Have we fallen out of love with elephant rides?

- BBC News

News

Sport

Weather

UK

Business

Home

Video

World

Asia

China

India

29/04/2016, 16:32

Shop

Tech

Earth

Travel

Science

Magazine

Have we fallen out of love with elephant

rides?
28 April 2016

Top

SA co

Asia

'Elev
crash

John
race

Fea

Afgh

The d
and da
Elephant ride in Thailand

Elephant rides and other animal encounters have long been a staple of the
Asian backpacking experience. But with steady reports of animal cruelty, the
BBC's Anna Jones asks whether tourists are starting to turn their backs on
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-36147265

Page 1 of 8

Have we fallen out of love with elephant rides? - BBC News

29/04/2016, 16:32

such adventures.
I've done it. Like so many tourists to Asia, I have ridden an elephant.
It was many years ago while backpacking in Thailand, and I recall it as a mostly
uncomfortable experience, sliding around a wooden seat on a purpose-built track
through a sticky jungle.

The n

That's me in the picture above.

Have
becom

There was also a degree of moral discomfort. To my untrained eye, the elephant
seemed fairly uncomfortable too.
The mahouts - the handlers - carried curved spikes to keep the elephants in line as
we trekked around that track for quite some time.
When I asked if the hooks hurt as they hit the elephants on the forehead with the
spikes every now and again, they said no. Their skin was too thick, I was told.

News

But on a more recent visit to Cambodia, the guide on our bus asked if anyone
wanted to ride an elephant up to an Angkor Wat temple. The response from
everyone was a resounding no.

What
week?

Hatin

Some
Repub

Getty Images

There is still a healthy market for elephanteering and those tour operators say they prioritise the
welfare of the elephant

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-36147265

Page 2 of 8

Have we fallen out of love with elephant rides? - BBC News

29/04/2016, 16:32

Then this week, an online petition calling on Cambodia to totally ban elephant rides
was launched, and has already exceeded its target of 50,000 signatures.
It was driven by the news that an elderly elephant had collapsed and died while
shuttling tourists along that same Angkor Wat route in 40C heat.

'No cruelty-free rides'

'Love

Killing
a nerv

Build

What
Earth?

Facebook/ Yem Senok

This elephant's death has prompted thousands of people to sign a petition against the animals' use in
tourism

Elephants have never been truly domesticated. They are captive wild animals, and
if they decide to turn on handlers or riders, it can be deadly.
Operators generally reassure tourists that they look after their elephants well, but
critics say there is simply no way rides can happen humanely.

Elect

A Sna
begins

Procuring an elephant to use in logging or tourism often means taking it from the
wild as a baby and literally breaking its spirit, in an often brutal process.
Years of carrying tourists takes its toll on an elephant's body. An Asian elephant is
meant to have a peaked back, for example, but heavy saddles can flatten it.
They risk dislocated legs, die younger than they would in the wild and, their
advocates say, the inability to behave naturally takes a severe toll on these highly
sociable and intelligent animals' mental health.
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-36147265

Tradi

Cross

Page 3 of 8

Have we fallen out of love with elephant rides? - BBC News

29/04/2016, 16:32

Pass

Russia

Mos
Read
Reuters

Photos with tigers often appear on dating profiles, but are they ethical?

Alyx Elliott, UK head of campaigns at World Animal Protection, says she has
noticed "a significant shift in public attitudes".
"You only have to look at the public comments to TripAdvisor on social media to
see people's shock and outrage as they learn about the cruelty that is involved
when elephant rides are offered."
But it's also clear from TripAdvisor, a travel review portal, that there's still
enthusiasm for such elephanteering.
"Elephants are trained to pose for pictures and make noises," one five-star review
said of a tour from Bangkok last January.
Another rave review of a tour in Nonthaburi praises an "incredibly fun and exciting"
day spent "elephant riding, monkey feeding and visiting tiger temple, where we fed
a 7 month old tiger cub".
Consistent five-star reviews mean a tour can get a TripAdvisor "Certificate of
Excellence".

'Eleven
helicop

What i
object

SA cor
Zuma

'Secre

Russia
from S

John W
race ro

Partne
killing

New fi
second

US 'dr
subsid

Turnin
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-36147265

Page 4 of 8

Have we fallen out of love with elephant rides? - BBC News

29/04/2016, 16:32

IS?

Anna jones

Elephants are highly sociable and form tight bonds among family groups

World Animal Protection, which has already persuaded more than 100 tour
operators to commit to stopping selling or promoting elephant tours and shows,
now has TripAdvisor in its sights.
It says most people just aren't aware of the cruelty involved in the attraction they're
reviewing. It wants TripAdvisor to give more information on animal attractions, and
to override ratings so no operation where animal welfare is in question can get a
certificate of excellence.
TripAdvisor has said its reviews are not endorsements, that it doesn't promote any
illegal animal operations and that it is up to national governments to to ensure
businesses are operating legally.

A key source of income

Intrepid Travel believes it was the first tour operator to stop including elephant rides
in its packages altogether.
It did so after commissioning extensive research from World Animal Protection in
2010 which found almost no operators met its welfare standards.
Co-founder Geoff Manchester said some clients still asked about elephants, but
that once they explained their view, "99% will come around".

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-36147265

Page 5 of 8

Have we fallen out of love with elephant rides? - BBC News

29/04/2016, 16:32

Anna Jones

Places like Thailand's Elephant Nature Park say they offer an ethical way for tourists to come close to
elephants

Tourists can have other options if they want to encounter elephants, at places like
hospitals which treat injured animals and sanctuaries like the Elephant Nature Park
in Thailand, which rescues animals or buys them from commercial operators and
sets them free to roam its secluded valley outside Chiang Mai.
But a flat ban on making money from elephants - which have been used as working
animals in Asia for centuries - isn't necessarily practical.
"If all elephant riding stops the mahouts who own the elephants wont have any
income, and they won't have any way of supporting the elephants," says Mr
Manchester.
The onus should be on governments to help operators diversify, he says, citing a
scheme announced in Thailand under which the government would pay mahouts to
take their elephants into the jungle to roam free instead of using them
commercially.
But he says that while demand for elephant rides might be declining from Western
tourists, he had noticed a rising enthusiasm for them from Asian tourists.
And the truth, he says, is that the rides "won't stop unless the demand stops".

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-36147265

Page 6 of 8

Have we fallen out of love with elephant rides? - BBC News

29/04/2016, 16:32

Related Topics
Animals

Share this story About sharing

More on this story

Cambodia tourism: Call to end rides after elephant's death
26 April 2016

Scottish tourist 'killed by elephant'

2 February 2016

Cruel trade in Asian elephants threatens survival - report

6 July 2014

Asia

US 'drops Pakistan fighter

jet subsidy'
29 April 2016

Asia

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-36147265

US man jailed for spying in

N Korea
29 April 2016

Asia

Tashkent bids sad farewell

to trams
29 April 2016

Asia

Page 7 of 8

Have we fallen out of love with elephant rides? - BBC News

29/04/2016, 16:32

BBC News Services

On your mobile

On your connected tv

Get news alerts

Explore the BBC

News

Sport

Weather

Shop

Earth

Travel

Capital

Culture

Autos

Future

TV

Radio

CBBC

CBeebies

Food

iWonder

Bitesize

Music

Arts

Make It Digital

Taster

Nature

Local

Terms of Use

About the BBC

Privacy Policy

Cookies

Accessibility Help

Parental Guidance

Contact the BBC

Advertise with us

Ad choices

Copyright 2016 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to
external linking.

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-36147265

Page 8 of 8