23
CHAPTER 2
PERMANENT MAGNET BRUSHLESS DC MOTOR,
21 INTRODUCTION
A brushless DC motor is similar to that brushed DC motor in that it
has an internal shaft position feedback which tells which windings to switch
on and what exact moment. This internal feedback gives both the brushed DC
motor and the brushless DC motor with their unique characteristics: linear
speed-torque curves which are well suited for speed and position control and
high starting torque. The internal feedback is accomplished in a brush type
DC motor with the mechanical commutator (a series of copper bars which are
insulated from each other) and the mechanical brushes through which the
current is fed into the commutator bars and switched sequentially into the
appropriate winding in the armature,
In a BLDC motor, the internal feedback is accomplished by shaft
position sensors of some type which gives the required shaft position
information to the drive electronics. The drive electronies in turn switches on
the appropriate windings exactly at the right moment. This internal shaft
position feedback also gives the BLDC motor characteristics which are
similar to the DC motor characteristics: Linear speed-torque characteristics
and high starting torque. The power supplied to a BLDC motor can be DC
power but it can also be AC if the drive electronics has the necessary circuitry
to convert the AC power to DC.24
The Brushless DC motor is actually a permanent magnet AC motor
whose torque-speed characteristics. mimic the DC motor. Instead of
commutating the armature current using brushes, electronic commutation is
used. Having the armature on the stator makes it easy to conduct heat away
from the windings, and if desired, having cooling arrangement for the
armature windings is much easier as compared to a DC motor. A BLDC
motor is a modified PMSM with the modification being that the back-emf is
trapezoidal instead of being sinusoidal as in the case of PMSM. The position
of the rotor can be sensed by Hall Effect position sensors, namely Hall A,
Hall B, and Hall C, each having a phase lag of 120° with respect to the earlier
one. Three Hall position sensors are used to determine the position of the
rotor field. BLDC motor is the choice in many applications requiring precise
control of speed. The BLDC motor model is explained as, the electromagnetic
torque, Tem is linearly proportional to the armature current l,. ie., Tem = Kr
1,, where Kr is the torque constant.
22 GENERAL ELECTRIC DRIVE SYSTEM
Motion control is required in large number of industrial and
domestic applications like transportation systems, rolling mills, paper
machines, textile mills, machine tools, fans, pumps, robots, washing machines
ete, Systems employed for motion control are called drives and may employ
any of the prime movers such as diesel or petrol engines, gas or steam
turbines, steam engines, hydraulic motors and electric motors, for supplying
mechanical energy for motion control. Drives employing electric motors are
known as electrical drives.25
[Sef te | SJL
| |
Control Sensing
Dit Unit
I Input Command
Figure 2.1 Block diagram of an electrical drive system
Block diagram of an electrical drive system is shown in Figure 2.1
Load is usually machinery designed to accomplish a given task. e.g. fans,
pumps, robots, washing machines, machine tools, trains and drills. Usually
load requirements can be specified in terms of speed and torque demands. A
motor having speed-torque characteristics and capabilities compatible to the
load requirements is chosen. Power modulator performs one or more of the
following four functions.
iii,
iv,
Modulates flow of power from the source to the motor in such
a manner that motor is imparted speed-torque characteristics
required by the load.
During transient operations
such as starting, braking and speed
reversal, it restricts source and motor currents within
permissible values; excessive current drawn from source may
overload it or may cause a voltage dip.
Converts electrical energy of the source in the form suitable to
the motor, e.g. if the source is DC and an induction motor is to
be employed, then the power modulator is required to convert
DC into a variable frequency AC.
Selects the mode of operation of the motor, i.e. motoring or
braking,26
Controls for power modulator are built in control unit which
us
ally operates at much lower voltage and power levels. In addition to
operating the power modulator as desired, it may also generate commands for
the protection of power modulator and motor. Input command signal, which
adjusts the operating point of the drive, forms an input to the control unit.
Sensing of certain drive parameters, such as motor current and speed may be
required either for protection or for closed loop operation
2.2.1 Advantages of Electrical Drives
Electrical drives are widely used because of the following
advantages:
1. They have flexible control characteristics. The steady-state
and dynamic characteristics of electrical drives can be shaped
to satisfy load requirements. Speed can be controlled and if
required, can be controlled in wide limits. Electric braking can
be employed. Control gear required for speed control, starting
and braking is usually simple and easy to operate.
Availability of semiconductor converters employing
thyristors, power transistors, IGBTs and GTOs, linear and
digital ICs, and microcomputers have made the control
characteristics even more flexible. It is possible to reshape
characteristics of drives almost at will to meet load
requirements in an optimum manner. Speed and torque, and
transitions from one mode to another can be controlled
smoothly and steplessly. Optimal control strategies can be
implemented to achieve high dynamic performance, high
efficiency or to minimize a suitable performance index. Drives
can be provided with automatic fault detection systems.27
Programmable logic controllers and computers canbe
employed to automatically control the drive operations in a
desired sequence.
They are available in wide range of torque, speed and power.
Electric motors have high efficiency, low no load losses and
considerable short time overloading capability. Can be made
in variety of designs to make them compatible with load.
‘Compared to other prime movers they have longer life, lower
noise, lower maintenance requirements and cleaner operation
They are adaptable to almost any operating conditions such as
explosive and radioactive environment, submerged in liquids,
vertical mountings, and so on.
Do not pollute the environment.
Can operate in all the four quadrants of speed-torque plane.
Electric braking gives smooth deceleration and increases life
of the equipment compared to other forms of braking. When
regenerative braking is possible, considerable saving of
energy is achieved. These features are not available in other
prime movers.
Unlike other prime movers, there is no need to refuel or warm-
up the motor. They can be started instantly and can
immediately be fully loaded.
They are powered by electrical energy which has a number of
advantages over other forms of energy. It can be generated
and transported to the desired point economically and
efficiently. Conversion of electrical to mechanical energy and
vice versa and electrical energy from one from to another can
also be done efficiently and economically.28
2.3 PARTS OF ELECTRICAL DRIVES
Electrical drive has the following major parts: load, motor, power
modulator, control unit and source. There is large number of loads and each
load has its own specific requirements. Here we examine four parts of
electrical drives; viz. motors, power modulators, sources and control unit.
2.3.1. Electrical Motors
Motors commonly used in electrical drives are: DC motors ~ Shunt,
series, compound and permanent magnet; Induction motors — Squirrel cage,
wound rotor and linear; synchronous motors — wound field and permanent
magnet; Brushless DC motors; Stepper motors; and switched reluctance
motors.
In the past, induction and synchronous motors were employed
mainly in constant speed drives. Variable speed drives consisting these
machines were either too expensive or have very poor efficiency
Consequently, variable speed drive applications were dominated by DC
motors. AC motors are now employed in variable speed drives also due to
development of semiconductor converters employing thyristors, power
transistors, IGBTs and GTOs.
Due to presence of commutator and brushes in DC motors have a
number of disadvantages as compared to AC motors (induction and
synchronous motors): higher cost, weight, volume and inertia for the same
rating, need for frequent maintenance, unsuitable for explosive and
contaminated environments and restrictions on maximum voltage, speed and
power ratings. Squirrel cage induction motor, which costs nearly one third of
the DC motor of the same rating, is extremely rugged, requires practically no29
maintenance and can be built for higher speeds, torques and power ratings.
Wound rotor motors are more expensive than squirrel cage motors. They are
also available in high power ratings. Wound field and permanent magnet
synchronous motors have a higher full load efficiency and power factor than
induction motors. Wound field motors can be designed for a higher power
rating than induction motors. However, compared to squirrel cage induction
motors they have higher cost and size for the same rating and require more
maintenance. The permanent magnet synchronous motors have all the
advantages of squirrel cage induction motors except that they are available in
lower power ratings. Because of numerous advantages of AC motors
described above, AC drives have succeeded in replacing DC drives in a
number of variable speed applications.
Brushless DC motor is somewhat similar to a permanent magnet
synchronous motor, but has lower cost and requires simpler and cheaper
converter. It is being considered for low power high speed drives and for
servo applications, as an alternative to DC servo motor which has been very
poplar so far. At low power levels, the coulomb friction between the brushes
and commutator is objectionable, as it adversely affects the steady state
accuracy of the drive. Brushless DC Motor (BLDC) has been quickly
demanded due to preciseness of industrial applications and increase of various
kinds of control techniques.
Recently, stepper motor has become popular for position control
and switched reluctance motor drive for speed control.30
2.3.2. Power Modulators
Some drives may employ more than one of these power
modulators. It can be classified into five categories.
i, Converters (AC to DC)
ii, Inverters (DC to AC)
iii, AC voltage controllers (AC to AC)
iv. DC choppers (DC to DC)
v. Cyclo converters (Frequency conversion)
2.3.2.1 AC to DC converter
Rectification is a process of converting an alternating current or
voltage a direct current or voltage. This conversion can be achieved by a
variety of circuits based on and using switching devices. The widely used
switching devices are diodes, thyristors, power-transistors, power MOSFETS,
ete, The rectifier circuits can be classified broadly into three classes;
uncontrolled, fully controlled and half controlled. An uncontrolled rectifier
used only diodes and the DC output voltage is fixed in amplitude by the
amplitude of the AC supply. The fully controlled rectifier uses thyristors as
the rectifying elements and the DC output voltage is a function of the
amplitude of the AC supply voltage and the point on wave at which the
thyristors are triggered called firing angle. The half controlled rectifier
contains a mixture of diodes and thyristors, allowing a more limited control
over the DC output voltage level than the fully controlled rectifier. The half
controlled rectifier is cheaper than a fully controlled rectifier of the same
ratings but has operational limitations.31
Uncontrolled and half controlled rectifiers will permit power to
flow only from the AC system to the DC load and are, therefore, referred to as
unidirectional converters. However, with a fully controlled rectifier it is
possible, by control of the point on wave at which switching takes place, to
allow power to be transferred from the DC side of the rectifier back into the
AC system, When this occurs, operation is said to be in the inverting mode.
The fully controlled converter many therefore be referred to as a bidirectional
converter. Here it is possible for the phase controlled converters to provide a
one quadrant, two quadrant or four quadrant operation at its DC terminals.
2.3.2.2 Inverters
Inverters are employed to get a variable frequency as supply from a
DC supply. Stepped inverters can be designed to behave as voltage source or
current source. Accordingly they are known as voltage source or current
source inverters. For the control of AC motor, voltage/current should also be
controlled along with frequency. Variation in output voltage/current can be
achieved by varying the input DC voltage. This is achieved either by
interposing a chopper in between fixed voltage DC source and the inverter or
the inverter may be fed from an AC-DC converter. Output voltage and current
have stepped waveform, consequently they have substantial amount of
harmonics. Variable frequency and variable voltage AC i
directly obtained
from fixed voltage DC when the inverter is controlled by pulse width
modulation (PWM). The PWM control also reduces harmonics in the output
voltage. Inverters are built using semiconductor devices such as thyristors,
power transistors, IGBTs, GTOs and power MOSFETs. They are controlled
by firing pulses obtained from a low power control unit. In the past variable
frequency supply used to be obtained from a frequency employing a rotating
machine. Such schemes have become outdated due to numerous
disadvantages.32
2.3.2.3 AC Voltage Controllers
AC voltage controllers are employed to get variable AC voltage of
the same frequency from a source of fixed AC voltage. The auto transformers
capable of giving variable output voltage are not employed due to sliding
contacts. Variable AC voltage with few discrete steps is obtained from the
controller. The control is exercised by a mechanical force. The output voltage
and source current are sinusoidal. Converter employs a thyristorised voltage
controller. Stepless control of the output voltage can be obtained by
controlling firing angle of converter thyristors by low power signals from a
control unit, Output voltage and source current have harmonics and power
factor is poor at low output voltages.
2.3.2.4 Choppers
They are used to get variable voltage DC from a fixed voltage DC
and are designed using semiconductor devices such as power transistors,
IGBTs, GTOs, power MOSFETs and thyristors. Output voltage can be varied
steplessly by controlling the duty ratio of the device by low power signals
from a control unit. The DC chopper offers greater efficiency, faster response,
lower maintenance, small size and smooth control. Solid state choppers due to
various advantages are widely used in trolley cars, battery-operated vehicles,
traction-motor control and control of a large number of DC motors from a
common DC bus with a considerable improvement of power factor.
2.3.2.5 Cycloconverter
Cycloconverter converts fixed voltage and frequency AC to
variable voltage and variable frequency AC. They are built using thyristors
and are controlled by firing signals derived from a low power control unit. A.
cycloconverter is controlled through the timings of its firing pulses, so that it33
produces an alternating output voltage. By controlling the frequency and
depth of phase modulation of the firing angles of the converters, it is possible
to control the frequency and amplitude of the output voltage. Thus, a
cycloconverter has the facility for continuous and independent control over
both its output frequency and voltage.
2.3.3. Sources
In India single-phase and three-phase 50 Hz AC supplies are
readily available in most locations. Very low power drives are generally fed
from single-phase source. Rest of the drives is powered from three-phase
source; except in the case of traction drives where even at very high power
levels
Single-phase supply is used because of economy. Most drives are
powered from AC source either directly or through a converter link. When fed
directly from 50 Hz AC supply maximum speeds of induction and
synchronous motors are limited to 3000 rpm. For higher speeds, conversion to
higher frequency supply becomes mandatory. Low and medium power motors
(tens of kilowatts) are generally fed from 400 V supply; for high ratings,
motors may be rated at 3.3 kV, 6.6 kV, 11 kV and higher.
In case of aircraft and space applications, 400 Hz AC supply is
generally used to achieve high power to weight ratio for motors. In main line
traction a high voltage supply is preferred because of economy. In India
25KV, 50 Hz supply is employed. In underground traction, major expenditure
is cost of the tunnel which should be minimized by keeping its cross-section
just enough for the train, Consequently, clearance between live conductor and
the earth has also to be minimum. In view of this, underground traction
systems employ a low voltage (500 to 750 V) DC supply. In western India
(Bombay to Igatpuri) 1500 V DC is used for main line and the suburban
traction which is uneconomical and therefore future installations will not
use it,34
Some drives are powered from a battery, e.g. fork lift trucks and
milk vans. Depending on size, battery voltage may have typical values of 6 V,
12 V, 24 V, 48 V and 110 V DC. Another example of drives fed from a low
voltage DC supply is solar powered drives used in space and water pumping
and low power transport applications. Although choice of a motor does
depend on the type of supply but there are many other factors which are even
more important, Therefore, a DC motor may be preferred over AC even the
AC supply is available in most locations.
2.3.4 Sensing Unit
i, Speed Sensing
ii, Current Sensing
Speed sensing is required for implementation of closed loop speed
control schemes. Speed is usually sensed by using tachometers. When very
high speed accuracies required, as in computer peripherals and paper mills
ete., digital tachometers are used.
Two commonly used methods of sensing the current (i) use of
current sensor employing Hall Effect (ii) It involves the use of a non-
inductive resistance shunt in conjunction with an isolation amplifier which
has an arrangement for an amplification and isolation between power and
control circuits.
2.3.5 Control Unit
Controls for a power modulator are provided in the control unit.
Nature of the control unit for a particular drive on the power modulator that is
used.35
When semiconductor converters are used, the control unit will
consists of firing circuits, which employ linear and digital integrated circuits
and transistors, and a microprocessor when sophisticated control is required.
switching operations are required to achieve any one of the following (i) for
changing motor connections to change its quadrant of operation, (ii) for
changing motor circuit parameters in discrete steps for automatic starting and
braking control, (iii) for operating motors and drives according to a
predetermined sequences. When control of switching circuits is required for
any of the purpose described above, function of control unit will be to provide
sequencing and interlocking. As already stated, solid state relays are used and
when control is complex programmable logic controllers can be used.
24 CONSTRUCTION OF BLDC MOTORS
A BLDC motor is a Permanent magnet brushless DC motor that
us
position detectors and an inverter to control the armature currents. The
BLDC motor is sometimes referred to as an inside out DC motor because its
armature is in the stator and the magnets are on the rotor and its operating
characteristics resemble those of a DC motor. Instead of using a mechanical
commutator as in the conventional DC motor, the BLDC motor employs
electronic commutation which makes it a virtually maintenance-free motor.
There are two main types of BLDC motor: trapezoidal type and
sinusoidal type. In the trapezoidal motor the Back EMF induced in the stator
windings has a trapezoidal shape and its phases must be supplied with quasi-
square currents for ripple-free torque operation, The sinusoidal motor on the
other hand has a sinusoidally shaped Back EMF and requires sinusoidal phase
currents for ripple-free torque operation. The shape of the Back EMF is
determined by the shape of the rotor magnets and the stator winding
distribution.36
The sinusoidal motor needs a high resolution position sensor
because the rotor position must be known at every time instant for optimal
operation. It also requires more complex software and hardware. The
trapezoidal motor is a BLDC motor attractive alternative for most applications
due to
simplicity, lower price and higher efficiency.
It has usually 4 magnets around the perimeter. The stator of the
motor is composed by the electromagnets, usually 4 of them, placed in a cross
pattern with 90° angle between them, The major advantage of the brushless
motors is that, due to the fact that the rotor carries only the permanent
magnets, it needs of no power at all. No connection needs to be done with the
rotor, thus, no brush-commutator pair needs to be made: This feature gives the
brushless motor great increment in reliability, as the brushes wear off very
fast.
Figure 2.2 Construction of BLDC motor
BLDC motors exist in many different configurations but the three
phase motor is the most common type due to its efficiency and low torque
ripple. This type of motor also offers a good compromise between precise
control and number of power electronic devices needed to control the stator
currents. Figure 2.2 shows the construction of BLDC motor. Position
detection is usually implemented using three Hall Effect sensors that detect
the presence of small magnets that are attached to the motor shaft.37
24.1 Permanent Magnets
Materials that retain magnetism are known as hard magnet
materials. Various materials, such as Alnico-S, ferrites, samarium-cobalt and
neodymium-iron are available as permanent magnets for use in machines.
Based on the required magnetic field density in the rotor, the proper magnetic
material is chosen to make the rotor. Ferrite magnets are traditionally used to
make permanent magnets. As the technology advances, rare earth alloy
magnets are gaining popularity. The ferrite magnets are less expensive but
they have the disadvantages of low flux density for a given volume.
Rare Earth magnets include Neodymium (Nd) ~ Iron (Fe)- Boron
(B) types and Samarium (Sm) ~ Cobalt (Co) classes. The most commonly
produced material is neodymium-iron-boron (NdFeB). This group of
magnetic material provides the highest available magnetic energies of any
material. NdFeB magnets allow small shapes and sizes with high magnetic
fields. Super strength Rare Earth Magnet Sintered NdFeB magnets, have the
characteristics of: Extreme strong Br Resident induction, excellent
demagnetization resistance capability, Good price relative to its high magnetic
properties, coating is needed for NdFeB. Both NdFeB and Sm, Co are
available in sintered as well as bonded forms.
The cheapest permanent magnets are usually made from ferrite
(have low coercive strength), whereas the more expensive and rare-earth type
stronger ones contain Samarium-Cobalt or Neodium-Iron-Boron. Because the
rare earth type magnets have a higher coercive strength, they usually
withstand the demagnetization effects better than the ferrite magnets, and
hence are usually preferred. The magnets are made into desired shapes, put in
an appropriate jaw and then magnetized by a pulse of high current obtained
from a capacitor bank. At low power ratings, especially the fractional
horsepower range, permanent magnet motors are economical. As the rating of38
the motor increases, the cost of permanent magnets and their manufacture
becomes costlier relative to the motors in which the field is generated by
applying an external source.
The smaller of the permanent magnet motors, usually in the
fractional horsepower range may have less than three phases. Motors with
large ratings may contain more than three phases so as to distribute the power
over more inverter legs, thus permitting the use of power semiconductor
switches with smaller ratings.
2.4.2. Hall Sensor
For the estimation of the rotor position, the motor is equipped with
three hall sensors. These hall sens
rs are placed every 120°, With these
sensors, 6 different commutations are possible. Phase commutation depends
on hall sensor values. Power supply to the coils changes when hall sensor
values change. With right synchronized commutations, the torque remains
nearly constant and high. Figure 2.3 shows the hall sensor signals for the
clockwise rotation,
Figure 2.3 Hall Sensor signals for CW rotation39
Figure 2.4 Hall sensor image
Figure 2.4 shows the Hall sensor image. The Hall sensor is this
little component under the right electromagnet, When it senses the South pole,
it keeps the coils tumed off, When the sensor senses no magnetic field
(or could be also the South pole), then it turns on the coils. The coils have
both the same magnetic polarity which is north, So they pull the opposite pole
and torque is then created. If you put a probe to the Hall sensor and watch the
signal, then you will discover that during a full rotation of the rotor, the Hall
sensor is two times HIGH and two times LOW. Figure 2.5 shows the Back
Emf, Current Waveforms and Hall position sensors for a BLDC motor drive.
Motor commutation is usually related to Hall Effect sensor outputs.
All of the electrical motors that do not require an electrical
connection (made with brushes) between stationary and rotating parts can be
considered as brushless permanent magnet (PM) machines, which can be
categorized based on the PMs mounting and the back-EMF shape. The PMs
can be surface mounted on the rotor (SMPM) or installed inside of the rotor
(IPM), and the back-EMF shape can either be sinusoidal or trapezoidal.
According to the back-EMF shape, PMAC synchronous motors (PMAC or
PMSM) have sinusoidal back-EMF and Brushless DC motors (BLDC or
BPM) have trapezoidal back-EMF. A PMAC motor is typically excited by a40
three-phase sinusoidal current, and a BLDC motor is usually powered by a set
of currents having a quasi-square waveform.
Lae
Pa ee Se
zy
Pisin al ‘A =
ip
fal Cd ot
o
om,
on,
Figure 2.5 Back emf, current waveforms and hall position sensors for a
BLDC motor drive
However, the BLDC motors are inherently electronically controlled
and require rotor position information for proper commutation of currents in
its stator windings. It is not desirable to use the position sensors for
applications where reliability is of utmost importance because a sensor failure
may cause instability in the control system. These limitations of using
position sensors combined with the availability of powerful and economical
microprocessors have spurred the development of sensorless control
technology.41
In recent years PWM techniques were effectively introduced to
improve the performance of nonlinear systems. The application of PWM is
very promising in system identification and control due to learning ability,
massive parallelism, fast adaptation, inherent approximation capability, and
high degree of tolerance. A single-phase uniform PWM DC-DC converter
with only one switching device able to produce a controllable DC voltage
ranging from zero to more than the maximum value of input de voltage has
been used for armature voltage control method of a BLDC motor.
2.4.3. Phase Commutations
To simplify the explanation of how to operate a three phase BLDC
motor, a typical BLDC motor with only three coils is considered. As
previously shown, phases commutation depends on the hall sensor values.
When motor coils are correctly supplied, a magnetic field is created and the
rotor moves. The most elementary commutation driving method used for
BLDC motors is an ON & OFF scheme: a coil is either conducting or not
conducting. Only two windings are supplied at the same time and the third
winding is floating. Connecting the coils to the power and neutral bus induces
the current flow. This is referred to as trapezoidal commutation or block
commutation. Figure 2.6 shows the power circuit diagram for BLDC motor.
8
8
TT
e