Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Acid Fosf 2
Acid Fosf 2
Biochimie
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/biochi
Mini-review
a r t i c l e i n f o
a b s t r a c t
Article history:
Received 21 May 2014
Accepted 30 July 2014
Available online 8 August 2014
Phosphatidic acid (PA) is the simplest phospholipid naturally existing in all-living organisms. It constitutes only a minor fraction of the total cell lipids but has attracted considerable attention being both a
lipid second messenger and a modulator of membrane shape. The pleiotropic functions of PA are the
direct consequence of its very simple chemical structure consisting of only two acyl chains linked by
ester bonds to two adjacent hydroxyl groups of glycerol, whose remaining hydroxyl group is esteried
with a phosphomonoester group. Hence the small phosphate head group of PA gives it the shape of a
cone providing exibility and negative curvatures in the context of a lipid bilayer. In addition, the
negatively charged phosphomonoester headgroup of PA is unique because it can potentially carry one or
two negative charges playing a role in the recruitment of positively charged molecules to biomembranes.
In consequence, PA has been proposed to play various key cellular functions. In the brain, a ne balance
between cell growth, migration and differentiation, and cell death is required to sculpt the nervous
system during development. In this review, we will summarize the various functions that have been
proposed for PA in neuronal development.
te
franaise de biochimie et biologie Mole
culaire (SFBBM). All rights
2014 Elsevier B.V. and Socie
reserved.
Keywords:
Phosphatidic acid
Neurite outgrowth
Phospholipase D
Dendritic spine
Vesicular fusion
1. Introduction
During brain development, neurons exhibit various morphological changes including axon and dendrite outgrowth, dendritic
branching and spine formation, as well as synapse formation,
which are critical events in the establishment of neuronal networks. Because of its complexity and heterogeneity, most molecular aspects of the nervous system development have been studied
using cell culture models. These include various types of neurons,
but also the rat neural crest derivative PC12 cells that develop
neuronal features in response to neuronal growth factor (NGF)
treatment.
In culture, hippocampal neurons undergo morphological
changes that were rst described by Dotti et al. [1]. Shortly after
plating, the cells begin to develop lamellipodia around the cell body
(Stage 1). The second phase of development is marked by the loss of
lamellipodia and the extension of neurites or neurite outgrowth
(Stage 2). After 1e2 days in vitro, the majority of cells have an
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: vitalen@unistra.fr (N. Vitale).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.biochi.2014.07.026
te
franaise de biochimie et biologie Mole
culaire (SFBBM). All rights reserved.
0300-9084/ 2014 Elsevier B.V. and Socie
52
Fig. 1. Biosynthetic pathways of structural and signaling PA. PA is a central phospholipid for biosynthetic and signaling reactions. Red arrows denote biosynthetic reactions that lead to structural PA synthesis whereas formation of signaling pools of PA
is shown with blue arrows.
diacyglycerol (DAG), which is an important source for the biosynthesis of triacylglycerols and phospholipids including phosphatidylcholine
(PC),
phosohatidylethanolamine
(PE)
and
phosphatidylserine (PS) [20]. In addition, PA can be deacylated by
phospholipases A (PLA) to LPA or degraded by CDP-DAG synthetase
into CDP-diacylglycerol, which is responsible for the synthesis of
phosphatidylinositol (PI), phosphatidylglycerol (PG) and cardiolipin (CL) [19] (Fig. 1).
Signaling forms of PA can be formed by three alternative
biosynthetic pathways (Fig. 1). The rst pathway involves phospholipase D (PLD), which catalyzes the hydrolysis of the distal
phosphodiester bond in PC to form PA and choline. PLD preferentially catalyzes a transphosphatidylation reaction to produce
phosphatidylalcohols at the expense of PA production in the presence of primary alcohols, such as ethanol and 1-butanol. Measuring
the production of labeled phosphatidylalcohols has been until
recently an important method used to study cellular functions of
PLD [21,22]. Cloning and characterization of genes encoding PLD
proteins have identied at rst two isoforms (PLD1 and PLD2) in
animal cells. Two alternative splicing variants of PLD1 (PLD1a and
PLD1b) and three for PLD2 (PLD2a, PLD2b and PLD2c) were subsequently identied. Both PLD isoforms contain two HKD motifs,
which are critical for enzymatic catalysis, a phox (PX) domain, a
pleckstrin homology (PH) domain and a PIP2 binding domain [23].
In addition, PLD1 contains a loop domain that is not found in
PLD2 and seems to be involved in the auto-inhibition of PLD1
[24,25]. PLD1 which is characterized by low basal activity, is activated principally by three classes of proteins: ARF GTPases, Rho
GTPases and several members of the family of protein kinases
including PKCs and RSK2. PLD2 which exhibits a higher basal activity, is also modulated by ARF and Rac proteins [26e28]. More
recently, structurally different isoforms of PLD were identied.
These include PLD3, PLD4 and a mitochondrial PLD (mito-PLD).
Mito-PLD in contrast to classical mammalian PLDs uses cardiolpin
as substrate to generate PA. An important structural difference
between mito-PLD and PLD1/2 is that mito-PLD has only a single
HKD half-catalytic site, requiring it to dimerize to create an active
enzymatic complex. Furthermore, mito-PLD displays no PX, PH or
PIP2 membrane binding domains and needs its N-terminal
sequence for mitochondrial surface anchoring. Regarding PLD3 and
PLD4 proteins, although their catalytic activity has not been
established to date PLD3 appears to be involved in cell differentiation [29] and PLD4 in phagocytosis of microglial cells [30].
The phosphorylation of DAG using ATP as a phosphate source by
DAG kinase (DGK) produces PA. Ten isoforms for mammalians DGK
(a, b, g, d, h, k, , z, i, and q) have been cloned and characterized.
These isoforms are classied in ve subtypes and all of them have a
conserved catalytic domain and at least two cysteine rich domains.
The three type I DGKs (a, b and g) contain calcium-binding EF
hands motifs in their N-termini, while type II (d, h and k) have
pleckstrin homology (PH) domains at their N termini. The type III
DGK () has the simplest structure and does not contain regulatory
units. The types IV DGK (z and i) have ankyrin repeats at their C
termini and a region homologous to the MARCKS protein's phosphorylation site. Finally, DGK q denes type V, has three cysteinerich domains and a PH domain [31].
The acylation of LPA by lysoPA-acyltransferases (LPAAT) also
leads to PA formation [32]. Six human LPAAT isoforms have been
cloned and characterized [33]. The isoforms LPAAT 1 & 2 have 34%
sequence homology and the highest LPAAT activity [34]. These
isoforms also contain from two to four transmembrane domains
and two highly conserved motifs (H (X) 4D and EGT), which are
essential for catalytic activity of the family of acyltransferases
[35,36]. Interestingly, more proteins displaying LPAAT activities
have been recently identied. For instance the protein RIBEYE in
53
phosphorylation of the membrane phospholipid phosphatidylinositol 4-phosphate to generate the pleiotropic PIP2. The PA pool
involved in the activation of PIP5K has not been precisely characterized but it seems that the two major sources of signaling PA,
namely PLD and DGK, are involved [58e61]. The three mammalian
PIP5K isozymes, a, b, and g, have been described as playing a role in
actin cytoskeleton reorganization (Reviewed in Ref. [62]) and
linked to neuronal outgrowth, axon elongation and branching, and
growth cone morphology [63e65].
Finally, PA has been described to regulate the membrane localization and activity of PKC isoforms a, and z [66e68]. PKCs are
known to inuence the morphology of the actin lament cytoskeleton. This kinase family has been implicated in a variety of
cellular functions, including neurite outgrowth (reviewed in Ref.
[69]).
In addition to GTPase and kinase regulated pathways, PA has
been reported to inuence the actin organization by interacting
directly with some actin-binding proteins. For instance, PA interacts with vinculin [70,71], an actin-binding protein described to
play a role in neurite outgrowth in PC12 cells and neurons. Yet, actin
plays intricate functions in neurite elongation, which range from a
structural function and the organization of vesicular trafcking to
the establishment/stabilization of cell membrane domains dedicated to vesicular fusion and membrane incorporation (Fig. 2).
3.2. PA and membrane trafcking
PA has been proposed to play a role in various trafcking events,
including endocytosis and regulated exocytosis leading to the
release of hormones from endocrine and neuroendocrine cells,
neurotransmitters from neurons, IL-8 from epithelial cells, mast cell
degranulation and insulin-stimulated translocation of the glucose
transporter Glut4 to the cell membrane (reviewed in Refs. [72,73].
These observations have been obtained mostly by the use of molecular and pharmacological inhibitors of PLDs and suggest that
PLD1 is the isoform mostly involved in membrane trafcking,
although few examples for the involvement of DGK-generated PA in
membrane trafcking have been also described.
Evidence supporting the involvement of PLD1-generated PA in
the late steps of exocytosis, such as membrane fusion and/or pore
expansion comes from studies in chromafn cells in which injection of a dominant-negative PLD1 mutant [74] or PLD1 silencing
[75] affects the fusion rate of single secretory granule release. Yet,
the mechanism(s) by which PA promotes membrane fusion remains debated. It may be linked to its ability to generate membrane
curvature and facilitate fusion [75], modulate syntaxin-1 activity
and the docking of vesicles [76] and/or recruit key proteins required
for the fusion process.
Although PLD-generated PA has been shown to be crucial to
neurite outgrowth in a variety of neuronal cell models (reviewed in
Refs. [39], the mechanisms implicating PA in the underlying
membrane trafcking events remain elusive. Supporting the
importance of PLD1-generated PA in neurite outgrowth, we
recently observed that neuronal maturation was signicantly
delayed in Pld1 knockout neurons [77]. Interestingly, this alteration
of neuronal development very much recapitulated that observed in
Rsk2 knockout neurons, a model for the human X-linked CofnLowry syndrome, a severe mental retardation disease [77]. We
found also that PLD1 became phosphorylated and activated by the
kinase RSK2 during neurite outgrowth in PC12 cells [77]. PLD1
activation leads to an increase of PA levels at the tips of growing
neurites as revealed by the PA sensor Spo20p-GFP [77]. Interestingly, PLD1 was found to be associated to trans Golgi-derived vesicular structures, also positive for the vesicular SNARE VAMP-7/
TiVAMP. These vesicles moved anterogradly and retrogradly in
54
Fig. 2. PA plays a role in axon and dendrite outgrowth, dendritic branching and spine formation. Schematic representation of dendritic spines and a growth cone with microtubules
(green), actin cytoskeleton (red) and trafcking vesicles. In dendrites, elevated PA favors spine maintenance through the regulation of actin dynamics. In growth cones, PA is
involved in neurite outgrowth by controlling actin organization and vesicular trafcking for membrane supply. The uorescence images on the right-hand side show a cortical
neuron dendrite labeled to visualize actin and MAP2 and a growth cone with its tubulin and actin cytoskeleton. Bars 10 mm.
the developing neurites [77]. RSK2 and PLD1 were found to interact
at the tip end of growing neurites, in line with the increased PA
level at this location [77]. We monitored the fusion rate of PLD1/
VAMP-7 vesicles and found that RSK2 and PLD1 inhibitors
dramatically reduced membrane supply required for neurite
outgrowth [77]. Taken together, these results reveal for the rst
time the direct involvement of PA-mediated membrane trafcking
in neurite outgrowth. The observation that quenching PA by
expressing a PA sensor in PC12 cells strongly reduces the number
and length of the NGF-induced neurites [77] suggests that PA acts
in part by recruiting key proteins at the vesicle fusion site during
neurite outgrowth.
4. PA in dendritic arborization and spine regulation
Pld1 knockout affects dendritic branching. Specically, the
number of secondary branching dendrites is signicantly reduced
in neurons cultured from Pld1-/- mice [77]. Additionally, the density of the spines, the tiny protrusions (0.5 mm wide, 2 mm long) on
neuronal dendrites that receive the majority of excitatory synaptic
inputs, is signicantly reduced in Pld1-/- hippocampal neurons and
this reduction in spine density specically affects mushroom and
branched spines, which are the forms of mature spines [77].
Accordingly, a previous report showed that the GTPase RalB promotes branching through a pathway involving PLD [78]. PLD1 has
also been described to negatively regulate dendritic branching in
hippocampal neurons [79], but this apparent contradiction is most
likely related to the methods used to modify PLD1 expression
levels, i.e. overexpression or silencing versus genetically knocked
down PLD1. Anyhow, these results imply critical functions of PLD1produced signaling PA in early stages of neuronal growth and
development.
Additionally, dendrite arborization and spines seem to rely on
DGK-generated signaling PA. For instance, overexpression of wildtype DGKb promotes dendrite outgrowth and spine maturation in
transfected hippocampal neurons, whereas a kinase-dead mutant
DGK has no effect [40]. Accordingly, primary cultured hippocampal
neurons from DGKb KO mice had less branches and spines
compared to the wild type [41]. DGKz has also been reported to be
important for the maintenance of dendritic spines and the regulation of the PA/DAG balance at excitatory synapses [80,81]. Indeed
the C-terminal PDZ-binding motif of DGKz interacts with the PDZ
domains of the postsynaptic density protein PSD-95, an abundant
postsynaptic scaffolding protein that regulates excitatory synaptic
structure and function. This interaction promotes synaptic localization of DGKz at synapses. Functionally, DGKz overexpression increases spine density in cultured hippocampal neurons in a manner
that requires DGK catalytic activity but also PSD-95 binding,
whereas knockdown of DGKz decreases spine density. Mice decient for DGKz expression show a reduction in spine density in
hippocampal CA1 pyramidal neurons and exhibit reduced excitatory synaptic transmission. Time-lapse imaging in DGKz-decient
mice revealed impaired spine maintenance but not formation [80].
Taken together, these data also reveal a key role of DGK-generated
PA in dendritic ramication and spine formation and maturation.
By tightly controlling the conversion of DAG to PA, DGK either
stabilizes (PA-dependent) or destabilizes (DAG-dependent) dendritic spines (Fig. 2; recently reviewed in Ref. [87]).
55
56
[37]
[38]
[39]
[40]
[41]
[42]
[43]
[44]
[45]
[46]
[47]
[48]
[49]
[50]
[51]
[52]
[53]
[54]
[55]
[56]
[57]
[58]
[59]
[60]
[61]
[97]
[98]
[99]
[100]
[101]
[102]
57