Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Internet IA Best Practice Analysis Dec 08 Egov Version PDF
Internet IA Best Practice Analysis Dec 08 Egov Version PDF
December 2008
Table of Contents
1. Executive Summary........................................................................................6
1.1
Best practices...................................................................................6
1.2
2. Introduction ...................................................................................................9
2.1
2.2
Approach .........................................................................................9
2.3
2.4
3. Background ..................................................................................................10
3.1
eGovernment ................................................................................. 10
3.1.1 Domains of eGovernment ....................................................... 10
3.1.2 Models of eGovernment evolution ............................................ 10
3.2
4.2
4.3
4.4
4.5
Page 2 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
5.2
5.3
5.4
5.5
5.6
Content ......................................................................................... 37
6.1.1 Health conditions and treatments resources .............................. 37
6.1.2 Index of services ................................................................... 38
6.2
6.3
Page 3 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
Bibliography ....................................................................................................42
Appendices ......................................................................................................44
Appendix A. Model of the domains of eGovernment ..................................... 44
6.3.2 Improving Government Processes: eAdministration.................... 44
6.3.3 Connecting Citizens: eCitizens and eServices............................. 44
6.3.4 Building External Interactions: eSociety .................................... 44
Appendix B. Best Practice Principles for Government (non IA)........................ 45
Website Content Best Practices......................................................... 45
6.3.5 Purpose-written content ......................................................... 45
6.3.6 Information is accurate, current and up-to-date......................... 45
6.3.7 Multilingual support................................................................ 46
6.3.8 Appropriate style of language .................................................. 46
6.3.9 Pyramid & chunking content.................................................... 46
Page 4 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
Acronyms/special terms
The following acronyms/terms are used within this document:
Term
Definition
API
Chrome features
Desktop Research
An informal research activity involving the accessing of information from published resources and
non-published sources.
IA
Information Architecture
MPO
Multi-player online
WMAS
Page 5 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
1. Executive Summary
This document records findings from the internet best practice analysis activity conducted by the
Information Architecture (IA) Strategy project team within the Web Domain Group, DHS. The best
practices outlined in this document will be used as a reference point for the project team to help ensure
the work produced by the IA Strategy project meets recognised best practices in the internet sector.
While this document was produced with the DHS internet presence in mind, it could serve as a useful
reference for other government departments and associated bodies.
A summary of the best practices identified in this document is below, follow by details of online trends
identified in the human services sector.
It should be noted that in order to be effective, best practice principles should be reviewed regularly.
1.1
Best practices
Section
A user-centred approach should be adopted to ensure the websites are easy and efficient to
use for all users.
4.1.1
An iterative design process should be adopted so that problems are identified early on and
user feedback can be incorporated throughout the process.
4.1.2
4.2.3
Section
The structure of a website should be based on tasks or topics, not by organisational structure.
Websites should incorporate cross-linking between different areas of the site. This will ensure
users wont have to move up and down the site structure to get to related information and
promotes discoverability. It also facilitates indexing of content by search engines and
improves usability.
4.2.1
4.2.2
Users should be able to arrive at the same content through a number of different paths. This
helps to accommodate the different mental models of different users.
4.2.3
4.2.4
Navigation should be easy to find, should appear in a consistent position and should appear
visually different to other links and buttons.
4.2.5
Section
Interactive elements should have a consistent look and behaviour and use consistent
terminology throughout the site.
There are a number of best practice guidelines for online forms, including: indicating which
fields are required; grouping related fields; providing tab support and providing informative
error messages.
User errors should be anticipated where possible. When a user makes an error, this should be
handled proactively.
4.3.1
4.3.2
4.3.3
Page 6 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
Pop-up windows should only be used when appropriate, such as when the user needs to look
at content in the original and new windows at the same time.
4.3.4
A warning should be provided when links open in a new window, and the number of open
windows should be kept to a minimum
4.3.4
The interface should be user-friendly: easy to learn, efficient to use, easy to remember,
pleasant to use and should be designed to minimise user errors
4.3.5
Section
A homepage should incorporate the two most important functions of a homepage: to deliver
the content that users are seeking and to provide the user with a strong scent to the pages
with the information they are seeking.
Page titles should be short, precise and self-contained using keywords critical to the content
on the page. Homepage titles should include critical keywords for the site, content page titles
should use the pages main heading.
The text, colour and style for links should be carefully chosen to minimise confusion and to
increase usability and accessibility (Blue underline for links and purple underline for visited
links).
At a minimum, navigation and key content should be provided in other languages. Links and
contact information for translated resources and translating services should be provided.
4.4.1
4.4.2
4.4.3
4.4.4
Section
Branding, including the logo, tagline, colours fonts and key graphics, should be consistent
across the website. Logos in particular should be designed to be recognisable at low
resolutions.
4.5.1
The visual design and content should encourage users to trust the website. Trust and
transparency are critical for the success of citizen-centric eGovernment.
4.5.2
The chosen font should be readable on computer screens, resizable and have good contrast.
4.5.3
Section
The search facility should have a clear and simple interface and be available throughout the
site. The search input box should be a minimum of 30 characters wide.
4.6.1
4.6.2
Search results should be clear and easily scannable. The amount of detail should be kept to a
minimum and the descriptions should be meaningful.
4.6.3
4.6.4
4.6.5
Most relevant search results should be shown first. The search results should be high
precision, low recall.
4.6.6
1.2
A desktop review of human services sector websites around the world resulted in the following
observations of trends in the content, features and structure of these sites.
Page 7 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
A number of sites visited were found to provide the following interactive features:
In terms of website structure, a number of government bodies within and outside of the human services
sector were found to separate customer-targeted content and organisational content. This often involves
providing a customer-targeted portal site which does not include official documentation like policy,
legislation and strategies. An example of such a site is www.direct.gov.uk.
Page 8 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
2. Introduction
2.1
Purpose of Document
The purpose of this document is to record findings from the web IA best practice analysis
activity conducted by the IA Strategy project team in May October 2008. This document forms
part of the Consultation and Analysis Finding and Recommendations Report.
Throughout the IA Strategy project, and in particular during design phases of the project, the
best practices outlined in this document will be used as a reference point to ensure the work
produced by the IA Strategy project meets recognised best practices in the sector.
The IA Strategy project team conducted this best practice analysis activity to build on the
preliminary best practice analysis work undertaken for the WMAS project (see the Web
Governance Model Implementation Plan document).
2.2
Approach
Desktop research was conducted to produce the best practices outlined in this document. The
project team conducted desktop research and examined over 65 Human Services sector
websites, government websites and other websites to examine for use of best practice principles
in IA and eGovernment. This document does not include coverage of other important userinteraction concepts such as feedback management and service standards pertaining to emails
from the public.
A list of research sources consulted can be found in the Bibliography.
In addition, Stamford has drawn on extensive previous experience creating and redeveloping
websites for both government and private sector clients and has a well established knowledgebase on international best practice in IA. Stamford is a regular supplier of internet usability
services to clients including the Australian Taxation Office, AGIMO, BUPA Australia (HBA), the
National Library, CPA Australia, William Angliss TAFE, Gippsland TAFE, Medicare Australia and
others.
2.3
Intended Audience
The intended audience for this document is the IA Strategy project team, the IA Strategy
project board, website owners and any other interested parties.
2.4
Development of a thematic DHS website architecture for the entire DHS web presence
(including Internet and Intranet) through stakeholder consultation and analysis,
investigation of best practice, and analysis of other government initiatives.
An understanding of user requirements for interactive tools such as e-Forms and search
capability.
Validation of the new information architecture by undertaking user walkthroughs and other
iterative design activities including the development of mock-ups and visual designs.
Page 9 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
3. Background
A government's web presence is the principle enabler for an eGovernment initiative. To provide some
context for the role of the web for government, this section provides a brief overview of the drivers for
and areas of influence of eGovernment initiatives. This is followed by a model for gauging the level of
eGovernment maturity of an organisation and a brief description of the impact of Web 2.0 on
eGovernment.
3.1
eGovernment
3.1.1
Domains of eGovernment
The Gartner group describes eGovernment as the continuous optimization of service delivery,
constituency participation, and governance by transforming internal and external relationships
through technology, the Internet, and new media (Gartner Group 2000).
The following model, adapted at the University of Manchester (Heeks 2002) from an earlier
KPMG model, categorises eGovernment initiatives into one of the following three domains:
The model covers the areas of activity covered by Gartners definition, and is explained in more
detail in the Appendices to this document.
3.1.2
Page 10 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
3.2
3.2.1
Values
Application
Technologies
Operational model of Web 2.0 (ECJRC 2008:17, adapted from OReilly and Forrester Research)
The underlying values indicated are of particular importance, as they describe a dramatic shift
from the previous use of the internet as primarily an information delivery mechanism.
The user as a producer value reflects the use of the knowledge and skills of users to improve
applications (or website content) and in many cases develop services themselves.
Collective intelligence is shown through the peer reviewing, collaboration and networking
offered by users.
Perpetual beta describes the practice of releasing applications early to include user feedback,
and often to continuously improve the service based on user feedback.
3.2.2
Producing content
2.
3.
4.
An important point to note here is that the use of Web 2.0 applications is of benefit not only to
the small percentage of users that contribute and offer ratings and reviews but also to the
internet using population in general who benefit from the contributions, reviews, ratings,
bookmarks and browsing of others.
Page 11 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
3.2.3
Knowledge management
Cross-agency collaboration
Connecting citizens
Service provision
Regulation
Cross-agency collaboration
Adapted from (ECJRC 2008)
The impact of Web 2.0 is most prominent in the field of political participation. Some applications
are provided by the government directly. Others applications are provided by individuals and
groups outside of government to have a political impact or to complement government services.
Following are some examples of the use of Web 2.0 in Government:
www.safeas.govt.nz/smf/
A critical component of the National Road Safety Committee pre-policy stakeholder
engagement workshops in New Zealand was the Safe As Road Safety Forum. The forum is an
online discussion board for stakeholders to engage the Ministry of Transport and each other in
a discussion about road safety policy for New Zealand.
Service provision
www.nhs.uk
UK National Health site providing health information and connection to services. Uses mashups
with online mapping and public transport services. Users are encouraged to provide feedback
on health services which is displayed to visitors to the site.
Cross-agency collaboration
www.caisa.ca
Wiki to enable the coordinated delivery of services to homeless people in the California area.
Page 12 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
4.1
4.1.1
unfavourable ideas are ruled out before it is too late (and too costly) to change
it ensures that the final product truly matches the way that users want to interact with
the website and the organisation it represents
a thorough understanding of what users need from the website and what they will
actually do with it in real life is gained, avoiding outcomes that do not represent the real
needs of the business or the key user requirements.
4.1.1.1
A user-centred approach to website design also aligns with the broader move by governments
around the world, including the Victorian Government 4 , towards citizen- and business-centric
models of service delivery (UN 2008:73; Ecotec 2007; Varney 2006). Citizen/business
involvement in the design of both offline and online government services is recommended
(Varney 2006).
1
Jakob Nielsen PhD is co-founder of the Nielsen Norman Group and a world renowned usability expert. His biography may be found here
http://www.useit.com/jakob/
2
Louis Rosenfeld is an independent and internationally recognised information architect. His biography may be found here
http://louisrosenfeld.com/biography/
3
http://www.finance.gov.au/e-government/better-practice-and-collaboration/better-practice-checklists/intranet.html
http://www.egov.vic.gov.au/index.php?env=-categories:m1514-1-1-8-0-0
Page 13 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
The European Union conducted a 24 month study of eGovernment initiatives in Europe, and
explores the methods that governments have worked towards similar goals to make their
presence more user-centric (Ecotec 2007). They underline the importance of an improved
understanding of user needs and explain that for best results it should be an iterative process
(Ecotec 2007:21). They report that the following methods are commonly employed to
understand user needs:
4.1.2
Profiles relating to the needs and characteristics of typical users, known as personas.
4.1.3
http://www.ogc.gov.uk/index.asp
Page 14 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
4.2
4.2.1
4.2.1.1
As mentioned in section 3.1.2, Sir David Varney (2006) recommends the grouping of
government services around themes that are meaningful to citizens and businesses. It follows
naturally that this thematic grouping would flow through to a governments website structure.
We can see that this is precisely what governments worldwide have been doing. In the recent
edition of the United Nations review of global eGovernment capabilities, they state that
integrated service offerings that hide, simplify or transcend the traditional machinery of
government have become a centrepiece of eGovernment project[s] (UN 2008:71).
Governments have been moving away from an online structure that reflects the internal
departmental, divisional and agency structure.
4.2.2
http://www.usability.gov/design/define.html
http://www.boxesandarrows.com/view/card_sorting_a_definitive_guide
http://www.searchengineguide.com/scott-allen/the-importance-of-internal-linking.php
http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.com/2008/10/importance-of-link-architecture.html
Page 15 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
Cross-linking may also take the form of simple text links within a paragraph. Some sites are
now introducing a dotted underline link that when clicked or moused-over provides additional
information in the form of a text box on the same page (like an alt tag). For example, an article
might mention the name of an organisation and the mouse-over would reveal relevant details
about that organisation, providing background to the story without the user having to leave the
page they are on and thus maintain their workflow. This is not strictly cross-linking as users are
not taken elsewhere in the hierarchy but it is mentioned here for completeness. It should be
noted it remains a very new form of interaction that requires further study as to its acceptance
by users.
4.2.3
4.2.4
4.2.5
10
http://trovabile.org/download/information-architecture-for-public-administration.pdf
Page 16 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
4.3
4.3.1
4.3.2
Use top aligned labels to help reduce completion times and when the data being inputted
by the user is familiar to them
To indicate required/optional fields, text indication is best (e.g. place the word
(optional) beside the label). For indicating required fields, using an asterisk often works.
Field length
o
When possible, use field length as an affordance (to help indicate the type or amount of
data input required of the user)
Otherwise, design a consistent length that provides enough room for inputs.
Content grouping
o
Use the minimum amount of visual elements necessary to communicate the groupings
and/or other relationships.
Form actions
o
Reset, Cancel, and Go Back are secondary actions (they rarely need to be used if at all)
Save, Continue, and Submit are primary actions (directly responsible for form
completion)
Aim to minimise the amount of help and tips users require to fill out a form
Help that is visible and adjacent to an input field (contextual help) is most useful
When lots of unfamiliar data is being requested, consider using a dynamic help system
(for example, automatic inline help, user activated inline help, user activated section
help).
Path to completion
Page 17 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Allow for flexible data entry (for example, accept different formats for entering a
telephone number: 03 9486 9536 and (03)94869536 are both valid)
For multi-page forms, show a progress indicator and provide a save action.
Tabbing Support
o
Consider how users will expect the tab order to flow when laying out a form.
Inline Validation
o
Use inline validation for inputs that have potentially high error rates
Action progress
o
Submission
o
For government websites, designing online forms to best practices is imperative to ensure best
possible accessibility (in the widest sense) of the form.
Within the web design industry, influential sites such as eBay, Yahoo! and Facebook are held in
esteem for their form interaction design practices.
4.3.3
Error handling
User errors on websites should be anticipated where possible, and where a user does make an
error, this should always be handled proactively. Handling user errors proactively helps to avoid
user frustration and increase comprehension of the problem at hand. User errors occur not only
when completing online forms, but also when navigating through a site. Websites should be
designed and optimised to reduce error. Information architecture should be user-friendly,
unambiguous and supportive to the needs of users.
When users need to be notified of an error they have made, Jakob Nielsen11 and Luke
Wroblewski 12 recommend the error message:
o
11
12
http://www.lukew.com/resources/articles/WebForms_LukeW.pdf
Page 18 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
When an error occurs within an online form, the error should be visually associated with fields
where an error has been identified.
4.3.4
The user can look at and use the original window and the new window at the same time.
The user can use the original window as a launching pad if there are many links of
interest in the original window.
Disadvantages include:
Pop-up windows or new browser windows can be a surprise for the user and can result
in confusion or not even realising a new window has been opened.
In some browsers, the browser back button does not work in the new window.
Opening many pop-ups can slow down the user's computer or even crash it (although
this is becoming a lesser issue as computer performance improves).
Warning that a link will open a new window. This can be done using a symbol, or adding
text such as opens in a new window to the link's title. The use of a dialogue box to
notify users that they are leaving the current site is not recommended.
Minimise the number of open windows - for example if the help page is already open
don't open another copy.
Using simple HTML code rather than javascript to open the new window or less
preferable is ensuring accessible pop-up windows.
The new window should include some standard browser features (commonly called the
chrome features). At a minimum the standard buttons, address and status bar.
While it is ideal (and most accessible) to include the warning about the link opening in a new
window as part of the link itself, there are other ways this warning can be handled. The
Department of Justice (Victoria) website provides this warning prior to a link or group of links to
publications or external sites.
Pop-up windows can be made accessible with the careful use of HTML and javascript.
When is it appropriate to enforce opening links in a new window? The most common examples
are:
A new window for help enables the user to stay focussed on their workflow, for example
completing a transaction or filling in a form. In these cases, they dont want to navigate away
from what they are doing so a new window provides them with the information they need while
letting them stay where they are. If the help provided is a short paragraph or less, then
dynamic tooltips may be better than a new window, depending on the information provided and
the task at hand.
Likewise, terms and conditions or a privacy policy may also be provided in a new window
(should users click on these when filling in a form for example) so that the process is not
interrupted or information in the form lost (thus risking the user bailing out of the process
completely).
Page 19 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Although linking to PC-native documents is not recommended, if this must be done then open
the document in a new window and remove the browser tool bar. Jakob Nielsen believes it is
even better to prevent the browser from opening it in the first place. He suggests giving the
user the choice of opening an application or saving the file 13 .
Smashingmagazine.com suggests that when the link leads to a large file (an image for example)
which takes time to load that opening it in a new window allows users to focus on your content
while the image is being loaded in the background 14 .
4.3.5
User-friendly interface
A user-friendly interface has many aspects, summarised by Nielsen as 15 :
1.
Easy to learn: The user can quickly go from not knowing the website to achieving their
goals or tasks by interacting with it.
2.
Efficient to use: Once the user has learned the website, a high level of productivity is
possible.
3.
Easy to remember: Infrequent users are able to return to the site after some period of
not having used it, without having to learn everything all over (assuming there have
been no changes).
4.
Few errors: Users do not make many errors using the site, or if they do make errors
they can easily recover from them.
5.
Pleasant to use: Users are subjectively satisfied by using the site; they like it.
4.4
4.4.1
Homepage
It has been said many times that the homepage is the most valuable real estate on any website.
It is here that users get an understanding of what the site does and whether it will have any
relevance to them often deciding in a matter of seconds whether they will follow a link on your
site or go back to where they came from and try somewhere else. While it is true that for many
users a site will live or die by its homepage, thanks to the increasing pervasiveness of Googles
and other sites use of deep-linking to external pages of relevance, many users wont see a
homepage and instead will find themselves linked straight to a content page within the site. In
fact, a 2008 study by Jakob Nielsen showed only 25% of users travel via a homepage. 16
This doesnt mean ignore your homepage and concentrate design on the content pages.
Instead, recognise this phenomena and design for it. Jared Spool, a leading internationally
recognised usability expert concurs, arguing that the landing pages, meaning the first page on a
site that a user sees, has to perform the same functions as a homepage:
That turns out to be a lot easier than many designers think, mostly because they usually
dont really understand the true functions of a home page.
In studying users visiting sites, we learned a long time ago that there are only two important
functions for a home page:
The home page delivers the content to [users] that they are seekingsuch as the top
story on CNNor
The home page provides strong scent to those pages that contain the content the user
seeks.
Those are the only two things users care about on a home page. (Lots of designers try to
make the home page serve other functions, such as [telling] the user about things the
13 http://www.useit.com/alertbox/open_new_windows.html
14 http://www.smashingmagazine.com/2008/07/01/should-links-open-in-new-windows/
15 Nielsen, J. Usability Engineering. Academic Press, San Diego, CA, 1993.
16 http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/7417496.stm
Page 20 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
organization cares about, but the user doesntsuch as financial news about the business or
what new products are on salebut users blow right past this content and pay no attention
to it. Weve found its all a waste of valuable design resources.) When designers focus on just
these two things on the home page, users tell us the site is substantially more usable. 17
4.4.2
The page title is an essential role from a search point of view, as the majority of search
engines index the page title and display it as the title of the page in the search results,
making it the first thing a user sees.
The page title is visible in the title bar of the browser window.
The page title is also used when the page is bookmarked by a browser.
On a homepage it is recommended the page title should include the critical keywords that
indicate what site the user is entering: Microsoft - home. On a content page, using the pages
main heading (<H1>) as the page title is recommended, as the heading best describes what is
on the page.
Page titles should be short, precise and self-contained (as it will be seen in search engine
results).
4.4.3
Link text
Link text is the term used to describe words used on a web page to link to another web page or
document. Writing descriptive link text is important for the following reasons:
Descriptive link text incorporating relevant keywords lets users know what information
they can expect if they click the link.
When scanning web pages, users scan links to help them find what they are looking for.
Descriptive link text helps them quickly understand the breadth of content on the page.
Some screen readers can scan a web page for vision impaired users by reading out loud
just the link text on the page. Descriptive link text helps visually impaired users to
quickly comprehend content on the page. Several repetitions of Click here and
nothing else would not help anyone understand what the page is about.
Non-descriptive link text such as "Click here" or "more..." are ambiguous and force
users to infer its probable destination.
Creating descriptive link text means describing clearly and succinctly the information available
at the links destination.
Visual representation of link text is also highly important. Jakob Nielsen recommends 18 links
should be coloured and underlined to achieve the best perceived affordance of clickability.
Qualifying this, Nielsen adds that assuming the link text is coloured, it's not always absolutely
necessary to underline it navigation menus and lists of links being the exceptions. Other link
text recommendations from Nielsen include:
Don't underline any text that's not a link. Reserve underlining for links.
Use different colours for visited and unvisited links. The two colours should be variants
or shades of the same colour, so that they're clearly related.
Shades of blue provide the strongest signal for links, but other colours work almost as
well.
Never show text in your chosen link colours unless it's a link.
There is no need to use special colours or other visualizations when the cursor hovers
over a link.
17 http://www.uxmatters.com/MT/archives/000212.php
18
http://www.useit.com/alertbox/20040503.html
Page 21 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Link colour on an intranet can be a special case. Showing listed links in blue or in the
site's main link colour is the recommended design.
The link text must include the file type and size if it targets a downloadable file (e.g.
PDF)
Links should contrast in colour with any surrounding text, and be underlined to stand
out visually when located within regular text
4.5
4.5.1
Consistent branding
Consistent branding across a website helps project a consistent concept and tone. Branding
consists of a logo, brand name, tagline, colours, fonts and key graphics. Corporate branding
guidelines for online branding must incorporate online best practices, including:
4.5.2
Preferably a blue-toned link colour. If this is unacceptable, use a strong colour that
matches the main corporate colour (not black, white or grey).
A useful secondary palette containing some colours with sufficient colour contrast
against white that let you use them on the web.
A sans-serif typeface. If the main typeface is serif then a secondary one is required for
web content.
A logo that is clear at low resolutions and its use online has been taken into account. For
example, insisting on vast areas of white space around the logo is wasteful on a
website.
Engender trust
Engendering trust online can be encouraged through site design and provision of trustenhancing information. Designing a site to match the ethos of the organisation it represents will
help to engender trust in its users. Similarly, establishing, publishing (and adhering to) a
privacy statement may help alleviate any users concerns over use of information provided by
them. Above all, users will come to trust a website if they feel the organisation has the users
best interests at heart and that the organisation is not trying to hide anything from the user.
Trust and transparency are critical for successful citizen-centric eGovernment (Ecotec 2007).
Governments must ensure that they address user fears regarding the security and use of the
personal data they supply. Engaging users in participation online is one way to establish trust
(Ecotec 2007:17, UN 2008:91).
In addressing trust and transparency concerns with government services online, Estonia has
gone as far as to allow citizens to log on and see which ministries have accessed their private
data and for what purpose. The Netherlands provide an e-citizen charter, which outlines the
expectations and responsibilities of both the government and the citizen 20 .
4.5.3
19
20
http://www.visionaustralia.org.au/docs/news_events/Ten%20tips%20for%20a%20more%20accessible%20website.doc
http://www.govtech.com/gt/articles/104894
Page 22 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
4.6
4.6.1
Go
Other choices such as drop down options have been shown to cause confusion and
misunderstandings for users, however sometimes it is appropriate to offer a choice of content to
search.
Independent experts agree that where the choice is between two (say for example, search
whole site or search products) then the choice should be indicated by a radio button; if the
choice is between three (there should be no need to offer more than three), then a dropdown
list should be used. These controls should be placed before the search box and clearly labelled
4.6.3
21
http://www.ahfx.net/weblog.php?article=135
22
http://www.useit.com/alertbox/20050509.html
Page 23 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Search results pages can often provide too much information to the user. For example, size in
bytes, links to other similar matches, and relevance expressed as a percentage. Scanning
search results can be made easier by limiting the detail provided for each result. AGIMO
recommend providing the following details for each search result:
4.6.5
Pages may use a range of words for the one subject, so any search using one term will
miss the results from pages using other terms.
Users for whom English is not their first language may misspell or enter foreign
language terms into search facilities.
These can be resolved by implementing a list of synonyms in the search engine. When the user
enters a term, it is looked up in the synonym list and any equivalent words are also included in
the search terms. In this way, the desired information can be found even if the search terms do
not exactly match the content of the pages.
Page 24 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Synonyms can also be used to increase the extent to which users from culturally and
linguistically diverse backgrounds can access the resources on the site. By providing, in the
synonym list, terms in other languages spoken by target groups, foreign language terms
entered can retrieve English language resources, and vice versa.
Consider stemming and fuzzy matching
Stemming and fuzzy matching are designed to provide matches even when the user does not
enter exactly the same terms as those used in the pages. While they can be useful, they can
also have the side effect of considerably increasing the number of search results returned and
may reduce the overall quality of matches.
Stemming involves a search engine automatically adding different endings to the words
entered. For example, walk would also find walks, walked and walking. This can be useful
for managing inconsistencies in the documents being searched, as well as address the
differences between Australian/British spelling and North American spelling.
Fuzzy matching is the name given to the general class of options that matches words that
sound like those entered by the user. The specific method of doing this varies between search
tools and is referred to by different names (soundex, phonetic matching, etc). Fuzzy matches
are best presented as suggestions, rather than being automatically applied, to avoid topic drift.
For example, a soundex algorithm rates lion, lean, lan, lawn, lane and logan (among many
others) as equivalent to loan.
Help users recover from spelling or typographical errors
A 2004 study of BBC search engine records found that one in 12 search terms were misspelled.
Search engines should account for common spelling and typographical errors to increase the
chance of a search success (Galitz 2007:249).
4.6.6
Page 25 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
5.1
5.1.1
consistent navigation
Page 26 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
5.2
5.2.1
Directgov, UK
www.direct.gov.uk acts as a portal to the breadth of UK services at all levels of
government and also provides extensive content on a variety of topics. The site structure
exhibits most of the features associated with site structure best practice:
Multiple paths to content are provided users can browse by subject or browse
by people.
Category labels are clear and mutually exclusive. Examples of the most significant
subcategories displayed under each category assist the understanding of the
labels.
The site navigation appears consistently (for all pages beneath the home page)
and has a distinct appearance from normal links.
Page 27 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
5.2.2
NHS Choices, UK
The UKs NHS Choices site (www.nhs.uk) provides an extensive resource on a variety of
health topics and also helps to connect people with services. The site is a good example
of content cross-linking.
The page pictured at left is from the section on arthritis. The useful links section on the
right of the page provides links to related topics elsewhere on the site and externally. The
find a service feature also appears in a number of places throughout the site.
Page 28 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
5.3
5.3.1
Amazon
The online store www.amazon.com is a good example of the consistent design of
interactive elements and has a user-friendly interface.
Buttons, form elements and clickable icons are always in the same position and
have a consistent behaviour.
o
The site header, which includes the search box, shopping cart, access to
account details and the shop departments appears on every page.
Page 29 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
5.3.2
Yahoo
The account signup form for the portal www.yahoo.com demonstrates best practice in the
areas of online form design and error handling:
Form labels are top aligned. They are also right aligned as vertical space is
constrained in order to avoid scrolling.
Field lengths are used an affordance. For example, the postcode field is shorter
than those for first and last names.
Form help and tips are minimal. If they are needed, they appear next to the
relevant field as it comes into focus.
The form provides support for tabbing, and the tab order of fields is sensible.
While the required fields are not indicated initially, if the form is completed
incorrectly the required fields are highlighted and the nature of the error is stated
next to the field, ie. This information is required. The form could be improved by
placing the word optional next to the one optional field, which is the Alternative
email address.
Fields in the form are arranged into groups such as Tell us about yourself and
Select an ID and password
The button for the primary action, Create my account is given more visual
importance than the Cancel button, which represents a secondary action.
Page 30 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
5.4
5.4.1
5.4.2
All page titles are meaningful and match the major heading of the page.
Link text is always descriptive and underlining is only used for linked text.
The font colour used for linked text is reserved only for text that is linked.
Different colours are used for visited and unvisited links (although the difference
in hue is difficult to discern).
The site content is written in a style of language that is appropriate for the
general public. Being a website for legal and justice related information, an area
often plagued by legalese and jargon, this is particularly important.
Page 31 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
Content on the NSW Department of Housing site is well-written and demonstrates the
following best practices:
5.5
5.5.1
Content is written in the active voice which makes sentences simpler in structure.
Concise copy means page lengths are generally short which minimises scrolling.
Use of bulleted lists to help users scan though text on the page
Page titles are meaningful and generally succinct. Page titles also match the
major heading of the page.
Link text is descriptive and underlining is only used for linked text. However, link
text for PDFs is not dealt with in a consistent way. In some instances the link text
includes the file size of the document, while in other places, the file size is not
included. It is not always made clear that a link leads to a downloadable
document.
The font colour used for linked text is only used for linked text. However, in
contrast to best practice principles, different colours are not used for visited and
unvisited links on this website.
The style of language used in this website is suitable for the general public.
Sentences are generally short and succinct and the tone is genial.
Information appears to be current and up-to-date (at the time of review, the most
recent news item was less than a week old).
Content is written in the pyramid style. For example, in the section dealing with
rental payments, the first sentence answers users likely questions: when and
how rent is paid.
Page 32 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
The EPA (www.epa.vic.gov.au), apart from the trust generated by a known government
entity, demonstrates the following branding and identity best practices:
Page 33 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
5.5.2
Directgov, UK
The UK governments Directgov site (www.direct.gov.uk) has a logo which is particularly suited to the web, and is recognisable even when only the first letter is
shown at a small size (see below).
The small D of the Directgov logo is used (as a favicon) to identify the site in the browser as can be seen above to the left of the address bar.
Page 34 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
5.6
5.6.1
Department of Health, UK
The UK Department of Health website provides an excellent search facility which follows
all best practice principles:
The search function is a simple interface consisting of a label, an input field, and a
go button. Note: an advanced search option is also available. The advanced
search interface is complex and does not conform to many best practice
principles.
The search results are clear and scannable. Each search result displays the
following:
o
A date. It is unclear if this date is the published date, last updated date or
alluding to another type of date.
The search engine employs stemming. A search for walk will includes results for
walk, walks, and walking in the search results.
The search facility provides synonym matching. The search results page suggests
related terms. For example, when searching for disease, the search results page
displays above the first result: Also try: Diseases, Communicable diseases,
Communicable disease transmission, Medical examination
The search results are faceted. A list of categories and the number of results
within each is displayed in the left-hand column.
Best bets are employed to promote key pages for selected search terms. For
example, when searching for influenza the first three search results are denoted
with We recommend.
Spelling errors are identified and corrected suggestions are made. For example:
You searched for influen. Did you mean: influenza, influence, influx
Page 35 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
5.6.2
The search facility is available on every page within the site. However the
duplication of the search facility on the search results page is debatable.
The search results are clear and scannable. Each search result displays the
following:
o
A date. It is unclear if this date is the published date, last updated date or
alluding to another type of date.
The search facility provides synonym matching. For example, when searching for
influenza, the search results page displays above the first result: You could
also try: flu
Best bets are employed. For example, when searching for influenza the first
result displayed is denoted as a Featured Link.
Spelling errors are identified and corrected suggestions are made. For example:
when searching for influensa the following is displayed above any search
results: Did you mean: influenza.
Page 36 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Version: 0.1
6.1
Content
6.1.1
Singapore (www.singhealth.com.sg)
USA (www.healthfinder.gov)
Page 37 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
6.1.2
Index of services
Common across government health sites is an index of services offered. Indexes of services
may be:
a more comprehensive database of public, community sector and private services offered.
They may also be searchable by topic, service name and location. It is common for all the
services of a department to be listed in one place, to save users having to navigate the
organisational structure. Service information may include eligibility information and instructions
on how to access the service. The United Kingdoms NHS Choices website offers a particularly
sophisticated service search feature across government and non-government services:
Examples:
Page 38 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
6.2
Interactive Features
6.2.1
6.2.2
USA (www.usa.gov)
USA (www.healthfinder.gov)
Page 39 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
6.2.3
Social interaction
Particularly in the area of consumer health, social interaction features are being offered. The
United Kingdoms NHS Choices site (www.nhs.uk) provides forums and the opportunity for users
to comments on articles and blog posts of featured bloggers.
Outside of government, online social support networks such as www.patientslikeme.com and
www.quitnet.com are becoming popular spaces in which users can interact and share advice and
stories related to their health challenges. The communities also become a valuable resource for
health researchers.
Examples:
www.patientslikeme.com provides online social support communities for a variety of health conditions
Page 40 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
6.2.4
As part of a broader trend in eGovernment (UN 2008), governments are beginning to offer online
payment as an option for partner agencies.
Example:
6.2.5
Customisation
In line with the move towards customer-centric service delivery, government health sites in particular are
beginning to offer greater customisation. The NHS Choices website (www.nhs.uk) allows health service
consumers to bookmark pages viewed within the site in their own Your pages section. Users can also
indicate their areas of interest, and these topics will be highlighted as the user browses the site.
The US Governments Healthfinder site (www.healthfinder.gov) provides a simple interface on the
homepage where users can enter their age and gender and relevant content will be displayed. A number
of countries around the world have enabled a high level of customisation of online by providing all
citizens with a unique identification number (UN 2008).
Examples:
USA (www.healthfinder.gov)
Singapore (www.ecitizen.gov.sg/singpass)
6.3
6.3.1
In the government space more broadly, there is a trend towards keeping content targeted to business
and citizen customers separate from organisational content such as policies, legislation and reports.
The United Kingdom provides a portal for all government services (www.direct.gov.uk) which includes the
full suite of human services, and a consumer-focused health site (www.nhs.uk). Information on
programs, policies, guidelines and information for service partners are restricted to departmental sites
such as www.dh.gov.uk and portal sites for partners such as www.info4local.gov.uk, which provides
information for local government.
The USA also has the consumer-target Healthfinder site (www.healthfinder.gov) as distinct from the
United States Department of Health and Human Services site (http://www.hhs.gov/) which contains
organisational information, information for local government and agencies as well as information about
services.
Page 41 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Bibliography
Australian Government Information Management Office (2006), Responsive Government A New Service
Agenda
Australian Government Information Management Office (2008), Consulting with Government online
Australian Government Information Management Office (2004), Information Architecture for Websites:
Better Practice Checklist
Bayens, G (2006), E Government in The Netherlands: An Architectural Approach, Netherlands ICTU
Burden, C (2007), 2007 Gold Mouse Report, Congressional Management Foundation
Capgemini (2007), The User Challenge: Benchmarking the Supply of Online Public Services, Report
prepared for the European Commission
Dillon, A and Turnbull, D (2005), Information Architecture, Encyclopaedia of Library and Information
Science
Ecotec Resarch & Consulting (2007), A Handbook for Citizen-centric eGovernment. (Prepared for the
European Union)
European Commission Joint Research Centre (2008), Web 2.0 in Government: Why and how?
Fuchs, S. and Rosati, L. (2005), The Italian and the English model of information retrieval used in
governmental websites, euroIA conference paper
Galitz, W. (2007), The Essential Guide to User Interface Design: An Introduction to GUI Design Principles
and Techniques, Wiley Press
Gartner Group (2000), Key Issues in E-Government Strategy and Management. Research Notes, Key
Issues
Heeks, R. (2002), e-Government in Africa: Promise and Practice, Institute for Development Policy and
Management, University of Manchester
Industry Advisory Council (2005), Managing Citizen-Centric Web Content, Best Practices Whitepaper
Lynch, P. J., Horton, S. and Rosenfeld, L. (2002), Web Style Guide: Basic Design Principles for Creating
Web Sites, Yale University Press
McGovern, G., Norton, R., ODowd, C (2002), The Web Content Style Guide, FT Press
Nielsen, J. (1993), Usability Engineering. Academic Press, San Diego, CA
Nielsen, J. (1993), Iterative User Interface Design, IEEE Computer Vol. 26, Issue 11 pp 32-41
Phoenix Strategic Perspectives (2008), New Technologies and Government of Canada Communications.
(Prepared for Agriculture and Agri-food Canada)
Seifert, J. (2003), A Primer on E-Government: Sectors, Stages, Opportunities and Challenges of Online
Governance. (Report for US Congress)
Sharp, D. (2006), Digital Lifestyles Monitor, Swinburne University of Technology
Toub, S. (2000), Evaluating Information Architecture, Argus Center for Information Architecture
United Nations (2008), United Nations E-Government Survey 2008
United Kingdom Cabinet Office (2006), Death of the Surfer Birth of the Supersite, UK Cabinet Office
Press Release
Varney, Sir David (2006), Service Transformation: A better service for citizens and businesses, a better
deal for the taxpayer
Vicnet (2007), Community Languages Online, (Prepared for the Department for Victorian Communities)
Vision Australia (2007), Ten Tips for a More Accessible Website,
Page 42 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Webcredible (2008), Local Council Websites: Good, But No Cigar, Webcredible Usability Study
Wroblewski, L. (2008), Web Form Design, Rosenfeld Media
Wyld, D. C. (2007), The Blogging Revolution: Government in the Age of Web 2.0, IBM Center for the
Business of Government Report
Page 43 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
Appendices
Appendix A.
Model of the domains of eGovernment
Following is a description of a model of the domains of eGovernment adapted by Richard Heeks at the
University of Manchester (Heeks 2002) from an earlier model developed by KPMG. The model proposes
three domains:
6.3.2
6.3.3
Cutting process costs: improving the input:output ratio by cutting financial costs and/or
time costs.
Making strategic connections in government: connecting arms, agencies, levels and data
stores of government to strengthen capacity to investigate, develop and implement the
strategy and policy that guides government processes.
Creating empowerment: transferring power, authority and resources for processes from
their existing locus to new locations.
6.3.4
Talking to citizens: providing citizens with details of public sector activities. This mainly
relates to certain types of accountability: making public servants more accountable for
their decisions and actions.
Listening to citizens: increasing the input of citizens into public sector decisions and
actions. This could be flagged as either democratisation or participation.
Improving public services: improving the services delivered to members of the public
along dimensions such as quality, convenience and cost.
Working better with business: improving the interaction between government and business.
This includes digitising regulation of, procurement from, and services to, business to
improve quality, convenience and cost.
Page 44 of 47
Developing communities: building the social and economic capacities and capital of local
communities.
Appendix B.
Best Practice Principles for Government (non IA)
Website Content Best Practices
6.3.5
Purpose-written content
One mistake commonly made in organisations is to simply take an existing printed document
and turn it into html. No one expects a printed document to work as a radio script and yet
many people think such a document would simply translate to web copy. Printed documents
may be repurposed for web but preferably, copy should be developed for the purpose of the
site. Gerry McGovern, worldwide authority on managing online content, emphasises that
writing for the web is not the same as writing for print. People read differently on the Web.
They scan read - jumping quickly from one piece of content to the next. People are much more
action-orientated on the Web. They get online to get something done. 23 Key points
recommended by McGovern include:
6.3.6
Use simple and informal writing - most users prefer the use of a conversational tone
when scanning online text.
A page heading should relate the key idea of the piece and comprise not more than
eight words.
Apply the inverted pyramid style of writing to text - start an article with the most
important fact followed by the next most important and so on.
Use the active voice, personal pronouns and action words this will encourage energetic
content.
Ensure that only one idea is outlined in each paragraph or chunk (manageable bit of
text).
Avoid scrolling as users become impatient when scanning reams of information. An ideal
article length is 500 words or less.
Highlight keywords and use bulleted lists to help users scan text.
Keep your text tight cut the word count and then cut it some more.
23 http://www.gerrymcgovern.com/nt/2003/nt_2003_04_28_writing_1.htm
Page 45 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria
6.3.7
Multilingual support
As the internet continues to provide a communication channel to the wider community,
improvement of translated content on Victorian government websites is needed to ensure that
online information is accessible for culturally and linguistically diverse (CALD) communities. This
is in line with wide-ranging Victorian Government policy that supports access to government
information for all Victorians 24 .
In late 2007, Vicnet, a division of the State Library of Victoria, delivered findings and
recommendations from research into how multilingual web-based government information can
be created and used in the best way for CALD communities. One of the key steps outlined in the
findings is the development of standards and guidelines for the creation of multilingual
content.
In 2001, Victoria Online conducted research into the feasibility of multilingual provisions for
vic.gov.au. The research recognised that languages are expensive to support on a website due
primarily to the need to employ external contractors to translate and manage the content 25 .
The resulting over-arching strategy for multilingual support recommended by the research was
to produce and maintain minimal content (navigation pages only) and concentrate on
aggregating links to existing translated resources.
6.3.8
6.3.9
Assume that the general public is one of the key audiences for the website homepage
and other major entry points of the site.
When writing for multiple audiences, tailor writing-style to the audience with the least
expertise.
Review homepages, major entry points, and navigational elements to ensure they are
written in plain language, for the general public.
Use language tools, including language software, to evaluate the readability of the
website's content.
24
http://www.egov.vic.gov.au/index.php?env=-innews/detail:m1182-1-1-8-s-0:n-1452-1-0--
25
http://www.egov.vic.gov.au/index.php?env=-innews/detail.tpl:m1516-1-1-8:l284-0-1-:n499-0-0
26
http://www.useit.com/alertbox/9703b.html
27
http://staff.bath.ac.uk/mpsmnkb/MNKBoulos_HDL04.PDF
28
http://www.usa.gov/webcontent/managing_content/writing_and_editing.shtml
Page 46 of 47
The inverted pyramid concept is a writing style that puts the most important information at
the top, followed by the remaining information in order of importance, with the least important
at the bottom. The pyramid writing style is popular with journalists and is also the
recommended way of writing content for the web.
The inverted pyramid should be made up of chunks of content. Chunking is the process of
dividing information into separate topics for users to read and comprehend more easily. After
breaking chunks up into manageable lengths, appropriate headings and subheadings should be
employed to provide an indication of the contents. Each chunk should consist of a single idea or
concept.
Page 47 of 47
Department of Human Services Copyright State Government of Victoria