Professional Documents
Culture Documents
VIKALP-kyon & Kaise - A Nagraj - 215
VIKALP-kyon & Kaise - A Nagraj - 215
bD k}NbC*
Ba T < PC Ja ba Ab b Bb<Tb T
DGb PC bD Tb D P|ED Da* b $ PDb CC y
Pb Tb DNB Tb RH GT <Te <h JT bD CT<E
<ED $ h ~D-P-h C*, PC, CT <Jy bD Tb
D P}B bC b $
bbG
<Te
bTb
y. Dbb, LCb
y. Dbb
h ~D P hb
< P}hbD
BDbg, }T^>T,
<Jb-~>bCJ (..)
()
T
()
<D< TDC T kb Ta a $ PCT <Te C* Ph
a h JT bD C*T< <}D bD CT DNPb
h <h, <TbP b b< <D<A P|L <D
bT<T bCDb, Db <b< $
.
PbD
.
()
b bs bL b b bs Tb bb bL ?
~bh_ bL b LCb bL ?
PaaD Gh< C* yT b AD Bb
bb AD Bb C* h}_b CT kb P}<bD PBb <q> b
<PC* b^>, b>ab, b>a-G_ Tb P_ bvb Db bCC
y D<<D< b_ bCDC Ta haT< P}<bD C* bCDb $
bC^>-DbC^ >(D) q>k}D PC DbC~ D<<D<
TPb ?
P}<bD C* <DC[b - yT bs, y} Pa CT
Pb DCT b<, P}b, PNb Tb eJC bCDb $
P}<bD C* PbDb - yT bs, Pa CT Pb b[L Tb
eJC b GTb bCDb
D}_ - ~bPD C* D<<D<bC* T <DbD GTb C* bC^>
DbC^> Tb q>k}D bCDb $
C TPb D}_ ? PbDb <DC[b ?
. D ADbC* CT }bJ PC NGs bDC TbC TbJaD <bD,
C<bC*, P|bDa T< <bC* CT PNb PC () b TbC b TDC CT <Jy Pb< yT b_ bhb
kbC <PC *DC haTb GTb $
() PbDb CT DNTJ hbD CT iT C* T^>T TbC
haTbb $
() PD PC PbDb T b|B GTb $
()
()
PD CT ~T C* PbDb C* bb b $
() PD C* Pb< P|ED bCDC T h< haTbDC C*
bb $ Pb< h< C* CC b~b <b n>bC* N
a* $ yCPa h< C* b TbC b bCDC Ta ^>Db ~E
a Ba P C* bb $ h< P PbDb
<D kb PC x>b }^>C T bCa a $
Pb<, bD, bLb T C* P} h hVT LbJa
*DC haTba $ bC kb P} bCDC PC Pb< bCDC Tb
bL haTbb $ Pb< PC P} P|ED bCDC T GTb
C* Ba ^>C PC ^>C JC C $ VTJh P}L
h P-h CT iT C* NC DNB b $
<PTb b ""h ~D Phb''
~bh_ CT C* hN b $
. Ph #- bT hN C* P}L E P}s y}
<D bD bCDb P C* bb $
Ph C* a #- bLN C* <TbPT CT C* BC
aL bLN C* a <TbP T q>DL bLNbC*
CT iT C* bCDb, Db P C* bb $
Ph C* a #- q>DL bLN E Tb-aD
C* bCDb P C* bb $
Ph C * a #- B C aL bLN LN
bLTbCbbC* PC a P|L DbC* b bLN LNbC* PC <
a b DCT <bC* Tb Db h^> bCDb P C* bb $
. h C* Bb<T Db a a a b<T << PC
PbD }_ GTb P< bLTbCbbC* PC < DbC* P}L
()
PC * P~NB P_ bDb b PbD C* ~NBbC[b bCDb
haTbb VTJhiT CDb <TbP e <~[b, P}<bD,
bL hb P P_ bvb, bD P|N hN
GTb RH $
B< h bC, DN Cb bC
PVTJ bC, <D ~NB bC $
- y. Dbb
<Te Tb h Tb-b C*
. <TbP T C* b hb y} bL hb $
bbhb #- a C* P}L Tb CT <DbC* PC P|ED bCDC
CT b} $
bLbhb #- PBa Tb CT D kC n>bC^>C }J DCT Tb
CT Dh<bC* PC P|ED bCDb bb bb $ D <DbC* CT
P}NJD C* bP P}N<J Db, Ba P C* bb $
Pb C* Ba P C* bb GT bD b< T C* a
CDb~ ab b PNb }bbC* C* bD a ~N bD,
b[P bD CT C* n>J, T^>, }B, b>, bC, <bC,
~bCL, NX, Pb, b, >, BC a NTT~ P|L
Tb CT b TDb bDT aDb bCb b <PPC
a kab bC $ <D TbCJb, <D CJ b
<GTLa bNbC* TbC a C* PC L TDb a CT
Pb b h^> $ P T C* a kab bC a b
()
bD CT DC JbT kCa GT Da* AD<E J b $
PCT <Te C* b kJ PC Tb b TDC Tb PNb $
Pb Tb P}k}a TLbC* TbC Phb kDbDC CT <Jy, b }
TbC bb PC bb bC TDC CT <Jy PNb $ b>a
bCDb CT E PbCDC CT <Jy Nb PNbb b $
. a CDb Tb bL a PBa P}<bDbC* C* Ja TbC
Ja PC bCTDb, b TbC b PC bCTDb, NX TbC NX
PC bCTDb CT h C* CDC TbC <Jb $ PC bDb $
- <~[b C* JbBbCEb, TbbCEb, BbCbCEba Tb
b CT <Jy bCPbD CDb $
- PBa Tb CT b b B b JbCBD CT C*
Tb a bD b< T <P yCPb NC P
C* bb $
. s TbLbC* PC DC* <Te hN TDC T haT< bC #Phba << PC b D ~aJ ~ bh_,
bba Pb~bh_, bD P}CDbba DbC<bD
~bh_ hN $
<PC* aDe - PN-~b}<-P}bC-bDE, bD J
a PbbD-P<X-B-Ph P }b C* P
PbCbDa hb << PC PVTJ bCDC Tb P}BbDb bL
bD bCDb hb< $
. bDa e = ab, ab, bb, b Tb TLb y}
bD J - PbbD P<X, B (bD C* <AbP
bbC* hbbC* CT Pb) bD bCDb hb< $
bD P}hT<, Pb <<, hb P bL bD
()
bCDb hb< a P<h $
hb< e - h P}k}bC* T bD, P}k}bC* C* ebC*
Tb <Db bCDb a P}hT< <D P P B >
Pb P_ bvb P bL bD bCDb hb< $
<~> ebC* CT Pb hNbC* Tb bbD, bD, L, PL
GTb TJb C* <D P bCDb a bD CDb P
B $ Ba hb< $
bD CDb a b C* bD $ bL C* <D $
. bD PbbD, P<X, B, Ph C* bL
bD P $
bD CDb P bD, <CT, <bD P| PbC <b
bCDb TbbCDb b VTJ GLb <bD <CT bD
P| bCDb a <D "PbbD' P a bD CDb P
B $ bD CDb P B a bD $
bD - Ph iTa 0 h ~D bD
0 aD bD
0 bDabL bL bD
<CT 0 aD P
0 ~a P DA
0 b P <D
bDabL bL-0 hD, hDba, hN
bL Tb b
0 P}k} e eb}TD B
<
()
0
D D D a Tb
PbC PN[b
<bD0 TbJ GTb <DLba bD
0 GTb T < = TbJ
0 GTb <D bD
Ph C* P|L T< GTb h C* bD
GTb - g < GLb
GLb Tb - q> D L bLN E
Tb aD
g Tb <gb - bD CDb P|ED }b
> Pb P_ bvb
b Pb B b hb
P P _ bvb =
N
yCLb <c = N_CLb, <cCLb, JbCCTLb $
< Tb } - C CDb, < CDb P B C*
Tb <c P~NB C* $
Pk D| y} aDb bD C*, PC, CT <Jy $
bCD P}BbDb
. a TbC bD b Tb <cbC* PC NGs
bDC CT <Jy DDba Tb Pb bCDb $
Pba PC PbbD-P bL bD bCDb $
PbbD P|ED Gb C* g <DbCD T P<X
()
()
. bD P}CDbba DbC<bD ~bh_
. <}D - ~D-b-~bh_ CT bb
aD <b kbCD LbJa h> $
bDa bb P}<b a
"P}<bD hb' (Tb~D GTb C*)
D CT <Jy bb<D , hN $
. Pa CT Pb "GBbb P}<b' hN TDC T bCDb $
()
()
.
.
.
y. Dbb
LCb
h ~D P hb
< P}hbD
BDbg, }T^>T,
<Jb-~>bCJ (..)
.
.
.
.
-() (b)
h #bCDb, <D} bCDb
<Bb #- bT hN C* yT-yT hNbC* Tb <D}
GTb~aJb, <D} bD Db $
bg #g T bD CDb DNPb bL hN
TDb $ DT bD CDb DNPb
bL hN TDb $
DE #bC <La << PC LDb P C* Da*
bb - bCDC T P}BbDb C $ TeDb C*
bC P C* Da* bb bC - b bCDC T
P}BbDb bC $
D #DNB P b~Da C* hL T GTb
b GTb TJb y} bP
> Pb #- bD b<, , b hb C* yT
b P}hT<, Pb, <<, hb C*
yTb P bD }b $
D| #- DT h P hN P
C* bDb
aL bLN #- bLN CT bCDC C* <DC }~bC* Ta
bATb PN < D<A a PPC
<T }~bC* Tb q>D bCDb <GTLab
Bb TbC PbG TC DC b DC PC
NTn> }~bC* TbC <P< TDC CT <Jy
D~aJ Db $
()
()
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
LN #-
bLNbC* Tb P}Gq> , yT PC
<T bLNbC* Tb P}sN GTb-TJb
b #-D, -Dba, -N, -abTba
Tb b y} P} PN < b TbC
ba<Tb bD <Jb b ~N bD,
b[P bD $
bD~aJb #- bD CT <Jy h_bC kDbC C y
bDT PX bCDb
B # bD C * <AbP-> Pb
PbBb hb P_ bvb bL $
L #NTn> CT JCDC T << PC L $ C[b
P< <DbCD GTb $
#GLb Tb (q>DLb)
N #PbCNa PbbD bL bD
b~b #PN T aDC T b~b
-
n>b #~D y} PCT ^>D T P}Ns <}D
GTb Tb <_L $
bDba #Pba TbC b<L TDC C T <Jy
<D<A bCDb b TDb $
T y
B < #- T PC T bC b bC PC <T P}k}bC* C*
ebC* Tb <Db
. Tb #-
. < #hbDb}L GD
()
()
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. C T #-
. a #-
. DA #. <D B #-
()
()
. <D< T #-
()
()
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. h #.
.
.
.
.
.
()
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
()
D-D-D a Tb PbC PN[b
P}k}a T bCD P< GTbED CT
<Jy bAT D b bbJb
. hN h< P #- C~ TbJ <~b
hN P #- NL hBb
P
. P}k} #(i) ~a P}k}
(v) bD P}k}
(ii) bD P}k} (vi) <<D P}k}
(iii) <~[b P}k} (vii) DP<T P}k}
(iv) hb P}k}
. h< P #- Pcb C* P}s T<
. Pba #bD <CT <bD
. PL #JCDC T n>b PC Ns bD GTb
. Pb #<< hb C* Bbaba, hb CT
C* P_ bvb
. P}hT< #Lb CT C* GTb b GTb TJb,
Tb b <BGs P}CLb Tb~D
. P<X #Gb P bATb PC <T
bD
. PbbD #Pba- bDba-<|C baBbaba Pba C T DN i T VTJ
GLb bCDb $
. hb< e #- . <AbP
. gXb
()
()
. P|bD
. b
. hDC
. bPe
. Tb
. C
. b
. P}s #>kb - Bab - <b $ Lb CT C*,
P}Lb CT C*
Lb - q>DLb, <TbLb bL
Lb, P|Lb = Tb + bbL
. PbBb bvb #- P PbCbDa GbJT hb
hb <PC * <kDb D C T
D<<D< PNJB bCDb $ PBa <<D<
Pba P < X PC P|ED bC D b $
Pba P|ED PX P< Gb Tb
<<D< bCDb y} bDa <~[b P}hTb,
Eb PN[b P}hTb, bD Tb P}hTb,
<<D Tb P}hTb, hbh P}
P}hTb, Tb C* Bbaba P Gb
<<D< <Db< }b C* bD
bCDb $
. Phb #- Pcb C* P|s E T< P
<D Bb <<< bD
. PbD #h} C* PC CT <Jy bh< P LD
. P} #Pba bDba <|Cba Bbaba
Tb bL }b
. Pb< #-
()
()
. ~bh_ #-
. <~[b #. <~[L #. g #-
. bD #. bb #. bDbhb #-
. bLN #-
h aD bL bD
P C* bDb, b<L bCDb
a CDb PC gCq> bD CDb
bD CDb PC gCq> C CDb
C CDb PC gCq> < CDb P bL
}b $
<DAb, hb JT Bb<Tb b h JT
b~b CT <Te TbC bD CTE <ED h ~D,
Phb CT iT C* bLa y. Dbb (kbkba) DC hN
GTb $ P ~D C* bD b< CT Ph ADbC* CT c, PBa
PhbbC* Tb PbbD b bD CT PN, P<X T aDC T
}b bL bCDC T hb $ P ~D TbC P T aDC CT
T C* <EbC*DC Ba bP GTC * DC* PbDT GLb $ h}
C* Db PC NGs b GbbC* C* P}ab Tb bbL kDb $
hTJbC* b TDaT <bJbC* C* Ba P ~D CT bb <~<
bbC< GTC C * $ <b<bC* C* h} PC JCT T< T Da
<|Cba CT < }Bab b $ P ~D TbC JbCbC* DC
Pb a C * b PbDC CT <Jy P}Te b bP } $
>bM. L<P} b
<Aa c C~
N P}hbD n>b^>a
(n>caP)
>bM. ba Pb}J
>bCs^> I.I.I.T.
bkb (bEC~)
()
Tb<~ Tb~DbaD kE
""h J T bD C T E <} D''
kDb "h ~D' P-hb CT EbC*
T Pa
~ D
. bD
. bD
. bD
. bD
b y} ~D
DNB ~D
bP ~D
T ~D
(Tb<~)
(Tb<~)
(Tb<~)
(Tb<~)
~bh_
. bba Pb~b
. bD~aJ <}D
. bD P}CDbba DbC<bD
(Tb<~)
(Tb<~)
(Tb<~)
b
. PbbDbT Bb<Tb
. bbT Db
. DNBbT bb
(Tb<~)
(Tb<~)
(Tb<~)
bC Db
. aD <b bCDb
. bD P}CDbba <~[b-P}hTb bCDb
. Gb JT hb hb bCDb
(Tb~DbaD)
(Tb~DbaD)
(Tb<~)
E
. GBbb P}<b
. aD <b - yT G
. <h y} h C* bLN Tb <TbP
. bDa P}<bD Tb b
aD <b a (JCT-a T)
(Tb<~)
(Tb<~)
(Tb<~)
(Tb<~)
(Tb<~)