Professional Documents
Culture Documents
c2222 PDF
c2222 PDF
of Economic Research
Volume Title: Output, Input, and Productivity Measurement
Volume Author/Editor: The Conference on Research in Income and Wealth
Volume Publisher: Princeton University Press
Volume ISBN: 0-870-14181-3
Volume URL: http://www.nber.org/books/unkn61-1
Publication Date: 1961
Chapter Title: Data Available for the Measurement of Output per Man-Hour
Chapter Author: Leon Greenberg
Chapter URL: http://www.nber.org/chapters/c2222
Chapter pages in book: (p. 147 - 200)
Introduction
NOTE: This paper was prepared with the assistance of Robert T. Adams, Eva
Jacobs, and Jerome A. Mark of the Division of Productivity and Technological Developments of the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
available data by sectors. Part II presents a comprehensive compilation of the data available by industries. From these tabulations it is
hoped that.specific gaps may be readily ascertained. The tabulations
are not exhaustive since the study was limited to regularly published,
readily available sources. Sampling techniques and sampling errors
have not been evaluated. Also, since my primary purpose is to indicate weaknesses in the available data, the positive value of the existing
series is not discussed.
I Statistical Gaps, Report of the Joint Committee on the Economic Report, 1948;
Employment and Unemployment Statistics, Hearings before the Joint Committee on the
Economic Report, 1955; Economic Statistics, Hearings before the Joint Committee on
2 The National Accounts of the United States, Hearings before the Subcommittee on
Economic Statistics, October 2930, 1957.
147
DATA FOR ME
measures which have been most generally used are those which relate
output to man-hours, sometimes known as labor productivity.
Measures of aggregate output per man-hour fall into three general
categories. First, there are the physical productivity measures which
show changes in the labor time required to produce a fixed composite
of goods and services. These measure changes in technical efficiency
alone. Second, there are the gross productivity measures which take
into account shifts in the relative
of component sectors
Because of
current output series
measures.
Annual productio
Labor Statistics for i
for manufacturing
using quantity data
include industries w
consumed and
(adjusted for estimal
represent almost 30
tries included in 19
value added of its a
ties produced and s
There is no single
are used.
Gross productivity measures generally are derived by deflating pro-
1'
Ix PUTS
uireinents
Dut and input both
k n be expressed in
Output
AGGREGATE MEASURES
may record
requires different
:!technical efficiency
sectors
iwell as changes in
are the net output
to changes in
;hanges in material
the effect of
of corn-
weights
estimate includes the market value of all final goods and services.
Since intermediate products are excluded, the duplication inherent
in an aggregation of industry gross output is eliminated. The method
of approach consists of estimating the deflated value of final product
consumption. However, departures in certain sectors are necessary
because cutrent expenditures data or appropriate deflators are lack-
latter should be
tput in question.
pproximations of
deflators.
George Jaszi, "The Statistical Foundations of the Gross National Product," Review
1956. See also National Economic Accounts of the U.S.,
149
Since the GNP estimates are derived from the product side without
weights because net output data are not available. However, for
It is difficult
because they are attributable to such varied factors as lack of homogeneity of product or service, lack of over-all control totals, a diver-
smaller units. For example, a sector physical production index cannot be constructed without first creating indexes for the component
available for major crop and livestock activities for total United
States, by geographic regions, and by states. Thus, measures of gross
output on almost any conceivable basis are possible. Information is
similarly available for gross farm income and expenditures and net
farm income. Price indexes are available for deflating both gross
income and expenditures and, therefore, for deriving net output. The
estimates of gross and net income, like the production estimates, are
Jack Alterman and Eva Jacobs, "Estimates of Real Product in the United States by
Industrial Sector, 194755," and Almarin Phillips, "A Review of Three Estimates of
Industry Output," this volume.
150
DATA FOR M
generally derived fi
census every five ye
possible.
Mining. Coverage 1
in four-digit industr
Industries on the q
ments, minerals rec
energy, and value a
For intercensal y
modity Canvasses a
of Mines. Data fron
of production and1
made). These data
although for major
The statistics are cc
fore, less than bern
Minerals Yearbook
mining occurring iii
in the case of total i
industries, a much
partial data on mm
The Accident A
modified four-digit:
natural gas. This se
Bureau of Mines. T
available,
Manufacturing. Tab
to which quantity c
Percentage of Total 0
Coverage
Total
Per cent
75100
5074
2549
0_242
;D INPUTS
if output definition.
quality of the data
:h is presented sepadata collected from
eel out.
of output data
measures of gross
sible. Information is
and net
both gross
'ving net output. The
estimates, are
in
of Three Estimates of
possible.
fore, less than benchmark only in that they may be tested against
Census data periodically. A reconciliation between Census and
Minerals Yearbook data is difficult because of the large amount of
modified four-digit industry basis for all mining except petroleum and
natural gas. This series covers only crude ore produced, but is com-
Number of Industries
Percentage of Employment
Total
Per cent
446
100.0
171
59
46.9
75100
5074
2549
14.2
7.5
36
180
33.4
Manufactures.
151
r
DATA FOR Ml
data. For industries representing almost 30 per cent of total employment, no quantity data are available.
Except where there are problems of disclosure or extensive duplication in the figures, value data from the 1954 Census of Manufactures
are available for all industries. Although shipments are reported in
adjusting for the net change in inventories.
The 1954 Census also presents data on total materials consumed,
for all industries. For some industries a commodity breakdown is also
included, while for others, commodity data are available only if the
TABLE 2
Percentage of Total Materials Consumed Covered by Commodity Data, Manufacturing
Industries
Coverage
Number of Industries
Percentage of Employment
Total
Per cent
446
100.0
75100
5074
2549
43
64
87
TABLE 3
Number of Manufacturing Industries Covered by Less than Benchmark Quantity Data
Number of Industries
Monthly
Quarterly
Annually
83
Percentage of
65
41
the regulated
whole. Some of the
published because o
The remaining ii
private employmeni
services not covered
nonexistent, irreguh
tion of IRS gross re
31
than benchmark quantity data. The figures are not additive since
152
48
Time Period
Noncommodity Sect
18
17
17
250
coverage is availabli
about 59 per cent of
are available for les:
coverage is uncertai:
nonuniform time pe
In order to deffi
indexes. As a res
S
Business Indicators, F
b INPUTS
manufacturing
1overed by quantity
of total employ10 tai
extensive duplica-
of \Ianufaciures
are reported in
nay be derived by
consumed,
breakdown is also
only if the
e 2 presents ratios
Data, Manufacturing
10
in an industry,
industries repre-
'ent. no materials
Data
of
Value Added
data are available several ways for certain industries. However, some
coverage is available for about 100 four-digit industries representing
about 59 per cent of both value added and employment. Such data as
are available for less than annual periods have a limited value. The
coverage is uncertain and it is from widely different sources and for
nonuniform time periods.
Noncoininodity Sectors. The industries here can be grouped according
to the types of data available. First, there are the industries which are
included in the 1954 Census of Business, namely, wholesale and retail
trade and service. The Censuses of Business provide benchmarks for
sales or receipts of these industries, which constituted more than one-
the agency's purposes. Such data might help to fill gaps in the
statistical measures.
ting the annual output value of some of these industries but the
problem of securing adequate deflators and less-than-annual data
remains.
Price Indexes
In order to deflate gross or net value series, appropriate price
31
nd inventories are
S on a basis cornof value data are
vajiahility of less
ot additive since
indexes are needed. Several price series are compiled by the government but none are collected specifically for deriving real production
indexes. As a result, problems of classification, reconciliation,
5
Business
153
weights, etc., arise when the existing price data are adapted to this
overcome. For example, it is generally impossible to express in commodity specifications all of the changing qualitative aspects of the
goods priced. To the extent that price indexes fail to allow for improvemerits in quality they are overstated and, if used for deflation,
data is the BLS Wholesale Price Index. While this series is perhaps the
154
DATA FOR
modities.
research
This anal3
resources, I
in the
crepancies
noted.
During 1953, to 1
input-output prOjec
indexes into indust
classification
and a
A tabulation was
component comm
of tota
combined index. I
proportion
industry i
D INPUTS
e to express in corn-
value of shipments
prices above the published levels with the result that the index is
understated. When supplies are plentiful, the index may be overstated because of the prevalence of discounts. When either of these
conditions is widespread and the differentials are measurable, some
correction is generally applied. However, since there is usually a lag
o be considered to
t definition. Ratios
crepancies noted.
y group or industry
i given index, since
[ted weights should
Li commodities and
the price of copper
yellow brass sheets
built," and
tools, airit WPI system, the
'c power group is
edient for any but
a method
tiveness in the BLS sample were responsible for many of the disINDUSTRY PRICE INDEXES
During 1953, to meet the needs of the appraisal phase of the 1947
input-output project, the BLS began arranging the WPI commodity
indexes into industry price indexes. The procedure involved coding
each WPI commodity with its corresponding Census commodity
classification and assigning its weight to the producing industries.
These industry indexes are limited in that only the primary products of each industry are included. Also, weights are available only
for the Census year, so that the indexes are base year weighted. When
155
TABLE 4
Percentage of Total Shipments Covered by Direct Pricing, Manufacturing Industries,
1947
Number of Industries
Total
Per cent
446
100
110
72
57
207
29
75100
5074
2549
0_242
19
17
35
DATA FOR MI
discount houses or
mediately reflected i
an upward bias.
services, no price da
put is shared by
monthly.
The BLS employi
Employment. Primai
Surveys of the Cens
the Bureau of Labor
D INPUTS
mediately reflected in the index. Over the short-run this may lead to
an upward bias.
discount houses or other low mark-up retail outlets are not imUNCOVERED AREAS
Industries,
e of Value Added
100
29
.,
19
17
35
services, no price data are available. For those industries whose output is shared by business and households, such as telephone, telegraph, gas and electric, and laundry services, where a CPI is available
it has been used to represent the price movement of the entire output
of the industry.
e added.
is expected in those
hoes could occur in
6ation between the
TOTAL NONFARM
ibed as measuring
ar1d services cus-
-worker families."
eases but there has
nerits of goods and
living in rural
pa1 consumption
Department of
Lchieve a broader
commodities
cut-off point is set separately for each industry and the criteria for its
determination are that the sample should "represent a substantial proportion of total employment in an industry" as well as "provide an
DATA FOR M
tures provides a c
fluctuate seasonally.
than of a bias in ei
The administrati
and the Social Seci
the difference between the CPS and BLS monthly estimates will
The ARLF estimates are based upon a labor force concept and
include all persons aged fourteen or more, including paid industry
tics. The BLS estimates refer only to paid industry employees. The
ARLF estimates include "persons with a job but not at work" beother voluntary reasons. The BLS estimates include only those absent
workers who are paid for their time off.
A complete reconciliation between the two series has never been
effected. The small discrepancy which remains after taking account of
all known differences could come from errors in the population and
benchmark estimates against which the respective sample estimates
are checked, or from errors in enumeration or reporting.
Another source of employment data is the Commerce Department.
The National Income Division of the Office of Business Economics
publishes three employment series: (1) "Average Number of Fulland Part-time Employees," (2) "Number of Full-time Equivalent
Employees" (two half-time employees equaling one full-time employee), and (3) "Number of Persons Engaged in Production." These
estimates are conceptually consistent with the national income and
GNP estimates. They are based almost entirely on secondary sources,
158
Table 5 provides
and their charactei
data on average w
hours paid for
sick leave, and ov
employment samp
report man-hours
The CPS estima
difference between
statistical discrepa:
INPUTS
industries, special
eli as "provide an
are understated.7
ks during the year,
thly estimates will
domes-
Number of Full-
Equivalent
bne full-time emThese
income and
jecondary sources,
of proprietors,
"persons
years from the
al years, from an
Joint Committee on
difference between this series and the BLS but it may be obscured by
statistical discrepancies. The CPS hours are obtained from the same
sample as the employment figures but since they are limited to time
spent on the job, coverage is more restricted. The Census and Annual
Survey of Manufactures provides data on man-hours for production
workers in all four-digit manufacturing industries. This series covers
all hours paid for (including overtime) providing the employee is at
the plant. Except for work stoppages, this concept approximates that
of the CPS.
Since the BLS collects only the hours of production and nonsupervisory employees, any estimate of total hours for an industry must
tained. Since the CPS average hours reflect only employees actually at
159
DATA FOR M
Item
BLS
Annual Survey
and Census of
Manufactures
CPS
U.1.
BOASI
Concept
Jobs
Jobs
Persons
Jobs
Jobs
Reporting
unit
Establishment
Establishment
Household
Firm
Firma
Coverage
All paid
All paid
Persons over
14, includ-
All paid
All paid
persons
persons
persons
persons
Administrative report
First Quarter
All firms
ing unpaid
Type of
Mail survey
Mail survey
Personal
Monthly
Annuallyb
Monthly
Administrative report
Quarterly
Modthed cut
off
Probability
Probability
All firms
sample
sample
survey
Reporting
period
Type of
sample
interview
Survey
period
Pay period
Week ending
Week includending nearest
15th of Mar.,
ing 12th of
15th of month May, Aug.,
month
Nov.'
Level of
SIC
aggrega-
3-digit
SIC
4-digit
Week ending
Week ending
nearest the
nearest 15th
15th of
of every
March
month
SSB
3_digite
SSB
ion
available for about 191 four-digit industries which account for 68 per
cent of total manufacturing employment but the employment estimates are generally available only on a three-digit level.
Farm. Securing a satisfactory measure of labor input for the farm
sector is uniquely difficult. The farm house is both the living quarters
and the place of employment of the farm family. Over two-thirds of
the farm work force consists of proprietors and unpaid family workers
160
not be determined
measures of emplo3
tive judgment. In s
ployment in othel
allocation of work
Employment. Data
and the
ture. Employment
under the title Far,
The CPS estimat
as the nonfarm esti:
it is based on pers
households, and th
The ARS estimate
sample of 20,000
plete calendar weel
excludes those un
The number ol
"Farm Employmet
INPUTS
BOASI
Jobs
jn
Firma
Ipaid
Al] paid
persons
rinistra.
Administralive report
report
trteriv
mis
ending
iarest
I every
bnth
First Quarter
isis.
measures of employment and man-hours reflect considerable subjective judgment. In some cases, consistency with the definition of employment in other sectors becomes an important criterion for
allocation of work time.
Employment. Data are available from the Census Population Survey
and the Agricultural Research Service of the Department of Agriculture. Employment data from the latter source are published monthly
under the title Farm Labor.
The CPS estimate of farm employment has the same characteristics
as the nonfarm estimate included in its reports on the labor force, i.e.,
least one hour of the survey week on farm work. Unpaid family
All firms
workers are included only if they spend at least fifteen hours on farm
Week ending
nearest the
15th of
March
3_digite
SSB
'B
who alternate between farm and household chores. Records are not
generally available to furnish a basis for separation. Therefore, the
time spent on farm work by the major portion of the work force can
have occurred
for 68 per
esti-
living quarters
two-thirds of
family workers
nearly one million during certain seasons. If the workday were eight
hours, eight million hours could thus be lost from the estimate in a
single day. Multiple job holders also present greater difficulties in the
8"Farm Employment," unpublished memorandum, Bureau of the Census, 1951.
161
farm sector than the nonfarm sector largely because of their relatively
greater number. The number of persons holding jobs on farms, but
who work most of their hours in other industries, fluctuates between
one-half and one million persons at different times of the year. The
farm hours of these workers are classified in the nonfarm sector while
the hours farm workers spend in secondary employment are credited
to the farm sector. Data are not available for a statistical determination of the net effect of multiple job holding on total farm man-hours.
In order.to develop estimates of total man-hours in the farm sector,
the USDA has derived a "man-hour requirements" series. It is
derived from benchmark estimates of the number of hours of direct
labor required by an average adult male worker to cultivate an acre
or produce a unit of livestock or livestock 'products. The benchmark
estimates are from farm management studies, and are made for crop
and livestock activities by separate areas within states. Total direct
man-hours required are derived as the product of average requirements times the number of acres of crop or units of livestock. The
hours of indirect labor are separately estimated and added. The
estimates are summarized for states, regions, and the total economy.
For nonbenchmark years, the estimates are derived from changes in
acreage or livestock units modified to take into account changes in
yield and changes in methods of production. The series is thus independent of employment estimates. It is essentially an adaptation of
the standard labor unit procedure of cost accounting, although less
precise.
It has been said that the taking account of the impact of technological change and yield between benchmark years builds into the
series a predetermined productivity estimate. This is not true for
benchmark years, and to the extent that the series is adjusted to
benchmark levels the influence of such "circularity" is minimized
over the long run.
DATA FOR
of establishments t
with different purp
account for a large
and BLS employme
and employment da
One of the basic
hour data is the
of classification. 0
total shipments or
industry wherever t
hours employed in
products in estabk
The following diag
Primary
Secondai
Physical output d
while man-hours a
Because of this
primary to an mdi.
be possible to adj'
require an extensu
other problems. F
is generally produ
production in an i
output.9
Where the defi
industry measure
value data are on
primary products
Another diffici
reported on a co
establishment
one industry or ir
Employees in
9 This is discussed
ratios are provided.
D INPUTS
use
of their relatively
er of hours of direct
to cultivate an acre
.icts. The benchmark
d are made for crop
eries is adjusted to
trity" is minimized
lan-Hours
d. the classification
the same. Despite
-m sYstem of classiand the assignment
AHj
Given
Industry
Primary Products
Secondary Products
Other
Industries
one industry or major sector, the two measures may not correspond.
Employees in central offices and auxiliaries who service, all the
9 This is discussed further in Part II, where the appropriate product specialization
ratios are provided.
1 63
-a
domestic investment.
A similar problem occurs in industries in which establishments customarily perform their own construction work. The output measures
Certain recommeri
For benchmark y
be collected for mo
purchased services
income tax returns
were collected in th
improving net outp
On the subject
consumer price in
additional segmen
additional retail
latter, prices
prices currently ol
collected for categ
ness services and
government.
D LNPUTS
istrators, purchasing
air and maintenance
inconsistent.
treatment of expenwhich represent a
vity. The results of
intangible. When a
associated research
sset. When research
mt. As a result, the
itput measures, On
rient employees are
in over-all produc-
n-hours. However,
information,
identifiable.
ate expenditure for
t of gross private
cus-
e output measures
s Construction but
are included
is not possible to
ies are affected by
ly troublesome in
e amount of such
in industry which
her problem. The
de military items,
ded in man-hour
\:ard bias in proing. This applies
Recommendations
Certain recommendations concerning steps that may be taken to
improve the collection of data follow from the preceding review.
With regard to output data, it is suggested that censuses be taken at
regular and predictable intervals. Not only does this source provide
puted from the Wholesale Price Index and, with respect to the
Industry Data
This section summarizes for each industry the sources and extent
of the data available for deriving production and productivity indexes. Included, is information on output quantities and values, and
employment and man-hours. Price data, usable with value data to
yield gross output measures, are noted, along with materials consumed data which constitute a vital element in the construction of net
output measures. The information was prepared in the finest industry
levels practical, generally in terms of the Standard Industrial Classification (SIC). Measures of the relative importance of each industry
are provided to aid students in assessing the significance of data gaps.
manufacturing, and
lyzed separately.
services is presented i
ing sectors is given n;
difficulty of ascertain
of defining and
Coi
Table 6 provides in
complete census of it
a sample page of th
complete table, with
interest to the
the specific industrie
request to the autho:
The availability ol
ratios which relate ti
which quantity data
ratios should relate 1
the movement of a
examined in conjun
indication of the
obtained.
D iNPUTS
it is suggested that
el. for employment
the transportation,
worked conpilected (a program
inderwav). Hours of
b the hours of force
represent a sig-
on farms by
lye methodological
1 done to solve the
ire, because of lack
the products. quansuch instances it
measurement, for
manufacturing, and the noncommodity producing sectors are analyzed separately. The information for manufacturing, mining, and
services is presented in tabular form. The information for the remaining sectors is given narrative form because the variety of sources, the
difficulty of ascertaining coverage ratios, and/or the alternative ways
of defining and measuring output, made tabulation impractical.
by the use of
ion, and obtaining
puld be a guide to
Appraisal
plant level studies.
factor.
value data to
materials con-
within the industry. As an indication of the significance of these imp utations, data are provided for each industry showing the importance of
primary products in relation to total shipments (specialization ratio),
a Census
Data for other
of net
the finest industry
Industrial Classie of each industry
eys or extrapolae.
which there is quantity data to the total value of industry shipments. However, since quantity data are available only on the
mining, and
TABLE 6
Productivity Data for Manufacturing Industries
INDUSTRY CODE
QUANTITY DATA
RELATIVE
IMPORTANCE
Benchmark Periods
VALUE
DATA
Nonbenchmark
Periods
MATERIALS
CONSUMED
PR
Per cent of
Primary Products
Coverage
Form of
Per cent
2-
3-
4-
(1)
(2)
(3)
201
2-
3-4-
(4)
(5)
(6)
8.7
100.0
14.4
84
98
Digit Digit
1947 1954
1954 Only
2011
2013
2.5
96
2015
1.5
97
202
16.8
92
1.0
.7
1.3
2025
2.5
.4
.71
100.0
96
44
2024
2026
2027
10.3 I
2031
9.7
.5
203
2032
.1
93
88
Special- Industry
ization Coverage
(9)
96
87
28
97
74
83
77
74
82
93
90
82
68
70
56
94
82
94
96
97
94
91
94
97
75
95
84
83
99
88
6.2
.4
2035
2036
2037
Li
.3
1.1
9.1
89
2041
2.4
4.4
85
95
97
98
94
95
77
99
71
80
100
45
96
96
100
98
97
99
93
2042
2043
2044
2045
205
2051
2052
1.3
.3
.8
14.8
11.7
3.0
Coverage
(10)
(11)
Per cent of
Commodity
Form
Available Coverage
(12)
90
95
80
86
79
94
88
168
(13)
71
90
80
86
S
S
79
P,M
P,M
s
88
73
S
60
76
81
P,A
100
2033
2034
204
tion
86.1
23
20
Data and
Frequency Approxiof Publica- mate
P,M
98
99
2021
2022
2023
(7)
Sot
96.0
34
P,A
P,A
P,A
P,A
P
P
76
35
P
P
P
10
34
54
76
84
90
88
47
92
46
5
5
58
54
(1
I.
INPUTS
bATA
Nonbenchmark
Periods
VALUE
DATA
MATERIALS
CONSUMED
PRICE INDEXES
Source
Form of
Data and
Frequency Approxi-
fi
ge
of Publica- mate
tion
Coverage
(10)
(11)
Per cent of
Form
Commodity
Available Coverage
(13)
(12)
90
92
80
86
S
S
86.1
79
78
88
73
60
76
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
96.0
P,A
P,A
P,A
P,A
C,M
(14)
(15)
71
P,M
P.M
P,M
Per cent
Direct
Pricing
P
P
P
P
P
P
P
S
S
S
S
WPI
91
,,
,,
85
72
,,
,,
,,
,,
,,
99
99
97
96
67
,,
,,
,,
100
100
Relative Importance
35
3-4Digit
(16)
(17)
(18)
(19)
10.5
100.0
18.9
13.4
2.7
2.8
C,L,S
C,L,S
C
C
C
C,L
C,L
C,L,S
C,L
17.2
1.3
.8
.8
2.2
.4
.9
10.8
12.0
,,
10
34
54
76
88
70
47
92
46
.9
.1
7.3
.4
1.3
.7
1.3
71
81
,,
26
,,
57
,,
,,
,,
,,
,,
87
,,
41
6.6
L8
3.6
.7
.2
.3
71
82
28
17.7
58
S
59
Source
2-
34
76
Source
Digit
5
58
MANHOURS
EMPLOYMENT
169
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C,L
C,L
C,L,S
C
C
C
C
C
C,L
C,L
C,L,S
C
C,L
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C,L
C
C
C,L,S
C
C
C,L
C,L
system. Most of the differences between the two represent combinations at the
four-digit level (see the 1954 Census of Manufactures, Vol. II, Pts. 1 and 2, for details).
Col. 4: The ratio of national income originating in each two-digit industry to total
national income originating in manufacturing, as computed from Table 13 in the
Survey of Current Business, July 1957.
Cot. 5: The ratio of value added of each four-digit industry to the value added of the
corresponding two-digit industry, computed from data in the 1954 Census of Manufactures. Since national income data are not available below the two-digit level,
these ratios are used as an approximation thereto.
u.
Col. 6: The 1954 value of primary products, wherever made, for which quantity data are
available on a comparable basis in 1947 and 1954, divided by the 1954 value of ship-
ments for all primary products wherever made. The two-digit and three-digit totals
are weighted by value added.
Cot. 7: The value of primary products, wherever made, for which quantity data are
available in 1954, divided by the 1954 value of shipments for all primary products,
wherever made. This ratio indicates the amount of quantity data available in 1954
for those industries for which the benchmark ratio is less than 50 per cent.
Col. 8: Ratio of an industry's shipments of its primary products to its shipments of all
products.
Col. 9: Ratio of an industry's shipments of its primary products to the value of shipments of these products, wherever made.
Col. 10: Legend indicates form of data available and frequency of availability: pro-
duction (P), consumption (C), shipments (S), annually (A), quarterly (Q), monthly (M).
Data are from Facts for Industry and other sources, a complete list of which is available separately.
Cot. 11: Ratio of the value of products for which quantity data were currently available
to the total value of industry shipments as of 1947.
Cot. 12: Legend indicates that the data are available in the form of production (P) or
shipments (S), the latter requiring adjustment for inventory change to obtain production.
Col. 13: The proportion of the total value of materials consumed by each industry for
which some commodity distribution data are available. Computed from data in
Table 7, 1954 Census of Manufhctures, Vol. II, Industry Statistics. The base of the
ratio does not include fuels which are available for most industries. Contract services
are
also omitted.
Cot. 14: WPI is the Wholesale Price Index, CPI, the Consumer Price Index.
Col. 15: Ratio of the value of each industry's primary products, wherever made, which
are directly priced, to total in 1947. Asterisk indicates lack of comparability between
the 1947 and 1954 industry classifications,
Col. 16: Ratio of total employment in an industry to total employment in manufacturing.
Cot. 17: Ratio of employment in each four-digit industry to employment in the corresponding two-digit industry.
Cot. 18: Legend indicates that data are available from one or more of the following
sources: Census Bureau, Census of Manufactures (C), Bureau of Labor Statistics,
Employment and Earnings (L), Bureau of Employment Security, Employment and
.E
,,_,
(3
Wages (S).
Cot. 19: Legend indicates that data are available from the Census Bureau (C) and/or
the Bureau of Labor Statistics (L), in the same publications, as above.
coverage.
170
F
0'
cy
-"
0.
g
0.
Coverage
0'
Number of
Industries
24
72
0.
0-
212
213
214
203
3-Digit
Code
Quantitya
17
31
10
10
214
207
204
202
3-Digit
Code
33
12
4
17
32
49
102
Per Cent of
2-Digit Number of
Shipments Industries
213"
214"
21 2d
211"
203
207
208
209
3-Digit
Code
4
45
44
100
12
29
Materials
Consumed
Per Cent of
2Digit
Materials Consunied'
identifiable by
Coverage is defined as the value of materials
commodity divided by total materials, parts, containers, and
35
84
Number of
Value Added Industries
2-Digit
Per Cent of
Price"
Kind of Data
THREE-DIGIT INDUsTIUE5 WITH DATA COVERING Lass THAN 50 Pra CENT OF THE INDUSTRY
mark Project.
og
TABLE 7
Summary of Gaps in Data for Manufacturing Industries
oE
0-1
0.$D
21
SIC Cooa
Tobacco
20
H
0)
Food
NondurableS
Total Manufacturing
INDUSTRY
,-.
cL0Q
227
3-I)igit
Code
ES WITh
TABLE 7 (continued)
()1
21
265d
267
2
9
12
'I
235d
236d
237d
238d
233d
229
3-Digit
Quanlitya
Per Cent of
2-Digit
Number of
3-Digit
Prices'
Kind of Data
2-Digit
Per Cent of
Number of
Materials
3-Digit
Materials
Per Cent of
2-Digit
21
28
10
34
13
12
75
Consumed
Code
2211
222d
223d
226d
228
2-Digit
Maicrials
3-Digit
Per Cent of
IF INI)(1SIl(Y
Alaer,als
(21 NI
Numbcr of
Shipments Industries
2-Digit
Per Cent of
31
6
2
264
261
236
238
239
224
3-Digit
Code
Priceb
Aii:il ui
(conliniicl)
Per Cent of
2-Digit
Number of
Value Added Industries
INI)(iSl
THREE-DIGIT iNDUSTRIES WITH DATA COVERING LESS THAN 50 PER CENT OF THE INDUSTRY
Number of
Industries
Number of
SIC CODE
26
INDUSTRY
23
Apparel
SIC (onn
22
NI)( Silky
Textiles
I.
TAItI
28
Chemicals
5
22
9
2
274d
275d
276d
289
283d
287d
12
II
33
13
57
23
10
289
283
284
285"
286
282
281
274
278
279d
18
9
11
31
93
2-Digit
Materials
Consumed
286
289
3
14
281
277"
278"
279"
276"
273"
274d
275d
15
32
100
3-Digit
Code
18
Per Cent of
Materials Consumedc
Per Cent of
2-Digit
Number of
Shipments Industries
271d
272d
282
3-Digit
Code
Priceb
Kind of Data
34
15
78
279"
281"
282
278"
277"
53
2-Digit
Number of
Value Added Industries
Per Cent of
273d
3-Digit
Code
Quantitya
mark Project.
2
21
267
269
Is
265d
51
94
264
261
THREE-DIGIT INDUsTRIEs WITH DATA COVERING Less THAN 50 PER CENT OF THE INDUSTRY
Number of
Industries
7
TABLE 7 (continued)
27
26
SIC CODE
JMIlj)
INDUSTRY
Paper ajid
238t
239d
30
31
Rubber
Leather
3
Industries
Number of
314
319
312d
299
3:Digit
Code
Coverage
INDUSTRY
SIC CODE
316
317
309
299d
295
3-Digit
Code
14
45
6'
31 7d
31 9d
31
31 5d
31 3d
31 2d
3JJd
303)
3095
301
302
295
3-Digit
Code
It'!a(erja/s
Number of
3-Digit
2-Digit
Per Cent of
Number of
3-Digit
Priceb
Kind of Dab
2-Digit
Per Cent of
Number of
('rub
3-Digit
('nnsiirned
Per Cent of
2-Digit
Materials
Materials Consu,neat'
52
2
9
23
100
41
100
Per Cent of
2-Digit
Materials
Consumed
CENT OF II IL INI)USTRV
2-Digit
Number of
Shipments Industries
Per Cent of
IAN 50
THREE-DIGIT INDUSTRIES WITH DATA COVERING LESS THAN 50 PER CENT OF THE INDUSTRY
TABLE 7 (continued)
mark Project.
60
64
4
4
of Data
Price5
Ki,zd
I)ATA CkivnnlNu
2-Digit
Number of
Value Added Industries
Per Ccnt of
29
-SIC CODE
INJ)IJSTRY
TlIlEEDl(IT INI)USTKIES
FAI3LI3 7 (contirnied)
by I he
25
32
Furniture
319'
317d
3I9tI
315'
3I31
322
323
326
328d
329
259d
256
252d
253d
254d
241d
243
244
249
3-Digit
Code
Quan,i,ya
7
3
17
18
50
329
328d
322
326
256d
12
6
241d
244d
249d
251
3-Digit
Code
32
7
9
22
12
50
2-Digit
Number of
Value Added Industries
Per Cent of
Price b
Kind of Data
19
17
6
45
94
fl
26
2-Digit
Number of
Shipments Industries
Per Cent of
322
323
324d
325"
326"
327d
328d
329
321
252
253
254
256
259
3-Digit
Code
9
52
24
26
16
9
100
5
5
28
Per Cent of
2-Digit
Materials
Consumed
Materials Consumedc
THREE-DIGIT INDUSTRIES WITH DATA COVERING LESS TItAN 50 PER CENT OF THE INDUSTRY
Number of
Industries
48
TABLE 7 (continued)
24
SIC CODE
as
Lumber
Durables
INDUSTRY
hems
ilcli,,cd
of () ''
3I9
(Ii VItIC,I
is
Q N ''
.i rk I 'rojeci.
priced
35
INDUSTRY
SIC CODE
34
33
SIC CODE
Primary metals
INDUSTRY
92
16
4
14
29
14
77
7
13
19
Number of
2-Digit
Value Added Industries
TABLE 7 (continued)
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
351
349
346d
347d
342
344
333
339
3-Digit
Code
Per Cent of
Qua ntiIy2
Per Cent of
Priceb
Kind of Data
352
354
355d
356
357
358
359
351
342
344
347
348
349
336d
3-Digit
Code
Prices'
Number of
Industries
Quantity2
16
14
9
15
16
11
92
13
30
4
65
12
4
4
-'
Per Cent of
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
351
342
343
347
339
3-Digit
Code
,sf
Lflioit
Materials
Cent of
2-Digit
Materials
Per
12
21
8
15
11
14
100
11
25
10
12
2-Digit
Materials
Consumed
Per Cent of
OF TIlE INDUSTRY
2-Digit
Number of
Shipments Industries
Per Cent of
Materials Consu,nedc
Ki,zd of Data
TABLE 7 (continucd)
37
Transportation equipment
3
3794
373*1
mark Project.
51
2
43
4
(S
21
12
355
356
357
358
35,)
14
16
Is
:151
40
2
45
6
2
95
Per Cent of
2-Digit Number of
Shipments Industries
379*1
375
373
366
367
365d
362
364
361
Code
3-Digit
2
2
100
4
2
48
6
96
2-Digit
Materials
Consumed
PcrCentof
Materials C'cn,su,nedc
IS
II
353
Ii
351
16
11
365
366
354*1
362
363
366
369
363*1
87
Code
3-Digit
361
Code
Industries
Per Cent of
2-Digit
Number of
Value Added industries
Priceb
Kind of Data
361
3-Digit
Qt,antitya
Number of
4
357
358
359
35(',
3554
352
35'I
TIIREE-l)IGIT INDUSTRIES wrrii DATA COVERING LESS THAN 50 PER CENT OF TIlE
36
SIC CODE
Electrical machinery
INDUSTRY
TABLE 7 (continued)
357
ME)
FOR
DATA
other
periods
For
inventorie
shipments,
fr
available
are
hours
in
as
industries
same
est
survey
a
of
error
a)
mee
to
fail
otherwise
case:
Such
published.
CO
the
Moreover,
year.
CO
an
availability
The
a)
monthly
on
same
employment
BLS
the
di
is
situation
4)
The
4)
md
four-digit
Census
l(
columns
nonbench
quency
6, of
CO
Table
u,_
CO
C'.
000000000000
0'.
0'.
ooIc.l
'.0
'I-.
0'.
z U
a)
V0
'0 a'.
r'4
C'.
f-S
(N
00000000000000
C'.
00
00
'Cl
U-
a)
I-
an
crop
the
Only
CU
services
Agricultural
00
.0
quinqu
Output.
The
0 C)
for
data
(-
acreage,
include
V 4) V
mark
IUC
livestock.
of
'-'
number
0'.
"0
ye
For
intercensal
4)
CO
sources
of
variety
4)
z
I-.
118,
No.
Handbook
'0
reports,
statistical
O'.O'.O'.
00000000
I_\
data
The
a)
activity.10
U.,
against
checked
estimates
The
suses.
4)
00
.0
importance
the
on
an
areas,
states,
for
4)
marketings,
of th
output
net
farm
0"
00
C0 U
The
a)
and
dwellings,
farm
produ'
intermediate
0-
>
annually
by
the
Inc Ag
Farm
the
in
able
C2
Cover.
Agriculture.
accc
to
CO_
rearranged
4.)
V C)
4)
l_-C)
Statistical
Major
10
Cc..>:
a) I-
pp.
1011.
VC
Cz
CO
C)
AGRICULTURE
4
5.
5.
.5
4
_
activity.'0 The data are based upon sample estimates which are
checked against a number of other sources such as State Farm CenSUSeS. The estimates range from semi-monthly to annual, depending
on the importance of the commodity. They are generally available
for states, areas, and for the United States.
The net output of farms is defined as the sum of cash receipts from
farm marketings, the value of home consumption, the rental value of
products consumed. Data for these estimates are available in the Farm Income Situation published monthly and summarized
annually by the Agricultural Research Service of the Department of
Agriculture. Coverage is complete. The ARS estimates have been
pp.]0-11.
179
received by farmers and measured at the first point of sale out of the
farmer's hand. It covers fifty-two farm commodities which account
for more than 90 per cent of total farm output.
The Index of Prices Paid by Farmers (the "parity index") measures
the average change in the prices of a representative selection of com-
Prod
Industry Code
3-
2-
(1)
(3)
101
1011
1021
2-
Digit
103
1032
1033
1034
104
1042
1043
1044
method is used. Three hundred forty-four commodities were included in the revised index of 1953. In general, these commodities
account for at least one-half of the total expenditure for a major
commodity group, such as food and tobacco. Data are not available
to determine coverage as a per cent of total expenditure for all
105
106
1051
1062
1064
1063
1069
commodities.
Employment and Hours. The labor input data of farms is described in
detail in the first part of this report.
108
109
1081
1092
1093
1094
1099
II
3.3
111
1111
1112
1113
23.5
12
121
1211
1212
1213
44.5
13
131
1312
1313
1314
13
1315
133
1331
1332
1339
14
13.7
141
180
(4)
15.0
102
(2)
10
MINING
4-
Import
P'.PtJTS
TABLE 8
Productivity Data for Mining Industries
the
Service
of Prices Received
a.rrners." The former
'-average" prices
Industry Code
2-
3-
(1)
(2)
Digit Digit
10
101
102
103
1t index") measures
ive
of corn-
alons with
is collected
farm communities.
personal interview
104
105
106
108
109
farms is described in
11
Employment and
Price
Indexes
Man-hours
coverage b (Nonbenchmark)c
111
Relative
Importance
4-
2-
(3)
(4)
Digit Digit
1011
1021
15.0
13
133
3.3
141
x
x
100.0
.3
9.0
3.3
2.0
pe
1.2
P
P
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
1.7
3.8
P
P
x
x
P's
100:0
100.0
84.9
14.8
44.5
1312
1313
1314
100.0
100.0
98.4
.7
.9
100.0
79.9
74.8
5.1
1315
14.6
1331
1332
x
(100.0)
x
x
x
x
P
P
P
x
x
P's
x
x
x
P's
6.3
100.0
1.3
181
8.1
13.7
(10) (11)
x
xx
x xx
x
100.0
.3
1211
1339
14
P's
31.1
1.0
23.5
131
100.0
40.5
1.4
.3
1111
13
(9)
2.5
1081
1212
1213
(8)
4.5
1112
1113
121
(7)
10.0
1062
1064
1063
1069
12
(6)
.3
1.0
1051
BESd BLS BM
(5)
.7
1042
1043
1044
1092
1093
1094
1099
Quantity and
10.0
1032
1033
1034
Output
100.0
100.0
x
x
x
xx
xx
x
x
x
Lidustry Code
2-
3-
(1)
(2)
Digit Digit
4.
Digit
(3)
1412
1413
1415
1417
142
144
145
146
147
14
1416)
14195
1422
1423
1424
1425
1426
1427
1429
1441
1452
1453
1454
1455
1456
1457
1459
1462
1469
1472
1473
1474
1475
1476
1477
1479
148
149
1481
1492
1493
1494
1495
1496
1497
1498
1499
Relative
Importance
2-
Digit
(4)
Price
Employment and
Indexes
Man-Hours
Coverageb (Nonbenchmark)c
Output
Quantity and
Value NonDigit Benchmarka benchmark
34-
Quantity
(5)
(6)
(7)
X
X
X
X
.2
.4
.2
.4
S
S
28.5
20.1
1.9
.4
tS
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
P
P
P
X
X
30.2
30.2
6.6
.8
.4
.4
28.8
1.2
X
X
1.9
.9
.1
S
S
X
X
X
2.9
.3
S
S
S
S
S
.3
1.4
1,5
.4
2.1
BESt
BM
(10) (11)
(9)
50.6
X
X
Production defined as
and silver, other
g
No separation of "dirr
66.4
X
X
income originating in
Business, July 1957.
corresponding two-digi
Industries.
Ccl. 6: Legend indicates v
When preceded by an
Census of Mineral Indu.
X
X
X
X
X
.8
*S
100.0
(100.0)
100.0
X
X
X
.4
.4
3.8
.5
.3
.4
.2
.2
.8
1.4
P
P
P
P
P
P
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
1.3
7.0
5.3
2.5
10.5
(8)
Benchmark (Census of 1
X
X
Price Index.
Col. 9: Bureau of Empli
Wages. Included are ti
unemployment insuras
Col. 10: BLS data
tion, see Part I, sectio1
published periodically
Employment refers tc
and repair work, supe
ND INPUTS
Price
Employment and
indexes
Man-Hours
Co verageb (Nonbenchmark)c
(8)
BLS BM
(9)
(10)
(11)
1314, and 1315. Value added here represents the sum of the value of shipments and
capital expenditures less the sum of intermediate products consumed and purchased
machinery. This definition differs from that used in manufacturing in that it includes the
difference between capital expenditures and purchased machinery.
Benchmark data are similarly available on supplies (including the cost of products
purchased wholly for resale), fuel, and energy, except for industries 146 and 1462.
b
C
50.6
66.4
Benchmark (Census of Minerals Industries) data on the value of shipments are avail-
able for all three-digit industries and all four-digit industries except 1094. Such data
generally represent the gross value of primary and secondary minerals physically transferred, contract work done, and the value of products purchased and resold without
further processing. Some duplication is present but where it is significant, a net ship-
and working and total proprietors are available for all three- and four-digit industries
with the exception that "other employees" are not available for industry 1462. Manhours of production and development employees who were at the establishment are
available for all three- and four-digit industries.
0Employment data only.
e Production defined as the quantity of placer materials washed.
tGold and silver, other than placer gold, combined.
g No
separation of "dimension" stone or "crushed and broken" stone.
Col. 5: Ratio of value added of each four-digit industry to the value added of the
corresponding two-digit industry. Data are derived from the 1954 Census of Mineral
Industries.
Col. 6: Legend indicates whether the data are in units of production (F) or shipments (S).
When preceded by an asterisk, "S" refers to net shipments. Source is the 1954
Census of Mineral industries.
x
x
x
x
x
x
100.0
(100.0)
100.0
x
x
Col. 7: Derived from the regular Commodity Canvasses of the Bureau of Mines and
published in the Minerals Yearbook. Data are on a wherever-made basis. Production
data are also obtained by the Bureau of Mines from the Accident Analysis Canvasses.
These data are not published but are generally available upon request.
Col. 8: Portion of the value of each industry's primary products, wherever made, which
are directly priced. Parentheses indicate that the data represent the average value of
output from the Minerals Yearbook. Otherwise, the source is the BLS Wholesale
Price Index.
183
Noncommodity Sectors
SERVICES
In dustry Code
2-
Digit
(1)
70
3-
Digit
(2)
701
702
703
704
4-
Digit
(3)
Relative
Importance
2-
Digit
(4)
6.8
7011
7012
702(1)
Census
34-
(Bench-
(5)
(6)
Digit
(90.3)
87.7
2.6
(9.7)
8.6
7031
7032
Output
(Receipts)
1.1
mark)
Price
Index
Employment
IRS
(Annual) CPI Census BLS
(7)
(8)
(9)
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
(10)
Man hours
7211
7212
7213
7214
722
723
724
725
726
7291
7221
7222
7231
7232
7241
7242
7243
725(1)
7262
7263
BES
(11)
(12)
X
a
X
X
X
7041
721
7042
72
(39.0)
28.5
.9
5.4
.6
.9
27.7
27.0
.7
(3.4)
(18.4)
7.1
10.8
.6
1.7
4.7
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
OUTPUT. Defined
quantity measure th
XC
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
'
of an allowance
ND INPUTS
request.
Falue data for houseand purchased
!n consumer services,
and man-hours
Employment
Manhours
Census
(9)
BLS
(10)
X
TI
BES
(11)
x
X
x
x
x
x
x
X
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
system used in the sources but differences have been reconciled wherever possible.
Col. 4: The ratio of national income originating in each two-digit industry to the total
national income of the services sector, as given in Table 13, Surveyof Current Business,
July 1955.
Col. 5: Ratio of employment (full workweek) in those three- and four-digit industries for
which such data are available in the Census of Business to employment in the corre-
CONSTRUCTION
b
x
x
Cols. 13: Based on the 1945 SIC. This classification does not always coincide with the
Col. 8: An entry here indicates that some form of this service is represented by an
(12)
BLS publishes estimates for the entire services and miscellaneous group and a few
component industries.
b Unpublished estimates of average weekly hours worked from the Current Population
Survey may be obtained from the Census.
721 and 722 combined.
improvement.
PRICE INDEX. None. The constant dollar value of output series published by the BDSA is derived through the use of a cost index. This
index is inappropriate as a price deflator and statistically unreliable
in several respects.
EMPLOYMENT. Contract construction with some three-digit breakdown (BLSmonthly). Contract construction by three-digit groups
(BES). These estimates are not consistent with the output estimates in
that the former includes only contract construction while the latter
includes contract and force account construction. Also, unlike the
constant dollar output series, the employment figures include maintenance and repairs.
MAN-HOURS. Contract construction, average weekly hours of nonsupervisory employees (BLS).
MATERIALS CONSUMED. There is no over-all estimate but scattered
data are available for a few segments of the industry.
TRANSPORTATION
industry).
OUTPUT. Ton miles and passenger miles for Class i, ii, and iii roads
(ICCmonthly). These items account for about 94 per cent of total
revenue. Also available, total revenue of Class I, ii, and iii roads with
breakdown by type of revenue (ICCmonthly). Note: ICC data published in Transport Statistics, Part I, unless otherwise specified.
PRICE INDEXES. Annual freight carload traffic rate index based on
1
traffic accounts for 97 per cent of frcight revenue. Also available, railroad passenger fares, coach (CPIquarterly).
EMPLOYMENT. All employees, by class of workexecutive, professional and clerical, maintenance and transportation (ICCmonthly).
(Local railways
OUTPUT. Total and
(BLS).
MATERIALS CONSU!v.
(Trucking an
tance 27 per
OUTPUT. Local to
(ICC-annual estima
Public Roads). Thi
MAN-HOURS. BI
compiled.
186
F
fl INPUTS
responsible
suggestions for
tuting 50 per cent of total expenditures for materials, including maintenance items.
TRANSPORTATION
per cent
is to the
in a given
index based on
-1). Such carload
\Iso available, rail-
1executive, profes-
(ICCmonthly).
service hours
fuel
and power,
20 per cent of
Total of other
nses as shown by
(Trucking and warehousingSIC 42, relative importance 27 per cent; trucking, local and long distance
SIC 421.)
OUTPUT. Local ton miles not available. Total intercity ton miles
quarterly).
MAN-HOURS. BLSnot available. ICCsome reported but not
compiled.
187
regulated carriers.
TRANSPORTATION
(Water transpor
percent;
OUTPUT. Tons of
e:
TRANSPORTATEON
Bus miles and passengers carried by long haul and short haul
but use of these would not take account of change in length of trip
within these categories. Data on school bus operation are compiled
by the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare.
Operating revenues for long and short haul bus operators
(McGraw-Hill, Bus Transportation). Operating revenue of Class i
carriers (ICC Statement Q-750quarterly). Revenue of Class ii
and iii carriers reported but not published.
PRICE INDEX. None.
sector (BESquarterly).
MAN-HOURS. Class i, total hours paid, by hourly employees (ICC).
188
of a questionnaire (
Response varies for
at between 50 and 6(
revenue (OBEqua
above). Average fare
questionnaires given
PRICE INDEX. Cert
others, must be filed
age ratio cannot be
a substantial portiOI
EMPLOYMENT. As
(BLS_monthlY)
f(
MAN-HOURS. Non
MATERIALS CONSU
(Water tran
SIC 442; G
OUTPUT. Tons c
0 INPUTS
storage-.---
of the combined
jThere are no sarisindustries which
footlockers,
warehousing.
TRANSPORTATiON
special studies.
of total industry
Bus Transportation
in length of trip
are compiled
eifare.
lul bus operators
of Class
1verlue of Class
ii
carriers carried 70 per cent of the total revenue freight in 1947. However, the sample appears to be biased in favor of freight carriers.
Ocean freight revenue of United States carriers (U.S. and foreign
flag ships: OBEquarterly). These estimates are made on the basis
DATA FOR MI
A, B, and C carriers constitute only 12 per cent of the total, since bulk
carriers and private carriers are not subject to regulation. Number of
passengers carried reported quarterly to the ICC by carriers accounting for about 85 per cent of passenger revenue. Passenger miles are
available only for domestic waterways, published in ICC statement
No. 580. Total revenue, not available.
PRICE INDEX. Revenue per ton by commodity and area of trade may
be computed from ICC data but these data are not representative of
exempt bulk carriers of commodities such as coal, iron ore, petroleum
products, and wheat.
EMPLOYMENT. As part of estimate for "other transportation and
services" (BLS); by three-digit group (BES); large regulated carriers
only (ICC).
MAN-HOURS. None.
carriers (ICC). More detailed expense items are reported but not
compiled.
TRANSPORTATION
Revenues by sou
accounts for about
EMPLOYMENT. Mc
(FCC).
HOURS. Average
(FCC).
MATERIALS
COMM
(Telecommunic
OUTPUT. Numbei
(Oil pipeline
lines. Trunklines ar
of the industry. TI
companies. Insofai
their inclusion is cc
data on barrels o
quarterly in Staten
Revenues are re
ac
the ICC,
industry.
PRICE INDEX. Nc
INPUTS
of the U.S.
p the ICC by Class
r the total, since bulk
Number of
by carriers accountPassenger miles are
in ICC statement
transportation and
ze regulated carriers
by Class A and B
e reported but not
451, relative
of carriers
ulation.)
express and mail
Air Carrier Traffic
evenues by type of
ancial Statistics
TIES
41
monthly). This
count of shifts in
argement of local
number of calls
industry.
(FCC).
required to file annual reports. In addition, the large carriers, representing most of the revenue of the industry, file monthly reports.
Annual summaries for the principal carriers, representing over 90 per
cent of total revenues, are published in Statistics of the Corninunicalions Industry in the U.S.
OUTPUT. Number of messages transmitted by the domestic telegraph industry and words transmitted by transoceanic and marine
communication facilities are reported. Number of words is the preferable measure but is not available for the domestic telegraph sector
which accounts for 80 per cent of message revenue.
TRANSPORTATION
191
DATA FOR M
EMPLOYMENT. Tot
Employment in the
establishments eng
TRANSPORTATION
of gas or electric
establishments.
An estimate of tc
MATERIALS CONSI.
HOURS. None.
utilities.
COW'
(Public utili
OUTPUT. Gross r
ning 195657 (IRS.
available.
PRICE INDEX. Re
the remainder.
EMPLOYMENT.
industries (BES).
HOURS. None.
(Wholesale
,
0 INPUTS
(BLS), regulated
1C 47, 428,
6 per cent.)
rvices such as for-
terminal facilities
transportation,
!is
the
except for
total.
MATERIALS
marized for electric power by the FPC and in Gas Facts for gas
utilities.
by class of
ers. averaae weekly
(FCC).
lTIES
53 per
iSIC 492;
iSIC 493.)
by
class of con-
Commission
utilities (FPC
TRADE
does not reflect the effect of changes in wholesale margins. Commodity gaps in the WPI are indicated under the discussion of manufacturing industries.
EMPLOYMENT. Paid employees and active proprietors of unincorporated businesses, by kind of operation and kind of business (Census).
TRADE
year.
OUTPUT. It is difficult to use Census sales data for deriving an
DATA FOR MI
deflation by a price
would imply that th
by that business wer
The Monthly Re
of business, based
adequate for use ir
limitations as the
Commonly used i
distributed weightec
pletely satisfactory.
should reflect the a
distribution of gooi
or the survey, it
margins.
Inventories were
monthly inventories
estimates prepared
sample has been re
retail establishmen
PRICE INDEXES.
to Census kind of
quarterly from the
the inconsistency o
sales, and the gene
Indexes are also
series on Prices Pa
and are not concer
EMPLOYMENT. B:
group (BESmon
MAN-HOURS.
drinking places ex
MATERIALS CONS
INPUTS
of the estimated
by the Census
and standard
Wholesale Trade
per cent of sales
I
6 in 1954. Estimates
ita. Commodity line
since each
50
inventories (OBE
jf business (Census).
kind of business
detail (BLS).
Bureau, contains estimates of total sales and sales for selected kinds
of business, based on sample surveys. It is considered generally
Since "cost of goods sold" data are not collected for the Census
or the survey, it is not possible to compute accurate industry
margins.
per cent.)
en:ed
kind of
Classification.
limitations.
mderstated. Howas the result
b-btain data from
establishments
for
an
es includes sales
EndeDendent estiby
ccmrnomtv line.
195
(Banking and other financial institutions; Banking.-SIC 60, relative importance 16 per cent; credit agencies
outside the banking sector and is not part of banking output. For
purposes of productivity measurement this concept would not be
suitable because output should, among other things, reflect the role
of the labor input involved in lending activities.
Once a suitable output indicator is selected it may require deflation
DATA FOR ME
the input-output st
PRICE INDEXES. A
EMPLOYMENT. Inc
HOURS. Average'
FINAt
(Real estate-
r.
OUTPUT. Data h
Indirect method
received figures f
cedure involves rc
fragmentary or ol
extrapolating the:
marks and lack C
satisfactory appro
Further complical
space rental rathe
INPUTS
TATE
Banking
agencies
curities and
62,
than of
6formed. There are
of checks, number
loans and investand there are
weighting system.
BLS interindustry
Ilcial intermediaries
Eyed by individuals
inking output. For
Under this
would not be
and Averages.
PRICE INDEXES. Automobile and hospitalization insurance (CPI).
EMPLOYMENT. Including agents (BLS); by three-digit groups (BES).
HOURS. Average weekly hours, includes agents (BLS).
0 and 62 (BLS).
significant.
misceflaneous
per cent
-
information to strength
fill in the more importa
2. The interrelati
3. Better quality
needed and m
MAN-HOURS. None.
COMMENT
RAYMOND T. BOWMAN, Bureau of the Budget
Leon Greenberg and his colleagues are owed a considerable debt for
the painstaking way in which they have catalogued the available data,
related it to productivity measurement problems, and highlighted its
more clearly se
these purposes
and interviewe:.
INPUTS
of owner occupied
of output
t of a productivity
for owner
since there is no
owners in manag-
it the imputation,
by paid
The hours spent
for.
Dent.)
down by type of
:, and price of the
reported to the
Dr hours.
data.
and interviewer biases. The timing and content of tabulations must better accord with user requirements.
A better understanding of the theoretical and practical aspects of
a whole, they represent little more than special per capita output
series. When such measurements are developed for the several
industrial sectors in a manner consistent with the economy's total
output, information is added concerning the extent to which the overall change in unit labor output is associated with shifts in the relative
importance of different industries as contrasted with changes intra
199