7 4 Talk twat
The Baling Talks in Perspective ;
: oo
Perhaps one useful way to approach an analysis on this topic is to
ascertain what each of the three main groups involved hoped to
achieve at the talks. Of course it should be made clear that from al]
accounts the underlying objective was not to discuss peace as such,
but rather to ascertain the position of each group in terms of the
necessary conditions to halt hostilities that might ultimately lead to
peace. Therefore, it is incorrect to raise the expectation that the talks
were aimed at achieving “peace”. Rather, the immediate task at hand
was merely to identify the maximum and minimum positions of the
respective groups involved and to work towards common ground if
possible. This, the talks failed to achieve.
Another important dimension in the analysis is to consider some
of the more important relevant background factors that contributed
towards the talks being initiated in the first place. This is particularly
important because the rapid change in events preceding the talks
effectively hastened the overall process and made it inevitable that the
different groups take stock of their respective positions in order to
agree on common preconditions to achieve peace. For purposes of
analysis it might be useful to take the year 1955, after the general
elections dramatically consolidated the power of the Tunku as the
leader of UMNO and the Alliance, as the cutting off point leading to
the organisation of the Baling Talks.
A starting point must surely be the emergence of Tunku Abdul
Rahman as the acknowledged leader of the Malay political party.
UMNO. Chin Peng acknowledged that the “Tunku had emerged all
powerful — (and that) there was (now) only one camp (among the
Malays) and the Tunku led it.”! Indeed there was considerable
nificance in this statement because it was tantamount to recog
that the Tunku was not a “running dog of colonialism” and that the
former was prepared to meet the Tunku despite the fact that the British
were still very much in political control. This made it possible for the
first time for a face-to-face meeting between the MCP and the leader