
/Z +
]!*
t ~ ] Z ` W a
\W
zq
-Z !*
}]gkZ { Zp Y1g
c*
kZ \W iZ k
,
q
-Z \W~ kZgzZ c*
} g
-Z mkZz ~
q
.ZJ
-V X c*
g\W Tce **
g Z
/
]
z
X @*
g Z
Z k Q
8q
V !Zj{z C! pt [iZ
gzZ 0*
Y x **
LZx Vzuz VrZ D Wx **
, Z Vp~ e
$Zzg
{ z ~
.Zq VrZ Va kZX q **
+O **
$
(7Z
0xpgzZ *
c J(,
W]!*
[ x **
LZ ZVrZgzZ ] !*
p
o { c*

i Y c*
f + kZ
z DwEZ J+ q X
kZ V }]
z DA
$%^g7g c*
z [ X

V c*
V Zz a V .Zz
] +Z m<!*
gzZce b i!Zj
] Vzuz c*
~i /l
 Og7 ]!*
kZ X V 5!*
a
{Z
+gzZ yv{ C " ~ kZ Xce ykZ (plagiarism) u
gzZ 4q
-Z G X 7
i Z Z T
X Le kZ [t Z !*
X YgzZ Yc*
Q (credit)
{z H > yYgzZ ~,
(
]!*
 @*
C
Za t wZ
V! Zz6,
C c*
[tW,G
& CZ f Z? Cu 0*
V!
~k
,
kZX CV ~k
,
T @*
{z[YZpX D7u 0*
49

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

tX @*
V{ c*
i Wx gzZ @*
V{zp @*
y kZ t
\W
/ZXce kC7g ~ q
g t Z
g
Z w~b \ W c*
~ \ W]  t6,kZ w
X k(,
W
C]!*
kZ [YZq
-ZXce7g ~
g
r!g ~ ft X  ]  ` Zzgt xk!*
~ * d
* d\ W CY t ~ a kZX @*
x [
Q Vzg7\ W
~ [ gzZ  g Y Z ~
-Zp y W r[ OX  ]!*
q
KZ}}gzZ  h
\W
~kZX D YZV~bgX r!YZ
t ~ ^] izZ h
+]
..ZzgzZ hZq
-ZX M(feedback)g
^! {z Z
# gzZ Cg (Z ^! {z g
/
7 }QgzZ CW
BBV1zzX Cg Wt 5 C gg (Z
yyZ
+Z`
d
] }
.nkZ~gzh
+]
.Xce g q
g ] Nd
gzZ g @*
]xsZ ]c*
OZ ? ;g H~ yQ ? ~ V !*
i ?
o&
+Z , Z ? ;g H~ g @*
\g- c*
R',Z Vz g0
+Z g @*
Q
] zZX Sg CW} ;
z+ZBBkZgzZ
bg +
Z/
g @*
Z !
/Z6,gwVX @*
x Z ]!*
kZ ~Z
+Z`
dg dZ
0 q \ W C Mg LZ {z J!g 6,
(gzZ
e **
q gJ
-yZ\W
/ZX |] yy~Z
+Z`
}uz
X YZa Wa\W
kZgzZ t [~^kZpX  D J (,W bkZ
50

pX nx 4{z G Y[_ zig WqBB

{z \vZX k

) !*
Y qt ~ tgzZ
/Z
g q~
z{gHq
-ZBBkZgzZB] Z
( }W )X 

A &

[Z
zwZ
? tH~,
k!*
c,
kZzgqZ

:wZ

X
W7
) !*
Z ~] yZp n
pg] ] zZ :[Z

\ W
/Z c*
;g Wt g !*

,Z (Z~k,
KZ
z \ Wt
9
N
F H7Z ]
V  3 7U /F
!k,
+ZO X Y Za W{ c*
i~K] !*
Y ~, ZVU
c*
7t \ W c *gzZq 5!*
c*
V
bzZi 6 a~ T
Zjkg Z~Z8 W n $
Y~ V- wVkZX Y
t *zz ?z kg Z ~ ~I ] O]Ic*
c*
W g t
(Z Zz
/Z [ Z ? kg Z :
L ~ Vz 1
wZp? g Z)f [ yZ H ? C 7Qq y, Ct0
+
K
) !*

t
/ZX _7,V- {z[  _7,` W{ z[
t
` W 7(Z
/ZX e g kg Z ~q
-Z ` W
X ]gzyYbhZa[ Z
kZ wZq
-Zt?
Ht
4$7ZV x
OhIG
/
u! )c*
wj kg Z|g HtwZZuz bZ
51

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

43X~[ kg Z ? C

[ X 7 Zj] G
5E
*
@Y c*
J 7,~g ~w', ~- z *
@Y c*
J 7,~gg
$u L X3Z
~i Z0
+Z6,Qq
-Z ?D J 7,6,iZ { +
E ZX Z ZzJ 7,p
V
/
u! ) H ? n
pg H yZ ] Z|yzkg Z yZ ? Ck,

:
L } aLkg Z t ] !*
S c*
?
C` Z't yZ 
{ c*
i kg Z VMv { z wX } aLbz6,yZgzZ ?7
6,kZ] _gzZ YK ] !*
{ C"gzZg
/
7q
-Z ~ Z
LZp76,g~
C
+ fp),D{z:
L ~Z
X  qzgzZ = + Q  D7gzZ By)F, + \ W
kZ Cc*
h
+]
. g 7{kg Z q
- 4,
V Zz tZy
W
E
$yQp kZ { c*
X ]gz+ Y0G
iz~
D Za Z
Zq kg Z It~i Z0
+Z [Z
~kZ N Y \W]!*
kZ f7, zZ +@W~ kg ZY
7
 ]!*
5q
-ZtkZ\W
/ZgzZX  Yt vX 7] OE
G
$ tZzZ 7]!*
OhI
t D Ctg z ZZgzZ gzZ ~
}5q
-Z\ WY {z  ]!*
5q
-Z\WZ
# X ;g WgzZ}
n](( ]c*
OZ bZ X  g t 6 c*
 g
X M
h]!*
bzZi6 \ W~k
,
0q
9N
F
/F
-Z ] KZ \Wt V &~J
q
-V
&aV
~} ^gzZ5q
gzZwJLE
-ZVzqV c*
c*
V
7c*
F6,\ WtgzZce
F
A &!tg0
+Z\ WX ;g Y ] OE
Z
52

H ? ]5\ W? HgCZ \W? ~ZX\W

kZgzZg\W?gN~F,
WzQc*
~w~ ZZ {q
X F
F6,
\ WBB
~yZX D7gb)P]zZyZgz

:wZ

-Z ] V *
q
@/6f ,
6 q~ #
Zt X
~#
Z pX h
MY],Vz% 4=gzZ *
@g mZ {C"
=QX H
Z 4 (Z| WqZ V
N .,
X Ey
6XtX *
@,
7*
* WskZ}9zgzZ ,
F
bqZ Vz qz r o Z A e ~tX Zuz
G
HX Y*
0 7Zg kZ ~gzZ Lg
~ f } E{O$
G
**
*
0 Zg b~g7 kZ *
c ~gz xg
~,
k E{O$ b
?ce

6,qV # @*
tW,G
& X @*
ZaXtB ZzC
] zZ :[ Z

] ,P] !*
t *
@Yn@',
kZ c*
V] ,Vz%h
++
Y
qkZY~/
/Z @*
X @*
7(Z $p $
Y~
kZg Dg6,yZ zgzZ Y1] yQM
h y] Z
Y Zb
Z kZ O
z 6,qWz gzZg C gzZZ ~
:NC
Za
~ 6,zEE
bkZ Y ~g !*
~g !*
6,Y Z b
Z yZgzZ N Yb
X  bVzq\ W6,` Z'
\ WtpX CY
,qg wt ~ ekZ ?Y Hgz J
-u] !*
~uz
ukZX  _0z a~g 6,g C!*
.,qgzZ Cz ];~g
_
53

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

]c*
] Z] !*
.LZ{g f~]g\W b W,G
_
& ~g ZY)J
ce
A &t ~ \ W
z!*
pg pX 7
gt n
pg 7
yZ+ ( @*
3 y 0*
 *
@Y }X N Z] 5\W
L kZY Yg Z z V'{z H]!*

/Z~}g !*
d
$
h] !*
yZ+ (aV'~ V/}uz ? 7J
-@ $
"
kZgzZ
7)lL
q
-Z Qq
-Z @*
(Z@',
kZpX CY
: {zX @*
tkZ ZO~wj gzZi Z0
+ZT c*
@*
B];
lkZ {z
z!*
kZp Zg
/7p Q"kZX w>:gzZ L
p
yys kZa kZX
8 9Juq
-Zh
++
gzZ @*
t
Tgg ZY) Z] c*
aKZ]5z a\W'!*
\W~
A &kZX ]gz [q
-Z Z
i6,yvz kZgzZ Z
iN
$E
Q ;g]!*
?
0G
\ W
]!*
#N Yt x
Z ? {gzZ! p H~kZ ? Z H%Y6,Kg Z LZ
"\ Wg ZJu kZX Y CWZ~ \W ,
X6,
wgzZ
kZ Zuz *
@YyZ
q
-Z E_N{q
-Z ~ 0
+
i {%izg
z6,kZ ZgzZ 7@*
: VY ~ #mZ e E_N }
kZ ? ;g {VY ? ;g]!*
bzZiZz%1 &{zY 7
(~ b e
? ;g] !*
t m Z LZ c*
**
Zh Q ME
$f Z= H ? H

$ECZ
 @*
g ZY)Juq
-Z
z!*
pgB0G
M F,
~g O
X YYHx ZtJukZX ]z',c*
]g ZwX~yZBkCVzq
54

G
at} w] E
5{O$gzZ]c*
LZ f LZZz Otp
 g6\ WD\ W V n
pg Zp% L
/ZgzZ 7e

/
kZgzZ ]!*
C
~t J
-ukZX KgzZ v i Z0
+Z m{q
-Z \W
X ce 7
kZgzZ b r z
]c*
LZ G7ZhZzbq
-Zv

ui Zta r z
] c*
LZX 9 6,g: Zg ZY)VzqBB
gzZ,1e\W1 LZp] c*
N 0*
7(Z \W
/ZgzZ ~gz
N

\W 7]gzW JukZ8

-g aKZpXN 0*
7] !*
\W
^8
-g" Vzq\ W ]gz8
-g" JukZ @*
X N Y8
-g"
X N~
(Emperical

i*
c CZ@x : i Z+
0Z z

:wZ

(Deskwork ! gzZ  D Y~ y Zy\W

Research)

~ q ,
4 \WX  D| ,
7 V1 \W
Research)
]*
! V *
!i\W#
Z,
6 gm{ ?ce *
*zJu CZ@x
V;zpVg ,
6 q0u\W} *
c Vg
V1pz $
d*
c ` ZzgzxgV;z \WgzZV: L
?

6,
}gzZVF
F6,V1
g]!*
tJ
-u :[ Z

-Z% .5gzZ kz&

J
+Z Y u 0*
W
V
/ZX
E
$ yZgzZyx
(ZpX yZZ6,yW

yZYce**
6q
-Z0G
{zBB kZ 7z yZZ yZ ]!*
t :
L kZ X 7
55

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

kZ ? J
-V {zB: ? gg Z
/0
+
i j
yZ ? H
V)B V V;z ? H]c*
Zzg ? Hb)
-Z~ VZaVyZ~V!*
q
~g yZ ?H6,~ !*
W]Z W,
Z

[ 7V *zz X Y CZ}uz
7@y 0*
z ~ kZQyZ[y
X  Dt V yZ { Z bkZ X yi
Z y
)g f [
/Z X q
-Z yZZ yZp
/Z  Zb) VyZY
IF
4&]gzZ g @*
L G
~ kS 4z@*
D7Zz Z ]5 Y J 7,
];yQ\W57YV;z\ Wpg6,u\W
/ZX Og
ZzgX6,
CV1 V}uz Y t D D 7Zz
g\ W n
pgg Z6,yZ ` CZ@x Y V;z
Zg Z,
'
gzZ
tgzZ M
h Za 7(originality)Z ~k
,
KZ\WpX Y
g
p\WakS X  c*
g
Ju{z g Z \W6,V1X M
h7
Xce**
YV ; z
gzZ x { c*
i } kZ CZ@xgzZ x p Z &+
G
\ W~ T z wpX GO gzZ
z { c*
i } kZ
gzZt M
hWx }g g z ZZ ~ Y J
- Z kS gzZ N Y J
-Z
g dZG X Y Wx }g e ~q
-ZgzZ w k
V;zgzZ y!*
i V;z Vgx 6,Tce **
x Zt a
8q zq

-Z a kZ gzZ 0
+
i ~g pX /Zz V
m{  Y 3g ~ f ZX  C { c*
i >] u}Xce
56

X ] !*
\ WBBkZpdgzZ CZ@x\ W6,q
$E
Xce**
0G
\ WakZ 7e*
*gzZ_(Z6,qC

G
y!*
i yZ 7,]Zg Z yZ w
Vs
# ( z }i E3N
XcewEZg7yZgzZbzZx t 'Y
O$E
Zz \Wyxg(Critic) G
gzZ (Researcher) [ :wZ
O$E
? Y G
[qZ *
c D~u*
c t

kZ} qz{zXg ZY)[q

-Zt ]g+4 :[ Z

 Z% 6,gCc*
X} x {z]!*
kZZJ
-V
\W6,w2T H qz^\W6,
C g ZY)!*
\W
Xg Z kZ c*

]!*
kZ W\ W G~ kZg\Wx
t] !*
-Z
q
H ? Vc*
gz$ H ? Z',H ? YZ H~ kZ
H

8{ ^
,Y
O$EG \W p kZ ?
h
e {^
,Y ~Wx K6,qYX  G
%W 't X Y0[YZ YZq
-ZX  M
h]!*
KZ \ W
~ kg Z  _ Y ~ wV 6X 7e $
Y
b{ ZpbkZ, :t\W[Zzg Z
J
-Z
# ? H:
L
V 7~ ci7 ]!*
KZ \WJ
-
z k Q @*
} ^
,Y ~Wc*
Y c*
x **
gzZ ,: !*
\WW Y 7(Z X BBWgzZ ZX
,wJq\ WTV] 5 \ W
CWX g D
X Zzg ~g YBB gzZW 4= X, g c*

LQX N J (,
W]!*
KZBBkZgzZg f
e{ ^
,Y ~Wq
57

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

p kZX 7c*

gtc*
W
~, W6,]!*
KZg r
kZ ? Y W,
Z H kZ Y e bkZ Y t
/Zv
:N,q {zgzZ  D ,q hG
%L~h W @*
yZX '0*
7HE
(Z L? @*
V
a
:N
B \W W |gX g Dw\W ~gzaHE
~uz c*
C0*
7B Vzq ~uz VYt ? H~ k
,
\W
]\ WZ ?CY VYt T e gZ Z\WZ
# Vzq
X *
@YI]!*
KZ :W
/ZX BB gzZW\W._
yi Z yxg Cc*
kZgzZ [q
-ZT e **
zskZ\ W
/Z
$E
 T e b \W bT}t 0G
-Z 0?
q
%Lsg rLpX Y ~g W~kZ fV
g ZY)c*
~E
w~g kZ **
p~ kZ 6,g i t4q
-Z X C 7
JukZ6,
zZ LZ? **
gz$"_
.x KZ kZ H ? H
v, ZX : VY }kZ e : ] !*
9=
8~zq
/ZXce **

76, Z]Z B LZ~ *t ]!*

~uzpX 

D
/YZ U z B B kZ k

) !*
(
,j
VzU LZ ~ ] q F,
+~ce **
$
3 3 Zg %$
+wq g
GLI
iX  B
ce : Za ~yZ **
yVZk
,
z
bg
A &"(,u W
) !*
Y~zs Za ~kZ Dt~&giBBkZ
w\W 7 \WF
F6,h mJukZx KZ
+ZXce
kZ *X 7ax gzZ 7a}g +Z { n
3wqglp7k
,
7~]g | (,
W
58

kZOX Y:x ~g } B
bgZpg Qx KZ KZ
X YHW !*
bg ZY)gzZ Cc*
ce
8Za yi Z q
-Z~
}kZ]5bTX *
@z}[qZ

:wZ

X  D i Z+
0Z ,
WZ ,
6 kZ {z C DB Vv
{g 7g Z ,
' ; kZ ~ T D Y ]5 n )]zZ
}g yZ [qZ wEZ X  h
M j y {z X C*
0
?Yg ~g YKZgzZY]5

q
-ZXg F~~ygzZ @*
#
i 5q
-Z ] !*
q
-Zt

:[Z

@*
Y Z ,'gzZ ;g W X **
Y wja p @*
W
BB] )~g tD~0
+
i {%izg bTX
{zh++
@*
W ,
X  CW,Mc }g BBgzZ
g 6%z~ a kZ g F ~ TX } Z W~
jZ C Za V*.6,Z C ta Wx bTX Y
X M
hb)akZgzZ @*
g F{zX C Za a[
0
+
ipgay k X LgzZ Vh
+{ c*
i LV*.6,t
x ~ A Z [m VE.6,yZOX {g 7
`
@*
: (ZX [ @*
W,
Ox Wx bTX @*
Zz
7~ {z} 7,g F~[gzZgwYV]g kZgzZg F~
kZBV}g
/Zce **
g `
@*
kZt \Wi Z X Vz
`
@*
X\WmkZXce (,
bZ \W f(,
]g
8 Za yi Z {z ? @*

Za yi Z b{zgzZ H ]g KZ
59

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

X} 7,
ZzZg VE.6,
yZcet\vZXce
!t#
Z ozBCreativity *
c D *
* VZH

:wZ

KZ *
c Y 3g: x~ yZykZ H~, ZX C Z Z.
}A
&
?cexg D

v ~  @*
kZt
z kZ  DD
Z
#

:[ Z

7xk!*
v"f t 3gzZ  { c*
i v  "f { c*
i
x t~ V P d
$
yJZgzZ V "f ~ @*
it 7ZX D
BCq T D
gz$ q
-Z @', kZ X  f
e .Zz {zgzZ V
{ c*
i {z Lg kZ ~gz$kZ KZZgzZ
8 FLZg !*
g !*
7
~g7 gzZzkZ]zZ$;fX qz bz{ c*
igzZ
$;f W {zgzZ *
@Y {g W"f {z~ hz 0
+
i igzZ
X ` ZZ $;fgzZ\W!xOX *
@Y| (,
WB
-ZX 4 BB q
$;f ~ kZ m J
-V
x AZ Z 8 7^g7g ~g x%y 0*
{z
/Z: VY"f H J 7,
^g7g kZ W$;f q
-Z@',
kZ ? Hwqgy 0*
 Y7
p kZX *
@Y V6,}4gzZ @*
W ] 4 Z
/tgz
X $
0w$
+$;fJ
-uq
-Z
T e G'g 'Z
# {zgz q
-Z ?Y
t ]!*
~uz
4Z Y\W
ce wkZXce bqz r
z ZX 
kZ DY HZ ~ VsyZ Dk
,
!X 7c*
M
h J
-Vzuz i Z0
+Z
 f7,a kZ\ W *gzZ  [[xgzZ wG \WZ
# agz
60

v, Z  C ] V ] zZ X A ]!*
5V; \W
t:
L kZX  D k- {z Q7]!*
57ZgzZ  _7,q [Z
#
dZ ? g ya X  D ]Zg Za Z
Z Z
LZ \WZ
#  @*
(Z ]zZ X a>g +F,
]!*
V LZ D W,
O \W{z  DW Vx {z
B Vg /{ c*
i LZ \WZ
# g rLgzZ @*
7W,
O  D
-ZgZg Z\WakZX  f
q
e bgzZ\W{z  Dg]!*
]!*
t ?Y H6,RZ kZQgzZ Y H6,RZ kZX Y H6,R
vz {0
+
ipX ]!*
Zz `zZ * Zz~TY zs
~k
/Z }X n
pgg Z
',ZgzZe
$ ZZ KZ
Tg
kZ
/ZpX 7yTkZ Y0z k{z Y c*
|
# g
} 3: Z]
.gzZ g |
# KZ |
# g \ W , |
# g x W\W~ k
6,q
/ZX *
@Y0yT\W{z  DZ\ WZ
# ~ * dX
RZ Z Y 0 b
{z CYW, Z 
]_
CZ,Z
# 6,Rq
-Z~]F,
KZX 7yT ZpY
E
+G
B
{
}
A &t \vZ G N Y ~ ZgzZ B
$$
X 7~i Z0
+ZiZ7ZgzZV'!*
G
+]6 ~f}g 
g ) z z  7Z *Z yQ  H O8Ev

v
X w Z
# hZ~]gZy!*
i ~g X ( g g
{^
,Y]!*
kZp\WX CYCBB
zy!*
iyZTg
w q
-ZgzZ g D_~ wq
-Z Kk
,
q
-Z \W M
h
61

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

4 {z kCt
q
-Z~Vz ,:i Z yZ
/ZX Kk
,
{g !*
z
4#
|yZ
D { c*
i
HZ~p Z f
X g Y W{ c*
i]!*
gzZ

/ g zgx \ W6,RT Z
>aa Wx X G

Dx CZ ._ kZgzZ BZg ZX /G a DIZ a

XN Y
?3gxqgzZ".
_~yZy \W

:wZ

VhZz}g Z Z, ZqZlp~pkZv

x VB}/
Zp5wj qZ
x ,
6} Z m{\W/
Z,
6gm{7],
F{ *
c ia
CY ],
Fax ,
6 } Z m{)  7g a
{z $
+YqZ a yZ  D W~ yZy v
~,Z ( 
~ o 7{ *
c i Z Z,jt $
+ Y ~uz 7
V7~ } ,
]Z } ,
( ,q yZgzZ yDg _
ZZzi Z+
0Z ,
WZ,
6 *
0 $~wj ,
m S Z *
0 X '*
0

g Hax ~, ZX  0Z yK
DZ~}g *
!
? b
Bgu\W
qH+ZgzZ ?ngx {i *
@V

P
~y c*
= m " CZ f }J
-V

:[ Z

g OZ g Zz WC
c*
C
c*
*
@Y J 7,~ wj y i Z0
+ZTgzZ
tZ~VPZz~ yZpX q
-Z JukZ*
@ YH
 C
]F,
~ fy
KZh
++
X 7V!*
J m
yZz6,tzf
t~V!*
?VY~sy
W 7! Z Iz]!*
t 4 (ZgzZ
62

t h
+y
[ gzZ "7,[ i W 0
+
iQ ?Z 7VY Za t
c*
D Y a }
z k Q k7,~ , ^W,~ Z
# X
k7,~
) ) ,g
H~Z
# X @*
1g{z
E
4&
5nz =
**
)]W9zg 0*
~ ~ yQX9zg: G
5F
f}[Z]W{zgzZ ~h
+y
( {E
+
szcY Zzg Z Zi W@
kZgzZ J 7,bhZ V yQ[k Q~ B
bg(Vc*
{~
 c*
C wj QX Za
q IzgzZ 4z [ X 1
\WLZX  M
hk
,
 M
hW\W Sg W~ ] !*
Y 1| 7,
Vzuz \W C l
\W

~ ] ;
KZ Zp Vc*

w ZX k(,
,j Dpv ,tQgzZ VW
~ TgzZce **
U [ Z ~ kZp Iz J
-uq
-Z '!*
~g t
H Hah
+y

[ q
-Z~ c*
=X7[
7 bziZY ;gxz
CY WV\WX 7a V\W{z ` WX
s7,0*
ZX7, Z]qa}pM
hIc6,kZ V\ WX 
5'!*
~g tDVc*
g6gzZbzwj BBkZ Iz]!*
X CYW
0~h iZ v (Z !*
t X tgzZ ] !*
Z !
Iz X M
h 07~h {z  M
h 0[iZ X M
h 07[{z  D Y
+ZX  CW bhZ {z  g '*
!
~ f c*
] }g \vZ6,
g
*ZiZ Lpg D J 7,0
+
iv N Y W\WBV
, ZX Z6,
}g zZ eB;~x Tpg D]g 0
+
iXn 07
63

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

}uz}}g bTX N Y >, Z N Y `

@*
4akZX V; }g jZVzi**
v ~V
t
/ZX} [ NZ LZ ._ gzZ t` Z'
LZ y
KZC

gzZ a LZ {z 4} kZ ~g a kZ x 
gzZ}[ NZ 5 Zg 9aLZ {z [ xC
C
~ 0
+
iX[ NZ
6,
g~g  BX[NZ 5 Zg a LZ {z
/Z x **

kZ Zg gzZ d
$
` Z'
}g ta kZ O% "z
]]_z ]c*
gzkZ g g 6,kZ [ Z 7 s GgzZ
X }7x **
\vZvZY +
yZ g6,
Vzq
yZ
/ZX **
Zg7
6,
kZ\WX !,
6g )vZY +
Z *
c gzZCq \W

:wZ

?e*
*{H

X *
@Y T
$ m{ c*
D 0*
7p Z
o6,
z ]zZ

:[ Z

+ZpSg 7 c*
] !*
L D c*
Y wx **
V2z R
]zZ
6q
-ZBV
KZ
tX ~g
/
V,
'
CY{g c*
bhZ,q

g~
Z c*
kZq H HR,

~ V~f }g \vZX @*
p ]Zg 3Z Vp D W yX @*
x 9z g: HgzZ
X 7]gzkZakZce xg7gzZ Lg7~f}g g 3Zq
-Z
] !*
X *
@Y {gS
-Z~fg 3Z {zQ ~g Zh
+y
}
/Zp
B X Sg c*
,q {z  n 6 q
-ZB}g 
X @*
7 BXCYw,q{zgzZ @*

( Y 200828)
64

}6
,
[

{,
6[
ZZ e

6,qm{ X
C 
g " izgC
~ *g g ! ` W
&N ~gzO @*
c*
Fg7g E
7ea
_ x Zz
/Zz { c*
i { c*
i @*
Y H { .Z (Book Reviews)
Xnq
&N
gzZ ]YgqkZ_ [\ Wt Z% ^g7g E
[ kZ Zuz% 7,[  @*
,{ WV Zz "7,LZ }p Z
&NXZg 9q
kZY x yWq
-Z[ ^g7g E
-Z 0
X YgzZ| 7,[n
pgp qgzZ]g 'y!*
i~q
-Z~
O{!gzZ 3[
$E 3E
}c*
}^
,YJ
-V p Y J
-Vzuz0
G
G
&Nt O$
8{ ^

,Y~WkZ~BgzZ '[ BB^g7g E

Zz[ kZ H ? H[  @*
Y t ~} ^
,Y }X
G
4O3![ Z ? c*
gg Z xgzZ [{zH
K EG

Z Z hLZ
O ? ! p H~ kZ c*
CY 0*
H~tzZi ? HtzZi kZ ?

z ]Zg Z }g xk!*
X x { c*
i ^g7g ,
- c*
[ g [
u @*
7{c*
{^
,Y|g {z Jx **
~bg
tX H'[kZ @*
Yc*
Ct} @*
sg V1J
65

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

IF
4&L[ J
], [ Z1Z[ kZX @*
Y 1 'Lc*
L G
-u
3{! ] **
{zq
/ZX H~
.Zt O E
ZyZgzZ]**
Z[Z1Z
h}g Z
M
q Zg F,
[ \ W& [g t X @*
Y c*

X

a {6,[ d ?}y[  @*
Za t wZ Z
76,x kZ {z ~p{z
/ZXZz
qkZg { ~gz
@*
p{z
/ZXnpkZ c*
ngk
,
g / 7,q
-Z Y
[~Vs9ZX Zgg Z Dq
-Z g
/ZgzZ o{z
c*
Vp[ {zWz kZ6,kZ 0k Q Yz {6,
Y} w
g kZ ~ ]g 0
+
K tgzZ Y0
+
K V{
X
T g
sg %Z

xk!*
}6,
V1zzX
~ V {X @*
b ] yZ
C 
 6,gx

Cg mZ ] 95 ~V1 ZzY ~}c*

~yZp x t J
-uq
-ZgzZ
CY ~ ] bb~T
Se **
f [ ? H[ ?
HT e  C 7Z
?
[zZi0
+
it?
yZ ~ Vz}g gzZ
CY  d@',kZ
] {z%kZce **
BzZi Zz[d Z
-N w {z gzZ
M
$
E
h wYb b~T g mZ (Z
c*
Zz {zp Y {)ztg 
Z
z~ kZ $
Wp
 Ve **
y Zz q
-Z d
U i LZ ~ V X C xz s@
66

}6
,
[

(Indian Nationalism) 46
,x *zygzZ g @*
y*zy Dr. Anil Seal
The [ y Z6
,qZ= D YRZ Zj6,

WE
-ZgzZ Zt Z "7,Emergence of Indian Nationalism
L 8q
H HwZVrZX c*
g Z
[hZq
-Z Z~Zg KZ ~D
-Z CZ Zz [ C
q
 VrZ ?
g}g Z
[ hZZ Zz \W
hZt}gz\WQ t Z zZi'\W
/Z @*
zZi
{ ' c*
[ dt
M
h t \ W:
/z [
N Zz: sg 6,g [ hZZ zZi \Wp Z
g{ W6,"7,[ {z}uz \W g Z
hZ[ Y
$E*zyt ZxH_[ ZjkZZ
gzZ ._0
G
# X

E
$ kZgzZ e
g mZ b a e
$0
G
$ D+&
+Z
Xg
E
E
!
{
yZ
EG43 m,Z t Zg ]!*
GL^z
$E yZ Zj y*zy p 7s %Z
 t 0
G
: y*zy m,
Z
/Z X HyZ Z (,6,V V #
V Vzm,
Z
+]
h
. ` W s Z
/8 y 8 7Z D Y {g IY c*
.Z vt D W
^
lpVyZ **
WV Vzm,
Z Z X: {)z whgzZ } wgVbgE{!
E
4E3E
$ (Colonial)Cc*
0
G
!*
WkZ EG
HX HyZ6,VE*zyVrZgzZ
}
CY Z._ ; `Z bZ ?Y 1t
c*
qb z i Z0
+Z gzZ Wq
-Z CZ V (Marxists) Himg
$E
V gzZ g @*
R',
 0
G
Z
yZ D
g @*
y 0*
67

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

X 5: Z]
.V
z$
+kZ q Z ]~ g @*
\WX $
7hZ[C

; `Z 0R',sZ
# [Z
9 ZkZ 6,
%Nc*
c*
9ZE
OF
{zZikZp
M
h p[
X
M
h
: (Z Xce xgg ZY)yk Z
z [ c*
[ g
'gzZ \WXi Z0
+Z W,Z6,Zg \WI**
c*
I nhZz ]Z f '
} Zg : VY *Z \ W{z { Zp6,kZ \W6,RkZn {eq
-ZtzZi
%Nc*
~f ZE
YZ n
z D{pX
M
hs%Z kZ
M
h
: W,O\ W# c*
4z  ~gz ',~g ZY)V Xce **
7
gzZ C pL[ KZ 'C
t U Zuz ~g ZY)X}
g L L6,q] ~z0
+y }Xce "Y ZjZ[ k Q
GL.g9 X ~
x gzZ V7,~
V
V #Z ] L LgzZ ~
V
{O X a Z
Z Cc*
{ c*
i c*
Yf~
V #Z ]gzZ a
GL.g9 ce D
]Ygq~
V #Z ] ~
V
bg~f ]!*
t
z D
]]uZzgzZ
HVY~y!*
iy WZ,: g dZgzZ
?I~: VY
9 6,g gzZ xgg ZY)
z D {6,[ Z
X ~gz
Vzuz [gzZ
DA
$%^g7g,
-Z
#  @*
ZatwZ[ Z
ZZ ~ }g ?Y 1: gzZ Y 1q
D Zzsg
wt p
/Z ) X CY Zz w (Precis Writing) ~g 3~ Vo)
68

}6
,
[

 t kX Le **
ug 6',
 a kZz }g
&NX ( nCfZ m,
E
Z LZ~ ],10 c*
5% ] ,50{zqZ Z u
c*
ZX Y ~ Zq ~ kZ CWx ~g 3t ^g7g
Ug '6, $;f {z ]zZ X F
F6,tzfg 3[NZ q Z
7b ~
/
%!*
{z LgzZ @*
Y VJ
-b ~
C [gzZ
8Y
!*
WxsZ~^g7gkZgzZ**
^g7g c*
**
3[ 6, !*
WxsZ }X @*
0*
!*
WxsZ] !*
~
CtpY~ C{)z ZV Z]Y~
~ ~g 3bx C
X 7
gtY C: #
|Zg Z y 0*
4.Zz[g 3Z
# W (Z
zq
-Zwg !*
g !*
X Zw
3O{!]zZ  7B p ~t X nZsg ~ i Z0
4Zp E
+Z
t wmZgzZ q
-Zt Xg 3C
q
-Z A@*
0*
73
7 ZIwZ Z , Z wVmZX $
Y q]g '
Yc*

zA~kZX Y: wkZ 8
-~[ @*
J
-Z
#$
W
~g 3 jS gzZ n Z4ZN Y `V 0*
B; k
,

X YYHqg ~
\W
/Z ?
vyMg \WOg~f LZ
z {6,[
 ~gz
7Zz { c*
i qkZ c*
~}g !*
[ Mg t
? Le rVY' ? H[ t, Zzt ~ Y ZZ~}g !*
[
~[
/Zt% Z kZ ? ZC~[ kZ]k QgzZ
{!
4E3E
. , Z EG
~
~ V1 6,g wVX Y H
/YQ 7Z
Vp
g Vzuz J
-yZ c*
D W7~V}uz Z
f
e wEZ
69

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

~ F,
',p
pgN q Z
+Zi6,'zg 7 c*
LZ ' p kZ X C 7
7Z Z Z Zzg r c*
.6
~
8{ ^
,Yt \W[Z X CY q
~] z)g fkZgzZZ ~
.tc*
{g%K wEZ
q wEZ ~
.6 La kZ X  kZ

z X @*
7Z z!*
wEZ ~
.6 LgzZ @*
Z ~ ]
X @*
Yc*
ZC
ZgzZ
C~DV,q
B 
India Wins Freedom Z
# ]z Zi W **

k',M6,]z yQ ._ z **
)i Z n ],M
Hc*
C
sv
.[ Z ci
+Z * India Wins Freedom [ kZX 
g
/
9M
N
],M **
C t g {X 8F
FF Z ],30 {
] 5 6,
( gz kZ c*
ZZ ~ #
B[ Z
5 H~ ] ,MyZ "Y \W t wZa \ W[Z X
Wt
g~}g !*
yZ gD+&
+Z {g !*
z Zi W**
?
]
Z {zth
C
+'
X: VYWZk
,
iz{z{ ZpX7 %]i YZ!{z
c*
z1VrZ6,b)kgz k Q Y7W,
O$;f z1w
] ,yZ ykZ ]!*
kZX
/6,V0*
V Zgzy
& 
g<
- ~7 H~ D+&
+Z: { zg0
+Z~ V', Z ~ Zi WLG
tZ
# n ] ,Mp?7VgzZ B yZ V Zi W **

LZX: x  7]!*
+Z ~ kZ Z x c*
Wt Z
c*
~*dwp | (,#
B[ ],Mce **
Ct ~}
$E
c*
WtwZ Z[ZX 7~] 0
G
c 0q
-Z
70

}6
,
[

c*
w$
+],yZ c*
zp
pguzg%Z Zi W**
q],M
YX ~gt }g q 5q
-ZgzZ
Hc*
7
& ZgzZ {z
H
) @*
Y ~
)
Z BzZ [  7 (Z~ ],yZ
c*
4E
0 6,]gz kZ c*
g @*
D+&
+Z T c*
CW7]g
N

t sgzZ @*
7(Z {z
/Zce ]!*
g {q
-ZJ
-ukZX @*
nZg **
Z Z h}{z
HZ ],M~kZgzZ ci
+Zh
+]
.t
8 rZ6,
X @*
7
[V X w c Z
:gzZce **
7v" { c*
i}

/ZX HtY c*
C B
z Y 0
+
KV!
 4
Hc*
#21~[ (kZgzZ#20Zz
/Z } t
t
y q
-ZY Y c*
i Z0
+Z V!*
+Z f
e x
~A kZvp
/Z ) CW7~p~ @*
7,7t
6,[
( Xs Z e] ,FFankZz Z}
Dk{ c*
i
c*
]uZz
/Zp
kZgzZ C c*
iuZutYc*
$Lgz}uz VQ]**
$Eq
ZgzZ y0
G
-Z
/ZX n
**
0
+
K
$E
wVkZXce
/VX Y 7,t
Y H7 0
G
oyzaO` mvZ G
*9g ~z**
nY 1970 $
Y ~
y q
-Z yZ g Zq
-ZXb ]**
VrZ6,3Zzz p=
E
~gzZ 1 Xh
e ~y
W~ Zg Z= kZ a \vZ H
~zq
-Z]!*
ZX }g
/D
z~y
WZV
HW:ZzzLZ
E
%~ Zg Z=TVg Z
/
]\vZ~ c*
yZ6,] z
71

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

TX KZ kZ VZi Z gzZ ( ~ M%Z ]z **

) 1X
E
O{!
q3E
/Z i Z0
+Z kZX Zg Zy 0*
~zh
+

Ct
& G
& Xce Y
x Zj y 0*
LG
/kZgzZ { ~
.ZLE
VrZ y 
3 P ~ Vzk
,
m,z6,
Z
& gzZ c*
hB}uz
X H Za W,G
3!
]g 0
+
Kt 6,x kZ {z Hce **
D] !*
kZOE
~ 0
+
KV!xk!*
? H] !*
9 ] !*

/Z n Cw ~
Yc*
w  t g i4 { c*
iX*
@Y c*
7w a kZ p CY
X}ttKZ 6,t{z
/Z Lgg a ] !*
kZg Z c*
q
-ZgzZ
96,g Zz\ W
/Zg Z~g Jzq
-Ztce **
VQaxC

zD
ZX N Y i V 0*
LZ\ W
H7,YzZt
/Zp Y Ou kZ
H
z qXR] !*
\ W ~gz"YgzZ 6,] !*
C

C
zDW
bZX gzy
KZ: VYo H{ ZpCq y
KZK:6,
C
EdN
Cq *ZX: VY Z *Q\ Wt { ZpK: L
C] !*
E
5_N]N\ Wc*
/4E
akZX $
t~ E
$
tkZ Yt
Ju ] \ W ;g Y  ByEZgzZ
kZX ykZ tq
-Z~kZX ,7nZ Z CZyEZ kZX
g
X nY H q kZ } 7,]gz q kZ {W\ W
/Zt {Z
+Zuz
G
GL1 ?7c*
]gz ] !*
H ~gzg w %Z kZ~}
Y ] ,kakZgzZ Y Y Hy ~}Lq
-Zb q
-Z ]gz
% i}[ q
$Z e ;gE- q
f
-Z6,kZ_LG
-Z` W6,gwV
M
h
72

}6
,
[

@*
{ i Z0
+Z "7,[ ~
z~
.zg r~[ kZX ~ ~
/e
$E
Hg (Z0
G
Z kZ] zZ

HH7{ .Z `g~
zkZ
kZ ~ V: ] ,k k0*
} $
+ah
e {^
,Y ] !*
kZ
/ZX
H
HHf V1X~g r

z[ kZ L
L VY~}Lq
-Z] !*
yEZ=z!*
kZpX H7{ .Z ' Z~(,q
-Z~yQ
/ZX Vj q y LZ bC

~ Y c*
VQ wZ0kZ
/Z
W{W{zgzZ 1t Z kZ ' kZ Yc*
VQ: wZ
6,
g {X YZg7 [ bkZX }[ AZ kZ~ lz Zz
(Z
/Z\ W

c_tv.ZzYceZz6,gD] !*
KZ
C

e h
e b LZ
z D0
+
K ta kZ ? zz H kZ
z DWZ Y [ Zy

W,G
& {W kZX } 7,VQ Z
ov gz
i Wa kZ Lg FBB
z Zz { @*
X ]gzo Z e
$.
G
E
+
\ WLZgzZ Y 1 {B CZ ] !*
kZ ]gz{ c*
igzZce b
[ gzZ WZ~kZ Y { c*
i _Y 1zJ
-yZym{
Z N Y D Wzp { c*
i AX Za ~4gzZ W~ Zg6,

/~}gzZ Zg ~g gzZ 7Z~_ Vgz$] ~g

c*
^g7g ,
- i W x LZce 6g~f }g ] !*
t X g 7yYgzZ
G
E
+
Np, [ sg
Y ` @*
Z ~ {BgzZ Z z D}g V V 8E
X N W J
- Book Review c*
[ Z
Vc*
0*
c*
zuP s Zz Z]zZ a [
]zZ X C7,**
VZ i: gz X @*
~gz g w X
CY ~Z
+
73

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

ce{p Z&6,
[kZ
tyZk
,
g ZZ[
$kZt
e
83kZpk
,
gzZ
{6,p Zg ZD
&\W
/Z
a}-[kZ k0*
}g } N*
\ W{z Y tgzZ
3gt
)
Z E
L _kZ
zDx [ c*
Z[ X 7R
c*
: ` W{z Z Z- eL L wz ` W Y *
@Y
` W
/ZX [ Z Ug wZyn" Z 'Reconciliation'
0*
*
@YUg
)
Z
/ZgzZV],z Y{6,
V1yZ
Z r$
+gzZ Sg r$
+Z [ B
zOX D Yb ],
-Z ? Y c*
q
q
-ZZ
t
% g c*
,
k
+ ~
?Y{c*
Yc*
C~VzSP?s Z
1
/Zc
?Y H i W?Y ? Y Hg Z }t wZ Z
V{gzZVpkZ sg [~Y ZZt iZzg kZ
, Z {xk!*
X Y ~} Zg KZ ~y
WgzZ Y c*
sg ZhZ h
x **
N l$){ L LzZp X 7wZ { a kZ p *
@Y
Z{zxk!*
~ V>yZXg Zz~]Zg Z}uzgzZr
L ]g L
] 
KZ Vc*
/ Z
Zp Vc*
/ Z~ X V1
Vz yZ X D H{~} Zc b Z'
z96,

{)z ~

E
$gzZtzZi CZ {zgzZ
C Vc*
0
G
/ b Z'

z
D Wt V

$E
$E
0
G
m{ q
-Z [
/Z Hg (Z0
G
VrZ X
y
$E
0
G
Cc*
!*
(Marxist) g v ]gz hZ Y ._
W c*
/'{z ZjkZgzZ $
7hZ [
6,V1 VpX
D
74

}6
,
[

yZX 7 0*LayZ E
0!NIF,
 z!*
}g Z0
+Y
hg \WtgzZ
}6,V1~ yZX
` 
M
~ ^!
}yZX
: ]gzZ: }Zq~ bZ

z]uZz ?Y oV!X
:%dZ gzZ `$c*
d
c*
g @*
[ Zz Dg F,
{ c*
it gzZ Hx kZ VrZ ?ce b
X 0[ Zzg Z *
V16,qm{ q
-Z p: J 7,{ c*
i  a Wx
z{zX
n
pgw g}/Z~akZ
rg p Vz
yZx Zz
~y!*
izg QXgk
,$N gq
-ZJ
-w:e
}iZ~g7i *bZXg 6,yZ {zgzZ
g Cg
/

Zzsg V V1 hZ %Z 7: p
/Z }t X

X
g=g f

[ZzwZ
tV;yZgzZ $
eZzg H}~ v* :wZ
? b

Z%C
!*
V ; }g X
f
e Z%* zq
-Z v L L

:[ Z

%1 y!*
i ~ m,
Z)uy*
0 Y C
!*

CY x Z Z Zz%1 ~ m,
Z s
Zz%1 ~ m,Z%Z X
7] ~~}g !*
X
x Z Z Zz
The New York Review of X
D 
g ZziZ ~ x Z Z

ZjV- / Z[ Z
( g @*
~ c*
q
-Z~ Books
Z} p Z [X *

@Y c*
{6, {hZx Zz

75

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

x Zz 
~ ~ m,
Z c*
~oyZ CZpkZgzZ @*
k
,

X N Y Z}{!*
6,yZ gzZ Y Ha } ~g
E
~} q :Z [ 5~ s Z
/Zcq
-ZLgzZ
M
h }O !{t ] zZ
gzZ ZE 
y bZXn { .Z kZ e 7,
/Z CY
V1 Zz W5~ yZ

Z ci
+Z ! Z ]Zg Z}uz
p6,dh
+
* ! f{zkZX CY~ Zg6,yZgzZ *
@Yc*
Zsg
}~}h
+`
dC
xk!*
X @*

% {(academic journal)
+ Zt h
+'
Y F
F6,tzfi
+Zt X @*
zmq
-Z
-Z Z
q
+Z`
X {)z
CWa}Xk0*
kZ
q] }
.
c*
Zz%1 ~ m,
Z ZX @*
6,[ szyxg q
-Z c*
a
~^ [ Le
$Zzgq
-Z Zsg V15~ * Zz
$E
gzZ hs %Z0
G
VV;zt] !*
hZ e
$Zzg kZgzZ
%NgzZiZ[ ~}X @*
X
D Yb 3UVz} E
rg
o 7 Wc*
i W kZ g e
$Zzg {V; }g
B V1 yZ C 
V; }g ~ ZZ X Z ( p )
G
E
! BOg!
$
CY p~ ]g W z E
~(,._gz k Q~ yZ X CY ] E
G

 y{ZuX %$
+okZ T (Z
X
J
L LVrZ/
gzZXA

$%* ~ Z E
LG4& W L gLzZ 
iz9g @*
5[ Z [ g
/: i M W Z [Z
X
Zpg o
y{Zut X o~i Z0
+Z Z kZOce O i Z0
+Z6 gzZ zg
Y:Z VrZgzZ W:I
CgCggzZ p{zzzk
,

pX 0*
76

}6
,
[

BBWgzZ oJ
-% kZ X s ZZ e
$Zzg o
U z c*

3 U Vz .Zz V; }g ~ i W~,
pg
z y!*
i KZ s~uzgzZ Cc*
h
+]
.sq
-Z 77v {z~ kZX c*
W
)x g Zu~i W~,
6,gwVXT e b F,
[ Z
t 2 **
[ Z ._kZgzZ 'gzh
+]
. T H~g Y y&L L
55~ y!*
i kZ Y c*
J (,WZgzZ Y HDy!*
i KZ Y ; g
k

HH Z ~g Y y&L LZ
# X Y c*
Zsg Vzq h
+]
.gzZ N Y ,q
{X aVzzq
-Z kZ
i Z0
+ZkZ ?ce **
Yb?ce **
X
,qt bggzZ @ yZX }gtc*
]c*
Z@
{z?
o ? *
@Y t ? H;#kZ ? H{
X Ws
g Ly+
$Y~uzosq
-Z~e
$Zzgd~g
zZikZ c*
bgZg}uz [ q
-Z
gb
lJ
-gz ~ ,a
gzZ BV kZ X [
Q !*

.McLZ OZ L L y0x Zg
ZizZ G
/
1Z x Z }X
$
Y
.nZ [ L ZizZ x Z a kZ [ q
] Z Z [ **
G
-Z x **
g kZ VrZOs %Z }p[ kZ yx ZgzZ 6,q
g gQgzZg [ZZ [Z [ Z V1 ~ X Hw ~gz r
, z !*
@*
**
[ ~ kZ X 3
~}}g [Zt gX Cps~ o
/Z
+Zg " X w={ c*
i t [ Z ~ 1
H ! Z i Z0
+Zp
77

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

X *
@Yc*
6,
g['~X
CY
y Wz }i~ pyZ c*
gV1 %Z kZ ]gz
kZ ? ~ Zg H~ZkZ ? M7X HX .ZzY O5"!
Xce HZg
g t
/Z ? gz$ c*
g
Jut ? yY X~
sq
-Z t VY c*
r z
~g {gzZ Y 36,V1 i Z0
+Z kZ
* zX :
L J(,
WZzDt
z} Z
] Mg
Dg Z 6,kZ {zgzZ q Z { Zj Z z D~
X

VZX
g C/zgzZV;}g Zj
~zg Z ._] **
~X  Z 6,Vz
XX
~ V {
z kZ:e Vz Z
Z Z
i Z0
+Z H~ yZ X

Vz J
-~g7 i * ~z~
HHg (Z
Z
Z,jVzq ? C
p { c*
i~gZ+?
q/Zz ` Wp
/ZX
$
Y@~ yZ ,q
t ?
)g fT=g fe
$.` W 7, p
 Zg fv
i
h [ NZ [ vx gzZ yZ V { v sz^{ c*
M
X

kZ :kZ '{z ~gzag {H

:wZ

;g {,
^Y ~WQ{z#
ZgzZ ?{ W ]&v kZ *
c a
X
454e ,q x t ~fkZ
G
6 g~ ZZ[,
qZ *
c G
%M
? YY3F
78

}6
,
[

H H~ [ kZX n [ Qst ]gq

-Z :[ Z
x H~Z0 qkZ [ kZ ?
Vx{ HgzZ Vp H~ kZ
G
tZ~Vzk
,
KZL X3Z? }3ZMxk!*
pX b C Juq
-Z ?
Y @~ [V#,mZgzZ t ~ kZ
}!Zj
$
~uz KZ '
/Zpce 6g i%zJ
-[ m{ Q ] zZ X
{ c*
i~ Zg KZ \WgzZ c*
!Zj ci
+Z LZ c*
3g}!Zj [
X
o_vakZ
T e**
~4
/Z p kZ
[ ~uz 4V T e **
{ jg7 \W
 Y c*
C ~}
/Z X
D Wci
+Z 6 V1 bZX B| 7,
aVzZz h
+y

[gzZ ~g t ZZ H6,ci
+Z~ ci
+Zh
+]
.
bZX **
_],Vz 5gzZ Z6,\ WakZC
gzZ
gz V"
$s~kZp xxz Ttp
/Zce Zgt\W
/ZX
~
c*
, ay

9zgg ZD
z\ W6,
C b & ZkZ Hp b & Ztp
 Y c*
Ct
/Z X z!*
V!KZ [  k0*
\W

K 
s Z
/Zc6 c*
k
,
zZ c*
Z ] ,100~ Th
+]
. '
%Na\ Wci
*\W [**
ZF
+Z G
n
pgp qkZ\W
/ZX
Xce9 ci
+Z
\W6,T+Z ) t : 1 t ? ~gz **
sg ' H
E
E
E
E
43{! c*
43{! qn( Vn
EG
!
M
hZz\W EG
pg:]g
"kZp Y 7']zZ X
$
] ~}g !*
:
L p
pg {0
+
i'
[ Z [ L L[ q
-Z ~gz o0X k
79

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

p
zJ
-VzSP] 0'kZX 6,q[Z
kZ 6,[ 'C
X CY Y6,g " Z q
-Z [t
hqgz] : e
/Z@*
7eZ **
q] ~}g !*
454Xe
G
t?
yv kZ qzZi?
rgmgz{z G
{k
,
igzZ ] \W kZ ?
~gzJut p
$
]
X F
F6,[
O{!\W~}iZ?
h
Ms %ZJu 3E
qZ

:wZ

yx Z \W 6
Ds %Z { *
c i \W/
Zt gzZ
{YZqZkZ\W H @,
' *
![ZizZx Z[
?
h
M

.nZ L L :[ Z
X q Z q
-Z i kZ ( ] b!*
V2 c*
g ) G
.nZ L gLzZ G
.nZ [ L L VrZX
g
X K.
Z G
/
1Zx Z yx Z
Y
z { c*
i yx Z
-Z Z ZL ~ V- !*
V q
WX Dg Z
/~
$E
t0
G
ZizZx ZX #
|Zg Zt: 7vZzWC
!*
7~r~(,
X V)
Tg~ V|Zg Z q yZ ] Z Z 
]z V/(Z
Dt yZb)yZgzZg )

gzZ 3 ]!*
LZ LZ ~ V1 KZ Vz X
Tg ~
$ECZ CZ
H t `
@*
) ? Z H ~g ZY) } Hy 0
G
454Xe
G
] i Z H H7Zax ?ce **
Y1LH`
@*
)q
-Z ?G
454Xe
G
H c*

M
hZ
zt H)q
-Z ._Vgz kZ ?G
$E
}uzq
-Zp Hx 0
G
LZ LZVz6,kZ ?
$
YC',Z
80

}6
,
[

$E
wEZyZgO r ge
$Zzgq
-ZgzZ s %Z0
G
X
HH
~uz
Zz {\WC
? YZJu{yt ] !*
E
E
$ IxsZq
$ kZ
gzZ 0
G
-Z0
G
/Z ? @*
{zZi{zB
YZp{z
/ZpXce **
YZ {kZq
- 4,
} !YVzq p Z {z
[k Q
/ZgzZ YW~gz$~bkZ 7p
rgzZi
g {~ T {z {YZX Y ` @*
gz$h
+'
{z c*
{%7,
WzgH ZJ 7,6,g}g7 [ kZ
gtzZi
Z N Y C F,
Vpt c*
V: Vpt
/ZXF
F6,bgzZ
g {z
X YCW~YZ}9
Lo
~}% [ H ? ZX~[ :wZ
Zz+,
6 gx t wZ Zuz ?7*
c ce *
* Y Hy
g 'qZ }
Dg{{zgzZ C 7 W zZi
HgkZ *
@7xZz{gzZ ;gZjxi Z
? YYH {dYZqZ (Z/
ZX ;gx t

$E'
zZi
/ZXce **
x i 0
G
z {t ]!*
:[ Z
6,g ] v X 7Z } V: ] 0
'ce **
Zz~bc*
}X 7{YZ {zpB| 7,Z
$E Zz {gzZ H0
G
$E
X *
@YT e:g Z kZgzZ H0
G
~uz
\ W
/ZX6,Mg \ Wt? ~gzH **
C[]E
L N[]!*

sg [kZv~ w\WgzZ
Z
ZCc*
#
/Zcq
-Z
kZn
/ZX $
]!*
~ q
-Z Y bs Z
81

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

YB{ YZ q
-Z {z z!*
kZ X Y Y c*
;] !*
KZ @',
Sg W~ ~g (ZX V { W zZikZ [\W
~J
-ugzZ% ?7c*
~gz7,kZ ?7c*
ce Z[ 
Rq
-Z
_x Z ] [
/Zt {z $
"
$U*
yzq 
y~],0*
% kZQ ZzJu: yZJ 7,
sg { c*
i 
~wq [q
-Z@',
kZX 7]gz
{tOX 7B p~% kZ [
7 W: 7
X D',[AZ kZVgzZ}y%J
-ugzZV{z g
X [f0yx ZgzZZizZx Zt ]*
!qZ

:wZ

LZ yx Z
 V- n ._ ] ~
L X3Z ] Z Z ZizZx ZX HY Zg W 1Zx Z *Z
.nZ [,
7 yx Z kZ G
6 kZ VrZ ?Zz H
.nZ ZZ L L - 1Z x Z
Z L yZ [p/
Z X ZizZ G
gzZhgZg LZ {z,
6 ] }g z*
! kZp
z*
!gOX
e
ft Z ZizZx ZhgZg *Z LZ
X CY *
0$
eZzgqgzZhZqZ
qZ/
Z }?ce g~fMg z {Ht wZ Z
yWZ y),
F L L /Z L L } r{a +
ZZ
` z bg Z
?} ,
7tH,
6}kZ ?V: Z]ZyZ H {)z

Xt] o] Zj- 1Zx ZgzZ ZizZx Z yx Z :[ Z

t ~ kZX @*
r._Mg yZaZ
+Z`
Zg {q
-Z] zZ
IF
4&]!*
gzZ c*
a /Z L LKa yWZ y)F,L L\W{ Zpce D
bgL G
82

}6
,
[

\W
g J
-ukZXce xg q
-ZzZi \ WXa g
-Z [Mg }h
q
+`
q
-Z e
M
hZb)Zi Z0
+Z
\W7et p Yt
ZjkZX }uzgzZ, Z { c*
iU
m{X
K ,MtZabgZzZi
zZigzZVzn Zz6,VZz {z Y7]g t WhZz ]
-Z ]c*
q
9gzZ y z y!*
ig Z]gzMg %ZX ;g]!*
B
X Yt
J
-u
?}LZg { :wZ

g rLX *
@Y H{aX
DZ7g {C
:[ Z
 @*
(Z LX i W c d5q
-Z{6,[ q
-Z
s ] }g ]!*
t @*
s %Zh
+ ]Ygq [
" Zg fgzZ *
@Y c*
~ ^}O g Zgtg Jg Z kZ
~ [ yZBv @*
*
@Y H{ W V@*
gzZ V!kZ ~ V/
+'
h
~ ] LZ $
c d~g {X CY 0*
V
$E
g
 Y tX Y**
g kZ c*
0
G
Y**
d @*
N Y { W kZ }uz
T e\ WgzZ S7,[hZq
-Z \W
~ ]zZ Zq
-ZgzZ zZi LZ LZ Zz {Xn > *
X Lg @*
Zsg V1gzZ q}']Z
P 
C Zj
:wZ
454Xe WxE~gz
G
ag {HX $Y 7%kZ G
454Xe,
G
?G
7V#Q
+Z
83

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

M Q qkZ ;g Y {6,[T {t C
!
:[ Z
7NY z~ ZZXce **
kZ 7 6 Zz [
/Zg { F

BZ'q
-Z 7
gt X
7Z~ ]!*
kZ @*
ce **
d
$
d
$

G
E
.n$yZ
PZX 7yY~ kZ e r{z
/ZgzZ}{6,yW
LG
454Xe i
G
ce r7ZgzZ q7{'C
6,[C
zz X G
G
E
B-!
{
4
}
E
a VzgzZ The New York Review of Books X G x t
C&~g v m
gzZ
DC
yZyLZ
Dvzg {~] OE
+
i
{z
/ZgzZ K: }{z :t
/ZX C ~g Z
/~ yZyZ VrZ 0
t GX
C7x }h
+`
kZ
C7x }kZ~ * d,
kZ [ kZ @*
VQ a }6,[ Tce Y g o
~ci7{z @*
ce /Zz Q ] ~
CkZ ]c*
9
4&_ ZtgzZ
_ ZZX ^N"q
454Xe6gLIG
F
G
-ZtvgzX
X G
{+
hI q ,
4DL X3Z q gzZqZ {z[ :wZ
: Z {z *
@Y $L{ .ZgzZ ",
7 ~ kZgzZ CY
c !
Va,
6} ,
(}uzgzZ s W- - gug *
c EL LD Review article*
}+
h
`*
c g ZpZ+
&  *
@ Book editor *
c Review editor ~
]*
!t~uz ? wH \W~}g *
!k QX r
gx Z ~
qZ {zgzZ
` 0g DL X3Z~*d  *
c W~ 
yZ VrZ
e
fx *
*V155a,
WO}uz
M%ZgzZ[f(C~*t ]*
! g\WX *
@H7_
g & 7q {ztp/
Z ) PolemicsX ~ $
eZzg d
%Nnx*
c v~ T CWl F
qZ wq (

84

}6
,
[

X
DW~}g *
![

0 q~ q
-ZtReview Article c*
!: Z :[ Z
*
@Y c*
J (,W] !*
KZgzZ *
@Y H{6,V1 n
pgt V1
}X
M
hU kZX yZq
-Z Z~xsZ L L6,gwVX
?
Z Hp Z Z g He
$Zzg kZ ? H Z
Z~b)x 0
+
i$q
-Z c*
? Y
C
Z H ?
H] i Z Z
b)b gzZi b)x 0
+
i$q
-ZV; L X3Z ?
rg
A&
a
zq
-Z ' yZgzZ @*
]Z Z z ~ J
-{)z u
zZi LZ \ W6,b)
yZ X
b) 0 ]Z Z X @*
i
Xce **
Z Z
z kZ H
gc \ WX
!q
-Z ._
6,qkZ
M
hCt h
+'
X}{g Z Z }: Z
q
-Z
M
h\W
ht U Vz tgzZ [ X Y 1| 7,Q g[ V#
M
~Bp qq
-Z~}\ WV- X
M
h} Zg KZ6,kZgzZ


M
hv z s Zt ] !*
ZX ~ Zsg [q
-Z \W

Z **
+ L sX VZz xEh
+]
.BBkZpV+ L
kZ~ [ V#N C }!Zj [ \ WBkZX 7a
%Nc*
$E
qLZ \W bkZOX ZE
YZt ~ kZgzZ ~ Z0
G
X N YD Zsg ~BgzZN YD J (,
W
W c*


z kZ V1P!q
-Z w!: Z
IF
4&
[
gzZ N YWt Ux T qZg7 q
-ZX *
@Y gL G
7
X !: ZN Y D Zsg BB\WZ[
7 ZjkZ
85

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

{z ,}6,g[
z N Z7sg ~B\W
/Z
X Y{g!
gzZ}}uzQ ,] !*
-Z~ [ \W 47
q
ot
-Z kJ W{z 4{ c*
q
it ak
,
akZX N ZC
Z~}a
c*
Xq Z
n Y!: Zq
-Z6,yZ @*
}Zj
zskZp
7~[
, ZU Z e **
Ct
/Zg !
X e~: Zg Z kZ ceY~
i
| 7,[ q
-Z ~
z q
-Z CZpV_ E
L 8 { c*
: ZaMg iZX Y1| 7,

W6,
qkZ Oh
e
@*
{ c*
igzZ *
@Y y Wr! )g fkZY 4{ c*
i!
6,q q
-Z ~ i WZ
+Z`
z bg Zz 
a kZ X
X

!: Zgt V1kJW
@*
)
*
!Juq=*
**
c q=[ *
* }

:wZ

? *
@Z Zg Z H~J ,
(Wc[{gzZ

c*
[  7~gzt ?
H
Fi 9 :[ Z
g66,"7,[ VWh
+]zZ X: w=[ Y
/ZX
v Z~0*
6,kZ~ y 0*
7,{ c*
i { c*
i^V#
e
Zg s[ VJ
-uq
-Z}X, qz 7,Q&
+
e &
+
e
L
X
D YJ
-[ V}t] zZX

W:
[ C
Z sz^a 0
+
iX
DV1 Vz wv
t pX Y Zgq
-Z Vz 4{ c*
ia kZ $
Y 7Z
/tgz
86

}6
,
[

[ X Ytgz kZ ~g h
+y

[ 7~gz
X
f
ewq~O 8~w=V1
g ZD
q
-ZX D 0*
7 Z Z]Z dgzZ: Z`
@*
t ! Zy

V; }g
:gZ c*
Y c*
: t{ Le **
Zz7{akZ**
[ Zz79zg
&L : [ gzZN Y b bkZ Y c*
X 4{ c*
i : {ZX E

s$
+]**
sgVBB
zpX }g (Z3 Zg g {zakZ
}{zX @*
W {D 7~{!*
]!*
kZ +**
dX
Tg
Z [ ]zZ Xzq
-Z ]g yZ c yZt X
a
iZ ~ w yZY *
@Y c*
\Y 6,kZ {C W7~ Lg
%N6,|
X
M
h wZ e W,Z ZE
# z
kZ}tgzZ C |
# z
{ c*
i[ }
W~  @*
N Zz{6,V1 KZ {z 
t ~ ] Z kZ
x`
@*
c*
iDpX Y 0*
Y { c*
i?kZgzZ 4' yg
a {W{za kZX
n
pg Zg Hvy~}g !*
' *
@Y
{6p
D G]Z W,
Z}ZX
M
h[NZ '4
G

{~g Z V;}g XV
Z ._ QV Z
Zc*
E"O%] Z W,
&L V\ kJ Wh
# z
|
V\ g ez 
{~}h
+`
dgzZ N Y E
+

&L : [ q
yZp E
-Z
z$
+} et Zg +**
X V
k ;
^WW,@*
tgzZ
D 
vt
CW,@*
-Z {?Yc*
q
\W{z , {tZ \ W kZs zz X {Z
+ 7Z
( Y 2009s6,Z D 2)
87

X
gz[

q
-Z6
,
yZdC1 @

qZ,
6yZdC1 @
Z6,
Y/Z e
n
:
L Z (,
kZ g ez yZd C1 @ T *
z kZ
~g tzzkZX A
l %gzZ A
l { c*
in
X ;
7
Z~ yvz tzz : ^X 7z ~ x Zzg
x **
gzZ V: yJZ ~ VjZgzZ V
/Z YY V- ]!*
kZ X
**
z ! x c*
yvz ?7, VD
:g e
Z ]g `
@*
-Z
q
/Z X  Cg66,y
KZ  ,q +Z
@*
`
@*
zz g e yvgzZ ?}VY{ c*
i {z **

~ kZ bkZ @*
n YZ V @*
4g y LZ
yvg7Z V
/Z ]g ~x ~g X @*
Z
ZZ" ~ n
X @*
7,7t
7Z Y b n
Y7
n
7D3Zzn
ZzYb}
.t
/ZX Z b
Z
/ZpX } n
yY bhZgzZ o Z {z~
O X } } n
@*
})}k
,
ZC
{z Y 7yv]g Z
zz ~uzX **
:
Z~yvz zzq
-Z Z ] O]IZ~ n

Credit t X c*
gz !*
}V VMN W+Z ] Z Z  t

gZ nq
-Z ~ Zt X Y Z`
Z ( w$
+ y **
n
) Default Swaps
89

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

Zzh
e n
C y **
/Z X @*

Y 1h
+y

Z n
X ()
N Y $ yv\ WgzZ N Y b \ W gZ kZ @*
7:Zz n

gzZ yY bhZ
/Z {z Credit Default Swaps }g Z Z X
/Z }X $

Zz~]yZdCV|gZ 6D
\Wt}X C,q F \ WvgZ  D Z ~h KZ \W
0
+
i bZX {)z 7c*
cZg ~h 7c*
8
-Zg e k0*

\W T7hn%k
,
(Z \W CYyYa
X @*
YH7\ W~]g+ZX$
Zz]
Swaps

gzZ yY % Z t ~ x ~g p

X ;g @*
Z" ~ n
% bZXg D Yb ( w &w$
+)
V(Credit Rating Agencies)V Z Zz{ i Z0
+Z s~uz
E"
H
G
5G3H
4
5
G
X W: 77Z
HyEZh
+'
Vzz Tb uiZ
X Z: (Z~|p
(Creditor){ Zpn
sV Swapst
/Z ZtX Zuzq
-Z

 Y t bZ C gZ K6,
Z6,c*
g i W h
+y

Z
X V:g ez yv\ W {y **

/Z 1p\ WLZ}n

\ W

&p
\W  T e **
ZzgZ ~h
/ZtngZ g /GG

tkZBh
+y

gZ ~h \ W WgzZVp Y7tM
hZt
VM bzV x yZ V gZ X q 3 Z Z}
.
/Z
~x ~g X Y {g !*
vgZ bkZ ZgZ
Credit {z Vg " }uzgzZ 1n
T c*
n
T Zt
] !*
gzZ] ZgD

90

q
-Z6
,
yZdC1 @

F,
Vz
Z izg ~ kZ : i `z uZ
# Xa h
+y
Default Swaps
X ayQmSwapstVX by **
gzZ g
H7,b z Z

Z~yZgzZmSwapsg ZD
q
-Z
/ZY 7
~ kZ Z } h
+y
Swaps t Vg "a X W: 7
Z
Z}uz {Zpn
s:
Hc*
n
Wq
-Z
H4ZK
~: i`zu z Z
Z VpXah
+y
Swaps
X W~(,~x ~g c*
WwZzi~up;g
w$
+ )}  D [
7 Swaps nZ~ Lg
+ y **
c*
(Foreign Exchange Swaps)
# (Credit Default Swaps)w$
Z
g Zl {z) derivatives c*
Swaps iZ e gR
,656 Z qzyZdt
* g kZ X Z Z Z
# Zz ~ Lg ( } e wp b g Zl ~uz
H: i Z( iZ e gR,
57 ) (GDP) Gross Domestic Product
* ~g7tpkZX Z Z Z
# Zz g ~(,Xt @*
{ i Z0
+Z Y
Y
gt W6,uZ
#  ]!*
DX gt { c*
i 5EN12 GDP
gzZ Swaps yZ Z b kZZ ~ ^ Z kZ X } Za X
~yZ~p Z}uz 6%~B;Vb 0*
C
# z
|
derivatives
x **
kZ WZg fZ
# g ]
}
.{ c*
i6,
z Z LZ v
gzZ : Zg7 Vzz LZ V|t
uZ
#  Z gzZ { {
X IZa ])

[ZyZdC1
kZX **
:
Z~ yvz zz ~] ; z yZd C1 @
91

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

Credit {z H{ W6
, n
@*
V q TgzZ A
l " n
{z

kZX } yZ ~
/
% VtzzgzZq
-ZX default Swaps
g Zt V Z Zz ~ zggzZ { i Z0
+Z ~g !*
zg {z
z!*
{y **
V Z yZ bkZ {zX Z ez CZ~ yZd
bkZ ZZ" Xah
+y
Swaps kZ VO X ~~ zg hZ yZ
hedge

c*
V 5Z Z V Za
HW} h W CZ V Z V 

V; yZg !*
zg : ~zg hZ
/Z eVrZ Z C funds
VK p%6,] { Z
V VrZOY
t g g !*
zg V ZgzZg OZ V~ V @*
c*
zg4 4
qgzZq
-Z {zkZX ZZ" ~ n
zz T :
L gzZq
-Z
# z
n
{z ZZ~ n
zz T
~xsZX (Sale of debt) |
n
\ W
/ZX 7]i YZ &n

@ (Script)kZ\W c*

: iq
-ZX **

Z',}
.: :Zzc*
3ZzkZ p\WX M
h7
gzZvZ @*
Zz[Z1? VY ~0*
t \vZ @*
Wwt =
Zi W~ & n
\ WgzZ: ~0*
t
/ZYX  9 ~
V wg kZ
bkZX Wh
+'
kZgzZgzZ kZ~
@t \ W t V
Y,gzZyYbhZVY~ n
\ WgzZ g t
}
. a\ WX
H (Risk) }
.\W~]g
@kZ
yZgz kZ eX W{zg !*
~y
Wk0*
Tk Q g e
/Z 7
7Nw$
1gzZ c*
n
:Dt~y
WkZgzZV F
+
B; Vp
7
@n
\ W @*
Y H6,kZ xsZ
/ZX
H@
l n
gzZ ;g @*

t1
] !*
gzZ] ZgD

92

q
-Z6
,
yZdC1 @

X @*
: (Z M
h
Z ZwT ) ^m^ n h^] ] L
L !kq
-Z~!
{z ga
/ZX ( } e Q ( 7ZwkZ T)
H
9
N}]g9zgg ez
Y^ F
HZ
/ZgzZ Y 7Z }~ga
Zw~*kZ $
+Z t vZt OZX n {gi !*
~ga {zQ
,gz$g0
+Z }+ \ WZ
# pX Y $ 7~ ]y
W Y $
E
$ Q :g []y
X ( g D e ) Y . G
W~fV
7 yY bhZa
sq
-Z ;g @*
~x
: w right of recourse ~ & n
gzZ ]i YZ & n
X
H3g
Zzh
e n
{zgzZ n
\W ~
/ZtRight of Secourse X
{z
Hc*
n
T7 kZ Yb {zQ @*
{y **
s
u @*
YHwEZ ht
/ZX c*
ntTV~p {y **

aZ~ n
C
OX
Hc*
t p$
W~ ;n
J
N

{ c*
iLZ @*
YtV~}, Zq
-ZgzZ ~^g b
n
\ W, n
{ c*
i { c*
i\ WZ
# YYc*
J (,
~]gZ gzZ J(,{ c*
i
o CZ\WO ~O 8 gzZ A z\WkZ N Y
\WQ 7~g Z)f \W @*
{y **

/ZgzZ
HJ (,
]g7Z ~ Z ; t ~
/
%V } (,bZ X ,e
OZ ~g7 o N Yx **
} (,} (,
/ZY Y c*
7{y **
t gzZ (deposits) ]YX U*
Z gR,
b k0*

/Z }Y
kZ V} (,
O $
2~ uo}g @*
x **
93

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

X N V0*
%KZ6,
;
 {zkZX ZZ Z" ~ V
zz X [Z {zt
{)z f eg ^i
+ bkZ  X g Zz~ ; n
K
\W **
5Z Z\ W
/ZX ` Zzg pn
)g f
$Ng
\ Wu\WbkZ Dh
+y

7q{z\ W : ~g F
/Zs 5
A KZ
X Z
Z,j~g Zh
+y

6,n
)g fCredit cardsp Sg~B;
( @*
6, Z
Zb *
0 ) yZ0
+{ O%Z zZ q
-Z ._} i Z0
+Z q
-Z
k0*
yZ0
+{ 7k0*
: {Z
Zt X  D i eg ^i
+{a {k0*
X  CY ~ ] F,
a wEZ i eg yZgzZ X Zi eg
$Z6,c*
f
@g wy~M%Z ( @*
Y H7 pkZ ~y 0*
)
$Nn
# OX n
Z
{ c*
iGDP~g7110 GDPk%Z ~g F

X (,
G] ) ;{ c*
i Z n

Teasing
HH{ Wah
e n
V bkZ 

%5Z Z!
H @g )g f $
Y$
+ b+Z rate
, qzkZ ,: 5Z Z V&z qz tQ Bh
+y

Y Z
5Z Z Z
# g y
Wp
HZh
+y
y &,q 6,n
gzZ Zg v O
zz  kZX ~ J(, b ^NxYI Za ] ) c*
W
z
**
',
3,
g ~
/
%M%Zs Z Z 
kZX J (,n

;g
t
zTpX Kg (Z jZ)~~r kZX H
!f{z } zg m,g wg 8k%Z **
', +
/Xg l{ {z
~ Zi WkZgzZce ~ Zi WnC
V zkZX qxi Z w_
] !*
gzZ] ZgD

94

q
-Z6
,
yZdC1 @

x {z 0*
a ~
/
%O X M
h 7 n\ W6,
~rg
/ZX KZp{zX} Zj~r]5
-Z 6 @*
q
V x t 7x ~rt |g X uzgZp
A\vZ ) !^e m ^ %] ^_^e n ] ]L
L @*

g Z~g
$u
]c*
Z@\ WyW
X
zg)g f#
{ c*
i kZ Yuzg)g fyW

zz xi Zw_X x #
tY7**
p]xKZp Y}
7a1zgZ ~
/
%pg^Wt
~ n
iz',izgtq g F,
y$
+y u VZi **
6,kZ vgzZX ;g
pzg m,
gwg 8{z$
uzgZ" kZ~n
q~y
WX ;gZ
qz **
k
,
+wZziuZ
5
# Q
H`@*
Z~n
ZX H: k Q
X If(,
] )kZgzZ qzy **
}vP
gR,1Y 3 gzZ 1we Vb: wg~g kZ wq
~]g Z ZLh+'
V Zz Z ZLc*
Zg tXK Z Z ViZe
XN Y8Y^ h+'
Q c*
b

uw
Z qzyZd C1t
zT ? 3uH wt]!*
[Z
Z Z g zg m,g wg 8gzZ V[ Z X iZ e t40q ]YX U*
Z p V
iZ et800 g ]YX U*
Z pyZgzZ c*
eV
Y
nuzzkZXauzgB;VzzyZdD{ c*
i 5EN20
iZ et40Z
# ,{i Z0
+Z\ WpYW OZ Z hQ~ ~r[Z Y
QYW OZ Z hLg X, HiZ et800Wn
',
i+Zzz
95

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

~g Zi !*
u
H3g a kZ ^Nb
z kZX Z Z" ~ ^N
YX
) !*
nqt B n
{ c*
i v ^NbX g D
X ;g Y H Za {g !*
z :
L Z kZ :
L Z yZd A
l { c*
i n

yZd kZ c*
WyZdzz T
H1 { c*
i n
 Z ~ V Zd}g
| (,]YX U*
Z p V X X ay
x g VgzZ J ~
/
%a% e
gzkZ c*
WyZdQX
H1n
{ c*
iQ c*
W OZ Zg f ~ Lg Z
# X
kZQ i~h OZX
Hc*
Zh
+'
~C
i kZ
Hc*
C
i a
CY0C
i z Zz X
HWyZdzzY{ c*
in
W W
g Z ^Nba
3 yZd wq ]g
z kZ X
{z WyZd Z kZp g}2
g ay
#

t q Zz Zh
+'
~ ^yZdX Zz] O]I{ c*
i yZd {
High

k 0*
V zz }g kZ X ;g | (,{g #
O%Z

C Za (  M
h}2
{z6,
CT]YX U*
Zp{z ) Powered Money
VY h
+g{z WyZd Z kZ M
h{ i Z0
+Z \WX
N Y| (, iZ e t800zz ay
Z" V] YX U*
Z
a }g
z kZQ #
X Z ~ n

Z
J e Zg t uZ
# W
zq
-ZJ
-Vg t } ZZ
X 9!*
{z~]x xsZ,gz!*
v
zkZvZY 
yZX Y

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

96

q
-Z6
,
yZdC1 @

[Z zwZ
Zj n( } Z/
) - ~ @ :wZ
~ *
!HgzZ Z$
"*
U H~ ,
Fu{z *
c VQx
? YYH (Z

~ ^NV;zp W~4~ u kZ 7~ kZ :[ Z

| 7,yZ ] p n
Vg t I yZ X
H3g x
%~Z @*
YHwEZx **
VgakZ`7pg !*
zg CZ'g
{nv p F,
Vzzx kZ GX @*
Y~
A
Effective rate of interest p 18 ^Nby QC
Y 
Effective rate X Y VJ
-85 ._ Vzi Z0
+Z gzZ4030

VnZ\W  D Y h
e n
\ WZ
#  t Z%of interest
^Nb gx tX b ^N18\WkZX C**
5Z Z
gzZ/YZk0*

/Z~]g+ZX Effective rate of interest{z
Zg e" {z 0*
^:g !*
zg
/Zp nQ @*
Y[x {z
}Z
/
gzZ M
h7,PU*
Z LZa5Z Z n
ZYX @*
YW~
n
\z
/q
-Z Z
Zb 0*
tg iyZX 3g" ~ zn

X, Z Z n
v !*
n }: n
~ yZ
/Z @*
g Z)f 5Z Z
Z e !*
6,kZ g6 Zv !*
0*
: Z Z n
zz q
-Z
/ZO
zz kZX @*
Y 7,
CZd
$}g e" a5Z Z n
gzZ @*
Y
LZ W {t ~ kZp q hZt X 99 5Z Z n

c*
0*
^g !*
zg kZ @*
0*
7t W
zf
e n
X M
h 7,& PU*
Z
97

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

{z %g F{zV ~h
+y
n
}X 7
x **
/ y
KZ V  M
h ]5 }g , Z X YW~
) Z @ X ,7,& PU*
Z }g LZ Wa 5Z Z n
gzZ Y
X `{ny ~kZ I}cZZ
QY:Zzn
tZ
#
HHf~}g !*
M%Z 6
n
e A\WQ ,
@kZ} n
\W ? Y VY
z n

@*
Y 7,~ W
/Z ~x kZ {X A oD \ W,
xsZ ~ kZ X **
:Zz n
Z N Y ,
- ,q ~g kZ {Zp
y Z  ~
q4 Y c*

7Zd
$ v tg i
n
yY[pZz n
 {Z
+t kZX
Z~yvz
wtVX Y c*
n
)g fyZi {)z{g YZ Z%Q c*
X }
~] q
-ZXg!*
tXN Yv n
v bkZ
{z  g !*
WV;z yZ0
+{ yZ0
+{ kZ Lg k',; k',
Dg Z)f { c*
i~ 5Z Z n
vd
$ 
H , zX Yv
n
{z Y7(Z Wd
$ f
eZs n
V vZX 
XM
h}7n
Vd
$g " !*
nZ ZtO :Zz
{z **
+y
h

g
/Z }) {g YZ Z%6,
C
Z~ yvz
sZ v c*
{)z ( g @*
Z Z 7 {z 9
L o kZ Y VQ6,}g YZ kZ
pX j4{ c*
i} j }Z/
tYc*
n
)g fVh
micro

- Zz }Z
/X D71 ! t Z Zg

xsZ yX
Hc*
x Z .
ZgzZ c*
;kZ e~ }g !*
credit
] !*
gzZ] ZgD

98

q
-Z6
,
yZdC1 @

qz6,
jsZx n
bZ  !7tLD
Wz b }Z
/p }g Z Z, Z6,e z~ y 0*
X ,
X 7 x
! Z
yx ~g ~ZyZd{  *
@kC(Z :wZ
",
7 }pZz ~ V zpX Z Za zz
Zjx }g7 }g7 yZgzyZdkZ *
@{i Z+
0Z
$N+
tux Zg F
h H
tgzZ VQ]Z
 #
szt qZ X Y x *
* (Capitalism) x ~g Z
$N,
VY {z,
6 W~}g *
! x }g F
6 C
V{ x ~g
9 IVQ,i ZzW+Z yZgz kZt wZZuzX g6
iyZd kZ~ zg ]xsZ H ? *
@7iHxsZce
?;g Hg kZ H7/
Z?H7}g Z Z*
c 

$N 7x ~g sXZg
-Z kZX 0
q
+
i Zg F

:[ Z

,jh
en
X ;g Y c*
;{ c*
i (consumption)s ZuZay

tzz
zz pg6%z6, ;ugzZ F,
n
X CY Z
Z
-Z ~
q
V xZ gX @*
Y c*
Z ]g ZZ ZX  D Za b)
X ( g Zi W zn
CZ )

X g
$u
] u ( i ( m #

e n
h
X C Z
g aV 7 Z
Z sg
$ut

Z q \ W
/ZX @*
7,' 7N VZpn
7Z c*
V Z
Z { Zp Zz
}]YZy
Zzz X ~gz s ZuZ Y" pb h
+y

gz ]gz
s:zz kZ @*
Y H ay

Bzgd" ~ {)z ]{ ~ 
V
99

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

ce ! pt ~x oC
X  C Za ])a u Z
Z
WZ H| (, kZX h
+y

6,n
Y Z ]gzKZ Z
Zq]gz

HH: x Z ]!*
kZ
/Z X n h
+y

: q ]gzKZ d
$p h
+y

e
X M
hWyZdzzkZgzZ g"
$
]gz X ,]YZy
Z LZ {z ~gzt a Z
ZgzZV
bY ~ y 0*
XN XM
h X AgzZ , h
+y
z s ,q
Z X @*
Y c*
X 42 GDP 42 bt ~ uX
yq
-Z .5 3525 bt ~ ( F,
~(, VM)
X { c*
ibYV;z o
bt zz ]YZy
Z wVgzZx Z~} 0*
sn
gzZX Y *
c J (,YgzZ YH ay

ti Z~kZX
a Z
Zd
$ x { X  ~gz Z" Y 1a Vzq yZ
y WVd
$TN x (Z  ntZg X @*

8n

XnYHn
6,
_ Z
;g^x Z Z { ~i Z+
0ZT \W

:wZ

]g8{kZ X Y {nt
ys *
! gzZ N WyZd+
h'~ kZ
8{x kZt Zuz ?n(kZ (Zx w  H~
* sZt *
c ( u) D O ug *
c E/
% Z~ ]g
? Y

CWZ
# X }7wJkZ *
z kZ1 x w  :[ Z
xsZzz yZd { B \ WX  Dg 6,gv
$Nk
,
+F,
5
-Z:gzX ;g Y e~}g !*
q
kZ ;g Y H_gx
] !*
gzZ] ZgD

100

q
-Z6
,
yZdC1 @

VY v~ }g !*
ib + ( ;g Y H~M%Z T )
~sfe
$KX w={ c*
ix xsZ WyZd ZZ
# p?v
yZd6,kZt!DZvZz? y(kZ @*

Y2~M%Z
/Z
p
/Z uX (kZ u Z @*
W~ V {gG k d
$k
/Z X @*
W
V;yQVZy

~kZgzZ 79x kZ1 $NZ (,

BRIC X 0*
^J
-
{z YY 7a kZ X  g Za ]) [Z

YYe~}g !*
X {ztugzZ]g kzgsi Z',
nations

yZM%ZtizZX (M%Zt 7pth

+

*`
M%Z uy0*
YM%ZX Z (, ~
~
q)Z yX y0*
Y uuX 1&3u
$N2 F,
X D YK 7}g F
V; }g 1 M
h| (,W e X 
}uz X 7X y 0*
st BX Z (,
y
Vs9}X
q (C
Zc*
g [~:^} y
?(M%Zy YY H~wq]gkZ 7 ] IZ~
yZgzZ sZ Z Wz {,
]Z V sZ :wZ
}X *
@W7{+
Z W$
d*
c Wx kZ,
6gip
sZt ~g *
! g ZZ sZ {~:7 (Z
bkZ7{ ]*
!kZ HX H
*
c ` b: x ~g
?,:7z,
6kZv{WgzZ Yx *
*+
$t

uZg **
Zg~ yZyC
0
+
igzZ}& s Zz w :[ Z
Y~ { Zgs Zzw b~x X x q
$
-Z ~kZ
t zg xsZa kZX
Z~ yvz q
-ZX  jzkZ ?
101

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

{q
-Z\ WgzZ ;gyv~]g kZ, n
\ W Z **

Yti s Z q
-ZX}
Z',p{z yvZg gzZ Y o{gH
] YX U*
Z k0*
V~y 0*
X: og0
+Z}tZuz
q
-Z P U*
ZX v {z84 ~ yZX  DV
27
q
-Z
yZ  6,zQ k PU*
Z XgzZ  D
H n
yZD G
5O;X&PU*
Z18c*
D 384 v pX
& a !Zj )X ] ? Mz
G
Essays on [ Z 8 W /G
s Z X Muslims and the Challenges of Globalization.P214)
7Z n
Z @*
W s6x }~O 8Z (,q
-Z gat
x }pA : n
VZ 7t kZ ce **
Y c*
{ c*
i
XceNn
Vd
$
s~uz
Z~yvz sq
-Z s Zz wO
7(Z ~VsZX ;g7(Z1X Y HZ
n
zO 8} (,
}
}Vzg Z ZXtzzkZ ? 7VY (ZV;z wZq
-Z tX ;g
 D}g Z ZgzZZ +ZX  7}g Z Z {zce **
n
V}g ~
~}g !*
kZ
8n

/Zt }X  D ~g !*
zg Vx
&J
[
7 ] nkZXnYc*
n
kZg Z LE
-u{z

7et X , n
V}g sZ $
Y t  7
,n
kZX { i Z0
+Z 9 ~g !*
zg VgzZ V }g Z Z
/Z D
 p YY RD ZyvZz&D kZ @*
{y **

X }wzkZ ;g
] !*
gzZ] ZgD

1 02

q
-Z6
,
yZdC1 @

F~ wzZ @*
Y~
Z
/Z~wq]g{
RV V ZgzZ S ~gza kZX  M
h w
tXX 7{g Z Z (ZXn :Zz @*
YY~&zgzZN Y
, Z s~uzX  T e
8
7D~}g !*
VyZ sq
-Z

/Zt q ~Xn :Zz ~
\Wzz X 7}g Z Z
~0*
6,kZa {W)g f Tce **
x (Z k0*
\ W 
Y c*
x **
kZ ~ V ZgzZ :Z Z i
+R,k% s WiX Y ~
]KZvY,g e **
+v @*
$
Y c*
C0Z **
kZ~]Zg Z
XV7{y **
1yYv N YKx ZZtT e**
76,
7
sZ~ VsZ sZ **
t ~ xVzg Z Z x yZ
X
4
45 e 7{ c*
G
:gz X G
i 6,g ~g ]u~g X 7et N Y
sgzZ Bx ce X ,[Zy
Zg~}g !*
]1 sZ
yQ Vc*
gz$gzZ Vx{~ Vzq X~x }g7 ,: V
X ,y
K
]*
!gZ CY ]*
!VsZ~KV :wZ
$NZg F
qZ
Z u 6 bZ X *
@Wf *
c gZ sZ
kZ *
c*
@ ,
6 g].
} f sZt HX x
?ce*
**
c w sZ

N Y { ~ }g !*
,q H~
Z u 6 sZ 8F
kZ :[ Z
454Xe
G
]xsZ  {)zShort Selling },q ~
Z u 6X G
: @*

g Z~pg
$uX o
103

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

( 7k0*
}g v :q{z)

n^ fi

kZs: \W ~gza|

# z
q t Z% kZ
@kZ \W 7k0*

\ W
z kZ ~h
/Z }X q {z V
kZx7\W ?~
qgzZ A
~h 7akZX M
h7
b7 kZ X V _ ~ga ,q ~g c*
V ~ga i],
N*

Short

pX M
h
@7~h +Z \WgzZ g ~ ( ) gt X $
Y

7(Z~Selling
Lg  @*
{ i Z0
+Z\ WtShort SellingX @*
tX CY ~} Deliveryh
+y

7Q Zz
/x Z(Shares)~
kZ~Lg pX M
h7
@\ W 7k0*
\W
/ZYi
}{ c*
i
\ W:t@*
wX CY~7Delivery~kZ @*
# z
|
zh
+y

 @*
& !*
i c*
! , Z {z \WgzZ :  D h
+y

X 7
g, qtX @*
Y{@%
\W G ~g Z /
/sqZ~ yZyzD \W :wZ
\WX YaVv *
* VZ {+
Z ]*
!z ]Z@x
I
!
?n 0{Zg L i aVzuz qH+Z~w

] $ ] ] m ] $ ^ t{zce6g~{ ~g q :[ Z
Z%( X WBGX WB) ] m
kZX MVkZkZ @*
W
/ZX x q
-Z **
Y
CW7!
/Z }X N ] KZa kZ YY H7q ~ 0
+
i%
yY - Y~}g Z Z  7~gzakZX ,IZ
!\WJ
-Z
# Y ~gz , z G! X $
Y -~
] !*
gzZ] ZgD

1 04

q
-Z6
,
yZdC1 @

\W (Z 7,F,
XVQ7{Z
+ kyW
3Y 7
{ c*
i G! X c*
} \ W !*
gzZ ~ w k Q gzZ c*
Wk0*

Za x kZ 6,Vzg e y ! L L[X 7x
x CZ  W! Z kZgzZ 7,,z ZZ kZp ~X Vzi
7ta Wx X Y^7x %~! g
$uzyW
X J(,
W
7G%! ayZgx ~m,
S Z sZ v\ WpYY
XM
h7#
}
.bhZxsZ\ W gJ7! \W
/ZX
akZ\W
/ZX 7%~x kZ m J
-V
7q ~ 0
+
i ,s
z6,yn,
z 8 [ V[
RgzZ V: g
/Zg rLX V7 8 yjz 8 ~X Y7 x d SgzZ Y

{q yn,
z 8 X V
8E_N{z [ c*
,
k
Z } C
X Sg c*
\ W{z_7,[ \W~kZCzz]
X _{ c*
i AX M
hN ~ [ {g !*
z  w Z J 7,
/Z
c*
6,eg LZ [ ~k
,
$
/ZX B F "7,ti_
q F kZ  g ! \W
/Z X B F(gzZ
V; }g X K 9
L o outline KZkZ B FgzZ 7,
o
7 4{ c*
i kZgzZ ~A k
,
Bv
G
&
.O&Y @*
.OG
XM
h^7BBDgzZE
Y{ DV;zYWKE
/ZX YY
Y
5X N ZC
 I k Q ' Z (, q
-Z G-#Ggz G
%F LZ
~x kZ7~ kZX V @*
t ZC
% Fk
,
KZ~
VzuzgzZ N ZC
p X
C7x %kZp @gzZ
z
105

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

yQps a}v c*
W~ X ,a}
5{ c*
i G
!Ozgt X @*
Y| m
{g 0*
yZ ~W6,yZ \W
/ZX n
pg
: nZg **
A
$}Wn
/Zce **
g akZX YY 7
4k
,
KZ
g X 7c*

gWkZBgbhZX V
X @*
7,
7t
kZX , hgkZ 79gzZN
kZ K gzZ K!agiZ ~gza ! x
\W 9
L okZN W} +gg aq kZ

/Z gm{gzZ **
_
X N ~4~ kZ
V**
ZC
g !*
FkZrQ
8F**
_Vzq0 kZ ry*
\ W\ WQ D ] m ] $ ^ D **
ZC
9
L oVzba}
6,kZv|~ g {! \ WZ
# p\ WX YuL
7g aG
gWgzZ X (,] E
O\ WgzZ,}iZ
{ c*
i kZ D~}g Z Z q
-Z\ WC
gzZX Y07 {z
# ZgzkZ  ~zK
/E
{zgzZ,G
/ZX ,F,Wz_CZ\W ]gz
B{)z_gzZ Bx y y ZzX ,s~_
z
7Z7 @*

z rg aV Zz"7,X ,gz_Q Y6,yx 

gzZ yZz X **
_~ 7, Y yX
z Zg
kZgzZ}x ~ y Wyce **
t st
D~Vw
:Og6,
g{ Zg
KZt LZ~0
+
iX a
zYW
YY Hq
)g f gzZ YY H7q % L L
X

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

1 06

q
-Z6
,
yZdC1 @

{V*
c Zz W~ +
0i \WZj+
0i: Zgz& :wZ
?Hg (ZiHa i WyZ\WgzZy

yZ\ W @*
ttzg \WX D W~0
+
iy
KZ {

:[ Z

\W}X DwJQ,j y"c*


g ;g e
Zuz OkZX 7~V} 9v\ Wt G
!Ozgq
-ZX a
gLZX N FLZ_X ,X , wJZ\W Yt G
!Ozg
YZ G\ W ,{g gzZN YV;zkZX ,~yLZp{z6,
@*
7,
**
t~qzX Q! xX\W7xH: (Z\W
/ZpX
\ W bZX  D FQ CY0] \WZ
# b~
X **
r!
X K,g ZN Outline 9
L o qt
zg kZ O nZg **
6,} QX g D4h
+'
kZ
X ,4~
X Hx gzZ q o yzgzZ y *
0 \W

:wZ

~ y *
0/
ZgzZ  \W Zz ~ i Z+
0Z Z~ *
?H~gza}g eb r z

7V; }g X D{ c*
i va~ C
!* :[ Z
g !*
g !*
p]Y! LZ v~ }uzX  7g vVX
kZDw! n6,kZBVf
e}D CV_7,
eq
-ZtX  D4h
+'
~ zg yZ X  Tg f
e F~ yZgz
Zz Wp $
WnJ 6,k
,
\W]zZ X  ]
X Y^7x nZg **

107

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

 q8
-N*
vg0
+ZVz ] zZ g~f t q ~uz
{ot yYce 7**
Z<
Vzq yZX  D/i s \W
{Z
+ e:vZJ
-Z
# gzZ Y7yv e:vZJ
-Z
# 
\ WC
 Y t X ~ kZ6,] F~ yW
X Y 7
H4 ~ h\ W t \W~p li s

h}g v{zgzZzI**
qq
-Z ? e) ]n ^n ] i ] oF
%Nt ZkC~ qz Z (Z6,Z B}pX ( hZ~
ZE
LZ\ WgzZA : F,
\W @*
(ZX ;g ~ h} kZy
s !*
pZ
%NfZ
vZ
/ZX ]Z f vZ {z 7!*
fZ \WZz F,
p' >ZE
{otZg X Y7} F,;e: vZ
/ZgzZ Y7uzg F,
\ W ;e
GL^ Wt ZgzZ A ] Z f vZA Ao
i Zg
X F,
F,
~0
+
i }6,
] x~ QgzZ}
~g e \W *
c t Z g x \W~ * dH :wZ
TqH{zpX Hi Wx ~]\WtwZZuz ?
qCZ]sZ O] H \Wzz
?Y*
c

ii
+
/}gzZ Le **
Y ~ c*
-bZ ~ Z ~
8

:[ Z

/Z Vj| 7,H~ 7{ i Z0

+Z = , Z ]q }p iZ
~X @*
: {Z
+ kZ Y: kZgzZ
8| 7,c*
-bZ wz
8
~a kZX q x t } 7,**
hg wzgzZ V
8k%
/Z e
}g kZ p H x D * Z kZQ 1x D! vZ:Z X H[ NZ k%
] !*
gzZ] ZgD

108

q
-Z6
,
yZdC1 @

bkZv
X~ 7,: ~= c*
W7(Z ~0
+
i ~~
ay
KZt X ,q ~BgzZ ,#
i 5 M
h
@*
YI y
KZ y W0
+
i
/Z X CY ] QY Lg
X
Wz6,V;z 1Z ~ k% ~ Z
# m wZ}uz J
-V
~ X Z JZ

~gzZ ~*Z e{z ]5 {)zZ gp
Y E"
55EsZgzZ ]sZ bkZQ X 5 _ xsZ
~ {)z E
~ ~g (Z kZ i(Accounting) Z J
-Z X S(,p
Z 8 V;z
HM%ZX Hx D* ZQX 1y* Banking ~ wa gzZ}
Money and Banking and Economic Develpment q Z~ ~ e

7M{ c*
i Vzq yZt |pX ;gm{ c*
i yZykZ bkZX
~6,]sZ= kZJ 7,~V-gE- gzZV X
kZX k g
A &q
-Z "7,
gzZ WX B7 { c*
i
kZ q g !*
g !*
WX  DX\W @*
4 ~
{z V-gE- gzZV\ W @*
7(Z X
8Zg V @*
b &Z
]!*
gzZ V w$
+]q[ Z
/ZX~\ W)g fT Y Z
g|kZ 74 xsZVJ 7,
~wj~~X
sZX 7]xsZ ,74 xsZ ~ kZ J 7,~ k%s W
Y E"
55EsZX y zJ
sZ
z kZ
/Z wqt E
-
z k Q ]
0 ]1 sZX 7 *& 0*
t v @*
] !*
] 1
7
w D Z g Z q
-Z ~ yZ [
7
z kZ X Z x YM%Z
109

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

Islamic

[ ^ zZg q
-Z Islam and the Theory of Interest

t1 i
kZgzZXy
KZ L L[~z**
gzZ Economics

/Zv\WX C7,**
pa"(,
W WX RZZ
Z{ C" Zg fvgzZ,
MZR,
6,qC
 q
t\ W ,
;g J 7,~gzZ ~M%Z~
zTX 7[
7
tp
VrZax kZX Z qz .
$Z
/a^gq
-Z yZx Z~6,]
$u ~ g kZ g ~(, q
g
-Z
z kZ K Z eJ e
X Hi Wx LZ6,xsZ~fzo)q
-ZX ,h
+y

}gzZ
bg ]!*
D
t
zC
~ f a x C
gzZ S Zj x
B~ szw~kZ\WX Y7 {z 7g ce
X 7e! x ~0
+
i%
] .
}(hZ~,
(,
6V;zgzZg Z /
z{~[~:\W :wZ
?,x \Way *
0  eL\WX ,x Zu

X 7g #
i 5= vV p Le **
Wy 0*
~ :[ Z
[~:QX
H`M%Z:Zz~zzT{ c*
i
(~Vzg Z Z V
y 0*
w&zkZX
H`V;z
#
i 5
[Z
Zpg kZ1~
Zpg #
i 5~ gE- ZyZgz kZX V YW
~ y 0*
/Z a kZ X : wJ

-g q
-Z wz
Zpg g )g
~ ]!*
Zz ]i ] oF ZYZtp q
-ZpX @*
YW Q#
i5
( Y 2010ag D 2)

X H{g~M%ZgzZ[~:~ Y7x {z Wy 0*

] !*
gzZ] ZgD

11 0

051-8438390

8438391-3