Professional Documents
Culture Documents
school ground
Ontario
Bring Nature Back to Your City
GREENING
Project Concept: Heidi Campbell, Toronto District School Board and Evergreen; Richard Christie, Toronto District
School Board
Writer: Heidi Campbell, Toronto District School Board and Evergreen
Developers: Krista Long, Evergreen; Maureen Whitehead, Toronto District School Board (retired)
Technical Consultant: Bruce Day, Toronto District School Board
Editors: Eleanor Dudar, Toronto District School Board; Catherine Mahler; Denny Manchee, Evergreen
Adaptation: Catherine Mahler
Illustrations: Samara Newman
Photography: Heidi Campbell; Cam Collyer
Schools in photos: Cassandra PS; Indian Road Crescent Jr PS; Jesse Ketchum PS; Wilkinson PS, all Toronto DSB
Reviewers: Mike Achilles, Toronto DSB; Ron Ballentine, Halton DSB; Edward Cheskey, Waterloo Region DSB;
Richard Christie, Toronto DSB; Bruce Day, Toronto DSB; Judy Gould, Durham DSB; Arlene Higgins-Wright,
York Region DSB; Eva Pathak; David Percival, Toronto DSB; Donna Rice, Toronto DSB; John Scherk, Toronto DSB
Every reasonable precaution has been taken to trace the owners of copyrighted material and to make due
acknowledgement. Any omission will gladly be rectified in future printings.
Designer: Comet art + design
School Ground
Greening and EcoSchools
Designing for Shade and Energy Conservation is the first in a series of EcoSchools
greening guides that promote best practices on school grounds and in the
classroom. The benefits of bringing nature into the learning environment are
addressed in many resources. This guide, with its deliberate focus on providing
shade for students (health) and buildings (energy conservation), draws on
greening practices specific to school boards and on emerging research about
how best to provide natural shade where children play and learn.
This resource will help students, teachers, parents and community members
learn how to select, position and plant trees that will last through the
generations, making our school grounds places of comfort and safety,
and making our planet just a little cooler than it would otherwise be.
AUGUST 2004
guides for getting started
1 Introduction to EcoSchools
and the Five-Step Process
2 Waste
Minimization Guide
3 Energy
Conservation Guide
This concise guide provides an overview of This guide outlines the 10 Ontario EcoSchools Similar in format to the Waste Minimization
the Ontario EcoSchools program and sets out a waste minimization guidelines. It provides the Guide, this resource outlines the 10 Ontario
practical method for successful implementation: school’s EcoTeam with tips for assessing the EcoSchools energy conservation guidelines.
(1) establish an EcoTeam, (2) assess the school’s school’s current waste minimization efforts, It provides the school’s EcoTeam with tips
needs, (3) identify priorities and develop an sample reviews and action plans and a set for assessing the school’s current energy
action plan, (4) implement the action plan, of tools for implementing improved waste conservation efforts, sample reviews and action
and (5) monitor and evaluate progress. minimization practices. plans and a set of tools for implementing
improved energy conservation practices.
1 2 3 4 5 6
4 Waste Minimization
by Grade (1-8)
5 Energy Conservation
by Grade (1-8)
6 Systems Thinking:
Grades 1-8
This resource is organized around “big Like Waste Minimization by Grade, this guide This resource helps shift our view of the nature
ideas” about waste and waste minimization is organized around “big ideas” about energy of the human and natural worlds: instead of
that are based on identified clusters of and energy conservation that are based on being collections of separate parts, they are seen
learning expectations in both Science identified clusters of learning expectations as whole systems greater than the sum of their
and Technology and Social Studies and in both Science and Technology and Social interdependent parts. Seeing the curriculum
Geography. Using these ideas as a focus Studies and Geography. Using these ideas through a Systems Thinking lens highlights how
helps the teacher incorporate ecological as a focus helps the teacher incorporate the interconnections among learning expectations
thinking into existing curriculum. Annotated ecological thinking into existing curriculum. bestow the power of describing how the
Internet resources offer background Annotated Internet resources offer background world works – seeing people in relation to the
facts and student learning activities. facts and student learning activities. environment. This approach integrates diverse
learning expectations into coherent clusters.
Available in 2005.
connecting ecoschools
to the elementary curriculum
i
connecting ecoschools
to the secondary curriculum
7 Climate Change
in Grade 9 Geography
8 Climate Change
in Grade 10 Civics
9 Climate Change
in Grade 10 Science
(Academic and Applied) (Academic and Applied)
This unit introduces students to the concept of
This resource consists of a culminating task citizenship through a series of well-supported This resource provides two possible culminating
for summative evaluation plus a unit-by-unit activities where they analyze the accomplishments tasks: students are introduced to an actual
breakdown of the conceptual understandings of environmental activists and organizations. problem and asked to propose solutions to either
about climate change needed to ensure student A simple Public Policy Primer helps students The Impact of Transportation Choices or Forest
success. Students select a Canadian town or see points at which they can influence issues. Management and Climate Change. Climate change
small city and develop an annotated map that Students apply their knowledge in responding related concepts have been identified in each
indicates the changes in the human and natural to the Government of Canada’s One-Tonne strand. Charts link authorized texts and the
environments that would reduce greenhouse Challenge for reducing climate change gases. An Teacher Resource for each to relevant learning
gases and thus slow climate change. Resource Environmental Citizenship Portfolio containing each expectations. A student Checklist of Preparation,
list, student worksheets and evaluation student’s class work and other materials sums up annotated Internet resources and evaluation
rubric are provided. See #17 for supporting her/his understanding of environmental citizenship. rubrics are also provided. See #17 for supporting
multimedia presentations. See #17 for supporting multimedia presentations. multimedia presentations.
7 8 9 10 11 12
10 Climate Change in
Grade 11 and 12 Science
11 Climate Change in
Grade 11 and 12 Geography
12 Interdisciplinary Studies:
Climate Change and Your
Future - Grade 12 (Open)
This resource ranges over 8 different Science This resource surveys 5 Geography
courses (University, University/College, College courses (University, University/College, This single-credit course reviews the
and Workplace), highlighting learning and Open). Overall and specific impacts of climate change on human and
expectations that can be met using climate expectations for each course are natural systems. Students investigate
change issues as the examples. Focus accompanied by guiding ideas linking local businesses and agencies to learn
questions help students connect the learning these expectations to different parts about environmental practices that reduce
of facts and concepts in a meaningful way. of the climate change story. Examples the impact of climate change. Through
The questions also suggest ways to adapt are provided for developing topics, case studies, students identify emerging
the existing curriculum to explore the data, and teaching and learning strategies work opportunities; in the culminating
evidence, interactions and technologies recommended for different student needs. task students develop a business plan
related to climate change issues. Lists of Resources for planning class activities related to mitigating or adapting to
resources that suit the needs of the courses and assignments are listed. See #17 for climate change. See #17 for supporting
are included. See #17 for supporting supporting multimedia presentations. multimedia presentations.
multimedia presentations. Available in 2005.
ii
guides to enrich your program
13 14 15 16 17
multimedia presentations
to anchor your program
iii
GUIDE
school ground
GREENING
Contents
Preface
The Special Role of Trees 2
Introduction
Why is it important to provide shade for children and youth? 5
Designing for Shade and Energy Conservation, Climate Change and EcoSchools 5
Designing for Shade and Energy Conservation … the five-step process at a glance 9
Toolkit 33
Words cannot adequately capture all that trees do to enhance our well-being.
They give us something to look up to, literally and metaphorically. Planting
trees in the school ground endows students, teachers and the community
with a precious gift for generations to come.
Trees are an essential part of Earth’s ecology. They “provide summer shade…
They block close to 60 percent of the sun’s rays, buffer cold winter winds,
reduce water runoff and soil erosion, filter dust…provide habitat and shelter
for songbirds and other urban wildlife…renew our oxygen and add moisture
to the air through transpiration…filter air pollution…and absorb carbon
dioxide, a principal greenhouse gas that contributes to climate change.”1
Planting trees has many positive effects on children’s health and behaviour
and can foster children’s awareness of their connection to the natural world.
The following inspirational stories illustrate how schools can green their
school grounds in unique ways to enrich the lives of children and have a
significant influence on the health of the local environment.
1 Elise Houghton, A Breath Of Fresh Air: Celebrating Nature and School Gardens. Photography: Robert Christie. Toronto: Learnx Foundation and
Sumach Press, 2003. p.106. This beautiful TDSB Millennium Project picture book was conceived of and directed by the Board’s Environmental
Education staff. Of particular interest in relation to this resource is chapter 6, “A Canopy of Green: The Special Role of Trees.”
It’s estimated that one in seven children born today in Canada will develop skin cancer later in
life.2 Why? Because of over-exposure to ultra violet radiation (UVR). In fact, one blistering
sunburn during childhood can double the risk of getting cancer.3 UVR has also been linked to
cataracts, suppression of the body’s immune system and the development of allergies.4 Children
and youth are particularly vulnerable because they rarely demonstrate ‘shade seeking’ behavior. At
school, children spend up to 25% of their time outdoors, typically during the period of highest
UVR exposure — between 10 a.m. and 4 p.m. In most cases, they have little choice about
exposure to the sun. One of the most effective means of protecting students from UVR is to plant
shade trees where they play and congregate - for example, around playground equipment, near
asphalt play areas, and along sports fields - to offer students a number of protection options.
Scientists expect climate change to increase global temperatures by 1.4 to 5.8 degrees Celsius
by the end of this century.5 The electricity generated to meet people’s additional cooling needs
will mean increased greenhouse gas emissions. When we plant trees and large shrubs in school
grounds to provide strategic shade and windbreaks, we conserve energy as well as providing
protection from harmful ultraviolet radiation. Trees planted to shade the south and southwest
sides of a school building can reduce cooling costs by as much as 15 - 20%. Trees planted north
2
Ontario Cancer Facts (May 2002). Available at www.cancercareon.ca/reports_219htm.
3
S. Graham, J. Marshall, B. Haughey et al., “An inquiry into the epidemiology of melanoma,” American Journal of Epidemiology 1985.122:606-19.
4
World Health Organization Fact Sheet # 261, Protecting Children from UVR (July 2001). Available at www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs261/en/
5
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Available at www.ipcc.ch
Designing for shade and energy conservation provides year-round comfort and safety for the
students and staff of our schools. When we improve our school grounds, we help improve the
environment for everyone.
UVR Protection
Designing for shade is only part of the story…
Protecting children and youth from harmful UVR rays
requires a multi-faceted approach. Along with providing
natural shade, schools can try to schedule outdoor
activities in shaded areas or during non-peak UVR
times. Parents can be advised to provide a hat for their
child to wear during recess. Teachers or other outdoor
supervisors can model sun smart behaviour by wearing
a broad-brimmed hat and sunglasses, and encourage
students to play in the shade. At the Board level,
Curriculum and Operations/Facility departments can
work together to develop a shade policy that includes
these strategies and others to provide effective protection
for students. For information about shade policies, see
the Resources section at the end of this document.
6
H. Akbari and H. Taha, “The Impact of trees and white surfaces on residential heating and cooling energy use in four Canadian cities,”
Energy: the International Journal, 1992
Henry Kock in A Breath of Fresh Air: Celebrating Nature and School Gardens
s
ep
res
Ec
rog
2
Designing for Shade and Energy Conservation
5
he
St CondouRcetvtiew
Monito
Five-Step
Evaluate Pr and
Process
Step
8
THE FIVE - STEP PROCESS AT A GLANCE
e
th
P
D
Ac e
t
nt lan
Ste
i on e ve ion
p
Act lem lo Pla
pt n
Imp he
3
Step
4
Step E S TA B L I S H A N E C O T E A M
1
Once you’ve decided to make some positive changes to your school
ground, invite others to join your EcoTeam – students, teachers,
parents, the Principal, custodian and community members.
TOOLS
Spread the word
Sample Letter
Hold a start-up Meeting
Volunteer Opportunities
9
now complete a series of steps that will result in your Action Plan.
TOOLS
Develop a Conceptual Plan (Map 4)
Complete a Detailed Phase One Site Plan Planning for Shade
Obtain Board Approvals Guidelines for Tree
Record Project Goals in Your School Plan Planting
Devise a Tree Care Plan Tree Care
Develop a Fundraising Strategy Fundraising
Step M O N I T O R A N D E VA L U AT E
5
The final step of your EcoTeam’s work is to evaluate your progress
toward the goals and targets you have set.
S T E P 1 . E S TA B L I S H A N
ECOTEAM FOR SHADE AND
E N E R G Y C O N S E R VAT I O N
* Available at www.yorku.ca/fes/envedu/ecoschools.asp
B Find out why trees are important and the special role they play
in maintaining a healthy environment.
The International Society of Arboriculture www.treesaregood.com
Tree Link www.treelink.org/linx/?navSubCatRef=56
Looking Ahead…
You might want to distribute the questionnaires
for conducting the survey of your school grounds
(Toolkit pp. 36-41) at this meeting.
2.1 Survey User Needs be used later when the team is mapping the
and Use Patterns play and use patterns on your school ground.
2.2 Survey your School further explore where shade is needed. This
Grounds is a great opportunity to involve the students
in collecting and analyzing information.
Before you can begin planning the details
To begin you must obtain a base plan of
of your shade project, you’ll need to learn a
your school grounds. If it is 8.5”x11”
few things about your school grounds. The
enlarge it to 11”x17” and make several
following mapping exercise will help your
copies. Go outside with your 11”x17”
team understand the physical features of the
plans and make three maps of the features
grounds, the way people use the site and
on your school ground.
14
Legend Slope Slope
Muddy
White
Willow
Views
Wet area Slope
Emergency and
maintenance Parking lot
Hot and Sunny vehicle access
Baseball
Crab
Line Snow pile Apple
Wet of Sugar
area Maples
Student drop off
Cool and Shady Muddy
Asphalt
wet area Entrance
Soccer field
Outside White
Play water taps
structure Ash
Garbage
Neighbours Classroom pick-up
windows
Lighting
Existing trees
Entrance Classroom
White
Asphalt windows
Ash
Entrance
Baseball Muddy
No grass
Sunnyview
Public School Wet area Grove of Sugar Maples
Views
B active play areas (sports fields, baseball, including naturally worn pathways
sandpits, etc); across grass;
B asphalt game areas (basketball, four B ‘out of bounds’ areas where students
16
PLAY AND USE PATTERNS
Legend
Spectator area
Active
play Parking lot
Pathways Active
play Entrance
Cool and Shady Meet
Active and Active play
play greet Play structure
area
Soccer field
Student
Westerly winds gathering
Spectator Active
area
area play
Entrance
Student Out of
gathering Entrance bounds
Entrance
Main entrance
Meet Active play
and Play Asphalt pathway Meet and greet area
greet structure
Active area
play
Spectator area
2.2 MAP 3
17
EXISTING SHADE AND USE PATTERNS
Legend
Spectator area
Active
play Parking lot
Entrance Classroom
Student windows
Student
gathering gathering Entrance Out of
Entrance
Main entrance
Meet Active play
and Play
greet Asphalt pathway Meet and greet area
structure
Active area
play
Student
gathering Kindergarten play area
Sunnyview Baseball area
Public School
Target/Goal: Provide natural shade on school grounds to protect students and staff from
exposure to solar UVR and to conserve energy
1. Active play areas near the school building including 12:00 p.m. Hopscotch play
asphalt play areas, adjacent to basketball courts, ✗ area to be shaded
hopscotch, ball hockey courts, etc.
10. Next to school buildings on the south 2:00 p.m. - 4:00 p.m.
and southwest sides. ✗
Block winter winds to conserve energy.
We recommend that you record the results of the review in your school plan to help raise the
visibility of this important part of school life. See sample on page 26.
3.1
3.6 Complete a conceptual plan
for shade and energy
Develop a fund- conservation
raising strategy
3.5
Create a
Action 3.2
tree care Plan Develop a detailed
phase one site plan
plan
3.4 3.3
Obtain Board
Record your phase one
activities in the school plan approvals
22
CONCEPTUAL PLAN FOR SHADE AND ENERGY CONSERVATION
Legend Phase 3
Phase 2
Naturalise slope
Allée of trees Phase 2
Phase 3 Grove of trees
Phase 1 Windbreak
• Shade play
structures Emergency and
maintenance Parking lot
• Shade meet
vehicle
and greet areas
(groves of trees) Phase 3 Baseball
• Extend Windbreak
Kindergarten
play area (fence
shaded area)
• Shade asphalt
active play Phase 2 Entrance
Phase 1
and shade the Grove Phase 1
Grove Play
building (plant of trees Trees
of trees structure
trees 7m from planted
the building and 7m from
Soccer field Phase 2 Classroom
add seating) the
Allée of windows
trees building
Phase 2
• Shade spectator
areas
(allée of trees) Phase 1
• Shade social Trees
Entrance
gathering areas planted Classroom
(groves of trees, 7m from windows
Entrance
Entrance
Woodland Phase 1
school grounds
(woodland project Main entrance Add seating
and naturalising Play in shade
Phase 1
north-west slope) Grove structure
• Develop walking
of trees
trail (tree trail) Phase 2
Baseball Grove
Phase 2
of trees
Circle
Sunnyview of trees
Public School Phase 1
Phase 3 Extend kindergarten
Phase 2 Tree trail play area
Emergency and Allée of trees
maintenance
vehicle
windows
Classroom
When making choices about your phase one plan, contact Board staff
who oversee school grounds. Early input from people with first-hand
experience can often help you avoid pitfalls and achieve greater success!
24
School
building
Hackberry
Benches
Play structure
Concrete edge
Red Maple
Silver Maple
White Ash
Trees planted along south and west side of play structure area, at 6m intervals, 2m from concrete edge.
3.3 Obtain Board Approvals 8 Detailed Phase One Site Plan
8 Tree Care plan (a task list and
Getting Board approval for your school
schedule)
ground greening project may be a multi-
step process, depending on your Board’s
3.4 Identify Priorities and
policies. Usually the school principal must
Develop the Action Plan
give initial approval to the plans. Often, the
department that is responsible for outdoor Consider using the School Improvement Plan
maintenance and landscaping will also want template to record your plans. The Targets
to see the proposal. Be flexible with your or Goals section corresponds to the priorities
design (have a few options) and be prepared for shade that came out of the planning
to do your project in phases. process. The Actions section corresponds
We recommend that you have the following to your detailed plans for adding shade.
information ready for review: Writing your project into the school plan
will demonstrate your school’s commitment
8 EcoReview Site Assessment for both to children’s health and conserving
Shade and Energy Conservation energy.
8 Existing Shade and Use Patterns Map
8 Conceptual Plan for Shade
26
Refer to your EcoReview Site Assessment Comments section as you complete your Action Plan below.
4.1 Prepare for Planting Day 8 Determine when your trees and/or
nursery stock will be available and select
Planting Day Checklist
a date for planting. Fall plantings are
8 Make sure you know where the highly recommended, especially if you
underground services are located on your
are unsure of the availability of summer
school grounds before you dig. Ask your
maintenance and watering.
custodian which utilities companies provide 8 Order your trees and shrubs as soon as
service to your school. Contact Ontario
funding is secured to ensure that your
One Call and other companies from which
stock will be available for planting day.
you require clearance (see below). 8 Notify the principal and any board
8 Take pictures of your site prior to grounds staff of the planting date
planting.
well in advance.
8 See if board staff are able to supply trees 8 Organize publicity and mobilize your
and what additional help they can offer
volunteers.
on planting day.
Give Ontario One Call one week’s notice and have the following information ready when you call:
B the address of your school B the closest cross street
B what side of the street your school is on B where you are planning to dig
Arrange clearance with each of the following (where applicable): Hydro One; natural gas provider; sewer and
water; telephone; cable. These companies will provide clearance numbers if all is clear, or a sketch detailing
service locations.
www.on1call.com
Toolkit
Sample Letter to Announce your Project 34
Volunteer Opportunities 35
Tree Care
Maintenance 68
What to do during the summer months 75
Fundraising
Writing funding applications and proposals 77
Sample budget 79
Fundraising and donation ideas 80
Funders 80
Date
[School Name] is initiating a project to design our school grounds for shade and energy conservation.
We will focus on creating shade for our students in areas where they play, are dropped off or picked up, line
up for classes and gather to eat and socialize. Providing shade is critical to protect students from the sun’s
harmful rays.
B Children spend up to 25% of their school day outside and are typically on the school grounds during
the periods of highest UVR exposure - between 10 a.m. and 4 p.m.
B Research shows that one in seven children born today will develop skin cancer in their lifetime
(Canadian Dermatology Association).
B Shaded areas also cool air temperatures on school grounds, making playing and learning outdoors
more enjoyable.
Shading the school building is also important for reducing both heating and cooling costs, thus saving
energy and reducing climate-changing greenhouse gas emissions.
We will be looking at ideas for creating more shade - planting trees, shrubs and vines, building shade
structures, and providing seating in shaded areas.
We welcome your input and involvement in this project. We need the support and effort of the entire
school community to be successful and we want to hear from you!
Please join us at our upcoming meeting [date, time, location] to share your thoughts and ideas about the
school ground. [If you can provide childcare, say so here.]
Sincerely,
[name]
[title — if there is one]
on behalf of the [School Name] EcoTeam
_____________________________________________________________________
4. Would you be willing to help with any parts of the project? What might you be interested
in doing? Please place a check mark beside the areas where you could help.
5. Please list other ways that you might be able to help. ___________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
1. What times of the day do you gather/play in the school grounds? __________________
____________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
5. What would you like to see done on your school grounds to increase the amount of shade
and make it more comfortable?
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
Note: You may wish to modify this form for secondary students.
We are looking at ways to shade the school grounds to improve children’s health and conserve
energy. We’re interested in knowing your views on these issues. Please complete this
questionnaire and return it to the EcoTeam or Principal by ______________ (date).
4. In your opinion, where do the majority of students play or gather on the school grounds, e.g.,
neat the school building (asphalt play areas), sports fields, baseball diamonds, etc.?
Please express your comments as percentages, e.g., 50% of students play within 25 metres of the
school building on the asphalt, 20% play in the sports fields, 30% play on the play structure.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
5. Are there shaded and/or sheltered areas which are out of bounds to students during recess and
lunch time? Yes 8 No 8. If yes, could these areas become accessible if additional supervision
or new boundaries were instituted? Please explain.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
continued...
6. What are your thoughts and/or recommendations (e.g., changes, additions) for increasing the
amount of useable shade on the school grounds to make them more comfortable and safer for
play and learning outside?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
2. Is the school building uncomfortable during hot days – for instance, are classrooms on the
south/west sides too warm? Yes 8 No 8 Don’t know 8
3. Is it uncomfortable being out on the school grounds in winter because of strong winds?
Yes 8 No 8 Don’t know 8
4. Would you be willing to devote class time to a greening project focused on shade and energy
conservation if the planning, development, maintenance and use could become part of delivering
the curriculum? Yes 8 No 8
We are looking at ways to shade our school grounds to protect students from harmful sun
exposure and to conserve energy. We’re interested in knowing your views on these issues.
Please complete this questionnaire and have your son or daughter return it to the
school by _______________ (date).
1. Are there places to get out of the wind and sun on your school grounds?
2. Do you think there is enough shade where students gather/play on the school grounds?
Yes 8 No 8 If no, which areas do you think need more shade? Please list.
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
3. Is there existing shade in ‘out of bounds’ areas (e.g., the front of the school or back of the sports
fields)? Yes 8 No 8 If yes, please list.
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
4. Is the school building uncomfortable during hot days – are classrooms on the south and south/west
sides too warm? Yes 8 No 8 Don’t know 8
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
We are currently looking at ways to shade the school grounds to improve children’s health and
conserve energy. We are interested in knowing your views on these issues. Please complete
this questionnaire and return it to the EcoTeam by _________ (date).
2. If no, please indicate which of the following you would choose to increase shade for students:
8 large shade trees
8 shrubs
8 metal shade structures – (e.g., gazebo)
8 wooden shade structure
8 other _______________________
3. What, if any, are your concerns with regard to the placement of these elements on the school ground?
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
3. Are there high wind speeds during winter months on the north and western exposures of the
building? Yes 8 No 8 Don’t know 8
4. Are there maintenance issues you would like to see addressed in the plan for the project?
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
Please complete this questionnaire and return it to the EcoTeam by ________________ (date).
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
2. Are there areas that could provide shade and/or shelter, but are out of bounds for students during
recess and lunch time? Yes 8 No 8. If yes, could they become accessible if additional supervision
or new boundaries were established? Please explain.
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
3. Do you have any current concerns about supervision on the school grounds? Please explain.
___________________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________
4. What are your recommendations (e.g., changes, additions) for increasing the amount of useable
shade on the school grounds to make them more comfortable and safer for gathering/play and
learning outside?
___________________________________________________________________________________
3. Are there high wind speeds during winter months on the school grounds on the north and western
exposures of the building? Yes 8 No 8 Don’t know 8
The canopy density guide will help you assess the level of UVR protection provided by different trees.7
View the tree canopy against the sky and compare with illustrated leaf/canopy patterns.
Estimate which pattern of sky and leaves most closely approximates the observed canopy.
7
J.S. Greenwood, G.P. Soulos and N.D. Thomas, Undercover: Guidelines for shade planning and design. Sydney: NSW Cancer Council
and NSW Health Department, 1998, p. 76.
Build upon data gathered from questionnaires, mapping and canopy density results.
Target/Goal: Provide natural shade on school grounds to protect students and staff from
exposure to solar UVR and to conserve energy
2. Play structures
Provide natural shade on school grounds to improve comfort and conserve energy
* Undercover: Guidelines for shade planning and design can be purchased by contacting
the Cancer Council South Australia - Email: tcc@cancersa.org.au
Tree form
When designing for shade consider tree broad and narrow shapes to achieve higher
size and form at maturity. Trees with broad rates of shade coverage. See pages 81-82 of
crowns and dense foliage provide the best the Resources section for recommended field
protection from UVR. However, trees with guides that will provide this information.
narrow form can be planted in a mix of
ROUND OR
VASE-SHAPED GLOBE-SHAPED
47
Ontario EcoSchools: Designing for Shade and Energy Conservation
N
P l a n t i n g o n e t r e e i s n ’t a s e f f e c t i v e a s p l a n t i n g m a n y i n a g r o v e t o f o r m a n a t u r a l g a z e b o f o r s h a d e . P l a n t a m i n i m u m
of 6 trees 6m apart in a grouping. Mulch to a depth of 15cm underneath the trees and add rocks for seating.
Planning for Shade
SEATING IN SHADE – Shade for spectators
48
Ontario EcoSchools: Designing for Shade and Energy Conservation
N P r o v i d i n g s h a d e w h e r e s t u d e n t s , s t a f f a n d p a r e n t s g a t h e r t o w a t c h s p o r t s e v e n t s i s a n i m p o r t a n t p a r t o f y o u r s h a d e s t r a t e g y.
P l a n t t r e e s i n a r o w 8 - 1 0 m f r o m b o u n d a r y l i n e s . I f t h e r e i s e n o u g h r o o m p l a n t a s e c o n d r o w t o c r e a t e a n a l l ée o f t r e e s .
Planning for Shade
SEATING IN SHADE – Grove of Evergreens
49
Ontario EcoSchools: Designing for Shade and Energy Conservation
N
Plant evergreens 6m apart in a grove. Mulch to a depth of 15cm and add rocks to provide seating.
Planning for Shade
SEATING IN SHADE – Trees adjacent to asphalt play area
50
Ontario EcoSchools: Designing for Shade and Energy Conservation
N
Plant a combination of evergreen and deciduous trees. Mulch to a depth of 15cm and add logs to provide seating.
Planning for Shade
SEATING IN SHADE – Habitat project
51
Ontario EcoSchools: Designing for Shade and Energy Conservation
N
Plant a combination of trees and shrubs. Mulch to a depth of 15cm and add rocks or logs to provide seating.
Planning for Shade
Planning for Shade
B Don’t use logs from old or sick trees B Place rocks right up against each other
that have been felled. These logs attract or space them out according to your
carpenter ants, termites, raccoons, wasps preferred design. When placing them
and rodents, rot quickly and can spread randomly or in a circle in the landscape
disease to other trees on your grounds. leave a 2 m distance between them
to discourage students from jumping
B Size is important: logs should be a
from one to the other.
minimum of 45 cm in diameter; this
allows them to be dug into the ground B Provide a soft bed of wood mulch around
8 cm to prevent rolling. rocks - approximately 10 - 15 cm in
depth.
B Do mulch around logs to a 10 cm depth
to secure them.
53
Ontario EcoSchools: Designing for Shade and Energy Conservation
N
Plant trees on the south and southwest sides of a play structure area. Maintain a 2m distance from the outer limit of the
fall zones and/or from the timber or concrete curbing surrounding the perimeter of the play structure.
Planning for Shade
ALLÉE OF TREES
54
Ontario EcoSchools: Designing for Shade and Energy Conservation
Planting double rows of trees 6m apart creates a dense canopy of green along pathways and trails and offers natural
protection from UVR.
N
Planning for Shade
Planning for Shade
For more about designing windbreaks, hedgerows and living fences see Evergreen’s resource
Design Ideas for the Outdoor Classroom, available on the Evergreen website at www.evergreen.ca
Remember, keeping sight lines clear to maintain good visibility is particularly important in
designing school greening projects!
From Evergreen’s
Learning Grounds Guide
for Elementary Schools
O BJECTS D ISTANCES
Spaces between trees 5-7 m
Seating 2m
Rocks, benches, picnic tables, game boards
Play structure 2m
(measure from outside the fall zones and/or
from the timber or concrete edging surrounding
the perimeter of the installation)
Base of a slide 4m
School building 7m
Fence lines 2m
(respect neighbours’ views)
Walkways 2m
Edge of asphalt 2m
Running track 5m
(no trees or shrubs should be planted on the inside of the track)
Fire hydrants 6m
Flag poles 10 m
(adjust according to branching patterns)
Maintaining visibility
B Avoid blocking night lighting or interfering with security cameras.
Nut trees have not been included in this list because of potential student allergies. American
Beech and Bur Oak are native nut trees that may be suitable for planting on school grounds.
Check to see if your Board has policies on planting nut or fruit trees. The Board’s grounds staff
may be able to help you select trees and shrubs best suited for your site.
Sugar Maple Acer 20-30m Slow Provides food and Fall colours red,
Saccharum shelter for birds orange, yellow
and butterflies
1 4 - 2 5m
Red Maple Acer rubrum 20-25m Medium Especially favoured Fall colour bright red;
by squirrels, flowers are red in
chipmunks and birds dense clusters and
1 2 - 1 8m bloom in March-April
Silver Maple † Acer 20-35m Fast Trunk sections may Fall colour pale
Saccharinum become hollow and yellow or brown
provide habitat for
squirrels, raccoons
1 2 - 1 8m and other animals
Basswood/ Tilia americana 20-35m Medium Fragrant yellow Fall colour pale
American flowers are an yellow or remain
Linden excellent source of green
nectar for bees and
12-16m other insects
White Ash † Fraxinus 20-30m Medium Seeds are eaten Fall colour purple-
Americana by birds yellow; flowers are
purple and bloom
1 5 - 1 8m in April-May
Tulip tree Liriodendron 25-30m Fast Seeds provide food Fall colour yellow;
tulipifera for birds and squirrels flower colour greenish
Attracts bees yellow and blooms
8-12m in June
Hackberry Celtis 12-18m Medium Birds are attracted to Fall colour yellow
occidentalis the fruit
1 2 - 1 8m
White Cedar Thuja 10-15m Slow Excellent food and Needles turn bronze
occidentalis shelter for birds colour in winter
3 - 5m
White Pine †
Pinus 25-30m Medium Provides food and Cones open in
strobus shelter for birds September and seeds
fall over the winter
6-12m
White Spruce † Picea glauca 20-30m Fast Excellent food and Cones open in
shelter for birds September and seeds
fall over the winter
3 - 7m
Downy Amelanchier 5-10m Provides food and shelter White flowers in April-May;
Serviceberry arborea for birds purple/red fruit in Sept.
Shadblow Amelanchier 5-10m Provides food and shelter White flowers in April-May;
Serviceberry Canadensis for birds blue/black fruit in Sept.
Nannyberry Viburnum 4-7m Provides food and shelter White flowers in May-June;
lentago for birds blue/black fruit in Aug-Sept.
Staghorn Rhus typhina 1-6m Provides food and shelter Yellowish flowers in June-July;
Sumac for birds red fruit cones in July-Aug.
Elderberry Sambucus 1 - 3m Provides food and shelter White flowers in June; edible
canadensis for birds and butterflies black berries in Aug.-Sept.
Pussy Willow Salix spp. 2-10m Flowers are an early food White/cream flowers in Mar.-
discolour source for bees and provide April; brown fruit in fall
material for hummingbird
nests
Alternate Cornus 3 - 5m Provides food and shelter Pale yellow flowers in June;
Dogwood alternifolia for birds bluish-black fruit in August
70-75mm caliper
(trunk diameter)
2m
Planting in turf
a) Dig a wide hole the height e) Backfill to 1/3 the rootball depth
of the rootball and twice and tamp to stabilize rootball
its width. The top of the and prevent air pockets.
rootball should be level
with the surrounding f ) Continue to backfill until the
ground. rootball is covered. Mound
backfill slightly to make
b) Be sure that the a saucer of soil around the
sides of the hole tree - see illustration.
are scarified*
to help roots g) Water the entire backfill area
penetrate until saturated. Add
surrounding more soil to compensate
soil and to for settling if needed.
increase drainage.
h) Apply 10-15 cm of tub grinder
c) Be sure that the rootball wood mulch to a diameter of 2m.
rests on solid ground (no less than 1/2 a cubic yard per tree).
before backfilling. Keep mulch weeded and replace annually.
15 cm layer of mulch
remove all
saucer of soil ropes and ties
rootball
dig hole at a 45O angle
Planting in poorly drained soils slightly out of the ground and amending
with sharp sand that drains well, you can
Many schools have poorly drained, heavy improve the tree’s chances of survival.
clay soil that retains water for long periods
of time. By raising the tree’s rootball
a) Dig a wide, shallow hole that e) Continue to backfill until the rootball
is twice the width of the rootball is covered. Mound backfill slightly
and only 1/2 as deep. to make a saucer of soil around
the tree - see illustration below.
b) Be sure that the rootball
rests on solid ground. f ) Water the entire backfill area
until saturated. Add more
c) Begin to fill in the hole soil to compensate for
around the tree with settling if needed.
a blend of 3/4 local soil
and 1/4 sharp sand. g) Mulch over soil with 10-15cm of wood
mulch to a diameter of 2m (no less
d) Backfill to 1/3 the than 1/2 a cubic yard per tree). Keep
rootball depth and tamp mulch weeded and replace annually.
to stabilize rootball and
prevent air pockets. h) Modify watering schedule to suit the
drainage conditions - watering
heavy clay soils too much will
drown your tree.
mulch
rootball
grade (surface)
turf stone
sand
rootball
drip line
drip line
mulch
Stones in a circle
Another way to
protect tree roots is to
use stones in a circle
approximately 2m
in diameter around
the trunk and fill this
area with daylilies,
native grasses or 10-15cm
of mulch. Make sure the
stones are placed on a solid
base, not on the mulch where
they can roll or shift.
10-15cm of mulch
Refer to the site map for the location of the plantings that need to be watered.
Trees in asphalt - Set water flow on low and water for a minimum of 10 minutes 3 times per week
Trees in turf - Water a minimum of six minutes twice a week, using a standard 5/8” hose
Spring (Students)
May Week 1
May Week 2
May Week 3
May Week 4
June Week 1
June Week 2
June Week 3
June Week 4
Summer (Families)
July Week 1
July Week 2
July Week 3
July Week 4
August Week 1
August Week 2
August Week 3
August Week 4
September Week 1
B Let parents and others know what you from suppliers and use these amounts
need - it’s amazing what you can find. on your budget page.
B Contact local service clubs and B Take time to anticipate all of your
businesses, which may contribute in- costs (don’t forget such things as
kind goods and services as well as cash taxes, delivery, film and processing).
donations.
2. Share the task with others.
3. Understand the grant criteria (this step B It’s a big job. Get several volunteers
will save you unnecessary work). to take different parts of the grant
B Call the representative of the funding application and write them up (e.g.,
agency to discuss your project. teacher representatives can write the
B Does your project meet its funding curriculum connections).
criteria? B Have one person compile all the parts
B What does it not fund (e.g., delivery and submit the final proposal (this
charges, salaries)? person should also be the contact).
3. Follow the grant application questions B Demonstrate that you are organized
precisely. and have a plan - include photos and
B Answer all the questions in the order site diagrams.
they appear on the application. B Include your in-kind donations of
B Include all attachments and goods and services in the budget -
documents requested. this shows community support for
B If you don’t use the application your project.
form itself, use the application form B Include a cover letter to express your
headings in your proposal. enthusiasm and your dedication to
the project.
4. Be clear and concise.
B Point form answers are often better 5. Provide recognition.
than paragraphs. B List several ways in which the funding
B Clearly articulate the project goals and organization will receive recognition
objectives related to the funds that for its support and ways in which the
you are requesting. organization can be involved.
B Make certain that your plant species
Sample budget
Native Plants
Other resources
trowels 5 $4 $20
SUBTOTAL $950
There are many ways to fundraise and find donations of materials for your project. Here are 10
ideas to get you started.
Funders
www.earthplay.net
Background information on UVR
• Solar noon calculator website
www.srrb.noaa.gov
Other Shade Treatments
Willow structures • Sun Safety Information Guide for Schools
Living Willow www.city.toronto.on.ca/health/sun/pdf/
www.livingwillow.com cp_sun_safety_info_for_schools.pdf
The Participatory Design Process Technical information, pictures and projects, easy-
to-use site.
• All Hands in the Dirt: A Guide to Designing
and Creating Natural School Grounds. Toronto: • plus.maths.org/issue11/features/sundials
Evergreen, 2000 Ideal for secondary students studying sundials.
This manual will guide you through the planning
process, providing tips and templates for • www.hps.cam.ac.uk/starry/sundcalen.html
designing a site that reflects your local natural The history of sundials and calendars.
environment and the ideas of all involved.
www.evergreen.ca/en/ lg/lg- • kids.msfc.nasa.gov/Earth/Sundials/
toolshed.htmlwww.evergreen.ca Sundials.asp
NASA
• Coffey, Anne. Asking Children, Listening to Children.
Ottawa: Canadian Biodiversity Institute, 2004.
This guide for consulting with students is
designed to accompany a video of the same Shade Policy
name to help schools organize and conduct class-
by-class brainstorming sessions at the start of • Creating Shade at Public Facilities – policy and
their school ground transformation projects. guidelines for local government. December 2002.
www.biodiversityonline.ca/schoolgrounds/ www.health.qld.gov.au/
ind ex.html
• Greenwood, J.S., G.P. Soulos, and N.D. Thomas.
• The Learning Grounds Guide for Secondary Schools. Undercover: Guidelines for shade planning and design.
Toronto: Evergreen, 2002 Sydney: NSW Cancer Council and NSW Health
This guide helps schools create outdoor learning Department, 1998.
environments on their school grounds by
providing a road map to assist in the planning, • Sunsmart Policy
design, implementation and maintenance of a www.arandaps.act.edu.au/environment/
school ground greening project. activity/healthy/sunsmart.htm#Seats
www.evergreen.ca/en/lg/green-street.html
• Sunsmart School Policy Guidelines
www.cancerresearchuk.org/sunsmart/
schoolsandchildren/schoolpolicyguidelines/
Project Administrators
Richard Christie, Toronto District School Board
Lewis Molot, Faculty of Environmental Studies, York University
Project Manager
Eleanor Dudar, Toronto District School Board
Steering Committee
Ron Ballentine, Halton DSB, Science Coordinators’ and Consultants’ Association of Ontario; Richard Christie,
Toronto DSB; Judy Gould, Durham DSB; David Green, Toronto and Region Conservation Authority;
Arlene Higgins-Wright, York Region DSB; Lewis Molot, York University; Pam Schwartzberg, Learning
for A Sustainable Future
Advisory Committee
Ted Cheskey, Waterloo Region DSB; Xavier Fazio/Susan Paradiso, Halton Catholic DSB; Joanne Harris,
Science Teachers’ Association of Ontario; Ethel Johnston/Kim Wallace, Ontario Association for Geography
and Environmental Educators; Catherine Kurucz, Thames Valley DSB; Gina Micomonaco, York Catholic DSB;
Anne Mitchell, Canadian Institute for Environmental Law and Policy; Marsha Yamamoto, Toronto DSB
Project Designer
Comet art + design
This guide is an adaptation of School Ground Greening: Designing for Shade and Energy
Conservation produced by Evergreen and the Toronto District School Board (TDSB).
The TDSB and Evergreen have donated this resource to Ontario EcoSchools as part of
their in-kind contribution to the project.
project partners
A M D ISTR
RH
IC
DU
T
CH
D
R
S
OOL BOA
www.yorku.ca/fes/envedu/ecoschools.asp