Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Email address:
debasishsur@yahoo.co.in (D. Sur), bhunia.amalendu@gmail.com (A. Bhunia)
Abstract: Purpose of the study: The present study investigates the influence of selected macroeconomic variables in terms of
international crude oil price, exchange rates, domestic gold price, real interest rates and wholesale price index on stock market
indices (sensex and nifty) of India. Background: Macroeconomic variables directly or indirectly affect the stock prices because it
influences strongly the stock returns by affecting the stock prices, which supports the existance of a long-run relationship
between the macroeconomic variables and stock prices. Methodology: This study is based on time series monthly data collected
from Reserve Bank of India database; BSE and NSE database, investing.com and yahoo, finance database for the period July
1997 to July 2015 with the application of financial econometrics. Results: The empirical results reveal that sensex and nifty
reactions to shocks on crude oil prices, exchanges rates, real interest rates and whole prices indices were positive while a negative
shock from sensex and nifty to real interest was noticed.
Keywords: Macroeconomic Indicators, Stock Market, India, Cointegration Test, Causality Test,
Vector Error Correction Model
1. Introduction
The hot and flowing questions in the stock market study are
whether the macroeconomic variables unswervingly or not
directly influence the stock prices. On this topic, academicians,
professionals and proficient finance experts are harshly
alienated into two schools of consideration. One school of
consideration believes macroeconomic variables just as
immaterial to the stock prices. In this context, the Efficient
Market Hypothesis (Fama, 1965, Fama, 1970) states that in an
efficient market all the relevant information about the
volatility in macroeconomic variables are fully reflected in the
current stock prices and thus, in such market abnormal profits
cannot be earned by the investors regardless of their
investment strategies. The other school of consideration
speaks out that macroeconomic variables persuade sturdily the
stock returns by influencing stock prices. In this context, the
Arbitrage Pricing Theory (Ross, 1976, Chen et al, 1986)
supports the existance of a long-run relationship between the
macroeconomic variables and stock prices. According to this
theory, the investors can predict the future stock prices by
analying the trends in macroeconomic variables and hence,
with the help of such prediction they can earn abnormal profits.
So, debate silently continues. In the midst of the prominent
change in the economic obverse ever since 1991 owing to
approval of liberalization measures, together with erstwhile
supports of Indian financial system the capital market in India
has furthermore transformed extensively bringing about
perceptible changes in the environment of its accomplices. In
fact, the foreign institutional as well as individual investors
have got an easy access to the Indian stock market. In this
milieu, this study endeavours to investigate the association
between the macroeconomic variables and and stock prices
during the period July 1997 to July 2015.
54
55
56
3.3.6. Sensex
Sensex is a leading index because it shows the situation of
the market and the overall economic situation of the country.
At the same time, it signifies the major and most impressive
companies in India. For that reason, sensex is considered as
most important economic indicator since it reveals what is
going to occur in the economy at some point.
3.3.7. Nifty
Nifty index is not merely a leading index however it is an
indicator of the flourishing Indian economy. In spite of the
current decelerate in the economic outlook the Nifty index has
maintained a usual development after conquering the
unexpected shock. This index has fascinated investors not
merely from the domestic market however also from foreign
countries. Therefore, nifty is considered as most important
economic indicator because it points out what is going to take
place in the economy at some point.
Mean
Median
Maximum
Minimum
Std. Dev.
Skewness
Kurtosis
Jarque-Bera
Probability
Observations
lcop
3.88981
4.06790
4.94164
2.41769
0.63414
-0.44484
1.99247
16.2585
0.00029
216
ler
3.87231
3.83789
4.18517
3.66854
0.12240
0.86881
2.93217
27.2154
0.0000
216
lgp
6.42996
6.445777
7.511251
5.544396
0.662573
0.116989
1.446214
22.22098
0.000015
216
lnfty
2.20412
2.221860
2.330454
2.072061
0.083803
-0.162512
1.443830
22.74576
0.000012
216
lrir
2.105116
2.074178
2.509762
1.629241
0.220383
0.153289
2.769451
1.324291
0.515744
216
lsx
9.09381
9.22449
10.2826
7.94117
0.75583
-0.10962
1.44134
22.2972
0.00001
216
lwpi
4.896833
4.869839
5.225209
3.561046
0.221334
-1.852850
13.18338
1056.901
0.000000
216
lcop
1
.883**
.000
.473**
.000
-.369**
.000
.363**
.000
.898**
.000
.904**
.000
lgp
ler
lrir
lwpi
lsx
lnfty
1
.607**
.000
-.249**
.000
.446**
.000
.937**
.000
.936**
.000
1
.014
.837
.595**
.000
.577**
.000
.563**
.000
1
-.265**
.000
-.207**
.002
-.215**
.002
1
.387**
.000
.380**
.000
1
0.997**
.000
57
loglik
1543.68206
1544.02670
1546.66524
1548.74508
1550.67921
p(LR)
0.95265
0.26003
0.38483
0.42413
AIC
-14.480399*
-14.445751
-14.432846
-14.414645
-14.395064
lsx
lgp
lcop
ler
lwpi
lrir
lnfty
Critical Values
1% level
5% level
10% level
At 1st Difference
-13.86328 (Stationary)
-16.74626 (Stationary)
-13.15422 (Stationary)
-12.86623 (Stationary)
-16.69276 (Stationary)
-8.873557 (Stationary)
-13.93940 (Stationary)
-3.460739
-2.874804
-2.573917
-3.460739
-2.874804
-2.573917
HQC
-14.377658*
-14.317325
-14.278735
-14.234850
-14.189583
0.05**
Max-Eigen*
0.05**
Statistic
Critical
Value
Statistic
Critical
Value
r0
184.75
125.62
106.89
r1
77.86
95.75
28.73
Null
Hypothesis
BIC
-14.226229*
-14.128039
-14.051592
-13.969849
-13.886725
r2
49.13
69.82
20.68
46.23
40.08
33.88
r3
28.45
47.86
13.62
27.58
r4
14.83
29.80
8.71
21.13
r5
6.12
15.49
5.48
14.26
r6
0.64
3.84
0.64
3.84
58
D(LCOP(-1))
D(LCOP(-2))
D(LER(-1))
D(LER(-2))
D(LGP(-1))
D(LGP(-2))
D(LNFTY(-1))
D(LNFTY(-2))
D(LRIR(-1))
D(LRIR(-2))
D(LSX(-1))
D(LSX(-2))
D(LCOP)
-0.011226
(0.01241)
[-0.9046]
0.086008
(0.08030)
[1.07108]
-0.007055
(0.07718)
[-0.09141]
0.217524
(0.33039)
[0.6584]
-0.220450
(0.33620)
[-0.65572]
-0.016357
(0.13507)
[-0.12110]
-0.253131
(0.13691)
[-1.84887]
-4.617877
(10.5136)
[-0.43923]
-12.76121
(10.4972)
[-1.21567]
0.401927
(0.16797)
[2.39286]
0.485804
(0.16756)
[2.8993]
0.325487
(1.18446)
[0.2748]
1.584637
D(LER)
0.004735
(0.0027)
[1.7734]
-0.014058
(0.0173)
[-0.8136]
0.004659
(0.0166)
[0.2805]
0.204789
(0.0711)
[2.8806]
-0.042307
(0.0723)
[-0.5848]
-0.028247
(0.0291)
[-0.9719]
0.058213
(0.0294)
[1.9759]
1.533598
(2.2623)
[0.6770]
0.298605
(2.2585)
[0.1320]
0.000428
(0.0364)
[0.0118]
-0.001156
(0.036)
[-0.0321]
-0.192031
(0.2549)
[-0.7534]
-0.042349
D(LGP)
0.010494
(0.0065)
[1.6274]
-0.075363
(0.0417)
[-1.8061]
-0.030367
(0.0401)
[-0.7572]
0.276693
(0.1717)
[1.6116]
-0.260222
(0.1747)
[-1.4895]
-0.107924
(0.0702)
[-1.5376]
-0.099119
(0.0711)
[-1.3932]
7.800421
(5.4633)
[1.4278]
-4.389192
(5.4542)
[-0.8045]
0.061749
(0.0878)
[0.7074]
0.384665
(0.087)
[4.4179]
-0.861559
(0.6155)
[-1.3998]
0.583455
D(LNFTY)
0.000575
(0.0011)
[0.5279]
0.010797
(0.0071)
[1.5316]
-6.46E-05
(0.0068)
[-0.0095]
0.057934
(0.0290)
[1.9975]
-0.042202
(0.0295)
[-1.4299]
0.000394
(0.0119)
[0.0332]
0.007491
(0.0120)
[0.6232]
-0.526811
(0.9229)
[-0.5700]
0.942522
(0.9210)
[1.0221]
0.003994
(0.0145)
[0.2709]
0.030128
(0.0147)
[2.0482]
0.058008
(0.1039)
[0.5579]
-0.093740
D(LRIR)
-0.013534
(0.00545)
[-2.4815]
0.037352
(0.03529)
[1.05835]
-0.010884
(0.03392)
[-0.32086]
-0.004952
(0.14521)
[-0.03410]
-0.039331
(0.14776)
[-0.26618]
-0.119540
(0.05936)
[-2.01369]
-0.060686
(0.06017)
[-1.00851]
-0.860830
(4.62078)
[-0.18630]
-2.506605
(4.61358)
[-0.54331]
-0.058787
(0.07382)
[-0.79632]
0.164459
(0.07364)
[2.2332]
0.124897
(0.52058)
[0.23992]
0.380164
D(LSX)
0.004585
(0.00966)
[0.4746]
0.090016
(0.06252)
[1.43985]
-0.003339
(0.06009)
[-0.05557]
0.553280
(0.25722)
[2.15099]
-0.384467
(0.26174)
[-1.46887]
-0.004155
(0.10516)
[-0.03951]
0.069822
(0.10659)
[0.65504]
-4.420173
(8.18529)
[-0.54001]
7.969100
(8.17255)
[0.97511]
0.052871
(0.13077)
[0.40430]
0.280388
(0.13045)
[2.1494]
0.493427
(0.92216)
[0.53508]
-0.793949
D(LWPI)
-0.119683
(0.0211)
[-5.6739]
0.298777
(0.1365)
[2.1889]
0.138993
(0.1312)
[1.0595]
-1.352261
(0.5616)
[-2.4078]
-0.462768
(0.5715)
[-0.8098]
0.514633
(0.2296)
[2.2414]
-0.231422
(0.2327)
[-0.9944]
27.83957
(17.872)
[1.5576]
3.703942
(17.848)
[0.2078]
-0.260404
(0.2852)
[-0.912]
0.150440
(0.2848)
[0.5282]
-3.296339
(2.0134)
[-1.6372]
-0.103580
Error Correction:
D(LWPI(-1))
D(LWPI(-2))
D(LCOP)
(1.18194)
[1.3407]
0.005564
(0.04969)
[0.11199]
0.010019
(0.04114)
[0.24352]
D(LER)
(0.2543)
[-0.1665]
-0.004834
(0.0107)
[-0.4521]
-0.018200
(0.0088)
[-2.0558]
D(LGP)
(0.6142)
[0.9499]
-0.036926
(0.0258)
[-1.4301]
-0.038168
(0.0214)
[-1.7852]
D(LNFTY)
(0.1038)
[-0.9035]
-0.002173
(0.0044)
[-0.4982]
-0.001784
(0.0036)
[-0.4938]
D(LRIR)
(0.51947)
[0.73183]
0.037556
(0.02184)
[1.71973]
0.000264
(0.01808)
[0.0146]
59
D(LSX)
(0.92019)
[-0.86281]
-0.014355
(0.03868)
[-0.37108]
-0.015668
(0.03203)
[-0.4891]
D(LWPI)
(2.0091)
[-0.0515]
-0.297363
(0.0845)
[-3.5206]
-0.087338
(0.0699)
[-1.2488]
60
LNFTY
0.000000
1.495021
1.399010
LRIR
0.000000
1.208778
4.441996
LSX
0.000000
0.016117
0.353691
LWPI
0.000000
0.208504
0.323667
LNFTY
0.000000
0.247982
0.553670
LRIR
0.000000
0.000172
0.001021
LSX
0.000000
0.108014
0.199698
LWPI
0.000000
0.548392
0.437720
LNFTY
0.000000
0.001972
0.092809
LRIR
0.000000
0.185994
4.759600
LSX
0.000000
0.466091
0.332190
LWPI
0.000000
0.026326
0.046660
LNFTY
88.15865
81.67435
77.77854
LRIR
0.000000
0.033066
1.093041
LSX
0.000000
0.084699
0.071954
LWPI
0.000000
0.000809
0.012627
LNFTY
7.094081
5.624334
3.498933
LRIR
86.57698
84.48705
82.91957
LSX
0.000000
0.002572
0.194800
LWPI
0.000000
0.263919
1.694775
LNFTY
87.60563
80.99572
77.22129
LRIR
0.002553
0.073532
1.320795
LSX
0.584545
0.912337
0.649052
LWPI
0.000000
0.004756
0.012783
LNFTY
0.172375
0.204574
1.204656
LRIR
1.532735
3.531559
3.638174
LSX
0.554041
2.909010
3.488757
LWPI
95.53085
87.74935
86.37276
61
sensex and crude oil price, (iii) nifty and gold price, (iv)
sensex and gold price, (v) nifty and real interest rates, (vi)
sensex and real interest rates, (vii) nifty and wholesale price
index and (viii) sensex and wholesale price index because the
probability was more than 0.05 in one direction and less than
0.05 in other direction. As a result, pairwise causal connection
between the selected macroeconomic variables and stock
market in India reflects that trend in one variable was not the
responsible for trend in other variable under study. Thus, the
present study may wrap up that causal connection is simply a
trend of the preferred data as argued by Awe (2012).
Type of Causality
Unidirectional causality
Unidirectional causality
No causality
No causality
Unidirectional causality
Unidirectional causality
Unidirectional causality
Unidirectional causality
Unidirectional causality
Unidirectional causality
F-Statistic
5.19766
3.15460
5.48380
2.77965
0.29244
3.41753
0.30777
3.61343
0.46059
5.37977
0.62124
5.24658
3.98477
2.99298
0.03337
9.70955
2.82281
3.73568
0.08019
10.1075
Note: Decision rule: reject H0 if P-value < 0.05, DNR = Do not reject; = does not Granger cause.
Prob.
0.0236
0.0771
0.0201
0.0969
0.5892
0.0659
0.5796
0.0587
0.4981
0.0213
0.4315
0.0230
0.0472
0.0851
0.8552
0.0021
0.0944
0.0446
0.7773
0.0017
Decision
reject H0
DNR H0
reject H0
DNR H0
DNR H0
DNR H0
DNR H0
DNR H0
DNR H0
reject H0
DNR H0
reject H0
reject H0
DNR H0
DNR H0
reject H0
DNR H0
DNR H0
DNR H0
reject H0
62
5. Conclusion
The effect of selected macroeconomic variables shocks on
the stock market of India would be survived if sensex and nifty
are significantly associated with the selected macroeconomic
variables during the study period. The selected time series data
were stationary at I(1) that is a pointer of the cointegration test
and causality and to find out the affiliation among all the
chosen variables in the long run. The cointegration test results
illustrate that unrestricted cointegration affiliation among the
chosen variables in this study existed in one cointegrated
vector using optimum lag length in the long-run period. It
confirms that Indias stock market was persuaded significantly
by gold price, crude oil price, exchange rates, real interest
rates and wholesale price index during the period under study.
Again, there was a unidirectional causal connection between
nifty and crude oil price, sensex and crude oil price, nifty and
gold price, sensex and gold price, nifty and real interest rates,
sensex and real interest rates, nifty and wholesale price index
and sensex and wholesale price index. The impulse response
functions exemplify that the sensex and nifty reactions to
shocks on crude oil prices, exchanges rates, real interest rates
and whole prices indices were positive while a negative shock
from sensex and nifty to real interest was noticed. Variance
decomposition test results indicate that international crude oil
price and exchange rates reflected the maximum comparative
liberty of their individual forecast error variance elucidated
respectively followed by domestic gold price, wholesale price
index, real interest rates, nifty and sensex. These results were
not contradicted with the economic policy of India because
Indias stock widely fluctuated on account of less foreign
investment and lack of confidence of the investors was
observed on account of financial crisis.
References
[1]
[2]
[6]
[7]
[8]
[9]
[3]
[4]
[5]
63