cunrree rou
Lucha Corpi and the Politics of
Detective Fiction
Tin Librets
‘cone moment in Wale Maly eectve ove A Red Death, Easy
Rinne idea Hy piesa evden, ist of names in a envelope
‘vith tent thon lar or 0, Hell, "lth mney bat
‘cote it with, Sometimes words ae wort or than son
‘speci if oar ari om ina(08) tm dan (os le te
i hi momen so sgnies Rains’ elle excation rom te |
Fosruretity of he apait marketplace, privileging tbe qs fot |
ttt, elie aod Homage over capital gun. As such i signs \
‘suo Moneys bit to anyon tatoo dete Htion fouls \
‘which cries wana eat a inked with and underweting |
|
|
Cpt enon ral. with the exception of Stephen Sots,
‘who sogucr that "Attian Aivercan dteive wes sigity
‘ements of th ective neo ovm ends such 5 "esting
Isis of lick natoslon and race pride enw was" 3. Ino
‘wie achat Cheer Hines in is Gaseigae ones aod Cotin El |
Tovel, land Hijo Primers in Cre, Janes Welt The
India ayer, Shera Ale nn ier, Wale Mosley tte
ay Ravine myst and Lista Cm in Esl or Brown Ange
nd Cactus Bods tae fe aos nd works—have ak.
__ ppd the ppl gre of detection n eer subj to
$Etgue dominant cull ab lgalit conapins of ce and
suse, di, folios ngtice aa ta foewar ae conceptions nfomed hy a8 sta
_ponnecie of thera exgerence mine US. \.
“nsatin crmosin thse novels the detectives of color inviahly_/
0, (iL i Gnd thamales asi bee the ed nd ste of lnc7 Ti Libre
rund dcp social eames a way of nove
‘the larger staal and isto pater of injtce perpetrated
agin pope of color. As Lach Cop's barat Gora Dano
Sips Eulogy fore Brown Ange wn fe pple a ile ina 1970,
Chicano using In LA. and their die re raised ono lb for
autopies, "ntme pep somo woul ditt th rete of
ht happened th a. But perp we aed ke the mane iat
insidon disease dt ha land tee, perhaps fur, more ves that
Inte August atemoon" 2). The nove atopy Cony perms,
‘vious is one heats the disease a racism oping the
eepoitve and pressive racial onder of US. society and poll
conan. The system ise asd thse who eadorc, ema, and
Undervte it are the real eiminal Has Franco Mort ares,
‘ditionally detective eon has restored social order by ining
“oividas guilty that aot can dca Half noe, Cop
von incites sty Hult with! messy until
iting indus wha com aime: Rather, her iston develo
2 imich more complex relation feten the nvidia sity.
Tesognaing the materi and discursive wc cts that pode
‘riminals tthe score of rimiaiy el.
Yet at we wil se, an overling prion of the copes of
Titerary ie of te detcineFction gee repeats the
Conservative ale ofthe genre andthe resistance of the generic
Tormula to sovation and to deplysien foe poli ad that
hulloges the dian soil ore, Ths, he pposona ae of
‘otctiveGcton by US. wees of color rege some then,
‘which his say wi uadeake A age argument of this sy wil
also be tat hese writes ave coscously tured tthe dtecive
Tico genre x op form nto ning eet lt the coc at
‘ater tics plc sae ied whi and by popular ola
‘movemeitThey chon th poplar form ofthe detve mel
over to reach Bonde aes, nded to each the public who
‘cul preps in tbexe movement While so mish the nlc
tend mula! ec ho een o lepine and arg for the
‘rary vale of multe rate lation othe dyeing
canon od the sada of rary valve tat urin tht era
ano, te spas bein he tm the popular fr pei
‘epithe lary sar wih ten remove eray practice
from th processes of everyday ie a rom fhe materia sn a
stgels of plicl fone well aro adopt an ations
Lucha Corp and the Politics of Detective Picton or
ance tard th ett (and as standards fhe dian care
‘The question tht ees toe explore, weve, bow andi sta
‘othe popular can function radially and i oppo to he rca
ita er
Tn cuying rough hese argument and explains, wil oes
schematialy on hey fess of Licha Cop's Cactus Blood and
{Exog for Brow Angel and make sre of pment wh opt
tothe ways in wich Corp's Chana pial pnpectve tks
ius o rina and nie. Eloy ora Brown Angel opens
othhe murder a seal ei aig ce eiogy pega to
the 1970 Los Angeles Chicano Mach ln ihe posse detection,
“however, he novel zealy becomes eng and ages of te
‘movement fm a contemporary perspective. Gla Dams
‘noing on sling the crime egcen years er and is Being 10
Pisce together te rte ae pat ofan interetosleesporte Pat
compan acs ofthe lobe from Germany te Bra augeating
{hate asst om Chinn the United Stes bx up with
imps nggresionlowanteThnd World peoples global And
ods, the murder of the sil while again an event secminaly
Peripheral tothe evens of the movement, Hecomes itty
[rnbvsted in he asst on the movement, As Danae sys nthe
mer of 1970 everyhieg anyone of us did ha wo be considered
‘Scoring opin impact om te Chine common (62-1 is
(his sentiment ht Fels Corp's reiki af iminaliy” an i
Darul ofthe ay in whieh se defines the diffe sk Toe he
‘ter of clo ning te eine ficton pene, Hist people of
ole has Ben rnin nh inte Sse, th wi of clr
“ust aegotte carefully between reinforcing this stereotypical
-tininaltion, expecially nh ae wc envi murder
‘tthe editor a the eae of mdr ease reduced 1029
Individual act—ie in fat Chicano, and seth iumiali
‘dg lense, Damas spp "he snoriten ral hat Feral
‘Cheam to go pblie on any Hie at could Be sed Uo Justify
Cinetmination aginst wn some ways 1 eied cur movement
frail equity tn sel dterminsion as 9 fleet om oes
liste ier pare of te wor But we were people wit ation
‘ur bhuvion we costa er srt, cu cals rlentesy
Undesige (68). Toop er detection, Damas gas fobs the
Investigation ofthe crime, whdcrtunding the ere less a the
dial ston othe Chan si of by Europe comomort
” Tm tbr
‘oe wr that pat fe Ingest pope of
‘aloe though the mechanisms eles and intemal ens,
‘Wt Dao finaly coves hs ay lagi i ity
‘cial oppresion.and what she deeper ete eof es”
(initiation, colonization, dseinistion, ee) which were
those mechanisms. Before moving ito dscstion ofthe novel
however, we ned Yo Took athe racial moun that te detective
velit of olor neds to ascend in esting the geste sales of
"he eed formulas of dative fon.
(CHANGING NARRATIVE ENDINGS, EXPOSING HISTORY:
‘THE DIALECTICS OF DETECTION
iil satis of detective ton have goer hid the gene
“inte ofthe frmalic native sie and pices wich ts
_wotk seem continually to repeduce a which neal soln ad
Scns conservative ideo This conserva, he ry goes
the nana! ideology of the detective Seton formu themes nd
is stubbornly resistant 1 innovation prectely teense itis 30
Combed rset, nthe Zamal ets of he pene Inde
' Fei meson fas noted in his coneptulzton ger nhs
scasson othe desenyof fom,
‘msg er fee at rm many dey
seg in ison i When cm ergo and
‘eae i qt dee! soci onl cul coe hs
farm. The logy of frm ts lim peso
Sige Casean 18,1)
Such seems o be the case with detective fon, at le as etal
‘isesments ofthe gee hve stented f0 ste te ee, Fran
Moret for example, declares delete ton “be wi genes
‘oan of contemporary capita” and “syn oclr's
sercive bites” ascii the pnt whales with neonate
‘ignation ited nly in perpetuating th exiting oe, whi i
{cha Corp and he Poe of Detective Psion “
ko elimate st of af, fund om testo of he rea
father and ranctoned by the fly te, which moderates and
seitialzes nividalegist"(35, 140,148). Sal, Denaie
Poser ages, ses tml tt te elo of he detective
‘ition fo sere coset nd vals nisin valor
because "popular ition iby dion = farm of ata that docs
‘ot affend delat an values ofits mate aon” such that
‘novels has ogo out of sway to sl eelsion and conic hit
onde” and mst “lays lhe sry ft well creed wer",
219). Be the Marsa erie Ernest Mande eget to coniee the
‘oppositional posses of deectve fiction, asetng hat “ihe
common ideology of th egal and csi detective ory in
Brite United Stas and the coun of he European content
remains qimesseatlly bourgeois” Bosse, fo Mandl "nda
onli ae "sed a geeried sabe for confit betwen
Sexi groups and layers "ie classmate of heat, proper
tnd justice eins comply baceed(215).
"This declopeal selene, cies ape, persists and asters
ul even ia works f dove ton ht atmo appropiate the
on forest llenge socials nw, Kathleen Grego
luis, fr example in erste ofthe woman eect, argc that
fundamen coazaton pis fetween te detective fon genre
‘nd feminist sender scope, rating a manent pacha
ology to dete Seb ona eau he work othe detest
nth psu of xe ter rr, and astral the Son
social rer as ben sacl pica Sho agus a,
he eine wo eres oder ce wl by
nesting mar may bes se, oa te sce
sty be feroml tao public Comeqny, he feminist
Sete wis vp sprig he xsi sem ns opens
Aer
Kaineevilen,
J wsos
tu Fareer
“fontereas
eulka*
66 Tim iret
a of hese ceedings fe dette fin Ferma
adits inane ideology homer, se pomied on paar
{Stumpins abot tesco ore in whith eft
[olued a owe i reponse tesons and Sut
{he eamposton ofthe ficton’s aden Por’ ape oe
‘xa reared ab ee te "deen ols
Soni Seot pea edo” schon aprathwoaes
toviluminate moce telly the gene's Ball"on the poplar
imagination") sated sore, ht of etc fis ris
steaing comin snd cont in hss ad tie des n
Fonerswew "by creating s mk at embodies inks arte
‘log! presoporons hat ae iy toll he aes
‘ogtin ad apron "hse sce, ea of 2
‘ed of dete ton “ts depen on alos of empl
Tetween am stor and tar invoving th selwledgmat ef
Shred cmriiy vals wa sed baate nm)
‘Buc Fore’ foun zn on eae scoala
‘coco of ly nd ctalyhmepnnus erp fine
Secruliedconsiostess conforms or though steed
‘coding othe dominet US at's goon sei rls and
tales is tery of dleine fon ignocs the fame and
“eaten he vos ad varable ctl chin, and
‘isan wich chrctri done th cred ea and
‘Sci iat te US aon nd wich deployed nh ci and
nee erring ad runing ene ed tela of
Woducton Specialy, Pre’ eerste pach te oan
pov conception of hooped vex,
'eologie, an cates. The apes thot nly rnd Ba
aos, tb agus ta eve ov ae capes
oto les an ofr a alms oi aoe a wr and a
sl aoe dt ctr qa 2,
itutng the prodicon of dative fiction tthe spect
condoned rc eer of te US. soil stem and pale
Sonam, weve Parte's ated sme seed ech
{erolematt he foming his sara of US aon
faatonas on of ese clninon sd congo, Unies
fciie popatons te Unit Sts tively coat
‘loi eh ese nos, nel Tid Wa
win the US. saint, we most st atte xpeicee of
Matonbond a nla te colar mys and ira of he aay
Lica Corp and he Poles of Detective ition o
colonized national populations wil differ dramatically, even
‘amet, fom ths the dint nd coonisng US, tonal
alu Corp's week registers both this national and cata
‘ieresnon ofthe Chicano population fom and within the US,
‘tons and dominant culture whe er curate Gloria Damo
Sats in Eulogy fora Brown Angel, “Bat we were a poole win &
‘ation. Our beavion was costly under sretiny our culture
‘elles unr siege” Ths, thet ovals” of he “mae
‘odnce ofthe Ciao satire for whom Corp mit by
large be ring Wl ily elon conrait howe ae
“les of the mis aniene iafooned. by and alias with te
Igor bli vals. ates of th US. dominant cute. A 2
society fissre by tcl antago and funded aad minined SS
eoigh al opresioe nd ashy shy os casted bya SS
sof ihe mn wales Ihe dec novel mst avays «SS
‘i he stay os cles word the arate comepioe a SS
Welbordred woe for 2 Third Wold readership would ot be te
‘inst of aia it oF wa, fhe racially oppresaive watts 7
quo. Serving justice forthe Third Wold render does not mean
Stpporiag the exsing sytem but rather enpging in 9 foal
‘unsformtion of the racist U.S. society and te capa and
Ingest pliteal economy tat motivates rca oppression std
cploton, Indeed, a Sherman Alex's character Thomas Bulls
their says to the judge who asks If "we can go about the
‘aniston of jusice” ring bist osc be on wal for
the history frac ne cries by Nave Ameian paint European
‘and wt American sels and colonies, shat el ase oie
‘ests (100,
"The pat tht he comma thoy of etetve ton aan
inherently conservative genre fal o ecgnie ht I ie baed
sumptions sbow ie demosaphiscompstion of a eaderhip a)
{beideloia eres of hat ede thai andes in
sierent esta and demographic content the detective fon”
Fonmota could as easily serve a politically radical and social 707 i
tsusformatve fonction, Thus, tis aces thatthe ats, £2 clo
‘sch ar Mande’ thew the adl pais of detcie BON pyr ce
bot ater hat they tend o Toews on ied umber of deectve
novels eoesituive of what one might term, somewhat ienically, (OULD
Caria eectve ton, Thay, hse sis es on thing, ot- Tin Libres
the basis Limied number of works the patie, ater tan he
feemal posites, of dott ien
Indeed, de mpl of detective ston to explain and inn sce
‘shea ps events gga it could ke deploy et cary
{orm par ecelence for undertaking an historical mates
‘otesoption so ertigue of dominant social farms and woe ad
Ie for hllenging What mean hastened inser teen
Meologe paradigms which contain wit hs los a peter
‘dig, Cannot wits appepithe fom with is ten mer
acai yet change tho ending or le invest that form wth aie
content? As Barbra Haslow har noted of Third Woed writers
‘eteraing with western Utes forms, "The we by Tied Wort
‘essace were of te novel frm aI has developed win the
‘ssn Iary triton oth sppopies and calenges este
tnd hiseriing presuppositions, ie nave concn, implied
within the west tion std ie devslopment'(), Following
Harlow’ ola, wold seem pas hatte ge fm of
tn dectve novel could be deployed tenet reristance a damian
Social fons and idols by seling diferent sere cnigs rom.
‘hose cootined within the tadtonal or consemonsdeslogia
"erry padi Indeed if we vdestnd ot ary geo nak
‘us sol a ieal forms passed dowe o nhertl though some
Bloenaon of rary raion ht somehow expt ro
shove mati story but ae iaseal condoned by spc hss
situations and development, hs we muss se fern hss
ning as already pan ginal ployment fm in
Harlow's words, “contained within the ntratve an
onstaction of the condos and problematic of the stare
Ssiution sel") Alene’ sey “The Tr of Thoma Bue
Fite." for example, Builth Fie'steimony In his own desea
involves reaping the hstary of vnlene against clonzation f
ave Ameren. sch hat he conception of jie on tht tos
Airey oat fhe str! and elt perpetve whi lenges
the foundational mythos of “American” naonhood, Wile Meet
gus th in detctive ton, a i aw isles mpeg
only as violation and such, st be oimaelyrerense038) on
rps detective ition, as Aleie's sty, hry Ts exposed
ows he eal proses and hog hes of detonate
tolvinge
‘Lich Corp and the Pols of Detective Fiction o
FALLING INTO HISTORY, RECOVERING POLITICAL
INNOCENCE,
A extended foray ito Cap soon detective novel Cactes Blood,
Iesied spans Mort's ital pronouncements oa te operation
and social onto of dete fton, wil tate my pi or
‘More the detective formula is lfcmed by a Freudian maxes
‘tative propelled by the death istic the dese otto the
‘beaning toa err sae of things A such, be agus, dete
‘ove at inherently aninoveic tty lk ative and as
not encode rent history or istic deeepment Thy ase
id reste soso, fining the sas gua by expling he gly
clement frre allen worl. Hewes
Spee ey eas
sainsingrratcsecten
SERS Acces nian
feecpereretieeepreiear ae
SovS Tacha scans pay
Seo taonse ss
eee enn antc
Scesacmes rea
io iicteewerneees
Mort's thcrztion ofthe Redan fl of and of he resting
proves cnered ty, dete Fito sn tht eaves itl oom ot
‘esing detective fiction awl fom fo afl itary pssice” Tim tre
eared toward chlleaping aed asso oman sil elton,
Yel in Cori’ detective icin, while we 386th many of
More's thmati deticaons equ site ad sigh, we
also vee that these themes of anoenes and sta yee le
Prominent, ar developed i sacha wn ao fre th exloration of
istry andra roses and te mative piel mamemeat and
etvim hat has grown sat, To borrow How's oat, Cop-
‘oaows te rave but ange the ending Ia Ctr Blood, for
‘example, Gla Damaso i ivetping th sone ofthe exh of et
frend ad ogtine Chicano svat Sonny. Pood rape, he ft
which Chicanos historically have boycotted Benue of he pesticides
‘ed which poison and il th farmer who pik the se fund
in his reget, and on his vdeo rcerer aap le piping of =
Chicano farmworkers suike fom 1973 in which Seon pst.
Cop's marion of Danaco's covery ofthe see proves hey
insight it the U.S. Third Word writers raring the geese
‘mula of detective Ft. She writes
"os rae arm insie Sonny’ apm bt ya fl
sand ened, Suey my econ wa he fot the ems
gre by So's deh an B's i lig
tonsil, hat someting ee wa at wc ai A Dist
‘lie pled at my he anand elo meson of A=
hd grown pote nse. Lae Tw align
itn, wishing tat hagy mete way hey lo en he
Incl, elit wa osha et pene
Teas passage registers Damasc'splicalyenonscius dese
or nin! to gen fo a “ater sate OF Wines” tins of pole
Fnmocece, we ee het th siete tte anecenc of pole ah
Lucha Car andthe otis of Detective Fiction ”
“oe mhich Damasco pees wanes otal one were
‘emotive by the Fen eson ofthe deth tin Rater the
nostalgic yaring wo recaptre the hited moment when one
aperinced one's mos intone sense of pole commitment i
orayed eres a oust the motat of the ete bith of 2
Polite or Eros inthe Cicaala nto pital sojet, and
‘vin a Freudian acyeanti famew ts Es, the pone
the dat istic, which rhe foe hat ntfs dsrbanees at
the process of lia” and works asin the death isin’ ending
“ganic ie back int an aint sited 46,38), Thos, wil
Cop's marae ie nferme osoe extent bythe detective novels
tetionl deep stacare or artive grammar of asta tthe
‘egioing is retum othe hepisng.oscence, mane not
the represion f a liste! wolton but rhe tthe scion
foemerng istry and asaing an tie sl the hse age:
sovatonecftetchmge.
Inthe above pasape, Damisco's ss-consionness already
exposes he politely ereive—andpuycholgially epee
mpl tend the wasting tin hing nce th way thy aed ben
the at sities and eu Seventies” She engines the dango and
‘istrkzng poten of metal o fig the past rece In
‘lenis terms and vecogies at "it wa ols to kng Toth mot
‘presive and reeessive ines we, a Chicanos, ad exetenad
Instead, ther hogy. wha she longs for ito respi the
est he poi nas aed cent the ps msde 0
revi and reiet the Chicago movement. This imocence Cor
figures 6a key ease of plea! walty which sacenay to ase
te hrrowing expences and storia! viltons tata the
present Coop's dtetne ton th gies the tational
thematic: and form ofthe geste ad temp tough hs lbs
‘naive proces of sinifiion the retreats of sng
ho heal and e-eneaz the Chicano pic! pyc rage by
the tsa violations anderson ofthe rca opesson and
ris rer of US. sce. While Cars pues landmark event tie
{Chicano Movement ich ae he 1970 Moros mach and the 1973
‘Unt Fem Worker” ke, acing the lse af naneese he
‘typical detective fon formula of roessinghisory and rst
canadetons trough te retraton of imeecce i eves a
Insoey-and the individ’ sity 6 parce cllsctvely in the
making of histery trough revotonry seal asfarmaton—--n “Tn Labret
‘tly and ioncly recover ugh th restaation of acess
Indeed, Corp's naive method of exploring and rethinking the
vii od legacy ofthe Chicano Movement hear ote of what
Frei Jmestn fas eed snl or the reset, let He
eos a6 a pedomigat charac ofa pooder teste "he
mesmerising se atthe ode self emerged sean elsboraed
Syeptom ofthe waning of history, of olive potato of
tparicning istry i some ative way” and demonstrate "the
‘noumiy ofa stanton in whieh we som inressinglyInapble of
fashioning representations of or own expience” Jameson 191 21)
Us preciely in response to this “waning of istry” and the
Ae o rpesnng a arent compet expec
Ic woul seem hat Cap tun the ete icon gees. a
Ssease, returns tothe see of the ei to detect snd eee the
ital history ad pas afte 1960s and ety 1970
RECOVERING CHICANO POLITICAL CONSCIOUSNESS,
SOLVING CRIMES OF HISTORY
Inde in Eulogy for Brown Angel lori Damato's qt sve
the marr of young shila fhe 1970 Chicano Maia chin
st Los Angle contines foreign years, sige, nse,
that ne cannot ave done wih istry ant wil eon rp
‘and inform the present sich tht he polital male the pst
Aloveloped to anderand experience and resist the condo of
eistence defining tat experience most noe he fogoten. Suh.
A ty araive of detetion des ws aly not pres ise, calls tenon
écensircet0 and cont ells up hist. The detection process nt only
i tad,
‘ropes and keeps alive nis conciostst nt th reset but
so pes Danae foro ack it th pst th ey claiztion
lit, ry of Coat Sanayi as he of Sy
‘which motivates the arte fr ou otto be murder ha an
Acids if ota ace sch date “sins” Kl which Damas
{seeks toate tugboat the noel ins oto Be a eine, Wh
‘simporn inthe marae, he, nt so musk teens or ve it
Solution asthe process of detction el and the exploration and
Interpretation of lve Because af the psycho histones heap
recovery and analyst which echirses abet msl
In Gactar Mood, for example, te ental ts in solving th
putsiedenthof Sonny i nding he character Cros Nava wh
aca Corps and the Poe of Detective Peon ”
‘had been sen leaving is apartment. Yel he seach for Cala wh
‘as hing od with Sony's ule igurinaly sig the seach
‘and veal encounter with the Chicano htrel pst aswell s-
‘wh the polialexigeces persistently defining the reser. Ax
‘egal immigrnt and undocumented wks who is raped by the
hasband of te family for which she works as a domestic and is
eixoned when in fg cn he family she rus tough a pesticide
Miten ld, Co teeomes the embodiment of the Chicana history
‘fran ppesion and alma, nr super expen,
‘nd seaualvoete wibia the ail patrcha ls ctr. What
Damas redscoves in oeaing Caron and ean er istry a al
of te istues ta safomed Chicano political eonrciousest and
‘ety ad motivated the Chicano Civil Rigs movement othe
190s and 1970. She feabon a he ving voce and repay oF
Ansogl nema. pt Com andtns a Dams nde Coa
story on tape made ty er decent frend Lin ho had eon
‘rend in inervowing Cans for a reject ene “Te Chins
Experience," which war to docume! the Chicano Civil Rights
Movement om the pengetve of Chicas.
In paral Carts registers te tation of Chino protest
and rettance 1 the contons of naional oppcsion oir
onze whle alo mapniying and questioning te waning of
{Chicanalo activism and pola commitment the wake of the
‘movements eyday and nthe face ofthese pesiting contons
‘Woe driving with Carta trough Sonoma a one moment inthe
story, or example, Damanco recounts sexing te howe of Gora
‘Mariano Vallejo a is beter Salvador Vallejo and engages io a0
Iistre eestion whic wil qute at nth frit stuns is,
is demonstrating Cm nerporaton of stra dames
‘socal conscounes nt the plo of dtstion and, soon.
rating within he pl the seting a cont tht hls Casio's
eihtena an Damass'siminahing pla sensithe view is
ee ae Arata
ab thy same
time
” Tim Laren
‘bat and he BF Rev Mont The manent a ee
‘cpa y the Hear Fg el ter te Mn Ay ed
‘Geel Valo hid down hams Att tine nce Vale's
‘aren, Cars US ty vey elgg
‘ito en.)
Damato's nie nation here fhe pesto of Sonoma
reveling wis Desa ituncovers he pchaps ifn vend oF
‘epee htry ofthe conan of the aliens by "Anglo
Seters bat an bean ofthe tral ome an whi this tame a
hisral documentary s ise note native. The ease ee
sings ike x pend between th "Ang" denna US cates
fn historieal perspec andthe Chicanfo on, For example
Damasco fst desctos Sonoma in tems of porte fam 38
scons perpetve of consumption, nes of what ths ad 9
Incas wii te capitis economy of comme postion ae
eat of he wine county” deserigton hat taste oats (7
of coamediy ftshism. The perspective te quickly cootere,
weve: by unsco's ulin irom a Chicana permet ts
Sonoma othe ite of historical events that ebangod the fate of
Mexia i Calon ever” Siy, Danas sion moves
ftom the Mean monument of he miso of San Pane Solna
the monument mevialtng tbe cooquest and colonization of
Cals the Bear Bag Revo Monument, reps the hist of
Cultural tif nd land spas between indigenous Moses sd
Invading "Anglo sears in Calter
But wie the patage sal effectively alls up that histor
onsen and even sey and esneically reveal al
Stragele and the proces ofthe commoifction and comedy
fein of he land ht reed in the repre of th Chica
Noa pepectve i the faze ofthe intuit of eit
Coltoraland economic inertvs, ana nartive representation =
Damasco's oncoues it seems sification th extent o>
‘ech she aang Hetween thee tela reese ic
Lucha Corpand he Plo Detective leon *
resnkthat she has ler and commited understanding of US
History om the Chicano pepe of tra esenztio, ut hi
Understanding est app only toe vent ofthe ps abl ot
{nfo her decoding fhe preset. er geting th urgent sons
‘hat ad rote us th Vay of Moon ert abo the
hisrcl esearch se did (fr salting he rine in Eloy fora Brown
“Angel exemplifies ths section of a al present in Dana's
tind, Bren the language she aes hare mark cular Sli 25
She peas of Sonoma, pat from her cory of Carma history
from a Chicano ptspectve, athe “Vay af th Moon,” eal op
‘tm alot ack Londonesiue elt guration of Sonoma, ats:
feta realize tht solving nes nthe preset oie ndersnding
them both series wt a hry anda rime of story Indeed,
Comp implicitly diagnoses her detecive's awed investigative
tecniqus as atrial. Damssco mat comest pst nd presen.
tox connection which for Damaico, a the esting loge a this
ome novel danas, re om ene he et pail
‘Wiha che coset ofthe pla, this pssge trash Sonoma eas
oa cameron Stora Damasco and Calta in whieh Dams's
‘ deplicization ofthe pst and, by extension, the dminton of
er plc commitment inte present come central ses, Can
‘eft to Sonoma a la cane de tain he erale of teson,
‘pking the ollowing interchange betwen he wo:
eng ha Carts comme! nd oetng no ho
ne yu
Pan cf iat bl, Lot oe Sh wk
‘and dank tin rg roi. "Wal se md "a Valo
suri wea? mn so ced er
‘Berard “And eed Clo pot inte ete4 hindi
for ab ten
Gitane(a
% Tim Libre
alts final comment bere reece the fat that the same
‘Chicanos moh ore than avail” en. One dente oneself
1 Chieanalo inorder inet oe poliealafiiton wh ed
ammiment the Movement. As Reet Linda Fro a Asi
Cara point out, te term “signed bos the timation of oa
‘srking hs an indigenous xg, ad the reject of simon,
‘ecultraton, andthe myth fhe Amerian melting pot. np in th
term Chicano was a seat elton ao eratey of auge wich
theatzed the Chicago comity and cle or sail vl od
‘efom’(205), Ths, fr Danco wcll eel Hane weld en
tony teins he resistance pies ofthe Cisano Move ut
sso eauying Beall with be dominant U.S cit nd ion
{tof the melas pot nto wc, in reality, Chica a te
‘aca miosis in the U.S Rave orally not en alowed to el
arate bl realy a be ef pola hy responding,
“You're ahsoluely sight melt ave heen tiking that ta
roving polly spate and que sels". And when thi Is
‘vers Tow Thuve od lt of mew adeno oasheping
just don't tink 'm ready to-do anything about my pola
‘lacency inthe mie ofthis mss(17479,
Buti esl in th idle hs men at Damaco, base
of Calta, I freed todo that “housekespig” train bet
ommitneat othe pips ofthe Movement At ons point when
Cri and Damasco are escaping a tight sot rshing tough
Mexia restsant, fr eam, iron ses 4 woman eating pe,
‘notches the bunt rom he da estes then with He shoe
‘hile Ting questions atte woman: "Dow't you care that fn
Seeker ate poisoned and deo cancer every yee? Tha babs ae
te with ih dees? Tt people go eazy from the pesticides sed
fon those grapes? Don't you Bow tha you hold) bye ale
tapss?“(17). When Damasco urges Carla t keep moving, Crt
lass, “simran people know (=) wot sll bapcting
tapes and way"078). Damaco i ose 0 ges find sell
Feveig to er activi mode ofthe 196Dr nd 17D, vain soa
tha thy il rrr othe restan abd spk ote manager if
ttyl no ess, pani pckt ite: While om ane eel base
omens igh read idl intros in th det le,
they actually consti the return ofthe hissy cereseo. he
Insenuption oe persistent emergence of the plo of sory wc
Iocomes at inient to Te pat ha rater the cen pot sl,
‘achaCorp and he Plies of Detective Pion ”
lesonstaing Ramin Salva sass tat history cannot be
anceived as the mee “ackeound” oe “cniext” of (Chica
‘erat; albert us at ob te deve dtr of the
{enn ad content of he ert").
DETECTION AS DEREIFTCATION: THE SCENE OF LABOR
ASTHE SCENE OF CRIME.
The detection process, in psychaterpewtcally recovering the
repessod hist of Chicas sugges ak opression and
‘tas exploitation, perforation of escort ing
bok charsters and reader ack othe coe of ako tt reso
‘od andthe motor his. The uesons Carlota ases andthe
soy ef racial and sox! eppression and aber exploitation abe
tities an undocumented worker an “egal aie” in er On
feleized land, re oes tht he forms: plato detective ition
Seuned by Moret aad hers anna make spent, Idee. Comp
‘wcunivel rings he lot bck tothe see of ab ae en ce
the ove Damaco' road Visi, «psc, dapnoses Care's
lesa cased by pmo pesca: Tv ed oper in media
journal abot he fet of psd and ies om man beg,
atl people sil a's oblem only fr he farm worker
slays ll ma hres aman peo ep forthe unblemished
fople of grape. But tha's wit we coneimers demand «The
eovebial poisoned ale. Amizing, n't H7(114). Trough te
Srcketration of earn and plot Cap invokes «perspective of
rodaction and xcs the dominotperspevive of consumption
{nforming US. capita clear wach fonction on Marxist
terms the fifa of conciousness aad the ftsism of te
omy that effectively msties ad elininaes abo fom the
purview of US soil ison Thu, wile Moret argues tat "Money
prwer and wages which ir the te sre of social wealth” and
Eondenne deectve fit sprfeming "coll ftshsn135,
152), Comp’ deve ston overt these conveadons by making
the sluion of the vine the discovery of story isl of the
fenctoning of the rial pare captive system a 3 Bae
Isionclly and i de presen shaped acl and clus style and
timiall npctdtndvdal ives ach as Calo a well the” Tm tibet
‘lev tives of worker and pope of clar general Ind, wile
Mandel ones the "rele desta he he fhe xis
sHory"(210), fering to dhe process by which death becomes a8
‘sled initio experene dived om scl ceunstances
‘or problems, Crp indies the semi srt ofall cpl
‘nds pout lates which consign peopl of caer the wast,
and oiled ally werk condones,
(Corps thus reworks the (ical detective tion formula by
slain the portance of tind xa wt beens
fs the later source of emily: the socal sete HslfoNO~
Soceoe a in Moe's naa, ve ested Ia fas as thee
ogress: it uncovers nly more guilt and more evsenceof the fale
‘nd of the socal nt ath scene above when te dator
‘Victor, speaking ofthe poisonos gprs, invokes the woe ofthe fal
from innocence. Damion and her Chicanaslos of the pos
‘Movement, pos-Lspsnran pial envionment have foram this
condition recalling Adora’s statement Lo Bejanin Uhl "every
felcaon ia frpetine Uy 29) and need obs reminded of tis
fallen coaition to eity tir poll Commitment the els of
the Movement Indeed, as Crp statues the nae, he fe Is
ot evealed af he esinning the nase bat rater covered at
elution of to arte eime nthe novel fer o siguientes
tecaseitserver moro moate the lt than o conse 3 cen
renin the pl
The murder isthe novel, a aeady mentioned, isnt that of
commited by Calta fend Jone Baldomar who, by her blesson,
‘ecientlly murdered er Anglo hshand beans she knew he a
en planing eve he fr ater woman Shs ha en tending
to murder him and wih thse itntony had been a work cet the
‘Srcumstancer tat wo allo hr i ane a ld Chana ac,
‘val for Calta’ ffesion, Dring farmers trike i 1973,
tha eigivings deciding woul! be plicallycouterpreductve 0
‘heends fhe sik, ad terse o persuade Ranoa nto execu
‘is pln. Who he di At an Sony. a momen of ambiance,
{etled pina i rng fest fhe Maven tgp htt
Lucha Corps and the Polis of Detective Picton ”
sense of ambivalence never diminishes and they contin harbor
ult foc having tetrajed comrade. Aware of tee event, sie
Ieaes postoned grape inthe relists of At and Sonny, seals
Some slsificant pogaps ofthese hanging om A's wl ta
Tcaes aatesnke in A's yard to mate them Glow that Rama
Seeking fevenge upon thom, er loge being tha iven ch
‘iteumstnes she wl be able frase Ramon fr any murder she
"Whilst pails ofthe complexities of he
lb should make appre ht the acl mdr Josie ort
frclovant in compart othe chin of events ie att to ene
Remon nigger: Dunas fit is eer een atmo solve the
‘nude of leri's hand bt rater the desth of Sona, which she
Istkeny lees to have ren a mn, ut one's action tae
the coma elements of he pot. the carves’ mediatons on the
lial ats dt examination ofthe stength a persistence of
‘hc poll commie inthe pea. At fo example, mt ome
to grips wih his having tested gust Ranon. And Sonny si
‘peculted,commied sce iter ssing the ape depicting een
from sitesn gers ago beste of a ses of otal fare oden,
te search forthe ising patogrps fm ARs walle which
ocument past Chiao staple smb this urgency to recover
the pees othe pst and eases one's prose postion and he at
ofthe Movereat welling of hat histry. This pet ofthe
Plot and is relative discon fom Josie’ mdr of ber shuns
fecome cle nthe clic see net th end which tke place
"Nave Americana te. AU his po Ar sil suspect tht Ramon
Caballo is behind Sony's death and the cer event nd oes this
alminaton afore of sts on te oom of the Move
Te sys,“ fel aia eee ta stated tack in 19TS i coming o 3
‘loses ope thse oe end with my we dee For
the eye to end Uke began, tous of us who were invalved ia de
feton of see yt agp ld ave fo be here the se tie
Are'teycles ppd work tht wy?)
Bot th ple dss nt eet nots Mort haere he
‘Sho wih ating changed nd oiglearted. Toh he ned
poco of ection. the acter ak tah he dat poll
"tons ofthe t,he confit etwoen Renon and A i ese
hd Dams at well us er pel commen ested Je, ho0 Tim Libre
‘cult the pat an the Movement, ought (0 took ad the
ies of possibilty fra Tid Wend working ls aay oe
renewed The questo’ and saenst ral by Cart ea
acid or overshadowed by Js’ ing hot oases fr
the novel recast cones f jain and ris in mc oder
‘ems, The esate of plical alr a thereon
has Damstco srs eal aly ora own Angel, we were
‘ope within nation” sigs at clot renewed begining
whichis wot a retin othe beginning but a recognition that the
Sains of intra colonization persia nth 19s ad that the
‘Thi Word Movers of he 1960s at arty 197s prove ruil
‘ol of essa nthe er in whch he sve eines juice. 8
the end of rial class and sexual oppression sad exploiatn. We
aust fe justice i jst bepanins.Appebending the eininl means
‘vehaling soci nd como th i rma ou
nde
In Bog fora Brown Angel, Darasco iil tying to the salve
the tie of 1971 eighcen Years Tater. Althogh the individ
‘orets, 4 Chicano Vietam veter who a tend aginst the
Movement had bznapresade in 1971, Dara uncover 989
he eonptcy wit whch he Was inks, a tuliaonl corporation,
signing the coniunon of sparing capitals ints
wt Mandel has eed “ate capitis,” In sh she sones nt
Jott “we were a people within anton” but tht Chinas ad
‘te aia mires sl re peoples within he US. nation ad that
‘nant-colnial nasal poles muse stl conse the eming
onde fiery cic ed polis esisace, Yt we hve
seen, Cop's novels aes the US. Thiel Worl naonal ences
‘arm otening theses ad aes, apport the Tied Word
Polka status quo which els for he revlionmy rasan of
the rail an economic
Works crrED
‘Alsi Semin, The one Rage ond ono Fifi in Heaven New Yr
pats, 185
‘ache Cor andthe ots of Das on ”
— cc Ratt Pre 188,
ed Sg. The vn New Yar: WM, Neon, 1980.
rnin o the Catal Loi of te Capon. uta
Date UF. 5
iy Main, Marzi nd Tol, ery Univesity of Cia res
16,
in, Kno Geary. The Wana Date: Gener and Gee, Ub:
Utes of ons Pe, 188,
Mendel, Ema “A Marit Ineetatin ofthe Cline Sty “Dene
‘ton: A Cleon of Cita Ey BR W. Wik, Vroot
The Cann Pe 98021328
rei; rn Sigs Tato Wane x in he Siig rary
sey, War Rd Dnt New Yok: Sion Ses 18
Pore, Deis The Para of Crime Anolon Dee ison,
Now ve: Yl UP, 18
Sais, Ramon. Chee Martie he Ds of Dirence. Main
Une of Wicoia Ps 150,
Sots Sepben. The Bes Dect ily of fica Aron De