Professional Documents
Culture Documents
DOI 10.1007/s10342-006-0129-3
O R I GI N A L P A P E R
Received: 28 February 2005 / Accepted: 17 February 2006 / Published online: 20 April 2006
Springer-Verlag 2006
Introduction
The management of renewable natural resources and the
formulation of the corresponding policies and conserCommunicated by Hans Pretzsch
C. Kleinn (&) D. Morales-Hidalgo
Institute of Forest Management, Georg-August-Universitat
Gottingen, Busgenweg 5, 37077 Gottingen, Germany
E-mail: ckleinn@gwdg.de
Tel.: +49-551-393472
Fax: +49-551-399787
Present address: E-mail: dmorale@gwdg.de
362
Study area
The study area is located in the central mountain range
of the Andes, in the Coee Region of Colombia, and
extends over parts of the Departments of Valle del
Cauca, Quindio, Risaralda and Caldas (see also Fig. 2),
the UTM grid coordinates being (zone 18) 1064421,
922515 and 1195757, 1122579. The area was selected
such that it covered an altitudinal range between 900
and 2,000 m, where there are favourable growing conditions for Guadua. The total area was 1,029,525 ha.
Coee had been the major crop in that region; pastures and plantain being other agricultural land uses.
Mean annual precipitation is 2,750 mm with two major
rainy seasons (April to June and August to November),
and mean annual temperature is around 21C. According to the life zoning proposed by Holdridge et al. (1971)
the study area belongs to the following life zones:
tropical humid forest, tropical very humid forest, tropical dry forest and premontane tropical humid forest.
For sampling studies, the sampling frame needs to be
dened from which sample selection takes place. Here,
the sampling frame is dened by all Guadua patches in
the study region with a minimum patch area of 0.3 ha.
This threshold value was dened in discussion with
Colombian experts, who stated that smaller patches are
less attractive for commercial harvesting.
Methods
Commonly, two basic elements of information are required in large area natural resources inventories: (1) the
estimation of area and (2) the estimation of characteristics of the resource per unit of area.
Estimation of the total area of the very irregular and
fragmented patches of Guadua is a challenge. Because of
the fragmentation, the small size of the patches and the
topography, medium resolution satellite imagery of
about 1530 m appeared to be problematic and was not
taken into consideration. For economic reasons, high
resolution satellite imagery could not be used, so that
we resorted to readily available aerial photographs
taken between 1990 and 1995. While photographs of
712 years old are critical for many inventory studies,
here it appeared justied as experts conrm that considerable changes have not taken place during that time
period. To check this statement, verication observations were taken and used for calibration of the aerial
photo-based area estimation.
From the interpretation of the aerial photographs,
the projected area of Guadua culms was estimated. This
area, however, needed to be reduced to correct for the
slop-over of culms at the Guadua stand boundary (see
Fig. 1). The width of this strip along the stand boundary, which is under the vertical projection of the culms
but where there are no culms growing was measured
during the inventory at many points at the stand
boundaries. The corrected area is then what we call the
eective area.
Sampling was done by systematic sampling, where
sample size was determined by the available budget. On
a randomly located 10 km 10 km grid in NorthSouth
orientation (see Fig. 2), 103 sample points fell into the
study area. For each point, the most recent aerial photograph was searched in the Instituto Geograco
Agust n Codazzi (IGAC, Bogota), the central point of
which was closest to the sampling point. Eventually,
suitable aerial photographs could be found for 89 sampling points. The remaining 14 sample points were
treated as non-response.
On each photograph a sample plot was installed such
that the area in the eld was 3 km 3 km. This air
photo plot was located at the centre of the photograph
to reduce geometric distortions as much as possible. For
cost reasons and the lack of appropriate digital elevation
models, distortion-free orthophotos could not be produced. The prints were scanned in 600 dpi resolution so
that an interpretation on screen was possible.
Because of its peculiar texture in the aerial photographs and their typical fragmented shape, it was not a
major problem to distinguish and identify Guadua
stands. Within the aerial photo plots, all Guadua patches were delineated.
Field verication was done for 21 randomly selected
sample areas out of the total of 89; the corresponding 21
aerial photo plots were geo-referenced for this exercise.
Following this verication, some new patches needed to
be included and some eliminated from the maps generated for the aerial photo sample plots. This eld verication recorded both interpretation errors and real
changes that have occurred between taking the aerial
photographs and the inventorywhere we assume that
interpretation errors were at a minimum because of the
specic and relatively easily identiable texture of Guadua stands. A calibration factor was calculated from
this verication exercise to calibrate the nal area estimate.
For the estimation of Guadua stand characteristics, a
two-stage sampling design was used, using the base grid
of 10 km 10 km. From the 89 aerial photo plotswhich were considered a set of primary plotsa subsample of 13 was randomly selected for eld sampling.
Within each of these 13 selected primary plots, 10 sec-
363
Fig. 1 Illustration of the
concept of eective area. Left: a
Guadua stand boundary where
the projection of crowns
extends into the adjacent
agricultural eld; the highly
irregular crown projection
requires smoothing when
delineation is done in aerial
photographs. Right: illustration
of the dierence between
crown-projected area and
eective area of a Guadua
patch; the outer bold line is the
smoothed delineation of crown
projection; the inner line is the
estimated area where culms
actually grow. Here, three
larger tree crowns are visible
within the Guadua area
364
Fig. 2 Study area and sample
point locations. Five provinces
in the western part of Colombia
of Caldas, Quind o, Risaralda,
Tolima and Valle form the
Coee Region of Colombia; the
study area is completely
situated within the Coee
Region (map A and enlarged
map). In sample points with
aerial photographs, aerial
photo plots were established
and all Guadua patches
mapped (map B); within these
patches, ten secondary plots
were randomly selected per
aerial photo plot
365
Results
Area estimation
Total Guadua stand area, delineated as crown projected
area and reduced by a calibration factor of 0.96 resulting
from eld verication, was estimated to be 3.9%
(SE% = 10.7%), corresponding to an absolute area of
about 40,000 ha. Mean patch size was estimated to be
2.9 ha (SE% = 4.8%), ranging in the aerial photograph
sample plots from 0.3 to 43.7 ha. It is interesting to note
that the maximum Guadua patch perimeter observed in
the sample was about 15,000 m for a Guadua patch of
42.3 ha. A square with that perimeter would have an
area of about 1,400 ha! This calculation gives an
impression of the high degree of irregularity and fragmentation of Guadua patches. The patch size distribution, produced from the mapped aerial photograph plots
(Fig. 3), shows that this biggest patch of 43.7 ha has the
character of an outlier. The vast majority of patch sizes
is 2 ha and less.
The eective area is calculated from the mapped
projected area by subtracting a strip at the outer edge of
each Guadua patch, where there are no culms. The mean
width of this strip was estimated 8.6 m from n = 230
eld measurements with a relative standard error of
SE% = 1.6; see Fig. 1 for illustration. Because of the
fragmented and elongated shape of the Guadua patches
this border strip covers a considerable area; it was estimated to be 31.1% of the total projected Guadua stand
450
400
350
Frequency
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
0
12 15 18 21 24 27 30 33 36 39 42
Guadua patch size [ha]
366
Table 1 Development classes
Development class (denitions adapted from Londono 1998)
Shoots: From emergence of the new shoot until reaching its maximum height.
Culm protected by culm leaves, and without developing branches or foliage
Young Guadua:Loss of the culm leaves, development of intense green colour,
branches and foliage
Mature Guadua: The culm loses its bright green colour and turns into an
opaque green and then gradually to grey, as lichens, fungi and mosses
appear on the culms surface
Dry Guadua: The plants death phase. It is expressed by yellow colour
of the culm, and dryness of the middle section of the branches
Broken Guadua: Damaged culms which are not complete
3.7 (12.8)
18.6 (10.8)
69.0 (7.1)
6.4 (15.9)
2.3 (18.9)
Obs: these classes are those that are commonly used in Guadua management and operations in the Coee Region in Colombia. They are
based on directly observable attributes and are suitable for practical application. It is hardly possible to link these development classes
directly to age classes, because age is virtually impossible to determine
60%
50%
Abundance (%)
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
4-8
Shoots
8-12
12-16
16-20
Diameter Classes (Dbh) (cm)
Young
Mature
Dry
>=20
Total
367
Table 2 Approximations to apparent volume, wood volume, biomass and carbon content
Development
class
Shoots
Young
Mature
Dry
Broken
Total
N/ha
258
1,290
4,785
445
162
6,940
Relative
frequency (%)
3.7
18.6
69.0
6.4
2.3
100.00
Commercial
Total
Apparent
volume (m3/ha)
Wood
volume (m3/ha)
Apparent
volume (m3/ha)
Wood
volume (m3/ha)
Dry biomass
(ton/ha)
Carbon
(ton/ha)
654.0
654.0
304.0
304.0
223.0
729.0
56.0
1,008.0
99.0
339.0
27.0
465.0
66.0
227.0
18.0
311.0
33.0
113.5
9.0
155.5
368
(Universitat Freiburg), and the United Kingdom (Imperial College
of Science). The nancial support to the second author is highly
appreciated. Special and particular thanks are due to our colleague
and friend Dr Juan Carlos Camargo, professor at the Faculty of
Environmental Sciences at the Technical University of Pereira,
Colombia, for his continuing support and suggestions, to Dr Michael Tistl, principal advisor in a German technical cooperation
project at that University, and to Dr Ximena Londono, president
of the Colombian Bamboo Society. An inventory is a study in
which many people participate to all of whom we extend our
thanks. Our particular thanks for assistance in dierent elds are
due to Marco Antonio Chavez, Gustavo Cardona, Gabriel Jaime
Aranjo and the eld teams, Diego Rubiano, Jhon Mario Rodr guez, Lidieth Mar n, Lorena Orozco, Juan Carlos Ram rez and
Victor Madrigal. We are indebted to Prof. Walter Liese, for his
valuable suggestions on this manuscript and his continued advises
to our Guadua related projects. The observations of an anonymous
reviewer helped improving the manuscript and are highly appreciated.
References
Arango G (2002) Informe nal del inventario de campo de los
guaduales en el Eje Cafetero de Colombia. Proyecto Guadua
Bamboo. Informe interno, CATIE, Turrialba
Arbelaez A (1996) Relacion entre los caracteres morfologicos del
tallo de la guadua (Guadua angustifolia Kunth). Universidad
Nacional de Colombia, Medell n, 21 p
Bernal L (2002) Estudio para denir criterios tecnicos y metodologicos para el inventario, ordenamiento, zonicacion y
manejo sostenible del recurso Guadua en el Eje Cafetero, Tolima y Valle del Cauca. Internal document. Proyecto de Manejo
sostenible de Bosques en Colombia (MSBC). Ministerio del
Medio Ambiente/GTZ, Pereira, Colombia, 85 p
Brown S (1997) Estimating biomass and biomass change of tropical
forests. A Primer. FAO Forestry Paper 134. FAO, Rome, 55 p
Camargo JC (2004) Silvicultura y productividad de la Guadua angustifolia en la Zona Cafetera de Colombia. In: Memoria del
Simposio International Guadua 2004, Sept. 27October 2,
Pereira, Colombia (563 p), pp 3140
Camargo JC (2006) Growth and productivity of the bamboo species Guadua angustifolia Kunth in the Coee Region of
Colombia. Ph.D. Dissertation, Faculty of Forestry Science.
Georg-August-Universitat Gottingen, Germany. Cuvillier Verlag, 206 p
Camargo J, Garc a J, Morales T (2003) Cambios en la productividad de rodales naturales de Guadua (Guadua angustifolia Kunth) bajo diferentes condiciones de sitio y de manejo
silvicultural en el eje cafetero de Colombia. In: Proceedings of
VI International seminar on environmental and sustainable
development. Bogota, Colombia, Oct. 810, 2003