ONE. ‘THE PATH OF ANCESTORS Four Types of Genealogical National Trees Inthe "park of ai” one, atl, would expt sce wes. Insist path we Wl el wih geese Wes. wich ae wing comet by any banner fm el a eo fo, fo beat self tie and space We wil sc four ‘pe of wich eso rather mdi Soul be eal 2 pest. sceethe" (I), Yotavine” 2) "prestigons” (3) Shivers (4). Each ration es vats combos of Ahese four apreaches when costing its iy, an one tary would Ed ation tls nly oa hse de "oweve. same nations may cose one or anther of the Kus chon the basa fo th natal pean, 2 the chosen mode aes 2a”Fae ample, te “skstve” mel sums ocorespnd the Ress wa ey emotion Td tt uy the an aches ind uppet po he nl genes tee tide tines) while ving te alien ache in he Ie Pa fir tines) wouched. For example, the gat Rasa ost Psa ahs Aen tacgwou is cnsieed a pe ote highest snr of Rann language and Rasa iver, whe is prfened hn oem Rca pecs in Posh’ tangy an pty, be eticly Rossin This ‘ot canbe foun nny aspects of Rusia eae. Ts, ‘nlc Rusin stats inte pena af so exe ‘eorpeanist branches ofthe "Panis (Aina) Sit, limer the denaceaton ine between Rust eo Rosa below (before) 388" AD, the year of Ross's comerion to Christin i nr ea Chest nae, Jenn bach fo the nk of Resins thse ade ies they do ‘nih Jove branches nmr ine The woking mecha, (oF this model wih v onstony shiing demarcation line be tween our peopl” ad "aes cat he sch he ere ‘oosttna ay inant Py Masco mayer Lugs! ce ‘aon, especialy pple of "Caucsinn natty wo have Moscow prope puma rsdnce) ae cmd! et ‘te (oan) wil howe wot propia conte fiat (ae) ade sje 1 fies a door Te ts eae pees he amet hanfoton of sl io "ue" ur poole) in the cow ofthe gesagt, proces of cng eu than” bans beng ove 1 the lee of sh st. Ae forthe “old reise Scr otto notte Hacknes of Puli, wale Eoin tribes re sat sompt for th ono ogg Riss he tote ta an asin fear Nat ak spon he Aner mean Cra i Cope ee ‘epee sagan om the Cans! Fs hg ‘insta sh eile chere lt vay he ‘Sera rence ok he Pah of Aces > cesar the get post! “hts ete ky, he “yore the “pein” andthe “omnivorous wll xpress the Traseavess trctrse ar "ora nang, sam te eae, Wi he ‘Sse ceneertin athe ese othe "Russi mod thy be alld respeatinely Ammer,” "Gs" and “Az [jon ml Thi conentona maton! sirbaton of the tls colts with poplar jokes of the Soviet prod = “Crbne hw oee upon ine at Armenian» Russia, Go fam and an Aven’ or asi pongo hse fo in ‘ren somitne fae one or aoe eal sittin es Ingin the suv of the ssale shaped monber ofthe san, whoo nny depend, tral the nationality ‘ft ket told be sid ht the ml (wes dincased here meat ey ead constuction alhugh vais pay cn “Xrble rein ottacting aa shaping hem, Each wo 4 ‘lt a calcve speculations beth cnt and uns and Forse Sometige, unc cnsracon eon ‘ren nee hell foes since may rele an etbogsnete ton mc move eal aa openly tan pt cee ‘non These mle gin hospi he ae Wa the Pats cup aera by many ee Tha can beac in the Seon, eared” ode, whih could abo heeled the Pein Aon wt ional sel ak hl Re- ‘syne ina at eed mo scope time nono fom pl J Sich hes ae very informatie for ean the ato an tbe eo ‘sop nn Resin nay peer el ih Ae ‘leis ante Fechpple seh hw Arsen (ie te ‘evr no a ced ac opin oh ot ‘oet t cim go he carci ees he ‘Seung soa ison) vpn al te oman ‘Shem an Asian eds Coogan suk cope ea ‘eee eked wal deve yh een ‘ses he Resihrc othr peor” mod wl asin the theron. “ue Path tard he Rots ‘The ewe” orth Arms, hare its igh against ls nh lowest arto he tna pe Ingles ng ths pet he oppose oie "ace sme. The "Arma ml te oposi of Sin one The only unde ao nth Armaan moe fe Lt arin aig pn wh oa Si af Urs he hia nd present etary of Imei nthe 9" cen Tat why ths “Ai Inde igs forte Aman Way of he Urns (Sh ‘eimn 2001" 6178) Aligh ete my” Amentn Uratin ctrpresnties nella! dgeney ne ‘eno ping io duns he pos and con is Kets tj ect stow hw ti cao ed ulin al anol th tions ‘We they of he Nes Ean Holand of te Indo-aopeans “cuts teact rt of ths Anse inti ery, he Hiren spaing Urs wth he gh flue present» gp inthe carat of he Arman as By ietjing irs ts Armei te Ament on peed iow ay hance hong tc genes te bck th txt cl tins In ores fd DRS Verona Porte Amen hisoin sven expesed be at sme foci plcosmvpol ens woul ef in era Sone in oth tea he alasteged ape Us te ws fund Geog” Ov hee as tha he = Tape mad am 8 ic ps ‘schon o inno be Ame a ery intl Hyco ee Sy me Amant ay a aly ‘pitt os ANC ht 43th,» Nt an fn fie tein in a heap wefan eet ‘Smear tai wisn sue tl acne ge 388 we dears he ceo Ee by Nene ot Epon racaon ft alm yop The Pao Ancestor. u [Armenians mee ahi of etry fan where nat fn he ance of the Indo-Europeans als the Home Ml baptaly hve ergata. Tat the Armenian see Iofical tce tong to he fend atthe ener of the Word ‘va sso ely pine ck he begining ns. ‘ina es “Amnenie ng seen, qu swe nd wonesrfe metas Te into ae sa 8 Raphac iSkncanthe nota appr of hs pit of ve ‘Sey labia 1989 Suen Aivazin, o onstanding Ame fv epg of fasting, ses the st mo Inch The lar even "rea" Uren ceo in Ae hin (Aina 1986303). An ters pa in his i ef the remming of Lint st the "Arratan Kingdom Ihe etmondd ogi abba! and wp Armenian uc 0 Tisancton sit sine Mount Arata ofthe mode stole Sols Arment ws ufone, ese on he orf ems ofthe Armenia eps) he nt 805 Aheame Ura became a sbi poplar pes ad fn Armen TV sn ao progr it survived gl) same ‘Satomi eons (cee. Adela ea 198)" The td ‘mal ata ovat Ura a etd 5 es t-pain nd ns idl ia sta pin However a he ae Cer Mer ny mt sale austen Ce “teeny sa ect STSLTSCSY Gave eee sl a satin is Get aroma es ree Sonne "Regan wy on tthe See ttity wacom cases tnt is pe SSeS iesmnaceeniomesack ‘manne woud hy ke plae were is Scone «ht ep ain, tis wonsciee posan iy proxy “el a ‘ppoing he mAs sotto the ei iy Foran tin an Ae rain eine om Newnio hana (Nope Krabgh, same he Uriah rg of iA ame Arch to steht ha mtn 0 wi the Aone who apa inthis regi, cog Yo Aveta apne ly nthe rece pst (se Ae 198815), Thas ese ae Sah fo iy in the sn ps, whch pele he "etal yh mb an ong The Patho Pesige ‘The "eons" Georgian” mod canbe dias 2 ay coming ntl ety by nso bn pe ‘ou fetes. Presto in nay eles mea ain ‘cle. This fling of mtn agus pec cance nt f Gorin hee hc me "Grp a he "yey ime thug, feu hy ae mt ane a i Armen ho suf fm npc int bin te fo ones in some cla seston or ante he are Sones atonal pe of tg "i ony ems ane the ds Europe who syed i atl fan cumple of ies Forth Gorin th igo aaa ence ee a be more dirt" The formu for neg le “they ons rate tha he Amel “est nse des oe debe pcr of achat ‘9 wl. For eampl, in oe ke tyng se nd tae. won te poe eile ger fo pel he seeps isa gat apis rte sce ey hanome let cong ua testes. Thy sak hin whet crtyone cat nae bla 30 some al gt answers Ie arm Then they a he sme quest Sb is Fea an wel Siylih ste onic fe, a, sho geting alfmnive a eR wma en ee so ie ata nan Sari emnaiereynt amet eS Phe Pao Ancestors 8 ver Fn, hey ask whirl he on i me Fm os sek pcos ana mh bps ation wea cing elfen: °No, cy Shai OD {ar Gary amc dave’ Te psig mde cl th lesan lingo naps he spe feng IS cating fran aces Ine tf unig aso Grate ant cls anes) oe cand Sans Ur ‘Son ape atin on ton pra ag os nonce ees Tt Ite vy wl he pout igunes tthe eso talc os oe ee ll express oni he ed 0 unite ba at ‘Sve pe pment asd he fo bse he Thao ners scot bre Ts pes tly the meer toon of manent ow ey oo ab snge coca th wo tp hea The an nan of Ese Grr sn Tein he sn Sime ¢ pn, Bath some wre med fier he ane {es that ita ts nso Tn oes thse we the os on oth in ces i te Ces. he Sect hs om rel byte Rona inthe Ye conn and er oie: Appin eR hina ofthe een AD Shapes tc posts of sch» ciel rhe a [Tat nhbontso Spin ete freer ofthe Gets, Se oe cay. te Gorn ete geist he Shon ben he ses ane svcd just y he tend he naa nh oi Cried by Appin ht he Georgians ad eng oad five a comm mcs Th ir hype hae Bone of mea tademe Geoghegan ema, Tae aoe» Bau ites in Amen, wich wre sce see et face prem ont arian Sn yep Shes Rev oat Ares Vise > ‘ivyulnn sorb desi Uo Ari ee sen Arc ie hs wr ho WN tical the" Aen nelhough itis wot commonly sed ve in Garin sls Ge Mii anoxia 198"). Hower ittnay bon an eta the Geen cbogeeti eel oe tn ac mes Wh italy “restos Toay the" ot of e Ceoa ity ay mai fcr apn, ‘fDon Quote hein Sin tele pel molto UNESCO rd era ofthe 50 ao 9 iss dscover: Georgian prtcians were spose {Spin and move Tt he Amica Constr festa Mat i Inceingly, the “chnogsn jes)” of te Armia ‘som his Gcorgn sng nh «masse ronen bye aren Say Arn (nee oe ny ‘ene, mich tn he pesos unten fhe Co swe toon pis Soe Site Geurgiasdo arpa fom asc ba thee So en ago eh th Tc in ty Acmennn won in anit tna sone sce nl Sy expedient Pn : Me Gea eel ho eine ary, whi cola Wah the “see “Tas Bate Kn mets ce nS the crown ofthat te, the Goan mel eopae ‘a sopesipis (wich ths reine eters fe) nh Arena Sc only te Touts in te eocalgal tne For Camp, Gene ny that Mesiop Mass an Armotin, meted ea ‘eon o te Goorin lps" In sodas wh be Dac Tims he ming ac ‘eine eps napa ae se Kovyn ugh Grea cn fi nett tsy Sia min fr snl oe ge ‘ott Moan s,s sc ined fmmoncs pats wees ce aes Siler un dn hh he tenian epee Maneova 986-6740) nae rw AE Phe Poof Acer s tut “our” Pushin wh mt be sy Hasin Pushkin er Geagin mol eis spe “anol alien ~ Sain donk the Ament mary of he ena tote 0 Sh by her aac ran and be revenge By Sdcian Chisin hing te The Psion ofS Sih {py The Sat Shs le sie she ist mom Peet Georgian erste Merare wih consequent iy Gergana iy ove he "vac" ng tet se oan in Gc. Sch a ale wt est became ‘Gul when Seas Parjnoy, the fas Ts om fl Ae of amentan descend pemigion sot + fimo 5 Shi bse on hi ori. "Awe fe ae mestoned, the resigns” model sonal dacs tes 10 snc ay "hey foot te haueness al dstncton of he secmptsens of “ea ‘robes eth pepe the Geog model ear ith {Re peclaics ote Goorin sei soc wi i iy ‘al network sbi, a sala sues oft eae Jputon, Oar noice dct ere, tral. would on ES resipowsapct ther ncn, they tapped fae meted bah dsce Hoe, ey seem 1 for "demmca intr see or anes, serch rss oe tery pie am. For exams the Aso achcslogls V1 Rao dl tite oc thy devebped bch o he Geman speaking Gas re Tose sen Rss he Rs tne ie (Shs [ooh 3730, an hacen Rn whe Scan. fet rig tonne Rade ute Rasa ao i Sth eat what my nines fr nay 1 widely cd Senin Viking ots Fr 197: $2523) reefer tom nte ou for cee, Rylako 159). Ati ore soncuba sage an dbs ie ht Hed ine Sth Rosson seype athe 6 cotry AD.” Whe the" onary. tam med a ge nih Neb bo ns Ine ‘hn sare aah 1988: Sosh T2224 1, ‘onevce Trucs eamtactin sling be as (hi ne ton) in te ming fb ame af he Resin sl on es drill ciay sober thon poo elles.ee pain of Renda wh he mi! we 2) 1830s, Ryblows tactic a those te asf be lsd asp a mata na sen tecnbls te ight with i alin oe Anes ‘nod cna petns iy ohn oo be pigns” ods gene ng {SSR ay ie in. the ay he einen procescs ig be easly me at Such ins, Tis is well one te bak stm he uth, the “conve. ean gt oot eign yy Seer es Ae cc Fea mah acm ine ag A ett erecta he ne Set ute ala oh me Gharabagh are thought to have ad = 2. Aan TAN eri Ah nr 98 52.87 Stan 3: NN 1 At Spal Aan bt bey af a me ee Scena of these Tke-ping nts jen Ra Phe Pa of cers ” ron in he ie 1980 cy 199, fing bot Az tit a Annies Pein ul en the Pl of Nang. hi Hight or oso Sey sy tole mn’ compat isc a seme Imniptatons Appropriations of alien faces wind tbe Serr” moe! fave wore ou pie ave eth ‘aby whch "uaa appropiate Inaeuge of 1 fing For example cong to a pon paula Ar Saran Amman apo Casson ATs ites a ido by tsa Alban tex io OW Armen and Sestayng th gin maar by destroying Aeron inert onthe metal ie one uments te tt clang tem oe Armia Akan a Aa Soe 1 “Anat “appepit idiy” of he Azer mods te Medan om Ashe Aon ty nd he ton Catesinn Aton e-upon Narr Aven. he Me dn ety das th Souther, or aan Arran The Matin heyy sone fH Turan pone, ae 7 Se no 195 7 wh cw nd Man 199: 62 ‘trams The dn of erga in nse Ray Nines se mek any {i9st)'On he Aton ot Armen seg ching ‘Sygecuing ohn Amen of exeyine Aion ‘ncnins in ctonens ng nef the lo fom Jo fen ind Smo ay a mse Are ‘the mfr nanen no he onamens of be manent i so ‘nie show a hem aged etn he oh ‘arn un men Aman (ean Sk 8 36 ‘jin mgt ger el om erin, ce tet Suet iors sean see Hae Frens Fe a kama Langage he Med ae Asa san We Comer he Mele One ofthe Fes he ‘rth Pol™ ese me sot oeAlo, inks, wt ied mks Aznjui g Hel seated ses ane dame tance ro ae Syn ao bing Su pl sy ie ly {ge a he cot pono ea ee Fy ein tet ond 50 pe oe a ‘ete Svet Uo and To Thea ae ‘esi md pot stew severe tows ‘Sofie ut of en by hs leans ele ee ‘te 9920p amen sate oes ‘ops Sina i om opr com in Aran Sneha ngs ay wml xe de el ne iy fo en st Toad ee pha {i ich ee ately ens saps or tev nn As we cane, dom cnet ess my ed ioe ite ams ah ee thy ay ely cna Woe ae ‘oT ne Sot pe Fane Stn, we phe saan oh tu Rc Norom Soc rsa sane ine ae ‘ns nay scm ah ar re tl concloness te Alma i Neda era ‘ped iin cmge esee Fey feria ot of wwe oa to Resin chee hy wo kent ‘eis aor Caan Alon why ee Ase shy mt Malo a Yr eal Yee a rca the wero i chain pe ei 4 cad te esol flowing pps eg at tat isn Anan and Mon ne pe se kn pT ngage seg Bates (ai wee soy coed Wy ten Hy ID, an hoc ef Ay eg ae i haat om th oT gg aie {this a te kngsge Acc Si mals sepsis 2 er © & Aloo wt xy in he Aza {Rab 875 chad Aen 198 Se By he way, Sans heat pra ie pogins Phe Patho nceors » wih ae a ee atch ast nies ease te ee Sere aie pacar eens ae etree Som Se Sees eneishees ee ach pene een oe ie iene dis geteaat heathen incon Fr ele yg cme te ao oe eerie fhe hat hem acon tc tn he testis ‘im nl lant Wes Stes Fr ts st po ‘ores ei ie Sn cee esr ‘Symmes nee serio mes Me Beet aay pis wan Se met 7 oe asin wm os hPa Reming20. ARMENIAN IDENTITY INA CHANGING WoRLD the only ving prot th Azer oli Caen shin tn ey. Despite gto infuses Ug Imam ops the Us yan lags to a tes of it-rlyeommutistion which It pod cede thatthe Armenian gata te sows 9 ath lon re oe ng (sition) White may Lins wh clang hea BE of dcaton Asia 1937 a a tye and ey equ, capil nthe ag oe nape it hs expecially anh lle Thee sequin pin emir lo vies vey le mann fr cael pee Ins san, pel sm! ld amples tn pce pole uaa ilps ake ple mths af hs a Iino esti tes fai pre eee eteaue: of rater. Ante smoking suamge al tht ce contions =e Ca, Son sad Neen Seay com os tn, vi tl aes ees toga Fratton ing ban islet te pee idea bang ay ah ot was nw somwdara ‘von ety 8 wn pint wo he nae na the Eagan thee fe ms gla ope at This isl” egitim wd coin co ‘ions. ny ide am he lato mea eas as 8 ney aid etry int case The mos ea oe Such “ele” ety ie eo hts eee Soul onde peop ther pn eas es ‘stalin ana “pada” fe tik eed ins, rea in ens when henna costaet a fi ede ta unin “olin ete ny ae let le a the proces fey wa a bs fo eth th se ene wits te mayer iy “of whether he noma htc peng poe {oval tran ow Ar Soko Arne in one aaa ed wk on he i he ow Aes sae ashe {oi ino eve af Ni nly he er cet ‘eh Ui oy. The me gna a "mtg ct no onl onan The Path of Ancestors ” ‘o'er ed hr nd pp) nee Chie sea rin tray oe (Von Seg 195: 200 pmb is mn of th Ain ei Pi tee tee insane tpi tsi re ops cra See toeeyeual ice mid eo SER arctan w a sa Sh tncsatpn opel ah Cpe CF Acne Coacrgnas eel Ot He ev arse22 ARMENIAN IDENTIFY IVA CHANGING WoRLD Westaly o sec ting wich tein ae towed ad wich ace tlowed tebe amc es aa ina we The “Alcan” Pi, fey ars fe he Reson tees th mc es Rasia. evs wer ant con tf consid dang seco tte tasonal Rossian anSemic todas ste mentored ear, he Getsping Ges a he Possible mec Fansh bani wet angers, ie ‘Cyt a aso fares oy oe Shenon 1999) © tis) can cla ony hata tity tom Ras On the ‘erg eee hve InAs te Ho ‘clone, and tie "Armonn™ ne excl he Uta at his thy ae "trlaed” (Cosi be hasta” ee a i tan chk olenme ae afer tng "aialie"Tn the Amerian Gan onde “a evan is eke, Tne wee Ana Syst of Paring in Ari on he Bags sy {vt rn bo se al Cai ee 8 tnws Maniknin arr family a aioli eed tack to + Chinese antag th gana won thot o be alt phon ofan Chane the te sehtoring he Maminsns lye ot ‘Top mish fr Choy Chase Ads PT as tie alge alien ots fs Heri ly wee eet sm {Sodas fonching wesinble nthe Res sls ‘Senay popu by shes fom Cape Hower st ‘se theses he ing sh" ot Fist Man,” ert he ces Bsc ee kon Foy wt bey eae ey tinge dey eed © ‘a 2 ct me, is te tubo rig of wad yy As smo Ge, ef Nw ant Fm 199) eid 7 ‘opr amin nnn pat ad lc ia ro Sah ci & Fon coping nono Mora oho hat lh ising ses ee ols br ea as ht a hr So ne ig nh Ainpti 201 143 Oe ine eterna The Pat of Aces a ction sore ae 1 cen Be it SREY Sno Fone, sr inraaon YP Mente ge sor nap sete pb we Tn Seyret eas Ch ‘Tova he lof be cna” bt ming owe Seas dnc ee bet coy ron he any coc eee mee clan ae can sa va Sophctmcumaus on then deal ne ma sta fig sca orcas ae sea eal ea Day apo een ‘See toy nod eteaes ois eee ceo be Siegen on amt ke Po eee pin be ase mall we ees isuhncnesn web aety mtenk ed ne rhe epenes ote Tri toa eatin try a the reset Rep of Azzam ba I sea odim he te coe a sw. Arr Wha ee png te oe Acs Men MPa sft cy Abe, Se ee ppl tf Hy a eae Cagis Aba Natal se aly mle Hawn fe hee ose Be salcometng ‘SUAS Smears One cane at erg malcom sa scp sn) ok thers nes, tS re iit me on ey Wh) Cia eenoga da ‘ weete cm concider othough some vations, a we Dave sok tte oan oft dace or ode, ale at iy wom parses ats en Rin, ‘Dal team nd Guna she nmi" Segre mm ett Ejeet ara i nd psn pe en of ospns eitRos24 ARMENIAN IDENTITY FY a CHANGING WoRLD ui” mods wile Amenians an Acct ok fr pes gous foes the the Geargians, and Arcus aed {Gorgon ike Armenians ed “hstocal apt ee ee acest, yng eng hi any enc “The Path of Namingi vos A i Two THE PATH OF NAMING. Naming as Nation Building “The Path of Demlunzes ‘Toremener senting we gt ae. Unmet tay d' east rity ex they have more fw chan post oway wow eving wae. ef suc oes, Ts hcl sti pho” ean fe sendy fn he moder Ceimuing wo, where soared es dispar ding l= ‘fon easlyons, Ad what Bir i hot sis oe ‘Shame Wend to brow am em tay sie evey fame actly sry fe boning. Fr expe an Ame an pt cology ofthe toponym Nairn ls oy sonia he plc whee Noah stepped dwn ea i Ak fori fstime ac tn ood “Fr ti a scene” nt in Arco nts ae. So te ae “cotins he ‘cl sy ante ont lgea on te Desig o he Annes, While the seat enol may tll ie am ‘ce storys Noah my na be pesto al. The git far oH¢ name Nation, in which Nico (kh) Ipc tenn y ih he Vik pope ofthe Now {Cauca he Choc sig ave of thecal themals (De- fakin 10743, 8). Sst ft sry of Non n bb context we might he try about he ancien as ‘Sti lc nh eotet of he eet press the gente ‘ton of aan and Ears Caan guages (Dako {na Stain 186 1988). ‘Somstints the hres of «ame coll enh 10 pu many aie srs ot of For exp rm a es ‘tom inripion fet by te Uriian Hing fsa on «rok ne {ae Sevan in Ava en dat he conquered 3 county‘ned Ue (Ulu. Nohing bu he nane shown of ths ey However sso e-cnfeace a rope re which ay inte th he eanguset pte wer Indo-Fatepans. Tis sem rele the ae Cale) ah ain Ino Europe gr ah agente eae au is ab refed in othr pce, nhee anton fo Europea ve, fr examin Hs ita oe he an Toponv 1976: 125126. Tony T98D"s7) This sae ould fer la ry aba hy te very mang ti in vs a “agon sone mame A al tps sak th pst an th pesca he ph or the pines Geahart ha (Get wi the fe ne Ponte srmatn of ths Ceti Tas the mse sven. ey fhe "ean hen among Theme “atonal ae." At he sae tins 8 we nls sesh pet demure power ncn ply terol sea whch nk ‘seo ges sta eg nd all oe ‘This mig ofthe ane she acc pound and is based on ative ia of he tame wt ese of hese evomintd. Thats wy mnogo ca 50m in icra ae fe tvng lating suet ithe mvaning of ter ae Io any ules ena is ibstited forte el oe in nro cea tee foc these fres an ven he Almighty a bre reo fy the revelation ofthe ane Tn many coamogaie he Deen aye exes the word jt by succes me of ang. The ‘bil Genesis so mpl bem this ane le oe ote ing the owed wr thal A of ‘eats, Gok Ano nae th (Gen, 2.19.20) Ine "adios the gent aneestoive name to evens te ‘une ring tr inital Journey af donc the pace ay worl the Austalian Wasa ses did it see "neo ins (Berth 1951 20). The susan pss oie ‘Armenian progenitor Hay dhe sme whe testo ninth Psane the svc! homeland ofthe Armen Stch sts of epening up the wd can be ipl sane red with ho rion (Aba 1983 119 ef Pos. Syan 20814 Hays of, lie oth name fe The Path of Naming » Spt eed ta iether esther adic err oe Soe saree Eee Moats oe eel ea ka Sad ate eactoy laa ee Cee iets shes DeShaney as igen out Rea oe ay aed oe “arc nib plana say om th isk 0” Reways inertinket ™ ne ‘ serene termes ta ‘many Favs’ (Haye isthe pom, plural of Ha), 6, 00 the eon lanfinaing vane pvc ming xn Kay Ct dns fhe ie whch ast ye neck scan! a-ha oye Real 0 Korea (191: 111, Ho Ame ee sr Ejay ht de ay ‘sm hi th ee in he cm it eS (Vege ape ‘inet ints tonne, whe eds ats “aii Kl pc cate ym tee i a ts a ee Seta on i iy an Armin 6. fre pa of Hk tee gel em te he ne gat A Petey 3% 20 9 lh "hig: varie const oh bl eos, sao ty othe cen Pe Di ‘am forsping tase) me Aten Fe The Paths Naming 4 fue Areca wore named afer Ansrig Ves, who Sof is pigs a Chips Clams. "ot deci mig plo CowMy and bunt 1 peony ae ellen mc, ln ay eget Tey amming ea breed mone or less cera. Tee ae pany ee hn hse tiesto nei nto an inven Sane Far emp he ctor Bor ote Take pou ave smne oa seo tty ce ‘Batol Danbc Rive ues gop tid hee a he Fens AD. Ths name ar poste Si popasion Sine ste Sich manent of he sea power of te mcr pc spl foeses When acta group MOSS ter new attoy, oing wo eongeing he mak “Te Path of Name Magi Tomeve, tonight lobe cred without iia ps Suc ani comes rely oul of he mai of mam Fst ivy os examples of sac ate oten eto. Borcdet Andesta (102. 157-158) presets ne sich exam ‘cringe Vikas atoalsn. On hit eoonton ints, Girtong wise Yo call hk rei Naw J whi Imcam “Sour Vit” and as Heft lin 1 the ok tem, bo the Masher, however. assed that i be {led Na hich means roughly" the sou of VE," 8 ‘Salm consol ye Han sevnteos cet eis, Being ‘a tcl apelin smatatng fom Peking ts mame ws fev uelexersvely ner hy the Chinese no by the Vaan ‘Ref nntonh cory, ene ax the tweet {ty Ander ules ali is ese: Tat o's ‘Vcames pray oda Vit Naser invent y Piston March dt res sf Rens tos {ha tins mt ave “ob ien de bss” a also por ‘lovely af he iinatve power of rational? (Anaeso8 1992138 However the pradoncs of this se em show ry the upper pt of en epeting tien pte Spel le of te name necting tonal sty. his ‘Rpet Remsen das tito wel oh ese: what ‘Timponnee forthe cntonporay Vintec, the este‘tom em Sect ces, at esate ini mse egy the Path of Anes Fer nian So nd liza lin ae 3 hrc Apa ct otha the src arp (Austen wold nie he for hones a Do the rain the “Armenian sci tl. However, ach na ing process ower athe me. The eo te SSS atin ey ete cna a 2 The Pash of Sai » Caen Alona of Askin which 9e brily monet ‘when dicsing the "Azebani”mesel a excl ec pie Thin ane very nasties eos combina merce sown ves ich me won icing ‘more al ere, “Ali we he sme oa King wich ‘te lcd on he ef sie ofthe Karn Rive, we rn om tacit autor like Saba Hens Albani re conte 0 tthe meer of he Azeri ig on he ery of he presentay Replica Arran which eves the etn af Ais ancien lagi This 4 nual way of cowtectng inl istry ad oss spe yoblens ad pardons 8 we 1 feet for ths sry fs the magi ofthe ae tht ‘vers th ony scouse oer ane "Mer the Armenian Kingdom case to exist 428 AD, 89 ‘Anmsian provines Tose onthe right barks of the Kars River Ut ad Aa he fte Mosinous Charo, foxneda par ofthe kingdom of Alta Hower son tee tern 9 the Albanian king a ened Yo exis and tee two provines now teeame part o Pein admiisate ut tho lll Alon fer k pedcomor Ae rel of Ars invasions, Pein daniation sept nth en, an» pi {ipa was fame bythe ond a he shad the Basin ff he seen centres, opin he place of is nit which Contin to ha tne mine "Altai" However, ao the soak ‘vo th aie “Albani” while te woe es cemcd a rch acl Sich rane exerson an sinking remot Somes gu. They eet he ny ve a the tia “ame” expec os tes But thi piu ne Decne he oo hisaiogrape ples an evenly ed 1 the} ey ADneod be wad atone sclera Sete puto fe Ui sane Nee rs tn coma os sin "Aanan fs the 5 oy ‘ena Agha” ened eee ‘evi is oft Roar nw oe Akon 7 TI,the cet ny wa inh ion, nthe ci en cary the asi Kings Amen ‘do ream the Arian proviso Gea Roe i Bot thy et suse, any bees of te nel ts” fal tendency towed dsieton (Akpan HT 9. 20, tis oppostion of cust an espe en Bg sn exacts of Arian i. we il se a the Path of Desi he ase of Alban Ah sh on ‘pestonomieaten ak a itetng mae ered 12 rove” cigs sven, gu ul er spe ae This was atly nesses ve A na 987: 26271 ao as vee gyn me {ning in hs mr opel caer yo sume pode, Nowa hw Bistro vas Dasha (Kghoisat” nie eek ths tk Ts aay ter or a Katine eth ey ihe aa Fite Nat Eula er cingteraatiereecce les chon ws ogo mc o he shit ines cease Sintec cartons case thy Steerancante eae sol itans rah beatae ete iS sero th accom i Sein isomer ne ares Sires teicher gent Spam eaearomaon sr ce ret meets SSEDrenUNStabbaoesene The Pao King as wwe havea case whe historian as consuting 2 “ato Tiny tn ater osm Armonia Boing with Movs orcs th “iste of Arian story ti a8 ree soapy Hoy was eer ero Gene the he “isting” forte sly sti) oe nerd ‘ih a chido psaspsal pespectve While Dsths Tamika aa pase athe rial ai — 1 fron ht Alo’ Aghan st specie cour fest om, mont psi pl ome om he Av this sense thei th work cul ive some ues the tisryemaing lg the suo AS A Takabian ss, fo tect Resa th nef work a Pa sr fcuk 1987: 1-16), whch can be {epee sry of ga’ Alani” "stony of the ‘XBhunins (Asc baths are grammatically emis An Gcnteniny cyt dy fe ‘Fame Agha vir ao who posible ser fas” my An) ‘ey af the Cay ofthe Anns (Arnis ich sessed oer ay” and wasltns* Now JKrneniat author vsualy pe fo ave the peo pte and ot fhe country, te ie Bul while C. Dorset (ce Dass Si 19st) enemy flows the aesator ten oun by Toms (re Kirt 1978), Maeva (1977 seems 1 flo ea han igus nes For Mansv, the {com Albian cooly meats an eta, ena (Tih erat were hough f be the distances of he esate ln es eo abn escape cnet tent Kagan Sean Se ysis of Khana tric conesp- tonne se oe toward te pas presen a {person to abn espn At el Gee ee nes by Ho ‘Sunny igen sang hi especie posi wee fas ine 19-2 epee ot ote ies he aad psd vee sate Ty Kehr nee Alpin 7 18iy a! et a apenas copes eco ‘etcetera oe ‘amplicitly Armenians) and that of the left banks them c plicitly barbarous northem tribes), ~ Show a leas eet ae ‘cing: ane iy ig Kies Ho po ie ay the Ame acl se he A {ly Armen nie" dP ‘Nomoy 5p 4 ei by Sen cu hi pape “Soe ay sn Ae Sama ‘ss mind ie Fan Armen leon Ss tem into te Attn een a st cas {het 3 te Aone eens nh ea she lr na eg, Mayne 1967 wl ss i nen Hy amon oy The Pa of Naming ” people had a different Win an beae 2 different pet Howey the utr dr no to fr aay fom the ‘Nem ol nestor, Pogo (Taal wha ws 2gmon of Nels san Jap athe ater Tayk. As 8 frat Tac he ou fay — the at of he word ‘he Armia ad Agni” were Toe ws thought be [Mabie bythe poles opting fom pth, But ince al the scents of pth ere akendy appro yn yeopk or ants, Dahan Kapka do sare an Incestor wi sone eter people. Te ator chase te Cypris the wer that ong rm ner ands of apt, Kinin, no wa Trg’: nephew The aoe dies the eit a ar the aga sas hat the Girne m efor es a hae wh tape in he oth fant ge i he Abana Kahana 198: ch. 12). orem hore edo iting te tonal end Ahovt yk wi he bist of De svn The er Itrassr foeete a story, theless hes pple an Cuter esate chose natal tess rm. As a {Stott tn the append with he Azan se ‘Sw een ete ta story in Sot ies. "Tas fr seve isco etn of sveegh po ie the mos sigan point wae fo Bove # history. bi fing fm spac hr progen or sintcreting 1 Ihe fll the lage of hs mesial dena sty, see, Iiough kms following he tna! way of srbing pli sss to corse wel wath» description mod Evaajst maul ive ace (Sih 991" 19.28) oF fn-Weser stg Sai 9B 11-12). Aer peste Chapter 12 te eloementoil geesogy’ of pth an he fog ofthe Aine (her LU ii intone Stes Nonh’s genealogy, he aor cotaus in Chapa 3 ‘Sih taming al coming he kgs er Soph a oti The brdo of te rk hare pts sons sad Hawes, the apr cabled "On ts popes which know writing ‘eine te fat sence of ts cape were pepls having ‘rite guage ae bts, Armenians and ARs among 6 mney (Downe 96 3) wes man” eg ae Te rot se nn wih (ef ng hi apes nt hc of saethe So te caper nes the econ ational fran ~ language Moran he kan at No iat ha ic sie ning Tipo shay ens, The it an them olin a esas {the hl ex hoy ite The ne oy ate ex es 12681589 sa stn Old ci anh ogo ee hom hc lst copy fe cal nce is parts 98x). Armea las he ‘but hat ot Morass were Ani and we eee tc in Amon ee Matalin 109s Age 196136226240 Methane that Areca savin in Ul and Ansa eve se fy een ut sg ‘tana Persin word in 408 ace Katka (eh ee ‘i any bone Mowat tl sate “Amen ‘oon ese to pov ely in eh sean ne see ic 127 a 3, At chy owe, ive the iil nage of the Tsay be Aone ‘Th tseve Aman deste he ng ewan fo Aten se a te Non tat cpl he on he ners hs aa german hn Wek aS Pa he forth her inte he fist re of Abani sadn The coy gene fe is cn ah tin "eon Amnian ante pl a the’ Atma potest (Matanan 1963 kate 19k: 286237) Ths men that st ed the eo People ml th "Alnor Si th olny Alben Aghn and xa eal ee (ts weal “Ams. Majr Aano ies ae nae a {he sae cae a en hth acc ws ed tote ist moc a, an Is nr apr ter nite Hound ‘es of Agha om he Ares Rv hp ge bounds of Grete Atri, Cron on Apa t {Keainnansi "13: 277 het” Hower “ots” aes he txt th ith hse, Se at The Path of Nei » eer st Sieg pe ae ee ea eee pect ty rece hopa a gabtezasesnt citar on St Pane ro Sree im Ses fa? Pater A a SEE SctSsSes nme age Ai Chl et erin {una he er Riera oer Ane pation ee ‘imcaly ote Ameo By eco pe he ee‘Thu we hfe man tits fain a tout in as nese aspen Howe sas sa a tmnt chats lo a Ths es inti of identity whch sary ch oat a Si cre ait ty re ‘Beoptbecome cpa eine wi Rep ree ik S610“ antes of he te i fever ms is big enn Hoeve hi sod ss moment of tsa Asian Taba, 26626). Athouh be einoscense Sr ro nk ens sepe e the Anan te po Aten ies nh soe ‘ced y hin te sanapemercomes Raphnenat U9: ch 125s Ala 987 395 245 a 261, 20626, 29)~s sean oy Alina ing ‘4 Atari then sug We Ps ithe Armen ing Vghusa ses thea ‘5s thom d way wit hndoy apy Bb ae Say Ths pp sere coed on th Se ‘fest even etn tate Aeon i then. Te ing pond rs oven thee popes ie rnp ray At we Ln nye pte he soe tine the coi Ba hs ram n coms eS ian eco sere ts senda oath ta Aer fexts The ls of he Cou Ah = evily nrg nh rape, nh ese me ve Jn te cat a pein pep str, bt so {tent to compet with apts ext hscane orn of Aci ~ et real be vetion ‘Crew ances forthe Almas. Alou suc isin cn Srectnsfrmnly semble the mode mets af stro ‘eon, thy cat be casted a sich, ete medical ft tovon? sour dif he mom oe Ct ‘Mopin.Mouradan,Yesbsian 1987: 17, fT; so ao ‘Snssn 1991, 6840) however, sme moder historians fa Ao sce ts dierene For example, Re Thomson's een of orem seems ob ads er stoner, tert med er Rha 1706, oe Thal p 8) Soeh an appronh actualy an acheter Shot af erase Kha A eae Ue. he pps npr spac eof A sei ih Spel ofthe ae Ag ao een Sorryrey Annan sf’ However on hs fee ear er mr rev ata oar Khoo {Erte tar of he meds aor Fr exam, ean bots Simon Himaakion compares the Taber Armenian °C tpl vein of eins usin ad Svein So ‘ite orion a te Rss aS {Roc n/t na pen *ornentim oypsicien ming Kent eS FtplorCamoson Ann dss the Patho ering ach iy fase oo ta yest de Yond ewer of Tito the haere 15121, Shean 201171|S ARMENIAW IDENTITY EN 8 CHANGING WORLD tiseogny” ko who the Amexanropl stg, fost! afta aa Tsay” wa Lad oe tes ‘ra fo whic ctl Interpret. Ti sa he “mova rn topes myolly cl a aha o tig 10 pcs and eral 3 bo of Armin soy serrata pce Somes ie Febuay IR he Ae San pgtomsnaten hn ald 0 He ove Amen Scholars hat Aomens hve Wt Ht) ‘moi ii of istry ie Nin wh com se map anon eh ts Fst ton se pny ch syria his) ost ‘oways ht ihe Become ont pope cs tool dcoune However. © maenesining dco fight te os of he eet dla is flowed ty oppncts thr an ing the oul a ts tons ae he osm cle okt ee ‘essen Tor exp, Armond Georg o ‘ey ite 8 mmf hal and cls pene once the mon hematin san ease iheteboks teh edo ed moat ha Ae bain isin who sf Ares eto on te to of Anca would ner ape wil hs Arena seve wo ame histo from coi else ie ‘er The dus bres Conan sn Anenons ay iy ‘eine on Reng fanaa ne capac epadag Mass ent ofthe Geo spat oy de with cly fe jeu son, wh he Amann ae ‘in ese is mcesing pans Kaeo yey fe py of he 1 io sy" mar piety eit finn fr ge tle fhe i ae cnet ego nen alin he 1218 comays ‘Pratl he hon te i ge hice ‘po el on te eg fal fe Hower Ame. ‘Sev tne Forse, he New Em Me i i Phe Pao Reneming s Asian isl apts ay del wih etre and even ‘an : During Sovit ule pons fom the sonal rubles st eat he eer rather” Rison seis om Moscow oe of thir dptx Ts esos pli ‘hss wl the cnc ss sh Aric a ‘econ ev Googa a Akan wee ssn tice in ‘rcmfn However ie seller baer” ale, cul oe the pion hoa ws pray ips wo sty bth Sf stn pi pts Iv ad, et” os Atay supe of ving ie oo lf the apps ing sles oe wo ate cise tne conflicts). The Sv etd sry bing wo il an ebro “eons ands tapltion tra eves, at ‘oul rly blp sang margin stripes, ep Sly on ey warn oe eco Sov pf he fa! pie Hine eee of the les! pt Bean ‘rein isp imeins a pon wes wee ‘Sona nae of sews pins sos ace ta a ‘ny key evens ere cocoyam he ir of tte Sone Union and te ctiticas" Many schools an estes even decal oper top aching mar i {oyun ew texas were publi This ion of co Stanly moting hry wow reste Sting te tine ofp So ina jue chaatrzng the Soviet Unio ate th te ompeicabest Pont Sov nal consis coins the same ra sion Even ty one nse ht eset evens epee tain cine hcl lange er {ns For xa, he lod rps of he mliay eo satay by Saver oeops ina HDD mr ceed Dy 4 Neomow TY chons mneity aie he mae eva 82 ‘om we conta bec pr Armenians by Ame ‘ow sins nde ae eo he is of Gear an 0 {Repo Gen a ener by Gea has SAE tant herein fst hangin Anis scampi ey dif oes) mich about the fist Ree a A 19181980 om ee creoFettion to a ations atenpt at anne seizure of power In anry 1981 the sane cnt! vid sve vor Sn presi ty Azcrbajpel TV. he same date event ‘re ow padi interred peso of the den fac denstations di wee protesting gt te fel Bo ‘Srmeu'scontvanct a oe Amenian pores lst ne ‘eae pon against Anncanstook plas nk jot Bele {he wltaryreresion). Fly nny 1996 th sat TV ‘Sie preset he st Azerbaijan! verso the vent ‘eas nw clase a awepanon a the more sin ‘ocr ete hetero uty of Azo This time refered he ital ease of he ais sk a5 Bing the decison of Mtns Gaba a sono pon inc of te former Azerbaijan SSR wha ajoriy of Anne is) Sete os Azcinjan Thas these repressive on, which rend ay mccain was int 3 hein the Krein’ recon nepctiely tothe Tana ato te ales (enp of an at-constata ame ep he Imiddle pat (Amesin pogroms) and the beyinhing (peice demonstrations, te accent now Bingo awa ‘Mets ons ‘When speaking of history consis, on sos 10 ake {no aco the sven see sus ate ie Usa enstnetion whieh can be fi ast ey cumin. Aug thse patos of ana” sory may Sometimes Tok rather fate, they care the ol of Key costs. wich acetic recor Hens nay be pes aly ini Whe mary see fue at ypologially close othe medieval modes af stony meking. modem ate ecntracon fro hi tye snmp wih he works of ase Naas NS ‘The ircing Path of Maniplations wih Tine ‘The suey of renaming dca in the bpm of his Path, tha the joarey in tin to he ont ess ps he pst 's womens wed by the opposed pati aa war etl 6 ‘mca of realinory “rane appeson” The cas del wih the dire pie ssc ete i epee ae) & nd Peer Se Artin fs colon he Ph of Renaming s ety se ay’ ae tient ne: Fe example te ‘erin Aa, ich stated Ags 1992, was pve by Teo sucesnne rltons psd respectively by the pare mons of Gem and AMara The nt dared tt te ew entton of Geng wold be nl nth costaon {the tnt eof Grrl f 1917-1921, Ascanig co hs ‘Sion, Abst es ato Gzoga, tn egos th ‘Ahsan alam sppesol to the Assan costo Toatos according nck Ati he sats Se vite Ts ops! byte ors a a a {Eso and Geonpan tops iva Abra peeve te ‘Samet of i coy. The scl worms eed by hs war a ames foolsng sytem ith he tla es of he ck of “Chmergsngs the wo tines etd Such Jue nine sre on of he mou yp pecans af Pos Sov sae iin. Alms ove tly indepen sine of he CIS hak sl slain, which ep clint he Soviet eid om thar hist, While mos the mts dened he Pail of Ant reie oexnin he a sty re) by onoprnting si hstny (ass Batches, ts me Ith th coo es oedema esape ty ene Ah nese pride Gees the Munk). AN ceanpe ‘Tsun plato sey wa eel ase by the osu Dun on Nae 15 199, which ac ested the Soret Un nt hea ret tt ad ae eras caller snes tog i ate ora inte ble ee ena ony acres antl. These Ionpulnos ar expel cher of reponal cvs ‘More te wo eppore sds sully crete pall ses Which dem tach ner Suh stato eth soa po Ie wv Sion Zon (988 19850 bats whe Few ns who mei rte seria cn) posession igo cota pee fs hry hs he Sher apn ace hn ct ‘hte ded canto Aha ime yb Eine ae on ec ‘ans hgh eon ws bh Ans inet‘xampl of the Gash cut when desing cx, hc ing neihr ith the wont exe sey a ‘nih tone tht xsd in th pst at har st ust ero anther pepe, ech ofthe stgung sds eo scape om is ppt ns some nlrb pot She past we cen th symbiosis een Abin md Gove hich Wat ann flowed by a al ‘oa wa Tn aon, ts ste ay use ahr symbolic meas inode tw undnate ourneys in tine” Fr exp th ay Arena Symbol i independence ai ining policy, rovaen 2 pod oporanity o lak nt the makings sch ame ms. thine” Armenia peel ts indepen a 2 rt the fist Rep of 19182, tna ke Azariaon and Georgia Sid In this comet, two arly bea supe tat he st Repubo's sate sys were pact dom tothe pew Republic. However, ithe ol tl itd uth da ot es serious ebjetins in th amet the ol ert a il od ‘content ane em Gat of rts us ven annonce THs est dv prove al aver, ao me vy ‘ler ate nly two veri ent n pple’ iy oe tee on th pate need a he Bs Republi the ht tase on he cot of arms of Sovict Arena The ames ses concerning the ett (Marts 26.1991) sow tht the rin goblet the symbian ofthe wo eas uh el pve rating mtr fortes of ay ed history bang) but re he apse he sy hae ‘ho Wet the Soviet ct of arms, wee nat rete 1 The pessinisie word of thew ane (het on the nly ts tang "alg cso stacey re scsi os, A mesg ee pe eter he ae ‘Rape ob he teins shiping va sen esi ib mei! hw rma he ml he-rnge ting ue bet on Armen Interesting he se two tg we dase ing Sov he wor eps tin the ear he Sov fp ecw ye Aen Sime nse te aol se, Cite ps eM Aw he ial yb of Ame ss eyo cose Rang 2 Te Pre Pas of Reman ° eae Sv inn" fin a Lt Tesi ‘Yar ing efecto heat devgn of the Soviet cont ‘Miveute en fhe sessn, whe tbe von hae ctl se try ant ets estan So com oreo he Republi of 19181920 was accep {ee ny ae” The snponets af Ste mb iam mame tt te new Arian te rae xp ong ‘Bn aa the it Rp ie nes Sot Aen The en og ake he Sine pom ws so pest n Aen a Ihe delat abot ‘Sipaence wo anda he ses of heme Repco tion af tos ofthe evn wo apes th oO as Soe eee ee cheat at Balecrinoe cu hart wring Peerainn woewsepom ieee oe ee oe cee jet ms of te Sis Request few gi aaa ane tin N's AL Cee tec tie cras toeeva me Sib othe elution the eat)Amen by 2 deputy whos sane Inpro. be Aram Manis, which wm the name of neo tno oder the ist rpc Atego syne rata ope Soviet timss was ype 1 each ne Soviet pe of te Tan Parle othe ephoif elem "ch eiions of she pst made some pole aus of ice ete In his “Ths an elderly woman whos joing wi or ompties For repaint te nce Frid ps, take ak th Ili fait hen th ret the ining bain be ‘alized wit sth ghening pion ~ up tothe mane of ‘Aram Manakin The lng aby Towa tect a tthe Levon Teton sce xprne a iculd ‘peak oF his lignes ttt sors 0 go back Precio wo the te ofthe ft Rep Hower, cov’ Fess the Tra” rr oth pas ad Fre te pte 0 ote in fivor ofthe ld eat “we have eso he dag dante, eave 1 also sce the ot eat of "Be aneloed Ts stating point shoul cy ben uns ble fo him eas of hs ae oh Dasha who were the ‘ong fre ing th fest Republic. One ray specu it {hs waste hldon res for hs een te si. to rata for hit sng pi thot Pass nd this ‘oth isos ein the tay of Ar “Tet poll perfomances hv many fxtues in common ith ie magia! sears During ‘ach crc the ‘at set i rperty promt spl tanto the pe Foresite totam ans se the le sky arly tvs 1 the bleed poi of ths Begining Ae ty these st frlanent actos were the lt chs of he ‘als hat nfo my pois of he he Festive, 1 we wl Sein he Pah of Retin ant Fes. However, {xa ner ast ong. th same a. te al tant tations ad jurey nine, whih wee ret by hep Times colony st fr a hot pero fine hme ‘ele, he mca stare esky. wich deren o ‘On theses sine of modem plea ce i pellets: Abana 13 he Path of Renin ‘hi war eto hl soya it, forme commu. tines anna db ois afeconmamst ina, Howser esters ae “i won ling te re reps fh Tn CRS Somat dm af Ss era, Aopen sar veins Sie et he Ps ‘Mago 1p open 3p. 10} On hp Sone ecto ene oe on 3062 ARMENIAN IDENTITY INA CHANGING WORLD people who are ow the por ofthe counts in quson So. wile thei tps of the Tram te to symbobaly ram t the times of the fst Replies ya femping to jp or the Savi pei, ety they fe Sat oo up etal inthis eet fst fi hich hey a ying tan ae ergs “The Path of Language Se Kapono) 201 ihe drones te i pon pony pono Ae \FOUR ‘THE PATH OF LANGUAGE, ‘Mother Tongue and the Cult of Translation “The Original Path ofthe Mater Tonge (Rue ase most ttn ck i rps ces toe de pat ean to the mato’ lores psy ence the mame "is Tiare Armeion oor aba wee: But we sos thatthe mow aie ners ft soy ate pul {ne ty mens fhe psa Tat sw the Pah of Anse fests the Patho Langigs “iow ithe so fcr Fring atonal icity Ln uage is smetins hohe be bot as pra thee ae fin cases when pens whe dtl sak te ae ong everest er ofthe ngage they dn {peak ober eine where feat popes wa dient ‘Biel &Suesspek hese ngage any case his = {ort este moe able compat of matin ty Them im cass the tox cca nang aon “raters angnge fn ke ths pine le I 581 inte othe cay auestn. This est by he Toming recent eps Dui spp Ruson TV program, ‘Mitten were he ose ome «word and then se ‘gerade o desc th orto pane of als AS ‘ie of eb as wee ton ae 1 tad sess ihe woat on he bn ofthe hs prvadd bythe chiens im vanillin evr hen hose an igs aon speaking Fi langage cue vo the word “nse Minnie I the same way. people tend 10 tik cose show language only won encbutving a frsign ng. I=cd,» person's moter tongue hea” odie Une congted with some he gigs tere ‘eoaron esos ality ony hon coun Cierny. Pog hat why in Rain te wn fo eam i cchaik Yen om aks) which Okt ‘rch Soon mci! Ba eggs cn (a tor 1978: 51) he aga, a an ont oe pe ‘on win speak linge On he te nde o's owe ii eS hg 2 ng oh a sue reign mgwgss fen appear nee {tcompesesie mumbling, Ta Hee cosret th opis who iv pk kobe Baran an he rd Bertsch was also alone bythe Amenianlnggs time To wor meaning "mambing” (Achar 197 520. Ineresingh the "ban English “tok resengs tenth roa tency with he moder meting Berto Get. Th Rassias ond Tor "Gen Ca Vesta” etre meet (nome presets even kr «ase ts not (one) dents om eet (em) can he” snr 191 62) fin ingest her Wy Resis ne ‘Thee abo es pobble onion ht bubaros dives fom the Artin bar “wor (i ey, pot In io the Greek a ough noe Tanase ‘lain {971 fo hs eprom of Sch Ta se ea of composi mumbling the atria ely * st th Yoon wy th he exon a gsge te ise a br "ane spay trad For eran eet expnay nary he Rn Fnginge wi op y Via alte tour Rain eg ‘apr ctoopopar nos ern Duan ar ran, IMPS wnt war sapped by ewe de Cory aes fms pecs saan rig eco Acre hit oh he ie ‘hema veh ch ming se “pp = ‘gy sek properly ae of he are ribs hing gees ‘tainted stan am Re 7, he Pato Lange a uuu wih od, 96 ih double wad (arr) — ke Rusia nary ste the diferentes of the word aro cou lite te Tope of inten a tlc imo one ova wor nope spec Beast fn bon spessh deed of human elutes harars From imnblg) wrbsomeInngs 2 weed (ars fo Iron) of halon who we woul ew dest ‘acuuble oct Seyi or arr fo Abin while ‘Athenians vrs foe Seyins” (Acorn TPTK 420 — ‘hing Anwar Hie Sethian). is ntewory ht for wm smiling ecally ums as 9 sin neue ‘sng st undentanl ores lower the peeeton a alien guy distinguish speech conto py fle i ser ines Peps he ‘Sins ste seority series af Aca wee hiking he Same ache yen he 1950s Tey incite racy ‘hin tpomigst Anni gas Toe og» sp for mera ign cote an he bso he many angangs Te'incw npg nthe Arona of the mik-9B0, the iene” of those speaking facanlngtages cmd a 9 Sino prob fart orm Present Levon Ter Pens, ‘thoes known a3 py, ado then, th vbr tongue — the neue tog which for tna ety ae arc ~ es Ives pear ange” tots yk Rae, ope the how ony th ve Fon st speak ie te her gue becomes ya of tina sai on Te wh Know eer, Treg iayeuges: Hence the univ deg on the ope of ner fngue when compared wl ie lnguges whieh ei considered © peat vec lib oneees of he phenomena of tahood The ms Stata comporsn sa std by Tish Graf he les of the 108 ecm Eopeannaons (Greed 9s 6370, 244) and wat racy reexamined Wy AED 5 evan of rig ae cuts tay whan ot) waft an nero nes ue Entec onninre Tl al sss ln is rol vn sand ‘enRoute abd co ‘is mest eee TuaAisin (2001) wth ina Armaan xa bean with the ftsetay Aenean sutbr Fghisie(Khscragen 1992 2, hs 1008 17) an stn ab the late ety phish concludes he compro ofthe Arwen lange wh nine ter ang" sweet ond capable a ‘ncn all hse fngnges sci” Ths hen as tater {veopa By Gig Tate an he ne cnt SAmenia set: an ab Aen abet eal a gages comply and eet ut thers a Arona Tay ap sored vein. beast langvges ate Inger Fee (Arm. Ava 2001 22.290)" Fou eis a ML (Giancan epned ths late oberon by the fot a “mein was not sabet othe cons of gauges ag ‘he destin ofthe Tower of Babel, contig tobe te ong ‘al Lng spoken by Ged, Adan nd Noah (Am. Avaian Doo 2-38, $384. No woe a hs pple iin iangigewonelts wih te “hiner,” Armenian ae di ‘nua th Path of Anstey” Wie he Engish eon of Tangige cnprioncorespingly comets ith Ie" rods” model te excelleey and sects of he English tongue i onl oo eat 0 gat, ke bss the ney of god properties of ter lnguages, ving tthe ‘rgs (Grell 192: 9.2, ing Rcd Cate’ pon ‘he veto ofthe Engi ange (1398.98). Inman tt, the aber gue Become yb of sina eo fo Bling uso tant nel ak who expeily champion the native Inga 98 2 {onal case Oten, sch indvidas ae sei ning {hos was theese Amtnia di he Rowen ston oc the te 98h ie he eg Preset rigs Amen sind by A An 20015, Porm te sal of on sme mt) Ans ‘ahi te ede tenn coat he eno A tpt Ine Europes the rand of te nenly ha! dp {ni Cupem scate Armesa Iigs f ape ‘is sao ves he te ses bees ‘yma tr iter ssn wa anenpoce ce, Mcaaneree Phe Pao ange o FerPoosn's poli ua i chance da Aza Sivan ead ft tn by athe Baus President, Hl iby, Let ws also all Sein he "abe fata” who ‘vt fond er "Marx ad the Problems of Li [usc along a aot ay bythe acancan Vinmpadon)? Tat hemos rail adeses of cet ol fr Inge in tn ces of rast oman ly sad ute fi vay om igus Sock peopl retrospect on the ‘vnc acne ong oder to gin “sien ‘Nbstantaton for ter naenist pola cosctons. We Seedy ow ow Asan toss bay spe thee mona! an pola tomsuctns to the Aypabess fT Gamlrtie t V. Wan (983) lich cates the amend ‘tbe tnd Eaoysne wi the Berea ine est fhe ‘imei, The ate penal Dudjes, the eel det Chet, lowe fro ner figs scr hs fe claimed thatthe Cheer would damit heather Cas ‘natn, o he Chsten language sas te mos ancien the vapon es Mingo 199: 8) Evid the ger in his {prelate pie hypothe tthe "ates fhe preety Eas-Caucsian langges ohh {top te Covhen angange Belong) tote ante aan = Eases Gee, cy Dakonov and Seon 1989, to whch he ‘rain anenge longed. Dy the wa Doser hal con- ‘uted is “tnguialy bse theory fatal dominance inthe Canes ie te Body war Ceciia nae Felton possi Ty his mse Hi wort meen Finke Bugis nretiog ebsevton onthe Competing tials fen conics Yoga os being pe east Py the symbole expresions # laatage (Bupa Tengu res Sin cons with i Gein ented arg Manan Har sn th be aie one Sues no fo soc tne Rese ap th Sms ‘Ea Rosin’ aint oh ahem "esp oe Moet sesering ofpeil ly 1G yi a ge a se Nae spec Got nl toon” a rien ehvm ing re rly i lie ns i ‘oo: eect he pion fn in mgs const tes, meg fe Sees he aly ene ti cas tor aso. Atd since i otic hel co fe omlon some spec igi tomy specie orc a og fe stn mg ht ts sping to ‘Sih nfs yy ae ingest phenomenon Sele to ‘Surigao a no ote tl toy. the formation at eptino f oleth olca ios. No won hatte pcs phy aco al rol pecan Canopies aay, sit thy em exe pula Ara wi cay et ht" and ld notion a al Wk tne pts epsiy vs cingentc spon ny ase he Sout et tenet me wn be ous mies is eset ha erm Aon cts wr a anata Pom sm we bah ae rpc iy sb ‘aout mac: How, cis on na ity wv Me ona i tenn r e“huke” tha eget ty Ted to Tago fet or ants nan ce! in of lth, iron ot at hogs lnvtions were tear th Sot Us at Si Bg eo Svat vr nee Sonat col of Pony ase dan poopie in Soviet Rss cece. Th ch di hey CE Ton 201 17 hyping ft anit ad ve {al lene peeing nisl vee The eel Esp pon hati “sk of tn en ei ig nna by meee eh ‘cen dtp rs ue te neyo eo aE GPa ela yl Sen poy ae Pn hi oh Kap hy The Pa of Langage ” ve the ter "ssa sory” ou eset ar hs amen SerRima eine powpe NT im Rasa (Shims Toes.) The nuit ery of Nil! Mae Bae tir fea dacoumging ogee resewch in he ety So it period. Manes seas damatd Soviet seteaes thse So or’ tory med the angge pyran usd dew Irving he "mata mae of tas langues sing 09 fe peak thats pitting fot common source — 1 he “Sa posting aoe ir) langage resing on a 8 of my dese nn. I st, Mas ast tery dei the Pei ofthe te ke diontinton of langgss over ine {an ence of te patnce an itenees on arr [Snguigers sein. ated the sevcopnen of Tnguaee though posrenve stage cmb by socal class ‘Pahups the staan commeqctce of Ma's theory a8 st pon dete he arly 100 by he Sot acne ‘og V1 Ronit, who working meted we bolo Tne aot ell camtext nth Path of Aes, A a tamer of Mrs ings oss, Radha orale a nove ca ofthe en righ o the Garmanspeaking Gs ho {hed in soutien Ras In ety mival tires. gins ‘Geman oppnens Rando expe he Geran lange Eine aa inten of Mars ge thou of languages Steen boiled dows 0 he sai tires peoples ting ‘ifn ees ght rte he san anna inept ny eto slr sot soatnacl conan (Sinn 1998 sm in 196, Pokrvsy's shoal was severely tick os ate sinrical Ths sia nox tend emphasing eon i foveal stein the Soviet acl sienes. Parada, ho ‘erst shry hangs nach apenas was, ul 1950, mel a comin of an’ won tn tyes, Mar’ {ta if was as oicialy denounced afer Sti pubis the afrencned linge wok ny case, fo the ne 1080s othe pou day, etimgencic speciation ~ together ‘vite Inui one Bat sepsemted the most pple Tramowor er dacs onal sry ah sy torso heme Soviet Una, ‘ome mio ep of Maen hse ee ‘poo 8 1172 ARMENIAN IDENTITY INA CHANGING WORLD ‘The Forking Pat of Pan Togaher wih the ehogentie spline discus in the Pah of Ancestors, the parca pais ang which maton bites erst, aa shape and coms he ga pl- icy of sso the ey Teast fe he Kalin of al ngage pices, Moreover, sch ics cn po urs sects asta 5a he Fao eae oe ‘Sot posible ure pial re, st tational anges pi ‘es tll sonra more about the present eget sow {bee sutra ets pablo he ots i ‘hey ate Rite, For example. bth Ie langue plea {he Yomcr Goorin Sov vp, an hat of the wey ne pnt Republic of Georgi, slemly refit all he polite Problems Geom hs had an conten oc ga fe EMnie mitre. Fo sas, he Corton of be Geog SSH of 197 dese Georpan see replete ngage Inlovgside Russian), whl the comitaon of the ABR ‘alors Repubic within Gog dlrs! Azan the ‘tombs republic's tte Inguage (torside Gora a Rama) Allowph the prose of lotion of cach thee documents hd iret ackgunds ce Jone 1995: 54-5. ‘x 6 ad 1 tyme Feu of eo constons Teeshaiowed the secession of Goria ro the USS, so te the secesun ot Abdi fom Georgia In comparion with Armenians tal Arians, Gcrgans vr lays moe rl in qesions concenng atonal be a patios in gene. A mt ote po Ist in Georgi gana! Soviet propor fo hpone Ris the only sae inguge in he uti romped te asp of the sforementonst ack she 178 Gerpan sonsttion oo Sttc-guge. Thess demonstrations fo the Suv sua {ie in Monow a gve Gagan the a stele. ‘Armenia ony ate nln rat! bjs sae ronal to dene Rosan th spb ste lng However. the ari, ightned bythe ne ation (Gerga,dctel dle Arersh al Asa tt ln fioger the repblican lvl wit wang sar mn festins neither seis. Th, thnks to the ati Georgian tis thee Tnscscin reps pind tr ational guage te sesond oil sat language, Phe Path of Lares a ud ones ot Sv eps toner lang py dsl aayscnespnt othe cin sine cy For cam, oa oa ‘Sheed one i sso [etiam of ano toswan ies ply wa sie etn Russ hg ne ep: Coe Sabato he Ratoni poptin. On he sree de nian of os en erg eal arbre heey mms een Re Sire ft ceil ap Resoanpeaking. Am ra xy ps in who mode usin mater being cal sn Arr ne PRD Tree ty apa an Armond at Ba Ts he ‘ee togeplcy may rth cobain fx enn me atte ewan or specs Es Rosin yy boc eel nga ey eyed fo rer ee ely. the sree SqeSvoraemen’s seta Resan anne yey wean kd byt! oo mony symboie pl, ns Aen mesial acne rom Resin ie ria hom sn tg oy Ar visa ean ees porate Th S22°R2 Mogan of asus tgs poi as cael sip ivan cxpeling =e fone he Bee. hom “xc Sony, we he nea ta mein sn of cea he same Ply nic mist discos a spent. eX Teas el in oes sl by expel fon ~ Resin mE en ron diy Tu, rng ee Son meal onan of Ann hart et ing teantasin anpage pty se he uno Rett Fea Ady rte reopen Avan etn Pre eee immed scope wich a he nga eta haere shun Aten Et Pane, Sy Re pl poe i ope ge rns So, et aay bon cen fiat pe et tec sail sl ii unsan -ovat aes 98, el abv Amie gis ile ne pope gn acing iets fon Rasa ys inthe et up of ang th ep te pata Poptart dost Ks Armes Ny eft nua erent tals lise indiseuty sof nln” ey she “prio eatin agg Pl dg By i pos-connun Amen gen ancy spain. pr sl played x cnr abi mic in crn Armenian mote, sce Are tim car ad gags eee sith set of ‘ern ge an cg ft Wh coe geoph Siting of Armia Tar ny ‘oom Amos as thug oes ach oh ss ‘aap a ee Bupa ann Fa da te ‘idemmber a ean copter Aon ngage Ths Postion na wie al ul TE. oy He es Dro Ana ep ne an eg "awe vento aoa of ase gage coin Arena sao ed seat pt eam poe Tegel apn he So sats mg tes {Toya wait isa sts ino Sve er ‘robe al rutin of eR lpg ne ‘moa pin Ts pose ene deed ‘poe os” sce sae espn Rs fre i ‘mot th Ss notype Rn ad te pcb iat sang it ngage. ar tice, I wou seb lov elds Sse of Stmporry pie ain” I aly 9H Sv ape "oop eon oe of 5 hn Ras ead "Stig Arment 1999 Canesten thse St an hs sgn le ei Sd cae eon aus ft Ra ora ‘the sae yn an esti 600000 ll Arenas he 3 ‘ton see he 198 Cnn) ety Homo se Toot tone ofthese Ansan eng he oe Se isons ‘semibhae et ren pose Th Path of Large 8 sie rely a ttl guint pscfal demonstrations the eto aror the poces soto oath a ste, My ‘mgt infra sta pk Resin Tra eouple oF as Friel owing tee vents inn te Sons a's kyo wig cle sin ‘io tough lngnge py es clone of he ct ‘25 Sted telly ofthe USSR, emt wih he tre common ts at Ge pring of a ens pe bn stent the dso tinge ise of mane cae te pct, nes ep bed the neues falc of pcceon te Rasa ei Fr exam te Erno he 1h entry he being fhe 2 ery, the esi povenmen tates Yr resin gongs poly of ‘ing scons ng natal anges pat fd icy spe he oan ms rc te, ‘Ronn age 2 bs aon ron ari ‘2 rman mons requ wih ses femoris at ‘Nc fac ie sing ge oli pty i ed fron ca rien Armen, ‘One mas alte ht ig the fot wo ede lowing he Bons volo th nage poicy of he So- ‘Ste ttc oestrone pe hs en py nu orn ve henge ins th my ttions an rat nots tt pnd Sons ey cl se ‘Non of many maton ngs by pew ete pbs fethaewh neve bil thom Ths i ti 19205, abo 30 owen Ings wer cated By 14, tbo nd Bsn Pen 16 nes Bt fm 138 hsb [Busse ply oa fran ses Brame te ntti Sos trl poy. Tah 19805, he ne {Dilemma silt poy elon Ras ne weet etwen tate Fabra te 1980 is ws nit pe spleen dv oun te Hl wi tay oS acing) teu cain atv ew eto ‘Alyse Sve pepe nd cen agin he USSR. To ‘Shore ts Mey, Sov apap al soils Gas ann wing Gn nog Tema ec ey fas tan 33 {seal wo)whe cmp “pve thet of no pool shar inga coments Svs Key tc a peg ornate owen burt of nn a i 19s a xy 19s nes the USS she a he eatin of sh uy wan nts et Ov eld ge at fe ‘a gateton sn a yer ort pe ed {rel meant omy th a Sx c e ing snort te srmndynamie dst Ad te fred tien opp, ovo pel gia te this process, = ie Amen, wee he socio 1915 fms ky thane 9 panign te ging nag oly of ee Soviet por ws naaed = angmgs See How cxe shad ote tpn i ops on "Sort Ameria devel ss» Snr Tenleey Sethe en yo Rosa ‘ot wih eiecl scl peste However he comme ‘Snainy ged o baa te ent Aone sy ‘cles be gue lens fetus pos wel se tah hi ngs i str inc my. {ew pe no ee cl > Msi bln elf aging hey phe oly te ioe ew sm Soup by spc ts agings a ech es ‘Sp ts ng The i a a langns in Arc sly el oh ben ‘bilingualism, aa Ch ig Gna a A aa ey "Sc Dud (190.6 who es Vcr Ture’ concep th “ony atc see ly fe ai Sar Are aly ees The Path of Lange ” “The Forking Path Bingo The ls elton bc lings watinaion quite ata se long pond of since aeons Tinggi ine soy ay well event te pr fo the lace ith ower stan Due wo tbe cep ‘Mets ofthe pst 995 sit in soviet polices aver fea {at sien sl the concotat sociation of RUSS ‘ite honor stats ihe Set hea. th na [seve the navn Soviet reps cae iid ‘Sti ie and smployoeapprtatis wih owe soi Stns The ssping sol cvsequnes ofthese his xpi The smense pecan tthe probe inguin nthe Baie mpi expecially is Etna, whore the Fit apis Sovst =e, Rasta lngunge~ daninaton ss sate ate fhm hh finer Soviet pubs. Apia ha bak. he Meng by sae Eoin tials to develop a sicmtic™ jt tat bing lt hana souisiesBocmes Pore understensbe “Aten oases he fit of ings om the ine ‘unis ofthe ings hid have ee he sabjec of mH tiseson crc argc pectin sine the ga ing te 2 ena samp favre Un iingninfs2epatve oF fect en the child fen el ins that he Second anges ieptvely inpocts the ing e's or er eee Sitar potion canbe et asks as he work of Rabin ‘ral Tar 1961) inn te 1th centr, wo conse tenboks fn langues nepal of serving os ean {or undtsmding he ninse of non ele Togo wes thos emp to sso forthe very rea difeenes bate the wot ese se exons a he aie work a five ele (ct Okonkwo TONS: 122, A contemporary ie Tupi a tat ie he mn opposition in Wester cus fd npg ht teen an death nthe Ini ie. He pcp ctpora-conceptal oppsion i be eer se and hfe camer Cray Inia aon 3 Seer camp Obs TR: 11126 (Ngetion ee) and ‘enti 199 (ae hepa Neth) Os Seer an ply ne cle np, se ‘pole 9eto at ie and dah as ofc cmos (Pity Tes: 43) Tha the vo lngtages ingly eserate x fier ner sonraison on very ie Socgptat-lngstc vl Ths ast th lnging-thougt ‘elon in the conta ofthe Sap Wht hypothe om the Mhnee of Imguge on thought, he geared to dsc atl difenaces between dan apd Western pli ‘sens an mes i. “Generally spesking, however, the ull consqucess of bigs are mich bender than he nul No wo that Seas Aruuoy (HAD: 11-127) deat 3 spa "hap the wtp Between iia a bing in is penetaing took on exe ngge and ety Since dst lnsgagc lossy eolate nth ctint ‘epescnations of “national throe bigunl people ay Fin henelvesermesbed in ala! tess bet die eves contin nana etn, In thi Way, ON My Sty, “extra” ete outs may ee perp “ane Stic conic atthe lv! of Ie posto Ml oe Sint psn Nor oman, however, ste agus 1 the let ht Bi alee my ky sey cmp he a esi om the “ewe” word (ce Chistoperson 1973, and ‘tenkve 198S 12). At tines, fer snes bilingl people fall develop el flay tebe of he angus. Accord ingto Gas Casiny (ARS), ach pop ca be abled ‘= sence hn nga. Sich "smiling per Ses Gusev stgzets, my ths develop an mero ontion Tht geet dapostion, Gusev easy De [ct of contin nab lo express ons by meas Sons Cusco tc osx he pychslogic matatns ff The aneArmotion prgtons in He Arto tow Surg i etary 9H ting the vee of e ati ts ck fo heirs ng “When mys et Fingal peopl (wo ae oly alas marked y a sseaple Meta) ae seb gtr, ay cont, eth he nest ‘neon one, hich npn can Be ed by dog [Shes ese stead oad lcs HS 37) 5 owes he ogee ih rl ilings an pe ding he Pa of Langage » Cerin, sc sos desire ena a as tis at play nthe inn of heya he deseo tne of ei ad maton nes, Moe soa pe {smd stl cet, however sonal dae that bi {asm in ely somshow sponse for ach robin No [tr haw gave fe nae consequences o inguin may enn the pole re of nga athe Beveopoen of ‘tons crs can dye dete. The einen and ‘elon fot fells He cla epson the Tipe ofthe sendin of aria, a the ish nti caput verdes hi or er pct ope to outs FitenccWibout Bunga sity would be condesmed 1 ‘comin fn a slat elation Yo the aust wn forthe ngs maria pos seen ost of ety ic cult cements tothe ei o hata comma ‘Monotngivn al puri, om fhe cota. can eas Ted & aoa espeiy 2selsaton nt ats sed cl Steg “The Forking Path of “Aiph TPreoge fics aoa ent pevily Yomnen rein angi 0 sy, Sanu Cliy and tin hi ey. Wg ps ‘ass in oem eee os ido "poo br snoring tangy of he tion a Uae. Monon hee ange ees te Shemp! eens fr sey argument ts} ell owe neste never neo nas pe lng cr 4 "elon woe" pesos” oF “Sonor” ores the ft iat Both Arne nt Compas hve hd a ses an eile sexe dest ics ot oat te begin of hen verde tise developmen af Ansan ani Grin ey Aone hve ph Hower. the Gena ep a Fon ‘Sw pe ne epi ol ‘Gti pms oe kes noon on on exe or Ate imeaplele bom fase m Suwa song ry ‘nook hou a gun For yr th Su meee hotleshs path domo he “resign ne ooking fr a resigns tf the 3 cemy BC This ime wo hide Msp Mos Te sver of te Amaia plat wo Arm aon to erode ts nvening the Georian and Cauca An phates bam Georgina hse. Afr all theo ton that an Armenian tered the Gong sr is to reds the tion prestige ois sri Iman cathe eia of national ngage cet ade ayn Bh Ania and Googi auomaelly nas tur tothe ain graphical design of feat langue. The it tn ery dfeen nee whee tonal anges had to ‘tendon bith Octbes Reve a lsat by ‘Grom Gnsno’s cont of an teresting suo he observed ina Moscow marketlice te sumer o 1988. scion ta fc iat many i salsa by Cont Asians ado bela with abc septs, which meter shoes oe the Symbolic maistan of etic and atin als een ‘hoe tray of thigh” vale ofthe On in compan ‘vik Resinlngioge a elie Gusioy subse de ‘ert ts phenomenon mena tad pamo a ‘es dawing mm amloy to he ote chins af amputees tho fete putt extrenaty (Casey 198K 3839) However, gen the mtr of symbole orm a he sing otto sey, sicher ight oth ca genre 8 Fel, no spam, “extemity” (weit th cs, ‘Sok nt that Arabi fmt so mich anaes [atgugeo he Kon ano ae fades. Hence the Spread of shmie ot and relaed forms of piel fun Inaous wih he nao sas balding projets ofthe foxmer Se ‘et Cena Avian opin. OF eau prognetting the pata evolution of te orignaly Must fer Soviet reps, bt sing yg sho Ye mil, complex and ee ih Gen ep The Poth of Lane " etesive polis and cla power tha the coieatn of ‘inc ange een nal “ssh ved “api bas f isi” in 2 Moscow inane elects th seperate the Fecal of Sot mtn! poly dre he fs yea ote Sct rege. Dung the ca Soviet ori he ae reine ‘Coad sce tend ain tes thse fal es {poted ats an ton noi aking writen ft lhe hes uae pce sa coment he sosequen depen develope Ato! ngage se domi fee he Fontan tngnge Buby 1936, ths Cena Contes of he {Commune Py td eer ian iil the atin tomo thse nc pa By thee ofthe 1930, when Rs ‘Sn dominaon Deane thoes! wen tol in Image Bin amos ery spe of ra polis al aphabes fe et ea een aay ear ot Aneto of Cyc spa Thos the yes a he Moscow tte etn ne i hem ipa by tetra fhe Arabic of the Kora Snel of fone muerte set! city Fllonne he ae {oof our” ey ware tying xp fom he “om {ur pho Sins sty poly nox a of “ster ‘SI pa Malo rss a expec inert eas of he ae ‘ims nmente ton beech gt onto ety a thecharcter ofthe “ola se ofthe mae lone keds te ate fon » et Noon Meaty cul Aevaled a ent of upbeat” since Moldovan ution in 1917 nthe te 980 made the rina asp 2 Lan sip aan te ri ep tte omge = prinary lowest of tei varus taste fps eh atm pet Sony fies he eon Tye wi 5 fee ae endo fen conceal Samy: pr became spn ny be Iacono pc Fer nc, the sumer geotteamemstebee onan ne dca ofthe it fr Moan monof Moldovan to Romanian, hich psd fm the Cie he {ati alpen the T940> Bey Hs bios a Resin ‘vet, th etn ti Nolavan fo he Ltn alphabet sho mane the stone feling of "hse wo Laie Epo ang Mativan nao For tans, slogan fcmed on» pac at 1989 natal ly i Raney rad “Tezlie oa LatoLety” (Lieven SME 180. pa Incest are th a ht Cri he ib te Ol Coch Savon isin the eh enya sees the ‘nora ngage af the Ore ch he toa gon ff both Romanins and Molva. hus the rest Melon Sah ors atin spe! wey” i fact daly coats he eegion's tinal cas cay. For ti eso the Moldovan lez intially opposed the ovens alin a the ‘Mepon of «Lin alate (esc 1990157, 163), In Molin, thn, we ce» ety opt rea 10d in th Fame Conta Asan rps of th Soviet Unio, hte the Sear fora wie ent ba peat ph eats ‘Arabic the nlpet ofthe ego's wana lig ent ‘Conesed retina Rewoen ancient ser ad toe teogacs ays play a signin role ine omen th ie ies an tnt spent The ese ofthe mode [Asya e Ammons, atonal mn of sot i asd ‘cong tthe 989 css, presets an eesti cape Ih eee yeas, the nem crit of Ariens igh ih he Iemy language of the rasn-spaking Cian of te Near Est hs been sprit finch alpha for moc Spoken Asian fo kia ew-Syin). which uly ‘sified a new-Arunean dls othe Asem nga, ihe eazy Tangugs, known Sy, moe Chin thot works were writen expcily betwcen te Sand TF centuron the prod ofthe flowering st Syria Iie Later ews the ml lngags of te Nests ‘nd Jacobites at ag. Sorina ther sors In the 1980s the revival of his ews pried by sume mde ‘Assyrian fir proof of sr ancotAsgg nC ‘gn the incr othe Assyrian empire ofthe 2 lca 1), a hey had eid te canton a th dead spoken Iangge of ance Anjan nisingy the jy fx ni seine 19, The Path of Lavage 8 sn “ancient Asian” lngge an cate come fo he ong genraton o€ moder ne Assy These eunst Itech nt, droapeds movement eh heey Ihe bene ofthe rl lings, th" ancet Mt. “hus wes ht te weg 0 "le ngs els inom As wunin he nent Tower sich 2 ledge may lye the com, 0 rege olen pica’ ener. Thay he exes of A Insist poston presi, Levon Tessin {kd mguger war vccesy ted in 0 pole Tay ‘ypu nc te Ter Rein eas ilo by rotescon, wth see hades of mone [Mice mete langage Ol Sys Theopniton vied on {Terreousin’s ook and oo soy pena and is Itong eres in dead ngngs ox ses Oe Thi Fel ince sos! a th pps, onal ok of the cry Toms imate Ths ke espa Amen vey {hte cone onditon Cs tine in ems of te res kn oper to a Arson othe da nga he ‘Sy knew Several east, daring he presen elven Snpign of Tse pare wee hosted oypstn ena Sons rl he people nt eit he pei ‘omerian no dad enginge Sn be presen ns Aeron canal place, df is knows fen anes. ‘Sc oes shad gh on he Nem mechan at work in Lausanne FREAT EC aerate {ie Seis Sun) Accrington eal Saeco ee Zetathe develpmentl sary of iden contction. AS mat of fi the Mtr of many eases ae ety contin, Ineluing hws dca hw ann he Path of Anos ein dere a peeaogy of ee ans aa Jl, However the cel of os and paras "teeth ‘au sbut "the atheran” inthe swsrton ssh eats te easily oveooked in yr becease natn etl te ‘ty tole people wit sally ck a ses of hue: ects aout the Presale speaking dea ngage ing us hack othe problem ofthe Fst Man and hs ngue Hr we encour quintessence this "Pit Ma fn of sar sen pal igure ling oer ce an tine" Bt here we have sepped ont tbe Royal Pa, which we will Faw i ats. The imetion of the Armcian alphabet by Maso in 40S igure a Mert of talon of Treg ext Sct ‘Aon. Tha the cetry Beene hss he Gaien Age of ransanan AS esos, umber of ancient et st Have bot lst in the orginal agape Ness ves {5 iro peeing ine owe he SS Beceem seach eee oeioeerramtaaey Ram aasneragei acer Pair eager ay bh Tan mh opt, however, ty genet» pulmo ga ach i Banc rteima meet Ere ani eerie ta ras Phe Pah of Lame 8s sive only in Acmsnian tametions (For example, works by enn, si, Teen of Alani, varios nopatone om cares on Ass wor ao 0 foi). This “alton Ino deep an sing tee Arnica 0B {ral and the Arena lng in pret as, ech ‘iomed tote Tsao seed the cents the ‘Anmenion Church canonized Masts together with the «8 feos Sok Pfr (vo sees i to doth i Pifeam th) al ny falowers of Masa a elas Tow na ee oho Oe of em, the Sait Tans tes fetal, wich ors te vention of te ipa {Te ramon oft ble locket scalar fsa Ife tee "0 On he nie evel my els Hom fhe Gest ete nods ing the fin fe cet o ans Ton stv hve clgaes ent to fenton com temporary Arc. Same er sas and wasstars evn prc gor calc fo more dary ahd ss pestis” Mods The eas pics hich setulae othe {Gallen Age ot ston ae te nest popula ots se ‘Sy molcm pure hr ve to ret oe al pure Ate on The rst pele hs smog sto a Sr ob entonsionotnstion mi” ats ney ot fect arin mening pope word in he mote ong Ioeeveyhing he wot” nate in a svt Aor ek eng, te ward wef m esha te SETS tes thin tn eres Ee rr eetnaed eg aga rat esahteemcnae mina, SS pnt in Ai mre era a er Supe telat id pot War theagtnce nes aan ra“he English won inert (ing snatoly ‘xlanaion of mening strlen) copay sme am mays ce {ction an the wt" Corgan) hat wee intestine ng! tran sd frig Dros ings on oh tnge. This ayo es frm 3 improvise jxtpostos of e uno an ie esome, ‘kn amir eva he worden ns igh Ani id toward pean sesponds oe ‘cay in he eile of Armenian wor ad asia Zu al“ "poy te hh tells announcing tine: ote may seo eal suds ‘ered on the wats nay Amin chs. The vento ofthe Armen pet nt oly occasioned 4 metho eal of tsa, bt lose elo ag So bos Area ce Ptanyen 300 3239 ono the pinay esos ey te ater tomes on dh Kato ws al ono ir ad a on isimetmee ‘abet Ameanand Roane nnn The Ph of Langa " sity of nce unre Yerevan, wth wich we ‘Sime onan Patr of Moy, eames emp {er Riven, The Monon st ge mambo of Shand mest tn sae ye oma Cty ns acho only pono SGufops tm bean ppl mune fe bok rsa Feat Red Goya Upto epson yon fe SS ono tse tty bi ole eames esl porto woip fret Po Neem a mks wh wc rep 580" A {sien ange of mh acl we atic SMyseos epnton ina me that ee werk ie 3 ott scene fis at oe ep iy exe am Mtns te ayant sed Imire tase po, Ii hod TRed uae by cnn he loon ung ig 1 ‘Ses dag ea eat Aen end en boat pts nal ee rts very maa te he popule owan testers designed n he mi Tete tne ied ce envy of contin ‘Stok nl eee on, whch wa wl te. AS on treme me, "Boks ring ot ov wr the snc mae v common Wey ay netta goal dvs te gen eat vane Aonpeesey See Arcee Aneto cig ets inde mh mre casa, een veel Aen tle ‘Sun ks and cy cal gtr Tn ate Soir wth Aina. Ofcoase Ty ein ‘orca ot eo Avoca i ahi fo 0 Men sted cy dere ter eyo they bola wih mre ins "ete rt ied more nthe indian of he sn a tig ern he ses AESron leer catersnay scoot ough play al with thea figs an i tires prior olen the it. Min Armen ated ‘nth pcr sty te hs fom, eh hey a tempt day an ier he ch ening ofthe mat a Ps. Soe pret went 0 far as be tacos fo ech Iie tie he ther ona "ig" hg a Sole fg ts at fom hf yo ‘Psp the of the writen word wil rman a omepce of Armonia nails programe tis foseton oma with bei enomous exact ta the ie tin xe wondering the “infration ‘eokton o Are han soi Preset we te waesing the fab fora ont tad Amen sp by ethene the ancl Aiterenec omer eerste ova tol Innes “The Forking Path in dhe Ditton ine ath Reelion and Festa ‘condi w the bial sy the dvson ote inal ‘ue of haanhnd "ah guise woul sy. he eng She fat igs of e git wee ocd when God Stonpe the bung of i Toe f Bal by sadn ane {ming he lange o ts brs to may, mata pcre inuguger. There ve moment ie al gua xe ances, ch spe te en of this sy. amen when he oi ane col ity seo be repinel. Thoxe mene are pee Imes of ctu eta Inch ing Yan 9 Soca "eon ok le dre thems tonal ales, ssp by stan or mle A an he tt figs Ort ws dal samc [Ecko pe ses ering ths ac - ‘anh el sate ches el cen pepe ome esting the Eye fay he My {hiesealralemsybeconeottien Steg. mie hap nda fr Amen chs sn ‘The Pas of anne » hich a many rps soe aie estas as we will Tien te Pub of Rebelion wal Fewival Dsing hese" {Sts dopo pics of Armes Risin igus i ‘ly Senedrcoms other we i er Sean a Ssnbolic opestions tt dasa oral ines he cla Tinea en “The snomenyuifitianothis agate opposition reat ge oth fis yo the Fen” sigs, Se paige ma pe ch pa The coma Gina the fg ran ant poll comes of thse ere, ane mht ges tha he people steed ote squire woul expres may at & Ronnie pe hen tnthe miu of ally for Aronson the otc! of ie speaker's menage damned any dscnet, "A ‘Comal Commits sey alse you a wore ap he essa sping kar sid and He poke Armenian ANG Inti he my 1 3007" The speaker went on cana de rnp wend fis prodectivor a his owe eau sts Stitt Amen poops tng fr clr toon {Kode sand many hangs wi plese ihe ero, cven thu ei em in Rassian or ht smen sh eof Vr hn’ roman ssn of picasa in November 198, {fe empationbencen theo languages i et ans. Tht pooneet buck is everday ie and ations dcoure shee he sesen of peice am is coms athe Sarre fine conrovey ove fhe ae of Armenian and Ress langinge schol the ceston of Annenin cir. Feed the stagcia of any Arnis tad te spn {ng of Riss Hecht cami he programmatic ‘oy of rnin lnggs and nt in edt poly. Never fae nassonehing specie and precio ne Teta yd theo eva Arenas a ost sre thing that ade the athe hades ofthe Tower of Bate lot GoFIVE ‘THE PATH OF MUSIC ‘Phe Sensitive Ear of Musical Identity and the All-Devouring Rabi ‘The Path of Uneard Mse The mms pope sins or lays ca defies soe ting au poole ny an Men mst as Tne thet, Atm not sie hte iis pons to eos Stnlope tes acurly a inguic west ce te {gn a king pts fon ee yee we will ieee, mh nr edo oily ron, wel ‘toca graf toes sng te slope pat, ch fray psc noe angled ptr mie sm oe tore coma th fngage iy ness he a an ot cesar he mind so pape da nee tunes in Deter peri Ins fal mosis ese, mi i ch more pening an nist penn tha js oy ‘ne is eset nthe tn of ec yeh ver} “hy ian wor, wean he sal pire sal. Es tater ce it cast yond the orders we us ink of For example iby ically celese 09 aby thr ihe chi falls sep ely to hs song oF Far psog fey the miolgt an someties by Te pets) some welltnown folsom. Many S05 Deter ak poms such sya ori sons BNE trie ing com odin the pul te ae analogy “Et on he peng “eles "sine Pn G0) od pc pr oth sestest would form cho singing in unis. Why i thee ch Abin 7. ing aii ag Beko eae nee of the cape design (ie Macagan 1977: 323, L- Abela stably)" no won becomes 4" are = mae ure ail ie copes ee neo eae ‘ne breton hls fo eed vig st hae ‘Coa tbat ot cane wl ei ‘heoulon the at te ple wel ul hin ef ol Pre Patho Nasi os Atciansafea ndvidisc” a sr mae mad Ft pul may sve the “node” Anni a alyphonis" Georgian tio ete a ch aate ‘Ami pene Georgi Lewin sie sch raph fat spciiainos ets teeny at the avout ‘syiplypny eileen ee thet me! snes es ‘Renda coe oi Near Eastern rasan eit Co finn neighbors. Wil nah eae hey ae mich ost he nr se ll so fr exalt Path Train. Anat niing section aly cover the live gs af tephra pas. Which eho se toe sce? Or, mui queso saber pape {he ach ess fet fer» wn. sng en 0 Sh in the Se way? Anoterquion cou be wie he two aes wer nse. Was thre an aia polyponie Fath which fred fr some kaon enon ho my odie Put Or the cnt, he my ond a evenly Phe ae wil meet sa pojpnie pal? Ol do the Imogdic an polyphonic as ost ran pall an meet aie tly aly nr nes a esl ofthe tet wl a nse of maken park eng? Koma, who tor [Renclan mony im polyphonic me, can sete a 8s: ‘ton of hs po, ‘abe mono tc Ros tl hh eh Arne ‘emda an clo Aman ne psd "Xp on he bp of Gein pp, nee bie, tyes mac Aree toe pn to Cos ne ne esl to ny ‘for etme, the pps chr 9. . Hach were srl inn" ray nb wth ay eu imi were deo sae al ering eh quk = ‘Cam osc norton peeved the Engl nes afvey eure ai cy figures whose images fons a i trie carci of he ele gustan, Lna soe se figures spas the Fit Man hor wil et ain he Roya Path Bu while he King coal be “ate om eeu ‘ide sme waning show ei the soit, een butsider tus cl he of ead igus of kina, he ey tite peso isan” rom wii He is ses to any stature changes inthe sce) uta he sabe ine earl the chases O te pats als he ft fue Tne Konia (1869-193 great compose a eae. Sse a's bode serse dan jst the munca! Going Tick fo he afremenivosd momyptphons apps, ‘oul be sad tht Komi nba the best of he monic Sie lees only mention swig eromances reset 08 ‘phonograph an his slunings olton of song = ‘sl are, Komas deat withthe some poston bi tee dicised nthe cinoma omen he eet riot ream ms, tt be wos embodying a He op pston betes East and Wes An analyte af it id ‘rd fotki shows ht he als casting» dep p00 Sitio teen he pga vs”) the Chia ha “sident fm te geo a nk colleting an singing Fl {pou toe This st oppsition aa feed the p> ice pc th tip 20: ste fy fos wi hp sa vee Koa Tih Pat Dl: 24) ae fan lect ae may Hm cvs mls ni Ts dos nf ‘une tht be nh mt cle ch mle te Cheha etd of bestest st hs eso he ty ‘eeu cn th “dap Mis perl a A i hii ee pia The Pah of Moi ” poston of scars (i 9 tral han musi sews) ur flit, Th are se other, minor spostons endo edn tis fey Tigres which ars nt 9 itt Gen oe tctlralpangrte bt cst tht Komi ey Fg since be eens to enol the posible senate op ‘sos that make ap Arnie Oe sich oposite insimane ” Konan spn! te st 20 yeaah ie in itl hosp in Pati res of his ate epic Tots the st as ofthe Geese No wonder Kota be ‘amt een enema Armenian cle: Ding thse ong yest class, Koes kept ses sadn ae ‘pronto, of spenkingtring eh othe It of oppositions ‘hoe by bs dramatic He Th seemingly ion op Poston gies a len che oh theme aes Cpa Tip ma) the tpi af the Gonside ef the te f Pao Sra pr nr gon caning neve Ble yl “neveraned i Armonia, wih ling 1h tn ete heaped spe” a he bell ad Ken ens Compare so the possible opposton of angi Wal pic pagans. Te st opostion gies 9 ther ‘luc tos sctesing onemenon fom he sen one ean Hi The poi of Konins x symbol of Amos ei sy toe in Yerevan whe the mtn weld gery peer tase bis mae rahe thn Koma’ works But ot ‘ean wt rie means ortporaty Amenin eae, ‘te snl examin hs plese he deep espe 33 gos eyo the masse fo embrace much fader ‘bison umenizaton (ihe ong of he ast ona ed "he ther src psn th fa elon Ania ‘Tefen scot by me Pion, or ‘dt sao a ne one msn tonein” othe inti) of the word Ras, te ony the altansion peso egsniain of ae wars ator ri sins Kasia ere he Seve Union the ey 102s whi Howat togtr brn range of era Workers (musics, arts peor, ee) bere tae in fell won, sate hen nd reine aon, ‘Whoa in Rossin this wr ie shar ony ete sets —the poet fitness ie nh preset ont Aronia the fate Rats was gui He the word ove us tenacious Piro the tes, Rabi ‘ncn! he epi de unig cmt, ot cre ar he ts whcn one of hoses of te abi tne Ben of OF thos sans (HOM) came ier the aos he i ‘et rigt down ur i, he muscle king phe BOM “eatin to comer thomactve mbt ofthe Rab sn rctonetwen the two tga sce Abra ‘na Pasco 199018). "A ipatan aetion oH Rs an he oly a es soccer he BOM es To povie the publ eh rary ‘sea serves, nlding ftv seb an solemn oe sions. Att bth te mise tl stints er ely Shona the afvemestinad sar (gst mp soming ‘shoe the da oes sil abe ring es) aes the wads: do double-sided = ‘zor (drm smong the pression, the Iammeo he Sige bowel ile or” amgaceked.nger place Samet wit double sontr) Kanon 0 Kn of athe) tino he strings. The pris cy othe Arian Rd ct Te allan cranzaion ha! gave bith to a pve athe ‘icy Tom the scene of Soviet carl Hk “Tol, ew kno af the exes f the BOM ip Yen may do ot even suspect the even ofthe fre i td foley epee Rate, Bt sna everyone knows the word "oh bic as an eid conan, The allawag isnt bistary oe mtamorpones ths word the teas an the hte, he Ras The th bs osc pfoming Aetna at Orel sie” api le td rx by te mebep Phe Path of Masi » But stating in ete hie nd fo: Baan eae fr fore pesto sc cscs nt pire socks dt tre ree sine, banging abt a las wong That musa mothe Rab Hs oh hese ne chs ator staf mn ele that en pres Sry sid ait ord stihl vow Beant Hk to pc tr ma phere, The mew sia se bog toby tse musi fon tbs Ann hab after ub oramieatn tat une he perfor ofthis se, Once fhving pec he ols cure ad even he Fecha abd offi stn, the saga ne oe {Shot of nin me hry Bt Gh cle eros i ut wr al tana a {Sheva presage changes inn ale Only with pect wo ti te iis an eth, uy One akan nepede ral se ‘Pee eter wo min roupigs wor ome the Rabi ne seciang tn 8 you fee a peo fans wedng, angers he her specail ‘rove wl pig at ona ney he sane musa {BM ya both wedngs aa icra This rele fo {ins New Ons inert rs proceso whch fred Ino joyos mana puns on hr wy ck eompanson 1 Re wed m aipomeo Wud be ped oa ht he word ois atone the poplin tage war cone wih the to te oper ta signed special metal sine Thre hewn inal meted wee payed xe ae ado mame ” The ungcrs nd pvr ofthe pew abi yk, ane who wat oustanding ian asin, woul tc at cus to te ie of he dpa andthe ease of hee {cn and en ta oesion fr teat fr sch pea even) ‘nln cet ne sg. These Sons ey {De he Levan iis oh an wena hi {es tect str sanyo “Rope Comme 9A ‘Nora Ament thew arin anna, "The Calle of ‘en ncn Lene Gr ee ee100, ARMENIAN IDENTITY INA CHANGING WORLD die tel md spay cane ‘on tamer sen Blas ene ai emer mie ma wos ne ‘sy nya econ carp Te ge of ae bo af ot a tengo ad ka One ny inline oman abt ged mse oraen thm sical min mse del po iets tt pmo one ecole tr Se he muliy we wey din eileen pat heh aye Sines wom af cuca ne Hla sat coe tov gn Reh talon thn lao tear hb mae peo fy ica ace hah Amc es swe hanced ym Ari in ed thecal ime on tt paar rl mas fa cote et as nia ce tac a nye oe ot paeno hcsed fetes gl oS of rece Tina wc up imc anos a Ploy sng Ors eas Ss oe ot {Dhyne mn gate nap sell et teers eet hr fii ‘Sm ics pny on wo gt fom mun hw fog ase ter the Geno of 113 "The nd” ae was pope the wntng cates of omen wee nes oa soon te 1D Th he "Nn ten mun ges he Ane mis, wc abo depen i nnn sa Tia oe Uebel Tp {Popa Artal mg inn ‘fre deb tet ofan Phin 92 ‘tt Asal ol cay eens Ray os fms pct te enya, he Bf Sta Renbaierby dite Waka wm The Path of Mie m1 lar rina inte rv ars todeig Azebajn,tn ‘Bema pt te a wi rn hr ins Charl ie Acre ghana reo popu, many (het ars wow salto have elle hero das Ue ‘potest piste wp the Baka rn progans: Dang Baht boner thy hr to" ts a ca sie is ‘leas paper or aes es aided poli SSoowet The "Tso pron mos fc de ‘liver clea the progam a foray an nes th Fefeamee bg wh the sand few ins of se known Rostan sng (sual boo othe psn fl ie ah ih a at Ain hse efor of rs in Diy te “Sound ens dete ape nan he ai ‘in bu oa eres" fa ort ech ‘hy oft perme. hat ats or pot eet he wo ri ray come fn ely 2s iba as re hing panne epescna and osumer of 2 ete same tote win evan he person os Suc in tens of ob, tts, cig, weal, and 80 Tea and invtly ith cot tie of om. Those a tne te a lure woul be desrbd peas ‘iesie vai shes dang ae deh wl even wing at For Ss hcg ebioays woud be pen by some Gh expres ann fesiagsThe ais tamsers of TAS preco el tects a sch ony ms ‘Sn leony and piss Sng heels i {Eom Atl tava Plenty may ote mss ae Jfauiel inno unestnding ant eto fence a the ne ‘ie ogent he word as talon pari sy om tcmscves wah he uss a the lps keen eal mca mien ‘ibe spines of idem proesonal roi ake ay ew Marlow a nc se stn, wt which i mes ometon tll ere Pence hat al mi exis ena i yn immo ‘Se Seeing twit opposes they eres ‘hm ew imi Thus apse 1 te lion, in pl ht sen widely popolrisd n the 1 ae102 ARMENIAN IDENTITY INA CHANGING WORLD 1, new varity f als apne tht may Be clad ike loi: Ara mater of fc rah nme wes every new ‘in whtever gece with spew song even mw apee Inedicton a oc or ants pet fs One sch ad ston ht played crac oe te sory at wa the tsi arangeten of abi ath zap sode This ws Ist doe beso mss th coneraory ei tine bat wsaccss aces arose, wi ee Plaine forthe ate conser ay Yo make ig, Actas {hey dese as and ws tr oso kil ie ie “ow” gem, which hey were dome Yo prt. The appa. ance ofthe new (pe of maisgnn Hh esis feet he “hinge in the Salo pesieanen soe he soc soyp the rbe Ths cw trond ata pe a more vise foun, oe that so fg less event ora iis, > tne sno betes of asl rab Many ofthe sine ah (refing tbe soc aspect oie te) who sly Tse wo maser ute vei th cole as afer tea one cnet of ate ou eae bis isi. AP ater of fat tr the population t pe ss He, ‘Sringeri bane he al "abl sv he "ie daar his “svi fom. This happened tiny tog ai eorigs, 9 ‘hraagh mis fom Armin we foe oe emigre a ‘dasorncomemnies inthe 19 70e Nowadnyy ih 80 many ‘Armenians om Ai (he so lle Hav sete {he USA, one can sn ft the eal rah people song them Isr ofthe athena cate eerily ais as tp expo isi nthe disp oul he cc sr the conor anything natn ing peso a sted ht mich moet han in Are Howe the Seaistance wih ad one he Oita mayan mise ‘spore Arnis ving in oan fom Ort cue * ye wan omg tn dingy of por Ame- sm le i Sats we ‘ary of theo tons anal aca il ms

You might also like

• The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: A Counterintuitive Approach to Living a Good Life

  

  From Everand

  The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: A Counterintuitive Approach to Living a Good Life

  Mark Manson

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (5794)
• The Gifts of Imperfection: Let Go of Who You Think You're Supposed to Be and Embrace Who You Are

  

  From Everand

  The Gifts of Imperfection: Let Go of Who You Think You're Supposed to Be and Embrace Who You Are

  Brene Brown

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1090)
• Never Split the Difference: Negotiating As If Your Life Depended On It

  

  From Everand

  Never Split the Difference: Negotiating As If Your Life Depended On It

  Chris Voss

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (838)
• • Magazines
  • Podcasts
  • Sheet music
• Principles: Life and Work

  

  From Everand

  Principles: Life and Work

  Ray Dalio

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (599)
• The Glass Castle: A Memoir

  

  From Everand

  The Glass Castle: A Memoir

  Jeannette Walls

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (1712)
• Sing, Unburied, Sing: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  Sing, Unburied, Sing: A Novel

  Jesmyn Ward

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1103)
• Hidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space Race

  

  From Everand

  Hidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space Race

  Margot Lee Shetterly

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (895)
• Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance

  

  From Everand

  Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance

  Angela Duckworth

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (588)
• Shoe Dog: A Memoir by the Creator of Nike

  

  From Everand

  Shoe Dog: A Memoir by the Creator of Nike

  Phil Knight

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (537)
• The Perks of Being a Wallflower

  

  From Everand

  The Perks of Being a Wallflower

  Stephen Chbosky

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (2100)
• The Hard Thing About Hard Things: Building a Business When There Are No Easy Answers

  

  From Everand

  The Hard Thing About Hard Things: Building a Business When There Are No Easy Answers

  Ben Horowitz

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (344)
• Elon Musk: Tesla, SpaceX, and the Quest for a Fantastic Future

  

  From Everand

  Elon Musk: Tesla, SpaceX, and the Quest for a Fantastic Future

  Ashlee Vance

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (474)
• Bad Feminist: Essays

  

  From Everand

  Bad Feminist: Essays

  Roxane Gay

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1015)
• The Outsider: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  The Outsider: A Novel

  Stephen King

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1839)
• Her Body and Other Parties: Stories

  

  From Everand

  Her Body and Other Parties: Stories

  Carmen Maria Machado

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (821)
• The Sympathizer: A Novel (Pulitzer Prize for Fiction)

  

  From Everand

  The Sympathizer: A Novel (Pulitzer Prize for Fiction)

  Viet Thanh Nguyen

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (120)
• The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer

  

  From Everand

  The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer

  Siddhartha Mukherjee

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (271)
• Angela's Ashes: A Memoir

  

  From Everand

  Angela's Ashes: A Memoir

  Frank McCourt

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (440)
• The Little Book of Hygge: Danish Secrets to Happy Living

  

  From Everand

  The Little Book of Hygge: Danish Secrets to Happy Living

  Meik Wiking

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (399)
• The World Is Flat 3.0: A Brief History of the Twenty-first Century

  

  From Everand

  The World Is Flat 3.0: A Brief History of the Twenty-first Century

  Thomas L. Friedman

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (2259)
• A Man Called Ove: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  A Man Called Ove: A Novel

  Fredrik Backman

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (4609)
• Brooklyn: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  Brooklyn: A Novel

  Colm Tóibín

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (1937)
• The Art of Racing in the Rain: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  The Art of Racing in the Rain: A Novel

  Garth Stein

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (4200)
• A Tree Grows in Brooklyn

  

  From Everand

  A Tree Grows in Brooklyn

  Betty Smith

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (1929)
• The Yellow House: A Memoir (2019 National Book Award Winner)

  

  From Everand

  The Yellow House: A Memoir (2019 National Book Award Winner)

  Sarah M. Broom

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (98)
• Steve Jobs

  

  From Everand

  Steve Jobs

  Walter Isaacson

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (806)
• Devil in the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New America

  

  From Everand

  Devil in the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New America

  Gilbert King

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (266)
• The Woman in Cabin 10

  

  From Everand

  The Woman in Cabin 10

  Ruth Ware

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (2322)
• Yes Please

  

  From Everand

  Yes Please

  Amy Poehler

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1891)
• A Heartbreaking Work Of Staggering Genius: A Memoir Based on a True Story

  

  From Everand

  A Heartbreaking Work Of Staggering Genius: A Memoir Based on a True Story

  Dave Eggers

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (231)
• Team of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln

  

  From Everand

  Team of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln

  Doris Kearns Goodwin

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (234)
• Fear: Trump in the White House

  

  From Everand

  Fear: Trump in the White House

  Bob Woodward

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (738)
• John Adams

  

  From Everand

  John Adams

  David McCullough

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (2409)
• Wolf Hall: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  Wolf Hall: A Novel

  Hilary Mantel

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (3811)
• On Fire: The (Burning) Case for a Green New Deal

  

  From Everand

  On Fire: The (Burning) Case for a Green New Deal

  Naomi Klein

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (73)
• The Light Between Oceans: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  The Light Between Oceans: A Novel

  M.L. Stedman

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (789)
• The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America

  

  From Everand

  The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America

  George Packer

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (45)
• Manhattan Beach: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  Manhattan Beach: A Novel

  Jennifer Egan

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (792)
• The Constant Gardener: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  The Constant Gardener: A Novel

  John le Carré

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (104)
• A Concise History of The Armenian People: From Ancient Times To The Present George A. Bournoutian

  

  Document517 pages

  A Concise History of The Armenian People: From Ancient Times To The Present George A. Bournoutian

  cognoscenti75

  100% (1)
• Rise of ISIS: A Threat We Can't Ignore

  

  From Everand

  Rise of ISIS: A Threat We Can't Ignore

  Jay Sekulow

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (137)
• Little Women

  

  From Everand

  Little Women

  Louisa May Alcott

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (104)
• Simple and Bias-Corrected Matching Estimators For Average Treatment Effects

  

  Document57 pages

  Simple and Bias-Corrected Matching Estimators For Average Treatment Effects

  cognoscenti75

  No ratings yet
• P937 Gaver PDF

  

  Document10 pages

  P937 Gaver PDF

  cognoscenti75

  No ratings yet
• Ggplot2 Cheatsheet

  

  Document2 pages

  Ggplot2 Cheatsheet

  wroin1

  No ratings yet
• What Is Data Science

  

  Document29 pages

  What Is Data Science

  cognoscenti75

  No ratings yet
• Ggplot2 Cheatsheet

  

  Document2 pages

  Ggplot2 Cheatsheet

  wroin1

  No ratings yet
• English Proficiency Economic Inquiry 2016

  

  Document21 pages

  English Proficiency Economic Inquiry 2016

  cognoscenti75

  No ratings yet