,

, ,
19 20. : 1884 1901,
, ,

,
, ,
,

, ,

.

.


. ,

.
,
,
().
1

 . , 1880-1925

, ,
() .
,

:
, , ,
. ,
:



( )
.

,
petit bourgeois 19
,
, , .1 , ,
:
,

/ ,
.2 ,
1

Geoffrey Crossick Heinz-Gerhard Haupt, The petite bourgeoisie in Europe 17801914, 1995, .135-136 191.
2
, , 18
, .
2

, .3
, ,
/,
, 4
. , 5
(lower middle class, Mittelstandt, classes
moyennes petite bourgeoisie, ceti medi piccola borghesia). ,
.
,

.
, ,

.
, , .

: ,
1910 .., , ,
.
3

, Pierre Bourdieu, .
, 2002, .389-391 ..,
.
4
Dror Wahrman, Imagining the middle class. The
political representation of class in Britain, c. 1780-1840, 1995.
5
( , 31985 ,
2
1990), Erik Olin Wright (Class, Crisis and the State, 1978 Classes,
1985, ..).
3

 . , 1880-1925

,
:
.
, .
, ,

, . .

: , ,

, , ( )
.6
(
,
, )
, ( )
.
,


.
, ,
6

Crossick Haupt, The petite bourgeoisie in Europe, .., .114.

4

1865: .
(
[.: .1.33])

,
.

. 1880
(
) (
, 1879 ). 1880
(1878-1880),
,
.
5

 . , 1880-1925

,
1910/14,
:
, , , (
,
). ,
1920.

: , ,
.


.7

. , ,
7

, 1927-29 :
1927
, 192728 ,
1929. , 1925,
,
( , ..,
). 1925, , :
.
6

,
, , -,
, ..
.8 ,
,

, ,
.9
( ) ,
. . ,

,
.
,
. ,
,
8

, , 1991
, . 1830-1922, 1977 , . , 1981 , ,
, , 1986 ( : .285).


, 1924-1935, 1988, .159, 165, 174-175, ..
, .
,
, 76-77 (2001), .79-81.
9
. . , ; ,
1993, .95-102.
7

 . , 1880-1925

, -
, .10


(
)


,



, .11
, , .12
,
.
.13
14
10

, (18981939), . , 1993, .16-19, ..

11
, . , 18301940, 1993, .43 .., 406-407, 370 .. (: .371).
12
: . , 1830-1940, 2003
, 1900-1975
, 1982.
13
, , 19091936. -, 1987 ,
1870-1940, 1995 , (1870-1922), 2002.
14
( 19 , 1986, . 340, . 207-208) (, : (.),
19 , 2006, .226-228, . .221-222).
8

, 1900
( )

, 1890-1905
.
9

 . , 1880-1925

, 1990 ,
,

,
, ( , , )
, .15 , , .
E. O. Wright

( ) ,

,
( )

.
,
. ,
.
15

, , 1993
, , 1993 ,
(1870-1936): , 6 (1995),
.9-78. . , . 1909-1940, 1989. , . John
Benson, The penny capitalists. A study of nineteenth-century working-class entrepreneurs,
1983.
10

, ,
.
,

.16
, ,

, ,
. ,
1920

( )
.
,
, :
,

(
).17 , , ,
(/, ). ,
, ,
16

, , .., .79 82 , ,
.., .114 142-143 , ..., .., .30-36.
17
,
:
;
11

 . , 1880-1925

, , .
, ,


.
,
( ),
.
, (
).
,
: .

,
,

.
/ ,

.18
,
,
18

George Mavrogordatos, Stillborn republic. Social coalitions and party strategies in

Greece 1922-1936, 1983, .136-141, , . 1916, 1996, .136-137.
12

,
- ,
, .19

,
.
, ,
(
, - ).20
, ,

.
.
(
) ,


.21 1910

(
19

Journal of modern history 56 (1984), .764-765 ( ), , : , , ,

: (1998), .
20
, . , , 1998, . 376, 378, 465
..
, 1917 (.384). : www.scribd.com/doc/20074536.
21
, , : (.),
20 , . 2, 1999, .37-105.
13

 . , 1880-1925

)
:
.22

, .

:
, .

, (

), . .
, 1960 .., , , .23

, , .24 22

, , ( ): 20 , 1999, . 1, .34-38 . ,
, , .345-347.
23
Crossick Haupt, The petite bourgeoisie in Europe
1780-1914, .., .10.
24
Heinrich August Winkler, From social protectionism to national socialism: the German
small-business movement in comparative perspective, Journal of Modern History 48
14

,
.
, 1970
1980,25 .
19 20 1979: Crossick, Haupt, Kurgan van
Hentenryk Vigier
petite bourgeoisie ,
,26
Crossick Haupt 1995.27

.28

25

26

27

28

(1976), .1-18 Shulamit Volkov, The rise of popular antimodernism in Germany. The
urban master artisans 1873-1896, 1978 Rudy Koshar (.), Splintered
classes. Politics and the lower middle class in interwar Europe, 1990.
, , .. Wright, Class, Crisis and the State, ..,
Classes, .. Peter Meiksins, Beyond the boundary question, New Left Review 157
(1986), . 101-120. Frank Bechhofer Brian Eliott,
The petite bourgeoisie. Comparative studies of the uneasy stratum,
Basingstoke 1981.
David Blackbourn, Economic crisis and the petite bourgeoisie in Europe during the
19th and 20th centuries, Social History 10/1 (1985), .95-104.
Michael Winstanley, The shopkeepers world 1830-1914, 1983 Philip
Nord, Paris shopkeepers and the politics of resentment, 1986 Clive Behagg,
Politics and production in the early nineteenth century, 1990 Steven Zdatny,
The politics of survival. Artisans in twentieth-century France, 1990 Bernadette
Angleraud, Les boulangers lyonnais aux XIX-XXe sicles (1836 1914). Une tude sur
la petite bourgeoisie boutiquire, , Universit de Lyon II 1993
Jonathan Morris, The political economy of shopkeeping in Milan 1886-1922,
1993 Crossick Haupt, The petite bourgeoisie in Europe, ..
1995
: Serge Jaumain, Les petits commerants Belges face la modernit
1880-1914, 1995 Geoffrey Crossick (.), The artisan and the European
town, Aldershot 1997 Pierre Guillaume (.), Histoire et historiographie des classes
moyennes dans les socits dveloppes, 1998 Steven Zdatny, Fashion, work
and politics in modern France, Houndmills 2006 Bruno Maida,
Proletari della borghesia. I piccoli commercianti dallUnit a oggi, 2009.
15

 . , 1880-1925

, 19 (
), ,
. :
,
29

, 30 , 31


,
.32
29

Dick van Lente, The crafts in industrial society: ideals and policy in the Netherlands
1890-1930, Economic and social history in the Netherlands 2 (1991), .99-119 .
Jrgen Kocka, New energies in the nineteenth-century. Toward a social history
of the electricity business, Industrial culture and bourgeois
society, 1999, .175-191.
30
Gareth Shaw, Recent research on the commercial structure of nineteenth-century British
cities, : Dietrich Denecke/Gareth Shaw (.), Urban historical geography. Recent
progress in Britain and Germany, 1988, .236-249 Christopher Hosgood,
The pigmies of commerce and the working-class community: small shopkeepers in
England 1870-1914, Journal of Social History 22/3 (1989), .439-460 ,
brave and daring folk? Shopkeepers and trade associational life in Victorian and
Edwardian England, Journal of Social History 26 (1992), .285-308.
31
Winstanley, The shopkeepers world, .., .8-9, 44-45 120 .. Alain Faure, The
grocery trade in 19th century Paris: a fragmented corporation, : Geoffrey Crossick
Heinz-Gerhard Haupt (.), Shopkeepers and master artisans in 19th century
Europe, 1984, .155-174 Matthew Hilton, Retailing history
as economic and cultural history: strategies of survival by specialist tobacconists in the
mass market, Business history 40/4 (1998), .115-137.
32
Behagg, Politics and production, .. Crossick Haupt, The petite bourgeoisie in
Europe, .., .62-63.
16

, . ,
,
,33
. Crossick

( ,
,
) ,
[ ] [ ].
, Haupt,
,
,
,
.
,
,
.
,
, . Haupt
Kocka /
: , ,
( ,
19 , ,
),

33

Crossick Haupt, The petite bourgeoisie in Europe, .., .64-86 Jean Le Yaouanq,
Trajectoires sociales Paris au XIXe sicle: le monde de la boutique, Bulletin du
Centre Pierre Lon dhistoire conomique et sociale 1993/4, .25-40.
17

 . , 1880-1925

, .34

. Hosgood

, ( )
.35 Monod ,
,
:
, .36

34

Geoffrey Crossick, The petite bourgeoisie in 19th century Britain: the urban and liberal
case, : Crossick Haupt (.), Shopkeepers and master artisans in 19th century Europe, .62-94 Crossick Haupt, The petite bourgeoisie in Europe, .., .8
86 ( , ,
petite bourgeoisie )
Jrgen Kocka Heinz-Gerhard Haupt, Vecchie e nuove classi nellEuropa del XIX
secolo, : Paul Bairoch Eric Hobsbawm (.), Storia dEuropa, . 5,
1996, .740. Heinz-Gerhard
Haupt, The petite bourgeoisie in France 1850-1914: in search of the juste milieu?,
: Crossick Haupt (.), Shopkeepers and master artisans in 19th century
Europe, 1984, .95-119.
35
Hosgood, The pigmies of commerce, .. , brave and daring
folk?, .. ,
, , .

Morris, The political economy of
shopkeeping, ..
36
David Monod, Culture without class: Canadas retailers and the problem of group
identification 1890-1940, Journal of Social History 28/3 (1994-1995), .521-545.
, ,
, , .
18

;
, .
,

,
, ,37
.
,

, , , , . , ,
( )

[ ]
( , , ).38
37

G.E.M. de Ste. Croix, :

, 1997, .72-73.
38
Gran Therborn, Why some classes are more successful than others, New Left Review
138 (1983), .39. ,
( ) - : Ronald Aminzade, Class analysis, politics and French
labor history, : Lenard Berlanstein (.), Rethinking labor history, Urbana 1993,
. 90-113 . , Ballots and barricades. Class formation and republican
politics in France, 1830-1871, 1993, .7-9 passim,

. , (. Social history
1992-1995), ,
19

 . , 1880-1925

( ,
)
.
;
, : (-)
, , . , , , .

;39

.


.
, Gareth
Stedman Jones, Languages of class, 1983, .21-22, Joan W. Scott, On language, gender and working-class history,
: Gender and the politics of history, 1988, .53-67.
, , ( ,
Wahrman, Imagining the middle class, .., .6-8).
39
, , .. , , . ,
1978, . 160 ..
,
.
,
: Sokratis Koniordos,
Towards a sociology of artisans, Aldershot 2001, .45 (Isaac Rubin).

: , . , . 786. ,


. 20

, .40


.41
,
;
: , 42
E. O. Wright
:
(, ,
) ,
,
43
,44

40

41

42

43

44

1970 1980 : Jacques

Chevalier, There is nothing simple about simple commodity production, Journal of
peasant studies 10/4 (1983), .153-186.
.. Behagg, Politics and production, ..
Frank Bechhofer Brian Eliott, Petty property: the survival of a moral economy,
( ): The petite bourgeoisie, 1981, .182-200,
, The petite bourgeoisie in late capitalism, Annual Revue of Sociology 11 (1985),
.181-207.
: , , 1984,
.111, 114-117. :
, .., . , .526 . , .423-424, ..
Wright, Class, Crisis and the State, .., Classes, .. . George Steinmetz
Erik Olin Wright, The fall and rise of the petty bourgeoisie: changing patterns of selfemployment in the postwar United States, American Journal of Sociology 94/5 (1989),
.971-1018.
, , , 2000.
21

 . , 1880-1925

.45
,

-
,

.
: 1900
. ( ) /
,

- ( , ).
, ,
, .46
, ,
.
, , ,

.47 , , 45

Sokratis Koniordos, Towards a sociology of artisans, Aldershot 2001, .93-97.

Charles Sabel Jonathan Zeitlin, Historical alternatives to mass production: politics,
markets and technology in nineteenth century industrialization, Past and Present 108
(1985), .133-176, (.), World of possibilities. Flexibility and mass
production in western industrialization, 1997.
47
, ..,
46

22

:48 , ,
, :
, ,

.
,

.
/ .
R. Weil
,
, .

.
,
: , .49
, ; Weil

,
,
( )

, : Karl Marx,
, 1982, .142-144 160.


, .., .1086-1087
. , , . , .786, 789, 798, ..
48
, , . , 1984, .455-458.
49
Robert Weil, Contradictory class definitions: petty bourgeoisie and the Classes of E. O.
Wright, Critical sociology 21/3 (1995), .3-37.
23

 . , 1880-1925

.50 ,
.., ,51
.52 ,

.53
: ,
.54
, , .
.55 ,
, ( 50

Wright, Class, Crisis and the state,

.., .64 ..
51
Jrgen Schlumbohm, Relations of production productive forces crises in protoindustrialization, : Peter Kriedte, Hans Medick Jrgen Schlumbohm, Industrialization before industrialization, 1981, .94-125.
52
Ronald Aminzade, Reinterpreting capitalist industrialization: a study of nineteenthcentury France, : Steven Kaplan Cynthia Koepp (.), Work in France, 1986, .393-417.
53
, , .., . , .526, , , .., .106. . Koniordos, Towards a sociology of artisans,
.., .100.
54
, . , , , 69-70 (1985), .3-11 , 19 : ,
3 (1985), .149-168, ,
19 , 10 (1989), .75104 , , .., .236 .. 289 ..
55
, ,
Wright, Class, Crisis and the State, .., Steinmetz Wright, The fall and rise of
the petty bourgeoisie, .., Koniordos, Towards a sociology of artisans, ..
24

)
, --
.56
,

, ,57
.
, ,
.58
, , . , ,
.
,
( )
, -
:

56

Jacques Gouverneur, , 1999, .151-155.

57
, .153-154.
58
Heinz-Gerhard Haupt, La petite bourgeoisie, une classe inconnue, Le mouvement
social 108 (1979), . 11-20 Daniel Bertaux Isabelle Bertaux-Wiame, Artisanal
bakery in France: how it lives and why it survives, : Bechhofer Elliott (.),
The petite Bourgeoisie, Basingstoke 1981, .155-181 . Winstanley,
The shopkeepers world, .., .57-58.
25

 . , 1880-1925

. ,


.
, ,
Crossick Haupt, , ,
, ,

,
. ,
(
, , ).
: /
59 (
),


, .

59

, ,
, / :
Bechhofer Eliott, Petty property, ..
, , ..,
, . , , .., .207,

3-5 .
26

60 .61

,
, .., ,
.
-,
, , , .
Faure 19
[...] ,

.62

.


. ,
( ) , ,
Przeworski Wacquant.63
,
60

: ,
18 , 1986, .155-156.
61
Ernesto Laclau, , 1983.
62
Faure, The grocery trade, ..
63
Adam Przeworski, Capitalism and social democracy, 1985,
.65-92, Lic Wacquant, Making class: the middle class(es) in social theory and
social structure, : Scott Mcnail, Ehonda Levine Rick Fantasia (.), Bringing
class back in, Boulder 1991, .39-64. E. P. Thompson,
The making of the English working class, 31981, .10,
, ,
, .
27

 . , 1880-1925

Wright,
.
, , 19 . ,
, ,


,
.64

:
65

.
:
( ) , .
,
: ,
, ,

,
. , . ,
,
.
64

Crossick Haupt, The petite bourgeoisie in Europe, .., .210, David Blackbourn, Between resignation and volatility: the German petite bourgeoisie in the 19th
century, , Populists and patricians. Essays in modern German history, 1987, .84-113.
65
Ronald Aminzade, Ballots and barricades, ..
28

,
, , ,
, .66

. ,
,
, , . 19
, ,
. , , 19


. 19 ,
-.67

66

, ,
Therborn, Why some classes are more successful than others, .., Wacquant,
Making class, .. Michael Mann, , . : - 1760-1914, 2009, .40-44. . Nigel
Thrift Peter Williams, The geography of class formation, (
): Class and space. The making of urban society, 1987,
.1-22, .
67
Geoffrey Crossick, Shopkeepers and the state in Britain 1870-1914, : Crossick
Haupt (.), Shopkeepers and master artisans in 19th century Europe, .., .238-269
, Petite bourgeoisie et histoire compare, Bulletin du Centre Pierre Lon dhistoire conomique et sociale 1992/1, .13-25 , Metaphors of the middle: the discovery of the petite bourgeoisie 1880-1914, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society
(London) 6 (1994), .251-279 Blackbourn, Between resignation and volatility, ..
29

 . , 1880-1925

, ,
, ( )
.
1890, . 1910/14
, 1920 ,
, .
. ,
20 ,
:
1920,
1914-16. ,
.
,

. . ,
: , ,
, . /
: ,
, , ,
, ,
.68
68

, ( ,
30

,
. , .
1870
, ,
1880 ,
.
.
,
. ,
,
.
, , ,
(
1880)
. ,
, ,
, . , ,
.69 , , . 1880-1925, , , 2011)
: , , :
http://elocus.lib.uoc.gr/dlib/6/f/8/metadata-dlib-1330425501-380121-25886.tkl
69
, , , . , 1957
1959.
31

 . , 1880-1925

:
1919 ..
( ),
.

, . ,
19 .
:
,

, ,

. -- -
. ,
,
,
.
:
, (,
, ), ,
, ( ),

.
32

,
.
;
; , ;
; ,
;
, ; , ,
;

,
. ,
,

,
. ,
,
.

. ,
, : ,


19 ;
, ,
,
: , ,
.
33

 . , 1880-1925

.
( )
1891 . ( )

.
,
,
1910. ,
.

.
,
,
,
.
1910/1916:
( )
1910
, 19081910 (,
, ) 1916 ..

,
.

34