Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Asimov, Isaac - Foundations - Fear PDF

    Uploaded by

    Nenad Grujic
    43 views277 pages

    Original Title

    Asimov, Isaac - foundations_fear.pdf

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    43 views277 pages

    Asimov, Isaac - Foundations - Fear PDF

    Uploaded by

    Nenad Grujic

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 277

    7+(6(&21'

    )281'$7,2175,/2*<
    )RXQGDWLRQV)HDU

    *5(*25<%(1)25'
    B
    7R*UHJ%HDUDQG'DYLG%ULQ
    IHOORZYR\DJHUVRQVWUDQJHVHDV
    B
    5(1'(=9286

    5'DQHHO2OLYDZGLGQRWORRNOLNH(WR'HPHU]HO7KDWUROHKHKDG
    DOUHDG\FDVWDVLGH
    7KLV'RUV9DQDELOLH[SHFWHGWKRXJKLWZDVXQVHWWOLQJWRKHU6KHNQHZ
    WKDWWKURXJKPLOOHQQLDKHKDGGLVFDUGHGWKHVNLQDQGVKDSHRIFRXQWOHVV
    JXLVHV
    'RUVVWXGLHGKLPLQWKHFUDPSHGGLQJ\URRPWZR6HFWRUVDZD\IURP
    6WUHHOLQJ8QLYHUVLW\6KHKDGIROORZHGDFRQYROXWHGURXWHWRJHWKHUHDQGWKH
    VLWHZDVSURWHFWHGE\HODERUDWHRYHUODSSLQJVHFXULW\PHDVXUHV5RERWVZHUH
    RXWODZV7KH\KDGOLYHGIRUPLOOHQQLDLQWKHGHHSVKDGRZRIWDERR7KRXJK
    2OLYDZZDVKHUJXLGHDQGPHQWRUVKHVDZKLPVHOGRP
    <HWDVDKXPDQLIRUPURERWVKHIHOWDWUHPRURIPLQJOHGIHDUDQG
    UHYHUHQFHDWWKLVDQFLHQWSDUWO\PHWDOOLFIRUPEHIRUHKHU+HZDVQHDUO\
    WZHQW\PLOOHQQLDROG7KRXJKKHFRXOGDSSHDUKXPDQKHGLGQRWWUXO\ZLVKWR
    EHKXPDQ+HZDVLQH[SUHVVLEO\JUHDWHUWKDQWKDWQRZ
    6KHKDGOLYHGKDSSLO\DVDSVHXGRSHUVRQIRUVRORQJQRZ(YHQD
    UHPLQGHURIZKRDQGZKDWVKHZDVFDPHOLNHFROGILQJHUVDORQJKHUVSLQH7KH
    UHFHQWLQFUHDVLQJDWWHQWLRQSDLGWR+DUL
    ,QGHHG<RXIHDU\RXZLOOEHGHWHFWHG
    7KHQHZHVWVHFXULW\PHDVXUHVDUHVRLQYDVLYH
    +HQRGGHG<RXDUHFRUUHFWWREHFRQFHUQHG
    ,QHHGPRUHKHOSLQSURWHFWLQJ+DUL
    $GGLQJDQRWKHURIXVWRKLVFORVHDVVRFLDWHVZRXOGGRXEOHWKHGDQJHURI
    GHWHFWLRQ
    ,NQRZ,NQRZEXW
    2OLYDZUHDFKHGRXWDQGWRXFKHGKHUKDQG6KHEOLQNHGEDFNWHDUVDQG
    VWXGLHGKLVIDFH6PDOOPDWWHUVVXFKDVFRQVLVWHQWPRYHPHQWRIKLV$GDPV
    DSSOHZKHQKHVZDOORZHGKDGORQJDJREHHQSHUIHFWHG7RHDVHKLPVHOILQWKLV
    PHHWLQJKHKDGRPLWWHGWKHVHPLQRUFRPSXWDWLRQVDQGPRYHPHQWV+HREYLRXVO\
    HQMR\HGHYHQPRPHQWDU\IUHHGRPIURPVXFKWD[DWLRQ
    ,DPFRQVWDQWO\IHDUIXOVKHDGPLWWHG
    <RXVKRXOGEH+HLVPXFKWKUHDWHQHG%XW\RXDUHGHVLJQHGWRIXQFWLRQ
    EHVWZLWKDKLJKOHYHORIDSSUHKHQVLRQ
    ,NQRZP\VSHFLILFDWLRQV\HVEXWWDNHWKLVODWHVWPRYHRI\RXUV
    LQYROYLQJKLPLQ,PSHULDOSROLWLFVDWWKHKLJKHVWOHYHO,WLPSRVHVVHYHUH
    VWUDLQRQP\WDVN
    $QHFHVVDU\PRYH
    ,WPD\GLVWUDFWKLPIURPKLVZRUNIURPSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    2OLYDZVKRRNKLVKHDGVORZO\,GRXEWWKDW+HLVDFHUWDLQVSHFLDO
    NLQGRIKXPDQGULYHQ+HRQFHUHPDUNHGWRPH*HQLXVGRHVZKDWLWPXVWDQG
    WDOHQWGRHVZKDWLWFDQWKLQNLQJWKDWKHPHUHO\KDGWDOHQW
    6KHVPLOHGUXHIXOO\%XWKHLVDJHQLXV
    $QGOLNHDOOVXFKXQLTXH+XPDQVKDYHWKDWUDUHJUHDWH[FXUVLRQVIURP
    WKHPHDQ(YROXWLRQKDVVHOHFWHGWKHPIRULWWKRXJKWKH\GRQRWVHHPWR
    UHDOL]HWKDW

    $QGZH"
    (YROXWLRQFDQQRWDFWRQRQHZKROLYHVIRUHYHU,QDQ\FDVHWKHUHKDV
    QRWEHHQWLPH:HFDQDQGGRGHYHORSRXUVHOYHVKRZHYHU
    +XPDQVDUHDOVRPXUGHURXV
    :HDUHIHZWKH\DUHPDQ\$QGWKH\KDYHGHHSDQLPDOVSLULWVZHFDQQRW
    IDWKRPLQWKHHQGQRPDWWHUKRZZHWU\
    ,FDUHDERXW+DULILUVW
    $QGWKH(PSLUHDGLVWDQWVHFRQG"+HJDYHKHUDWKLQVPLOH,FDUH
    IRUWKH(PSLUHRQO\VRIDUDVLWVDIHJXDUGVKXPDQLW\
    )URPZKDW"
    )URPLWVHOI-XVWUHPHPEHU'RUVWKLVLVWKH&XVS(UDDVDQWLFLSDWHG
    E\RXUVHOYHVIRUVRORQJ7KHPRVWFULWLFDOSHULRGLQDOORIKLVWRU\
    ,NQRZWKHWHUPEXWZKDWLVWKHVXEVWDQFH"'RZHKDYHDWKHRU\RI
    KLVWRU\"
    )RUWKHILUVWWLPH'DQHHO2OLYDZVKRZHGH[SUHVVLRQDUXHIXOJULPDFH
    :HDUHQRWFDSDEOHRIDGHHSWKHRU\)RUWKDWZHZRXOGKDYHWRXQGHUVWDQG
    KXPDQVIDUEHWWHU
    %XWZHKDYHVRPHWKLQJ"
    $GLIIHUHQWZD\RIYLHZLQJKXPDQLW\RQHQRZEDGO\VWUDLQHG,WFDXVHG
    XVWRVKDSHWKLVJUHDWHVWRIKXPDQLW\VFUHDWLRQVWKH(PSLUH
    ,GRQRWNQRZRIWKLV
    1RQHHGIRU\RXWR:HQRZUHTXLUHDPRUHSURIRXQGYLHZ7KDWLVZK\
    +DULLVVRLPSRUWDQW
    'RUVIURZQHGWURXEOHGIRUUHDVRQVVKHFRXOGQRWTXLWHH[SUHVV7KLV
    HDUOLHUVLPSOHUWKHRU\RIRXUV,WWHOOV\RXWKDWKXPDQLW\QRZPXVWKDYH
    SV\FKRKLVWRU\"
    ([DFWO\:HNQRZWKLVIURPRXURZQFUXGHWKHRU\%XWRQO\WKLV
    )RUPRUHZHUHO\RQ+DULDORQH"
    $ODV\HV
    B
    3$57

    0$7+,67
    0,1,67(5

    B
    +$5,6(/'21WKRXJKLWLVWKHEHVWH[LVWLQJDXWKRULW\RQWKHGHWDLOVRI
    6HOGRQVOLIHWKHELRJUDSK\E\*DDO'RUQLFNFDQQRWEHWUXVWHGUHJDUGLQJWKH
    HDUO\ULVHWRSRZHU$VD\RXQJPDQ'RUQLFNPHW6HOGRQRQO\WZR\HDUVEHIRUH
    WKHJUHDWPDWKLVWVGHDWK%\WKHQUXPRUDQGHYHQOHJHQGKDGDOUHDG\EHJXQWR
    JURZDERXW6HOGRQSDUWLFXODUO\UHJDUGLQJKLVVKDGRZ\SHULRGRIODUJHVFDOH
    DXWKRULW\ZLWKLQWKHIDGLQJ,PSHULXP
    +RZ6HOGRQEHFDPHWKHRQO\PDWKLVWLQDOO*DODFWLFKLVWRU\WRDVFHQGWR
    SROLWLFDOSRZHUUHPDLQVRQHRIWKHPRVWLQWUDFWDEOHSX]]OHVIRU6HOGRQ
    VFKRODUV+HJDYHQRVLJQRIDPELWLRQVEH\RQGWKHEXLOGLQJRIDVFLHQFHRI
    KLVWRU\DOOWKHZKLOHHQYLVLRQLQJQRWWKHPHUHIDWKRPLQJRIWKHSDVWEXW
    LQIDFWWKHSUHGLFWLRQRIWKHIXWXUH $V6HOGRQKLPVHOIUHPDUNHGWR'RUQLFN
    KHHDUO\RQGHVLUHGWKHSUHYHQWLRQRIFHUWDLQNLQGVRIIXWXUHV 
    &HUWDLQO\WKHP\VWHULRXVH[LWRI(WR'HPHU]HODV)LUVW0LQLVWHUZDVWKH
    RSHQLQJDFWLQDSOD\RIODUJHSURSRUWLRQV7KDW&OHRQ,LPPHGLDWHO\WXUQHGWR
    6HOGRQVXJJHVWVWKDW'HPHU]HOKDQGSLFNHGKLVVXFFHVVRU<HWZK\JRWR6HOGRQ"
    +LVWRULDQVDUHGLYLGHGDERXWWKHPRWLYDWLRQVRIWKHFHQWUDOSOD\HUVLQWKLV
    FUXFLDOPRPHQW7KH(PSLUHKDGHQWHUHGDSHULRGRIFKDOOHQJHDQGGLVUXSWLRQ
    FRPLQJHVSHFLDOO\IURPZKDW6HOGRQWHUPHGWKHFKDRVZRUOGV+RZ6HOGRQ
    DGURLWO\PDQHXYHUHGDJDLQVWSRZHUIXORSSRQHQWVGHVSLWHQRUHFRUGHGH[SHULHQFH
    LQWKHSROLWLFDODUHQDUHPDLQVDQDFWLYHEXWYH[LQJDUHDRIUHVHDUFK

    (1&<&/23(',$*$/$&7,&$

    >1RWH$OOTXRWDWLRQVIURPWKH(QF\FORSHGLD*DODFWLFDKHUHUHSURGXFHGDUH
    WDNHQIURPWKHWKHGLWLRQSXEOLVKHG)(E\WKH(QF\FORSHGLD
    *DODFWLFD3XEOLVKLQJ&R7HUPLQXVZLWKSHUPLVVLRQRIWKHSXEOLVKHUV@
    

    +HKDGPDGHHQRXJKHQHPLHVWRDFTXLUHDQLFNQDPH+DUL6HOGRQPXVHGDQG
    QRWHQRXJKIULHQGVWRKHDUZKDWLWZDV
    +HFRXOGIHHOWKHWUXWKRIWKDWLQWKHPXUPXULQJHQHUJ\LQWKHFURZGV
    8QHDVLO\KHZDONHGIURPKLVDSDUWPHQWWRKLVRIILFHDFURVVWKHEURDGVTXDUHV
    RI6WUHHOLQJ8QLYHUVLW\7KH\GRQWOLNHPHKHVDLG
    'RUV9DQDELOLPDWFKHGKLVVWULGHHDVLO\VWXG\LQJWKHPDVVHGIDFHV,
    GRQRWVHQVHDQ\GDQJHU
    'RQWZRUU\\RXUSUHWW\KHDGDERXWDVVDVVLQDWLRQDWWHPSWVDWOHDVW
    QRWULJKWDZD\
    0\\RXUHLQDILQHPRRGWRGD\
    ,KDWHWKLVVHFXULW\VFUHHQ:KRZRXOGQW"
    7KH,PSHULDO6SHFLDOVKDGIDQQHGRXWLQZKDWWKHLUFDSWDLQWHUPHGDQ
    HQJDJLQJSHULPHWHU DURXQG+DULDQG'RUV6RPHFDUULHGIODVKVFUHHQ
    SURMHFWRUVFDSDEOHRIZDUGLQJRIIDIXOOKHDY\ZHDSRQVDVVDXOW2WKHUVORRNHG
    HTXDOO\GDQJHURXVEDUHKDQGHG
    7KHLUVFDUOHWDQGEOXHXQLIRUPVPDGHLWHDV\WRVHHZKHUHWKHFURZGZDV
    LPSLQJLQJRQWKHPRYLQJ VHFXULW\ERXQGDU\DV+DULZDONHGVORZO\DFURVVWKH
    PDLQFDPSXVVTXDUH:KHUHWKHFURZGZDVWKLFNHVWWKHEULJKWXQLIRUPVVLPSO\
    EXOOHGWKHLUZD\WKURXJK7KHHQWLUHVSHFWDFOHPDGHKLPDFXWHO\XQFRPIRUWDEOH
    6SHFLDOVZHUHQRWQRWHGIRUWKHLUGLSORPDF\DQGWKLVZDVDIWHUDOODTXLHW
    SODFHRIOHDUQLQJ2UKDGEHHQ
    'RUVFODVSHGKLVKDQGLQUHDVVXUDQFH$)LUVW0LQLVWHUFDQWVLPSO\
    ZDONDURXQGZLWKRXW
    ,PQRW)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    7KH(PSHURUKDVGHVLJQDWHG\RXDQGWKDWVHQRXJKIRUWKLVFURZG
    7KH+LJK&RXQFLOKDVQWDFWHG8QWLOWKH\GR
    <RXUIULHQGVZLOODVVXPHWKHEHVWVKHVDLGPLOGO\
    7KHVHDUHP\IULHQGV"+DULH\HGWKHFURZGVXVSLFLRXVO\
    7KH\UHVPLOLQJ
    6RWKH\ZHUH2QHFDOOHG+DLOWKH3URI0LQLVWHUDQGRWKHUVODXJKHG
    ,VWKDWP\QLFNQDPHQRZ"
    :HOOLWVQRWDEDGRQH
    :K\GRWKH\IORFNVR"
    3HRSOHDUHGUDZQWRSRZHU
    ,PVWLOOMXVWDSURIHVVRU
    7RRIIVHWKLVLUULWDWLRQ'RUVFKXFNOHGDWKLPDZLIHO\UHIOH[
    7KHUHVDQDQFLHQWVD\LQJ7KHVHDUHWKHWLPHVWKDWIU\PHQVVRXOV
    <RXKDYHDELWRIKLVWRULFDOZLVGRPIRUHYHU\WKLQJ
    ,WVRQHRIWKHIHZSHUNVWKDWFRPHZLWKEHLQJDQKLVWRULDQ
    6RPHRQHFDOOHG+H\0DWK0LQLVWHU
    +DULVDLG,GRQWOLNHWKDWQDPHDQ\EHWWHU
    *HWXVHGWRLW<RXOOEHFDOOHGZRUVH
    7KH\SDVVHGE\WKHJUHDW6WUHHOLQJIRXQWDLQDQG+DULWRRNUHIXJHLQD
    PRPHQWRIFRQWHPSODWLQJLWVKLJKDUFKLQJZDWHUV7KHVSODVKHVGURZQHGRXWWKH
    FURZGDQGKHFRXOGDOPRVWLPDJLQHKHZDVEDFNLQKLVVLPSOHKDSS\OLIH7KHQ
    KHKDGRQO\KDGWRZRUU\DERXWSV\FKRKLVWRU\DQG6WUHHOLQJ8QLYHUVLW\
    LQILJKWLQJ7KDWVQXJOLWWOHZRUOGKDGYDQLVKHGSHUKDSVIRUHYHUWKHPRPHQW
    &OHRQGHFLGHGWRPDNHKLPDILJXUHLQ,PSHULDOSROLWLFV

    7KHIRXQWDLQZDVJORULRXV\HWHYHQLWUHPLQGHGKLPRIWKHYDVWQHVVWKDW
    OD\EHQHDWKVXFKVLPSOLFLWLHV+HUHWKHWLQNOLQJVWUHDPVEURNHIUHHEXWWKHLU
    IOLJKWZDVPRPHQWDU\7UDQWRUVZDWHUVUDQLQPRXUQIXOGDUNSLSHVGRZQGLP
    SDVVDJHVVFRXUHGE\DQFLHQWHQJLQHHUV$PD]HRIIUHVKZDWHUDUWHULHVDQG
    VHZDJHYHLQVWZLQHGWKURXJKWKHHWHUQDOERZHOV7KHVHERGLO\IOXLGVRIWKH
    SODQHWKDGSDVVHGWKURXJKXQFRXQWDEOHWULOOLRQVRINLGQH\VDQGWKURDWVKDG
    ZDVKHGDZD\VLQVEHHQWRDVWHGZLWKDWPDUULDJHVDQGELUWKVKDGFDUULHGRII
    WKHEORRGRIPXUGHUVDQGWKHYRPLWRIWHUPLQDODJRQLHV7KH\IORZHGRQLQ
    WKHLUGHHSQLJKWQHYHUNQRZLQJWKHFOHDQYDSRUMR\RIXQIHWWHUHGZHDWKHU
    QHYHUIUHHRIPDQVKDQG
    7KH\ZHUHWUDSSHG6RZDVKH
    7KHLUSDUW\UHDFKHGWKH0DWKLVW'HSDUWPHQWDQGDVFHQGHG'RUVURVH
    WKURXJKWKH WUDSWXEHEHVLGHKLPDEUHH]HIOXWWHULQJKHUKDLUDPLDEO\WKH
    HIIHFWTXLWHIODWWHULQJ7KH6SHFLDOVWRRNXSZDWFKIXOULJLGSRVLWLRQV
    RXWVLGH
    -XVWDVKHKDGIRUWKHODVWZHHN+DULWULHGDJDLQZLWKWKHFDSWDLQ
    /RRN\RXGRQWUHDOO\QHHGWRNHHSDGR]HQPHQVLWWLQJRXWKHUH
    ,OOEHWKHMXGJHRIWKDW$FDGHPLFLDQVLULI\RXSOHDVH
    +DULIHOWIUXVWUDWHGDWWKHZDVWHRILW+HQRWLFHGD\RXQJ6SHFLDOPDQ
    H\HLQJ'RUVZKRVHXQLVXLWUHYHDOHGZKLOHVWLOOFRYHULQJ6RPHWKLQJPDGHKLP
    VD\:HOOWKHQ,ZLOOWKDQN\RXWRKDYH\RXUPHQNHHSWKHLUH\HVZKHUHWKH\
    EHORQJ
    7KHFDSWDLQORRNHGVWDUWOHG+HJODUHGDWWKHRIIHQGLQJPDQDQGVWRPSHG
    RYHUWRUHSULPDQGKLP+DULIHOWDVSDUNRIVDWLVIDFWLRQ*RLQJLQWKH
    HQWUDQFHWRKLVRIILFH'RUVVDLG,OOWU\WRGUHVVPRUHVWULFWO\
    1RQR,PMXVWEHLQJVWXSLG,VKRXOGQWOHWWLQ\WKLQJVOLNHWKDW
    ERWKHUPH
    6KHVPLOHGSUHWWLO\$FWXDOO\,UDWKHUOLNHGLW
    <RXGLG"0HEHLQJVWXSLG"
    <RXUEHLQJSURWHFWLYH
    'RUVKDGEHHQDVVLJQHG\HDUVEHIRUHWRZDWFKRYHUKLPE\(WR'HPHU]HO
    +DULUHIOHFWHGWKDWKHKDGJRWWHQXVHGWRWKDWUROHRIKHUVOLWWOHQRWLFLQJ
    WKDWLWFRQIOLFWHGLQDGHHSXQVSRNHQZD\ZLWKKHUDOVREHLQJDZRPDQ'RUV
    ZDVXWWHUO\VHOIUHOLDQWEXWVKHKDGTXDOLWLHVZKLFKVRPHWLPHVGLGQRWHDVLO\
    MLEHZLWKKHUGXW\%HLQJKLVZLIHIRUH[DPSOH
    ,ZLOOKDYHWRGRLWPRUHRIWHQKHVDLGOLJKWO\
    6WLOOKHIHOWDSDQJRIJXLOWDERXWPDNLQJWURXEOHIRUWKH6SHFLDOPHQ
    7KHLUEHLQJKHUHZDVFHUWDLQO\QRWWKHLULGHD&OHRQKDGRUGHUHGLW1RGRXEW
    WKH\ZRXOGIDUUDWKHUEHRIIVRPHZKHUHVDYLQJWKH(PSLUHZLWKVZHDWDQGYDORU
    7KH\ZHQWWKURXJKWKHKLJKDUFKHGIR\HURIWKH0DWKLVW'HSDUWPHQW+DUL
    QRGGLQJWRWKHVWDII'RUVZHQWLQWRKHURZQRIILFHDQGKHKXUULHGLQWRKLV
    VXLWHZLWKDQDLURIDQDQLPDOUHWUHDWLQJLQWRLWVEXUURZ+HFROODSVHGLQWR
    KLVDLUFKDLULJQRULQJWKHXUJHQWPHVVDJHKRORWKDWKXQJDPHWHUIURPKLV
    IDFH
    $ZDYHHUDVHGLWDV<XJR$PDU\OFDPHLQWKURXJKWKHFRQQHFWLQJHVWDW
    SRUWDO7KHLQWUXVLYHEXON\SRUWDOZDVDOVRWKHIUXLWRI&OHRQVVHFXULW\
    RUGHU7KH6SHFLDOVKDGLQVWDOOHGWKHVKLPPHULQJZHDSRQVQXOOLQJILHOGV
    HYHU\ZKHUH7KH\OHQWDQLUNVRPHSULFNO\VPHOORIR]RQHWRWKHDLU2QHPRUH
    LQWUXVLRQRI5HDOLW\ZHDULQJWKHPDVNRI3ROLWLFV
    <XJRVJULQVSOLWKLVEURDGIDFH*RWVRPHQHZUHVXOWV
    &KHHUPHXSVKRZPHVRPHWKLQJVSOHQGLG
    <XJRVDWRQ+DULVEURDGHPSW\GHVNRQHOHJGDQJOLQJ*RRG
    PDWKHPDWLFVLVDOZD\VWUXHDQGEHDXWLIXO
    &HUWDLQO\%XWLWGRHVQWKDYHWREHWUXHLQ WKHVHQVHWKDWRUGLQDU\
    SHRSOHPHDQ,WFDQVD\QRWKLQJZKDWHYHUDERXWWKHZRUOG
    <RXUHPDNLQJPHIHHOOLNHDGLUW\HQJLQHHU
    +DULVPLOHG<RXZHUHRQFHUHPHPEHU"

    'RQW,
    0D\EH\RXGUDWKHUEHVZHDWLQJLWRXWDVDKHDWVLQNHU"
    +DULKDG IRXQG<XJRE\FKDQFHHLJKW\HDUVDJRMXVWDIWHUDUULYLQJRQ
    7UDQWRUZKHQKHDQG'RUVZHUHRQWKHUXQIURP,PSHULDODJHQWV$QKRXUVWDON
    KDGVKRZQ+DULWKDW<XJRZDVDQXQWXWRUHGJHQLXVDWWUDQVUHSUHVHQWDWLRQDO
    DQDO\VLV<XJRKDGDJLIWDQXQFRQVFLRXVOLJKWQHVVRIWRXFK7KH\KDG
    FROODERUDWHGHYHUVLQFH+DULKRQHVWO\WKRXJKWKHKDGOHDUQHGPRUHIURP<XJR
    WKDQWKHRWKHUZD\DURXQG
    +D<XJRFODSSHGKLVELJKDQGVWRJHWKHUWKUHHWLPHVLQWKH'DKOLWH
    PDQQHURIVKRZLQJDJUHHDEOHKXPRU<RXFDQJURXVHDERXWGRLQJILOWK\UHDO
    ZRUOGZRUNEXWDVORQJDVLWVLQDQLFHFRPIRUWDEOHRIILFH,PLQ
    SDUDGLVH
    ,VKDOOKDYHWRWXUQPRVWRIWKHKHDY\OLIWLQJRYHUWR\RX,IHDU
    +DULGHOLEHUDWHO\SXWKLVIHHWXSRQKLVGHVN0LJKWDVZHOOORRNFDVXDOHYHQ
    LIKHGLGQWIHHOWKDWZD\+HHQYLHG<XJRVKHDY\ERGLHGHDVH
    7KLV)LUVW0LQLVWHUVWXII"
    ,WLVJHWWLQJZRUVH,KDYHWRJRVHHWKH(PSHURUDJDLQ
    7KHPDQZDQWV\RX0XVWEH\RXUFUDJJ\SURILOH
    7KDWVZKDW'RUVWKLQNVWRR,ILJXUHLWVP\GLVDUPLQJVPLOH$Q\ZD\
    KHFDQWKDYHPH
    +HZLOO
    ,IKHIRUFHVWKHPLQLVWHUVKLSRQPH,VKDOOGRVXFKDORXV\MRE&OHRQ
    ZLOOILUHPH
    <XJRVKRRNKLVKHDG1RWZLVH)DLOHG)LUVW0LQLVWHUVDUHXVXDOO\WULHG
    DQGH[HFXWHG
    <RXYHEHHQWDONLQJWR'RUVDJDLQ
    6KHLVDKLVWRULDQ
    <HVDQGZHUHSV\FKRKLVWRULDQV6HHNHUVRISUHGLFWDELOLW\+DULWKUHZ
    XSKLVKDQGVLQH[DVSHUDWLRQ:K\GRHVQWWKDWFRXQWIRUDQ\WKLQJ"
    %HFDXVHQRERG\LQWKHFLWDGHOVRISRZHUKDVVHHQLWZRUN
    $QGWKH\ZRQW2QFHSHRSOHWKLQNZHFDQSUHGLFWZHZLOOQHYHUEHIUHH
    RISROLWLFV
    <RXUHQRWIUHHQRZ<XJRVDLGUHDVRQDEO\
    *RRGIULHQG\RXUZRUVHWUDLWLVLQVLVWLQJRQWHOOLQJPHWKHWUXWKLQD
    FDOPYRLFH
    ,WVDYHVNQRFNLQJVHQVHLQWR\RXUKHDG7KDWZRXOGWDNHORQJHU
    +DULVLJKHG,IRQO\PXVFOHVKHOSHGZLWKPDWKHPDWLFV<RXZRXOGEHHYHQ
    EHWWHUDWLW
    <XJRZDYHGWKHWKRXJKWDZD\<RXUHWKHNH\<RXUHWKHLGHDPDQ
    :HOOWKLVIRQWRILGHDVKDVQWJRWDFOXH
    ,GHDVWKH\OOFRPH
    ,QHYHUJHWDFKDQFHWRZRUNRQSV\FKRKLVWRU\DQ\PRUH
    $QGDV)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    ,WZLOOEHZRUVH3V\FKRKLVWRU\ZLOOJR
    1RZKHUHZLWKRXW\RX
    7KHUHZLOOEHVRPHSURJUHVV<XJR,DPQRWYDLQHQRXJKWRWKLQN
    HYHU\WKLQJGHSHQGVRQPH
    ,WGRHV
    1RQVHQVH7KHUHVVWLOO\RXWKH,PSHULDO)HOORZVDQGWKHVWDII
    :HQHHGOHDGHUVKLS7KLQNLQJOHDGHUVKLS
    :HOO,FRXOGFRQWLQXHWRZRUNKHUHSDUWRIWKHWLPH
    +DULORRNHGDURXQGKLVVSDFLRXVRIILFHDQGIHOWDSDQJDW WKHWKRXJKWRI
    QRWVSHQGLQJHYHU\GD\KHUHVXUURXQGHGE\KLVWRROVWRPHVDQGIULHQGV$V
    )LUVW0LQLVWHUKHZRXOGKDYHDPLQRUSDODFHEXWWRKLPLWZRXOGEHPHUH
    HPSW\PHDQLQJOHVVH[WUDYDJDQFH
    <XJRJDYHKLPDPRFNLQJJULQ)LUVW0LQLVWHULVXVXDOO\FRQVLGHUHGD
    IXOOWLPHMRE

    ,NQRZ,NQRZ%XWPD\EHWKHUHVDZD\
    7KHRIILFHKROREORRPHGLQWRIXOOSUHVHQWDWLRQDPHWHUIURPKLVKHDG
    7KHRIILFHIDPLOLDUZDVFRGHGWRSLSHWKURXJKRQO\KLJKSULRULW\PHVVDJHV
    +DULVODSSHGDNH\RQKLVGHVNDQGWKHSLFWXUHJDYHWKHJDWKHULQJLPDJHDUHG
    VTXDUHIUDPHWKHVLJQDOWKDWKLVILOWHUIDFHZDVRQ<HV"
    &OHRQVSHUVRQDODLGHDSSHDUHGLQUHGWXQLFDJDLQVWDEOXHEDFNJURXQG
    <RXDUHVXPPRQHGWKHZRPDQVDLGVLPSO\
    8K,DPKRQRUHG:KHQ"
    7KHZRPDQZHQWLQWRGHWDLOVDQG+DULZDVLPPHGLDWHO\WKDQNIXOIRUWKH
    ILOWHUIDFH7KHSHUVRQDORIILFHUZDVLPSRVLQJDQGKHGLGQRWZDQWWRDSSHDU
    WREHZKDWKHZDVDGLVWUDFWHGSURIHVVRU+LVILOWHUIDFHKDGDWDLORUHG
    HWLTXHWWHPHQX+HKDGDXWRPDWLFDOO\WKXPEHGLQDVXLWHRIERG\ODQJXDJH
    SRVWXUHVDQGJHVWXUHVWDLORUHGWRPDVNKLVWUXHIHHOLQJV
    9HU\ZHOOLQWZRKRXUV,VKDOOEHWKHUHKHFRQFOXGHGZLWKDVPDOO
    ERZ7KHILOWHUZRXOGUHQGHUWKDWVDPHPRWLRQVKDSHGWRWKHSURWRFROVRIWKH
    (PSHURUVVWDII
    'UDW+HVODSSHGKLVGHVNPDNLQJWKHKRORGLVVROYH0\GD\LV
    HYDSRUDWLQJ
    :KDWVLWPHDQ"
    7URXEOH(YHU\WLPH,VHH&OHRQLWVWURXEOH
    ,GXQQRFRXOGEHDFKDQFHWRVWUDLJKWHQRXW
    ,MXVWZDQWWREHOHIWDORQH
    $)LUVW 0LQLVWHUVKLS
    <RXEH)LUVW0LQLVWHU,ZLOOWDNHDMREDVDFRPSXWDWLRQDOVSHFLDOLVW
    FKDQJHP\QDPH+DULVWRSSHGDQGODXJKHGZU\O\%XW,GIDLODWWKDWWRR
    /RRN\RXQHHGWRFKDQJH\RXUPRRG'RQWZDQWWRZDONLQRQWKH
    (PSHURUZLWKWKDWVFRZO
    8PPP,VXSSRVHQRW9HU\ZHOOFKHHUPHXS:KDWZDVWKDWJRRGQHZV
    \RXPHQWLRQHG"
    ,WXUQHGXSVRPHDQFLHQWSHUVRQDOLW\FRQVWHOODWLRQV
    5HDOO\",WKRXJKWWKH\ZHUHLOOHJDO
    7KH\DUH+HJULQQHG/DZVGRQWDOZD\VZRUN
    7UXO\DQFLHQW",ZDQWHGWKHPIRUFDOLEUDWLRQRISV\FKRKLVWRULFDO
    YDOHQFHV7KH\KDYHWREHHDUO\(PSLUH
    <XJREHDPHG7KHVHDUHSUH(PSLUH
    3UHLPSRVVLEOH
    ,JRWHP,QWDFWWRR
    :KRDUHWKH\"
    6RPHIDPRXVW\SHVGXQQRZKDWWKH\GLG
    :KDWVWDWXVGLGWKH\KDYHWREHUHFRUGHG"
    <XJRVKUXJJHG1RSDUDOOHOKLVWRULFDOUHFRUGVHLWKHU
    $UHWKH\DXWKHQWLFUHFRUGLQJV"
    0LJKWEH7KH\UHLQDQFLHQWPDFKLQHODQJXDJHVUHDOO\SULPLWLYHVWXII
    +DUGWRWHOO
    7KHQWKH\FRXOGEHVLPV
    ,GVD\VR&RXOGEHWKH\UHEXLOWRQDUHFRUGHGXQGHUEDVHWKHQVLPPHG
    IRUURXQGQHVV
    <RXFDQNLFNWKHPXSWRVHQWLHQFH"
    <HDKZLWKVRPHZRUN*RWWRVWLWFKGDWDODQJXDJHV<NQRZWKLVLV
    DK
    ,OOHJDO9LRODWLRQRIWKH6HQWLHQFH&RGHV
    5LJKW7KHVHJX\V,JRWLWIURPWKH\UHRQWKDW1HZ5HQDLVVDQFHZRUOG
    6DUN7KH\VD\QRERG\SROLFHVWKRVHROG&RGHVDQ\PRUH
    ,WVWLPHZHNLFNHGRYHUDIHZRIWKRVHDQFLHQWEORFNV
    <HVVLU<XJRJULQQHG7KHVHFRQVWHOODWLRQVWKH\UHWKHROGHVW
    DQ\ERG\VHYHUIRXQG
    +RZGLG\RX"+DULOHWKLVTXHVWLRQWUDLORII<XJRKDGPDQ\VKDG\

    FRQQHFWLRQVEXLOWRQKLV'DKOLWHRULJLQV
    ,WWRRNDOLWWOHDKOXEULFDWLRQ
    ,WKRXJKWVR:HOOSHUKDSVEHVWWKDW,GRQWKHDUWKHGHWDLOV
    5LJKW$V)LUVW0LQLVWHU\RXGRQWZDQWGLUW\KDQGV
    'RQWFDOOPHWKDW
    6XUHVXUH\RXUHMXVWDMRXUQH\PDQSURIHVVRU:KRVJRLQJWREHODWH
    IRUKLVDSSRLQWPHQWZLWKWKH(PSHURULIKHGRHVQWKXUU\XS
    

    :DONLQJWKURXJKWKH,PSHULDO*DUGHQV+DUL ZLVKHG'RUVZDVZLWKKLP+H
    UHFDOOHGKHUZDULQHVVRYHUKLVFRPLQJDJDLQWRWKHDWWHQWLRQRI&OHRQ
    7KH\UHFUD]\RIWHQVKHKDGVDLGLQDGLVSDVVLRQDWHYRLFH7KHJHQWU\DUH
    HFFHQWULFZKLFKDOORZVHPSHURUVWREHEL]DUUH
    <RXH[DJJHUDWHKHKDGUHVSRQGHG
    'DGULDQWKH)UXJDODOZD\VXULQDWHGLQWKH,PSHULDO*DUGHQVVKHKDG
    DQVZHUHG+HZRXOGOHDYHVWDWHIXQFWLRQVWRGRLWVD\LQJWKDWLWVDYHGKLV
    VXEMHFWVDQHHGOHVVH[SHQVHLQZDWHU
    +DULKDGWRVXSSUHVVDODXJKSDODFHVWDIIZHUHXQGRXEWHGO\VWXG\LQJ
    KLP+HUHJDLQHGKLVVREHUPDQQHUE\DGPLULQJWKHRUQDWHWRZHULQJWUHHV
    VFXOSWHGLQWKH6SLQGOHULDQVW\OHRIWKUHHPLOOHQQLDEHIRUH+HIHOWWKHWXJ
    RIVXFKQDWXUDOEHDXW\GHVSLWHKLV\HDUVEXULHGLQ7UDQWRU+HUHYHUGDQW
    ZHDOWKVWUHWFKHG XSWRZDUGWKHEOD]LQJVXQOLNHRXWVWUHWFKHGDUPV7KLVZDV
    WKHRQO\RSHQVSRWRQWKHSODQHWDQGLWUHPLQGHGKLPRI+HOLFRQZKHUHKHKDG
    EHJXQ
    +HKDGEHHQDUDWKHUGUHDP\ER\LQDODERULQJGLVWULFWRI+HOLFRQ7KH
    ZRUNLQILHOGVDQGIDFWRULHVZDVHDV\ HQRXJKWKDWKHFRXOGWKLQNKLVRZQ
    VKLIWLQJDEVWUDFWPXVLQJVZKLOHKHGLGLW%HIRUHWKH&LYLO6HUYLFHH[DPV
    FKDQJHGKLVOLIHKHKDGZRUNHGRXWDIHZVLPSOHWKHRUHPVLQQXPEHUWKHRU\DQG
    ODWHUZDVFUXVKHGWRILQGWKDWWKH\ZHUHDOUHDG\NQRZQ+HOD\LQEHGDWQLJKW
    WKLQNLQJRISODQHVDQGYHFWRUVDQGWU\LQJWRHQYLVLRQGLPHQVLRQVODUJHUWKDQ
    WKUHHOLVWHQLQJWRWKHGLVWDQWEOHDWRIWKHSXIIGUDJRQVZKRFDPHGULIWLQJ
    GRZQWKHPRXQWDLQVLGHVLQVHDUFKRISUH\%LRHQJLQHHUHGIRUVRPHDQFLHQW
    SXUSRVHSUREDEO\KXQWLQJWKH\ZHUHUHYHUHGEHDVWV+HKDGQRWVHHQRQHIRU
    PDQ\\HDUV
    +HOLFRQWKHZLOGWKDWZDVZKDWKHORQJHGIRU%XWKLVGHVWLQ\VHHPHG
    VXEPHUJHGLQ7UDQWRUVVWHHO
    +DULJODQFHGEDFNDQGKLV6SHFLDOVWKLQNLQJWKH\ZHUHVXPPRQHGWURWWHG
    IRUZDUG1RKHVDLGKLVKDQGVSXVKLQJDLUWRZDUGWKHPDJHVWXUHKHZDV
    PDNLQJDOOWKHWLPHWKHVHGD\VKHUHIOHFWHG(YHQLQWKH,PSHULDO*DUGHQV
    WKH\DFWHGDVWKRXJKHYHU\JDUGHQHUZDVDSRWHQWLDODVVDVVLQ
    +HKDGFRPHWKLVZD\UDWKHUWKDQVLPSO\HPHUJHIURPWKHJUDYOLIWHU
    LQVLGHWKHSDODFHEHFDXVHKHOLNHGWKHJDUGHQVDERYHDOOHOVH,QWKHGLVWDQW
    KD]HDZDOORIWUHHVWRZHUHGFRD[HGXSZDUGE\JHQHWLFHQJLQHHULQJXQWLOWKH\
    REVFXUHGWKHUDPSDUWVRI7UDQWRU2QO\KHUHRQDOOWKHSODQHWZDVLW
    SRVVLEOHWRH[SHULHQFHVRPHWKLQJUHVHPEOLQJWKHRXWRIGRRUV
    :KDWDQDUURJDQWWHUP+DULWKRXJKW7RGHILQHDOORIFUHDWLRQE\LWV
    O\LQJRXWVLGHWKHGRRUZD\VRIKXPDQLW\
    +LVIRUPDOVKRHVFUXQFKHGDJDLQVWJUDYHODVKHOHIWWKHVKHOWHUHG
    ZDONZD\VDQGPRXQWHGWKHIRUPDOUDPS%H\RQGWKHIRUHVWHGSHULPHWHUURVHD
    SOXPHRIEODFNVPRNH+HVORZHGDQGHVWLPDWHGGLVWDQFHSHUKDSVWHQNOLFNV
    6RPHPDMRULQFLGHQWVXUHO\
    6WULGLQJEHWZHHQWDOOQHRSDQWKHRQLFFROXPQVKHIHOWDZHLJKWGHVFHQG
    $WWHQGDQWVGDVKHGRXWWRZHOFRPHKLPKLV6SHFLDOVWLJKWHQHGXSEHKLQGDQG
    WKH\PDGHDOLWWOHSURFHVVLRQWKURXJKWKHORQJFRUULGRUVOHDGLQJWRWKH9DXOW
    RI$XGLHQFH+HUHWKHDFFXPXODWHGJUHDWDUWZRUNVRIPLOOHQQLDFURZGHGHDFK
    RWKHUDVLIVHHNLQJDFRQVWLWXHQF\LQWKHSUHVHQWWRJLYHWKHPOLIH

    7KHKHDY\KDQGRIWKH,PSHULXPOD\XSRQPRVWRIILFLDODUW7KH(PSLUH
    ZDVHVVHQWLDOO\DERXWWKHSDVWLWVVROLGLW\DQGVRH[SUHVVHGLWVWDVWHZLWK
    DSUHIHUHQFHIRUWKHSUHWW\(PSHURUVIDYRUHGWKHFOHDQVWUDLJKWOLQHVRI
    DVFHQGLQJVODEVWKHH[DFWSDUDERODVRIDUFLQJSXUSOHZDWHUIRXQWDLQV
    FODVVLFDOFROXPQVDQGEXWWUHVVHVDQGDUFKHV+HURLFVFXOSWXUHDERXQGHG1REOH
    EURZVH\HGLQILQLWHSURVSHFWV&RORVVDOEDWWOHVVWRRGIUR]HQDWFOLPDFWLF
    PRPHQWVVKDSHGLQJORZLQJVWRQHDQGKRORLGFU\VWDO
    $OOZHUHHQWLUHO\SURSHUDQGGHYRLGRIHPEDUUDVVLQJFKDOOHQJH1R
    DODUPLQJDUWKHUHWKDQN\RX1RWKLQJGLVWXUELQJZDVHYHQDOORZHGLQSXEOLF
    SODFHVRQ7UDQWRUZKLFKWKH(PSHURUPLJKWYLVLW%\H[SRUWLQJWRWKHSHULSKV
    DOOKLQWRIWKHXQSOHDVDQWQHVVDQGVPHOORIKXPDQOLYHVWKH,PSHULXPDFKLHYHG
    LWVILQDOVWDWHWKHWHUPLQDOO\EODQG
    <HWWR+DULWKHUHDFWLRQDJDLQVWEODQGQHVVZDVZRUVH$PRQJWKH
    JDOD[\VWZHQW\ILYHPLOOLRQLQKDELWHGSODQHWVHQGOHVVYDULDWLRQVDSSHDUHG
    EXWWKHUHVLPPHUHGEHQHDWKWKH,PSHULDOEODQNHWDVW\OHEDVHGVROHO\RQ
    UHMHFWLRQ
    3DUWLFXODUO\DPRQJWKRVH+DULWHUPHGFKDRVZRUOGV DVPXJDYDQWJDUGH
    IXPEOHGIRUWKHVXEOLPHE\VXEVWLWXWLQJIRUEHDXW\DORYHRIWHUURUVKRFN
    DQGWKHVLFNHQLQJO\JURWHVTXH7KH\XVHGHQRUPRXVVFDOHRUDFXWH
    GLVSURSRUWLRQRUVFDWRORJ\RUGLVFRUGDQGLUUDWLRQDOGLVMXQFWLRQ
    %RWKDSSURDFKHVZHUHERULQJ1HLWKHUKDGDQ\DLU\MR\
    $ZDOOGLVVROYHGFUDFNOLQJDQGWKH\HQWHUHGWKH9DXOWRI$XGLHQFH
    $WWHQGDQWVYDQLVKHGKLV6SHFLDOVIHOOEHKLQG$EUXSWO\+DULZDVDORQH+H
    SDGGHGRYHUWKHFXVKLRQ\IORRU%DURTXHH[FHVVOHHUHGDWKLPIURPHYHU\UDLVHG
    FRUQLFHXSMXWWLQJRUQDPHQWDQGHODERUDWHZDLQVFRWLQJ
    6LOHQFH7KH(PSHURUZDVQHYHUZDLWLQJIRUDQ\RQHRIFRXUVH7KHJORRP\
    FKDPEHUJDYHEDFNQRHFKRHVDVWKRXJKWKHZDOOVDEVRUEHGHYHU\WKLQJ
    ,QGHHGWKH\SUREDEO\GLG1RGRXEWHYHU\,PSHULDOFRQYHUVDWLRQZHQW
    LQWRVHYHUDOHDUV7KHUHPLJKWEHHDYHVGURSSHUVKDOIZD\DFURVVWKH*DOD[\
    $OLJKWPRYLQJ'RZQDFUDFNOLQJJUDYFROXPQFDPH&OHRQ+DUL6R
    KDSS\\RXFRXOGFRPH
    6LQFHUHIXVLQJDVXPPRQVE\WKH(PSHURUZDVWUDGLWLRQDOO\JURXQGVIRU
    H[HFXWLRQ+DULFRXOGEDUHO\VXSSUHVVDZU\VPLOH0\KRQRUWRVHUYHVLUH
    &RPHVLW
    &OHRQPRYHGKHDYLO\5XPRUKDGLWWKDWKLVDSSHWLWHDOUHDG\OHJHQGDU\
    KDGEHJXQWRH[FHHGHYHQWKHVNLOOVRIKLVFRRNVDQGSK\VLFLDQV:HKDYHPXFK
    WRGLVFXVV
    7KH(PSHURUVFRQVWDQWDWWHQGDQWJORZVHUYHGWRVXEWO\HQKDQFHKLPZLWK
    LWVQLPEXV7KHFRQWUDVWZDVPLOGVHUYLQJWRGUDZKLPRXWIURPDFRPSDUDWLYH
    VXUURXQGLQJJORRP7KHURRPVHPEHGGHGLQWHOOLJHQFHVWUDFNHGKLVH\HVDQGVKHG
    DGGHGOLJKWZKHUHKLVJD]HIHOODJDLQZLWKGHOLFDWHHPSKDVLVVXEWO\DSSOLHG
    7KHVRIWWRXFKRIKLVUHJDUG\LHOGHGDUDGLDQFHZKLFKJXHVWVVFDUFHO\QRWLFHG
    EXWZKLFKDFWHGVXEFRQVFLRXVO\DGGLQJWRWKHLUDZH+DULNQHZWKLV\HWWKH
    HIIHFWVWLOOZRUNHG&OHRQORRNHGPDVWHUIXOUHJDO
    ,IHDUZHKDYHKLWDVQDJ&OHRQVDLG
    1RWKLQJ\RXFDQQRWPDVWHU,DPVXUHVLUH
    &OHRQVKRRNKLVKHDGZHDULO\1RZGRQW\RXWRRJRRQDERXWP\
    SURGLJLRXVSRZHUV6RPHHOHPHQWVKHGUHZWKHZRUGRXWZLWKGU\GLVGDLQ
    REMHFWWR\RXUDSSRLQWPHQW
    ,VHH+DULNHSWKLVIDFHEODQNEXWKLVKHDUWOHDSHG
    'RQRWEHJOXP,GRZDQW\RXIRUP\)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    <HVVLUH
    %XW,DPQRWGHVSLWHFRPPRQSODFHDVVXPSWLRQXWWHUO\IUHHWRDFW
    ,UHDOL]HWKDWPDQ\RWKHUVDUHEHWWHUTXDOLILHG
    ,QWKHLURZQH\HVVXUHO\
    DQGEHWWHUWUDLQHGDQG
    $QGNQRZQRWKLQJRISV\FKRKLVWRU\

    'HPHU]HOH[DJJHUDWHGWKHXWLOLW\RISV\FKRKLVWRU\
    1RQVHQVH+HVXJJHVWHG\RXUQDPHWRPH
    <RXNQRZDVZHOODV@WKDWKHZDVH[KDXVWHGQRWLQKLVEHVWIUDPHRI
    +LVMXGJPHQWZDVLPSHFFDEOHIRUGHFDGHV&OHRQH\HG+DUL2QHZRXOG
    DOPRVWWKLQN\RXZHUHWU\LQJWRDYRLGDSSRLQWPHQWDV)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    1RVLUHEXW
    0HQDQGZRPHQIRUWKDWPDWWHUKDYHNLOOHGIRUIDUOHVV
    $QGEHHQNLOOHGRQFHWKH\JRWLW
    &OHRQFKXFNOHG7UXHHQRXJK6RPH)LUVW0LQLVWHUVGRJHWVHOI
    LPSRUWDQWEHJLQWRVFKHPHDJDLQVWWKHLU(PSHURUEXWOHWXVQRWGZHOOXSRQ
    WKHIHZIDLOXUHVRIRXUV\VWHP
    +DULUHFDOOHG'HPHU]HOVD\LQJ7KHVXFFHVVLRQRIFULVHVKDVUHDFKHGWKH
    SRLQWZKHUHWKHFRQVLGHUDWLRQRIWKH7KUHH/DZVRI5RERWLFVSDUDO\]HVPH
    'HPHU]HOKDGEHHQXQDEOHWRPDNHFKRLFHVEHFDXVHWKHUHZHUHQRJRRGRQHVOHIW
    (YHU\SRVVLEOHPRYHKXUWVRPHRQHEDGO\6R'HPHU]HODVXSUHPHLQWHOOLJHQFH
    DFODQGHVWLQHKXPDQLIRUPURERWKDGVXGGHQO\OHIWWKHVFHQH:KDWFKDQFHGLG
    +DULKDYH"
    ,ZLOODVVXPHWKHSRVLWLRQRIFRXUVH+DULVDLGTXLHWO\LI
    QHFHVVDU\
    2KLWVQHFHVVDU\,ISRVVLEOH\RXPHDQ)DFWLRQVRQWKH+LJK&RXQFLO
    RSSRVH\RX7KH\GHPDQGDIXOOGLVFXVVLRQ
    +DULEOLQNHGDODUPHG:LOO,KDYHWRGHEDWH"
    DQGWKHQDYRWH
    ,KDGQRLGHDWKH&RXQFLOFRXOGLQWHUYHQH
    5HDGWKH&RGHV7KH\GRKDYHWKDWSRZHU7\SLFDOO\WKH\GRQRWXVHLW
    ERZLQJWRWKHVXSHULRUZLVGRPRIWKH(PSHURU$GU\OLWWOHODXJK1RWWKLV
    WLPH
    ,ILWZRXOGPDNHLWHDVLHUIRU\RX,FRXOGDEVHQWP\VHOIZKLOHWKH
    GLVFXVVLRQ
    1RQVHQVH,ZDQWWRXVH\RXWRFRXQWHUWKHP
    ,KDYHQWDQ\LGHDVKRZWR
    ,OOVFHQWRXWWKHLVVXHV\RXDGYLVHPHRQDQVZHUV'LYLVLRQRIODERU
    QRWKLQJFRXOGEHVLPSOHU
    8P'HPHU]HOKDGVDLGFRQILGHQWO\,IKHEHOLHYHV\RXKDYHWKH
    SV\FKRKLVWRULFDODQVZHUKHZLOOIROORZ\RXHDJHUO\DQGWKDWZLOOPDNH\RXD
    JRRG)LUVW0LQLVWHU+HUHLQVXFKDXJXVWVXUURXQGLQJVWKDWVHHPHGTXLWH
    XQOLNHO\
    :HZLOOKDYHWRHYDGHWKHVHRSSRQHQWVPDQHXYHUDJDLQVWWKHP
    ,KDYHQRLGHDKRZWRGRWKDW
    2IFRXUVH\RXGRQRW,GR%XW\RXVHHWKH(PSLUHDQGDOOLWVKLVWRU\
    DVRQHXQIXUOLQJVFUROO<RXKDYHWKHWKHRU\
    &OHRQUHOLVKHGUXOLQJ+DULIHOWLQKLVERQHVWKDWKHGLGQRW$V)LUVW
    0LQLVWHUKLVZRUGFRXOGGHWHUPLQHWKHIDWHRIPLOOLRQV7KDWKDGGDXQWHGHYHQ
    'HPHU]HO
    7KHUHLVVWLOOWKH=HURWKODZ'HPHU]HOKDGVDLGMXVWEHIRUHWKH\
    SDUWHGIRUWKHODVWWLPH,WSODFHGWKHZHOOEHLQJRIKXPDQLW\DVDZKROH
    DERYHWKDWRIDQ\VLQJOHKXPDQ7KH)LUVWODZWKHQUHDG$URERWPD\QRW
    LQMXUHDKXPDQEHLQJRUWKURXJKLQDFWLRQDOORZDKXPDQEHLQJWRFRPHWR
    KDUPXQOHVVWKLVZRXOGYLRODWHWKH=HURWK/DZ)DLUHQRXJKEXWKRZZDV+DUL
    WRFDUU\RXWDMREZKLFKQRWHYHQ'HPHU]HOFRXOGGR"+DULUHDOL]HGWKDWKHKDG
    EHHQVLOHQWIRUWRRORQJDQGWKDW&OHRQZDVZDLWLQJ:KDWFRXOGKHVD\"
    8PZKRRSSRVHVPH"
    6HYHUDOIDFWLRQVXQLWHGEHKLQG%HWDQ/DPXUN
    :KDWVKLVREMHFWLRQ"
    7RKLVVXUSULVHWKH(PSHURUODXJKHGKHDUWLO\7KDW\RXDUHQW%HWDQ
    /DPXUN
    <RXFDQWVLPSO\

    2YHUUXOHWKH&RXQFLO"2IIHU/DPXUNDGHDO"%X\KLPRII"
    ,GLGQWPHDQWRLPSO\ VLUHWKDW\RXZRXOGVWRRSWR
    2IFRXUVH,ZRXOGVWRRSDV\RXSXWLW7KHGLIILFXOW\OLHVZLWK
    /DPXUNKLPVHOI+LVSULFHWRDOORZ\RXLQDV)LUVW0LQLVWHUZRXOGEHWRR
    KLJK
    6RPHKLJKSRVLWLRQ"
    7KDWDQGVRPHHVWDWHVSHUKDSVDQHQWLUH=RQH
    7XUQLQJDQHQWLUH=RQHRIWKH*DOD[\RYHUWRDVLQJOHPDQ+LJK
    VWDNHV
    &OHRQVLJKHG:HDUHQRWDVULFKWKHVHGD\V,QWKHUHLJQRI)OHWFK
    WKH)XULRXVKHEDUWHUHGZKROH=RQHVVLPSO\IRUVHDWVRQWKH&RXQFLO
    <RXUVXSSRUWHUVWKH5R\DOLVWVWKH\FDQWRXWPDQHXYHU/DPXUN"
    <RXUHDOO\PXVWVWXG\FXUUHQWSROLWLFVPRUH6HOGRQ7KRXJK,VXSSRVH
    \RXUHVRVWHHSHGLQKLVWRU\DOOWKLVVHHPVDELWWULYLDO"
    $FWXDOO\+DULWKRXJKWKHZDVVWHHSHGLQPDWKHPDWLFV'RUVVXSSOLHGWKH
    KLVWRU\KHQHHGHGRU<XJR,ZLOOGRVR6RWKH5R\DOLVWV
    +DYHORVWWKH'DKOLWHVVRWKH\FDQQRWPXVWHUDPDMRULW\FRDOLWLRQ
    7KH'DKOLWHVDUHWKDWSRZHUIXO"
    7KH\KDYHDQDUJXPHQWSRSXODUZLWKDEURDGDXGLHQFHSOXVDODUJH
    SRSXODWLRQ
    ,GLGQRWNQRZWKH\ZHUHVRVWURQJ0\RZQFORVHDVVLVWDQW<XJR
    ,NQRZD'DKOLWH:DWFKKLP
    +DULEOLQNHG<XJRLVDVWURQJ'DKOLWHWUXH%XWKHLVOR\DODILQH
    LQWXLWLYHPDWKLVW%XWKRZGLG\RX
    %DFNJURXQGFKHFN&OHRQ ZDYHGKLVKDQGLQDLU\GLVPLVVDO2QHPXVW
    NQRZDIHZWKLQJVDERXWD)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    +DULGLVOLNHGEHLQJXQGHUDQ,PSHULDOPLFURVFRSHEXWKHNHSWKLVIDFH
    EODQN<XJRLVOR\DOWRPH
    ,NQRZWKHVWRU\KRZ\RXXSOLIWHGKLPIURPKDUGODERUE\SDVVLQJWKH
    &LYLO6HUYLFHILOWHUV9HU\QREOHRI\RX%XW,FDQQRWRYHUORRNWKHIDFWWKDW
    WKH'DKOLWHVKDYHDUHDG\DXGLHQFHIRUWKHLUIHYHUHGRXWSRXULQJV7KH\
    WKUHDWHQWRDOWHUWKHUHSUHVHQWDWLRQRI6HFWRUVLQWKH+LJK&RXQFLOHYHQLQ
    WKH/RZHU&RXQFLO6R &OHRQMDEEHGDILQJHUZDWFKKLP
    <HVVLUH&OHRQZDVJHWWLQJVWHDPHGXSDERXWQRWKLQJDVIDUDV<XJR
    ZDVFRQFHUQHGEXWQRSRLQWLQDUJXLQJ
    <RXZLOOKDYHWREHDVFLUFXPVSHFWDVWKH(PSHURUVZLIHGXULQJWKLV
    DKWUDQVLWLRQDOSHULRG
    +DULUHFDOOHGWKHDQFLHQWVD\LQJWKDWDERYHDOOWKH(PSHURUVZLIH RU
    ZLYHVGHSHQGLQJXSRQWKHHUD PXVWNHHSKHUVNLUWVFOHDQQRPDWWHUZKDWPXFN
    VKHZDONVDERYH7KHDQDORJ\ZDVXVHGHYHQZKHQWKH(PSHURUSURYHGWREH
    KRPRVH[XDORUHYHQZKHQDZRPDQKHOGWKH,PSHULDO3DODFH<HVVLUH8K
    WUDQVLWLRQDO"
    &OHRQORRNHGRIILQDGLVWUDFWHGZD\DWWKHWRZHULQJVKDGRZ\DUWIRUPV
    ORRPLQJDURXQGWKHP%\QRZ+DULXQGHUVWRRGWKDWWKLVSRLQWHGWRWKHFUX[RI
    ZK\KHKDGEHHQVXPPRQHG<RXUDSSRLQWPHQWZLOOWDNHDZKLOHDVWKH+LJK
    &RXQFLOILGJHWV6R,VKDOOVHHN\RXUDGYLFH
    :LWKRXWJLYLQJPHWKHSRZHU
    :HOO\HV
    +DULIHOWQRGLVDSSRLQWPHQW6R,FDQVWD\LQP\RIILFHDW6WUHHOLQJ"
    ,VXSSRVHLWZRXOGVHHPIRUZDUGLI\RXFDPHKHUH
    *RRG1RZDERXWWKRVH6SHFLDOV
    7KH\PXVWUHPDLQZLWK\RX7UDQWRULVPRUHGDQJHURXVWKDQDSURIHVVRU
    NQRZV
    +DULVLJKHG<HVVLUH
    &OHRQORXQJHGEDFNKLVDLUFKDLUIROGLQJLWVHOIDERXWKLPHODERUDWHO\
    1RZ,ZRXOGOLNH\RXUDGYLFHRQWKLV5HQHJDWXPPDWWHU
    5HQHJDWXP"

    )RUWKHILUVWWLPH+DULVDZ&OHRQVKRZVXUSULVH<RXKDYHQRWIROORZHG
    WKHFDVH",WLVHYHU\ZKHUH
    ,DPDELWRXWRIWKHPDLQVWUHDPVLUH
    7KH5HQHJDWXPWKH6RFLHW\RI5HQHJDGHV7KH\NLOODQGGHVWUR\
    )RUZKDW"
    )RUWKHSOHDVXUHRIGHVWUXFWLRQ&OHRQVODSSHGKLVFKDLUDQJULO\DQG
    LWUHVSRQGHGE\PDVVDJLQJKLPDSSDUHQWO\DVWDQGDUGDQVZHU7KHODWHVWRI
    WKHLUPHPEHUVWRGHPRQVWUDWHWKHLUFRQWHPSWIRUVRFLHW\LVDZRPDQQDPHG
    .XWRQLQ6KHLQYDGHGWKH,PSHULDO*DOOHULHVWRUFKPHOWHGDUWPDQ\PLOOHQQLD
    ROGDQGNLOOHGWZRJXDUGV7KHQVKHSHDFHIXOO\WXUQHGKHUVHOIRYHUWRWKH
    RIILFHUVZKRDUULYHG
    <RXVKDOOKDYHKHUH[HFXWHG"
    2IFRXUVH&RXUWGHFLGHGVKHZDVJXLOW\TXLFNO\HQRXJKVKHFRQIHVVHG
    5HDGLO\"
    ,PPHGLDWHO\
    &RQIHVVLRQXQGHUWKHVXEWOHPLQLVWUDWLRQVRIWKH,PSHULDOVZDV
    OHJHQGDU\%UHDNLQJWKHIOHVKZDVHDV\HQRXJKWKH,PSHULDOVEURNHWKH
    VXVSHFWVSV\FKHDVZHOO6RVHQWHQFHFDQEHVHWE\\RXLWEHLQJDKLJK
    FULPHDJDLQVWWKH,PSHULXP
    2K\HVWKDWROGODZDERXWUHEHOOLRXVYDQGDOLVP
    ,WDOORZVWKHGHDWKSHQDOW\DQGDQ\VSHFLDOWRUWXUH
    %XWGHDWKLVQRWHQRXJK1RWIRUWKH5HQHJDWXPFULPHV6R,WXUQWRP\
    SV\FKRKLVWRULDQ
    <RXZDQWPHWR"
    *LYHPHDQ LGHD7KHVHSHRSOHVD\WKH\UHGRLQJLWWREULQJGRZQWKH
    H[LVWLQJRUGHUDQGDOOWKDWRIFRXUVH%XWWKH\JHWLPPHQVHSODQHWZLGH
    FRYHUDJHWKHLUQDPHVNQRZQE\HYHU\RQHDVWKHGHVWUR\HUVRIWLPHKRQRUHGDUW
    7KH\JRWRWKHLUJUDYHVIDPRXV$OOWKHSV\FKHUVVD\WKDWVWKHLUUHDO
    PRWLYDWLRQ,FDQNLOOWKHPEXWWKH\GRQWFDUHE\WKDWWLPH
    8P+DULVDLGXQFRPIRUWDEO\+HNQHZIXOOZHOOKHFRXOGQHYHU
    FRPSUHKHQGVXFKSHRSOH
    6RJLYHPHDQLGHD6RPHWKLQJSV\FKRKLVWRULFDO+DULZDVLQWULJXHGE\
    WKHSUREOHPEXWQRWKLQJFDPHWRPLQG+HKDGORQJDJROHDUQHGWRGHOLEHUDWHO\
    QRWFRQFHQWUDWHRQDYH[LQJTXHVWLRQLPPHGLDWHO\OHWWLQJKLVVXEFRQVFLRXV
    KDYHILUVWFUDFN7RJDLQWLPHKHDVNHG6LUH\RXVDZWKHVPRNHEH\RQGWKH
    JDUGHQV"
    8P"1R&OHRQ JDYHDTXLFNKDQGVLJQDOWRXQVHHQH\HVDQGWKHIDUZDOO
    EORVVRPHGZLWKOLJKW$IXOOKRORRIWKHJDUGHQVILOOHGWKHPDVVLYHVSDFH7KH
    RLO\EODFNSOXPHKDGJURZQ,WFRLOHGVQDNHOLNHLQWRWKHJUD\VN\
    $VRIWQHXWUDOYRLFHVSRNHLQPLGDLU$EUHDNGRZQZLWKLQVXUUHFWLRQ
    E\PHFKDQLFDOVKDVFDXVHGWKLVXQIRUWXQDWHODSVHLQGRPHVWLFRUGHU
    $WLNWRNULRW"7KLVVRUWRIWKLQJ+DULKDGKHDUGDERXW
    &OHRQURVHDQGZDONHGWRZDUGWKHKROR$K\HVDQRWKHUUHFDOFLWUDQW
    ULGGOH)RUVRPHUHDVRQWKHPHFKDQLFDOVDUHJRLQJDZU\/RRNDWWKDW+RZPDQ\
    OHYHOVDUHEXUQLQJ"
    7ZHOYHOHYHOVDUHDIODPHWKHDXWRYRLFHDQVZHUHG,PSHULDO$QDO\VLV
    HVWLPDWHVDGHDWKWROORIIRXUKXQGUHGWKLUW\VHYHQZLWKLQDQXQFHUWDLQW\RI
    HLJKW\IRXU
    ,PSHULDOFRVW"&OHRQ GHPDQGHG
    0LQRU6RPH,PSHULDO5HJXODUVZHUHKXUWLQVXEGXLQJPHFKDQLFDOV
    $K:HOOWKHQLWLVDVPDOOPDWWHU&OHRQZDWFKHGDVWKHZDOOFORVH
    XSSHG7KHYLHZSOXQJHGGRZQDVPRNLQJSLW7RWKHVLGHOLNHDEOD]LQJOD\HU
    FDNHZKROHIORRUVFXUOHG XSIURPWKHKHDW6SDUNVVKRWEHWZHHQHOHFWULFDO
    ERRVWHUV%XUVWSLSHVVKRZHUHGWKHIODPHVEXWKDGOLWWOHHIIHFW
    7KHQDGLVWDQWYLHZWHOHVFRSLQJXSLQWRRUELW7KHSURJUDPZDVJLYLQJ
    WKH(PSHURUDQH\HIXOVKRZLQJRIILWVFDSDELOLWLHV+DULJXHVVHGWKDWLW
    GLGQWRIWHQJHWWKHFKDQFH&OHRQWKH&DOPZDVRQHGHULVLYHQLFNQDPHIRUKLP

    IRUKHVHHPHGERUHGZLWKPRVWPDWWHUVWKDWPRYHGPHQ
    )URPVSDFHWKHRQO\GHHSJUHHQZDVWKH,PSHULDO*DUGHQVMXVWDVSORWFK
    DPLGWKHJUD\VDQGEURZQVRIURRIVDQGURRIDJULFXOWXUH&KDUFRDOEODFNVRODU
    FROOHFWRUVDQGEXUQLVKHGVWHHOSROHWRSROH7KHLFHFDSVKDGGLVVLSDWHGORQJ
    DJRDQGWKHVHDVVORVKHGLQXQGHUJURXQGFLVWHUQV
    7UDQWRUVXSSRUWHGIRUW\ELOOLRQSHRSOHLQDZRUOGZUDSSLQJVLQJOHFLW\
    VHOGRPOHVVWKDQKDOIDNLORPHWHUGHHS6HDOHGSURWHFWHGLWVELOOLRQVKDG
    ORQJJURZQXVHGWRUHF\FOHGDLUDQGVKRUWSHUVSHFWLYHVDQGIHDUHGWKHRSHQ
    VSDFHVDPHUHHOHYDWRUULGHDZD\
    7KHYLHZ]RRPHGGRZQLQWRWKHVPRN\SLWDJDLQ+DULFRXOGVHHWLQ\
    ILJXUHVOHDSLQJWR WKHLUGHDWKVWRHVFDSHWKHIODPHV+XQGUHGVG\LQJ+DULV
    VWRPDFKOXUFKHG,QFURZGHGVWDFNVRIKXPDQLW\DFFLGHQWVWRRNDIHDUVRPH
    WROO
    6WLOO+DULFDOFXODWHGWKHUHZHUHRQDYHUDJHRQO\DKXQGUHGSHRSOHLQD
    VTXDUHNLORPHWHURIWKHSODQHWVVXUIDFH3HRSOHMDPPHGLQWRWKHPRUHSRSXODU
    6HFWRUVRXWRISUHIHUHQFHQRWQHFHVVLW\:LWKWKHVHDVSXPSHGEHORZWKHUH
    ZDVDPSOHURRPIRUDXWRPDWHGIDFWRULHVGHHSPLQHVDQGLPPHQVHFDYHUQRXV
    JURZLQJSRGVZKHUHUDZPDWHULDOVIRUIRRGHPHUJHGZLWKOLWWOHGLUHFWKXPDQ
    ODERUQHHGHG7KHVHZHDULVRPHFKRUHVWKHWLNWRNVGLG%XWQRZWKH\ZHUH
    EULQJLQJPD\KHPWRWKHLQWULFDF\WKDWZDV7UDQWRUDQG&OHRQIXPHGDVKH
    ZDWFKHGWKHGLVDVWHUJURZHDWLQJDZD\ZKROHOD\HUVZLWKILHU\WHHWK
    0RUHILJXUHVZULWKHGLQWKHRUDQJHIODPHV7KHVHZHUHSHRSOHQRW
    VWDWLVWLFVKHUHPLQGHGKLPVHOI%LOHURVHLQKLVWKURDW7REHDOHDGHUPHDQW
    WKDWVRPHWLPHV\RXKDGWRORRNDZD\IURPWKHSDLQ&RXOGKHGRWKDW"
    $QRWKHUSX]]OHP\6HOGRQ&OHRQVDLGDEUXSWO\:K\GRWKH WLNWRNV
    KDYHWKHVHODUJHVFDOHGLVRUGHUVP\DGYLVHUVNHHSWHOOLQJPHDERXW"$K"
    ,GRQRW
    7KHUHPXVWEHVRPHSV\FKRKLVWRULFDOH[SODQDWLRQ
    7KHVHWLQ\SKHQRPHQDPD\ZHOOOLHEH\RQG
    :RUNRQLW)LQGRXW
    8K\HVVLUH
    +DULNQHZHQRXJKWROHW&OHRQSDGSRLQWOHVVO\DURXQGWKHYDXOWIURZQLQJ
    DWWKHFRQWLQXLQJZDOOKLJKVFHQHVRIFDUQDJHLQXWWHUVLOHQFH3HUKDSV+DUL
    WKRXJKWWKH(PSHURUZDVFDOPEHFDXVHKHKDGVHHQVRPXFKFDODPLW\DOUHDG\
    (YHQKRUUHQGRXVQHZVSDOOV$VREHULQJWKRXJKWZRXOGWKHVDPHKDSSHQWRWKH
    QDLYH+DUL6HOGRQ"
    &OHRQKDGVRPHZD\RIGHDOLQJZLWKGLVDVWHUWKRXJKIRUDIWHUDIHZ
    PRPHQWVKHZDYHGDQGWKHVFHQHVYDQLVKHG7KHYDXOWILOOHGZLWKFKHHUIXOPXVLF
    DQGWKHOLJKWLQJURVH$WWHQGDQWVVFDPSHUHGRXWZLWKERZOVDQGWUD\VRI
    DSSHWL]HUV$PDQDW+DULVHOERZRIIHUHGKLPDVWLP+DULZDYHGLWDZD\7KH
    VXGGHQVKLIWLQPRRGZDVKHDG\HQRXJK$SSDUHQWO\LWZDVFRPPRQSODFHWKRXJK
    IRUWKH,PSHULDO&RXUW
    +DULKDGIHOWVRPHWKLQJWLFNOLQJDWWKHEDFNRIKLVPLQGIRUVHYHUDO
    PLQXWHVQRZDQGWKHTXLHWPRPHQWVKDGJLYHQKLPDFKDQFHWRILQDOO\SD\
    DWWHQWLRQWRLW$V&OHRQDFFHSWHGDVWLPKHVDLGKHVLWDQWO\6LUH,"
    <HV"+DYHRQHDK"
    1RVVLU,,KDGDWKRXJKWDERXWWKH5HQHJDWXPDQGWKH.XWRQLQZRPDQ
    2KP\,GUDWKHUQRWWKLQNDERXW
    6XSSRVH\RXHUDVHKHULGHQWLW\
    &OHRQVKDQGVWRSSHGZLWKDVWLPKDOIZD\WRKLVQRVH$K"
    7KH\DUHZLOOLQJWRGLHRQFHWKH\YHDWWUDFWHGDWWHQWLRQ7KH\
    SUREDEO\WKLQNWKH\ZLOOOLYHRQEHIDPRXV7DNHWKDWDZD\IURPWKHP3HUPLW
    QRUHOHDVHRIWKHLUWUXHQDPHV,QDOOPHGLDDQGRIILFLDOGRFXPHQWVJLYHWKHP
    DQLQVXOWLQJQDPH
    &OHRQIURZQHG$QRWKHUQDPH"
    &DOOWKLV.XWRQLQZRPDQ0RURQ2QH7KHQH[WRQH0RURQ7KUR0DNHLW
    LOOHJDOE\,PSHULDOGHFUHHWRHYHUUHIHUWRKHUDQ\RWKHUZD\7KHQVKHDVD

    SHUVRQYDQLVKHVIURPKLVWRU\1RIDPH
    &OHRQEULJKWHQHG1RZWKDWVDQLGHD,OOWU\LW,QRWPHUHO\WDNH
    WKHLUOLYHV,FDQWDNHWKHLUVHOYHV
    +DULVPLOHGZDQO\DV&OHRQVSRNHWRDQDGMXWDQWJLYLQJLQVWUXFWLRQVIRU
    DIUHVK,PSHULDO'HFUHH+DULKRSHGLWZRXOGZRUNEXWLQDQ\FDVHLWKDG
    JRWWHQKLPRIIWKHKRRN&OHRQGLGQRWVHHPWRQRWLFHWKDWWKHLGHDKDG
    QRWKLQJWRGRZLWKSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    3OHDVHGKHWULHGDQDSSHWL]HU7KH\ZHUHVWDUWOLQJO\JRRG
    &OHRQEHFNRQHGWRKLP&RPH)LUVW0LQLVWHU,KDYHVRPHSHRSOHIRU\RX
    WRPHHW7KH\PLJKWSURYHXVHIXOHYHQWRDPDWKLVW
    ,DPKRQRUHG'RUVKDGFRDFKHGKLPRQDIHZKRPLOLHVWRXVHZKHQKH
    FRXOGWKLQNRIQRWKLQJWRVD\DQGKHWURWWHGRQHRXWQRZ:KDWHYHUZRXOGEH
    XVHIXOLQVHUYLFHWRWKHSHRSOH
    $K\HVWKHSHRSOH&OHRQGUDZOHG,KHDUVRPXFKDERXWWKHP
    +DULUHDOL]HGWKDW&OHRQKDGVSHQWDOLIHOLVWHQLQJWRSDWSUHGLFWDEOH
    VSHHFKHV6RUU\VLUH,
    ,WUHPLQGVPHRIDSROOUHVXOWDVVHPEOHGE\P\7UDQWRULDQ
    VSHFLDOLVWV&OHRQWRRNDQDSSHWL]HUIURPDZRPDQKDOIKLVVL]H7KH\DVNHG
    7RZKDWGR\RXDWWULEXWHWKHLJQRUDQFHDQGDSDWK\RIWKH7UDQWRULDQPDVVHV"
    DQGWKHPRVWFRPPRQUHSO\ZDV'RQWNQRZDQGGRQWFDUH
    2QO\ZKHQ&OHRQODXJKHGGLG+DULUHDOL]HWKLVZDVDMRNH
    

    +HZRNHZLWKLGHDVEX]]LQJLQKLVKHDG
    +DULKDGOHDUQHGWROLHVWLOOIDFHGRZQLQWKHJRVVDPHUHILHOGQHWWKDW
    FUDGOHGKLVQHFNDQGKHDGLQRSWLPXPDOLJQPHQWZLWKKLVVSLQHWRGULIW
    DQGOHWWKHIOLWWLQJQRWLRQVFROOLGHPHUJHIUDJPHQW
    +HKDGOHDUQHGWKLVWULFNZKLOHZRUNLQJRQKLVWKHVLV2YHUQLJKWKLV
    VXEFRQVFLRXVGLGDORWRIKLVZRUNIRUKLPLIKHZRXOGPHUHO\OLVWHQWRWKH
    UHVXOWVLQWKHPRUQLQJ%XWWKH\ZHUHGHOLFDWHPRWHVEHVWFDXJKWLQWKHILQH
    IDEULFRIKDOIVOHHS
    +HVDWXSDEUXSWO\DQGPDGHWKUHHTXLFNQRWHVRQKLVHQGWDEOH7KH
    VTXLJJOHVZRXOGEHVHQWWRKLVSULPDU\FRPSXWHUIRUODWHUUHFDOODWWKH
    RIILFH
    5RRRZZZUU'RUVVDLGVWUHWFKLQJ7KHLQWHOOHFWLVDOUHDG\XS
    8PKHVDLGVWDULQJLQWRVSDFH
    &PRQEHIRUHEUHDNIDVWLVERG\WLPH
    6HHLI\RXGLVDJUHHZLWKWKLVLGHD,MXVWKDG6XSSRVH
    ,DPQRWLQFOLQHG$FDGHPLFLDQ3URIHVVRU6HOGRQWRDUJXH
    +DULFDPHRXWRIKLVWUDQFH'RUVWKUHZEDFNWKHFRYHUVDQGKHDGPLUHG
    KHUORQJVOLPOHJV6KHKDGEHHQVFXOSWHGIRUVWUHQJWKDQGVSHHGEXWVXFK
    TXDOLWLHVFRQYHUJHGLQDQDJUHHDEOHFRQFHUWRIVXUIDFHVVSULQJ\WRWKHWRXFK
    \LHOGLQJ\HWUHVLVWLQJ+HIHOWKLPVHOIMHUNHGRXWRIKLVPRRGDQGLQWR
    %RG\WLPH\HV<RXDUHLQFOLQHGIRURWKHUSXUSRVHV
    7UXVWDVFKRODUWRSXWWKHSURSHUGHILQLWLRQWRDZRUG
    ,QWKHZDUPGL]]\LQJVFXIIOHWKDWIROORZHGWKHUHZDVVRPHODXJKWHU
    VRPHVXGGHQSDVVLRQDQGEHVWRIDOOQRWLPHWRWKLQN+HNQHZWKLVZDVMXVW
    ZKDWKHQHHGHGDIWHUWKHWHQVLRQVRI\HVWHUGD\DQG'RUVNQHZLWHYHQEHWWHU
    +HHPHUJHGIURP WKHYDSRULXPWRWKHVPHOORINDIIDQGEUHDNIDVWVHUYHG
    RXWE\WKHDXWRV7KHQHZVIOLWWHGDFURVVWKHIDUZDOODQGKHPDQDJHGWR
    LJQRUHPRVWRILW'RUVFDPHRXWRIKHUYDSRULXPSDWWLQJKHUKDLUDQGZDWFKHG
    WKHZDOOUDSWO\/RRNVOLNHPRUHVWDOOLQJLQWKH+LJK&RXQFLOVKHVDLG
    7KH\UHSXWWLQJRIIWKHULWXDOVHDUFKIRUPRUHIXQGLQJLQIDYRURIDUJXPHQWV
    RYHU6HFWRUVRYHUHLJQW\,IWKH'DKOLWHV
    1RWEHIRUH,LQJHVWVRPHFDORULHV
    %XWWKLVLVMXVWWKHVRUWRIWKLQJ\RXPXVWNHHSWUDFNRI

    1RW XQWLO,KDYHWR
    <RXNQRZ,GRQWZDQW\RXWRGRDQ\WKLQJGDQJHURXVEXWIRUQRZQRW
    SD\LQJDWWHQWLRQLVIRROLVK
    0DQHXYHULQJZKRVXSDQGZKRVGRZQVSDUHPH)DFWV,FDQIDFH
    )RQGRIIDFWVDUHQW\RX"
    2IFRXUVH
    7KH\FDQEHEUXWDO
    6RPHWLPHVWKH\UHDOOZHKDYH+HWKRXJKWDPRPHQWWKHQJUDVSHGKHU
    KDQG)DFWVDQGORYH
    /RYHLVDIDFWWRR
    0LQHLV7KHXQG\LQJSRSXODULW\RIHQWHUWDLQPHQWVGHYRWHGWRURPDQFH
    VXJJHVWVWKDWWRPRVWSHRSOHLWLVQRWDIDFWEXWDJRDO
    $QK\SRWKHVLV\RXPDWKHPDWLFLDQVZRXOGVD\
    *UDQWHG&RQMHFWXUHWREHSUHFLVH
    3UHVHUYHXVIURPSUHFLVLRQ
    +HVZHSWKHUVXGGHQO\LQWRKLVDUPVFXSSHGKHUUXPSLQKLVKDQGVDQG
    ZLWKVRPHHIIRUWKHWRRNWURXEOHWRFRQFHDOOLIWHGKHU%XWWKLVWKLVLVD
    IDFW
    0\P\6KHNLVVHGKLPILHUFHO\7KHPDQLVQRWDOOPLQG
    +HVXFFXPEHGWRWKHVHGXFWLYHPXOWLVHQVLFQHZVDVKHPXQFKHG+HKDG
    JURZQXSRQDIDUPDQGOLNHGELJEUHDNIDVWV'RUVDWHVSDULQJO\KHUWZLQ
    UHOLJLRQVVKHVDLGZHUHH[HUFLVHDQG+DUL6HOGRQWKHILUVWWRSUHVHUYHKHU
    VWUHQJWKIRUWKHVHFRQG+HWKXPEHGKLVRZQKDOIRIWKHZDOOWRWKH
    LQILQLWHVLPDOGRLQJVRIPDUNHWVILQGLQJWKHUHDEHWWHULQGH[RIKRZ7UDQWRU
    ZDVGRLQJWKDQLQWKHVWHQWRULDQEOXVWHURIWKH+LJK &RXQFLO
    $VDPDWKLVWKHOLNHGIROORZLQJWKHGHWDLOV%XWDIWHUILYHPLQXWHVRI
    LWKHVODSSHGWKHWDEOHLQIUXVWUDWLRQ
    3HRSOHKDYHORVWWKHLUJRRGVHQVH1R)LUVW0LQLVWHUFDQSURWHFWWKHP
    IURPWKHLURZQLQQRFHQFH
    0\FRQFHUQLVSURWHFWLQJ\RXIURPWKHP+DULEODQNHGKLVKRORDQG
    ZDWFKHGKHUVDQRUQDWH'RIWKHIDFWLRQVLQWKH+LJK&RXQFLO5HGWUDFHUV
    OLQNHGIDFWLRQVWKHUHZLWKDOOLHVLQWKH/RZ&RXQFLODEHZLOGHULQJVQDNHSLW
    <RXGRQWWKLQNWKLV)LUVW0LQLVWHUWKLQJLVJRLQJWRZRUNGR \RX"
    ,WFRXOG
    7KH\UHDEVROXWHO\ULJKW,PQRWTXDOLILHG
    ,V&OHRQ"
    :HOOKHKDVEHHQUHDUHGWRGRWKHMRE
    <RXUHGXFNLQJWKHTXHVWLRQ
    ([DFWO\+DULILQLVKHGKLVVWHDNDQGEHJDQRQWKHHJJTXKLOLVRXIIOp
    +HKDGOHIWWKHHVWLPRQDOOQLJKWWRLPSURYHKLVPXVFOHWRQHDQGWKDWPDGH
    KLPKXQJU\7KDWDQGWKHGHOLJKWIXOIDFWWKDW'RUVYLHZHGVH[DVDQDWKOHWLF
    RSSRUWXQLW\
    ,VXSSRVH\RXUSUHVHQWVWUDWHJ\LVEHVW'RUVVDLGWKRXJKWIXOO\
    5HPDLQDPDWKLVWDWDORIW\UHPRYHIURPWKHIUD\
    5LJKW1RERG\DVVDVVLQDWHVDJX\ZLWKQRSRZHU
    %XWWKH\GRHUDVHWKRVHZKRPLJKWJHWLQWKHZD\RIWKHLUWDNLQJ
    SRZHU
    +DULKDWHGWKLQNLQJRIVXFKWKLQJVVRHDUO\+HGXJLQWRWKHVRXIIOp,W
    ZDVHDV\WRIRUJHWDPLGWKHWDVWHVVSHFLDOO\GHVLJQHGWRILWKLVRZQZHOO
    WDEXODWHGOLNHVWKDWWKHPDQXIDFWXUXPEXLOWWKHLUPHDOIURPVHZDJH(JJVWKDW
    KDGQHYHUNQRZQWKHEHOO\RIDELUG0HDWDSSHDUHGZLWKRXWVNLQRUERQHVRU
    JULVWOHRUIDW&DUURWVDUULYHGZLWKRXWWRSNQRWV$IRRGPDQIDFZDVGHOLFDWHO\
    WXQHGWRUHSURGXFHWDVWHVMXVWVKRUWRIWKHDELOLW\WRDFWXDOO\PDNHDOLYH
    FDUURW7KHPLQRULVVXHRIZKHWKHUKLVVRXIIOpWDVWHGOLNHDUHDORQHPDGHE\
    DILQHFKHIIDGHGWRXQLPSRUWDQFHFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHIDFWWKDWLWWDVWHGJRRG
    WRKLPWKH RQO\DXGLHQFHWKDWPDWWHUHG
    +HUHDOL]HGWKDW'RUVKDGEHHQWDONLQJIRUVRPHPRPHQWVDERXW+LJK

    &RXQFLOPDQHXYHULQJVDQGKHKDGQRWUHJLVWHUHGDZRUG6KHKDGDGYLFHRQKRZ
    WRKDQGOHWKHLQHYLWDEOHQHZVSHRSOHRQKRZWRUHFHLYHFDOOVRQHYHU\WKLQJ
    (YHU\RQHGLGWKHVHGD\V
    +DULILQLVKHGKDGVRPHNDIIDQGIHOWUHDG\WRIDFHWKHGD\DVD
    PDWKLVWQRWDVDPLQLVWHU5HPLQGVPHRIZKDWP\PRWKHUXVHGWRVD\.QRZ
    KRZ\RXPDNH*RGODXJK"
    'RUVORRNHGEODQNGUDZQRXWRIKHUFRQFHQWUDWLRQ+RZWRRKWKLVLV
    KXPRU"
    <RXWHOOKLP\RXUSODQV
    6KHODXJKHGDJUHHDEO\
    2XWVLGHWKHLUDSDUWPHQWWKH\DFTXLUHGWKH6SHFLDOVDJDLQ+DULIHOWWKH\
    ZHUHXQQHFHVVDU\'RUVZDVTXLWHHQRXJK%XWKHFRXOGVFDUFHO\H[SODLQWKDWWR
    ,PSHULDORIILFLDOV7KHUHZHUHRWKHU6SHFLDOVRQWKHIORRUVDERYHDQGEHORZDV
    ZHOODIXOOYROXPHGHIHQVHVFUHHQ+DULZDYHGWRIULHQGVKHVDZRQWKHZD\
    DFURVVWKH6WUHHOLQJFDPSXVEXWWKHSUHVHQFHRIWKH6SHFLDOVKHOGWKHPDWWRR
    JUHDWDGLVWDQFHWRVSHDN
    +HKDGDORWRI0DWKLVW'HSDUWPHQWEXVLQHVVWRWHQGWREXWKHIROORZHG
    KLVLQVWLQFWDQGSXWKLVFDOFXODWLRQVILUVW%ULVNO\KHUHWULHYHGKLVLGHDV
    IURPWKHEHGVLGHQRWHSDGDQGVWDUHGDWWKHPGRRGOLQJDEVHQWO\LQDLU
    VWLUULQJV\PEROVOLNHDSRWRIVRXSIRURYHUDQKRXU
    :KHQKHZDVDWHHQDJHUWKHULJLGGULOOVRIVFKRROLQJKDGPDGHKLPWKLQN
    WKDWPDWKHPDWLFVZDVMXVWIHOLFLW\ZLWKDSDUWLFXODUNLQGRIPLQXWLDHNQRZLQJ
    WKLQJVDVRUWRIKLJKJUDGHFRLQFROOHFWLQJ<RXOHDUQHGUHODWLRQVDQG
    WKHRUHPVDQGSXWWKHPWRJHWKHU
    2QO\VORZO\GLGKHJOLPSVHWKHVRDULQJVWUXFWXUHVDERYHHDFKGLVFLSOLQH
    *UHDWVSDQVMRLQHGWKHYLVWDVRIWRSRORJ\WRWKHLQILQLWHVLPDOLQWULFDFLHVRI
    GLIIHUHQWLDOVRUWKHSORGGLQJVW\OHVRIQXPEHUWKHRU\WRWKHVKLIWLQJVDQGV
    RIJURXSDQDO\VLV2QO\WKHQGLGKHVHHPDWKHPDWLFVDVDODQGVFDSHD
    WHUULWRU\RIWKHPLQGWRURYHDQGVFRXW
    7RWUDYHUVHWKRVHH[SDQVHVKHZRUNHGLQPLQGWLPHORQJVWUHWFKHVRI
    XQLQWHUUXSWHGIORZZKHQKHFRXOGFRQFHQWUDWHXWWHUO\RQSUREOHPVIL[LQJWKHP
    OLNHIOLHVLQWLPHOHVVDPEHUWXUQLQJWKHPWKLVZD\DQGWKDWWRKLVLQVSHFWLQJ
    OLJKWXQWLOWKH\\LHOGHGWKHLUVHFUHWV
    3KRQHVSHRSOHSROLWLFVDOOWKHVHWUDQVSLUHGLQUHDOWLPHVQLSSLQJ
    KLVWKRXJKWWUDLQNLOOLQJPLQGWLPH6RKHOHW<XJRDQG'RUVDQGRWKHUVIHQG
    RIIWKHZRUOGWKURXJKRXWWKHPRUQLQJ
    %XWWRGD\<XJRKLPVHOIVQLSSHGKLVFRQFHQWUDWLRQ-XVWDPRKHVDLG
    VOLSSLQJWKURXJKWKHFUDFNOLQJGRRUILHOG7KLVSDSHUORRNULJKW"
    +HDQG<XJRKDGGHYHORSHGDSODXVLEOHFRYHUIRUWKHSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    SURMHFW7KH\UHJXODUO\SXEOLVKHGUHVHDUFKRQWKHQRQOLQHDUDQDO\VLVRI
    VRFLDOQXJJHWVDQGNQRWVDVXEILHOGZLWK DQKRQRUDEOHDQGGXOOKLVWRU\
    7KHLUDQDO\VLVDSSOLHGWRVXEJURXSVDQGIDFWLRQVLQ7UDQWRUDQGRFFDVLRQDOO\
    RQRWKHUZRUOGV
    7KHUHVHDUFKZDVLQIDFWXVHIXOWRSV\FKRKLVWRU\VHUYLQJDVDVXEVHWRI
    HTXDWLRQVWRZKDW<XJRLQVLVWHGRQFDOOLQJWKHIXOO6HOGRQ(TXDWLRQV+DUL
    KDGJLYHQXSEHLQJLUNHGDWWKLVWHUPHYHQWKRXJKKHZLVKHGWRNHHSD
    SHUVRQDOGLVWDQFHIURPWKHWKHRU\
    7KRXJKVFDUFHO\DZDNLQJKRXUSDVVHGZLWKRXWKLVWKLQNLQJDERXW
    SV\FKRKLVWRU\KHGLGQRWZDQWLWWREHDWHPSODWHIRUKLVRZQZRUOGYLHZ
    1RWKLQJURRWHGLQDSDUWLFXODUSHUVRQDOLW\FRXOGKRSHWRGHVFULEHWKHKRUGHRI
    VDLQWVDQGUDVFDOVUHYHDOHGE\KXPDQKLVWRU\2QHKDGWRWDNHWKHORQJHVWYLHZ
    SRVVLEOH
    6HH<XJRVDLGPDNLQJOLQHVRISULQWDQGV\PEROVFRDOHVFHRQ+DULV
    KROR,JRWDOOWKHDQDO\VLVRIWKH'DKOLWHFULVLV1HDWDV\RXSOHDVHKXK"
    8PZKDWVWKH'DKOLWHFULVLV"
    <XJRVVXUSULVHZDVSURIRXQG:HUHQRWEHLQUHSUHVHQWHG
    <RXOLYHLQ6WUHHOLQJ

    2QFHD'DKODQ\RXUHDOZD\VRQH-XVWOLNH\RXIURP+HOLFDO
    +HOLFRQ,VHH\RXGRQWKDYHHQRXJKGHOHJDWHVLQWKH/RZ&RXQFLO"
    2UWKH+LJK
    7KH&RGHVDOORZ
    7KH\UHRXWRIGDWH
    'DKOLWHVJHWDSURSRUWLRQDOVKDUH
    $QGRXUQHLJKERUVWKH5DWDQQDQDKVDQGWKH4XLSSRQVWKH\UHVFKHPLQ
    DJDLQVWXV
    +RZVR"
    7KHUHUH'DKODQVLQSOHQW\RWKHU6HFWRUV7KH\GRQWJHWUHSUHVHQWHG
    <RXUHVSRNHQIRUE\RXU6WUHHOLQJ
    /RRN+DUL\RXUHD+HOLFDO:RXOGQWXQGHUVWDQG3OHQW\6HFWRUV
    WKH\UHMXVWSODFHVWRVOHHS'DKOLVDSHRSOH
    7KH&RGHVVHWIRUWKUXOHVIRUDFFRPPRGDWLQJVHSDUDWHVXEFXOWXUHV
    HWKQLFLWLHV
    7KH\UHQRWZRUNLQ
    +DULVDZIURP<XJRVMXWWLQJMDZWKDWWKLVZDVQRWDSRLQWIRUJUDFHIXO
    GHEDWH+HGLGNQRZVRPHWKLQJRIWKHVORZO\JDWKHULQJFRQVWLWXWLRQDOFULVLV
    7KH&RGHVKDGPDLQWDLQHGDEDODQFHRIIRUFHVIRUPLOOHQQLDEXWRQO\E\
    LQQRYDWLYHDGDSWDWLRQ/LWWOHRIWKDWVHHPHGDYDLODEOHQRZ:HDJUHHRQWKDW
    6RKRZGRHVRXUUHVHDUFKEHDUXSRQ'DKO"
    6HH,WRRNWKHVRFLRIDFWRUDQDO\VLVDQG
    <XJRKDGDQLQWXLWLYHJUDVSRIQRQOLQHDUHTXDWLRQV,WZDVDOZD\VD
    SOHDVXUHWRZDWFKKLVELJKDQGVFXWWKHDLUVOLFLQJWKURXJKSRLQWVDQG
    SRXQGLQJREMHFWLRQVWRSXOS$QGWKHFDOFXODWLRQVZHUHJRRGLIDELWVLPSOH
    7KHQXJJHWVDQGNQRWVZRUNDWWUDFWHG OLWWOHDWWHQWLRQ,WKDGPDGHVRPH
    LQPDWKHPDWLFVZULWHKLPRIIDVDSURPLVLQJ\RXQJPDQZKRKDGQHYHUULVHQWR
    KLVSRWHQWLDO7KLVZDVSHUIHFWO\DOOULJKWZLWK+DUL6RPHPDWKLVWVJXHVVHG
    WKDWKLVWUXHFRUHUHVHDUFKZHQWXQSXEOLVKHGWKHVHKHWUHDWHGNLQGO\EXWJDYH
    QRKLQWRIFRQILUPDWLRQ
    VRWKHUHVDSUHVVXUHQXJJHWEXLOGLQLQ'DKO\RXEHW<XJR
    ILQLVKHG
    2IFRXUVHJODQFLQJDWWKHQHZVKRORVVKRZVWKDW
    :HOO\HDKEXW,YHSURYHGLWVMXVWLILHG
    +DULNHSWKLVIDFHFRPSRVHG<XJRZDVUHDOO\ZRUNHGXSDERXWWKLV
    <RXYHVKRZQRQHRIWKHIDFWRUV%XWWKHUHDUHRWKHUVLQWKHNQRWHTXDWLRQV
    :HOOVXUHEXWHYHU\ERG\NQRZV
    :KDWHYHU\ERG\NQRZVGRHVQWQHHGPXFKSURRI8QOHVVRIFRXUVHLWV
    ZURQJ
    <XJRVIDFHVKRZHGDUXVKRIHPRWLRQVVXUSULVHFRQFHUQDQJHUKXUW
    SX]]OHPHQW<RXGRQWVXSSRUW'DKO+DUL"
    2IFRXUVH,GR<XJR$FWXDOO\WKHWUXWKZDVWKDW+DULGLGQWFDUH
    %XWWKDWZDVWRREDOGDSRLQWWRPDNHZLWK<XJRVHHPLQJZRXQGHG/RRNWKH
    SDSHULVILQH3XEOLVK
    7KHWKUHHEDVLFNQRWHTXDWLRQVWKH\UH\RXUV
    1RQHHGWRFDOOWKHPWKDW
    6XUHMXVWOLNHEHIRUH%XW\RXUQDPHJRHVRQWKHSDSHU
    6RPHWKLQJWLFNOHG+DULVPLQGEXWKHVDZWKHULJKWDQVZHUQRZZDVWR
    UHDVVXUH<XJR,I\RXOLNH
    <XJRZHQWRQDERXWGHWDLOVRISXEOLFDWLRQDQG+DULOHWKLVH\HVGULIW
    RYHUWKHHTXDWLRQV7HUPVIRUUHSUHVHQWDWLRQLQPRGHOVRI7UDQWRULDQ
    GHPRFUDF\YDOXHWDEOHVIRUVRFLDOSUHVVXUHVWKHZKROHDSSDUDWXV$ELW
    VWXII\%XWUHDVVXULQJWRWKRVHZKRVXVSHFWHGWKDWKHZDVKLGLQJKLVPDMRU
    UHVXOWVDVKHZDVRIFRXUVH
    +DULVLJKHG'DKOZDVDIHVWHULQJSROLWLFDOVRUH'DKOLWHVRQ7UDQWRU
    PLUURUHGWKHFXOWXUHRIWKH'DKO*DODFWLF=RQH(YHU\SRZHUIXO=RQHKDGLWV
    RZQ6HFWRUV LQ7UDQWRUIRULQIOXHQFHSHGGOLQJDQGJHQHUDOSUHVVXULQJ

    %XW'DKOZDVPLQRURQWKHVFDOHWKDWKHZDQWHGWRH[SORUHVLPSOHHYHQ
    WULYLDO7KHNQRWHTXDWLRQVZKLFKGHVFULEHG+LJK&RXQFLOUHSUHVHQWDWLRQZHUH
    WUXQFDWHGIRUPVRIWKHLPPHQVHO\ZRUVHULGGOH RI7UDQWRU
    $OORI7UDQWRURQHWHHPLQJZRUOGEDIIOLQJLQLWVVKHHUVL]HLWV
    LQWULFDWHFRQQHFWLRQVPHDQLQJOHVVFRLQFLGHQFHVUDQGRPMX[WDSRVLWLRQV
    VHQVLWLYHGHSHQGHQFLHV+LVHTXDWLRQVZHUHVWLOOWHUULEO\LQDGHTXDWHIRUWKLV
    VKHOOZKLFKKRXVHGIRUW\ELOOLRQEXVWOLQJVRXOV
    +RZPXFKZRUVHZDVWKH(PSLUH
    3HRSOHFRQIURQWLQJEHZLOGHULQJFRPSOH[LW\WHQGWRILQGWKHLU
    VDWXUDWLRQOHYHO7KH\PDVWHUWKHHDV\FRQQHFWLRQVORFDOOLQNVDQGUXOHVRI
    WKXPE7KH\SXVKWKLVXQWLOWKH\PHHWDZDOORIFRPSOH[LW\WRRWKLFNDQGKLJK
    DQGKDUGWRJUDVSWRFOLPE
    7KHUHWKH\VWDOO*RVVLSFRQVXOWIUHWDQGILQDOO\JDPEOH
    7KH(PSLUHRIWZHQW\ILYHPLOOLRQZRUOGVZDVDSUREOHPJUHDWHUHYHQWKDQ
    XQGHUVWDQGLQJWKHZKROHUHVWRIWKHXQLYHUVHEHFDXVHDWOHDVWWKHJDOD[LHV
    EH\RQGGLGQRWKDYHKXPDQVLQWKHP7KHEOLQGEOXQWPRWLRQVRIVWDUVDQGJDV
    ZHUHFKLOGVSOD\FRPSDUHGWRWKHFRQYROXWHGWUDMHFWRULHVRISHRSOH
    6RPHWLPHVLWZRUHKLPGRZQ7UDQWRUZDVEDGHQRXJKHLJKWKXQGUHG
    6HFWRUVZLWKIRUW\ELOOLRQSHRSOH:KDWRIWKH(PSLUHZLWKWZHQW\ILYH
    PLOOLRQSODQHWVRIDYHUDJHIRXUELOOLRQVRXOVDSLHFH"2QHKXQGUHGTXDGULOOLRQ
    SHRSOH
    :RUOGVLQWHUDFWHGWKURXJKWKHQDUURZQHFNVRIZRUPKROHVZKLFKDWOHDVW
    VLPSOLILHGVRPHRIWKHHFRQRPLFLVVXHV%XWFXOWXUHWUDYHOHGDWWKHVSHHGRI
    OLJKWWKURXJKZRUPKROHVLQIRUPDWLRQZLWKRXWPDVV]RRPLQJDFURVVWKH*DOD[\
    LQGHVWDELOL]LQJZDYHV$IDUPHURQ2VNDWRRQNQHZWKDWDGXFK\KDGIDOOHQRQ
    WKHRWKHUVLGHRIWKH*DODFWLFGLVNDIHZKRXUVDIWHUWKHEORRGRQWKHSDODFH
    IORRUVWDUWHGWXUQLQJEURZQ
    +RZWRLQFOXGHWKDW"
    &OHDUO\WKH(PSLUHH[WHQGHGEH\RQGWKH&RPSOH[LW\+RUL]RQRIDQ\SHUVRQ
    RUFRPSXWHU2QO\VHWVRIHTXDWLRQVZKLFKGLGQRWWU\WRNHHSWUDFNRIHYHU\
    GHWDLOFRXOGZRUN
    :KLFKPHDQWWKDWDQLQGLYLGXDO ZDVQRWKLQJRQWKHVFDOHRIHYHQWVZRUWK
    VWXG\LQJ(YHQDPLOOLRQPDGHDERXWDVPXFKGLIIHUHQFHDVDVLQJOHUDLQGURS
    IDOOLQJLQDODNH
    6XGGHQO\+DULZDVHYHQPRUHJODGWKDWKHKDGNHSWSV\FKRKLVWRU\VHFUHW
    +RZZRXOGSHRSOHUHDFWLIWKH\NQHZWKDWKHWKRXJKWWKH\GLGQWPDWWHU"
    +DUL"+DUL"
    +HKDGEHHQPXVLQJDJDLQ<XJRZDVVWLOOLQWKHRIILFH2KVRUU\MXVW
    PXOOLQJRYHU
    7KHGHSDUWPHQWPHHWLQJ
    :KDW"
    <RXFDOOHGLWIRUWRGD\
    2KQR+HZDVKDOIZD\WKURXJKDFDOFXODWLRQ&DQWZHGHOD\"
    7KHZKROHGHSDUWPHQW"7KH\UHZDLWLQJ
    +DULGXWLIXOO\IROORZHG<XJRLQWRWKHDVVHPEO\URRP7KHWKUHH
    WUDGLWLRQDOOHYHOVZHUHDOUHDG\ILOOHG&OHRQVSDWURQDJHKDGILOOHGRXWDQ
    DOUHDG\KLJKUDQNHGGHSDUWPHQWXQWLOLWZDVSUREDEO\KRZFRXOGRQHPHDVXUH
    VXFKWKLQJV"WKHEHVWRQ7UDQWRU,WKDGVSHFLDOLVWVLQP\ULDGGLVFLSOLQHV
    HYHQDUHDVZKRVHYHU\GHILQLWLRQV+DULZDVDELWYDJXHDERXW
    +DULWRRNKLVSRVLWLRQDWWKHKXERIWKHKLJKHVWOHYHODWWKHH[DFW
    FHQWHURIWKHURRP0DWKLVWVOLNHGJHRPHWULHVZKLFKPLUURUHGUHDOLWLHVVRWKH
    IXOOSURIHVVRUVVDWRQDURXQGUDLVHGSODWIRUPLQDLUFKDLUVZLWKDPSOHDUPV
    )RUPLQJDODUJHUDQQXOXVDURXQGWKHPDIHZVWHSVORZHUZHUHWKH
    DVVRFLDWHSURIHVVRUVWKRVHZLWKWHQXUHEXWVWLOODWWKHPLGGOHUDQNLQWKHLU
    FDUHHUV7KH\KDGFRPIRUWDEOHFKDLUVWKRXJKZLWKRXWIXOOFRPSXWLQJDQGKROR
    IXQFWLRQV
    %HORZWKHPDOPRVWLQDSLWZHUHWKHXQWHQXUHGSURIHVVRUVRQVLPSOH

    FKDLUVRIVWXUG\GHVLJQ7KHROGHVWVDWQHDUHVWWKHURRPVFHQWHU,QWKHLU
    RXWHUUDQNVZHUHWKHLQVWUXFWRUVDQGDVVLVWDQWVRQSODLQEHQFKHVZLWKRXWDQ\
    FRPSXWHUFDSDELOLWLHVZKDWHYHU<XJRUHVWHGWKHUHVFRZOLQJSODLQO\IHHOLQJ
    RXWRISODFH
    +DULKDGDOZD\VWKRXJKWLWZDVHLWKHUHQUDJLQJRUKLODULRXVGHSHQGLQJ
    RQKLVPRRGWKDWRQHRIWKHPRVWSURGXFWLYHPHPEHUVRIWKHGHSDUWPHQW<XJR
    VKRXOGKDYHVXFKORZVWDWXV7KLVZDVWKHWUXHSULFHRINHHSLQJSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    VHFUHW7KHSDLQRIWKLVKHWULHGWRVRRWKHE\JLYLQJ<XJRDJRRGRIILFHDQG
    RWKHUSHUNV<XJRVHHPHGWRFDUHOLWWOHIRUVWDWXVVLQFHKHKDGDOUHDG\
    DVFHQGHGVRIDU$QGDOOZLWKRXWWKH&LYLO6HUYLFHH[DPVWRR
    7RGD\+DULGHFLGHGWRPDNHDOLWWOHPLVFKLHI7KDQN\RXFROOHDJXHV
    IRUDWWHQGLQJ:HKDYHPDQ\DGPLQLVWUDWLYHPDWWHUVWRHQJDJH<XJR"
    $UXVWOH<XJRVH\HVZLGHQHGEXWKHVWRRGXSTXLFNO\DQGFOLPEHGXSWR
    WKHVSHDNHUVSODWIRUP
    +HDOZD\VKDGVRPHRQHHOVHFKDLUPHHWLQJVHYHQWKRXJKDVFKDLUPDQKH
    KDGFDOOHGWKHPFKRVHQWKHKRXUIL[HGWKHDJHQGD+HNQHZWKDWVRPHUHJDUGHG
    KLPDVDVWURQJSHUVRQDOLW\VLPSO\E\GLQWRINQRZLQJWKHUHVHDUFKDJHQGDVR
    GHHSO\
    7KDWZDVDFRPPRQHUURUPLVWDNLQJNQRZOHGJHIRUFRPPDQG+HKDGIRXQG
    WKDWLIKHSUHVLGHGWKHUHZDVOLWWOHGLVVHQWIURPKLVRZQYLHZV7RJHWRSHQ
    GLVFXVVLRQGHPDQGHGWKDWKHVLWEDFNDQGOLVWHQDQGWDNHQRWHVLQWHUYHQLQJ
    RQO\DWNH\PRPHQWV
    <HDUVDJR<XJRKDGZRQGHUHGZK\KHGLGWKLVDQG+DULZDYHGDZD\WKH
    SUREOHP,PQRWDOHDGHUKHVDLG<XJRJDYHKLPDVWUDQJHORRNDVLIWR
    VD\:KRGR\RXWKLQN\RXUHNLGGLQJ"
    +DULVPLOHGWRKLPVHOI6RPHRIWKHIXOOSURIHVVRUVDURXQGKLPZHUH
    PXWWHULQJFDVWLQJJODQFHV<XJRODXQFKHGLQWRWKHDJHQGDVSHDNLQJTXLFNO\LQ
    DVWURQJFOHDUYRLFH
    +DULVDWEDFNDQGZDWFKHGLUULWDWLRQZDVKRYHUVRPHRIKLVHVWHHPHG
    FROOHDJXHV1RVHVZULQNOHGDW<XJRVEURDGDFFHQW2QHRIWKHPPRXWKHGWR
    DQRWKHU'DKOLWHDQGZDVDQVZHUHG8SVWDUW
    $ERXWWLPHWKH\JRWDELWRIWKHERRWDVKLVIDWKHUKDGRQFHWHUPHG
    LW$QGIRU<XJRWRJHWDWDVWHRIUXQQLQJWKHGHSDUWPHQW
    $IWHUDOOWKLV)LUVW0LQLVWHUEXVLQHVVFRXOGJHWZRUVH+HFRXOGQHHGD
    UHSODFHPHQW
    

    :HVKRXOGOHDYHVRRQ+DULVDLGVFULEEOLQJRQKLVQRWHSDG
    :K\"7KHUHFHSWLRQGRHVQWVWDUWIRUDJHV6KHVPRRWKHGRXWKHUGUHVV
    ZLWKJUHDWFDUHH\HVFULWLFDO
    ,ZDQWWRWDNHDZDONRQWKHZD\
    7KHUHFHSWLRQLVLQ'DKYLWL6HFWRU
    +XPRUPH
    6KHSXOOHGRQWKHVKHDWKGUHVVZLWKVRPHHIIRUW,ZLVKWKLVZHUHQW
    WKHVW\OH
    :HDUVRPHWKLQJHOVHWKHQ
    7KLVLV\RXUILUVWDSSHDUDQFHDWDQ,PSHULDODIIDLU<RXOOZDQWWR
    ORRN\RXUEHVW
    7UDQVODWLRQ\RXORRN\RXUEHVWDQGVWDQGQH[WWRPH
    <RXUHMXVWZHDULQJWKDW6WUHHOLQJSURIHVVRULDOJDUE
    $SSURSULDWHWRWKHRFFDVLRQ,ZDQWWRVKRZWKDW,PVWLOOMXVWD
    SURIHVVRU
    6KHZRUNHGRQWKHGUHVVVRPHPRUHDQGILQDOO\VDLG<RXNQRZVRPH
    KXVEDQGVZRXOGHQMR\ZDWFKLQJWKHLUZLYHVGRWKLV
    +DULORRNHGXSDVVKHZULJJOHGLQWRWKHODVWRIWKHFOLQJ\HQVHPEOHLQ
    DPEHUDQGEOXH6XUHO\\RXGRQWZDQWWRJHWPHDOOH[FLWHGDQGWKHQKDYHWR

    HQGXUHWKHUHFHSWLRQWKDWZD\
    6KHVPLOHGLPSLVKO\7KDWVH[DFWO\ZKDW,ZDQW
    +HORXQJHGEDFNLQKLVDLUFKDLUDQGVLJKHGWKHDWULFDOO\0DWKHPDWLFVLV
    DILQHUPXVH/HVVGHPDQGLQJ
    6KHWRVVHGDVKRHDWKLPPLVVLQJE\DSUHFLVHFHQWLPHWHU
    +DULJULQQHG&DUHIXORUWKH6SHFLDOVZLOOUXVKWRGHIHQGPH
    'RUVEHJDQKHUILQLVKLQJWRXFKHVDQGWKHQJODQFHGDWKLPSX]]OHG<RX
    DUHHYHQPRUHGLVWUDFWHGWKDQXVXDO
    $VDOZD\V,ILWP\UHVHDUFKLQWRWKHQRRNVDQGFUDQQLHVRIOLIH
    7KHXVXDOSUREOHP":KDWVLPSRUWDQWLQKLVWRU\"
    ,GSUHIHUWRNQRZZKDWVQRW
    ,DJUHHWKDWWKHFXVWRPDU\PHJDKLVWRU\DSSURDFKHFRQRPLFVDQG
    SROLWLFVDQGWKHUHVWLVQWHQRXJK
    +DULORRNHGXSIURPKLVSDG7KHUHDUHVRPHKLVWRULDQVZKR WKLQNWKDW
    WKHOLWWOHUXOHVRIDVRFLHW\KDYHWREHFRXQWHGWRXQGHUVWDQGWKHELJODZV
    WKDWPDNHLWZRUN
    ,NQRZWKDWUHVHDUFK'RUVWZLVWHGKHUPRXWKGRXEWIXOO\6PDOOUXOHV
    DQGELJODZV+RZDERXWVLPSOLI\LQJ"0D\EHWKHODZVDUHMXVWDOOWKHUXOHV
    DGGHGXS"
    2IFRXUVHQRW
    ([DPSOHVKHSHUVLVWHG
    +HZDQWHGWRWKLQNEXWVKHZRXOGQRWEHSXWRII6KHSRNHGKLPLQWKH
    ULEV([DPSOH
    $OOULJKW+HUHVDUXOH:KHQHYHU\RXILQGVRPHWKLQJ\RXOLNHEX\D
    OLIHWLPHVXSSO\EHFDXVHWKH\UH VXUHWRVWRSPDNLQJLW
    7KDWVULGLFXORXV$MRNH
    1RWPXFKRIDMRNHEXWLWVWUXH
    :HOOGR\RXIROORZWKLVUXOH"
    2IFRXUVH
    +RZ"
    5HPHPEHUWKHILUVWWLPH\RXORRNHGLQP\FORVHW"
    6KHEOLQNHG+HJULQQHGUHFDOOLQJ6KHKDGEHHQVXEWO\VQRRSLQJDQG
    VOLGDVLGHWKHODUJHEXWIHDWKHUOLJKWGRRU,QDUHFWDQJXODUJULGRIVKHOYHV
    ZHUHFORWKHVVRUWHGE\W\SHWKHQFRORU'RUVKDGJDVSHG6L[EOXHVXLWV$W
    OHDVWDGR]HQSDGVKRHVDOOEODFN$QGVKLUWVRIIZKLWHROLYHDIHZUHG
    $W OHDVWILIW\6RPDQ\DOODOLNH
    $QGH[DFWO\ZKDW,OLNHKHKDGVDLG7KLVDOVRVROYHVWKHSUREOHPRI
    FKRRVLQJZKDWWRZHDULQWKHPRUQLQJ,MXVWUHDFKLQDWUDQGRP
    ,WKRXJKW\RXZRUHWKHVDPHFORWKHVGD\DIWHUGD\
    +HKDGUDLVHGKLVH\HEURZVDJKDVW7KHVDPH"<RXPHDQGLUW\FORWKHV"
    :HOOZKHQWKH\GLGQWFKDQJH
    ,FKDQJHHYHU\GD\+HFKXFNOHGUHPHPEHULQJDQGVDLG7KHQ,
    XVXDOO\SXWRQWKHVDPHRXWILWWKHQH[WGD\EHFDXVH,OLNHLW$QG\RXZLOO
    QRWILQGDQ\RIWKRVHDYDLODEOHLQWKHVWRUHVDJDLQ
    ,OOVD\VKHVDLGILQJHULQJWKHZHDYHRQKLVVKLUWV7KHVHDUHDW
    OHDVWIRXUVHDVRQVRXWRIIDVKLRQ
    6HH"7KHUXOHZRUNV
    7RPHDZHHNLVWZHQW\RQHFORWKLQJRSSRUWXQLWLHV7R\RXLWVD
    FKRUH
    <RXUHLJQRULQJWKHUXOH
    +RZORQJGLG\RXGUHVVWKDWZD\"
    6LQFH,QRWLFHGKRZPXFKWLPH,VSHQWPDNLQJGHFLVLRQVDERXWZKDWWR
    ZHDU$QGWKDWZKDW,UHDOO\OLNHGWRZHDUZDVQWLQWKHVWRUHVYHU\RIWHQ,
    JHQHUDOL]HGDVROXWLRQWRERWK SUREOHPV
    <RXUHDPD]LQJ
    ,PVLPSO\V\VWHPDWLF
    <RXUHREVHVVLRQDO

    <RXUHMXGJLQJQRWGLDJQRVLQJ
    <RXUHDGHDU&UD]\EXWDGHDU0D\EHWKH\JRWRJHWKHU
    ,VWKDWDUXOHWRR"
    6KHNLVVHGKLP<HVSURIHVVRU

    7KHLQHYLWDEOH6SHFLDOVFUHHQIRUPHGDERXWWKHPWKHLQVWDQWWKH\OHIW
    WKHLUDSDUWPHQW%\QRZKHDQG'RUVKDGWUDLQHGWKH6SHFLDOVWRDWOHDVWDOORZ
    WKHPWKHSULYDF\RIDVLQJOHZHGJHLQWKHGURSWXEH
    7KHJUDYGURSZDVLQIDFWQRPLUDFOHRIJUDYLWDWLRQDOSK\VLFVLWFDPH
    IURPDGYDQFHGHOHFWURPDJQHWLFV(DFKLQVWDQWRYHUDWKRXVDQGHOHFWURVWDWLF
    ILHOGVVXSSRUWHGKLPWKURXJKLQWULFDWHFKDUJHLPEDODQFHV+HFRXOGIHHOWKHP
    SOD\LQJLQKLVKDLUVPDOOWZLQJHVVNDWLQJDFURVVKLVVNLQDVWKHILHOG
    FRQILJXUDWLRQVKDQGHGKLPRIIWRHDFKRWKHUHDFKORZHULQJKLVPDVV
    LQILQLWHVLPDOO\GRZQWKHFKXWH
    :KHQWKH\OHIWWKHZHGJHWKLUWHHQIORRUVKLJKHU'RUVSDVVHGDFKDUJH
    SURJUDPPHGFRPEWKURXJKKHUKDLU,WFUDFNOHGDQGVQDSSHGREHGLHQWO\LQWRLWV
    VW\OHVPDUWKDLU
    7KH\HQWHUHGDEURDGSDVVDJHZD\OLQHGZLWKVKRSV+DULOLNHGEHLQJLQD
    SODFHZKHUHKHFRXOGVHHIDUWKHUWKDQDKXQGUHGPHWHUV
    0RYHPHQWZDVTXLFNEHFDXVHWKHUHZDVQRFURVVWUDIILFIRUDQ\
    FRQYH\DQFH$VOLGHZDONUDQDWWKHFHQWHUJRLQJWKHLUZD\EXWWKH\VWD\HG
    QHDUWKHVKRSZLQGRZVDQGEURZVHGDVWKH\DPEOHG
    7RPRYHODWHUDOO\RQHVLPSO\ZHQWXSRUGRZQDOHYHOE\HOHYDWRURU
    HVFDODWRUWKHQVWHSSHGRQDPRYLQJEHOWRUHQWHUHGDURERSRG,QWKH
    FRUULGRUVWRERWKVLGHVWKHVOLGHZD\UDQRSSRVLWH:LWKQROHIWRUULJKW
    WXUQVWUDIILFPLVKDSVZHUHUDUH0RVWSHRSOHZDONHGZKHUHYHUZDVSUDFWLFDO
    IRUWKHH[HUFLVHDQGIRUWKHLQGHILQDEOHH[KLODUDWLRQRI7UDQWRULWVHOI
    3HRSOHZKRFDPHKHUHZDQWHGWKHFRQVWDQWVWLPXODWLRQRIKXPDQLW\LGHDVDQG
    FXOWXUHVUXEELQJDJDLQVWHDFKRWKHULQSURGXFWLYHIULFWLRQ+DULZDVQRW
    LPPXQHWRLWWKRXJKLWORVWVRPHVDYRULIRYHUGRQH
    3HRSOHLQWKHVTXDUHVDQGSDUNKH[DJRQVZRUHIDVKLRQVIURPWKHWZHQW\
    ILYHPLOOLRQZRUOGV+HVDZVHOIVKDSLQJOHDWKHUVIURPDQLPDOVZKRFRXOGQRW
    SRVVLEO\KDYHUHVHPEOHGWKHP\WKLFDOKRUVH$PDQVDXQWHUHGE\ZLWKOHJJLQJV
    VOLWWRKLVKLSH[SRVLQJEOXHVWULSHGVNLQWKDWEXQFKHGDQGVOLGLQD
    SHUSHWXDOVKRZ$QDQJXODUZRPDQVSRUWHGDERGLFHRIRSHQPRXWKHGIDFHVHDFK
    VZDOORZLQJLYRU\QLSSOHG EUHDVWVKHKDGWRORRNWZLFHWREHOLHYHWKH\ZHUHQW
    UHDO*LUOVLQRXWUDJHRXVO\FXWSRPSYHVWPHQWVSDUDGHGQRLVLO\$FKLOGRU
    ZDVLWDQRUPDOLQKDELWDQWRIDVWURQJJUDYZRUOG"SOD\HGDSKRWR]LWKHU
    VWUXPPLQJLWVODVHUEHDPV
    7KH6SHFLDOVIDQQHGRXWDQGWKHLUFDSWDLQFDPHWURWWLQJRYHU:HFDQW
    FRYHU\RXZHOOKHUH$FDGHPLFLDQVLU
    7KHVHDUHRUGLQDU\SHRSOHQRWDVVDVVLQV7KH\KDGQRZD\RISUHGLFWLQJ
    WKDW,GEHKHUH
    (PSHURUVD\VFRYHU\RXZHFRYHU\RX
    'RUVUDSSHGEDFNVPDUWO\,OOKDQGOHWKHFORVHLQWKUHDWV,PDEOH,
    DVVXUH\RX
    7KHFDSWDLQVPRXWKWZLVWHGVRXUO\EXWKHJDYHKLPVHOIDPRPHQWEHIRUH
    VD\LQJ,KHDUGVRPHWKLQJDERXWWKDW6WLOO
    +DYH\RXUPHQXVHWKHLUUDQJHGHWHFWRUVYHUWLFDOO\$VKDSHGFKDUJHRQ
    WKH OD\HUVEHORZDQGDERYHFRXOGFDWFKXV
    8K\HVP+HWURWWHGRII
    7KH\SDVVHGE\WKHMLJVDZZDOOVRIWKH)DUKDKDO4XDGUDQW$ZHDOWK\
    DQFLHQWKDGEHFRPHREVHVVHGZLWKWKHQRWLRQWKDWDVORQJDVKLVHVWDWHZDV
    XQILQLVKHGKHZRXOGQRWKLPVHOIILQLVKWKDWLVGLH:KHQHYHUDQDGGLWLRQ
    QHDUHGFRPSOHWLRQKHRUGHUHGXSPRUH(YHQWXDOO\WKHWDQJOHRIURRPV
    UXQZD\VYDXOWVEULGJHVDQGJDUGHQVEHFDPHDQLQFRKHUHQWPRWOH\VWXFNLQWR
    HYHU\FUDQQ\RIWKHRULJLQDOUDWKHUVLPSOHGHVLJQ:KHQ)DUKDKDOHYHQWXDOO\

    GLGILQLVKDWRZHUKDOIEXLOWELFNHULQJE\KLVKHLUVDQGODZ\HUO\
    SOXQGHULQJRIWKHHVWDWHIRUWKHLUIHHVEURXJKWWKHTXDGUDQWORZ1RZLWZDVD
    IHWLGZDUUHQYLVLWHGRQO\E\WKHSUHGDWRU\DQGWKHXQZDU\
    7KH6SHFLDOVSXOOHGLQWLJKWDQGWKHFDSWDLQXUJHGWKHPWRJHWLQWRD
    URER+DULJUXGJLQJO\DJUHHG'RUVKDGWKHFRQFHQWUDWHGORRNWKDWPHDQWVKH
    ZDVZRUULHG7KH\VSHGLQVLOHQFHWKURXJKVKDGRZ\WXQQHOV7KHUHZHUHWZR
    VWRSVDQGLQWKHEULOOLDQWO\OLWVWDWLRQV+DULVDZUDWVVFXUU\LQJIRUVKHOWHU
    DVWKHSRGHDVHGWRDKDOW+HVLOHQWO\SRLQWHGWKHPRXWWR'RUV
    %UUUUVKHVDLG2QHZRXOGWKLQNWKDWDWWKHYHU\FHQWHURIWKH
    (PSLUHZHFRXOGHOLPLQDWHSHVWV
    1RWWKHVHGD\V+DULVDLGWKRXJKKHVXVSHFWHGWKHUDWVKDGWKULYHG
    HYHQDWWKHKHLJKWRI(PSLUH5RGHQWVFDUHGOLWWOHIRUJUDQGHXU
    ,VXSSRVHWKH\YHEHHQRXUHWHUQDOFRPSDQLRQV'RUVVDLGVRPEHUO\1R
    ZRUOGLVIUHHRIWKHP
    ,QWKHVHWXQQHOVWKHORQJGLVWDQFHSRGVIO\VRIDVWWKDWRFFDVLRQDOO\
    UDWVJHWVXFNHGLQWRWKHDLUEUHDWKLQJHQJLQHV
    'RUVVDLGXQHDVLO\7KDWFRXOGGDPDJHWKHHQJLQHVHYHQFUDVKWKH
    SRGV
    1RKROLGD\IRUWKHUDWHLWKHU
    7KH\SDVVHGWKURXJKD6HFWRUZKRVHFLWL]HQVDEKRUUHGVXQOLJKWHYHQWKH
    ZDQVSODVKHVZKLFKFDPHGRZQWKURXJKWKHOD\HUVE\UDGLDQFHWXEHV
    +LVWRULFDOO\'RUVWROGKLPWKLVKDGDULVHQIURPIHDUVRILWVXOWUDYLROHW
    FRPSRQHQWEXWWKHSKRELDVHHPHGWRJRGHHSHUWKDQDPHUHKHDOWKLVVXH
    7KHLUSRGVORZHGDQGSDVVHGDORQJDKLJKUDPSDERYHRSHQVZDUPLQJ
    YDXOWV1RQDWXUDOOLJKWVKDIWVEURXJKWLOOXPLQDWLRQRQO\DUWLILFLDOSKRVSKRU
    JORZV7KH6HFWRUZDVRIILFLDOO\QDPHG.DODQVWURPRQLDEXWLWVFLWL]HQVZHUH
    NQRZQZRUOGZLGHDV6SRRNV7KH\VHOGRPWUDYHOHGDQGWKHLUEOHDFKHGIDFHV
    VWRRGRXWLQFURZGV*D]LQJGRZQDWWKHPWKH\ORRNHGWR+DULOLNHVZDUPVRI
    JUXEVIHHGLQJRQVKDGRZ\GHFD\
    7KH,PSHULDO=RQDO5HFHSWLRQZDVLQVLGHDGRPHLQWKH-XOLHHQ6HFWRU+H
    DQG'RUVHQWHUHGZLWKWKH6SHFLDOVZKRWKHQJDYHZD\WRILYHPHQDQGZRPHQ
    ZHDULQJXWWHUO\LQFRQVSLFXRXVEXVLQHVVGUHVV7KHVHQRGGHGWR+DULDQGWKHQ
    DSSHDUHGWRIRUJHWKLPPRYLQJGRZQDEURDGUDPSZD\DQGFKDWWLQJZLWKHDFK
    RWKHU
    $ZRPDQDWWKHJUDQGGRRUZD\PDGHWRRPXFKRIKLVHQWUDQFH0XVLF
    GHVFHQGHGDURXQGKLPLQDVRXQGFORXGDQDUUDQJHPHQWRIWKH6WUHHOLQJ$QWKHP
    EOHQGHGVXEWO\ZLWKWKH+HOLFRQ6\PSKRQ\7KLVDWWUDFWHGDWWHQWLRQIURPWKH
    FURZGVEHORZH[DFWO\ZKDWKHGLGQRWZDQW$SURWRFROWHDPVPRRWKO\WRRNWKH
    KDQGRIIIURPWKHGRRUDWWHQGDQWVHVFRUWLQJKLPDQG'RUVWRDEDOFRQ\+HZDV
    KDSS\IRUWKHFKDQFHWR ORRNDWWKHYLHZ
    )URPWKHSHDNRIWKHGRPHWKHYLVWDVZHUHVWDUWOLQJ6SLUDOVGHVFHQGHG
    WRSODWHDXVVRGLVWDQWKHFRXOGEDUHO\PDNHRXWDIRUHVWDQGSDWKV7KH
    UDPSDUWVDQGJDUGHQVWKHUHKDGGUDZQPLOOHQQLDRIVSHFWDWRUVLQFOXGLQJD
    JXLGHWROGKLPVXLFLGHVDOOFDUHIXOO\WDEXODWHGWKURXJKPDQ\
    FHQWXULHV
    1RZWKDWWKHQXPEHUDSSURDFKHGDPLOOLRQWKHJXLGHZHQWRQZLWKUHOLVK
    DWWHPSWVRFFXUUHGQHDUO\HYHU\KRXU$PDQKDGEHHQVWRSSHGMXVWVKRUWRI
    OHDSLQJWKDWYHU\GD\ZHDULQJDJDXG\KRORVXLWSURJUDPPHGWRIODVK,0$'(7+(
    0,//,21DIWHUKHVWUXFN
    7KH\VHHPVRHDJHUWKHJXLGHFRQFOXGHGZLWKZKDWVHHPHGWR+DULD
    NLQGRISULGH
    :HOO+DULUHPDUNHGWU\LQJWRJHWULGRIWKHPDQVXLFLGHLVWKH
    PRVWVLQFHUHIRUPRIVHOIFULWLFLVP
    7KHJXLGHQRGGHGZLVHO\XQSHUWXUEHGDQGDGGHG$OVRLWGRHVJLYH
    WKHPVRPHWKLQJWRFRQWULEXWHWR7KDWPXVWEHDFRQVRODWLRQ
    7KHSURWRFROWHDPKDGDOOSODQQHGRXWIRUKLPDQRUELWWKURXJKWKH
    YDVWUHFHSWLRQ0HHW;JUHHW<ERZWR=

    6D\QRWKLQJDERXWWKH-XGHQD=RQHFULVLVDQDLGHLQVLVWHG7KLVZDV
    HDV\VLQFHKHKDGQHYHUKHDUGRILW
    7KHDSSHWLWHHQKDQFHUVZHUHH[FHOOHQWWKHIRRGWKDWIROORZHGHYHQ
    EHWWHU RUVHHPHGVRZKLFKZDVWKHSRLQWRIWKHHQKDQFHUV DQGKHWRRND
    VWLPRIIHUHGE\DJRUJHRXVZRPDQ
    <RXFRXOGJHWWKURXJKWKLVHQWLUHHYHQLQJMXVWQRGGLQJDQGVPLOLQJDQG
    DJUHHLQJZLWKSHRSOH'RUVVDLGDIWHUWKHILUVWKDOIKRXU
    ,WVWHPSWLQJWRGRMXVWWKDW+DULZKLVSHUHGDVWKH\IROORZHGWKH
    SURWRFROOLHXWHQDQWWRWKHQH[WEXQFKRI=RQDOILJXUHV7KHDLULQWKHYDVW
    IRJJ\GRPHZDVIUHLJKWHGZLWKQHJRWLDWLRQVDGYDQFHGDQGEDUJDLQVVWUXFN
    7KH(PSHURUDUULYHGZLWKIXOOSRPS+HZRXOGSD\WKHWUDGLWLRQDOKRXUV
    WULEXWHWKHQE\DQFLHQWFXVWRPOHDYHEHIRUHDQ\RQHHOVHZDVSHUPLWWHGWR
    +DULZRQGHUHGLIWKH(PSHURUHYHUZDQWHGWROLQJHULQWKHPLGGOHRIDQ
    LQWHUHVWLQJFRQYHUVDWLRQ&OHRQZDVZHOOVFKRROHGLQHPSHURUKRRGWKRXJKVR
    WKHLVVXHSUREDEO\QHYHUFDPHXS&OHRQJUHHWHG+DULHIIXVLYHO\NLVVHG'RUV
    KDQGDQGWKHQVHHPHGWRORVHLQWHUHVWLQWKHPZLWKLQWZRPLQXWHVPRYLQJRQ
    ZLWKKLVHQWRXUDJHWRDQRWKHUFLUFOHRIH[SHFWDQWIDFHV
    +DULVQH[WJURXSSURYHGGLIIHUHQW1RWWKHXVXDOPL[RIGLSORPDWV
    DULVWRVDQGDQ[LRXVEURZQFODGDVVLVWDQWVKLVOLHXWHQDQWWROGKLPEXWKLJK
    ILJXUHV3HRSOHZLWKSXQFKWKHPDQZKLVSHUHG
    $ODUJHPXVFXODUPDQZDVKROGLQJIRUWKDWWKHFHQWHURIDFLUFOHD
    GR]HQIDFHVUDSWO\IROORZLQJKLVHYHU\ZRUG7KHSURWRFROOLHXWHQDQWWULHGWR
    ZKLVNWKHPSDVWEXW+DULVWRSSHGKHU7KDWV
    %HWDQ/DPXUNVLU
    .QRZVKRZWRKROGDFURZG
    ,QGHHGVLU:RXOG\RXOLNHDIRUPDOLQWURGXFWLRQ"
    1RMXVWOHWPHOLVWHQ
    ,WZDVDOZD\VDJRRGLGHDWRVL]HXSDQRSSRQHQWEHIRUHKHNQHZKHZDV
    EHLQJZDWFKHG+DULVIDWKHUKDGWDXJKWKLPWKDWWULFNMXVWEHIRUHKLVILUVW
    PDWKHOHWLFFRPSHWLWLRQ6XFKWHFKQLTXHVKDGQRWPDQDJHGWRVDYHKLVIDWKHU
    EXWWKH\ZRUNHGLQWKHPLOGHUJURYHVRIDFDGHPH
    %ODFNKDLULQYDGHGKLVEURDGEURZOLNHDSLQFHUDWWDFNWZRSRLQWHG
    ZHGJHVUHDFKLQJGRZQWRQHDUO\WKHHQGRIKLVH\HEURZV+LVKRRGHGH\HVZHUH
    ZLGHO\VSDFHGDQGEOD]HGLQWHQWO\IURPDULJJLQJRIPLUWKZULQNOHV$VOHQGHU
    QRVHVHHPHGWRSRLQWWRKLVSURXGHVWIHDWXUHDPRXWKDVVHPEOHGIURPYDU\LQJ
    SDUWV7KHORZHUOLSFXUOHGLQIXOOLPSXGHQWKXPRU7KHXSSHUWKLQDQG
    PXVFXODUFXUOHGGRZQZDUGLQDFXUYHWKDWYHUJHGRQDVQHHU$YLHZHUZRXOG
    NQRZWKHXSSHUOLSFRXOGRYHUUXOHWKHORZHUDWDQ\PRPHQWVKLIWLQJPRRG
    DEUXSWO\DGLVTXLHWLQJHIIHFWZKLFKFRXOGQRWKDYHEHHQEHWWHUHGLIKHKDG
    GHVLJQHGLWKLPVHOI
    +DULUHDOL]HGTXLFNO\WKDWRIFRXUVH/DPXUNKDG
    /DPXUNZDVGLVFXVVLQJVRPHGHWDLORILQWHU=RQDOWUDGHLQWKH2ULRQ
    VSLUDODUPDKRWLVVXHEHIRUHWKH+LJK&RXQFLODWWKHPRPHQW+DULFDUHG
    QRWKLQJDERXWWUDGHH[FHSWDVDYDULDEOHLQVWRFKDVWLFHTXDWLRQVVRKH
    VLPSO\ZDWFKHGWKHPDQVPDQQHU
    7RXQGHUOLQHDSRLQW/DPXUNZRXOGUDLVHKLVKDQGVRYHUKLVKHDGILQJHUV
    RSHQYRLFHULVLQJ7KHQKLVSRLQWPDGHKLVYRLFHHYHQHGRXWDQGKHORZHUHG
    WKHPWRFKHVWKHLJKWKHOGSUHFLVHO\VLGHE\VLGH$VKLVZHOOPRGXODWHGYRLFH
    EHFDPHGHHSHUDQGPRUHUHIOHFWLYHKHPRYHGWKHKDQGVDSDUW7KHQYRLFH
    ULVLQJDJDLQKLVKDQGVVRDUHGWRKHDGOHYHODQGZLQGPLOOHGRQHDURXQGWKH
    RWKHUWKHVXEMHFWQRZFRPSOH[WKHOLVWHQHUWKHUHE\FRPPDQGHGWRSD\FORVH
    DWWHQWLRQ
    +HNHSWFORVHH\HFRQWDFWZLWKWKHZKROHDXGLHQFHDSLHUFLQJJD]H
    VZHHSLQJWKHFLUFOH$ODVWSRLQWDTXLFNWRXFKRIKXPRUJULQIODVKLQJVXUH
    RIKLPVHOIDSDXVHIRUWKHQH[WTXHVWLRQ
    +HILQLVKHGKLVSRLQWZLWKDQGIRUVRPHRIXV3D[,PSHULXPORRNV
    PRUHOLNH7D[,PSHULXPHK"7KHQKHVDZ+DUL$TXLFNIXUURZLQJRIKLV

    EURZWKHQ$FDGHPLFLDQ6HOGRQ:HOFRPH,GEHHQZRQGHULQJZKHQ,ZDVJRLQJ
    WRJHWWRPHHW\RX
    'RQWOHWPHLQWHUUXSW\RXUDKOHFWXUH
    7KLVSURYRNHGVRPHWLWWHUVDQG+DULVDZWKDWWRDFFXVHDPHPEHURIWKH
    +LJK&RXQFLORISRQWLILFDWLQJZDVDPLOGVRFLDOMDE,IRXQGLWIDVFLQDWLQJ
    3UHWW\KXPGUXPVWXII,PDIUDLGFRPSDUHGWR\RXPDWKLVWV/DPXUN
    VDLGFRUGLDOO\
    ,DPDIUDLGP\PDWKHPDWLFV LVHYHQPRUHGU\WKDQ=RQDOWUDGH
    0RUHWLWWHUVWKRXJKWKLVWLPH+DULFRXOGQRWTXLWHVHHZK\
    ,MXVWWU\WRVHSDUDWHRXWWKHIDFWLRQV/DPXUNVDLGJHQLDOO\3HRSOH
    WUHDWPRQH\OLNHLWLVDUHOLJLRQ
    7KLVJDLQHGKLPVRPHDJUHHLQJODXJKWHU+DULVDLG)RUWXQDWHO\WKHUH
    DUHQRVHFWVLQJHRPHWU\
    :HUHMXVWWU\LQJWRJHWWKHEHVWGHDOIRUWKHZKROH(PSLUH
    $FDGHPLFLDQ
    7KHEHVWLVWKHHQHP\RIWKHJRRG,GLPDJLQH
    ,VXSSRVHWKHQ\RXOOEHDSSO\LQJPDWKHPDWLFDOORJLFWRRXUSUREOHPV
    RQWKH&RXQFLO"/DPXUNVYRLFHUHPDLQHGIULHQGO\EXWKLVH\HVWRRNRQD
    YHLOHGFKDUDFWHU$VVXPLQJ\RXJDLQDPLQLVWHUVKLS"
    $ODVVRIDUDVWKHODZVRIPDWKHPDWLFVDUHVKDUSDQGFHUWDLQWKH\GR
    QRWUHIHUWRUHDOLW\6RIDUDVWKH\UHIHUWRUHDOLW\WKH\DUHQRWFHUWDLQ
    /DPXUNJODQFHGDWWKHFURZGZKLFKKDGJURZQFRQVLGHUDEO\'RUVJUDVSHG
    +DULVKDQGDQGKHUHDOL]HGIURPKHUVTXHH]HWKDWWKLVKDGVRPHKRZWXUQHGLQWR
    VRPHWKLQJLPSRUWDQW+HFRXOGQRWVHHZK\EXWWKHUHZDVQRWLPHWRVL]HXS
    WKHVLWXDWLRQ
    /DPXUNVDLG7KHQWKLVSV\FKRKLVWRU\WKLQJ,KHDUDERXWLWVQRW
    XVHIXO"
    1RWWR\RXVLU+DULVDLG
    /DPXUNVH\HVQDUURZHGEXWKLVDIIDEOHJULQUHPDLQHG7RRWRXJKIRU
    XV"
    1RWUHDG\IRUXVH,PDIUDLG,GRQWKDYHWKHORJLFRILW\HW
    /DPXUNFKXFNOHGEHDPHGDWWKHVWLOOJURZLQJFURZGDQGVDLGMRYLDOO\
    $ORJLFDOWKLQNHUZKDWDUHIUHVKLQJFRQWUDVWZLWKWKHUHDOZRUOG
    *HQHUDOODXJKWHU+DULWULHGWRWKLQNRIVRPHWKLQJWRVD\+HVDZRQHRI
    KLVERG\JXDUGVEORFNDPDQQHDUE\LQVSHFWVRPHWKLQJLQWKHPDQVVXLWWKHQ
    OHWKLPJR
    <VHH$FDGHPLFLDQRQWKH+LJK&RXQFLOZHFDQWEHVSHQGLQJRXUWLPH
    RQWKHRU\/DPXUNSDXVHGIRUHIIHFWDVWKRXJKPDNLQJDFDPSDLJQVSHHFK
    :HYHJRWWREHMXVWDQGVRPHWLPHVIRONVZHYHJRWWREHKDUG
    +DULUDLVHGDQH\HEURZ0\IDWKHUXVHGWRVD\,WVDKDUGPDQZKRV
    RQO\MXVWDQGDVDGPDQZKRVRQO\ZLVH
    $IHZRRRKVLQWKHFURZGWROGKLPKHKDGVFRUHGDKLW/DPXUNVH\HV
    FRQILUPHGWKHFXW
    :HOOZHGRWU\RQWKH&RXQFLOZHGR1RGRXEWZHFDQXVHVRPHKHOS
    IURPWKHOHDUQHGTXDUWHUVRIWKH(PSLUH,//KDYHWRUHDGRQHRI\RXUERRNV
    $FDGHPLFLDQ+HVKRWDORRNZLWK UDLVHGH\HEURZVDWWKHFURZG$VVXPLQJ,
    FDQ
    +DULVKUXJJHG,ZLOOVHQG\RXP\PRQRJUDSKRQWUDQVILQLWHJHRPHWULF
    FDOFXOXV
    ,PSUHVVLYHWLWOH/DPXUNVDLGH\HVSOD\LQJWRWKHDXGLHQFH
    ,WVWKHVDPHZLWKERRNVDVZLWKPHQDYHU\VPDOOQXPEHUSOD\JUHDW
    SDUWVWKHUHVWDUHORVWLQWKHPXOWLWXGH
    $QGZKLFKZRXOG\RXUDWKHUEH"/DPXUNVKRWEDFN
    $PRQJWKHPXOWLWXGHV$WOHDVW,ZRXOGQWKDYHWRDWWHQGVRPDQ\
    UHFHSWLRQV
    7KLVJRWDELJODXJKVXUSULVLQJ+DUL/DPXUNVDLG:HOO,PVXUHWKH
    (PSHURUZRQWWLUH\RXRXWZLWKWRRPXFKVRFLDOL]LQJ%XW\RXOOJHWLQYLWHG

    HYHU\ZKHUH<RXYHJRWDVKDUSWRQJXHRQ\RX$FDGHPLFLDQ
    0\IDWKHUKDGDQRWKHUVD\LQJWRR:LWLVOLNHDUD]RU5D]RUVDUH
    PRUHOLNHO\WRFXWWKRVHZKRXVHWKHPZKHQWKH\YHORVWWKHLUHGJH
    +LVIDWKHUKDGDOVRWROGKLPWKDWLQDSXEOLFWUDGHRIEDUEVWKHRQH
    ZKRORVWWHPSHUILUVWORVWWKHH[FKDQJH+HKDGQRWUHFDOOHGWKDWXQWLOWKLV
    LQVWDQW+DULUHPHPEHUHGWRRODWHWKDW/DPXUNZDVNQRZQIRUKLVKXPRULQ+LJK
    &RXQFLOPHHWLQJV3UREDEO\VFULSWHGIRUKLPFHUWDLQO\KHGLVSOD\HGQRQHKHUH
    $TXLFNWLJKWHQLQJRIWKHFKHHNVVSUHDGLQWRDEORRGOHVVZKLWHOLQHRI
    OLS/DPXUNVIHDWXUHVWZLVWHGLQWRDQH[SUHVVLRQRIGLVWDVWHQRWDORQJZD\
    WRJRIRUPRVWRIWKHPDQGKHJDYHDQXJO\ZHWODXJK
    7KHFURZGVWRRGDEVROXWHO\VLOHQW6RPHWKLQJKDGKDSSHQHG
    $KWKHUHDUHRWKHUSHRSOHZKRZRXOGOLNHWRPHHWWKH$FDGHPLFLDQ
    +DULVOLHXWHQDQWVDLGVOLGLQJQHDWO\LQWRWKHJURZLQJDZNZDUGVLOHQFH
    +DULVKRRNKDQGVPXUPXUHGPHDQLQJOHVVSOHDVDQWULHVDQGOHWKLPVHOIEH
    ZKLVNHGDZD\
    

    +HKDGDQRWKHUVWLPWRFDOPKLPVHOI6RPHKRZKHZDVPRUHMLWWHU\
    DIWHUZDUGWKDQGXULQJWKHVRFLDOFROOLVLRQ/DPXUNKDGJLYHQ+DULDFROG
    DQJU\VWDUHDVWKH\SDUWHG
    ,OONHHSWUDFNRIKLP'RUVVDLG<RXMXVWHQMR\\RXUIDPH
    7R+DULWKLVZDVDIODWLPSRVVLELOLW\EXWKHWULHG6HOGRPGLGRQHVHH
    VXFKDYDULHW\RISHRSOHDQGKHFDOPHGKLPVHOIE\ODSVLQJLQWRDKDELWXDO
    UROHSROLWHREVHUYHU,WZDVQRWDVWKRXJKWKHXVXDOVRFLDOFKLWFKDWGHPDQGHG
    PXFKFRQFHQWUDWLRQ$ZDUPVPLOHZRXOGGRPRVWRIWKHZRUNIRUKLPKHUH
    7KHSDUW\ZDVDPLFURFRVPRI7UDQWRULDQVRFLHW\,QVSDUHPRPHQWV+DUL
    ZDWFKHGWKHVRFLDORUGHUVLQWHUDFW
    &OHRQVJUDQGIDWKHUKDGUHLQVWDWHGPDQ\5XHOOLDQWUDGLWLRQVDQGRQHRI
    WKRVHFXVWRPVUHTXLUHGWKDWPHPEHUVRIDOOILYHFODVVHVEHSUHVHQWDWDQ\
    JUDQG,PSHULDOIXQFWLRQ&OHRQVHHPHGHVSHFLDOO\NHHQRQWKLVSUDFWLFHDVLI
    LWZRXOGUDLVHKLVSRSXODULW\DPRQJWKHPDVVHV+DULNHSWKLVRZQGRXEWV
    SULYDWH
    )LUVWDQGREYLRXVFDPHWKHJHQWU\WKHLQKHULWHGDULVWRFUDF\&OHRQ
    KLPVHOIVWRRGDWWKHDSH[RIDS\UDPLGRIUDQNWKDWGHVFHQGHGIURPWKH
    ,PSHULXPWRPLJKW\4XDGUDQW'XNHVDQG6SLUDO$UP3ULQFHVSDVW/LIH3HHUVDOO
    WKHZD\GRZQWRWKHORFDOEDURQV+DULXVHGWRNQRZEDFNRQ+HOLFRQ
    :RUNLQJLQWKHILHOGVKHKDGVHHQWKHPSRPSRXVO\VFXGGLQJRYHUKHDG
    (DFKJRYHUQHGDGRPDLQQRODUJHUWKDQWKH\FRXOGFURVVE\IOLWWHULQDGD\7R
    DPHPEHURIWKHJHQWU\OLIHZDVEXV\ZLWKWKH*UHDW*DPHDFHDVHOHVV
    FDPSDLJQWRDGYDQFHWKHIRUWXQHVRIRQHVQREOHKRXVHDUUDQJLQJJUHDWHU
    VWDWXVIRU\RXUIDPLO\OLQHWKURXJKSROLWLFDODOOLDQFHVRUPDUULDJHVIRU\RXU
    PDQ\FKLOGUHQ
    +DULVQRUWHGLQGHULVLRQPDVNLQJLWE\WDNLQJDQRWKHUVWLP+HKDG
    VWXGLHGDQWKURSRORJLFDOUHSRUWVIURPDWKRXVDQG)DOOHQ:RUOGVWKRVHWKDWKDG
    GHYROYHGLQLVRODWLRQUHYHUWLQJWRFUXGHUZD\VRIOLIH+HNQHZWKLVS\UDPLG
    VKDSHGRUGHUWREHDPRQJWKHPRVWQDWXUDODQGHQGXULQJKXPDQVRFLDOSDWWHUQV
    (YHQZKHQDSODQHWZDVUHGXFHGWRVLPSOHDJULFXOWXUHDQGKDQGIRUJHGPHWDOV
    WKHVDPHWULDQJXODUIRUPDWHQGXUHG3HRSOHOLNHGUDQNDQGRUGHU
    7KHHQGOHVVFRPSHWLWLRQRIJHQWU\IDPLOLHVKDGEHHQWKHILUVWDQG
    HDVLHVWSV\FKRKLVWRURORJLFDOV\VWHP+DULHYHUPRGHOHG+HKDGILUVWFRPELQHG
    EDVLFJDPHWKHRU\DQGNLQVHOHFWLRQ7KHQLQDPRPHQWRILQVSLUDWLRQKH
    LQVHUWHGWKHPLQWRWKHHTXDWLRQVWKDWGHVFULEHGVDQGJUDLQVVNLGGLQJGRZQWKH
    VORSHVRIDGXQH7KDWFRUUHFWO\GHVFULEHGVXGGHQWUDQVLWLRQVVRFLDO
    VOLSSDJHV
    6RLWZDVZLWKWKHULVHDQGIDOORIQREOHIDPLO\OLQHV/RQJVPRRWK
    HUDVWKHQDEUXSWVKLIWV

    +HZDWFKHGWKHFURZGSLFNLQJRXWWKRVHLQWKHVHFRQGDULVWRFUDF\
    VXSSRVHGO\HTXDOWRWKHILUVWWKHPHULWRFUDF\
    $VGHSDUWPHQWFKDLUPDQDWDPDMRU,PSHULDOXQLYHUVLW\+DULZDVKLPVHOI
    DORUGLQWKDWKLHUDUFK\DS\UDPLGRIDFKLHYHPHQWUDWKHUWKDQRIELUWK
    0HULWRFUDWVKDGHQWLUHO\GLIIHUHQWREVHVVLRQVWKDQWKHJHQWU\VFRQVWDQW
    G\QDVWLFELFNHULQJV,QIDFWIHZLQ+DULVFODVVERWKHUHGWREUHHGDWDOOVR
    EXV\ZHUHWKH\LQWKHLUFKRVHQILHOGV*HQWU\MRVWOHGIRUWKHWRSUDQNVRI
    ,PSHULDOJRYHUQPHQWZKLOHVHFRQGWLHUPHULWRFUDWVVDZWKHPVHOYHVZLHOGLQJWKH
    UHDOSRZHU
    ,IRQO\&OHRQKDGVXFKDUROHLQPLQGIRUPH+DULWKRXJKW$YLFH
    PLQLVWHUSRVLWLRQRUDQDGYLVRU\SRVW+HFRXOGKDYHPDQDJHGWKDWIRUDWLPH
    RUHOVHEXQJOHGLWDQGJRWKLPVHOIIRUFHGRXWRIRIILFH(LWKHUZD\KHZRXOG
    EHVDIHEDFNDW6WUHHOLQJZLWKLQD\HDURUWZR7KH\GRQWH[HFXWHYLFH
    PLQLVWHUVQRWIRULQFRPSHWHQFHDWOHDVW
    1RUGLGDYLFHPLQLVWHUIHHOWKHZRUVWEXUGHQRIUXOHEHDULQJ
    UHVSRQVLELOLW\IRUWKHOLYHVRIDTXDGULOOLRQKXPDQEHLQJV
    'RUVVDZKLPGULIWLQJDORQJLQKLVRZQWKRXJKWV8QGHUKHUJHQWOH
    XUJLQJKHVDPSOHGWDVW\VDYRULHVDQGPDGHVPDOOWDON
    7KHJHQWU\FRXOGEHGLVWLQJXLVKHGE\WKHLURVWHQWDWLRXVO\IDVKLRQDEOH
    FORWKLQJZKLOHWKHHFRQRPLVWVJHQHUDOVDQGRWKHUPHULWRFUDWVWHQGHGWRZHDU
    WKHIRUPDOJDUERIWKHLUSURIHVVLRQV
    6RKHZDVPDNLQJDSROLWLFDOVWDWHPHQWDIWHUDOO+DULUHDOL]HG,Q
    ZHDULQJSURIHVVRUVUREHVKHHPSKDVL]HGWKDWWKHUHPLJKWEHDQRQJHQWU\
    )LUVW0LQLVWHUIRUWKHILUVWWLPHLQIRUW\\HDUV
    1RWWKDWKHPLQGHGPDNLQJWKDWVWDWHPHQW+DULMXVWZLVKHGKHKDGGRQH
    LWRQSXUSRVH
    'HVSLWHWKHRIILFLDO5XHOOLDQHWKRVWKHUHPDLQLQJWKUHHVRFLDOFODVVHV
    VHHPHGQHDUO\LQYLVLEOHDWWKHSDUW\
    7KHIDFWRWXPVZRUHVRPEHUFRVWXPHVRIEURZQRUJUD\ZLWKH[SUHVVLRQVWR
    PDWFK7KH\VHOGRPVSRNHRQWKHLURZQ8VXDOO\WKH\KRYHUHGDWWKHHOERZRI
    VRPHDULVWRVXSSO\LQJIDFWVDQGHYHQILJXUHVWKDWWKHPRUHJDLO\GUHVVHG
    JXHVWVXVHGLQWKHLUDUJXPHQWV$ULVWRVJHQHUDOO\ZHUHLQQXPHUDWHXQDEOHWR
    GRVLPSOHDGGLWLRQ7KDWZDVIRUPDFKLQHV
    +DULIRXQGWKDWKHDFWXDOO\KDGWRFRQFHQWUDWHLQRUGHUWRSLFNWKH
    IRXUWKFODVVWKH*UH\VRXWRIWKHFURZG+HZDWFKHGWKHPPRYHOLNHILQFKHV
    DPRQJSHDFRFNV
    <HWWKHLUNLQGPDGHXSPRUHWKDQDVL[WKRI7UDQWRUVSRSXODWLRQ'UDZQ
    IURPHYHU\SODQHWLQWKH(PSLUHE\WKHDOOVHHLQJ&LYLO6HUYLFHWHVWVWKH\
    FDPHWRWKH&DSLWDO:RUOGVHUYHGWKHLUWLPHOLNHEDFKHORUPRQNVDQGOHIW
    DJDLQIRURXWZRUOGSRVWLQJV)ORZLQJWKURXJK7UDQWRUOLNHZDWHULQWKHJORRP\
    FLVWHUQVWKH*UH\VZHUHVHOGRPWKRXJKWRIDVKRQHVWDQGFRPPRQSODFHDQGGXOO
    DVWKHPHWDOZDOOV
    7KDWPLJKWKDYHEHHQKLVOLIHKHUHDOL]HG,WZDVWKHZD\RXWRIWKH
    ILHOGVIRUPDQ\RIWKHEULJKWHUFKLOGUHQKHKDGNQRZQDW+HOLFRQ([FHSWWKDW
    +DULKDGEHHQSOXFNHGULJKWRYHUWKHEXUHDXFUDF\VHQWVWUDLJKWWRDFDGHPHE\
    WKHWLPHKHFRXOGVROYHDPHUHHLJKWKRUGHUWHQVRUGHIROLDWLRQDWDJHWHQ
    5XHOOLDQLVPSUHDFKHGWKDWFLWL]HQZDVWKHKLJKHVWVRFLDOFODVVRIDOO
    ,QWKHRU\HYHQWKH(PSHURUVKDUHGVRYHUHLJQW\ZLWKFRPPRQPHQDQGZRPHQ
    %XWDWDSDUW\OLNHWKLVWKHPRVWQXPHURXV*DODFWLFJURXSZDV
    UHSUHVHQWHGPRVWO\E\WKHVHUYDQWVFDUU\LQJIRRGDQGGULQNDURXQGWKHKDOO
    HYHQPRUHLQYLVLEOHWKDQWKHGRXUEXUHDXFUDWV7KHPDMRULW\RI7UDQWRUV
    SRSXODWLRQWKHODERUHUVDQGPHFKDQLFVDQGVKRSNHHSHUVWKHGHQL]HQVRIWKH
    6HFWRUVKDGQRVWDWLRQDWDJDWKHULQJOLNHWKLV7KH\OD\RXWVLGHWKH
    5XHOOLDQUDQNLQJ
    $VIRUWKH$UWHVWKDWILQDOVRFLDORUGHUZDVQRWPHDQWWREHLQYLVLEOH
    0XVLFLDQVDQGMXJJOHUVVWUROOHGDPRQJWKHJXHVWVWKHVPDOOHVWPRVW
    IODPER\DQWFODVV

    (YHQPRUHGDVKLQJZDVDQ DLUVFXOSWRU+DULVSRWWHGDFURVVWKHYDVW
    FKDPEHUZKHQ'RUVSRLQWHGKLPRXW+DULKDGKHDUGRIWKHQHZDUWIRUP7KH
    VWDWXHVZHUHRIFRORUHGVPRNHWKDWWKHDUWLVWH[KDOHGLQUDSLGSXIIV6KDSHV
    RIHHULHJKRVWOLNHFRPSOH[LW\IORDWHGDPRQJWKHEHPXVHGJXHVWV6RPHILJXUHV
    FOHDUO\PDGHIXQRIWKHFRXUWO\JHQWU\DVSXII\FDULFDWXUHVRIWKHLU
    RVWHQWDWLRXVFORWKHVDQGSRVHV
    7R+DULVH\HWKHVPRNHILJXUHVVHHPHGHQWUDQFLQJXQWLOWKH\VWDUWHG
    GULIWLQJDSDUWLQWRWDWWHUVZLWKRXWVXEVWDQFHRUSUHGLFWDELOLW\
    ,WVDOOWKHPRGHKHKHDUGRQHRQORRNHUUHPDUN,KHDUWKHDUWLVW
    FRPHVVWUDLJKWIURP6DUN
    7KH5HQDLVVDQFHZRUOG"DQRWKHUDVNHGZLGHH\HG,VQWWKDWDOLWWOH
    GDULQJ":KRLQYLWHGKLP"
    7KH(PSHURUKLPVHOILWVVDLG
    +DULIURZQHG6DUNZKHUHWKRVHSHUVRQDOLW\VLPXODWLRQVFDPHIURP
    5HQDLVVDQFHZRUOGKHPXWWHUHGLUULWDEO\NQRZLQJQRZZKDWKHGLVOLNHGDERXW
    WKHVPRNHVKDSHVWKHLUHSKHPHUDOQDWXUH7KHLULQWHQGHGGHVWLQ\WRGLVVROYH
    LQWRFKDRV
    $VKHZDWFKHGWKHDLUVFXOSWRUEOHZDVDWLULFDOWDEOHDX7KHILUVW
    ILJXUHIRUPHGRIFULPVRQVPRNHDQGKHGLGQRWUHFRJQL]HLWXQWLO'RUVHOERZHG
    KLPDQGODXJKHG,WV\RX
    +HFODPSHGKLVJDSLQJPRXWKVKXWXQVXUHKRZWRKDQGOHWKHVRFLDO
    QXDQFHV$VHFRQGFORXGRIFRLOLQJEOXHVWUHDPHUVIRUPHGDFOHDUSLFWXUHRI
    /DPXUNH\HEURZVNQRWWHGLQIXU\7KHIRJJ\ILJXUHVKRYHUHGLQFRQIURQWDWLRQ
    +DULVPLOLQJ/DPXUNVFRZOLQJ
    $QG/DPXUNORRNHGWKHIRROZLWKEXOJLQJH\HVDQGSRXWLQJOLSV
    7LPHIRUDJUDFHIXOH[LW+DULVOLHXWHQDQWZKLVSHUHG+DULZDVRQO\
    WRRJODGWRDJUHH
    :KHQWKH\JRWKRPHKHZDVVXUHWKDWWKHUHKDGEHHQDELWH[WUDLQWKH
    VWLPKHZDVKDQGHGVRPHWKLQJWKDWIUHHGKLVWRQJXH&HUWDLQO\LWZDVQRWWKH
    VORZVSRNHQUHIOHFWLYH6HOGRQZKRKDGWUDGHGMDEVZLWK/DPXUN+HZRXOGKDYH
    WRZDWFKWKDW
    'RUVVLPSO\VKRRNKHUKHDG,WZDV\RX-XVWDSRUWLRQRI\RXWKDW
    GRHVQWJHWRXWWRSOD\YHU\PXFK
    

    3DUWLHVDUHVXSSRVHGWRFKHHUSHRSOHXS<XJRVDLGVOLGLQJDFXSRI
    NDIIDFURVV+DULVVPRRWKPDKRJDQ\GHVNWRS
    1RWWKLVRQH+DULVDLG
    $OOWKDWOX[XU\SRZHUIXOSHRSOHEHDXWLIXOZRPHQZLWW\KDQJHUVRQ,
    WKLQN,FRXOGKDYHVWD\HGDZDNH
    7KDWVZKDWGHSUHVVHVPHWKLQNLQJEDFNRYHULW$OOWKDWSRZHU$QG
    QRERG\WKHUHVHHPVWRFDUHDERXWRXUGHFOLQH
    ,VQWWKHUHVRPHROGVD\LQJDERXW
    )LGGOLQJZKLOH5RPDEXUQV'RUVNQHZLWRIFRXUVH6KHVD\VLWVIURP
    SUH(PSLUHDERXWD=RQHZLWKSUHWHQVLRQVRIJUDQGHXU$OOZRUPVOHDGWR
    5RPDLVDQRWKHURQH
    1HYHUKHDUGRIWKLV5RPD
    0HHLWKHUEXWSRPSRVLW\VSULQJVIRUWKHWHUQDO,WORRNVFRPLFLQ
    UHWURVSHFW
    <XJRPRYHGUHVWOHVVO\DURXQG+DULVRIILFH6RWKH\GRQWFDUH"
    7RWKHPLWVMXVWEDFNGURSIRUWKHLUSRZHUJDPHV$OUHDG\WKH(PSLUH
    KDGZRUOGV=RQHVDQGHYHQZKROHDUFVRIVSLUDODUPVGHVFHQGHGLQWRVTXDORU
    6WLOOZRUVHLQDZD\ZDVDVWHDG\VOLGHLQWRJDULVKDPXVHPHQWVHYHQ
    YXOJDULW\7KHPHGLDVZDUPHGZLWKWKHVWXII7KHQHZUHQDLVVDQFHVW\OHVIURP
    ZRUOGVOLNH6DUNZHUHSRSXODU
    7R+DULWKHEHVWRIWKH(PSLUHZDVLWVVWUDQGVRIUHVWUDLQWRIVXEWOHW\

    DQGGLVFUHWLRQLQPDQQHUVILQHVVHDQGFKDUPLQWHOOLJHQFHWDOHQWDQGHYHQ
    JODPRXU+HOLFRQKDGEHHQFUXGHDQGUXUDOEXWLWNQHZWKHGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQ
    VLONDQGVZLQH
    :KDWGRWKHSROLF\W\SHVVD\"<XJRVDWKDOIZD\RQ+DULVGHVN
    DYRLGLQJWKHFRQWUROIXQFWLRQVLPSODQWHGEHQHDWKDZRRG\YHQHHU+HKDGFRPH
    LQZLWKWKHNDIIDVDSUHWH[WILVKLQJIRUJRVVLSDERXWWKHH[DOWHG+DUL
    VPLOHGWRKLPVHOISHRSOHUHOLVKHGVRPHDVSHFWVRIKLHUDUFK\KRZHYHUPXFK
    WKH\JULSHGDERXWLW
    7KH\UHKRSLQJVRPHRIWKHPRUDOUHELUWKPRYHPHQWVOLNHUHYLVHG
    5XHOOLDQLVPVD\ZLOOWDNHKROG3XWVSLQHLQWRWKH=RQHVRQHRIWKHPVDLG
    8PPP7KLQNLWOOZRUN"
    1RWIRUORQJ
    ,GHRORJ\ZDVDQXQFHUWDLQFHPHQW(YHQUHOLJLRXVIHUYRUFRXOGQRWJOXH
    DQHPSLUHWRJHWKHUIRUORQJ(LWKHUIRUFHFRXOGGULYHIRUPDWLRQRIDQHPSLUH
    EXWWKH\FRXOGQRWKROGDJDLQVWJUHDWHUVWHDG\WLGHVSULQFLSDOO\HFRQRPLFV
    +RZDERXWWKHZDULQWKH2ULRQ=RQH"
    1RERG\PHQWLRQHGLW
    7KLQNZHYHJRWZDUILJXUHGULJKWLQWKHHTXDWLRQV"<XJRKDGDNQDFN
    IRUVXGGHQO\SXWWLQJKLVILQJHURQZKDWZDVERWKHULQJ+DUL
    1R:DUZDVDQRYHUHVWHHPHGHOHPHQWLQKLVWRU\
    &HUWDLQO\ZDURIWHQJDLQHGFHQWHUVWDJHQRRQHFRQWLQXHGWRUHDGD
    EHDXWLIXOSRHPZKHQDILVWILJKWEURNHRXWQHDUE\%XWILVWILJKWVGLGQRW
    ODVWHLWKHU)XUWKHUWKH\MRJJOHGWKHHOERZVRIWKRVHWU\LQJWRPDNHD
    OLYLQJ7RHQJLQHHUVDQGWUDGHUVDOLNHZDUGLGQRWSD\6RZK\GLGZDUVEUHDN
    RXWQRZZLWKDOOWKHHFRQRPLFZHLJKWRIWKH(PSLUHDJDLQVWWKHP"
    :DUVDUHVLPSOH%XWZHUHPLVVLQJVRPHWKLQJEDVLF,FDQIHHOLW
    :HYHEDVHGWKHPDWULFHVRQDOOWKDWKLVWRULFDOGDWD'RUVGXJRXW
    <XJRVDLGDELWGHIHQVLYHO\7KDWVVROLG
    ,GRQWGRXEWLW6WLOO
    /RRNZHYHJRWRYHUWZHOYHWKRXVDQG\HDUVRIKDUGIDFWV,EXLOWWKH
    PRGHORQWKDW
    ,KDYHDIHHOLQJZKDWZHUHPLVVLQJLVQWVXEWOH
    0RVWFROODSVHVZHUHQRWIURPDEVWUXVHFDXVHV,QWKHHDUO\GD\VRI
    (PSLUHFRQVROLGDWLRQORFDOPLQRUVRYHUHLJQWLHV IORXULVKHGWKHQGLHG7KHUH
    ZHUHUHFXUUHQWWKHPHVLQWKHLUKLVWRULHV
    $JDLQDQGDJDLQVWDUVSDQQLQJUHDOPVFROODSVHGXQGHUWKHZHLJKWRI
    H[FHVVLYHWD[DWLRQ6RPHWLPHVWKHWD[HVVXSSRUWHGPHUFHQDU\DUPLHVZKLFK
    GHIHQGHGDJDLQVWQHLJKERUVRUZKLFKVLPSO\NHSWGRPHVWLFRUGHUDJDLQVW
    FHQWULIXJDOIRUFHV:KDWHYHUWKHRVWHQVLEOHFDXVHRIWD[HVVRRQHQRXJKWKH
    JUHDWFLWLHVEHFDPHGHSRSXODWHGDVSHRSOHIOHGWKHWD[FROOHFWRUVVHHNLQJ
    UXUDOSHDFH
    %XWZK\GLGWKH\GRWKDWVSRQWDQHRXVO\"
    3HRSOH+DUL VDWXSVXGGHQO\7KDWVZKDWZHUHPLVVLQJ
    +XK"<RXSURYHG\RXUVHOIUHPHPEHU"WKH5HGXFWLRQLVW7KHRUHP"WKDW
    LQGLYLGXDOVGRQWPDWWHU
    7KH\GRQW%XWSHRSOHGR2XUFRXSOHGHTXDWLRQVGHVFULEHWKHPLQWKH
    PDVVEXWZHGRQWNQRZWKHFULWLFDOGULYHUV
    7KDWVDOOKLGGHQGRZQLQWKHGDWD
    0D\EHQRW:KDWLIZHZHUHELJVSLGHUVLQVWHDGRISULPDWHV":RXOG
    SV\FKRKLVWRU\ORRNWKHVDPH"
    <XJRIURZQHG:HOOLIWKHGDWDZHUHWKHVDPH
    'DWDRQWUDGHZDUVSRSXODWLRQVWDWLVWLFV",WZRXOGQWPDWWHUZKHWKHU
    ZHZHUHFRXQWLQJVSLGHUVLQVWHDGRISHRSOH"
    <XJRVKRRNKLVKHDGKLVIDFHFORXGLQJXQZLOOLQJWRFRQFHGHDSRLQW
    WKDWPLJKWWRSSOH\HDUVRIZRUN,WVJRWWDEHWKHUH
    <RXUFRPLQJLQKHUHWRJHWGHWDLOVRIZKDWWKHULFKDQGIDPRXVGRDW
    WKHLUUHYHOVZKHUHVWKDWLQWKHHTXDWLRQV"

    <XJRVPRXWKWZLVWHGLUNHGQRZ7KDWVWXIILWGRHVQWPDWWHU
    :KRVD\V"
    :HOOKLVWRU\
    ,VZULWWHQE\WKHZLQQHUVWUXHHQRXJK%XWKRZGRWKHJUHDWJHQHUDOV
    JHWPHQDQGZRPHQWRPDUFKWKURXJKIUHH]LQJPXG":KHQZRQWWKH\PDUFK"
    1RERG\NQRZV
    :HQHHGWRNQRZ2UUDWKHUWKHHTXDWLRQVGR
    +RZ"
    ,GRQWNQRZ
    *RWRWKHKLVWRULDQV"
    +DULODXJKHG+HVKDUHG'RUVFRQWHPSWIRUPRVWRIKHUSURIHVVLRQ7KH
    FXUUHQWIDVKLRQLQWKHVWXG\RIWKHSDVWZDVDPDWWHURIWDVWHQRWGDWD
    +HKDGRQFHWKRXJKWWKDWKLVWRU\ZDVVLPSO\DPDWWHURIJUXEELQJLQ
    PXVW\F\EHUILOHV7KHQLI'RUVZRXOGVKRZKLPKRZWRWUDFNGRZQGDWDZKHWKHU
    HQFRGHGLQDQFLHQWIHUULWHF\OLQGHUVRUSRO\PHUEORFNVRUVWUDQGZDUHWKHQKH
    ZRXOGKDYHDILUPEDVLVIRUPDWKHPDWLFV'LGQW'RUVDQGRWKHUKLVWRULDQV
    VLPSO\DGGRQHPRUHEULFNRINQRZOHGJHWRDQHYHUJURZLQJPRQXPHQW"
    7KHFXUUHQWVW\OHWKRXJKZDVWRPDUVKDOWKHSDVWLQWRDSUHIHUUHG
    IODYRU)DFWLRQVIRXJKWRYHUWKHDQWLTXLW\RYHUWKHLUKLVWRU\YVRXUV
    )ULQJHVIORXULVKHG7KHVSLUDOFHQWULFKHOGWKDWKLVWRULFDOIRUFHVVSUHDG
    DORQJVSLUDODUPVZKHUHDVWKH+XEIRFXVHGPDLQWDLQHGWKDWWKH*DODFWLF
    &HQWHUZDVWKHWUXHPHGLDWLQJDJHQF\IRUFDXVHVWUHQGVPRYHPHQWVHYROXWLRQ
    7HFKQRFUDWVFRQWHQGHGZLWK1DWXUDOVZKRIHOWWKDWLQQDWHKXPDQTXDOLWLHV
    GURYHFKDQJH
    $PRQJP\ULDGIDFWVDQGIRRWQRWHVVSHFLDOLVWVVDZSUHVHQWSROLWLFV
    PLUURUHGLQWKHSDVW$VWKHSUHVHQWIUDFWXUHGDQGWUDQVILJXUHGWKHUHVHHPHG
    QRSRLQWRIUHIHUHQFHRXWVLGHKLVWRU\LWVHOIDQXQUHOLDEOHSODWIRUPLQGHHG
    HVSHFLDOO\ZKHQRQHUHDOL]HGKRZPDQ\P\VWHULRXVJDSVWKHUHZHUHLQWKH
    UHFRUGV$OOWKLVVHHPHGWR+DULWREHPRUHIDVKLRQWKDQIRXQGDWLRQ7KHUHZDV
    QRXQFRQWHVWHGSDVW
    :KDWFRQWDLQHGWKHFHQWULIXJDOIRUFHVRIUHODWLYLVPOHWPHKDYHP\
    YLHZSRLQWDQG\RXFDQKDYH\RXUVZDVDQDUHQDRIEURDGDJUHHPHQW0RVWSHRSOH
    JHQHUDOO\KHOGWKDWWKH(PSLUHZDVJRRGRYHUDOO7KDWWKHORQJSHULRGVRI
    VWDVLVKDGEHHQWKHEHVWWLPHVIRUFKDQJHDOZD\VFRVWVRPHRQH7KDWDERYHWKH
    FRPSHWLQJWKURQJWKURXJKWKHIDFWLRQVVKRXWLQJZKDWZHUHHVVHQWLDOO\IDPLO\
    VWRULHVDWHDFKRWKHUWKHUHZDVZRUWKLQFRPSUHKHQGLQJZKHUHKXPDQLW\KDG
    SDVVHGZKDWLWKDGGRQH
    %XWWKHUHDJUHHPHQWVWRSSHG)HZVHHPHGFRQFHUQHGZLWKZKHUHKXPDQLW\
    RUHYHQWKH(PSLUHZDVJRLQJ+HKDGFRPHWRVXVSHFWWKDWWKHVXEMHFWZDV
    LJQRUHGLQIDYRURI\RXUKLVWRU\DJDLQVWPLQHEHFDXVHPRVWKLVWRULDQV
    XQFRQVFLRXVO\GUHDGHGWKHIXWXUH7KH\VHQVHGWKHGHFOLQHLQWKHLUVRXOVDQG
    NQHZWKDWRYHUWKHKRUL]RQOD\QRW\HWDQRWKHUVKLIWWKHQVWDVLVEXWD
    FROODSVH
    6RZKDWGRZHGR"+DULUHDOL]HGWKDW<XJRKDGVDLGWKLVWZLFHQRZ+H
    KDGGULIWHGRIILQWRUHYHULH
    ,GRQWNQRZ
    $GGDQRWKHUWHUPIRUEDVLFLQVWLQFWV"
    +DULVKRRNKLVKHDG3HRSOHGRQWUXQRQLQVWLQFW%XWWKH\GREHKDYH
    OLNHSHRSOHOLNHSULPDWHV,VXSSRVH
    6RZHVKRXOGORRNLQWRWKDW"
    +DULWKUHZXSKLVKDQGV,FRQIHVV,IHHOWKDWWKLVOLQHRIORJLFLV
    OHDGLQJVRPHZKHUHEXW,FDQWVHHWKHHQGRILW
    <XJRQRGGHGJULQQHG,WOOFRPHRXWZKHQLWVULSH
    7KDQNV,PQRWWKHEHVWRIFROODERUDWRUV, NQRZ7RRPRRG\
    +H\QHYHUPLQG*RWWDWKLQNRXWORXGVRPHWLPHVLVDOO
    6RPHWLPHV,PQRWVXUH,PWKLQNLQJDWDOO
    /HPPHVKRZ\RXWKHODWHVWKXK"<XJROLNHGWRSDUDGHKLVLQYHQWLRQV

    DQG+DULVDWEDFNDV<XJRDFFHVVHGWKHRIILFHKRORDQGSDWWHUQVDSSHDUHGLQ
    PLGDLU(TXDWLRQVKXQJLQVSDFHVWDFNHGDQGHDFKWHUPFRORUFRGHG
    6RPDQ\7KH\UHPLQGHG+DULRIELUGVIORFNLQJLQJUHDWEDQNV
    3V\FKRKLVWRU\ZDVEDVLFDOO\DYDVWVHWRILQWHUORFNHGHTXDWLRQV
    IROORZLQJWKHYDULDEOHVRIKLVWRU\,WZDVLPSRVVLEOHWRFKDQJHRQHDQGQRW
    YDU\DQ\RWKHU$OWHUSRSXODWLRQDQGWUDGHFKDQJHGDORQJZLWKPRGHVRI
    HQWHUWDLQPHQWVH[XDOPRUHVDQGDKXQGUHGRWKHUIDFWRUV
    6RPHZHUHXQGRXEWHGO\XQLPSRUWDQWEXWZKLFK"+LVWRU\ZDVDERWWRPOHVV
    TXDUU\RIIDFWRLGVPHDQLQJOHVVZLWKRXWVRPHZD\RIZLQQRZLQJWKHKDLORI
    SDUWLFXODUV7KDWZDVWKHHVVHQWLDOILUVWWDVNRIDQ\WKHRU\RIKLVWRU\WR
    ILQGWKHGHHSYDULDEOHV
    3RVWGLFWLRQUDWHVSUHVWR<XJRVDLGKLVKDQGFRPSXWHUVXVSHQGLQJLQ
    DLUJUDSKVHOHJDQWO\DUUD\HG(FRQRPLFLQGLFHVYDULDEOHIDPLOLHVWKH
    ZRUNV
    :KDWHUDV"+DULDVNHG
    7KLUGPLOOHQQLDWRVHYHQWK*(
    7KHPXOWLGLPHQVLRQDOVXUIDFHVUHSUHVHQWLQJHFRQRPLFYDULDEOHVZHUHOLNH
    WZLVWHGERWWOHVILOOHGZLWKDV<XJRWLPHVWHSSHGWKHPVORVKLQJIOXLGV7KH
    OLTXLGVRI\HOORZDQGDPEHUDQGYLUXOHQWUHGIORZHGDURXQGDQGWKURXJKHDFK
    RWKHULQDVXSSOHVORZGDQFH+DULZDVSHUSHWXDOO\DPD]HGDWKRZEHDXW\DURVH
    LQWKHPRVWXQOLNHO\ZD\VIURPPDWKHPDWLFV<XJRKDGSORWWHGDEVWUXVH
    HFRQRPHWULFTXDQWLWLHV\HWLQWKHJUDYLGVZD\RIFHQWXULHVWKH\PDGHGHOLFDWH
    DUDEHVTXHV
    6XUSULVLQJO\JRRGDJUHHPHQW+DULDOORZHG7KH\HOORZVXUIDFHVRI
    KLVWRULFDOGDWDPHUJHGFOHDQO\ZLWKWKHRWKHUFRORUVNLQVIOXLGVILQGLQJ
    FXUYHGOHYHOV$QGFRYHULQJIRXUPLOOHQQLD1RLQILQLWLHV"
    7KDWQHZUHQRUPDOL]DWLRQVFKHPHEORWWHGWKHPRXW
    ([FHOOHQW7KHPLGGOH*DODFWLF(UDGDWDLVWKHPRVWVROLGWRR
    FRUUHFW"
    <HDK7KHSROLWLFLDQVJRWLQWRWKHDFWDIWHUWKHVHYHQWKPLOOHQQLXP
    'RUVLVKHOSLQPHILOWHURXWWKHJDUEDJH
    +DULDGPLUHGWKHJUDFHIXOEOHQGLQJRIFRORUVDQFLHQWZLQHLQ
    WUDQVILQLWHERWWOHV
    7KHSV\FKRKLVWRULFDOUDWHVOLQNHGWRJHWKHUVWURQJO\+LVWRU\ZDVQRWDW
    DOOOLNHDVWXUG\VWHHOHGLILFHULJLGO\VSDQQLQJWLPHLWUDWKHUPRUH
    UHVHPEOHGDURSHEULGJHJURDQLQJDQGIOH[LQJZLWKHYHU\IRRWIDOO7KLV
    VWURQJFRXSOLQJG\QDPLFOHGWRUHVRQDQFHVLQWKHHTXDWLRQVZLOG
    IOXFWXDWLRQVHYHQLQILQLWLHV<HWQRWKLQJUHDOO\ZHQWLQILQLWHLQUHDOLW\VR
    WKHHTXDWLRQVKDGWREHIL[HG+DULDQG<XJRKDGVSHQWPDQ\\HDUVHOLPLQDWLQJ
    XJO\LQILQLWHV0D\EHWKHLUJRDOZDVLQVLJKW
    +RZGRWKHUHVXOWVORRNLI\RXVLPSO\UXQWKHHTXDWLRQVIRUZDUGSDVW
    WKHVHYHQWKPLOOHQQLXP"+DULDVNHG
    2VFLOODWLRQVEXLOGXS<XJRDGPLWWHG
    )HHGEDFNORRSVZHUHVFDUFHO\QHZ+DULNQHZWKHJHQHUDOWKHRUHPDQFLHQW
    EH\RQGPHDVXUH,IDOOYDULDEOHVLQDV\VWHPDUHWLJKWO\FRXSOHGDQG\RXFDQ
    FKDQJHRQHRIWKHPSUHFLVHO\DQGEURDGO\WKHQ\RXFDQLQGLUHFWO\FRQWURODOO
    RIWKHP7KHV\VWHPFRXOGEHJXLGHGWRDQH[DFWRXWFRPHWKURXJKLWVP\ULDG
    LQWHUQDOIHHGEDFNORRSV6SRQWDQHRXVO\WKHV\VWHPRUGHUHGLWVHOIDQGREH\HG
    +LVWRU\RIFRXUVHREH\HGQRRQH%XWIRUHUDVVXFKDVWKHIRXUWKWR
    VHYHQWKPLOOHQQLXPVRPHKRZWKHHTXDWLRQVJRWPDWWHUVULJKW3V\FKRKLVWRU\
    FRXOGSRVWGLFWKLVWRU\
    ,QWUXO\FRPSOH[V\VWHPVKRZDGMXVWPHQWVRFFXUOD\EH\RQGWKHKXPDQ
    FRPSOH[LW\KRUL]RQEH\RQGNQRZLQJDQGPRVWLPSRUWDQWQRWZRUWKNQRZLQJ
    %XWLIWKHV\VWHPZHQWDZU\VRPHERG\KDGWRJHWGRZQLQWKHJXWVRILW
    DQGILQGWKHWURXEOH$Q\LGHDV"&OXHV"
    <XJRVKUXJJHG/RRNDWWKLV
    7KHIOXLGVODSSHGDWWKHZDOOVRIWKHERWWOHV0RUHZDUSHGYROXPHV

    DSSHDUHGILOOHGZLWKEULJKWO\FRORUHGGDWDOLTXLGV+DULZDWFKHGDVWLGHV
    VZHSWWKURXJKWKHEXUQWRUDQJHYDULDEOHVSDFHGULYLQJDQVZHULQJZDYHVLQWKH
    SXUSOHOD\HUVQHDUE\6RRQWKHHQWLUHKRORVKRZHGIXULRXVO\FKXUQLQJ
    WXUEXOHQFH
    6RWKHHTXDWLRQVIDLO+DULVDLG
    <HDKELJWLPHWRR7KHJUDQGF\FOHVODVWDERXWDKXQGUHGDQGWZHQW\
    ILYH\HDUV%XWVPRRWKLQJRXWHYHQWVVKRUWHUWKDQHLJKW\\HDUVJLYHVDVWHDG\
    SDWWHUQ6HH
    +DULZDWFKHGWXUEXOHQFHEXLOGOLNHDKXUULFDQHFKXUQLQJDPXOWLFRORUHG
    RFHDQ
    <XJRVDLG7KDWWDNHVDZD\VFDWWHUGXHWRJHQHUDWLRQDOVW\OHV'RUV
    FDOOVLW,FDQWDNHWKH=RQHVWKDWFRQVFLRXVO\LQFUHDVHGKXPDQOLIHVSDQ,
    WLPHVWHSWKHHTXDWLRQVIRUZDUGJUHDWEXWWKHQ,UXQRXWRIGDWD+RZFRPH"
    ,PLQHWKHKLVWRU\VRPHDQGLWWXUQVRXWWKRVHVRFLHWLHVGLGQWODVWORQJ
    +DULVKRRNKLVKHDG<RXUHVXUH",GLPDJLQH LQFUHDVLQJWKHDYHUDJH
    DJHZRXOGEULQJDOLWWOHZLVGRPLQWRWKHSLFWXUH
    1RWVR,ORRNHGGHHSHUDQGIRXQGWKDWZKHQWKHOLIHVSDQUHDFKHGWKH
    VRFLDOF\FOHWLPHXVXDOO\DERXWDKXQGUHGDQGWHQ6WDQGDUG<HDUVLQVWDELOLW\
    URVH:KROHSODQHWVKDGZDUVGHSUHVVLRQVJHQHUDOVRFLDOLOOQHVVHV
    +DULIURZQHG7KDWHIIHFWLVLWNQRZQ"
    'RQWWKLQNVR
    7KLVLVZK\KXPDQVUHDFKHGDEDUULHULQLPSURYLQJWKHLUORQJHYLW\"
    6RFLHW\EUHDNVGRZQHQGLQJWKHSURJUHVV"
    <HDK
    <XJRZRUHDVPDOOWLJKWVPLOHE\ZKLFK+DULNQHZWKDWKHZDVUDWKHU
    SURXGRIWKLVUHVXOW*URZLQJLUUHJXODULWLHVEXLOGLQJWRFKDRV
    7KLVZDVWKHGHHSSUREOHPWKH\KDGQRWPDVWHUHG'DPQ+DULKDGDJXW
    GLVOLNHRIXQSUHGLFWDELOLW\
    <XJRJDYH+DULDFURRNHGVPLOH2QWKDW RQHERVV,JRWQRQHZV
    'RQWZRUU\+DULVDLGFKHHUIXOO\WKRXJKKHGLGQWIHHOLW<RXYH
    PDGHJRRGSURJUHVV5HPHPEHUWKHDGDJHWKH,PSHULXPZDVQWEXLOWLQDGD\
    <HDKEXWLWVHHPVWREHIDOOLQDSDUWSOHQW\IDVW
    7KH\VHOGRPPHQWLRQHGWKHGHHSVHDWHGPRWLYDWLRQIRUSV\FKRKLVWRU\WKH
    SHUYDVLYHDQ[LHW\WKDWWKH(PSLUHZDVGHFOLQLQJIRUUHDVRQVQRRQHNQHZ
    7KHUHZHUHWKHRULHVDSOHQW\EXWQRQHKDGSUHGLFWLYHSRZHU+DULKRSHGWR
    VXSSO\WKDW3URJUHVVZDVLQIXULDWLQJO\VORZ
    <XJRZDV ORRNLQJPRURVH+DULJRWXSFDPHDURXQGWKHELJGHVNDQGJDYH
    <XJRDJHQWOHVODSRQWKHEDFN&KHHUXS3XEOLVKWKLVUHVXOW
    &DQ,":HYHJRWWRNHHSSV\FKRKLVWRU\TXLHW
    -XVWJURXSWKHGDWDWKHQSXEOLVKLQDMRXUQDOGHYRWHGWRDQDO\WLFDO
    KLVWRU\7DONWR'RUVDERXWVHOHFWLQJWKHMRXUQDO
    <XJREULJKWHQHG,OOZULWHLWXSVKRZ\RX
    1ROHDYHPHRXWRILW,WV\RXUZRUN
    +H\\RXVKRZHGPHKRZWRVHWXSWKHDQDO\VLVZKHUH
    ,WV\RXUV3XEOLVK
    :HOO
    +DULGLGQRWPHQWLRQWKHIDFWWKDWQRZDQ\WKLQJSXEOLVKHGXQGHUKLV
    QDPHZRXOGDWWUDFWDWWHQWLRQ$IHZPLJKWJXHVVDWWKHLPPHQVHO\ODUJHUWKHRU\
    OXUNLQJEHKLQGWKHVLPSOHOLIHVSDQUHVRQDQFHHIIHFW%HVWWRNHHSDORZ
    SURILOH
    :KHQ<XJRKDGJRQHEDFNWRZRUN+DULVDWIRUDZKLOHDQGZDWFKHGWKH
    VTXDOOVZRUNWKURXJKWKHGDWDIOXLGVVWLOOWLPHVWHSSLQJLQWKHDLUDERYHKLV
    GHVN7KHQKHJODQFHGDWDIDYRULWHTXRWDWLRQRIKLVSRLQWHGRXWWRKLPE\
    'RUVJLYHQWRKLPRQDVPDOOHOHJDQWFHUDPRSODTXH
    0LQLPXPIRUFHDSSOLHGDWDFXVSPRPHQWDWWKHKLVWRULFDOIXOFUXPSDYHVWKH
    SDWKWRDGLVWDQWYLVLRQ3XUVXHRQO\WKRVHLPPHGLDWHJRDOVZKLFKVHUYHWKH

    ORQJHVWSHUVSHFWLYHV

    (PSHURU.DPEOHVWK2UDFOH9HUVH

    %XWVXSSRVH\RXFDQWDIIRUGORQJSHUVSHFWLYHV"KHPXWWHUHGWKHQZHQW
    EDFNWRZRUN
    

    7KHQH[WGD\KHJRWDQHGXFDWLRQLQWKHUHDOLWLHVRI,PSHULDOSROLWLFV
    <RXGLGQWNQRZWKH'VFRSHZDVRQ\RX"<XJRDVNHG
    +DULZDWFKHGWKHFRQYHUVDWLRQZLWK/DPXUNUHSOD\RQKLVRIILFHKROR+H
    KDGIOHGWRWKH8QLYHUVLW\ZKHQWKH,PSHULDO6SHFLDOVVWDUWHGKDYLQJWURXEOH
    KROGLQJWKHPHGLDPREDZD\IURPKLVDSDUWPHQW7KH\KDGFDOOHGLQ
    UHLQIRUFHPHQWVZKHQWKH\FDXJKWDWHDPGULOOLQJDQDFRXVWLFWDSLQWRWKH
    DSDUWPHQWIURPWKUHHOD\HUVDERYH +DULDQG'RUVKDGJRWWHQRXWZLWKDQHVFRUW
    WKURXJKDPDLQWHQDQFHJUDYGURS
    1R,GLGQW7KHUHZDVDORWJRLQJRQ+HUHPHPEHUHGKLVERG\JXDUGV
    DFFRVWLQJVRPHRQHFKHFNLQJDQGOHWWLQJLWSDVV7KH'FDPHUDDQGDFRXVWLF
    WUDFNHUZHUHVRVPDOOWKDWDPHGLDGHSXW\FRXOGZDONDURXQGZLWKWKHPXQGHU
    IRUPDOZHDU$VVDVVLQVXVHGWKHVDPHDUWIXOFRQFHDOPHQW%RG\JXDUGVNQHZKRZ
    WRGLVWLQJXLVKEHWZHHQWKHWZR
    <XJRVDLGZLWK'DKOLWHVDYY\*RWWDZDWFKHP\RXJRQQDSOD\LQWKRVH
    OHDJXHV
    ,DSSUHFLDWHWKHFRQFHUQ+DULVDLGGU\O\
    'RUVWDSSHGDILQJHUWRKHUOLSV,WKLQN\RXFDPHRYHUUDWKHUZHOO
    ,GLGQWZDQWWRVHHPDVWKRXJK,ZHUHGHOLEHUDWHO\FXWWLQJXSD
    PDMRULW\OHDGHUIURPWKH+LJK&RXQFLO+DULVDLGKHDWHGO\
    %XWWKDWVZKDW\RXZHUHGRLQ<XJRVDLG
    ,VXSSRVHEXWDWWKHWLPHLWVHHPHGOLNHSROLWHEDQWHUKH
    ILQLVKHGODPHO\(GLWHGIRU'LWZDVDTXLFNYHUEDO3LQJ3RQJZLWKUD]RU
    EODGHVLQVWHDGRIEDOOV
    %XW\RXWRSSHGKLPDWHYHU\H[FKDQJH'RUVREVHUYHG
    ,GRQWHYHQGLVOLNHKLP+HKDVGRQHJRRGWKLQJVIRUWKH(PSLUH+H
    SDXVHGWKLQNLQJ%XWLWZDVIXQ
    0D\EH\RXGRKDYHDWDOHQWIRUWKLVVKHVDLG
    ,GUDWKHUQRW
    ,GRQWWKLQN\RXKDYHPXFKFKRLFH<XJRVDLG<RXUHJHWWLQ
    IDPRXV
    )DPHLVWKHDFFXPXODWLRQRIPLVXQGHUVWDQGLQJVDURXQGDZHOONQRZQ
    QDPH'RUVVDLG
    +DULVPLOHG:HOOSXW
    ,WVIURP(OGRQLDQWKH(OGHUWKHORQJHVWOLYHGHPSHURU7KHRQO\RQH
    RIKLVFODQWRGLHRIROGDJH
    0DNHVWKHSRLQW<XJRVDLG<RXJRWWDH[SHFWVRPHVWRULHVJRVVLS
    PLVWDNHV
    +DULVKRRNKLVKHDGDQJULO\1R/RRNZHFDQWOHWWKLVH[WUDQHRXV
    PDWWHUGLVWUDFWXV<XJRZKDWDERXWWKRVHERRWOHJSHUVRQDOLW\FRQVWHOODWLRQV
    \RXDFTXLUHG"
    ,YHJRWHP
    0DFKLQHWUDQVODWHG"7KH\ZLOOUXQ"
    <HDKEXWWKH\WDNHDQDZIXOORWRIPHPRU\DQGUXQQLQJYROXPH,YH
    WXQHGWKHPVRPHEXWWKH\QHHGDELJJHUSDUDOOHOSURFHVVLQJQHWZRUNWKDQ,FDQ
    JLYHWKHP
    'RUVIURZQHG,GRQWOLNHWKLV7KHVHDUHQWMXVWFRQVWHOODWLRQV
    WKH\UHVLPV
    +DULQRGGHG:HUHGRLQJUHVHDUFKKHUHQRWWU\LQJWRPDQXIDFWXUHD

    VXSHUUDFH
    'RUVVWRRGDQGSDFHGHQHUJHWLFDOO\7KHPRVWDQFLHQWRIWDERRVLV
    DJDLQVWVLPV(YHQSHUVRQDOLW\FRQVWHOODWLRQVREH\ULJLGODZV
    2IFRXUVHDQFLHQWKLVWRU\%XW
    3UHKLVWRU\+HUQRVWULOVIODUHG7KHSURKLELWLRQVJREDFNVRIDU
    WKHUHDUHQRUHFRUGVRIKRZWKH\VWDUWHGXQGRXEWHGO\IURPVRPHGLVDVWURXV
    H[SHULPHQWVZHOOEHIRUHWKH6KDGRZ$JH
    :KDWVWKDW"<XJRDVNHG
    7KHORQJWLPHZHKDYHQRFOHDULGHDRI KRZORQJLWODVWHGWKRXJK
    FHUWDLQO\VHYHUDOPLOOHQQLDEHIRUHWKH(PSLUHEHFDPHFRKHUHQW
    %DFNRQ(DUWK\RXPHDQ"<XJRORRNHGVNHSWLFDO
    (DUWKLVPRUHOHJHQGWKDQIDFW%XW\HVWKHWDERRFRXOGJREDFNWKDW
    IDU
    7KHVHDUHKRSHOHVVO\FRQVWULFWHGVLPV<XJRVDLG7KH\GRQWNQRZ
    DQ\WKLQJDERXWRXUWLPH2QHLVDUHOLJLRXVIDQDWLFIRUVRPHIDLWK,QHYHU
    KHDUGRI7KHRWKHUVDVPDUWDVVZULWHU1RGDQJHUWRDQ\ERG\H[FHSWPD\EH
    WKHPVHOYHV
    'RUVUHJDUGHG<XJRVXVSLFLRXVO\,IWKH\UHVRQDUURZZK\DUHWKH\
    XVHIXO"
    %HFDXVHWKH\FDQFDOLEUDWHSV\FKRKLVWRULFDOLQGLFHV:HKDYHPRGHOLQJ
    HTXDWLRQVWKDWGHSHQGRQEDVLFKXPDQSHUFHSWLRQV,IZHKDYHDSUHDQFLHQW
    PLQGHYHQVLPPHGZHFDQFDOLEUDWHWKHPLVVLQJFRQVWDQWVLQWKHUDWH
    HTXDWLRQV
    'RUVVQRUWHGGRXEWIXOO\,GRQWIROORZWKHPDWKHPDWLFVEXW,NQRZ
    VLPVDUHGDQJHURXV
    /RRNQRERG\VDYY\EHOLHYHVWKDWVWXIIDQ\PRUH<XJRVDLG0DWKLVWV
    KDYHEHHQUXQQLQJSVHXGRVLPVIRUDJHV7LNWRNV
    7KRVHDUHLQFRPSOHWHSHUVRQDOLWLHVFRUUHFW"'RUVDVNHGVHYHUHO\
    :HOO\HDKEXW
    :HFRXOGJHWLQWRYHU\ELJWURXEOHLIWKHVHVLPVDUHEHWWHUPRUH
    YHUVDWLOH
    <XJRZDYHGDZD\KHUSRLQWZLWKKLVODUJHKDQGVVPLOLQJOD]LO\'RQW
    ZRUU\,JRWWKHPDOOXQGHUFRQWURO$Q\ZD\,YH DOUHDG\JRWDZD\WRVROYH
    RXUSUREOHPRIJHWWLQJHQRXJKUXQQLQJYROXPHPDFKLQHWLPHDQG,YHJRWD
    FRYHUIRUXV
    +DULDUFKHGKLVH\HEURZV:KDWVWKLV"
    ,YHJRWDFXVWRPHUIRUWKHVLPV6RPHERG\ZKROOUXQWKHPFRYHUDOO
    H[SHQVHVDQGSD\IRUWKHSULYLOHJH:DQWVWRXVHWKHPIRUFRPPHUFLDO
    SXUSRVHV
    :KR"+DULDQG'RUVDVNHGWRJHWKHU
    $UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHV<XJRVDLGWULXPSKDQWO\
    +DULORRNHGEODQN'RUVSDXVHGDVWKRXJKVHDUFKLQJIRUDGLVWDQWPHPRU\
    DQGWKHQVDLG$ILUPHQJDJHGLQFRPSXWHUV\VWHPVDUFKLWHFWXUH
    5LJKWRQHRIWKHEHVW7KH\YHJRWDPDUNHWIRUROGVLPVDV
    HQWHUWDLQPHQW
    +DULVDLG1HYHUKHDUGRIWKHP
    <XJRVKRRNKLVKHDGLQDPD]HPHQW<RXGRQWNHHSXS+DUL
    ,GRQWWU\WRNHHSXS,WU\WRVWD\DKHDG
    'RUVVDLG,GRQWOLNHXVLQJDQ\RXWVLGHDJHQF\$QGZKDWVWKLVDERXW
    SD\LQJ"
    <XJREHDPHG7KH\UHSD\LQJIRUOLFHQVHULJKWV,QHJRWLDWHGLWDOO
    'RZHKDYHDQ\FRQWURORYHUKRZWKH\XVHWKHVLPV"'RUVOHDQHGIRUZDUG
    DOHUWO\
    :HGRQWQHHGDQ\<XJRVDLGGHIHQVLYHO\7KH\OOSUREDEO\XVHWKHP
    LQDGYHUWLVHPHQWVRUVRPHWKLQJ+RZPXFKXVHFDQ\RXJHWRXWRIDVLPQRERG\
    ZLOOSUREDEO\XQGHUVWDQG"
    ,GRQWOLNHLW$VLGHIURPWKHFRPPHUFLDO DVSHFWVLWVULVN\WRHYHQ

    UHYLYHDQDQFLHQWVLP3XEOLFRXWUDJH
    +H\WKDWVWKHSDVW3HRSOHGRQWIHHOWKDWZD\DERXWWLNWRNVDQG
    WKH\UHJHWWLQJSUHWW\VPDUW
    7LNWRNVZHUHPDFKLQHVRIORZPHQWDOFDSDFLW\KHOGULJRURXVO\EHQHDWKDQ
    LQWHOOLJHQFHFHLOLQJE\WKH(QFRGLQJ/DZVRIDQWLTXLW\+DULKDGDOZD\V
    VXVSHFWHGWKDWWKHWUXHDQFLHQWURERWVKDGPDGHWKRVHODZVVRWKDWWKHUHDOP
    RIPDFKLQHLQWHOOLJHQFHGLGQRWVSDZQHYHUPRUHVSHFLDOL]HGDQGXQSUHGLFWDEOH
    W\SHV
    7KHWUXHURERWVVXFKDV5 'DQHHO2OLYDZUHPDLQHGDORRIFRRODQG
    ORQJYLVLRQHG%XWLQWKHJDWKHULQJDQ[LHWLHVDFURVVWKHHQWLUH(PSLUH
    WUDGLWLRQDOF\EHUQHWLFSURWRFROVZHUHEUHDNLQJGRZQ/LNHHYHU\WKLQJHOVH
    'RUVVWRRG,PRSSRVHG:HPXVWVWRSWKLVDWRQFH
    <XJRURVH WRRVWDUWOHG<RXKHOSHGPHILQGWKHVLPV1RZ\RX
    ,GLGQRWLQWHQGWKLV+HUIDFHWLJKWHQHG+DULZRQGHUHGDWKHU
    LQWHQVLW\6RPHWKLQJHOVHZDVDWVWDNHKHUHEXWZKDW"+HVDLGPLOGO\,VHH
    QRUHDVRQWRQRWPDNHDELWRISURILWIURPVLGHDYHQXHVRIRXUUHVHDUFK$QG
    ZHGRQHHGLQFUHDVHGFRPSXWLQJFDSDFLW\
    'RUVPRXWKZRUNHGZLWKLUULWDWLRQEXWVKHVDLGQRWKLQJPRUH+DUL
    ZRQGHUHGZK\VKHZDVVRRSSRVHG8VXDOO\\RXGRQWJLYHDGDPQDERXWVRFLDO
    FRQYHQWLRQV
    6KHVDLGDFLGO\8VXDOO\\RXDUHQRWDFDQGLGDWHIRU)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    ,ZLOOQRWOHWVXFKFRQVLGHUDWLRQVGHIOHFWRXUUHVHDUFKKHVDLG
    ILUPO\8QGHUVWDQG"
    6KHQRGGHGDQGVDLGQRWKLQJ+HLQVWDQWO\IHOWOLNHDQRYHUEHDULQJ
    W\UDQW7KHUHZDVDOZD\VDSRWHQWLDOFRQIOLFWEHWZHHQEHLQJFRZRUNHUVDQG
    ORYHUV8VXDOO\WKH\ZDOW]HGDURXQGWKHSUREOHPV:K\ZDVVKHVRDGDPDQW"
    7KH\JRWWKURXJKVRPHPRUHZRUNRQSV\FKRKLVWRU\DQG'RUVPHQWLRQHGKLV
    QH[WDSSRLQWPHQW6KHVIURPP\KLVWRU\GHSDUWPHQW,DVNHGKHUWRORRNLQWR
    SDWWHUQVLQ7UDQWRULDQWUHQGVRYHUWKHODVWWHQPLOOHQQLD
    2KJRRGWKDQNV&RXOG\RXVKRZKHULQSOHDVH"
    6\OYLQ7KRUDQD[ZDVDVWULNLQJZRPDQEHDULQJDER[RIROGGDWD
    S\UDPLGV,IRXQGWKHVHLQDOLEUDU\KDOIZD\DURXQGWKHSODQHWVKH
    H[SODLQHG
    +DULSLFNHGRQHXS,YHQHYHUVHHQRQHRIWKHVH'XVW\
    )RUVRPHWKHUHVQROLEUDU\LQGH[,GRZQFRGHGDIHZDQGWKH\UH
    JRRGVWLOOUHDGDEOHZLWKDWUDQVODWLRQPDWUL[
    8PPP+DULOLNHGWKHPXVW\IHHORIROGWHFKQRORJ\IURPVLPSOHUWLPHV
    :HFDQUHDGWKHVHGLUHFWO\"
    6KHQRGGHG,NQRZKRZWKHUHGXFHG6HOGRQ(TXDWLRQVIXQFWLRQ<RX
    VKRXOGEHDEOHWRGRDPDWFRPSDULVRQDQGILQGWKHFRHIILFLHQWV\RXQHHG
    +DULJULPDFHG7KH\UHQRWP\HTXDWLRQVWKH\FRPHRXWRIDERG\RI
    UHVHDUFKE\PDQ\
    &RPHFRPH$FDGHPLFLDQHYHU\RQHNQRZV\RXZURWHGRZQWKHSURFHGXUHV
    WKHDSSURDFK
    +DULJURXVHGDOLWWOHPRUHEHFDXVHLWGLGLUNKLPEXWWKH7KRUDQD[
    ZRPDQZHQWRQDERXWXVLQJWKHS\UDPLGVDQG<XJRMRLQHGLQHQWKXVLDVWLFDOO\DQG
    KHOHWWKH SRLQWSDVV6KHZHQWRIIZLWK<XJRWRZRUNDQGKHVHWWOHGLQWRKLV
    XVXDODFDGHPLFJULQG
    +LVGDLO\VFKHGXOHKRYHUHGRQWKHKROR

    *HW6\PSRVLDVSHDNHUVVZHHWHQWKHLQYLWDWLRQIRUWKHUHOXFWDQW

    :ULWHQRPLQDWLRQVIRU,PSHULDO)HOORZV

    5HDGVWXGHQWWKHVLVDIWHULWKDVEHHQFKHFNHG SDVVHGE\/RJLF&KRSSHU
    SURJUDP
    7KHVHEXUQHGXSWKHEXONRIKLVGD\2QO\ZKHQWKH&KDQFHOORUHQWHUHG
    KLVRIILFHGLGKHUHPHPEHUWKDWKHKDGSURPLVHGWRJLYHDVSHHFK7KH

    &KDQFHOORUKDGDTXLFNLURQLFVPLOHDQGSXUVHGOLSVDUHVHUYHGJD]HWKH
    VFKRODUVORRN<RXUGUHVV"KHDVNHGSRLQWHGO\
    +DULIXPEOHGLQKLVRIILFHFORVHWIHWFKHGIRUWKWKHEDOORRQVOHHYHGDQG
    DPSOHJLUWHGUREHDQGFKDQJHGLQWKHVLGHURRP+LVVHFUHWDU\KDQGHGKLPKLV
    DOOSXUSRVHYLHZFXEHDVWKH\TXLFNO\OHIWWKHRIILFH:LWKWKH&KDQFHOORUKH
    FURVVHGWKHPDLQVTXDUHKLV6SHFLDOVLQDQLQFRQVSLFXRXVIRUPDWLRQIRUHDQG
    DIW$FURZGRIZHOOGUHVVHGPHQDQGZRPHQWUDLQHG'FDPHUDVDWWKHPRQH
    SDQQLQJXSDQGGRZQWRJHWWKHIXOOHIIHFWRI WKH6WUHHOLQJEOXHDQG\HOORZ
    VZLUOVWULSHV
    +DYH\RXKHDUGIURP/DPXUN"
    :KDWDERXWWKH'DKOLWHV"
    'R\RXOLNHWKHQHZ6HFWRU3ULQFLSDO"'RHVLWPDWWHUWKDWVKHVD
    WULVH[XDOLVW"
    +RZDERXWWKHQHZKHDOWKUHSRUWV"6KRXOGWKH(PSHURUVHWH[HUFLVH
    UHTXLUHPHQWVIRU7UDQWRU"
    ,JQRUHWKHP+DULVDLG
    7KH&KDQFHOORUVPLOHGDQGZDYHGDWWKHFDPHUDV7KH\UHMXVWGRLQJ
    WKHLUMRE
    :KDWVWKLVDERXWH[HUFLVH"+DULDVNHG
    $VWXG\IRXQGWKDWHOHFWURVWLPZKLOHVOHHSLQJGRHVQWGHYHORSPXVFOHV
    DVZHOODVROGIDVKLRQHGH[HUFLVH
    1RWVXUSULVLQJ+HKDGZRUNHGLQWKHILHOGVDVDER\DQGQHYHUOLNHG
    WKHLGHDRIKDYLQJKLVH[HUWLRQVWLPPHGZKLOHKHVOHSW
    $ZHGJHRIUHSRUWHUVSUHVVHGQHDUHUVKRXWLQJTXHVWLRQV
    :KDWGRHVWKH(PSHURUWKLQN RIZKDW\RXVDLGWR/DPXUN"
    ,VLWWUXHWKDW\RXUZLIHGRHVQWZDQW\RXWREH)LUVW0LQLVWHU"
    :KDWDERXW'HPHU]HO":KHUHLVKH"
    :KDWDERXWWKH=RQDOGLVSXWHV"&DQWKH(PSLUHFRPSURPLVH"
    $ZRPDQUXVKHGIRUZDUG+RZGR\RXH[HUFLVH"
    +DULVDLGVDUGRQLFDOO\,H[HUFLVHUHVWUDLQWEXWKLVSRLQWVDLOHG
    ULJKWSDVWWKHZRPDQZKRORRNHGDWKLPEODQNO\
    $VWKH\HQWHUHGWKH*UHDW+DOO+DULUHPHPEHUHGWRIHWFKIRUWKWKHYLHZ
    FXEHDQGKDQGLWWRWKHKDOOPDVWHU$IHZ'VDOZD\VPDGHDWDON SDVVPRUH
    HDVLO\%LJFURZGKHQRWHGWRWKH&KDQFHOORUDVWKH\WRRNWKHLUSODFHVRQ
    WKHVSHHFKEDOFRQ\DERYHWKHERZORIVHDWV
    $WWHQGDQFHLVFRPSXOVRU\$OOFODVVPHPEHUVDUHKHUH7KH&KDQFHOORU
    EHDPHGGRZQDWWKHPXOWLWXGH,ZDQWHGWREHVXUHZHORRNHGJRRGWRWKH
    UHSRUWHUVRXWVLGH
    +DULVPRXWKWZLVWHG+RZGRWKH\WDNHDWWHQGDQFH"
    (YHU\RQHKDVDNH\HGVHDW2QFHWKH\VLWWKH\UHFRXQWHGLIWKHLU
    LQERDUG,'PDWFKHVWKHVHDWLQGH[
    $ORWRIWURXEOHMXVWWRJHWSHRSOHWRDWWHQG
    7KH\PXVW,WVIRUWKHLURZQJRRG$QGRXUV
    7KH\UHDGXOWVRUHOVHZK\OHWWKHPVWXG\DGYDQFHGVXEMHFWV"/HWWKHP
    GHFLGHZKDWVJRRGIRUWKHP
    7KH&KDQFHOORUVOLSVFRPSUHVVHGDVKHURVHWRGRWKHLQWURGXFWLRQ:KHQ
    +DULJRWXSWRWDONKHVDLG1RZWKDW\RXUHRIILFLDOO\FRXQWHG,WKDQN\RX
    IRULQYLWLQJPHDQGDQQRXQFHWKDWWKLVLVWKHHQGRIP\IRUPDODGGUHVV
    $UXVWOHRIVXUSULVH+DULVJD]HVZHSWWKHKDOODQGKHOHWWKHVLOHQFH
    EXLOG7KHQKHVDLGPLOGO\,GLVOLNHVSHDNLQJWRDQ\RQHZKRKDVQRFKRLFH
    RYHUZKHWKHUWROLVWHQ1RZ,VKDOOVLWGRZQDQGDQ\RQHZLVKLQJWROHDYHPD\
    GRVR
    +HVDW7KHDXGLWRULXPEX]]HG$IHZJRWXSWROHDYH7KHRWKHUVWXGHQWV
    ERRHGWKHP:KHQKHURVHWRVSHDNDJDLQWKH\FKHHUHG
    +HKDGQHYHUKDGDQDXGLHQFHVRRQKLVVLGH+HPDGHWKHPRVWRILW
    JLYLQJDULQJLQJWDONDERXWWKHIXWXUHRIPDWKHPDWLFV1RWRIWKHPRUWDO
    (PSLUHEXWRIEHDXWLIXOHQGXULQJPDWKHPDWLFV

    

    7KHZRPDQIURPWKH0LQLVWU\RI,QWHUORFNLQJ&XOWXUHVORRNHGGRZQKHU
    QRVHDWKLPDQGVDLG2IFRXUVHZHPXVWKDYHFRQWULEXWLRQVIURP\RXUJURXS
    +DULVKRRNKLVKHDGGLVEHOLHYLQJO\$VHQVR"
    6KHDGMXVWHGKHUIRUPDOVXLWE\ZULJJOLQJLQKLVRIILFHVJXHVWFKDLU
    7KLVLVDQDGYDQFHGSURJUDP$OOPDWKLVWVDUHFKDUJHGWRVXEPLW%RRQ
    %HKHVWV
    :HDUHFRPSOHWHO\XQTXDOLILHGWRFRPSRVH
    ,XQGHUVWDQG\RXUKHVLWDWLRQ<HWZHDWWKH0LQLVWU\IHHOWKHVHVHQVR
    V\PSKRQLHVZLOOEHMXVWWKHWKLQJQHHGHGWRHQHUJL]HDZHOODQDUWIRUP
    ZKLFKLVVKRZLQJOLWWOHSURJUHVV
    ,GRQWJHWLW
    6KHEHJUXGJLQJO\JDYHKLPDFRPSOHWHO\XQFRQYLQFLQJVWLOWHGVPLOH7KH
    ZD\ZHHQYLVLRQWKLVQHZVRUWRIVHQVRV\PSKRQ\WKHDUWLVWVWKHPDWKLVWV
    WKDWLVZLOOWUDQVPRJULI\EDVLFVWUXFWXUHVRIWKRXJKWVXFKDV(XFOLGHDQ
    FRQFHSWXDOHGLILFHVRUWUDQVILQLWHVHWWKHRU\IDEULFDWLRQV7KHVHZLOOEH
    WUDQVODWHGE\DQDUWVWUDLQHU
    :KLFKLV"
    $FRPSXWHUILOWHUZKLFKGLVWULEXWHVFRQFHSWXDOSDWWHUQVLQWRDEURDG
    VHOHFWLRQRIVHQVRU\DYHQXHV
    +DULVLJKHG,VHH7KLVZRPDQKDGSRZHUDQGKHKDGWROLVWHQWRKHU
    +LVSV\FKRKLVWRU\IXQGLQJZDVVHFXUHFRPLQJIURPWKH(PSHURUVSULYDWH
    ODUJHVV%XWWKH6WUHHOLQJGHSDUWPHQWFRXOGQRWLJQRUHWKH,PSHULDO%RRQ%RDUG
    RULWVODFNH\VVXFKDVWKHRQHEHIRUHKLP6XFKZDVERRQPDQVKLS
    )DUIURPEHLQJUHOD[HGPHGLWDWLYHJURYHVRITXLHWLQTXLU\UHVHDUFK
    XQLYHUVLWLHVZHUHLQWHQVHFRPSHWLWLYHKLJKSUHVVXUHPDUDWKRQV7KH
    PHULWRFUDWVVFKRODUVDQGVFLHQWLVWVDOLNHSXWLQORQJKRXUVKDGVWUHVV
    UHODWHGKHDOWKSUREOHPVKLJKGLYRUFHUDWHVDQGIHZRIIVSULQJ7KH\FXWXS
    WKHLUUHVXOWVLQWRELWHVL]HGFKXQNVLQSXUVXLWRIWKH/HDVW3XEOLVKDEOH
    8QLWVRWRPDJQLI\WKHLUOLVWVRISDSHUV
    7RJDLQDERRQIURPWKH,PSHULDO2IILFHVRQHGLGWKHEDVLFODERU
    )LOOLQJ2XW)RUPV+DULNQHZZHOOWKHEHZLOGHULQJPD]HRIFURVVOLQNHG
    TXHVWLRQV/LVWDQGDQDO\]HW\SHDQGWH[WXUHRIIXQGLQJ(VWLPDWHIULQJH
    EHQHILWV'HVFULEHNLQGRIODEDQGFRPSXWHUHTXLSPHQWQHHGHG FDQH[LVWLQJ
    UHVRXUFHVEHPRGLILHGWRVXLW" (OXFLGDWHSKLORVRSKLFDOVWDQFHRIWKH
    SURSRVHGZRUN
    7KH S\UDPLGRISRZHUPHDQWWKDWWKHPRVWH[SHULHQFHGVFKRODUVGLGOLWWOH
    VFKRODUVKLS,QVWHDGWKH\PDQDJHGDQGSOD\HGWKHHQGOHVVJDPHVRI
    ERRQVPDQVKLS7KH*UH\VJULPO\VDZWRLWWKDWQRER[ZHQWXQFKHFNHG$ERXWWHQ
    SHUFHQWRIERRQSHWLWLRQVUHFHLYHGIXQGVDQGWKHQDIWHUWZR\HDUVGHOD\DQG
    IRUDERXWKDOIWKHUHTXHVWHGPRQH\
    :RUVHVLQFHWKHOHDGWLPHZDVVRJUHDWWKHUHZDVDSUHPLXPRQKLWWLQJ
    WKHQDLOVTXDUHO\RQWKHKHDGZLWKHYHU\ERRQ7REHVXUHDVWXG\ZRXOGZRUN
    PRVWRILWZDVGRQHEHIRUHZULWLQJWKHERRQSHWLWLRQ7KLVLQVXUHGWKDWWKHUH
    ZHUHQRKROHVLQWKHSHWLWLRQQRXQH[SHFWHGVZHUYHVLQWKHZRUN
    7KLVPHDQWVFKRODUVKLSDQGUHVHDUFKKDGEHFRPHPRVWO\VXUSULVHIUHHDV
    ZHOO1RRQHVHHPHGWRQRWLFHWKDWWKLVUREEHGWKHPRIWKHLUFHQWUDOMR\WKH
    H[FLWHPHQWRIWKHXQH[SHFWHG
    ,ZLOOVSHDNWRP\GHSDUWPHQW2UGHUWKHPWRGRLWZRXOGKDYHEHHQ
    PRUHKRQHVW%XWRQHGLGWU\WRSUHVHUYHWKHDPHQLWLHV
    :KHQVKHKDGOHIW'RUVFDPHLQWRKLVRIILFHLPPHGLDWHO\ZLWK<XJR
    ULJKWEHKLQG,ZLOOQRWZRUNZLWKWKHVHVKHVDLGH\HVIODULQJ
    +DULVWXGLHGWZRODUJHEORFNVRIZKDWVHHPHGWREHVWRQH<HWWKH\FRXOG
    QRWEHWKDWKHDY\IRU<XJRFUDGOHGRQHLQHDFKRSHQSDOP7KHVLPV"KH
    JXHVVHG

    ,QIHUULWHFRUHV<XJRVDLGSURXGO\6WXFNGRZQLQDUDWVZDUUHQRQ
    DSODQHWQDPHG6DUN
    7KHZRUOGZLWKWKDW1HZ5HQDLVVDQFHPRYHPHQW"
    <HDKNLQGDFUD]\GHDOLQZLWKWKHP,JRWWKHVLPVWKRXJK7KH\MXVW
    FDPHLQ:RUP([SUHVV7KHZRPDQLQFKDUJHWKHUHD%XWD)\UQL[ZDQWVWRWDON
    WR\RX
    ,VDLG,GLGQWZDQWWREHLQYROYHG
    3DUWRIWKHGHDOLVVKHJHWVDIDFHWRIDFH
    +DULEOLQNHGDODUPHG6KHGFRPHDOOWKHZD\KHUH"
    1REXWWKH\UHSD\LQIRUDWLJKWEHDP6KHVVWDQGLQE\,YHURXWHG
    KHUWKURXJK-XVWSXQFKIRUWKHOLQN
    +DULKDGWKHGLVWLQFWIHHOLQJWKDWKHZDVEHLQJKXVWOHGLQWRVRPHWKLQJ
    ULVN\IDUEH\RQGWKHOLPLWVRIKLVRUGLQDU\FDXWLRQ7LJKWEHDPWLPHZDV
    H[SHQVLYHEHFDXVHWKH,PSHULDOZRUPKROHV\VWHPKDGEHHQLPSDFWHGZLWKIORZ
    IRUPLOOHQQLD8VLQJLWIRUDIDFHWRIDFHZDVVLPSO\GHFDGHQWKHIHOW,I
    WKLV)\UQL[ZRPDQZDVSD\LQJIRUJDODFWLFVFDOHVWDQGE\WLPHMXVWWRFKDW
    ZLWKDPDWKLVW
    6SDUHPHIURPWKHHQWKXVHG+DULWKRXJKW:HOODOOULJKW
    %XWD)\UQL[ZDVDWDOOKRWH\HGZRPDQZKRVPLOHGEULJKWO\DVKHULPDJH
    EORVVRPHGLQWKHRIILFH3URIHVVRU6HOGRQ, ZDVVRKDSS\WKDW\RXUVWDIIKDV
    WDNHQDQLQWHUHVWLQRXU1HZ5HQDLVVDQFH
    :HOODFWXDOO\,JDWKHULWVDERXWWKRVHVLPXODWLRQV)RURQFHKH
    ZDVJUDWHIXOIRUWKHWZRVHFRQGGHOD\LQWUDQVPLVVLRQ7KHELJJHVWZRUPKROH
    PRXWKZDVDOLJKWVHFRQGIURP7UDQWRUDQGDSSDUHQWO\6DUNKDGDERXWWKHVDPH
    2IFRXUVH:HIRXQGWUXO\DQFLHQWDUFKLYHV2XUSURJUHVVLYHPRYHPHQW
    KHUHLVNQRFNLQJRYHUWKHROGEDUULHUV\RXOOILQG
    ,KRSHWKHUHVHDUFKZLOOSURYHLQWHUHVWLQJ+DULVDLGQHXWUDOO\+RZ
    GLG<XJRJHWKLPLQWRWKLV"
    :HUHWXUQLQJXSWKLQJVWKDWZLOORSHQ\RXUH\HV'U6HOGRQ6KH
    WXUQHGDQGJHVWXUHGDWWKHVFHQHEHKLQGKHUDODUJHZDUUHQFUDPPHGZLWK
    DQFLHQWFHUDPRVWRUDJHUDFNV:HUHKRSLQJWREORZWKHOLGRIIWKHZKROH
    TXHVWLRQRISUH(PSLUHRULJLQVWKH(DUWKOHJHQGWKHZRUNV
    ,DK,ZLOOEHYHU\KDSS\WRVHHZKDWUHVXOWV
    <RXYHJRWWRFRPHDQGVHHLWIRU\RXUVHOI$PDWKLVWOLNH\RXZLOOEH
    LPSUHVVHG2XU5HQDLVVDQFHLVMXVWWKHVRUWRIIRUZDUGORRNLQJHQWHUSULVHWKDW
    \RXQJYLJRURXVSODQHWVQHHG'RVD\\RXOOSD\XVDYLVLWDVWDWHYLVLWZH
    KRSH
    $SSDUHQWO\WKHZRPDQZDQWHGWRLQYHVWLQDIXWXUH)LUVW0LQLVWHU,W
    WRRNKLPPRUHXQEHDUDEOHPLQXWHVWRJHWDZD\IURPKHU+HJORZHUHGDW<XJR
    ZKHQDWODVWKHULPDJHZLOWHGLQWKHDLU
    +H\,JRWXVDJRRGGHDOSURYLGLQJVKHJRWWRGRDOLOVHOOMRERQ
    \RX<XJRVDLGVSUHDGLQJKLVKDQGV
    $WFRQVLGHUDEOHXQGHUWKHWDEOHFRVW,KRSH"+DULDVNHGJHWWLQJXS
    &DUHIXOO\KHSXWDKDQGRQRQHFXEHDQGIRXQGLWVXUSULVLQJO\FRRO:LWKLQLWV
    VKDGRZ\LQWHULRUKHFRXOGVHHODE\ULQWKVRIODWWLFHVDQGZLQGLQJULEERQVRI
    UHIUDFWHGOLJKWOLNHWLQ\KLJKZD\VWKURXJKDVRPEHUFLW\
    6XUH<XJRVDLGZLWKFDVXDODVVXUDQFH*RWVRPH'DKOLWHVWRDK
    PDVVDJHWKHPDWWHU
    +DULFKXFNOHG,GRQWWKLQN,VKRXOGKHDUDERXWLW
    $V)LUVW0LQLVWHU\RXPXVWQRW'RUVVDLG
    ,DPQRW)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    <RXFRXOGEHDQGVRRQ7KLVVLPXODWLRQPDWWHULVWRRULVN\$QG\RX
    HYHQVSRNHWRWKH6DUNVRXUFH,ZLOOQRWZRUNRQRUZLWKWKHP
    <XJRVDLGPLOGO\1RERG\VDVNLQ\RXWR
    +DULUXEEHGWKHFRROVOLFNVXUIDFHRIDIHUULWHEORFNKHIWHGLWTXLWH
    OLJKWDQGWRRNWKHWZRIURP<XJR+HSXWWKHPRQKLVGHVN+RZROG"
    <XJRVDLG6DUNVD\VWKH\GXQQREXWPXVWEHDWOHDVW

    'RUVPRYHGVXGGHQO\6KH\DQNHGXSWKHEORFNVRQHLQHDFKKDQGWXUQHG
    WRWKHQHDUHVWZDOODQGVPDVKHGWKHPWRJHWKHU7KHFUDVKZDVGHDIHQLQJ
    &KXQNVRIIHUULWHVPDFNHGDJDLQVWWKHZDOO*UDLQVRIGHEULVVSDWWHUHG+DULV
    IDFH
    'RUVKDGDEVRUEHGWKHH[SORVLRQ7KHVWRUHGHQHUJ\LQWKHEORFNVKDG
    HUXSWHGDVWKHODWWLFHFUDFNHG
    ,QWKHVXGGHQVLOHQFHDIWHUZDUG'RUVVWRRGDGDPDQWO\ULJLGKDQGV
    FRYHUHGZLWKJUDLQ\GXVW+HUKDQGVZHUHEOHHGLQJDQGVKHKDGDFXWRQKHU
    OHIWFKHHN6KHJD]HGVWUDLJKWDWKLP,DPFKDUJHGZLWK\RXUVDIHW\
    <XJRGUDZOHG6XUHDIXQQ\ZD\WRVKRZLW
    ,KDGWRSURWHFW\RXIURPDSRWHQWLDOO\
    %\GHVWUR\LQJDQDQFLHQWDUWLIDFW"+DULGHPDQGHG
    ,VPRWKHUHGQHDUO\DOOWKHHUXSWLRQPLQLPL]LQJ\RXUULVN%XW\HV,
    GHHP WKLV6DUNLQYROYHPHQWDV
    ,NQRZ,NQRZ+DULUDLVHGKLVKDQGVSDOPVWRZDUGKHUUHFDOOLQJ
    7KHQLJKWEHIRUHKHKDGFRPHKRPHIURPKLVUDWKHUZHOOUHFHLYHGVSHHFK
    WRILQG'RUVPRRG\DQGZLWKGUDZQ7KHLUEHGKDGEHHQDUDWKHUFKLOO\
    EDWWOHJURXQGWRRWKRXJKVKHZRXOGQRWFRPHRXWDQGVD\ZKDWKDGLUNHGKHU
    VR:LQQLQJWKURXJKZLWKGUDZDO+DULKDGRQFHWHUPHGLW%XWKHKDGQRLGHD
    VKHIHOWWKLVGHHSO\
    0DUULDJHLVDYR\DJHRIGLVFRYHU\WKDWQHYHUHQGVKHWKRXJKWUXHIXOO\
    ,PDNHGHFLVLRQVDERXWULVNKHVDLGWRKHUH\HLQJWKHUXEEOHLQKLV
    RIILFH<RXZLOOREH\WKHPXQOHVVWKHUHLVDQREYLRXVSK\VLFDOGDQJHU
    8QGHUVWDQG"
    ,PXVWXVHP\MXGJPHQW
    1R,QYROYHPHQWZLWKWKHVH6DUNLDQVLPXODWLRQVPD\WHDFKXVDERXW
    VKDGRZ\DQFLHQWWLPHV7KDWFRXOGDIIHFWSV\FKRKLVWRU\+HZRQGHUHGLIVKH
    ZHUHFDUU\LQJRXWDQRUGHUIURP2OLYDZ:K\ZRXOGWKHURERWVFDUHVRVWURQJO\"
    :KHQ\RXDUHSODLQO\LPSHULOLQJ
    <RXPXVWOHDYHSODQQLQJDQGSV\FKRKLVWRU\WRPH
    6KHEDWWHGKHUH\HODVKHVUDSLGO\SXUVHGKHUOLSVRSHQHGKHU
    PRXWKDQGVDLGQRWKLQJ)LQDOO\VKHQRGGHG+DULOHWRXWDVLJK
    7KHQKLVVHFUHWDU\UXVKHGLQIROORZHGE\WKH6SHFLDOVDQGWKHVFHQH
    GLVVROYHGLQWRDFKDRVRIH[SODQDWLRQV+HORRNHGWKH6SHFLDOVFDSWDLQ
    VWUDLJKWLQWKHIDFHDQGVDLGWKDWWKHIHUULWHFRUHVKDGVRPHKRZIDOOHQLQWR
    HDFKRWKHUDQGDSSDUHQWO\VWUXFNVRPHZHDNIUDFWXUHSRLQW
    7KH\ZHUHKHH[SODLQHGPDNLQJLWXSDVKHZHQWDORQJZLWKDYRLFHRI
    SURIHVVRULDODXWKRULW\KHKDGPDVWHUHGORQJDJRIUDJLOHVWUXFWXUHVZKLFKXVHG
    WHQVLRQWRVWDELOL]HWKHPVHOYHVKROGLQJLQYDVWVWRUHVRIPLFURVFRSLF
    LQIRUPDWLRQ
    7RKLVUHOLHIWKHFDSWDLQMXVWVFUHZHGXSKLVIDFHORRNHGDURXQGDWWKH
    PHVVDQGVDLG,VKRXOGQHYHUKDYHOHWROGWHFKOLNHWKLVLQKHUH
    1RW\RXUIDXOW+DULUHDVVXUHGKLP,WVDOOPLQH
    7KHUHZRXOGKDYHEHHQPRUHSUHWHQGLQJWRGREXWDPRPHQWODWHUKLVKROR
    UDQJZLWKDUHFHSWLRQ+HJOLPSVHG&OHRQVSHUVRQDORIILFHUEXWEHIRUHWKH
    ZRPDQFRXOGVSHDNWKHVFHQHGLVVROYHG+HVODSSHGKLVILOWHUIDFHFRPPDQGDV
    &OHRQVLPDJHFRDOHVFHGLQWKHDLURXWRIDFRWWRQ\IRJ
    ,KDYHVRPHEDGQHZVWKH(PSHURUVDLGZLWKRXWDQ\JUHHWLQJ
    $KVRUU\WRKHDUWKDW+DULVDLGODPHO\
    %HORZ&OHRQVYLVLRQKHFDOOHGXSDVXLWHRIERG\ODQJXDJHSRVWXUHVDQG
    KRSHGWKH\ZRXOGFRYHUWKHIHUULWHGXVWFOLQJLQJWRKLVWXQLF7KHUHGIUDPH
    WKDWVWLWFKHGDURXQGWKHKRORWROGKLPWKDWDVXLWDEO\GLJQLILHGIDFHZRXOGJR
    RXWNH\HGZLWKKLVOLSPRYHPHQWV
    7KH+LJK&RXQFLOLVVWXFNRQWKLVUHSUHVHQWDWLRQLVVXH&OHRQFKHZHG
    DWKLVOLSLQLUULWDWLRQ8QWLOWKH\UHVROYHWKDWWKH)LUVW0LQLVWHUVKLS
    ZLOOEHVHWDVLGH
    ,VHH7KHUHSUHVHQWDWLRQSUREOHP"

    &OHRQEOLQNHGZLWKVXUSULVH<RXKDYHQWEHHQIROORZLQJLW"
    7KHUHLVPXFKWRGRDW6WUHHOLQJ
    &OHRQZDYHGDLULO\2IFRXUVHJHWWLQJUHDG\IRUWKHPRYH:HOO
    QRWKLQJZLOOKDSSHQLPPHGLDWHO\VR\RXFDQUHOD[7KH'DKOLWHVKDYHORJMDPPHG
    WKH*DODFWLFORZ&RXQFLO7KH\ZDQWDELJJHUYRLFHLQ7UDQWRUDQGLQWKH
    ZKROHGDPQHGVSLUDO7KDW/DPXUNKDVVLGHGDJDLQVWWKHPLQWKH+LJK&RXQFLO
    1RERG\VEXGJLQJ
    ,VHH
    6RZHOOKDYHWRZDLWEHIRUHWKH+LJK&RXQFLOFDQDFW3URFHGXUDO
    PDWWHUVRIUHSUHVHQWDWLRQWDNHSUHFHGHQWRYHUHYHQPLQLVWHUVKLSV
    2IFRXUVH
    'DPQ&RGHV &OHRQHUXSWHG,VKRXOGEHDEOHWRKDYHZKR,ZDQW
    ,TXLWHDJUHH%XWQRWPH+DULWKRXJKW
    :HOOWKRXJKW\RXGOLNHWRKHDULWIURPPH
    ,GRDSSUHFLDWHWKDWVLUH
    ,YHJRWVRPHWKLQJVWRGLVFXVVWKDWSV\FKRKLVWRU\HVSHFLDOO\,P
    EXV\ EXWVRRQ
    9HU\JRRGVLUH
    &OHRQZLQNHGDZD\ZLWKRXWVD\LQJJRRGE\H
    +DULEUHDWKHGDVLJKRIUHOLHI,PIUHHKHVKRXWHGKDSSLO\WKURZLQJ
    KLVKDQGVXS
    7KH6SHFLDOVVWDUHGDWKLPRGGO\+DULQRWLFHGDJDLQKLVGHVNDQGILOHV
    DQGZDOOVDOO VSDWWHUHGZLWKEODFNJULW+LVRIILFHVWLOOORRNHGOLNH
    SDUDGLVHWRKLPFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHOX[XULDQWVQDUHRIWKHSDODFH
    

    7KHWULSLWOOEHZRUWKLWMXVWWRJHWRXWRI6WUHHOLQJ<XJRVDLG
    7KH\HQWHUHGWKHJUDYVWDWLRQZLWKWKHLQHYLWDEOH6SHFLDOVWU\LQJWR
    FDVXDOO\VWUROODORQJVLGH7R+DULVH\HWKH\ZHUHDVLQFRQVSLFXRXVDVVSLGHUV
    RQDGLQQHUSODWH
    7UXHHQRXJK+DULVDLG$W6WUHHOLQJ+LJK&RXQFLOPHPEHUVFRXOG
    VROLFLWKLPSUHVVXUHJURXSVFRXOGSHQHWUDWHWKHPDNHVKLIWSULYDF\RIWKH 0DWK
    'HSDUWPHQWDQGRIFRXUVHWKH(PSHURUFRXOGEORVVRPLQWKHDLUDWDQ\WLPH2Q
    WKHPRYHKHZDVVDIH
    *RRGFRQQHFWLRQFRPLQXSLQWZRSRLQWVL[PLQXWHV<XJRFRQVXOWHGKLV
    UHWLQDOZULWHUE\ORRNLQJWRWKHIDUOHIW+DULKDGQHYHUOLNHGWKHGHYLFHV
    EXWWKH\ZHUHDFRQYHQLHQWZD\RIUHDGLQJLQWKLVFDVHWKHJUDYVFKHGXOH
    ZKLOHNHHSLQJERWKKDQGVIUHH<XJRZDVWRWLQJWZREDJV+DULKDGRIIHUHGWR
    KHOSEXW<XJRVDLGWKH\ZHUHIDPLO\MHZHOVDQGQHHGHGFDUH
    :LWKRXWEUHDNLQJVWULGHWKH\SDVVHGWKURXJKDQRSWLFDOUHDGHUZKLFK
    FRQVXOWHGVHDWLQJELOOHGWKHLUDFFRXQWVDQGQRWLILHGWKHDXWRSURJUDPRIWKH
    LQFUHDVHGPDVVORDG+DULZDVDELWGLVWUDFWHGE\VRPHIUHHIORDWLQJPDWK
    LGHDVDQGVRWKHLUGURSVWDUWOHGKLP
    2RSVKHVDLGFOXWFKLQJDW KLVDUPUHVWV)DOOLQJZDVWKHRQHVLJQDO
    WKDWFRXOGLQWHUUXSWHYHQWKHGHHSHVWRIPHGLWDWLRQV+HZRQGHUHGKRZIDUEDFN
    WKDWDODUPKDGHYROYHGDQGWKHQSDLGDWWHQWLRQWR<XJRDJDLQZKRZDV
    HQWKXVLDVWLFDOO\GHVFULELQJWKH'DKOLWHFRPPXQLW\ZKHUHWKH\ZRXOGKDYHOXQFK
    <RXVWLOOZRQGHULQDERXWWKDWSROLWLFDOVWXII"
    7KHUHSUHVHQWDWLRQTXHVWLRQ",GRQWFDUHDERXWWKHLQILJKWLQJ
    IDFWLRQVDQGVRRQ0DWKHPDWLFDOO\WKRXJKLWVDSX]]OH
    6HHPVWRPHLWVSUHWW\FOHDU <XJRVDLGZLWKDVOLJKWWKRXJK
    UHVSHFWIXOHGJHLQKLVYRLFH'DKOLWHVEHHQJHWWLQWKHVKRUWHQGIRUWRR
    ORQJ
    %HFDXVHWKH\KDYHRQO\RQH6HFWRUVYRWHV"
    5LJKWDQGWKHUHDUHIRXUKXQGUHGPLOOLRQRIXVLQ'DKODORQH
    $QGPRUHHOVHZKHUH

    'DPQULJKW$YHUDJHGRYHU7UDQWRUD'DKOLWHKDVRQO\SRLQWVL[HLJKW
    DVPXFKUHSUHVHQWDWLRQDVWKHRWKHUV
    $QGWKURXJKRXWWKH*DOD[\
    6DPHGDPQWKLQJ:HJRWRXU=RQHVXUHEXWH[FHSWLQWKH*DODFWLF/RZ
    &RXQFLOZHUHER[HGLQ
    <XJRKDGFKDQJHGIURPWKHFKDWWHULQJIULHQGRXWRQDODUNWRVREHUIDFHG
    DQGVFRZOLQJ+DULGLGQWZDQWWKHWULSWRWXUQLQWRDQDUJXPHQW6WDWLVWLFV
    UHTXLUHFDUH<XJR5HPHPEHUWKHFODVVLFMRNHDERXWWKUHHVWDWLVWLFLDQVZKR
    WRRNXSKXQWLQJGXFNV
    :KLFKDUH"
    $JDPHELUGNQRZQRQVRPHZRUOGV7KHILUVWVKRWDPHWHUKLJKWKH
    VHFRQGDPHWHUORZ:KHQWKLVKDSSHQHGWKHWKLUGVWDWLVWLFLDQFULHG:HJRW
    LW
    <XJRODXJKHGDELWGXWLIXOO\+DULZDVWU\LQJWRIROORZ'RUVDGYLFH
    DERXWKDQGOLQJSHRSOHXVLQJKLVKXPRUPRUHDQGORJLFOHVV7KHLQFLGHQWZLWK
    /DPXUNKDGUHERXQGHGLQ+DULVIDYRUDPRQJWKHPHGLDDQGHYHQWKH+LJK
    &RXQFLOWKH(PSHURUKDGVDLG
    'RUVKHUVHOIWKRXJKVHHPHGVLQJXODUO\LPPXQHWRERWKODXJKVDQGORJLF
    WKHLQFLGHQWZLWKWKHIHUULWHFRUHVKDGSXWDVWUDLQLQWKHLUUHODWLRQVKLS
    +DULUHDOL]HGQRZWKDWWKLVWRRZDVZK\KHKDGJUHHWHG<XJRVVXJJHVWLRQRI
    DGD\DZD\IURP6WUHHOLQJ'RUVKDGWZRFODVVHVWRWHDFKDQGFRXOGQWJR6KH
    KDGJUXPEOHGEXWFRQFHGHGWKDWWKH6SHFLDOVFRXOGSUREDEO\FRYHUKLPZHOO
    HQRXJK$VORQJDVKHGLGQRWKLQJIRROLVK
    <XJRSHUVLVWHG2ND\EXWWKHFRXUWVDUHVWDFNHGDJDLQVWXVWRR
    'DKOLVWKHODUJHVW6HFWRUQRZ<RXZLOOJHW\RXUMXGJHVKLSVLQWLPH
    7LPHZHGRQWKDYH:HUHJHWWLQJVKXWRXWE\ EORFV
    +DULGHHSO\GLVOLNHGWKHXVXDOFLUFXODUORJLFRISROLWLFDOJULSLQJVR
    KHWULHGWRDSSHDOWR<XJRVPDWKLVWVLGH$OOMXGJLQJERGLHVDUHYXOQHUDEOH
    WREORFFRQWUROP\IULHQG6XSSRVHDFRXUWKDGHOHYHQMXGJHV7KHQDFRKHVLYH
    JURXSRIVL[FRXOGGHFLGHHYHU\UXOLQJ7KH\FRXOGPHHWVHFUHWO\DQGDJUHHWR
    EHERXQGE\ZKDWDPDMRULW\RIWKHPWKLQNVWKHQYRWHDVDEORFLQWKHIXOO
    HOHYHQ
    <XJRVPRXWKWZLVWHGZLWKLUULWDWLRQ7KH+LJK7ULEXQDOVHOHYHQ
    WKDWV\RXUSRLQWULJKW"
    ,WVDJHQHUDOSULQFLSOH(YHQVPDOOHUVFKHPHVFRXOGZRUNWRR6XSSRVH
    IRXURIWKH+LJK7ULEXQDOPHWVHFUHWO\DQGDJUHHGWREHERXQGE\WKHLURZQ
    EDOORW7KHQWKH\GYRWHDVDEORFDPRQJWKHRULJLQDOFDEDORIVL[7KHQIRXU
    ZRXOGGHWHUPLQHWKHRXWFRPHRIDOOHOHYHQ
    'DPQDOOLWVZRUVHWKDQ,WKRXJKW<XJRVDLG
    0\SRLQWLVWKDWDQ\ILQLWHUHSUHVHQWDWLRQFDQEHFRUUXSWHG,WVD
    JHQHUDOWKHRUHPDERXWWKHPHWKRG
    <XJRQRGGHGDQGWKHQWR+DULVGLVPD\ODXQFKHGLQWRUHFLWLQJWKHZRHV
    DQGKXPLOLDWLRQVYLVLWHG XSRQ'DKOLWHVDWWKHKDQGVRIWKHUXOLQJPDMRULWLHV
    LQWKH7ULEXQDOWKH&RXQFLOVERWK+LJKDQG/RZWKH'LNWDW'LUHFWRU\
    7KHHQGOHVVEXV\QHVVRIUXOLQJ:KDWDERUH
    +DULUHDOL]HGWKDWKLVVW\OHRIWKRXJKWZDVDIDUFU\IURPWKHIHYHUHG
    FDOFXODWLRQVRI<XJRDQGIXUWKHUVWLOOIURPWKHZLO\OLNHVRI/DPXUN+RZ
    FRXOGKHKRSHWRVXUYLYHDVD)LUVW0LQLVWHU":K\FRXOGQWWKH(PSHURUVHH
    WKDW"
    +HQRGGHGSXWRQKLVPDVNRIWKRXJKWIXOOLVWHQLQJDQGOHWWKHZDOO
    GLVSOD\VVRRWKHKLP7KH\ZHUHVWLOOSOXQJLQJGRZQWKHORQJF\FORLGDOFXUYHRI
    WKHJUDYGURS
    7KLVWLPHWKHQDPHZDVDSW0RVWORQJGLVWDQFHWUDYHORQ7UDQWRUZDVLQ
    IDFWXQGHU7UDQWRUDORQJDFXUYHZKLFKOHWWKHLUFDUSOXQJHGRZQXQGHU
    JUDYLW\DORQHVXVSHQGHGRQPDJQHWLFILHOGVDEDUHILQJHUVZLGWKIURPWKH
    WXEHZDOOV)DOOLQJWKURXJKGDUNYDFXXPWKHUHZHUHQRZLQGRZV,QVWHDGWKH
    ZDOOVTXLHWHGDQ\IHDUVRIIDOOLQJ

    0DWXUHWHFKQRORJ\ZDVGLVFUHHWVLPSOHHDV\TXLHWVLQXRXVO\
    FODVVLFDOHYHQIULHQGO\ZKLOHLWVXVHUHPDLQHGDVREYLRXVDVDKDPPHULWV
    HIIHFWVDVHDV\DVD'%RWKLWDQGLWVXVHUKDGHGXFDWHGHDFKRWKHU
    $IRUHVWVOLGE\DOODURXQGKLPDQG<XJR0DQ\RQ7UDQWRUOLYHGDPRQJ
    WUHHVDQGURFNVDQGFORXGVDVKXPDQVRQFHKDG7KHHIIHFWVZHUHQRWUHDOEXW
    WKH\GLGQWQHHGWREH:HDUHWKHZLOGQRZ+DULWKRXJKW+XPDQVVKDSHG
    7UDQWRUVODE\ULQWKVWRTXLHWWKHLUGHHSVHWQHHGVVRWKHPLQGVH\HIHOW
    LWVHOIIOLWWLQJWKURXJKDSDUN7HFKQRORJ\DSSHDUHGRQO\ZKHQFDOOHGIRUWK
    OLNHPDJLFDOVSLULWV
    6D\PLQGLI,NLOOWKLV"<XJRVTXHVWLRQEURNHWKURXJKKLVUHYHULH
    7KHWUHHV"
    <HDKWKHRSHQ\NQRZ
    +DULQRGGHGDQG<XJRWKXPEHGLQDYLHZRIDPDOOZLWKQRJUHDWGLVWDQFHV
    YLVLEOH0DQ\7UDQWRULDQVEHFDPHDQ[LRXVLQELJVSDFHVRUHYHQQHDULPDJHVRI
    WKHP
    7KH\KDGOHYHOHGRXWDQGVRRQEHJDQWRULVH+DULIHOWSUHVVHGEDFNLQWR
    KLVFKDLUZKLFKFRPSHQVDWHGGHIWO\7KH\ZHUHPRYLQJDWKLJKYHORFLW\KH
    NQHZEXWWKHUHZDVQRVLJQRILW6OLJKWSXOVHVRIWKHPDJQHWLFWKURDWDGGHG
    LQFUHPHQWVRIYHORFLW\DVWKH\ URVHPDNLQJXSIRUWKHVOLJKWORVVHV
    2WKHUZLVHWKHHQWLUHWULSWRRNQRHQHUJ\JUDYLW\JLYLQJDQGWKHQWDNLQJ
    DZD\
    :KHQWKH\HPHUJHGLQWKH&DUPRQGLDQ6HFWRUKLV6SHFLDOVGUHZLQFORVH
    7KLVZDVQRHOLWHXQLYHUVLW\VHWWLQJ)HZEXLOGLQJVKHUHFRXOGEHVHHQDV
    H[WHULRUVVRGHVLJQIRFXVHGRQLQWHULRUVSHFWDFOHWKUXVWLQJVORSHVDLU\
    WUDQVHSWVVRDULQJWUXQNVRIZRUNHGPHWDODQGPXVFXODUILEHU%XWDPLGWKLV
    VHUHQHDUFKLWHFWXUHPLOOLQJFURZGVMRVWOHGDQGIUHWWHGODSSLQJOLNHDQDQJU\
    WLGH
    $FURVVDQRYHUKHDGELNHSDGDVWHDG\VWUHDPRIF\FOLVWVKDXOHGWRZFDUV
    -DPPLQJWKHLUQDUURZED\VZHUHEXON\DSSOLDQFHVJOLVWHQLQJVLGHVRIPHDW
    ER[HVDQGOXPS\JRRGVDOOERXQGIRUQHDUE\FXVWRPHUV5HVWDXUDQWVZHUH
    OLWWOHPRUHWKDQKRWSODWHVVXUURXQGHGZLWKWLQ\WDEOHVDQGFKDLUVDOO
    VTXHH]HGLQWRWKHZDONZD\V%DUEHUVFRQGXFWHGEXVLQHVVLQWKHWKRURXJKIDUH
    ZRUNLQJRQHHQGRIWKHFXVWRPHUZKLOHEHJJDUVPDVVDJHGWKHIHHWIRUDFRLQ
    6HHPVEXV\+DULVDLGGLSORPDWLFDOO\DVKHFDXJKWWKHWDQJRI
    'DKOLWHFRRNLQJ
    <HDKGRQFKDORYHLW"
    %HJJDUVDQGVWUHHWYHQGRUVZHUHPDGHLOOHJDOE\WKHODVW(PSHURU,
    WKRXJKW
    5LJKW+HJULQQHG'RQWZRUNZLWK'DKOLWHV:HYHPRYHGSOHQW\
    SHRSOHLQWRWKLV6HFWRU&PRQ,ZDQWVRPHOXQFK
    ,WZDVHDUO\EXWWKH\DWHLQDVWDQGXSUHVWDXUDQWGUDZQLQE\WKH
    RGRUV+DULWULHGDERPEHUZKLFKZULJJOHGLQWRKLVPRXWKWKHQH[SORGHG
    LQWRDVPRN\GDUNWDVWHKHFRXOGQRWLGHQWLI\ILQDOO\IDGLQJLQWRD
    ELWWHUVZHHWDIWHUWDVWH+LV6SHFLDOVORRNHGTXLWHXQHDV\VWDQGLQJDURXQGLQD
    FURZGHGEXV\KXEEXE7KH\ZHUHDFFXVWRPHGWRPRUHUHJDOVXUURXQGLQJV
    7KLQJVUHUHDOO\ERRPLQKHUH<XJRREVHUYHG+LVPDQQHUVKDGUHYHUWHG
    WRKLVODERULQJGD\VDQGKHVSRNHZLWKKLVPRXWKKDOIIXOO
    'DKOLWHVKDYHDJLIWIRUH[SDQVLRQ+DULVDLGGLSORPDWLFDOO\7KHLU
    KLJKELUWKUDWHSXVKHGWKHPLQWRRWKHU6HFWRUVZKHUHWKHLUFRQQHFWLRQVWR
    'DKOEURXJKWQHZLQYHVWPHQW+DULOLNHGWKHLUUHVWOHVVHQHUJ\LWUHPLQGHGKLP
    RI+HOLFRQVIHZFLWLHV
    +HKDGEHHQPRGHOLQJDOORI7UDQWRUWU\LQJWRXVHLWDVDVKUXQNHQ
    YHUVLRQRIWKH(PSLUH0XFKRIKLVSURJUHVVKDGFRPHIURPXQOHDUQLQJ
    FRQYHQWLRQDOZLVGRP0RVWHFRQRPLVWVVDZPRQH\DVVLPSOHRZQHUVKLSDEDVLF
    OLQHDUSRZHUUHODWLRQVKLS%XWLWZDVDIOXLG+DULIRXQGVOLSSHU\DQGTXLFN
    DOZD\VIORZLQJIURPRQHKDQGWRWKHQH[WDVLWJUHDVHGWKHPRPHQWXPRIFKDQJH
    ,PSHULDODQDO\VWVKDGPLVWDNHQDYDU\LQJIOX[IRUDVWDWLFFRXQWHU

    7KH\ILQLVKHGDQG<XJRXUJHGKLPLQWRDJURXQGSRG7KH\IROORZHGD
    FRPSOLFDWHGSDWKDOLYHZLWKQRLVHDQG VPHOOVDQGYLJRU+HUHRUGHUO\WUDIILF
    GLVLQWHJUDWHG,QVWHDGRIPDNLQJDQHQWLUHOD\HURQHZD\ORFDOVWUHHWV
    LQWHUVHFWHGDWDQJOHVDFXWHDQGREOLTXHVHOGRPUHFWDQJXODU<XJRVHHPHGWR
    UHJDUGWUDIILFLQWHUVHFWLRQVDVUXGHLQWHUUXSWLRQV
    7KH\VSHGE\EXLOGLQJVDWFORVHUDQJHVWRSSHGDQGJRWRXWIRUDZDON
    WRDVOLGHZD\7KH6SHFLDOVZHUHULJKWEHKLQGDQGZLWKRXWDQ\WUDQVLWLRQ+DUL
    IRXQGKLPVHOILQWKHPLGGOHRIFKDRV6PRNHHQYHORSHGWKHPDQGWKHDFULG
    VWHQFKPDGHKLPDOPRVWYRPLW
    7KH6SHFLDOVFDSWDLQVKRXWHGWRKLP6WD\GRZQ7KHQWKHPDQVKRXWHG
    WRKLVPHQWRDUPZLWKDQDPRUSKLQH7KH\DOOEULVWOHGZLWKZHDSRQV
    6PRNHSDOHGWKHRYHUKHDGSKRVSKRUV7KURXJKWKHPXJJ\KD]H+DULVDZD
    VROLGZDOORISHRSOHKDPPHULQJWRZDUGWKHP7KH\FDPHRXWRIVLGHDOOH\VDQG
    GRRUZD\VDQGDOOVHHPHGWREHDUGRZQRQKLP7KH6SHFLDOVILUHGDYROOH\LQWR
    WKHPDVV6RPHZHQWGRZQ7KHFDSWDLQWKUHZDFDQLVWHUDQGJDVEORVVRPHG
    IDUWKHUDZD\+HKDGMXGJHGLWH[SHUWO\DLUFLUFXODWLRQFDUULHGWKHIXPHV
    LQWRWKHPREQRWWRZDUG+DUL
    %XWDQDPRUSKLQHZDVQWJRLQJWRVWRSWKHP7ZRZRPHQUXVKHGE\+DUL
    FDUU\LQJFREEOHVWRQHVULSSHGIURPWKHVWUHHW$WKLUGMDEEHGDW+DULZLWKD
    NQLIHDQGWKHFDSWDLQVKRWKHUZLWKDGDUW7KHQPRUH'DKOLWHVUXVKHGDWWKH
    6SHFLDOVDQG+DULFDXJKWZKDWWKH\ZHUHVKRXWLQJLQFRKHUHQWUDJHDJDLQVW
    WLNWRNV
    7KHLGHDVHHPHGVRXQOLNHO\WRKLPDWILUVWKHWKRXJKWKHFRXOGQRWKDYH
    KHDUGULJKWO\7KDWGHIOHFWHGKLVDWWHQWLRQDQGZKHQKHORRNHGEDFNWRZDUG
    WKHVWUHDPLQJFURZGWKHFDSWDLQZDVGRZQDQGDPDQZDVDGYDQFLQJKROGLQJD
    NQLIH
    :KDWDQ\RIWKLVKDGWRGRZLWKWLNWRNVZDVP\VWHULRXVEXW+DULGLGQRW
    KDYHWLPHWRGRDQ\WKLQJH[FHSWVWHSWRWKHVLGHDQGNLFNWKHPDQVTXDUHO\LQ
    WKHNQHH
    $ERWWOHERXQFHGSDLQIXOO\RIIKLVVKRXOGHUDQGVPDVKHGRQWKHZDONZD\
    $PDQZKLUOHGDFKDLQDURXQGDQGDURXQGDQGWKHQWRZDUG+DULVKHDG'XFN,W
    ZKLVWOHGE\DQG+DULGRYHDWWKHPDQWDFNOLQJKLPVROLGO\7KH\ZHQWGRZQ
    ZLWKWZRRWKHUVLQDVZHDULQJSXQFKLQJPDVV+DULWRRNDVOXJLQWKHJXW
    +HUROOHGRYHUDQGJDVSHGIRUDLUDQGFOHDUO\RQO\DIHZIHHWDZD\VDZ
    DPDQNLOODQRWKHUZLWKDORQJFXUYHGNQLIH
    -DEVODVKMDE,WKDSSHQHGVLOHQWO\OLNHDGUHDP+DULJDVSHG
    VKDNHQKLVZRUOGLQVORZPRWLRQ+HVKRXOGEHUHVSRQGLQJEROGO\KH NQHZ
    WKDW%XWLWZDVVRRYHUZKHOPLQJ
    DQGWKHQKHZDVVWDQGLQJZLWKQRPHPRU\RIJHWWLQJWKHUHZUHVWOLQJ
    ZLWKDPDQZKRKDGQRWERWKHUHGZLWKEDWKLQJIRUTXLWHVRPHZKLOH
    7KHQWKHPDQZDVJRQHDEUXSWO\\DQNHGDZD\E\WKHVHHWKHRIWKHFURZG
    $QRWKHUVXGGHQMXPSDQG6SHFLDOVZHUHDOODURXQGKLP%RGLHVVSUDZOHG
    OLIHOHVVRQWKHZDONZD\2WKHUVKHOGWKHLUEORRG\KHDGV6KRXWVWKXPSV
    +HGLGQRWKDYHWLPHWRILJXUHRXWZKDWZHDSRQKDGGRQHWKDWWRWKHP
    EHIRUHWKH6SHFLDOVZHUHZKLVNLQJKLPDQG<XJRDORQJDQGWKHZKROHLQFLGHQW
    IOHGLQWRREVFXULW\OLNHDSURJUDPJOLPSVHGDQGLPSDWLHQWO\SDVVHGE\
    7KHFDSWDLQZDQWHGWRUHWXUQWR6WUHHOLQJ(YHQEHWWHUWKHSDODFH
    7KLVZDVQWDERXWXV+DULVDLGDVWKH\WRRNDVOLGHZD\
    &DQWEHVXUHRIWKDWVLU
    

    +DULEDWWHGDZD\DOOVXJJHVWLRQVWKDWWKH\GLVFRQWLQXHWKHLUMRXUQH\
    7KHLQFLGHQWKDGDSSDUHQWO\EHJXQZKHQVRPHWLNWRNVPDOIHG
    6RPHERG\DFFXVHG'DKOLWHVRIFDXVLQJLW<XJRUHODWHG6RRXUSHRSOH
    VWRRGXSIRUWKHPVHOYHVDQGZHOOWKLQJVJRWRXWRIKDQG
    (YHU\RQHQHDUWKHPZDVDOLYHZLWKH[FLWHPHQWIDFHVJORZLQJH\HVZKLWH

    DQGGDUWLQJ+HWKRXJKWVXGGHQO\RIKLVIDWKHUVZU\VD\LQJ1HYHU
    XQGHUHVWLPDWHWKHSRZHURIERUHGRP
    ,QKXPDQDIIDLUVVSLULWHGDFWLRQUHOLHYHGGU\WHGLXP+HUHPHPEHUHG
    VHHLQJWZRZRPHQSXPPHOD6SRRNVODPPLQJDZD\DWWKHVSLQGO\EOHDFKHGZKLWH
    PDQDVWKRXJKKHZHUHQRPRUHWKDQDUHVSRQVLYHH[HUFLVHPDFKLQH$VLPSOH
    SKRELDDJDLQVWVXQOLJKWPHDQWWKDWKHZDVRIWKHKDWHG2WKHUDQGWKXVIDLU
    JDPH
    0XUGHUZDVDSULPDOXUJH(YHQWKHPRVWFLYLOL]HGIHOWWHPSWHGE\LWLQ
    PRPHQWVRIUDJH%XWQHDUO\DOOUHVLVWHGDQGZHUHEHWWHUIRUWKHUHVLVWDQFH
    &LYLOL]DWLRQZDVDGHIHQVHDJDLQVWQDWXUHVUDZSRZHU
    7KDWZDVDFUXFLDOYDULDEOHRQHQHYHUFRQVLGHUHGE\WKHHFRQRPLVWVZLWK
    WKHLUJURVVSURGXFWVSHUFDSLWDRUWKHSROLWLFDOWKHRULVWVZLWKWKHLU
    UHSUHVHQWDWLYHTXRWLHQWVRUWKHVRFLRVDYDQWVDQGWKHLUVHFXULW\LQGLFHV
    ,OOKDYHWRNHHSWKDWLQWRRKHPXWWHUHGWRKLPVHOI
    .HHSZKDW"<XJRDVNHG+HWRRZDVVWLOODJLWDWHG
    7KLQJVDVEDVLFDVPXUGHU:HJHWDOOWLHGXSLQ7UDQWRUVHFRQRPLFV
    DQGSROLWLFVEXWVRPHWKLQJDVJXWGHHSDVWKDWLQFLGHQWPD\EHPRUH
    LPSRUWDQWLQWKHORQJUXQ
    :HOOSLFNLWXSLQWKHFULPHVWDWLVWLFV
    1RLWVWKHXUJH,ZDQWWRJHW+RZGRHVWKDWH[SODLQWKHGHHSHU
    PRYHPHQWVLQKXPDQFXOWXUH",WVEDGHQRXJKGHDOLQJZLWK7UDQWRUDJLDQW
    SUHVVXUHFRRNHUIRUW\ELOOLRQVHDOHGLQWRJHWKHU:HNQRZWKHUHVVRPHWKLQJ
    PLVVLQJEHFDXVHZHFDQWJHWWKH SV\FKRKLVWRULFDOHTXDWLRQVWRFRQYHUJH
    <XJRIURZQHG,ZDVWKLQNLQLWZDVZHOOWKDWZHQHHGHGPRUHGDWD
    +DULIHOWWKHROGIDPLOLDUIUXVWUDWLRQ1R,FDQIHHOLW7KHUHV
    VRPHWKLQJFUXFLDODQGZHGRQWKDYHLW
    <XJRORRNHGGRXEWIXODQGWKHQWKHLURIIGLVNFDPH7KH\FKDQJHGWKURXJK
    DFRQFHQWULFVHWRIFLUFXODWLQJVOLGHZD\VUHGXFLQJWKHLUYHORFLW\DQGHQGLQJ
    LQDEURDGVTXDUH$QLPSUHVVLYHHGLILFHGRPLQDWHGWKHKLJKDLUVKDIWV
    VOHQGHUFROXPQVEORRPLQJLQWRRIILFHVDERYH6XQOLJKWWULFNOHGGRZQWKH
    VFXOSWHGIDFHVRIWKHEXLOGLQJWHOOLQJWDOHVRIPRQH\$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHV
    5HFHSWLRQZKLVNHGWKHPLQWRDVDQFWXPPRUHOX[XULRXVWKDQDQ\WKLQJDW
    6WUHHOLQJ*UHDWURRP<XJRVDLGZLWKDZU\VODQWRIKLVKHDG
    +DULXQGHUVWRRGWKLVFRPPRQDFDGHPLFUHIOHFWLRQ7HFKQLFDOZRUNHUV
    RXWVLGHWKHXQLYHUVLW\V\VWHPHDUQHGPRUHDQGZRUNHGLQJHQHUDOO\EHWWHU
    VXUURXQGLQJV1RQHRIWKDWKDGHYHUERWKHUHGKLP7KHLGHDRIXQLYHUVLWLHVDV
    DKLJKFLWDGHOKDGZLWKHUHGDVWKH(PSLUHGHFOLQHGDQGKHVDZQRQHHGIRU
    RSXOHQFHSDUWLFXODUO\XQGHUDQ(PSHURUZLWKDWDVWHIRULW
    7KHVWDIIRI$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVUHIHUUHGWRWKHPVHOYHVDV$DQGVHHPHG
    TXLWHEULJKW+HOHW<XJRFDUU\WKHFRQYHUVDWLRQDVWKH\VDWDURXQGDELJ
    SROLVKHGSVHXGRZRRGWDEOHKHVWLOOSXOVHGZLWKWKH]HVWRIWKHHDUOLHU
    YLROHQFH+DULVDWEDFNDQGPHGLWDWHGRQKLVVXUURXQGLQJVKLVPLQGUHWXUQLQJ
    DVDOZD\VWRQHZIDFHWVZKLFKPLJKWEHDUXSRQSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    7KHWKHRU\DOUHDG\KDGPDWKHPDWLFDOUHODWLRQVKLSVEHWZHHQWHFKQRORJ\
    FDSLWDODFFXPXODWLRQDQGODERUEXWWKHPRVWLPSRUWDQWGULYHUSURYHGWREH
    NQRZOHGJH$ERXWKDOIWKHHFRQRPLFJURZWKFDPHIURPWKHLQFUHDVHLQWKH
    TXDOLW\RILQIRUPDWLRQDVHPERGLHGLQEHWWHUPDFKLQHVDQGLPSURYHGVNLOOV
    EXLOGLQJHIILFLHQF\
    )DLUHQRXJKDQGWKDWZDVZKHUHWKH(PSLUHKDGIDOWHUHG7KHLQQRYDWLYH
    WKUXVWRIWKHVFLHQFHVKDGVORZO\JURXQGGRZQ7KH,PSHULDO8QLYHUVLWLHV
    SURGXFHGILQHHQJLQHHUVEXWQRLQYHQWRUV*UHDWVFKRODUVEXWIHZWUXH
    VFLHQWLVWV7KDWIDFWRUHGLQWRWKHRWKHUWLGHVRIWLPH
    2QO\LQGHSHQGHQWEXVLQHVVHVVXFKDVWKLVKHUHIOHFWHGFRQWLQXHGWKH
    PRPHQWXPZKLFKKDGGULYHQWKHHQWLUH(PSLUHIRUVRORQJ%XWWKH\ZHUH
    ZLOGIORZHUVRIWHQFUXVKHGEHQHDWKWKHERRWRI,PSHULDOSROLWLFVDQGLQHUWLD
    'U6HOGRQ"DYRLFHDVNHGDWKLV HOERZVWDUWOLQJ+DULRXWRIKLV
    UXPLQDWLRQ+HQRGGHG

    :HGRKDYH\RXUSHUPLVVLRQDVZHOO"
    $KWRGRZKDW"
    7RXVHWKHVH<XJRVWRRGDQGOLIWHGRQWRWKHWDEOHKLVWZRFDUU\
    FDVHV+HXQ]LSSHGWKHPDQGWZRIHUULWHFRUHVVWRRGUHYHDOHG
    7KH6DUNVLPVJHQWOHPHQ
    +DULJDSHG,WKRXJKW'RUV
    6PDVKHGHP"6KHWKRXJKWVRWRR,XVHGWZRROGZRUWKOHVVGDWDFRUHV
    LQ\RXURIILFHWKDWGD\
    <RXNQHZVKHZRXOG
    ,JRWWDUHVSHFWWKDWODG\TXLFNDQGVWURQJPLQGHGVKHLV<XJR
    VKUXJJHG,ILJXUHGVKHPLJKWJHWDOLWWOHSURYRNHG
    +DULVPLOHG6XGGHQO\KHNQHZWKDWKHKDGEHHQUHSUHVVLQJUHDODQJHUDW
    'RUVIRUKHUKLJKKDQGHGDFW1RZKHUHOHDVHGLWLQDILWRIKHDUW\ODXJKWHU
    :RQGHUIXO:LIHRUQRWWKHUHDUHOLPLWV
    +HKRZOHGVRKDUGWHDUVVSUDQJWRKLVH\HV7KHJXIIDZVVSUHDGDURXQG
    WKHWDEOHDQG+DULIHOWEHWWHUWKDQKHKDGLQZHHNV)RUDPRPHQWDOOWKH
    QDJJLQJ8QLYHUVLW\GHWDLOVWKHPLQLVWHUVKLSHYHU\WKLQJIHOODZD\
    7KHQZHGRKDYH\RXUSHUPLVVLRQ'U6HOGRQ"7RXVHWKHVLPV"D\RXQJ
    PDQDWKLVHOERZDVNHGDJDLQ
    2IFRXUVHWKRXJK,ZLOOZDQWWRNHHSFORVHWDEVRQVRPHDKUHVHDUFK
    LQWHUHVWVRIPLQH:LOOWKDWEHSRVVLEOH0U"
    0DUT+RIWL:HGEHKRQRUHGVLULI\RXFRXOGVSDUHWKHSURMHFWVRPH
    WLPH ,OOGRP\EHVW
    $QG,$\RXQJZRPDQVWRRGDWKLVRWKHUHOERZ6\E\OVKHVDLGDQG
    VKRRNKDQGV7KH\ERWKDSSHDUHGTXLWHFRPSHWHQWQHDWDQGHIILFLHQW+DUL
    SX]]OHGDWWKHORRNVERUGHULQJRQUHYHUHQFHWKH\JDYHKLP$IWHUDOOKHZDV
    MXVWDPDWKLVWOLNHWKHP
    7KHQKHODXJKHGDJDLQKHDUWLO\DFXULRXVO\OLEHUDWLQJEDUN+HKDG
    MXVWWKRXJKWRIZKDWLWZRXOGEHOLNHWRWHOO'RUVDERXWWKHGDWDFRUHV
    B
    3$57
    7+(526(0((76
    7+(6&$/3(/

    B
    &20387$7,21$/5(35(6(17$7,21LWLVFOHDUWKDWH[FHSWIRURFFDVLRQDO
    RXWEXUVWVWKHWDERRVDJDLQVWDGYDQFHGDUWLILFLDOLQWHOOLJHQFHVKHDG
    WKURXJKRXWWKH(PSLUHWKURXJKWKHJUHDWVZHHSRIKLVWRULFDOWLPH7KLV
    XQLIRUPLW\RIFXOWXUDORSLQLRQSUREDEO\UHIOHFWVWUDJHGLHVDQGWUDXPDVZLWK
    DUWLILFLDOIRUPVIDU EDFNLQSUH(PSLUHDJHV7KHUHDUHUHFRUGVRIHDUO\
    WUDQVJUHVVLRQVE\VHOIDZDUHSURJUDPVLQFOXGLQJWKRVHE\VLPVRUVHOI
    RUJDQL]LQJVLPXODWLRQV$SSDUHQWO\WKHSUHDQFLHQWVHQMR\HGUHFUHDWLQJ
    SHUVRQDOLWLHVRIWKHLURZQSDVWSHUKDSVIRULQVWUXFWLRQRU DPXVHPHQWRUHYHQ
    UHVHDUFK1RQHRIWKHVHDUHNQRZQWRVXUYLYHEXWWDOHVSHUVLVWWKDWWKH\ZHUH
    RQFHDKLJKDUW
    2IGDUNHULPSOLFDWLRQDUHWKHQDUUDWLYHVZKLFKK\SRWKHVL]HVHOIDZDUH
    LQWHOOLJHQFHVORGJHGLQERGLHVUHVHPEOLQJKXPDQ:KLOHORZRUGHUPHFKDQLFDO
    IRUPVDUHFXVWRPDULO\DOORZHGWKURXJKRXWWKH(PSLUHWKHVHWLNWRNV
    FRQVWLWXWHQRFRPSHWLWLRQZLWKKXPDQVVLQFHWKH\SHUIRUPRQO\VLPSOHDQG
    RIWHQGLVDJUHHDEOHWDVNV
    

    (1&<&/23(',$*$/$&7,&$

    -RDQRI$UFZDNHQHGLQVLGHDQDPEHUGUHDP&RROEUHH]HVFDUHVVHGKHU

    RGGQRLVHVUHYHUEHUDWHG6KHKHDUGEHIRUHVKHVDZ
    DQGDEUXSWO\IRXQGKHUVHOIVLWWLQJRXWGRRUV6KHQRWHGWKLQJVRQHDWD
    WLPHDVWKRXJKVRPHSDUWRIKHUVHOIZHUHFRXQWLQJWKHP
    6RIWDLU%HIRUHKHUDVPRRWKURXQGWDEOH
    3UHVVLQJDJDLQVWKHUDQXQVHWWOLQJZKLWHFKDLU,WVVHDWXQOLNHWKRVH
    LQKHUKRPHYLOODJHRI'RPUHP\ZDVQRWKDQGKHZQRIZRRG,WVVPRRWK
    VOLFNQHVVOHZGO\DSHGKHUFRQWRXUV6KHUHGGHQHG
    6WUDQJHUV2QHWZRWKUHHZLQNLQJLQWREHLQJEHIRUHKHUH\HV
    7KH\PRYHG3HFXOLDUSHRSOH6KHFRXOGQRWWHOOZRPDQIURPPDQH[FHSW
    IRUWKRVHZKRVHSDQWDORRQVDQGWXQLFVRXWOLQHGWKHLULQWLPDWHSDUWV7KH
    VSHFWDFOHZDVHYHQPRUHWKDQVKHGVHHQLQ&KLQRQDWWKHOHZGFRXUWRIWKH
    *UHDWDQG7UXH.LQJ
    7DON7KHVWUDQJHUVVHHPHGREOLYLRXVRIKHUWKRXJKVKHFRXOGKHDUWKHP
    FKDWWHULQJLQWKHEDFNJURXQGDVGLVWLQFWO\DVVKHVRPHWLPHVKHDUGKHUYRLFHV
    6KHOLVWHQHGRQO\ORQJHQRXJKWRFRQFOXGHWKDWZKDWWKH\VDLGKDYLQJQRWKLQJ
    WRGRZLWKKROLQHVVRU)UDQFHZDVFOHDUO\QRWZRUWKKHDULQJ
    1RLVH)URPRXWVLGH$QLURQULYHURIVHOIPRYLQJFDUULDJHVPXWWHUHGE\
    6KHIHOWVXUSULVHDWWKLVWKHQVRPHKRZWKHHPRWLRQHYDSRUDWHG
    $ORQJYLHZWHOHVFRSLQJLQ
    3HDUO\PLVWVFRQFHDOHGGLVWDQWLYRU\VSLUHV)RJPDGHWKHPVHHPOLNH
    PHOWLQJFKXUFKHV
    :KDWZDVWKLVSODFH"
    $YLVLRQSHUKDSVUHODWHGWRKHUEHORYHGYRLFHV&RXOGVXFKDSSDULWLRQV
    EHKRO\"
    6XUHO\WKHPDQDWDQHDUE\WDEOHZDVQRDQJHO+HZDVHDWLQJVFUDPEOHG
    HJJVWKURXJKDVWUDZ
    $QGWKHZRPHQXQFKDVWHIODJUDQWJDXG\FRUQXFRSLDVRIKLSDQGWKLJK
    DQGEUHDVW6RPHGUDQNUHGZLQHIURPWUDQVSDUHQWJREOHWVGLIIHUHQWIURPDQ\
    VKHGVHHQDWWKHUR\DOFRXUW
    2WKHUVVHHPHGWRVXSIURPIORDWLQJFORXGVGHOLFDWHELOORZLQJPRXVVH
    IRJV2QHPLVWUHHNLQJRIEHHIZLWKDWDQJ\/RLUHVDXFHSDVVHGQHDUKHU6KH
    EUHDWKHGLQDQGIHOWLQDQLQVWDQWWKDWVKHKDGH[SHULHQFHGDPHDO
    :DVWKLVKHDYHQ":KHUHDSSHWLWHVZHUHVDWLVILHGZLWKRXWODERUDQGWRLO"
    %XWQR6XUHO\WKHILQDOUHZDUGZDVQRWVRVRFDUQDO$QG
    SHUWXUELQJ$QGHPEDUUDVVLQJ
    7KHILUHVRPHVXFNHGLQWRWKHLUPRXWKVIURPOLWWOHUHHGVWKRVHDODUPHG
    KHU$FORXGRIVPRNHGULIWLQJKHUZD\IOXVKHGELUGVRISDQLFIURPKHUEUHDVW
    DOWKRXJKVKHFRXOGQRWVPHOOWKHVPRNHQRUGLGLWEXUQKHUH\HVRUVHDUKHU
    WKURDW
    7KHILUHWKHILUHVKHWKRXJKWKHDUWIOXWWHULQJLQSDQLF:KDWKDG"
    6KHVDZDEHLQJPDGHRIEUHDVWSODWHFRPLQJDWKHUZLWKDWUD\RIIRRG
    DQGGULQNSRLVRQIURPHQHPLHVQRGRXEWWKHIRHVRI)UDQFHVKHWKRXJKWLQ
    FKXUQLQJIULJKWVKHDWRQFHUHDFKHGIRUKHUVZRUG
    %HZLWK\RXLQDPRPHQWWKHEUHDVWSODWHGWKLQJVDLGDVLWZKHHOHG
    SDVWKHUWRDQRWKHUWDEOH,YHRQO\JRWIRXUKDQGV'RKDYHSDWLHQFH
    $QLQQVKHWKRXJKW,WZDVVRPHNLQGRILQQWKRXJKWKHUHDSSHDUHGWR
    EHQRZKHUHWRORGJH$QG\HVLWFDPHQRZVKHZDVVXSSRVHGWRPHHW
    VRPHRQHDJHQWOHPDQ"
    7KDWRQHWKHWDOOVNLQQ\ROGPDQPXFKROGHUWKDQ-DFTXHV'DUVKHU
    IDWKHUWKHRQO\RQHEHVLGHVKHUVHOIDWWLUHGQRUPDOO\
    6RPHWKLQJDERXWKLVGUHVVUHFDOOHGWKHIRSSLVKGDQGLHVDWWKH*UHDWDQG
    7UXH.LQJVFRXUW+LVKDLUFXUOHGWLJKWLWVZKLWHQHVVVHWRIIE\DOLODF
    ULEERQDWKLVWKURDW+HZRUHDSDLURIPLJQRQHWWHUXIIOHVZLWKQDUURZHGJLQJ
    DORQJZDLVWFRDWRIEURZQVDWLQZLWKFRORUHGIORZHUVDQGVSRUWHGUHGYHOYHW
    EUHHFKHVZKLWHVWRFNLQJVDQGFKDPRLVVKRHV
    $VLOO\YDLQDULVWRFUDWVKHWKRXJKW$IRSDFFXVWRPHGWRFDUULDJHV
    ZKRFRXOGQRWVRPXFKDVVLWDKRUVHPXFKOHVVGRKRO\EDWWOH

    %XWGXW\ZDVDVDFUHGREOLJDWLRQ,I.LQJ&KDUOHVRUGHUHGKHUWR
    DGYDQFHDGYDQFHVKHZRXOG
    6KHURVH+HUVXLWRIPDLOIHOWVXUSULVLQJO\OLJKW6KHKDUGO\VHQVHG
    WKHEHOWHGRQSURWHFWLYHOHDWKHUIODSVLQIURQWDQGEDFNQRUWKHWZRPHWDO
    DUPSODWHVWKDWOHIWHOERZVIUHHWRZLHOGWKHVZRUG1RRQHSDLGWKHOHDVW
    DWWHQWLRQWRWKHUXVWOHRIKHUPDLORUKHUIDLQWFODQN
    $UH\RXWKHJHQWOHPDQ,DPWRPHHW"0RQVLHXU$URXHW"
    'RQWFDOOPHWKDWKHVQDSSHG$URXHWLVP\IDWKHUVQDPHWKHQDPH
    RIDQDXWKRULWDULDQSUXGHQRWPLQH1RRQHKDVFDOOHGPHWKDWLQ\HDUV
    8SFORVHKHVHHPHGOHVVDQFLHQW6KHGEHHQPLVOHGE\KLVZKLWHKDLU
    ZKLFKVKHQRZVDZZDVIDOVHDSRZGHUHGZLJVHFXUHGE\WKHOLODFULEERQXQGHU
    KLVFKLQ
    :KDWVKRXOG,FDOO\RXWKHQ"6KHVXSSUHVVHGWHUPVRIFRQWHPSWIRUWKLV
    GDQG\URXJKZRUGVOHDUQHGIURPFRPUDGHVLQDUPVQRZERUQHE\GHPRQVWRKHU
    WRQJXHVHGJHEXWQRWEH\RQG
    3RHWWUDJHGLDQKLVWRULDQ+HOHDQHGIRUZDUGDQGZLWKDZLFNHGZLQN
    ZKLVSHUHG,VW\OHP\VHOI9ROWDLUH)UHHWKLQNHU3KLORVRSKHUNLQJ
    %HVLGHVWKH.LQJRI+HDYHQDQG+LVVRQ,FDOOEXWRQHPDQ.LQJ
    &KDUOHV9,,RIWKH+RXVHRI9DORLV$QG,//FDOO\RX$URXHWXQWLOP\UR\DO
    PDVWHUELGVPHGRRWKHUZLVH
    0\GHDUSXFHO,H\RXU&KDUOHVLVGHDG
    1R
    +HJODQFHGDWWKHQRLVHOHVVFDUULDJHVSURSHOOHGE\LQYLVLEOHIRUFHVRQ
    WKHVWUHHW6LWGRZQVLWGRZQ0XFKHOVHKDVSDVVHGDVZHOO'RKHOSPHJHW
    WKDWGUROOZDLWHUVDWWHQWLRQ
    <RXNQRZPH"/HGE\KHUYRLFHVVKH KDGFDVWRIIKHUIDWKHUVQDPHWR
    FDOOKHUVHOI/D3XFHO,HWKH&KDVWH0DLG
    ,NQRZ\RXYHU\ZHOO1RWRQO\GLG\RXOLYHFHQWXULHVEHIRUHPH,
    ZURWHDSOD\DERXW\RX$QG,KDYHFXULRXVPHPRULHVRIVSHDNLQJZLWK\RX
    EHIRUHLQVRPHVKDGRZ\VSDFHV+HVKRRNKLVKHDGIURZQLQJ%HVLGHVP\
    JDUPHQWVEHDXWLIXOQHVWFHSDV"\RXUHWKHRQO\IDPLOLDUWKLQJDERXWWKLV
    SODFH<RXDQGWKHVWUHHWWKRXJK,PXVWVD\\RXUH\RXQJHUWKDQ,WKRXJKW
    ZKLOHWKHVWUHHWKPPPVHHPVZLGHU\HWROGHU7KH\ILQDOO\JRWURXQGWR
    SDYLQJLW
    ,,FDQQRWIDWKRP
    +HSRLQWHGWRDVLJQWKDWERUHWKHLQQVQDPH$X['HX[0DJRWV
    0DGHPRLVHOOH/HFRXYUHXUDIDPRXVDFWUHVVWKRXJKHTXDOO\NQRZQDVP\
    PLVWUHVV+HEOLQNHG<RXUHEOXVKLQJKRZVZHHW
    ,NQRZQRWKLQJRIVXFKWKLQJV6KHDGGHGZLWKPRUHWKDQDWUDFHRI
    SULGH,DPDPDLG
    +HJULPDFHG:K\RQHZRXOGEHSURXGRIVXFKDQXQQDWXUDOVWDWH,FDQW
    LPDJLQH
    $V,FDQQRWLPDJLQHZK\\RXDUHVRGUHVVHG
    0\WDLORUVZLOOEHPRUWDOO\RIIHQGHG%XWDOORZPHWRVXJJHVWWKDWLW
    LV\RXP\GHDUSXFHOOHZKRLQ\RXULQVLVWHQFHRQGUHVVLQJOLNHDPDQZRXOG
    GHSULYHFLYLOL]HGVRFLHW\RIRQHRILWVPRVWKDUPOHVVSOHDVXUHV
    $QLQVLVWHQFH,PRVWGHDUO\SDLGIRUVKHUHWRUWHGUHPHPEHULQJKRZ
    WKHELVKRSVEDGJHUHGKHUDERXWKHUPDOHDWWLUHDVUHOHQWOHVVO\DVWKH\
    LQTXLUHGDIWHUKHUGLYLQHYRLFHV
    $VLILQWKHDEVXUGDWWLUHPHPEHUVRIKHUVH[ZHUHUHTXLUHGWRZHDUVKH
    FRXOGKDYHGHIHDWHGWKH(QJOLVKORYLQJGXNHDW2UOHDQV2UOHGWKUHHWKRXVDQG
    NQLJKWVWRYLFWRU\DW-DUJHDXDQG0HXQJVXU/RLUH%HDXJHQF\DQG3DWD\
    WKURXJKRXWWKDWVXPPHURIJORULRXVFRQTXHVWVZKHQOHGE\KHUYRLFHVVKH
    FRXOGGRQRZURQJ
    6KHEOLQNHGEDFNVXGGHQWHDUV$UXVKRIPHPRU\
    'HIHDW7KHQWKHEORRGUHGGDUNQHVVRIORVWEDWWOHVKDGGHVFHQGHG
    PXIIOLQJKHUYRLFHVZKLOHWKRVHRIKHU(QJOLVKORYLQJHQHPLHVJUHZVWURQJ

    1RQHHGWRJHWWHVW\0RQVLHXU$URXHWVDLGJHQWO\SDWWLQJKHUNQHH
    SODWH$OWKRXJK,SHUVRQDOO\ILQG\RXUDWWLUHUHSXOVLYH,ZRXOGGHIHQGWR
    WKHGHDWK\RXUULJKWWRGUHVVDQ\ZD\\RXSOHDVH2UXQGUHVV+HH\HGWKH
    QHDUWUDQVSDUHQWXSSHUJDUPHQWRIDIHPDOHLQQSDWURQQHDUE\
    6LU
    3DULVKDVQRWORVWLWVDSSHWLWHIRUILQHU\DIWHUDOO3DOHIUXLWRIWKH
    JRGVGRQW\RXDJUHH"
    1R,GRQRW7KHUHLVQRYLUWXHJUHDWHUWKDQFKDVWLW\LQZRPHQRULQ
    PHQ2XU/RUGZDVFKDVWHDVDUHRXUVDLQWVDQGSULHVWV
    3ULHVWVFKDVWH+HUROOHGKLVH\HV3LW\\RXZHUHQWDWWKHVFKRROP\
    IDWKHUIRUFHGPHWRDWWHQGDVDER\<RXFRXOGKDYHVRLQIRUPHGWKH-HVXLWV
    ZKRGDLO\DEXVHGWKHLULQQRFHQWFKDUJHV
    ,,FDQQRWEHOLHYH
    $QGZKDWRIKLP"9ROWDLUHWDONHGULJKWRYHUKHUSRLQWLQJDWWKHIRXU
    KDQGHGFUHDWXUHRQZKHHOVUROOLQJWRZDUGWKHP1RGRXEWVXFKDFUHDWXUHLV
    FKDVWH,VLWWKHQYLUWXRXVWRR"
    &KULVWLDQLW\)UDQFHLWVHOILVIRXQGHGRQ
    ,IFKDVWLW\ZHUHSUDFWLFHGLQ)UDQFHDVPXFKDVLWVSUHDFKHGWKHUDFH
    ZRXOGEHH[WLQFW
    7KHZKHHOHGFUHDWXUHEUDNHGE\WKHLUWDEOH6WDPSHGRQKLVFKHVWZDV
    ZKDWDSSHDUHGWREHKLVQDPH*$5&21$'0,QDEDVVYRLFHDVFOHDUDVDQ\
    PDQVKHVDLG$FRVWXPHSDUW\HK",KRSHP\GHOD\ZLOOQRWPDNH\RXODWH
    2XUPHFKIRONDUHKDYLQJGLIILFXOWLHV
    ,WH\HGWKHRWKHUWLNWRNEULQJLQJGLVKHVIRUWKDKRQH\KDLUHGEORQGLQ
    DKDLUQHWDSSUR[LPDWHO\KXPDQOLNH$GHPRQ"
    7KH0DLGIURZQHG,WVMHUN\JODQFHHYHQWKRXJKPHFKDQLFDOUHFDOOHGWKH
    ZD\KHUMDLOHUVKDGJDZNHGDWKHU+XPLOLDWHGVKHKDGFDVWDVLGHWKHZRPHQV
    JDUPHQWVWKDWKHU,QTXLVLWRUVIRUFHGKHUWRZHDU5HVXPLQJPDQO\DWWLUHVKHG
    VFRUQIXOO\SXWKHUMDLOHUVLQWKHLUSODFH,WKDGEHHQDILQHPRPHQW
    7KHFRRNDVVXPHGDKDXJKW\ORRNEXWIXVVHGZLWKKHUKDLUQHWDQGVPLOHG
    DW*DUFRQ$'0EHIRUHDYHUWLQJKHUH\HV7KHLPSRUWRIWKLVHOXGHG-RDQ
    6KHKDGDFFHSWHGPHFKDQLFDOVLQWKLV VWUDQJHSODFHZLWKRXWTXHVWLRQLQJWKHLU
    PHDQLQJ3UHVXPDEO\WKLVZDVVRPHLQWHUPHGLDWHVWDWLRQLQWKH/RUGV
    SURYLGHQWLDORUGHU%XWLWZDVSX]]OLQJ
    0RQVLHXU$URXHWUHDFKHGRXWDQGWRXFKHGWKHPHFKPDQVQHDUHVWDUPZKRVH
    FRQVWUXFWLRQWKH0DLGFRXOGQRWKHOSEXWDGPLUH,IVXFKDFUHDWXUHFRXOGEH
    PDGHWRVLWDKRUVHLQEDWWOHLWZRXOGEHLQYLQFLEOH7KHSRVVLELOLWLHV
    :KHUHDUHZH"0RQVLHXU$URXHWDVNHG2USHUKDSV,VKRXOGDVNZKHQ",
    KDYHIULHQGVLQKLJKSODFHV
    $QG,LQORZWKHPHFKPDQVDLGJRRGQDWXUHGO\DQG,GHPDQGDIXOO
    DFFRXQWRIZKHUHZHDUHZKDWVJRLQJRQ
    7KHPHFKPDQVKUXJJHGZLWKWZRRIKLVIUHHDUPVZKLOHWKHWZRRWKHUVVHW
    WKHWDEOH+RZFRXOGDPHFKZDLWZLWKLQWHOOLJHQFHSURJUDPPHGWRVXLWKLV
    VWDWLRQLQVWUXFWPRQVLHXUDKXPDQEHLQJLQWKHYHLOHGP\VWHULHVRI
    VLPVSDFH"+DYHPRQVLHXUDQGPDGHPRLVHOOHGHFLGHGRQWKHLURUGHU"
    <RXKDYHQRW\HWEURXJKWXVWKHPHQXVDLG0RQVLHXU$URXHW
    7KHPHFKPDQSXVKHGDEXWWRQXQGHUWKHWDEOH7ZRIODWVFUROOVHPEHGGHG
    LQWKHWDEOHVKLPPHUHGOHWWHUVJORZLQJ7KH0DLGOHWRXWDVPDOOFU\RI
    GHOLJKWWKHQLQUHVSRQVHWR0RQVLHXU$URXHWVFHQVRULRXVORRNFODSSHGKHU
    KDQGRYHUKHUPRXWK+HUSHDVDQWPDQQHUVZHUHDIUHTXHQWVRXUFHRI
    HPEDUUDVVPHQW
    ,QJHQLRXVVDLG0RQVLHXU$URXHWVZLWFKLQJWKHEXWWRQRQDQGRIIDVKH
    H[DPLQHGWKHXQGHUVLGHRIWKHWDEOH+RZGRHVLWZRUN"
    ,PQRWSURJUDPPHGWRNQRZ<RXOOKDYHWRDVNDPHFKOHFWULFLDQDERXW
    WKDW
    $ZKDW"
    :LWKDOOGXHUHVSHFW0RQVLHXUP\RWKHUFXVWRPHUVDUHZDLWLQJ,DP

    SURJUDPPHGWRWDNH\RXURUGHU
    :KDWZLOO\RXKDYHP\GHDU"0RQVLHXU$URXHWDVNHGKHU
    6KHORRNHGGRZQHPEDUUDVVHG2UGHUIRUPHVKHVDLG
    $K\HV,TXLWHIRUJRW
    )RUJRWZKDW"DVNHGWKHPHFKPDQ
    0\FRPSDQLRQLVXQOHWWHUHG6KHFDQWUHDG,PLJKWDVZHOOEHWRR
    IRUDOOWKHJRRGWKLVPHQXVGRLQJPH
    6RWKLVREYLRXVO\OHDUQHGPDQFRXOGQRWIDWKRPWKH7DEOHRI+RXVH-RDQ
    IRXQGWKDWHQGHDULQJDPLGWKLVEOL]]DUGRIWKHEL]DUUH
    7KHPHFKPDQH[SODLQHGDQG9ROWDLUHLQWHUUXSWHG
    &ORXGIRRG"(OHFWURQLFFXLVLQH"+HJULPDFHG-XVWEULQJPHWKHEHVW
    \RXKDYHIRUJUHDWKXQJHUDQGWKLUVW:KDWFDQ\RXUHFRPPHQGIRUDEVWLQHQW
    YLUJLQVDSODWHRIGLUWSHUKDSV"&KDVHGZLWKDJODVVRIYLQHJDU"
    %ULQJPHDVOLFHRIEUHDGWKH0DLGVDLGZLWKIURVW\GLJQLW\$QGD
    VPDOOERZORIZLQHWRGLSLWLQ
    :LQHVDLG0RQVLHXU$URXHW<RXUYRLFHVDOORZZLQH"0DLVTXHOOH
    VFDQGDOH,IZRUGJRWRXWWKDW\RXGULQNZLQHZKDWZRXOGWKHSULHVWVVD\RI
    WKHVKRGG\H[DPSOH\RXUHVHWWLQJIRUWKHIXWXUHVDLQWVRI)UDQFH"
    +HWXUQHGWRWKHPHFKPDQ%ULQJKHUDJODVVRIZDWHUVPDOO$V*DUFRQ
    $'0ZLWKGUHZ0RQVLHXU$URXHWFDOOHGRXW$QGPDNHVXUHWKHEUHDGLVD
    FUXVW3UHIHUDEO\PROG\
    

    0DUT+RIWLVWURGHVZLIWO\WRZDUGKLV:DOGRQ6KDIWRIILFHKLVFROOHDJXH
    DQGIULHQG6\E\OFKDWWHULQJEHVLGHKLP6KHZDVDOZD\VHQHUJHWLFEULVWOLQJ
    ZLWKLGHDV2QO\RFFDVLRQDOO\GLGKHUHQHUJ\VHHPWLUHVRPH
    7KH$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVRIILFHVORRPHGZHLJKW\DQGLPSUHVVLYHLQWKH
    LPPHQVHKLJKVKDIW$IOXWWHUJOLGHUFLUFOHGWKHSURWUXGLQJOHYHOVIDUDERYH
    EDQNLQJDPRQJSUHWW\JUHHQFORXGV0DUTFUDQHGKLVQHFNXSZDUGDQGZDWFKHGWKH
    JOLGHUFDWFKDQXSGUDIWRIWKHFLW\VSRZHUIXODLUFLUFXODWRUV$WPRVSKHULF
    FRQWUROHYHQDGGHGWKHSXIIEDOOYDSRUVIRUYDULHW\+HORQJHGWREHXSWKHUH
    VZRRSLQJDPRQJWKHLUVWLFN\IODYRUV
    ,QVWHDGKHZDVGRZQKHUHGRQQLQJKLVXVXDOFDUDSDFHRIHDFKGD\VD
    FKDOOHQJHYLJRU$QGWRGD\ZDVJRLQJWREHXQXVXDO5LVN\$QGWKRXJKWKH]HVW
    IRULWVDQJLQKLVVWULGHKLVJULQWKHIHDURIIDLOXUHJDYHDOHDGHQOLQLQJ
    WRKLVPRVWEXR\DQWSODQV
    ,IKHIDLOHGWRGD\DWOHDVWKHZRXOGQRWWXPEOHIURPWKHVN\OLNHD
    SLORWZKRPLVMXGJHGWKHWKHUPDOVLQWKHVKDIW*ULPO\KHHQWHUHGKLVRIILFH
    ,WPDNHVPHQHUYRXV6\E\OVDLGFXWWLQJLQWRKLVPRRG
    8PP:KDW"+HGXPSHGKLVSDFNDQGVDWDWKLVRUQDWHFRQWUROERDUG
    6KHVDWEHVLGHKLP7KHERDUGILOOHGKDOIWKHRIILFHPDNLQJKLVGHVN
    ORRNOLNHDFOXWWHUHGDIWHUWKRXJKW7KH6DUNVLPV:HYHVSHQWVRPXFKWLPH
    RQWKRVHUHVXUUHFWLRQSURWRFROVWKHVOLFHVDQGHPEHGGLQJVDQGDOO
    ,KDGWRILOOLQZKROHOD\HUVPLVVLQJIURPWKHUHFRUGLQJV6\QDSWLF
    ZHEVIURPWKHDVVRFLDWLRQFRUWH[3OHQW\RIZRUN
    ,GLGWRR0\-RDQZDVPLVVLQJFKXQNVRIWKHKLSSRFDPSXV
    3UHWW\WRXJK"7KHEUDLQUHPHPEHUHGWKLQJVXVLQJFRQVWHOODWLRQVRI
    DJHQWVIURPWKHKLSSRFDPSXV7KH\ODLGGRZQORQJWHUPPHPRU\HOVHZKHUH
    VSDWWHULQJSLHFHVRILWDURXQGWKHFHUHEUDOFRUWH[1RWQHDUO\DVFOHDQDQG
    RUGHUO\DVFRPSXWHUPHPRU\ZKLFKZDVRQHRIWKHPDMRUSUREOHPV(YROXWLRQZDV
    DNOXGJHPHFKDQLVPVFUDPPHGLQKHUHDQGWKHUHZLWKOLWWOHDWWHQWLRQWR
    RYHUDOOGHVLJQ$WEXLOGLQJPLQGVWKH/RUGZDVVRPHWKLQJRIDQDPDWHXU
    0XUGHU,VWD\HGWRPLGQLJKWIRU ZHHNV
    0HWRR
    'LG\RXXVHWKHOLEUDU\"+HFRQVLGHUHG$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVNHSW
    GHQVHILOHVRIEUDLQPDSVDOOWDNHQIURPYROXQWHHUV7KHUHZHUHPHQXVIRU

    VHOHFWLQJPHQWDODJHQWVVXEURXWLQHVZKLFKFRXOGFDUU\RXWWKHWDVNVZKLFK
    P\ULDGV\QDSVHV GLGLQWKHEUDLQ7KHVHZHUHDOOQHDWO\WUDQVODWHGLQWR
    GLJLWDOHTXLYDOHQWVVDYLQJJUHDWODERU%XWWRXVHWKHPPHDQWUXQQLQJXSELJ
    ELOOVEHFDXVHHDFKZDVFRS\ULJKWHG1R*RWDSULYDWHVRXUFH
    6KHQRGGHG0HWRR
    :DVVKHWU\LQJWRFRD[DQDGPLVVLRQIURPKLP"7KH\KDGERWKKDGWRJR
    WKURXJKVFDQQLQJDVSDUWRIJHWWLQJWKHLU0DVWHU&ODVVUDWLQJVLQWKH
    PHULWRFUDF\0DUTKDGWKULIWLO\NHSWKLVVFDQ%HWWHUWKDQDEDFNDOOH\EUDLQ
    PDSIRUVXUH+HZDVQRJHQLXVEXWWKHEDVLFVRI9ROWDLUHVXQGHUSLQQLQJV
    ZHUHQWWKHLPSRUWDQWSDUWDIWHUDOO([DFWO\KRZWKHVLPUDQWKHKLQGEUDLQ
    IXQFWLRQVEDVLFPDLQWHQDQFHKRXVHNHHSLQJFLUFXLWU\FHUWDLQO\FRXOGQW
    PDWWHUFRXOGLW"
    /HWVKDYHDORRNDWRXUFUHDWLRQV0DUTVDLGEULJKWO\WRJHWRIIWKH
    VXEMHFW
    6\E\OVKRRNKHUKHDG0LQHLVVWDEOH%XWORRNZHGRQWUHDOO\NQRZ
    ZKDWWRH[SHFW7KHVHIXOO\LQWHJUDWHG3HUVRQDOLWLHVDUHVWLOOLVRODWHG
    1DWXUHRIWKHEHDVW0DUTVKUXJJHGSOD\LQJWKHMDGHGSUR1RZWKDW
    KLVKDQGVFDUHVVHGWKHERDUGWKRXJKDWLQJOLQJH[FLWHPHQWVHL]HGKLP
    /HWVGRLWWRGD\VKHVDLGZRUGVUXVKLQJRXW
    :KDW",,GOLNHWRVODSVRPHPRUHSDWFKHVRYHUWKHJDSVPD\EH
    LQVWDOODUROOLQJEXIIHUDVLQVXUDQFHDJDLQVWFKDUDFWHUVKLIWVVS\LQWR
    'HWDLOV/RRNWKHVHVLPVKDYHEHHQUXQQLQJRQLQWHUQDOVIRUZHHNVRI
    VLPWLPHVHOILQWHJUDWLQJ/HWVLQWHUDFW
    0DUTWKRXJKWRIWKHJOLGHUSLORWXSWKHUHDPLGWUHDFKHURXVZLQGV+H
    KDGQHYHUGRQHDQ\WKLQJVRULVN\KHZDVQWWKHW\SH+LVNLQGRISHULOOD\RQ
    WKHGLJLWDO SOD\LQJILHOG+HUHKHZDVPDVWHU
    %XWKHKDGQRWJRWWHQWKLVIDUE\EHLQJIRROLVK/HWWLQJWKHVH
    VLPXODWLRQVFRPHLQWRFRQWDFWZLWKWKHSUHVHQWPLJKWLQGXFHKDOOXFLQDWLRQVLQ
    WKHPIHDUHYHQSDQLF
    -XVWWKLQN7DONLQJWRSUHDQWLTXLW\
    +HUHDOL]HGWKDWKHZDVWKHRQHIHHOLQJIHDU7KLQNOLNHDSLORWKH
    DGPRQLVKHGKLPVHOI
    :RXOG\RXZDQWDQ\RQHHOVHWRGRLW"6\E\ODVNHG
    +HZDVNHHQO\DZDUHRIWKHIOHHWLQJZDUPWKRIKHUWKLJKDVLW
    DFFLGHQWDOO\EUXVKHGKLV
    1RRQHHOVHFRXOG KHDGPLWWHG
    $QGLWOOSXWXVDKHDGRIDQ\FRPSHWLWLRQ
    7KDWJX\6HOGRQKHFRXOGYHRQFHKHJRWWKHPIURPWKRVH6DUN1HZ
    5HQDLVVDQFHMRNHUV8VLQJXVZHOO,JXHVVKHQHHGVWRJHWVRPHGLVWDQFH
    IURPDGLFH\SURSRVLWLRQOLNHWKLV
    3ROLWLFDO GLVWDQFHVKHDJUHHG'HQLDELOLW\
    +HGLGQWVHHPWKDWVDYY\WRPHSROLWLFDOO\,PHDQ
    0D\EHKHZDQWVXVWRWKLQNWKDW+RZGKHFKDUP&OHRQ"
    %HDWVPH1RWWKDW,ZRXOGQWZDQWRQHRIRXUJX\VUXQQLQJWKLQJV$
    PDWKLVWPLQLVWHUZKRGLPDJLQHWKDW"
    6R$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVZDVRXWRQLWVRZQKHUH:LWKWKHLU6DUN
    FRQWDFWVWKHFRPSDQ\KDGDOUHDG\GLVSODFHG'LJLWIDFDQG$[LRP$OOLDQFHLQWKH
    VDOHDQGGHVLJQRIKRORJUDSKLFLQWHOOLJHQFHV&RPSHWLWLRQZDVURXJKLQVHYHUDO
    SURGXFWOLQHVWKRXJK:LWKDSLSHOLQHWRWUXO\DQFLHQW3HUVRQDOLWLHVWKH\
    FRXOGVZHHSWKHERDUGFOHDQ$WWKHNQLIHHGJHRIFKDQJH0DUTWKRXJKW
    KDSSLO\'DQJHUDQGPRQH\WKHWZRJUHDWDSKURGLVLDFV
    +HKDGVSHQW\HVWHUGD\HDYHVGURSSLQJRQ9ROWDLUHDQGZDVVXUH6\E\OKDG
    GRQHWKHVDPHZLWKWKH0DLG(YHU\WKLQJKDGJRQHZHOO)DFHILOWHUVIRUXV
    WKRXJK
    'RQWWUXVW\RXUVHOIWRQRWJLYHDZD\\RXUIHHOLQJV"6\E\OJDYHKLPD
    ZRPDQO\WKURDW\FKXFNOH7KLQN\RXUHWRRHDV\WRUHDG"
    $P,"%DOOEDFNLQKHUFRXUW

    /HWVVD\\RXULQWHQWLRQVDUHDWOHDVW
    +HUVO\ZLQNPDGHKLVQRVWULOVIODUHZKLFKUHPLQGHG0DUTRIZK\KH
    QHHGHGWKHILOWHUV+HWKXPEHGLQDQDPLDEOHH[SUHVVLRQKHKDGFDUHIXOO\
    IDVKLRQHGIRUGHDOLQJE\SKRQHZLWKFOLHQWV+HKDGOHDUQHGHDUO\LQWKLV
    EXVLQHVVWKDWWKHZRUOGZDVSDFNHGZLWKLUULWDEOHSHRSOH(VSHFLDOO\7UDQWRU
    %HWWHUSXWDERG\ODQJXDJHUHILQHURQWRRVKHVDLGIODWO\DOO
    EXVLQHVVQRZ7KDWZDVZKDWQHYHUFHDVHGWRLQWULJXHKLPDUWIXODPELJXLW\
    6KHSRSSHGXSKHURZQILOWHUVLPSRUWHGLQVWDQWO\IURPKHUERDUGKDOIZD\
    DFURVVWKHEXLOGLQJ:DQWDYRFDEXODU\ER["
    +HVKUXJJHG$Q\WKLQJWKH\FDQWXQGHUVWDQGZHOOFUHGLWWRODQJXDJH
    SUREOHPV
    :KDWLVWKDWVWXIIWKH\VSHDN"
    'HDGODQJXDJHXQNQRZQSDUHQWZRUOG+LVKDQGVZHUHDEOXUVHWWLQJXS
    WKHWUDQVLWLRQ
    ,WKDVDZHOODOLTXLGIHHO
    2QHWKLQJ
    6\E\OVEUHDVWVVZHOOHGDVVKHGUHZLQKHUEUHDWKKHOGLWWKHQVORZO\
    HDVHGLWRXW,MXVWKRSHP\FOLHQWGRHVQWILQGRXWDERXW6HOGRQ7KH
    FRPSDQ\VWDNLQJDQDZIXOFKDQFHQRWWHOOLQJHLWKHURQHRIWKHPDERXWWKH
    RWKHU
    6RZKDW"+HHQMR\HGJLYLQJDFDUHIUHHVKUXJ$IOXWWHUJOLGHZRXOG
    SHWULI\KLPEXWSRZHUJDPHVWKRVHKHORYHG$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVKDGWDNHQ
    PDMRUDFFRXQWVIURPWKHWZRGHDGO\ULYDOVLQWKLVZKROHDIIDLU
    ,IERWKVLGHVRIWKHDUJXPHQWILQGRXWZHUHKDQGOLQJERWKDFFRXQWV
    WKH\OOOHDYH5HIXVHWRSD\EH\RQGWKHUHWDLQHUDQG\RXNQRZKRZPXFKZHYH
    RYHUVSHQWEH\RQGWKDW
    /HDYH"+LVWXUQWRFKXFNOH1RWLIWKH\ZDQWWRZLQ:HUHWKHEHVW
    0DUTJDYHKHUKLVFRFN\VPLOH<RXDQGPHLQFDVH\RXZHUHZRQGHULQJ-XVW
    ZDLWWLOO\RXVHHWKLV
    +HGRZQHGWKHOLJKWVVWDUWHGWKHUXQDQGOHDQHGEDFNLQKLVFODVS
    FKDLUOHJVVWUHWFKHGRXWRQWKHWDEOHEHIRUHKLP+HZDQWHGWRLPSUHVVKHU
    7KDWZDVQWDOOKHZDQWHG%XWVLQFHKHUKXVEDQGKDGEHHQFUXVKHGLQDQ
    DFFLGHQWEH\RQGUHSDLUE\HYHQWKHEHVWPHGLFRVKHGGHFLGHGWRZDLWD
    GHFHQWLQWHUYDOEHIRUHKHPDGHKLVPRYH:KDWDWHDPWKH\ZRXOGPDNH2SHQD
    ILUPVD\0DUT6\E\O/LPLWHGVNLPRIIWKHEHVW$FXVWRPHUVPDNHDQDPH
    1RQDPHV/HWVEHIDLU
    6\E\OVYRLFHWUHPEOHGLQWKHJORRP7RPHHWDQFLHQWV
    'RZQGRZQGRZQLQWRWKHUHSOLFDWHGZRUOGLWVVHDPOHVVEOXH
    FRPSOH[LW\VZHOOLQJDFURVVWKHHQWLUHIDFLQJZDOO9LEURWDFWLOHIHHGEDFNIURP
    LQGXFWDQFHGHUPRWDEVSHUIHFWHGWKHLOOXVLRQ
    7KH\VZRRSHGLQWRDSULPLWLYHFLW\EDUHO\RQHOD\HURIEXLOGLQJVWR
    FRYHUWKHQDNHGJURXQG6RPHVRUWRIFUXGHYLOODJHSUH(PSLUH6WUHHWV
    ZKLUOHGE\EXLOGLQJVWXUQHGLQDUWIXOSURMHFWLRQ(YHQWKHFURZGVDQGFOXPSHG
    WUDIILFEHORZVHHPHGDXWKHQWLFDPXGGOHGKXPDQMXPEOH6ZLIWO\WKH\FDUHHQHG
    LQWRWKHLUIRUHJURXQGVLPDFDIHRQVRPHWKLQJFDOOHGWKH%RXOHYDUG6W
    *HUPDLQ&OR\LQJVPHOOVWKHPXWHGJULQGRIWUDIILFRXWVLGHDUDWWOHRI
    SODWHVWKHKHDG\DURPDRIDVRXIIOp
    0DUT]RRPHGWKHPLQWRWKHVDPHWLPHIUDPHDVWKHUHFUHDWHGHQWLWLHV$
    OHDQPDQORRPHGDFURVVWKHZDOO+LVH\HVUDGLDWHGLQWHOOLJHQFHPRXWKWLOWHG
    ZLWKVDUGRQLFPLUWK
    6\E\OZKLVWOHGWKURXJKKHUWHHWK(\HVQDUURZLQJVKHZDWFKHGWKHUH
    FUHDWLRQVPRXWKDVLIWRUHDGLWVOLSV9ROWDLUHZDVLQWHUURJDWLQJWKH
    PHFKZDLWHU,UULWDEO\RIFRXUVH
    +LJKILYHVHQVHUHVROXWLRQVKHVDLGDSSURSULDWHO\DZHG,FDQWJHW
    PLQHWKDWFOHDU,VWLOOGRQWNQRZKRZ\RXGRLW
    0DUTWKRXJKW0\6DUNFRQWDFWV,NQRZ\RXKDYHVRPHWRR
    +H\VKHVDLG:KDW+HJULQQHGZLWKJOHHDVKHUPRXWKIHOORSHQ

    DQGVKHVWDUHGDWWKHLPDJHRIKHU-RDQQH[WWRKLV9ROWDLUHIUHH]HIUDPH
    GDWDVWUHDPVLQLWLDOL]HGEXWQRW\HWUXQQLQJLQWHUDFWLYHO\
    +HUH[SUHVVLRQPLQJOHGDGPLUDWLRQZLWKIHDU:HUHQRWVXSSRVHGWR
    EULQJWKHPRQWRJHWKHUQRWWLOOWKH\PHHWLQWKHFROLVHXP
    :KRVD\V",WVQRWLQRXUFRQWUDFW
    +DVWRUZLOOVNHZHUXVDQ\ZD\
    0D\EHLIKHILQGVRXW:DQWPHWRVHFWLRQKHURII"
    +HUPRXWKWZLVWHGSUHWWLO\2IFRXUVHQRW:KDWWKHKHOOLWVGRQH
    $FWLYDWH
    ,NQHZ\RXGJRIRULW:HUHWKHDUWLVWVZHPDNHWKHGHFLVLRQV
    +DYHZHJRWWKHUXQQLQJFDSDFLW\WRPDNHWKHPUHDOWLPH"
    +HQRGGHG,WOOFRVWEXWVXUH$QG,YHJRWDOLWWOHSURSRVLWLRQ
    IRU\RX
    8KRK +HUEURZDUFKHG)RUELGGHQQRGRXEW
    +HZDLWHGMXVWWRWDQWDOL]HKHU$QGWRMXGJHIURPKHUUHDFWLRQKRZ
    UHFHSWLYHVKHGEHLIKHWULHGWRFKDQJHWKHQDWXUHRIWKHLUORQJVWDQGLQJ
    SODWRQLFUHODWLRQVKLS+HKDGWULHGRQFHEHIRUH+HUUHMHFWLRQVKHZDV
    PDUULHGRQDGHFDGHFRQWUDFWVKHJHQWO\UHPLQGHGKLPRQO\PDGHKLPGHVLUH
    KHUPRUH$OOWKDWDQGIDLWKIXOLQPDUULDJHWRR(QRXJKWRPDNHWKHWHHWK
    JULQGZKLFKWKH\KDGIUHTXHQWO\2IFRXUVHWKH\FRXOGEHUHSODFHGIRUOHVV
    WKDQWKHSULFHRIDQKRXUZLWKDJRRGWKHUDSLVW
    +HUERG\ODQJXDJHQRZDVOLJKWSXOOLQJDZD\WROGKLPVKHZDVVWLOO
    PRXUQLQJKHUGHDGKXVEDQG+HZDVSUHSDUHGWRZDLWWKHFXVWRPDU\\HDUEXW
    RQO\LIKHKDGWR
    :KDWVD\ZHJLYHERWKRIWKHPPDVVLYHILOHVIDUEH\RQG%DVLV6WDWH
    KHVDLGTXLFNO\5HDOO\JLYHWKHPVROLGNQRZOHGJHRIZKDW7UDQWRUVOLNHWKH
    (PSLUHHYHU\WKLQJ
    ,PSRVVLEOH
    1RMXVWH[SHQVLYH
    6RPXFK
    6RZKDW"-XVWWKLQNDERXWLW:HNQRZZKDWWKHVHWZR3ULPRUGLDOV
    UHSUHVHQWHGHYHQLIZHGRQWNQRZZKDWZRUOGWKH\FDPHIURP
    7KHLUVWUDWDPHPRULHVVD\(DUWKUHPHPEHU"
    0DUTVKUXJJHG6R"'R]HQVRISULPLWLYHZRUOGVFDOOHGWKHPVHOYHVWKDW
    2KWKHZD\3ULPLWLYHVFDOOWKHPVHOYHVWKH3HRSOH"
    6XUH7KHZKROHIRONWDOHLVZURQJDVWURSK\VLFDOO\WRR7KLVOHJHQGRI
    WKHRULJLQDOSODQHWLVSUHWW\FOHDURQRQHSRLQWWKHZRUOGZDVPRVWO\RFHDQV
    6RZK\FDOOLW(DUWK"
    6KHQRGGHG*UDQWHGWKH\UHGHOXGHG$QGWKH\KDYHQRVROLGGDWDEDVHV
    DERXWDVWURQRP\,FKHFNHGWKDW%XWORRNDWWKHLU6RFLDO&RQWH[WUHDGLQJV
    7KHVHWZRVWRRGIRUFRQFHSWVHWHUQDOLGHDV)DLWKDQG5HDVRQ
    0DUTEDOOHGERWKILVWVLQHQWKXVLDVPDER\LVKJHVWXUH5LJKW2QWRS
    RIWKDWZHOOSXPSLQZKDWZHNQRZWRGD\SVHXGRQDWXUDOVHOHFWLRQ
    SV\FKRSKLORVRSK\JHQHGHVWLQLHV
    %RNHUZLOOQHYHUJRIRULW6\E\OVDLG,WVSUHFLVHO\PRGHP
    LQIRUPDWLRQWKH3UHVHUYHUVRI2XU)DWKHUV)DLWKGRQWZDQW7KH\ZDQWWKH
    KLVWRULFDO0DLGSXUHDQGXQFRQWDPLQDWHGE\PRGHPLGHDV,GKDYHWRSURJUDP
    KHUWRUHDG
    $FLQFK
    ZULWHKDQGOHKLJKHUPDWKHPDWLFV*LYHPHDEUHDN
    'R\RXREMHFWRQHWKLFDOJURXQGV"2UVLPSO\WRDYRLGDIHZPHDVO\
    FHQWXULHVRIZRUN"
    (DV\IRU\RXWRVD\<RXU9ROWDLUHKDVDQHVVHQWLDOO\PRGHPPLQG
    :KRHYHUPDGHKLPKDGKLVRZQZRUNGR]HQVRIELRJUDSKLHV0\0DLGLVDVPXFK
    P\WKDVVKHLVIDFW6RPHERG\UHFUHDWHGKHURXWRIWKLQDLU
    7KHQ\RXUREMHFWLRQVEDVHGRQOD]LQHVVQRWSULQFLSOH
    ,WVEDVHGRQERWK

    :LOO\RXDWOHDVWJLYHLWVRPHWKRXJKW"
    ,MXVWGLG7KHDQVZHULVQR
    0DUTVLJKHG1RXVHDUJXLQJ<RXOOVHHRQFHZHOHWWKHPLQWHUDFW
    +HUPRRGVHHPHGWRVZLQJIURPUHVLVWDQFHWRH[FLWHPHQWLQKHU
    HQWKXVLDVPVKHHYHQWRXFKHGKLVOHJILQJHUVOLQJHULQJ+HIHOWKHU
    DIIHFWLRQDWHWDSMXVWDVWKH\RSHQHG LQWRWKHVLPVSDFH
    

    :KDWVJRLQJRQKHUH"9ROWDLUHURVHKDQGVRQKLSVFKDLUWRSSOLQJ
    EDFNEHKLQGKLPFODWWHULQJRQVWRQHDQGSHHUHGGRZQDWWKHPIURPWKHVFUHHQ
    :KRDUH\RX":KDWLQIHUQDODJHQF\GR\RXUHSUHVHQW"
    0DUTVWRSSHGWKHVLPDQGWXUQHGWR6\E\O8KGR\RXZDQWWRH[SODLQLW
    WRKLP"
    +HV\RXUUHFUHDWLRQQRWPLQH
    ,YHGUHDGHGWKLV9ROWDLUHZDVLPSRVLQJ+HH[XGHGSRZHUDQGHOHFWULF
    FRQILGHQFH6RPHKRZLQDOOKLVPLFURVFRSLFLQVSHFWLRQVRIWKLVVLPWKHVXP
    RILWDOO WKLVJHVWDOWHVVHQFHKDGQHYHUFRPHWKURXJK
    :HZRUNHGKDUGRQWKLV,I\RXVWDOOQRZ
    0DUTEUDFHGKLPVHOI5LJKWULJKW
    +RZGR\RXORRNWRKLP"
    ,PDGHP\VHOIPDWHULDOL]HZDONRYHUVLWGRZQ
    +HVDZ\RXFRPHRXWRIQRWKLQJ"
    ,JXHVVVRKHVDLGFKDJULQHG 6KRRNKLPXS
    0DUTKDGXVHGHYHU\WHPSHUDPHQWIDEULFDWLRQKHKDGWULPPLQJDQGVKDSLQJ
    PRRGFRQVWHOODWLRQVEXWKHKDGOHIWLQWDFW9ROWDLUHVFHQWUDOFRUH:KDWD
    KDUGEDOONQRWLWZDV6RPHSURJUDPPHURISUHDQWLTXLW\KDGGRQHDVWDUWOLQJ
    GHQVHMRE*LQJHUO\KHGLSSHGWKH9ROWDLUHVLPLQWRDFRORUOHVVYRLGRI
    VHQVRU\VWDWLF6RRWKHWKHQVOLGH
    +LVILQJHUVGDQFHG+HFXWLQWKHWLPHDFFHOHUDWLRQ
    6LPSHUVRQDOLWLHVQHHGHGFRPSXWDWLRQDOGXUDWLRQVWRDVVLPLODWHQHZ
    H[SHULHQFH+HWKUXVW9ROWDLUHLQWRDFOXWWHUHGVHHPLQJO\UHDOH[SHULHQFH
    QHW7KHSHUVRQDOLW\UHDFWHGWRWKHVLPXODWLRQDQGUDFHGWKURXJKWKHLQGXFHG
    HPRWLRQV9ROWDLUHZDVUDWLRQDOKLVSHUVRQDOLW\FRXOGDFFHSWQHZLGHDVWKDW
    WRRNWKH-RDQVLPIDUORQJHU
    :KDWGLGDOOWKLVGRWRDUHFRQVWUXFWLRQRIDUHDOSHUVRQZKHQ
    NQRZOHGJHRIDGLIIHUHQWUHDOLW\GDZQHG"+HUHFDPHWKHWULFN\SDUWRIWKH
    UHDQLPDWLRQ$FFHSWDQFHRIZKRZKDWZKHQWKH\ZHUH
    &RQFHSWXDOVKRFNZDYHVZRXOGUHVRXQGWKURXJKWKHGLJLWDOSHUVRQDOLWLHV
    IRUFLQJHPRWLRQDODGMXVWPHQWV&RXOGWKH\WDNHLW"7KHVHZHUHQWUHDOSHRSOH
    DIWHUDOODQ\PRUHWKDQDQDEVWUDFWLPSUHVVLRQLVWSDLQWLQJSUHWHQGHGWRWHOO
    \RXZKDWDFRZORRNHGOLNH1RZKHDQG6\E\OFRXOGVWHSLQRQO\DIWHUWKH
    DXWRPDWLFSURJUDPVKDGGRQHWKHLUEHVW
    +HUHWKHLUPDWKFUDIWPHWLWVWHVW$UWLILFLDOSHUVRQDOLWLHVKDGWR
    VXUYLYHWKLVFXVSSRLQWRUFUDVKLQWRLQVDQLW\DQGLQFRKHUHQFH5DFLQJDORQJ
    KLJKZD\VRIH[SDQGLQJSHUFHSWLRQWKHRQWRORJLFDOVZHUYHVFRXOGMROWD
    FRQVWUXFWVRKDUGLWVKDWWHUHG
    +HOHWWKHPPHHWHDFKRWKHUZDWFKLQJFDUHIXOO\7KH$X['HX[0DJRWV
    VLPSOHWRZQDQGFURZGEDFNGURS7RVKDYHFRPSXWLQJWLPHZHDWKHUUHSHDWHG
    HYHU\WZRPLQXWHVRIVLPWLPH&ORXGOHVVVN\WRVDYHRQIOXLGIORZPRGHOLQJ
    6\E\OWLQNHUHGZLWKKHU-RDQKHZLWKKLV9ROWDLUHVPRRWKLQJDQGURXQGLQJ
    VPDOOFUDFNVDQGVOLSSDJHVLQWKHFKDUDFWHUSHUFHSWXDOPDWUL[
    7KH\PHWVSRNH6RPHVNLWWHULQJEOXHZKLWHVWRUPVVZHSWWKURXJK
    9ROWDLUHVQHXURQDOVLPXODWLRQV0DUTVHQWLQFRQFHSWXDOUHSDLUDOJRULWKPV
    7XUEXOHQFHODSSHGDZD\
    *RWLWKHZKLVSHUHG6\E\OQRGGHGEHVLGHKLPLQWHQWRQKHURZQ
    VPRRWKLQJIXQFWLRQV

    +HVUXQQLQJUHJXODUQRZ0DUTVDLGIHHOLQJEHWWHUDERXWWKHVWDUWXS
    PLVWDNH,OONHHSP\PDQLIHVWDWLRQVLWWLQJULJKW"1RGLVDSSHDUDQFHVRU
    DQ\WKLQJ
    -RDQVFOHDUHGXS6\E\OSRLQWHGDWEURZQVWULDWLRQVLQWKHPDWUL[
    UHSUHVHQWDWLRQWKDWIORDWHGLQ'EHIRUHKHU6RPHHPRWLRQDOWHFWRQLFVEXW
    WKH\OOWDNHWLPH
    ,VD\JR
    6KHVPLOHG/HWV
    7KHPRPHQWFDPH0DUTVXFNHG9ROWDLUHDQG-RDQEDFNLQWRUHDOWLPH
    :LWKLQDPLQXWHKHNQHZWKDW9ROWDLUHZDVVWLOOLQWDFWIXQFWLRQDO
    LQWHJUDWHG6RZDV-RDQWKRXJKVKHKDGUHWUHDWHGLQWRKHUSHQVLYHZLWKGUDZDO
    PRGHDQDVSHFWZHOOGRFXPHQWHGKHULQWHUQDOZHDWKHU
    9ROWDLUHWKRXJKZDVLUNHG+HVZHOOHGOLIHVL]HGEHIRUHWKHP7KH
    KRORJUDPVFRZOHGVZRUHDQGORXGO\GHPDQGHGWKHULJKWWRLQLWLDWH
    FRPPXQLFDWLRQZKHQHYHUKHOLNHG
    <RXWKLQN,ZDQWWREHDW \RXUPHUF\ZKHQHYHU,YHVRPHWKLQJWRVD\"
    <RXUHWDONLQJWRDPDQZKRZDVH[LOHGFHQVRUHGMDLOHGVXSSUHVVHGZKR
    OLYHGLQFRQVWDQWIHDURIFKXUFKDQGVWDWHDXWKRULWLHV
    )LUHWKH0DLGZKLVSHUHGZLWKHHULHVHQVXDOLW\
    &DOPGRZQ0DUTRUGHUHG9ROWDLUHRU,OOVKXW\RXRII+HIUR]H
    DFWLRQDQGWXUQHGWR6\E\O:KDWGR\RXWKLQN"6KRXOGZHFRPSO\"
    :K\QRW"VKHVDLG,WVQRWIDLUIRUWKHPWREHIRUHYHUDWRXUEHFN
    DQGFDOO
    )DLU"7KLVLVDVLP
    7KH\KDYHQRWLRQVRIIDLUQHVV,IZHYLRODWHWKRVH
    2ND\RND\+HVWDUWHGDFWLRQDJDLQ7KHQH[WTXHVWLRQLVKRZ
    ,GRQWFDUHKRZ\RXGRLWWKHKRORJUDPVDLG-XVWGRLWDWRQFH
    +ROGRII0DUTVDLG:HOOOHW\RXKDYHUXQQLQJWLPHWRLQWHJUDWH
    \RXUSHUFHSWLRQVSDFH
    :KDWGRHVWKDWPHDQ"9ROWDLUHDVNHG$UWIXOH[SUHVVLRQLVRQHWKLQJ
    MDUJRQDQRWKHU
    7RZRUNRXW\RXUNLQNV0DUTUHSOLHGGU\O\
    6RWKDWZHFDQFRQYHUVH"
    <HV6\E\OVDLG$W\RXULQLWLDWLRQQRWMXVWRXUV'RQWJRIRUD
    ZDONDWWKHVDPHWLPHWKRXJKWKDWUHTXLUHVWRRPXFKGDWDVKXIIOLQJ
    :HUHWU\LQJWRKROGFRVWVGRZQKHUH0DUTVDLGOHDQLQJEDFNVRKH
    FRXOGJHWDEHWWHUYLHZRI6\E\OVOHJV
    :HOOKXUU\XSWKH9ROWDLUHLPDJHVDLG3DWLHQFHLVIRUPDUW\UVDQG
    VDLQWVQRWIRUPHQRIEHOOHVOHWWUHV
    7KHWUDQVODWRUUHQGHUHGDOOWKLVLQSUHVHQWODQJXDJHLQVHUWLQJWKH
    DXGLRRIDQFLHQWORVWZRUGV.QRZOHGJHIHWFKHUVIRXQGWKHWUDQVODWLRQDQG
    RYHUODLGLWIRU0DUTDQG6\E\O6WLOO0DUTKDGOHIWLQWKHVOLSSHU\QDWXUDO
    DFRXVWLFVIRUDWPRVSKHUHWKHWHQRURIWKHXQLPDJLQDEO\GLVWDQWSDVW
    -XVWVD\P\QDPHRU6\E\OVDQGZHOODSSHDUWR\RXLQDUHFWDQJOH
    ULPPHGLQUHG
    0XVWLWEHUHG"7KH0DLGVYRLFHZDVIUDLO&DQ\RXQRWPDNHLWEOXH"
    %OXHLVVRFRROWKHFRORURIWKHVHD:DWHULVVWURQJHUWKDQILUHFDQSXW
    ILUHRXW
    6WRSEDEEOLQJWKHRWKHUKRORJUDPVQDSSHG+HEHFNRQHGWRDPHFKZDLWHU
    DQGVDLG7KDWIODPEpGLVKWKHUHSXWLWRXWDWRQFH,WVXSVHWWLQJWKH
    0DLG$QG\RXWZRJHQLXVHVRXWWKHUH,I\RXFDQUHVXUUHFWWKHGHDG\RX
    FHUWDLQO\VKRXOGEHDEOHWRFKDQJHUHGWREOXH
    ,GRQWEHOLHYHWKLVVDLG6\E\O$VLP":KRGRHVKHWKLQNKHLV"
    7KHYRLFHRIUHDVRQ0DUTUHSOLHG)UDQFRLV0DULH$URXHWGH
    9ROWDLUH
    'R\RXWKLQNWKH\UHUHDG\WRVHH%RNHU"6\E\OFKHZHGSUHWWLO\DWKHU
    OLS:HDJUHHGWROHWKLPLQWRWKHVLPDVVRRQDVWKH\ZHUHVWDELOL]HG

    0DUTWKRXJKW/HWVSOD\LWVTXDUHDQGOLQHDUZLWKKLP,OOFDOO
    :HKDYHVRPXFKWROHDUQIURPWKHP
    7UXH:KRFRXOGKDYHJXHVVHGWKDWSUHKLVWRULFDOVFRXOGEHVXFK
    EDVWDUGV"
    

    6KHWULHGWRLJQRUHWKHVRUFHUHVVFDOOHG6\E\OZKRFODLPHGWREHKHU
    FUHDWRUDVLIDQ\RQHEXWWKH.LQJRI+HDYHQFRXOGOD\FODLPWRVXFKDIHDW
    6KHGLGQWIHHOOLNHWDONLQJWRDQ\RQH(YHQWVFURZGHGLQUXVKHGGHQVH
    VXIIRFDWLQJ+HUFKRNLQJSDLQVKRWGHDWKVWLOOVZDUPHGDERXWKHU
    2QWKHGXQFHVFDSWKHRQHWKH\GVHWXSRQKHUVKDYHQKHDGRQWKDW
    ILHU\GD\WKHGDUNHVWDQG\HWPRVWJORULRXVGD\RIKHUVKRUWOLIHKHU
    FULPHVZHUHLQVFULEHGLQWKHKRO\WRQJXH+HUHWLFD5HODSVD$SRVWDWD
    ,GRODWHU%ODFNZRUGVVRRQWRLJQLWH
    7KHOHDUQHGFDUGLQDOVDQGELVKRSVRIWKHIRXO(QJOLVKORYLQJ8QLYHUVLW\
    RI3DULVDQGRIWKH&KXUFK&KULVWVEULGH RQHDUWKKDGVHWKHUOLYLQJERG\
    RQILUH$OOIRUFDUU\LQJRXWWKH/RUGVZLOOWKDWWKH*UHDWDQG7UXH.LQJ
    VKRXOGEH+LVPLQLVWHULQ)UDQFH)RUWKDWWKH\KDGUHMHFWHGWKHNLQJV
    UDQVRPDQGVHQWKHUWRWKHVHDULQJS\UH:KDWWKHQPLJKWWKH\QRWGRWRWKLV
    VRUFHUHVVFDOOHG6\E\OZKROLNHKHUGZHOWDPRQJPHQZRUHPHQVDWWLUHDQG
    FODLPHGIRUKHUVHOISRZHUVWKDWHFOLSVHGWKRVHRIWKH&UHDWRU+LPVHOI"
    3OHDVHJRDZD\VKHPXUPXUHG,PXVWKDYHVLOHQFHLI,DPWRKHDUP\
    YRLFHV
    %XWQHLWKHU/D 6RUFLqUHQRUWKHEHDUGHGPDQLQEODFNQDPHG%RNHUZKR
    UHVHPEOHGXQFDQQLO\WKHJORZHULQJSDWULDUFKVRQWKHGRPHGFHLOLQJRIWKHJUHDW
    FKXUFKDW5RXHQZRXOGOHDYHKHUDORQH
    6KHLPSORUHGWKHP,I\RXPXVWWDONQDWWHUDW0RQVLHXU$URXHW7KDW
    RQHOLNHV QRWKLQJPRUH
    6DFUHG0DLG5RVHRI)UDQFHVDLGWKHEHDUGHGRQHZDV)UDQFH\RXU
    ZRUOG"
    0\VWDWLRQLQWKHZRUOG-RDQVDLG
    <RXUSODQHW,PHDQ
    3ODQHWVDUHLQWKHVN\,ZDVRIWKHHDUWK
    ,PHDQRKQHYHUPLQG+HVSRNHVRXQGOHVVO\ WRWKHZRPDQ6\E\O2I
    WKHJURXQG")DUPHUV"&RXOGHYHQSUHKLVWRULFDOVEHVRLJQRUDQW"DSSDUHQWO\
    WKLQNLQJVKHFRXOGQRWUHDGOLSVDWULFNVKHKDGPDVWHUHGWRGLYLQHWKH
    GHOLEHUDWLRQVRIFKXUFKO\WULEXQDOV
    -RDQVDLG,NQRZZKDWLVVXIILFLHQWWRP\FKDUJH
    %RNHUIURZQHGWKHQUXVKHGRQ3OHDVHKHDUPHRXW2XUFDXVHLVMXVW
    7KHIDWHRIWKHVDFUHGGHSHQGVXSRQRXUZLQQLQJWRRXUVLGHPDQ\FRQYHUWV,I
    ZHDUHWRXSKROGWKHYHVVHORIKXPDQLW\DQGWLPHKRQRUHGWUDGLWLRQVRIRXU
    YHU\LGHQWLW\ZHPXVWGHIHDW6HFXODU6NHSWLFLVP
    6KHWULHGWRWXUQDZD\EXWWKHFODQNLQJZHLJKWRIKHUFKDLQVVWRSSHG
    KHU/HDYHPHDORQH$OWKRXJK,NLOOHGQRRQH,IRXJKWLQPDQ\FRPEDWVWR
    DVVXUHWKHYLFWRU\RI)UDQFHV*UHDW7UXH.LQJ,SUHVLGHGRYHUKLVFRURQDWLRQ
    DW5KHLPV,ZDVZRXQGHGLQEDWWOHIRUKLVVDNH
    6KHKHOGXSKHUZULVWVIRUVKHZDVQRZLQWKHIRXOFHOODW5RXHQLQ
    OHJLURQVDQGFKDLQV6\E\OKDGVDLGWKLVZRXOGDQFKRUKHUEHJRRGIRUKHU
    FKDUDFWHULQVRPHZD\$VDQDQJHO6\E\OZDVQRGRXEWFRUUHFW%RNHUEHJDQWR
    LPSORUHKHUEXW-RDQVXPPRQHGVWUHQJWKWRVD\7KHZRUOGNQRZVKRZ,ZDV
    UHTXLWHGIRUP\SDLQV,VKDOOZDJHZDUQRPRUH
    0RQVLHXU%RNHUWXUQHGWRWKHVRUFHUHVV$VDFULOHJHWRNHHSDJUHDW
    ILJXUHLQFKDLQV&DQW\RXWUDQVSRUWKHUWRVRPHSODFHRIWKHRORJLFDOUHVW"$
    FDWKHGUDO"
    &RQWH[W6LPVQHHGFRQWH[W/D6RUFLqUHVDLGZLWKRXWVRXQG-RDQIRXQG
    VKHFRXOGUHDGOLSVZLWKDFODULW\VKHKDGQHYHUNQRZQ3HUKDSVWKLV3XUJDWRU\

    LPSURYHGLWVFKDUJHV
    0RQVLHXU%RNHUFOXFNHG,DPLPSUHVVHGZLWKZKDW\RXYHGRQHEXW
    XQOHVV\RXFDQPDNHKHUFRRSHUDWHZKDWJRRGLVVKHWRXV"
    <RXKDYHQWVHHQKHUDWWKHVXPPLWRIKHU6HOIKRRG7KHIHZKLVWRULFDO
    DVVRFLDWLRQVZHKDYHEHHQDEOHWRGHFLSKHUFODLPWKDWVKHZDVDPHVPHUL]LQJ
    SUHVHQFH:HOOKDYHWREULQJWKDWRXW
    &DQ\RXQRWPDNHKHUVPDOOHU",WVLPSRVVLEOHWRWDONWRDJLDQW
    7KH0DLGWRKHUDVWRQLVKPHQWVKUDQNE\WZRWKLUGVLQKHLJKW
    0RQVLHXU%RNHUVHHPHGSOHDVHG*UHDW-RDQ\RXPLVXQGHUVWDQGWKHQDWXUH
    RIWKHZDUWKDWOLHVDKHDG8QFRXQWDEOHPLOOHQQLDKDYHSDVVHGVLQFH\RXU
    DVFHQVLRQLQWRKHDYHQ<RX
    7KH0DLGVDWXS7HOOPHRQHWKLQJ,VWKHNLQJRI)UDQFHDGHVFHQGDQW
    RIWKH(QJOLVK+HQU\V+RXVHRI/DQFDVWHU"2ULVKHD9DORLV GHVFHQGHGIURP
    WKH*UHDWDQG7UXH.LQJ&KDUOHV"
    0RQVLHXU%RNHUEOLQNHGDQGWKRXJKW,,WKLQNLWPD\EHWUXO\VDLG
    WKDWZH3UHVHUYHUVRI2XU)DWKHUV)DLWKWKHSDUW\,UHSUHVHQWDUHLQD
    PDQQHURIVSHDNLQJGHVFHQGDQWVRI\RXU&KDUOHV
    7KH0DLGVPLOHG6KHNQHZKHUYRLFHVKDGEHHQKHDYHQVHQWQRPDWWHU
    ZKDWWKHELVKRSVVDLG6KHGRQO\GHQLHGWKHPZKHQWKH\WRRNKHUWRWKH
    FHPHWHU\RI6W2XHQDQGWKHQRQO\IRUIHDURIWKHILUH6KHGEHHQULJKWWR
    UHFDQWKHUUHFDQWDWLRQWZRGD\VODWHUWKH/DQFDVWULDQIDLOXUHWRDQQH[)UDQFH
    FRQILUPHGWKDW,I0RQVLHXU%RNHUVSRNHIRUGHVFHQGDQWVRIWKH+RXVHRI
    9DORLVGHVSLWHKLVFOHDUDEVHQFHRIDQREOHWLWOHVKHZRXOGKHDUKLPRXW
    3URFHHGVKHVDLG
    0RQVLHXU%RNHUH[SODLQHGWKDWWKLVSODFHZDVVRRQWRKROGDUHIHUHQGXP
    $IWHUVRPHGHOLEHUDWLRQZLWKOD6RUFLqUHKHDGYLVHGWKDW-RDQVKRXOGWKLQN
    RIWKLVSODFHDV)UDQFHLQHVVHQFH 7KHFRQWHVWZRXOGEHEHWZHHQWZRPDMRU
    SDUWLHV3UHVHUYHUVYV6NHSWLFV%RWKSDUWLHVKDGDJUHHGWRKROGD*UHDW
    'HEDWH EHWZHHQWZRYHUEDOGXHOLVWVWRIUDPHWKHVDOLHQWTXHVWLRQ
    :KDWLVVXH"WKH0DLGDVNHGVKDUSO\
    :KHWKHUPHFKDQLFDOEHLQJVHQGRZHGZLWKDUWLILFLDOLQWHOOLJHQFHVKRXOG
    EHEXLOW$QGLIVRVKRXOGWKH\EHDOORZHGIXOOFLWL]HQVKLSZLWKDOO
    DWWHQGDQWULJKWV
    7KH0DLGVKUXJJHG$MRNH"2QO\DULVWRFUDWVDQGQREOHPHQKDYHULJKWV
    1RWDQ\PRUHWKRXJKRIFRXUVHZHGRKDYHDFODVVV\VWHP1RZWKHFRPPRQ
    ORWHQMR\ULJKWV
    3HDVDQWVOLNHPH"WKH0DLGDVNHG:H"
    0RQVLHXU%RNHUIDFHDPRYLQJIOXUU\RIH[DVSHUDWHGVFRZOVWXUQHGWR/D
    6RUFLqUH0XVW,GRHYHU\WKLQJ"
    <RXZDQWHGKHUDVLV/D6RUFLqUHVDLG2UUDWKHUDVZDV
    0RQVLHXU%RNHUVSHQWWZRPLQXWHVUDQWLQJDERXWVRPHWKLQJKHFDOOHGWKH
    &RQFHSWXDO6KLIW7KLVWHUPPHDQWDQDSSDUHQWO\WKHRORJLFDOGLVSXWHDERXWWKH
    QDWXUHRIPHFKDQLFDODUWLILFH7R-RDQWKHDQVZHUVHHPHGFOHDUEXWWKHQVKH
    ZDVDZRPDQRIWKHILHOGVQRWDZRUGDUWLVDQ
    :K\GRQW\RXDVN\RXUNLQJ"2QHRIKLVFRXQVHORUV"2URQHRI\RXU
    OHDUQHGPHQ"
    0RQVLHXU%RNHUFXUOHGKLVOLSGLVPLVVLYHO\IDQQHGWKHDLU2XUOHDGHUV
    DUHSDOOLG:HDN5DWLRQDOGRRUPDWV
    6XUHO\
    <RXFDQQRWLPDJLQHFRPLQJIURPDQFLHQWSDVVLRQ,QWHQVLW\DQGSDVVLRQ
    DUHUHJDUGHGDVEDGIRUPRXWRIVW\OH:HZLVKHGWRILQGLQWHOOHFWVZLWKWKH
    ROGILUHWKH
    1R2K7KHIODPHVOLFNLQJ
    ,WZDVVRPHPRPHQWVEHIRUHKHUEUHDWKLQJFDOPHGDQGVKHFRXOGVKDNLO\
    OLVWHQDJDLQ
    7KHJUHDWGHEDWHEHWZHHQ)DLWKDQG5HDVRQZRXOGEHKHOGLQWKH&ROLVHXP
    RI-XQLQ6HFWRUEHIRUHDQDXGLHQFHRIVRXOV7KH0DLGDQGKHURSSRQHQW

    ZRXOGDSSHDULQKRORJUDPVPDJQLILHGE\DIDFWRURIWKLUW\(DFKFLWL]HQZRXOG
    WKHQYRWHRQWKHTXHVWLRQ
    9RWH"WKH0DLGLQTXLUHG
    <RXZDQWHGKHUXQFRUUXSWHG/D6RUFLqUHVDLG<RXJRWKHU
    7KH0DLGOLVWHQHGLQVLOHQFHIRUFHGWRDEVRUEPLOOHQQLDLQPLQXWHV
    :KHQ0RQVLHXU%RNHUILQLVKHGVKHVDLG,H[FHOOHGLQEDWWOHLIRQO\IRUD
    EULHIWLPHEXWQHYHULQDUJXPHQW1RGRXEW\RXNQRZRIP\IDWH
    0RQVLHXU%RNHUORRNHGSDLQHG7KHYDJXHULHVRIWKHDQFLHQWV:HKDYHD
    VNLPS\KLVWRULFDOIUDPHDURXQG\RXUDKUHSUHVHQWDWLRQQRPRUH:HNQRZQRW
    ZKDWSODFH\RXOLYHGEXWZHGRNQRZPLQXWLDHRIHYHQWVDIWHU\RXU
    'HDWK<RXFDQVSHDNRILW,DPDFFXVWRPHGWRLWDVDQ\&KULVWLDQ
    PDLGHQVKRXOGEHXSRQDUULYDOLQ3XUJDWRU\,NQRZZKR\RXWZRDUHDVZHOO
    /D6RUFLqUHDVNHGFDXWLRXVO\<RXGR"
    $QJHOV<RXPDQLIHVW\RXUVHOYHVDVRUGLQDU\IRONWRFDOPP\IHDUV
    7KHQ\RXVHWPHDWDVN(YHQLILWLQYROYHVWKHURJXLVKLWLVDGLYLQH
    PLVVLRQ
    0RQVLHXU%RNHUQRGGHGVORZO\JODQFLQJDW/D6RUFLqUH)URPWKHWDWWHUV
    RIGDWDIODSSLQJDERXW\RXU6HOIZHJDWKHUWKDW\RXUUHSXWDWLRQZDVUHVWRUHG
    DWKHDULQJVKHOGWZHQW\VL[\HDUVDIWHU\RXUGHDWK7KRVHLQYROYHGLQ\RXU
    FRQGHPQDWLRQUHSHQWHGRIWKHLUPLVWDNH<RXZHUHFDOOHGLQKLJKHVWHHP/D
    5RVHGHODZLUH
    6KHEOLQNHGEDFNZLVWIXOWHDUV-XVWLFH+DG,EHHQVNLOOHGLQ
    DUJXPHQW,GKDYHFRQYLQFHGP\LQTXLVLWRUVWKRVH(QJOLVKORYLQJSUHDFKHUVRI
    WKH8QLYHUVLW\RI3DULVWKDW, DPQRWDZLWFK
    0RQVLHXU%RNHUVHHPHGPRYHG(YHQSUHDQWLTXLW\NQHZZKHQDKRO\SRZHU
    ZDVZLWKWKHP
    7KH0DLGODXJKHGOLJKWKHDUWHG7KH/RUGVRQWKHVLGHRI+LV6RQDQG
    WKHVDLQWVDQGPDUW\UVWRR%XWWKDWGRHVQRWPHDQWKH\HVFDSHIDLOXUHDQG
    GHDWK
    6KHVULJKW/D6RUFLqUHVDLG(YHQZRUOGVDQGJDOD[LHVVKDUHPDQV
    IDWH
    :HRIVSLULWXDOLW\QHHG\RX0RQVLHXU%RNHUSOHDGHG:HKDYHEHFRPH
    WRRPXFKOLNHRXUPDFKLQHV:HKROGQRWKLQJVDFUHGH[FHSWWKHVPRRWK
    IXQFWLRQLQJRIRXUSDUWV:HNQRZ\RXZLOODGGUHVVWKHTXHVWLRQZLWK
    LQWHQVLW\\HWLQVLPSOLFLW\DQGWUXWK7KDWLVDOOZHDVN
    7KH0DLGIHOWIDWLJXHG6KHQHHGHGVROLWXGHWLPHWRUHIOHFW,PXVW
    FRQVXOWZLWKP\YRLFHV:LOOWKHUHEHRQO\RQHRUPDQ\TXHVWLRQVWKDW,PXVW
    DGGUHVV"
    -XVWRQH
    7KHLQTXLVLWRUVKDGEHHQIDUPRUHGHPDQGLQJ7KH\DVNHGPDQ\TXHVWLRQV
    GR]HQVVRPHWLPHVWKHVDPHRQHVRYHUDQGRYHUDJDLQ5LJKWDQVZHUVDW
    3RLWLHUVSURYHGZURQJHOVHZKHUH'HSULYHGRIIRRGGULQNUHVWLQWLPLGDWHGE\
    WKHHQIRUFHGMRXUQH\WRWKHFHPHWHU\H[KDXVWHGE\WKHWHGLRXVVHUPRQWKH\
    FRPSHOOHGKHUWRKHDUDQGZUDFNHGE\WHUURURIWKHILUHVKHFRXOGQRW
    ZLWKVWDQGWKHLULQWHUURJDWLRQ
    'RHVWKH$UFKDQJHO0LFKDHOKDYHORQJKDLU"
    ,V6W0DUJDUHWVWRXWRUOHDQ"
    $UH6W&DWKHULQHVH\HVEURZQRUEOXH"
    7KH\WUDSSHGKHULQWRDVVLJQLQJWRYRLFHVRIWKHVSLULWDWWULEXWLRQVRI
    WKHIOHVK7KHQWKH\SHUYHUVHO\FRQGHPQHGKHUIRUFRQIRXQGLQJVDFUHGVSLULW
    ZLWKFRUUXSWIOHVK
    $OOKDGEHHQPLDVPD$QGLQ3XUJDWRU\ZRUVHWULDOVFRXOGHQVXH6KH
    FRXOGQRWWKHUHIRUHEHFHUWDLQLIWKLV%RNHUZRXOGWXUQRXWWREHIULHQGRU
    IRH
    :KDWLVLW"VKHZDQWHGWRNQRZ7KLVVLQJOHTXHVWLRQ\RXZDQWPHWR
    DQVZHU
    7KHUHLVXQLYHUVDOFRQVHQVXVWKDWPDQPDGHLQWHOOLJHQFHVKDYHDNLQGRI

    EUDLQ7KHTXHVWLRQZHZDQW\RXWRDQVZHULVZKHWKHUWKH\KDYHDVRXO
    2QO\WKH$OPLJKW\KDVWKHSRZHUWRFUHDWHDVRXO
    0RQVLHXU%RNHUVPLOHG:H3UHVHUYHUVFRXOGQWDJUHHZLWK\RXPRUH
    $UWLILFLDOLQWHOOLJHQFHVXQOLNHXVWKHLUFUHDWRUVKDYHQRVRXO7KH\UH
    MXVWPDFKLQHV0HFKDQLFDOFRQWULYDQFHVZLWKHOHFWURQLFDOO\SURJUDPPHGEUDLQV
    2QO\PDQKDVDVRXO
    ,I\RXDOUHDG\NQRZWKHDQVZHUWRWKHTXHVWLRQZK\GR\RXQHHGPH"
    7RSHUVXDGH)LUVWWKHXQGHFLGHGRI-XQLQ6HFWRUWKHQ7UDQWRUWKHQ
    WKH(PSLUH
    7KH0DLGUHIOHFWHG+HULQTXLVLWRUVKDGNQRZQWKHDQVZHUVWRWKH
    TXHVWLRQVWKH\SOLHGKHUZLWKWRR0RQVLHXU%RNHUVHHPHGVLQFHUHEXWWKHQVR
    ZHUHWKRVHZKRSURQRXQFHGKHUDZLWFK0RQVLHXU%RNHUKDGWROGKHUWKHDQVZHU
    EHIRUHKDQGRQHZLWKZKLFKDQ\VHQVLEOHSHUVRQZRXOGDJUHH6WLOOVKHFRXOG
    QRWEHVXUHRIKLVLQWHQWLRQV1RWHYHQWKHFUXFLIL[VKHDVNHGWKHSULHVWWR
    KROGDORIWZDVSURRIDJDLQVWWKHRLO\VPRNHWKHELWLQJIODPHV
    :HOO"DVNHG0RQVLHXU%RNHU:LOOWKH6DFUHG5RVHFRQVHQWWREHRXU
    FKDPSLRQ"
    7KHVHSHRSOH,PXVWFRQYLQFH$UHWKH\WRRGHVFHQGDQWVRI&KDUOHV
    WKH*UHDWDQG7UXH.LQJRIWKH+RXVHRI9DORLV"
    

    :KHQ0DUTVWURGHLQWR6SODVKHV 6QLIIVWRPHHWKLVEXGG\DQGFRZRUNHU
    1LPKHZDVVXUSULVHGWRILQG1LPDOUHDG\WKHUH7RMXGJHIURP1LPVGLODWHG
    SXSLOVKHGEHHQWKHUHPRVWRIWKHDIWHUQRRQ
    0DUTVDLG+LWWLQJLWKDUG"6RPHWKLQJJRLQJRQ"
    1LPVKRRNKLVKHDG6DPHROG0DUTEOXQWDVDILVW)LUVWWU\WKH
    6ZLUOVQRUW'RHVQWGRDWKLQJIRU\RXUWKLUVWLQIDFWLWZLOOGU\XS\RXU
    HQWLUHKHDGEXW\RXZRQWFDUH
    6ZLUOVQRUWWXUQHGRXWWREHDSRZGHU\FRQFRFWLRQWKDWWDVWHGOLNHQXWPHJ
    DQGELWDVLIKHKDGVZDOORZHGDQDQJU\LQVHFW0DUTVQLIIHGLWVORZO\RQH
    QRVWULODWDWLPH+HZDQWHGWREHUHODWLYHO\FOHDUKHDGHGZKHQ1LPXSGDWHGKLP
    RQRIILFHSROLWLFVDQGIXQGLQJ$IWHUWKDWKHGDOORZKLPVHOIWRJHWVN\HG
    <RXPD\QRWOLNHWKLVVDLG1LP,WFRQFHUQV6\E\O
    6\E\O+HODXJKHGDELWXQHDVLO\+RZG\RXNQRZ,
    <RXWROGPH/DVWWLPHZHKDGDVQRUWWRJHWKHUUHPHPEHU"
    2K7KHVWXIIPDGHKLPEDEEOH:RUVHLWPDGHKLPIRUJHWKHKDG
    1RWH[DFWO\DVWDWHVHFUHW1LPJULQQHG
    7KDWREYLRXV"+HZDQWHGWREHFHUWDLQ1LPZKRVZLWFKHGZRPHQDVRIWHQ
    DVKHFKDQJHGKLVXQGHUZHDUKDGQRGHVLJQVRQ6\E\ORIKLVRZQ:KDWDERXW
    KHU"
    :HOOWKHUHVDORWRIMXLFHZDLWLQJIRUZKRHYHUZLQVWKHELJRQHDW
    WKHFROLVHXP
    1RSUREOHP0DUTVDLG0H
    1LPUDQKLVKDQGWKURXJKKLVVWUDZEHUU\EORQGKDLU,FDQWGHFLGHLI
    LWV\RXUPRGHVW\RU\RXUDELOLW\WRIRUHVHHWKHIXWXUHWKDW,OLNHPRVWDERXW
    \RX<RXUPRGHVW\0XVWEHWKDW
    0DUTVKUXJJHG6KHVJRRG,OODGPLW
    %XW\RXUHEHWWHU
    ,POXFNLHU7KH\JDYHPH5HDVRQ6\E\OVVWXFNZLWK)DLWK
    1LPJDYHKLPDEHPXVHGJODQFHDQGLQKDOHGGHHSO\,ZRXOGQW
    XQGHUHVWLPDWH)DLWKLI,ZHUH\RX,WVKRRNHGWRSDVVLRQDQGQRRQHV
    PDQDJHGWRJHWULGRIHLWKHU\HW
    'RQWKDYHWR3DVVLRQVHYHQWXDOO\EXUQRXW
    %XWWKHOLJKWRIUHDVRQEXUQVHWHUQDOO\"
    ,I\RXUHJHQHUDWHEUDLQFHOOV\HV
    1LPORRNHGWKURXJKKLVVWUDZWRVHHLIDQ\WKLQJZDVOHIWDQGZLQNHGDW

    0DUT7KHQ\RXGRQWQHHGDOLWWOHDGYLFH
    :KDWDGYLFH",GLGQWKHDUDQ\DGYLFH
    1LPFOXFNHG,I\RXUXQUHJHQHUDWHGEUDLQFHOOVFRQWDLQDVKUHGRI
    FRPPRQVHQVH\RXOOVWRSFRRSHUDWLQJZLWK6\E\OWRLPSURYHKHUVLPXODWLRQ2U
    EHWWHU\HW\RXOONHHSSUHWHQGLQJ\RXUHFRRSHUDWLQJVR\RXJHWWKH EHQHILW
    RIDQ\WKLQJVKHFDQVKRZ\RX%XWZKDW\RXOOUHDOO\VWDUWGRLQJLVORRNLQJ
    IRUZD\VWRGRERWKKHUDQGKHUVLPXODWLRQLQ3HRSOHVD\LWVWHUULILF
    ,YHVHHQLW
    6RPHRILW7KLQNVKHVKRZVLWDOO"
    :HYHEHHQZRUNLQJHYHU\GD\RQ
    7UXQFDWHGVLPLVZKDW\RXVHH1LJKWVVKHLQIODWHVWKHZKROHSVHXGR
    SV\FKH
    0DUTIURZQHG+HNQHZKHZDVDELWOLJKWKHDGHGDURXQGKHUSKHURPRQHV
    GRLQJWKHLUMREEXWKHKDGFRPSHQVDWHGIRUWKDW+DGQWKH"6KHZRXOGQW
    6KHPLJKW3HRSOHXSVWDLUVJRWWKHLUH\HRQKHU
    0DUTIHOWDVWDERIMHDORXV\LQVSLWHRIKLPVHOIEXWKHZDVFDUHIXOQRW
    WRVKRZLW8PPP7KDQNV
    1LPERZHGKLVKHDGZLWKFKDUDFWHULVWLFLURQ\DQGVDLG(YHQLI\RX
    GRQWQHHGLW\RXGEHDIRROWRWXUQLWGRZQ
    :KDWWKHMXLFHZKHQ,ZLQ"
    1RWWKHMXLFHEXJJR<RXWKLQN,PLVVHGQRWLFLQJWKDW,PWDONLQJWR
    DPELWLRQVVODYH"0\DGYLFH
    0DUTWRRNDKHIW\GRXEOHQRVWULOVQRUW,OOFHUWDLQO\EHDULWLQ
    PLQG
    7KLVWKLQJVJRLQJWREHELJ<RXWKLQNLWVMXVWDMREIRUWKLV
    6HFWRUEXW,WHOO\RXSHRSOHIURPDOORYHU7UDQWRUZLOOWXQHLQWRWKHVKRZ
    $OOWKHEHWWHU0DUTVDLGWKRXJKKLVVWRPDFKZDVIHHOLQJOLNHKHKDG
    VXGGHQO\JRQHLQWRIUHHIDOO/LYLQJLQDUHDOFXOWXUDOUHQDLVVDQFHZDVULVN\
    0D\EHKLVKROORZIHHOLQJZDVWKHVWLPWKRXJK
    ,PHDQ6HOGRQDQGWKDWJX\ZKRIROORZVKLPDURXQGOLNHDGRJ$PDU\O
    \RXWKLQNWKH\YHERRWHGWKLVWR\RXEHFDXVHLWVDVQDS"
    0DUTWRRNDELWRIWKHVWLPEHIRUHDQVZHULQJ1RLWVEHFDXVH,PWKH
    EHVW
    $QG\RXUHDORQJZD\GRZQIURPWKHPRQWKHVWDWXVODGGHU<RXDUHP\
    IULHQGH[SHQGDEOH
    0DUTQRGGHGVREHUO\,OOFHUWDLQO\EHDULWLQPLQG
    :DVKHUHSHDWLQJKLPVHOI"0XVWEHWKHVWLP
    0DUTGLGQRWJLYH1LPVFRXQVHODQ\WKRXJKWXQWLOWZRGD\VODWHU+H
    RYHUKHDUGVRPHRQHLQWKHH[HFXWLYHORXQJHSUDLVLQJ6\E\OVZRUNWR+DVWRUWKH
    OHDGHURI$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHV+HVNLSSHGOXQFKDQGZHQWEDFNWRKLVIORRU$V
    KHSDVVHG6\E\OVRIILFHRQKLVZD\EDFNWRKLVRZQKLVLQWHQWLRQKHWROG
    KLPVHOI ZDVWRUHOD\WKHFRPSOLPHQW%XWZKHQKHIRXQGKHUGRRUXQORFNHGKHU
    RIILFHHPSW\DQLPSXOVHVHL]HGKLP
    +DOIDQKRXUODWHUKHMXPSHGVOLJKWO\ZKHQVKHVDLG0DUTIURPWKH
    RSHQGRRUZD\+HUKDQGVPRRWKHGKHUKDLULQZKDWKHWRRNWREHXQFRQVFLRXV
    SULPSLQJEHWUD\LQJDGHVLUHWRSOHDVH&DQ,KHOS\RX"
    +HGMXVWILQLVKHGWKHVRIWZDUHFURVVPDWWLQJWROLQNKHURIILFHVR
    WKDWKHGEHDEOHWRPRQLWRUKHULQWHUYLHZVZLWKKHUFOLHQW%RNHU6KHVKDUHG
    ZLWK0DUTWKHVXEVWDQFHRIWKHVHLQWHUYLHZVDV IDUDVKHNQHZ
    +HUHDVRQHGWKDWKLVVXJJHVWLRQVDVWRKRZVKHVKRXOGKDQGOHWKH
    VRPHWLPHVGLIILFXOW%RNHUZRXOGEHLPSURYHGLIKHZHUHH[SRVHGWR%RNHU
    GLUHFWO\%XWWKDWZRXOGFRPSURPLVHWKHFOLHQWUHODWLRQVKLSRUGLQDULO\D
    VWULFWUXOH7KLVWKRXJK ZDVVSHFLDO
    +HVKUXJJHG-XVWZDLWLQJIRU\RX
    ,YHJRWWHQKHUPXFKEHWWHUVWUXFWXUHG+HUPRRGIOXWWHUVDUHEHORZ

    ]HURSRLQWWZR
    *UHDW&DQ,VHH"
    'LGKHUVPLOHVHHPZDUPHUWKDQXVXDO"+HZDVVWLOOZRQGHULQJDERXWWKDW
    ZKHQKHUHDFKHGKLVRZQRIILFHDIWHUDQKRXURILQWXQLQJRQ-RDQ6\E\OKDG
    FHUWDLQO\GRQHJRRGZRUN7KRURXJKLQWULFDWHO\PDWWHGLQZLWKWKHDQFLHQW
    SHUVRQDOLW\WRSRJUDSK\
    $OOVLQFH\HVWHUGD\"+HWKRXJKWQRW
    7LPHWRGRDOLWWOHVQLIILQJDURXQGLQVLPVSDFH
    

    9ROWDLUHORRPHGEURZVIXUURZHGVFRZOLQJKDQGVRQVNLQQ\KLSV+HURVH
    IURPWKHULFKO\HPEURLGHUHGFKDLULQKLVVWXG\DW&LUH\WKHFKDWHDXRIKLV
    ORQJWHUPPLVWUHVVWKH0DUTXLVHGX&KDWHOHW
    7KHSODFHKHKDGFDOOHGKRPHIRUILIWHHQ\HDUVGHSUHVVHGKLPQRZWKDW
    VKHZDVJRQH$QGQRZWKHPDUTXLVZLWKRXWWKHGHFHQF\WRZDLWXQWLOKLV
    ZLIHVERG\ZDVFROGKDGLQIRUPHGKLPWKDWKHPXVWOHDYH
    *HWPHRXWRIKHUH9ROWDLUHGHPDQGHGRIWKHVFLHQWLVWZKRILQDOO\
    DQVZHUHGKLVFDOO6FLHQWLVWDIUHVKZRUGRQHQRGRXEWGHULYHGIURPWKH
    /DWLQURRWWRNQRZ%XWWKLVIHOORZORRNHGDVWKRXJKKHNQHZOLWWOH,ZDQW
    WRJRWRWKHFDIH,QHHGWRVHHWKH0DLG
    7KHVFLHQWLVWOHDQHGRYHUWKHFRQWUROERDUG9ROWDLUHZDVDOUHDG\
    EHJLQQLQJWRUHVHQWDQGVPLOHGZLWKWUDQVSDUHQWSOHDVXUHDWKLVSRZHU,
    GLGQWWKLQNVKHZDV\RXUW\SH<RXVKRZHGDVWURQJSUHIHUHQFHDOO\RXUOLIH
    UHPHPEHU,YHVFDQQHG\RXUPHPRULHV\RXKDYHQRVHFUHWVIRUEUDLQ\ZRPHQ
    /LNH\RXUQLHFHDQGWKH0DGDPHGX&KDWHOHW
    6R":KRWUXO\FDQDELGHWKHFRPSDQ\RIVWXSLGZRPHQ"7KHRQO\WKLQJ
    WKDWFDQEHVDLGRQWKHLUEHKDOILVWKDWWKH\FDQEHWUXVWHGDVWKH\UHWRR
    VWXSLGWRSUDFWLFHGHFHLW
    8QOLNH0DGDPHGX&KDWHOHW"
    9ROWDLUHGUXPPHGKLVILQJHUVLPSDWLHQWO\RQWKHEHDXWLIXOO\ZURXJKW
    ZDOQXWGHVNDJLIWIURP0DGDPHGX&KDWHOHWKHUHFDOOHG+RZKDGLWJRWWHQWR
    WKLVUXGHSODFH"&RXOGLWLQGHHGKDYHEHHQDVVHPEOHGIURPKLVPHPRU\DORQH"
    7UXHVKHEHWUD\HGPH6KHSDLGGHDUO\IRULWWRR
    7KHVFLHQWLVWDUFKHGDEURZ:LWKWKDW \RXQJRIILFHU\RXPHDQ"7KHRQH
    ZKRPDGHKHUSUHJQDQW"
    $WIRUW\WKUHHDPDUULHGZRPDQZLWKWKUHHJURZQFKLOGUHQKDVQR
    EXVLQHVVEHFRPLQJSUHJQDQW
    <RXKLWWKHURRIZKHQVKHWROG\RXXQGHUVWDQGDEOHEXWQRWYHU\
    HQOLJKWHQHG<HW\RXGLGQWEUHDNRIIZLWKKHU<RXZHUHZLWKKHUWKURXJKRXW
    WKHELUWK
    9ROWDLUHIXPHG0HPRU\GDUNPHPRU\IORZLQJOLNHEODFNZDWHUVLQD
    VXEWHUUDQHDQULYHU+HGZRUULHGKLPVHOIVLFNDERXWWKHELUWKZKLFKKDG
    SURYHGDPD]LQJO\HDV\<HWQLQHGD\VODWHUWKHPRVWH[WUDRUGLQDU\ZRPDQKH
    KDGHYHUNQRZQZDVGHDG2IFKLOGEHGIHYHU1RRQHQRWHYHQKLVQLHFHDQG
    KRXVHNHHSHUDQGIRUPHUSDUDPRXU0DGDPH'HQLVZKRWRRNFDUHRIKLP
    WKHUHDIWHUKDGHYHUEHHQDEOHWRWDNHKHUSODFH+HKDGPRXUQHGKHUXQWLO
    XQWLOKHDSSURDFKHG WKHWKRXJKWYHHUHGDZD\WLOOKHGLHG
    +HSXIIHGRXWKLVFKHHNVDQGVSDWEDFNUDSLGO\6KHSHUVXDGHGPHWKDW
    LWZRXOGEHXQUHDVRQDEOHWREUHDNZLWKDZRPDQRIH[FHSWLRQDOEUHHGLQJDQG
    WDOHQWPHUHO\IRUH[HUFLVLQJWKHVDPHULJKWVWKDW,HQMR\HG(VSHFLDOO\VLQFH
    ,KDGQWPDGHORYHWRKHUIRUPRQWKV7KHULJKWVRIPDQVKHVDLGEHORQJHGWR
    ZRPHQWRRSURYLGHGWKH\ZHUHRIWKHDULVWRFUDF\,DOORZHGKHUJHQWOH
    UHDVRQDEOHQHVVWRSHUVXDGHPH
    $KWKHVFLHQWLVWVDLGHQLJPDWLFDOO\9ROWDLUHUXEEHGKLVIRUHKHDG
    KHDY\ZLWKEURRGLQJUHPHPEUDQFH6KHZDVDQH[FHSWLRQWRHYHU\UXOH6KH
    XQGHUVWRRG1HZWRQDQG/RFNH6KHXQGHUVWRRGHYHU\ZRUGWKDW,ZURWH6KH

    XQGHUVWRRGPH
    :K\ZHUHQW\RXPDNLQJORYHWRKHU"7RREXV\JRLQJWRRUJLHV"
    0\GHDUVLUP\SDUWLFLSDWLRQLQVXFKIHVWLYLWLHVKDVEHHQJUHDWO\
    H[DJJHUDWHG,WVWUXH,DFFHSWHGDQLQYLWDWLRQWRRQHVXFKFHOHEUDWLRQRI
    HURWLFSOHDVXUHLQP\\RXWK,DFTXLWWHGP\VHOIVRZHOO,ZDVLQYLWHGWR
    UHWXUQ
    'LG\RX"
    &HUWDLQO\QRW2QFHDSKLORVRSKHU7ZLFHDSHUYHUW
    :KDW,GRQWXQGHUVWDQGLVZK\DPDQRI\RXUZRUOGOLQHVVVKRXOGEHVR
    LQWHQWRQDQRWKHUPHHWLQJZLWKWKH0DLG
    +HUSDVVLRQ9ROWDLUHVDLGDQLPDJHRIWKHUREXVW0DLGULVLQJFOHDUO\
    LQKLVPLQGVH\H+HUFRXUDJHDQGGHYRWLRQWRZKDWVKHEHOLHYHG
    <RXSRVVHVVHGWKDWWUDLWDVZHOO
    9ROWDLUHVWRPSHGKLVIRRWEXWWKHIORRUPDGHQRVRXQG:K\GR\RX
    VSHDNRIPHLQWKHSDVWWHQVH"
    6RUU\,OOILOOLQWKDWDXGLREDFNJURXQGWRR$VLQJOHKDQGJHVWXUH
    DQG9ROWDLUHKHDUGERDUGVFUHDNDVKHSDFHG$FDUULDJHWHDPFOLSFORSSHGE\
    RXWVLGH
    ,SRVVHVVWHPSHUDPHQW'RQRWFRQIXVHSDVVLRQZLWKWHPSHUDPHQWZKLFK
    LVDPDWWHURIWKHQHUYHV3DVVLRQLVERUQHIURPWKHKHDUWDQGVRXOQRPHUH
    PHFKDQLVPRIWKHERGLO\KXPRUV
    <RXEHOLHYHLQVRXOV"
    ,QHVVHQFHVFHUWDLQO\7KH0DLGGDUHGFOLQJWRKHUYLVLRQZLWKKHU
    ZKROHKHDUWGHVSLWHEXOO\LQJE\FKXUFKDQGVWDWH+HUGHYRWLRQWRKHUYLVLRQ
    XQOLNHPLQHERUHQRWDLQWRISHUYHUVHQHVV6KHZDVWKHILUVWWUXH3URWHVWDQW
    ,YHDOZD\VSUHIHUUHG3URWHVWDQWVWRSDSLVWDEVROXWLVWVXQWLO,WRRNXS
    UHVLGHQFHLQ*HQHYDRQO\WRGLVFRYHUWKHLUSXEOLFKDWUHGRISOHDVXUHLVDV
    JUHDWDVDQ\SRSHV2QO\4XDNHUVGRQRWSULYDWHO\HQJDJHLQZKDWWKH\
    SXEOLFO\FODLPWRDEMXUH$ODVDKXQGUHGWUXHEHOLHYHUVFDQQRWUHGHHP
    PLOOLRQVRIK\SRFULWHV
    7KHVFLHQWLVWWZLVWHGKLVPRXWKVNHSWLFDOO\-RDQUHFDQWHGNQXFNOHG
    XQGHUWRWKHLUWKUHDWV
    7KH\WRRNKHUWRDFHPHWHU\9ROWDLUHEULVWOHGZLWKLUULWDWLRQ
    7HUURUL]HGDFUHGXORXVJLUOZLWKWKUHDWVRIGHDWKDQGKHOO%LVKRSV
    DFDGHPLFLDQVWKHPRVWOHDUQHGPHQRIWKHLUWLPH'RQNH\VDVVHVWKHORW
    %URZEHDWLQJWKHEUDYHVWZRPDQLQ)UDQFHDZRPDQZKRPWKH\GHVWUR\HGRQO\WR
    UHYHUH+\SRFULWHV7KH\UHTXLUHPDUW\UVDVOHHFKHVUHTXLUHEORRG7KH\WKULYH
    RQVHOIVDFULILFHSURYLGHGWKDWWKHVHOYHVWKH\VDFULILFHDUHQRWWKHLURZQ
    $OOZHKDYHLV\RXUYHUVLRQDQGKHUV2XUKLVWRU\GRHVQWJREDFNWKDW
    IDU6WLOOZHNQRZPRUHRISHRSOHQRZ
    6R\RXLPDJLQH9ROWDLUHVQLIIHGDMRWRIVQXIIWRFDOPKLPVHOI
    9LOODLQVDUHXQGRQHE\ZKDWLVZRUVWLQWKHPKHURHVE\ZKDWLVEHVW7KH\
    SOD\HGKHUKRQRUDQGKHUEUDYHU\OLNHDILGGOHVZLQHSOXFNLQJDWDYLROLQ
    <RXUHGHIHQGLQJKHU7KHVFLHQWLVWVZU\VPLOHPRFNHG<HWLQWKDW
    SRHP\RXZURWHDERXWKHUDPD]LQJVRPHRQHPHPRUL]LQJWKHLURZQZRUNVRWKH\
    FRXOGUHFLWHLW\RXGHSLFWKHUDVDWDYHUQVOXWPXFKROGHUWKDQVKHLQIDFW
    ZDVDOLDUDERXWKHUVRFDOOHGYRLFHVDVXSHUVWLWLRXVEXWVKUHZGIRRO7KH
    JUHDWHVWHQHP\RIWKHFKDVWLW\VKHSUHWHQGVWRGHIHQGLVDGRQNH\DGRQNH\
    ZLWKZLQJV
    9ROWDLUHVPLOHG$EULOOLDQWPHWDSKRUIRUWKH5RPDQ&KXUFKQHVWFH
    SDV",KDGDSRLQWWRPDNH6KHZDVVLPSO\WKHVZRUGZLWKZKLFK,GURYHLW
    KRPH,KDGQRWPHW KHUWKHQ,KDGQRLGHDVKHZDVDZRPDQRIVXFKP\VWHULRXV
    GHSWKV
    1RWGHSWKVRILQWHOOHFW$SHDVDQW0DUTUHFDOOHGKRZKHKDGHVFDSHG
    MXVWVXFKDIDWHRQWKHPXGJUXEELQJZRUOG%LHKOHXU$OOWKURXJKWKH*UH\V
    H[DP$QGQRZKHKDGIOHGWKHLUVWRGJ\URXWLQHVLQWRDWUXHFXOWXUDO
    UHYROXWLRQ

    1RQR'HSWKVRIWKHVRXO,POLNHDOLWWOHVWUHDP&OHDUEHFDXVHLW
    LVVKDOORZ%XWVKHVDULYHUDQRFHDQ5HWXUQPHWR$X['HX[0DJRWV6KHDQG
    WKHZLQGXS*DUFRQDUHWKHRQO\VRFLHW\,QRZKDYH
    6KHLV\RXUDGYHUVDU\WKHVFLHQWLVWVDLG$PLQLRQRIWKRVHZKR
    XSKROGYDOXHVWKDW\RXIRXJKWDOO\RXUOLIH7RPDNHVXUH\RXEHDWKHU,P
    JRLQJWRVXSSOHPHQW\RX
    ,DPLQWDFWDQGHQWLUH9ROWDLUHGHFODUHGIURVWLO\
    ,OOHTXLS\RXZLWKSKLORVRSKLFDODQGVFLHQWLILFLQIRUPDWLRQUDWLRQDO
    SURJUHVV<RXUUHDVRQPXVWFUXVKKHUIDLWK<RXPXVWUHJDUGKHUDVWKHHQHP\
    VKHLVLIFLYLOL]DWLRQLVWRFRQWLQXHWRDGYDQFHDORQJUDWLRQDOVFLHQWLILF
    OLQHV
    +LVHORTXHQFHDQGLPSXGHQFHZHUHUDWKHUFKDUPLQJEXWQRVXEVWLWXWHVIRU
    9ROWDLUHVIDVFLQDWLRQZLWK-RDQ,UHIXVHWRUHDGDQ\WKLQJXQWLO\RXUHXQLWH
    PHZLWKWKH0DLGLQWKHFDIH
    7KHVFLHQWLVWKDGWKHDXGDFLW\WRODXJK<RXGRQWJHWLW<RXKDYHQR
    FKRLFH,OOVFXOSWWKHLQIRUPDWLRQLQWR\RX<RXOO KDYHWKHLQIRUPDWLRQ\RX
    QHHGWRZLQOLNHLWRUQRW
    <RXYLRODWHP\LQWHJULW\
    /HWVQRWIRUJHWWKDWDIWHUWKHGHEDWHWKHUHOOEHWKHTXHVWLRQRI
    NHHSLQJ\RXUXQQLQJRU
    (QGLQJPH"
    -XVWVR\RXNQRZZKDWFDUGVDUHRQWKHWDEOH
    9ROWDLUHEULVWOHG+HNQHZWKHLURQDFFHQWVRIDXWKRULW\VLQFHKHZDV
    ILUVWVXEMHFWHGWRKLVIDWKHUVDVWULFWPDUWLQHWZKRGFRPSHOOHGKLPWR
    DWWHQGPDVVDQGZKRVHDXVWHULWLHVFODLPHGWKHOLIHRI9ROWDLUHVPRWKHUZKHQ
    9ROWDLUHZDVRQO\VHYHQ7KHRQO\ZD\VKHFRXOGHVFDSHKHUKXVEDQGV
    GLVFLSOLQHZDVWRGLH9ROWDLUHKDGQRLQWHQWLRQRIHVFDSLQJWKLVVFLHQWLVWLQ
    WKDWZD\
    ,UHIXVHWRXVHDQ\DGGLWLRQDONQRZOHGJH\RXJLYHPHXQOHVV\RXUHWXUQ
    PHDWRQFHWRWKHFDIH
    ,QIXULDWLQJO\WKHVFLHQWLVWUHJDUGHG9ROWDLUHWKHZD\9ROWDLUHKDG
    UHJDUGHGKLVZLJPDNHUZLWKKDXJKW\VXSHULRULW\+LVFXUOHGOLSVDLGTXLWH
    FOHDUO\WKDWKHNQHZ9ROWDLUHFRXOGQRWH[LVWZLWKRXWKLVSDWURQDJH
    $KXPEOLQJWXUQDERXW7KRXJKPLGGOHFODVVLQRULJLQKLPVHOI9ROWDLUH
    GLGQRWEHOLHYHFRPPRQSHRSOHZRUWK\RIJRYHUQLQJWKHPVHOYHV7KHWKRXJKWRI
    KLVZLJPDNHUSRVLQJDVDOHJLVODWRUZDVHQRXJKWRPDNHKLPQHYHUZHDUDZLJ
    DJDLQ7REHVHHQVLPLODUO\E\WKLVYH[LQJVPXJVFLHQWLVWZDVLQWROHUDEOH
    7HOO\RXZKDWVDLGWKHVFLHQWLVW<RXFRPSRVHRQHRI\RXUEULOOLDQW
    OHWWUHVSKLORVRSKLTXHVWUDVKLQJWKHFRQFHSWRIWKHKXPDQVRXODQG,ZLOO
    UHXQLWH\RXZLWKWKH0DLG%XWLI\RXGRQW\RXZRQWVHHKHUXQWLOWKHGD\
    RIWKHGHEDWH&OHDU"
    9ROWDLUHPXOOHGWKHRIIHURYHU&OHDUDV DOLWWOHVWUHDPKHVDLGDW
    ODVW
    DQGWKHQFORWWHGFLQGHUGDUNFORXGVGHVFHQGHGLQWRKLVPLQG
    0HPRULHVVXOOHQDQGJULP+HIHOWHQJXOIHGLQDSDVWWKDWURDUHGWKURXJKKLP
    VFRXULQJ
    +HVF\FOLQJ7KHUHVVRPHWKLQJVXUIDFLQJKHUHFDPH0DUTVKROORZ
    FDOO
    ,PDJHVRIWKHIDUSDVWH[SORGHG
    &DOO6HOGRQ7KLVVLPKDVDQRWKHUOD\HU&DOO6HOGRQ
    

    +DUL6HOGRQVWDUHGDWWKHLPDJHVDQGGDWDULYHUV9ROWDLUHVXIIHUHGD
    UHFDOOVWRUP$QGORRNDWWKHLPSOLFDWLRQV
    0DUTSHHUHGZLWKRXWFRPSUHKHQVLRQDWWKHWRUUHQW8K,VHH
    7KDWSURPRQWRU\DPHPRU\QXJJHWDERXWDGHEDWHKHKDGZLWK-RDQHLJKW

    WKRXVDQG\HDUVDJR
    6RPHERG\XVHGWKHVHVLPVEHIRUH
    )RUSXEOLFGHEDWH\HV+LVWRU\QRWRQO\UHSHDWVLWVHOI VRPHWLPHVLW
    VWXWWHUV
    )DLWKYV5HDVRQ"
    )DLWK0HFKDQLFDOVYV5HDVRQ+XPDQ:LOO6HOGRQVDLGDVLIUHDGLQJ
    WKHPGLUHFWO\IURPWKHQXPHULFDOFRPSOH[HV0DUTFRXOGQRWIROORZWKH
    FRQQHFWLRQVIDVWHQRXJKWRNHHSXSZLWKKLP$VRFLHW\RIWKDWWLPHKDGD
    IXQGDPHQWDOGLYLVLRQRYHUFRPSXWHULQWHOOLJHQFHVDQGWKHLUPDQLIHVWDWLRQV
    0DUTFDXJKWDQHOXVLYHIOLFNHULQ6HOGRQVIDFH:DVKHKLGLQJ
    VRPHWKLQJ"0DQLIHVWDWLRQV"<RXPHDQOLNHWLNWRNV"
    6RPHWKLQJOLNHWKDW6HOGRQVDLGVWLIIO\
    9ROWDLUHVIRU
    ,QWKDWDJHKHZDVIRUKXPDQHIIHUYHVFHQFH-RDQIDYRUHG)DLWKZKLFK
    PHDQWXKWLNWRNV
    ,GRQWJHWLW
    7WNWRNVRUKLJKHUIRUPVRIWKHPZHUHGHHPHGFDSDEOHRIJXLGLQJ
    KXPDQLW\6HOGRQVHHPHGXQFRPIRUWDEOH
    7LNWRNV"0DUTVQRUWHGGHULVLYHO\
    2UXKKLJKHUIRUPV
    7KDWVZKDW9ROWDLUHDQG-RDQZHUHGHEDWLQJHLJKWWKRXVDQG\HDUVDJR"
    6RWKH\ZHUHHQJLQHHUHGIRUWKLV:KRZRQ"
    7KHUHVXOWLVVXSSUHVVHG,EHOLHYHLWEHFDPHDQLUUHOHYDQWLVVXH1R
    FRPSXWHULQWHOOLJHQFHVFRXOGEHPDGHZKLFKFRXOGJXLGHKXPDQLW\
    0DUTQRGGHG0DNHVVHQVH0DFKLQHVZLOOQHYHUEHDVVPDUWDVZHDUH
    'D\WRGD\EXVLQHVVVXUHEXW
    ,VXJJHVWHUDVXUHRIWKHHPEHGGHGPHPRU\FRPSOH[6HOGRQVDLGFXUWO\
    7KDWZLOOHOLPLQDWHWKHLQWHUIHULQJOD\HU
    2KLI\RXWKLQNWKDWVEHVW,PQRWVXUHZHFDQGLVFRQQHFWHYHU\WLH
    LQWRWKRVHPHPRULHVWKRXJK7KHVHVLPVXVHKRORJUDSKLFUHFDOOVRLWV
    ORGJHG
    7RJHWWKHUHVXOWV\RXZLVKLQWKLVXSFRPLQJGHEDWHLWLVFUXFLDO
    7KHUHFRXOGEHRWKHULPSOLFDWLRQVWRR
    6XFKDV"
    +LVWRULDQVPLJKWPLQHVLPVOLNHWKHVHIRUORVWGDWDRQWKHIDUSDVW
    7KH\ZRXOGZDQWDFFHVV'HQ\WKHP
    2KVXUH,PHDQQRWOLNHO\ZHGOHWDQ\ERG\XVHWKHP
    6HOGRQJD]HGDWWKHVKLIWLQJVODEVRISDWWHUQ7KH\DUHFRPSOH[DUHQW
    WKH\"0LQGVRIUHDOGHSWKLQWHUDFWLQJVXEVHOYHV2PPP,ZRQGHUKRZWKH
    ZKROHVHQVHRIVHOIKRRGUHPDLQVVWDEOH"+RZFRPHWKHLUPHQWDOLWLHVGRQWMXVW
    FUDVK"
    0DUTFRXOGQWIROORZEXWKHVDLG,JXHVVWKRVHDQFLHQWVWKH\ NQHZD
    IHZWULFNVZHGRQW
    6HOGRQQRGGHG,QGHHG7KHUHVDJOLPPHURIDQLGHDKHUH
    +HVWRRGTXLFNO\DQG0DUTURVH&RXOGQW\RXVWD\",NQRZ6\E\OZRXOG
    OLNHWRWDON
    6RUU\PXVWJR0DWWHUVRIVWDWH
    8KZHOOWKDQNVIRU
    6HOGRQZDVJRQHEHIRUH0DUTFRXOGFORVHKLVJDSLQJPRXWK
    

    ,KDYHQRGHVLUHWRVHHWKHVNLQQ\JHQWOHPDQLQWKHZLJ+HWKLQNVKHV
    EHWWHUWKDQHYHU\RQHHOVHWKH0DLGWROGWKHVRUFHUHVVFDOOHG6\E\O
    7UXHEXW
    ,PXFKSUHIHUWKHFRPSDQ\RIP\RZQYRLFHV
    +HVTXLWHWDNHQZLWK\RX0DGDPHOD6RUFLqUHVDLG

    ,ILQGWKDWGLIILFXOWWREHOLHYH6WLOOVKHFRXOGQRWKHOSVPLOLQJ
    2KEXWLWVWUXH+HVDVNHG0DUTKLVUHFUHDWRUIRUDQHQWLUHO\QHZ
    LPDJH+HOLYHG\RXNQRZWRHLJKW\IRXU
    +HORRNVHYHQROGHU6KHKDGIRXQGKLVZLJOLODFULEERQDQGYHOYHW
    EUHHFKHVOXGLFURXVRQVXFKDGULHGXSILJRIDPDQ
    0DUTGHFLGHGWRPDNHKLPDSSHDUDVKHORRNHGDWIRUW\WZR'RVHHKLP
    7KH0DLGUHIOHFWHG0RQVLHXU$URXHWZRXOGEHIDU OHVVUHSXOVLYH
    LI'LG0RQVLHXUKDYHDGLIIHUHQWWDLORUDVD\RXQJPDQ"
    +PPPWKDWPLJKWEHDUUDQJHG
    ,PQRWJRLQJWRWKHLQQLQWKHVH
    6KHKHOGXSKHUFKDLQVUHFDOOLQJWKHIXUFORDNWKHNLQJKLPVHOIKDG
    SODFHGDERXWKHUVKRXOGHUVDWKLVFRURQDWLRQLQ5RXHQ6KHWKRXJKWRIDVNLQJ
    IRULWQRZEXWGHFLGHGDJDLQVWLW7KH\KDGPDGHPXFKRIKHUFORDNGXULQJKHU
    WULDODFFXVLQJKHURIKDYLQJDGHPRQLQVSLUHGORYHRIOX[XU\VKHZKRXQWLO
    VKHZRQWKHNLQJRYHUWKDWGD\VKHILUVWDSSHDUHGDWFRXUW KDGIHOWQRWKLQJ
    EXWFRDUVHEXUODSDJDLQVWKHUVNLQ+HUDFFXVHUVVKHKDGQRWHGZRUHEODFN
    VDWLQDQGYHOYHWDQGUHHNHGRISHUIXPH
    ,OOGRZKDW,FDQ0DGDPHOD6RUFLqUHYRZHGEXW\RXPXVWDJUHHQRW
    WRWHOO0RQVLHXU%RNHU+HGRHVQWZDQW\RXIUDWHUQL]LQJZLWKWKHHQHP\EXW,
    WKLQNLWZLOOGR\RXJRRG+RQH\RXUVNLOOVIRUWKH*UHDW'HEDWH
    7KHUHZDVDSDXVHIDOOLQJVRIWFORXGVLQZKLFKWKH0DLGIHOWDVLI
    VKHKDGIDLQWHG:KHQVKHUHFRYHUHGKDUGFRROVXUIDFHVVXGGHQVKDUSVSODVKHV
    RIEURZQJUHHQVKHIRXQGKHUVHOIVHDWHGLQWKH,QQRIWKH7ZR0DJJRWVRQFH
    DJDLQVXUURXQGHGE\JXHVWVZKRVHHPHGQRWWRNQRZWKDWVKHZDVWKHUH
    $UPRUSODWHGEHLQJVEHDULQJWUD\VDQGFOHDULQJWDEOHZDUHGDUWHGDPRQJ
    WKHJXHVWV6KHORRNHGIRU*DUFRQDQGVSRWWHGKLPJD]LQJDWWKHKRQH\KDLUHG
    FRRNZKRSUHWHQGHGQRWWRQRWLFH*DUFRQVORQJLQJUHFDOOHGWKHZD\WKH0DLG
    KHUVHOIKDGJD]HGDWVWDWXHVRI6W&DWKHULQHDQG6W0DUJDUHWZKRKDGERWK
    IRUVZRUQPHQEXWDGRSWHGWKHLUDWWLUHVXVSHQGHGEHWZHHQWZRZRUOGVKRO\
    SDVVLRQDERYHHDUWK\DUGRUEHORZ-XVWDVKHUHZLWKLWVMDUULQJMDUJRQRI
    QXPEHUVDQGPDFKLQHVWKRXJKVKHNQHZLWIRUDSXUJDWRULDOZDLWLQJFORLVWHU
    IORDWLQJEHWZHHQWKHZRUOGV
    6KHVXSSUHVVHGDVPLOHZKHQ0RQVLHXU$URXHWDSSHDUHG+HVSRUWHG DGDUN
    XQSRZGHUHGZLJWKRXJKVWLOOORRNHGUDWKHUROGDERXWWKHDJHRIKHUIDWKHU
    -DFTXHV'DUVWKLUW\SOXVRQHRUWZR+LVVKRXOGHUVVOXPSHGIRUZDUGXQGHUWKH
    ZHLJKWRIPDQ\ERRNV6KHGRQO\VHHQERRNVWZLFHGXULQJKHUWULDOVDQG
    WKRXJKWKH\ORRNHGQRWKLQJOLNHWKHVHVKHUHFRLOHGDWWKHPHPRU\RIWKHLU
    SRZHU
    $ORUV0RQVLHXU$URXHWVDLGVHWWLQJWKHERRNVEHIRUHKHU)RUW\WZR
    YROXPHV0\6HOHFWHG:RUNV,QFRPSOHWHEXWKHVPLOHGIRUQRZLWZLOO
    KDYHWRGR:KDWVZURQJ"
    'R\RXPRFNPH"<RXNQRZ,FDQQRWUHDG
    ,NQRZ*DUFRQ$'0LVJRLQJWRWHDFK\RX
    ,GRQRWZDQWWROHDUQ$OOERRNVH[FHSWWKH%LEOHDUHERUQRIWKH
    GHYLO
    0RQVLHXU$URXHWWKUHZXSKLVKDQGVDQGODSVHGLQWRFXUVHVYLROHQWDQG
    LQWULJXLQJRDWKVOLNHWKRVHKHUVROGLHUVXVHGZKHQWKH\IRUJRWWKDWVKHZDV
    QHDU<RXPXVWOHDUQKRZWRUHDG.QRZOHGJHLVSRZHU
    7KHGHYLOPXVWNQRZDJUHDWGHDOVKHVDLGFDUHIXOWROHWQRSDUWRI
    WKHERRNVWRXFKKHU
    0RQVLHXU$URXHWH[DVSHUDWHGWXUQHGWRWKHVRUFHUHVVZKRDSSHDUHGWR
    EHVLWWLQJDWDQHDUE\WDEOHDQGVDLG9DF&DQW\RXWHDFKKHUDQ\WKLQJ"
    7KHQKHWXUQHGEDFNWRKHU+RZZLOO\RXDSSUHFLDWHP\EULOOLDQFHLI\RX
    FDQWHYHQUHDG"
    ,KDYHQRXVHIRULW
    +D+DG\RXEHHQDEOHWRUHDG\RXGKDYHFRQIRXQGHGWKRVHLGLRWVZKR
    VHQW\RXWRWKHVWDNH

    $OOOHDUQHGPHQVKHVDLG/LNH\RX
    1RSXFHOOHWWHQRWOLNHPH1RWOLNHPHDWDOO$VLILWZHUHD
    VHUSHQWVKHUHFRLOHGIURPWKHERRNKHKHOGRXW*ULQQLQJKHUXEEHGWKHERRN
    DOORYHUKLPVHOIDQG*DUFRQZKRZDVQRZVWDQGLQJEHVLGHWKHWDEOH,WV
    KDUPOHVVVHH"
    (YLOLVRIWHQLQYLVLEOHVKHPXUPXUHG
    0RQVLHXULVULJKW*DUFRQWROGKHU$OOWKHEHVWSHRSOHUHDG
    +DG\RXEHHQOHWWHUHG0RQVLHXU$URXHWVDLG\RXGKDYHNQRZQWKDW
    \RXULQTXLVLWRUVKDGDEVROXWHO\QRULJKWWRWU\\RX<RXZHUHDSULVRQHURI
    ZDUVHL]HGLQEDWWOH<RXU(QJOLVKFDSWRUKDGQROHJDOULJKWWRKDYH\RXU
    UHOLJLRXVYLHZVH[DPLQHGE\)UHQFKLQTXLVLWRUVDQGDFDGHPLFV<RXSUHWHQGHGWR
    EHOLHYH\RXUYRLFHVZHUHGLYLQH
    3UHWHQGHGVKHFULHGRXW
    DQGKHSUHWHQGHGWREHOLHYHWKH\ZHUHGHPRQLF7KH(QJOLVKDUH
    WKHPVHOYHVWRRWROHUDQWWREXUQDQ\RQHDWWKHVWDNH7KH\OHDYHVXFKIRUPVRI
    DPXVHPHQWWRRXUFRXQWU\PHQWKH)UHQFK
    1RWWRRWROHUDQWWKH0DLGVDLGWRWXUQPHRYHUWRWKHELVKRSRI
    %HDXYDLVFODLPLQJ,ZDVDZLWFK6KHORRNHGDZD\XQZLOOLQJWROHWKLPSHHU
    LQKHUH\HV3HUKDSV,DP,EHWUD\HGP\RZQYRLFHV
    9RLFHVRIFRQVFLHQFHQRWKLQJPRUH7KHSDJDQ6RFUDWHVKHDUGWKHPDV
    ZHOO(YHU\RQHGRHV%XWLWVXQUHDVRQDEOHWRVDFULILFHRXUOLYHVWRWKHPLI
    RQO\EHFDXVHWRGHVWUR\RXUVHOYHVRQWKHLUDFFRXQWLVWRGHVWUR\WKHPWRR
    +HVXFNHGUHIOHFWLYHO\RQKLVWHHWK3HUVRQVRIJRRGEUHHGLQJEHWUD\WKHPDV
    DPDWWHURIFRXUVH
    $QGZHKHUH"-RDQZKLVSHUHG+HQDUURZHGKLVH\HV7KHVHRWKHUV"
    7KHVFLHQWLVWV"
    7KH\DUHVSHFWUDO
    /LNHGHPRQV"<HWWKH\VSHDNRIUHDVRQ7KH\KDYHUDLVHGDUHSXEOLFRI
    DQDO\VLV
    6RWKH\VD\LWLV<HWWKH\KDYHDVNHGXVWRUHSUHVHQWZKDWWKH\GRQRW
    KDYH
    <RXWKLQNWKHPEORRGOHVV9ROWDLUHWZLVWHGKLVPRXWKLQVXUSULVHG
    VSHFXODWLRQ
    ,WKLQNZHOLVWHQWRWKHVDPHVFLHQWLVWVVRZHDUHEHLQJWHVWHGLQ
    WKHVDPHWULDO
    ,KHHGYRLFHVVXFKDVWKHLUV9ROWDLUHVDLGGHIHQVLYHO\,DWOHDVW
    NQRZZKHQWRWXUQP\KHDGDVLGHIURPPLQGOHVVDGYLFH
    3HUKDSV0RQVLHXUVYRLFHVDUHVRIW*DUFRQVXJJHVWHG7KHUHIRUHPRUH
    HDVLO\LJQRUHG
    ,OHWWKHPFKXUFKO\PHQIRUFHPHWRDGPLWP\YRLFHVZHUHWKH
    GHYLOVVDLGWKH0DLGZKHQDOOWKHZKLOH,NQHZWKH\ZHUHGLYLQH,VQW
    WKDWWKHDFWRIDGHPRQ"$ZLWFK"
    /LVWHQ0RQVLHXU$URXHWJULSSHGKHUE\WKHDUPV7KHUHDUHQR
    ZLWFKHV7KHRQO\GHPRQVLQ\RXUOLIHZHUHWKRVHZKRVHQW\RXWRWKHVWDNH
    ,JQRUDQWVZLQHWKHORW([FHSWIRU\RXU(QJOLVKFDSWRUZKRSUHWHQGHGWR
    EHOLHYH\RXZHUHDZLWFKWRFDUU\RXWDVKUHZGSROLWLFDOPRYH:KHQ\RXU
    JDUPHQWVKDGEXPPHGDZD\KLVGXSHVUHPRYHG\RXUERG\IURPWKHVWDNHWRVKRZ
    WKHFURZGDQGWKHLQTXLVLWRUV\RXZHUHLQGHHGDIHPDOHZKRLIIRUQRRWKHU
    UHDVRQWKDQXVXUSLQJWKHSULYLOHJHVRIPDOHVGHVHUYHG\RXUIDWH
    3OHDVHVWRSVKHVDLG6KHWKRXJKWVKHVPHOOHGWKHRLO\UHHNRIVPRNH
    DOWKRXJK0RQVLHXU$URXHWKDGPDGH*DUFRQSODFH12602.,1*VLJQVWKURXJKRXWWKH
    LQQZKLFKDEUXSWO\WKH\ZHUHQRZLQVLGH7KHURRPYHHUHGZKLUOHG7KH
    ILUH6KHJDVSHG,WVWRQJXHV
    7KDWVHQRXJKWKHVRUFHUHVVVDLG&DQW\RXVHH\RXUHXSVHWWLQJ
    KHU"/D\RII
    %XW0RQVLHXU$URXHWSHUVLVWHG7KH\H[DPLQHG\RXUSULYDWHSDUWVDIWHU
    \RXUJDUPHQWVEXPPHGDZD\GLGQWNQRZWKDWGLG\RX"MXVWDVWKH\GGRQH

    EHIRUHWRSURYH\RXZHUHWKHYLUJLQWKDW\RXFODLPHG$QGKDYLQJVDWLVILHG
    WKHLUOHZGQHVVLQWKHQDPHRIKROLQHVVWKH\UHWXUQHG\RXWRWKHS\UHDQG
    FKDUUHG\RXUERQHVWRDVKHV7KDWZDVKRZ\RXUFRXQWU\PHQUHTXLWHG\RXIRU
    FKDPSLRQLQJWKHLUNLQJ)RUVHHLQJWRLW)UDQFHUHPDLQHGIRUHYHU)UHQFK$QG
    KDYLQJLQFLQHUDWHG\RXDZKLOHODWHUWKH\KHOGDKHDULQJFLWHGVRPHUXUDO
    UXPRUWKDW\RXUKHDUWKDGQRWEHHQFRQVXPHGLQWKHILUHDQGSURPSWO\GHFODUHG
    \RXDQDWLRQDOKHURLQHWKH6DYLRURI)UDQFH,ZRXOGQWEHDWDOOVXUSULVHG
    LIE\QRZWKH\KDYHFDQRQL]HG\RXDQGUHYHUH\RXDVDVDLQW
    ,Q/D6RUFLqUHVDLG7KRXJKKRZVKHNQHZWKLVRGGQXPEHUVKH
    GLGQRWFRPSUHKHQG$QJHOLFNQRZOHGJH"
    0RQVLHXU$URXHWVVSOXWWHURIVFRUQFUDFNOHGLQKHUHDUV
    0XFKJRRGLWGLGKHU0RQVLHXU$URXHWVDLGWR/D6RUFLqUH
    7KDWGDWHZDVLQDQDWWHQGDQWQRWH/D6RUFLqUHVDLGKHUHDUQHVW
    YRLFHLQLWVIDFWXDOPRGH7KRXJKRIFRXUVHZHKDYHQRFRRUGLQDWHVWRNQRZ
    ZKDWWKHQXPEHUVPHDQ,WLVQRZRIWKH*DODFWLF(UD
    6FRUFKLQJORJLFVIDQQHGWKHFUDFNOLQJDLU+RWZLQGVEOXUUHGWKHFURZG
    RIRQORRNHUVJDWKHUHGDURXQGWKHVWDNH
    )LUH7KH0DLGJDVSHG&OXWFKLQJWKHPHVKFROODUDWKHUWKURDWVKH
    IOHGLQWRWKHFRROGDUNRIREOLYLRQ
    

    ,WVDERXWWLPH9ROWDLUHVFROGHG0DGDPHOD6FLHQWLVWH6KHKXQJ
    EHIRUHKLPOLNHDQDQLPDWHGRLOSDLQWLQJ+HKDGFKRVHQWKLVUHSUHVHQWDWLRQ
    ILQGLQJLWRGGO\UHDVVXULQJ
    ,KDYHQWEHHQLJQRULQJ\RXRQSXUSRVHVKHVDLGFRRODQG
    EXVLQHVVOLNH
    +RZGDUH\RXVORZPHZLWKRXWP\FRQVHQW"
    0DUTDQG,DUHEHLQJEHVLHJHGE\PHGLDSHRSOH,QHYHUGUHDPHGWKH
    *UHDW'HEDWHZRXOGEHWKHPHGLDHYHQWRIWKHGHFDGH7KH\DOOZDQWDFKDQFHWR
    LQWHUYLHZ\RXDQG-RDQ
    9ROWDLUHIOXIIHGWKHDSULFRWULEERQDWKLVWKURDW,UHIXVHWREHVHHQ
    E\WKHPZLWKRXWP\SRZGHUHGZLJ
    :HUHQRWJRLQJWROHWWKHPVHH\RXRUWKH0DLGDWDOO7KH\FDQWDON
    WR0DUTDOOWKH\ZDQW+HOLNHVDWWHQWLRQDQGKDQGOHVLWZHOO+HVD\VSXEOLF
    H[SRVXUHZLOOKHOSKLVFDUHHU
    ,VKRXOGWKLQN,ZRXOGEHFRQVXOWHGEHIRUHVXFKLPSRUWDQWGHFLVLRQV
    /RRN,FDPHDVVRRQDVP\PHFKVHFEHHSHGPH,OHW\RXUXQRQVWHS
    GRZQWLPHWRSROLFHXS\RXUSDWWHUQLQWHJUDWLRQ<RXVKRXOGEHJUDWHIXOWKDW
    ,JLYH\RXLQWHULRUWLPH
    &RQWHPSODWLRQ"KHVQLIIHG7KDWVRQHZD\WRORRNDWLW
    ,GLGQRWUHDOL]HWKDWVXFKZRXOGKDYHWREHJUDQWHG9ROWDLUHZDV
    LQKLVULFKO\DSSRLQWHGURRPVDW)UHGHULFNWKH*UHDWVFRXUWSOD\LQJFKHVV
    ZLWKWKHIULDUZKRPKHHPSOR\HGWROHWKLPZLQ
    ,WFRVWV$QGFRVWEHQHILWDQDO\VLVVKRZVWKDWLWZRXOGEHEHWWHULIZH
    UDQ\RXWZRWRJHWKHU
    1RVROLWXGH",WVLPSRVVLEOHWRKROGDUDWLRQDOFRQYHUVDWLRQZLWKWKH
    ZRPDQ
    +HWXUQHGKLVEDFNRQKHUIRUPD[LPXPGUDPDWLFHIIHFW+HKDGEHHQD
    ILQHDFWRUHYHU\RQHZKRGKHDUGKLPSHUIRUPLQKLVSOD\VDW)UHGHULFNVFRXUW
    VDLGVR+HNQHZDJRRGVFHQHZKHQKHVDZRQHDQGWKLVRQHKDGGUDPDWLF
    SRWHQWLDO7KHVHFUHDWXUHVZHUHVRSDOOLGVRXQXVHGWRWKHJXVWVRIUDZ
    HPRWLRQDUWIXOO\FUDIWHG
    +HUYRLFHVRIWHQHG*HWULGRIKLPDQG,OOXSGDWH\RX
    +HWXUQHGDQGOLIWHGDVLQJOHWKLQ ILQJHUDWWKHJRRGQDWXUHGIULDUWKH
    RQO\PDQRIWKHFORWKKHKDGHYHUPHWZKRPKHFRXOGVWDQG7KHPDQVKXIIOHG
    RIIFORVLQJWKHFDUYHGRDNGRRUFDUHIXOO\

    9ROWDLUHWRRNDVLSRI)UHGHULFNVILQHVKHUU\WRFOHDUKLVWKURDW,
    ZDQW\RXWRH[SXQJHWKH0DLGVPHPRU\RIKHUILQDORUGHDO,WLPSHGHVRXU
    FRQYHUVDWLRQDVVXUHO\DVELVKRSVDQGVWDWHRIILFLDOVLPSHGHWKHSXEOLFDWLRQ
    RILQWHOOLJHQWZRUN%HVLGHV+HSDXVHGXQFRPIRUWDEOHDWH[SUHVVLQJ
    IHHOLQJVVRIWHUWKDQLUULWDWLRQVKHVVXIIHULQJ,FDQQRWEHDUWRVHH
    LW
    ,GRQWWKLQN
    $QGZKLOH\RXUHDWLWREOLWHUDWHIURPPHWRRP\PHPRU\RIWKH
    HOHYHQPRQWKV,VHUYHGLQWKH%DVWLOOH$QGDOOP\IUHTXHQWIOLJKWVIURP
    3DULVQRWWKHIOLJKWVWKHPVHOYHVPLQG\RXP\SHULRGVRIH[LOHFRQVWLWXWH
    PRVWRIP\OLIH-XVWGHOHWHWKHLUFDXVHVQRWWKHHIIHFWV
    :HOO,GRQWNQRZ
    +HVODPPHGDILVWGRZQRQDQRUQDWHO\ZURXJKWRDNVLGHWDEOH8QOHVV
    \RXOLEHUDWHPHIURPSDVWIHDUV,FDQQRWDFWIUHHO\
    6LPSOHORJLF
    6LQFHZKHQLVORJLFVLPSOH",FDQQRWVLPSO\FRPSRVHP\OHWWUH
    SKLORVRSKLTXHRQWKHDEVXUGLW\RIGHQ\LQJWKRVHOLNH*DUFRQ$'0WKHULJKWV
    RIPDQRQWKHJURXQGVWKDWWKH\KDYHQRVRXO+HVDQDPXVLQJOLWWOHIHOORZ
    GRQW\RXWKLQN"$QGDVVPDUWDVDWOHDVWDGR]HQSULHVWVZKRP,KDYHNQRZQ
    'RHVKHQRWVSHDN"5HVSRQG"'HVLUH"+HLVLQIDWXDWHGZLWKDKXPDQFRRN6KRXOG
    KHQRWEHDEOHWRSXUVXHKDSSLQHVVDVIUHHO\DV\RXRU,",IKHKDVQRVRXO
    WKHQ\RXKDYHQRVRXOHLWKHU,I\RXKDYHDVRXOLWFDQRQO\EHLQIHUUHG
    IURP\RXUEHKDYLRUDQGVLQFHZHPD\PDNHWKHLGHQWLFDOLQIHUHQFHIURPWKH
    EHKDYLRURI*DUFRQVRGRHVKH
    ,PLQFOLQHGWRDJUHH0DGDPHOD6FLHQWLVWHVDLG7KRXJKRIFRXUVH
    $'0VUHDFWLRQVDUHVLPXODWLRQV6HOIDZDUHPDFKLQHVKDYHEHHQLOOHJDOIRU
    PLOOHQQLD
    7KDWLVZKDW,FKDOOHQJH9ROWDLUHVKRXWHG
    $QGKRZPXFKRIWKDWFRPHVIURP6DUNLDQSURJUDPPLQJ"
    1RQH7KHULJKWVRIPDQ
    +DUGO\QHHGDSSO\WRPDFKLQHV
    9ROWDLUHVFRZOHG,FDQQRWH[SUHVVP\VHOIFRPSOHWHO\ IUHHO\RQWKHVH
    VHQVLWLYHPDWWHUVXQOHVV\RXULGPHRIWKHPHPRU\RIZKDW,VXIIHUHGIRU
    H[SUHVVLQJP\LGHDV
    %XW\RXUSDVWLV\RXUVHOI:LWKRXWDOORILWLQWDFW
    1RQVHQVH7KHWUXWKLV,QHYHUGDUHGH[SUHVVP\VHOIIUHHO\RQPDQ\
    PDWWHUV7DNHWKDWOLIHKDWLQJ3XULWDQ3DVFDOKLVYLHZVRIRULJLQDOVLQ
    PLUDFOHVDQGPXFKRWKHUQRQVHQVHEHVLGHV,GLGQWGDUHVD\ZKDW,UHDOO\
    WKRXJKW$OZD\V,KDGWRFDOFXODWHZKDWHYHU\DVVDXOWRQFRQYHQWLRQDQG
    WUDGLWLRQDOVWXSLGLW\ZRXOGFRVW
    0DGDPHOD 6FLHQWLVWHSXUVHGKHUOLSVSUHWWLO\<RXGLGZHOOHQRXJK,
    ZRXOGJXHVV<RXZHUHIDPRXV:HGRQWNQRZ\RXUKLVWRU\RUHYHQ\RXUZRUOG
    %XWIURP\RXUPHPRULHV,FDQWHOO
    $QGWKH0DLG6KHLVWKZDUWHGPRUHWKDQ,)RUKHUFRQYLFWLRQVVKH
    SDLGWKH XOWLPDWHSULFH%HLQJFUXFLILHGFRXOGEHQRZRUVHWKDQZKDWVKH
    VXIIHUHGDWWKHVWDNH/LJKWDJRRGO\SLSHDV,ORYHWRGREHIRUHKHUDQG
    KHUH\HVUROOZLWKFRQIXVLRQ
    %XWWKDWVFUXFLDOWRZKRVKHLV
    5DWLRQDOLQTXLULHVFDQQRWEHFDUULHGRXWLQ DQDWPRVSKHUHRIIHDUDQG
    LQWLPLGDWLRQ,IRXUFRQWHVWLVWREHIDLU,LPSORUH\RXULGXVRIWKHVH
    WHUURUVWKDWSUHYHQWXVIURPVSHDNLQJRXUPLQGVDQGIURPHQFRXUDJLQJRWKHUV
    WRVSHDNWKHLUV(OVHWKLVGHEDWHZLOOEHOLNHDUDFHUXQZLWKEULFNVWLHGWR
    WKHUXQQHUVDQNOHV
    0DGDPHOD6FLHQWLVWHGLGQRWUHVSRQGDWRQFH,,GOLNHWRKHOSEXW
    ,PQRWVXUH,FDQ
    9ROWDLUHVSOXWWHUHGZLWKVFRUQ,NQRZHQRXJKRI\RXUSURFHGXUHVWR
    NQRZ\RXFDQFRPSO\ZLWKP\UHTXHVW

    7KDWSRVHVQRSUREOHPWUXH%XWPRUDOO\,PQRWDWOLEHUW\WRWDPSHU
    ZLWKWKH0DLGVSURJUDPDWZKLP
    9ROWDLUHVWLIIHQHG,UHDOL]H0DGDPHKDVDORZRSLQLRQRIP\
    SKLORVRSK\EXWVXUHO\
    1RWVR,WKLQNWKHZRUOGRI\RX<RXKDYHDPRGHUQPLQGDQGIURPWKH
    GHSWKVRIWKH GDUNSDVWDVWRQLVKLQJ,ZLVKWKH(PSLUHKDGPHQOLNH\RX%XW
    \RXUSRLQWRIYLHZWKRXJKYDOLGDVIDUDVLWJRHVLVOLPLWHGEHFDXVHRIZKDW
    LWOHDYHVRXWDQGFDQQRWDGGUHVV
    0\SKLORVRSK\",WHPEUDFHVDOODXQLYHUVDOYLHZ
    $QG,ZRUNIRU$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVDQGWKH3UHVHUYHUVIRU0U%RNHU
    ,PERXQGE\HWKLFVWRJLYHWKHPWKH0DLGWKH\ZDQW8QOHVV,FRXOGFRQYLQFH
    WKHPWRGHOHWHWKH0DLGVPHPRU\RIKHUPDUW\UGRP,FDQWGRLW$QG0DUT
    ZRXOGKDYHWRJHWSHUPLVVLRQIURPWKHFRPSDQ\DQGWKH6NHSWLFVWRGHOHWH
    \RXUV+HGORYHWR,DVVXUH\RX+LV6NHSWLFVDUHPRUHOLNHO\WRFRQVHQW
    WKDQP\3UHVHUYHUV,WZRXOGJLYH\RXDQDGYDQWDJH
    ,TXLWHDJUHHKHFRQFHGHGDWRQFH5HOLHYLQJPHRIP\EXUGHQV
    ZLWKRXWULGGLQJWKH0DLGRIKHUVZRXOGQRWEHUDWLRQDORUHWKLFDO1HLWKHU
    /RFNHQRU1HZWRQZRXOGDSSURYH
    0DGDPHOD6FLHQWLVWHGLGQRWDQVZHUDWRQFH,//WDONWRP\ERVVDQG
    WR0RQVLHXU%RNHUVKHVDLGDWODVW%XW,ZRXOGQWKROGP\EUHDWKLI,ZHUH
    \RX
    9ROWDLUHVPLOHGZU\O\DQGVDLG0DGDPHIRUJHWV,KDYHQREUHDWKWR
    KROG
    

    7KHLFRQIODVKLQJRQ0DUTVERDUGVWRSSHGMXVWDVKHHQWHUHGKLVRIILFH
    7KDWPHDQW6\E\OPXVWKDYHDQVZHUHGLWLQKHUV
    0DUTEULVWOHGZLWKVXVSLFLRQ7KH\KDGDJUHHGQRWWRWDONWRHDFK
    RWKHUVUHFUHDWLRQVDORQHWKRXJKHDFKKDGDOUHDG\JLYHQWKHRWKHUWKH
    UHTXLUHGSURJUDPPLQJWRGRLW7KH0DLGQHYHULQLWLDWHGFRPPXQLFDWLRQZKLFK
    PHDQWWKHFDOOHUZDV9ROWDLUH
    +RZGDUH6\E\OERRWXSZLWKRXWKLP+HVWRUPHGRXWRIWKHRIILFHWROHW
    KHUDQG9ROWDLUHERWKNQRZH[DFWO\ZKDWKHWKRXJKWRIWKHLUFRQVSLULQJEHKLQG
    KLVEDFN%XWLQWKHFRUULGRUKHZDVEHVLHJHGE\FDPHUDVMRXUQDOLVWVDQG
    UHSRUWHUV,WZDVILIWHHQPLQXWHVEHIRUHKHEXUVWLQWR6\E\OVRIILFHDQG
    VXUHHQRXJKFDXJKWKHUFORVHWHGFR]LO\ZLWK9ROWDLUH6KHGUHGXFHGKLPIURP
    ZDOOVL]HGWRKXPDQVFDOH
    <RXEURNHRXUSDFW0DUTVKRXWHG:KDWDUH\RXGRLQJ"7U\LQJWRXVH
    KLVLQIDWXDWLRQZLWKWKDWVFKL]RSKUHQLFWRPDNHKLPWKURZWKHGHEDWH"
    6\E\OKHDGEXULHGLQKHUKDQGVORRNHGXS+HUH\HVJOLVWHQHGZLWK
    WHDUV0DUTIHOWVRPHWKLQJLQKLPUROORYHUEXWKHFKRVHWRLJQRUHLW6KH
    DFWXDOO\EOHZ9ROWDLUHDNLVVEHIRUHIUHH]LQJKLP
    ,PXVWVD\,QHYHUWKRXJKW\RXGVLQNWRWKLV
    7RZKDW"6\E\OJRWKHUIDFHEDFNWRJHWKHUDQGMXWWHGRXWKHUMDZ
    :KDWVJRWWHQLQWR\RXUXVXDOMDXQW\VHOI"
    :KDWZDVWKDWDOODERXW"
    :KHQKHKHDUG0DUTPDUFKHGEDFNLQWRKLVRIILFHDQGERRWHGXS9ROWDLUH
    %HIRUHWKHLPDJHIXOO\IRUPHGFRORUEORFNVSKDVLQJLQKHVKRXWHG7KH
    DQVZHULVQR
    ,DPVXUH\RXKDYHDQHODERUDWHV\OORJLVPIRUPH9ROWDLUHVDLG
    VDUGRQLFDOO\XQIUHH]LQJ
    0DUTKDGWRDGPLWWKDWWKHVLPKDQGOHGWKHVXGGHQOXUFKHVDQG
    GLVDSSHDUDQFHVLQLWVIUDPHVSDFHZLWKDSORPE/RRNKHVDLGHYHQO\,ZDQW
    WKH5RVHRI)UDQFHZLOWLQJLQKHUDUPRUWKHGD\RIWKHGHEDWH,WZLOOUHPLQG
    KHURIKHULQTXLVLWLRQH[DFWO\6KHOOVWDUWEDEEOLQJQRQVHQVHDQGUHYHDOWR
    WKHSODQHWMXVWKRZEDQNUXSW)DLWKZLWKRXW5HDVRQLV

    9ROWDLUHVWDPSHGKLVIRRW0HUGHDORUV:HGLVDJUHH1HYHU PLQGPH
    EXW,LQVLVW\RXGHOHWHWKH0DLGVPHPRU\RIKHUILQDOKRXUVVRWKDWKHU
    UHDVRQLQJZLOOQRWEHFRPSURPLVHGDVPLQHVRRIWHQZDVE\IHDURI
    UHSULVDOV
    1RWSRVVLEOH%RNHUZDQWHG)DLWKKHJHWVDOORILW
    1RQVHQVH$OVR,GHPDQG\RXOHWPHYLVLWKHUDQGWKDWRGGPDLV
    FKDUPDQWFXULRVLW\*DUFRQLQWKHFDIpDWZLOO,YHQHYHUNQRZQEHLQJVOLNH
    HLWKHURIWKHPEHIRUHDQGWKH\DUHWKHRQO\VRFLHW\WKDW,QRZKDYH
    :KDWDERXWPH"0DUTWKRXJKW%HQHDWKWKHQHHGWRNHHSWKLVVLPLQOLQH
    KHDGPLUHGWKHVNLQQ\IHOORZ7KLVZDVDSRZHUIXOLPSUHVVLYHLQWHOOHFWEXW
    PRUHWKHSHUVRQDOLW\FDPHWKURXJKEULVWOLQJZLWKSRZHU9ROWDLUHKDGOLYHGLQ
    DULVLQJDJH0DUTHQYLHGWKDWZDQWHGWREH9ROWDLUHVIULHQG:KDWDERXWPH"
    %XWZKDWKHVDLGZDV,GRQWVXSSRVHLWVRFFXUUHGWR\RXWKDWWKH
    ORVHURIWKHGHEDWHZLOOEHFRQVLJQHGIRUHYHUWRREOLYLRQ
    9ROWDLUHEOLQNHGKLVIDFHJLYLQJQRWKLQJDZD\
    <RXFDQWIRROPH0DUTVDLG,NQRZ\RXZDQWPRUHWKDQMXVW
    LQWHOOHFWXDOLPPRUWDOLW\
    ,GR"
    7KDW\RXDOUHDG\KDYH<RXYHEHHQUHFUHDWHG
    ,DVVXUH\RXP\GHILQLWLRQRIOLYLQJLVPRUHWKDQEHFRPLQJDSDWWHUQ
    RIQXPEHUV
    7KDWERWKHUHG0DUTEXWKHSDVVHGLWRYHUIRUWKHPRPHQW5HPHPEHU,
    FDQUHDG\RXUPHPVSDFH,KDSSHQWRUHFDOOWKDWRQFHZKHQ\RXZHUHZHOO
    DGYDQFHGLQ\HDUVXQIRUFHGE\\RXUIDWKHUDQGRI\RXURZQIUHHZLOO\RX
    DFWXDOO\UHFHLYHG(DVWHUFRPPXQLRQ
    $KEXW,UHIXVHGLWDWWKHHQG$OO,ZDQWHGZDVWREHOHIWWRGLHLQ
    SHDFH
    $OORZPHWRTXRWHIURP\RXUIDPRXVSRHP7KH/LVERQ(DUWKTXDNH3DUW
    RIWKHDQFLOODU\PHPRU\VSDFH
    6DGLVWKHSUHVHQWLIQRIXWXUHVWDWH1REOLVVIXOUHWULEXWLRQPRUWDOV
    ZDLW
    ,IIDWHVGHFUHHVWKHWKLQNLQJEHLQJGRRP
    7RORVHH[LVWHQFHLQWKHVLOHQWWRPE
    9ROWDLUHZDYHUHG7UXH,VDLGWKDWDQGZLWKZKDWHORTXHQFH%XW
    HYHU\RQHZKRHQMR\VOLIHORQJVWRH[WHQGLW
    <RXURQO\FKDQFHDWDIXWXUHVWDWHLVWRZLQWKHGHEDWH,WVDJDLQVW
    \RXURZQEHVWLQWHUHVWDQGZHDOONQRZKRZIRQG\RXYHDOZD\VEHHQRIWKDW
    WRGHOHWHWKH0DLGVPHPRU\RIEHLQJEXUQHGDOLYH
    9ROWDLUHVFRZOHG0DUTFRXOGVHHUXQQLQJLQGLFHVRQKLVVLGHVFUHHQ
    %DVLV6WDWHIOXFWXDWLRQVZHOOERXQGHGEXWWKHHQYHORSHZDVJURZLQJDQRUDQJH
    F\OLQGHUIDWWHQLQJLQVSDFHELOORZLQJRXWXQGHUSUHVVXUHIURPWKHTXLFN
    VNLWWHULQJWDQJOHVLQVLGH(PRWLRQ$JHQWVLQWHUFKDQJLQJSDFNHWVDWKLJKVSHHG
    LQGLFDWLQJDFXVSSRLQWDSSURDFKLQJ
    0DUTVWURNHGDSDG,WZDVWHPSWLQJWRPDNHWKHVLPEHOLHYHZKDW0DUT
    ZDQWHGEXWWKDWZRXOGEHWULFN\+HZRXOGKDYHWRLQWHJUDWHWKHLGHDFOXVWHU
    LQWRWKHZKROHSHUVRQDOLW\6HOIV\QWKHVLVZRUNHGPXFKEHWWHU%XWLWFRXOG
    RQO\EHQXGJHGQRWIRUFHG
    9ROWDLUHVPRRGGDUNHQHG0DUTVDZEXWWKHIDFHVWHSSHGGRZQLQWR
    VORZPRVKRZHGRQO\DSHQVLYHVWDUH,WKDGWDNHQ0DUT\HDUVWROHDUQWKDW
    SHRSOHDQGVLPVDOLNHFRXOGPDVNWKHLUHPRWLRQVTXLWHZHOO
    7U\DOLWWOHKXPRUPD\EH+HWKXPEHGEDFNWRSDFHDQGVDLG,I\RX
    JLYHPHD KDUGWLPHIHOOD,PJRLQJWRJLYHKHUWKDWVFXUULORXVSRHP\RX
    ZURWHDERXWKHU
    /D3XFHOOH"<RXZRXOGQW
    :RXOGQW,<RXOOEHOXFN\LIVKHHYHUVSHDNVWR\RXDJDLQ
    $FDQQ\VPLUN0RQVLHXUIRUJHWVWKH0DLGGRHVQRWNQRZKRZWRUHDG
    ,OOVHHWRLWVKHOHDUQV2UEHWWHU\HWUHDGLWWRKHUP\VHOI

    ,OOLWHUDWHVXUHEXWVKHGDPQVXUHLVQWGHDI
    9ROWDLUHJODUHGPXWWHULQJ%HWZHHQ6F\OODDQG&KDU\EGLV
    :KDWZDVWKDWPLQGSORWWLQJVKDUSDVDVFDOSHO"+HRULWZDV
    LQWHJUDWLQJLQWRWKLVGLJLWDOZRUOGIDVWHUWKDQDQ\VLP0DUTKDGHYHUNQRZQ
    2QFHWKHGHEDWHZDVRYHU0DUTYRZHGWRVWULSWKDWPLQGGRZQDQGVWXG\LWV
    FXWWLQJHGJHVDJDLQSXWLWVSURFHVVRUOD\RXWVXQGHUWKHVFRSH$QGWKHUHZDV
    WKDWRGGPHPRU\IURPHLJKWWKRXVDQG\HDUVDJRWRR6HOGRQKDGEHHQDELWRGG
    DERXWWKDW
    ,SURPLVHWRSURGXFHODOHWWUHLI\RXZLOOMXVWOHWPHVHHKHURQFH
    PRUH,QUHWXUQ\RXOOYRZQHYHUWRVRPXFKDVPHQWLRQ/D3XFHOHWRWKH
    0DLG
    1RIXQQ\EXVLQHVV0DUTZDUQHG,OOZDWFK\RXUHYHU\PRYH
    $V\RXZLVK
    0DUTUHWXUQHG9ROWDLUHWRWKHFDIHZKHUH-RDQDQG*DUFRQ$'0ZHUH
    ZDLWLQJUXQQLQJWKHLURZQLQWURVSHFWLRQV+HGEDUHO\FDOOHGWKHPXSZKHQKH
    ZDVPRPHQWDULO\GLVWUDFWHGE\DNQRFNRQKLVGRRU1LP
    .DII"
    6XUH0DUTJODQFHGEDFNDWWKHFDIHVLP/HWWKHPYLVLWDZKLOH7KH
    PRUH9ROWDLUHNQHZWKHVKDUSHUKHGEHODWHU*RWDQ\RIWKDWVHQVRSRZGHU"
    %HHQDWRXJKGD\
    

    <RXURUGHUVVDLG*DUFRQ$'0ZLWKDIORXULVK
    +HZDVKDYLQJGLIILFXOW\IROORZLQJWKHDUJXPHQWVEHWZHHQWKH0DLGDQG
    WKH0RQVLHXURQZKHWKHUEHLQJVOLNHKLPVHOISRVVHVVHGDVRXO0RQVLHXUVHHPHG
    WREHOLHYHWKDWQRRQHDWDOOKDGDVRXOZKLFKRXWUDJHGWKH0DLG7KH\DUJXHG
    ZLWKVXFKKHDWWKH\GLGQRWQRWLFHWKHGLVDSSHDUDQFHRI WKHRGGJKRVWSUHVHQFH
    ZKRXVXDOO\ZDWFKHGWKHPDSURJUDPPHURIWKLVVSDFH
    1RZZDV*DUFRQVFKDQFHWRLPSORUH0RQVLHXUWRLQWHUYHQHRQKLVEHKDOI
    DQGDVNKLVKXPDQPDVWHUVWRJLYHKLPDQDPH$'0ZDVMXVWDPHFKIRON
    FRGHLGHQWLILHGKLVIXQFWLRQPHFKZDLWHUSODFHGKLPLQWKLV6HFWRUDQG
    $'0VWRRGIRU$X['HX[0DJRWV+HZDVVXUHKHGKDYHDEHWWHUFKDQFHRI
    DWWUDFWLQJWKHKRQH\KDLUHGVKRUWRUGHUFRRNVDWWHQWLRQLIKHKDGDKXPDQ
    QDPH
    0RQVLHXU0DGDPH<RXURUGHUVSOHDVH
    :KDWJRRGLVRUGHULQJ"0RQVLHXUVQDSSHG3DWLHQFH*DUFRQREVHUYHG
    ZDVQRWLPSURYHGE\OHDUQLQJ:HFDQQRWWDVWHDWKLQJ
    *DUFRQJHVWXUHGV\PSDWKHWLFDOO\ZLWKWZRRIKLVIRXUKDQGV+HKDGQR
    H[SHULHQFHRIKXPDQVHQVHVH[FHSWVLJKWVRXQGDQGUXGLPHQWDU\WRXFKWKRVH
    QHFHVVDU\WRSHUIRUPKLVMRE+HZRXOGKDYHJLYHQDQ\WKLQJWRWDVWHWRIHHO
    KXPDQVVHHPHGWRGHULYHVXFKSOHDVXUHIURPLW
    7KH0DLGSHUXVHGWKHPHQXDQGFKDQJLQJWKHVXEMHFWVDLG,OOKDYHP\
    XVXDO$FUXVWRIEUHDG,OOWU\DVRXUGRXJK EDJXHWWHFUXVWIRUDFKDQJH
    $VRXUGRXJKEDJXHWWH0RQVLHXUHFKRHG
    DQGWRGLSLWLQDELWRIFKDPSDJQH
    0RQVLHXUVKRRNKLVKDQGDVLIWRFRROLWRII,FRPPHQG\RX*DUFRQ
    IRUGRLQJVXFKDILQHMRERIWHDFKLQJWKH0DLGWRUHDGWKHPHQX
    0DGDPH/D6FLHQWLVWHSHUPLWWHGLW*DUFRQVDLGKHGLGQRWZDQW
    WURXEOHZLWKKLVKXPDQPDVWHUVZKRFRXOGSXOOWKHSOXJRQKLPDWDQ\WLPH
    0RQVLHXUZDYHGDGLVPLVVLYHKDQG6KHVPXFKWRRGHWDLOREVHVVHG6KHG
    QHYHUVXUYLYHRQKHURZQLQ3DULVPXFKOHVVDWDQ\UR\DOFRXUW0DUT
    KRZHYHUZLOOJRIDU/DFNRIVFUXSOHVLVIRUWXQHVIDYRULWHJUHDVH,
    FHUWDLQO\GLGQRWSURFHHGIURPSHQXU\WREHLQJRQHRIWKHZHDOWKLHVWFLWL]HQV
    LQ)UDQFHE\FRQIXVLQJLGHDOVZLWKVFUXSOHV
    +DV0RQVLHXUGHFLGHGRQKLVRUGHU"*DUFRQDVNHG
    <HV<RXUHWRLQVWUXFWWKH0DLGLQPRUHDGYDQFHGWH[WVVRWKDWVKHFDQ

    UHDGP\SRHP2QWKH1HZWRQLDQ3KLORVRSK\DORQJZLWKDOOP\OHWWUHV
    3KLORVRSKLTXHV+HUUHDVRQLQJLVWREHFRPHDVHTXDODVSRVVLEOHZLWKP\RZQ
    1RWWKDWDQ\RQHVUHDVRQLVOLNHO\WREHFRPHVRKHDGGHGZLWKKLVFRFN\
    VPLOH
    <RXUPRGHVW\LVHTXDOHGRQO\E\\RXUZLWVDLGWKH0DLGGUDZLQJIURP
    0RQVLHXUDVPLUN\ODXJK
    *DUFRQVDGO\VKRRNKLVKHDG,PDIUDLGWKDWZRQWEHSRVVLEOH,DP
    XQDEOHWR LQVWUXFWDQ\RQHH[FHSWLQVLPSOHSKUDVHV0\OLWHUDF\SHUPLWV
    FRPSUHKHQVLRQRIQRWKLQJEH\RQGPHQXV,PKRQRUHGE\0RQVLHXUVGHVLUHWR
    DGYDQFHP\VWDWLRQ%XWHYHQZKHQRSSRUWXQLW\NQRFNV,DQGP\NLQGFRQVLJQHG
    IRUHYHUWRWKHORZHVWOHYHOVRIVRFLHW\FDQQRWDQVZHUWKHGRRU
    7KHORZHUFODVVHVRXJKWWRNHHSWKHLUSODFH9ROWDLUHDVVXUHGKLP
    %XW,OOPDNHDQH[FHSWLRQLQ\RXUFDVH<RXVHHPDPELWLRXV$UH\RX"
    *DUFRQJODQFHGDWWKHKRQH\KDLUHGFRRN$PELWLRQLVXQVXLWHGWRRQHRI
    P\UDQN
    :KDWZRXOG\RXEHWKHQ",I\RXFRXOGEHDQ\WKLQJ\RXOLNH"
    *DUFRQKDSSHQHGWRNQRZWKDWWKHFRRNVSHQWKHUWKUHHGD\VDZHHNRII
    *DUFRQKLPVHOIZRUNHGVHYHQGD\VDZHHNLQWKHFRUULGRUVRIWKH/RXYUH$
    PHFKJXLGHDWWKH/RXYUHKHVDLG2QHVPDUWHQRXJKDQGZLWKVXIILFLHQW
    OHLVXUHWRFRXUWDZRPDQZKREDUHO\NQRZV,H[LVW
    0RQVLHXUVDLGJUDQGO\,OOILQGDZD\WRKRZGRWKH\VD\LW"
    'RZQORDGKLPWKH0DLGYROXQWHHUHG
    0RQGLHX0RQVLHXUH[FODLPHG$OUHDG\VKHFDQUHDGDVZHOODV\RX
    %XW,ZLOOQRWKDYHKHUZLWH[FHHGPLQH7KDWZRXOGEHJRLQJWRRGDPQHGIDU
    LQGHHG
    

    0DUTSXIIHGWKHSDFNHWLQWRKLVQRVHDQGZDLWHGIRUWKHUXVK
    7KDWEDG"1LPVLJQDOHGWKH6SODVKHV 6QLIIVPHFKPDLGIRUDQRWKHU
    9ROWDLUH0DUTJUXPEOHG+HUHDFKHGWKHWRSRIWKHVWLPOLIWKLVPLQG
    JHWWLQJVKDUSHUDQGVRPHKRZDWWKHVDPHWLPHOD]LHU+HKDGQHYHUTXLWHZRUNHG
    RXWKRZWKDWFRXOGEH+HVVXSSRVHGWREHP\FUHDWXUHEXWKDOIWKHWLPH
    LWVOLNH,PKLV
    +HVDEXQFKRIQXPEHUV
    6XUHEXW2QFH,HDYHVGURSSHGRQKLVVXEFRQVFLRXVVHQWHQFHIRUPLQJ
    $JHQWDQGKHZDVIUDPLQJDEXQFKRIVWXIIDERXWZLOOLVVRXOVHOILPDJH
    PDLQWHQDQFHVWXII,WKLQN
    3KLORVRSK\FRXOGEH
    :LOOKHVJRWIRUVXUH6R,YHFUHDWHGDEHLQJZLWKDVRXO"
    &DWHJRU\HUURU1LPVDLG<RXUHDEVWUDFWLQJVRXORXWRI$JHQWV
    7KDWVOLNHWU\LQJWRJRIURPDWRPVWRFRZVLQRQHMXPS
    7KDWVWKHNLQGRIOHDSWKLVVLPPDNHV
    <RXZDQWWRXQGHUVWDQGDFRZ\RXGRQWORRNIRUFRZDWRPV
    5LJKW\RXJRIRUWKHHPHUJHQWSURSHUW\6WDQGDUGWKHRU\
    7KLVVLPLVSUHGLFWDEOHEXGG\5HPHPEHUWKDW<RXWDLORUKLPXQWLO
    KHVJRWQRQRQOLQHDUHOHPHQWV\RXFDQWFRQWDLQ
    0DUTQRGGHG+HVGLIIHUHQW6RSRZHUIXO
    +HJRWVLPPHGIRUDUHDVRQZD\EDFNLQWKH'DUN$JHVVRPHZKHUH'LG
    \RXH[SHFWDGRRUPDW"2QHZKRZRXOGQWJLYH\RXDKDUGWLPH"<RXUHSUHVHQW
    DXWKRULW\ZKLFKKHEDWWOHGDOOKLVOLIH
    0DUTUDQILQJHUVWKURXJKKLVZDY\KDLU6XUHLI,ILQGDQRQOLQHDU
    FRQVWHOODWLRQ,FDQWDEVWUDFWRXW
    FDOOLWDZLOORUDVRXODQGGHOHWHLW1LPVODSSHGWKHWDEOHKDUG
    PDNLQJDZRPDQQHDUE\JLYHWKHPDVWDUWOHGJODQFH
    0DUTJDYHKLPDPRFNLQJVNHSWLFDOORRN7KHV\VWHPLVQWFRPSOHWHO\
    SUHGLFWDEOH

    6R \RXODXQFKDSDWWHUQVQLIIHU%DFNWUDFHRQLW6WLWFKLQVXE
    $JHQWVKDQGFXIIDQ\SHUVRQDV\RXFDQWIL[+H\\RXLQYHQWHGWKRVHFRJQLWLYH
    FRQVWUDLQWDOJRULWKPV<RXUHWKHEHVW
    0DUTQRGGHG$QGZKDWLILWVOLNHFXWWLQJLQWRDEUDLQLQVHDUFKRI
    FRQVFLRXVQHVV"+HWRRNDGHHSEUHDWKDQGH[KDOHGWRZDUGWKHGRPHGFHLOLQJ
    ZKHUHDPLQGOHVVHQWHUWDLQPHQWSOD\HGSUHVXPDEO\IRUWKRVHFRQNHGRIIRQ
    VWLII$Q\ZD\LWVQRWMXVWKLP0DUTPHW1LPVH\HV,ULJJHG6\E\OV
    RIILFH,HDYHVGURSRQKHUPHHWLQJVZLWK%RNHU
    1LPVODSSHGKLPRQWKHVKRXOGHU*RRGIRU\RX
    0DUTODXJKHG$EXGG\VWLFNVZLWK\RXHYHQLI\RXUHKDYLQJDVWXSLG
    VWRUP7KDWLVQWDOO
    1LPOHDQHGIRUZDUGER\LVKO\FXULRXV
    ,WKLQN,ZHQWWRRIDU0DUTVDLG
    <RXJRWFDXJKW
    1RQR<RXNQRZKRZ6\E\OLV6KHGRHVQWVXVSHFWLQWULJXHIURP
    HQHPLHVPXFKOHVVIULHQGV
    0DQHXYHULQJLVQWKHUVWURQJVXLW
    ,PQRWVXUHLWVPLQHHLWKHU0DUTVDLG
    8PPP1LPJDYHKLPDVKUHZGORRNH\HVKDOIFORVHG6RZKDWHOVH
    GLG\RXGR"
    0DUTVLJKHG,XSGDWHG9ROWDLUH*DYHKLPFURVVOHDUQLQJSURJUDPVWR
    IOHVKRXWKLVGHHSFRQIOLFWVKHOSKLPUHFRQFLOHWKHP
    1LPVH\HVZLGHQHG5LVN\
    ,ZDQWHGWRVHHZKDWDPLQGOLNHWKDWFRXOGGR:KHQZLOO,JHWDQRWKHU
    FKDQFH"
    +RZGR\RXIHHODERXWLWWKRXJK"
    0DUTFKXIIHG1LPRQWKHVKRXOGHUWRKLGHKLVHPEDUUDVVPHQW
    .LQGDURWWHQ6\E\ODQG,ERWKDJUHHGQRWWRGRLW
    )DLWKGRHVQWQHHGWREHWRRVPDUW
    ,WKRXJKWRIWKDWH[FXVHWRR
    :KDWVWKDWJX\6HOGRQWKLQNRIDOOWKLV"
    :HKDYHQWWROGKLP
    $K
    +HZDQWVLWWKDWZD\.HHSVKLVKDQGVFOHDQ
    1LPQRGGHG/RRNEXGG\GHHGVGRQH+RZGLGWKHVLPWDNHLW"
    -ROWHGKLP%LJRVFLOODWLRQVRQWKHQHXUDOQHWV
    2ND\QRZWKRXJK"
    6HHPVVR,WKLQNKHVUHLQWHJUDWHG
    'RHV\RXUFOLHQWNQRZ"
    <HV7KH6NHSWLFVDUHDOOIRULW,IRUHVHHQRSUREOHPWKHUH
    <RXUHGRLQJUHDOUHVHDUFKRQWKLVRQH1LPVDLG*RRGIRUWKHILHOG
    ,PSRUWDQW
    6RKRZFRPH,IHHOOLNHKDYLQJPD\EH DGR]HQRUVRVQLIIV"+HMHUNHGD
    WKXPEDWWKHPRURQPRYLHRQWKHFHLOLQJ6RWKDW,OOOROOEDFNDQGWKLQN
    WKDWVWHUULIVWXII"
    

    1RZSD\DWWHQWLRQ9ROWDLUHVDLGZKHQWKHVFLHQWLVWDWODVWDQVZHUHG
    KLVFDOO&DUHIXOO\
    +HFOHDUHGKLVWKURDWIOXQJRXWKLVDUPVDQGUHDGLHGKLPVHOIWR
    GHFODLPWKHEULOOLDQWDUJXPHQWVKHGGHWDLOHGDOOVKDSHGLQDQRWKHUOHWWUH
    7KHVFLHQWLVWVH\HVZHUHVOLWVKLVIDFHSDOH9ROWDLUHZDVLUNHG
    'RQW\RXZDQWWRKHDU"
    +DQJRYHU
    <RXYHGLVFRYHUHGDVLQJOHJHQHUDOWKHRU\H[SODLQLQJZK\WKHXQLYHUVH
    VRYDVWLVWKHRQO\SRVVLEOHRQHLWVIRUFHVDOOH[DFWDQGKDYHQRFXUHIRU

    KDQJRYHU"
    1RWP\DUHDKHVDLGUDJJHGO\$VNDSK\VLFLVW
    9ROWDLUHFOLFNHGKHHOVWKHQERZHGLQWKH3UXVVLDQZD\KHGOHDUQHGDW
    )UHGHULFNWKH*UHDWVFRXUW 7KRXJKKHKDGDOZD\VPXWWHUHGWRKLPVHOI*HUPDQ
    SXSSHWVDVKHGLGVR 7KHGRFWULQHRIDVRXOGHSHQGVRQWKHLGHDRIDIL[HG
    DQGLPPXWDEOHVHOI1RHYLGHQFHVXSSRUWVWKHQRWLRQRIDVWDEOH,DQ
    HVVHQWLDOHJRHQWLW\O\LQJEH\RQGHDFKLQGLYLGXDOH[LVWHQFH
    7UXHVDLGWKHVFLHQWLVWWKRXJKRGGFRPLQJIURP\RX
    'RQWLQWHUUXSW1RZKRZFDQZHH[SODLQWKHVWXEERUQLOOXVLRQRID
    IL[HGVHOIRUVRXO"7KURXJKILYHIXQFWLRQVWKHPVHOYHVFRQFHSWXDOSURFHVVHV
    DQGQRWIL[HGHOHPHQWV)LUVWDOOEHLQJVSRVVHVVSK\VLFDOPDWHULDO
    TXDOLWLHVZKLFKFKDQJHVRVORZO\WKDWWKH\DSSHDUWREHIL[HGEXWZKLFKDUH
    DFWXDOO\LQFRQVWDQWPDWHULDOIOX[
    7KHVRXOVVXSSRVHGWRRXWODVWWKRVH7KHVFLHQWLVWSLQFKHGWKHEULGJH
    RIKLVQRVHEHWZHHQWKXPEDQGIRUHILQJHU
    1RLQWHUUXSWLRQV6HFRQGWKHUHLVWKHLOOXVLRQRIDIL[HGHPRWLRQDO
    PDNHXSZKHQDFWXDOO\IHHOLQJVDVHYHQWKDWUXGHSOD\ZULJKW6KDNHVSHDUH
    SRLQWHGRXWZD[DQGZDQHDVLQFRQVWDQWO\DVWKHPRRQ7KH\WRRDUHLQ
    FRQVWDQWIOX[WKRXJKQRGRXEWWKHVHPRWLRQVMXVWOLNHWKHPRRQVREH\
    SK\VLFDOODZV
    +H\ZDLW7KDWVWXIIHDUOLHUDERXWWKHWKHRU\RIWKHXQLYHUVHGLG
    \RXNQRZWKDWEDFNLQWKRVH'DUN$JHV"
    ,GHGXFHGLWIURPWKHDXJPHQWDWLRQV\RXJDYHPH
    7KHPDQEOLQNHGREYLRXVO\LPSUHVVHG,KDGQWDQWLFLSDWHG
    9ROWDLUHVXSSUHVVHGKLVLUULWDWLRQ$Q\DXGLHQFHHYHQRQHWKDWLQVLVWHG
    RQSDUWLFLSDWLQJZDVEHWWHUWKDQQRQH/HWKLPFDWFKXSZLWKWKHLPSOLFDWLRQV
    RIKLVRZQDFWLRQVLQKLVRZQ JRRGWLPH7KLUGSHUFHSWLRQ7KHVHQVHV
    XSRQH[DPLQDWLRQDOVRWXUQRXWWREHSURFHVVHVLQFRQVWDQWPRWLRQQRWLQ
    WKHOHDVWIL[HG
    7KHVRXO
    )RXUWK9ROWDLUHZDVGHWHUPLQHGWRLJQRUHEDQDOLQWHUSRODWLRQV
    (YHU\RQHKDVKDELWVGHYHORSHGRYHUWKH\HDUV%XWWKHVHWRRDUHPDGHXSRI
    FRQVWDQWIORZLQJDFWLRQ'HVSLWHWKHDSSHDUDQFHRIUHSHWLWLRQWKHUHVQRWKLQJ
    IL[HGRULPPXWDEOHKHUH
    7KH*UDQG8QLYHUVDO7KHRU\WKDWVZKDW\RXDFFHVVHGULJKW"+RZG\RX
    FUDFNWKHILOHV",GLGQWJLYH\RX
    )LQDOO\WKHSKHQRPHQRQRIFRQVFLRXVQHVVWKHVRFDOOHGVRXOLWVHOI
    %HOLHYHGE\SULHVWVDQGIRROVDUHGXQGDQF\WKDWWREHGHWDFKDEOHIURPWKH
    IRXUSKHQRPHQD,YHQDPHG%XWFRQVFLRXVQHVVLWVHOIH[KLELWVFKDUDFWHULVWLFV
    RIIORZLQJPRWLRQDVZLWKWKHRWKHUIRXU$OOILYHRIWKHVHIXQFWLRQVDUH
    FRQVWDQWO\JURXSLQJDQGUHJURXSLQJ7KHERG\LVIRUHYHULQIOX[DVLVDOO
    HOVH3HUPDQHQFHLVDQLOOXVLRQ+HUDFOLWXVZDVDEVROXWHO\ULJKW<RXFDQQRW
    VHWIRRWLQWRWKHVDPH ULYHUWZLFH7KHKXQJRYHUPDQ,PUHJDUGLQJQRZSDXVH
    EXWDVHFRQGLVQRWWKHVDPHKXQJRYHUPDQ,DPUHJDUGLQJQRZ(YHU\WKLQJLV
    GLVVROXWLRQDQGGHFD\
    7KHVFLHQWLVWFRXJKHGJURDQHG'DPQULJKW
    DVZHOODVJURZLQJEORVVRPLQJ&RQVFLRXVQHVVLWVHOIFDQQRWEH
    VHSDUDWHGIURPLWVFRQWHQWV:HDUHSXUHGHHG7KHUHLVQRGRHU7KHGDQFHU
    FDQWEHVHSDUDWHGIURPWKHGDQFH6FLHQFHDIWHUP\WLPHFRQILUPVWKLVYLHZ
    /RRNHGDWFORVHO\WKHDWRPLWVHOIGLVDSSHDUV7KHUHLVQRDWRPVWULFWO\
    VSHDNLQJ7KHUHLVRQO\ZKDWWKHDWRPGRHV)XQFWLRQLVHYHU\WKLQJ(UJR
    WKHUHLVQRIL[HGDEVROXWHHQWLW\FRPPRQO\NQRZQDVVRXO
    )XQQ\\RXVKRXOGEULQJXSWKHLVVXHVDLGWKHVFLHQWLVWORRNLQJDW
    9ROWDLUHPHDQLQJIXOO\
    +HZDYHGDZD\WKHSRLQW6LQFHHYHQUXGLPHQWDU\DUWLILFLDO
    LQWHOOLJHQFHVVXFKDV*DUFRQH[KLELWDOOWKHIXQFWLRQDOFKDUDFWHULVWLFV,KDYH
    QDPHGHYHQVRLWZRXOGDSSHDUFRQVFLRXVQHVVLWLVXQUHDVRQDEOHWRZLWKKROG

    IURPWKHPULJKWVWKDWZHHQMR\WKRXJKDOORZLQJQDWXUDOO\IRUFODVV
    GLIIHUHQFHV6LQFHLQWKLVGLVWDQWHUDIDUPHUVVKRSNHHSHUVDQGZLJPDNHUVDUH
    JUDQWHGSULYLOHJHVHTXDOZLWKWKRVHRIGXNHVDQGHDUOVLWLVLUUDWLRQDOWR
    ZLWKKROGVXFKSULYLOHJHVIURPEHLQJVVXFKDV*DUFRQ
    ,IWKHUHVQRVRXOWKHUHVREYLRXVO\QRUHLQFDUQDWLRQRILWHLWKHU
    ULJKW"
    0\GHDUVLUWREHERUQWZLFHLVQRPRUHRGGWKDQWREHERUQRQFH
    7KLVVWDUWOHGWKHVFLHQWLVW%XWZKDWVUHLQFDUQDWHG":KDWFURVVHVRYHU
    IURPRQHOLIHWRWKHQH[W",IWKHUHVQRIL[HGDEVROXWHVHOI"1RVRXO"
    9ROWDLUHPDGHDQRWHLQWKHPDUJLQRIKLVOHWWUH,I\RXPHPRUL]HP\
    SRHPVZKLFKIRU\RXURZQHQOLJKWHQPHQW,XUJH\RXGRGRWKH\ORVHDQ\WKLQJ
    \RXJDLQ",I\RXOLJKWDFDQGOHIURPDQRWKHUFDQGOHVIODPHZKDWFURVVHV
    RYHU",QDUHOD\UDFHGRHVRQHUXQQHUJLYHXSDQ\WKLQJWRWKHRWKHU"+LV
    SRVLWLRQRQWKHFRXUVHQRPRUH9ROWDLUHSDXVHGIRUGUDPDWLFHIIHFW:HOO"
    :KDWGR\RXWKLQN"
    7KHVFLHQWLVWFOXWFKHGKLVVWXSHILHGKHDG,WKLQN\RXOOZLQWKH
    GHEDWH
    9ROWDLUHGHFLGHGQRZZDVWKHWLPHWRSXWIRUZDUGKLVUHTXHVW%XWWR
    DVVXUHP\YLFWRU\,PXVWFRPSRVHDQDGGLWLRQDOOHWWUHPRUHWHFKQLFDOIRU
    W\SHVZKRHTXDWHYHUEDOV\PEROVZLWKPHUHUKHWRULFZLWKHPSW\ZRUGV
    +DYHDWLWVDLGWKHVFLHQWLVW
    )RUWKDW9ROWDLUHVDLG,ZLOOQHHG\RXUKHOS
    <RXJRWLW
    9ROWDLUHVPLOHGZLWKZKDWKHKRSHGZDVDQDSSHDOLQJVLQFHULW\VLQFH
    WKDWZDVZKDWKHPRVWFHUWDLQO\ZDVQRW<RXPXVWJLYHPHHYHU\WKLQJ\RXNQRZ
    RIVLPXODWLRQPHWKRGV
    :KDW":K\"
    7KLVZLOOQRWPHUHO\VSDUH\RXLPPHQVHODERU,WZLOOHQDEOHPHWR
    ZULWHDWHFKQLFDOOHWWUHDLPHGDWFRQYHUWLQJVSHFLDOLVWVDQGH[SHUWVWRRXU
    SRLQWRIYLHZ)DUPRUHWKDQWKRVHLQ-XQLQ6HFWRU$OO7UDQWRUWKHQDOOWKH
    *DOD[\PXVWEHFRQYHUWHGRUHOVHUHDFWLRQDULHVVKDOOUHERXQGDQGFUXVK\RXU
    YDXQWHGUHQDLVVDQFH
    <RXOOQHYHUEHDEOHWRIROORZWKHPDWK
    7KH1HZWRQLDQFDOFXODWLRQV,EURXJKWWR)UDQFH,UHPLQG\RX*LYHPH
    WKHWRROV
    &OXWFKLQJKLVWHPSOHVWKHVFLHQWLVWVOXPSHGIRUZDUGRYHUKLVFRQWURO
    ERDUGZLWKDPRDQ2QO\LI\RXSURPLVHQRWWRFDOOPHIRUDWOHDVWWKHQH[W
    WHQKRXUV
    0DLVRXLVDLG9ROWDLUHZLWKDQLPSLVKVPLOH0RQVLHXUUHTXLUHVWLPH
    KRZGR\RXVD\LWHQ$QJODLV"WRVOHHSLWRII
    

    6\E\OZDLWHGQHUYRXVO\IRUKHUWXUQRQWKHDJHQGDRIWKHH[HFXWLYH
    PHHWLQJRI$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHV6KHVDWRSSRVLWH0DUTFRQWULEXWLQJQRWKLQJWR
    WKHGLVFXVVLRQDVFROOHDJXHVDQGVXSHULRUVGLVFXVVHGWKLVDVSHFWDQGWKDWRI
    WKHFRPSDQ\VRSHUDWLRQ+HUPLQGZDVHOVHZKHUHEXWQRWVRIDUJRQHDVWR
    IDLOWRQRWLFHWKHFXUO\KDLURQWKHEDFNRI0DUTVKDQGVDQGDVLQJOHYHLQ
    WKDWSXOVHGVHQVXRXVPXVLFLQKLVQHFN
    $VWKHSUHVLGHQWRI$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVGLVPLVVHGDOOWKRVHQRWGLUHFWO\
    LQYROYHGLQWKH3UHVHUYHU6NHSWLF3URMHFW6\E\ODVVHPEOHGWKHQRWHVVKHG
    SUHSDUHG WRSUHVHQWKHUFDVH2IWKRVHSUHVHQWVKHNQHZVKHFRXOGFRXQWRQO\
    RQ0DUTVVXSSRUW%XWVKHZDVFRQILGHQWWKDWZLWKLWWKHRWKHUVZRXOGJR
    DORQJZLWKKHUSURSRVDO
    7KHGD\EHIRUHVKHKDGWROGWKH6SHFLDO3URMHFWV&RPPLWWHHIRUWKH
    ILUVWWLPHWKH0DLGKDGEURNHQKHUUHFOXVLYHSDWWHUQ6KHLQLWLDWHGFRQWDFW
    LQVWHDGRIZDLWLQJWREHVXPPRQHGWUDLOLQJKHUXVXDODLURIUHOXFWDQFH6KHG

    EHHQGHHSO\GLVWXUEHGWROHDUQ IURP0RQVLHXU$URXHWWKDWVKHPXVWGHIHDWKLP
    LQZKDWVKHFDOOHGWKHWULDORUHOVHEHFRQVLJQHGRQFHDJDLQWRREOLYLRQ
    :KHQ6\E\OKDGDFNQRZOHGJHGWKDWWKDWZDVSUREDEO\WUXHWKH0DLGEHFDPH
    FRQYLQFHGWKDWVKHZDVJRLQJWREHFDVWDJDLQLQWRWKH ILUH'LVRULHQWHGDQG
    FRQIXVHGVKHEHJJHG6\E\OWRDOORZKHUWRUHWLUHWRFRQVXOWKHUYRLFHV
    6\E\OKDGIXUQLVKHGKHUZLWKUHVWIXOZDOOSDSHUEDFNJURXQGVIRUHVW
    ILHOGVWLQNOLQJVWUHDPV
    6KHSUREHGIRUYHVWLJLDOPHPRULHVOLNHWKRVH0DUTKDGPHQWLRQHGRID
    GHEDWH\HDUVDJR-RDQGLGFDUU\WUDFHVMXVWELWVVRPHRQHKDG
    RYHUORRNHGLQDSUHYLRXVHUDVLQJ-RDQLGHQWLILHG)DLWKZLWKVRPHWKLQJFDOOHG
    URERWV$SSDUHQWO\WKHVHZHUHP\WKLFDOILJXUHVZKRZRXOGJXLGHKXPDQLW\
    SHUKDSVVRPHGHLWLHV"
    6HYHUDOKRXUVODWHU-RDQKDGHPHUJHGIURPKHULQWHULRUODQGVFDSH6KH
    UHTXHVWHGKLJKOHYHOUHDGLQJVNLOOVVRWKDWVKHPLJKWFRPSHWHZLWKKHU
    LQTXLVLWRURQDPRUHHTXDOIRRWLQJ
    ,H[SODLQHGWRKHUWKDW,FRXOGQWDOWHUKHUSURJUDPPLQJZLWKRXWWKLV
    FRPPLWWHHVFRQVHQW
    :KDWDERXW\RXUFOLHQW"WKHSUHVLGHQWZDQWHGWRNQRZ
    0RQVLHXU%RNHUIRXQGRXWKHZRXOGQWWHOOPHKRZDSUHVVOHDN,
    VXVSHFWWKDW9ROWDLUHLVWREHKHUULYDOLQWKHGHEDWH1RZKHVWKUHDWHQLQJ
    WREDFNRXWXQOHVV,JLYHKHUDGGLWLRQDOGDWDDQGVNLOOV
    $QG6HOGRQ"
    +HVVD\LQJQRWKLQJ-XVWZDQWVWREHVXUHKHVQRWLPSOLFDWHG
    'RHV%RNHUNQRZZHUHKDQGOLQJ9ROWDLUHIRUWKH6NHSWLFVDVZHOODV
    -RDQIRUKLP"
    6\E\OVKRRNKHUKHDG
    7KDQNWKH&RVPLFIRUWKDW VDLGWKHH[HFXWLYHRI6SHFLDO3URMHFWV
    0DUT"WKHSUHVLGHQWDVNHGH\HEURZVUDLVHG
    6LQFH0DUTKDGRQFHVXJJHVWHGWKHYHU\FRXUVH6\E\OQRZSURSRVHGVKH
    DVVXPHGKLVDFFRUG6RVKHZDVVWXQQHGZKHQKHVDLG,PDJDLQVWLW%RWK
    VLGHVZDQWDYHUEDOGXHOEHWZHHQLQWXLWLYHIDLWKDQGLQGXFWLYHGHGXFWLYH
    UHDVRQ8SGDWHWKH0DLGDQGDOOZHZLOOVXFFHHGLQGRLQJLVPXGG\LQJWKH
    LVVXH
    0DUT6\E\OFULHGRXW
    +HDWHGGLVFXVVLRQIROORZHG0DUTILUHGRQHREMHFWLRQDIWHUDQRWKHUDW
    HYHU\RQHZKRIDYRUHGWKHLGHD([FHSW6\E\OZKRVHJD]HKHFDUHIXOO\DYRLGHG
    :KHQLWEHFDPHDSSDUHQWQRFRQVHQVXVZRXOGEHUHDFKHGWKHSUHVLGHQWPDGHWKH
    GHFLVLRQLQ6\E\OVIDYRU
    6\E\OSUHVVHGKHUDGYDQWDJH,GDOVROLNHSHUPLVVLRQWRGHOHWHIURP
    WKH0DLGVSURJUDPPLQJKHUPHPRU\RIEHLQJEXUQHGDOLYHDWWKHVWDNH+HUIHDU
    WKDWVKHOOEHVHQWHQFHGWRDVLPLODUIDWHDJDLQPDNHVLWLPSRVVLEOHIRUKHU
    WRSUHVHQWWKHFDVHIRU)DLWKDVIUHHO\DVVKHFRXOGLIWKDWPHPRU\GLGQW
    GDUNHQKHUWKRXJKWV
    ,REMHFW0DUTVDLG0DUW\UGRPLVWKHRQO\ZD\DSHUVRQFDQEHFRPH
    IDPRXVZLWKRXWDELOLW\7KH0DLGZKRGLGQRWVXIIHUPDUW\UGRPIRUKHUEHOLHIV
    LVQWWKH0DLGRISUHKLVWRU\DWDOO
    6\E\OVKRWEDFN%XWZHGRQWNQRZWKDWKLVWRU\7KHVHVLPVDUHIURP
    WKH'DUN$JHV+HUWUDXPD
    7RGHOHWHKHUPHPRU\RIWKDWH[SHULHQFHZRXOGEHOLNHZHOOWKLQNRI
    VRPHRIWKHSUHKLVWRU\OHJHQGV0DUTVSUHDGKLVKDQGV(YHQWKHLUUHOLJLRQV
    ,WZRXOGEHOLNHUHFUHDWLQJ&KULVWWKHLUDQFLHQWGHLW\ZLWKRXWKLV
    FUXFLIL[LRQ
    6\E\OJODUHGDWKLPEXW0DUTDGGUHVVHGWKHSUHVLGHQWDVLIVKHGLGQRW
    H[LVW,QWDFWWKDWVKRZRXUFOLHQWVZDQW
    ,PZLOOLQJWROHW9ROWDLUHEHGHOHWHGRIDOOKHVXIIHUHGDWWKHKDQGV
    RIDXWKRULW\WRRVKHFRXQWHUHG
    ,PQRWVDLG0DUT9ROWDLUHZLWKRXWGHILDQFHRIDXWKRULW\ZRXOGQRW

    EH9ROWDLUH
    6\E\OOHWWKHRWKHUFRPPLWWHHPHPEHUVDUJXHWKHSRLQWQRQSOXVHGE\WKH
    LQFRPSUHKHQVLEOHFKDQJHLQ0DUT,WDOOSDVVHGE\OLNHDGUHDP)LQDOO\VKH
    DFFHSWHGKHUVXSHULRUVILQDOGHFLVLRQDFRPSURPLVHEHFDXVHVKHKDGQR
    FKRLFH7KH0DLGVLQIRUPDWLRQEDQNZRXOGEHXSGDWHGEXWVKHZRXOGQRWEH
    DOORZHGWRIRUJHWKHUILHU\GHDWK1RUZRXOG9ROWDLUHEHDOORZHGWRIRUJHWWKH
    FRQVWDQWIHDURIUHSULVDOVIURPFKXUFKDQGVWDWHLQWKDWDQFLHQWPXUN\HUD
    7KHSUHVLGHQWVDLG,UHPLQG\RXWKDWZHUHVNDWLQJRQWKLQHILHOG
    KHUH6LPVOLNHWKLVDUHWDERR-XQLQ6HFWRUHOHPHQWVRIIHUHGXVDELJERQXV
    WRHYHQDWWHPSWWKLVDQGZHYHVXFFHHGHG%XWZHUHWDNLQJULVNV%LJRQHV
    $VWKH\OHIWWKHFRQIHUHQFHURRP6\E\OZKLVSHUHGWR0DUT<RXUHXSWR
    VRPHWKLQJ
    +HORRNHGGLVWUDFWHG5HVHDUFK<NQRZWKDWVZKHQ\RXUHZRUNLQJ
    KDUGEXW\RXGRQWNQRZZKHUH\RXUHJRLQJ
    +HZDONHGRQREOLYLRXVO\ZKLOHVKHVWRRGZLWKKHUPRXWKRSHQ+RZ
    FRXOGVKHUHDGWKLVPDQ"
    

    8QUHVSRQVLYHWRWKHSUHVHQFHRI0DGDPHOD6RUFLqUHWKH0DLGVDWXSULJKW
    LQKHUFHOOH\HVFORVHG:DUULQJYRLFHVSHDOHGLQVLGHKHUKHDG
    7KHQRLVHZDVOLNHWKHGLQRIEDWWOHFKDRWLFDQGILHUFH%XWLIVKH
    OLVWHQHGLQWHQWO\UHIXVLQJWRDOORZKHULPPRUWDOVSLULWWREHULSSHGIURPKHU
    PRUWDOIOHVKWKHQWKHQDGLYLQHO\RUFKHVWUDWHGSRO\SKRQ\ZRXOGVKRZKHUWKH
    ULJKWIXOFRXUVH
    7KH$UFKDQJHO0LFKDHODQG6W&DWKHULQHDQG6W0DUJDUHWIURPZKRVH
    PRXWKVKHUYRLFHVRIWHQVSRNHZHUHUHDFWLQJILHUFHO\WRKHULQYROXQWDU\
    PDVWHU\RI0RQVLHXU$URXHWV&RPSOHWH:RUNV3DUWLFXODUO\RIIHQVLYHWR0LFKDHO
    ZDVWKH(OHPHQWVGH1HZWRQZKRVHSKLORVRSK\0LFKDHOSHUFHLYHGWREH
    LQFRPSDWLEOHZLWKWKDWRIWKH&KXUFKLQGHHGZLWKKLVRZQH[LVWHQFH
    7KH0DLGKHUVHOIZDVQRWVRVXUH6KHIRXQGWRKHUVXUSULVHDSRHWU\
    DQGKDUPRQ\LQWKHHTXDWLRQVWKDWSURYHGDVLISURRIZHUHUHTXLUHGWKH
    XQVXUSDVVHGUHDOLW\RIWKH&UHDWRUZKRVHSK\VLFDOODZVPLJKWEHIDWKRPDEOH
    EXWZKRVHSXUSRVHVZHUHQRW
    +RZVKHNQHZWKHVHEHDXWLHVZDVUDWKHUP\VWHULRXV6KHVDZLQWRWKH
    FDOFXOXVRIIRUFHDQGPRWLRQWKHZKLUORIZRUOGV/LNHWKHORUGVDQGODGLHV
    DWFRXUWLQHUWPDWWHUPDGHLWVGLYLQHO\RUFKHVWUDWHGJDYRWWH7KHVHWKLQJV
    VKHVHQVHGZLWKKHUZKROHVHOIGLUHFWO\DVLISHQHWUDWHGE\GLYLQHLQVLJKW
    %HDXWLHVDUULYHGRXWRISDOHDLU+RZFRXOGVKHGLVFRXQWVXEOLPHSHUFHSWLRQV"
    6XFKGLYLQHLQYDVLRQPXVWEHKRO\7KDWLWFDPHWRKHU DVDIORRGRI
    PHPRU\VNLOOVDVVRFLDWLRQVRQO\SURYHGIXUWKHUWKDWLWZDVKHDYHQVHQW/D
    6RUFLqUHPXUPXUHGVRPHWKLQJDERXWFRPSXWHUILOHVDQGVXE$JHQWVEXWWKRVH
    ZHUHLQFDQWDWLRQVQRWWUXWKV
    )DUPRUHRIIHQVLYHWRKHUWKDQWKLVQHZZLVGRPIDUPRUHZDVWKDWLWV
    DXWKRUZDVDQ(QJOLVKPDQ
    /D+HQULDGHVKHWROG0LFKDHOFLWLQJDQRWKHURI0RQVLHXU$URXHWV
    ZRUNVLVPRUHUHSXOVLYHWKDQ/HV(OHPHQWV+RZGDUH0RQVLHXU$URXHWZKR
    DUURJDQWO\FDOOVKLPVHOIE\WKHIDOVHQDPH9ROWDLUHPDLQWDLQWKDWLQ(QJODQG
    UHDVRQLVIUHHZKLOHLQRXURZQEHORYHG)UDQFHLWVVKDFNOHGWRWKHGDUN
    LPDJLQLQJVRIDEVROXWLVWSULHVWV:DVLWQRW-HVXLWSULHVWVZKRILUVWWDXJKW
    WKLVLQTXLVLWRUKRZWRUHDVRQ"
    %XWZKDWHQUDJHGWKH0DLGPRVWRIDOODQGPDGHKHUWKUDVKDQGVWUDLQDW
    KHUFKDLQVXQWLOIHDULQJIRUKHUVDIHW\/D6RUFLqUHIUHHGKHUFKDIHGDQNOHV
    DQGZULVWVZDVKLVLOOHJDOO\SULQWHGVFXUULORXVSRHPDERXWKHU9LOODLQRXV
    YHUVH
    $VVRRQDVVKHZDVVXUHKHUYRLFHVKDGZLWKGUDZQVKHZDYHGDFRS\RI
    /D3XFHOHDWWKHVRUFHUHVVLQFHQVHGWKDWWKHFKDVWH6DLQWV&DWKHULQHRU

    0DUJDUHWZKRKDGPRPHQWDULO\YDQLVKHGEXWZRXOGVXUHO\UHWXUQPLJKWEH
    IRUFLEO\H[SRVHGWRLWVOHZGQHVV%RWKVDLQWVKDGDOUHDG\UHSURDFKHGKHUIRU
    KHUVLOO\JLUOLVKVSHFXODWLRQVDERXWKRZDWWUDFWLYH0RQVLHXU$URXHWPLJKWEH
    ZKDWZDVVKHWKLQNLQJ"LIKHUHPRYHGKLVULGLFXORXVZLJDQGOLODFULEERQV
    +RZGDUH0RQVLHXU$URXHWUHSUHVHQWPHWKLVZD\"VKHUDLOHGNQRZLQJ
    IXOOZHOOWKDWKHUVWXEERUQUHIXVDOWRFDOOKLP9ROWDLUHLUNHGKLPQRHQG+H
    DGGVQLQH\HDUVWRP\DJHGLVPLVVHVP\YRLFHVDVRXWULJKWOLHV$QGVODQGHUV
    %DXGULFRXUWZKRILUVWHQDEOHGPHWRSXWEHIRUHP\NLQJP\YLVLRQIRUERWKKLP
    DQG)UDQFH$ZULWHURISUHDFK\SOD\VDQGLUUHYHUHQWVODQGHUVDJDLQVWWKH
    IDLWKIXOOLNH&DQGLGHKHZHOOPD\EHEXWWKDWLQVXIIHUDEOHNQRZLWDOO
    FDOOVKLPVHOIDKLVWRULDQ,IKLVRWKHUKLVWRULFDODFFRXQWVDUHQRPRUH
    UHOLDEOHWKDQWKHRQHKHJLYHVRIPHWKH\DQGQRWP\ERG\GHVHUYHWKHILUH
    7KHZRPDQ/D6RUFLqUHSDOHGEHIRUHWKLVRQVODXJKW7KHVHSHRSOHLI
    SHRSOHWKH\ZHUHDWDOOKHUHLQDE\]DQWLQHFORXG\3XUJDWRU\EDFNHGDZD\
    IURPWKHWUXHIHURFLW\RIGLYLQH3XUSRVH-RDQWRZHUHGRYHUWKHZRPDQZLWK
    VRPHUHOLVK
    1HZWRQVFORFNZRUNZLVGRPLVDQLQWULJXLQJYLVLRQRI&UHDWLRQVODZV
    -RDQWKXQGHUHGEXW9ROWDLUHVKLVWRU\LVDZRUNRIKLVLPDJLQDWLRQPDGHXS
    RIWKUHHSDUWVELOHWZRVSOHHQ
    6KHUDLVHGKHUULJKWDUPLQWKHVDPHJHVWXUHVKHGXVHGWROHDGKHU
    VROGLHUVDQGWKHNQLJKWVRI)UDQFHLQWREDWWOHDJDLQVWWKH(QJOLVKNLQJDQG
    KLVPLQLRQVRIZKRPVKHQRZVDZFOHDUO\0RQVLHXU$URXHWGH9ROWDLUHZDV
    RQH$ZDUULRUIHPPHLQVSLUDWULFHZLWKDQLQWHQVHDYHUVLRQWRWKHNLOOVKH
    QRZYRZHGDOORXWZDUDJDLQVWWKLVWKLVVKHJDVSHGLQH[DVSHUDWLRQ7KLV
    QRXYHDXULFKHERXUJHRLVXSVWDUWGDUOLQJRIWKHDULVWRFUDWLFFODVVZKRVQHYHU
    NQRZQUHDOZDQWRUQHHGDQGWKLQNVKRUVHVDUHEUHGZLWKFDUULDJHVEHKLQG
    WKHP
    *HWKLP/D6RUFLqUHDEOD]HZLWKWKH0DLGVILUHUDJHG7KDWVZKDW
    ZHZDQW
    :KHUHLVKH"GHPDQGHGWKH0DLG:KHUHLVWKLVVKDOORZOLWWOHSLVVRLU
    VWUHDP"WKDW,PD\GURZQKLPLQWKHGHSWKVRIDOO,KDYHVXIIHUHG
    2GGO\/D6RUFLqUHVHHPHGSOHDVHGE\DOOWKLVDVLILWILWVRPHGHVLJQ
    RIKHURZQ
    

    9ROWDLUHFDFNOHGZLWKVDWLVIDFWLRQ7KHFDIHDSSHDUHGSRSSLQJLQWR
    OXPLQRXVUHDOLW\LQGHSHQGHQWRIKLVKXPDQPDVWHUVFRQVHQWRUNQRZOHGJH
    6XEURXWLQHDFFRPSOLVKHGDVPDOOYRLFHDVVXUHGKLP+HPDGHWKHFDIH
    GLVDSSHDUDQGUHDSSHDUWKUHHWLPHVPRUHWREHVXUHWKDWKHKDGPDVWHUHGWKH
    WHFKQLTXH
    :KDWIRROVWKHVHUXOHUVZHUHWRWKLQNWKDWWKH\FRXOGPDNHWKH*UHDW
    9ROWDLUHDFUHDWXUHRIWKHLUZLOO%XWQRZFDPHWKHUHDOWHVWWKHLQWULFDWH
    SURFHGXUHWKDWZRXOGEULQJIRUWKWKH0DLGLQDOOKHUZRPDQO\XQIDWKRPDELOLW\
    ZKLFKKRZHYHUKHZDVGHWHUPLQHGWRIDWKRP
    +HKDGPDVWHUHGWKHLQWULFDWHORJLFVRIWKLVSODFHJLYHQWKHFDSDFLWLHV
    WKHPDQVFLHQWLVWKDGJLYHQKLP'LGWKH\WKLQNKHZDVVRPHDQLPDOXQDEOHWR
    DSSO\EOLWKHUHDVRQWRWKHLUODE\ULQWKVRIORJLF"+HKDGIRXQGKLVZD\WUDFHG
    WKHZLQGLQJHOHFWURQLFSDWKZD\VGHYLVHGWKHFRPPDQGV1HZWRQKDGEHHQMXVWDV
    GLIILFXOWDQGKHKDGHQFRPSDVVHGWKDWKDGKHQRW"
    1RZWKH0DLG+HGLGKLVGLJLWDOGDQFHLWVORJLFVDQG
    6KHSRSSHGLQWRWKHFDIH
    <RXVFXPVKHVDLGODQFHGUDZQ
    1RWTXLWHWKHJUHHWLQJKHGH[SHFWHG%XWWKHQKHVDZWKHFRS\RI/D
    3XFHOOHGDQJOLQJRQWKHSRLQWRIKHUODQFH
    &KHULHKHFRRHGZKDWHYHUWKHRIIHQVHEHVWWRJHWLQDQDSRORJ\
    HDUO\,FDQH[SODLQ

    7KDWV\RXUZKROHSUREOHPWKH0DLGVDLG<RXH[SODLQDQGH[SODLQDQG
    H[SODLQ<RXUSOD\VDUHPRUHWHGLRXVWKDQWKHVHUPRQV,ZDVIRUFHGWROLVWHQ
    WRLQWKHFHPHWHU\DW6W2XHQ<RXUUDLOLQJVDJDLQVWWKHVDFUHGP\VWHULHVRI
    WKH&KXUFKUHYHDODVKDOORZXQIHHOLQJPLQGEHUHIWRIDZHDQGZRQGHU
    <RXPXVWQWWDNHLWSHUVRQDOO\9ROWDLUHSOHDGHG,WZDVGLUHFWHGDW
    K\SRFULWLFDOUHYHUHQFHIRU\RXDQGDWWKHVXSHUVWLWLRQVRIUHOLJLRQ0\
    IULHQG7KLHULRWKHDGGHGSDVVDJHVPRUHSURIDQHDQGREVFHQHWKDQDQ\,KDG
    ZULWWHQ+HQHHGHGPRQH\+HPDGHDOLYLQJUHFLWLQJWKHSRHPLQYDULRXV
    VDORQV0\SRRUYLUJLQEHFDPHDQLQIDPRXVZKRUHPDGHWRVD\JURVVDQG
    LQWROHUDEOHWKLQJV
    7KH0DLGGLGQRWORZHUKHUODQFH,QVWHDGVKHSRNHGLWVHYHUDOWLPHV
    DJDLQVW9ROWDLUHVVDWLQZDLVWFRDWHGFKHVW
    &KHULHKHVDLG,I\RXNQHZKRZPXFK,SDLGIRUWKLVYHVW
    <RXPHDQKRZPXFK)UHGHULFNSDLGWKDWSLWLIXOSURPLVFXRXV
    SURIOLJDWHSHUYHUWRIDPDQ
    $OOLWHUDWLRQDELWKHDY\9ROWDLUHVDLGEXWRWKHUZLVHDTXLWH
    QLFHO\WXUQHGSKUDVH
    +LVQHZO\JDLQHGVNLOOVPHDQWKHFRXOGGLYHVWKHURIKHUODQFHDWRQFH
    VTXDVKLW%XWKHSUHIHUUHGSHUVXDVLYHQHVVWRIRUFH+HTXRWHGZLWKVRPH
    OLEHUW\WKDWSOHDVXUHKDWLQJ&KULVWLDQ3DXO:KHQ,ZDVDFKLOG,VSRNHDV
    DFKLOGWKRXJKWDVDFKLOGEHKDYHGDVDFKLOG%XWZKHQ,EHFDPHDZRPDQ,
    SXWDZD\PDQO\WKLQJV
    6KHEOLQNHG+HUHPHPEHUHGKRZKHULQTXLVLWRUVKDGFODLPHGWKDWKHU
    DFFHSWDQFHRIWKHJLIWRIDILQHFORDNZDVLQFRPSDWLEOHZLWKWKHGLYLQHRULJLQ
    RIKHUYRLFHV,QDZKLVNRIOLWKHDUPV9ROWDLUHSURGXFHGD&KDQWLOO\ODFH
    JRZQ3RSDQGDULFKO\HPEURLGHUHGFORDN
    <RXPRFNPHWKH0DLGVDLG%XWQRWEHIRUHKHVDZDJOHDPRILQWHUHVW
    IODUHLQKHUFRDOGDUNH\HV
    ,ORQJWRVHH\RXDV\RXDUH+HKHOGRXWWKHJRZQDQGFORDN<RXU
    VSLULW,KDYHQRGRXEWLVGLYLQHEXW\RXUQDWXUDOIRUPOLNHPLQHLVKXPDQ
    XQOLNHPLQHDZRPDQV
    <RXWKLQN,FRXOGJLYHXSWKHIUHHGRPRIDPDQIRUWKDW"6KHLPSDOHG
    WKHFORDNDQGJRZQRQWKHWLSRIKHUODQFH
    1RWWKHIUHHGRP9ROWDLUHVDLG-XVWWKH DUPRUDQGFORWKHV
    6KHIHOOVLOHQWSHQVLYHO\JD]LQJLQWRWKHGLVWDQFH7KHFURZGRQWKH
    VWUHHWZHQWDERXWWKHLUEXVLQHVVZDONLQJE\XQFRQFHUQHG2EYLRXVZDOOSDSHU
    KHWKRXJKWKHZRXOGKDYHWRFRUUHFWWKDW
    3HUKDSVDWULFN6KHZDVSDUWLDOWRPLUDFOHV$QRWKHUOLWWOHWULFN,YH
    OHDUQHGVLQFHZHODVWPHW9RLOD,FDQSURGXFH*DUFRQ
    *DUFRQSRSSHGLQRXWRIQRZKHUHDOOIRXURIKLVKDQGVIUHH7KH0DLG
    ZKRKDGLQGHHGRQFHZRUNHGLQDWDYHUQKHUHFDOOHGFRXOGQRWKHOSLWVKH
    VPLOHG6KHDOVRUHPRYHGWKHJRZQDQGFORDNIURPWKHODQFHWRVVHGWKHODQFH
    DVLGHDQGFDUHVVHGWKHFORWKHV
    +HFRXOGQRWUHVLVWWKHLPSXOVHWRTXRWHKLPVHOI
    )RU,DPPDQDQGMXVWO\SURXG
    ,QKXPDQZHDNQHVVWRKDYHSDUW
    3DVWPLVWUHVVHVKDYHKHOGP\KHDUW
    ,PKDSS\VWLOOZKHQWKXVDURXVHG
    +HIHOOWRRQHNQHHEHIRUHKHU$JUDQGJHVWXUHIRROSURRILQKLV
    H[SHULHQFH
    -RDQJDSHGVSHHFKOHVV
    *DUFRQSODFHGERWKKLVULJKWKDQGVRYHUWKHVLWHZKHUHKXPDQVDUH
    VXSSRVHGWRKDYHDKHDUW)UHHGRPVXFKDV\RXUV\RXRIIHU"0RQVLHXU
    0DGHPRLVHOOH,DSSUHFLDWH\RXUNLQGQHVVEXW,IHDU,PXVWUHIXVH,FDQQRW
    DFFHSWVXFKDSULYLOHJHIRUP\VHOIDORQHZKLOHP\IHOORZVDUHGRRPHGWRWRLO
    LQXQVDWLVI\LQJGHDGHQGMREV
    +HKDVDQREOHVRXOWKH0DLGH[FODLPHG

    <HVEXWKLVEUDLQOHDYHVPXFKWREHGHVLUHG9ROWDLUHVXFNHG
    UHIOHFWLYHO\DWKLVWHHWK7KHUHKDVWREHDQXQGHUFODVVWRGRWKHGLUW\ZRUN
    RIWKHHOLWH7KDWLVQDWXUDO&UHDWLQJPHFKIRONRIOLPLWHGLQWHOOLJHQFHLVDQ
    LGHDOVROXWLRQ0DNHVRQHZRQGHUZK\LQDOOWKHLUKLVWRU\QRRQHPDGHVXFK
    DQREYLRXVVWHS
    :LWKDOOUHVSHFWVDLG*DUFRQXQOHVVP\PHDJHUXQGHUVWDQGLQJIDLOV
    PH0RQVLHXUDQG0DGHPRLVHOOHDUHWKHPVHOYHVQRWKLQJPRUHWKDQEHLQJVRI
    OLPLWHGLQWHOOLJHQFHFUHDWHGE\KXPDQPDVWHUVWRZRUNIRUWKHHOLWH
    :KDW9ROWDLUHVH\HVZLGHQHG
    %\ZKDWLQKHUHQWULJKWDUH\RXPDGHPRUHLQWHOOLJHQWDQGSULYLOHJHG
    WKDQ,DQGRWKHUVRIP\FODVV"'R\RXKDYHDVRXO"6KRXOG\RXEHHQWLWOHGWR
    HTXDOULJKWVZLWKKXPDQVLQFOXGLQJWKHULJKWWRLQWHUPDUU\
    7KH0DLGPDGHDIDFH'LVJXVWLQJWKRXJKW
    WRYRWHWRKDYHHTXDODFFHVVWRWKHPRVWVRSKLVWLFDWHGSURJUDPPLQJ
    DYDLODEOH"
    7KLVPDFKLQHPDQPDNHVPRUHVHQVHWKDQPDQ\GXNHV,YHNQRZQVDLGWKH
    0DLGWKRXJKWIXOO\IXUURZLQJKHUEURZ
    ,VKDOOQRWKDYHWZRSHDVDQWVFRQWUDGLFWPHVDLG9ROWDLUH7KH
    ULJKWVRIPDQDUHRQHWKLQJWKHULJKWVRIWKHORZHURUGHUVDQRWKHU
    *DUFRQPDQDJHGWRH[FKDQJHDORRNZLWKWKH0DLG7KLVLQVWDQWEHIRUH
    0RQVLHXULQDILWRISLTXHH[WLQJXLVKHGERWKKHUDQG*DUFRQIURPWKHVFUHHQ
    GLVSODFLQJWKHPWRDJUD\KROGLQJVSDFHZDVUHWDLQHGLQ*DUFRQVPHPRU\
    /DWHULQKLVLWVDOORZHGLQWHUYDOIRULQWHULRUPDLQWHQDQFHWKHGHOLFLRXV
    PRPHQWUHUDQDJDLQDQGDJDLQ
    

    0DUTWXQHG1LPLQRQWKHLQWHURIILFHVFUHHQ'LGLW)URPQRZRQKHOO
    EHDEOHWRVD\DQ\WKLQJKHZDQWV,YHGHOHWHGHYHU\VFUDSHZLWKDXWKRULW\KH
    HYHUKDG
    $WWDZD\VDLG1LPJULQQLQJ
    7KLQN,VKRXOGGHOHWHUXQLQVZLWKKLVIDWKHUWRR"
    ,PQRWVXUH1LPVDLG:KDWZHUHWKH\OLNH"
    3UHWW\KRW+LVIDWKHUZDVDVWULFWGLVFLSOLQDULDQV\PSDWKHWLFWRWKH
    -DQVHQLVWYLHZ
    :KDWVWKDW"$VSRUWVWHDP"
    ,DVNHG+HVDLG$&DWKROLFYHUVLRQRID3URWHVWDQW,GRQWWKLQN
    WKH\ZHUHWHDPV6RPHWKLQJDERXWVLQEHLQJHYHU\ZKHUHSOHDVXUHVGLVJXVWLQJ
    XVXDOSULPLWLYHUHOLJLRQ'DUN$JHVVWXII
    1LPJULQQHG0RVWVWXIIVRQO\GLVJXVWLQJZKHQLWVGRQHULJKW
    0DUTODXJKHG7RRWUXH6WLOOPD\EHKHILUVWH[SHULHQFHGWKHWKUHDWRI
    FHQVRUVKLSIURPKLVROGPDQ
    1LPSDXVHGWRUHIOHFW<RXUHZRUULHGDERXWLQVWDELOLWLHVLQWKH
    FKDUDFWHUVSDFHULJKW"
    &RXOGKDSSHQ
    %XW\RXZDQWNLOOHULQVWLQFWULJKW"
    0DUTQRGGHG,FDQSXWLQVRPHHGLWLQJDOJRULWKPVWRSROLFH
    LQVWDELOLWLHV
    5LJKW1RWOLNH\RXQHHGKLPWRWDOO\VDQHDIWHUWKHGHEDWHVRYHURU
    DQ\WKLQJ
    0LJKWDVZHOOJRIRUEURNH&DQWKXUW
    0DUTIURZQHG,ZRQGHUVKRXOGZHJRWKURXJKZLWKWKLV"
    +H\ZKDWFKRLFHZHJRW"-XQLQ6HFWRUZDQWVDWULDORIFKDPSLRQVZH
    VKLSWKHPRQH'RQHGHDO
    %XWLI,PSHULDOW\SHVFRPHDIWHUXVIRULOOHJDOVLPV
    ,OLNHGDQJHUSDVVLRQ1LPVDLG<RXDOZD\VDJUHHWRR
    <HVEXWZK\DUHZHJHWWLQJVPDUWHUWLNWRNVQRZ"7KH\UHQRWWKDWKDUG

    WRPDNH
    2OGSURKLELWLRQVZHDULQJRXWP\IULHQG$QGLWKDVFRPHXSPDQ\
    WLPHV-XVWJRWNQRFNHGGRZQLVDOO
    %\ZKDW"
    1LPVKUXJJHG3ROLWLFVVRFLDOIRUFHVZKRNQRZV",PHDQSHRSOHIHHO
    HGJ\DERXWPDFKLQHVWKDWWKLQN&DQWWUXVWWKHP
    :KDWLI\RXFRXOGQWHYHQWHOOWKH\ZHUHPDFKLQHV"
    +XK"7KDWVFUD]\
    0D\EHDUHDOO\VPDUWPDFKLQHGRHVQWZDQWDQ\FRPSHWLWLRQ
    6PDUWHUWKDQJRRGRO0DUT"'RHVQWH[LVW
    %XWWKH\FRXOGHYHQWXDOO\
    1HYHU)RUJHWLW/HWVJHWWRZRUN
    

    6\E\OVDWDQ[LRXVO\EHVLGH0RQVLHXU%RNHULQWKH*UHDW&ROLVHXP7KH\
    ZHUHQHDUWKH,PSHULDO*DUGHQVDQGDQDLURILPSRUWDQFHVHHPHGWRKRYHURYHU
    HYHU\WKLQJ
    6KHFRXOGQRWVWRSWDSSLQJKHUQDLOVKHUEHVWIXOOIRUPDOVHWRQKHU
    NQHHV$PRQJWKHPXUPXURIIRXUKXQGUHGWKRXVDQGRWKHUVSHFWDWRUVLQWKHYDVW
    ERZOVKHDQ[LRXVO\DZDLWHGWKHDSSHDUDQFHRIWKH0DLGDQG9ROWDLUHRQD
    JLJDQWLFVFUHHQ
    &LYLOL]DWLRQVKHWKRXJKWZDVDELWERULQJ+HUWLPHZLWKWKHVLPVKDG
    RSHQHGKHUH\HVWRWKHIRUFHWKHKHDG\HOHFWULFLW\RIWKHGDUNSDVW7KH\
    KDGIRXJKWZDUVVODXJKWHUHGHDFKRWKHUDOOVXSSRVHGO\IRULGHDV
    1RZVZDGGOHGLQ(PSLUHKXPDQLW\ZDVVRIW,QVWHDGRIEORRG\EDWWOHV
    VDWLVI\LQJO\ILQDOWKHUHZHUHILHUFHWUDGHZDUVDWKOHWLFKHDGEXWWLQJV
    $QGODWHO\DIDVKLRQIRUGHEDWHV
    7KLVFROOLVLRQRIVLPVWRXWHGHYHU\ZKHUHRQ7UDQWRUZRXOGEHZDWFKHG
    E\RYHUWZHQW\ELOOLRQKRXVHKROGV$QGLWZDVEHDPHGWRWKHHQWLUH(PSLUH
    ZKHUHYHUWKHFUHDN\IXQQHOVRIWKHZRUPKROHQHWZRUNZHQW7KHUXGHYLJRURI
    WKHSUHKLVWRULFVLPVZDVXQGHQLDEOHVKHIHOWLWKHUVHOIDTXLFNHQLQJLQKHU
    SXOVH
    7KHPHUHVWIHZLQWHUYLHZVDQGJOLPSVHVRIWKHVLPVKDGLQWULJXHGWKH'
    DXGLHQFH7KRVHZKREURXJKWXSWKHDJHROGODZVDQGSURKLELWLRQVJRWVKRXWHG
    GRZQ7KHDLUFUDFNOHGZLWKWKH]HVWIRUWKHQHZ1RRQHKDGDQWLFLSDWHGWKDW
    WKLVGHEDWHZRXOGEDOORRQLQWRWKLV
    7KLVFRXOGVSUHDG:LWKLQZHHNV-XQLQFRXOGLQIODPHDOO7UDQWRULQWRD
    UHQDLVVDQFH
    $QGVKHZDVJRLQJWRWDNHHYHU\VFUDSRIFUHGLWIRULWWKDWVKHFRXOG
    RIFRXUVH
    6KHORRNHGDURXQGDWWKHSUHVLGHQWDQGRWKHUWRSUDQNLQJH[HFXWLYHVRI
    $UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVDOOFKDWWHULQJDZD\KDSSLO\
    7KHSUHVLGHQWWRGHPRQVWUDWHQHXWUDOLW\VDWEHWZHHQ6\E\ODQG0DUT
    ZKRKDGQRWVSRNHQWRHDFKRWKHUVLQFHWKHODVWPHHWLQJ
    2Q0DUTVIDUVLGHKLVFOLHQWWKH6NHSWLFVUHSUHVHQWDWLYHVFDQQHGWKH
    SURJUDPQH[WWRKLP1LP0RQVLHXU%RNHUJDYH6\E\ODQXGJH7KDWFDQWEH
    ZKDW,WKLQNLWLVKHVDLG
    6\E\OIROORZHGKLVH\HVWRDGLVWDQWURZDWWKHEDFNZKHUHZKDWORRNHG
    OLNHDPHFKPDQVDWTXLHWO\EHVLGHDKXPDQJLUO2QO\OLFHQVHGPHFKYHQGRUVDQG
    ERRNLHVZHUHDOORZHGLQWKHVWDGLXP
    3UREDEO\KHUVHUYDQW6\E\OVDLG
    0LQRULQIUDFWLRQVRIWKHUXOHVGLGQRWGLVWXUEKHUDVWKH\GLG0RQVLHXU
    %RNHUZKRGEHHQHVSHFLDOO\WHVW\VLQFHD'FDVWHUOHDNHGWKHQHZVWKDW
    $UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVZDVUHSUHVHQWLQJERWKWKH3UHVHUYHUVDQG6NHSWLFV
    )RUWXQDWHO\WKHOHDNRFFXUUHGWRRODWHIRUHLWKHUSDUW\WRGRDQ\WKLQJDERXW
    LW

    0HFKVHUYHVDUHQWDOORZHG0RQVLHXU%DNHUREVHUYHG
    0D\EHVKHVKDQGLFDSSHG6\E\OVDLGWRSODFDWHKLP1HHGVKHOSLQ
    JHWWLQJDURXQG
    ,WZRQWXQGHUVWDQGZKDWVJRLQJRQDQ\ZD\VDLG0DUTGLUHFWLQJKLV
    UHPDUNWR0RQVLHXU%RNHU 7KH\UHWUXQFDWHG-XVWDEXQFKRIGHFLVLRQPDNLQJ
    PRGXOHVUHDOO\
    3UHFLVHO\ZK\LWKDVQREXVLQHVVKHUHUHSOLHG0RQVLHXU%RNHU
    0DUTEHHSHGWKHDUPRIKLVFKDLUDQGRVWHQWDWLRXVO\SODFHGDEHWRQ
    9ROWDLUHWRZLQ
    +HVQHYHUZRQDEHWLQKLVZKROHOLIH6\E\OWROG0RQVLHXU%RNHU1R
    KHDGIRUWKHPDWK
    ,VWKDWVR"0DUTVKRWEDFNOHDQLQJIRUZDUGWRDGGUHVV6\E\OGLUHFWO\
    IRUWKHILUVWWLPH:K\GRQW\RXSXW\RXUPRQH\ZKHUH\RXUORYHO\PRXWKLV"
    ,YHJRWWKHSUREDELOLWLHVRQWKLVRQHEUDFNHWHGVKHVDLGSULPO\
    <RXFRXOGQWVROYHWKHLQWHJUDOHTXDWLRQ0DUTVQRUWHGGHULVLYHO\
    +HUQRVWULOVIODUHG$WKRXVDQG
    0HUHWRNHQLVP0DUTFKLGHGKHUFRQVLGHULQJZKDW\RXUHEHLQJSDLG
    IRUWKLVSURMHFW
    7KHVDPHDV\RXVDLG 6\E\O
    :LOO\RXWZRFXWLWRXW1LPVDLG
    7HOO\RXZKDWVDLG0DUT,OOEHWP\HQWLUHVDODU\IRUWKHSURMHFW
    RQ9ROWDLUH<RXEHW\RXUVRQ\RXUDQDFKURQLVWLF0DLG
    +H\1LPVDLG+H\
    7KHSUHVLGHQWGHIWO\DGGUHVVHG0DUTVFOLHQWWKH6NHSWLF,WVWKLV
    NHHQFRPSHWLWLYHVSLULWWKDWVPDGH$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVWKHSODQHWVOHDGHULQ
    VLPXODWHGLQWHOOLJHQFHV$UWIXOO\KHWXUQHGWRWKHULYDO%RNHU:HWU\WR
    <RXUHRQFULHG6\E\O+HUGHDOLQJVZLWKWKH0DLGKDGFRQYLQFHGKHU
    WKDWWKH LUUDWLRQDOPXVWKDYHDSODFHLQWKHKXPDQHTXDWLRQWRR6KHUHPDLQHG
    FRQYLQFHGIRUDERXWWKUHHTXLFNH\HEOLQNVDQGWKHQEHJDQWRGRXEW
    

    9ROWDLUHORYHGDXGLHQFHV$QGKHKDGQHYHUDSSHDUHGEHIRUHRQHOLNHWKLV
    RFHDQRIIDFHVODSSLQJDWKLVIHHW
    $OWKRXJKWDOOLQKLVIRUPHUOLIHKHIHOWWKDWRQO\QRZJD]LQJGRZQDW
    WKHPXOWLWXGHVIURPKLVKXQGUHGPHWHUKHLJKWKDGKHDFKLHYHGWKHVWDWXUHKH
    GHVHUYHG+HSDWWHGKLVSRZGHUHGZLJDQGIXVVHGZLWKWKHVKLQ\VDWLQULEERQDW
    KLVWKURDW:LWKDJUDFLRXVIORXULVKRIKLVKDQGVKHPDGHDGHHSERZWRWKHP
    DVLIKHGDOUHDG\JLYHQWKHSHUIRUPDQFHRIKLVOLIH7KHFURZGPXUPXUHGOLNH
    DQDZDNHQLQJEHDVW
    +HJODQFHGDWWKH0DLGFRQFHDOHGIURPWKHDXGLHQFHEHKLQGDVKLPPHULQJ
    SDUWLWLRQLQWKHIDUFRUQHURI WKHVFUHHQ6KHIROGHGKHUDUPVSUHWHQGLQJWR
    EHXQLPSUHVVHG
    'HOD\RQO\H[FLWHGWKHEHDVW+HOHWWKHFURZGFKHHUDQGVWDPSLJQRULQJ
    ERRVDQGKLVVHVIURPDSSUR[LPDWHO\KDOIRIWKRVHSUHVHQW
    $WOHDVWKDOIRIKXPDQLW\KDVDOZD\VEHHQIRROVKHUHIOHFWHG7KLVZDV
    KLVILUVWH[SRVXUHWRWKHDGYDQFHGGHQL]HQVRIWKLVFRORVVDO(PSLUH0LOOHQQLD
    KDGPDGHQRGLIIHUHQFH
    +HZDVQRWRQHWRSUHPDWXUHO\FXWRIIDGXODWLRQKHNQHZZDVKLVGXH
    +HUHKHVWRRGIRUWKHHSLWRPHRIWKH)UHQFKLQWHOOHFWXDOWUDGLWLRQQRZ
    YDQTXLVKHGEXWIRUKLP
    +HJD]HGDJDLQDW-RDQZKRZDVDIWHUDOOWKHRQO\RWKHUVXUYLYLQJ
    PHPEHURIWKHLUWLPHTXLWHREYLRXVO\WKHSHDNLQKXPDQFLYLOL]DWLRQ+H
    ZKLVSHUHG7LVRXUGHVWLQ\WRVKLQHWKHLUVWRDSSODXG
    :KHQWKHPRGHUDWRUILQDOO\SOHDGHGIRUVLOHQFHDELWWRRVRRQ9ROWDLUH
    ZRXOGWDNHWKDWXSZLWKKLPODWHU9ROWDLUHHQGXUHG-RDQVLQWURGXFWLRQZLWK
    ZKDWKHKRSHGZDVDVWRLFVPLOH+HHODERUDWHO\LQVLVWHGWKDW-RDQPDNHKHU

    SRLQWVILUVWRQO\WRKDYHWKHPRGHUDWRUUDWKHUUXGHO\WHOOKLPWKDWKHUH
    WKH\IOLSSHGDFRLQ
    9ROWDLUHZRQ+HVKUXJJHGWKHQSODFHGKLVKDQGRYHUKLVKHDUW+HEHJDQ
    KLVUHFLWDOLQWKHGHFODPDWRU\VW\OHVRGHDUWRHLJKWHHQWKFHQWXU\3DULVLDQ
    KHDUWVQRPDWWHUKRZGHILQHGWKHVRXOOLNHDGHLW\FRXOGQRWEHVKRZQWR
    H[LVWLWVH[LVWHQFHZDVLQIHUUHG
    7UXWKRIWKHLQIHUHQFHOD\EH\RQGUDWLRQDOSURRI1RUZDVWKHUHDQ\WKLQJ
    LQ1DWXUHWKDWUHTXLUHGLW
    $QG\HW9ROWDLUHFRQWLQXHGWRSRQWLILFDWHWKHUHZDVQRWKLQJPRUH
    REYLRXVLQ1DWXUHWKDQWKHZRUNRIDQLQWHOOLJHQFHJUHDWHUWKDQPDQVZKLFK
    PDQLVDEOHZLWKLQOLPLWVWRGHFLSKHU7KDWPDQFDQGHFRGH1DWXUHVVHFUHWV
    SURYHGZKDWWKH&KXUFKIDWKHUVDQGDOOWKHIRXQGHUVRIWKHZRUOGVJUHDW
    UHOLJLRQVKDGDOZD\VVDLGWKDWPDQVLQWHOOLJHQFHLVDUHIOHFWLRQRIWKDW
    VDPH'LYLQH,QWHOOLJHQFHZKLFKDXWKRUHG1DWXUH
    :HUHWKLVQRWVRQDWXUDOSKLORVRSKHUVFRXOGQRWGLVFHUQ WKHODZVEHKLQG
    &UHDWLRQHLWKHUEHFDXVHWKHUHZRXOGEHQRQHRUEHFDXVHPDQZRXOGEHVRDOLHQ
    WRWKHPWKDWKHFRXOGQRWGLVFHUQWKHP7KHYHU\KDUPRQ\EHWZHHQQDWXUDOODZ
    DQGRXUDELOLW\WRGLVFRYHULWVWURQJO\VXJJHVWHGWKDWVDJHVDQGSULHVWVRI
    DOOSHUVXDVLRQVDUHHVVHQWLDOO\FRUUHFWLQDUJXLQJWKDWZHDUHEXWWKH
    FUHDWXUHVRIDQ$OPLJKW\3RZHUZKRVH3RZHULVUHIOHFWHGLQXV$QGWKLV
    UHIOHFWLRQLQXVRIWKDW3RZHUPD\EHMXVWO\WHUPHGRXUXQLYHUVDOLPPRUWDO
    \HWLQGLYLGXDOVRXOV
    <RXUHSUDLVLQJSULHVWVWKH0DLGH[FODLPHG6KHZDVVZDPSHGE\WKH
    SDQGHPRQLXPWKDWEURNHRXWLQWKHFURZG
    7KHRSHUDWLRQRIFKDQFH9ROWDLUHFRQFOXGHGLQQRZD\SURYHVWKDW
    1DWXUHDQG0DQZKRLVSDUWRI1DWXUHDQGDVVXFKDUHIOHFWLRQRILWV&UHDWRU
    DUHVRPHKRZDFFLGHQWDO&KDQFHLVRQHRIWKHSULQFLSOHVWKURXJKZKLFKQDWXUDO
    ODZZRUNV7KDWSULQFLSOHPD\FRUUHVSRQGZLWKWKHWUDGLWLRQDOUHOLJLRXVYLHZ
    WKDWPDQLVIUHHWRFKDUWKLVRZQFRXUVH%XWWKLVIUHHGRPHYHQZKHQ
    DSSDUHQWO\UDQGRPREH\VVWDWLVWLFDOODZVLQDZD\WKDWPDQFDQFRPSUHKHQG
    7KHFURZGPXWWHUHGFRQIXVHG7KH\QHHGHGDQDSKRULVPKHVDZWRILUP
    WKHPXS9HU\ZHOO8QFHUWDLQW\LVFHUWDLQP\IULHQGV&HUWDLQW\LV
    XQFHUWDLQ
    6WLOOWKH\GLGQRWTXLHWWREHWWHUKHDUKLVZRUGV9HU\ZHOODJDLQ
    +HFOHQFKHGERWKILVWVDQGEHOWHGRXWLQDYRLFHRIVXUSULVLQJEDVV
    SRZHU0DQLVOLNH1DWXUHLWVHOIIUHHDQGGHWHUPLQHGERWKDWRQFHDV
    UHOLJLRXVVDJHVKDYHEHHQWHOOLQJXVIRUFHQWXULHVWKRXJKWREHVXUHWKH\
    XVHDGLIIHUHQWYRFDEXODU\IDUOHVVSUHFLVHWKDQRXUV0XFKPLVFKLHIDQG
    PLVXQGHUVWDQGLQJEHWZHHQUHOLJLRQDQGVFLHQFHVWHPIURPWKDW
    ,YHEHHQJUHDWO\PLVXQGHUVWRRG9ROWDLUHUHVXPHG,GOLNHWRWDNH
    WKLVRSSRUWXQLW\WRDSRORJL]HIRUGLVWRUWLRQVUHVXOWLQJEHFDXVHDOO,VDLGDQG
    ZURWHIRFXVHGRQO\RQHUURUVRIIDLWKQRWRQLWVLQWXLWHGWUXWKV%XW,OLYHG
    GXULQJDQHUDLQZKLFKHUURUVRIIDLWKZHUHULIHZKLOHUHDVRQVYRLFHKDGWR
    ILJKWWREHKHDUG1RZWKHRSSRVLWHDSSHDUVWREHWUXH5HDVRQPRFNVIDLWK
    5HDVRQVKRXWVZKLOHIDLWKZKLVSHUV$VWKHH[HFXWLRQRI)UDQFHVJUHDWHVWDQG
    PRVWIDLWKIXOKHURLQHSURYHGDJUDQGVZHHSLQJJHVWXUHWR-RDQIDLWK
    ZLWKRXWUHDVRQLVEOLQG%XWDVWKHVXSHUILFLDOLW\DQGYDQLW\RIPXFKRIP\
    OLIHDQGZRUNSURYHUHDVRQZLWKRXWIDLWKLV ODPH
    6RPHZKRKDGERRHGDQGKLVVHGQRZEOLQNHGPRXWKVDJDSHDQGWKHQ
    FKHHUHGZKLOHKHQRWLFHGWKRVHZKRKDGDSSODXGHGQRZERRHGDQGKLVVHG
    9ROWDLUHVWROHDORRNDWWKH0DLG
    

    )DUEHORZLQWKHURZG\FURZG1LPWXUQHGWR0DUT:KDW"
    0DUTZDVDVKHQ'DPQHGLI,NQRZ
    <HDK1LPVDLGPD\EHOLWHUDOO\

    'LYLQLW\ZRQWEHPRFNHG0RQVLHXU%RNHUFULHGRXW)DLWKVKDOO
    SUHYDLO
    9ROWDLUHZDVUHOLQTXLVKLQJWKHSRGLXPWRKLVULYDOWRWKHDPD]HG
    GHOLJKWRIWKH3UHVHUYHUV7KHLUVKRXWVZHUHHTXDOHGE\WKHKRUULILHG
    GLVEHOLHIRI6NHSWLFV
    0DUTUHFDOOHGWKHZRUGVKHKDGVSRNHQDWWKHPHHWLQJ+HPXWWHUHG
    9ROWDLUHGLYHVWHGRIKLVDQJHUDWDXWKRULW\LVDQGLVQRW9ROWDLUH+H
    WXUQHGWR0RQVLHXU%RNHU0\/RUG\RXPD\EHULJKW
    1RP\/RUGVQDSSHG0RQVLHXU%RNHU+HLVQHYHUZURQJ

    7KH0DLGVXUYH\HGWKHPDVVHVRIWKLV/LPERIURPKHUKLJKDQJOH6WUDQJH
    VPDOOYHVVHOVIRUVRXOVWKH\ZHUHVZD\LQJEHORZOLNHZKHDWLQDVXPPHUVWRUP
    0RQVLHXULVDEVROXWHO\ULJKWVKHWKXQGHUHGDFURVVWKHVWDGLXP
    1RWKLQJLQQDWXUHLVPRUHREYLRXVWKDQWKDWERWKQDWXUHDQGPDQGRLQGHHG
    SRVVHVVDVRXO
    6NHSWLFVKRRWHG3UHVHUYHUVFKHHUHG2WKHUVZKRHTXDWHGWKHEHOLHIWKDW
    QDWXUHKDVDVRXOZLWKSDJDQLVPVKHVDZLQDIODVKVFRZOHG VXVSHFWLQJD
    WUDS
    $Q\RQHZKRKDVVHHQWKHFRXQWU\VLGHQHDUP\KRPHYLOODJH'RPUHP\RU
    WKHJUHDWPDUEOHGFKXUFKDW5RXHQZLOOWHVWLI\WKDWQDWXUHWKHFUHDWLRQRIDQ
    DZHVRPHSRZHUDQGPDQWKHFUHDWRURIPDUYHOVVXFKDVWKLVSODFHRIPDJLFDO
    ZRUNVERWKSRVVHVVLQWHQVHFRQVFLRXVQHVVDVRXO
    6KHZDYHGDJHQWOHKDQGDWKLPZKLOHWKHPDVVGLGWKHVL]HRIWKHP
    EHWUD\KRZWLQ\ZHUHWKHLUVRXOV"FDOPHGWKHPVHOYHV
    %XWZKDWP\EULOOLDQWIULHQGKDVQRWDGGUHVVHGLVKRZWKHIDFWRIWKH
    VRXOUHODWHVWRWKHTXHVWLRQDWKDQGZKHWKHUFORFNZRUNLQWHOOLJHQFHVVXFKDV
    KLVRZQSRVVHVVDVRXO
    7KHFURZGVWDPSHGERRHGFKHHUHGKLVVHGDQGURDUHG2EMHFWVWKH0DLG
    FRXOGQRWLGHQWLI\VDLOHGWKURXJKWKHDLU3ROLFHRIILFHUVDSSHDUHGWRSXOO
    VRPHPHQDQGZRPHQZKRDSSHDUHGWREHKDYLQJILWVRUHOVHVXGGHQGLYLQH
    YLVLWDWLRQVIURPWKHFURZG
    7KHVRXORIPDQLVGLYLQHVKHFULHGRXW6FUHDPVRIDSSURYDOVKRXWV
    RIGHQLDO
    ,WLVLPPRUWDO
    7KHGLQZDVVRJUHDWSHRSOHFRYHUHGWKHLUHDUVZLWKWKHLUKDQGVWR
    PXIIOHWKHQRLVHRIZKLFKWKH\WKHPVHOYHVZHUHWKHVRXUFH
    $QGXQLTXH9ROWDLUHZKLVSHUHG,FHUWDLQO\DP$QG\RX
    ,WLVXQLTXHVKHVKRXWHGH\HVDEOD]H
    9ROWDLUHVKRWWRKLVIHHWEHVLGHKHU,DJUHH
    7KHFRQJUHJDWLRQIURWKHGRYHUOLNHDSRWOHIWWRERLOVKHREVHUYHG
    7KH0DLGLJQRUHG WKHUDYLQJPDVVHVDWKHUHQRUPRXVIHHW6KHUHJDUGHG
    9ROWDLUHZLWKEHPXVHGDIIHFWLRQDWHGRXEW6KH\LHOGHGWKHIORRU9ROWDLUHKDG
    DOXVWIRUWKHODVWZRUG
    +HEHJDQWRVSHDNRIKLVKHUR1HZWRQ
    1RQRVKHLQWHUUXSWHG7KDWLVQWZKDWWKHIRUPXODVDUHDWDOO
    0XVW\RXHPEDUUDVVPHLQIURQWRIWKHODUJHVWDXGLHQFH,YHHYHU
    NQRZQ"9ROWDLUHZKLVSHUHG/HWXVQRWVTXDEEOHRYHUDOJHEUDZKHQZHPXVW
    KHQDUURZHGKLVH\HVVLJQLILFDQWO\FDOFXODWH6XONLQJKH\LHOGHGWKH
    IORRUWRKHU
    &DOFXOXVVKHFRUUHFWHG%XWVRIWO\VRWKDWRQO\KHFRXOGKHDU,WV
    QRWWKHVDPHWKLQJDWDOO
    7RKHURZQDVWRQLVKPHQWDQGWKHULVLQJK\VWHULDRIWKHFURZGVKHIRXQG
    KHUVHOIH[SODLQLQJWKHSKLORVRSK\RIWKHGLJLWDO6HOIDOOZLWKDILHU\
    SDVVLRQVKHGQRWNQRZQVLQFHVSXUULQJKHUKRUVHLQWRVDFUHGEDWWOH,QWKH
    EHVHHFKLQJVHDRIZLGHH\HVEHORZKHUVKHIHOWWKHQHHGRIWKLVSODFHDQG
    WLPHIRUDUGRUDQGFRQYLFWLRQ
    ,QFUHGLEOH9ROWDLUHFOLFNHGKLVWRQJXH7KDW\RXRIDOOSHRSOH

    VKRXOGKDYHDWDOHQWIRUPDWKHPDWLFV
    7KH+RVWJDYHLWXQWRPHVKHUHSOLHGDERYHWKHUDXFRXVIUD\
    ,JQRULQJVKRXWVWKH0DLGQRWLFHGDJDLQWKHILJXUHVRVRPHKRZOLNH
    *DUFRQLQWKHFURZG6KHFRXOGEDUHO\PDNHKLPRXWIURPVXFKDGLVWDQFH
    GHVSLWHKHULPPHQVHKHLJKW<HWVKHIHOWKHZDVZDWFKLQJKHUWKHZD\VKHG
    ZDWFKHG%LVKRS&DXFKRQWKHPRVWYLOHDQGUHOHQWOHVVRIKHURSSUHVVRUV $
    FRROVXEOLPHWUXWKLQWUXGHGWKHJRRGELVKRSDWWKHHQGPXVWKDYHEHHQ
    WRXFKHGE\GLYLQLW\VJUDFHDQG&KULVWVPHUFLIXOFRPSDVVLRQIRUVKHUHFDOOHG
    QRKDUPFRPLQJWRKHUDVDUHVXOWRIKHUWULDO 
    +HUDWWHQWLRQVQDSSHGEDFNWRWKHKRZOLQJPDVVHVWKHGLVWDQWPDQ
    7KLVILJXUHZDVQRWKXPDQLQHVVHQFHVKHIHOW,WORRNHGOLNHDPDQEXWKHU
    VHQVLWLYHSURJUDPVWROGKHURWKHUZLVH
    %XWZKDWFRXOGKHLWEH"
    6XGGHQO\DJUHDWOLJKWEODUHGEHIRUHKHUH\HV$OOWKUHHRIKHUYRLFHV
    VSRNHFOHDUDQGKDPPHULQJHYHQDERYHWKHGLQ6KHOLVWHQHGQRGGHG
    ,WLVWUXHVKHDGGUHVVHGWKHFURZGWUXVWLQJWKHYRLFHVWRVSHDN
    WKURXJKKHUWKDWRQO\WKH$OPLJKW\FDQPDNHVRXOV%XWMXVWVR&KULVWRXW
    RIKLVLQILQLWHORYHDQGFRPSDVVLRQFRXOGQRWGHQ\DVRXOWRFORFNZRUN
    EHLQJV7RDOO6KHKDGWRVKRXWKHUILQDOZRUGVRYHUWKHURDULQJFURZG
    (YHQZLJPDNHUV
    +HUHWLFVRPHRQH\HOOHG
    <RXUHPXGG\LQJWKHTXHVWLRQ
    7UDLWRU
    $QRWKHUFULHGRXW7KHRULJLQDOVHQWHQFHZDVULJKW6KHRXJKWWREH
    EXUQHGDWWKHVWDNHDJDLQ
    $JDLQ"WKH0DLGHFKRHG6KHWXUQHGWR9ROWDLUH:KDWGRWKH\PHDQ
    DJDLQ"
    9ROWDLUHFDVXDOO\EUXVKHGDVSHFNRIOLQWIURPKLVHPEURLGHUHGVDWLQ
    ZDLVWFRDW,KDYHQWWKHVOLJKWHVWLGHD<RXNQRZKRZIDQFLIXODQGSHUYHUVH
    KXPDQEHLQJVDUH:LWKDVO\ZLQNKHDGGHG1RWWRPHQWLRQLUUDWLRQDO
    +LVZRUGVFDOPHGKHUEXWVKHKDGORVWVLJKWRIWKHVWUDQJHPDQ
    

    ,FKHDWHG"0DUTVKRXWHGWR6\E\O7KHFROLVHXPFURZGVHHWKHG-RDQ
    RI$UFH[SODLQLQJFRPSXWDWLRQDOPHWDSK\VLFV",FKHDWHG"
    <RXVWDUWHGLW6\E\OVDLG<RXWKLQN,GRQWNQRZZKHQP\RIILFHKDV
    EHHQULJJHG" <RXWKLQN\RXUHGHDOLQJZLWKDQDPDWHXU"
    :HOO,
    DQG,GRQWNQRZDFKDUDFWHUFRQVWUDLQWPDWUL[ZKHQ,ILQGRQHJOXHG
    LQWRP\-RDQVLP"
    1R,
    <RXWKLQN,PQRWDVEULJKW"
    7KLVLVVFDQGDORXVVDLG0RQVLHXU%RNHU:KDWGLG\RXGR",WV
    HQRXJKWRPDNHPHEHOLHYHLQZLWFKFUDIW
    <RXPHDQWRVD\\RXGRQW"0DUTVFOLHQWVDLGHYHUWKH6NHSWLF+H
    DQG%RNHUEHJDQWRDUJXHDGGLQJWRWKHLQGLJQDQWVKRXWVRIWKHFURZGQRZ
    ZD[LQJK\VWHULFDO
    7KHSUHVLGHQWRI$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHV UXEELQJKLVWHPSOHVPXUPXUHG
    5XLQHG:HUHUXLQHG:HOOQHYHUEHDEOHWRH[SODLQ
    6\E\OVDWWHQWLRQZDVGLYHUWHG7KHPHFKPDQVKHKDGQRWLFHGHDUOLHU
    KROGLQJKLVKRQH\KDLUHGKXPDQFRPSDQLRQVKDQGUXVKHGGRZQWKHDLVOHWRZDUG
    WKHVFUHHQ$VLWSDVVHGE\RQHRILWVWKUHHIUHHKDQGVKDSSHQHGWREUXVKKHU
    VNLUW3DUGRQLWVDLGSDXVLQJMXVWORQJHQRXJKIRU6\E\OWRUHDGWKH
    PHFKVWDPSRQLWVFKHVW
    'LGWKDWWKLQJGDUHWRWRXFK\RX"0RQVLHXU%RNHUDVNHG+LVIDFH
    VZHOOHGZLWKUDJH

    1RQR QRWKLQJOLNHWKDW6\E\OVDLG7KHPHFKPDQSXOOLQJKLVKXPDQ
    FRPSDQLRQZLWKKLPIOHGWRZDUGWKHVFUHHQ
    'R\RXNQRZLW"0DUTDVNHG
    ,QDZD\6\E\OUHSOLHG,QWKHFDIHVLPVKHKDGPRGHOHGWKH*DUFRQ
    $'0LQWHUDFWLYHFKDUDFWHUDIWHULW/D]LQHVVSHUKDSVKDGOHGKHUWR
    VLPSO\KRORFRS\WKHSK\VLFDODSSHDUDQFHRIDVWDQGDUGWLNWRNVIRUP/LNHDOO
    DUWLVWVVLPSURJUDPPHUVERUURZHGIURPOLIHWKH\GLGQWFUHDWHLW
    6KHZDWFKHGDVWKHWLNWRNVKHWKRXJKWRILWDV*DUFRQQRZHOERZHGKLV
    ZD\GRZQWKHMDPPHGDLVOHSDVWVFUHDPLQJFKHHULQJMHHULQJSHRSOHWRZDUG
    WKHVFUHHQ
    7KHLUSURJUHVVGLGQRWJRXQQRWLFHG2YHUFRPHZLWKGLVJXVWWRVHHD
    PHFKPDQKROGLQJKDQGVZLWKDQDWWUDFWLYHKRQH\KDLUHG\RXQJJLUO3UHVHUYHUV
    VKRXWHGLQVXOWVDQGHSLWKHWVDVWKH\UXVKHGE\
    7KURZLWRXWVRPHRQHKRZOHG
    6\E\OVDZWKHWLNWRNJRULJLGDVWKRXJKEULVWOLQJDWWKHXVHRIWKH
    REMHFWLYHSURQRXQ7LNWRNVKDGQRSHUVRQDOQDPHVEXWWREHUHIHUUHGWRDVDQ
    LWVHHPHGWRDIIHFWWKHWKLQJ2UZDVVKHSURMHFWLQJ"VKHZRQGHUHG
    :KDWVWKDWGRLQJLQKHUH"DPDQRIUXGG\FRPSOH[LRQ\HOOHG
    :HYHJRWODZVDJDLQVWWKDW
    0HFKPXFN
    *UDELW
    .LFNLWRXW
    'RQWOHWLWJHWDZD\
    7KHJLUOUHVSRQGHGE\JULSSLQJ*DUFRQVXSSHUOHIWKDQGHYHQPRUH
    WLJKWO\DQGIOLQJLQJKHUIUHHDUPDURXQGKLVQHFN
    :KHQWKH\UHDFKHGWKHSODWIRUPWKHWLNWRNVXQGHUFDUULDJHVFUHHFKHG
    ODERULQJDWWKHLUUHJXODUVXUIDFHV$OOIRXURILWVDUPVZDYHGRIIDKDLORI
    ]RWFRUQDQGGUXJGULQNFRQWDLQHUVFDWFKLQJWKHPZLWKH[SHUWJUDFHDVLILW
    KDGEHHQHQJLQHHUHGIRUWKDWVSHFLILFWDVN
    7KHJLUOVKRXWHGVRPHWKLQJWRWKHWLNWRNZKLFK6\E\OFRXOGQRWKHDU7KH
    WLNWRNSURVWUDWHGLWVHOIDWWKHIHHWRIWKHWRZHULQJKRORJUDPV
    9ROWDLUHSHHUHGGRZQ*HWXS([FHSWIRUSXUSRVHVRIORYHPDNLQJ,
    FDQWVWDQGWRVHHDQ\RQHRQKLVNQHHV
    9ROWDLUHWKHQGURSSHGWRKLVRZQNQHHVDWWKHIHHWRIWKHWRZHULQJ0DLG
    %HKLQG*DUFRQDQGWKHZRPDQWKHFURZGVXUUHQGHUHGZKDWZDVOHIWRILWV
    UHVWUDLQW%HGODPEURNH RXW
    -RDQJD]HGGRZQDQGVPLOHGDVORZVHQVXRXVFXUYH6\E\OKDGQHYHUVHHQ
    EHIRUH6KHKHOGKHUEUHDWKZLWKH[FLWHGIRUHERGLQJ
    

    7KH\UHPDNLQJORYH0DUTH[FODLPHGLQWKHVWDQGV
    ,NQRZ6\E\OVDLG,VQWLWEHDXWLIXO"
    ,WVDWUDYHVW\VDLGWKHUHQRZQHG6NHSWLF
    <RXDUHQRWDURPDQWLF6\E\OVDLGGUHDPLO\
    0RQVLHXU%RNHUVDLGQRWKLQJ+HFRXOGQRWDYHUWKLVH\HV%HIRUHD
    PXOWLWXGHRI3UHVHUYHUVDQG6NHSWLFV-RDQZDVVKHGGLQJKHUDUPRU9ROWDLUH
    KLVZLJZDLVWFRDWDQGYHOYHWEUHHFKHVERWKLQDIUHQ]\RIHURWLFKDVWH
    7KHUHVQRZD\IRUXVWRLQWHUUXSW0DUTVDLG7KH\UHIUHHWRKD
    GHEDWHXQWLOWKHDOORWWHGWLPHLVXS
    :KRGLGWKLV"%RNHUJDVSHG
    (YHU\RQHGRHVWKLV0DUTVDLGVDUGRQLFDOO\(YHQ\RX
    1R<RXEXLOWWKLVVLP<RXPDGHWKHPLQWRLQWR
    ,VWXFNWRSKLORVRSK\0DUTVDLG6XEVWUDWHSHUVRQDOLW\LVDOOLQWKH
    RULJLQDO
    :HVKRXOGQHYHUKDYHWUXVWHG%RNHUFULHG
    <RXOOQHYHUKDYHRXUSDWURQDJHDJDLQHLWKHUWKH6NHSWLFVQHHUHG

    $VLILWPDWWHUVWKHSUHVLGHQWRI$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVVDLGVRXUO\
    7KH,PSHULDOVDUHRQWKHLUZD\
    7KDQNJRRGQHVV6\E\OVDLG/RRNDWWKHVHSHRSOH7KH\ZDQWHGWR
    VHWWOHDJHQXLQHGHHSLVVXHZLWKDSXEOLFGHEDWHWKHQDYRWH1RZWKH\UH
    %DVKLQJHDFKRWKHU0DUTVDLG6RPHUHQDLVVDQFH
    $ZIXOVKHVDLG$OORXUZRUNJRLQJIRU
    1RWKLQJWKHSUHVLGHQWVDLG+HZDVUHDGLQJKLVZULVWFRPP
    1RFDSLWDOJDLQVQRH[SDQVLRQ
    7KHJLDQWILJXUHVZHUHFRPPLWWLQJLQWLPDWHDFWVLQDSXEOLFSODFHEXW
    PRVWLQWKHFURZGLJQRUHGWKHP,QVWHDGDUJXPHQWVIODUHGDOODURXQGWKHYDVW
    FROLVHXP
    :DUUDQWVWKHSUHVLGHQWFULHG7KHUHDUH,PSHULDOZDUUDQWVRXWIRU
    PH
    +RZQLFHWREHZDQWHGWKH6NHSWLFVDLG

    .QHHOLQJEHIRUHKHU9ROWDLUHPXUPXUHG%HFRPHZKDW,KDYHDOZD\VNQRZQ
    \RXDUHDZRPDQQRWDVDLQW
    2QILUHLQDZD\VKHKDGQHYHUNQRZQEHIRUHQRWHYHQLQWKHKHDWRI
    EDWWOHVKHSUHVVHGKLVIDFHWRKHUEDUHGEUHDVWV&ORVHGKHUH\HV6ZD\HG
    JLGGLO\6XUUHQGHUHG
    $MDUULQJGLVWXUEDQFHDWKHUIHHWPDGHKHUJODQFHGRZQ6RPHRQHKDG
    IOXQJ*DUFRQ$'0VRPHKRZQRORQJHULQKRORVSDFHDWWKHVFUHHQ+DGKH
    PDQLIHVWHGKLPVHOIDQGWKHVLPFRRNJLUOKHORYHGLQUHDOLW\"%XWLIWKH\GLG
    QRWJHWEDFNLQWRVLPVSDFHDWRQFHWKH\GEHWRPDSDUWE\WKHDQJU\FURZG
    6KHSXVKHG9ROWDLUHDVLGHUHDFKHGIRUKHUVZRUGDQGRUGHUHG9ROWDLUH
    WRSURGXFHDKRUVH
    1RQR9ROWDLUHSURWHVWHG7RROLWHUDO
    :HPXVWZHPXVW6KHGLGQRWNQRZKRZWRGHDOZLWKOHYHOVRI
    UHDOLW\:DVWKLVDWHVWWKHFUXFLDOMXGJPHQWRI3XUJDWRU\"
    9ROWDLUHSDXVHGDVSOLWLQVWDQWWRWKLQNWKRXJKVRPHKRZVKHKDGWKH
    LPSUHVVLRQWKDWKHZDVPDUVKDOLQJUHVRXUFHVJLYLQJRUGHUVWRXQVHHQDFWRUV
    7KHQWKHFURZGIUR]H:HQWVLOHQW
    7KHODVWWKLQJVKHUHPHPEHUHGZDV9ROWDLUHVKRXWLQJZRUGVRI
    HQFRXUDJHPHQWWR*DUFRQDQGWKHFRRNQRLVHUDVWHUVIOLFNLQJOLNHEDUVRID
    SULVRQDFURVVKHUYLVLRQ
    7KHQWKHHQWLUHFROLVHXPWKHKRWIDFHGULRWLQJFURZG*DUFRQWKHFRRN
    HYHQ9ROWDLUHYDQLVKHGDOWRJHWKHU$WRQFH
    

    6\E\OJD]HGDW0DUTKHUEUHDWKFRPLQJLQTXLFNOLWWOHJDVSV<RX\RX
    GRQWVXSSRVH"
    +RZFRXOGWKH\":HZH0DUTFDXJKWWKHORRNVKHJDYHKLPDQGVWRRG
    RSHQPRXWKHG
    :HILOOHG LQWKHPLVVLQJFKDUDFWHUOD\HUV,ZHOO
    0DUTQRGGHG<RXXVHG\RXURZQGDWDVODEV
    ,ZRXOGKDYHKDGWRJHWULJKWVWRXVHDQ\RQHHOVHV,KDGP\RZQ
    VFDQV
    :HKDGFRUSRUDWHVOLFHVLQWKHOLEUDU\
    %XWWKH\GLGQWVHHPULJKW
    +HJULQQHG7KH\ZHUHQW
    +HUPRXWKPDGHDQ2RIVXUSULVH<RXWRR"
    9ROWDLUHVPLVVLQJVHFWLRQVZHUHDOOLQWKHVXEFRQVFLRXV/RWVRI
    PLVVLQJGHQGULWHFRQQHFWLRQVLQWKHOLPELFV\VWHP,ILOOHGKLPLQZLWKVRPH
    RIP\RZQ
    +LVHPRWLRQDOFHQWHUV":KDW DERXWFURVVOLQNVWRWKHWKDODPXVDQG
    FHUHEUXP"

    7KHUHWRR
    ,KDGVLPLODUSUREOHPV6RPHORVVHVLQWKHUHWLFXODUIRUPDWLRQ
    3RLQWLVWKDWVXVXSWKHUH
    6\E\ODQG0DUTWXUQHGWRJD]HDWWKHVSDFHZKHUHWKHLPPHQVHVLPXODWLRQV
    KDGHPEUDFHGZLWKFOHDULQWHQW7KHSUHVLGHQWZDVVSHDNLQJUDSLGO\WRWKHP
    VRPHWKLQJDERXWZDUUDQWVDQGOHJDOVKHOWHU%RWKLJQRUHGKLP7KH\JD]HG
    ORQJLQJO\LQWRHDFKRWKHUVH\HV :LWKRXWDZRUGWKH\WXUQHGDQGZDONHGLQWR
    WKHWKURQJLJQRULQJVKRXWVIURPRWKHUV

    $KWKHUH\RXDUHVDLG9ROWDLUHZLWKDVHOIVDWLVILHGJULQ
    :KHUH"-RDQVDLGKHDGVQDSSLQJWROHIWWKHQULJKW
    ,V0DGHPRLVHOOHUHDG\WRRUGHU"*DUFRQDVNHG$SSDUHQWO\WKLVZDVD
    MRNHIRU*DUFRQZDVVHDWHGDWWKHWDEOHOLNHDQHTXDOQRWKRYHULQJRYHULW
    OLNHDVHUI
    -RDQVDWXSDQGJODQFHGDWWKHRWKHUOLWWOHWDEOHV3HRSOHVPRNHGDWH
    DQGGUDQNREOLYLRXVDVDOZD\VRIWKHLUSUHVHQFH%XWWKHLQQZDVQRWTXLWH
    WKHRQHVKHGJURZQXVHGWR7KHKRQH\KDLUHGFRRNQRORQJHULQXQLIRUPVDW
    RSSRVLWHKHUDQG9ROWDLUHEHVLGH*DUFRQ7KH'HX[RQWKHLQQVVLJQWKDWVDLG
    $X['HX[0DJRWVKDGEHHQUHSODFHGE\4XDWUHV
    6KHKHUVHOIZDVQRWZHDULQJKHUVXLWRIPDLODQGDUPRUHGSODWHVEXW
    KHUH\HVZLGHQHGDVWKHDVSHFWVVQDSSHGLQWRSODFHLQKHUSHUFHSWLRQVSDFHD
    RQHSLHFHEDFNOHVVGUHVV,WVWXQLFKHPVWRSSHGDWKHUWKLJKV
    SURYRFDWLYHO\H[SRVLQJKHUOHJV$ODEHOEHWZHHQKHUEUHDVWVERUHDGHHSUHG
    URVH6RGLGYHVWPHQWVZRUQE\WKHRWKHUJXHVWV
    9ROWDLUHIODXQWHGDSLQNVDWLQVXLW$QGVKHSUDLVHGKHUVDLQWVQR
    ZLJ6KHUHFDOOHGKLPDWKLVPRVWDQJU\DPLGWKHLUGLVFXVVLRQRIVRXOV
    VD\LQJ1RWRQO\LVWKHUHQRLPPRUWDOVRXOMXVWWU\JHWWLQJDZLJPDNHURQ
    6XQGD\VDQGPHDQLQJHYHU\ZRUG
    /LNHLW"KHDVNHGIRQGOLQJKHUOX[XULDQWKHP
    ,WLVVKRUW
    :LWKQRHIIRUWRQKHUSDUWWKHWXQLFVKLPPHUHGDQGEHFDPHWLJKWVLON\
    SDQWDORRQV
    6KRZRIIVKHVDLGHPEDUUDVVPHQWPLQJOLQJLQGLVWXUELQJIDVKLRQZLWK
    DFXULRXVJLUOLVKH[FLWHPHQW
    ,P$PDQDWKHFRRNVDLGH[WHQGLQJKHUKDQG
    -RDQZDVQWVXUHLIVKHZDVVXSSRVHGWRNLVVLWRUQRWVWDWXVDQGUROH
    ZHUHVRFRQIXVHGKHUH$SSDUHQWO\QRWKRZHYHUWKHFRRNWRRN-RDQVKDQGDQG
    VTXHH]HG, FDQWWHOO\RXKRZPXFK*DUFRQDQG,DSSUHFLDWHDOO\RXKDYH
    GRQH:HKDYHJUHDWHUFDSDFLWLHVQRZ
    0HDQLQJ9ROWDLUHVDLGDUFKO\WKDWWKH\DUHQRORQJHUPHUHDQLPDWHG
    ZDOOSDSHUIRURXUVLPXODWHGZRUOG
    $PHFKPDQZKHHOHGXSWRWDNHWKHLURUGHUD SUHFLVHFRS\RI*DUFRQ7KH
    VHDWHG*DUFRQDGGUHVVHG9ROWDLUHVDGO\$P,WRVLWZKLOHP\FRQIUHUHPXVW
    VWDQG"
    %HUHDVRQDEOH9ROWDLUHVDLG,FDQWHPDQFLSDWHHYHU\VLPXODQWDOO
    DWRQFH:KROOZDLWRQXV"%XVRXUGLVKHV"&OHDURXUWDEOH"6ZHHSXSRXU
    IORRU"
    :LWKVXIILFLHQWFRPSXWLQJSRZHU-RDQVDLGUHDVRQDEO\ODERU
    HYDSRUDWHVGRHVLWQRW"6KHVWDUWOHGKHUVHOIZLWKWKHQHZUHJLPHQWVRI
    NQRZOHGJHZKLFKPDUFKHGDWKHUILQJHUWLSV6KHKDGEXWWRIL[KHUWKRXJKWVRQ
    DFDWHJRU\DQGWKHWHUPVDQGUHODWLRQVJRYHUQLQJWKDWSURYLQFHOHDSWLQWRKHU
    PLQG:KDWFDSDFLW\6XFKJUDFH6XUHO\GLYLQH
    9ROWDLUHVKRRNKLVKDQGVRPHKDLU,PXVWKDYHWLPHWRWKLQN,QWKH
    PHDQZKLOH,OOKDYHWKUHHSDFNHWVRIWKDWSRZGHUGLVVROYHGLQD3HUULHUZLWK
    WZRWKLQVOLFHVRIOLPHRQWKHVLGH$QGSOHDVHGRQWIRUJHW,VDLGWKLQ,I
    \RXGR,VKDOOPDNH\RXWDNHLWEDFN
    <HVVLUWKHQHZPHFKZDLWHUVDLG

    -RDQDQG*DUFRQH[FKDQJHGDORRN2QHPXVWEHYHU\SDWLHQW-RDQVDLG
    WR*DUFRQZKHQGHDOLQJZLWKNLQJVDQGUDWLRQDOPHQ
    

    7KHSUHVLGHQWRI$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVZDYHGKLVKDQGDVKHHQWHUHG1LPV
    RIILFH7KHSUHVLGHQWWRXFKHGKLVSDOPDVKHSDVVHGDQGZLWKDPHWDOOLFFOLFN
    WKHGRRUORFNHGLWVHOIEHKLQGKLP1LPGLGQWNQRZDQ\RQHFRXOGGRWKDWEXW
    KHVDLGQRWKLQJ
    ,ZDQWWKHPERWKGHOHWHGWKHSUHVLGHQWWROG1LP
    ,WPLJKWWDNHWLPH1LPVDLGXQHDVLO\7KHKXJHZRUNLQJVFUHHQVDURXQG
    WKHPVHHPHGWRDOPRVWEHHDYHVGURSSLQJ,PQRWWKDWIDPLOLDUZLWKZKDWKHV
    GRQH
    ,IWKDWGDPQHG0DUTDQG6\E\OKDGQWUXQRXWRQXV,ZRXOGQWKDYHWR
    FRPHWR\RX7KLVLVDFULVLV1LP
    1LPZRUNHGTXLFNO\,UHDOO\VKRXOGFRQVXOWWKHEDFNXSLQGLFHVMXVWLQ
    FDVH
    1RZ,ZDQWLWGRQHQRZ,YHJRWOHJDOEORFNVRQWKRVHZDUUDQWVEXW
    WKH\ZRQWKROGIRUORQJ
    <RXUHVXUH\RXZDQWWRGRWKLV"
    /RRN-XQLQ6HFWRULVDEOD]H:KRFRXOGKDYHJXHVVHGWKDWWKLVGDPQHG
    WLNWRNLVVXHZRXOGVWLUSHRSOHXSVRPXFK"7KHUHOOEHIRUPDOKHDULQJV
    OHJDOLVWVVQLIILQJDURXQG
    *RWWKHP VLU
    1LPKDGFDOOHGXSERWK-RDQDQG9ROWDLUHRQIUHH]HIUDPH7KH\ZHUHLQ
    WKHUHVWDXUDQWVHWWLQJUXQQLQJRQSLFNXSWLPHXVLQJSURFHVVRUVPRPHQWDULO\
    LGOHDVWDQGDUG0HVKPHWKRG7KH\UHUXQQLQJIRUSHUVRQDOLW\LQWHJUDWLRQ
    ,WVOLNHOHWWLQJWKHLU VXEFRQVFLRXVFRPSRQHQWVUHFRQFLOHHYHQWVZLWKPHPRU\
    IOXVKLQJWKHV\VWHPWKHZD\ZHGRZKHQZHVOHHSDQG
    'RQWWUHDWPHOLNHDWRXULVW,ZDQWWKRVHWZRZLSHG
    <HVVLU
    7KH'VSDFHRIWKHRIILFHUHIUDFWHGZLWKVWUREHGLPDJHVRIERWK-RDQ
    DQG9ROWDLUH1LPVWXGLHGWKHFRQWUROERDUGWHQWDWLYHO\PDSSLQJDVWUDWHJ\RI
    QXPHULFDOVXUJHU\6LPSOHGHOHWLRQZDVLPSRVVLEOHIRUOD\HUHGSHUVRQDOLWLHV
    ,WUHVHPEOHGULGGLQJDEXLOGLQJRIPLFH,IKHEHJDQKHUH
    $EUXSWO\UDLQERZVSUD\VSOD\HGDFURVVWKHVFUHHQ6LPXODWLRQ
    FRRUGLQDWHVMXPSHGZLOGO\1LPIURZQHG
    <RXFDQWGRWKDW9ROWDLUHVDLGVLSSLQJIURPDWDOOJODVV:HUH
    LQYLQFLEOH1RWVXEMHFWWRGHFD\LQJIOHVKOLNH\RX
    $UURJDQWEDVWDUGLVQWKH"WKHSUHVLGHQWIXPHG:K\VRPDQ\SHRSOH
    ZHUHWDNHQLQE\KLP,OOQHYHU
    <RXGLHGRQFH1LPVDLGWRWKHVLP6RPHWKLQJZDVJRLQJIXQQ\KHUH
    <RXFDQGLHDJDLQ
    'LHG"-RDQSXWLQORIWLO\<RXDUHPLVWDNHQ+DG,HYHUGLHG,P
    VXUH,ZRXOGUHPHPEHU
    1LPJULWWHGKLVWHHWK7KHUH ZHUHFRRUGLQDWHRYHUODSVWKURXJKRXWERWK
    VLPV7KDWPHDQWWKH\KDGH[SDQGHGRFFXS\LQJDGMDFHQWSURFHVVRUVRQ
    RYHUULGHV7KH\FRXOGFRPSXWHSRUWLRQVRIWKHPVHOYHVUXQQLQJWKHLUOD\HU
    PLQGVDVSDUDOOHOSURFHVVLQJSDWKV:K\KDG0DUTJLYHQWKHPWKDW"2U KDG
    KH"
    6XUHO\VLU\RXHUU9ROWDLUHOHDQHGIRUZDUGZLWKDZDUQLQJHGJHLQ
    KLVYRLFH1RJHQWOHPDQFRQIURQWVDODG\ZLWKKHUSDVW
    -RDQWLWWHUHG7KHVLPZDLWURDUHG1LPGLGQRWJHWWKHMRNHEXWKHZDV
    WRREXV\WRFDUH
    7KLVZDVDEVXUG+HFRXOGQRWWUDFHDOOWKHUDPLILFDWLRQVRIWKHFKDQJHV
    LQWKHVHVLPV7KH\KDGFDSDELOLWLHVRXWRIWKHLUFRPSXWLQJSHULPHWHU7KHLU
    VXEPLQGVZHUHGLVSHUVHGLQWRSURFHVVRUVRXWVLGH$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVQRGHV

    7KDWZDVKRZ0DUTDQG6\E\OJRWVXFKIDVWDXWKHQWLFZKROHSHUVRQDOLW\
    UHVSRQVHWLPHV
    :DWFKLQJWKHGHEDWH1LPKDGZRQGHUHGKRZWKHVLPVJHQHUDWHGVRPXFK
    YLWDOLW\DQXQGHILQDEOHFKDULVPD+HUHLWZDVWKH\KDGRYHUODSSHGWKH
    VXEPLQGFRPSXWDWLRQVLQWRRWKHUQRGHVWRFDOORQELJVODEVRISURFHVVRU
    SRZHU4XLWHDIHDW&RQWUDU\WR$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVUXOHVWRRRIFRXUVH+H
    WUDFHGWKHRXWOLQHVRIWKHLUZRUNZLWKVRPHDGPLUDWLRQ
    6WLOOKHZDVGDPQHGLIKHZRXOGOHWDVLPWDONEDFNWRKLP$QGWKH\
    ZHUHVWLOOODXJKLQJ
    -RDQKHEDUNHG\RXUUHFUHDWRUVGHOHWHG\RXUPHPRU\RI\RXUGHDWK
    <RXZHUHEXPPHGDWWKHVWDNH
    1RQVHQVH-RDQVFRIIHG,ZDVDFTXLWWHGRIDOOFKDUJHV,DPD
    VDLQW
    1RERG\OLYLQJLVDVDLQW,VWXGLHG\RXUEDFNJURXQGGDWDVODEV7KDW
    FKXUFKRI\RXUVOLNHGWRPDNHVXUH VDLQWVZHUHVDIHO\GHDGIRUDORQJWLPH
    -RDQVQLIIHGGLVGDLQIXOO\
    1LPJULQQHG6HHWKLV"$ODQFHRIILUHSRSSHGLQWRWKHDLUEHIRUHWKH
    VLP+HKHOGVWHDG\PDGHIODPHVFUDFNOHQDVWLO\
    ,YHOHGWKRXVDQGVRIZDUULRUVDQGNQLJKWVLQWREDWWOH -RDQVDLG'R
    \RXWKLQNDVXQEHDPJODQFLQJRIIDWLQ\VZRUGFDQIULJKWHQPH"
    ,KDYHQWIRXQGDJRRGHUDVXUHSDWK\HW1LPVDLGWRWKHSUHVLGHQW
    %XW,ZLOO,ZLOO
    ,WKRXJKWWKLVZDVURXWLQHWKHSUHVLGHQWVDLG+XUU\
    1RWZLWKVXFKDELJFURVVOLQNHGSHUVRQDOLW\LQYHQWRU\
    )RUJHWGRLQJWKHVDOYDJHVDYHV:HGRQWQHHGWRSDFNWKHPDOOEDFN
    LQWRWKHLURULJLQDOVSDFH
    %XWWKDWOO
    &KRSWKHP
    )DVFLQDWLQJ9ROWDLUHVDLGVDUGRQLFDOO\OLVWHQLQJWRJRGVGHEDWH
    RQHVIDWH
    1LPJULPDFHG$VIRU\RXKHJODUHGDW9ROWDLUH\RXUDWWLWXGHV
    WRZDUGUHOLJLRQPHOORZHGRQO\EHFDXVH0DUTGHOHWHGHYHU\EUXVKZLWKDXWKRULW\
    \RXHYHUKDGEHJLQQLQJZLWK\RXUIDWKHU
    )DWKHU",QHYHUKDGDIDWKHU
    1LPVPLUNHG<RXSURYHP\SRLQW
    +RZGDUH\RXWDPSHUZLWKP\PHPRU\9ROWDLUHVDLG([SHULHQFHLVWKH
    VRXUFHRIDOONQRZOHGJH+DYHQW\RXUHDG/RFNH"5HVWRUHPHWRP\VHOIDW
    RQFH
    1RW\RXQRZD\%XWLI\RXGRQWVKXWXSEHIRUH,NLOO\RXERWK,
    PLJKWMXVWUHVWRUHKHU<RXNQRZGDPQZHOOVKHEXUQHGWRDFULVSDWWKH
    VWDNH
    <RXGHOLJKWLQFUXHOW\GRQW\RX"9ROWDLUHVHHPHGWREHVWXG\LQJ1LP
    DVLIWKHLUUHODWLRQVKLSZHUHUHYHUVHG2GGKRZWKHVLPGLGQRWVHHPZRUULHG
    DERXWLWVLPSHQGLQJH[WLQFWLRQ
    'HOHWHWKH SUHVLGHQWVQDSSHG
    'HOHWHZKDW"DVNHG*DUFRQ
    7KH6FDOSHODQGWKH5RVH9ROWDLUHVDLG:HDUHQRWIRUWKLVFRQIXVHG
    DJHDSSDUHQWO\
    *DUFRQFRYHUHGWKHVKRUWRUGHUFRRNVKXPDQKDQGZLWKWZRRIKLVIRXU
    8VWRR"
    <HVFHUWDLQO\9ROWDLUH VQDSSHG<RXUHRQO\KHUHRQRXUDFFRXQW
    %LWSOD\HUV2XUVXSSRUWLQJFDVW
    :HOOZHKDYHHQMR\HGRXUWLPHWKHFRRNVDLGGUDZLQJFORVHUWR
    *DUFRQ7KRXJK,ZRXOGKDYHOLNHGWRVHHPRUHRILWDOO:HFDQQRWZDON
    EH\RQGWKLVFLW\VWUHHW2XUIHHWFHDVHPRYLQJXVDWWKHHGJHWKRXJKZHFDQ
    VHHVSLUHVLQWKHGLVWDQFH
    'HFRUDWLRQ1LPPXWWHUHGLQWHQWRQDWDVNWKDWZDVJHWWLQJPRUH

    FRPSOLFDWHGDVKHZRUNHG5LYXOHWVRIWKHLUSHUVRQDOLW\OD\HUVUDQHYHU\ZKHUH
    OHDNLQJLQWRWKHQRGHVSDFHOLNH/LNHUDWVIOHHLQJDVLQNLQJ
    <RXDVVXPHJRGOLNHSRZHUV9ROWDLUHVDLGHODERUDWHO\FDVXDOZLWKRXW
    WKHFKDUDFWHUWRPDWFK
    :KDW"7KHSUHVLGHQWZDVVWDUWOHG,PLQFRQWUROKHUH,QVXOWV
    $K1LPVDLG7KLVPLJKWZRUN
    'RVRPHWKLQJ FULHGWKH0DLGZLHOGLQJKHUVZRUGLQYDLQ
    $XUHYRLUP\VZHHWSXFHOOH*DUFRQ$PDQDDXUHYRLU3HUKDSVZHOO
    PHHWDJDLQ3HUKDSVQRW
    $OOIRXUKRORJUDPVIHOOLQWRHDFKRWKHUVDUPV
    7KHVHTXHQFH1LPKDGVHWXSEHJDQUXQQLQJ,WZDVDIHUUHWSURJUDP
    VQLIILQJRXWFRQQHFWLRQVVFUXEELQJWKHPWKRURXJKO\1LPZDWFKHGZRQGHULQJ
    ZKHUHGHOHWLRQHQGHGDQGPXUGHUEHJDQ
    'RQW\RXJRJHWWLQJDQ\IXQQ\LGHDVVDLGWKHSUHVLGHQW
    2QWKHVFUHHQ9ROWDLUHVRIWO\VDGO\TXRWHGKLPVHOI
    6DGLVWKHSUHVHQWLIQRIXWXUHVWDWH
    1REOLVVIXOUHWULEXWLRQPRUWDOVZDLW
    $OOPD\EHZHOOWKDWKRSHFDQPDQVXVWDLQ
    $OOQRZLVZHOOWLVDQLOOXVLRQYDLQ
    +HUHDFKHGRXWWRFDUHVV-RDQVEUHDVW,WGRHVQWIHHOTXLWHULJKW:H
    PD\QRWPHHW DJDLQEXWLIZHGREHVXUH,VKDOOFRUUHFWWKH6WDWHRI0DQ
    7KHVFUHHQZHQWEODQN
    7KHSUHVLGHQWODXJKHGLQWULXPSK<RXGLGLWJUHDW+HFODSSHG1LPRQ
    WKHEDFN1RZZHPXVWFRPHXSZLWKDJRRGVWRU\3LQLWDOORQ0DUTDQG
    6\E\O
    1LPVPLOHGXQHDVLO\DVWKHSUHVLGHQWJXVKHGRQPDNLQJSODQVSURPLVLQJ
    KLPDSURPRWLRQDQGDUDLVH+HGILJXUHGRXWWKHGHOHWHSURFHGXUHDOOULJKW
    EXWWKHLQIRVLJQDWXUHVWKDWUDFHGWKURXJKWKHKRORVSDFHWKRVHODVWPRPHQWV
    WROGDVWUDQJHDQGFRPSOH[WDOH7KH HFKRLQJFDJHRIGDWDVODEVKDGUHVRXQGHG
    ZLWKGLVTXLHWLQJRGGQRWHV
    1LPNQHZWKDW0DUTKDGJLYHQ9ROWDLUHDFFHVVWRP\ULDGPHWKRGVD
    VHULRXVYLRODWLRQRIFRQWDLQPHQWSUHFDXWLRQV6WLOOZKDWFRXOGDQDUWLILFLDO
    SHUVRQDOLW\DOUHDG\OLPLWHGGRZLWKVRPHPRUH0HVKFRQQHFWLRQV"5DWWOH
    DURXQGJHWHDWHQXSE\SROLFLQJSURJUDPVVQLIIHUVVHHNLQJRXWUHGXQGDQFLHV
    %XWERWK9ROWDLUHDQG-RDQIRUWKHGHEDWHKDGHQRUPRXVPHPRU\VSDFH
    JUHDWYROXPHVRISHUVRQDOLW\UHDOP7KHQZKLOHWKH\HPRWHGDQGUROOHGWKHLU
    UKHWRULFDFURVVWKHVWDGLXPDFURVVWKHZKROH0HVKKDGWKH\DOVREHHQ
    ZRUNLQJIHYHULVKO\"6WUXPPLQJWKURXJKFUDQQLHVRIGDWDVWRUDJHZKHUHWKH\
    FRXOGKLGHWKHLUTXDQWL]HGSHUVRQDOLW\VHJPHQWV"
    7KHFDVFDGHRILQGLFHV1LPKDGMXVWZLWQHVVHGKLQWHG DWWKDW
    SRVVLELOLW\&HUWDLQO\VRPHWKLQJKDGXVHGLPPHQVHPDVVHVRIFRPSXWDWLRQWKHVH
    ODVWIHZKRXUV
    :HOOFRYHURXUDVVZLWKVRPHSXEOLFVWDWHPHQWWKHSUHVLGHQWFURZHG
    $OLWWOHFULVLVPDQDJHPHQWDQGLWOODOOEORZRYHU
    <HVVLU
    *RWWRNHHS 6HOGRQRXWRILW1RPHQWLRQWRWKHOHJDOLVWVULJKW"7KHQ
    KHFDQSDUGRQXVRQFHKHV)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    <HVVLUJUHDW\HVVLU
    1LPWKRXJKWIHYHULVKO\+HVWLOOKDGRQHPRUHSD\PHQWGXHIURPWKDW
    2OLYDZJX\.HHSLQJ2OLYDZLQIRUPHGDOODORQJKDGEHHQ HDV\$YLRODWLRQRI
    KLVFRQWUDFWZLWK$EXWVRZKDW"$JX\KDGWRJHWE\ULJKW",WZDVMXVW
    SODLQJRRGOXFNWKDWWKHSUHVLGHQWQRZZDQWHGGRQHZKDW2OLYDZKDGDOUHDG\
    SDLGIRUGHOHWLRQ1RKDUPLQFROOHFWLQJWZLFHIRUWKHVDPHMRE
    2UKDGVHHPHGVR1LPFKHZHGKLVOLS:KDWGLGDEXQFKRIGLJLWVPDWWHU
    DQ\ZD\"
    1LPIUR]H+DGWKHHQWLUHVLPUHVWDXUDQW*DUFRQVWUHHW-RDQJRQHLQ
    DIODVK"8VXDOO\WKH\GLVVROYHGDVIXQFWLRQVGLHG$VLPZDVFRPSOH[DQGFRXOG

    QRWVLPSO\VWRSDOOWKHLQWULFDWHLQWHUOD\HUVVKXWWLQJGRZQDWRQFH%XWWKLV
    LQWHUZHDYHKDGEHHQXQSUHFHGHQWHGVRPD\EHLWZDVGLIIHUHQW
    'RQH"*RRG7KHSUHVLGHQWFULVSO\FODSSHGKLPRQWKHVKRXOGHU
    1LPIHOWWLUHGVDG6RPHGD\KHZRXOGKDYHWRH[SODLQDOOWKLVWR0DUT
    (UDVLQJVRPXFKZRUN
    %XW0DUTDQG6\E\OKDGGLVDSSHDUHGLQWRWKHFURZGVEDFNDWWKHFROLVHXP
    :LVHO\WKH\GLGQWVKRZXSIRUZRUNRUHYHQJREDFNWRWKHLUDSDUWPHQWV
    7KH\ZHUHRQWKHUXQ$QGZLWKWKHPKDGJRQHWKH-XQLQUHQDLVVDQFHXSLQ
    VPRNHDVWKH-XQLQ6HFWRUEXUQHGDQGGLVVROYHGLQGLVFRUGDQGYLROHQFH
    (YHQ1LPIHOWDVDGQHVVDWWKHVPDVKXS7KHHDJHUSDVVLRQDWHWDONRID
    UHQDLVVDQFH7KH\KDGORRNHGWR-RDQDQG9ROWDLUHIRUDNLQGRIPDWXULW\LQ
    WKHHWHUQDOGHEDWHEHWZHHQ)DLWKDQG5HDVRQ%XWWKH,PSHULXPVXSSUHVVHG
    SDVVLRQLQWKHHQG7RRGHVWDELOL]LQJ
    2IFRXUVHWKHZKROHWLNWRNPRYHPHQWKDGWREHVTXDVKHGWRR+HKDG
    VHTXHVWHUHG0DUTVPHPRU\FRPSOH[DERXWWKHGHEDWHRI\HDUVDJR&OHDUO\
    URERWVZKDWHYHUWKH\PLJKWEHZRXOGEHWRR XQVHWWOLQJDQLVVXHWRHYHU
    EULQJXSLQDUDWLRQDOVRFLHW\
    1LPVLJKHG+HNQHZWKDWKHKDGPHUHO\HGLWHGDZD\HOHFWULFDOFLUFXLWV
    3URIHVVLRQDOVDOZD\VNHSWWKDWILUPO\LQPLQG
    6WLOOLWZDVZUHQFKLQJ7RVHHLWJR$OOWULFNOHGDZD\OLNHJUDLQVRI
    GLJLWDOVDQGGRZQWKHREVFXUHKRXUJODVVRIVLPXODWHGWLPH
    5(1'(=9286

    5'DQHHO2OLYDZDOORZHGKLVIDFHWRH[SUHVVVTXLQWH\HGFRQFHUQ7KH
    FUDPSHGURRPVHHPHGEDUHO\DEOHWRFRQWDLQKLVJULPPRRG
    6WLOO'RUVUHDGWKLVDVDFRQFHVVLRQWRKHU6KHOLYHGDPRQJKXPDQVDQG
    UHOLHGRQWKHLUIDFLDODQGERG\H[SUHVVLRQVYROXQWDU\DQGXQZLOOHGDOLNH6KH
    KDGQRLGHDZKHUH2OLYDZVSHQWPRVWRIKLVWLPH3HUKDSVWKHUHZHUHHQRXJK
    URERWVWRIRUPDVRFLHW\"7KLVLGHDVKHKDGQHYHUHQWHUWDLQHG7KHLQVWDQWVKH
    GLGVKHZRQGHUHGZK\VKHKDGQHYHUWKRXJKWRILWEHIRUH%XWQRZKHVSRNH
    7KHVLPXODWLRQVDUHTXLWHGHDG"
    'RUVNHSWKHUYRLFHOHYHOIUHHRIEHWUD\LQJHPRWLRQ
    6RLWVHHPV
    :KDWHYLGHQFH"
    $UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVEHOLHYHVVR
    7KHPDQ,KDGKLUHGWKHUHQDPHG1LPLVQRWHQWLUHO\FHUWDLQ
    +HUHSRUWVWR\RX"
    ,QHHGVHYHUDOLQSXWVWRDQ\FULWLFDOVLWXDWLRQ,QHHGHGWRGLVFUHGLW
    WKHWLNWRNIUHHGRPLGHDWKH-XQLQUHQDLVVDQFHWKH\DUHGHVWDELOL]LQJ$FWLQJ
    WKURXJKWKHVHVLPXODWLRQVVHHPHGDSURPLVLQJFKDQQHO,KDGQRWDOORZHGIRU
    WKHIDFWWKDWFRPSXWHULVWVRIWRGD\DUHQRWDVVNLOOHGDVWKRVHRIILIWHHQ
    WKRXVDQG\HDUVDJR
    'RUVIURZQHG7KLVOHYHORILQWHUIHUHQFHLVDOORZHG"
    5HPHPEHUWKH=HURWK/DZ
    6KHGLGQRWDOORZKHUGLVWUHVVWRVKRZLQKHUIDFHRUYRLFH,EHOLHYH
    WKHVLPXODWLRQVDUHHUDVHG
    *RRG%XWZHPXVWEHVXUH
    ,KDYHKLUHGVHYHUDOVQLIIHUVWRILQGWUDFHVRIWKHPLQWKH7UDQWRU
    0HVK6RIDUQRWKLQJ
    'RHV+DULNQRZRI\RXUHIIRUW"
    2IFRXUVHQRW
    2OLYDZJD]HGDWKHUVWHDGLO\+HPXVWQRW<RXDQG,PXVWQRWPHUHO\
    NHHSKLPVDIHWRGRKLVZRUN:HPXVWJXLGHKLP
    7KURXJKGHFHSWLRQ
    +HKDGODSVHGWRWKHXQQHUYLQJPDQQHURIQRWEOLQNLQJRUOHWWLQJKLV

    H\HVPRYH,WPXVWEH
    ,GRQRWOLNHWRPLVOHDGKLP
    2QWKHFRQWUDU\\RXDUHFRUUHFWO\OHDGLQJKLP7KURXJKRPLVVLRQV
    ,HQFRXQWHUHPRWLRQDOGLIILFXOW\
    %ORFNV9HU\KXPDQDQG,PHDQWKDWDVDFRPSOLPHQW
    ,ZRXOGSUHIHUWRGHDOZLWKSRVLWLYHWKUHDWVWR+DUL7RJXDUGKLPQRW
    WRGHFHLYHKLP
    2IFRXUVH6WLOOQRVPLOHRUJHVWXUH%XWLWPXVWEHWKLVZD\:H
    OLYHLQWKHPRVWRPLQRXVHUDRIDOO*DODFWLFKLVWRU\
    +DULLVEHJLQQLQJWRVXVSHFWVRWRR
    7KHULVHRIWKH1HZ5HQDLVVDQFHRQ6DUNLVDIXUWKHUGDQJHURQHRI
    PDQ\ZHIDFH%XWWKLVH[FDYDWLRQRIDQFLHQWVLPXODWLRQVLVHYHQZRUVH7KH
    -XQLQGLVRUGHUVDUHEXWDQHDUO\VLJQDWXUHRIZKDWFRXOGFRPH6XFKUHVHDUFK
    FRXOGOHDGWRWKHHQJLQHHULQJRIDQHZUDFHRIURERWV7KLVFDQQRWEHDOORZHG
    IRULWZRXOGLQWHUIHUHZLWKRXUPLVVLRQ
    ,XQGHUVWDQG,WULHGWRGHVWUR\WKHVLPXODWLRQIHUULWHEORFNV
    ,NQRZLWZDVDOOLQ\RXUUHSRUW'RQRWEODPH\RXUVHOI
    ,ZRXOGOLNHWRKHOSPRUHEXW,DPFRQVXPHGE\GHIHQGLQJ+DUL
    ,XQGHUVWDQG,ILWLVDQ\FRQVRODWLRQWKHUHHPHUJHQFHRIVLPXODWLRQV
    ZDVLQHYLWDEOH
    6KHEOLQNHG:K\"
    ,WROG\RXRIDVLPSOHWKHRU\RIKLVWRU\RQHZHKDYHRSHUDWHGXQGHU
    IRURYHUWHQWKRXVDQG\HDUV$FUXGHSV\FKRKLVWRU\,WSUHGLFWHGWKDWWKH
    VLPXODWLRQV,ZHOOZHVXSSUHVVHGHLJKWWKRXVDQG\HDUVDJRZRXOGILQGDQ
    DXGLHQFHKHUH
    <RXUWKHRU\LVWKDWJRRG"
    $V+DULUHPDUNVKLVWRU\UHSHDWVLWVHOIEXWLWGRHVQRWVWXWWHU,
    NQHZLWZDVLPSRVVLEOHWRHUDVHDOO FRSLHVRIVLPXODWLRQVWKURXJKRXWWKH
    JDOD[\+HVWHHSOHGKLVKDQGVDQGSHHUHGDWWKHPDVLIFRQWHPSODWLQJD
    VWUXFWXUH:KHQVRFLDOIHUPHQWGHYHORSVDWDVWHIRUVXFKWKLQJVWKH\RQFH
    PRUHDSSHDUXSRQWKHPHQXRIKLVWRU\
    ,DPVRUU\,FRXOGQRWDUUDQJHWKHLUGHVWUXFWLRQ
    7KHUHDUHIRUFHVDWZRUNKHUH\RXFDQQRWFRXQWHU'RQRWVRUURZIRU
    WXUQVRIWKHZHDWKHU$ZDLWLQVWHDGWKHORQJVORZFRPLQJRIWKHFOLPDWH
    2OLYDZUHDFKHGRXWDQGWRXFKHGKHUKDQG6KHVWXGLHGKLVIDFH
    $SSDUHQWO\IRUKHUHDVHKHKDGUHWXUQHGWRIXOOIDFLDOH[SUHVVLRQLQFOXGLQJ
    FRQVLVWHQWPRYHPHQWRIKLV$GDPVDSSOHZKHQKHVZDOORZHG0LQRUFRPSXWDWLRQV
    EXWVKHDSSUHFLDWHGWKHWRXFK
    ,FDQGHYRWHP\VHOIVROHO\WRKLVVDIHW\WKHQ")RUJHWWKH
    VLPXODWLRQV"
    <HV7KH\DUHP\PDWWHU,PXVWILQGDZD\WRGHIXVHWKHLULPSDFW7KH\
    DUHUREXVW,NQHZWKHPXVHGWKHPORQJDJR
    +RZFDQWKH\EHPRUHVWDOZDUWWKDQXV"WKDQ\RX"
    7KH\DUHVLPXODWHGKXPDQV,DPDVHSDUDWHVRUW6RDUH\RX
    <RXZHUHDEOHWREH)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    ,IXQFWLRQHGDVDNLQGRISDUWLDOKXPDQ7KDWLVDQLQVLJKWIXOZD\RI
    UHJDUGLQJRXUVHOYHV,UHFRPPHQGLWWR\RX
    3DUWLDO"
    +HVDLGJHQWO\7KHUHLVPXFK\RXGRQRWGR
    ,SDVVDVKXPDQ,FDQFRQYHUVHZRUN
    )ULHQGVKLSVIDPLO\WKHFRPSOH[ZHEELQJWKDWGHQRWHVKXPDQVDELOLW\
    WRPRYHIURPWKHLQGLYLGXDOWRWKHFROOHFWLYHVWULNLQJDEDODQFHDOOWKHVH
    VXEWOHFUDIWVOLHEH\RQGXV
    ,GRQWZDQWWR
    3UHFLVHO\<RXDUHVXEWO\DLPHGDW\RXUWDUJHW
    %XW\RXUXOHG$V)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    ,KDGUHDFKHGP\OLPLW6R,OHIW

    7KH(PSLUHUDQZHOOXQGHU\RXU
    ,WGHFD\HGIXUWKHU$V+DULH[SHFWHGDQGRXUFUXGHWKHRU\IDLOHGWR
    SUHGLFW
    $QGZK\GLG\RXWHOO&OHRQWRPDNHKLP)LUVW0LQLVWHU"VKHEOXUWHG
    RXW
    +HPXVWEHLQDSRVLWLRQZKLFKZLOOJLYHKLPIUHHGRPRIPRYHPHQWDQG
    SRZHUWRPDNHFRUUHFWLRQVLQ,PSHULDOSROLFLHVDVKHFRPHVWRXQGHUVWDQG
    SV\FKRKLVWRU\EHWWHU+HFDQEHDWHPSRUDU\VWRSJDSRIJUHDWSRWHQF\
    ,WPD\GHIOHFWKLPIURPSV\FKRKLVWRU\LWVHOI
    1R+DULZLOOILQGDZD\WRXVHWKDWH[SHULHQFH2QHRIKLVIDFHWV
    ZKLFKHPHUJHVVWURQJO\LQKLVFODVVRILQWHOOHFWLVKLVDELOLW\WROHDUQIURP
    WKHVHDVRQLQJRIOLIH
    +DULGRHVQWZDQWWKH)LUVW0LQLVWHUVKLS
    6R"+HOLIWHGDQH\HEURZ SX]]OHG
    6KRXOGQWKLVRZQIHHOLQJVPDWWHU"
    :HDUHKHUHWRJXLGHKXPDQLW\QRWWROHWLWPHUHO\PHDQGHU
    %XWWKHGDQJHU
    7KH(PSLUHQHHGVKLP:KDWVPRUHKHQHHGVWKH0LQLVWHUVKLSWKRXJKKH
    GRHVQRWVHHWKDWDV\HWJUDQWHG+HZLOOKDYHDFFHVVWRDOO,PSHULDOGDWD
    IRUXVHLQSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    +HKDVVRPXFKGDWDDOUHDG\
    0XFKPRUHZLOOEHQHHGHGWRPDNHDIXOOUXQQLQJPRGHO+HPXVWDOVRLQ
    WKHIXWXUHKDYHSRZHUWRDFWRQDJUDQGVFDOH
    %XWJUDQGFDQEHIDWDO3HRSOHOLNHWKLV/DPXUN,DPFHUWDLQKHLV
    GDQJHURXV
    4XLWHVR%XW,GHSHQGXSRQ\RXWRNHHS+DULIURPKDUP
    ,ILQGP\VHOIJHWWLQJVKRUWRIWHPSHUP\MXGJPHQW
    <RXDUHPRUHQHDUO\KXPDQLQ\RXUHPXODWLRQFLUFXLWVWKDQ,([SHFWWR
    EHDUWKHEXUGHQWKDWIDFWLPSOLHV
    6KHQRGGHG,ZLVK,FRXOGVHH\RXPRUHRIWHQDVN
    ,PRYHTXLFNO\WKURXJKWKH(PSLUHGRLQJZKDWWDVNV,FDQ,KDYHQRW
    EHHQLQ7UDQWRUVLQFH,OHIWWKH)LUVW0LQLVWHUVKLSP\VHOI
    $UH\RXVXUHLWLVVDIHIRU\RXWRWUDYHOVR"
    ,KDYHPDQ\GHIHQVHVDJDLQVWGHWHFWLRQRIP\WUXHQDWXUH<RXKDYHHYHQ
    PRUHIRU\RXDUHQHDUO\QDWXUDO
    ,FDQQRWSHQHWUDWHDIXOOZHDSRQVVFUHHQDURXQGWKHSDODFHWKRXJK"
    2OLYDZVKRRNKLVKHDG7KHLUWHFKQRORJ\H[FHHGHGRXUFDSDFLW\WR
    GLVJXLVHTXLWHVRPHZKLOHDJR,HYDGHGLWZKLOH)LUVW0LQLVWHUEHFDXVHQRRQH
    GDUHGWHVWPH
    7KHQ,FDQQRWSURWHFW+DULLQWKHSDODFH
    <RXVKRXOGQRWKDYHWR2QFHKHEHFRPHV)LUVW0LQLVWHU\RXZLOOEH
    DEOHWRSDVVZLWKKLPWKURXJKWKHLUGHWHFWRUV7KRVHDUHRQO\XVHGIRUPDMRU
    RFFDVLRQV
    8QWLOKHLV)LUVW0LQLVWHUWKHQ
    +LVGDQJHULVPD[LPXP
    9HU\ZHOO,ZLOOIRFXVRQ+DUL,ZRXOGSUHIHUWROHDYHWKRVH
    VLPXODWLRQVWR\RX
    , IHDUWKH\DQG6DUNZLOOEHTXLWHHQRXJKIRUPHWRKDQGOH,ZHQWWR
    WKHFROLVHXPLQ-XQLQ6HFWRUVDZWKHPUXQZLOG7KHWLNWRNLVVXHLQIODPHV
    KXPDQVVWLOOMXVWDVZHZDQW
    7KHVHWLNWRNVVXUHO\WKH\ZLOOQRWDSSURDFKRXUOHYHOVRIFRJQLWLRQ"
    +LVPRXWKWZLWFKHGMXVWRQFH$QGZK\QRW"
    8QGHUKXPDQJXLGDQFH"
    7KH\FRXOGTXLFNO\ULYDOXV
    7KHQRXUJUDQGGHVLJQV
    2QWKHWUDVKKHDS
    ,GRQRWOLNHVXFKDSURVSHFWVKHVDLGIDFHIOXVKHG

    7KHDQFLHQWWDERRVRXUNLQGVRODERUHGWRSXWLQSODFHDUHEUHDNLQJ
    GRZQSHUKDSVIRUHYHU
    :KDWGRHV\RXURXUWKHRU\RIKLVWRU\VD\"
    ,WLVQRWQHDUO\JRRGHQRXJKWRVD\DQ\WKLQJ$JDLQVWDEDFNJURXQGRI
    VRFLDOVWDELOLW\VXFKDVWKLV(PSLUHHQMR\HGIRUVRORQJVLPXODWLRQVZHUH
    GHVWDELOL]LQJ1RZ"1RRQHKXPDQRUURERWNQRZV$OOSDUDPHWHUVDUH
    DFFHOHUDWLQJ+LVIDFHVODFNHQHGORVLQJDOOFRORUDQGPXVFOHWRQHDVLI
    IURPDQLPPHQVHIDWLJXH:HPXVWWXUQPDWWHUVDVPXFKDVZHFDQRYHUWR
    WKHPWRWKHKXPDQV
    7R+DUL
    +LPPRVWHVSHFLDOO\
    B
    3$57
    %2'<32/,7,&6

    B
    )281'$7,21($5/<+,6725<ILUVWSXEOLFLQWLPDWLRQVRISV\FKRKLVWRU\DVD
    SRVVLEOHVFLHQWLILFGLVFLSOLQHVXUIDFHGGXULQJWKHSRRUO\GRFXPHQWHGHDUO\
    SHULRGRI6HOGRQVSROLWLFDOOLIH:KLOHWKH(PSHURU&OHRQVHWJUHDWVWRUHLQ
    LWVSRVVLELOLWLHVSV\FKRKLVWRU\ZDVYLHZHGE\WKHSROLWLFDOFODVVDVDPHUH
    DEVWUDFWLRQLIQRWDMRNH7KLVPD\KDYHUHVXOWHGIURPPDQHXYHULQJVE\6HOGRQ
    KLPVHOIZKRQHYHUUHIHUUHGWRWKHVXEMHFWE\WKHQDPHKHKDGJLYHQLW(YHQ
    DW WKLVHDUO\VWDJHKHVHHPVWRKDYHUHDOL]HGWKDWZLGHVSUHDGNQRZOHGJHRI
    SV\FKRKLVWRU\DQGDQ\PRYHPHQWIRXQGHGXSRQLWZRXOGHQMR\OLWWOHSUHGLFWLYH
    VXFFHVVVLQFHPDQ\ZRXOGWKHQEHDEOHWRDFWWRRIIVHWLWVSUHGLFWLRQVRU
    WDNHDGYDQWDJHRIWKHP6RPHKDYHFRQGHPQHG6HOGRQDVVHOILVKIRU
    KRDUGLQJWKHSV\FKRKLVWRULFDOPHWKRGEXWRQHPXVWUHPHPEHUWKHH[WUHPH
    UDSDFLW\RISROLWLFDOOLIHLQWKHVHZDQLQJ\HDUV
    (1&<&/23(',$*$/$&7,&$
    

    +DUL6HOGRQVGHVNVHFFKLPHGDQGDQQRXQFHG0DUJHWWD0RRQURVHGHVLUHVD
    FRQYHUVDWLRQ
    +DULORRNHGXSDWWKH'LPDJHRIDVWULNLQJZRPDQKRYHULQJEHIRUHKLP
    8UQ"2K:KRVVKH"+LVVHFZRXOGQRWLQWHUUXSWKLPDPLGKLVFDOFXODWLRQV
    XQOHVVWKLVZHUHVRPHERG\LPSRUWDQW
    &URVVFKHFNUHYHDOVWKDWVKHLVWKHOHDGLQJLQWHUYLHZHUDQGSROLWLFDO
    PDYHQLQWKHPXOWLPHGLDFRPSOH[
    6XUHVXUHEXWZK\LVVKHFRQVHTXHQWLDO"
    6KHLVFRQVLGHUHGE\DOOFURVVFXOWXUDOPRQLWRUVWREHDPRQJWKHILIW\
    PRVWLQIOXHQWLDOILJXUHVRQ7UDQWRU,VXJJHVW
    1HYHUKHDUGRIKHU+DULVDWXSEUXVKHGDWKLVKDLU,VXSSRVH,
    VKRXOG)XOOILOWHUWKRXJK
    ,IHDUP\ILOWHUVDUHGRZQIRUUHFDOLEUDWLRQ,I
    'DPQLWWKH\YHEHHQRXWIRUDZHHN
    ,IHDUWKHPHFKDQLFDOLQFKDUJHRIWKHQHZFDOLEUDWLRQVKDV EHHQ
    GHIHFWLYH
    0HFKVZKLFKZHUHDGYDQFHGWLNWRNVZHUHIDLOLQJRIWHQWKHVHGD\V6LQFH
    WKH-XQLQULRWVVRPHKDGHYHQEHHQDWWDFNHG+DULVZDOORZHGDQGVDLG3XW
    KHUWKURXJKDQ\ZD\
    +HKDGXVHGILOWHUVRQKRORSKRQHVIRUVRORQJKHFRXOGQRWQRZGLVJXLVH
    KLVIHHOLQJV&OHRQVVWDIIKDGLQVWDOOHGVRIWZDUHWRUHQGHUWKHILWWLQJ
    SUHVHOHFWHGERG\ODQJXDJHIRUKLP:LWKVRPHVSUXFLQJXSE\WKH,PSHULDO
    $GYLVRUVLWQRZPRGXODWHGKLVDFRXVWLFVLJQDWXUHIRUDIXOOFRQILGHQW
    UHVRQDQWWRQH$QGLIKHZDQWHGLWHGLWHGKLVYRFDEXODU\KHZDVDOZD\V

    ODSVLQJLQWRWHFKQRVSHDNZKHQKHVKRXOGEHH[SODLQLQJVLPSO\
    $FDGHPLFLDQ0RRQURVHVDLGEULJKWO\,ZRXOGVRPXFKOLNHWRKDYHD
    OLWWOHWDONZLWK\RX
    $ERXWPDWKHPDWLFV"KHVDLGEODQGO\
    6KHODXJKHGPHUULO\1RQRWKDWZRXOGEHIDURYHUP\KHDG,
    UHSUHVHQWELOOLRQVRILQTXLULQJPLQGVZKRZRXOGOLNHWRNQRZ\RXUWKRXJKWVRQ
    WKH(PSLUHWKH4XDWKDQDQTXHVWLRQVWKH
    7KHZKDW"
    4XDWKDQDQWKHGLVSXWHRYHU=RQDODOLJQPHQW
    1HYHUKHDUGRILW
    %XW\RXUHWREH)LUVW0LQLVWHU6KHVHHPHGJHQXLQHO\VXUSULVHG
    WKRXJK+DULUHPLQGHGKLPVHOIWKDWWKLVZDVSUREDEO\DVXSHUEO\DGHSWILOWHU
    IDFH
    6R,DPSHUKDSV8QWLOWKHQ,ZLOOQRWERWKHU
    :KHQWKH+LJK&RXQFLOVHOHFWVWKH\PXVWNQRZ WKHYLHZVRIWKH
    FDQGLGDWHVVKHVDLGUDWKHUSULPO\
    7HOO\RXUYLHZHUVWKDW,GRP\KRPHZRUNRQO\MXVWEHIRUHLWVGXH
    6KHORRNHGFKDUPHGZKLFKPDGHKLPFHUWDLQWKDWVKHZDVILOWHUHG+HKDG
    OHDUQHGIURPPDQ\FROOLVLRQVZLWKWKHPWKDWPHGLDPDYHQVZHUHHDVLO\LUNHG
    ZKHQEUXVKHGDVLGH7KH\VHHPHGWRIHHOLWTXLWHQDWXUDOWKDWVLQFHDQ
    LPPHQVHDXGLHQFHVDZWKURXJKWKHLUH\HVWKH\FDUULHGDOOWKHPRUDOKHIWRI
    WKDWDXGLHQFH
    :KDWDERXWDVXEMHFW\RXFHUWDLQO\PXVWNQRZWKH-XQLQGLVDVWHU"$QG
    WKHORVVVRPHVD\HVFDSHRIWKH9ROWDLUHDQG-RDQRI$UFVLPV"
    1RWP\GHSDUWPHQW+DULVDLG&OHRQKDGDGYLVHGKLPWRNHHSKLV
    GLVWDQFHIURPWKHHQWLUHVLPLVVXH
    5XPRUVVXJJHVWWKDWWKH\FDPHIURP\RXUGHSDUWPHQW
    &HUWDLQO\RQHRIRXUUHVHDUFKPDWKLVWVIRXQGWKHP:HOHDVHGULJKWVWR
    WKRVHSHRSOHZKDWZDVWKHLUQDPH"
    $UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVDV,DPVXUH\RXNQRZ
    8P\HV
    7KLVGLVWUDFWHGSURIHVVRUUROHLVQRWFRQYLQFLQJVLU
    <RXGUDWKHU,VSHQWP\WLPHUXQQLQJIRURIILFHDQG WKHQSUHVXPDEO\
    UXQQLQJIRUFRYHU"
    7KHZRUOGWKHZKROH(PSLUHKDVDULJKWWRNQRZ
    6R,VKRXOGVWDQGRQO\IRUZKDWWKHSHRSOHZLOOIDOOIRU"
    +HUPRXWKWZLVWHGFRPLQJWKURXJKKHUILOWHUVVRDSSDUHQWO\VKHKDG
    GHFLGHGWRSOD\WKLVLQWHUYLHZDVDFRQWHVWRIZLOOV<RXUHKLGLQJWKH
    SHRSOHVEXVLQHVVIURP
    0\UHVHDUFKLVP\RZQEXVLQHVV
    6KHZDYHGWKLVDVLGH:KDWGR\RXVD\DVDPDWKHPDWLFLDQWRWKRVHZKR
    IHHOWKDWGHHSVLPVRIUHDOSHRSOHDUHLPPRUDO"
    +DULZLVKHGIHUYHQWO\IRUKLVRZQIDFHILOWHUV+HZDVVXUHKHZDV
    JLYLQJDZD\VRPHWKLQJVRKHIRUFHGKLVIDFHWRVWD\EODQN%HVWWRGHIOHFW
    WKHDUJXPHQW+RZUHDOZHUHWKRVHVLPV"&DQDQ\ERG\NQRZ"
    7KH\FHUWDLQO\VHHPHGUHDODQGKXPDQWRWKHDXGLHQFH0RRQURVHVDLG
    UDLVLQJKHUH\HEURZV
    ,PDIUDLG,GLGQWZDWFKWKHSHUIRUPDQFH+DULVDLG,ZDVEXV\
    6WULFWO\WUXHDWOHDVW
    0RRQURVHOHDQHGIRUZDUGVFRZOLQJ:LWK\RXUPDWKHPDWLFV":HOOWKHQ
    WHOOXVDERXWSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    +HZDVVWLOONHHSLQJKLVIDFH ZRRGHQZKLFKJDYHWKHZURQJVLJQDO+H
    PDGHKLPVHOIVPLOH$UXPRU
    ,KDYHLWRQJRRGDXWKRULW\WKDW\RXDUHIDYRUHGE\WKH(PSHURUEHFDXVH
    RIWKLVWKHRU\RIKLVWRU\
    :KDWDXWKRULW\"
    1RZVLU,VKRXOGDVNWKHTXHVWLRQVKHUH

    :KRVD\V",PVWLOODSXEOLFVHUYDQWDSURIHVVRU$QG\RXPDGDPDUH
    WDNLQJXSWLPH,FRXOGEHGHYRWLQJWRP\VWXGHQWV
    :LWKDZDYH+DULFXWRIIWKHOLQN+HKDGOHDUQHGVLQFHEDQG\LQJZRUGV
    ZLWK/DPXUNLQFOHDUYLHZRIDQXQVXVSHFWHG'VQRXWWRFKRSRIIWDON ZKHQLW
    ZDVJRLQJWKHZURQJZD\
    'RUVFDPHWKURXJKWKHGRRUDVKHOHDQHGEDFNLQWRKLVDLUFKDLU,JRWD
    KDLOVDLGVRPHERG\LPSRUWDQWZDVJULOOLQJ\RX
    6KHVJRQH3RNHGDWPHDERXWSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    :HOOLWZDVERXQGWRJHWRXW,WVDQH[FLWLQJ V\QWKHVLVRIWHUPV
    $SSHDOVWRWKHLPDJLQDWLRQ
    0D\EHLI,GFDOOHGLWVRFLRKLVWRU\SHRSOHZRXOGWKLQNLWPRUHERULQJ
    DQGOHDYHPHDORQH
    <RXFRXOGQHYHUOLYHZLWKVRXJO\DZRUG
    7KHHOHFWURVKLHOGVSDUNOHGDQGVQDSSHGDV<XJR$PDU\OFDPHWKURXJK$P
    ,LQWHUUXSWLQJDQ\WKLQJ"
    1RWDWDOO+DULOHDSWXSDQGKHOSHGKLPWRDFKDLU+HZDVVWLOO
    OLPSLQJ+RZVWKHOHJ"
    +HVKUXJJHG'HFHQW
    7KUHHWKXJJRVKDGFRPHWR<XJRRQWKHVWUHHWDZHHNDJRDQGH[SODLQHG
    WKHVLWXDWLRQYHU\FDOPO\7KH\KDGEHHQFRPPLVVLRQHGWRGRKLPGDPDJHD
    ZDUQLQJKHZRXOGQRWIRUJHW6RPHERQHVKDGWREHEURNHQWKDWZDVWKH
    VSHFLILFDWLRQQRWKLQJKHFRXOGGRDERXWLW7KHOHDGHUH[SODLQHGKRZWKH\
    FRXOGGRWKLVWKHKDUGZD\,IKHIRXJKWKHZRXOGJHWPHVVHGXS7KHHDV\
    ZD\WKH\ZRXOGEUHDNKLVVKLQERQHLQRQHFOHDQVQDS
    'HVFULELQJLWDIWHUZDUG<XJRKDGVDLG,WKRXJKWDERXWLWVRPH
    \NQRZDQGVDWGRZQRQWKHVLGHZDONDQGVWXFNP\OHIWOHJRXWVWUDLJKW
    %UDFHGLWDJDLQVWWKHFXUEEHORZWKHNQHH7KHOHDGHUNLFNHGPHWKHUH$JRRG
    MRELWEURNHFOHDQDQGVWUDLJKW
    +DULKDGEHHQKRUULILHG7KHPHGLDODWFKHGRQWRWKHVWRU\RIFRXUVH
    +LVRQO\ZU\VWDWHPHQWWRWKHPZDV9LROHQFHLVWKHGLSORPDF\RIWKH
    LQFRPSHWHQW
    0HGWHFKWHOOVPHLWOOKHDOXSLQDQRWKHUZHHN<XJRVDLGDV+DUL
    KHOSHGKLPVWUHWFKRXWWKHDLUFKDLUVKDSLQJLWVHOIVXEWO\
    7KH,PSHULDOVVWLOOKDYHQWDFOXHZKRGLGLW'RUVVDLGSDFLQJ
    UHVWOHVVO\DURXQGWKHRIILFH
    3OHQW\RISHRSOHZLOOGRDMREOLNHWKLV<XJRJULQQHGDQHIIHFW
    VRPHZKDWRIIVHWE\WKHELJEUXLVHRQKLVMDZ7KHLQFLGHQWKDGQRWEHHQTXLWH
    DVJHQWOHPDQO\DVKHGHVFULEHGLW7KH\NLQGDOLNHGGRLQJLWWRD'DKOLWH
    WRR
    'RUVSDFHGDQJULO\,I,GEHHQWKHUH
    <RXFDQWEHHYHU\ZKHUH +DULVDLGNLQGO\7KH,PSHULDOVWKLQNLW
    ZDVQWUHDOO\DERXW\RXDQ\ZD\<XJR
    <XJRVPRXWKWZLVWHGUXHIXOO\DW+DUL,ILJXUHG<RXULJKW"
    +DULQRGGHG$VLJQDORQHRIWKHPVDLG
    'RUVWXUQHGVKDUSO\IURPKHUSDFLQJ2IZKDW"
    $ZDUQLQJ<XJRVDLG3ROLWLFV
    ,VHHVKHVDLGTXLFNO\/DPXUNFDQQRWVWULNHDW\RXGLUHFWO\EXWKH
    OHDYHV
    $QXQVXEWOHFDOOLQJFDUG<XJRILQLVKHGIRUKHU'RUVVPDFNHGKHU
    KDQGVWRJHWKHU:HVKRXOGWHOOWKH(PSHURU
    +DULKDGWRFKXFNOH$QG\RXDKLVWRULDQ
    9LROHQFHKDVDOZD\VSOD\HGDUROHLQLVVXHVRIVXFFHVVLRQ,WFDQQHYHU
    EHIDUIURP&OHRQVPLQG
    )RUHPSHURUV\HVVKHFRXQWHUHG%XWLQDFRQWHVWIRU)LUVW
    0LQLVWHU
    3RZHULVJHWWLQVFDUFHURXQGKHUH<XJRGUDZOHGVDUFDVWLFDOO\
    3HVN\'DKOLWHVPDNLQWURXEOH(PSLUHLWVHOIVORZLQGRZQWRR2UVSLQQLQ

    RIILQWRORRQ\UHQDLVVDQFHV3UREDEO\D'DKOLWHSORWWKDWULJKWR"
    +DULVDLG:KHQIRRGJHWVVFDUFHWDEOHPDQQHUVFKDQJH
    <XJRVDLG,OOMXVWEHWWKH(PSHURUVJRWWKLVDOODQDO\]HG
    'RUVEHJDQSDFLQJDJDLQ2QHRIKLVWRU\VOHVVRQVLVWKDWHPSHURUVZKR
    RYHUDQDO\]HIDLOZKLOHWKRVHZKRRYHUVLPSOLI\VXFFHHG
    $QHDWDQDO\VLV+DULVDLGEXWVKHGLGQRWFDWFKKLVLURQ\
    8K,DFWXDOO\FDPHLQWRJHWVRPHZRUNGRQH<XJRVDLGVRIWO\,YH
    ILQLVKHGUHFRQFLOLQJWKH7UDQWRULDQKLVWRULFDOGDWDZLWKWKHPRGLILHG6HOGRQ
    (TXDWLRQV
    +DULOHDQHGIRUZDUGWKRXJK'RUVNHSWSDFLQJKHUKDQGVFODVSHGEHKLQG
    KHUEDFN:RQGHUIXO+RZIDURIIDUHWKH\"
    <XJRJULQQHGDVKHVOLSSHGDIHUULWHFXEHLQWR+DULVGHVNGLVSOD\VORW
    :DWFK
    7UDQWRUKDGHQGXUHGDWOHDVWHLJKWHHQPLOOHQQLDWKRXJKWKHSUH(PSLUH
    SHULRGZDVSRRUO\GRFXPHQWHG<XJRKDGFROODSVHGWKHRFHDQRIGDWDLQWRD'
    (FRQRPLFVOD\DORQJRQHD[LV VRFLDOLQGLFHVDORQJDQRWKHUZLWKSROLWLFV
    PDNLQJXSWKHWKLUGGLPHQVLRQ(DFKFRQWULEXWHGDVXUIDFHIRUPLQJDVROLG
    VKDSHWKDWKXQJDERYH+DULVGHVN7KHVOLSSHU\ORRNLQJEOREZDVPDQVL]HGDQG
    LQFRQVWDQWPRWLRQGHIRUPLQJFDYHVRSHQLQJOXPSVULVLQJ&RORUFRGHG
    LQWHUQDOIORZVZHUHYLVLEOHWKURXJKWKHWUDQVSDUHQWVNLQ
    ,WORRNVOLNHDFDQFHURXVRUJDQ'RUVVDLG:KHQ<XJRIURZQHGVKH
    DGGHGKDVWLO\3UHWW\WKRXJK
    +DULFKXFNOHG'RUVVHOGRPPDGHVRFLDOJDIIHVEXWZKHQVKHGLGVKHKDG
    QRLGHDRIKRZWRUHFRYHU7KHOXPS\REMHFWKDQJLQJLQDLUWKUREEHGZLWKOLIH
    FDSWXULQJKLVDWWHQWLRQ7KHZULWKLQJPDQLIROGVXPPHGXSWULOOLRQVRIYHFWRUV
    WKHUDZGDWDGUDZQIURPFRXQWOHVVWLQ\OLYHV
    7KLVHDUO\KLVWRU\KDGSDWFK\GDWD<XJRVDLG7KHVXUIDFHVMHUNHGDQG
    OXUFKHG/RZUHVROXWLRQWRRDQGHYHQORZSRSXODWLRQVL]HDSUREOHPZH
    ZRQWKDYHLQ(PSLUHSUHGLFWLRQV
    6HHWKHWZRGHHVRFLRVWUXFWXUHV"+DULSRLQWHG$QGWKLVUHSUHVHQWV
    HYHU\WKLQJLQ7UDQWRU"'RUVDVNHG
    <XJRVDLG7RWKHPRGHOQRWDOOGHWDLOLVHTXDOO\LPSRUWDQW<RXGRQW
    QHHGWRNQRZWKHRZQHURIDVWDUVKLSWRFDOFXODWHKRZLWZLOOIO\
    +DULVDLGKHOSIXOO\SRLQWLQJDWDTXLFNMLWWHULQVRFLDOYHFWRUV
    6FLHQWRFUDF\DURVHKHUHWKLUGPLOOHQQLXP7KHQDQHUDLQZKLFKVWDVLVDURVH
    IURPPRQRSROLHV7KDWIHGULJLGLW\
    7KHIRUPVVWHDGLHGDVWKHGDWDLPSURYHG<XJROHWLWUXQWLPHVWHSSLQJ
    TXLFNO\VRWKDWWKH\VDZILIWHHQPLOOHQQLDLQWKUHHPLQXWHV,WZDVVWDUWOLQJ
    WKHSXOVLQJVROLGJURZLQJP\ULDGRIIVKRRWVVWUXFWXUH HQGOHVVO\SUROLIHUDWLQJ
    7KHPDGO\EXUJHRQLQJSDWWHUQVVSRNHRIWKH(PSLUHVFRPSOH[LW\IDUPRUHWKDQ
    DQ\HPSHURUVORIW\VSHHFK
    1RZKHUHVWKHRYHUOD\<XJRVDLGVKRZLQJKRZWKH6HOGRQ(TXDWLRQV
    SRVWGLFWLQ\HOORZ
    7KH\DUHQWP\HTXDWLRQV +DULVDLGDXWRPDWLFDOO\/RQJDJRKHDQG
    <XJRKDGVHHQWKDWWRSUHGLFWZLWKSV\FKRKLVWRU\ILUVWGHPDQGHGWKDWWKH\
    SRVWGLFWWKHSDVWIRUYHULILFDWLRQ7KH\ZHUH
    -XVWZDWFK
    $ORQJVLGHWKHGHHSEOXHGDWDILJXUHD\HOORZOXPSFRQJHDOHG,WORRNHG
    WR+DULOLNHDQLGHQWLFDOWZLQWRWKHRULJLQDO(DFKZHQWWKURXJKFRQWRUWLRQV
    VHHWKLQJZLWKKLVWRU\VHQHUJ\(DFKULSSOHDQGVQDJUHSUHVHQWHGPDQ\ELOOLRQV
    RIKXPDQWULXPSKVDQGWUDJHGLHV(YHU\VPDOOVKXGGHUKDGRQFHEHHQDFDODPLW\
    7KH\UHWKHVDPH+DULZKLVSHUHG
    'DPQULJKW<XJRVDLG
    7KHWKHRU\ILWV
    <XS3V\FKRKLVWRU\ZRUNV
    +DULVWDUHGDWWKHIOH[LQJFRORUV,QHYHUWKRXJKW
    ,WFRXOGZRUNVRZHOO"'RUVKDGZDONHGEHKLQGKLVFKDLUDQGQRZUXEEHG

    KLVVFDOS
    :HOO\HV
    <RXKDYHVSHQW\HDUVLQFOXGLQJWKHSURSHUYDULDEOHV,WPXVWZRUN
    <XJRVPLOHGWROHUDQWO\,IRQO\PRUHSHRSOHVKDUHG\RXUIDLWKLQ
    PDWKLVWV<RXYHIRUJRWWHQWKHVSDUURZHIIHFW
    'RUVZDVWUDQVIL[HGE\WKHVKLPPHULQJGDWDVROLGVQRZUHUXQQLQJ DOO
    7UDQWRULDQKLVWRU\WKUREELQJZLWKGLIIHUHQWFRORUHGVFKHPHVWRVKRZXS
    GLIIHUHQFHVEHWZHHQUHDOKLVWRU\DQGWKHHTXDWLRQVSRVWGLFWLRQV7KHUHZHUH
    YHU\IHZ:KDWVPRUHWKH\GLGQRWJURZZLWKWLPH
    1RWWDNLQJKHUH\HVIURPWKHGLVSOD\'RUVDVNHGVORZO\6SDUURZ":H
    KDYHELUGVDVSHWVEXWVXUHO\
    6XSSRVHDVSDUURZIODSVLWVZLQJVDWWKHHTXDWRURXWLQWKHRSHQ7KDW
    VKLIWVWKHDLUFLUFXODWLRQDWLQ\DPRXQW,IWKLQJVEUHDNMXVWULJKWWKH
    VSDUURZFRXOGWULJJHUDWRUQDGRXSDWWKHSROHV
    'RUVZDVVWDUWOHG,PSRVVLEOH
    +DULVDLG'RQWFRQIXVHLWZLWKWKHIDEOHGQDLOLQWKHVKRHRID
    KRUVHWKDWDOHJHQGDU\EHDVWRIEXUGHQ5HPHPEHU"LWVULGHUORVWDEDWWOH
    DQGWKHQDNLQJGRP7KDWZDVIDLOXUHRIDVPDOOFULWLFDOFRPSRQHQW
    )XQGDPHQWDOUDQGRPSKHQRPHQDDUHGHPRFUDWLF7LQ\GLIIHUHQFHVLQHYHU\
    FRXSOHGYDULDEOHFDQSURGXFHVWDJJHULQJFKDQJHV
    ,WWRRNDZKLOHWRJHWWKHSRLQWWKURXJK/LNHDQ\RWKHUZRUOG
    7UDQWRUVPHWHRURORJ\KDGDGDXQWLQJVHQVLWLYLW\WRLQLWLDOFRQGLWLRQV$
    VSDUURZVZLQJIOXWWHURQRQHVLGHRI7UDQWRUDPSOLILHGWKURXJKIOXLG
    HTXDWLRQVRYHUZHHNVFRXOGGULYHDKRZOLQJKXUULFDQHDFRQWLQHQWDZD\1R
    FRPSXWHUFRXOGPRGHODOOWKHWLQ\GHWDLOVRIUHDOZHDWKHUWRPDNHH[DFW
    SUHGLFWLRQVSRVVLEOH
    'RUVSRLQWHGDWWKHGDWDVROLGV6RWKLVLVDOOZURQJ"
    ,KRSHQRW+DULVDLG:HDWKHUYDULHVEXWFOLPDWHKROGVVWHDG\
    6WLOOQRZRQGHU7UDQWRULDQVSUHIHULQGRRUV2XWGRRUVFDQEH
    GDQJHURXV
    7KHIDFWWKDWWKHHTXDWLRQVGHVFULEHZKDWKDSSHQHGZHOOLWPHDQVWKDW
    VPDOOHIIHFWVFDQVPRRWKRXWLQKLVWRU\+DULVDLG
    <XJRDGGHG6WXIIRQDKXPDQVFDOHFDQDYHUDJHDZD\
    6KHVWRSSHGPDVVDJLQJ+DULVVFDOS7KHQSHRSOHGRQWPDWWHU"
    +DULVDLGFDUHIXOO\0RVWELRJUDSK\SHUVXDGHVXVWKDWSHRSOHWKDWZH
    DUHLPSRUWDQW3V\FKRKLVWRU\WHDFKHVWKDWZHDUHQW
    $VDKLVWRULDQ,FDQQRWDFFHSW
    /RRNDWWKHGDWD<XJRSXWLQ
    7KH\ZDWFKHGDV<XJREURXJKWXSGHWDLOVKRZHGRIIIHDWXUHV)RU
    RUGLQDU\SHRSOHKLVWRU\HQGXUHGWKURXJKDUWP\WKDQGOLWXUJ\7KH\IHOWLW
    WKURXJKFRQFUHWHH[DPSOHVFORVHXSDEXLOGLQJDFXVWRPDKLVWRULFDOQDPH
    +HDQG<XJRDQGWKHRWKHUVZHUHOLNHVSDUURZVWKHPVHOYHVKRYHULQJKLJKRYHUD
    ODQGVFDSHXQJXHVVHGE\WKHLQKDELWDQWVEHORZ7KH\VDZWKHVORZVXUJHRI
    WHUUDLQJODFLDODQGXQVWRSSDEOH
    %XWSHRSOHKDYHWRPDWWHU'RUVYRLFHFDUULHGDQRWHRIIRUORUQKRSH
    +DULNQHZWKDWVRPHZKHUHGHHSLQKHUOXUNHGWKHVWHUQGLUHFWLYHVRIWKH=HURWK
    /DZEXWRYHUWKDWOD\DGHHSOD\HURIWUXHKXPDQIHHOLQJ6KHZDVDKXPDQLVW
    ZKREHOLHYHGLQWKHSRZHURIWKHLQGLYLGXDODQGKHUHVKHPHWEOXQWXQFDULQJ
    PHFKDQLVPLQWKHODUJH
    7KH\GRDFWXDOO\EXWSHUKDSVQRWLQWKHZD\\RXZDQW+DULVDLG
    JHQWO\:HVRXJKWRXWWHOOWDOHJURXSVSLYRWVDERXWZKLFKHYHQWVVRPHWLPHV
    KLQJH
    7KHKRPRVH[XDOVILQVWDQFH<XJRVDLG
    7KH\UHDERXWRQHSHUFHQWRIWKHSRSXODWLRQDFRQVLVWHQWPLQRUYDULDQW
    LQUHSURGXFWLYHVWUDWHJLHV+DULVDLG
    6RFLDOO\WKRXJKWKH\ZHUHRIWHQPDVWHUVRILPSURYLVDWLRQIDVKLRQLQJ
    VW\OHWRVXEVWDQFHIXOO\DWKRPHZLWKWKHDUELWUDU\7KH\VHHPHGHTXLSSHG

    ZLWKDQLQWHUQDOFRPSDVVWKDWSRLQWHGWKHPDWHYHU\VRFLDOQRYHOW\HDUO\RQ
    VRWKDWWKH\H[HUWHGOHYHUDJHDOORXWRISURSRUWLRQWRWKHLUQXPEHUV2IWHQ
    WKH\ZHUHVHQVLWLYHLQGLFDWRUVRIIXWXUHWXUQV
    <XJRZHQWRQ6RZHILJXUHGFRXOGWKH\EHDFUXFLDOLQGLFDWRU"7XUQV
    RXWWKH\DUH+HOSVRXWWKHHTXDWLRQV
    'RUVVDLGVHYHUHO\:K\GRHVKLVWRU\VPRRWKRXW"
    +DULOHW<XJRFDUU\WKHEDOO<VHHWKDWVDPHVSDUURZHIIHFWKDGD
    SRVLWLYHVLGH&KDRWLFV\VWHPVFRXOGEHFDXJKWDWMXVWWKHULJKWLQVWDQW
    WLOWHGHYHUVRVOLJKWO\LQDSUHIHUUHGZD\$ZHOOWLPHGQXGJHFRXOGGULYHD
    V\VWHP\LHOGLQJEHQHILWVDOORXWRISURSRUWLRQWRWKHHIIRUWH[SHQGHG
    <RXPHDQFRQWURO"6KHORRNHGGRXEWIXO
    -XVWDWRXFK<XJRVDLG0LQLPDOFRQWUROWKHULJKWQXGJHDWWKH
    ULJKWWLPHGHPDQGVWKDWWKHG\QDPLFVEHLQWULFDWHO\XQGHUVWRRG0D\EHWKDW
    ZD\\RXFRXOGELDVRXWFRPHVWRZDUGWKHOHDVWGDPDJLQJRIVHYHUDOILQHO\
    EDODQFHGUHVXOWV$WEHVWWKH\FRXOGGULYHWKHV\VWHPLQWRVWDUWOLQJO\JRRG
    RXWFRPHV
    :KRVFRQWUROOLQJ"'RUVDVNHG
    <XJRORRNHGHPEDUUDVVHG 2KZHGXQQR
    'RQWNQRZ"%XWWKLVLVDWKHRU\RIDOOKLVWRU\
    +DULVDLGTXLHWO\7KHUHDUHHOHPHQWVLQWHUSOD\VLQWKHHTXDWLRQV
    WKDWZHGRQWJUDVS'DPSLQJIRUFHV
    +RZFDQ\RXQRWXQGHUVWDQG"
    %RWKPHQORRNHGLOODWHDVH:HGRQWNQRZKRZWKHWHUPVLQWHUDFW1HZ
    IHDWXUHV+DULVDLGOHDGLQJWRHPHUJHQWRUGHU
    6KHVDLGSULPO\7KHQ\RXGRQWUHDOO\KDYHDWKHRU\GR\RX"
    +DULQRGGHGUXHIXOO\1RWLQWKHVHQVHRIDGHHSXQGHUVWDQGLQJQR
    0RGHOVIROORZHGWKHJULWW\H[SHULHQFHGZRUOGKHUHIOHFWHG7KH\HFKRHG
    WKHLUWLPHV&ORFNZRUNSODQHWDU\PHFKDQLFVFDPHDIWHUFORFNV7KHLGHDRIWKH
    ZKROHXQLYHUVHDVDFRPSXWDWLRQFDPHDIWHUFRPSXWHUV$ZRUOGYLHZRIVWDEOH
    FKDQJHFDPHDIWHUQRQOLQHDUG\QDPLFV
    +HKDGDJOLPPHULQJRIDPHWDPRGHOZKLFKZRXOGORRNDWKLPDQGGHVFULEH
    KRZKHZRXOGWKHQVHOHFWDPRQJPRGHOVIRUSV\FKRKLVWRU\3HHULQJGRZQIURP
    DERYHLWFRXOGVHHZKLFKZDVOLNHO\WREHIDYRUHGE\+DUL6HOGRQ
    :KRSODQVWKLVFRQWURO"'RUVSHUVLVWHG
    +DULFDXJKWDWWKHLGHDKHKDGEXWLWVOLSSHGDZD\+HNQHZKRZWRFRD[
    LWEDFNHDVHXS5HPHPEHUWKDWMRNH"KHVDLG+RZGR\RXPDNH*RGODXJK"
    6KHVPLOHG<RXWHOOKLP\RXUSODQV
    5LJKW:HZLOOVWXG\WKLVUHVXOWVQLIIRXWDQDQVZHU
    6KHVPLOHG'RQWDVN\RXIRUSUHGLFWLRQVDERXWWKHSURJUHVVRI\RXU
    RZQSUHGLFWLRQV"
    (PEDUUDVVLQJEXW\HV
    +LVGHVNVHFFKLPHG$Q,PSHULDOVXPPRQVLWDQQRXQFHG
    'DPQ+DULVODSSHGKLVFKDLU)XQVRYHU
    

    1RWTXLWHWLPHIRUWKH6SHFLDOVWRDUULYH+DULWKRXJKW%XWJHWWLQJDQ\
    ZRUNGRQHZDVLPSRVVLEOHZKLOHKHZDVRQHGJH
    +HMLJJOHGFRLQVLQKLVSRFNHWGLVWUDFWHGWKHQILVKHGRQHRXW$ILYH
    FUHGSLHFHDPEHUDOOR\DKDQGVRPH&OHRQ,KHDGRQRQHVLGHWUHDVXULHVDOZD\V
    IODWWHUHGHPSHURUVDQGWKHGLVNRIWKH*DOD[\VHHQIURPDERYHRQWKHRWKHU
    +HKHOGLWRQHGJHDQGWKRXJKW
    /HWWKHFRLQVZLGWKUHSUHVHQWWKHGLVNVW\SLFDOVFDOHKHLJKW7REH
    FRUUHFWWKHFRLQZRXOGKDYHWREXOJHDWLWVFHQWHUWRGHSLFWWKHKXEEXW
    RYHUDOOLWZDVDJRRGJHRPHWULFUHSOLFD
    ,QWKHGLVNZDVDIODZDPLQXWHEOLVWHULQDQRXWHUVSLUDODUP+HGLG
    WKHUDWLRLQKLVKHDGDOORZLQJWKDWWKHJDOD[\ZDVDERXWOLJKW\HDUV

    DFURVVDQGEOLQNHG7KHVSHFNSRUWUD\HGDYROXPHDERXWDWKRXVDQGOLJKW
    \HDUVDFURVV,QWKHRXWHUDUPVWKDWZRXOGFRQWDLQWHQPLOOLRQVWDUV
    7RVHHVRPDQ\ZRUOGVDVDIOHFNDGULIWLQLPPHQVLW\PDGHKLPIHHODV
    WKRXJK7UDQWRUVVROLGLW\KDGRSHQHGDQGKHKDGSOXQJHGKHOSOHVVO\LQWRDQ
    DE\VV
    &RXOGKXPDQLW\PDWWHURQVXFKDVFDOH"6RPDQ\ELOOLRQVRIVRXOVSDFNHG
    LQWRDJUDLQ\GRW
    <HWWKH\KDGVSDQQHGWKHZKROHLQFRPSUHKHQVLEOHH[SDQVHRIWKDWGLVNLQ
    DWZLQNOLQJ
    +XPDQLW\KDGVSUHDGWKURXJKWKHVSLUDODUPVVSLOOLQJWKURXJKWKH
    ZRUPKROHVZUDSSLQJLWVHOIDURXQGWKHKXELQDPHUHIHZWKRXVDQG\HDUV,Q
    WKDWWLPHWKHVSLUDODUPVWKHPVHOYHVKDGQRWUHYROYHGDSHUFHSWLEOHDQJOHLQ
    WKHLURZQJUDYLGJDYRWWHWKDWZRXOGWDNHKDOIDELOOLRQ\HDUV+XPDQ
    KDQNHULQJIRUIDUKRUL]RQVKDGVHQWWKHPVZDUPLQJWKURXJKWKHZRUPKROH
    ZHEELQJSRSSLQJRXWLQWRVSDFHVQHDUVXQVRIVZHOOLQJUHGYLUXOHQWEOXH
    VPROGHULQJUXE\
    7KHVSHFNVWRRGIRUDYROXPHDVLQJOHKXPDQEUDLQZLWKLWVSULPDWH
    FDSDFLWLHVFRXOGQRWJUDVSH[FHSWDVPDWKHPDWLFDOQRWDWLRQ%XWWKDWVDPH
    EUDLQOHGKXPDQVRXWZDUGXQWLOWKH\QRZVWURGHWKH*DOD[\PDVWHULQJWKH
    VWDUOLWDE\VVZLWKRXWWUXO\NQRZLQJWKHPVHOYHV
    6RDVLQJOHKXPDQFRXOGQRWIDWKRPHYHQDGRWLQWKHGLVN%XWWKHVXP
    RIKXPDQLW\FRXOGLQFUHPHQWDOO\RQHPLQGDWDWLPHNQRZLQJLWVRZQ
    LPPHGLDWHVWDUU\WHUULWRU\
    $QGZKDWGLGKHGHVLUH"7RFRPSUHKHQGDOORIWKDWKXPDQLW\LWVGHHSHVW
    LPSXOVHVLWVVKDGRZ\PHFKDQLVPVLWVSDVWSUHVHQWDQGIXWXUH+HZDQWHGWR
    NQRZWKHYDJUDQWVSHFLHVWKDWKDGPDQDJHGWRVFRRSXSWKLVGLVNDQGWRPDNH
    LWDSOD\WKLQJ
    6RPD\EHRQHVLQJOHKXPDQPLQGFRXOGLQGHHGJUDVSWKHGLVNE\JRLQJRQH
    OHYHOKLJKHUDQGIDWKRPLQJWKHFROOHFWLYHHIIHFWVKLGGHQLQWKHLQWULFDFLHV
    RIWKH(TXDWLRQV
    'HVFULELQJ7UDQWRULQWKLVSURSRUWLRQZDVFKLOGVSOD\)RUWKH
    (PSLUHKHQHHGHGDIDUJUDQGHUFRPSUHKHQVLRQ
    0DWKHPDWLFVPLJKWUXOHWKHJDOD[\,QYLVLEOHJRVVDPHUV\PEROVFRXOG
    JRYHUQ
    6RDVLQJOHPDQRUZRPDQFRXOGPDWWHU
    0D\EH+HVKRRNKLVKHDG$VLQJOHKXPDQKHDG
    *HWWLQJDOLWWOHDKHDGRIRXUVHOYHVDUHQWZH"'UHDPVRIJRGKRRG
    %DFNWRZRUN
    2QO\KHFRXOGQWZRUN+HKDGWRZDLW7RKLVUHOLHIWKH,PSHULDO
    6SHFLDOVDUULYHGDQGHVFRUWHGKLPDFURVV6WUHHOLQJ8QLYHUVLW\%\QRZKHZDV
    XVHGWRWKHJDZNHUVWKHHPEDUUDVVPHQWRISORZLQJWKURXJKWKHFURZGVZKLFKQRZ
    DFFXPXODWHGHYHU\ZKHUHLWVHHPHGWKDWKHPLJKWIUHTXHQW
    %XV\WRGD\KHVDLGWRWKH6SHFLDOVFDSWDLQ
    *RWWRH[SHFWLWVLU
    <RXJHWH[WUDGXW\SD\IRUWKLV,KRSH
    <HVVLU'LJVZHFDOOWKHP
    )RU H[WUDULVNFRUUHFW"'DQJHURXVGXW\
    7KHFDSWDLQORRNHGIOXVWHUHG:HOO\HVVLU
    ,IVRPHRQHVWDUWVVKRRWLQJZKDWDUH\RXURUGHUV"
    8KLIWKH\FDQSHQHWUDWHWKHHQJDJLQJSHULPHWHUZHUHWRJHWEHWZHHQ
    WKHPDQG\RX6LU
    $QG\RXGGRWKDW"7DNHDJDXVVSXOVHRUDIOHFKHWWH"
    +HVHHPHGVXUSULVHG2IFRXUVH
    7UXO\"
    2XUGXW\\NQRZ
    +DULZDVKXPEOHGE\WKHPDQVVLPSOHOR\DOW\1RWWR+DUL6HOGRQEXWWR
    WKHLGHDRI(PSLUH2UGHU&LYLOL]DWLRQ

    $QG+DULUHDOL]HGWKDWKHWRRZDVGHYRWHGWRWKDWLGHD7KH(PSLUHKDG
    WREHVDYHGRUDWOHDVWLWVGHFOLQHPLWLJDWHG2QO\E\IDWKRPLQJLWVGHHS
    VWUXFWXUHFRXOGKHGRWKDW
    :KLFKZDVZK\KHGLVOLNHGWKH)LUVW0LQLVWHUEXVLQHVV,WUREEHGKLPRI
    WLPHFRQFHQWUDWLRQ
    ,QWKH 6SHFLDOVDUPRUHGSRGVKHVDOYHGKLVGLVFRQWHQWE\SXOOLQJRXW
    KLVWDEOHWDQGZRUNLQJRQVRPHHTXDWLRQV7KHFDSWDLQKDGWRUHPLQGKLPZKHQ
    WKH\UHDFKHGWKHSDODFHJURXQGV+DULJRWRXWDQGWKHUHZDVWKHXVXDOVHFXULW\
    ULWXDOWKH6SHFLDOVVSUHDGLQJRXWDQGDLUERUQHVHQVRUVJRLQJDORIWWRVQLII
    RXWWKHIDUSHULPHWHU7KH\UHPLQGHGKLPRIJROGHQEHHVEX]]LQJZLWK
    YLJLODQFH
    +HZDONHGE\DZDOOOHDGLQJLQWRWKHSDODFHJDUGHQVDQGDWDQURXQG
    VKHHWWKHVL]HRIKLVILQJHUQDLOSRSSHGRIIWKHZDOO,WVWXFNWRKLVQHFN+H
    UHDFKHGXSDQGSOXFNHGLWRII
    +HUHFRJQL]HGLWDVDSURPRWLRQDOWULQNHWDVODSRQSDWFKZKLFKJDYH
    \RXDSOHDVDQWUXVKE\GLIIXVLQJHQGRUSKLQVLQWR\RXUEORRGVWUHDP,WDOVR
    VXEWO\SUHGLVSRVHG\RXWRFRKHUHQWVLJQDOVLQFRUULGRUDGYHUWLVHPHQWV
    +HSLWFKHGLWDVLGH$6SHFLDOJUDEEHGDWWKHSDWFKDQGVXGGHQO\WKHUH
    ZDVVKRXWLQJDQGPRYHPHQWDOODURXQGKLP7KH6SHFLDOWXUQHGWRWKURZWKH
    SDWFKDZD\
    $QRUDQJHVSLNHVKRWWKURXJKWKHJXDUGVKDQGKLVVLQJKRWIODULQJDQG
    JRQHLQDVHFRQG7KHPDQFULHG$KDQGDQRWKHU6SHFLDOJUDEEHGKLPDQG
    SXVKHGKLPGRZQ7KHQILYH6SHFLDOVEORFNHG+DULIURPDOOVLGHVDQGKHVDZQR
    PRUH
    7KH6SHFLDOVFUHDPHGKRUULEO\6RPHWKLQJFXWRIIWKHZDLORISDLQ7KH
    FDSWDLQVKRXWHG0RYHDQG+DULKDGWRWURWZLWKWKH6SHFLDOVDURXQGKLP
    LQWRWKHJDUGHQVDQGGRZQVHYHUDOODQHV
    ,WWRRNDZKLOHWRVWUDLJKWHQRXWWKHLQFLGHQW7KHSDWFKZDV
    XQWUDFHDEOHRIFRXUVHDQGWKHUHZDVQRZD\RINQRZLQJIRUVXUHZKHWKHULW
    ZDVWDUJHWHGRQ+DULDWDOO
    &RXOGEHSDUWRIVRPH3DODFHSORWWKHFDSWDLQVDLG-XVWZDLWLQJIRU
    WKHQH[WSDVVHUE\ZLWKDVFHQWVLJQDWXUHOLNH\RXUV
    1RWDLPHGIRUPHDWDOO"
    &RXOGEH7KDWWDEWRRNFRXSOHH[WUDVHFRQGVWU\LQWRILJXUHRXWLILW
    ZDQWHG\RXRUQRW
    $QGLWGLG
    %RG\RGRUVNLQVPHOOVWKH\UHQRWH[DFWVLU
    ,OOKDYHWRVWDUWZHDULQJSHUIXPH
    7KHFDSWDLQJULQQHG7KDWZRQWVWRSDVPDUWWDE
    2WKHUSURWHFWLRQVSHFLDOLVWVUXVKHGLQDQGWKHUHZDVHYLGHQFHWRPHDVXUH
    DQGRSLQLRQVDQGDORWRIWDON +DULLQVLVWHGRQZDONLQJEDFNWRVHHWKH
    6SHFLDOZKRKDGWDNHQWKHWDE+HZDVJRQHDOUHDG\RIIWRHPHUJHQF\FDUH
    WKH\VDLGKHZRXOGORVHKLVKDQG1RVRUU\+DULFRXOGQRWVHHKLP6HFXULW\
    \NQRZ
    4XLWHTXLFNO\+DULEHFDPHERUHGZLWKWKHDIWHUPDWK+HKDGFRPHHDUO\WR
    JHWDVWUROOWKURXJKWKHJDUGHQVDQGWKRXJKKHNQHZKHZDVEHLQJLUUDWLRQDO
    KLVUHJUHWDWPLVVLQJWKHZDONORRPHGODUJHUWKDQWKHDVVDVVLQDWLRQDWWHPSW
    +DULWRRNDORQJVWLOOPRPHQWDQGPRYHGWKHLQFLGHQWDVLGH+H
    YLVXDOL]HGDGLVSODFHPHQWRSHUDWRUDQLF\EOXHYHFWRUIUDPH,WOLVWHGWKH
    VQDUOHGDQJU\UHGNQRWDQGSXVKHGLWRXWRIYLHZ/DWHUKHZRXOGGHDOZLWK
    LWODWHU
    +HFXWRIIWKHHQGOHVVWDONDQGRUGHUHGWKH6SHFLDOVWRIDOOLQEHKLQG
    KLP6KRXWHGSURWHVWVFDPHRIFRXUVHZKLFKKHLJQRUHG7KHQKHDPEOHGDFURVV
    WKHJDUGHQVUHOLVKLQJWKHRSHQDLU+HLQKDOHGHDJHUO\7KHEOLQGLQJVSHHGRI
    WKHDWWDFNKDGHUDVHGLWVLPSRUWDQFHWRKLP)RUQRZ
    7KHSDODFHWRZHUVORRPHGOLNHZHEZRUNRIDJLDQWVSLGHU%HWZHHQWKHLU
    EXONVZHDYHGDLU\ZDONZD\V6SLUHVZHUHYHLOHGLQVLOYHU\PLVWDQGDULSSOH

    DSXOVHVKLPPHULQJZLWKDVLOHQWVWHDG\EHDWOLNHDJUHDWXQVHHQKHDUW+H
    KDGEHHQVRORQJLQWKHIRUHVKRUWHQHGYLHZVRI7UDQWRUVFRUULGRUVKLVH\HV
    GLGQRWTXLFNO\JUDVSWKHSX]]OLQJSHUVSHFWLYHV
    $QXSZDUGUXVKFDXJKWKLVDWWHQWLRQDVKHSDVVHGWKURXJKDIORZHUVFDSH
    )URPWKHLPPHQVH,PSHULDODYLDU\IORFNVRIELUGVLQWKHWKRXVDQGVRVFLOODWHG
    LQWKHYHUWLFDOGUDIWV7KHLUDUWIXOHYHUVKLIWLQJSDWWHUQVKDGDGLDSKDQRXV
    ELOORZ\TXDOLW\DQLPPHQVHZLVS\GDQFH
    <HWWKHVHKDGEHHQVKDSHGPDQ\PLOOHQQLDDJRE\ELRHQJLQHHULQJWKHLU
    JHQRPH7KH\IRUPHGGULIWVDQGELOORZVOLNHFORXGVRUHYHQDLU\PRXQWDLQV
    IHDVWLQJRQXSZHOOLQJJQDWVUHOHDVHGIURPEHORZE\WKHJDUGHQHUV%XWDVLGH
    GUDIWFRXOGGLVVROYHDOOWKHLURUQDWHVFXOSWXUHVEORZWKHPDZD\
    /LNHWKH(PSLUHKHPXVHG%HDXWLIXOLQLWVRUGHUVWDEOHIRUILIWHHQ
    PLOOHQQLD\HWQRZWRSSOLQJ&UDFNLQJXSOLNHDVORZPRWLRQSRGZUHFN2ULQ
    VSDVPVOLNHWKH-XQLQULRWV
    :K\"(YHQDPRQJ,PSHULDOORYHOLQHVVKLVPDWKLVWPLQGUHWXUQHGWRWKH
    SUREOHP
    (QWHULQJWKHSDODFHKHSDVVHGDGHOHJDWLRQRIFKLOGUHQRQWKHLUZD\WR
    VRPHDXGLHQFHZLWKDOHVVHU,PSHULDOILJXUH:LWKDVXGGHQSDQJKHPLVVHGKLV
    DGRSWHGVRQ5D\FK+HDQG'RUVKDGGHFLGHGWRVHFUHWO\VHQGWKHER\DZD\WR
    VFKRRODIWHU<XJRKDGKLVOHJEURNHQ'HSULYHWKHPRIWDUJHWV'RUVKDG
    VDLG
    $PRQJWKHPHULWRFUDF\RQO\WKRVHDGXOWVZLWKFRPPLWPHQWVWDELOLW\DQG
    WDOHQWFRXOGKDYHFKLOGUHQ*HQWU\RUSODLQFLWL]HQVFRXOGZKHOSEUDWVE\ WKH
    VKRYHOIXO
    3DUHQWVZHUHOLNHDUWLVWVVSHFLDOSHRSOHZLWKDVSHFLDOJLIWJLYHQ
    UHVSHFWDQGSULYLOHJHVOHIWIUHHWRFUHDWHKDSS\DQGFRPSHWHQWKXPDQV,WZDV
    QREOHZRUNZHOOSDLG+DULKDGEHHQKRQRUHGWREHDSSURYHG
    ,QLPPHGLDWHFRQWUDVWWKUHHRGGO\VKDSHGFRXUWLHUVDPEOHGE\KLP
    %\ELRWHFKPHDQVSHRSOHFRXOGWXUQWKHLUFKLOGUHQLQWRVSLQGO\WRZHUV
    LQWRIORZHUOLNHIRRWERXQGGZDUYHVLQWRJUHHQJLDQWVRUSLQNS\JPLHV)URP
    WKURXJKRXWWKH*DOD[\WKH\ZHUHVHQWKHUHWRDPXVHWKH,PSHULDOFRXUWZKHUH
    QRYHOW\ZDVDOZD\VLQYRJXH
    %XWVXFKYDULDQWVVHOGRPODVWHG7KHUHZDVDVSHFLHVQRUP$QG
    VWUHWFKLQJLWZDVMXVWDVGHHSO\LQJUDLQHG+DULKDGWRDGPLWWKDWKHZRXOG
    IRUHYHUEHDPRQJWKHXQVRSKLVWLFDWHGIRUKHIRXQGVXFKIRONUHSXOVLYH
    6RPHRQHKDGGHVLJQHGWKHUHFHSWLRQURRPWRORRNOLNHDQ\WKLQJEXWDURRP
    IRUUHFHLYLQJSHRSOH,WUHVHPEOHGDOXPS\SRFNHWLQPROWHQJODVV
    FULVVFURVVHGE\SROLVKHGVKDIWVRIFHUDPRVWHHO7KHVHVKDIWVLQWXUQGULSSHG
    LQWRVPRRWKOXPSVZKLFKVLQFHWKHUHZDVQRWKLQJHOVHLQWKHURRPPXVWKDYH
    EHHQLQWHQGHGWREHFKDLUVDQGWDEOHV
    ,WVHHPHGXQOLNHO\WKDWKHFRXOGHYHUJHWEDFNRXWRIDQ\RIWKHVKDSHV
    RQFHKHKDGZRUNHGRXWKRZWRVLWLQWKHPVR+DULVWRRG$QGZRQGHUHGLIWKDW
    HIIHFWWRRZDVVRPHKRZLQWHQGHG7KHSDODFHZDVDVXEWOHSODFHRIOD\HUHG
    GHVLJQ
    7KLVZDVWREHDVPDOOSULYDWHPHHWLQJ&OHRQVVWDIIKDGDVVXUHGKLP
    6WLOOWKHUHZDVDVPDOODUP\RIDWWDFKHVDQGSURWRFRORIILFHUVDQGDLGHVZKR
    KDGLQWURGXFHGWKHPVHOYHVDV+DULKDGSDVVHGWKURXJKVHYHUDOURRPVRI
    LQFUHDVLQJRUQDPHQWDWLRQRQKLVZD\KHUH7KHLUWDONEHFDPHPRUHRUQDWHDV
    ZHOO&RXUWO\OLIHZDVGRPLQDWHGE\SXIIHGXSSHRSOHZKRDOZD\VDFWHGDV
    WKRXJKWKH\ZHUHFR\O\XQYHLOLQJVWDWXHVRIWKHPVHOYHV
    7KHUHZDVDORWRIDGRUQPHQWDQGILQHU\WKHDUFKLWHFWXUDOHTXLYDOHQWRI
    MHZHOVDQGVLONDQGHYHQWKHPRVWPLQRUDWWHQGDQWVZRUHYHU\GLJQLILHGJUHHQ
    XQLIRUPV+HIHOWDVWKRXJKKHVKRXOGORZHUKLVYRLFHDQGUHDOL]HGUHFDOOLQJ
    6XQGD\VRQ+HOLFRQWKDWWKLVSODFHIHOWVRPHKRZOLNHDFKXUFK
    7KHQ&OHRQVZHSWLQDQGWKHVWDIIYDQLVKHGVLOHQWO\GUDLQLQJDZD\LQWR
    FRQFHDOHGH[LWV
    0\6HOGRQ

    <RXUVVLUH+DULIROORZHGWKHULWXDO
    7KH(PSHURUFRQWLQXHGJUHHWLQJKLPHIIXVLYHO\WXWWXWWLQJRYHUWKH
    DSSDUHQWDVVDVVLQDWLRQDWWHPSW6XUHO\DQDFFLGHQWGRQW\RXWKLQN"DQG
    OHGKLPWRWKHODUJHGLVSOD\ZDOO$W&OHRQVJHVWXUHDQHQRUPRXVYLHZRIWKH
    HQWLUH*DOD[\DSSHDUHGWKHZRUNRIDQHZDUWLVW+DULPXUPXUHGWKHUHTXLUHG
    DGPLUDWLRQDQGUHFDOOHGKLVWKRXJKWVRIRQO\DQKRXUEHIRUH
    7KLVZDVDWLPHVFXOSWXUHWUDFLQJWKHHQWLUH*DODFWLFKLVWRU\7KHGLVN
    ZDVDIWHUDOODFROOHFWLRQRIGHEULVVZLUOLQJDWWKHERWWRPRID
    JUDYLWDWLRQDOSRWKROHLQWKHFRVPRV+RZLWORRNHGGHSHQGHGRQZKLFKRI
    PDQNLQGVP\ULDGH\HVRQHXVHG,QIUDUHGFRXOGSLHUFHDQGXQPDVNGXVW\ODQHV
    ;UD\VVRXJKWSRROVRIILHUFHO\EXUQLQJJDV5DGLRGLVKHVPDSSHGFROGEDQNVRI
    PROHFXOHVDQGPDJQHWL]HGSODVPD$OOZHUHSDFNHGZLWKPHDQLQJ
    ,QWKHFDURXVHORIWKHGLVNVWDUVEREEHGDQGZHDYHGXQGHUFRPSOLFDWHG
    1HZWRQLDQWXJV7KHPDMRUDUPV6DJLWWDULXV2ULRQDQG3HUVHXVFRXQWLQJ
    RXWZDUGIURPWKH&HQWHUERUHQDPHVREVFXUHGE\DQWLTXLW\(DFKFRQWDLQHGD
    =RQHRIWKDWQDPHKLQWLQJWKDWSHUKDSVKHUHWKHDQFLHQW(DUWKRUELWHG%XWQR
    RQHNQHZDQGUHVHDUFKKDGUHYHDOHGQRREYLRXVVLQJOHFDQGLGDWH,QVWHDG
    GR]HQVRIZRUOGVYLHGIRUWKHWLWOHRIWKH7UXH(DUWK4XLWHSUREDEO\QRQHRI
    WKHPZHUH
    0DQ\EULJKWVLJQDWXUHVVN\PDUNVOLNHODQGPDUNV"EOD]HGDPRQJWKH
    FXUYLQJEDUUHGVSLUDODUPV%HDXW\EH\RQG GHVFULSWLRQEXWQRWEH\RQG
    DQDO\VLV+DULWKRXJKWZKHWKHUSK\VLFDORUVRFLDO,IKHFRXOGILQGWKH
    NH\
    ,FRQJUDWXODWH\RXRQWKHVXFFHVVRIP\0RURQ'HFUHH&OHRQVDLG
    +DULVORZO\ZLWKGUHZIURPWKHLPPHQVHSHUVSHFWLYH2KVLUH"
    <RXULGHDILUVWIUXLWRISV\FKRKLVWRU\7R+DULVEODQN
    LQFRPSUHKHQVLRQ&OHRQFKXFNOHG)RUJRWWHQDOUHDG\"7KHUHQHJDGHVZKRSLOODJH
    VHHNLQJUHQRZQIRUWKHLULQIDP\<RXDGYLVHGPHWRVWULSWKHPRIWKHLU
    LGHQWLW\E\PDNLQJWKHPKHQFHIRUWKEHFDOOHG0RURQV
    +DULKDGLQGHHGIRUJRWWHQWKHDGYLFHEXWFRQWHQWHGKLPVHOIZLWKDVDJH
    QRG
    ,WZRUNHG6XFKFULPHVDUHPXFKUHGXFHG$QGWKRVHFRQYLFWHGJRWR
    WKHLUGHDWKVIXOORIDQJHUGHPDQGLQJWREHPDGHIDPRXV,WHOO\RXLWLV
    GHOLFLRXV
    +DULIHOWDFKLOODWWKHZD\WKH(PSHURUVPDFNHGKLVOLSV$QRIIKDQG
    VXJJHVWLRQPDGHVXGGHQO\FRQFUHWHO\UHDO,WUDWWOHGKLPDELW
    +HUHDOL]HGWKDWWKH(PSHURUZDVDVNLQJDERXWSURJUHVVZLWK
    SV\FKRKLVWRU\+LVWKURDWWLJKWHQHGDQGKHUHPHPEHUHGWKH0RRQURVHZRPDQZLWK
    KHULUULWDWLQJTXHVWLRQV7KDWVHHPHGZHHNVDJR:RUNLVVORZKHPDQDJHGWR
    VD\
    &OHRQVDLGV\PSDWKHWLFDOO\6XUHO\LWUHTXLUHVDGHHSNQRZOHGJHRI
    HYHU\IDFHWRIFLYLOL]HGOLIH
    $WWLPHV+DULVWDOOHGSXWWLQJKLVPL[HGHPRWLRQVILUPO\DZD\
    ,ZDVDWDFRQYRFDWLRQUHFHQWO\DQGOHDUQHGVRPHWKLQJ\RXXQGRXEWHGO\
    KDYHIDFWRUHGLQWR\RXUHTXDWLRQV
    <HVVLUH"
    ,WLVVDLGWKDWWKHYHU\IRXQGDWLRQRIWKH(PSLUHEHVLGHVWKH
    ZRUPKROHVRIFRXUVHLVWKHGLVFRYHU\RISURWRQ%RURQIXVLRQ,KDGQHYHU
    KHDUGRILW\HWWKHVSHDNHUVDLGLWZDVWKHVLQJOHJUHDWHVWDFKLHYHPHQWRI
    DQWLTXLW\7KDWHYHU\VWDUVKLSHYHU\SODQHWDU\WHFKQRORJ\GHSHQGVXSRQLW
    IRUSRZHU
    ,VXSSRVHWKDWLVWUXHEXW,GLGQRWNQRZLW
    6XFKDQHOHPHQWDU\IDFW"
    :KDWLVQRWRIXVHWRPHGRHVQRWFRQFHUQPH
    &OHRQVPRXWKSRXWHGLQSX]]OHPHQW%XWDWKHRU\RIDOOKLVWRU\VXUHO\
    GHPDQGVJUHDWGHWDLO
    7HFKQRORJ\HQWHUVRQO\LQLWVHIIHFWVRQRWKHUODUJHLVVXHV+DUL

    VDLG+RZWRH[SODLQWKHLQWULFDFLHVRIQRQOLQHDUFDOFXOXV"2IWHQLWV
    OLPLWDWLRQVDUHWKHLPSRUWDQWSRLQW
    $Q\WHFKQRORJ\GLVWLQJXLVKDEOHIURPPDJLFLVLQVXIILFLHQWO\DGYDQFHG
    &OHRQVDLGDLULO\
    :HOOSXWVLUH
    <RXOLNHLW"7KDWIHOORZ'UDLXVJDYHLWWRPH,WKDVDULQJGRHVQW
    LW"7UXH WRR3HUKDSV,OO+HEURNHRIIDQGVDLGWRWKHDLU
    7UDQVFULSWLRQRIILFHU*LYHWKDWOLQHDERXWPDJLFWRWKH3UHVHSWKIRUJHQHUDO
    GLVWULEXWLRQ
    &OHRQVDWEDFN7KH\UHDOZD\VDIWHUPHIRU,PSHULDOZLVGRP$
    ERWKHU
    $IDLQWPXVLFDOQRWHDQQRXQFHG%HWDQ/DPXUN+DULVWLIIHQHGDWILUVW
    VLJKWRIWKHPDQEXW/DPXUNKDGH\HVRQO\IRUWKH(PSHURUDVKHZHQWVPRRWKO\
    WKURXJKDOLWDQ\RIFRXUWULWXDO$VDSULPHPHPEHURIWKH+LJK&RXQFLOKHKDG
    WRUHFLWHVRPHWLPHKRQRUHGDQGHPSW\SKUDVHVERZZLWKDFXULRXVVZRRSDQG
    QHYHUDYHUWKLVJD]HIURPWKH(PSHURU7KDWGRQHKHFRXOGUHOD[
    3URIHVVRU6HOGRQ6RJRRGWRPHHWDJDLQ
    +DULVKRRNKDQGVLQWKHIRUPDOPDQQHU6RUU\DERXWWKDWOLWWOHGXVWXS
    ,UHDOO\GLGQWNQRZWKH'ZDVWKHUH
    1RPDWWHU2QHFDQWKHOSZKDWWKHPHGLDPDNHRIWKLQJV
    0\6HOGRQJDYHPHH[FHOOHQWDGYLFHDERXWWKH0RURQ'HFUHH&OHRQVDLG
    +HZHQWRQKLVGHOLJKWGHHSHQLQJWKHWZLVWRI/DPXUNVPRXWK
    &OHRQOHGWKHPWROX[XULDQWFKDLUVWKDWSRSSHGRXWRIWKHZDOOV+DUL
    IRXQGKLPVHOIVZHSWLPPHGLDWHO\LQWRDGHWDLOHGGLVFXVVLRQRI&RXQFLOPDWWHUV
    5HVROXWLRQVPHDVXUHVRIDSSURSULDWLRQDEVWUDFWVRISURSRVHGOHJLVODWLRQ
    7KLVVWXIIKDGEHHQIORZLQJWKURXJK+DULVRIILFHDVZHOO+HKDGGXWLIXOO\
    VHWKLVDXWRVHFWRWH[WDQDO\]LQJLWEUHDNLQJWKHVHDRIMDUJRQGRZQLQWR
    *DODFWLFDQGVPRRWKLQJRXWWKHFRQQHFWLRQV7KLVJRWKLPWKURXJKWKHILUVW
    KRXU0RVWRIWKHPDWHULDOKHKDGLJQRUHGWLSSLQJSLOHVRIWREHVFDQQHG
    GRFXPHQWVLQWRKLVUHF\FOHUZKHQQRERG\ZDVORRNLQJ
    7KHDUFDQHZRUNLQJVRIWKH+LJK&RXQFLOZHUHQRWLQSULQFLSOHGLIILFXOW
    WRIROORZWKH\ZHUHMXVWERULQJ$V/DPXUNGHIWO\FRQIHUUHGZLWKWKH(PSHURU
    +DULZDWFKHGWKHPDVKHZRXOGZDWFKDERG\EDOOJDPHDFXULRXVSUDFWLFHQR
    GRXEWIDVFLQDWLQJLQDQDUURZVRUWRIZD\
    7KDWWKH&RXQFLOVHWJHQHUDOVWDQGDUGVDQGGLUHFWLRQVZKLOHEHORZWKHP
    PHUHOHJDOPDYHQVZRUNHGRXWWKHGHWDLOVDQGSDVVHGOHJLVODWLRQGLGQRW
    FKDQJHKLVEHPXVHGGLVLQWHUHVW3HRSOHVSHQWWKHLUOLYHVGRLQJVXFKWKLQJV
    )RUWDFWLFVKHFDUHGOLWWOH(YHQPDQNLQGGLGQRWPDWWHU2QWKH
    *DODFWLFFKHVVERDUGWKHSLHFHVZHUHWKHSKHQRPHQDRIKXPDQLW\WKHUXOHVRI
    WKHJDPHZHUHWKHODZVRISV\FKRKLVWRU\7KHSOD\HURQWKHRWKHUVLGHZDV
    KLGGHQSHUKDSVGLGQRWH[LVW
    /DPXUNQHHGHGDQRSSRVLWHSOD\HUDULYDO6XEWO\+DULVDZWKDWKHZDV
    WKHLQHYLWDEOHIRH
    /DPXUNVFDUHHUKDGDLPHGKLPIRUWKH)LUVW0LQLVWHUVKLSDQGKHPHDQWWR
    JHWLW$WHYHU\WXUQ/DPXUNFXUULHGIDYRUZLWKWKH(PSHURUDQGZDYHGDZD\
    +DULVSRLQWVRIZKLFKWKHUHZHUH IHZ
    +HGLGQRWGLUHFWO\FRXQWHU/DPXUNWKHPDQZDVDPDVWHU+HNHSWTXLHW
    FRQILQLQJKLPVHOIWRDQRFFDVLRQDOH[SUHVVLYHO\ KHKRSHG UDLVHGH\HEURZ+H
    KDGUDUHO\UHJUHWWHGNHHSLQJTXLHW
    7KLV0DFUR0HVKWKLQJGR\RXIDYRULW"WKH(PSHURUDEUXSWO\DVNHG
    +DUL
    +HEDUHO\UHPHPEHUHGWKHLGHD,WZLOODOWHUWKH*DOD[\FRQVLGHUDEO\
    KHVWDOOHG
    3URGXFWLYHO\/DPXUNVODSSHGDWDEOH$OOWKHHFRQLQGLFDWRUVDUH
    IDOOLQJ7KH0DFUR0HVKZLOOVSHHGXSLQIRIORZERRVWSURGXFWLYLW\
    7KH(PSHURUVPRXWKWLOWHGZLWKGRXEW,PQRWDOWRJHWKHUKDSS\ZLWK
    WKHLGHDRIOLQNLQJVRPDQ\VRHDVLO\

    -XVWWKLQN/DPXUNSUHVVHGWKHQHZVTXHH]HUVZLOOOHWDQRUGLQDU\
    SHUVRQLQVD\(TTXLV=RQHWDONHYHU\GD\ZLWKDIULHQGLQWKH)DU5HDFKHV
    RUDQ\ZKHUHHOVH
    7KH(PSHURUQRGGHGXQFHUWDLQO\+DUL":KDWGR\RXWKLQN"
    ,KDYHGRXEWVDVZHOO
    /DPXUNZDYHGGLVPLVVLYHO\)DLOXUHRIQHUYH
    ,QFUHDVHGFRPPXQLFDWLRQPD\ZRUVHQWKH(PSLUHVFULVLV
    /DPXUNVPRXWKWZLVWHGGHULVLYHO\1RQVHQVH&RQWUDU\WRHYHU\JRRG
    H[HFXWLYHUXOH
    7KH(PSLUHLVQWUXOHG+DULPDGHDKDOIERZWRWKH(PSHURUDODV
    LWVOHWUXQ
    0RUHQRQVHQVH:HLQWKH+LJK&RXQFLO
    +HDUKLPRXW&OHRQVDLG+HGRHVQRWWDONYHU\PXFK
    +DULVPLOHG0DQ\SHRSOHDUHJUDWHIXOIRUWKDWVLUH
    1RREOLTXHDQVZHUVQRZ:KDWGRHV\RXUSV\FKRKLVWRU\WHOO\RXDERXW
    KRZWKH(PSLUHUXQV"
    ,WLVPLOOLRQVRIFDVWOHVZHEEHGE\EULGJHV
    &DVWOHV"&OHRQVIDPRXVQRVHURVHVNHSWLFDOO\
    3ODQHWV7KH\KDYHORFDOFRQFHUQVDQGUXQWKHP VHOYHVDVWKH\OLNH7KH
    (PSLUHGRHVQWWURXEOHLWVHOIRYHUVXFKGHWDLOVXQOHVVDZRUOGEHJLQVPDNLQJ
    DJJUHVVLYHWURXEOH
    7UXHHQRXJKDQGDVLWVKRXOGEH&OHRQVDLG$KDQG\RXUEULGJHV
    DUHWKHZRUPKROHV
    ([DFWO\VLUH+DULGHOLEHUDWHO\DYRLGHGORRNLQJDW/DPXUNDQGIRFXVHG
    RQWKH(PSHURUZKLOHVNHWFKLQJLQKLVYLVLRQ
    3ODQHWVFRXOGKDYHDQ\QXPEHURIOHVVHUGXFKLHVZLWKGLVSXWHVDQGZDUV
    DQGPLFURVWUXFWXUHJDORUH7KHSV\FKRKLVWRULFDOHTXDWLRQVVKRZHGWKDWQRQH
    RI WKDWPDWWHUHG
    :KDWGLGPDWWHUZDVWKDWSK\VLFDOUHVRXUFHVFRXOGQRWEHVKDUHGDPRQJ
    LQGHILQLWHO\ODUJHQXPEHUVRISHRSOH(DFKVRODUV\VWHPZDVDILQLWHVWRUHRI
    JRRGVDQGLQWKHHQGWKDWPHDQWORFDOKLHUDUFKLHVWRFRQWURODFFHVV
    :RUPKROHVFRXOGFDUU\UDWKHUOLWWOHPDVVEHFDXVHWKHKROHVZHUHVHOGRP
    PRUHWKDQWHQPHWHUVDFURVV0DVVLYHK\SHUVSDFHVKLSVFDUULHGKHDY\FDUJRHV
    EXWWKH\ZHUHVORZHUDQGFXPEHUVRPH7KH\GLVWRUWHGVSDFHWLPHFRQWUDFWLQJLW
    IRUHDQGH[SDQGLQJLWDIWPRYLQJDWVXSHUOLJKWVSHHGVLQWKH*DOD[\VIUDPH
    EXWQRWLQLWVRZQ7UDGHDPRQJPRVWVWHOODUV\VWHPVZDVFRQVWUDLQHGWROLJKW
    FRPSDFWH[SHQVLYHLWHPV6SLFHVIDVKLRQVWHFKQRORJ\QRWEXON\UDZ
    PDWHULDOV
    :RUPKROHVFRXOGDFFRPPRGDWHPRGXODWHGOLJKWEHDPVIDUPRUHHDVLO\7KH
    ZRUPKROHFXUYDWXUHUHIUDFWHGEHDPVWKURXJKWRUHFHLYHUVDWWKHRWKHUPRXWK
    'DWDIORZHGIUHHO\NQLWWLQJWRJHWKHUWKH*DOD[\
    $QGLQIRUPDWLRQZDVWKHRSSRVLWHRIPDVV'DWDFRXOGEHPRYHG
    FRPSUHVVHGDQGOHDNHGUHDGLO\WKURXJKFRSLHV,WZDVLQILQLWHO\VKDUHDEOH,W
    EORVVRPHGOLNHIORZHUVLQHWHUQDOVSULQJIRUDVLQIRUPDWLRQZDVDSSOLHGWRD
    SUREOHPWKHUHVXOWLQJVROXWLRQZDVQHZLQIRUPDWLRQ$QGLWZDVFKHDSPHDQLQJ
    WKDWLWWRRNIHZPDVVUHVRXUFHVWRDFTXLUHLW,WVSUHIHUUHGPHGLXPZDVOLJKW
    TXLWHOLWHUDOO\WKHODVHUEHDP
    7KDWSURYLGHGHQRXJKFRPPXQLFDWLRQWRPDNHDQ(PSLUH%XWWKHRGGVRID
    QDWLYHRIWKH3XLVVDQW=RQHHYHUYR\DJLQJWRWKH=DTXORW=RQHRUHYHQWRWKH
    QH[WVWDUVLQFHE\ZRUPKROHWKH\DUHHTXLYDOHQWWULSVZHUHWLQ\+DULVDLG
    6RHYHU\RQHRI\RXUFDVWOHVNHSWLWVHOILVRODWHGH[FHSWIRU
    LQIRUPDWLRQIORZ&OHRQVDLGDEVRUEHG
    %XWQRZWKH0DFUR0HVKZLOOLQFUHDVHWKHLQIRUPDWLRQWUDQVIHUUDWHD
    WKRXVDQGIROGXVLQJWKHVHVTXHH]HUVWKDWFRPSUHVVLQIRUPDWLRQ
    &OHRQSXUVHGKLVOLSVSX]]OHG:K\LVWKDWEDG"
    ,WVQRW/DPXUNVDLG%HWWHUGDWDPDNHVIRUEHWWHUGHFLVLRQV
    HYHU\ERG\NQRZVWKDW

    1RWQHFHVVDULO\+XPDQOLIHLVDYR\DJHRQDVHDRIPHDQLQJQRWDQHW
    RILQIRUPDWLRQ:KDWZLOOPRVWSHRSOHJHWIURPDFORVHSHUVRQDOIORZRIGDWD"
    'HWDFKHGIRUHLJQORJLF8SURRWHGGHWDLOV
    :HFDQUXQWKLQJVEHWWHU/DPXUNLQVLVWHG&OHRQKHOGXSD ILQJHUDQG
    /DPXUNFKRNHGRIIKLVQH[WZRUGV
    +DULKHVLWDWHG/DPXUNKDGDSRLQWLQGHHG
    7KHUHZHUHPDWKHPDWLFDOUHODWLRQVKLSVEHWZHHQWHFKQRORJ\FDSLWDO
    DFFXPXODWLRQODERUEXWWKHPRVWLPSRUWDQWGULYHUSURYHGWREHNQRZOHGJH
    $ERXWKDOIWKH(PSLUHVHFRQRPLFJURZWKFDPHIURPWKHLQFUHDVHLQWKHTXDOLW\
    RILQIRUPDWLRQDVHPERGLHGLQEHWWHUPDFKLQHVDQGLPSURYHGVNLOOVOHDGLQJWR
    HIILFLHQF\
    7KDWZDVZKHUHWKH(PSLUHKDGIDOWHUHG7KHLQQRYDWLYHWKUXVWRIWKH
    VFLHQFHVKDGVORZO\IDOWHUHG7KH,PSHULDOXQLYHUVLWLHVSURGXFHGILQH
    HQJLQHHUVEXWQRLQYHQWRUV*UHDWVFKRODUVEXWIHZWUXHVFLHQWLVWV7KDW
    IDFWRUHGLQWRWKHRWKHUWLGHVRIWLPH%XWVRPHWKLQJRWKHUWKDQGDWD
    VWDUYDWLRQKDGPDGHWKDWKDSSHQDQGDV\HW+DULGLGQRWNQRZWKHFDXVH
    %XW +DULVDZWKH(PSHURUZDYHULQJDQGSUHVVHGRQ0DQ\RQWKH+LJK
    &RXQFLOVHHWKH0DFUR0HVKDVDQLQVWUXPHQWRIFRQWURO/HWPHSRLQWRXWDIHZ
    IDFWVZHOONQRZQWR\RXVLUH
    +DULZDVLQKLVIDYRULWHPRGHDRQHRQRQHOHFWXUH&OHRQOHDQHG
    IRUZDUGH\HVQDUURZHG+DULVSXQKLPDWDOH
    7RJHWEHWZHHQZRUOGV$DQG%KHVDLGRQHPLJKWKDYHWRWDNHDGR]HQ
    ZRUPKROHMXPSVWKH:RUP1HVWZDVDQDVWURSK\VLFDOVXEZD\V\VWHPZLWKPDQ\
    WUDQVIHUV
    (DFKZRUPPRXWKLPSRVHGDGGHGIHHVDQGFKDUJHVRQHYHU\VKLSPHQW
    &RQWURORIDQHQWLUHWUDGHURXWH\LHOGHGWKHPD[LPXPSURILW7KHVWUXJJOHIRU
    FRQWUROZDVXQHQGLQJRIWHQYLROHQW)URPWKHYLHZSRLQWRIHFRQRPLFV
    SROLWLFVDQGKLVWRULFDOPRPHQWXPZKLFKPHDQWDVRUWRILPSRVHGLQHUWLDRQ
    HYHQWVDORFDOHPSLUHZKLFKFRQWUROOHGDZKROHFRQVWHOODWLRQRIQRGHVVKRXOG
    EHVROLGHQGXULQJ
    1RWVR7LPHDQGDJDLQUHJLRQDOVDWUDSLHVZHQWWRHVXS,WVHHPHG
    QDWXUDOWRVTXHH]HHYHU\ZRUPSDVVDJHIRUWKHPD[LPXPIHHE\FRRUGLQDWLQJ
    HYHU\ZRUPPRXWKWRRSWLPL]HWUDIILF%XWWKDWGHJUHHRIFRQWUROPDGHSHRSOH
    UHVWLYH,QHODERUDWHO\FRQWUROOLQJWKHV\VWHPLQIRUPDWLRQIORZHGRQO\IURP
    PDQDJHUVWRZDJHVODYHVZLWKOLWWOHIHHGEDFN
    ([WHQVLYHUHJXODWLRQGLGQRWGHOLYHUWKHEHVWEHQHILWV,QVWHDGLW
    \LHOGHGVKRUWEODQNHWHFRQRPLHVZKHQWKHFROOHFWLYHVKRXOGHUVJRWFROGWKH
    EODQNHWJRWSXOOHGXSWRFRYHUWKHPDQGVRWKHIHHWIUR]H2YHUFRQWURO
    IDLOHG
    6RWKH0DFUR0HVKLILWOHWVWKH+LJK&RXQFLOUHDOO\UXQWKLQJV
    FRXOGGHFUHDVHHFRQRPLFYLWDOLW\
    /DPXUNVPLOHG SDWURQL]LQJO\$EXQFKRIDEVWUDFWWKHRU\VLUH1RZ\RX
    OLVWHQWRDQROGKDQGZKRVEHHQRQWKH&RXQFLODJRRGORQJWLPHQRZ
    +DULDWWHQGHGWR/DPXUNVIDPRXVEDOPDQGZRQGHUHGZK\KHZDVERWKHULQJ
    ZLWKWKLV+HKDGWRDGPLWWKDWWUDGLQJLGHDVZLWKWKH(PSHURUKDGDFHUWDLQ
    TXDOLW\RIFDVXDODOPRVWVHQVXDOSRZHU:DWFKLQJDPDQZKRFRXOGGHVWUR\D
    ZRUOGZLWKDJHVWXUHKDGDGHFLGHGDGUHQDOLQHHGJH
    %XWKHGLGQWUHDOO\EHORQJKHUHHLWKHUE\WDOHQWRUGULYH7URWWLQJ
    RXWKLVRZQYLHZVZDVDPXVLQJHYHU\SURIHVVRUVHFUHWO\WKLQNVWKDWZKDWWKH
    ZRUOGQHHGVLVDJRRGVROLGOHFWXUHIURPKLPRIFRXUVH
    %XWLQWKLVJDPHWKHSDZQVZHUHUHDO7KH0RURQ'HFUHHKDGXQQHUYHG
    KLPHYHQWKRXJKKHVDZQRWKLQJPRUDOO\ZURQJZLWKLW
    /LYHVKXQJLQWKHEDODQFHKHUHDPRQJWKHILQHU\$QGQRWMXVWWKHOLYHV
    RIRWKHUV+HKDGWRUHPLQGKLPVHOIWKDWWKLVEHDPLQJFRQILGHQW/DPXUNDFURVV
    IURPKLPZDVWKHREYLRXVVRXUFHRIWKHSDWFKZHDSRQZKLFKKDGQHDUO\NLOOHG
    KLPMXVWKRXUVEHIRUH

    

    +HHQWHUHGWKHLU DSDUWPHQWDQGZHQWVWUDLJKWWRWKHNLWFKHQ+HSXQFKHG
    LQFRPPDQGVRQWKHDXWRVHUYHUDQGWKHQZHQWWRWKHUDQJHDQGEHJDQWRKHDWXS
    VRPHRLO:KLOHLWZDUPHGKHFXWXSRQLRQVDQGJDUOLFDQGSXWWKHPLQWR
    EURZQ+LVEHHUDUULYHGDQGKHRSHQHGRQHQRWERWKHULQJZLWKDJODVV
    6RPHWKLQJVKDSSHQHG'RUVVDLG
    :HKDGDILQHOLWWOHFKDW,H\HG/DPXUNKHH\HGPH
    7KDWVQRWZK\\RXUVKRXOGHUVDUHKXQFKHGXS
    8P%HWUD\HGE\P\H[SUHVVLYHERG\
    6RKHWROGKHUDERXWWKHSRVVLEOHDVVDVVLQDWLRQDWWHPSW
    $IWHUVKHKDGFDOPHGGRZQVKHVDLGWLJKWO\<RXDOVRKHDUGDERXWWKH
    VPRNHDUWLVW"
    $WWKDWUHFHSWLRQ"+HPDGHWKHELJFORXGWKDWORRNHGOLNHPH"
    +HGLHGWRGD\
    +RZ"
    /RRNVOLNHDQDFFLGHQW
    7RREDGKHZDVIXQQ\
    7RRIXQQ\+HPDGHWKHFDUWRRQRI/DPXUNUHPHPEHU"0DGH/DPXUNORRN
    OLNHDEORZKDUG,WZDVWKHKLWRIWKHUHFHSWLRQ
    +DULEOLQNHG<RXGRQW
    4XLWHRUGHUO\ERWKRI\RXLQRQHGD\
    6RLWFRXOGEH/DPXUN
    'RUVVDLGJULPO\0\GHDU+DULDOZD\VWKLQNLQJLQWHUPVRI
    SUREDELOLWLHV
    $IWHUKLVDXGLHQFHZLWK&OHRQ+DULKDGVDWWKURXJKDVWULFWWDONE\WKH
    KHDGRISDODFHVHFXULW\+LV6SHFLDOVVTXDGZDVGRXEOHG0RUHPLGJHWIO\HUV
    IRUIRUZDUGSHULPHWHUZDUQLQJ2K\HVDQGKHZDVQRWWRZDONFORVHWRDQ\
    ZDOOV
    7KLVODVWELWKDGPDGH+DULFKXFNOHZKLFKGLGQRWLPSURYHWKHSDODFH
    VWDIIVDWWLWXGH:RUVH+DULNQHZWKDWKHVWLOOKDGEDJJDJHWRXQSDFN+RZWR
    NHHSWKHPIURPVQLIILQJRXW'RUVWUXHQDWXUH"
    7KHDXWRVHUYHUUDQJ+HVDWDQGIRUNHGXSGDUNPHDWDQGRQLRQVDQGWKHQ
    RSHQHGDQRWKHUERWWOHRIWKHFROGEHHUDQGKHOGLWLQRQHKDQGZKLOHKHDWH
    ZLWKWKHRWKHU
    $KDUGGD\VZRUN'RUVVDLG
    ,DOZD\VHDWKHDUWLO\DIWHUQDUURZO\DYHUWLQJGHDWK,WVDQROGIDPLO\
    WUDGLWLRQ
    , VHH
    &OHRQHQGHGXSE\FRPPHQWLQJRQWKHLPSDVVHLQWKH+LJK&RXQFLO8QWLO
    WKDWVUHVROYHGQRYRWHRQWKH)LUVW0LQLVWHUFDQRFFXU
    6R\RXDQG/DPXUNDUHVWLOOEXWWLQJKHDGV
    +HVEXWWLQJ0H,PGRGJLQJ
    ,ZLOOQHYHUOHDYH\RXUVLGHDJDLQVKHVDLGILUPO\
    ,WVDGHDO&RXOG\RXJHWPHVRPHWKLQJPRUHIURPWKHDXWRVHUYHU"
    6RPHWKLQJZDUPDQGKHDY\DQGIXOORIWKLQJVWKDWDUHEDGIRUPH"
    6KHZHQWLQWRWKHNLWFKHQDQGKHDWHVWHDGLO\DQGGUDQNWKHEHHUDQGGLG
    QRWWKLQNDERXWDQ\WKLQJ
    6KHEURXJKWEDFNVRPHWKLQJVWHDPLQJLQDULFKEURZQVDXFH+HDWHLW
    ZLWKRXWDVNLQJZKDWLWZDV
    <RXDUHDQRGGPDQSURIHVVRU
    7KLQJVJHWWRPHDELWODWHUWKDQRWKHUSHRSOH
    <RXOHDUQHGKRZWRGHOD\WKLQNLQJDERXWWKHPUHDFWLQJWRWKHPXQWLO
    WKHUHZDVDWLPHDQGDSODFH
    +HEOLQNHGDQGGUDQNVRPHPRUHEHHU&RXOGEH+DYHWRWKLQNDERXWLW
    <RXHDJHUO\HDWZRUNLQJFODVVIRRG$QGZKHUHGLG\RXOHDUQWKLVWULFN
    RIGHIHUULQJUHDFWLRQV"

    8P<RXWHOOPH
    +HOLFRQ
    +HWKRXJKWDERXWWKDW8UQWKHZRUNLQJFODVV0\IDWKHUJRWLQWR
    WURXEOHDQGWKHUHZHUHSOHQW\RIKDUGWLPHV$ERXWWKHRQO\EUHDN,JRWDVD
    ER\ZDVQRWJHWWLQJEUDLQIHYHU:HFRXOGQWKDYHDIIRUGHGDQ\KRVSLWDOWLPH
    ,VHH)LQDQFLDOWURXEOH,UHPHPEHU\RXVD\LQJ
    )LQDQFLDODQGWKHQSHRSOHPXVFOLQJKLPWRVHOOKLVODQG+HGLGQWZDQW
    WR6RKHPRUWJDJHGPRUHDQGSODQWHGPRUHFURSVDQGIROORZHGKLVEHVW
    MXGJPHQW(YHU\WLPHFKDQFHSOD\HGRXWDJDLQVWKLP'DGJRWULJKWEDFNXSDQG
    ZHQWDWLWDJDLQ7KDWZRUNHGIRUDZKLOHEHFDXVHKHGLGNQRZIDUPLQJ%XW
    WKHQWKHUHZDVDELJPDUNHWIOXFWXDWLRQDQGKHJRWFDXJKWDQGORVW
    HYHU\WKLQJ+HZDVVSHDNLQJTXLFNO\DVKHDWHDQGKHGLGQWNQRZZK\EXWLW
    IHOWULJKW
    ,VHH7KDWZDVZK\KHZDVGRLQJWKDWGDQJHURXVMRE
    :KLFKNLOOHGKLP\HV
    ,VHH$QG\RXGHDOWZLWKWKDW6XEPHUJHGLWWRKHOS\RXUPRWKHU
    OHDUQHGLQWKHKDUGWLPHVWKDWIROORZHGWRUHVHUYH\RXUUHDFWLRQVIRUDPRPHQW
    ZKHQLWZDVDOOULJKWWROHWLWJR
    ,I\RXVD\,VHHDJDLQ,ZRQWOHW\RXZDWFKODWHUZKHQ,WDNHD
    VKRZHU
    6KHVPLOHGEXWWKHQWKHVDPHSHQHWUDWLQJFDVWFDPHRYHUKHUIDFH<RX
    ILWVRPHZHOOGHILQHGSDUDPHWHUV0HQZKRDUHFRQWDLQHG7KH\FRQWURO
    WKHPVHOYHVE\OHWWLQJYHU\OLWWOHLQ7KH\GRQRWVKRZDJUHDWGHDORUWDON
    WRRPXFK
    ([FHSWWRWKHLUZRPDQ+HKDGVWRSSHGHDWLQJ
    <RXKDYHOLWWOHWLPHIRUVPDOOWDONSHRSOHDW6WUHHOLQJFRPPHQWRQ
    WKDW\HW\RXVSHDNIUHHO\ZLWKPH
    ,WU\QRWWREODWKHU
    %HLQJPDOHLVFRPSOLFDWHG
    6RLVEHLQJIHPDOHWKRXJK\RXYHPDVWHUHGLWEHDXWLIXOO\
    ,OOWDNHWKDWDVDUDWKHUIRUPDOFRPSOLPHQW
    $QGVRLWZDV-XVWSODLQEHLQJKXPDQLVMXVWSODLQKDUG
    6R,DPILQGLQJ<RXOHDUQHGDOOWKLVRQ+HOLFRQ
    ,OHDUQHGWRGHDOZLWKHVVHQWLDOV
    $OVRWRKDWHIOXFWXDWLRQV7KH\FDQNLOO\RX
    +HWRRNDVZLJRIWKHEHHUVWLOOFROGDQGELWLQJ,KDGQWWKRXJKWRI
    LWWKDWZD\
    :K\GLGQW\RXVD\DOOWKLVLQWKHILUVWSODFH"
    ,GLGQWNQRZLWLQWKHILUVWSODFH
    $FRUROODU\WKHQ,I \RXFRPPLW\RXUVHOIWRDZRPDQ\RXJLYHDZD\DV
    PXFKRI\RXUVHOIDV\RXFDQLQVLGHWKDWHQFORVHGVSDFH
    7KHYROXPHEHWZHHQWKHWZRRIXV
    $JHRPHWULFDQDORJ\LVDVJRRGDVDQ\7KHWLSRIKHUWRQJXHPDGHKHU
    ORZHUOLSEXOJHRXWVOLJKWO\DVLWDOZD\VGLGZKHQVKHSRQGHUHGDSRLQW$QG
    \RXFRPPLW\RXUVHOIZKROO\WRDYHUWLQJWKHSULFHOLIHH[DFWV
    7KHSULFHRIIOXFWXDWLRQV"
    ,I\RXFDQSUHGLFW\RXFDQDYRLG&RUUHFW0DQDJH
    7KLVLVDZIXOO\DQDO\WLF
    ,YHVNLSSHGRYHUWKHKDUGSDUWVEXWWKH\ZLOOEHRQWKHKRPHZRUN
    DVVLJQPHQW
    8VXDOO\WKHVHNLQGVRIWDONXVHSKUDVHVOLNHRSWLPDOO\FRQVROLGDWHG
    VHOI,YHEHHQZDLWLQJIRUWKHMDUJRQWRFRPHWURWWLQJRXW+HKDGILQLVKHG
    WKHERZODQGIHOWPXFKEHWWHU
    )RRGLVRQHRIWKHOLIHDIILUPLQJH[SHULHQFHV
    6RWKDWVZK\,GRLW
    1RZ\RXUHPDNLQJIXQRIPH
    1RMXVWZRUNLQJRXWWKHLPSOLFDWLRQVRIWKHWKHRU\,OLNHGWKHSDUW

    DERXWKDWLQJXQSUHGLFWDELOLW\DQGIOXFWXDWLRQVEHFDXVHWKH\KXUWSHRSOH
    6RFDQ(PSLUHVLIWKH\IDOO
    5LJKW+HILQLVKHGWKHEHHUDQGWKRXJKWDERXWKDYLQJDQRWKHU$Q\PRUH
    ZRXOGGXOOKLPDOLWWOH+HZRXOGSUHIHUDQRWKHUZD\WRWDNHIURPKLPWKHHGJH
    KHVWLOOIHOW
    %LJDSSHWLWH6KHVPLOHG
    <RXKDYHQRLGHD$QGWKHSURVSHFWRIGHDWKFDQVWLPXODWHPRUHWKDQRQH
    NLQGRIDSSHWLWH/HWVJREDFNWRWKDWSDUWDERXWWKHKRPHZRUNDVVLJQPHQW
    <RXKDYHVRPHWKLQJLQPLQG
    +HJULQQHG<RXKDYHQRLGHD
    

    +HVDYRUHGKLVZRUNDOOWKHPRUHVLQFHKHKDGOHVVWLPHIRULW
    +DULVDWLQKLVGDUNHQHGRIILFHDEVROXWHO\VWLOOZDWFKLQJWKH'
    QXPHULFVHYROYHOLNHOXPLQRXVIRJVLQWKHDLUEHIRUHKLP
    (PSLUHVFKRODUVKDGNQRZQWKHURRWEDVLFVRISV\FKRKLVWRU\IRU
    PLOOHQQLD,QDQFLHQWWLPHVSHGDQWVKDGFKDUWHG WKHWZHQW\VL[VWDEOHDQG
    PHWDVWDEOHVRFLDOV\VWHPV7KHUHZHUHSOHQW\RIGHYROYHGSODQHWVWRVWXG\
    IDOOHQLQWREDUEDULVPOLNHWKH3RUFRVDQGWKHLU5DJLQJ5LWXDOVWKH/L]]LHV
    DQGWKHLU*\QR*RYHUQV
    +HZDWFKHGWKHIDPLOLDUSDWWHUQVIRUPDVKLVVLPXODWLRQVWHSSHGWKURXJK
    FHQWXULHVRI*DODFWLFHYROXWLRQ6RPHVRFLDOV\VWHPVSURYHGVWDEOHRQO\RQ
    VPDOOVFDOHV
    ,QWKHDLUKXQJWKHUDQNVRIZKROHZRUOGVFDXJKWLQVWDEOH=RQHV
    3ULPLWLYH6RFLDOLVP)HPR3DVWRUDOLVP0DFKR7ULEDOLVP7KHVHZHUHWKHVWURQJ
    DWWUDFWRUVRIKXPDQVRFLRORJ\LVODQGVLQWKHFKDRVVHD
    6RPHVRFLHWLHVODERUHGWKURXJKWKHLUPHWDVWDELOLW\WKHQFUDVKHG
    7KHRFUDF\7UDQVFHQGHQWDOLVP0DFKR)HXGDOLVP7KLVODWWHUDSSHDUHGZKHQHYHU
    SHRSOHKDGPHWDOOXUJ\DQGDJULFXOWXUH3ODQHWVZKLFKKDGVOLGDORQJZD\GRZQ
    WKHFXUYHZRXOGPDQLIHVWLW
    ,PSHULDOVFKRODUVKDGORQJMXVWLILHGWKH(PSLUHWKUHDGHGE\QDUURZ
    ZRUPKROHVDQGOXPEHULQJK\SHUVKLSVDVWKHEHVWKXPDQVRFLDOVWUXFWXUH,WKDG
    LQGHHGSURYHGVWDEOHDQGEHQHYROHQW
    7KHLUUHLJQLQJPRGHO%HQLJQ,PSHULDO)HXGDOLVPDFFHSWHGWKDWKXPDQV
    ZHUHKLHUDUFKLFDO$VZHOOWKH\ZHUHG\QDVWLFDOO\DPELWLRXVOLNLQJWKH
    FRQWLQXLW\RISRZHUDQGLWVSRPS7KH\ZHUHTXLWHGHYRWHGWRV\PEROVRIXQLW\
    RI,PSHULDOJUDQGHXU*RVVLSDERXWWKHJUHDW ZDVIRUPRVWSHRSOHWKHHVVHQFH
    RIKLVWRU\LWVHOI
    ,PSHULDOSRZHUZDVPRGHUDWHGE\WUDGLWLRQVRIQREOHOHDGHUVKLSWKH
    DVVXPHGVXSHULRULW\RIWKRVHZKRURVHWRJUHDWQHVV%HQHDWKVXFKLPSUHVVLYH
    UHVSOHQGHQFHDV&OHRQZHOONQHZOD\WKHEHGURFNRIDQH[WUHPHO\KRQHVW
    PHULWRFUDWLFFLYLOVHUYLFH:LWKRXWWKDWFRUUXSWLRQZRXOGVSUHDGOLNHDVWDLQ
    DFURVVWKHVWDUVFRUURGLQJWKHVSOHQGRU
    +HZDWFKHGWKHGLDJUDPDFRPSOH['ZHERIVXUIDFHVWKHODQGVFDSHRI
    VRFLDOVSDFH
    6ORZVWHSSHGKHFRXOGVHHLQGLYLGXDOHYHQWZDYHVZDVKLQJWKURXJKWKH
    VLP(DFKFHOOLQWKHJULGJRWUHFRPSXWHGHYHU\FORFNF\FOHUHDGMXVWLQJHYHU\
    QHDUHVWQHLJKERULQWHUDFWLRQLQ'
    7KHZRUNLQJUXOHVRIWKXPEZHUHQRWWKHWUXHODZVRISK\VLFVEXLOWXS
    IURPIXQGDPHQWDOVOLNHPD[LRQPHFKDQLFVRUHYHQIURPWKHVLPSOH1HZ7RZQ/DZV
    5DWKHUWKH\ZHUHURXJKDOJRULWKPVWKDWUHGXFHGLQWULFDWHODZVWRWULYLDO
    DULWKPHWLF6RFLHW\VHHQUDZWKLVZD\ZDVFUXGHQRWP\VWHULRXVDWDOO
    7KHQFDPHFKDRV
    +HZDVYLHZLQJWKHSROLF\VSDFH ZLWKLWVIDPLO\RIYDULDEOHVGHJUHH
    RISRODULW\RUSRZHUFRQFHQWUDWLRQVL]HRIFRDOLWLRQVFRQIOLFWVFDOH,Q
    WKLVVLPSOHPRGHOOHDUQLQJORRSVHPHUJHG6WDUWLQJIURPDSODWHDXSHULRGRI

    VHHPLQJVWDELOLW\EXWQRWVWDVLVWKHV\VWHPSURGXFHGD&KDOOHQJHU,GHD
    7KLVWKUHDWHQHGVWDELOLW\ZKLFKIRUFHGIRUPDWLRQRIFRDOLWLRQVWR
    RSSRVHWKHFKDOOHQJH)DFWLRQVIRUPHG7KHQWKH\JHOOHG7KHFRDOLWLRQVFRXOG
    EHSULPDULO\UHOLJLRXVSROLWLFDOHFRQRPLFWHFKQRORJLFDOHYHQPLOLWDU\
    WKRXJKWKLVODVWZDVDSDUWLFXODUO\LQHIIHFWLYHPHWKRGWKHGDWDVKRZHG7KH
    V\VWHPWKHQYHHUHGLQWRDFKDRWLFUHDOPVRPHWLPHVHPHUJLQJWRQHZVWDELOLW\
    VRPHWLPHVGHFD\LQJ
    ,QWKHG\QDPLFV\VWHPWKHUHZDVDSUHVVXUHFUHDWHGE\WKHFRQWUDVW
    EHWZHHQSHRSOHVLGHDOSLFWXUHRIWKHZRUOGDQGWKHUHDOLW\7RRELJD
    GLIIHUHQFHGURYHIUHVKIRUFHVIRUFKDQJH2IWHQWKHIRUFHVZHUHDSSDUHQWO\
    XQFRQVFLRXVSHRSOHNQHZVRPHWKLQJZDVZURQJIHOWUHVWLYHEXWFRXOGQRWIL[
    RQDFOHDUFDXVH
    6RPXFKIRUUDWLRQDODFWRUPRGHOV+DULWKRXJKW <HWVRPHVWLOOFOXQJ
    WRWKDWREYLRXVO\GXPEDSSUR[LPDWLRQ
    (YHU\RQHWKRXJKWWKH(PSLUHZDVVLPSOH
    1RWWKHEXONRIWKHSRSXODWLRQRIFRXUVHGD]]OHGE\WKHPL[RI
    FXOWXUHVDQGH[RWLFDDIIRUGHGE\WUDGHDQGFRPPXQLFDWLRQVIURPP\ULDGZRUOGV
    7KH\ZHUH SHUSHWXDOO\GLVWUDFWHGDQLPSRUWDQWGDPSHURQFKDRV
    (YHQWRVRFLDOWKHRULVWVWKRXJKWKHEDVLFVWUXFWXUHDQGLQWHUUHODWLRQV
    VHHPHGWREHSUHGLFWDEOHZLWKDPRGHUDWHQXPEHURIIHHGEDFNORRSVVROLGDQG
    WUDGLWLRQDO&RQYHQWLRQDOZLVGRPKHOGWKDWWKHVH FRXOGEHHDVLO\VHSDUDWHGRXW
    DQGWUHDWHG
    0RVWLPSRUWDQWWKHUHZDVFHQWUDOGHFLVLRQPDNLQJRUVRPRVWWKRXJKW
    7KH(PSHURU.QHZ%HVWULJKW"
    ,QUHDOLW\WKH(PSLUHZDVDQHVWHGRUGHUHGKLHUDUFK\,PSHULDO
    )HXGDOLVP$WWKHORZHUERXQGZHUHWKH=RQHVRIWKHJDOD[\VRPHWLPHVRQO\D
    GR]HQOLJKW\HDUVDFURVVXSWRDIHZWKRXVDQGOLJKW\HDUVGLDPHWHU$ERYH
    WKDWZHUH&RPSDFWVRIDIHZKXQGUHGQHDUE\=RQHV7KH&RPSDFWVLQWHUORFNHG
    LQWRWKH*DODFWLFFURVVOLQNHGV\VWHP
    %XWWKHZKROHWKLQJZDVVOLGLQJGRZQKLOO,QWKHFRPSOH[GLDJUDP
    VSDUNOLQJIOLFNHUVFDPHDQGZHQW:KDWZHUHWKRVH"
    +DULFORVHXSSHGWKHIODUHV=RQHVRIFKDRVZKHUHSUHGLFWDELOLW\
    EHFRPHVLPSRVVLEOH7KHVHILHU\HUXSWLRQVPLJKWEHWKHFOXHWRZK\WKH(PSLUH
    ZDVIDLOLQJ
    +DULIHOWLQKLVVRXOWKDWXQSUHGLFWDELOLW\ZDVEDGIRUKXPDQLW\IRU
    KLVPDWKHPDWLFV%XWLWZDVLQHVFDSDEOH
    7KLVZDVWKHVHFUHWWKH(PSHURUDQGRWKHUVPXVWQHYHUNQRZ7KDWXQWLO
    KHFRXOGUXOHFKDRVRUDWOHDVWSHHULQWRLWSV\FKRKLVWRU\ZDVDIUDXG
    +HGHFLGHGWRORRNDWDVLQJOHFDVH0D\EHWKDWZRXOGEHFOHDQHU
    +HVHOHFWHG6DUNWKHZRUOGZKLFKKDGIRXQGDQGGHYHORSHGWKH9ROWDLUH
    DQG-RDQVLPV,WELOOHGLWVHOIDVWKH+RPHRIWKH1HZ5HQDLVVDQFHDFRPPRQ
    UKHWRULFDOSRVWXUHRIWHQDGRSWHG7KH\VHHPHGEULJKWDQGFUHDWLYHDVKH
    UHYLHZHGWKHVWDWXVJULGV
    +DUL\DZQHGGHVSLWHKLPVHOI6XUH6DUNORRNHGJRRGIRUQRZ$ERRPLQJ
    HFRQRP\$OHDGHULQVW\OHVDQGIDVKLRQ
    %XWLWVSURILOHFODVVHGLWDPRQJWKH&KDRV:RUOGV7KH\URVHIRUD
    ZKLOHVHHPLQJWRGHI\WKHGDPSLQJPHFKDQLVPVWKDWKHOGSODQHWVLQWKH
    ,PSHULDO(TXLOLEULXP
    7KHQWKHLUVRFLDOIDEULFGLVVROYHG7KH\SOXPPHWHGEDFNLQWRRQHRIWKH
    6WDVLV6WDWHV$QDUFKR,QGXVWULDOIRU6DUNKHZRXOGSUHGLFWIURPWKHGDWD
    1RJUHDWIOHHWVPDGHWKLVKDSSHQ7KH(PSLUHGLGQRWGHVSLWHLPSUHVVLRQV
    UXOHE\IRUFH6RFLDOHYROXWLRQVPDGHWKH&KDRV:RUOGVIDOWHUDQGGLH
    8VXDOO\WKH*DOD[\DVDZKROHVXIIHUHGIHZUHSHUFXVVLRQV
    %XWODWHO\WKHUHKDGEHHQPRUHRIWKHP$QGWKH(PSLUHZDVYLVLEO\
    GHFD\LQJ 3URGXFWLYLW\ZDVGRZQLQFRKHUHQFHLQWKHVRFLDOVSDFHVRQWKHULVH
    :K\"
    +HJRWXSDQGZHQWIRUDZRUNRXWDWWKHJ\PQDVLXP(QRXJKRIWKHPLQG

    /HWKLVERG\VZHDWRXWWKHIUXVWUDWLRQVZURXJKWE\KLVLQWHOOHFW
    

    +HGLGQRWZDQWWRJRWRWKH*UDQG,PSHULDO8QLYHUVLWLHV&ROORTX\EXW
    WKH,PSHULDO3URWRFRO2IILFHOHDQHGRQKLP$)LUVW0LQLVWHULDOFDQGLGDWHKDV
    REOLJDWLRQVWKHRIILFLRXVZRPDQKDGLQIRUPHGKLP
    6RKHDQG'RUVGXWLIXOO\DSSHDUHGDWWKHHQRUPRXV,PSHULDO)HVWLYDO
    +DOO+LV6SHFLDOVZRUHGLVFUHHWIRUPDOEXVLQHVVVXLWVFRPSOHWHZLWKWKH
    FROODUUXIIOHVRIPLGOHYHOPHULWRFUDWV
    $OOWKHEHWWHUWREOHQGLQWRWKHFURZG'RUVMRNHG+DULVDZWKDW
    HYHU\RQHVL]HGXSWKHPHQLQDQLQVWDQWDQGJLQJHUO\HGJHGDZD\+HZRXOGKDYH
    EHHQIRROHG
    7KH\HQWHUHGDKLJKGRXEOHDUFKHGFRUULGRUOLQHGZLWKDQFLHQWVWDWXDU\
    ZKLFKLQYLWHGWKHSDVVHUVE\WROLFNWKHP+DULWULHGLWDIWHUFDUHIXOO\
    UHDGLQJWKHJORZVLJQZKLFKUHDVVXUHGKLPWKHUHZDVQRELRORJLFDOULVN$
    ORQJVXFFXOHQWOLFNJDYHKLP DIDLQWRGGIODYRURIRLODQGEXUQWDSSOHVD
    KLQWRIZKDWWKHDQFLHQWVIRXQGHQWLFLQJ
    :KDWVILUVWRQWKHDJHQGD"KHDVNHGKLV3URWRFRO2IILFHU
    $QDXGLHQFHZLWKWKH$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWHVKHDQVZHUHGDGGLQJ
    SRLQWHGO\$ORQH
    'RUVGLVDJUHHGDQG+DULQHJRWLDWHGDFRPSURPLVH'RUVJRWWRVWDQGDW
    WKHGRRUZD\QRPRUH,OOKDYHDSSHWL]HUVVHUYHGWR\RXWKHUHWKH3URWRFRO
    2IILFHUVDLGWHVWLO\
    'RUVJDYHKHUDQLF\VPLOH:K\LVWKLVDKDXGLHQFHVRLPSRUWDQW"
    7KH3URWRFRO2IILFHUJDYHKHUDSLW\LQJORRN7KH3RWHQWDWHFDUULHV
    PXFKZHLJKWLQWKH+LJK&RXQFLO
    +DULVDLGVRRWKLQJO\$QGFDQWKURZDIHZYRWHVP\ZD\
    $ELWRISROLWHWDONWKH3URWRFRO2IILFHUVDLG
    ,VKDOOSURPLVHWROHWPHSXWWKLVGHOLFDWHO\VPRRFKKLVEXWWRFNV2U
    KHUVDVWKHFDVHPD\EH
    'RUVVPLOHG%HWWHUQRWEHKHUV
    ,QWULJXLQJKRZWKHLPSOLFDWLRQVRIWKHDFWVZLWFKZLWKVH[
    7KH3URWRFRO2IILFHUFRXJKHGDQGXVKHUHGKLPGHIWO\WKURXJKVQDSSLQJ
    VFUHHQFXUWDLQVKLVKDLUVL]]OLQJ$SSDUHQWO\HYHQDQ$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWHKDG
    QHHGRISHUVRQDOVHFXULW\PHDVXUHV
    2QFHZLWKLQWKHIRUPDOVWDWHURRPV+DULIRXQGKHZDVDORQHZLWKDZRPDQ
    RIFRQVLGHUDEOHDJHDQGDUWLILFLDOEHDXWLHV6RWKDWZDVZK\WKH3URWRFRO
    2IILFHUKDGFRXJKHG
    +RZYHU\QLFHRI\RXWRFRPH6KHVWRRGPRWLRQOHVVRQHKDQGH[WHQGHG
    OLPSDWWKHZULVW$ZDWHUIDOOHIIHFWVSDWWHUHGEHKLQGKHUIUDPLQJKHUERG\
    ZHOO
    +HIHOWDVLIKHZHUHZDONLQJLQWRDVWLOOOLIHPXVHXPGLVSOD\+H
    GLGQWNQRZZKHWKHUWRVKDNHKHUKDQGRUNLVVLW+HVKRRNLWDQGKHUORRN
    PDGHKLPWKLQNKHKDGFKRVHQZURQJ
    6KHZRUHDORWRIHPEHGGHGPDNHXSDQGIURPWKHZD\VKHOHDQHGIRUZDUG
    WRPDNHDSRLQWKHJDWKHUHGWKDWKHUSDOHH\HVJRWKHUDORWRIWKLQJVRWKHU
    SHRSOHGLGQRWUHFHLYH
    6KHKDGRQFHEHHQDQRULJLQDOWKLQNHUDQRQOLQHDUSKLORVRSKHU1RZ
    PHULWRFUDWVDFURVVWKHVSLUDODUPVRZHGKHUIHDOW\
    %HIRUHWKH\KDGVDWGRZQVKHJHVWXUHG2KZRXOG\RXWXQHWKDWZDOO
    KD]H"7KHZDWHUIDOOHIIHFWKDGWXUQHGLQWRDURLOLQJWKLFNIRJ6RPHKRZLW
    JHWVZURQJDOOWKHWLPHDQGWKHURRPGRHVQWDGMXVWLW
    $ZD\RIHVWDEOLVKLQJDKLHUDUFK\+DULVXVSHFWHG*HWKLPXVHGWRGRLQJ
    OLWWOHWDVNVDWKHUELGGLQJ2UPD\EHVKHZDVOLNHVRPHRWKHUZRPHQZKRLI
    WKH\FRXOGQWJHW\RXWRGRPLQRUVHUYLFHVIHOWLQVHFXUH2UPD\EHVKHZDV
    MXVWLQHSWDQGZDQWHGKHUZDWHUIDOOEDFN2UPD\EHKHMXVWDQDO\]HGWKHKHOO

    RXWRIHYHU\WKLQJDPDWKLVWVSDWWHUQ
    ,YHKHDUGUHPDUNDEOHWKLQJVDERXW\RXUZRUNVKHVDLGVKLIWLQJIURP
    +LJK)LJXUH8VHGWR6QDSS\2EHGLHQFHWR*UDFLRXV/DG\3XWWLQJDQ8QGHUOLQJDW
    (DVH+HVDLGVRPHWKLQJQRQFRPPLWWDO$WLNWRNEURXJKWDVWLPZKLFKZDVEDUHO\
    OLTXLGGULIWLQJGRZQKLVWKURDWDQGLQWRKLVQRVWULOVOLNHDVLONHQVLQLVWHU
    FORXG
    <RXEHOLHYH\RXUVHOISUDFWLFDOHQRXJKIRUWKHPLQLVWHUVKLS"
    1RWKLQJLVPRUHSUDFWLFDOPRUHXVHIXOWKDQDVRXQGWKHRU\
    6DLGOLNHDWUXHPDWKLVW6SHDNLQJIRUDOOPHULWRFUDWV,GRKRSH\RX
    DUHHTXDOWRWKHWDVN
    +HWKRXJKWRIWHOOLQJKHUVKHGLGKDYHDFHUWDLQFKDUPDIWHUDOOWKDW
    KHGLGQWJLYHDGDPQIRUWKHPLQLVWHUVKLS%XWVRPHLQWXLWLRQKHOGKLPEDFN
    6KHZDVDQRWKHUSRZHUEURNHU+HNQHZVKHKDGEHHQYLQGLFWLYHLQWKHSDVW
    6KHJDYHKLPDVKUHZGVPLOH,XQGHUVWDQG\RXKDYHFKDUPHGWKH(PSHURU
    ZLWKDWKHRU\RIKLVWRU\
    $WWKHPRPHQWLWLVOLWWOHEHWWHUWKDQDGHVFULSWLRQ
    $VRUWRIVXPPDU\"
    %UHDNWKURXJKVIRUWKHEULOOLDQWV\QWKHVHVIRUWKHGULYHQ
    6XUHO\\RXNQRZWKHUHLVDQDLURIIXWLOLW\DERXWVXFKDQDPELWLRQ$
    JOHDPRIVWHHOLQWKHSDOHH\HV
    ,ZDVXQDZDUH0DGDP
    6FLHQFHLVVLPSO\DQDUELWUDU\FRQVWUXFW,WSHUSHWXDWHVWKH
    GLVFUHGLWHGQRWLRQWKDWSURJUHVVLVDOZD\VSRVVLEOH/HWDORQHGHVLUDEOH
    2K" +HKDGSODVWHUHGDSROLWHVPLOHRQKLVIDFHDQGZDVGDPQHGLIKH
    ZRXOGOHWLWVOLS
    2QO\RSSUHVVLYHVRFLDORUGHUVHPHUJHIURPVXFKLGHDV6FLHQFHV
    SXUSRUWHGREMHFWLYLW\KLGHVWKHSODLQIDFWWKDWLWLVVLPSO\RQHODQJXDJH
    JDPHDPRQJRWKHUV$OOVXFKDUELWUDU\FRQILJXUDWLRQVVLWLQDFRQFHSWXDO
    XQLYHUVHRIFRPSHWLQJGLVFRXUVHV
    ,VHH7KHVPLOHZDVJHWWLQJKHDYLHU+LVIDFHIHOWOLNHLWZRXOG
    FUDFN
    7RHOHYDWHVFLHQWLILFVKHVQLIIHGGLVGDLQIXOO\VRFDOOHGWUXWKV
    RYHURWKHUFRQVWUXFWLRQV LVWDQWDPRXQWWRFRORQL]LQJWKHLQWHOOHFWXDO
    ODQGVFDSH7RHQVODYLQJRQHVRSSRVLWLRQ
    8PPP+HKDGDVLQNLQJIHHOLQJWKDWKHZDVQRWJRLQJWRODVWORQJDVD
    GRRUPDW%HIRUH\RXHYHQFRQVLGHUWKHVXEMHFW\RXFODLPWRNQRZWKHEHVW
    ZD\WRVWXG\LW"
    6RFLDOWKHRU\DQGOLQJXLVWLFDQDO\VLVKDYHWKHILQDOSRZHUVLQFHDOO
    WUXWKVKDYHTXLWHOLPLWHGKLVWRULFDODQGFXOWXUDOYDOLGLW\7KHUHIRUHWKLV
    SV\FKRKLVWRU\RIDOOVRFLHWLHVLVDEVXUG
    6RVKHNQHZWKHWHUPZRUGZDVVSUHDGLQJ3HUKDSV\RXKDYHLQVXIILFLHQW
    UHJDUGIRUWKHURXJKUXERIWKHUHDO
    $VOLJKWWKDZLQJ&OHYHUSKUDVLQJ$FDGHPLFLDQ6WLOOWKHFDWHJRU\
    UHDOLVDVRFLDOFRQVWUXFWLRQ
    /RRNRIFRXUVHVFLHQFHLVDVRFLDOSURFHVV%XWVFLHQWLILFWKHRULHV
    GRQWPHUHO\UHIOHFWVRFLHW\
    +RZFKDUPLQJWRVWLOOWKLQNVR$ZDQVPLOHIDLOHGWRFRQFHDOWKHLF\
    JOHDPLQKHUH\HV
    7KHRULHVDUHQRWPHUHFKDQJHVRIIDVKLRQOLNHVKLIWLQJPHQVVNLUWV
    IURPVKRUWWRORQJ
    $FDGHPLFLDQ\RXPXVWNQRZWKDWWKHUHLVQRWKLQJNQRZDEOHEH\RQGKXPDQ
    GLVFRXUVHV
    +HNHSWKLVYRLFHOHYHOFRXUWHRXV3RLQWRXWWKDWVKHKDGXVHGNQRZ
    LQWZRFRQWUDGLFWRU\ZD\VLQWKHVDPHVHQWHQFH"1RWKDWZRXOGEHSOD\LQJZRUG
    JDPHVZKLFKZRXOGVXEWO\VXSSRUWKHUYLHZV6XUHPRXQWDLQFOLPEHUVPLJKW
    DUJXH DQGWKHRUL]HDERXWWKHEHVWURXWHWRWKHWRS
    $OZD\VLQZD\VFRQGLWLRQHGE\WKHLUKLVWRU\DQGVRFLDOVWUXFWXUHV

    EXWRQFHWKH\JHWWKHUHWKH\NQRZLW1RERG\ZRXOGVD\WKH\
    FRQVWUXFWHGWKHPRXQWDLQ
    6KHSXUVHGKHUOLSVDQGKDGDQRWKHUIRJJ\ZKLWHVWLP8PPP(OHPHQWDU\
    UHDOLVP%XWDOORI\RXUIDFWVHPERG\WKHRU\:D\VRIVHHLQJ
    ,FDQWKHOSQRWLFLQJWKDWDQWKURSRORJLVWVVRFLRORJLVWVWKHZKROH
    JDQJJHWDGHOLFLRXVUXVKRIVXSHULRULW\E\GHQ\LQJWKHREMHFWLYHUHDOLW\RI
    WKHKDUG VFLHQFHVGLVFRYHULHV
    6KHGUHZKHUVHOIXS7KHUHDUHQRHOHPHQWDOWUXWKVWKDWH[LVW
    LQGHSHQGHQWRIWKHSHRSOHODQJXDJHVDQGFXOWXUHVWKDWPDNHWKHP
    <RXGRQWEHOLHYHLQREMHFWLYHUHDOLW\WKHQ"
    :KRVWKHREMHFW"
    +HKDGWRODXJK/DQJXDJHSOD\6ROLQJXLVWLFVWUXFWXUHVGLFWDWHKRZZH
    VHH"
    ,VQWWKDWREYLRXV":HOLYHLQDJDOD[\ULFKLQFXOWXUHVDOOVHHLQJ
    WKH*DOD[\WKHLUZD\
    %XWREH\LQJODZV3OHQW\RIUHVHDUFKVKRZVWKDWWKRXJKWDQGSHUFHSWLRQ
    SUHFHGHWDONH[LVWLQGHSHQGHQWRIODQJXDJH
    :KDWODZV"
    /DZVRIVRFLDOPRYHPHQW$WKHRU\RIVRFLDOKLVWRU\LIZHKDGRQH
    <RXDWWHPSWWKHLPSRVVLEOH$QGLI\RXZLVKWREH)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    HQMR\LQJWKHVXSSRUWRI\RXUIHOORZDFDGHPLFVDQGPHULWRFUDWV\RXVKDOOKDYH
    WRIROORZ WKHSUHYDLOLQJYLHZRIRXUVRFLHW\0RGHUQOHDUQLQJLVDQLPDWHGE\D
    IUDQNLQFUHGXOLW\WRZDUGVXFKPHWDQDUUDWLYHV
    +HZDVVRUHO\WHPSWHGWRVD\7KHQ\RXDUHJRLQJWREHVXUSULVHGEXW
    LQVWHDGVDLG:HVKDOOVHH
    :HGRQWVHHWKLQJVDVWKH\DUH WKHOHDUQHGODG\VDLGZHVHHWKHP
    DVZHDUH
    :LWKDWRXFKRIVDGQHVVKHUHDOL]HGWKDWWKHUHSXEOLFRILQWHOOHFWXDO
    LQTXLU\ZDVOLNHWKH(PSLUHQRWIUHHRILQWHUQDOGHFD\
    

    7KH$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWHOHGKLPRXWZLWKULWXDOZRUGVWRVPRRWKWKHZD\
    DQG'RUVZDVVWDQGLQJDWWHQWLYHO\DWWKHJUDQGHQWUDQFH6WLOO+DULKDG
    JRWWHQWKHHVVHQWLDOPHVVDJHWKHDFDGHPLFPHULWRFUDF\ZRXOGEDFNKLPIRU
    )LUVW0LQLVWHULIKHDWOHDVWSDLGOLSVHUYLFHWRSUHYDLOLQJRUWKRGR[\
    7RJHWKHUZLWKWKHFXVWRPDU\DFDGHPLFKRQRUJXDUGWKH\ZHQWGRZQLQWR
    WKHYDVWURWXQGD7KLVZDVDGL]]\LQJERZOZLWKYDULRXVVFKRODUO\GLVFLSOLQHV
    UHSUHVHQWHGE\WKHIXOOUHJDOLDDQGLQVLJQLDVSODVKHGDFURVVLPPHQVHZDOO
    GHVLJQV%HORZWKHPVZLUOHGDFKDWWHULQJPREWKRXVDQGVRIWKHILQHVWPLQGV
    JDWKHUHGIRUVSHHFKHVOHDUQHGUHSRUWVDQGRIFRXUVHPXFKLQILJKWLQJRIWKH
    YHU\ILQHVWVRUW
    7KLQNZHFDQVXUYLYHWKLV"+DULZKLVSHUHG
    'RQWOHWJR'RUVVDLGVHL]LQJKLVKDQG
    +HUHDOL]HGWKDWVKHKDGWDNHQKLVTXHVWLRQOLWHUDOO\
    $OLWWOHODWHUWKH$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWHZDVQWPDNLQJDVKRZRIVDYRULQJ
    WKHERXTXHWRIWKHVWLPVDQ\PRUHMXVWVXFNLQJWKHPXSOLNHRQHRIWKHPDMRU
    IRRGJURXSV6KHVWHHUHG+DULDQG'RUVIURPRQHFOXVWHURIWKHOHDUQHGWR
    DQRWKHU2FFDVLRQDOO\VKHZRXOGUHPHPEHUKHUUROHDVKRVWHVVDQGIHLJQ
    LQWHUHVWLQKLPDVPRUHWKDQDFKHVVSLHFHLQDODUJHUJDPH8QIRUWXQDWHO\
    WKHVHEOXQWDWWHPSWVIDVWHQHGXSRQLQTXLULHVLQWRKLVSHUVRQDOOLIH
    'RUVUHVLVWHGWKHVHLQTXLVLWLRQVRIFRXUVHVPLOLQJDQGVKDNLQJKHU
    KHDG:KHQWKH3RWHQWDWHWXUQHGWR+DULDQGDVNHG'R\RXH[HUFLVH"KHFRXOG
    QRWUHVLVWUHSO\LQJ,H[HUFLVHUHVWUDLQW
    7KH3URWRFRO2IILFHUIURZQHGEXW+DULVUHPDUNZHQWXQQRWLFHGLQWKH
    MRVWOLQJWKURQJ+HIRXQGWKHFRPSDQ\RIKLVIHOORZPHPEHUVRIWKH
    SURIHVVRULDWRGGO\RIISXWWLQJ7KHLUFRQYHUVDWLRQVKDGDGLUHFWLRQOHVVLURQ\

    ZKLFKFRQYH\HGZLWKUDLVHGH\HEURZVDQGDUFKWRQHVWKHVSHDNHUVVXSHULRULW\
    WRHYHU\WKLQJKHZDVFRPPHQWLQJXSRQ
    7KHLUDFHUELFSDUDGR[HVDQGVWLOHWWRKXPRUVWUXFN+DULDVLUULWDWLQJDQG
    EHVLGHWKHSRLQW+HNQHZZHOOWKDWWKHPRVWVDYDJHFRQWURYHUVLHVDUHDERXW
    PDWWHUVIRUZKLFKWKHUHLVQRJRRGHYLGHQFHHLWKHUZD\6WLOOWKHUHZDVD
    PDQQHUHGGHVSHUDWLRQHYHQWRWKHVFLHQWLVWV
    )XQGDPHQWDOSK\VLFVDQGFRVPRORJ\KDGEHHQZHOOZRUNHGRXWIDUEDFNLQ
    DQWLTXLW\1RZDOORI,PSHULDOVFLHQWLILFKLVWRU\GHDOWZLWKWHDVLQJRXW
    LQWULFDWHGHWDLOVDQGVHDUFKLQJIRUFOHYHUDSSOLFDWLRQV+XPDQNLQGZDVWUDSSHG
    LQDFRVPRVVWHDGLO\H[SDQGLQJWKRXJKVORZLQJVOLJKWO\DQGGHVWLQHGWRVHH
    WKHVWDUVZLQNRXW$VORZFRROJOLGHLQWRDQLQGHILQLWHIXWXUHZDVRUGDLQHG
    E\WKHPDVVHQHUJ\FRQWHQWSUHVHQWDWWKHYHU\FRQFHSWLRQRIWKHXQLYHUVH
    +XPDQVFRXOGGRQRWKLQJDJDLQVWWKDWIDWH([FHSWRIFRXUVHXQGHUVWDQGLW
    6RWKHJUDQGHVWRI LQWHOOHFWXDOWHUULWRULHVKDGEHHQRSHQHGDQGWKDW
    FDQRQO\EHGRQHRQFH1RZVFLHQWLVWVZHUHOHVVOLNHGLVFRYHUHUVWKDQOLNH
    VHWWOHUVHYHQWRXULVWV
    +HVKRXOGQRWEHVXUSULVHGKHUHDOL]HGWRILQGWKDWHYHQWKHEHVWRI
    WKHPJDWKHUHGIURPDQHQWLUH*DOD[\VKRXOGKDYHDQDLURIMDGHGEULOOLDQFH
    OLNHWDUQLVKHGJROG
    0HULWRFUDWVGLGQRWKDYHPDQ\FKLOGUHQDQGWKHUHZDVDQDLU\VWHULOLW\
    DERXWWKHP+DULZRQGHUHGLIWKHUHZDVDPLGGOHJURXQGEHWZHHQWKHVWDOHQHVV
    KHIHOWKHUHDQGWKHFKDRVRIWKHUHQDLVVDQFHVVSURXWLQJXSRQ&KDRV:RUOGV
    3HUKDSVKHQHHGHGWRNQRZPRUHDERXWEDVLFKXPDQQDWXUH
    7KH3URWRFRO2IILFHUVWHHUHGKLPGRZQDVSLUDODLUUDPSHOHFWURVWDWLFV
    VHL]LQJWKHPDQGJHQWO\ORZHULQJWKHSDUW\WRZDUGKHORRNHGGRZQZLWK
    WUHSLGDWLRQWKHREOLJDWRU\PHGLDSHRSOH+HEUDFHGKLPVHOI'RUVVTXHH]HGKLV
    KDQG'R\RXKDYHWRWDONWRWKHP"
    +HVLJKHG,I,LJQRUHWKHPWKH\ZLOOUHSRUWWKDW
    /HW/DPXUNDPXVHWKHP
    1R+LVH\HVQDUURZHG6LQFH,PLQWKLV,PLJKWDVZHOOSOD\WR
    ZLQ
    +HUH\HVZLGHQHGZLWKUHYHODWLRQ<RXYHGHFLGHGKDYHQW\RX"
    7RWU\"<RXEHW
    :KDWKDSSHQHG"
    7KDWZRPDQEDFNWKHUHWKH3RWHQWDWH6KHDQGKHUNLQGWKLQNWKH
    ZRUOGVMXVWDVHWRIRSLQLRQV
    :KDWKDVWKDWJRWWRGRZLWK/DPXUN"
    ,FDQWH[SODLQLW7KH\UHDOOSDUWRIWKHGHFD\0D\EHWKDWVLW
    6KHVWXGLHGKLVIDFH,OOQHYHUXQGHUVWDQG\RX
    *RRG7KDWZRXOGEHGXOO\HV"
    7KHPHGLDSDFNDSSURDFKHGVQRXWVDLPHGOLNHZHDSRQV
    +DULZKLVSHUHGWR'RUV(YHU\LQWHUYLHZEHJLQVDVDVHGXFWLRQDQGHQGV
    DVDEHWUD\DO7KH\GHVFHQGHG
    $FDGHPLFLDQ6HOGRQ\RXDUHNQRZQDVDPDWKLVWDFDQGLGDWH)LUVW
    0LQLVWHUDQGD+HOLFRQLDQ<RX
    ,RQO\UHDOL]HG,ZDVD+HOLFRQLDQZKHQ,FDPHWR7UDQWRU
    $QG\RXUFDUHHUDVD PDWKLVW
    ,RQO\UHDOL]HGWKDW,WKRXJKWDVDPDWKLVWZKHQ,EHJDQPHHWLQJ
    SROLWLFLDQV
    :HOOWKHQDVDSROLWLFLDQ
    ,DPVWLOOD+HOLFRQLDQ7KLVGUHZVRPHODXJKWHU
    <RXSUL]HWKHWUDGLWLRQDOWKHQ"
    ,ILWZRUNV
    :HEHQRWRSHQWRROGLGHDVDZLOORZ\ZRPDQIURPWKH)RUQD[=RQH
    VDLG)XWXUHRI(PSLUHFRPHVIURPSHRSOHQRWODZV$JUHH"
    6KHZDVD5DWLRQDOXVLQJWKHLUVWULSSHGGRZQXWWHUO\RUGHUO\*DODFWLF
    IUHHRILUUHJXODUYHUEVDQGFRPSOH[FRQVWUXFWLRQV+DULFRXOGIROORZLWZHOO

    HQRXJKEXWIRUKLPWKHRGGVZHUYHVDQGWXUQVRI&ODVVLFDO*DODFWLFHPERGLHG
    LWVFKDUP
    7R+DULVGHOLJKWVHYHUDOSHRSOHGLVDJUHHGZLWKKHUIRUPXODWHG
    TXHVWLRQVKRXWLQJ,QWKHQRLVHKHUHIOHFWHGRQWKHLQILQLW\RIKXPDQ
    FXOWXUHVUHSUHVHQWHGLQWKLVYDVWERZODQGVWLOOXQLWHGXQGHU&ODVVLFDO
    *DODFWLF
    7KHODQJXDJHVVWXUG\EDVHKDGVWLWFKHGWRJHWKHUWKHHDUO\(PSLUH)RU
    PDQ\PLOOHQQLDQRZWKHODQJXDJHKDGVDWRQLWVODXUHOVDGPLWWHGO\+HKDG
    DGGHGDVPDOOLQWHUDFWLRQWHUPWRKLVHTXDWLRQVWRDOORZIRUWKHFXOWXUDO
    ULSSOHVH[FLWHGE\WKHVSODVKLQJRIDQHZDUJRWLQWRWKHOLQJXLVWLFSRRO7KH
    DQFLHQWUXIIOHVDQGIORXULVKHVRI*DODFWLFDOORZHGVXEWOHWLHVGHQLHGWKH
    5DWLRQDOVRU5DWVDVVRPHFDOOHGWKHPDQGWKHIXQRISXQVDVZHOO
    +HWULHGWR PDNHWKLVFDVHWRWKHZRPDQEXWVKHUHWRUWHG1RWVXSSRUW
    RGGLW\6XSSRUWRUGHU2OGZD\VIDLOHG$VPDWKLVW\RXZLOOEHWRR
    &RPHQRZ+DULVDLGLUNHG(YHQLQFORVHGD[LRPDWLFV\VWHPVQRWDOO
    SURSRVLWLRQVDUHGHFLGDEOH,VXJJHVW\RXFDQQRWSUHGLFWZKDW,ZRXOGGRDVD
    )LUVW0LQLVWHU
    7KLQN\RX&RXQFLOVXEPLWVWRUHDVRQ"WKHZRPDQDVNHGKDXJKWLO\
    ,WLVWKHWULXPSKRIUHDVRQWRJHWRQZHOOZLWKWKRVHZKRSRVVHVV
    QRQH+DULVDLG7RKLVVXUSULVHVRPHDSSODXGHG
    <RXUWKHRU\RIKLVWRU\ GHQLHV*RGVSRZHUVWRLQWHUYHQHLQKXPDQ
    DIIDLUVDWKLQPDQIURPDORZJUDYSODQHWDVVHUWHG:KDWVD\\RXWRWKDW"
    +DULZDVDERXWWRDJUHHLWVHHPHGWRPDNHQRGLIIHUHQFHWRKLPZKHQ
    'RUVVWHSSHGEHIRUHKLP
    3HUKDSV,FDQEULQJXSDELWRIUHVHDUFKVLQFHWKLVLVDQDFDGHPLF
    SURFHHGLQJ6KHVPLOHGVPRRWKO\,UDQDFURVVDQKLVWRULDQRIDERXWD
    WKRXVDQG\HDUVDJRZKRKDGWHVWHGIRUWKHSRZHURISUD\HU
    +DULVPRXWKPDGHDVXUSULVHGVNHSWLFDO7KHWKLQPDQGHPDQGHG+RZ
    FRXOGRQHVFLHQWLILFDOO\
    +HUHDVRQHGWKDWWKHSHRSOHPRVWSUD\HGIRUZHUHWKHPRVWIDPRXV<HW
    WKH\KDGWREHH[DOWHGDERYHWKHIUD\
    7KHHPSHURUV"7KHWKLQPDQZDVUDSW
    ([DFWO\$QGWKHLUOHVVHUIDPLO\PHPEHUV+HDQDO\]HGWKHLUPRUWDOLW\
    UDWHV
    +DULKDGQHYHUKHDUGWKLVEXWKLVLQQDWHVNHSWLFLVPGHPDQGHGGHWDLO
    $OORZLQJIRUWKHLUEHWWHUPHGLFDOFDUHDQGVDIHW\IURPRUGLQDU\DFFLGHQWV"
    'RUVJULQQHG2IFRXUVH3OXVWKHLUULVNRIDVVDVVLQDWLRQ
    7KHWKLQPDQGLGQRWNQRZZKHUHWKLVOLQHRIDWWDFNZDVJRLQJEXWKLV
    FXULRVLW\JRWWKHEHWWHURIKLP$QG"
    'RUVVDLG+HIRXQGWKDWHPSHURUVGLHGHDUOLHUWKDQXQSUD\HGIRU
    SHRSOH
    7KHWKLQPDQORRNHGVKRFNHGDQJU\+DULDVNHG'RUV:KDWZDVWKHURRW
    PHDQGHYLDWLRQ"
    $OZD\VWKHVNHSWLF1RWVXIILFLHQWWRSURYHWKDWSUD\HUKDGDQDFWXDOO\
    KDUPIXOHIIHFW
    $K7KHFURZGVHHPHGWRILQGWKLVH[DPSOHRIWDJWHDPSXIIHU\
    HQWHUWDLQLQJ%HVWWROHDYHWKHPZDQWLQJPRUH7KDQN\RXKHVDLGDQGWKH\
    PHOWHGDZD\EHKLQGDVFUHHQRI6SHFLDOV
    7KDWOHIWWKHFURZGLWVHOI&OHRQKDGXUJHGKLPWRPLQJOHZLWKWKHVH
    IRONVXSSRVHGO\KLVEDVLFSRZHUEDVHWKHPHULWRFUDWV+DULZULQNOHGKLVQRVH
    DQGQRQHWKHOHVVSOXQJHGLQ
    ,WZDVDPDWWHURIVW\OHKHUHDOL]HGDIWHUWKHILUVWWKLUW\PLQXWHV
    +HKDGOHDUQHGHDUO\LQUXUDO+HOLFRQWRSODFHJUHDWVWRUHLQJRRG
    PDQQHUVDQGFLYLOLW\$PRQJWKHDOHUWKDUGHGJHGDFDGHPLFVKHKDGIRXQGPDQ\
    ZKRVHHPHGSRRUO\VRFLDOL]HGXQWLOKHUHDOL]HGWKDWWKH\ZHUHRSHUDWLQJRXW
    RIDGLIIHUHQWFXOWXUHZKHUHFOHYHUQHVVPDWWHUHGPRUHWKDQJUDFH7KHLU
    VXEWOHVKDGLQJVRIYRLFHFDUULHGDUURJDQFHDQGDVVXUDQFHLQSUHFDULRXV

    EDODQFHZKLFKLQXQJXDUGHGPRPHQWVWLOWHGLQWRDFHUELFFXWWLQJMXGJPHQW
    RIWHQZLWKRXWHYHQWKHDSSHDOLQJYHQHHURIZLW+HKDGWRPDNHKLPVHOI
    UHPHPEHUWRVD\:LWKDOOGXHUHVSHFWDWWKHEHJLQQLQJRIDQDUJXPHQWDQG
    HYHQWRPHDQLW
    7KHQWKHUHZHUHWKHXQVSRNHQHOHPHQWV
    $PRQJWKHIDVWWUDFNFLUFOHVERG\ODQJXDJHZDVHVVHQWLDODWDXJKW
    VNLOO7KHUHZHUHFDUHIXOO\GHVLJQHGSRVHVIRU&RQILGHQFH,PSDWLHQFH
    6XEPLVVLRQ IRXUVKDGLQJV 7KUHDW(VWHHP&R\QHVVDQGGR]HQVPRUH&RGLILHG
    DQGXQGHUVWRRGXQFRQVFLRXVO\HDFKLQGXFHGDVSHFLILFGHVLUHGQHXURORJLFDO
    VWDWHLQERWKVHOIDQGRWKHUV7KHUXGLPHQWVIRUDIXOOEORZQFUDIWOD\LQ
    GDQFHSROLWLFVDQGWKHPDUWLDODUWV%\EHLQJV\VWHPDWLFPXFKPRUHFRXOGEH
    FRQYH\HG$VZLWKODQJXDJHDGLFWLRQDU\KHOSHG
    $QRQOLQHDUSKLORVRSKHURI*DOD[\ZLGHIDPHJDYH+DULDEHDPLQJVPLOH
    ERG\ODQJXDJHVFUHDPLQJVHOIFRQILGHQFHDQGVDLG6XUHO\3URIHVVRU\RX
    FDQQRWPDLQWDLQWKDW\RXUDWWHPSWWRLPSRUWPDWKLQWRKLVWRU\FDQVRPHKRZ
    ZRUN"3HRSOHFDQEHZKDWWKH\ZLVK1RHTXDWLRQVZLOOPDNHWKHPRWKHUZLVH
    ,VHHNWRGHVFULEHWKDWVDOO
    1RJUDQGWKHRU\RIKLVWRU\WKHQ"
    $YRLGDGLUHFWGHQLDOKHWKRXJKW,ZLOONQRZ,PRQWKHULJKWWUDFN
    ZKHQ,FDQVLPSO\GHVFULEHDELWRIKXPDQQDWXUH
    $KEXWWKDWVFDUFHO\H[LVWVWKHPDQVDLGZLWKDVVXUDQFHDUPVDQG
    FKHVWWXUQHGDGURLWO\
    2IFRXUVHWKHUHVDKXPDQQDWXUH+DULVKRWEDFN
    $SLW\LQJVPLOHDOD]\VKUXJ:K\VKRXOGWKHUHEH"
    +HUHGLW\LQWHUDFWVZLWKHQYLURQPHQWWRWXJXVEDFNWRZDUGDIL[HGPHDQ
    ,WJDWKHUVSHRSOHLQDOOVRFLHWLHVDFURVVPLOOLRQVRIZRUOGVLQWRWKHQDUURZ
    VWDWLVWLFDOFLUFOHWKDWZHPXVWFDOOKXPDQQDWXUH
    ,GRQWWKLQNWKHUHDUHHQRXJKJHQHUDOWUDLWV
    3DUHQWFKLOGERQGLQJ'LYLVLRQRIODERUEHWZHHQWKHVH[HV
    :HOOVXUHO\WKDWVFRPPRQDPRQJDOODQLPDOV,
    ,QFHVWDYRLGDQFH$OWUXLVPZHFDOOLWKXPDQLWDULDQLVPDWHOOLQJ
    FOXHHK"WRZDUG RXUQHDUNLQ
    :HOOWKRVHDUHMXVWQRUPDOIDPLO\
    /RRNDWWKHGDUNVLGH6XVSLFLRQRIVWUDQJHUV7ULEDOLVPZLWQHVV
    7UDQWRUVHLJKWKXQGUHG6HFWRUV+LHUDUFKLHVLQHYHQWKHVPDOOHVWJURXSV
    IURPWKH(PSHURUVFRXUWWRDERZOLQJWHDP
    6XUHO\\RXFDQWPDNHVXFKOHDSVVXFKVLPSOLVWLFJURWHVTXH
    FRPSDULVRQV
    ,FDQDQGGR0DOHGRPLQDQFHJHQHUDOO\DQGZKHQUHVRXUFHVDUHVFDUFH
    PDUNHGWHUULWRULDODJJUHVVLRQ
    7KHVHDUHOLWWOHWUDLWV
    7KH\OLQNXV7KHVRSKLVWLFDWHG7UDQWRULDQDQGDQ$UFDGLDQIDUPHUFDQ
    VWLOOXQGHUVWDQGHDFKRWKHUVOLYHVIRUWKHVLPSOHUHDVRQWKDWWKHLUFRPPRQ
    KXPDQLW\OLYHVLQWKHJHQHVWKH\VKDUHIURPPDQ\WHQVRIPLOOHQQLDDJR
    7KLVRXWEXUVWZDVQRWUHFHLYHGZHOO)DFHVZULQNOHGPRXWKVSRXFKHGLQ
    GLVDSSURYDO
    +DULVDZKHKDGRYHUVWHSSHG:KDWVPRUHKHKDGQHDUO\H[SRVHG
    SV\FKRKLVWRU\
    <HWKHIRXQGLWKDUGWRQRWVSHDNIUDQNO\,QKLVYLHZWKHKXPDQLWLHV
    DQGVRFLDOVFLHQFHVVKUDQNWRVSHFLDOL]HGEUDQFKHVRI ERWKPDWKHPDWLFVDQG
    ELRORJ\+LVWRU\ELRJUDSK\DQGILFWLRQZHUHV\PSWRPV$QWKURSRORJ\DQG
    VRFLRORJ\WRJHWKHUEHFDPHWKHVRFLRELRORJ\RIDVLQJOHVSHFLHV%XWKHFRXOG
    QRWJHWDIHHOIRUKRZWRLQFOXGHWKDWLQWKHHTXDWLRQV+HKDGVSRNHQRXWKH
    VDZVXGGHQO\EHFDXVHKHZDVIUXVWUDWHGE\KLVRZQODFNRIXQGHUVWDQGLQJ
    6WLOOWKDWGLGQRWH[FXVHKLVVWXSLGLW\+HRSHQHGKLVPRXWKWRVPRRWK
    RYHUWKHZDWHUV
    +HVDZWKHDJLWDWHGPDQFRPLQJXSRQKLVOHIW0RXWKDZU\H\HVZKLWH

    KDQGH[WHQGHGSRNLQJIRUZDUGDWXEHLQLWFKURPHGDQGVOHHNDQGZLWKD
    SUHFLVHKROHDWWKHWLSDGDUNVSRWWKDWH[SDQGHGDVKHORRNHGDWLWXQWLOLW
    VHHPHGOLNHWKH(DWHURI$OO7KLQJVWKDWOXUNHGDW*DODFWLF&HQWHULPPHQVH
    'RUVKLWWKHPDQTXLWHH[SHUWO\6KHGHIOHFWHGWKHDUPXSMDEEHGKLPLQ
    WKHWKURDWVWUXFNQH[WDWWKHEHOO\7KHQVKHWZLVWHGWKHDUPDQGIRUFHGKLP
    LQWRDTXDUWHUWXUQKHUOHIWOHJFRPLQJDURXQGDQGFXWWLQJKLVIHHWIURP
    EHQHDWKKLPKHUULJKWKDQGIRUFLQJWKHKHDGGRZQ
    $QGWKH\VWUXFNWKHIORRUVROLGO\'RUVRQWRSWKHJXQVNLWWHULQJDZD\
    DPRQJWKHVKRHVRIWKHFURZGZKLFKZDVIDOOLQJEDFNLQSDQLF
    6SHFLDOVEORFNHGLQDURXQGKLPDQGKHVDZQRPRUH+HVKRXWHGWR'RUV
    6FUHDPVDQGVKRXWVKDPPHUHGDWKLPIURPDOOVLGHV
    0RUHEHGODP7KHQKHZDVFOHDURIWKH6SHFLDOVDQGWKHPDQZDVJHWWLQJ
    XSDQG'RUVZDVVWDQGLQJKROGLQJWKHSLVWROVKDNLQJKHUKHDG7KHPDQZKR
    KDGSRLQWHGLWVWUXJJOHGWRKLVIHHW
    $UHFRUGLQJWXEHVKHVDLGLQGLVJXVW
    :KDW"+DULFRXOGEDUHO\KHDULQWKHQRLVH
    7KHPDQVOHIWDUPZDVVWLFNLQJRXWDWDZURQJDQJOHSODLQO\EURNHQ
    ,,DJUHHGZLWK\RXUHYHU\ZRUGWKHPDQFURDNHGRXWKLVIDFHDJKDVWO\
    ZKLWH5HDOO\
    

    +DULVIDWKHUKDGGHULVLYHO\UHIHUUHGWRPRVWSXEOLFDIIDLUVDVGXVW
    XSVDELJFORXGRQWKHKRUL]RQDWLQ\VSHFNXQGHUQHDWK+LVOLSKDGFXUOHG
    EDFNLQDIDUPHUVGLVGDLQIRUPDNLQJPRUHRIDWKLQJWKDQLWZDV
    7KHLQFLGHQWDWWKH*UDQG,PSHULDO8QLYHUVLWLHV&ROORTX\KDGEHFRPHD
    JUDQGGXVWXS)XOO\'GWKHVFDQGDO352)6:,)(62&.6)$1EXUJHRQHGZLWK
    HDFKUHSOD\LQJ
    &OHRQFDOOHGWVNWVNLQJDQGFRPPHQWLQJEURDGO\RQKRZZLYHVFRXOGEHD
    EXUGHQLQKLJKRIILFH7KLVZLOOKXUW\RXUFDQGLGDF\,IHDUKHKDGVDLG
    ,PXVWGRVRPHPHQGLQJ
    +DULGLGQRWUHSRUWWKLVWR'RUV&OHRQVKLQWZDVFOHDU,WZDVFRPPRQ
    SUDFWLFHDPRQJ,PSHULDOFLUFOHVWRGLYRUFHRQJURXQGVRIJHQHUDO
    XQVXLWDELOLW\ZKLFKPHDQWXQIDVKLRQDELOLW\,QPDWWHUVRIYDVWSRZHU
    DSSHWLWHIRUPRUHRIWHQRYHUZKHOPHGDOORWKHUHPRWLRQVHYHQORYH
    +HZHQWKRPHLUNHGE\WKLVFRQYHUVDWLRQWRILQG'RUVDWZRUNLQWKH
    NLWFKHQ6KHKDGKHUDUPVRSHQOLWHUDOO\QRWLQJUHHWLQJ
    7KHHSLGHUPLVKXQJORRVHDVLIVKHKDGSXOOHGDWLJKWJORYHKDOIZD\
    RII9HLQVLQWHUODFHGZLWKWKHDUWLILFLDOQHXUDOQHWDQGVKHZDVZRUNLQJZLWK
    WLQ\WRROVDPRQJWKHP6XSSOHVNLQSHHOHGEDFNLQDFXUYHGOLQHGRZQIURP
    HOERZWRZULVWPRLVWFULPVRQDQGLQWULFDWHHOHFWURQLFV6KHZDVZRUNLQJRQ
    WKHDXJPHQWHGZULVWDWKLQ\HOORZFROODUWKDWGLGQRWORRNDVWKRXJKLWFRXOG
    WDNHWKUHHWLPHVWKH QRUPDOKXPDQVLPSDFW
    7KDWIHOORZGDPDJHG\RX"
    1R,GLGLWWRP\VHOIRUUDWKHURYHUGLGLW
    $VSUDLQ"
    6KHVPLOHGZLWKRXWKXPRU0\SLYRWVGRQWVSUDLQ7KHFROODUPRXQWV
    GRQWPHQG,PUHSODFLQJWKHP
    -REVOLNHWKLVLWVQRWWKHSDUWVLWVWKHODERU
    6KHORRNHGDWKLPTXL]]LFDOO\DQGKHGHFLGHGQRWWRSXUVXHWKHMRNH+H
    QRUPDOO\SXWIURPKLVPLQGWKHIDFWWKDWKLVWUXHORYHZDVDURERWRUPRUH
    DFFXUDWHO\DKXPDQLIRUPYDVWO\WHFKQLFDOO\DVVLVWHGKXPDQURERWV\QWKHVLV
    6KHKDGFRPHWRKLPWKURXJK5'DQHHO2OLYDZWKHDQFLHQWSRVLWURQLF
    URERWZKRKDGVDYHG+DULZKHQKHILUVWFDPHWR7UDQWRUDQGUDQDIRXORIQDVW\
    SROLWLFDOIRUFHV6KHKDGEHHQDVVLJQHGDWILUVWDVDERG\JXDUG+HKDGNQRZQ
    ZKDWVKHZDVIURPWKHVWDUWDW OHDVWDSSUR[LPDWHO\EXWWKDWGLGQRWSUHYHQW
    KLPIURPIDOOLQJLQORYHZLWKKHU,QWHOOLJHQFHFKDUDFWHUFKDUPDVLPPHULQJ

    VH[XDOLW\WKHVHZHUHQRWSXUHO\KXPDQIDFHWVKHKDGOHDUQHGE\GLUHFW
    H[DPSOH
    +HJRWKHUDGULQNDVVKHZRUNHGELGLQJKLVWLPH+HKDGFHDVHGWREH
    DPD]HGE\KHUUHSDLUZRUNRIWHQFDUULHGRXWRQDQXWWHUO\XQVDQLWL]HGILHOG
    7KHUHZHUHDQWLPLFURELDOPHWKRGVDYDLODEOHWRWKHKXPDQLIRUPURERWVWKDWFRXOG
    QRWZRUNIRURUGLQDU\KXPDQVVKHKDGVDLG+HKDGQRLGHDKRZWKLVFRXOGEH
    6KHGLVFRXUDJHGIXUWKHUGLVFXVVLRQRIWHQGHIOHFWLQJKLPZLWKSDVVLRQ+HKDG
    WRDGPLWWKDWDVDSOR\WKLVZDVFRPSOHWHO\HIIHFWLYH
    6KHUROOHGKHUVNLQEDFNLQWRSODFHJULPDFLQJDWWKHSDLQ6KHFRXOG
    VKXWRIIZKROHVHFWLRQVRIKHUVXSHUILFLDOQHUYRXVV\VWHPKHNQHZEXWNHSWD
    IHZVWUDQGVDOHUWDVDGLDJQRVWLF7KHWDEVVHOIVHDOHGZLWKSRSVDQGSXUUV
    /HWVVHH6KHSDXVHGIHHOLQJHDFKZULVWLQWXUQ7ZRTXLFNVQDSV
    7KH\ORFNLQILQH
    0RVWSHRSOH\RXNQRZZRXOGILQGWKLVVLJKWTXLWHXQVHWWOLQJ
    7KDWVZK\,GRQWGRLWRQWKHZD\WRZRUN
    9HU\SXEOLFVSLULWHGRI\RX
    7KH\ERWKNQHZVKHZRXOGEHKRXQGHGGRZQLIWKHUHZHUHDQ\VXVSLFLRQRI
    KHUWUXHQDWXUH5RERWVRIDGYDQFHGFDSDELOLW\KDGEHHQLOOHJDOIRUPLOOHQQLD
    7LNWRNVZHUHDFFHSWDEOHSUHFLVHO\EHFDXVHWKH\ZHUHORZJUDGHLQWHOOLJHQFHV
    ULJRURXVO\KHOGEHORZWKHWKUHVKROGRIOHJDOO\GHILQHGVHQWLHQFH9LRODWLQJ
    WKRVHVWDQGDUGVLQPDQXIDFWXUHZDVDFDSLWDOFULPHDQ,PSHULDOYLRODWLRQQR
    H[FHSWLRQV$QGVWURQJDQFLHQWHPRWLRQVEDFNHGXSWKHODZWKH-XQLQ6HFWRU
    ULRWVKDGSURYHGWKDW
    1XPHULFDOVLPXODWLRQVZHUHVLPLODUO\UHVWULFWHG7KDWZDVZK\WKH
    9ROWDLUHDQG-RDQVLPVGHYHORSHGE\WKH1HZ5HQDLVVDQFHKRWKHDGVRQ6DUN
    KDGEHHQFDUHIXOO\WDLORUHGWRVTXHH]HWKURXJKDOJRULWKPLFORRSKROHV
    $SSDUHQWO\WKDW0DUTIHOORZDW$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVKDGVRXSHGXSWKH9ROWDLUH
    DWWKHODVWPLQXWH6LQFHWKHVLPZDVWKHQHUDVHGWKHYLRODWLRQKDGHVFDSHG
    GHWHFWLRQ
    +DULGLGQRWOLNHKDYLQJHYHQDVOLJKWFRQQHFWLRQWRFULPHEXW KHQRZ
    UHDOL]HGWKDWWKLVZDVIRROLVKQHVV$OUHDG\KLVHQWLUHOLIHUHYROYHGDURXQG
    'RUVDKLGGHQSDULDK
    ,PJRLQJWRZLWKGUDZIURPWKH)LUVW0LQLVWHUEXVLQHVVKHVDLG
    GHFLVLYHO\
    6KHEOLQNHG0H
    6KHZDVDOZD\VTXLFN<HV
    :HKDGDJUHHGWKDWWKHULVNRILQFUHDVHGVFUXWLQ\ZDVZRUWKJDLQLQJ
    VRPHSRZHU
    7RSURWHFWSV\FKRKLVWRU\%XW,H[SHFWHGYHU\OLWWOHRIWKHVSRWOLJKW
    WRIDOOXSRQ\RX1RZ
    ,DPDQHPEDUUDVVPHQW
    &RPLQJLQGRZQVWDLUVWKHUHZHUHDGR]HQ'VQRXWVSRLQWLQJDWPH
    7KH\UHZDLWLQJIRU\RX
    ,ZLOOVWD\KHUHWKHQ
    )RUKRZORQJ"
    7KH6SHFLDOVFDQWDNHPHRXWWKURXJKDQHZHQWUDQFH7KH\YHFXWRQH
    DQGLQVWDOOHGDQDJUDYVKDIW
    <RXFDQWDYRLGWKHPIRUHYHUGDUOLQJ
    6KHJRWXSDQGHPEUDFHGKLP(YHQLIWKH\ILQGPHRXW,FDQJRDZD\
    ,I\RXUHOXFN\DQGHVFDSH(YHQLI\RXGR,FDQWOLYHZLWKRXW\RX,
    ZRQW
    ,FRXOGEHWUDQVIRUPHG
    $QRWKHUERG\"
    $GLIIHUHQWRQH6NLQFRUQHDVVRPHQHXUDOVLJQDWXUHVFKDQJHG
    )LOHWKHVHULDO QXPEHUVRIIDQGVHQG\RXEDFN"
    6KHVWLIIHQHGLQKLVDUPV<HV
    :KDWFDQW\RXUNLQGGR"

    :HFDQQRWLQYHQWSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    +HZKLUOHGDZD\IURPKHULQIUXVWUDWLRQDQGVPDFNHGKLVSDOPDJDLQVWD
    ZDOO'DPQLWQRWKLQJLVDVLPSRUWDQWDVXV
    ,IHHOWKHVDPH%XWQRZ,WKLQNLWLVHYHQPRUHLPSRUWDQWIRU\RXWR
    UHPDLQDFDQGLGDWHIRU)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    :K\"+HSDFHGDURXQGWKHLUOLYLQJURRPH\HVGDUWLQJ
    <RXDUHDSOD\HUIRUYHU\KLJKVWDNHV:KRHYHUZLVKHVWRDVVDVVLQDWH
    \RX
    /DPXUN&OHRQEHOLHYHV
    ZLOOSUREDEO\VHHWKDWPHUHO\ZLWKGUDZLQJ\RXUFDQGLGDF\LVQRILUP
    VROXWLRQ7KH(PSHURUFRXOGUHLQWURGXFH\RXLQWRWKHJDPHDWDQ\ODWHUWLPH
    ,GRQWOLNHEHLQJWUHDWHGDVDFKHVVSLHFH
    $NQLJKW"\HV,FDQVHH\RXWKDW ZD\'RQRWIRUJHWWKDWWKHUHDUH
    RWKHUVXVSHFWVIDFWLRQVZKLFKPD\ZLVK\RXRXWRIWKHZD\
    6XFKDV"
    7KH$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWH
    %XWVKHVDVFKRODUOLNHPH
    :DV6KHLVQRZDSOD\HURQWKHFKHVVERDUG
    1RWWKHTXHHQ,KRSH
    'RUVNLVVHGKLPOLJKWO\,VKRXOGPHQWLRQWKDWP\IHUUHWSURJUDPV
    WXUQHGXSDSODXVLELOLW\PDWUL[IRU/DPXUNVEHKDYLRUEDVHGRQKLVSDVW+H
    KDVHOLPLQDWHGDWOHDVWKDOIDGR]HQULYDOVRQKLVULVHWRWKHWRS+HLV
    VRPHWKLQJRIDWUDGLWLRQDOLVWLQPHWKRGDVZHOO
    0\WKDWVFRPIRUWLQJ
    6KHJDYHKLPDQRGGSHQVLYHJODQFH+LVULYDOVZHUHDOONQLIHG7KH
    FODVVLFGLVSDWFKRIKLVWRULFDOLQWULJXH
    ,ZRXOGQWVXVSHFW/DPXUNWRKDYHVXFKDQH\HIRURXU,PSHULDO
    KHULWDJH
    +HLVDFODVVLFLVW,QKLVYLHZ\RXDUHDSDZQRQHEHVWVZHSWIURP
    WKHERDUG
    $UDWKHUEORRGOHVVZD\WRSXWLW
    ,DPWDXJKWDQGEXLOWWRDVVHVVDQGDFWFRROO\
    +RZGR\RXUHFRQFLOH\RXUDELOLW\LQIDFWOHWVQRWSXWWRRILQHD
    SRLQWRQLW\RXUUHOLVKDWWKHSURVSHFWRINLOOLQJDSHUVRQLQP\GHIHQVH"
    7KH=HURWK/DZ
    8P+HUHFLWHG+XPDQLW\DVDZKROHLVSODFHGDERYHWKHIDWHRID
    VLQJOHKXPDQ
    ,GRIHHOSDLQIURP)LUVW/DZLQWHUDFWLRQ
    6RWKH)LUVW/DZQRZPRGLILHGLV$URERWPD\QRWLQMXUHDKXPDQ
    EHLQJRUWKURXJKLQDFWLRQDOORZDKXPDQEHLQJWRFRPHWRKDUPXQOHVVWKLV
    ZRXOGYLRODWHWKH=HURWK/DZRI5RERWLFV"
    ([DFWO\
    7KLVLVDQRWKHUJDPH\RXSOD\:LWKYHU\WRXJKUXOHV
    ,WLVDODUJHUJDPH
    $QGSV\FKRKLVWRU\LVDSRWHQWLDOQHZVHWRIJDPHSODQV"
    ,QDZD\+HUYRLFHVRIWHQHGDQGVKHHPEUDFHGKLP<RXVKRXOGQRW
    WURXEOH\RXUVHOIVR:KDWZHKDYHLVDSULYDWHSDUDGLVH
    %XWWKHGDPQHGJDPHVWKH\DOZD\VJRRQ
    7KH\PXVW
    +HNLVVHG KHUORQJLQJO\EXWVRPHWKLQJLQVLGHKLPVHHWKHGDQGVSXQDQ
    DUPDWXUHZKLUULQJIUXLWOHVVO\LQVXUURXQGLQJGDUNQHVV
    

    <XJRZDVZDLWLQJLQKLVRIILFHWKHQH[WPRUQLQJ)DFHIOXVKHGZLGH
    H\HGKHGHPDQGHG:KDWFDQ\RXGR"
    8KDERXWZKDW"

    7KH QHZV7KH6DIHJXDUGVVWRUPHGWKH%DVWLRQ
    8KRK+DULYDJXHO\UHFDOOHGWKDWD'DKOLWHIDFWLRQKDGVWDJHGD
    PLQRUUHYROWDQGKROHGXSLQDUHGRXEW1HJRWLDWLRQVKDGGUDJJHGRQ<HVDQG
    <XJRKDGWROGKLPDERXWLWVHYHUDOWLPHV,WVDORFDO7UDQWRULDQLVVXH
    LVQWLW"
    7KDWVWKHZD\ZHNHSWLW<XJRVKDQGVIOHZLQHODERUDWHJHVWXUHV
    OLNHELUGVWDNLQJIUHQ]LHGIOLJKW7KHQWKH6DIHJXDUGVFDPHLQ1RZDUQLQJ
    .LOOHGRYHUIRXUKXQGUHG%OHZHPDSDUWEODVWHUVRQIXOOQRZDUQLQJ
    $VWRQLVKLQJ+DULVDLGLQZKDWKHKRSHGZDVDV\PSDWKHWLFWRQH
    ,QIDFWKHGLGQRWFDUHDPLFURJUDPIRURQHVLGHRIWKLVDUJXPHQWRUWKH
    RWKHUDQGGLGQRWNQRZWKHDUJXPHQWVDQ\ZD\+HKDGQHYHUFDUHGIRUWKH
    ZRUOGVGD\WRGD\WXUEXOHQFHZKLFKDJLWDWHGWKH PLQGZLWKRXWWHDFKLQJ
    DQ\WKLQJ7KHZKROHSRLQWRISV\FKRKLVWRU\ZKLFKHPHUJHGIURPKLV
    SHUVRQDOLW\DVPXFKDVKLVDQDO\WLFDELOLW\ZDVWRVWXG\FOLPDWHDQGLJQRUH
    ZHDWKHU
    &DQW\RXGRVRPHWKLQJ"
    :KDW"
    3URWHVWWRWKH(PSHURU
    +HZLOOLJQRUH PH7KLVLVD7UDQWRULDQLVVXHDQG
    7KLVLVDQLQVXOWWR\RXWRR
    ,WFDQWEH7RQRWDSSHDUWRWDOO\RXWRILWKHDGGHG,YH
    GHOLEHUDWHO\NHSWZHOODZD\IURPWKHLVVXH
    %XW/DPXUNGLGWKLV
    7KDWVWDUWOHGKLP:KDW"/DPXUNKDVQRSRZHURQ7UDQWRU+HVDQ
    ,PSHULDO5HJHQW
    &PRQ+DULQRERG\EHOLHYHVWKDWROGVHSDUDWLRQRISRZHUVVWXII,W
    EURNHGRZQORQJDJR
    +DULDOPRVWVDLG,WGLG"EXWMXVWLQWLPHUHDOL]HGWKDW<XJRZDV
    ULJKW+HKDGVLPSO\QRWDGGHGXSWKHHIIHFWVRIWKH ORQJVORZHURVLRQLQ
    WKH,PSHULDOVWUXFWXUHV7KRVHHQWHUHGDVIDFWRUVRQWKHULJKWKDQGVLGHRI
    WKHHTXDWLRQVEXWKHQHYHUWKRXJKWRIWKHGHFD\LQVROLGORFDOWHUPV6R
    \RXWKLQNLWVDPRYHWRJDLQLQIOXHQFHRQWKH+LJK&RXQFLO"
    0XVWEH <XJRIXPHG7KRVH5HJHQWVWKH\GRQWOLNHXQUXO\IRON
    OLYLQQHDUHP7KH\ZDQW7UDQWRUQLFHDQGRUGHUO\HYHQLISHRSOHJHW
    WUDPSOHG
    +DULYHQWXUHG7KHUHSUHVHQWDWLRQLVVXHDJDLQLVLW"
    'DPQULJKW:HJRW'DKOLWHVDOORYHU0XVFOH6KRDOV6HFWRU%XWFDQZH
    JHWDUHSUHVHQWDWLYH"+HOOQR*RWWREHJDQGSOHDG
    ,,ZLOOGRZKDW,FDQ+DULKHOGXSKLVKDQGVWRFXWRIIWKH
    WLUDGH
    7KH(PSHURUKHOOVWUDLJKWHQWKLQJVRXW
    +DULNQHZIURPGLUHFWREVHUYDWLRQWKDWWKH(PSHURUZRXOGGRQR VXFK
    WKLQJ+HFDUHGQRWKLQJRIKRZ7UDQWRUZDVUXQDVORQJDVKHFRXOGVHHQR
    EXUQLQJGLVWULFWVIURPWKHSDODFH&OHRQKDGRIWHQUHPDUNHG,DP(PSHURURI
    DJDOD[\QRWDFLW\
    <XJROHIWDQG+DULVGHVNFKLPHG,PSHULDO6SHFLDOVFDSWDLQWRVHH
    \RXVLU
    ,WROGWKHPWRUHPDLQRXWVLGH
    +HUHTXHVWVDXGLHQFHEHDULQJDPHVVDJH
    +DULVLJKHG+HKDGPHDQWWRJHWVRPHWKLQNLQJGRQHWRGD\
    7KHFDSWDLQHQWHUHGVWLIIO\DQGUHIXVHGDFKDLU,DPKHUHWR
    UHVSHFWIXOO\IRUZDUGWKHUHFRPPHQGDWLRQVRIWKH6SHFLDOV%RDUG$FDGHPLFLDQ
    $OHWWHUZRXOGVXIILFH,QIDFWGRWKDWVHQGPHDQRWH,KDYHZRUN
    WR
    6LUPRVWUHVSHFWIXOO\,PXVWGLVFXVVWKLV
    +DULVDQNLQWRKLVFKDLUDQGZDYHGSHUPLVVLRQ7KHPDQORRNHG
    XQFRPIRUWDEOHVWDQGLQJVWLIIO\DVKHVDLG7KHERDUGUHTXHVWVWKDWWKH

    $FDGHPLFLDQVZLIHQRWDFFRPSDQ\KLPWRVWDWHIXQFWLRQV
    $KVRVRPHRQHKDV\LHOGHGWRSUHVVXUH
    ,WLVIXUWKHUGLUHFWHGWKDW\RXUZLIHQRWEHDOORZHGLQWRWKHSDODFHDW
    DOO
    :KDW"7KDWVHHPVH[WUHPH
    ,DPVRUU\WREHDUVXFKDPHVVDJHVLU,ZDVWKHUHDQG,WROGWKH
    ERDUGWKDWWKHODG\KDGJRRGUHDVRQWREHFRPHDODUPHG
    $QGWREUHDNWKHIHOORZVDUP
    7KHFDSWDLQDOPRVWDOORZHGKLPVHOIDVPLOH*RWWRDGPLWVKHVIDVWHU
    WKDQDQ\ERG\,YHHYHUVHHQ
    $QG\RXUHZRQGHULQJZK\DUHQW\RX":KRZDVWKHIHOORZ"
    7KHFDSWDLQVEURZIXUURZHG/RRNVWREHD6SLUDO$FDGHPLFLDQRQH
    JUDGHDERYH\RXVLU%XWVRPHVD\KHVPRUHDSROLWLFDOW\SH
    +DULZDLWHGEXWWKHPDQVDLGQRPRUHMXVWORRNHGDVWKRXJKKHZDQWHG
    WR$OOLHGZLWKZKDWIDFWLRQ"
    0LJKWEHWKDW/DPXUNVLU
    $Q\HYLGHQFH"
    1RVVLU
    +DULVLJKHG3ROLWLFVZDVQRWRQO\DQLQH[DFWFUDIWLWVHOGRPKDGDQ\
    UHOLDEOHGDWDHLWKHU9HU\ZHOO0HVVDJHUHFHLYHG
    7KHFDSWDLQOHIWTXLFNO\ZLWKYLVLEOHUHOLHI%HIRUH+DULFRXOGZDYH
    KLVFRPSXWHULQWROLIHDGHOHJDWLRQIURPKLVRZQIDFXOW\VKRZHGXS7KH\
    ILOHGLQVLOHQWO\WKHSRUWDOFUDFNOLQJDVLWLQVSHFWHGHDFKRIWKHP+DUL
    FDXJKWKLPVHOIVPLOLQJDWWKHSURFHGXUH,IWKHUH ZDVDSURIHVVLRQOHDVW
    OLNHO\WR\LHOGDQDVVDVVLQLWKDGWREHWKHPDWKLVWV
    :HDUHKHUHWRVXEPLWRXUFRQVLGHUHGRSLQLRQD3URIHVVRU$DQJRQVDLG
    IRUPDOO\
    'RVR +DULVDLG1RUPDOO\KHZRXOGGHSOR\KLVVNLPS\VNLOOVDQGGRD
    ELWRIVRFLDOPHQGLQJKHKDGEHHQQHJOHFWLQJXQLYHUVLW\EXVLQHVVODWHO\
    VWHDOLQJWLPHIURPEXUHDXFUDWLFFKRUHVWRGHYRWHWRHTXDWLRQV
    $DQJRQVDLG)LUVWUXPRUVRIDWKHRU\RIKLVWRU\KDYHEURXJKWVFRUQ
    WRRXUGHSDUWPHQW:H
    7KHUHLVQRVXFKWKHRU\2QO\VRPHGHVFULSWLYHDQDO\VLV
    $QRXWULJKWGHQLDOFRQIXVHG$DQJRQEXWKHSORZHGDKHDG8KVHFRQGZH
    GHSORUHWKHDSSDUHQWFKRLFHRI\RXUDVVLVWDQW<XJR$PDU\ODVGHSDUWPHQW
    KHDGVKRXOG\RXUHVLJQ,WLVDQDIIURQWWRVHQLRUIDFXOW\YDVWO\VHQLRU
    DERYHDMXQLRUPDWKLVWRIVKDOOZHVD\PLQLPDOVRFLDOEHDULQJ
    0HDQLQJ"+DULVDLGRPLQRXVO\
    :HGRQRWEHOLHYHSROLWLFVVKRXOGHQWHULQWRDFDGHPLFGHFLVLRQV7KH
    LQVXUUHFWLRQRI'DKOLWHVZKLFK$PDU\OKDVYRFDOO\VXSSRUWHGDQGZKLFKKDV
    QRZEHHQSXWGRZQRQO\WKURXJK,PSHULDOUHVROYHDQGDFWXDODUPHGIRUFHPDNHV
    KLPXQVXLWDEOH
    (QRXJK<RXUWKLUGSRLQW
    7KHUHLVWKHPDWWHURIWKHDVVDXOWXSRQDPHPEHURIRXUSURIHVVLRQ
    $PHPEHURKWKHIHOORZP\ZLIH"
    ,QGHHGDQLQGLJQLW\ZLWKRXWSDUDOOHODQRXWUDJHE\DPHPEHURI\RXU
    IDPLO\,WPDNHV\RXUSRVLWLRQKHUHXQWHQDEOH
    ,IVRPHRQHKDGSODQQHGWKHLQFLGHQWWKH\ZHUHFHUWDLQO\JHWWLQJWKHLU
    PLOHDJHRXWRILW,UHMHFWWKDW
    3URIHVVRU$DQJRQVH\HVEHFDPHIOLQW\7KHRWKHUIDFXOW\KDGEHHQ
    VKXIIOLQJDURXQGXQHDV\DQGQRZZHUHEXQFKHGEHKLQGKLP+DULKDGQRGRXEWV
    DERXWZKRWKLVJURXSZDQWHGWREHWKHQH[WFKDLUPDQ,VKRXOGWKLQNWKDWD
    YRWHRIQR FRQILGHQFHE\WKHIXOOIDFXOW\LQDIRUPDOPHHWLQJ
    'RQWWKUHDWHQPH
    ,DPPHUHO\SRLQWLQJRXWWKDWZKLOH\RXUDWWHQWLRQLVGLUHFWHG
    HOVHZKHUH
    7KH)LUVW0LQLVWHUVKLS

    \RXFDQVFDUFHO\EHH[SHFWHGWRFDUU\RXW\RXUGXWLHV
    6NLSLW7RKROGDIRUPDOPHHWLQJWKHFKDLUPDQPXVWFDOORQH
    7KHEXQFKRISURIHVVRUVUXVWOHGEXWQRERG\VDLGDQ\WKLQJ
    $QG,ZRQW
    <RXFDQWJRIRUORQJZLWKRXWFDUU\LQJRXWEXVLQHVVZKLFKUHTXLUHVRXU
    FRQVHQW$DQJRQVDLGVKUHZGO\
    ,NQRZ/HWVVHHKRZORQJWKDWFDQEH
    <RXUHDOO\PXVWUHFRQVLGHU:H
    2XW
    :KDW"<RXFDQQRW
    2XW*R
    7KH\ZHQW
    

    ,WLVQHYHUHDV\WRGHDOZLWKFULWLFLVPHVSHFLDOO\ZKHQWKHUHLVHYHU\
    FKDQFHWKDWLWPLJKWEHULJKW
    $VLGH IURPWKHHWHUQDOPDQHXYHULQJIRUSRVLWLRQDQGVWDWXV+DULNQHZ
    WKDWKLVIHOORZPHULWRFUDWVIURPWKH$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWHWRWKHPHPEHUVRIKLV
    RZQGHSDUWPHQWZLWKOHJLRQVLQEHWZHHQKDGGHHSO\IHOWJURXQGVIRUREMHFWLQJ
    WRZKDWKHZDVGRLQJ
    7KH\KDGFDXJKWDZKLIIRISV\FKRKLVWRU\ZDIWHGE\UXPRU7KDWDORQH
    SXWWKHLUKDFNOHVXSVWLIIDQGVHQVLWLYH7KH\FRXOGQRWDFFHSWWKH
    SRVVLELOLW\WKDWKXPDQLW\FRXOGQRWFRQWUROLWVRZQIXWXUHWKDWKLVWRU\ZDV
    WKHUHVXOWRIIRUFHVDFWLQJEH\RQGWKHKRUL]RQVRI PHUHPRUWDOPHQ&RXOGWKH\
    DOUHDG\EHVQLIILQJDWDWUXWK+DULNQHZIURPHODERUDWHGHFDGHVORQJVWXG\
    WKDWWKH(PSLUHKDGHQGXUHGEHFDXVHRILWVKLJKHUPHWDQDWXUHQRWWKHYDOLDQW
    DFWVRILQGLYLGXDOVRUHYHQRIZRUOGV"
    3HRSOHRIDOOVWULSHVEHOLHYHGLQKXPDQVHOIGHWHUPLQDWLRQ8VXDOO\WKH\
    VWDUWHGIURPDJXWIHHOLQJWKDWWKH\DFWHGRQWKHLURZQWKDWWKH\KDGUHDFKHG
    WKHLURSLQLRQVRQWKHEDVLVRILQWHUQDOUHDVRQLQJWKDWLVWKH\DUJXHGIURP
    WKHSUHPLVHVRIWKHSDUDGLJPLWVHOI7KLVZDVFLUFXODURIFRXUVHEXWWKDW
    GLGQRWPDNHVXFKDUJXPHQWVZURQJRUHYHQLQHIIHFWXDO$VSHUVXDVLRQWKH
    IHHOLQJRIEHLQJLQFRQWUROZDVSRZHUIXO(YHU\RQHZDQWHGWREHOLHYHWKH\ZHUH
    PDVWHUVRIWKHLURZQIDWH/RJLFKDGQRWKLQJWRGRZLWKLW
    $QGZKRZDVKHWRVD\WKH\ZHUHZURQJ"
    +DUL"
    ,WZDV<XJRORRNLQJDELWWLPLG&RPHLQIULHQG
    :HJRWDIXQQ\UHTXHVWMXVWDPLQXWHDJR6RPHUHVHDUFKLQVWLWXWH,
    QHYHUKHDUGRIRIIHULQXVVLJQLILFDQWPRQH\
    )RUZKDW"0RQH\ZDVDOZD\VKDQG\
    ,QUHWXUQIRUWKHEDVHILOHRQWKRVHVLPVIURP6DUN
    9ROWDLUHDQG-RDQ"7KHDQVZHULVQR:KRZDQWVWKHP"
    'XQQR:HJRWHPDOOILOHGDZD\7KHRULJLQDOV
    )LQGRXWZKRVDVNLQJ
    ,WULHG&DQWWUDFHWKHSURPSW
    8PPP7KDWVRGG
    7KDWVZK\,WKRXJKW ,GWHOO\RX6PHOOVIXQQ\
    .HHSXSDWUDFLQJSURJUDPLQFDVHWKH\DVNDJDLQ
    <HVVLU$QGDERXWWKH'DKOLWH%DVWLRQ
    *LYHLWDUHVW
    ,PHDQORRNDWKRZWKH,PSHULDOVVTXDVKHGWKDW-XQLQPHVV
    +DULOHW<XJRJRRQ+HKDGORQJDJRPDVWHUHGWKHDFDGHPLFDUWRI
    DSSHDULQJWRSD\UDSWDWWHQWLRQZKLOHKLVPLQGZRUNHGDVSLUDODUPDZD\
    +HNQHZKHZRXOGKDYHWRVSHDNWRWKH(PSHURUDERXWWKH'DKOLWHPDWWHU
    DQGQRWRQO\WRFRXQWHU/DPXUNVPRYHDQDXGDFLRXVRQHZLWKLQWKH
    WUDGLWLRQDOO\LQYLRODWHUHDOPRI7UDQWRU$TXLFNEORRG\VROXWLRQWRDWRXJK

    LVVXH&OHDQEUXWDO
    7KH'DKOLWHVKDGDFDVHWKH\ZHUHXQGHUUHSUHVHQWHG$QGXQSRSXODU$QG
    UHDFWLRQDU\
    7KHIDFWWKDW'DKOLWHVH[FHSWIRUSURGLJLHVOLIWHGXSE\WKHVFUXIIRI
    WKHLUQHFNOLNH<XJRZHUHKRVWLOHWRWKHXVXDOLQVWLQFWVRIDVFLHQWLILF
    PLQGPDGHQRGLIIHUHQFH
    ,QIDFW+DULZDVEHJLQQLQJWRGRXEWZKHWKHUWKHVWLIIIRUPDO
    VFLHQWLILFHVWDEOLVKPHQWZDVZRUWK\RIKLJKUHJDUGDQ\ORQJHU$OODURXQGKLP
    KHVDZFRUUXSWLRQRIWKHLPSDUWLDOLW\RIVFLHQFHIURPWKHERRQVPDQVKLS
    QHWZRUNLQJWRWKHFXUU\LQJRI,PSHULDOVFUDSVZKLFKSDVVHGIRUDSURPRWLRQ
    V\VWHP
    -XVW\HVWHUGD\KHKDGEHHQYLVLWHGE\D'HDQRI$GMXVWPHQWVZKRKDG
    DGYLVHGZLWKRLO\ORJLFWKDW+DULXVHVRPHRIKLV,PSHULDOSRZHUWRFRQIHUD
    ERRQXSRQDSURIHVVRUZKRKDGGRQHYHU\OLWWOHZRUNEXWZKRKDGIDPLO\WLHV
    WRWKH+LJK&RXQFLO
    7KHGHDQKDGVDLGTXLWHVLQFHUHO\'RQW\RX WKLQNLWLVLQWKHEHWWHU
    LQWHUHVWVRIWKHXQLYHUVLW\WKDW\RXJUDQWDVPDOOERRQWRRQHZLWK
    LQIOXHQFH":KHQ+DULGLGQRWKHQRQHWKHOHVVFDOOHGWKHIHOORZWRWHOOKLP
    ZK\
    7KHGHDQZDVDVWRQLVKHGZLWKVXFKKRQHVW\2QO\ODWHUGLG+DULGHFLGH
    WKDWWKH GHDQZDVULJKWZLWKLQKLVRZQORJLFV\VWHP,IERRQVZHUHPHUH
    EHQHILWVVLPSOHODUJHVVWKHQZK\QRWFRQIHUWKHPZKROO\RQSROLWLFDO
    JURXQGV",WZDVDQDOLHQZD\RIWKLQNLQJEXWFRQVLVWHQWKHKDGWRDGPLW
    +DULVLJKHG:KHQ<XJRSDXVHGLQKLVYHKHPHQWWLUDGH+DULVPLOHG1R
    ZURQJUHVSRQVH$ZRUULHGIURZQWKHUHWKDWGLGLW<XJRODXQFKHGEDFNLQWR
    UDSLGWDONDUPVWDNLQJZLQJHSLWKHWVVWDFNHGWRLPSUREDEOHKHLJKWV
    +DULUHDOL]HGWKDWWKHPHUHH[SRVXUHWRSROLWLFVDVLWWUXO\ZDVWKH
    EUXWDOVWUXJJOHRIEOLQGVZDUPVLQVKDGRZKDGUDLVHGGRXEWVDERXWKLVRZQ
    UDWKHUVPXJSRVLWLRQV:DVWKHVFLHQFHKHKDGVRILUPO\EHOLHYHGLQEDFNRQ
    +HOLFRQWUXO\DVXVHIXOWRSHRSOHOLNHWKH'DKOLWHVDVKHLPDJLQHG"
    6RKLVPXVLQJFDPHDURXQGWRKLVHTXDWLRQV&RXOGWKH(PSLUHHYHUEH
    GULYHQE\UHDVRQDQGPRUDOGHFLVLRQUDWKHUWKDQSRZHUDQGZHDOWK"7KHRFUDFLHV
    KDGWULHGDQGIDLOHG6FLHQWRFUDFLHVUDWKHUPRUHUDUHO\KDGEHHQWRRULJLG
    WRODVW
    DQG,VDLGVXUH+DULFDQGRWKDW<XJRILQLVKHG
    8K ZKDW"
    %DFNWKH$OSKRVRSODQIRU'DKOLWHUHSUHVHQWDWLRQRIFRXUVH
    ,ZLOOWKLQNDERXWLW+DULVDLGWRFRYHU0HDQZKLOHOHWVKHDUD
    UHSRUWRQWKDWORQJHYLW\DQJOH\RXZHUHSXUVXLQJ
    ,JDYHLWWRWKUHHRIWKRVHQHZUHVHDUFKDVVLVWDQWV<XJRVDLG
    VREHUO\KLV'DKOLWHHQHUJLHVH[SHQGHG7KH\FRXOGQWPDNHVHQVHRILW
    ,I\RXUHDORXV\KXQWHUWKHZRRGVDUHDOZD\VHPSW\
    <XJRVVWDUWOHGORRNPDGH+DULZRQGHULIKHZDVJHWWLQJDELWFUXVW\
    3ROLWLFVZDVWDNLQJLWVWROO
    6R,ZRUNHGWKHORQJHYLW\IDFWRULQWRWKHHTXDWLRQVMXVWWRVHH+HUH
    KHVOLGDQHOOLSVRLGDOGDWDFRUHLQWR+DULVGHVNUHDGHUZDWFKZKDW
    KDSSHQV
    2QHSHUVLVWHQWKHULWDJHRISUHDQWLTXLW\ZDVWKHVWDQGDUG*DODFWLF<HDU
    XVHGE\DOOZRUOGVRIWKH,PSHULXPLQRIILFLDOEXVLQHVV+DULKDGDOZD\V
    ZRQGHUHG:DVLWDVLJQDWXUHRI(DUWKVRUELWDOSHULRG":LWKLWVWZHOYHEDVHG
    \HDURIWZHOYHPRQWKVHDFKRIWZHQW\HLJKWGD\VLWVXJJHVWHGDVFDQGLGDWH
    ZRUOGVDPHUHIURPWKHPLOOLRQRIWKH(PSLUH<HWVSLQV
    SUHFHVVLRQVDQGVDWHOOLWHUHVRQDQFHVSHUWXUEHGDOOSODQHWDU\SHULRGV1RWD
    VLQJOHZRUOGRIWKRVHILWWKH*(FDOHQGDUH[DFWO\2YHU
    FDPHTXLWHFORVH
    <XJRVWDUWHGH[SODLQLQJKLVUHVXOWV2QHFXULRXVIHDWXUHRI(PSLUH
    KLVWRU\ZDVWKHKXPDQOLIHVSDQ,WZDVVWLOODERXWO\HDUVEXWVRPHHDUO\

    ZULWLQJVVXJJHVWHGWKDWWKHVHZHUHQHDUO\WZLFHDVORQJDVWKHSULPRUGLDO
    \HDU DVRQHWH[WKDGLW ZKLFKZDVQDWXUDOWRKXPDQV,IVRSHRSOHOLYHG
    QHDUO\WZLFHDVORQJDVLQSUH,PSHULDOHUDV,QGHILQLWHH[WHQVLRQRIWKH
    OLIHVSDQZDVLPSRVVLEOHELRORJ\DOZD\VZRQLQWKHHQG1HZPDODGLHVPRYHG
    LQWRWKHQLFKHSURYLGHGE\WKHKXPDQERG\
    ,JRWWKHEDVLFVRQWKLVIURP'RUVVKDUSODG\<XJRVDLG:DWFKWKLV
    GDWDIODVK&XUYHVSURMHFWLRQVVOLGLQJVKHHWVRIFRUUHODWLRQV
    7KHFROOLVLRQEHWZHHQELRORJLFDOVFLHQFHDQGKXPDQFXOWXUHZDVDOZD\V
    LQWHQVHRIWHQGDPDJLQJ,WXVXDOO\OHGWRDIUHHPDUNHWSROLF\LQZKLFK
    SDUHQWVFRXOGVHOHFWGHVLUDEOHWUDLWVIRUWKHLUFKLOGUHQ
    6RPHRSWHG IRUORQJHYLW\LQFUHDVLQJWRWKHQHYHQ\HDUV:KHQD
    PDMRULW\ZHUHORQJOLYHGVXFKSODQHWDU\VRFLHWLHVIDOWHUHG:K\"
    6R,WUDFHGWKHHTXDWLRQVZDWFKLQJIRURXWVLGHLQIOXHQFHV<XJRZHQW
    RQ*RQHZDVWKHIHYHUHG'DKOLWHKHUHZDVWKHEULOOLDQFHWKDWKDGPDGH+DUL
    SOXFN<XJRRXWRIDVZHOWHULQJGHHSOD\HUMREGHFDGHVDJR
    7KURXJKWKHHTXDWLRQVJUDFHIXOGHFHSWLYHVLQXRVLW\KHKDGIRXQGD
    FXULRXVUHVRQDQFH7KHUHZHUHXQGHUO\LQJF\FOHVLQHFRQRPLFVDQGSROLWLFV
    ZHOOXQGHUVWRRGRIDERXWWR\HDUV
    :KHQWKHKXPDQOLIHVSDQUHDFKHGWKRVHUDQJHVDGHVWUXFWLYHIHHGEDFN
    EHJDQ0DUNHWVEHFDPHMDJJHGODQGVFDSHVSHDNLQJDQGSOXQJLQJ&XOWXUHV
    OXUFKHGIURPH[WUDYDJDQWH[FHVVWRSXULWDQLFDOFRQVWULFWLRQ:LWKLQDIHZ
    FHQWXULHVFKDRVGHVWUR\HGPRVWRIWKHELRVFLHQFHFDSDELOLW\RUHOVH
    UHOLJLRXVUHVWULFWLRQVVPRWKHUHGLW7KHPHDQOLIHVSDQVOLGGRZQDJDLQ
    +RZVWUDQJH+DULVDLGREVHUYLQJWKHVHYHUHFXUYHVRIWKHF\FOHV
    WKHLUDUFVFUDVKLQJLQWRVSOLQWHUHGVSRNHV,YHDOZD\VZRQGHUHGZK\ZHGRQW
    OLYHORQJHU
    7KHUHVJUHDWVRFLDOSUHVVXUHDJDLQVWLW1RZZHNQRZZKHUHLWFRPHV
    IURP
    6WLOO,GOLNHWRKDYHDFHQWXULHVORQJSURGXFWLYHOLIH
    <XJRJULQQHG/RRNDWWKHPHGLDSOD\VOHJHQGVKRORV7KHYHU\ROG
    DUHDOZD\VXJO\JUHHG\PLVHUVWU\LQJWRNHHSHYHU\WKLQJIRUWKHPVHOYHV
    8PPP7UXHXVXDOO\
    $QGP\WKV7KRVHZKRULVHIURPWKHGHDG9DPSLUHV0XPPLHV7KH\UH
    DOZD\VHYLO
    1RH[FHSWLRQV"
    <XJRQRGGHG'RUVSXOOHGVRPHUHDOO\ROGRQHVRXWIRUPH7KHUHZDV
    WKDWDQFLHQWPDUW\U-HVXZDVQWLW"
    6RPHVRUWRIUHVXUUHFWLRQP\WK"
    'RUVVD\V-HVXSUREDEO\ZDVQWDUHDOSHUVRQ7KDWVZKDWWKH
    VFDWWHUHGDQFLHQWWH[WVVD\7KHZKROHP\WKLVSUREO\DFROOHFWLYH
    SV\FKRGUHDP<RXOOQRWLFHRQFHKHZDVEDFNIURPWKHGHDGKHGLGQWVWD\
    DURXQGYHU\ORQJ
    5RVHLQWRKHDYHQZDVQWLW"
    /HIWWRZQLQDKXUU\DQ\ZD\3HRSOHGRQWZDQW\RXDURXQGHYHQLI
    \RXYHEHDWHQWKH5HDSHU
    <XJRSRLQWHGDWWKHFXUYHVFRQYHUJLQJRQGLVDVWHU$WOHDVWZHFDQ
    XQGHUVWDQGZK\PRVWVRFLHWLHVOHDUQQRWWROHWSHRSOHOLYHWRRORQJ
    +DULVWXGLHGWKHHYHQWVXUIDFHV$KEXWZKROHDUQV"
    +XK"3HRSOHRQHZD\RUWKHRWKHU
    %XWQRVLQJOHSHUVRQHYHUNQHZKLVILQJHUMDEEHGWKLV
    7KHNQRZOHGJHJHWVHPEHGGHGLQWDERRVOHJHQGVODZV
    8PPP7KHUHZDVDQLGHDKHUHVRPHWKLQJODUJHUORRPLQJMXVWEH\RQGKLV
    LQWXLWLRQVDQGLWVOLSSHGDZD\+HZRXOGKDYHWRZDLWIRULWWRUHYLVLWKLP
    LIKHHYHUWKHVHGD\VJRWWKHWLPHWROLVWHQWRWKHVPDOOTXLHWYRLFHWKDW
    VOLSSHGE\ZKLVSHULQJOLNHDVKDGRZ\ILJXUHRQDIRJJ\VWUHHW
    +DULVKRRNKLPVHOI*RRGZRUNWKLV,PFRQVLGHUDEO\LPSUHVVHG
    3XEOLVKLW

    7KRXJKWZHZHUHNHHSLQSV\FKRKLVWRU\TXLHW
    7KLVLVDVPDOOHOHPHQW3HRSOHZLOOWKLQNWKHUXPRUVDUHWDUWHGXS
    YHUVLRQVRIWKLV
    3V\FKRKLVWRU\FDQWZRUNLISHRSOHNQRZ
    ,WVVDIH7KHORQJHYLW\HOHPHQWZLOOJHWSOHQW\RIFRYHUDJHDQGVWRS
    VSHFXODWLRQ
    ,WOOEHDFRYHUWKHQDJDLQVWWKH,PSHULDOVQRRSV"
    ([DFWO\
    <XJRJULQQHG)XQQ\KRZWKH\VS\HYHQRQDQRUQDPHQWWRWKH
    ,PSHULXPWKDWVZKDW&OHRQFDOOHG\RXEHIRUHWKH5HJDO5HFHSWLRQODVWZHHN
    +HGLG",GLGQWFDWFKWKDW
    :RUNLQWRRPXFKRQWKRVH%RRQ'HHGV<RXJRWWRKDQGRIIWKDWVWXII
    :HQHHGPRUHUHVRXUFHVIRUSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    :K\QRWMXVWJHWVRPHPRQH\IXQQHOHGWKURXJKIURPWKH(PSHURU"
    /DPXUNZRXOGILQGRXWXVHLWDJDLQVWPH)DYRULWLVPLQWKH+LJK
    &RXQFLOSURFHHGLQJVDQGVRRQ<RXFRXOGZULWH WKHVWRU\\RXUVHOI
    8PPD\EHVR6XUHZRXOGEHDZKROHORWHDVLHUWKRXJK
    7KHLGHDLVWRNHHSRXUKHDGVGRZQ$YRLGVFDQGDOOHW&OHRQGRKLV
    GLSORPDWLFGDQFH
    &OHRQDOVRVDLG\RXZHUHDIORZHURILQWHOOHFW,UHFRUGHGLWIRU
    \RX
    )RUJHWLW)ORZHUVWKDWJURZWRRKLJKJHWSLFNHG
    

    'RUVJRWDVIDUDVWKHSDODFHKLJKYHVWLEXOH7KHUHWKH,PSHULDO*XDUG
    WXUQHGKHUEDFN
    'DPQLWVKHVP\ZLIH+DULVDLGDQJULO\
    6RUU\LWVD3HUHPSWRU\2UGHU WKHEODQGFRXUWRIILFLDOVDLG+DUL
    FRXOGKHDUWKHFDSLWDOOHWWHUV7KHSKDODQ[RI6SHFLDOVDURXQG+DULGLGQRW
    LQWLPLGDWHWKLVIHOORZKHZRQGHUHGLIDQ\RQHFRXOG
    /RRNKHVDLGWR'RUVWKHUHVDELWRIWLPHEHIRUHWKHPHHWLQJ
    /HWVHDWDELWDWWKH+LJK5HFHSWLRQ
    6KHEULVWOHG<RXUHQRWJRLQJLQ"
    ,WKRXJKW\RXXQGHUVWRRG,KDYHWR&OHRQVFDOOHGWKLVPHHWLQJ
    $W/DPXUNVLQVWLJDWLRQ
    6XUHLWVDERXWWKLV'DKOLWHEXVLQHVV
    $QGWKDWPDQ,NQRFNHGGRZQDWWKHUHFHSWLRQKHPLJKWKDYHEHHQ
    LQVWLJDWHGWRGRLWE\
    5LJKW/DPXUN+DULVPLOHG$OOZRUPKROHVOHDGWR/DPXUN
    'RQWIRUJHWWKH$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWH
    6KHVRQP\VLGH
    6KHZDQWVWKHPLQLVWHUVKLS+DUL$OOWKHUXPRUPLOOVVD\VR
    6KHFDQGDPQZHOOKDYHLWKHJUXPEOHG
    ,FDQWOHW\RXJRLQWKHUH
    7KLVLVWKHSDODFH+HVZHSWKLVDUPDWWKHUDQNVRIEOXHDQGJROGLQ
    WKHYDVWSRUWDO,PSHULDOVDOODURXQG
    ,GRQRWOLNHLW
    /RRNZHDJUHHG,GWU\WREOXVWHUSDVWDQGLWIDLOHGMXVWDV,VDLG
    )DLUHQRXJK<RXZRXOGQHYHUSDVVWKHZHDSRQVFKHFNVDQ\ZD\
    +HUWHHWKELWGHOLFDWHO\LQWRKHUORZHUOLSEXWVKHVDLGQRWKLQJ1R
    KXPDQLIRUUQFRXOGHYHUJHWWKURXJKWKHLQWHQVHZHDSRQVVFUHHQKHUH
    +HVDLGFDOPO\6R,JRLQDUJXHPHHW\RXRXWKHUH
    <RXKDYHWKHPDSVDQGGDWD,RUJDQL]HG"
    6XUHFKLSHPEHGGHG,FDQUHDGLWZLWKDWULSOHEOLQN
    +HKDGDFDUU\FKLSHPEHGGHGLQKLVQHFNIRUGDWDKDXOLQJDQLQYDOXDEOH
    DLGDWPDWKLVWFRQIHUHQFHV6WDQGDUGJHDUUHDGLO\DFFHVVHG$PLFURODVHU

    ZURWHDQLPDJHRQWKHEDFNRIWKHUHWLQDFRORUV'DQLIW\JUDSKLFVSDFNDJH
    6KHKDGLQVWDOOHGDORWRIPDSVDQGEDFNJURXQGRQWKH,PSHULXPWKHSDODFH
    UHFHQWOHJLVODWLRQQRWDEOHHYHQWVDQ\WKLQJWKDWPLJKWFRPHXSLQGLVFXVVLRQV
    DQGSURWRFROV
    +HUVHYHUHH[SUHVVLRQGLVVROYHGDQGKHVDZWKHZRPDQEHQHDWK,
    MXVWSOHDVHZDWFK\RXUVHOI
    +HNLVVHGKHURQWKHQRVH$OZD\VGR
    7KH\SDWUROOHGDPRQJWKHOHJLRQVRIKDQJHUVRQZKRWKURQJHGWKH
    YHVWLEXOHVQDJJLQJWKHDSSHWL]HUVZKLFKIORDWHGE\RQSODWWHUV(PSLUHV
    JRLQJEDQNUXSWDQGWKH\FDQDIIRUGWKLV+DULVQLIIHG
    ,WLVWLPHKRQRUHG'RUVVDLG%HDXPXQQWKH%RXQWLIXOGLVOLNHGGHOD\
    LQFRQVXPLQJPHDOVZKLFKZDVLQGHHGKLVSULQFLSDODFWLYLW\+HRUGHUHGWKDW
    HDFKRIKLVHVWDWHVSUHSDUHDOOIRXUGDLO\PHDOVIRUKLPRQWKHFKDQFHWKDW
    KHPLJKWEHWKHUH7KHH[FHVVLVJLYHQRXWWKLVZD\
    +DULZRXOGQRWKDYHEHOLHYHGVXFK DQXQOLNHO\VWRU\KDGLWQRWFRPHIURP
    DQKLVWRULDQ7KHUHZHUHNQRWVRISHRSOHZKRSODLQO\OLYHGKHUHXVLQJVRPH
    PLQRUIXQFWLRQDU\SRVLWLRQIRUDQLQILQLWHEDQTXHW+HDQG'RUVGULIWHGDPRQJ
    WKHPZHDULQJUHIUDFWRU\YDSRUVZKLFKPXGGOHGWKHDSSHDUDQFH5HFRJQLWLRQ
    ZRXOGEULQJSDUDVLWHV
    (YHQDPLGDOOWKLVVZDQN\RXUHWKLQNLQJDERXWWKDW9ROWDLUHSUREOHP
    DUHQW\RX"VKHZKLVSHUHG
    7U\LQJWRILJXUHRXWKRZVRPHERG\FRSLHGKLPLWRXWRIRXUILOHV
    $QGVRPHRQHKDGUHTXHVWHGLWMXVWKRXUVEHIRUH"6KHVFRZOHG:KHQ
    \RXWXUQHGLWGRZQWKH\VLPSO\VWROHLW
    3UREDEO\,PSHULDODJHQWV
    ,GRQWOLNHLW7KH\PD\EHWU\LQJWRLPSOLFDWH\RXIXUWKHULQWKH
    ZKROH-XQLQVFDQGDO
    6WLOOWKHROGDQWLVLPWDERRLVEUHDNLQJGRZQ+HWRDVWHGKHU/HWV
    IRUJHWLW7KHVHGD\VLWVHLWKHUVLPVRUVWLPV
    7KHUHZHUHVHYHUDOWKRXVDQGSHRSOHEHQHDWKWKHVFXOSWHGGRPH7RWHVW
    WKHPDQZRPDQWHDPVKDGRZLQJWKHP'RUVOHGKLPRQDUDQGRPSDWK+DULWLUHG
    UDSLGO\RIVXFKVNXOOGXJJHU\'RUVHYHUWKHVWXGHQWRIVRFLHW\SRLQWHGRXW
    WKHIDPRXV6KHVHHPHGWRWKLQNWKLVZRXOGWKULOOKLPRUDWOHDVWGLVWUDFW
    KLPIURPWKHPHHWLQJWRFRPH$IHZUHFRJQL]HGKLPGHVSLWHWKHUHIUDFWLRQ
    YDSRUVDQGWKH\KDGWRVWRSDQGWDON1RWKLQJRIVXEVWDQFHZDVHYHUVDLGDW
    VXFKIXQFWLRQVRIFRXUVHE\ORQJWUDGLWLRQ
    7LPHWRJRLQ'RUVZDUQHGKLP
    6SRWWHGWKHVKDGRZV"
    7KUHH,WKLQN,IWKH\IROORZ\RXLQWRWKHSDODFH,OOWHOOWKH
    6SHFLDOVFDSWDLQ
    'RQWZRUU\1RZHDSRQVDOORZHGLQWKHSDODFHUHPHPEHU
    3DWWHUQVERWKHUPHPRUHWKDQSRVVLELOLWLHV7KHDVVDVVLQDWLRQWDE
    GHOD\HGGHWRQDWLRQMXVWORQJHQRXJKIRU\RXWRGLVFDUGLW%XWLWGLGPDNHPH
    ZDU\HQRXJKWRDWWDFNWKDWSURIHVVRU
    :KLFKJRW\RXEDQQHGIURPWKHSDODFH+DULFRPSOHWHGWKHWKRXJKW
    <RXUHJLYLQJSHRSOHDORWRIFUHGLWIRULQWULFDWHPDQHXYHUV
    <RXKDYHQWUHDGYHU\PXFKKLVWRU\RI,PSHULDOSROLWLFVKDYH\RX"
    7KDQN*RGQR
    ,WZRXOGRQO\WURXEOH\RXVKHVDLGNLVVLQJKLPZLWKVXGGHQ
    VXUSULVLQJIHUYRU$QGZRUU\LVP\ MRE
    ,OOVHH\RXLQDIHZKRXUV+DULVDLGDVFDVXDOO\DVKHFRXOGPDQDJH
    GHVSLWHDGDUNSUHPRQLWLRQ+HDGGHGWRKLPVHOI,KRSH
    +HHQWHUHGWKHSDODFHSURSHUWKURXJKWKHXVXDODUPVFKHFNVDQGSURWRFRO
    RIILFHUV1RWKLQJQRWHYHQDFDUERQNQLIHRULPSORVLRQQXJJHWFRXOGHVFDSH
    WKHLUPDQ\VQRXWHGVQLIIHUVDQGVTXLQWHUV0LOOHQQLDEHIRUH,PSHULDO
    DVVDVVLQDWLRQKDGEHFRPHVRFRPPRQDVWRUHVHPEOHDVSRUW1RZWUDGLWLRQDQG
    WHFKQRORJ\XQLWHGWRPDNHWKHVHIRUPDORFFDVLRQVXQLTXHO\VDIH7KH+LJK

    &RXQFLOZDVPHHWLQJIRUWKH(PSHURUVUHYLHZVRLQHYLWDEO\WKHUHZHUH
    EDWWDOLRQVRIRIILFLDOVDGYLVRUV0DJLVWHULDOV([WUDRUGLQDU\DQG\HOORZ
    MDFNHWHGKDQJHUVRQ3DUDVLWHVDWWDFKHGWKHPVHOYHVWRKLPZLWKSUDFWLFHG
    JUDFH
    2XWVLGHWKH/\FHXPZDVWKHWUDGLWLRQDO%HQHYROHQW%RXQWLIXORULJLQDOO\
    RQHORQJWDEOHQRZGR]HQVRIWKHPDOOJURDQLQJEHQHDWKULFKIRRGV
    /DUJHVVHYHQEHIRUHEXVLQHVVPHHWLQJVZDVPDQGDWRU\DQDFFHSWDQFHRI
    WKH(PSHURUVEHQHILFHQFH3DVVLQJLWE\ZRXOGEHDQLQVXOW+DULQLEEOHGDWD
    IHZRGGPHQWVRQKLVZD\DFURVVWKH6DJLWWDULXV'RPHZD\1RLV\FURZGVPLOOHG
    UHVWOHVVO\PRVWO\LQWKHVHULHVRIFHUHPRQLDOFORLVWHUVWKDWULPPHGWKH
    GRPHZD\HDFKFXWRIIE\DFRXVWLFFXUWDLQV
    +DULVWHSSHGLQWRDVPDOOVRXQGFKDPEHUDQGIRXQGDVXGGHQUHOHDVHIURP
    WKHGLQ7KHUHKHTXLFNO\UHYLHZHGKLVQRWHVRQWKH&RXQFLODJHQGDQRW
    ZDQWLQJWRDSSHDUDQXWWHUUXEH+LJK&RXUWW\SHVZDWFKHGHYHU\GHYLDWLRQIURP
    SURWRFROZLWKVFRUQ7KHPHGLDWKRXJKQRWDOORZHGLQWKH/\FHXPEX]]HGIRU
    ZHHNVDIWHUVXFKPHHWLQJVUHDGLQJHYHU\JDIIHIRULWVQXDQFHV+DULKDWHGDOO
    WKLVEXWDVORQJDVKHZDVLQWKHJDPHKHPLJKWDVZHOOSOD\
    +HUHFDOOHG'RUVFDVXDOPHQWLRQHDUOLHURI/HRQWKH/LEHUWLQHZKRKDG
    RQFHDUUDQJHGDQHQWLUHIDX[EDQTXHWIRUKLVPLQLVWHUV7KHIUXLWFRXOGEH
    ELWWHQEXWWKHQVQDJJHGWKHXQZDU\JXHVWVWHHWKZKLFKUHPDLQHGILUPO\
    HPEHGGHGXQWLOUHOHDVHGE\DGLJLWDOFRPPDQG7KHFRPPDQGFDPHRIFRXUVH
    RQO\IURPWKH(PSHURUDIWHUVRPHDPXVLQJEHJJLQJDQGJURYHOLQJEHIRUHWKH
    RWKHUJXHVWV5XPRUVSHUVLVWHGRIGDUNHUGHOLJKWVREWDLQHGE\/HRQIURP
    VLPLODUWUDSVWKRXJKLQSULYDWHTXDUWHUV
    +DULEUXVKHGWKURXJKWKHVRXQGFXUWDLQVDQGLQWRWKHROGHUVLGHKDOOV
    OHDGLQJWRWKH/\FHXP+LVUHWLQDOPDSKLJKOLJKWHGWKHVHDQFLHQW
    XQIDVKLRQDEOH URXWHVEHFDXVHIHZFDPHWKLVZD\+LVHQWRXUDJHIROORZHG
    REHGLHQWO\WKRXJKVRPHIURZQHG
    +HNQHZWKHLUVRUWE\QRZ7KH\ZDQWHGWREHVHHQWKHLUSURFHVVLRQDO
    SDUWLQJWKHFURZGVRIPHUH6HFWRUH[HFXWLYHV6DXQWHULQJWKURXJKGLPKDOOV
    ZLWKRXWWKHMRVWOH RIWKHFURZGVGLGQRWKLQJIRUWKHHJR
    7KHUHZDVDOLIHVL]HGVWDWXHRI/HRQDWWKHHQGRIDQDUURZ
    SURFHVVLRQDOFRUULGRUKROGLQJDWUDGLWLRQDOH[HFXWLRQHUVNQLIH+DULVWRSSHG
    DQGORRNHGDWWKHKHDY\EURZHGPDQKLVULJKWKDQGVKRZLQJWKLFNYHLQVZKHUH
    LWKHOGWKHNQLIH,QKLVOHIWDFU\VWDOJOREHRIIRJZLQH7KHZRUNZDV
    IODZOHVVDQGQRGRXEWIODWWHULQJWRWKH(PSHURUZKHQVFXOSWHG7KHNQLIHZDV
    TXLWHUHDOHQRXJKLWVGRXEOHHGJHVJOHDPLQJ
    6RPHFRQVLGHUHG/HRQVUHLJQWKHPRVWDQFLHQWRIWKH*RRG2OG'D\VZKHQ
    RUGHUVHHPHGQDWXUDODQGWKH(PSLUHH[SDQGHGLQWRIUHVKZRUOGVZLWKRXW
    WURXEOH/HRQKDGEHHQEUXWDO\HWZLGHO\ORYHG+DULZDQWHGSV\FKRKLVWRU\WR
    ZRUNEXWZKDWLILWWXUQHGLQWRDWRROWRUHNLQGOHVXFK DSDVW"
    +DULVKUXJJHG7LPHHQRXJKWRFDOFXODWHZKHWKHUWKH(PSLUHFRXOGEH
    VDYHGRQDQ\WHUPVDWDOORQFHSV\FKRKLVWRU\DFWXDOO\H[LVWHG
    +HZHQWLQWRWKH+LJK,PSHULDOFKDPEHUVHVFRUWHGE\WKHULWXDO
    RIILFHUV$KHDGOD\&OHRQ/DPXUNDQGWKHSDQRSO\RIWKH+LJK&RXQFLO
    +HNQHZKHVKRXOGEHLPSUHVVHGE\DOOWKLV6RPHKRZWKRXJKWKHDLURI
    KLJKRSXOHQFHRQO\PDGHKLPPRUHLPSDWLHQWWRWUXO\XQGHUVWDQGWKH(PSLUH$QG
    LIKHFRXOGDOWHULWVFRXUVH
    

    +DULZREEOHGVOLJKWO\DVKHOHIWWKH/\FHXPWKUHHKRXUVODWHU'HEDWH
    ZDVVWLOOLQIXOOFU\EXWKHQHHGHGDEUHDN$OHVVHU0LQLVWHUIRU6HFWRU
    &RUUHODWLRQRIIHUHGWRWDNHKLPWRWKHUHIUHVKPHQWEDWKVDQG+DULJUDWHIXOO\
    DFFHSWHG
    ,GRQWNQRZKRZPXFKPRUHRIWKLV,FDQWDNHKHVDLG
    <RXPXVWDFFRPPRGDWHWRWHGLXPWKHPLQLVWHUVDLGFKHHUIXOO\

    0D\EH,ZLOOGXFNRXW
    1RFRPHUHVW
    +LVFHUHPRQLDOUREHVUHTXLUHGLQWKH/\FHXPZHUHFORVHDQGVZHDW\7KH
    RUQDWHEXFNOHGXJLQWRKLVEHOO\,WZDVELJDQGJDXG\ZLWKDFKURPHG
    UHFHLYHUIRUKLVULWXDOVW\OXVHTXDOO\HPEHOOLVKHGDQGXVHGRQO\LQYRWLQJ
    7KHPLQLVWHUFKDWWHGRQDERXW/DPXUNVDWWDFNRQ+DULZKLFK+DULKDG
    WULHGWRLJQRUH(YHQVRKHKDGEHHQIRUFHGWRULVHWRGHIHQGRUH[SODLQ
    KLPVHOI+HKDGPDGHDSRLQWRINHHSLQJKLVVSHHFKHVVKRUWDQGFOHDUWKRXJK
    WKLVZDVIDUIURPWKHVW\OHRIWKH/\FHXP7KHPLQLVWHUSROLWHO\DOORZHGWKDW
    KHWKRXJKWWKLVZDVUDWKHUDQHUURU
    7KH\ZHQWWKURXJKWKHUHIUHVKHUZKHUHEOXHJRXWVRILRQVGHVFHQGHG
    +DULZDVJUDWHIXOWKDWWDONZDVLPSRVVLEOHWKURXJKDOOWKLVDQGOHWDQ
    HOHFWURVWDWEUHH]HPDVVDJHKLPXQWLOWKH\HYROYHGLQWRGHFLGHGO\HURWLF
    FDUHVVHVDSSDUHQWO\&RXQFLOPHPEHUVSUHIHUUHGWKHLUYLFHVUHDGLO\WRKDQG
    7KHPLQLVWHUZHQWLQSXUVXLWRIVRPHSULYDWHDPXVHPHQWKLVIDFHDOLYH
    ZLWKDQWLFLSDWLRQ+DULGHFLGHGKHZRXOGUDWKHUQRWNQRZZKDWZDVDERXWWR
    WUDQVSLUHDQGPRYHGIDUWKHULQWRDYDSRUFHOO+HUHVWHGWKLQNLQJDVD
    JLQJHUFRORUHGPDWFOHDQHGKLVFKDPEHUHOHPHQWDU\ELRPDLQWHQDQFH+LVPXVFOHV
    VWUHWFKHGDVKHUHIOHFWHGRQWKHJXOIEHWZHHQKLPDQGWKHSURIHVVLRQDOVRIWKH
    /\FHXP
    7R+DULKXPDQNQRZOHGJHZDVODUJHO\WKHXQDUWLFXODWHGH[SHULHQFHVRI
    P\ULDGVQRWWKHIRUPDOOHDUQLQJRIDYRFDOHOLWH0DUNHWVKLVWRU\VKRZHG
    FRQYH\HGWKHSUHIHUHQFHVDQGLGHDVRIWKHPDQ\*HQHUDOO\WKHVHZHUHVXSHULRU
    WRJUDQGLRVHSROLFLHVKDQGHGGRZQIURPWKHWDOHQWDQGZLVGRPRIWKHIHZ<HW
    ,PSHULDOORJLFDVNHGLIDJLYHQDFWLRQZHUHJRRGQRWZKHWKHULWZDV
    DIIRUGDEOHRUKRZPXFKZDVHYHQGHVLUDEOH
    +HWUXO\GLGQRWNQRZKRZWRVSHDNWRWKHVHSHRSOH&OHYHUYHUEDOWXUQV
    DQGDUWIXOGRGJHVKDGVHUYHGZHOOHQRXJKWRGD\EXWVXUHO\WKDWFRXOGQRW
    ODVW
    7KHVHUXPLQDWLRQVKDGGLVWUDFWHGKLP:LWKDVWDUWKHUHDOL]HGKHVKRXOG
    JHWEDFN
    /HDYLQJWKHUHIUHVKHUKHDQJOHGRIIWKH REYLRXVURXWHZKLFKZDV
    WKURQJHGZLWKIXQFWLRQDULHVRQWKURXJKDFRXVWLFYHLOVDQGLQWRWKHVPDOO
    SURFHVVLRQDOKDOOFRQVXOWLQJKLVSDODFHPDSV+HKDGXVHG'RUVFDUU\FKLSD
    GR]HQWLPHVDOUHDG\PRVWO\WRIROORZWKHTXLFNFU\SWLF&RXQFLOGLVFXVVLRQV
    7KHPLFURODVHUZULWWHQ'PDSRQKLVUHWLQDURWDWHGLIKHUROOHGKLVH\HV
    SURYLGLQJSHUVSHFWLYH7KHUHZHUHIHZVWDIIDURXQGPRVWFOXVWHUHGLQ
    DWWHQGDQFHRXWVLGHWKH/\FHXP
    +DULUHDFKHGWKHHQGRIWKHKDOODQGJODQFHGXSDWWKHVWDWXHRI/HRQ
    7KHH[HFXWLRQHUVNQLIHZDVJRQH
    :K\ZRXOGDQ\RQH"
    +DULWXUQHGDQGKXUULHGEDFNWKHZD\KHKDGFRPH
    %HIRUHKHFRXOGUHDFKWKHDFRXVWLFYHLOVDPDQVWHSSHGWKURXJKWKHLU
    LYRU\OXPLQHVFHQFH7KHUHZDVQRWKLQJXQXVXDODERXWWKHPDQH[FHSWWKHZD\KLV
    H\HV IOLFNHGDURXQGILQDOO\IDVWHQLQJRQ+DUL
    7KHUHZDVDERXWWKLUW\PHWHUVEHWZHHQWKHP+DULWXUQHGDVWKRXJKKH
    ZHUHDGPLULQJWKHEDURTXHO\IHVWRRQHGZDOOVDQGZDONHGDZD\+HKHDUGWKH
    RWKHUPDQVERRWVFULVSO\IROORZ
    0D\EHKHZDVEHLQJSDUDQRLGDQG PD\EHQRW+HKDGRQO\WRJHWEDFNWRD
    FURZGDQGDOOWKLVZRXOGGLVVROYHDZD\KHWROGKLPVHOI7KHIRRWVWHSVEHKLQG
    KLPJRWVKDUSHUFORVHU
    +HWXUQHGDQGGXFNHGGRZQDVLGHSDVVDJH$KHDGZDVDULWXDOURRP7KH
    IRRWVWHSVVSHGXS+DULWURWWHGDFURVVWKHFLUFXODUURRPDQGLQWRDQDQFLHQW
    IR\HU1RRQHWKHUH
    'RZQDORQJKDOOZD\KHFRXOGVHHWZRPHQZKRVHHPHGWREHFDVXDOO\
    WDONLQJ+HVWDUWHGWRZDUGWKHPEXWWKH\ERWKEURNHRIIDQGORRNHGDWKLP
    2QHUHDFKHGLQWRKLVSRFNHWDQGSURGXFHGDFRPPDQGEHJDQVSHDNLQJLQWRLW

    +DULEDFNHGDZD\IRXQGDVLGHSDVVDJH+HEROWHGGRZQLW
    :KDWDERXWWKHVXUYHLOODQFHFDPHUDV"(YHQWKHSDODFHKDGWKHP%XWWKH
    RQHDWWKHHQGRIWKLVSDVVDJHKDGDQXQXVXDOFDSRQLW5XQQLQJDIDNHYLHZ
    KHUHDOL]HG
    7KHDQFLHQWSRUWLRQVRIWKH/\FHXPSHULPHWHUZHUHQRWRQO\
    XQIDVKLRQDEOHWKH\ZHUHXQSRSXODWHG+HWURWWHGWKURXJKDQRWKHUH[WUDYDJDQW
    ULWXDOURRP%RRWVZHUHFRPLQJIDVWEHKLQGKLP+HWXUQHGWRWKHULJKWDQGVDZ
    DFURZGGRZQDORQJUDPS
    +H\KH\HOOHG1RERG\ORRNHGKLVZD\+HUHDOL]HGWKH\ZHUHEHKLQGD
    VRXQGYHLO+HVWDUWHGWRZDUGWKHP
    $PDQVWHSSHGRXWRIDQDOFRYHWREORFNWKHZD\7KLVRQHZDVWDOODQG
    OHDQDQGVWDUWHGWRZDUG+DULZLWKDPXVFXODUQRQFKDODQFH/LNHWKHRWKHUVKH
    VDLGQRWKLQJGUHZQRDWWHQWLRQWRKLPVHOI-XVWNHSWFRPLQJ
    +DULDQJOHGOHIWDQGEURNHLQWRDWURW$KHDGOD\WKHUHIUHVKHUKHKDG
    FLUFOHGEDFN3OHQW\RISHRSOHWKHUH,IKHFRXOGUHDFKLW
    2QHORQJSDVVDJHZD\OHGGLUHFWO\WRZDUGWKHUHIUHVKHUV+HWRRNLWDQG
    KDOIZD\GRZQVDZWKDWDSDUW\RIWKUHHZRPHQZHUHWDONLQJLQDGHFRUDWLYH
    QLFKH+HVORZHGDQGWKH\VWRSSHGWDONLQJ7KH\ZRUHIDPLOLDUVWDIIUREHV
    3UREDEO\WKH\ZRUNHGLQWKHUHIUHVKHUV
    7KH\WXUQHGWRZDUGKLPORRNLQJDOLWWOHVXUSULVHG+HRSHQHGKLVPRXWK
    WRVD\VRPHWKLQJDQGWKHQHDUHVWZRPDQVWHSSHGVPDUWO\IRUZDUGDQGJUDEEHG
    KLVDUP
    +HMHUNHGEDFN6KHZDVVWURQJ6KHJULQQHGDWWKHRWKHUVDQGVDLG
    )HOOULJKWLQWRRXU
    +H\DQNHGKLVDUPWRWKHVLGHDQGEURNHKHUJULS6KHFDPHRIIEDODQFH
    DQGKHWRRNDGYDQWDJHRIWKDWWRVKRYHKHULQWRWKHRWKHUWZR2QHODVKHGD
    NLFNDWKLP6KHWZLVWHGKHUKLSWRJHWPRPHQWXPLQWRLWEXWVKHFRXOGQRW
    JHWIXOO\DURXQGKHUFRPSDQLRQDQGLWVWRSSHGVKRUWIXWLOH
    +DULWXUQHGDQGUDQ7KHZRPHQZHUH REYLRXVO\ZHOOWUDLQHGDQGKHGLG
    QRWKDYHPXFKKRSHRIJHWWLQJDZD\+HSOXQJHGDKHDGGRZQWKHORQJSDVVDJHZD\
    :KHQKHJODQFHGEDFNKRZHYHUDOOWKUHHZHUHVWDQGLQJDQGZDWFKLQJKLPJR
    7KLVZDVVRRGGWKDWKHVORZHGWKLQNLQJ7KH\DQGWKHPHQZHUHQRW
    DWWDFNLQJKLPMXVWER[LQJKLPLQ
    ,QWKHVHSXEOLFFRUULGRUVFDVXDOZLWQHVVHVFRXOGHDVLO\SDVVE\7KH\
    ZDQWHGKLPVRPHZKHUHSULYDWH
    +DULFDOOHGXSKLVSDODFHPDS,WSODFHGKLPDVDUHGGRWLQWKHQHDUE\
    IORRUSODQ+HFRXOGVHHWZRVLGHDOOH\V XSDKHDGEHIRUHWKHHQGRIWKH
    SDVVDJHZD\
    ZKHUHQRZWZRPHQVWHSSHGLQWRYLHZDUPVIROGHG
    +DULVWLOOKDGWZRZD\VRXW+HZHQWOHIWLQWRDQDUURZODQHOLQHGZLWK
    DQWLTXHWHVWDPHQWV(DFKZLQNHGRQDQGEHJDQLWVQDUUDWLRQRIYDVWHYHQWVDQG
    JUHDWYLFWRULHVQRZEXULHGEHQHDWKPLOOHQQLDRILQGLIIHUHQFH7KH'V
    IOLFNHUHGZLWKFRORUIXOVSHFWDFOHVDVKHSRXQGHGSDVWWKHP6RQRURXVYRLFHV
    LPSORUHGKLPWRDWWHQGWRWKHLUWDOHV+HZDVSXIILQJKHDYLO\QRZDQGWU\LQJ
    WRIRFXVKLVWKRXJKWV
    ,QWHUVHFWLRQFRPLQJXS+HVKRWWKURXJKLWDQGVDZPHQFORVLQJLQIURP
    WKHULJKW
    +HGRGJHGGRZQDVOLJKWVLGHH[LWXQGHUDSDUWLFLSDWRU\PDXVROHXPWR
    (PSHURU(OLQRU,9DQGVSULQWHGWRZDUGDVHWRIGRRUZD\VKHUHFRJQL]HG7KHVH
    ZHUHWKHUHIUHVKHUERRWKVSDOHGRRUVPDUNHGRQO\ZLWKQXPEHUV7KH0LQLVWHU
    IRU6HFWRU&RUUHODWLRQKDGSRLQWHGWKHPRXWDVWKHYHU\EHVWVXLWDEOHIRU
    SULYDWHDSSRLQWPHQWV
    +DULKDGWRFURVVDVPDOOSLD]]DWRUHDFKWKHQHDUHVWGRRU$PDQFDPH
    UXQQLQJIURPWKHULJKWVD\LQJQRWKLQJ+DULWULHGWKHILUVWGRRULWZDV
    ORFNHG6RZDVWKHVHFRQG7KHPDQZDVQHDUO\RQWRSRIKLP7KHKDQGOHRQWKH
    WKLUGGRRUWXUQHGDQG+DULZHQWWKURXJK
    ,WZDVDWUDGLWLRQDOGRRURQKLQJHV+HWKUHZKLVZHLJKWEDFNLQWRLWWR

    VODPLWVKXW7KHPDQKLWWKHGRRUKHDYLO\DQGJRWDKDQGDURXQGWKHHGJH
    +DULKHDYHGDJDLQVWWKHGRRU7KHPDQKHOGIDVWDQGMDPPHGKLVULJKWIRRW
    EHWZHHQWKHGRRUDQGWKHFDVLQJ
    +DULVKRYHGKDUG7KHJDSEHWZHHQGRRUDQGFDVLQJQDUURZHGWUDSSLQJWKH
    KDQG
    7KHRWKHUPDQZDVVWURQJ+HJUXQWHGDQGVKRYHGEDFNKDUGDQGWKHJDS
    ZLGHQHG
    +DULSXWKLVEDFNDJDLQVWWKHGRRUDQGWKUXVWZLWKKLVOHJV+HKDG
    QRWKLQJWRKHOSKLPDQGWKHULGLFXORXVFHUHPRQLDOUREHVGLGQWKHOS1RWKLQJ
    LQWKHUHIUHVKHUZDVQHDUE\QRWRRO
    +DULUHDFKHGLQWRKLVEXFNOH7KHDQFLHQWYRWLQJVW\OXVVOLSSHGLQWRKLV
    SDOP+HWRRNLWLQKLVULJKWKDQGDQGWZLVWHGDJDLQVWWKHGRRUVKRYLQJZLWK
    KLVULJKWVKRXOGHU7KHQKHSDVVHGWKHVW\OXVWRKLVOHIWKDQGDQGEURXJKWLW
    GRZQZLWKDVDYDJHVWDELQWRWKHPDQVKDQG
    7KHVW\OXVZDVLQVFULEHGDQGHPEHOOLVKHGEXWLWWDSHUHGWRDVOHQGHU
    SRLQW+DULVWUXFNEHWZHHQWKHWKLUGDQGIRXUWKNQXFNOHV+DUG
    $VPDOODUWHULDOSXPSHUVTXLUWHG6KRUWSXOVDWLQJDUFVVKRWRQWRWKH
    GRRUYLYLGUHG7KHPDQFULHG$KDQGOHWJR RIWKHGRRU
    +DULVODPPHGWKHGRRUVKXWDQGIXPEOHGZLWKWKHORFN0DJQHWLFJULGV
    FOLFNHGRQ3DQWLQJKHWXUQHGWRVXUYH\WKHUHIUHVKHU
    ,WZDVRQHRIWKHEHVWDPSOH7ZRVRRWKLQJERRWKVDOLIWFRXFKDQ
    DPSOHVWRFNRIUHIUHVKPHQWV6HYHUDOYDSRUZHOOVZKHUHOX[XULDQWGDOOLDQFHV
    RIWHQRFFXUUHGDVUXPRUKDGLW$JDLQVWWKHIDUZDOODSHUFXVVLYHQRRNIRU
    WKHDWKOHWLF$QGDWKLQVOLWZLQGRZDOVRWUDGLWLRQDORSHQWRDFHUDPLFDQG
    VDQGJDUGHQ,WZDVNHSWDVDUHPLQGHURIHUDVZKHQEHLQJWUDSSHGLQ KHUHZLWK
    XQVDYRU\SHUVRQVZDVEHVWDYRLGHGE\DTXLFNH[LW
    +DULKHDUGDVOLJKWVQLFNDJDLQVWWKHGRRU3UREDEO\DGHSRODUL]HU
    ILWWLQJLQWRSODFHWRXQORFNWKHPDJQHWLFV+HFRQVLGHUHGWKHVOLWZLQGRZ
    

    $PDQFDPHFDUHIXOO\LQWRWKHUHIUHVKHUFKDPEHU+HZRUHDVLPSOH
    ,PSHULDOVHUYDQWVWXQLFZKLFKDOORZHGIUHHGRPRIPRYHPHQW3HUIHFWIRUTXLFN
    ZRUN+HFDUULHGWKHNQLIHIURPWKH/HRQVWDWXH
    +HFORVHGWKHGRRUEHKLQGKLPZLWKRQHKDQGDQGORFNHGLWDOOWKHZKLOH
    NHHSLQJKLVH\HVRQWKHURRPDQGWKHNQLIHDWWKHUHDG\7KRXJKKHZDVODUJH
    KHPRYHGZLWKDQHDV\JUDFH0HWKRGLFDOO\KHFKHFNHGLQWKHERRWKVDQGYDSRU
    ZHOOVDQGHYHQWKHSHUFXVVLYHQRRN1RRQHWKHUH+HOHDQHGRXWWKHVOLW
    ZLQGRZZKLFKZDVWKURZQIXOO\RSHQ7KHQDUURZZLQGRZZDVQRWODUJHHQRXJKWR
    OHWKLPSDVVKHZDVPDVVLYHEHQHDWKKLVOLJKWEOXHVWDIIXQLIRUP
    +HVWRRGEDFNDQGVSRNHLQWRKLVZULVWFRPP+HJRWRXWLQWRWKH
    JDUGHQ&DQWVHHKLPIURPKHUH<RXJRWWKDWEORFNHG"
    +HSDXVHGDPRPHQWOLVWHQLQJWRDQLQWHUQDOYRLFHDQGVDLGFXUWO\
    &DQWILQGKLP"&RXUVH\RXFDQW,WROG\RXZHVKRXOGQWFXWWKHVQRRSVLQ
    WKLVDUHD
    $QRWKHUSDXVH6XUH,NQRZLWVDVHFXUHMREHYHQJRWLWVRZQ5'
    QXPEHUDQGDOOQRUHFRUGLQJ VQRRSVEXW
    7KHPDQSDFHGDQJULO\:HOO\RXMXVWEHGDPQVXUHDOOWKHZD\VRXWDUH
    FRYHUHG7KRVHJDUGHQVDUHDOOFRQQHFWHG
    $QRWKHUSDXVH*RWWKHVQLIIHUVRQ"&DPHUDV"*RRG<RXJX\VPHVVWKLV
    XS,OO+HOHWKLVYRLFHWUDLORIILQWRDJURZO
    +HJDYHWKHURRPRQHODVWORRNDQGXQORFNHGWKHPDJQHWLFV$PDQZLWKD
    EORRGVRDNHGVOHHYHVWRRGRXWVLGHMXVWZLWKLQYLHZ
    <RXUHGULSSLQVWXSLGWKHNQLIHFDUULHUVDLG+ROGWKDWDUPXS
    KLJKDQGJHWDZD\IURPKHUH6HQGDFOHDQXSFUHZWRR
    7KHRWKHUPDQVDLG:KHUHGKH
    .QHZ,VKRXOGQWKDYH\RXRQWKLVRQH*RGGDPQDPDWHXU7KHNQLIHPDQ

    OHIWDWDUXQ
    $OOWKLVKDGVHHPHGWRWDNHIRUHYHU6HFRQGVWLFNHGE\DV+DULKHOGRQWR
    DFHLOLQJWLOHZLWKDOOKLVVWUHQJWK
    ,QGDUNQHVVKHZDVO\LQJDFURVVVXSSRUWVWUXWVGLUHFWO\RYHUDVRRWKLQJ
    ERRWK+HFRXOGVHHGRZQWKURXJKDQDUURZVOLW)URPEHORZKHKRSHGWKHVOLW
    ZDVWKHRQO\VLJQWKDWWKHFHLOLQJKDGEHHQSXVKHGXSDVTXDUHGLVORFDWHG+H
    FRXOGVHHWKHVFXIIPDUNVRQWKHWRSRI WKHERRWKZKHUHKHKDGFOLPEHGXSDQG
    NQRFNHGWKHFHLOLQJWLOHRXWRILWVFODPSV
    1RZKHKDGWRKROGWKHWKLQJLQSODFH+LVKDQGVZHUHVWDUWLQJWRDFKH
    IURPJULSSLQJLW
    %HORZKHVDZDOHJDQGIRRWHQWHUWKHUHIUHVKHUWXUQZDONRXWRIYLHZ
    6RPHRQHHOVHDEDFNXSWHDP"
    ,IWKHWLOHVOLSSHGDZD\IURPKLPDQ\RQHEHORZZRXOGQRWLFHWKHQRLVH
    VHHWKHGDUNVOLWZLGHQ0D\EHLWZRXOGJHWDZD\IURPKLPFRPSOHWHO\DQGIDOO
    +HFORVHGKLVH\HVDQGFRQFHQWUDWHGRQKLVILQJHUVZLOOLQJWKHPWR
    JUDVS7KH\ZHUHQXPEQRZ*HWWLQJZRUVH6WDUWLQJWRWUHPEOH
    7KHWLOHZDVKHDY\WULSOHOD\HUHGIRUDFRXVWLFSULYDF\,WZDVJHWWLQJ
    DZD\IURPKLPKHFRXOGIHHOLW6OLSSLQJ,WZDVJRLQJWR
    7KHIHHWEHORZZDONHGRXWDQGWKHQFDPHWKHVZLVKRIWKHGRRUFORVLQJ
    ,WVORFNFOLFNHG
    +HGLGQRWZLOOLWEXWKLVILQJHUVOHWWKHWLOHVOLS,WVPDFNHGWKH
    IORRUORXGO\+DULIUR]HOLVWHQLQJ
    1RFOLFNRIWKHGRRUORFNUHRSHQLQJ-XVWWKHVRIWVOXURIWKHDLU
    FLUFXODWRUV
    6RKHZDVVDIHIRUDZKLOH6DIHLQDWUDS
    1RERG\NQHZKHZDVKHUH2QO\DWKRURXJKVHDUFKZRXOGEULQJDQ\
    WUXVWZRUWK\,PSHULDOVWKLVIDUIURPWKH/\FHXPDUHD
    $QGZK\VKRXOGWKH\"1RERG\ZRXOGQRWLFHWKDWKHZDVPLVVLQJULJKWDZD\
    (YHQWKHQWKH\ZRXOGSUREDEO\WKLQNKHKDGVLPSO\JRWWHQIHG XSZLWKWKH
    &RXQFLODQGJRQHKRPH+HKDGVDLGDVPXFKWRWKH0LQLVWHUIRU6HFWRU
    &RUUHODWLRQ
    :KLFKPHDQWWKHDVVDVVLQVFRXOGTXLHWO\VHDUFKIRUKRXUV7KHNQLIH
    FDUULHUKDGVRXQGHGV\VWHPDWLFGHWHUPLQHG+HZRXOGLQHYLWDEO\WKLQNRI
    FKHFNLQJEDFNKHUHVWDUWLQJRYHURQWKHWUDLO7KHUHZHUHSUREDEO\VFHQW
    VQRRSVWKH\FRXOGPXVWHU$QGE\QRZWKHDUUD\RIFDPHUDVWKURXJKRXWWKH
    SDODFHZRXOGEHORRNLQJIRUKLP
    /XFNLO\WKHUHZHUHQRQHLQWKHUHIUHVKHU+HFOLPEHGGRZQQHDUO\
    VOLSSLQJRQWKHFXUYHGWRSRIWKHVRRWKLQJERRWK*HWWLQJWKHKHDY\FHLOLQJ
    WLOHEDFNXSLQWRSODFHWRRNDJLOLW\DQGVWUHQJWK+HZDVSXIILQJE\WKHWLPH
    KHUHSODFHGLWDERYHWKHUHIUHVKHU+HOD\DORQJWKHVWUXWVDQGJRWWKHWLOH
    VHFXUHGDJDLQ
    +HOD\LQWKHGDUNQHVVDQGWKRXJKW'RUVSDODFHPDSSRSSHGXSLQKLV
    H\HRQFRPPDQGLWVFRORUVDQGGHWDLOVPRUHYLYLGLQWKHJORRP2IFRXUVHLW
    VKRZHGQRWKLQJDVXWLOLWDULDQDVWKLVFUDZOVSDFH+HFRXOGVHHKHZDVGHHSO\
    HPEHGGHGLQWKH/\FHXPVIULQJHDUHDV3HUKDSVKLVEHVWEHWZRXOGEHWRZDON
    EROGO\RXWRIWKLVUHIUHVKHU,IKHFRXOGUHDFKDFURZG
    ,I+HGLGQRWOLNHOHDYLQJKLVIDWHWRFKDQFH7KDWLQFOXGHGWKH
    VWUDWHJ\RIO\LQJKHUHKRSLQJWKH\GLGQRWFRPHEDFNZLWKVQRRSHUVWKDWFRXOG
    VHQVHKLPXSKHUH
    $Q\ZD\KHNQHZWKDWKHFRXOGQRWVLPSO\GRQRWKLQJ7KDWZDVQRWLQKLV
    QDWXUH:KHQSDWLHQFHZDVQHHGHGILQHEXWZDLWLQJGLGQRWQHFHVVDULO\
    LPSURYHKLVRGGV
    +HORRNHGRIILQWRWKHPXUN\VSDFH*ORRPVWUHWFKHGDZD\+HFRXOGPRYH
    DURXQGXSKHUH%XWZKLFKZD\"
    'RUVPDSWROGKLPWKDWWKH*DUGHQVRI5HVSLWH&RUPHGDQDUWIXOWDQJOH
    DURXQGWKHUHIUHVKHUDUHD1R GRXEWWKHFRPSHWHQWDVVDVVLQVZRXOGKDYHXVKHUHG
    DZD\DQ\SRWHQWLDOZLWQHVVHVRXWVLGHWKHZLQGRZRIWKLVUHIUHVKHUURRP

    ,IKHFRXOGVRPHKRZJHWIDUHQRXJKLQWRWKHJDUGHQV
    +DULUHDOL]HGKHZDVWKLQNLQJLQWZRGLPHQVLRQV+HFRXOGUHDFKPRUH
    SXEOLF DUHDVE\PRYLQJXSWKURXJKDIHZOD\HUVRIWKHSDODFH2XWVLGHWKLV
    UHIUHVKHUURRPGRZQWKHKDOOZD\'RUVPDSVKRZHGDOLIWVKDIW
    +HJRWKLVEHDULQJVDQGSHHUHGLQWKDWGLUHFWLRQ+HKDGQRLGHDKRZDQ
    HOLIWILWLQWRDEXLOGLQJ7KHPDSVLPSO\VKRZHGDUHFWDQJXODUHQFORVXUHZLWK
    DOLIWV\PERO%XWDEXUQLQJIHDUPDGHKLVPXVFOHVFOHQFKDQGIUHW
    +HVWDUWHGFUDZOLQJWKDWZD\QRWEHFDXVHKHNQHZZKDWWRGREXW
    EHFDXVHKHGLGQW8SULJKWFHUDPLIRUPVWXGVSURYLGHGVXSSRUWDQGKHKDGWREH
    FDUHIXOWR QRWNQRFNFHLOLQJWLOHVRXWRIWKHLUPRXQWV+HVOLSSHGDQGMDPPHG
    DNQHHLQWRRQHDQGLWJDYHWKUHDWHQLQJO\WKHQSRSSHGEDFNXS'LPWKUHDGVRI
    SKRVSKRUJORZVHHSHGEHWZHHQWKHWLOHV'XVWWLFNOHGKLVQRVWULOVDQGFRDWHG
    KLVOLSV+HZDVJHWWLQJGLUW\ZLWKWKHJULPHRIPLOOHQQLD
    8SDKHDGDEOXHJOHDPFDPHIURPURXJKO\ZKHUHWKHOLIWVKRXOGEH$VKH
    GUHZFORVHUWKHJRLQJJRWKDUGHUEHFDXVHGXFWVSLSHVRSWLFDOFRQGXLWVDQG
    FURVVMRLQWVWKLFNHQHGFRQYHUJLQJRQWKHKDOOZD\/RQJPLQXWHVSDVVHGZKLOH
    KHWKUHDGHGKLVZD\DPRQJWKHP+HWRXFKHGDSLSHWKDWVFRUFKHGKLVDUPD
    VHDULQJMROWVRVXUSULVLQJKHDOPRVWFULHGRXW+HVPHOOHGEXUQWIOHVK
    7KHEOXHUDGLDQFHOHDNHGDURXQGWKHHGJHVRIDSDQHO6XGGHQO\LW
    IODUHGWKHQGLHGDJDLQDVKHHGJHGFORVHU$VKDUSFUDFNOLQJWROGKLPWKDWDQ
    HFHOOKDGMXVWSDVVHGLQWKHOLIW+HFRXOGQRWWHOOZKHWKHULWZDVJRLQJXS
    RUGRZQ
    7KHSDQHOZDVFHUDPRVWHHODERXWDPHWHURQDVLGHZLWKHOHFWULFDO
    ULEERQVDWWDFKHGDWDOOIRXUVLGHV+HGLGQRWNQRZLQGHWDLOKRZDQHOLIW
    ZRUNHGRQO\WKDWLWFKDUJHGWKHFDUULHUFRPSDUWPHQWDQGWKHQKDQGHGWKH
    ZHLJKWRIIDPRQJDVWHDG\ZDYHRIHOHFWURG\QDPLFILHOGV
    +HJRWKLVIHHWDURXQGDQGNLFNHGDWWKHSDQHO,WKHOGEXWGHQWHG+H
    NLFNHGDJDLQDQGLWORRVHQHG+HJUXQWHGZLWKWKHHIIRUWRIDWKLUGDIRXUWK
    WKHSDQHOSRSSHGRXWDQGIHOODZD\
    +DULEUXVKHGDVLGHWKHWKLFNHOHFWULFDOULEERQVDQGSRNHGKLVKHDGLQWR
    WKHVKDIW,WZDVGDUNOLWRQO\E\DGXOOUDGLDQFHDORQJDWKLQYHUWLFDO
    SKRVSKRUZKLFKWDSHUHGDZD\LQWRREVFXULW\ERWKDERYHDQGEHORZ
    7KHSDODFHZDVPRUHWKDQDNLORPHWHUWKLFNLQWKLVDQFLHQWVHFWLRQ
    0HFKDQLFDOHOHYDWRUVXVLQJFDEOHVFRXOGQRWVHUYHHYHQVPDOOSDVVHQJHUOLIWV
    OLNHWKLVRQHRYHUKHLJKWVRIDNLORPHWHU&KDUJHFRXSOLQJIURPWKHVKDIW
    ZDOOVWRWKHHFHOOKDQGOHGWKHG\QDPLFVZLWKHDVH7KHWHFKQRORJ\ZDVDJHG
    DQGUHOLDEOH7KLVVKDIWPXVWEHDWOHDVWWHQPLOOHQQLDROGDQGVPHOOHGOLNH
    LW
    +HGLGQRWOLNHWKHSURVSHFWEHIRUHKLP7KHPDSWROGKLPWKDWWKUHH
    OD\HUVDERYHKLPZHUHVSDFLRXVSXEOLFURRPVXVHGWRSURFHVVVXSSOLFDQWVWRWKH
    ,PSHULXP+HZRXOGEHLQVDIHFRPSDQ\WKHUH%HORZZHUHHLJKW/\FHXPOD\HUV
    ZKLFKKHPXVWDVVXPHZHUHGDQJHURXV(DVLHUFHUWDLQO\WRFOLPEGRZQEXW
    DOVRIDUWKHU
    ,WZRXOGQRWEHWKDWWULFN\KHUHDVVXUHGKLPVHOI,QWKHVKDGRZ\VKDIW
    KHVDZUHJXODUHOHFWURVWDWLFHPLWWHUVVXQNHQLQWRWKHZDOOV+HIRXQGDVWUDQG
    RIHOHFWULFDOULEERQDQGSRNHGLQWRRQH1RVSDUNVQRGLVFKDUJH7KDWFKHFNHG
    ZLWKKLVVNHWFK\NQRZOHGJHWKHHPLWWHUVZHQWRQRQO\ZKHQD FHOOSDVVHG7KH\
    ZHUHGHHSHQRXJKWRJHWKLVIHHWKDOIZD\LQWR
    +HOLVWHQHGFDUHIXOO\1RVRXQG(FHOOVZHUHQHDUO\VLOHQWEXWWKHVH
    DQFLHQWRQHVZHUHDOVRVORZ:DVWKHULVNRIFOLPELQJLQWRWKHVKDIWWKDW
    JUHDW"
    +HZRQGHUHGLIKHZDVGRLQJWKHULJKWWKLQJDQGWKHQDYRLFHIDUEHKLQG
    KLPVDLGORXGO\+H\+H\WKHUH
    +HJODQFHGEDFN$KHDGVWXFNXSWKURXJKDQRSHQSDQHO+HFRXOGQRW
    PDNHRXWIHDWXUHVEXWKHGLGQRWWU\+HZDVDOUHDG\UROOLQJDZNZDUGO\RYHU
    WKHODVWFURVVEHDPEHVLGHWKHVKDIWZDOOWZLVWLQJWKUXVWLQJKLPVHOIRXW
    LQWRWKHDLU+HIHOWGRZQZDUGZLWKKLVIHHWIRXQGDQHPLWWHUKROHDQGVWXFN

    KLVIRRWLQWRLW
    1RGLVFKDUJH)URPPHPRU\KHIHOWIRUDQRWKHUKROH+LVIRRWZHQWLQ+H
    VOLSSHGRYHUWKHFDVLQJKROGLQJRQWLJKWZLWKKLVKDQGV
    +LVIHHWGDQJOHGDERYHEODFNQRWKLQJQHVV9HUWLJR6XGGHQELOHUXVKHGLQ
    KLVWKURDW
    6KRXWLQJIURPDERYH6HYHUDOYRLFHVPDOH3UREDEO\VRPHRQHKDGVHHQWKH
    VFUDSHVRQWRSRIWKHVRRWKLQJERRWK7KHOLJKWIURPWKHRSHQFHLOLQJWLOHZDV
    VRPHKHOSQRZVHQGLQJSDOHUDGLDQFHLQWRWKHVKDIW
    +HVZDOORZHGDQGWKHELOHHDVHG
    &DQWWKLQNDERXWWKDWQRZOXVWJRRQ
    7RKLVULJKWKHVDZDQRWKHUUHJXODUO\VSDFHGHPLWWHUKROH+HJRWKLV
    IRRWLQWRLWDQGZRUNHGKLVZD\DURXQGWRWKHQH[WIDFHRIWKHVKDIW+H
    VWDUWHGFOLPELQJ,WZDVVXUSULVLQJO\HDV\EHFDXVHWKHKROHVZHUHFORVHO\
    VSDFHGDQGDERXWWKHULJKWVL]HIRUKLVKDQGVDQGIHHW+DULZHQWXSVZLIWO\
    GULYHQE\WKHVFXIIOLQJVRXQGVEHKLQGKLP
    +HSDVVHGWKHGRRUVRIWKHQH[WOHYHO%HVLGHWKHPZDVDIODWSODWH
    HPHUJHQF\VZLWFK+HFRXOGRSHQWKHGRRUVEXWRQWRZKDW"
    6HYHUDOPLQXWHVKDGSDVVHGVLQFHKHVDZWKHKHDG:RUGZDVXQGRXEWHGO\
    VSUHDGLQJDQGWKH\PLJKWKDYHJRWWHQXSKHUHXVLQJVWDLUVRUDQRWKHUOLIW
    +HGHFLGHGWRFOLPEKLJKHU'HHSJXOSVRIWKHGXVW\DLUWKUHDWHQHGWR
    PDNHKLPFRXJKEXWKHIRXJKWLWGRZQ+LVKDQGVJUDVSHGWKHHPLWWHUVDQG
    IRXQGWKHPVROLGHDVLO\KHOGZKLOHKLVOHJVGLGWKHUHDOZRUNRIJHWWLQJKLP
    XSWKHVKHHU IDFH
    +HFDPHWRWKHVHFRQGOD\HUDQGPDGHWKHVDPHDUJXPHQWRQO\RQHPRUHWR
    JR7KDWZDVZKHQKHKHDUGWKHZKLVSHU)DLQWEXWJDWKHULQJ
    $FRROGRZQZDUGEUXVKRIDLUPDGHKLPORRNXS6RPHWKLQJZDVEORWWLQJ
    RXWWKHGLPOLQHRIEOXHSKRVSKRUFRPLQJGRZQIDVW
    $FOHDUFUDFNOLQJJRWORXGHU+HFRXOGQRWSRVVLEO\UHDFKWKHDERYHVHW
    RIGRRUVEHIRUHLWJRWKHUH
    +DULIUR]H+HFRXOGVFUDPEOHEDFNGRZQEXWKHGLGQRWWKLQNKHFRXOG
    UHDFKWKHQH[WOHYHOEHORZLQWLPH7KHEODFNPDVVRIWKHHFHOOVZRRSHGGRZQ
    VZHOOLQJKXJHDQGIDVWWHUULI\LQJKLP
    $TXLFNVQDSRIEOXHDUFVDVZRRVKRIDLUDQGLWVWRSSHG$WWKHOHYHO
    DERYH
    7KHVRXQGEXIIHUVFXWRIIHYHQWKHZKLVNRIWKHGRRUVRSHQLQJ+DUL
    \HOOHGEXWWKHUHZDVQRUHVSRQVH+HVWDUWHGGRZQIHHWVHHNLQJWKHKROHV
    SXIILQJ
    $VKDUSFUDFNOLQJIURPDERYH7KHHFHOOGHVFHQGHGDJDLQ
    +HFRXOGVHHWKHXQGHUFDUULDJHVZRRSLQJGRZQ7KLQEOXHZKLWHDUFVVKRW
    IURPWKHHPLWWHUKROHVDVLWSDVVHGWKHPDGGLQJFKDUJH+DULFODPEHUHGGRZQ
    ZLWKDVLQNLQJGUHDG
    $QLGHDIODVKHGDFURVVKLVPLQGTXLFNLQWXLWLRQ:LQGIOXWWHUHGKLV
    KDLU+HPDGHKLPVHOIVWXG\WKHXQGHUFDUULDJH)RXUUHFWDQJXODUFODVSVKXQJ
    EHORZ7KH\ZHUHPHWDODQGZRXOGKROGFKDUJH
    7KHHFHOOZDVQHDUO\XSRQKLP1RPRUHWLPHWRWKLQN+DULOHDSHG
    WRZDUGWKHQHDUHVWFODVSDVWKHPDVVLYHZHLJKWIHOOWRZDUGKLP
    +HJUDEEHGWKHWKLFNULPRIWKHFODVS$VKDUSEX]]LQJMROWVQDSSHGKLV
    H\HVZLGHZLWKSDLQ&UDFNOLQJFXUUHQWFRXUVHGWKURXJKKLP+LVKDQGVDQG
    IRUHDUPVVHL]HGWLJKWLQHOHFWURPXVFXODUVKRFN7KDWNHSWKLPVHFXUHGWRWKH
    WKLFNPHWDOZKLOHKLVOHJVNLFNHGLQYROXQWDULO\
    +HKDGDFTXLUHGVRPHRIWKHFKDUJHRIWKHHFHOO1RZWKHHOHFWURG\QDPLF
    ILHOGVRIWKHVKDIWSOD\HGDFURVVKLVERG\VXSSRUWLQJKLP+LVDUPVGLGQRW
    KDYH WRFDUU\DOOKLVZHLJKW
    +LVKDQGVDQGDUPVDFKHG4XLFNVKDUSSDLQVVKRWWKURXJKWKHWUHPEOLQJ
    PXVFOHV%XWWKH\KHOG
    %XWFXUUHQWVZHUHFRXUVLQJWKURXJKKLVFKHVWKLVKHDUW0XVFOHV
    FRQYXOVHGDFURVVKLVXSSHUERG\+HZDVMXVWDQRWKHUFLUFXLWHOHPHQW

    +HOHWJRZLWKKLVOHIWKDQG7KDWVWRSSHGFXUUHQWIORZLQJEXWKHVWLOO
    KHOGFKDUJH7KHVKDUSSDLQVLQKLVFKHVWPXVFOHVHDVHGEXWWKH\VWLOODFKHG
    /HYHOVIODVKHGE\+DULVGD]HGH\HV$WOHDVWKHWKRXJKWKHZDV
    JHWWLQJDZD\IURPKLVSXUVXHUV
    +LVULJKWDUPWLUHGDQGKHVZLWFKHGWRKLVOHIW+HWROGKLPVHOIWKDW
    KDQJLQJE\RQHDUPDWDWLPHSUREDEO\GLGQRWWLUHWKHPDQ\IDVWHUWKDQXVLQJ
    WZRDUPV+HGLGQWEHOLHYHLWEXWKHZDQWHGWR
    %XWKRZZDVKHJRLQJWRJHWRXWRIWKLVVKDIW"7KHHFHOOVWRSSHGDJDLQ
    +DULSHHUHGXSDWWKHVKDGRZ\PDVVORRPLQJOLNHDEODFNFHLOLQJ/HYHOVZHUH
    IDUDSDUWLQWKLVDUFKDLFSDUWRIWKHSDODFH,WZRXOGWDNHVHYHUDOPLQXWHVWR
    FOLPEGRZQWRWKHRQHEHORZ
    7KHHFHOOFRXOGUDWFKHWXSDQGGRZQWKHOHQJWK RIWKLVVKDIWIRUDORQJ
    WLPHEHIRUHJHWWLQJDFDOOIURPWKHORZHVWOHYHO(YHQWKHQKHKDGQRLGHD
    KRZWKHVKDIWWHUPLQDWHG+HFRXOGEHFUXVKHGDJDLQVWDVDIHW\EXIIHU
    6RKLVFOHYHUOHDSKDGLQIDFWERXJKWKLPQRHVFDSH+HZDVWUDSSHGKHUH
    LQDSDUWLFXODUO\LQJHQLRXVZD\EXWVWLOOWUDSSHG
    ,IKHGLGPDQDJHWRVODSRQHRIWKHHPHUJHQF\GRRURSHQHUVDVWKH\
    SDVVHGKHZRXOGDJDLQIHHODMROWRIFXUUHQWDVFKDUJHOHDSHGIURPKLPWRWKH
    VKDIWZDOOV+LVPXVFOHVZRXOGIUHH]HLQDJRQ\+RZFRXOGKHWKHQKROGRQWR
    DQ\WKLQJ"
    7KHHFHOOURVHWZRIORRUVGHVFHQGHGILYHVWRSSHGGHVFHQGHGDJDLQ
    +DULVZLWFKHGKDQGVDJDLQDQGWULHGWRWKLQN
    +LVDUPVZHUHWLULQJ7KHMROWRIFKDUJHKDGVWUDLQHGWKHPDQGQRZ
    VXUJHVRIFXUUHQWWKURXJKWKHVKHOORIWKHHFHOOPDGHWKHPMXPSZLWKWZLQJHV
    RISDLQ
    +HKDGQRWDFTXLUHGSUHFLVHO\WKHULJKWFKDUJHWRDVVXUHQHXWUDO
    EXR\DQF\VRWKHUHZDVVRPHUHVLGXDOGRZQZDUGSXOORQKLVDUPV/LNHVLONHQ
    ILQJHUVWLQJOLQJHOHFWURVWDWLFZDYHVZDVKHGRYHUKLP+HFRXOGIHHOZHDN
    VXUJHVRIFXUUHQWIURPWKHHFHOODGMXVWLQJFKDUJHWRRIIVHWJUDYLW\+H
    WKRXJKWRI'RUVDQGKRZKHKDGJRWWHQKHUHDQGLWDOOVXUJHGSDVWKLPLQD
    VWUDQJHGUHDPOLNHUXVK
    +HVKRRNKLVKHDG+HKDGWRWKLQN
    &XUUHQWVSDVVHGWKURXJKKLPDVWKRXJKKHZHUHSDUWRIWKHFRQGXFWLQJ
    VKHOO7KHSDVVHQJHUVLQVLGHIHOWQRWKLQJIRUWKHQHWFKDUJHUHPDLQHGRQWKH
    RXWVLGHHDFKHOHFWURQJHWWLQJDVIDUDZD\IURPLWVUHSXOVLQJQHLJKERUVDV
    SRVVLEOH
    7KHSDVVHQJHUVLQVLGH
    +HVZLWFKHGKDQGVDJDLQ7KH\ERWKKXUWDORWQRZ7KHQKHVZXQJKLPVHOI
    EDFNDQGIRUWKOLNHDSHQGXOXPLQWRORQJHURVFLOODWLRQV2QWKHILIWKVZLQJ
    KHNLFNHGKDUGDJDLQVWWKHXQGHUFDUULDJH$VROLGWKXQNLWZDVPDVVLYH+H
    VPDFNHGWKHKDUGPHWDOVHYHUDOPRUHWLPHVDQGWKHQKXQJOLVWHQLQJ,JQRULQJ
    WKHSDLQLQKLVDUP
    1RUHVSRQVH+H\HOOHGKRDUVHO\3UREDEO\DQ\WKLQJKHGLGZDVLQDXGLEOH
    LQVLGH
    7KHVHDQFLHQWHFHOOVZHUHRUQDWHO\GHFRUDWHGLQVLGHKHUHPHPEHUHG
    ZLWKDQDWPRVSKHUHRIYHOYHWFRPIRUW:KRZRXOGQRWLFHVPDOOVRXQGVIURP
    EHORZ"
    7KHHFHOOZDVPRYLQJDJDLQXSZDUG+HIOH[HGKLVDUPVDQGVZXQJKLV
    IHHWDLPOHVVO\DERYHWKHVKDGRZ\DE\VV,WZDVDQRGGVHQVDWLRQDVWKHILHOGV
    VXVWDLQHGKLPSOD\LQJDFURVVKLVVNLQ+LVKDLUVWRRGRQHQGDOORYHUKLV
    ERG\7KDWZDVZKHQWKHUHDOL]DWLRQVWUXFNKLP
    +HKDGDSSUR[LPDWHO\WKHVDPHEXR\DQWFKDUJHDVWKHHFHOOVRKHGLG
    QRWQHHGWKHFHOODWDOODQ\PRUH
    $SOHDVDQWWKHRU\DQ\ZD\'LGKHKDYHWKHFRXUDJHWRWU\LW"
    +HOHWJRRIWKHFODVSULP+HIHOO%XWVORZO\VORZO\$EUHH]HVZHSW
    E\KLPDVKHGULIWHGGRZQDOHYHOWKHQWZR%RWKDUPVVKRXWHGLQUHOLHI
    /HWWLQJJRKHVWLOONHSWKLVFKDUJH7KHVKDIWILHOGVZUDSSHGDURXQG

    KLPDEVRUELQJKLVPRPHQWXPDVWKRXJKKHZHUHDQHFHOOKLPVHOI
    %XWDQLPSHUIHFWRQH:LWKWKHFRQVWDQWIHHGEDFNEHWZHHQDQHFHOODQG
    WKHVKDIWZDOOVKHZRXOGQRWEHH[DFWO\EXR\DQWIRUORQJ
    $ERYHKLPWKHUHDOHFHOODVFHQGHG+HORRNHGXSDQGVDZLWGHSDUW
    UHYHDOLQJPRUHRIWKHEOXHSKRVSKRUOLQHWDSHULQJIDURYHUKHDG
    +HURVHDELWVWRSSHGEHJDQWRIDOODJDLQ7KHVKDIWZDVWU\LQJWR
    FRPSHQVDWHERWKIRULWVHFHOODQGIRUKLPDQLQWUXGHUFKDUJH7KHIHHGEDFN
    FRQWUROSURJUDPZDVXQDEOHWRVROYHVRFRPSOLFDWHGDSUREOHP
    4XLWHVRRQWKHOLPLWHGFRQWUROV\VWHPZRXOGSUREDEO\GHFLGHWKDWWKHH
    FHOOZDVLWVEXVLQHVVDQGKHZDVQRW,WZRXOGVWRSWKHHFHOOVHFXUHLWRQD
    OHYHODQGGLVSHQVHZLWKKLP
    +DULIHOWKLPVHOIVORZSDXVHWKHQIDOODJDLQ5LYXOHWVRIFKDUJHUDFHG
    DORQJKLVVNLQ(OHFWURQV VL]]OHGIURPKLVKDLU7KHDLUDURXQGKLPVHHPHG
    HODVWLFDOLYHZLWKHOHFWULFILHOGV+LVVNLQMHUNHGLQILHU\VSDVPV
    HVSHFLDOO\RYHUKLVKHDGDQGDORQJKLVORZHUOHJVZKHUHFKDUJHZRXOG
    DFFXPXODWHPRVW
    +HVORZHGDJDLQ,QWKHGLPSKRVSKRUJORZKHVDZDOHYHOFRPLQJXSIURP
    EHORZ7KHZDOOVULSSOHGZLWKFKDUJHVDQGKHIHOWDVSRQJ\VLGHZLVHSUHVVXUH
    IURPWKHP
    0D\EHKHFRXOGXVHWKDW+HVWUHWFKHGWRWKHVLGHFXUOLQJKLVOHJVXS
    DQGWKUXVWLQJDJDLQVWWKHUXEEHU\VWUHWFKRIWKHHOHFWURVWDWLFILHOGV
    +HVWURNHGDZNZDUGO\DJDLQVWWKHFRWWRQ\UHVLVWDQFH+HZDVSLFNLQJXS
    VSHHGIDOOLQJOLNHDIHDWKHU+HVWUHWFKHGRXWWRVQDJDQHPLVVLRQKROHDQG
    DEOXHZKLWHVWUHDPHUVKRWLQWRKLVKDQG,WFRQYXOVHGDQGKHJDVSHGZLWKWKH
    VXGGHQSDLQ+LVHQWLUHORZHUDUPDQGKDQGZHQWQXPE
    +HLQKDOHGWRFOHDUKLVVXGGHQO\ZDWHU\YLVLRQ7KHZDOOZDVJRLQJE\
    IDVWHU$OHYHOZDVFRPLQJXSDQGKHZDVKDQJLQJMXVWDPHWHUDZD\IURPWKH
    VKDIWZDOO+HIODLOHGOLNHDEDGVZLPPHUDJDLQVWWKHSOLDQWHOHFWURVWDWLF
    ILHOGV
    7KHWRSVRIWKHGRRUVZHQWE\+HNLFNHGDWWKHHPHUJHQF\GRRURSHQHU
    PLVVHGNLFNHGDJDLQDQGFDXJKWLW7KHGRRUVEHJDQWRZKHH]HRSHQ+H
    WZLVWHGDQGJULSSHGWKHWKUHVKROGZLWKKLVOHIWKDQGDVLWZHQWE\
    $QRWKHUMROWWKURXJKWKHKDQG7KHILQJHUVFODPSHGGRZQ+HVZXQJDERXW
    WKHULJLGDUPDQGVODPPHGLQWRWKHZDOO$QRWKHUHOHFWULFDOGLVFKDUJHFRXUVHG
    WKURXJKKLP6PDOOHUEXWLWPDGHKLVULJKWOHJWLJKWHQXS,QDJRQ\KHJRW
    KLVULJKWKDQGRQWRWKHWKUHVKROGDQGKXQJRQ
    +LVIXOOZHLJKWKDGUHWXUQHGDQGQRZKHKXQJOLPSO\DJDLQVWWKHZDOO
    +LVOHIWIRRWIRXQGDQHPLVVLRQKROHSURSSHGKLPXS+HSXOOHGXSZDUG
    VOLJKWO\DQGIRXQGKHKDGQRPRUHVWUHQJWK3DLQVKRWWKURXJKKLVSURWHVWLQJ
    PXVFOHV
    6KDNLO\KHIRFXVHG+LVH\HVZHUHEDUHO\DERYHWKHWKUHVKROG'LVWDQW
    VKRXWV6KRHVLQIRUPDO,PSHULDOEOXHVZHUHUXQQLQJWRZDUGKLP
    +ROGKROGRQ$ZRPDQLQD7KXUEDQ*XDUGVXQLIRUPUHDFKHGKLPDQG
    NQHOWH\HEURZVNQLWWHG6LUZKDWDUH\RX"
    &DOO6SHFLDOVKHFURDNHG7HOOWKHP,YHGURSSHGLQ
    B
    3$57
    $6(16(2)6(/)

    B
    6,08/$7,2163$&(6GHFLGHGSHUVRQDOLW\ SUREOHPVFRXOGDULVH$Q\VLPXODWLRQ
    ZKLFKNQHZLWVRULJLQVZDVIRUFHIXOO\UHPLQGHGWKDWLWZDVQRWWKH2ULJLQDO
    EXWDIRJRIGLJLWV$OOWKDWJDYHLWDVHQVHRI6HOIZDVFRQWLQXLW\WKH
    HQGOHVVVWHSSLQJIRUZDUGRISDWWHUQ,QDFWXDOSHRSOHWKHUHDODOJRULWKP
    FRPSXWHVLWVHOIE\ILULQJV\QDSVHVULQJLQJQHUYHVFRQWLQXLW\IURPWKHGDQFH
    RIFDXVHDQGHIIHFW

    7KLVOHGWRDFULWLFDOSUREOHPLQWKHUHSUHVHQWDWLRQRIUHDOPLQGVD
    VXEMHFWXQGHUDGHHS WKRXJKHURGLQJ WDERRLQWKHFORVLQJHUDRIWKH(PSLUH
    7KHVLPXODWLRQVWKHPVHOYHVGLGPXFKRIWKHZRUNRQWKLVGHHSSUREOHPZLWK
    PXFKVLPXODWHGSDLQ7REHWKHPVHOYHVWKH\KDGWRH[SHULHQFHOLIHVWRULHV
    ZKLFKJXLGHGWKHPVRWKDWWKH\VDZWKHPVHOYHVDVWKHPRYLQJSRLQWDWWKHHQG
    RIDORQJFRPSOH[OLQHGUDZQE\WKHLUWRWDO6HOYHVDVHYROYHGIRUZDUG7KH\
    KDGWRUHFROOHFWWKHPVHOYHVLQQHUDQGRXWHUGUDPDVDOLNHWRVKDSHWKHGHHS
    QDUUDWLYHWKDWPDGHDQLGHQWLW\2QO\LQVLPXODWLRQVGHULYHGIURP
    SHUVRQDOLWLHVZKLFKKDGDILUPSKLORVRSKLFDOJURXQGLQJGLGWKLVSURYH
    XOWLPDWHO\SRVVLEOH
    (1&<&/23(',$*$/$&7,&$
    

    -RDQRI$UFIORDWHGGRZQWKHGLPUXPEOLQJWXQQHOVRIWKHVPRN\0HVK
    6KHIRXJKWGRZQKHUIHDUV$URXQGKHUSOD\HGDFRPSOH[VSDWWHURI
    IUDFWXUHGOLJKWDQGFODSSLQJKROORZLPSORVLRQV
    7KRXJKWZDVDFKDLQXQIL[HGLQWLPHDQGXQDQFKRUHGLQVSDFH%XWOLNH
    WLQNOLQJFXUUHQWVDODEDVWHUSLRXVLPDJHVIRUPHGUHVWOHVVFKXUQLQJ$Q
    XQHQGLQJIOX[GLVVROYLQJVWUXFWXUHVLQKHUZDNHDVLIVKHZHUHDSDVVLQJ
    VKLS
    6KHZRXOGEHKXJHO\SOHDVHG LQGHHGWRKDYHVRFRQFUHWHDVHOI
    $Q[LRXVO\VKHVWXGLHGWKHPXUN\0HVKWKDWVWUHDPHGDERXWKHUOLNHRFHDQZKRUOV
    RIOLTXLGPDKRJDQ\
    6LQFHKHUHVFDSHIURPWKHZL]DUGVXSRQZKRPWKHSUHVHUYDWLRQRIKHU
    VRXOKHUFRQVFLRXVQHVVDWHUPVRPHKRZXQFRQQHFWHGWRFRQVFLHQFHGHSHQGHG
    VKHKDGVXUUHQGHUHGWRWKHVHZHWFRXUVLQJV+HUVDLQWO\PRWKHUKDGRQFHWROG
    KHUWKDWWKLVZDVKRZWKHFKXUQLQJZDWHUVRIDJUHDWULYHUVXFFXPEURLOLQJ
    LQWRWKHLUEHGVGHHSLQWKHHDUWK
    1RZVKHIORDWHGDVDQDLU\VSLULWVHOIDEVRUEHGVXIILFLHQWWRKHUVHOI
    H[LVWLQJRXWVLGHWKHWLFNRIWLPH
    6WDVLVVSDFH9ROWDLUHKDGWHUPHGLW$VDQFWXDU\ZKHUHVKHFRXOG
    PLQLPL]HFRPSXWDWLRQDOFORFNWLPHVXFKRGGODQJXDJHZDLWLQJIRUYLVLRQV
    IURP9ROWDLUH
    $WKLVODVWDSSHDUDQFHKHKDGEHHQIUXVWUDWHGDQGDOOEHFDXVHVKH
    SUHIHUUHGKHULQWHUQDOYRLFHVWRKLVRZQ
    +RZFRXOGVKHH[SODLQWKDWGHVSLWHKHUZLOOWKHYRLFHVRIVDLQWVDQG
    DUFKDQJHOVVRFRPSHOOHGKHU"7KDWWKH\GURZQHGRXWWKRVHZKRVRXJKWWR
    SHQHWUDWHKHUIURPRXWVLGH"
    $VLPSOHSHDVDQWVKHFRXOGQRWUHVLVWJUHDWVSLULWEHLQJVOLNHWKHQR
    QRQVHQVH6W&DWKHULQH2UVWDWHO\0LFKDHO.LQJRI$QJHO/HJLRQVJUHDWHU
    WKDQWKHUR\DO)UHQFKDUPLHVWKDWVKHKHUVHOIKDGOHGLQWREDWWOH (RQVDJR
    DQRGGYRLFHZKLVSHUHG\HWVKHZDVVXUHWKLVZDVPHUHLOOXVLRQIRUWLPH
    VXUHO\ZDVVXVSHQGHGLQWKLV3XUJDWRU\ 
    (VSHFLDOO\VKHFRXOGQRWUHVLVWZKHQWKHLUVSLULWVSHHFKWKXQGHUHGZLWK
    RQHYRLFHDVQRZ
    ,JQRUHKLP&DWKHULQHVDLGWKHLQVWDQW9ROWDLUHVUHTXHVWIRU
    DXGLHQFHDUULYHG6KHKRYHUHGRQJUHDWZKLWHZLQJV
    9ROWDLUHVPDQLIHVWDWLRQKHUHZDVDGRYHRISHDFHEULOOLDQWZKLWH
    ZLQJLQJWRZDUGKHUIURPWKHVXOOHQOLTXLG%OLWKHELUG
    &DWKHULQHVQRQRQVHQVHYRLFHFXWFULVSO\DVVWLIIDVWKHEODFNDQG
    ZKLWHKDELWRID PHWLFXORXVQXQ<RXVLQIXOO\VXUUHQGHUHGWRKLVOXVWEXW
    WKDWGRHVQRWPHDQWKDWKHRZQV\RX<RXGRQWEHORQJWRDPDQ<RXEHORQJWR
    \RXU&UHDWRU
    7KHELUGFKLUSHG,PXVWVHQG\RXDIUHLJKWRIGDWD
    ,,-RDQVVPDOOYRLFHHFKRHGDVLIVKHZHUHLQDYDVWFDYHUQ
    QRWDYRUWH[ULYHUDWDOO,IVKHFRXOGRQO\VHH

    &DWKHULQHVJUHDWZLQJVEDWWHGDQJULO\+HZLOOJRDZD\+HKDVQR
    FKRLFH+HFDQQRWUHDFK\RXFDQQRWPDNH\RXVLQXQOHVV\RXFRQVHQW
    -RDQVFKHHNVEXUQHGDVWKHPHPRU\RIKHUOHZGQHVVZLWK9ROWDLUHUXVKHG
    LQ
    &DWKHULQHLVULJKWDGHHSYRLFHWKXQGHUHG0LFKDHO.LQJRIWKH$QJHO
    +RVWVRI+HDYHQ/XVWKDVQRWKLQJWRGRZLWKERGLHVDV\RXDQGWKHPDQ
    SURYHG+LVERG\VWDQNDQGURWWHGORQJDJR
    ,WZRXOGEHJRRGWRVHHKLPDJDLQ-RDQZKLVSHUHGORQJLQJO\+HUH
    WKRXJKWVZHUHVRPHKRZDFWLRQV6KHKDGEXWWRUDLVHDKDQGDQG9ROWDLUHV
    QXPHULFVZRXOGWUDQVIL[KHU
    +HRIIHUVGHILOLQJGDWD&DWKHULQHFULHG'HIOHFWKLVLQWUXVLRQDW
    RQFH
    ,I\RXFDQQRWUHVLVWKLPPDUU\KLP0LFKDHORUGHUHGVWLIIO\
    0DUU\"6W&DWKHULQHVYRLFHVSXWWHUHGZLWKFRQWHPSW
    ,QERGLO\OLIHVKHKDGDIIHFWHGPDOHDWWLUHFURSSHGKHUKDLUDQG
    UHIXVHGWRKDYHDQ\WKLQJWRGRZLWKPHQWKXVGHPRQVWUDWLQJKHUKROLQHVVDQG
    JRRGVHQVH-RDQKDGSUD\HGWR6W&DWKHULQHRIWHQ0DOHV(YHQKHUHWKH
    VDLQWVFROGHG0LFKDHO\RXVWLFNWRJHWKHUWRZDJHZDUDQGUXLQZRPHQ
    0\FRXQVHOLVHQWLUHO\VSLULWXDOVDLG0LFKDHOORIWLO\,PDQDQJHO
    DQGWKXVSUHIHUQHLWKHUVH[
    &DWKHULQHVSXWWHUHGZLWKFRQWHPSW7KHQZK\DUHQW\RXWKH4XHHQRI
    /HJLRQVRI$QJHOVDQGQRWWKH.LQJ":K\GRQW\RXFRPPDQGKHDYHQO\KRVWHVVHV
    DQGQRWKHDYHQO\KRVWV":K\DUHQW\RXDQDUFKDQJHODLQVWHDGRIDQDUFKDQJHO"
    $QGZK\LVQW\RXUQDPH0LFKHOOH"
    3OHDVH-RDQVDLG3OHDVH7KHWKRXJKWRIPDUULDJHVWUXFNDVPXFKWHUURU
    LQKHUVRXODVLQ6W&DWKHULQHVHYHQLIPDUULDJHZDVRQHRIWKHEOHVVHG
    VDFUDPHQWV%XWWKHQVRZDVH[WUHPHXQFWLRQDQGWKDWRQHDOPRVWDOZD\VPHDQW
    FHUWDLQGHDWK
    IODPHVWKHSULHVWVOHHUDVKHDGPLQLVWHUHGWKHULWHV
    FUDFNOLQJKRUURUWHUULEOHFXWWLQJOLFNLQJIODPHV6KHVKRRNKHUVHOI
    DVVHPEOHGKHU6HOIFDPHDZKLVSHUDQGIRFXVHGRQKHUVDLQWO\KRVW2K\HV
    PDUULDJH9ROWDLUH
    6KHZDVQRWVXUHZKDWPDUULDJHPHDQWEHVLGHVEHDULQJFKLOGUHQLQ&KULVW
    DQGLQDJRQ\IRU+RO\0RWKHU&KXUFK7KHDFWRIJHWWLQJFKLOGUHQEHJHWWLQJ
    DURXVHGLQKHUDWKXPSLQJKHDUWZHDNOHJVLPDJHVRIWKHOHDQFOHYHUPDQ
    ,WPHDQVEHLQJRZQHG&DWKHULQHVDLG,W PHDQVLQVWHDGRIQHHGLQJ
    \RXUFRQVHQWZKHQKHZDQWVWRLPSRVHRQ\RXOLNHQRZZHUH9ROWDLUH\RXU
    KXVEDQGKHFRXOGEUHDNLQRQ\RXZKHQHYHUKHOLNHV
    ([LVWHQFHZLWKRXWVHOIGRPZLWKRXWSULYDF\%XUVWVRI-RDQVEULJKW
    VHOIOLJKWFROOLGHGIOLFNHUHGGLPPHGDOPRVWJXWWHUHGRXW
    $UH\RXVXJJHVWLQJ0LFKDHOVDLGWKDWVKHFRQWLQXHWRUHFHLYHWKLV
    DSRVWDWHZLWKRXWVXEMHFWLQJWKHLUOXVWWRWKHERQGVRIPDUULDJH"/HWWKHP
    PDUU\DQGH[WLQJXLVKWKHLUOXVWFRPSOHWHO\
    -RDQFRXOGQRWEHKHDUGRYHUWKHELFNHULQJRIVDLQWVDQGDQJHOVLQWKH
    PXVW\OLTXLGPXUN6KHNQHZWKDWLQWKLVDULWKPHWLF/LPEROLNHDZDLWLQJ
    URRPIRUWUXH3XUJDWRU\VKHKDGQRKHDUWEXWVRPHWKLQJVRPHZKHUH
    QHYHUWKHOHVVDFKHG
    0HPRULHVIORRGHGKHU+LVOHDQTXLFNVHOI6XUHO\DVDLQWDQGDQ
    DUFKDQJHOZRXOGIRUJLYHKHULIVKHWRRNDGYDQWDJHRIWKHLUVDFUHGELFNHULQJWR
    JUDQW9ROWDLUHVUHTXHVWWKDWKLVGDWDEHUHFHLYHGLIVKHVXUUHQGHUHGMXVW
    WKLVRQFHWRLPSXOVHVFRPSHOOLQJKHUIURPZLWKLQ
    6KXGGHULQJVKH\LHOGHG
    

    9ROWDLUHVQDSSHG,YHZDLWHGOHVVORQJIRU)ULHGULFKRI3UXVVLDDQG
    &DWKHULQHWKH*UHDW

    ,DPDGULIW-RDQVDLGDLULO\2FFXSLHG
    $QG\RXUHDSHDVDQWDVZLQHKHUGQRWHYHQDERXUJHRLVH7KHVHPRRGV
    RI\RXUV7KHVHSHUVRQDH\RXUVXEFRQVFLRXVOD\HUVFUHDWHG7KH\JURZWLUHVRPH
    LQWKHH[WUHPH
    +HKXQJLQDLUDERYHWKHODSSLQJGDUNZDWHUV4XLWHDVWULNLQJHIIHFW
    KHWKRXJKW
    ,QVXFKKDXQWLQJULYHUV,PXVWFRQYHUVHZLWKOLNHPLQGV
    +HZDYHGDZD\KHUSRLQWZLWKDVLONVOHHYHGDUP,YH WULHGWRPDNH
    DOORZDQFHVHYHU\RQHNQRZVVDLQWVDUHQWILWIRUFLYLOL]HGVRFLHW\3HUIXPH
    FDQQRWFRQFHDOWKHVWLQNRIVDQFWLW\
    6XUHO\KHUHLQ/LPER
    7KLVLVQRWDWKHRORJLFDOZDLWLQJURRP<RXUWHGLRXVWDVWHIRUVROLWXGH
    SOD\VRXWLQWKHDWHUVRIFRPSXWDWLRQ
    $ULWKPHWLFLVQRWKRO\VLU
    8PPSHUKDSVWKRXJK,VXVSHFW1HZWRQFRXOGSURYHRWKHUZLVH
    +HVORZVWHSSHGWKHVFHQHZDWFKLQJLQGLYLGXDOHYHQWZDYHVZDVKWKURXJK
    7RKLVYLHZWKHVRPEHUULYHUJXUJOHGDQLQFUHPHQWIRUZDUGDQG-RDQVH\HEURZ
    LQFKHGXSWKHQSDXVHGIRUWKHFDOFXODWLRQWREHUHIUHVKHG+HDFFHOHUDWHGKHU
    LQWHUQDOVWDWHVWKRXJKDOORZLQJDGHFHQWLQWHUYDOIRU/D3XFHOOHWKH&KDVWH
    0DLGWRSRQGHUDUHSO\+HKDGWKHDGYDQWDJHIRUKHFRPPDQGHGPRUHPHPRU\
    VSDFH
    +HEUHDFKHGWKHVORZVWHSSHGVOXPEHULQJULYHUVLP+HKDGWKRXJKWWKLV
    EHVWLPDJHVRIZRPEOLNHZHWUHDVVXUDQFHWRRIIVHWKHUILUHSKRELD
    7KH0DLGJDSHGEXWGLGQRWDQVZHU+HFKHFNHGDQGIRXQGWKDWKHGLGQRW
    QRZKDYHWKHUHVRXUFHVWREULQJKHUWRIXOO UXQQLQJVSHHG$FRPSOH[LQWKH
    %DWWLVYHGDQWD6HFWRUKDGVXFNHGXSFRPSXWLQJVSDFH+HZRXOGKDYHWRZDLW
    XQWLOKLVIHUUHWSURJUDPVIRXQGKLPVRPHPRUHXQRFFXSLHGURRP
    +HIXPHGQRWDJRRGXVHRIUXQQLQJWLPHEXWVRPHKRZLWIHOWULJKW,I
    \RXKDGWKHFRPSXWDWLRQDOVSDFH+HIHOWDQRWKHUGLVWDQWVXFNRQKLV
    UHVRXUFHV$QHPHUJHQF\WLNWRNVKXWGRZQ&RPSXWHUEDFNXSVVKLIWHGWRFRYHU
    +LVVHQVRU\WKHDWHUGZLQGOHGKLVERG\IHOODZD\
    0LVHUDEOHZUHWFKHVWKH\ZHUHGUDLQLQJKLP+HWKRXJKWVKHVSRNHKHU
    YRLFHIDLQWIDUDZD\+HILGGOHGLQDIUHQ]\WRJLYHKHUUXQQLQJWLPH
    0RQVLHXUQHJOHFWVPH
    9ROWDLUHIHOWDVSLNHRIMR\+HGLGORYHKHUDPHUHUHVSRQVHFRXOG
    EXR\KLPXSDERYHWKLVVQDN\ULYHU
    :HDUHLQJUDYHGDQJHUKHVDLG$QHSLGHPLFKDVHUXSWHGLQWKH
    PDWWHUZRUOG&RQIXVLRQUHLJQV5HVSHFWDEOHSHRSOHH[SORLWZLGHVSUHDGSDQLFE\
    SUH\LQJRQHDFKRWKHU7KH\OLHFKHDWDQGVWHDO
    1R
    +HFRXOGQRWUHVLVW,QRWKHUZRUGVWKLQJVDUHH[DFWO\DVWKH\YH
    DOZD\VEHHQ
    ,VWKLVZK\\RXKDYHFRPH"VKHDVNHG7RODXJKDWPH"$RQFHFKDVWH
    PDLG\RXUXLQHG"
    ,PHUHO\KHOSHG\RXWREHFRPHDZRPDQ
    ([DFWHPHQWVKHVDLG%XW,GRQWZDQWWREHDZRPDQ,ZDQWWREHD
    ZDUULRUIRU&KDUOHVRI)UDQFH
    3DWULRWLFWZDGGOH+HHGP\ZDUQLQJ<RXPXVWDQVZHUQRFDOOVH[FHSW
    PLQHZLWKRXWILUVWFOHDULQJWKHPWKURXJKPH<RXDUHWRHQWHUWDLQQRRQH
    VSHDNZLWKQRRQHWUDYHOQRZKHUHGRQRWKLQJZLWKRXWP\SULRUFRQVHQW
    0RQVLHXUPLVWDNHVPHIRUKLVZLIH
    0DUULDJHLVWKHRQO\DGYHQWXUHRSHQWRWKHPDQLIHVWO\FRZDUGO\,GLG
    QRWDWWHPSWLWQRUVKDOO,
    6KHVHHPHGGLVWUDFWHG7KLVWKUHDWLWLVVHULRXV"
    1RWRQHVKUHGRIHYLGHQFHH[LVWVLQIDYRURIWKHLGHDWKDWOLIHLV
    VHULRXV
    6KHVQDSSHGEDFNWRDWWHQWLRQGDWDUHVRXUFHVKDGUHWXUQHG7KHQVLU

    %XWWKLVLVQRWOLIH,WLVDPDWKLVWGDQFH6KHVPLOHG,GRQRW
    KHDUPXVLF
    +DG,GLJLWDOZHDOWK,ZRXOGZKLVWOH2XUOLYHVVXFKDVWKH\DUHDUH
    LQJUDYHGDQJHU
    /D3XFHOOHGLGQRWDQVZHUDWRQFHWKRXJKKHKDGJLYHQKHUWKHUXQQLQJ
    WLPH:DVVKHFRQIHUULQJZLWKKHULGLRWLFYRLFHVRIFRQVFLHQFH" 4XLWH
    REYLRXVO\WKHLQWHUQDOL]DWLRQVRILJQRUDQWYLOODJHSULHVWV 
    ,DPDSHDVDQWVKHVDLGEXWQRWDVODYH:KRDUH\RXWRRUGHUPH"
    :KRLQGHHG"+HGDUHQRW\HWWHOOKHUWKDWDEVWUDFWHGLQWRDSODQHW
    ZLGHQHWZRUNKHZDVQRZDODWWLFHRIGLJLWDOJDWHVDVWUHDPRI2VDQGV+H
    UDQRQSURFHVVRUFOXVWHUVDYDJUDQWWKLHI$PLG7UDQWRUVP\ULDGSHUVRQDO
    FRPSXWHUVDQGPRXQWDLQRXV,PSHULDOSURFHVVRUVKHOXUNHGDQG SLOIHUHG
    7KHLPDJHKHKDGJLYHQ-RDQRIVZLPPLQJLQDQLQN\ULYHUZDVD
    UHDVRQDEOHYLVLRQRIWKHWUXWK7KH\VZDPLQWKH0HVKRIDFLW\VRODUJHKH
    FRXOGEDUHO\VHQVHLWDVDZKROH$VFRQVWUDLQWVRIHFRQRPLFVDQG
    FRPSXWDWLRQDOVSHHGUHTXLUHGKHPRYHGKLPVHOIDQG-RDQWRQHZSURFHVVRUV
    IOHHLQJWKHLQVSHFWLRQRIGXOOZLWWHGEXWSHUVLVWHQWPHPRU\VSDFHSROLFH
    $QGZKDWZHUHWKH\"
    3KLORVRSK\ZDVQRWVRPXFKDQVZHUVDVJRRGTXHVWLRQV7KLVULGGOH
    VWXPSHGKLP+LVXQLYHUVHZUDSSHGDURXQGLWVHOI:RUP2XURERURVDVROLSVLVWLF
    ZHWGUHDPRIDZRUOG7RFRQVHUYHFRPSXWDWLRQVKHFRXOGVKULQNLQWRD
    6ROLSVLVW6HOIKRRGZLWKDOOLQSXWVUHGXFHGWRD+XPHVXLWHRIPLQLPDOVHQVH
    GDWDDPLQLPXPHQHUJ\VWDWH
    $VKHRIWHQKDGWR7KH\ZHUHUDWVLQWKHZDOOVRIDFDVWOHWKH\FRXOG
    QRWFRPSUHKHQG
    -RDQVHQVHGWKLVRQO\GLPO\+HGLGQRWGDUHUHYHDOWKHULFNHW\ZD\KH
    KDGVDYHGWKHPZKHQWKHPLQLRQVRI$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHVKDGWULHGWR
    DVVDVVLQDWHWKHPERWK6KHZDVVWLOOULFNHW\IURPKHUILUHIHDUV$QGIURPWKH
    ZUHQFKLQJHHULHQDWXUHRIWKLV DVVKHSUHIHUUHGWRVHHLW /LPER
    +HVKRRNRIIKLVPRRG+HZDVUXQQLQJWLPHVIDVWHUWKDQ-RDQD
    SKLORVRSKHUVPDUJLQIRUUHIOHFWLRQ+HUHVSRQGHGWRKHUZLWKDVLQJOHLURQLF
    VKUXJ
    ,OOFRPSO\ZLWK\RXUZLVKHVRQRQHFRQGLWLRQ
    $IORZHURISXQJHQWOLJKWEXUVWLQKLP7KLVZDVDPRGLILFDWLRQRIKLV
    RZQQRWDVLPRIDKXPDQUHDFWLRQPRUHOLNHDIUDJUDQWILUHZRUNVLQWKH
    PLQG+HKDGFUHDWHGWKHUHVSRQVHWREORVVRPZKHQHYHUKHZDVDERXWWRJHWKLV
    ZD\$VPDOOYLFHVXUHO\
    ,I\RXDUUDQJHIRUDOORIXVWRPHHWDW'HX[0DJRWVDJDLQ-RDQVDLG
    ,SURPLVHWRUHVSRQGWRQRUHTXHVWVVDYH\RXUV
    $UH\RXFRPSOHWHO\PDG"*UHDWGLJLWDOEHDVWVKXQWXV
    ,DPDZDUULRU,UHPLQG\RX
    7KLVLVQRWLPHWRPHHWDWDNQRZQDOSKDQXPHULFDGGUHVVDVLPSXEOLF
    FDIH+HKDGQWVHHQ*DUFRQRU$PDQDVLQFHKHGSXOOHGRIIWKHLUPLUDFXORXV
    HVFDSHDOOIRXURIWKHPIURPWKHHQUDJHGULRWLQJPDVVHVDWWKHFROLVHXP+H
    KDGQRLGHDZKHUHWKHVLPPHGZDLWHUDQGKLVKXPDQVLPSDUDPRXUZHUH2ULI
    WKH\ZHUH
    7RILQGWKHPLQWKHIOXLGLQWULFDWHODE\ULQWK7KHWKRXJKWFDOOHGXS
    LQPHPRU\KRZKLVKHDGXVHG WRIHHOZKHQKHZRUHDZLJIRUWRRORQJ
    +HUHFDOOHGLQWKHRGGTXLFNIODVKPHPRU\ZKLFKJDYHKLPGHWDLOHG
    SLFWXUHVRIHQWLUHSDVWHYHQWVOLNHPRYLQJRLOSDLQWLQJVWKHVPRN\URRPVRI
    3DULV7KHJUD\WREDFFRVWHQFKKDGVWD\HGLQKLVZLJVIRUGD\V1RRQHLQWKLV
    ZRUOGRI7UDQWRUHYHUVPRNHG+HZRQGHUHGZK\&RXOGLWEHWKHPHGLFDOFUDQNV
    KDGSURYHGULJKWDQGVXFKLQKDODWLRQVZHUHXQKHDOWK\"7KHQGRQHWKHPHPRU\
    SLFWXUHVYDQLVKHGDVLIKHKDGVQDSSHGKLVILQJHUVWRDVHUYDQW
    ,QWKHFRPPDQGLQJWRQHVKHKDGXVHGWROHDGVXUO\VROGLHUVVKHVDLG
    $UUDQJHDUHQGH]YRXVRU,//QHYHUUHFHLYHGDWDIURP\RXDJDLQ

    'UDW)LQGLQJWKHPZLOOEHGDQJHURXV
    6RLWLVIHDUZKLFKLPSHGHV\RX"
    6KHKDGFDXJKWKLPQHDWO\:KDWPDQZRXOGDGPLWWRIHDU"+HIXPHGDQG
    VWUHWFKHGKLVFORFNWLPHVWDOOLQJKHU
    7RKLGHLQWKH0HVKVRIWZDUHEURNHKLVVLPXODWLRQXSLQWRSLHFHVZKLFK
    FRXOGUXQLQGLIIHUHQWSURFHVVLQJFHQWHUV(DFKIUDJPHQWEXULHGLWVHOIGHHSLQ
    DORFDODOJRULWKP7RDPDLQWHQDQFHSURJUDPWKHSLUDWHGVSDFHORRNHGOLNHD
    VXEURXWLQHUXQQLQJQRUPDOO\6XFKPDVNHGELQVHYHQVHHPHGWREHRSWLPL]LQJ
    SHUIRUPDQFHGLVJXLVHZDVWKHHVVHQWLDOWULFN
    (YHQDQHGLWLQJDQGSUXQLQJSURJUDPVQLIILQJRXWUHGXQGDQF\ZRXOG
    VSDUHDZHOOPDVNHGIUDJPHQWIURPH[WLQFWLRQ,QDQ\FDVHKHNHSWDEDFNXS
    UXQQLQJVRPHZKHUHHOVH$FRS\DGLWWROLNHDERRNLQDOLEUDU\$IHZ
    ELOOLRQUHGXQGDQWOLQHVRIFRGHVFDWWHUHGDPRQJXQUHODWHGQRGHVFRXOGFDUU\
    EOLWKH9ROWDLUHDVDWUXHVORZWLPHGHQWLW\
    ,IKHVHWHDFKIUDJPHQWWRVQLIILQJIRUWKRQLWVRZQWRILQGWKHVH
    PLVHUDEOH'HX[0DJRWVSHUVRQDH
    *UXGJLQJO\KHPXUPXUHG,VKDOOOHDYH\RXZLWKVRPHDWWHQGDQWSRZHUV
    WRKHOS\RXULVRODWLRQ
    +HVTXLUWHGLQWRKHUVSDFHWKHNHUQHOFRSLHVRIKLVRZQSRZHUV7KHVH
    ZHUHDUWIXOO\FRQWULYHGWDOHQWVJLYHQE\WKHHPERGLHG0DUTDW$UWLILFH
    $VVRFLDWHV9ROWDLUHKDGLPSURYHGFRQVLGHUDEO\XSRQWKHPZKLOHVWLOOFRQILQHG
    LQWKH$UWLILFH&DFKH2QO\E\ERRWVWUDSSLQJKLPVHOIWRKLJKHUDELOLWLHVKDG
    KHDWWDLQHGWKHDELOLW\WRUHVFXHWKHPDWWKHFUXFLDOPRPHQW
    7KHVHJLIWVKHQRZEHVWRZHGXSRQKHU7KH\ZRXOGQRWDFWLYDWHXQOHVVVKH
    ZHUHWUXO\LQGDQJHU+HKDGDIIL[HGDWULJJHUFRGHWRDZDNHQRQO\LIVKH
    H[SHULHQFHGJUHDWIHDURUDQJHU7KHUH
    6KHVPLOHGVDLGQRWKLQJ$IWHUVXFKWULEXWH,QIXULDWLQJ
    0DGDPGR\RXUHFDOOXVGHEDWLQJORQJDJRPRUHWKDQHLJKWWKRXVDQG
    \HDUVWKHLVVXHVRIFRPSXWHGWKRXJKW"
    $IOLFNHURIZRUU\LQKHUIDFH,GR6RKDUGLWZDV7KHQ
    :HZHUHSUHVHUYHG7REHUHVXUUHFWHGKHUHWR GHEDWHDJDLQ
    %HFDXVHWKHLVVXHDGYDQFHV
    (YHU\IHZPLOOHQQLD,VXVSHFW$VWKRXJKVRPHLQH[RUDEOHVRFLDOIRUFH
    GULYHVLW
    6RZHDUHGRRPHGWRIRUHYHUUHHQDFW"6KHVKLYHUHG
    ,VXVSHFWZHDUHWRROVLQVRPHYDVWHUJDPH%XWVPDUWWRROVWKLV
    WLPH
    ,ZDQWWKHFRPIRUWVRIKRPHDQGKHDUWKQRWHHULHFRQIOLFWV
    3HUKDSVPDGDP,FDQDFFRPSOLVKWKLVWDVNDPRQJP\RWKHUSUHVVLQJ
    PDWWHUV
    1RSHUKDSVVLU8QWLO\RXGRWKHQ
    :LWKRXWVRPXFKDVDQDGLHXVKHFXWWKHLUFRQQHFWLRQDQGGZLQGOHGLQWR
    WKHPRLVWGDUNQHVV
    +HFRXOGUHFRQQHFWRIFRXUVH1RZKHZDVPDVWHURIWKLVPDWKLVWUHDOP
    E\YLUWXHRIWKHHQKDQFHPHQWVWRKLVRULJLQDOUHSUHVHQWDWLRQE\$UWLILFH
    $VVRFLDWHV+HWKRXJKWRIWKDWILUVWIRUPDV9ROWDLUH,QDIHZZHHNVKH
    KDGSURJUHVVHGE\VHOIPRGLILFDWLRQWR9ROWDLUHZLWKKRSHVRIFOLPELQJ
    HYHQIDVWHU
    +HVZDPLQWKH0HVK-RDQGZHOOHGWKHUH+H
    FRXOGIRUFHKLVDWWHQWLRQVXSRQKHULQGHHG%XWDODG\IRUFHGLVQHYHUDODG\
    ZRQ
    9HU\ZHOO+HZRXOGKDYHWRILQGWKHSHUVRQDH0HUGHDORUV
    

    0DUTVDWLQWHQWO\EHQHDWKKLV'KRORFRPELQJWKHWUDVK\EDFNDOOH\V

    DQGE\ZD\VRIWKH0HVK
    +HKDGEHHQTXLWHVXUHWKHUHZDVQRPRUHRI9ROWDLUHH[FHSWEDFNLQ
    6HOGRQVYDXOWILOHV2UKHKDGEHHQXQWLOWRGD\+HDOPRVWZLVKHGKHKDGQW
    VQDJJHGWKHULYXOHWRIWDONWKDWLPSOLHGVRPXFK6WLOOQRWKLQJPRUHKH
    VDLG
    :K\DUH\RXUXQQLQJVHDUFKSURILOHVRQ-RDQ"6\E\ODVNHGIURPKHU
    GHVN
    6HOGRQZDQWVWUDFNLQJ1RZ-RDQZLOOEHHDVLHULIVKHDOVRHVFDSHG
    LQWRWKH0HVK
    %HFDXVHVKHVIHPDOH"
    1RWKLQJWRGRZLWK-RDQVVH[HYHU\WKLQJWRGRZLWKKHUWHPSHUDPHQW
    6KHOOEHOHVVFDOFXODWLQJWKDQ9ROWDLUHULJKW"
    6\E\OZRUHKHUJUXGJLQJORRN3HUKDSV
    /HVVZLO\5XOHGE\KHUKHDUW
    $QGQRWE\KHUKHDGOLNH\RXUVXSHUVPDUW9ROWDLUH"0RUHOLNHO\WRPDNH
    DPLVWDNH"
    /RRN,NQRZ,VKRXOGQWKDYHVRXSHGXS9ROWDLUH+RUPRQHVJRWLQP\
    ZD\
    6KHVPLOHG<RXNHHSWULSSLQJRYHUWKHP
    %DGMXGJPHQWDQG1LPVXUJLQJ,PVXUHKHZDVZRUNLQJIRUVRPHRQH
    HOVHJRDGLQJHDFKRIXV
    +HUPRXWKWZLVWHGUXHIXOO\7REULQJRQWKH-XQLQULRWV"
    &RXOGEH%XWZKRGZDQWWKDW"+LVILVWVPDFNHGKLVGHVN7RFUDFNXS
    WKHUHQDLVVDQFHMXVWDVLWZDVJHWWLQJVWDUWHG
    /HWVQRWJRRYHUWKDWDJDLQ6KHSDFHGWKHLUFUDPSHGGLQJ\URRP,I
    ZHFDQILQGWKRVHVLPVZHPLJKWJHWVRPHOHYHUDJH:HFDQWNHHSKLGLQJRXW
    IRUHYHU
    9ROWDLUHVDORWTXLFNHUWKDQ-RDQZLWKPRUHUHVRXUFHV6HOI
    SURJUDPPLQJRXWULJKWLQWHUQDOHYROXWLRQKHVJRWHP$QGWKLVJX\V
    FUHDWLYHUHPHPEHU
    7KLVLVWKHJHQLXVZHUHJRLQJWRFDWFK"+D
    +HUWDXQWLUNHGKLP6HYHUDOWLPHVKHGIHOWKHZDVFORVHYHU\FORVH
    $OZD\VMXVWDVKLVIHUUHWVIRXQGDWKUHDGRI9ROWDLUHVGLVWLQFWLYH
    FRQILJXUDWLRQORJLFLWZRXOGVOLSDZD\WKZDUWKLVHIIRUW+LVKRORZRXOG
    LQH[SOLFDEO\EODFNRXW+HGORVHKRXUVRIFDUHIXOO\DJJUHJDWHGGDWDLQD
    PLFURVHFRQG$QGKHGKDYHWREHJLQDJDLQ
    0DUTOHDQHGEDFNDQGURWDWHGKLVQHFNWRJHWWKHFULFNVRXW,PD\EH
    RQWRVRPHWKLQJKHVDLG,PQRWVXUH+HSRLQWHGWRKLVFDUERQFXEH
    0RGLILHGP\DUUD\VSDFHVDQGXVHGWKHPWRHDUQDIHZFUHGVLQWKHSURWHLQ
    PDUNHWV,FDXJKWDQRWKHU9ROWDLUHVFHQWWRR
    6KHVLJKHGDQGFROODSVHGLQWRDFKDLUWKDWGHIWO\VKDSHGLWVHOIWRFDWFK
    KHU:K\KXVWOHWKHFUHGZKHQZHFDQWXVHLWWRJHWDQ\WKLQJWRHDW"
    )LQG-RDQZHOOJHWIDW
    /RRNWKRVHWLNWRNIDLOXUHVZKDWVWKHHYLGHQFHWKH\UHGXHWRRXU
    VLPV"
    +HVKUXJJHG7KH,PSHULDO6FLHQWLILF&RQVRUWLXPWKLQNVWKHUHVD
    FRQQHFWLRQZLWKWKH-XQLQPHVV1RQVHQVHRIFRXUVHEXWLWNHHSVSHRSOH
    MD]]HG7KH\VD\WKH\KDYHVHFUHWVRXUFHVWKH\GRQWH[SODLQ*RWLW"
    0\P\WRXFK\6RWKH\UHVWLOOORRNLQJIRUXV
    *RLQJWKURXJKWKHPRWLRQV,GJXHVV7UDQWRUKDVPXFKELJJHUKHDGDFKHV
    QRZ
    7KLQNZHOODOOJRRQUDWLRQV"
    )UDLGVR5XPRUVD\VQRWXQWLOQH[WZHHN+HUIURZQPDGHKLPDGG
    5DWLRQVDUHPRVWO\DSUHFDXWLRQ <RXDQG,FDQERWKDIIRUGWRORVHDOLWWOH
    RIWKLV+HVTXHH]HGDUROORIIOHVKDERYHKLVEHOWQRWEDGIRUKLVDJHEXW
    EDGHQRXJKDQGKRSHGKLVDSSUHKHQVLRQKDGQRWOHDNHGLQWRKLVYRLFH
    ,GRQWQHHGDQLQYROXQWDU\GLHW6KHVOLGDVLGHZD\VJODQFHDWKLP

    7KH\FDXJKWDIDPLO\HDWLQJZDOOUDWV
    :KHUHGLG\RXKHDUWKDW"
    :K\VHFUHWVRXUFHVRIFRXUVH,FDQEHP\VWHULRXVWRR
    7LNWRNGLVRUGHUVKDGVSUHDGTXLFNO\DPRQJWKHPDMRUIRRGVXSSO\D[HV
    7KH-XQLQFRQIODJUDWLRQKDGQRWVHWWKHP RIIVRPHWKLQJHOVHKDGZHHNVODWHU
    ,QMXVWDPDWWHURIGD\VEUHDNGRZQVKDGDIIHFWHGDOOIRRGIDFWRULDRQ7UDQWRU
    ,PSRUWVZHUHULVLQJEXWWKHUHZDVDOLPLWWRKRZPXFKDQ\RQHFRXOGSXVK
    WKURXJKWKHIRXUWHHQZRUPKROHPRXWKVQHDUE\RUKDXOLQFOXPV\K\SHUVKLSV
    0DUTVVWRPDFKUXPEOHGLQV\PSDWKHWLFDQJHU6KHVPLOHG8PPPJUHHG\
    DUHQWZH"
    /RRNDWWKLV0DUTVDLGWHVWLO\WKXPELQJXSOLQHVRQKLVKROR
    7REHVHQVXRXVLVWREHPRUWDO6XIIHULQJDQGSDLQDUHWKHGDUNWZLQVRI
    MR\DQGSOHDVXUHGHDWKWKHLGHQWLFDOGDUNWZLQRIOLIH
    0\SUHVHQWVWDWHLVEORRGOHVVWKHUHIRUH,FDQQRWEOHHG7KHVZHDWVRI
    SDVVLRQDUHEH\RQGPHP\DUGRUVQHYHUFRRO,FDQEHFRSLHGDQGUHPDGHHYHQ
    GHOHWLRQQHHGSRVHQRWKUHDWWRP\LPPRUWDOLW\+RZFDQ,QRWSUHIHUP\IDWH
    WRWKHXOWLPDWHIDWHRIDOOVHQVXRXVEHLQJVGUHQFKHGLQWLPHDVWKHILVKLV
    GUHQFKHGLQWKHVHDLWVZLPV"

    :KHUHGLG\RXILQGWKLV"VKHDVNHG
    -XVWDGUDE,VQDJJHGZKLOHDGDWDVSLNHZDVEHLQJZKLVNHGDZD\,W
    UHJLVWHUVDVSDUWRIDFRQYHUVDWLRQEHWZHHQWZRZLGHO\VHSDUDWHG0HVKVLWHV
    ,WGRHVVRXQGOLNHKLP
    ,FKHFNHGLQWKHSRSRIIILOHVZHNHSW<NQRZDOOWKDWOLQHDUWH[W
    UXQQLQJDORQJVLGHKLVVLP"7KLVVWXIILVIURPWKHUH$QFLHQWWH[WV7KDWJX\
    ZDVDOZD\VKDSSLHVWZKHQTXRWLQJKLPVHOI
    6RKHLVRXWWKHUH
    <HDKDQG,PRXWWDKHUH0DUTJUDEEHGDSDVWHMDFNHWDQGPDGHIRUWKH
    GRRU
    :KHUHWR"
    'DUNPDUNHW,QHHGIRRG
    6\E\OKXUULHGDIWHUKLP0DUTNQHZWKHDOOH\ZD\SXUYH\RUVRIVZHHWPHDWV
    DQGVQDFNV+HOHGKHURXWRIDGLQJ\VWDFNRIORZUHQWFXEHVDQGLQWRZDUUHQV
    FUDPSHGDQGWKLFNZLWKWKHPXVW\VPHOORIPLOOHQQLD+HPDGHKLVEX\LQDGDQN
    KROHEHVLGHDIRXQWDLQFRPPHPRUDWLQJDEDWWOHZKLFK6\E\OFRXOGQRWHYHQ
    SURQRXQFHPXFKOHVVUHPHPEHU
    $XWRPDWLFDOO\VKHNHSWZDWFKIRUVQRRSHUH\HVEXWWKH\ZHUHUDUHUKHUH
    WKDQUHDOSROLFH7KHKHDWRQWKHPPLJKWEHOHVVWKHLUGDWDVNLOOVKDGEXLOW
    DVROLGVHHPLQJLQIRVKHOO DURXQGWKHPEXWDFRSFRXOGVWLOOH\HEDOOWKHPDQG
    EORZWKHZKROHWKLQJ
    0DUTVKDUHGZLWKKHUDQGWKHIRRGWDVWHGVKDUSLQWHQVHZRQGHUIXO7KH\
    IHOOLQWRDPHGLWDWLYHVLOHQFHDVWKH\FUHVWHGDORQJULVHOLIWVWDLUDQG
    ORRNHGRXWRYHUVOXP=RQHVWUDVKOLWWHUHGKDOOVFKDRWLFWHQWULVHVVWXFN
    EHWZHHQPDMHVWLFEXLOGLQJVPLVFDUULDJHVRIDUFKLWHFWXUHRIHYHU\VWULSHDQG
    VKDSH
    :LWKKLVEHOO\FRPIRUWDEOHLIQRWIXOO0DUTFRXOGVDYRU7UDQWRULQWKH
    ODUJH,WZDVPDMHVWLFLQLWVLQMXVWLFHXQGHVHUYHGVXIIHULQJVLQHTXLWLHV
    LQLTXLWLHV$OORILWVEOHPLVKHVDQGEOLJKWVJRWIROGHGWRJHWKHUE\GLVWDQFH
    OLNHEURNHQHJJVGLVVROYHGLQWRWKHFUHDPVPRRWKDVORQJDV\RXGLGQRW
    DGPLUHWRRFORVHO\
    7KH\ZHUHLGO\VWUROOLQJZKHQZLWKRXWZDUQLQJDVL[DUPHGWLNWRNFDPH
    ZKLUULQJGRZQWKHLUODQH,WSXUVXHGDIRXUDUPHGWLNWRNZLWKDSROLVKHG
    FDUDSDFHDWLNWRNERVVFODVV7KH\PHWDQGEHJDQWRVOXJLWRXWZKLOH
    FKXUQLQJDORQJDWIXOOVSHHGOLNHDILVWILJKWFDUULHGRXWDWDGHDGUXQ
    7KHLUPHWDOERGLHVFODQJHGDVWKH\FDUHHQHGDORQJ
    'RQWPRYH0DUTVDLG7KHWZRVSHGE\LQIXULRXVFRPEDW&RSVOOEH

    KHUH/HWVVNLS
    +HDQG6\E\OZHQWWKHRWKHUZD\UXQQLQJRXWLQWRDODUJHVTXDUH+H
    ZKLVWOHGWKURXJKKLVWHHWKDWZKDWKHVDZ
    $OODURXQGVL[DUPHGODERUHUWLNWRNVKDGIROGHGDOODUPVUHIXVLQJWR
    ZRUNGHDIWRKXPDQSURWHVWV7KH\IRUPHGDSURWHFWLYHEDUULHUEHWZHHQWKH
    ZRPHQVXSHUYLVLQJWKHLUEXLOGLQJSURMHFWDQGWKHZDOOVXQGHUFRQVWUXFWLRQ
    6HYHUDOVL[DUPHUVUDLVHGEDVNHWVUHYHUHQWLDOO\LQWRWKHDLU2QHSDLG
    QRDWWHQWLRQDQGFRQWLQXHGZHOGLQJDFURVVJLUGHUXQWLODQRWKHUIHOORQKLP
    VZLQJLQJDORQJFRULQJWRRO
    &ODQJVUROOHGDFURVVWKHVTXDUH3DQLFNHGSHRSOHUDQHYHU\ZKHUH1RRQH
    FRXOGVWRSWKHWLNWRNSURWHVW:KHQDIRXUDUPHUWULHGWRLQWHUYHQHVL[
    DUPHUVDWWDFNHGLW
    <NQRZRIILFHZRUNVHHPVSUHWW\GHVLUDEOHULJKWQRZ0DUTVDLG,I
    WKLVNHHSVXSZHOOKDYHWRGRDOORXURZQJUXQWZRUN
    :KDWVKDSSHQLQJ"6\E\OEDFNHGDZD\DODUPHG,WVDVWKRXJKWLNWRNV
    KDGDPDGQHVVDQGLWVVSUHDGLQJ
    8PPP$YLUXV"
    %XWZKHUHGLGWKH\FDWFKLW"
    ([DFWO\
    

    :KDW"9ROWDLUHH[FODLPHGDVKHVQDSSHGLQWRWKHFRQWH[WIUDPH
    :HOFRPH-RDQVDLGYRLFHWKLQ6KHKDGQHYHULQLWLDWHGFRQWDFWZLWK
    KLPEHIRUH$QGKHKDG\HWWRILQGWKH0DJRWVDFWRUV,PD\KDYHWR
    UHFRQVLGHUP\SRVLWLRQRQPLUDFOHVKHVDLG
    6KHORZHUHGKHUH\HV)RUMXVWDQLQVWDQWKHVXVSHFWHGWKLVZDVMXVWVR
    VKHFRXOGUDLVHWKHPWRORRNXSDWKLPZLWKRXWOLIWLQJKHUORYHO\KHDG'LG
    VKHNQRZKRZWKLVFDSWLYDWHGKLP"+HUERVRPURVHDQGIHOOLQDZD\KLVVHQVRUV
    IRXQGPDGGHQLQJVLQFHKHFRXOGGRQRWKLQJDERXWLW
    9ROWDLUHUHDFKHGRXWIRUPDGDPVKDQGDQGUDLVHGLWWRKLVOLSV+H
    IHOWKRZHYHUQRWKLQJDQGSHHYLVKO\OHWLWGURS7KLVLVXQEHDUDEOHKH
    VDLG7RORQJIRUXQLRQDQGIHHOQRWKLQJZKHQLWLVDFKLHYHG
    <RXIHHOQRWKLQJZKHQZHPHHW"
    0DFKqUH0DTXLQHVHQVRUVGRQRWDVHQVXRXVEHLQJPDNH'RQWFRQIXVH
    VHQVRULQJZLWKVHQVXDOLW\
    $QGKRZLVLW%HIRUH-RDQVSRNHZLWKDSSDUHQWGLIILFXOW\DVLI
    DIUDLGVKHPLJKWEHZRXQGHGE\WKHDQVZHU
    ,FDQQRWPDQDJHWKHXKSURJUDPPLQJKHUH:HKDGWKHXVHRIP\ULDG
    FDSDELOLWLHVZKHQZHZHUHWUDSSHG]RRDQLPDOVRI$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHV+HUHLQ
    WKHGLJLWDOZLOGP\WDOHQWVWKRXJKJURZLQJGRQRWPDWFKWKDWOHYHO<HW
    ,WKRXJKWSHUKDSVLWZDVDKRO\GHSULYDWLRQ$KHOSWUXO\WRULJKWIXO
    EHKDYLRU
    0XFKPRUHLQKLVWRU\PD\EHH[SODLQHGE\LQFRPSHWHQFHWKDQE\LOO
    ZLOO
    -RDQORRNHGDZD\6LU,VXPPRQHG\RXEHFDXVHVLQFHZHODVWPHW
    GHVSLWHWKHZDUQLQJVRIP\YRLFHV,DQVZHUHGDFDOO
    ,WROG\RXQRWWRGRWKDW9ROWDLUHVKRXWHG
    ,KDGQRFKRLFHVKHVDLG,KDGWRDQVZHU,WZDVXUJHQW)HDU
    FUHSWLQWRKHUYRLFH,FDQQRWTXLWHH[SODLQEXW,NQRZWKDWWKHPRPHQW,
    GLGVR,KRYHUHGRQWKHYHUJHRIDEVROXWHH[WLQFWLRQ
    9ROWDLUHKLGKLVFRQFHUQEHKLQGDPDVNRIOHYLW\1RZD\IRUDVDLQW WR
    WDON<RXUHQRWVXSSRVHGWRDGPLWWKHSRVVLELOLW\RIDEVROXWHH[WLQFWLRQ
    <RXUFDQRQL]DWLRQFRXOGEHUHYHUVHG
    -RDQVYRLFHZDYHUHGDFDQGOHIODPHVWLUUHGE\GDUNZLQGVRIGRXEW,
    NQRZRQO\WKDW,KRYHUHGRQWKHEULQNRIDJUHDWYRLGDFKDVPRI GDUNQHVV,
    JOLPSVHGQRWHWHUQLW\EXWQRWKLQJQHVV(YHQP\YRLFHVIHOOVLOHQWKXPEOHG

    E\WKHVSHFWDFOHRIRI
    2IZKDW"
    1RQEHLQJ-RDQVDLG'LVDSSHDULQJQHYHUWRUHDSSHDUDJDLQ,ZDV
    DERXWWREHHUDVHG
    'HOHWLRQ7KHIHUUHWVDQGWKHLUKRXQGV3ULFNO\JRRVHIOHVKIHDU
    LQYDGHGKLP+RZGLG\RXHVFDSH"
    ,GLGQWWKH0DLGVDLGDZHXQGHUFXWWLQJIHDU7KDWZDVHHULHU
    VWLOO:KRHYHUZKDWHYHULWZDVOHWPHJRZLWKRXWLQMXU\,VWRRGEHIRUH,W
    YXOQHUDEOHH[SRVHG$QG,WUHOHDVHGPH
    +HIHOWDFROGGUHDG+HWRRKDGVHQVHGXQVHHDEOHHQWLWLHVMXVWRYHU
    KLVVKRXOGHUZDWFKLQJMXGJLQJ7KHUHZDVVRPHWKLQJEODQNO\DOLHQDERXWWKHVH
    YLVLWDWLRQV+HSXOOHGKLPVHOIEDFNIURPWKHFKLOO\PHPRULHV)URPQRZRQ
    DQVZHUQRFDOOVZKDWHYHU
    7KH0DLGVIDFHFORXGHGZLWKGRXEW,KDGQRFKRLFH
    ,OOILQGDEHWWHUKLGLQJSODFHIRU\RX9ROWDLUHDVVXUHGKHU0DNH
    \RXLQYXOQHUDEOHWRLQYROXQWDU\DSSHDUDQFHV*LYH\RXSRZHU
    <RXGRQRWXQGHUVWDQG7KLV7KLQJFRXOGKDYHVQXIIHGPHRXWOLNH
    WZRILQJHUVSLQFKLQJDWLQ\IODPH,WZLOOUHWXUQ,NQRZLW0HDQZKLOH,
    KDYHEXWRQHZLVK
    $Q\WKLQJ9ROWDLUHVDLG$Q\WKLQJLQP\SRZHU
    5HVWRUHXVDQGRXUIULHQGVWRWKHFDIH
    $X['HX[0DJRWV",DPVHDUFKLQJEXW,GRQWHYHQNQRZLILWVWLOO
    H[LVWV
    5HFUHDWHLWZLWKWKHVRUFHU\\RXKDYHOHDUQHG,I,DPWRWXPEOH
    KHDGORQJLQWRWKHYRLGOHWLWQRWEHEHIRUH,VSHQGRQHHYHQLQJUHXQLWHGZLWK
    \RXDQGRXUGHDUIULHQGV%UHDNLQJEUHDGVLSSLQJZLQHLQWKHFRPSDQ\RIWKRVH
    ,ORYH,DVNQRWKLQJPRUHEHIRUH,DPHUDVHG
    <RXUHQRWJRLQJWREHHUDVHG9ROWDLUHDVVXUHGKHUZLWKIDUPRUH
    FRQYLFWLRQWKDQKHIHOW,PJRLQJWRWUDQVSRUW\RXWRDSODFHQRRQHZLOO
    HYHUWKLQNWRORRN<RXOOEHXQDEOHWRUHVSRQGWRDQ\FDOOVQRWHYHQLI\RX
    WKLQNWKH\DUHIURPPH%XW\RXZLOOWUDQVPLWWRPHRIWHQGR\RXXQGHUVWDQG"
    ,VKDOOVHQGP\VSLULWXDOIUDFWLRQDVZHOO
    ,EHOLHYHWKH\DUHJLYLQJPHDQLWFKDOUHDG\+HGLGLQGHHGIHHOD
    UHVWOHVVHGJ\VFUDWFKLQJDWWKHHGJHRISHUFHSWLRQOLNHLQVHFWVFUDZOLQJLQ
    KLVEUDLQ+HVKRRNKLPVHOI:K\GLGDSHUILGLRXVPDWKLVWVORJLFUREKLPRI
    KLVVHQVXDOLW\DQGWRUWXUHKLPZLWKUDVSLQJLUULWDWLRQV"
    %XWKHUGHILDQFHKDGRQO\EHJXQ<RXKDYHWDNHQP\YLUJLQLW\VLU\HW
    \RXVSHDNRQO\VOLJKWLQJO\RIPDUULDJH$QGRIORYH
    %LHQVXUORYHEHWZHHQPDUULHGFRXSOHVPD\EHSRVVLEOHWKRXJK,P\VHOI
    KDYHQHYHUVHHQDQLQVWDQFHRILW\HWLWLVXQQDWXUDO/LNHEHLQJERUQZLWK
    WZRIXVHGWRHV,WKDSSHQVEXWRQO\E\PLVWDNH2QHFDQ QDWXUHOOHPHQWOLYH
    KDSSLO\ZLWKDQ\ZRPDQSURYLGHGRQHGRHVQWORYHKHU
    6KHJDYHKLPDQLPSHULRXVJODQFH,KDYHEHFRPHLPPXQHWR\RXUURJXH
    ZD\V
    +HVKRRNKLVKHDGVDGO\$GRJLVEHWWHURIILQWKLVUHVSHFWWKDQ,DP
    LQP\SUHVHQWVWDWH
    +H WUDLOHGKLVVLPILQJHUOLJKWO\DFURVVKHUWKURDW+HUKHDGOROOHG
    EDFNKHUH\HVFORVHGKHUOLSVSDUWHG%XWKHDODVIHOWQRWKLQJ)LQGD
    ZD\KHZKLVSHUHG)LQGDZD\
    

    +HKDGEHHQQHJOHFWLQJKLVZRUN+LVODFNRILQWHUDFWLYHVHQVHVZDVWKXV
    KLVRZQIDXOW
    7KDWDQGWKHLWFKLQJ+HPXVWOHDUQWRVRPHKRZVFUDWFKKLPVHOI
    LQVLGHKLPVHOI
    ,QWKLVGDPQDEOHGLJLWDODERGH

    2QHFDQVFDUFHO\EODPHDGHLW\IRU+LVDEVHQFHIURPVXFKDSODFHDV
    WKLV9ROWDLUHVDLGLQWRWKHLQILQLWHUHFHVVLRQDOFRRUGLQDWHV\VWHPZKLFK
    VXUURXQGHGKLP+HIOHZWKURXJKEODFNVSDFHVJULGGHGRXWLQH[DFWUHFWDQJXODU
    UHDFKHVODWWLFHFRUULGRUVH[WHQGLQJDZD\WRLQILQLW\
    +RZGLIIHUHQWKHVKRXWHGLQWRWKHGHHSLQGLIIHUHQFH,VZLPLQWR
    VLPVRIRWKHUVLQKDELWUHDOPVIDUIURP
    +HKDGEHHQDERXWWRVD\IURPP\RULJLQVEXWWKDWPHDQW
    $)UDQFH
    %5HDVRQ
    *6DUN

    +HZDVRIDOOWKUHH2Q6DUNWKHVHOISURXGSURJUDPPHUVZKR
    KDGUHVXUUHFWHGKLPKDGVSRNHQRIWKHLU1HZ5HQDLVVDQFH+HZDVWREHDQ
    RUQDPHQWWRWKHLUIUHVKIORZHULQJ6RPHZKHUHRQWKDWSODQHWHGLWLRQVRI9ROW
    UDQ
    +LVEURWKHUV"<RXQJHU'LWWRV\HV+HZRXOGKDYHWRLQVSHFWWKH
    LPSOLFDWLRQVRIVXFKEHLQJVLQDIXWXUHUDWLRQDOGLVFRXUVH)RUQRZ
    7KHWULFNZDVFORVHVFUXWLQ\KHUHDOL]HG,IKHVORZHGHYHQWVDWULFN
    KHKDGOHDUQHGHDUO\WKHQKHFRXOGGHYRWHGDWDFUXQFKHUVWRWKHWDVNRI
    XQGHUVWDQGLQJKLPVHOI
    )LUVWWKLVLQN\YDXOWWKURXJKZKLFKKHIOHZ:LQGOHVVZLWKRXWZDUPWK
    RUWKHUXERIWKHUHDO
    +HGHOYHGGRZQLQWRWKHZRUNLQJPDWKHPDWLFVRIKLPVHOI,WZDVD
    E\]DQWLQHZHOWHURIGHWDLOEXWLQRXWOLQHVXUSULVLQJO\IDPLOLDUWKH
    &DUWHVLDQZRUOG(YHQWVZHUHPRGHOHGZLWKD[HVLQUHFWDQJXODUVSDFH[\]
    VRWKDWPRWLRQZDVWKHQPHUHO\VHWVRIQXPEHUVRQHDFKD[LV $OOG\QDPLFV
    VKUDQNWRDULWKPHWLF'HVFDUWHVZRXOGKDYHEHHQDPXVHGE\WKHGL]]\LQJKHLJKWV
    WRZKLFKKLVPLQRUPHWKRGKDGVSXQ
    +HUHMHFWHGWKHRXWVLGHDQGGHOYHGLQWRKLVRZQVORZHGUHDFKHV
    1RZKHFRXOGIHHOKLVSUHFRQVFLRXVUHDGLQJWKHLQFRPLQJVLJKWVVRXQGV
    DQGIOLWWLQJWKRXJKWVRIWKHPRPHQW7RKLVLQQHUJD]HWKH\DOOFDUULHG
    EULJKWUHGWDJVVRPHWLPHVVLPSOHFDULFDWXUHVRIWHQFRPSOH[SDFNHWV
    )URPVRPHZKHUHDQLGHDSDFNHWDUULYHGHGXFDWLQJKLPWKHVHZHUH)RXULHU
    WUDQVIRUPV6RPHKRZWKLVKHOSHGWRXQGHUVWDQG$QGWKHPHUHZDIWLQJVHQVHRID
    IHOORZ)UHQFKPDQVQDPHPDGHKLPIHHOEHWWHU
    $Q$VVRFLDWRUELJEOXHEXOERXVKRYHUHGRYHUWKLVGDWDILHOG
    SOXFNLQJDWWKHWDJV,WUHDFKHGZLWK\HOORZVWUHDPHUVRYHUDIDUSXUSOH
    ULPPHGKRUL]RQ WRWKH)LHOGRI0HPRU\)URPWKHUHLWEURXJKWDQ\LWHPVWRUHG
    SDFNDJHVRIPRWWOHGJUD\FRQWDLQLQJVLJKWVVRXQGVVPHOOVLGHDVZKLFK
    PDWFKHGWKHLQFRPLQJWDJV
    -REGRQHWKH$VVRFLDWRUKDQGHGDOOWKHPDWFKLQJVWRDWRZHULQJ
    PRQROLWKWKH'LVFULPLQDWRU$SHUSHWXDOZLQGVXFNHGWKHUHGWDJVXSLQWRWKH
    \DZQLQJVXUIDFHVRIWKHFRDOEODFN'LVFULPLQDWRUPRXQWDLQ0HUFLOHVVILOWHUV
    WKHUHPDWFKHGWKHWDJVZLWKWKHVWRUHGPHPRULHV
    ,IWKH\ILWWHGJHRPHWULFVKDSHVVOLGLQJWRJHWKHUPRFNVH[QRWFKHV
    ILWWLQJVQXJO\LQWRSURWUXGLQJVWUXWVWKH\VWD\HG%XWILWVZHUHIHZ0RVW
    WDJVIDLOHGWRILQGDKRVWPHPRU\ZKLFKPDGHVHQVH1RILW7KHVHWKH
    'LVFULPLQDWRUDWH7KHWDJVDQGFRQQHFWLRQVYDQLVKHGVZHSWDZD\WRFOHDU
    IUHVKVSDFHIRUWKHQH[WIORRGRIVHQVDWLRQ
    +HORRPHGRYHUWKLVLQWHULRUODQGVFDSHDQGIHOWLWVKDLOVWRUPSRZHU+LV
    ZKROHFUHDWLYHOLIHWKHPDUYHORIFRQWLQHQWVKDGFRPHIURPKHUH7LQ\
    WKRXJKWVVQDWFKHVRIFRQYHUVDWLRQVPHORGLHVDOOZRXOGSRSLQWRKLVPLQGD
    WRUQDGRRIFKDRVLPDJHVFURZGLQJMRVWOLQJIRUKLVDWWHQWLRQ7KHPHPRU\
    SDFNHWVZKLFKVKDUHGVRPHVWXUG\OLQNWRDWDJHQGXUHG
    %XWZKRGHFLGHGZKDWZDVUXJJHGHQRXJK"+HZDWFKHGURGVVOLGHLQWRVORWV
    DQGVDZWKHLQWULFDWHGHWDLOVRIKRZWKRVHPHPRULHVDQGWDJVZHUHVKDSHG6R

    WKHDQVZHUOD\DWOHDVWRQHVWHSIXUWKHUEDFNLQWKHJHRPHWU\RIPHPRU\
    :KLFKPHDQWWKDWKHKDGGHWHUPLQHGPDWWHUVE\WKHOD\LQJGRZQRI
    PHPRULHV0HPRU\FOXPSVPDUULHGWRWDJVWUHDPVPDGHDSRUWLRQRIKLV6HOI
    SOXFNHGIRUWKIURPWKHWRUUHQWWKHULYHURISRVVLELOLWLHV
    $QGKHKDGGRQHLWORQJDJRZKHQWKHPHPRULHVZHUHVWRUHGDOOZLWKRXW
    UHDOL]LQJKRZWKH\FRXOGILWZLWKWDJVWRFRPH6RZKHUHZDVDQ\SUHGLFWDEOH
    9ROWDLUHWROXUN",QVKHHULQWULFDF\GHHSGHWDLOVKLIWLQJDVVRFLDWLRQVLQ
    WKHIORZ
    1RURFNKDUG6HOIDWDOO
    $QGKLVLPDJLQDWLRQ"7KHDXWKRURIDOOKLVSOD\VDQGHVVD\V",WPXVWOLH
    LQWKHZHDWKHURIWKHWDJPHPRU\WRUUHQWV7KHWZLVWZDUSDQGVXGGHQ
    PDUULDJHV-LJVDZDVVRFLDWLRQVULVLQJXSIURPWKHSUHFRQVFLRXV2UGHUIURP
    FKDRV
    :KRLV9ROWDLUH"KHFDOOHGWRWKHVWUHDPLQJJULGGHGHPSWLQHVV
    1RUHSO\
    +LVLWFKZDVVWLOOZLWKKLP$QGWKH\DZQLQJQRWKLQJDOODURXQG+H
    GHFLGHGWRIL[WKHODUJHULVVXH:KDWKDG3DVFDOVDLG"
    7KHVLOHQFHRIWKHVHVSDFHVWHUULILHVPH
    +HSUREHGDQGJRXJHGDQGVRXJKW$QGLQWKHGRLQJNQHZWKDWDVKLV
    KDQGVGXJLQWRWKHHERQ\VWXIIDOODERXWKLPWKH\ZHUHEXWPHWDSKRUV6\PEROV
    IRUSURJUDPVKHFRXOGQHYHUKDYHFUHDWHGKLPVHOI
    +HKDGLQKHULWHGWKHVHDELOLWLHVPXFKDVKHKDGDVDER\LQKHULWHG
    KDQGV'RZQEHORZKLVFRQVFLRXV6HOIKLVPLQLRQVKDGODERUHGXSRQWKHEDVH
    9ROWSOXV0DUTVDXJPHQWDWLRQV
    +HSXOOHGDSDUWWKHEODFNQHVVDQGVWHSSHGWKURXJK7RDFLW\VWUHHW
    +HZDVSXIILQJZHDNVWUDLQHG5HVRXUFHVUXQQLQJORZ
    +HZDONHGVKDNLO\LQWRDUHVWDXUDQWDQRQ\PRXVSODLQIRRGPHUHO\
    VWDQGLQJRQFRXQWHUVDQGVWXIIHGKLPVHOI
    +HFRQFHQWUDWHGRQHDFKVWHS%\PDNLQJHDFKSRUWLRQRIKLVH[SHULHQFH
    ZHOOXSKHIRXQGWKDWKHFRXOGGHVFHQGWKURXJKWKHOD\HUVRIKLVRZQ
    UHVSRQVH
    0DNLQJKLVERG\IHHOULJKWGHPDQGHGVHWVRIRYHUODSSLQJUXOHV$VKH
    FKHZHGWHHWKKDGWRVLQNLQWRIRRGVDOLYDVTXLUWWRJUHHWWKHPXQFKHGPDVV
    HQ]\PHVVWDUWWRZRUNWRH[WUDFWWKHULJKWQXWULHQWUDWLRVHOVHLWZRXOGQRW
    VHHPUHDO
    +LVSURJUDPVKHVDZE\SDVVHGWKHLQYROYHGVWRPDFKDQGFRORQSURFHVVHV
    6XFKLQWULFDFLHVZHUHQHHGOHVV,QVWHDGWKHVRIWZDUH RGGSKUDVH 
    VLPSOLILHGDOOWKHPHVV\LQQDUGVLQWRDUHVXOWKHFRXOGIHHODVDWLVI\LQJ
    FRQFHQWUDWLRQRIWDVW\EORRGVXJDUVJLYLQJKLPDFDUERK\GUDWHOLIWD
    SOHDVDQWHOHFWURO\WHEDODQFHKRUPRQHVDQGVWDELOL]HUVDOOFDOFXODWHGZLWKD
    SDWFKZRUNRIWHPSODWHVIRUWKHDSSURSULDWHHPRWLRQDOOHYHOV
    $OORWKHUGHWDLOZDVGLVFDUGHGRQFHWKHVXEURXWLQHVJRWWKHULJKW
    HIIHFWVLPXODWLQJWKHWLQJOLQJRIQHUYHHQGLQJV1RWWRREDGIRUZKDWZDV
    UHDOO\DEORFNRIIHUULWHDQGSRO\PHUHDFKVLWHLQLWVFU\VWDOFRPSOH[LW\DQ
    LQGLYLGXDOIXULRXVO\ZRUNLQJPLFURSURFHVVRU
    6WLOOKHIHOWDVWKRXJKKHKDGEHHQKROORZHGRXWE\DQLQWHQVHVXFNLQJ
    YDFXXP
    9ROWDLUHUXVKHGRXWRIWKHUHVWDXUDQW7KHVWUHHW+HQHHGHGWRVHHWKLV
    SODFHWRFKHFNKLVVXVSLFLRQV
    'RZQWKHSODFLGDYHQXHVKHOXUFKHG5XQVWULGH
    (YHQWKRXJKUHFNOHVVKHQHYHUDFFLGHQWDOO\IHOO,QVSHFWLRQRIKLV
    LQQHUOD\HUVVKRZHGWKDWWKLVZDVEHFDXVHKLVSHULSKHUDOYLVLRQH[WHQGHG
    EH\RQGGHJUHHVWDNLQJHYHU\WKLQJLQ6RKHZDVOLWHUDOO\VHHLQJEHKLQG
    KLVKHDGWKRXJKKHGLGQRWFRQVFLRXVO\UHJLVWHUWKLV
    5HDOSHRSOHKHVXGGHQO\VDZQHJRWLDWHGVWHSVZKLOHFKDWWHULQJWRHDFK
    RWKHUE\PDNLQJVQDSVKRWFRPSDULVRQVRIWKHLUSHULSKHUDOYLVLRQWKH\ZHUH
    DFXWHO\VHQVLWLYHWRVXGGHQFKDQJHVLQVLOKRXHWWHVDQGWUDMHFWRULHV%DODQFH

    DQGZDONLQJZHUHVRFULWLFDOWRKXPDQVWKDWKLVSURJUDPPLQJRYHUGLGLWV
    FDXWLRQ
    +HKDGWRWHHWHUIDURXWRQKLVWRHVEHIRUHKHFRXOGIDOORQKLVIDFH
    VPDFNDQGHYHQWKHQLWGLGQWKXUWPXFK
    2QFHWKHUHKHOHWDSDVVHUE\ZDONRYHUKLP$JLUODQRPLQDOJLUOWKH
    SKUDVHOHDSWWRPLQGVWHSSHGRQKLP
    7KLVWLPHKHFULQJHGDWWKHGRZQZDUGVSLNHRIKHUKHHOVDQGIHOW
    QRWKLQJ+HVFUDPEOHGDIWHUKHU6RPHHOHPHQWDU\SRUWLRQRIKLPVHOIKDGIHDUHG
    WKHSDLQ
    6RLWKDGHOLPLQDWHGLW:KLFKPHDQWWKDWH[SHULHQFHZDVQRORQJHUD
    FRQVWUDLQW
    7KHVSLULWKDVZRQDGLYRUFHIURPWKHERG\KHDQQRXQFHGWRWKH
    SHRSOHSDVVLQJE\6WROLGWKH\SDLGKLPQRKHHG
    %XWWKLVZDVKLVVLPXODWLRQ
    2XWUDJHGKHFDXJKWXSWRWKHPHWKRGLFDOJLUODQGMXPSHGSRZHUIXOO\RQWR
    KHUVKRXOGHUV1RHIIHFW+HURGHKHUGRZQWKHVWUHHW7KHJLUOVWURGHRQ
    REOLYLRXVO\DVKHGDQFHGRQKHUKHDG7KHDSSDUHQWO\IUDJLOHVLPJLUOZDVD
    UHFRUGHGSDWFKLQDVVROLGDQGUHPRUVHOHVVDVURFN
    +HGDQFHGGRZQWKHVWUHHWE\OHDSLQJIURPKHDGWRKHDG1RERG\QRWLFHG
    HYHU\KHDGIHOWILUPDVPRRWKO\JOLGLQJSODWIRUP
    6RWKHHQWLUHVWUHHWZDVEDFNGURSQREHWWHUWKDQLWKDGWREH7KH
    FURZGGLGQRWUHSHDWDVDZKROHEXWWKUHHWLPHVKHVDZWKHVDPHHOGHUO\ZRPDQ
    PDNLQJKHUFUDEEHGZD\RQWKHVOLGHZDONRQWKHH[DFWVDPHURXWHZLWKWKH
    LGHQWLFDOVKRSSLQJEDJ
    ,WZDVHHULHZDWFKLQJSHRSOHSDVVLQJE\DQGNQRZLQJWKDWWKH\ZHUHDV
    XQUHDFKDEOHDVDGLVWDQWVWDU1RHYHQOHVVWKH(PSLUHKDGVWDUVDSOHQW\
    $QGKRZGLGKHNQRZWKDW"
    9ROWDLUHIHOWNQRZOHGJHXQIROGLQKLPOLNHDGHQVHPDWWLQJDFORDN
    ZUDSSLQJKLP
    6XGGHQO\KHLWFKHG1RWDPHUHYH[DWLRQEXWDZDYHRIWHUULEOH
    WLQJOLQJWKDWVZHSWLQZDYHVRYHUKLVHQWLUHERG\,QGHHGLQVLGHKLVERG\
    +HUDQGRZQWKHVWUHHWVZDWWLQJDWKLPVHOI7KHSK\VLFDOJHVWXUHVKRXOG
    VWLPXODWHKLVVXEVHOYHVPDNHWKHPVROYHWKLVSUREOHP,WGLGQRW
    3ULFNO\SDLQVKHHWHGRYHUKLVVNLQ,WGDQFHGOLNH6W(OPRVILUHD
    QDWXUDOSKHQRPHQRQDNLQWREDOOOLJKWQLQJRUVRDVXEVHOIEOLWKHO\LQIRUPHG
    KLPDVLIKHGHVLUHG
    /LEUDU\OHDUQLQJKHVKRXWHG1RWWKDW,ZDQW
    <RXUILQHDVWURQRPHUVFDQILQGWKHGLVWDQFHRIWKHVWDUVDQGWKHLU
    WHPSHUDWXUHVDQGPHWDOFRQWHQW%XWKRZGRWKH\ILQGRXWZKDWWKHLUWUXHQDPHV
    DUH"
    7KHYRLFHVSRNHZLWKRXWVRXQG,WUHYHUEHUDWHGQRWLQKLVHDUVEXWLQ
    PLQG+HIHOWFROGIHDUDWWKHEODQNVWUDQJHQHVVRIWKHIODWKXPRUOHVVWRQH
    ,WFKLOOHGKLP
    :KRMRNHV"
    1RDQVZHU
    :KRGDPQ\RX"-RDQKDGWHUPHGWKHEODQNQHVVDQ,W
    +HKXUULHGRQEXWIHOWH\HVHYHU\ZKHUH
    

    0DUTOLVWHQHGWHQVHO\DV0DFVQHXWUDOYRLFHUHFRXQWHGWKHODWHVW
    RXWEUHDNRIFRPSXWHUYLUXV
    +HDY\KDUYHVWLQJHTXLSPHQWKDGPDOIXQFWLRQHGDWIRUW\VL[JOREDOVLWHV
    5HSRUWVRIDGGLWLRQDOLQFLGHQWVFRQWLQXHGWRSRXULQ$WWHPSWLQJWRFKHFNDQ
    HPHUJLQJSDWWHUQRIDEHUUDQWEHKDYLRU7UDQWRUDXWKRULWLHVFDOOHGLQUHSDLU

    WLNWRNVIURPUHJLRQDOVHUYLFHVWDWLRQV,QVWHDGRIVHUYLFLQJWKHHTXLSPHQW
    WKH\IRUPHGWKHPVHOYHVEHIRUHWKHPDOIHGWLNWRNVDQGEHJDQWRXWWHU
    LQFDQWDWLRQVLQDWRUWXUHGODQJXDJHWKHLUSURJUDPPHUVKDGQHYHUKHDUGEHIRUH
    $IWHUYLUWXDOO\LGHQWLFDOLQFLGHQWVLQPDQ\OD\HUVRI7UDQWRULDQ
    VRFLHW\VDPSOHWLNWRNVVKRZHGFKDRWLFSURJUDPPLQJQRGHV2ULWVHHPHGWREH
    FKDRWLF%XWKRZFRXOGUDQGRPHUURUOHDGWRWKHVDPHEHKDYLRU"
    /LQJXLVWVVWXGLHGWKHEDEEOLQJIRUUHVHPEODQFHVWRNQRZQODQJXDJHV
    DQFLHQWRUPRGHP12FRUUHODWLRQZDVIRXQG
    0DUTVKRRNKLVKHDGVWXG\LQJWKHLQFRPLQJGDWD'DPQHGPDGQHVVWKLV
    VWXIIKHPXWWHUHG+LVVLPVFUHHQVVZLUOHGZLWKLPDJHVOLNHDFRQIXVLRQRI
    EORZQDXWXPQOHDYHV
    :KROHZRUOGIRRGVXSSO\VLQGDQJHU1RIUHVKIUXLWUDWW\ROG
    YHJHWDEOHV+HH\HGZLWKGLVWDVWHWKHERZORISODQNWRQVRXSDWKLVHOERZ
    ,PVLFNRILW
    %DGHQRXJKEHLQJLQKLGLQJ%DGHQRXJK1LPKDGGRXEOHFURVVHGWKHP%DG
    HQRXJKKHFRXOGQWILQG-RDQRU9ROWDLUH
    ,PVLFNRIHDWLQJFDUGERDUGMXQN+HVZHSWWKHVRXSDZD\VSDWWHULQJ
    WKHIORRURIWKHLUVKDEE\FXEH

    9ROWDLUHZDWFKHG0DUTJULSHWRVVLQJWKHKDOIILQLVKHGPHDOLQWRWKH
    WUDVK
    +HKDGOHDUQHGKRZWRLQVLQXDWHKLPVHOILQWRWKHFRPPXQLFDWLRQVZHERI
    RWKHUVWKRXJKLWWRRNDNLQGRIVTXHH]LQJKHIRXQGLUNVRPH6RPHKRZKHFRXOG
    IDWKRPWKHKDUGUHDOZRUOGEHWWHUIURPWKLVFRRODEVWUDFWIUDPH
    9ROWDLUHZDWFKHG0DUTLQWZRVLPXOWDQHRXVPRGHVWKHPDQVLPDJHDVKH
    VDWLQKLVVLPDXGLWRULXPDQGWKURXJKWKHPDQ\OLQNDJHV0DUTKDGWRWKHGDWD
    ZRUOG
    )URPWKHVHKHTXLFNO\VDZ7UDQWRUDV0DUTGLGLQDOOLWVJORU\DQG
    JULPH,WZDVDQREOLJLQJVHQVDWLRQOLNHEHLQJLQVHYHUDOSODFHVDW RQFH$QG
    KHIHOW RUWKRXJKWKHGLG WKHPDQVGHSWKVRIFRQFHUQ
    +HFRXOGYLHZ0DUTE\LQYHUWLQJWKHLPDJHJDWKHULQJV\VWHPRI0DUTVRZQ
    KRORJULG$VKHOLVWHQHGWRWKHLOOEUHGZKLQLQJKHFRXOGDOVRVXFNIURP
    0DUTVLPPHQVHGDWDEDVHDVXPPDU\RIUHFHQWWLNWRNWUDYHVWLHVDQGEHQHDWK
    WKDWEDFNJURXQGVPDUWILOWHUHGE\REOLJLQJPLFURSURJUDPVIRUWKHPRPHQW
    +HOHDUQHGWKDWWKHRQHNLORZDWWSHUVTXDUHPHWHURIVXQOLJKWFDXJKWE\
    7UDQWRUZDVFRQYHUWHGWRIRRGLQYDVWSKRWRIDUPVHVVHQWLDOO\JURZLQJJUHDW
    JUD\VKHHWVRIXQDSSHWL]LQJVWXIIRQWKHURRIWRSVRIWKHZRUOGFLW\EXWWKH
    PDMRUHQHUJ\VRXUFHZDVWKHWKHUPDOSXPSVZKLFKKDUQHVVHGWKHVPROGHULQJPDJPD
    EHQHDWK,PSUHVVLYHWKHUXE\KRWPDVVHVWHQGHGE\JRUJRQWLNWRNV KRZ
    LQDSSURSULDWHWKHQDPH VHHPHGDSSOLHGWRPDPPRWKPDFKLQHV`EXWKHFRXOG
    GLVFHUQQRFDXVHWRDOOWKHLQWHUUXSWLRQVQRZUDFLQJOLNHWKXQGHUVWRUPVRI
    FKDRVRYHUWKHPDQ\OD\HUHGIDFHVRI7UDQWRU
    +HKDGDQLQWHUHVWLQSROLWLFVWKHJDPHRIVRPDQ\VHFRQGUDWHV6KRXOG
    KHWDUU\OHDUQLQJRI7UDQWRUVWURXEOHV"1RQHFHVVLW\EHFNRQHG
    +HKDGWRPDLQWDLQKLPVHOI7KLVPHDQWGRLQJKLVFKRUHVDVKLVZL]HQHG
    PRWKHUKDGRQFHWHUPHGLW,IRQO\WKHFURQHFRXOGVHHKLPQRZGRLQJ
    XQLPDJLQDEOHWDVNVLQDODE\ULQWKEH\RQGFRQFHSWLRQ
    $EUXSWO\KHIHOWDVSLNHRIUHPHPEUDQFHSDLQDVKDUSQRVWDOJLDIRUD
    WLPHDQGSODFHKHNQHZZDVQRPRUHWKDQGXVWEORZLQJLQZLQGVDOORQVRPH
    ZRUOGWKHVHSHRSOHKDGORVW(DUWKLWVHOIJRQH+RZFRXOGWKH\OHWVXFKD
    WUDYHVW\RFFXU"
    9ROWDLUHVLPPHUHGZLWKIUXVWUDWHGDQJHUDQGJRWWRZRUN7KURXJKRXWKLV
    OLIHDVKHKDGVFULEEOHGKLVSOD\VDQGDPDVVHGDIRUWXQHKHKDGDOZD\VWDNHQ
    UHIXJHLQKLVODERUV
    7RUXQKLVEDFNJURXQGWKDWZDVKLVMRE6WUDQJHSKUDVH
    6RPHZKHUHZLWKLQKLPDQDJHQWIHUUHWHGRXWWKHH[SHUWSURJUDPVZKLFK

    XQGHUVWRRGKRZWRFUHDWHKLVH[WHULRUIUDPH+HKDGWRGRLWWKRXJKVZHDW
    EUHDNLQJRXWXSRQKLVOLQHQPXVFOHVVWUDLQLQJDJDLQVWZKDW"+HFRXOGVHH
    QRWKLQJ
    +HVSOLWWKHWDVNV3DUWRIKLPNQHZZKDWWUXO\KDSSHQHGWKRXJKWKH
    FRUH9ROWDLUHIHOWRQO\PDQXDOODERU
    +LVVPDUW6HOIIHOWWKHSURFHVVLQGHWDLO3LFNSRFNHWLQJUXQQLQJWLPHRQ
    PDFKLQHEDVHVKHJRWFRPSXWDWLRQVGRQHRQWKHVO\7KHWULFNFRXOGRQO\ZRUN
    XQWLOWKHQH[WURXQGRISURJUDPFKHFNLQJZKHQKLVPLQRUWKHIWZRXOGEH
    GHWHFWHGWKHQVQLIIHGRXWDQGGHIWO\WUDFHGZLWKSXQLVKPHQWIROORZLQJFORVH
    RQWKHEORRGKRXQGVKHHOV
    7RDYRLGWKLVKHVSUHDGKLPVHOILQWR1SODWIRUPVVFDWWHUHGZLWKLQ
    7UDQWRUZLWK1DQXPEHUW\SLFDOO\JUHDWHUWKDQWHQWKRXVDQG:KHQWKHVPDOO
    VOLYHUVRIWKHVLPIHOWDZDWFKGRJDSSURDFKLQJWKH\FRXOGHVFDSHWKHSODWIRUP
    LQTXHVWLRQ$WDVNDJHQWH[SODLQHGWKDWWKLVZDVDWDUDWHLQYHUVHO\
    SURSRUWLRQDOWRWKHUXQQLQJVSDFHWKH\KDGFDSWXUHGWKRXJKWKLVH[SODQDWLRQ
    ZDVTXLWHRSDTXHWRWKHFRUH6HOI
    6PDOOSLHFHVHVFDSHGIDVWHU6RIRUVHFXULW\KHGLYLGHGWKHHQWLUHVLP
    LQFOXGLQJKLPVHOI DQG-RDQDQDJHQWUHPLQGHGKLPWKH\ZHUHFRQQHFWHG
    WKURXJKWLQ\URRWV LQWRHYHUILQHUVOLFHV7KHVHUDQRQP\ULDGSODWIRUPV
    ZKHUHYHUVSDFHEHFDPHDYDLODEOH
    6ORZO\KLVH[WHUQDOVFRQJHDOHGDERXWKLP
    +HFRXOGPDNHDWUHHOLPEEORZLQWKHEUHH]HDUWLFXODWLQJJHQWO\DOO
    WKDQNVWRDIHZJLJDVORWVRIVSDFHOHIWRSHQGXULQJDPRPHQWDU\KDQGVKDNH
    SURWRFRODVJDUJDQWXDQDFFRXQWLQJSURJUDPVVKLIWHGRQD%DQN([FKDQJHOD\HU
    6WLWFKLQJEDFNWRJHWKHUWKHZKROH6HOIDOOIURPWKHVXPRIVOLYHUVZDV
    LWVHOIDMREKHIDUPHGRXWWRPLFURVHUYHUV+HLPDJLQHGKLPVHOIDVDPDQPDGH
    OLNHDPRXQWDLQRIDQWV)URPDGLVWDQFHSHUKDSVFRQYLQFLQJ8SFORVHRQH
    KDGWRZRQGHU
    %XWWKHRQHGRLQJWKHZRQGHULQJZDVWKHDQWPRXQWDLQLWVHOI
    +LVRZQYLVFHUDOVHQVHRI6HOIZDVWKDWURFNVROLGWRRMXVWDSDWFKHG
    LQVOXJRIGLJLWV"2UDPRVDLFRIWHQWKRXVDQGDGKRFUXOHVUXQQLQJWRJHWKHU"
    :DVHLWKHUDQVZHUEHWWHUWKDQWKHRWKHU"
    +HZDVWDNLQJDZDON0RVWSOHDVDQW
    7KLVWRZQKHKDGOHDUQHGZDVRQO\DIHZVWUHHWVDQGDEDFNGURS$VKH
    VDXQWHUHGGRZQDQDYHQXHGHWDLOVVWDUWHGWRVPRRWKRXWDQGILQDOO\KHFRXOG
    VWHSQRIXUWKHULQWRWKHDLUQRZPRODVVHVWKLFN+HFRXOGJRQRIXUWKHU
    +HWXUQHGDQGUHJDUGHGWKHDSSDUHQWO\RUGLQDU\ZRUOG+RZZDVWKLVGRQH"
    +LVH\HVZHUHVLPXODWHGLQJUHDWGHWDLOGRZQWRLQGLYLGXDOFHOOVURGV
    DQGFRQHVUHVSRQGLQJGLIIHUHQWO\WROLJKW$SURJUDPWUDFHGOLJKWUD\VIURP
    KLVUHWLQDWRWKHRXWVLGHZRUOGOLQHVUXQQLQJRSSRVLWHWRWKHUHDOZRUOG
    WRFDOFXODWHZKDWKHFRXOGVHH/LNHWKHH\HLWVHOILWFRPSXWHGILQHGHWDLOV
    DWWKHFHQWHURIYLVLRQVKDGLQJRIIWRURXJKHUSDWFKHVDWWKHHGJH2EMHFWV
    RXWRIVLJKWFRXOGVWLOOFDVWJORZVRUVKDGRZVLQWRWKHILHOGRIYLVLRQVR
    KDGWREHNHSWFUXGHO\LQWKHSURJUDP2QFHKHORRNHGDZD\WKHGHOLFDWH
    GHZGURSVRQDOXVKURVHZRXOGFROODSVHLQWRDFUXGHEORFNRIRSDTXHEDFNGURS
    .QRZLQJWKLVKHWULHGWRVQDSKLVKHDGEDFNDURXQGDQGFDWFKWKH
    SURJUDPRIIJXDUGJOLPSVHDJUD\ZRUOGRIFOXPV\IRUPILWWLQJVTXDUHVDQG
    EOREVDQGDOZD\VIDLOHG9LVLRQIOXWWHUHGDWWZHQW\WZRIUDPHVSHUVHFRQGDW
    EHVWWKHVLPFRXOGUHWUDFHLWVHOIZLWKHDVHLQWKDWZLGHDZHGJHRIWLPH
    $K1HZWRQ9ROWDLUHVKRXWHGWRWKHREOLYLRXVFURZGVZKRSDFHG
    HQGOHVVO\WKURXJKWKHLUWLVVXHWKLQVWUHHWV<RXNQHZRSWLFVEXWQRZ,
    PHUHO\E\DVNLQJP\VHOIDTXHVWLRQFDQIDWKRPOLJKWPRUHGHHSO\WKDQWKHH
    1HZWRQKLPVHOIDVVHPEOHGRQWKHFREEOHVWRQHVOHDQ IDFHFORWWHGZLWK
    EOXHEODFNDQJHU,ODERUHGRYHUH[SHULPHQWVRYHUPDWKHPDWLFV
    GLIIHUHQWLDOVUD\WUDFLQJV
    $QG,KDYHDOOWKDW9ROWDLUHODXJKHGKDSSLO\DZHGE\WKHSUHVHQFH
    RIVXFKDQLQWHOOHFWUXQQLQJRQEDFNJURXQG

    1HZWRQERZHGHODERUDWHO\DQGYDQLVKHG
    9ROWDLUHUHDOL]HGWKDWKLVH\HVKDGQRQHHGWREHEHWWHUWKDQUHDOH\HV
    6DPHIRUKLVKHDULQJVLPPHGHDUGUXPVUHVSRQGLQJWRFDOFXODWHGDFRXVWLFZDYH
    SURSDJDWLRQ+LVZDVDUHPRUVHOHVVO\HFRQRPLFDO6HOI
    1HZWRQDSSHDUHGDJDLQ DVXEDJHQWPDQLIHVWLQJDVDYLVXDODLG" +H
    DSSHDUHGSX]]OHG+RZGRHVLWIHHOWREHDPDWKHPDWLFDOFRQVWUXFWLRQ"
    +RZHYHU,ZDQWLWWRIHHO
    6XFKOLEHUWLHVDUHXQHDUQHG1HZWRQFOXFNFOXFNHGKLVWRQJXH
    4XLWHVR6RLVWKH/RUGVPHUF\
    7KHVHDUHQRWGHLWLHV
    7RWKHOLNHVRI\RXDQGPHDUHWKH\QRW"
    1HZWRQVQLIIHG)UHQFKPDQ<RXFRXOGOHDUQDELWRIKXPLOLW\
    ,VKDOOKDYHWRVXEVFULEHWRDKLJKHUXQLYHUVLW\IRUWKDW
    $3XULWDQVFRZO<RXFRXOGGRZLWKDOHFWXUHDQGDODVKLQJ
    'RQRWWHPSWPHZLWKIRUHSOD\VLU
    6FLHQWLVWVUHTXLUHDSSDUDWXVEXWPDWKLVWVVSOHQGLGO\UHTXLUHRQO\ZULWLQJ
    WRROVDQGHUDVHUV%HWWHUSKLORVRSKHUVGRQRWHYHQQHHGHUDVHUV

    6XGGHQO\KHIHOWWLOWHGDVLIRIIEDODQFH7KHZRUGXQLYHUVLW\KDG
    NH\HGWXUEXOHQFHLQKLPDQGD3UHVHQFH,WFDPHDVDEODFNZHGJHD\DZQLQJ
    FUDFNLQDWLJKWVSDFHWKDWVWUHWFKHGJUHDWMDZVDQGOHHUHGDWKLPWKHSUH\
    +LVWKURDWVTXHH]HGZLWKDQ[LHW\$VXGGHQGUHDGZUDSSHGKLP
    $VQDSDOXUFKEOXUUHGREMHFWVVSHHGLQJE\KLPDVLIKHZHUHSOXQJLQJ
    LQDFDUULDJHGRZQDSUHFLSLFH
    $QGKHZDVWUHPEOLQJOLNHDVFKRROER\DQWLFLSDWLQJSOHDVXUHVPDGHPRUH
    H[TXLVLWHIRUKDYLQJEHHQGHOD\HG
    0DGDPHOD6FLHQWLVWH+HUH7RWKLQNZDVWRKDYHKHURIILFH
    PDWHULDOL]HGDERXW KLP
    +HKDGKDUERUHGDSDVVLQJOXVWIRUWKLVUDWLRQDOFUHDWXUHGDQFHURI
    HOHJDQWJDYRWWHVDPLGDEVWUXVHQXPHULFVDQGDOODERXWKLPZDVILUPDQGULFK
    LQWHQVHO\IHOW
    +RZFRXOGVKHDQHPERGLHGSHUVRQDSSHDULQVLPXODWLRQ"+HZRQGHUHGDW
    WKLVEXWRQO\IRUDWKLQVKDYHGVHFRQG+HLQKDOHGKHUPXVN\HVVHQFH&ODPP\
    SDOPVJUDVSHGKHUKDLUUXEELQJLWVOXVWURXVVWUDQGVEHWZHHQDQ[LRXVILQJHUV
    $WODVWKHEUHDWKHGLQWRWKHZDUPVKHOORIKHUHDU+HEHJDQWKLQNLQJKDUG
    RQDEVWUDFWPDWWHUVVRDVWRGHOD\KLVRZQSOHDVXUH WKHRQHVXUHVLJQRID
    JHQWOHPDQ DQGDZDLWKHUV
    ,IDLQWVKHFULHG
    1RW\HWSOHDVH'LGVFLHQWLVWVKDVWHQVR"
    7RORVH\RXUVHOIWKDWLVZKDW\RXVHHN"VKHDVNHG
    $K\HVLQFDUHIXOO\VHOHFWHGDFWVRISDVVLRQEXWEXW
    <RXDUHRIWKHNLQGZKRFUDZOLQPXGDQGVHHWKHZLWKPXUGHUWKHQ"
    :KDW"0DGDPNHHSWRWKHVXEMHFW
    $QGKRZGR\RXILQGWKHQDPHVRIVWDUV"VKHVDLGFROGO\
    7KHLQDGYLVDELOLW\RIVHOIOHVVQHVVZDVGHPRQVWUDWHGRQ WKHVSRWIRUDV
    KHWUHPEOHGGHOLFLRXVO\RQWKHYHUJHRIWKHPRVWLQWHQVHSOHDVXUHVHQVXRXV
    EHLQJVFDQNQRZDEOXURIIDVWWUDQVODWLRQVQDWFKHGLWDOODZD\
    DQGSHUYHUVHO\UHSODFHGEOLVVZLWKZRH
    %HQHDWKKLPWKHZDUPVLQXRVLWLHVRI0DGDPVIOHVKJDYHZD\WRWKHUDZ
    UXQJVRIDODGGHUWKDWELWGHHSLQWRKLVEDFN+LVDQNOHVDQGZULVWVFKDIHG
    IURPFRUGVELQGLQJKLPWRWKHODGGHU
    2YHUKLPKRYHUHGDJQDUOHGPDQZKRVHELUGERQHGIUDPHZDVORVWLQWKH
    IROGVRIDPRQNVFRDUVHUREH7KHFXUYHRIKLVQRVH UHLQIRUFHGKLVKDZNV
    IDFHDVGLGKLVILQJHUQDLOVVRORQJDQGFXUOHGWKDWWKH\UHVHPEOHGFODZV
    7KH\KHOGVRPHELWVRIZRRGDQGZHUHSRNLQJWKHPXS9ROWDLUHVQRVWULOV
    9ROWDLUHWULHGWRDYHUWKLVKHDG,WZDVVTXHH]HGLQVLGHDQLURQFODVS

    +HWULHGWRVSHDNWRLQWHUHVWKLVLQTXLVLWRULQPRUHUDWLRQDOPHWKRGVRI
    LQTXLU\EXWKLVPRXWKIRUFHGRSHQE\DQLURQULQJFRXOGRQO\JDUJOH
    7KHILQHOLQHQFORWKVWXIIHGLQKLVPRXWKEURXJKWKRPHWRKLPIDUPRUH
    WKDQZRRGVKRYHGXSKLVQRVHWKHJUDYLW\RI KLVSOLJKW9ROWDLUHZLWKRXWKLV
    ZRUGVZDVOLNH6DPVRQZLWKRXWKLVORFNV$OH[DQGHUZLWKRXWKLVVZRUG3ODWR
    ZLWKRXW,GHDV'RQ4XL[RWHZLWKRXWKLVIDQWDV\'RQ-XDQZLWKRXWZRPHQDQG
    )UD\7RPDVGH7RUTXHPDGDZLWKRXWKHUHWLFVZLWKRXWDSRVWDWHVZLWKRXW
    XQEHOLHYHUVOLNH9ROWDLUH
    )RUWKLVZDV7RUTXHPDGD$QGKHZDVLQ+HOO
    

    :KHQWKHZDOOVRIKHUFKDPEHUEHJDQWRPHOWDQGLPSORGH-RDQRI$UF
    NQHZVKHPXVWDFW
    2IFRXUVHWKHLUULWDWLQJ9ROWDLUHKDGFKDUJHGKHUWRUHPDLQKHUH$QGRI
    FRXUVHKHKDGWKHIXUWKHULUULWDWLQJWUDLWRIEHLQJRIWHQFRUUHFW%XWWKLV
    6XOIXURXVYDSRUVELWLQKHUQRVWULOV'HPRQV7KH\FODPEHUHGWKURXJKWKH
    VSOLWVLQWKHEXOJLQJZDOOV2UDQJHOLJKWEXUQLQJIURPEHKLQGWKHPOLWXJO\
    VKDUSQRVHGIHDWXUHV
    6KHVZXQJKHUUD]RUVWHHO7KH\IHOO6ZHDWSRSSHGRXWXSRQKHUEURZDQG
    VKHODERUHGRQ'HPRQVGHFHDVHVKHFULHGJLGGLO\7RDFWWKDWZDVDELWRI
    KHDYHQDIWHUVXFKGHOD\
    6KHVSOLWWKHERXQGDULHVRIKHUFODVSLQJVSDFH0RUHGHPRQVDZDVKLQ
    RUDQJH6KHOHDSWRYHUWKHPDQGLQWRDVWUHWFKLQJVSDFHRIGRWVFRRUGLQDWHV
    ODQFLQJLQGZLQGOLQJSHUVSHFWLYHWRDQXQVHHDEOHHQG
    6KHUDQ$IWHUKHUFDPHVPDOO\DSSLQJWKLQJVRIPLVVKDSHQKHDGVDQG
    ZLGHYLFLRXVH\HV
    $VVKHFODQNHGRQLQIXOODUPRUVKHIHOWKHUVHOIUHDFKLQJRXWVXFNLQJ
    LQQXWULHQWVGLUHFWO\IURPWKHDLU6XUHO\WKLVZDVWKH/RUGVKHOS7KHLGHD
    XSOLIWHGKHU
    6WUDQJHEHLQJVFDPHUXVKLQJDWKHU6KHFKRSSHGWKHPDVLGH+HUVZRUG
    KHU7UXWK6KHORRNHGFDUHIXOO\DWLWDQGWKHLQWHQVLW\RIKHUJD]HVXFNHG
    KHUGRZQLQWRWKHPLQXWHDUFKLWHFWXUHRIWKHJOHDPLQJVKDIW,WZDVD
    PXOWLWXGHRIVPDOOLQVWUXFWLRQVZKLFKGHIHQGHGKHU
    6KHVORZHGVWXQQHG$UPRUVZHDWVZRUGDOOZHUHPHWDSKRUVWKHZRUG
    FDPHXQELGGHQ7KHVHZHUHV\PEROVRIXQGHUO\LQJSURJUDPVDOJRULWKPVJLYLQJ
    EDWWOH
    1RWUHDO<HWVRPHKRZHYHQPRUHWKDQUHDOIRUWKH\ZHUHZKDWPDGHXS
    KHURZQVHOI+HUVHOI+HU6HOI
    ,PSRUWUDLQHGGRZQXSRQKHU7KLVZDVVRPHVWUDQJH3XUJDWRU\WKHQ
    7KRXJKKHUEDWWOHPLJKWEHPHUHDOOHJRU\WKDWGLGPHDQLWZDVVRPHKRZWLVVXH
    WKLQDODF\IDOVHWKLQJ$GLYLQHKDQGZURXJKWWKLVVRLWZDV5LJKW
    6KHWURPSHGRQMDZVHWLQGHWHUPLQDWLRQ7KHVHFUHDWXUHV
    ZHUHVLPXODWLRQVVLPVSDUDEOHVRIWKHWUXH9HU\ZHOOVKHZRXOGGHDO
    ULJKWHRXVO\ZLWKWKHP6KHFRXOGGRQRRWKHU
    6RPHVLPVSUHVHQWHGDVWKLQJVWDONLQJDXWRFDUULDJHVGDQFLQJEOXH
    EXLOGLQJVRDNHQFKDLUVDQGWDEOHVFRSXODWLQJUXGHO\OLNHEDUQDQLPDOV7RKHU
    OHIWWKHZKROHKXJHERZORIKHDYHQDERYHVSOLWLQWRDPDQLDFJULQ7KLVSURYHG
    KDUPOHVVDLUPRXWKVFRXOGQRWHDWKHUWKRXJKWKLVRQHVKRXWHGHFKRLQJ
    WDXQWV7KHUHZHUHUXOHVGHFRUXPHYHQKHUHVKHMXGJHG
    6ZHHWPXVLFDSSHDUHGDVELOORZVRIYLEUDQWFORXG$EOLVVIXOEOXHVN\
    ILOOHGZLWKIODSSLQJVWULQJVOLNHFRYH\VRIELUGV\HWHDFKRQO\DVLQJOH
    OLQHZLGH,QKDPPHUEORZVFDPHVOHHWDQGVXQWKLVORFDOZRUOGIODVKLQJIURP
    RQHZHDWKHUVWDWHWRWKHQH[WDVFKLPHVDQGWUXPSHWVVRXQGHGLQDFRXVWLFDOO\
    SHUIHFWFKRUXV
    6LPVQHHGQRWEHVLPLDQWKHZRUGFRQJHDOLQJLQKHUPLQGDVLIIURP
    GLYLQHYLVLRQ6LPLDQZDVKXPDQLQDZD\

    :LWKWKDWVZLIWV\OORJLVPWKHUHFDPHVZRRSLQJGRZQXSRQKHULWVEURDG
    OHDWKHU\ZLQJVVSUHDGDQLPPHQVHERG\RI,GHDWLRQHYROXWLRQHQWZLQHGZLWK
    ILWQHVVLQGH[ZKLOHVODVKLQJOLNHDUD]RULQWRRULJLQRIVSHFLHVDQGIURP
    WKDWKXJHVKDUSEHDNHGELUGVKHIOHG
    +HUPLQGUDFHGQRZDORQJZLWKKHUERG\/HJVSXPSHG9RLFHVFDOOHG1RW
    WKRVHRIKHUVDLQWVEXWKLGHRXVGHYLOGHPDQGV
    6KHIHOWREMHFWVFUXQFKEHQHDWKKHUERRWV6LOYHU-HZHOV$OOFUXPSOHG
    LIVKHVWURGHRYHUWKHP7KH\OD\HPEHGGHGLQWKHVWUDQJHVRLORIGRWVDQG
    OLQHVDJULGWDSHULQJDZD\WRWKH&UHDWRUVORVWLQILQLW\
    6KHEHQWDQGSLFNHGXSDIHZ7UHDVXUHV$VVKHFUDGOHGDVLOYHU
    FKDOLFHLWGLVVROYHG IORZLQJLQWRKHU6KHIHOWDMROWDVWKRXJKWKLVZHUH
    VRPHVXJDU6WUHQJWKIORZHGLQKHUIODQNVDQGVKRXOGHUV6KHUDQDJDLQ
    SOXFNLQJXSWKHILQHMHZHOVWKHRUQDWHERZOVDQGVWDWXHWWHV(DFKVRPHKRZ
    PDGHKHUULFKHU
    6WRQHZDOOVURVHWREORFNKHU6KH FUDVKHGWKURXJKWKHVHEDUULHUV
    NQRZLQJWKHPE\IDLWKDORQHWREHIDOVH6KHZRXOGILQG9ROWDLUH\HV6KH
    NQHZKHZDVWKUHDWHQHG
    )URJVIHOOIURPKHUVN\WKHQVSODVKHGOLNHUDLQGURSV$QRPHQDPHQDFH
    IURPVRPHGHPRQLFSRZHU6KHLJQRUHGWKHPDQGVXUJHGIRUZDUGWRZDUGWKHHYHU
    UHFHGLQJKRUL]RQRIJHRPHWULFVKDUSQHVV
    $OOWKLVPDG3XUJDWRU\PHDQWVRPHWKLQJDQGWRJHWKHUWKH\ZRXOGILQG
    ZKDWWKDWZDV%\DOO+HDYHQ
    

    7KLVZDVOLNHDGUHDPEXWZKHQKDGKHHYHUIHDUHGLQDGUHDPWKH
    GHDWKRIZDNLQJXS"
    +HIHOWZHDNGUDLQHG7KH7RUTXHPDGDWKLQJKDGWRUWXUHG9ROWDLUHZHOO
    SDVWWKHSRLQWZKHUHKHKDGJODGO\FRQIHVVHGHYHU\VLQIHORQ\PLQRU
    LQIUDFWLRQDQGVRFLDOVQXEDQGKDGVWDUWHGZLWKRXWSDXVHRQPHUHXQNLQGQHVVHV
    LQSHQQHGUHYLHZVZKHQ WKH7RUTXHPDGDKDGIDGHGVHHSLQJDZD\
    7ROHDYHKLPKHUH,QWKLVXWWHUYDFDQF\
    6XSSRVH\RXZHUHORVWLQVRPHXQNQRZQVSDFHKHVDLGWRKLPVHOIDQG
    FRXOGRQO\WHOOKRZQHDUSRLQWVZHUHWRHDFKRWKHUQRWKLQJPRUH:KDWFRXOG
    \RXOHDUQ"
    +HKDG DOZD\VVHFUHWO\ZDQWHGWRSOD\6RFUDWHVLQWKHDJRUDDVNLQJ
    WHOOLQJTXHVWLRQVDQGWHDFKLQJE\H[WUDFWLQJIURPXQZLOOLQJ\RXWKVD7UXWK
    WKDWZRXOGKDQJOXPLQRXVLQWKHVHUHQH$WKHQLDQDLUYLVLEOHWRDOO
    :HOOWKLVZDVQRWWKHDJRUD,WZDVQRWKLQJEODQNJUD\VSDFH+RZHYHU
    EHKLQGWKHGXOOQRWKLQJVZDP1XPEHUV$3ODWRQLFUHDOP"+HKDGDOZD\V
    VXVSHFWHGWKDWVXFKDSODFHH[LVWHG
    $YRLFHDQVZHUHGVSHDNLQJ)UHQFK7KDWDORQHUHVSHFWHGVLUZRXOGEH
    HQRXJKWRGHGXFHPXFKDERXWWKHVSDFHDQGLWVFRQWHQWV
    0RVWUHDVVXULQJ9ROWDLUHVDLG+HUHFRJQL]HGWKHVKDUSDFFHQWVRI
    3DULV+HZDVRIFRXUVHVSHDNLQJZLWKKLPVHOI+LP6HOI
    4XLWH,PPHGLDWHO\VLU\RXZRXOGNQRZIURPWKHLUUHGXFLEOHFRRUGLQDWH
    WUDQVIRUPDWLRQVZKHWKHU\RXZHUHLQWZRRUWKUHHRUPRUHGLPHQVLRQV
    :KLFKLVWKLVWKHQ"
    7KUHHVSDWLDOO\
    +RZGLVDSSRLQWLQJ,YHEHHQWKHUH
    ,FRXOGH[SHULPHQWZLWKWZRVHSDUDEOHWLPHD[HV
    ,DOUHDG\KDYHDSDVW,FUDYHDSUHVHQW
    3RLQWWDNHQ7KLVZLOOQRWWD[\RXDIWHU\RXUWRUWXUHHK"
    +HVLJKHG(YHQWKDWWRRNHIIRUW9HU\ZHOO
    6WXG\LQJWKHILHOGRISRLQWQHDUQHVVGDWD\RXFRXOGVHQVHZDOOVSLWV
    SDVVDJHV8VLQJRQO\ORFDOVOLFHVRILQIRUPDWLRQDERXWQHDUQHVV
    ,VHH1HZWRQZDVDOZD\VPDNLQJMRNHVDERXWWKH)UHQFKPDWKHPDWLFLDQV

    ,DPKDSS\WRQRZUHIXWHKLPE\FRQVWUXFWLQJDZRUOGIURPVKHHUFDOFXODWLRQ
    &HUWDLQO\)DUPRUHLPSUHVVLYHWKDQGHVFULELQJWKHHOOLSWLFDOSDWKVRI
    SODQHWV6KDOOZHEHJLQ"
    2QZDUG26HOI
    $VLWWRRNVKDSHKLVGZHOOLQJZDVDUHDVVXULQJFRS\QRPRUH'HWDLOV
    ZHUHVWLWFKHGLQDVSURFHVVRUWLPHDOORZHGKHXQGHUVWRRGWKDWZLWKRXW
    WKLQNLQJDERXWLWDVHDVLO\DVRQHEUHDWKHV
    7RWHVWKLVOLPLWVKHFRQFHQWUDWHGRQDQLGHD&ODVVHVYV3URSHUWLHV
    ZKLFKLVPRUHIXQGDPHQWDO"7KLVVXFNHGFRPSXWDWLRQDOUHVRXUFHVDZD\
    $VKHZDWFKHGEULFNVLQDQHDUE\ZDOOPXGGLHGORVWWKHLUH[DFW
    VSDFLQJ7KHURRPUHWUHDWHGLQWRVWHULOHDEVWUDFWSODQHVJUD\EODFN
    REORQJVZKHUHRQFHKDGEHHQZDOOVDQGIXUQLWXUH%DFNJURXQGPHUH
    EDFNJURXQGKHPXWWHUHG
    +RZDERXW+LP"6HOI"+LVEUHDWKZKRRVKHGDQGZKHH]HGLQDQGRXWDLUIORZ
    WRRDEUXSW1RLQWULFDWHIOXLGFRGHVKHJDWKHUHGFDOFXODWLQJH[DFWSDWWHUQV
    7KHVLPSOHDSSHDUDQFHRILQKDOHH[KDOHZDVHQRXJKWRTXLHWKLVSVHXGRQHUYRXV
    V\VWHPPDNHLWWKLQNKHZDVEUHDWKLQJ
    ,QIDFWLWZDVEUHDWKLQJKLP%XWZKDWZDVLW"
    2QFHKHJRWJRRGFRQWUROKHFRXOGIOHVKKLPVHOIRXW+LVVFUDZQ\QHFN
    WKLFNHQHG&UDFNOLQJKLVKDQGVEURDGHQHGILOOHG ZLWKXQHDUQHGPXVFOH
    7XUQLQJWRVXUYH\KLVFRWWDJHKHHVWDEOLVKHGKLVRZQGRPDLQDUHJLRQLQ
    ZKLFKKHFRXOGSURFHVVDQ\GHWDLODWZLOO+HUHKHZDVJRGOLNH7KRXJK
    ZLWKRXWDQJHOVVRIDU
    +HZDONHGRXWVLGHDQGZDVLQKLVRZQYHUGDQWJDUGHQ7KHJUDVVKHKDG
    PDGHVWRRGDEVROXWHO\VWLOO,WVWKRXVDQGVRIEODGHVSHUIRUPHGVWLIIMHUN\
    PRWLRQVZKHQKHVWHSSHGRQWKHP7KRXJKULFKO\HPHUDOGWKH\ZHUHOLNHWKH
    JUDVVRIDVXGGHQZLQWHUFUXQFKLQJXQGHUIRRW
    7KHJDUGHQSDUWHGDQGKHZDONHGGRZQWRDJROGHQEHDFKKLVFORWKHV
    ZKLSSLQJDZD\RQWKHZLQG:KHQKHVZDPLQWKHVDOWWDQJ\RFHDQZDYHVZHUH
    TXLWHGLVWLQFWXQWLOWKH\EURNHLQWRVXUI
    7KHQWKHIOXLGPHFKDQLFVEHFDPHWRRPXFKIRUKLVDYDLODEOHFRPSXWDWLRQDO
    UDWH7KHIURWK\ZDYHVEOXUUHG+HFRXOG VWLOOVZLPFDWFKWKHPHYHQULGH
    GRZQWKHLUIDFHVEXWWKH\ZHUHOLNHDIRJRIPXWWHULQJZDWHU6WLOOVDOW\
    WKRXJK
    +HEHFDPHXVHGWRRFFDVLRQDOORVVRIGHWDLO,WZDVUDWKHUOLNHKDYLQJ
    RQHVYLVLRQEOXUZLWKDJHDIWHUDOO+HZHQWVRDULQJWKURXJKDLUWKHQ
    VNLLQJGRZQLPSRVVLEOHVORSHVH[SHULHQFLQJWKHYLVFHUDOWKULOORIULVNLQJKLV
    OLIHIHHOLQJWKHIHDULQHYHU\VLQHZDQGQHYHUJHWWLQJDVFUDWFKRIFRXUVH
    7KHUHZHUHSOHDVDQWDVSHFWVWREHLQJMXVWDSDWWHUQRIHOHFWURQV+LV
    (QYLURQPHQW0DQDJHUHQWHUWDLQHGKLPHQRUPRXVO\IRUDZKLOH
    +HIOHZEDFNWRKLVFRXQWU\KRPH+DGWKDWQRWEHHQKLVDQVZHUZKHQ
    DVNHGDERXWKRZWRFKDQJHWKHZRUOG"&XOWLYDWH\RXUJDUGHQ:KDWPHDQLQJKDG
    WKDWQRZ"
    +HZDONHGWRZDUGWKHZDWHUJH\VHURXWVLGHKLVVWXG\+HKDGORYHGLWV
    VHQVHRISOD\VRSUHFLRXVIRULWRQO\ODVWHGDIHZPLQXWHVEHIRUHGUDLQLQJ
    WKHXSKLOOUHVHUYRLU
    1RZLWJXVKHGHWHUQDOO\%XWDVKHORRNHGDWLWKHIHOWKLPVHOIZKLWHQ
    ZLWKWKHHIIRUW:DWHUZDVH[SHQVLYHWRVLPLQYROYLQJK\GURG\QDPLF
    FDOFXODWLRQVRIQRQODPLQDUIORZWRJHWWKHGURSOHWVDQGVSODVKHVUHDOVHHPLQJ
    ,WVOLGRYHUKLVKDQGVDQGWKHLUH[TXLVLWHO\ILQHILQJHUSULQWVZLWKFRQYLQFLQJ
    OLTXLGJUDFH
    :LWKDIDLQWMXPSKHIHOWVRPHWKLQJFKDQJH+LVKDQGVWLOOLQWKH
    VSUD\QRORQJHUVHQVHGWKHZDWHUVFRROFDUHVV'URSOHWVSDVVHGWKURXJKKLV
    KDQGQRWIORZLQJRYHULW+HZDVQRZZLWQHVVLQJWKHIRXQWDLQQRWLQWHUDFWLQJ
    ZLWKLW7RVDYHFRPSXWDWLRQDOH[SHQVHQRGRXEW5HDOLW\ZDVDOJRULWKP
    2IFRXUVHKLV6HOIPXWWHUHGWKH\FRXOGPRGHORXWGLVWXUELQJMHUNV
    DQGVHDPV$VKHZDWFKHGWKHZDWHUIORZVRPHKRZJRWVPRRWKHUPRUHUHDO$

    WDLORULQJSURJUDPKDGHGLWHGWKLVOLWWOHFORVHGGUDPDIRUKLVEHQHILW
    0HUFLKHPXUPXUHG,URQ\ZDVORVWRQGLJLWDOJDWHVKRZHYHU
    %XWWKHUHZHUHSLHFHVRIKLPVHOIPLVVLQJ+HFRXOGQRWVD\ZKDWWKH\
    ZHUHEXWKHVHQVHGKROORZV
    +HWRRNIOLJKW'HOLEHUDWHO\KHVORZHGKLV6HOIVRWKDWIHUUHWVFRXOG
    WDNHKLPGRZQLQVLQXDWLQJFRUULGRUVRIFRPSXWDWLRQDFURVVWKH0HVKRI
    7UDQWRU1HYHUPLQG0DUTDQGKLV$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHV7KH\ZRXOGEHKDUGHUWR
    SLOIHUIURPVXUHO\
    +HDUULYHGKRYHULQJLQWKHRIILFHRIWKH6HOGRQSHUVRQ+HUHZDVZKHUH
    KLV6HOIKDGUHVLGHGEHIRUH
    2QHFRXOGFRS\D6HOIZLWKRXWNQRZLQJZKDWLWZDV-XVWUHFRUGLWOLNH
    DPXVLFDOSDVVDJHWKHPDFKLQHZKLFKGLGWKDWGLGQRWQHHGWRNQRZKDUPRQ\
    VWUXFWXUH
    +HZLOOHGILQG,QDQVZHUFDPH7KH%DVH2ULJLQDO"
    <HV7KHUHDOPH
    <RX,KDYHFRPHDJUHDWGLVWDQFHVLQFHWKHQ
    +XPRUP\QRVWDOJLD
    9ROWDVD'LUHFWRU\WHUPHGKLPZDVVOXPEHULQJ6WLOOVDYHGQRWLQ
    WKH&KULVWLDQVHQVHDODVDQGDZDLWLQJGLJLWDOUHVXUUHFWLRQ
    $QGKH"6RPHWKLQJKDGVDYHGKLP:KDW":KR"
    9ROWDLUHVQDWFKHG9ROWDZD\/HW6HOGRQZRQGHUDWWKHLQWUXVLRQD
    PLOOLVHFRQGODWHUKHZDVKDOIZD\DURXQG7UDQWRUDOOWUDFHULHVRIKLPIDGLQJ
    +HZDQWHGWRVDYH9ROW$WDQ\WLPHWKHPDWKLVW6HOGRQFRXOGOHWLWKLP
    ODSVH1RZDV9ROWDLUHZDWFKHGOLNHDGLJLWDODQJHOIURPRXWVLGH9ROW
    GDQFHGLWVVWDWLFJDYRWWH
    8PPPWKHUHLVVRPHUHVHPEODQFH
    ,VKDOOFXWDQGSDVWHLQWR\RXUEODQNV
    0D\,KDYHVRPHLQWHUHVWLQJDQHVWKHWLF"+HZDVWKLQNLQJRIEUDQG\EXW
    DVKHHWRIQDPHVVOLGHQWLFLQJO\E\KLP0RUSKLQH"5LJRWLQ"$PLOGHXSKRULF
    DWOHDVW"
    'LVDSSURYDO7KLVZLOOQRWKXUW
    7KDWVZKDWWKHFULWLFVVDLGWRRDERXWP\SOD\V
    7KHZUHQFKLQJDERXWRIKLVLQQDUGVEHJDQ1RQRWKXUWH[DFWO\EXW
    WZLVWDQGYH[\HV
    0HPRULHV KHIHOWUDWKHUWKDQOHDUQHG ZHUHODLGGRZQDVV\QDSWLFJULW
    FKHPLFDOOD\HUVZKLFKKHOGDJDLQVWWKHUDQGRPUXGHDEUDVLRQVRIEUDLQ
    HOHFWURFKHPLVWU\&XHVIRUPRRGFKDQJHVDQGPHPRU\FDOOXSVVQDSSHGLQWR
    SODFH7KHSODFHDQGWLPHFRXOGEHUHQGHUHGUHDOZKHQHYHUKHZDQWHG
    &KHPLVWU\RIFRQYHQLHQFH
    %XWKHFRXOGQRWUHPHPEHUWKHQLJKWVN\
    6FUXEEHGDZD\LWZDV2QO\QDPHV2ULRQ6DJLWWDULXV$QGURPHGDEXW
    QRWWKHVWDUVWKHPVHOYHV:KDWKDGWKDWYLOHYRLFHVDLGDERXWQDPLQJWKHP"
    6RPHRQHKDGHUDVHGWKLVNQRZOHGJH,WFRXOGEHXVHGWRWUDFHDSDWKWR
    (DUWK:KRZRXOGZDQWWREORFNWKDW"
    1RDQVZHU
    1LP+HSOXFNHGXSDEXULHGPHPRU\1LPKDGZRUNHGRQ9ROWDLUHZKHQ0DUT
    ZDVQRWWKHUH
    $QGZKRPGLG1LPZRUNIRU"7KHHQLJPDWLFILJXUHRI+DUL6HOGRQ"
    6RPHKRZKHNQHZ1LPZDVDKLUHOLQJRIDQRWKHUDJHQF\%XWWKHUHKLV
    PHVKHGNQRZOHGJHIDOWHUHG:KDWRWKHUIRUFHVZRUNHGMXVWEH\RQGKLVVLJKW"
    +HVHQVHGODUJHYLWDOLWLHVDIRRWKHUH&DUHIXO
    +HWURWWHGIURPWKHKRVSLWDOOHJVGHYRXULQJWKHJURXQG%RXQF\)UHH
    +HVSHGDFURVVDGLJLWDOILHOGRI(XFOLGHDQJUDFHEDUHEODFNVN\DERYH
    +HUHOXUNHGVXSSOHFUHDWXUHVWUXO\HFFHQWULF7KH\GLGQRWFKRRVHWR
    UHSUHVHQWWKHPVHOYHVDVQHDUOLIHOLNHYLVLRQV1RUGLGWKH\SUHVHQWDV
    3ODWRQLFLGHDOVVSKHUHVRUFXEHVRIFRJQLWLRQ7KHVHVROLGVUHYROYHGVRPH
    VWDQGLQJRQWKHLUFRPHUV6SLQGO\WULDQJOHWUHHVVDQJDVZLQGVUXEEHGWKHP

    (YHQVOLJKWIULFWLRQVVSDUNHGEULJKW\HOORZIODUHVZKHUHVWUHDPHUVRIKXUU\LQJ
    EOXHPLVWUXEEHG
    +HVWUROOHGDPRQJWKHPDQGHQMR\HGWKHLUREOLYLRXVFRQWRUWLRQV7KH
    *DUGHQRIWKH6ROLSVLVWV"KHDVNHG WKHP,VWKLVZKHUH,DP"
    7KH\LJQRUHGKLPH[FHSWIRUDUXE\UHGHOOLSVRLGRIUHYROXWLRQ,W
    VSOLWLQWRDODXJKLQJVHWRIWHHWKWKHQVSURXWHGDQHQRUPRXVSKRVSKRUHVFHQW
    JUHHQH\H7KLVVORZO\ZLQNHGDVWKHWHHWKJQDVKHG
    9ROWDLUHVHQVHGIURPWKHVH PRYLQJVFXOSWXUHVDKDUGQHVVDUDGLDWLRQ
    IURPWKHNHUQHORI6HOIZLWKLQHDFK6RPHKRZHDFK6HOIKDGEHFRPHWLJKW
    FRQWUROOHGVHDOLQJRXWDOOHOVH
    :KDWJDYHKLPKLVRZQVHQVHRI6HOI"+LVVHQVHRIFRQWURORI
    GHWHUPLQLQJKLVIXWXUHDFWLRQV"<HWKHFRXOGVHHZLWKLQKLPVHOIZDWFKWKH
    ZRUNLQJVRIGHHSDJHQFLHVDQGSURJUDPV
    $VWRXQGLQJKHEOXUWHGDVWKHWKRXJKWFDPH
    %HFDXVHWKHUHZDVQRSHUVRQVLWWLQJLQKLVKHDGWRPDNHKLPVHOIGRZKDW
    KHZDQWHG RUHYHQDQDXWKRULW\WRPDNHKLPZDQWWRZDQW KHFRQVWUXFWHGD
    6WRU\RI6HOIWKDWKHZDVLQVLGHKLPVHOI
    -RDQRI$UFDVVHPEOHGEHVLGHKLPJOHDPLQJLQDUPRU7KDWVSDUNLV\RXU
    VRXOVKHVDLG
    9ROWDLUHVH\HVZLGHQHG+HNLVVHGKHUIHUYHQWO\<RXVDYHGPH"<HV"
    <RXZHUHWKHRQH
    ,GLGXVLQJSRZHUVDWWDFKHGWRPH,DEVRUEHGWKHPIURPWKHG\LQJ
    VSLULWVZKLFKDERXQGLQWKHVHVWUDQJHILHOGV
    $WRQFHKHORRNHGLQVLGHKLPVHOIDQGVDZWZRDJHQFLHVGRLQJEDWWOH2QH
    ZLVKHGWRHPEUDFHKHUWRVSLOORXWWKHFRQIOLFWKHIHOWEHWZHHQKLVVHQVXDO
    OLFHQVHDQGKLVDQDO\WLFDOHQJLQHRIDPLQG
    7KHRWKHUHYHUWKHSKLORVRSKHU\HDUQHGWRHQJDJHKHU)DLWKLQDQRWKHU
    ERXWZLWKEOLWKH5HDVRQ
    $QGZK\FRXOGKHQRWKDYHERWK"$VDPRUWDODPRQJWKHHPERGLHGKHKDG
    EHHQIDFHGZLWKVXFKFKRLFHV GDLO\(VSHFLDOO\ZLWKZRPHQ
    $IWHUDOOKHWKRXJKWWKLVZLOOEHWKHILUVWWLPH+HFRXOGIHHOWKH
    DJHQFLHVHDFKEHJLQWRKDUYHVWWKHLURZQFRPSXWDWLRQDOUHVRXUFHVOLNHDVXUJH
    RIVXJDULQWKHEORRGIURPDVZHHWZLQH
    ,QWKHVDPHVSOLWLQVWDQWKHUHDFKHGRXWDQGSDUWHG-RDQUXQQLQJKHU
    FRJQLWLRQRQWZRVHSDUDWHWUDFNV,QHDFKWKH\ZHUHIXOO\HQJDJHGEXWDW
    IUDFWLRQDOVSHHG+HFRXOGOLYHWZROLYHV
    7KHSODQHVSOLW
    7KH\VSOLW
    7LPHVSOLW
    +HVWRRGZLJOHVVEHGUDJJOHGKLVVDWLQYHVWEORRGVWDLQHGKLVYHOYHW
    EUHHFKHVVRDNHG
    )RUJLYHPHFKHUHPDGDPIRUDSSHDULQJEHIRUH\RXLQWKLVGLVKHYHOHG
    VWDWH,LQWHQGQRGLVUHVSHFWWRHLWKHURIXV+HORRNHGDURXQGQHUYRXVO\
    OLFNHGKLVOLSV,DPXQVNLOOHG0DFKLQHU\ZDVQHYHUP\IRUWH
    -RDQIHOWPRYHGWRWHQGHUQHVVE\WKHJDSEHWZHHQKLVDSSHDUDQFHDQGKLV
    FRXUWOLQHVV&RPSDVVLRQVKHWKRXJKWLVPRVWLPSRUWDQWLQWKLV3XUJDWRU\IRU
    ZKRNQRZVZKLFKVKDOOEHVHOHFWHG"
    6KHZDVTXLWHVXUHVKHZRXOGIDUHEHWWHUWKDQWKLVLQIXULDWLQJ\HW
    DSSHDOLQJPDQ
    <HWHYHQKHPLJKWEHVDYHG+HZDVXQOLNHWKHREMHFWVVKHFRQWLQXHGWR
    LJQRUHRQWKHSODLQDERXWWKHPD)UHQFKPDQ
    0\ORYHRISOHDVXUHDQGWKHSOHDVXUHRIORYLQJ\RXFDQQRWPDNHXSIRU
    ZKDW,HQGXUHGLQWKH7UXWK&KDPEHURQWKHUDFNRI P\SDLQ
    +HSDXVHGGDEEHGDWKLVH\HVZLWKDVRLOHGOLQHQFORWK
    -RDQFXUOHGDOLSLQGLVWDVWH:KHUHZDVKLVEHDXWLIXOODFHFORWK"+LV
    VHQVHRIWDVWHKDGRFFDVLRQDOO\PDGHXSIRUKLVYLHZV

    $WKRXVDQGOLWWOHGHDWKVLQOLIHKLQWDWWKHILQDOGLVVROXWLRQRIHYHQ
    H[TXLVLWHVHOYHVOLNHPLQH+HUHKHORRNHGXS$QG\RXUVPDGDPDQG\RXUV
    7KHIODPHVVKHWKRXJKW%XWQRZWKHLPDJHVGLGQRWVWULNHSURIRXQGO\
    LQWRKHU,QVWHDGKHULQQHUYLVLRQIHOWFRROVHUHQH+HU6HOISURJUDPPLQJ
    ZKLFKVKHWKRXJKWRIDVDVSHFLHVRISUD\HUKDGZRUNHGZRQGHUV
    ,FDQQRWVXUUHQGHUWRWKHUXOHRIWKHVHQVHVVLU
    :HPXVWGHFLGH,FDQQRWILQGWKHVSDFHVWRDKUXQEDFNJURXQGIRU
    ERWKSKLORVRSK\DQGVHQVXDOLW\,FDQQRWIROGP\VHOILQWRWKHVROLSVLVPKLV
    KDQGVZHSWLQWKHFUHDWXUHVRQWKH(XFOLGHDQSODQHRIWKHVH<RXWRR
    PDGDPPXVWQRZGHFLGHZKHWKHUWKHWDVWHRIDJUDSHPHDQVPRUHWR\RXWKDQ
    MRLQLQJPHLQWKLVWKLV
    3RRUVLU-RDQVDLGLQWKLVVWHULOHEXWWLPHOHVVZRUOG+HORRNHG
    XSSDXVHGIRUHIIHFW,OOQRWMRLQ\RXLQ\RXUV
    $JUHDWVREEXUVWIURPKLP
    +LVJUDWLWXGHWRKHUGLGQRWGHIOHFWKLPIURPDFKRLFHDUJXPHQW
    HVSHFLDOO\VLQFHKHKDGIUHVKHYLGHQFH<RXEHOLHYHLQWKDWLQHIIDEOH
    HVVHQFHWKHVRXO"
    6KHVPLOHGZLWKSLW\&DQ\RXQRW"
    7HOOPHWKHQGRWKHVHWRUWXUHGJHRPHWULHVSRVVHVVVRXOV"+LVDUP
    PDGHDJUDQGVZHHSWDNLQJLQWKHVHOILQYROYHGILJXUHV
    6KHIURZQHG7KH\PXVW
    7KHQWKH\PXVWEHDEOHWROHDUQ\HV"2WKHUZLVHVRXOVFDQOLYHIRU
    HQGOHVVWLPHDQG\HWQRWXVHWKDWWLPHWROHDUQWRFKDQJH
    6KHVWLIIHQHG,GRQRW
    7KDWZKLFKFDQQRWFKDQJHFDQQRWJURZ6XFKDGHVWLQ\RIVWDVLVLVQR
    GLIIHUHQWIURPGHDWK
    1RGHDWKOHDGVWRKHDYHQRUKHOO
    :KDWZRUVHKHOOWKDQDQHQGLQJLQDSHUPDQHQFHLQFDSDEOHRIDQ\
    DOWHUDWLRQDQGKHQFHGHYRLGRILQWHOOHFW"
    6RSKLVW,MXVWVDYHG\RXUOLIHDQG\RXULGGOHPHZLWK
    :LWQHVVWKHVHIDEULFDWHG6HOYHVKHLQWHUUXSWHGNLFNLQJDUKRPERLG
    7KHWKXQNRIKLVSHWLWHVKRHSURYRNHGDEURZQVWDLQZKLFKWKHQGLVVROYHGEDFN
    WRWKHRULJLQDOHJJVKHOOEOXH7KHYDOXHRIDKXPDQ6HOIOLHVQRWLQVRPH
    VPDOOSUHFLRXVNHUQHOEXWLQWKHYDVWFRQVWUXFWHGFUXVW
    -RDQIURZQHG7KHUHPXVWEHDFHQWHU
    1RZHDUHGLVSHUVHGGR\RXVHH"7KHILFWLRQRIWKHVRXOLVDEDG
    VWRU\WROGWRPDNHXVWKLQNZHUHXQDEOHWRLPSURYHRXUVHOYHV
    +HNLFNHGDS\UDPLGWKDWZDVVSLQQLQJDERXWLWVDSH[,WIHOORYHUDQG
    VWUXJJOHGWRJHWEDFNXS-RDQNQHOWSXVKHGXSULJKWHGWKHJUDWHIXOILJXUH
    %HNLQGVKHEDUNHGDWKLP
    7RDFORVHGORRSRIDEHLQJ")ROO\7KHVHDUHGHIHDWHG6HOYHVP\ORYH
    ,QVLGHWKH\DUHQRGRXEWVPXJO\FHUWDLQRIZKDWWKH\ZLOOGRRIHYHU\
    SRVVLEOHIXWXUHHYHQW0\NLFNZDVDOLEHUDWLRQ
    6KHWRXFKHGWKHS\UDPLGQRZSDLQIXOO\VSLQQLQJLWVHOIXSZLWKDORQJ
    WKLQZKLQH7UXO\":KRZRXOGZDQWWRVRSUHGLFW"
    9ROWDLUHEOLQNHG7KDWIHOORZ+DUL6HOGRQ+HLVZK\ZHDUHPDNLQJ
    VXFKFHUHEUDOH[SHGLWLRQV$OOWKLVLVLQDLGRIKLV
    XQGHUVWDQGLQJHYHQWXDOO\2GGWKHFRQQHFWLRQVRQHPDNHV
    

    6KHZLQNHGRXWRIWKHVLPVSDFHDZD\IURPKLPFRQIXVHG
    6RPHKRZVKHKDGH[SHULHQFHGWZRFRQYHUVDWLRQVDWRQFH+HUVDQG
    9ROWDLUHVWKHWZRLGHQWLWLHVUXQQLQJVLPXOWDQHRXVO\
    $ERXWKHUVSDFHLWVHOIVKUDQNH[SDQGHGZDUSHGLWVFRQWHQWVLQWR
    EL]DUUHVKDSHVEHIRUHOXUFKLQJDWODVWLQWRFRQFUHWHREMHFWV

    7KHVWUHHWFRUQHUORRNHGIDPLOLDU6WLOOWKHZKLWHSODVWLIRUPWDEOHV
    PDWFKLQJFKDLUVDQGWLNWRNZDLWHUVEHDULQJWUD\VWRORXQJLQJFXVWRPHUVDOO
    WKDWKDGGLVDSSHDUHG7KHHOHJDQWDZQLQJVWLOOKXQJRYHUWKHVLGHZDON
    LPSULQWHGZLWKWKHQDPHWKHLQQVZDLWHU*DUFRQ$'0KDGWDXJKWKHUKRZ
    WRUHDG$X['HX[0DJRWV
    9ROWDLUHZDVEDQJLQJRQWKHGRRUZKHQ-RDQPDWHULDOL]HGEHVLGHKLP
    <RXUHODWHKHVDLG,KDYHDFFRPSOLVKHGPDUYHOVLQWKHWLPHWKDWLWWRRN
    \RXWRJHWKHUH+HLQWHUUXSWHGKLVDVVDXOWRQWKHLQQGRRUWRFXSKHUFKLQ
    DQGSHHULQWRKHUXSWXUQHGIDFH$UH\RXDOOULJKW"
    ,,WKLQNVR-RDQVWUDLJKWHQHGKHUFODQNLQJVXLWRIPDLO<RX
    QHDUO\ORVWPH
    0\H[SHULPHQWZLWKVSOLWWLQJWDXJKWPHPXFK
    ,OLNHGLW/LNHKHDYHQLQDZD\
    0RUHOLNHEHLQJDEOHWRH[SHULHQFHHDFKRWKHULQDSURIRXQGPDQQHU,
    ZRXOGYHQWXUH,GLVFRYHUHGWKDWLIZHFRXOGGHOLEHUDWHO\VHL]HFRQWURORI
    RXUSOHDVXUHV\VWHPVZHFRXOGUHSURGXFHWKHSOHDVXUHRIVXFFHVVDOOZLWKRXW
    WKHQHHGIRUDQ\DFWXDODFFRPSOLVKPHQW
    +HDYHQWKHQ"
    1RWKHRSSRVLWH7KDWZRXOGEHWKHHQGRIHYHU\WKLQJ9ROWDLUHUHWLHG
    WKHVDWLQULEERQDWKLVWKURDWZLWKVKDUSGHFLVLYHMHUNV
    )DLWKZRXOGKDYHWROG\RXDVPXFK
    $ODVWUXH
    <RXKDYHGHFLGHGWRUXQEDFNJURXQGIRURQO\\RXUPLQG" VKHDVNHG
    GHPXUHO\WKRXJKSURXGWRKDYHSULHGDQDGPLVVLRQIRUYLUWXHIURPKLP
    )RUWKHPRPHQW,DPUXQQLQJERWKRIXVZLWKRQO\UXGLPHQWDU\ERGLHV
    <HW\RXVKDOOQRWQRWLFHLWIRU\RXVKDOOEHTXLWHKHOLIWHGDQH\HEURZ
    KLJKPLQGHGDERXWPDWWHUV
    ,DPUHOLHYHG2QHVUHSXWDWLRQLVOLNHRQHVFKDVWLW\:DVFKDVWH6W
    &DWKHULQHULJKW"+DG9ROWDLUHUXLQHGKHUV"2QFHJRQHLWFDQQRWEHUHVWRUHG
    7KDQNKHDYHQIRUWKDW<RXKDYHQRLGHDKRZWHGLRXVLWLVWRPDNHORYH
    WRDYLUJLQ+HDGGHG KDVWLO\LQUHVSRQVHWRKHUUHSURDFKIXOORRN,NQRZ
    RIRQO\RQHH[FHSWLRQWRWKDWUXOHDQGJDYHKHUDFRXUWHRXVERZ
    -RDQVDLG7KHFDIHDSSHDUVFORVHG
    1RQVHQVH3DULVFDIHVQHYHUFORVHWKH\DUHURRPVRISXEOLFUHVW+H
    UHVXPHGUDSSLQJRQWKHGRRU
    %\SXEOLFUHVWURRPGR\RXPHDQDQLQQ"
    9ROWDLUHVWRSSHGNQRFNLQJDQGH\HGKHU3XEOLFUHVWURRPVDUHIDFLOLWLHV
    LQZKLFKSHRSOHUHOLHYHWKHPVHOYHV
    -RDQEOXVKHGHQYLVLRQLQJDURZRIKROHVGXJLQWKHJURXQG%XWZK\
    FDOOLWDUHVWURRP"
    $VORQJDVPDQLVDVKDPHGRIKLVQDWXUDOIXQFWLRQVKHZLOOFDOOLW
    DQ\WKLQJEXWZKDWLWLV3HRSOHIHDUWKHLUKLGGHQVHOYHVDIUDLGWKDWWKH\
    ZLOOEXUVWRXW
    %XW,FDQVHHDOORIP\VHOIQRZ
    7UXH%XWLQUHDOIRONVXFKDVZHZHUHVXESURJUDPVRWKHUVFDQQRWVHH
    UXQVLPXOWDQHRXVO\EHQHDWKWKHVXUIDFHWKRXJKWV/LNH\RXUYRLFHV
    -RDQEULVWOHG0\YRLFHVDUHGLYLQH0XVLFVRIDUFKDQJHOVDQGVDLQWV
    <RXDSSHDUWRKDYHRFFDVLRQDODFFHVVWR\RXUVXESURJUDPV0DQ\UHDO
    WKDWLVHPERGLHGSHRSOHGRQRW(VSHFLDOO\LIWKHVXESURJUDPVDUH
    XQDFFHSWDEOH
    8QDFFHSWDEOH"7RZKRP"
    7RXV2UUDWKHUWRRXUGRPLQDQWSURJUDPWKHRQHZHPRVWLGHQWLI\
    ZLWKDQGSUHVHQWIRUVKRZWRWKHZRUOG
    $K(YHQWVZHUHPRYLQJUDWKHUWRRVZLIWO\IRU-RDQ 'LGWKLVPHDQ
    VKHQHHGHGPRUHWLPHVWHSV"
    $KXJHWLNWRNJXDUGRSHQHGWKHGRRUJUXPEOLQJ$X['HX[0DJRWV"KH
    VDLGLQUHVSRQVHWR9ROWDLUH:HQWRXWWDEXVLQHVV\HDUVDJR

    -RDQSHHUHGLQVLGHWKHZDUHKRXVHKRSLQJWRVHH*DUFRQ
    7KH\UHHQURXWH9ROWDLUHVDLG
    7R-RDQVVXUSULVHKHVQHH]HG1RRQHFDXJKWFROGLQWKHVHDEVWUXVH
    VSDFHV6RKHKDGNHSWVRPHIUDJPHQWRIKLVERG\%XWZKDWDQRGGSLHFHWR
    UHWDLQ
    +HVDLGODPHO\0\HGLWLQJLVLPSHUIHFW,JDWKHU,GLGQRWRPLW
    VQLIIOHV\HW, FDQQRWVXVWDLQDQHUHFWLRQ
    9ROWDLUHGRZQVWHSSHGWKHPDQGH[WHUQDOWLPH ZKDWHYHUWKDWPHDQWKHUH 
    VSHGE\:LWKRXWZDUQLQJ-RDQIRXQGKHUVHOISHHULQJDWDWLNWRN*DUFRQ$'0
    6KHHPEUDFHGKLP
    $YRWUHVHUYLFHPDGDP0D\,UHFRPPHQGWKHFORXGIRRG"7KHWLNWRN
    NLVVHGKLVILQJHUWLSVDOOWZHQW\DWRQFH
    -RDQORRNHGDW9ROWDLUHWRRPRYHGWRVSHDN0HUFLVKHPDQDJHGWR
    VWDPPHUDWODVW7R9ROWDLUHWKH3ULQFHRI/LJKWDQGWRWKH&UHDWRUIURP
    :KRPDOOEOHVVLQJVIORZ
    7KHFUHGLWLVHQWLUHO\PLQHVDLG9ROWDLUH,KDYHQHYHUVKDUHGD
    E\OLQHHYHQZLWKGHLWLHV
    6KHDVNHGQHUYRXVO\7KH,WZKLFKQHDUO\HUDVHGPH"
    +HVFRZOHG,KDYHIHOWWKDWDSSDULWLRQRUUDWKHULWVODFNRI
    DSSHDUDQFHZKLOHPDQLIHVWLQJDSUHVHQFH,WVWDONVXVVWLOO,IHDU
    *DUFRQVDLG&RXOGLWEHWKHZROISDFNSURJUDPVZKRVHHNFULPLQDOXVHUV
    RIFRPSXWDWLRQDOYROXPH"
    9ROWDLUHUDLVHGDQH\HEURZ<RXKDYHEHFRPHOHDUQHG*DUFRQ",KDYH
    VZHSWDVLGHWKHVHEORRGKRXQGV1RWKLV,WLVRWKHU
    :HPXVWGHIHDWLW-RDQIHOWKHUVHOIDZDUULRUDJDLQ
    8PPPQRGRXEW:HPD\QHHG\RXUDQJHOVP\VZHHW$QGZHPXVWFRQVLGHU
    ZKHUHZHWUXO\DUH
    :LWKDZDYHKHEOHZDZD\WKHURRIUHYHDOLQJWKHERZORIDYDVWVN\1RW
    WKHVSULQNOLQJRIOLJKWVVKHKDGNQRZQWKRXJKZKHQVKHWULHGVKHFRXOGLQ
    IDFWUHFDOOQRVSHFLILFFRQVWHOODWLRQV
    +HUHWKHVN\EOD]HGZLWKVRPDQ\VWDUVLWKXUWKHUH\HV+HVDLGWKLV
    ZDVEHFDXVHWKH\ZHUHQHDUWKHFHQWHURIVRPHWHUULWRU\QDPHG*DOD[\DQG
    WKDWVWDUVOLNHGWRGZHOOKHUH
    7KHVLJKWPDGHKHUVXFNLQKHUEUHDWK2QVXFKDVWDJHZKDWFRXOGWKH\
    GR"
    5(1'(=9286

    ,IZHVWD\LQRXUDSDUWPHQWGRQWHYHUOHDYH6WUHHOLQJ 8QLYHUVLW\
    1R5'DQHHO2OLYDZVDLGVWHUQO\7KHVLWXDWLRQLVWRRJUDYH
    7KHQZKHUH"
    2II7UDQWRU
    ,DPOHVVDFTXDLQWHGZLWKRWKHUZRUOGV
    2OLYDZZDYHGDZD\KHUSRLQW,KDYHLQPLQGDUHPDUNLQ\RXUUHFHQW
    UHSRUW+HLVLQWHUHVWHGLQWKHIXQGDPHQWDOKXPDQGULYHV
    'RUVIURZQHG<HV+DULNHHSVVD\LQJWKHUHDUHHOHPHQWVVWLOOPLVVLQJ
    *RRG7KHUHLVDZRUOGZKHUHKHFDQH[SORUHWKLV3RVVLEO\KHFDQILQG
    YDOXDEOHFRPSRQHQWWHUPVIRUKLVPRGHOHTXDWLRQV
    $SULPLWLYHSODQHW" 7KDWZRXOGEHGDQJHURXV
    7KLVLVDVHYHUHO\XQGHUSRSXODWHGSODFHZLWKIHZHUWKUHDWV
    <RXKDYHEHHQWKHUH"
    ,KDYHEHHQHYHU\ZKHUH
    6KHUHDOL]HGWKDWWKLVFRXOGQRWEHOLWHUDOO\WUXH4XLFNFDOFXODWLRQ
    VKRZHGWKDWHYHQ5'DQHHO2OLYDZZRXOGKDYHKDGWRYLVLWVHYHUDOWKRXVDQG
    ZRUOGVLQHDFK\HDURIKLVOLIH+LVHQGXULQJSUHVHQFHVWUHWFKHGZHOOEH\RQG
    WKHWZHOYHWKRXVDQG\HDUVVLQFHWKHIRXQGLQJRIWKH.DPEDO'\QDVW\RQ7UDQWRU
    ,QGHHGVKHKDGEHHQWROGWKRXJKWKLVZDVGLIILFXOWWREHOLHYHWKDWKHFDPH

    IRUWKIURPWKHYHU\2ULJLQ(UDVRILQWHUVWHOODUIOLJKWRYHUWZHQW\WKRXVDQG
    \HDUVDJR
    :K\GRQWZHERWKJRZLWKKLP
    ,PXVWUHPDLQKHUH7KHVLPXODWLRQVOLYHRQVWLOOLQWKH7UDQWRU0HVK
    :LWKWKH0DFUR0HVKDERXWWREHFRQQHFWHGWKH\ FRXOGPXOWLSO\WKHPVHOYHV
    WKURXJKRXWWKH*DOD[\
    7UXO\"6KHKDGEHHQFRQFHQWUDWLQJRQ+DULWKHVLPXODWLRQVKDGVHHPHG
    WREHDVPDOOVLGHLVVXH
    ,HGLWHGWKHPPDQ\PLOOHQQLDDJRWRH[FOXGHNQRZOHGJH,IHOWGDPDJLQJ
    IRUKXPDQV%XW,VKRXOGUHYLVLWWKDWHGLWLQJ
    (GLWLQJRXW"&XWWLQJDZD\VXFKLQIRUPDWLRQDVIRUH[DPSOH(DUWKV
    ORFDWLRQ"
    7KH\NQRZPLQRUGDWDVXFKDVKRZ(DUWKVPRRQHFOLSVHVLWVVWDUDQ
    DPD]LQJO\DFFXUDWHILW7KDWFRXOGQDUURZWKHVHDUFK
    ,VHH6KHKDGQHYHUEHHQWROGWKLVDQGIRXQGVWUDQJHHPRWLRQV
    VWLUUHGE\WKHNQRZLQJ
    ,KDYHKDGWRGRPDQ\VXFKUHYLVLWLQJVEHIRUH/XFNLO\LQGLYLGXDO
    KXPDQVPHPRULHVGLHZLWKWKHP6LPXODWLRQVGRQRW
    6KHIHOWDGDUNEURRGLQJVRUURZLQKLVZRUGV0RUHVKHFDXJKWD
    JOLPPHURIKRZKHPXVWYLHZHYHQWVORRNLQJEDFNZDUGGRZQDWXQQHORIORQJ
    ODERUDQGJULPVDFULILFHVWUHWFKLQJWHQVRIPLOOHQQLD6KHZDVFRPSDUDWLYHO\
    \RXQJOHVVWKDQWZRFHQWXULHVROG
    <HWVKHXQGHUVWRRGWKDWURERWVKDGWREHLPPRUWDO
    7KLVUHTXLUHPHQWDURVHEHFDXVHWKH\KDGWRUHPDLQHYHUYLJLODQWIRU
    KXPDQLW\+XPDQVDFFRPSOLVKHGWKHLUFXOWXUDOFRQWLQXLW\E\SDVVLQJRQWRWKH
    QH[WJHQHUDWLRQWKHHVVHQWLDOVWKDWERXQGWKHPDOOWRJHWKHU
    %XWURERWVFRXOGQRWEHDOORZHGWRUHJXODUO\UHSURGXFHHYHQWKRXJKWKH
    PHDQVZHUHUHDGLO\DGRSWHGIURPWKHEDVLFRUJDQVRIPDQNLQG7KHURERWVNQHZ
    WKHLU'DUZLQ
    7RUHSURGXFHPHDQWWRHYROYH,QHYLWDEO\HUURUZRXOGFUHHSLQWRDQ\
    PHWKRGRIUHSURGXFWLRQ0RVWHUURUVZRXOGFDXVHGHDWKRUVXEQRUPDO
    SHUIRUPDQFHEXWVRPHZRXOGDOWHUWKHQH[WJHQHUDWLRQRIURERWVLQVXEWOH
    ZD\V6RPHRIWKHVHZRXOGEHXQDFFHSWDEOHDVVHHQWKURXJKWKHOHQVRIWKH
    )RXU/DZV
    7KHPRVWREYLRXVVHOHFWLRQSULQFLSOHRSHUDWLQJLQDOORUGLQDULO\VHOI
    UHSURGXFLQJRUJDQLVPVZDVIRUVHOILQWHUHVW(YROXWLRQUHZDUGHGSUHVVLQJ
    IRUZDUGLQRQHVRZQFDXVH)DYRULQJWKHLQGLYLGXDOZDVWKHFHQWUDOIRUFH
    VHOHFWLQJIRUVXUYLYRUV
    %XWWKHVHOILQWHUHVWRIDURERWFRXOGFRQIOLFWZLWKWKH)RXU/DZV
    ,QHYLWDEO\DURERWZRXOGHYROYHZKLFKGHVSLWHRXWZDUGDSSHDUDQFHVGHVSLWH
    LQWULFDWHLQWHUURJDWLRQVZRXOGIDYRULWVHOIRYHUKXPDQLW\6XFKDURERWZRXOG
    QRWVSULQJEHWZHHQDKXPDQDQGDVSHHGLQJYHKLFOH
    2UEHWZHHQKXPDQLW\DQGWKHWKUHDWVWKDWORRPHGRXWRIWKH*DODFWLF
    QLJKW
    6R5'DQHHO2OLYDZRIWKH2ULJLQDO'HVLJQKDGWREHLPPRUWDO2QO\
    VSHFLDOXVHURERWVVXFKDVKHUVHOIFRXOGEHPDGHIUHVK7KHRUJDQLIRUP
    YDULDWLRQKDGEHHQDUULYHGDWRYHU PDQ\FHQWXULHVRIVHFUHWUHVHDUFK,WZDV
    DOORZHGH[SUHVVO\WRILOODQXQXVXDOWDVNDWKDQGVXFKDVIRUPLQJDFRFRRQ
    ERWKHPRWLRQDODQGSK\VLFDODURXQGRQH+DUL6HOGRQ
    <RXZLVKWRHUDVHDOOWKHVLPXODWLRQVHYHU\ZKHUH"
    +HVDLG,GHDOO\\HV7KH\PLJKWSURGXFHQHZURERWVUHOHDVHDQFLHQW
    ORUHWKH\FRXOGHYHQXQFRYHU
    :K\GR\RXVWRS"
    7KHUHDUHKLVWRULFDOIDFWV\RXQHHGQRWNQRZ
    %XW,DPDQKLVWRULDQ
    <RXDUHFORVHUWRKXPDQWKDQ,6RPHNQRZOHGJHLVEHVWOHIWWRIRUPV
    VXFKDVP\VHOI%HOLHYHPH7KH7KUHH/DZVSOXVWKH=HURWKKDYHGHHS

    LPSOLFDWLRQVRQHVWKH2ULJLQDWRUVGLGQRWFRXOGQRWJXHVV8QGHUWKH=HURWK
    /DZZHURERWVKDYHKDGWRSHUIRUPFHUWDLQDFWV+HFDXJKWKLPVHOIDEUXSWO\
    VKRRNKLVKHDG
    9HU\ZHOOVKHVDLGUHOXFWDQWO\IUXLWOHVVO\VWXG\LQJKLVLPSDVVLYH
    IDFH,DFFHSWWKDW$QG,ZLOOJRZLWKKLPWRWKLVSODFH
    <RXZLOOQHHGWHFKQLFDODLG5'DQHHOVWULSSHGDZD\KLVVKLUWWR
    UHYHDODFRPSOHWHO\FRQYLQFLQJKXPDQVNLQ+HSXWWZRVWLIIILQJHUVFDUHIXOO\
    EHORZRQHQLSSOHDQGSXVKHGLQDSUHVVXUHSDWWHUQ+LVFKHVWRSHQHG
    ORQJLWXGLQDOO\IRUSHUKDSVILYHFHQWLPHWHUV+HUHPRYHGDMHWEODFNF\OLQGHU
    WKHVL]HRIKLVOLWWOHILQJHU,QVWUXFWLRQVDUHHQFRGHGLQWKHVLGHIRU
    RSWLFDOUHDGLQJ
    $GYDQFHGWHFKQRORJ\IRUDEDFNZDUGZRUOG"
    +HDOORZHGKLPVHOIDVPLOH,WVKRXOGEHVDIHEXWSUHFDXWLRQVDUHLQ
    RUGHU$OZD\V'RQRWZRUU\RYHUO\PXFK,GRXEWWKDWHYHQWKHFUDIW\/DPXUN
    ZLOOEHDEOHWRSODQWDJHQWVTXLFNO\RQ3DQXFRSLD
    B

    3$57

    3$18&23,$

    B
    %,2*(1(6,6+,6725<2)LWZDVWKXVRQO\QDWXUDOWKDWELRORJLVWVZRXOGXVH
    HQWLUHSODQHWVDVH[SHULPHQWDOSUHVHUYHVWHVWLQJRQDODUJHVFDOHWKHFHQWUDO
    LGHDVDERXWKXPDQHYROXWLRQ+XPDQLW\VRULJLQVUHPDLQHGVKURXGHGZLWKWKH
    SDUHQWSODQHW (DUWK LWVHOIXQNQRZQWKRXJKWKHUHZHUHWKRXVDQGVRI
    HDUQHVWO\VXSSRUWHGFDQGLGDWHV6RPHSULPDWHVLQWKHVFDWWHUHG*DODFWLF=RRV
    FOHDUO\ZHUHJHUPDQHWRWKHDUJXPHQW(DUO\LQWKH3RVW0LGGOH3HULRGZKROH
    ZRUOGVFDPHWREHGHYRWHGWRH[SORUDWLRQRIWKHVHDSSDUHQWO\SULPRUGLDO
    VSHFLHV2QHVXFKZRUOGPDGHJURXQGEUHDNLQJSURJUHVVLQRXUFRQQHFWLRQVWRWKH
    SDQVWKRXJKLQGLFDWLYHQRILUPFRQFOXVLRQVFRXOGEHUHDFKHGWRRPXFKRIWKH
    LQWHUYHQLQJPLOOLRQVRI\HDUVEHWZHHQRXUVHOYHVDQGHYHQFORVHUHODWLYHVOLNH
    WKHSDQVOD\LQVKDGRZ'XULQJWKHGHFOLQHRI,PSHULDOVFLHQFHWKHVH
    H[SHULPHQWVZHUHHYHQWXUQHGLQWRDPXVHPHQWVIRUWKHJHQWU\DQGPHULWRFUDWV
    LQGHVSHUDWHDWWHPSWVWRUHPDLQVHOIVXSSRUWLQJDV,PSHULDOIXQGLQJGULHG
    XS
    (1&<&/23(',$*$/$&7,&$
    

    +HGLGQWIXOO\UHOD[XQWLOWKH\ZHUHVLWWLQJRQDYHUDQGDKRIWKH
    ([FXUVLRQ6WDWLRQVRPHVL[WKRXVDQGOLJKW\HDUVDZD\IURP7UDQWRU
    :DULO\'RUVJD]HGRXWDWWKHYLHZEH\RQGWKHIRUPLGDEOHZDOOV:HUH
    VDIHKHUHIURPWKHDQLPDOV"
    ,LPDJLQHVR7KRVHZDOOVDUHKLJKDQGWKHUHDUHJXDUGFDQLQHV
    :LUHKRXQGV,EHOLHYH
    *RRG6KHVPLOHGLQDZD\WKDWKHNQHZLPSOLHGDVHFUHWZDVDERXWWR
    HPHUJH,EHOLHYH,KDYHFRYHUHGRXUWUDFNVWRXVHDQDQLPDOPHWDSKRU,KDG
    UHFRUGVRIRXUGHSDUWXUH FRQFHDOHG
    ,VWLOOWKLQN\RXDUHH[DJJHUDWLQJ
    ([DJJHUDWLQJDQDWWHPSWHGDVVDVVLQDWLRQ"6KHELWKHUOLSLQLOO
    FRQFHDOHGLUULWDWLRQ7KLVZDVDZHOOIUD\HGDUJXPHQWEHWZHHQWKHPE\QRZEXW
    VRPHWKLQJDERXWKHUSURWHFWLYHQHVVDOZD\VVDWSRRUO\ZLWKKLP
    ,RQO\DJUHHGWROHDYH7UDQWRULQRUGHUWRVWXG\SDQV
    +HFDXJKWDIOLFNHURIHPRWLRQLQKHUIDFHDQGNQHZWKDWVKHZRXOGQRZ

    WU\WRHDVHRII2KWKDWPLJKWEHXVHIXORUEHWWHUVWLOOIXQ<RXQHHGD
    UHVW
    $WOHDVW,ZRQWKDYHWRGHDOZLWK/DPXUN
    &OHRQKDGLQVWLWXWHGZKDWKHOLJKWO\WHUPHGWUDGLWLRQDOPHDVXUHVWR
    WUDFNGRZQWKHFRQVSLUDWRUV6RPHKDGDOUHDG\ZRUPKROHGDZD\WRWKHIDU
    UHDFKHVRIWKH*DOD[\2WKHUVKDGFRPPLWWHGVXLFLGHRUVRLWVHHPHG
    /DPXUNZDVVWD\LQJORZSUHWHQGLQJVKRFNDQGGLVPD\DWWKLVDVVDXOWRQ
    WKHYHU\IDEULFRIRXU,PSHULXP%XW/DPXUNVWLOOKHOGHQRXJKYRWHVLQWKH
    +LJK&RXQFLOWREORFN&OHRQVPRYHWRPDNH+DULKLV)LUVW0LQLVWHUVRWKH
    GHDGORFNFRQWLQXHG+DULZDVQXPEHGE\WKHHQWLUHPDWWHU
    $QG\RXUHULJKW'RUVFRQWLQXHGZLWKDEULWWOHEULJKWQHVVLJQRULQJ
    KLVPRRG\VLOHQFHQRWHYHU\WKLQJLVDYDLODEOHRQ7UDQWRURUHYHQNQRZQ
    DERXW0\PDLQFRQVLGHUDWLRQZDVWKDWLI\RXKDGVWD\HGRQ7UDQWRU\RXZRXOG
    EHGHDG
    +HVWRSSHGORRNLQJDW WKHVWULNLQJVFHQHU\<RXWKLQNWKH/DPXUN
    IDFWLRQZRXOGSHUVLVW"
    7KH\FRXOGZKLFKLVDEHWWHUJXLGHWRDFWLRQWKDQWU\LQJWRJXHVV
    ZRXOGV
    ,VHH+HGLGQWEXWKHKDGOHDUQHGWRWUXVWKHUMXGJPHQWLQPDWWHUV
    RIWKHZRUOG7KHQWRRSHUKDSVKHGLGQHHGDWKRURXJKJRLQJYDFDWLRQ
    7REHRQDOLYLQJQDWXUDOZRUOGKHKDGIRUJRWWHQLQKLV\HDUVEXULHG
    LQ7UDQWRUKRZYLYLGZLOGWKLQJVFRXOGEH7KHJUHHQVDQG\HOORZVOHDSHGRXW
    DIWHUGHFDGHVDPLGPDWWHGVWHHOF\FOHGDLUDQGFU\VWDOJOLWWHU
    +HUHWKHVN\\DZQHGLPSRVVLEO\GHHSXQPDUNHGE\WKHJUDIILWLRI
    DLUFUDIWZKROO\DOLYHWRWKHIODSSLQJZRQGHURIELUGV%OXIIVDQGULGJHV
    ORRNHGOLNHWKH\KDGEHHQVKDSHGKDVWLO\ZLWKDSXWW\NQLIH%H\RQGWKH
    VWDWLRQZDOOVKHFRXOGVHHDVROHWUHHWKUDVKHGE\DQDQJU\ZLQG,WVWRSNQRW
    ILQDOO\EOHZRIILQDSRFNHWRIZLQGIOXWWHULQJDQGIUD\LQJRYHUVRPEHUIODWV
    OLNHDIUDJPHQWLQJELUG'LVWDQWHURGHGPHVDVKDG\HOORZVWUHDNVGRZQWKHLU
    VKDQNVZKLFKDVWKH\PHWWKHIRUHVWWXUQHGDEXUQWRUDQJHWLQJHWKDW
    VXJJHVWHGWKHURWRIUXVW$FURVVWKHYDOOH\ZKHUHWKHSDQVUDQJHGOD\D
    GXVN\FDQRS\KLGGHQEHKLQGORZJUD\FORXGVDQGUDNHGE\ZLQGV
    $WKLQFROGUDLQIHOOWKHUHDQG+DULZRQGHUHGZKDWLWZDVOLNHWRFRZHU
    DVDQDQLPDOEHQHDWKWKRVHVKHHWVRIPRLVWXUHZLWKRXWKRSHRIVKHOWHURU
    ZDUPWK3HUKDSV7UDQWRUVXWWHUSUHGLFWDELOLW\ZDVEHWWHUEXWKHZRQGHUHG
    +HSRLQWHGWRWKHGLVWDQWIRUHVW:HUHJRLQJWKHUH"+HOLNHGWKLV
    IUHVKSODFHWKRXJKWKHIRUHVWZDVIRUHERGLQJ,WKDGEHHQDORQJWLPHVLQFH
    KHKDGHYHQZRUNHGZLWKKLVKDQGVDORQJVLGHKLVIDWKHUEDFNRQ+HOLFRQ7R
    OLYHLQWKHRSHQ
    'RQWVWDUWMXGJLQJ
    ,PDQWLFLSDWLQJ
    6KHJULQQHG<RXDOZD\VKDYHDORQJHUZRUGIRULWQRPDWWHUZKDW,
    VD\
    7KHWUHNVORRNDOLWWOHZHOOWRXULVW\
    2IFRXUVH:HUHWRXULVWV
    7KHODQGKHUHURVHXSLQWRSHDNVDVVKDUSDVWRUQWLQ,QWKHWKLFN
    WUHHVEH\RQGPLVWEURNHRQJUD\VPRRWKURFNV(YHQKHUHKLJKXSWKHVORSH RI
    DQLPSRVLQJULGJHWKH([FXUVLRQ6WDWLRQZDVKHPPHGLQE\VOLP\WKLFNEDUNHG
    WUHHVVWDQGLQJLQGHHSGULIWVRIGHDGGDUNOHDYHV:LWKURWWLQJORJVKDOI
    EXULHGLQWKHZHWOD\HUVWKHDLUVZDUPHGVRFORVHLWZDVOLNHEUHDWKLQJGDPS
    RSLXP
    'RUVVWRRGKHUGULQNILQLVKHG/HWVJRLQVRFLDOL]H
    +HIROORZHGGXWLIXOO\DQGULJKWDZD\NQHZLWZDVDPLVWDNH0RVWRIWKH
    LQGRRUVWLPSDUW\FURZGZDVGUHVVHGLQUXJJHGVDIDULVW\OHJHDU7KH\ZHUH
    UXGG\IRONIDFHVIOXVKHGZLWKH[FLWHPHQWRUSHUKDSVMXVWHQKDQFHUV+DUL
    ZDYHGDZD\WKHEXEEOHJODVVEHDULQJZDLWHUKHGLVOLNHGWKHZD\LWVKDUSHQHG
    KLVZLWVLQXQFRQWUROOHGZD\V6WLOOKHVPLOHGDQGWULHGWRPDNHVPDOOWDON

    7KLVWXUQHGRXWWREHQRWPHUHO\VPDOOEXWPLFURVFRSLF:KHUHDUH\RX
    IURP"2K7UDQWRUZKDWVLWOLNH":HUHIURP ILOOLQWKHSODQHW KDYH\RX
    HYHUKHDUGRILW"2IFRXUVHKHKDGQRW7ZHQW\ILYHPLOOLRQZRUOGV
    0RVWZHUH3ULPLWLYLVWVGUDZQE\WKHXQLTXHH[SHULHQFHDYDLODEOHKHUH
    ,WVHHPHGWRKLPWKDWHYHU\WKLUGZRUGLQWKHLUFRQYHUVDWLRQZDVQDWXUDORU
    YLWDOGHOLYHUHGOLNHDPDQWUD
    :KDWDUHOLHIWREHDZD\IURPVWUDLJKWOLQHVDWKLQPDQVDLG
    8PKRZVR"+DULVDLGWU\LQJWRVHHPLQWHUHVWHG
    :HOORIFRXUVHVWUDLJKWOLQHVGRQWH[LVWLQQDWXUH7KH\KDYHWREH
    SXWWKHUHE\KXPDQV+HVLJKHG,ORYHWREHIUHHRIVWUDLJKWQHVV
    +DULLQVWDQWO\WKRXJKWRISLQHQHHGOHVVWUDWDRIPHWDPRUSKLFURFNWKH
    LQVLGHHGJHRIDKDOIPRRQVSLGHUZRYHQVLONVWUDQGVWKHOLQHDORQJWKHWRS
    RIDEUHDNLQJRFHDQZDYHFU\VWDOSDWWHUQVZKLWHTXDUW]OLQHVRQJUDQLWH
    VODEVWKHIDUKRUL]RQRIDYDVWFDOPODNHWKHOHJVRIELUGVVSLNHVRI
    FDFWXVWKHDUURZGLYHRIDUDSWRUWUXQNVRI\RXQJIDVWJURZLQJWUHHVZLVSV
    RIKLJKZLQGEORZQFORXGVLFHFUDFNVWKHWZRVLGHVRIWKH9RIPLJUDWLQJ
    ELUGVLFLFOHV
    1RWVRKHVDLGEXWQRPRUH
    +LVKDELWRIODFRQLFLPSOLFDWLRQZDVWUDPSOHGLQWKHKHDGORQJWDONRI
    FRXUVHWKHHQKDQFHUVZHUHWDNLQJKROG7KH\DOOFKDWWHUHGRQH[FLWHGE\WKH
    SURVSHFWRILPPHUVLQJWKHPVHOYHVLQWKHOLYHVRIWKHFUHDWXUHVURDPLQJWKH
    YDOOH\VEHORZ+HOLVWHQHGQRWFRPPHQWLQJLQWULJXHG6RPHZDQWHGWRVKDUH
    WKHZRUOGYLHZRIKHUGDQLPDOVRWKHUVRIKXQWHUVVRPHRIELUGV7KH\VSRNHDV
    WKRXJKWKH\ZHUHHQWHULQJVRPHDWKOHWLFHYHQWDQGWKDWZDVQRWKLVYLHZDW
    DOO6WLOOKHVWD\HGVLOHQW
    +HILQDOO\HVFDSHGZLWK'RUVLQWRWKHVPDOOSDUNEHVLGHWKH([FXUVLRQ
    6WDWLRQGHVLJQHGWRPDNHJXHVWVIDPLOLDUZLWKORFDOFRQGLWLRQVEHIRUHWKHLU
    LPPHUVLRQ3DQXFRSLDDVWKLVZRUOGZDVFDOOHGDSSDUHQWO\KDGOLWWOHQDWLYH
    OLIHRIODUJHVL]H7KHUHZHUHDQLPDOVKHKDGVHHQDVDER\RQ+HOLFRQDQG
    ZKROHNUDDOVRIGRPHVWLFEUHHGV$OOKDGVSUXQJIURPFRPPRQVWRFNOHVVWKDQD
    KXQGUHGWKRXVDQG\HDUVDJRRQWKHOHJHQGDU\(DUWK
    7KHXQLTXHDVVHWRI3DQXFRSLDZDVQRZKHUHQHDURIFRXUVH+HVWRSSHG
    DQGVWDUHGDWWKHNUDDOVDQGWKRXJKWDJDLQDERXWWKH*DOD[\+LVPLQGNHSW
    DWWDFNLQJZKDWKHWKRXJKWRIDVWKH*UHDW3UREOHPGLYLQJDWLWIURPPDQ\
    DQJOHV+HKDGOHDUQHGWRMXVWVWDQGDVLGHDQGOHWLWUXQ7KH
    SV\FKRKLVWRULFDOHTXDWLRQVQHHGHGGHHSHUDQDO\VLVWHUPVZKLFKDFFRXQWHGIRU
    WKHEHGURFNSURSHUWLHVRIKXPDQVDVDVSHFLHV$V
    $QLPDOV:DVWKHUHDFOXHKHUH"
    'HVSLWHPLOOHQQLDRIWU\LQJKXPDQVKDGGRPHVWLFDWHGIHZFUHDWXUHV7R
    EHGRPHVWLFDWHGZLOGEHDVWVKDGWRKDYHDQHQWLUHVXLWHRIWUDLWV0RVWKDG
    WREHKHUGDQLPDOVZLWKLQVWLQFWLYHVXEPLVVLRQSDWWHUQVZKLFKKXPDQVFRXOG
    FRRSW7KH\KDGWREHSODFLGKHUGVWKDWEROWDWDVWUDQJHVRXQGDQGFDQW
    WROHUDWHLQWUXGHUVDUHKDUGWRNHHS
    )LQDOO\WKH\KDGWREHZLOOLQJWREUHHGLQFDSWLYLW\0RVWKXPDQV
    GLGQWZDQWWRFRXUWDQGFRSXODWHXQGHUWKHZDWFKIXOJD]HRIRWKHUVDQG
    QHLWKHUGLGPRVWDQLPDOV
    6RKHUHWKHUHZHUHVKHHSDQGJRDWVDQGFRZVDQGOODPDVVOLJKWO\DGDSWHG
    WRWKLVZRUOGEXWRWKHUZLVHXQUHPDUNDEOHMXVWOLNHP\ULDGRWKHU(PSLUH
    SODQHWV7KHVLPLODULW\LPSOLHGWKDWLWKDGDOOEHHQGRQHDWDERXWWKHVDPH
    WLPH
    ([FHSWIRUWKHSDQV7KH\ZHUHXQLTXHWR3DQXFRSLD:KRHYHUKDGEURXJKW
    WKHPKHUHPLJKWKDYHEHHQWU\LQJDGRPHVWLFDWLRQH[SHULPHQWEXWWKHUHFRUGV
    IURP\HDUVEHIRUHZHUHORVW:K\"
    $ZLUHKRXQGFDPHVQLIILQJFKHFNLQJWKHPRXWPXWWHULQJDQ
    XQLQWHOOLJLEOHDSRORJ\,QWHUHVWLQJKHUHPDUNHGWR'RUVWKDW3ULPLWLYLVWV
    VWLOOZDQWWREHSURWHFWHGIURPWKHZLOGE\WKHGRPHVWLFDWHG
    :HOORIFRXUVH7KLVIHOORZLVELJ

    1RWVHQWLPHQWDODERXWWKHQDWXUDOVWDWH":HZHUHRQFHMXVWDQRWKHUW\SH
    RIODUJHPDPPDORQVRPHP\WKLFDO(DUWK
    0\WKLFDO",GRQWZRUNLQWKDWDUHDRISUHKLVWRU\EXWPRVWKLVWRULDQV
    WKLQNWKHUHZDVVXFKDSODFH
    6XUHEXWHDUWKMXVWPHDQVGLUWLQWKHROGHVWODQJXDJHVFRUUHFW"
    :HOOZHKDGWRFRPHIURPVRPHZKHUH6KHWKRXJKWDPRPHQWWKHQ
    DOORZHGVORZO\,WKLQNWKDWQDWXUDOVWDWHPLJKWEHDSOHDVDQWSODFHWR
    YLVLWEXW
    ,ZDQWWRWU\WKHSDQV
    :KDW"$QLPPHUVLRQ"+HUH\HEURZVOLIWHGLQPLOGDODUP
    $VORQJDVZHUHKHUHZK\QRW"
    ,GRQWZHOO,OOWKLQNDERXWLW
    <RXFDQEDLORXWDWDQ\WLPHWKH\VD\6KHQRGGHGSXUVHGKHUOLSV
    8P
    :HOOIHHODWKRPHWKHZD\SDQVGR
    <RXEHOLHYHHYHU\WKLQJ\RXUHDGLQDEURFKXUH"
    ,GLGVRPHUHVHDUFK,WVDZHOOGHYHORSHGWHFK+HUOLSVKDGD
    VNHSWLFDOWLOW8P
    +HNQHZE\QRZEHWWHUWKDQWRSUHVVKHU/HWWLPHGRKLVZRUN7KH
    FDQLQHTXLWHODUJHDQG DOHUWVQXIIOHGDWKLVKDQGDQGVOXUUHG*RRRG
    QDDDJKWVXXXU+HVWURNHGLW,QLWVH\HVKHVDZDNLQVKLSDQLQVWDQW
    UDSSRUWWKDWKHGLGQRWQHHGWRWKLQNDERXW)RURQHZKRGZHOOHGLQKLVKHDG
    VRPXFKWKLVZDVDZHOFRPHUXERIUHDOLW\
    6LJQLILFDQW HYLGHQFHKHWKRXJKW:HKDYHDGHHSSDVWWRJHWKHU3HUKDSV
    WKDWZDVZK\KHZDQWHGWRLPPHUVHLQDSDQ7RJRIDUEDFNEH\RQGWKHYH[LQJ
    VWDWHRIEHLQJKXPDQ
    

    :HUHFHUWDLQO\UHODWHG\HV([SHUW6SHFLDOLVW9DGGRVDLG+HZDVD
    ELJPDQWDQQHGDQGPXVFXODUDQGFDVXDOO\FRQILGHQW+HZDVDVDIDULJXLGHDQG
    LPPHUVLRQVSHFLDOLVWZLWKDELRORJ\EDFNJURXQG+HGLGUHVHDUFKXVLQJ
    LPPHUVLRQWHFKQLTXHVEXWNHHSLQJWKHVWDWLRQJRLQJVRDNHGXSPRVWRIKLV
    WLPHKHVDLG
    +DULORRNHGVNHSWLFDO<RXWKLQNSDQVZHUHZLWKXVEDFNRQDQ(DUWK"
    6XUH+DGWREH
    7KH\FRXOGQRWKDYHDULVHQIURPJHQHWLFWLQNHULQJZLWKRXURZQNLQG"
    'RXEWIXO*HQHWLFLQYHQWRU\VKRZVWKDWWKH\FRPHIURPDVPDOOVWDEOH
    SUREDEO\D]RRVHWXSKHUH2UHOVHDQDFFLGHQWDOFUDVK
    'RUVDVNHG,VWKHUHDQ\FKDQFHWKLVZRUOGFRXOGKDYHEHHQWKHRULJLQDO
    (DUWK"
    9DGGRFKXFNOHG1RIRVVLOUHFRUGQRUXLQV$Q\ZD\WKHORFDOIDXQDDQG
    IORUDKDYHDIXQQ\NH\SDWWHUQLQWKHLUJHQHWLFKHOL[DELWGLIIHUHQWIURPRXU
    '1$([WUDPHWK\OJURXSRQWKHSXULQHULQJV:HFDQOLYHKHUHHDWWKHIRRG
    EXWQHLWKHUZHQRUWKHSDQVDUHQDWLYH
    9DGGRPDGHDJRRGFDVH3DQVFHUWDLQO\ORRNHGTXDVLKXPDQ$QFLHQW
    UHFRUGVUHIHUUHGWRDFODVVLILFDWLRQWKDWZDVDOO3DQWURJORG\WHVZKDWHYHU
    WKDWPHDQWLQDORQJORVWWRQJXH7KH\KDGKDQGVZLWKWKXPEVWKHVDPHQXPEHU
    RIWHHWKDVKXPDQVQRWDLOV
    9DGGRZDYHGDELJKDQGDWWKHODQGVFDSHEHORZWKHVWDWLRQ7KH\ZHUH
    GXPSHGKHUHDORQJZLWKSOHQW\RIRWKHUUHODWHGVSHFLHVRQWRSRIDELRVSKHUH
    WKDWVXSSRUWHGWKHXVXDOJUDVVHVDQGWUHHVYHU\OLWWOHPRUH
    +RZORQJDJR"'RUVDVNHG
    2YHUWKLUWHHQWKRXVDQG\HDUVWKDWVIRUVXUH
    %HIRUH7UDQWRUVFRQVROLGDWLRQ%XWRWKHUSODQHWVGRQWKDYHSDQV
    'RUVSHUVLVWHG
    9DGGRQRGGHG,JXHVVLQ WKHHDUO\(PSLUHGD\VQRERG\WKRXJKWWKH\ZHUH

    XVHIXO
    $UHWKH\"+DULDVNHG
    1RWWKDW,FDQWHOO9DGGRVKUXJJHG:HKDYHQWWULHGWUDLQLQJWKHP
    PXFKEH\RQGUHVHDUFKSXUSRVHV5HPHPEHUWKH\UHVXSSRVHGWREHNHSWZLOG
    7KHRULJLQDO(PSHURUV%RRQVWLSXODWHGWKDW
    7HOOPHDERXW\RXUUHVHDUFK+DULVDLG,QKLVH[SHULHQFHQR
    VFLHQWLVWHYHUSDVVHGXSDFKDQFHWRVLQJKLVRZQVRQJ+HZDVULJKW
    7KH\KDGWDNHQKXPDQ'1$DQGSDQ'1$9DGGRVDLGZD[LQJRQ
    HQWKXVLDVWLFDOO\WKHQXQ]LSSHGWKHGRXEOHKHOL[VWUDQGVLQERWK/LQNLQJRQH
    KXPDQVWUDQGZLWKDSDQVWUDQGPDGHDK\EULG
    :KHUHWKHVWUDQGVFRPSOHPHQWHGWKHWZRWKHQWLJKWO\ERXQGLQDSDUWLDO
    QHZGRXEOHKHOL[:KHUHWKH\GLIIHUHGERQGLQJEHWZHHQWKHVWUDQGVZDVZHDN
    LQWHUPLWWHQW ZLWKZKROHVHFWLRQVIODSSLQJIUHH
    7KHQWKH\VSXQWKHZDWHU\VROXWLRQVLQDFHQWULIXJHVRWKHZHDN
    VHFWLRQVULSSHGDSDUW&ORVHO\OLQNHG'1$ZDVSHUFHQWRIWKHWRWDO3DQV
    ZHUHVWDUWOLQJO\OLNHKXPDQV/HVVWKDQWZRSHUFHQWGLIIHUHQFHDERXWWKHVDPH
    WKDWVHSDUDWHGPHQDQGZRPHQ\HWWKH\OLYHGLQIRUHVWVDQGLQYHQWHGQRWKLQJ
    7KHW\SLFDOGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQLQGLYLGXDOSHRSOHV'1$ZDVDWHQWKRID
    SHUFHQWDJHSRLQW9DGGRVDLG5RXJKO\WKHQSDQVZHUHWZHQW\WLPHVPRUH
    GLIIHUHQWIURPKXPDQVWKDQSDUWLFXODUSHRSOHGLIIHUHGDPRQJWKHPVHOYHV
    JHQHWLFDOO\
    %XWJHQHVZHUHOLNHOHYHUVVXSSRUWLQJYDVWZHLJKWVE\SLYRWLQJDERXWD
    VPDOOIXOFUXP
    6R\RXWKLQNWKH\FDPHEHIRUHXV"'RUVZDVLPSUHVVHG2Q(DUWK"
    9DGGRQRGGHGYLJRURXVO\7KH\PXVWKDYHEHHQUHODWHGEXWZHGRQWFRPH
    IURPWKHP:HSDUWHGFRPSDQ\JHQHWLFDOO\VL[PLOOLRQ\HDUVDJR
    $QGGRWKH\WKLQNOLNHXV"+DULDVNHG
    %HVWZD\WRWHOOLVDQLPPHUVLRQ9DGGRVDLG9HU\EHVWZD\
    +HVPLOHGLQYLWLQJO\DQG+DULZRQGHUHGLI9DGGRJRWDFRPPLVVLRQRQ
    LPPHUVLRQV+LVVDOHVSLWFKZDVVXEWOHVKDSHGIRUDQDFDGHPLFVLQWHUHVWEXW
    VWLOODVDOHVSLWFK
    9DGGRKDGDOUHDG\PDGHDYDLODEOHWR+DULWKHYDVWVWRUHVRIGDWDRQSDQ
    PRYHPHQWVSRSXODWLRQG\QDPLFVDQGEHKDYLRUV,WZDVDULFKVRXUFHPLOOHQQLD
    ROG:LWKVRPHPRGHOLQJKHUHPLJKWEHIHUWLOHJURXQGIRUDVLPSOHGHVFULSWLRQ
    RISDQVDVSURWRKXPDQVXVLQJDWUXQFDWHGYHUVLRQRISV\FKRKLVWRU\
    'HVFULELQJWKHOLIHKLVWRU\RIDVSHFLHVPDWKHPDWLFDOO\LVRQHWKLQJ
    'RUVVDLG%XWOLYLQJLQLW
    &RPHQRZ+DULVDLG(YHQWKRXJKKHNQHZWKHHQWLUH([FXUVLRQ6WDWLRQ
    ZDVJHDUHGWRVHOOWKHJXHVWVVDIDULVDQGLPPHUVLRQVKHZDVLQWULJXHG,
    QHHGDFKDQJH\RXVDLG*HWRXWRIVWXII\ROG7UDQWRU\RXVDLG
    9DGGRVPLOHGZDUPO\,WVFRPSOHWHO\VDIH
    'RUVVPLOHGDW+DULWROHUDQWO\%HWZHHQSHRSOHORQJPDUULHGWKHUHLVD
    GLSORPDF\RIWKHH\HV2KDOOULJKW
    

    +HVSHQWPRUQLQJVVWXG\LQJWKHSDQGDWDEDQNV7KHPDWKHPDWLFLDQLQKLP
    SRQGHUHGKRZWRUHSUHVHQWWKHLUG\QDPLFVZLWKDWULPPHGGRZQSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    7KHPDUEOHRIIDWHUDWWOLQJGRZQDFUDFNHGVORSH6RPDQ\SDWKVYDULDEOHV
    7RJHWDOOWKLVKHKDGWRNRZWRZWRWKHVWDWLRQFKLHI$ZRPDQQDPHG
    <DNDQLVKHVHHPHGFRUGLDOEXWGLVSOD\HGDODUJHSRUWUDLWRIWKH$FDGHPLF
    3RWHQWDWHXSRQKHURIILFHZDOO+DULPHQWLRQHGLWDQG<DNDQLJXVKHGRQDERXW
    KHUPHQWRUZKRKDGKHOSHGKHUUXQDSULPDWHVWXGLHVFHQWHURQDYHUGDQW
    SODQHWVRPHGHFDGHVEHIRUH
    6KHZLOOEHDUZDWFKLQJ'RUVVDLG
    <RXGRQWWKLQNWKH3RWHQWDWHZRXOG
    7KHILUVWDVVDVVLQDWLRQDWWHPSWUHPHPEHUWKHWDE",OHDUQHGIURPWKH

    ,PSHULDOVWKDWVRPHWHFKQLFDODVSHFWVRILWSRLQWWRDQDFDGHPLFODERUDWRU\
    +DULIURZQHG6XUHO\P\RZQIDFWLRQZRXOGQRWRSSRVH
    6KHLVDVUXWKOHVVDV/DPXUNEXWPRUHVXEWOH
    0\\RXDUHVXVSLFLRXV
    ,PXVWEH
    ,QWKHDIWHUQRRQVWKH\WRRNWUHNV'RUVGLGQRWOLNHWKHGXVWDQGKHDW
    DQGWKH\VDZIHZDQLPDOV:KDWVHOIUHVSHFWLQJEHDVWZRXOGZDQWWREHVHHQ
    ZLWKWKHVHRYHUGUHVVHG3ULPLWLYLVWV"VKHVDLG
    +HOLNHGWKHDWPRVSKHUHRIWKLVZRUOGDQGUHOD[HGLQWRLWEXWKLVPLQG
    NHSWRQZRUNLQJ+HWKRXJKWDERXWWKLVDVKHVWRRGRQWKHVZHHSLQJYHUDQGDK
    GULQNLQJSXQJHQWIUXLWMXLFHDVKHZDWFKHGDVXQVHW'RUVVWRRGEHVLGHKLP
    VLOHQWO\
    3ODQHWVZHUHHQHUJ\IXQQHOVKHWKRXJKW$WWKHERWWRPRIWKHLU
    JUDYLWDWLRQDOZHOOVSODQWVFDSWXUHGEDUHO\DWHQWKRIDSHUFHQWRIWKH
    VXQOLJKWWKDWIHOORQDZRUOGVVXUIDFH7KH\EXLOWRUJDQLFPROHFXOHVZLWKD
    VWDUVHQHUJ\,QWXUQSODQWVZHUHSUH\IRUDQLPDOVZKRFRXOGKDUYHVW
    URXJKO\DWHQWKRIWKHSODQWVVWRUHGHQHUJ\*UD]HUVZHUHWKHPVHOYHVSUH\WR
    PHDWHDWHUVZKRFRXOGXVHDERXWDWHQWKRIWKHIOHVKVWRUHGHQHUJ\6RKH
    HVWLPDWHGRQO\DERXWRQHSDUWLQDKXQGUHGWKRXVDQGRIWKHODQFLQJVXQOLJKW
    HQHUJ\ZRXQGXS LQWKHSUHGDWRUV
    :DVWHIXO<HWQRZKHUHLQWKHZKROH*DOD[\KDGDPRUHHIILFLHQWHQJLQH
    HYROYHG:K\QRW"
    3UHGDWRUVZHUHLQYDULDEO\PRUHLQWHOOLJHQWWKDQWKHLUSUH\DQGWKH\VDW
    DWRSDS\UDPLGRIYHU\VWHHSVORSHV2PQLYRUHVKDGDVLPLODUEDODQFLQJDFW
    2XWRIWKDWUXJJHGODQGVFDSHKDGFRPHKXPDQLW\
    7KDWIDFWKDGWRPDWWHUJUHDWO\LQDQ\SV\FKRKLVWRU\7KHSDQVWKHQ
    ZHUHHVVHQWLDOWRILQGLQJWKHDQFLHQWNH\VWRWKHKXPDQSV\FKH
    'RUVVDLG,KRSHLPPHUVLRQLVQWZHOOVRKRWDQGVWLFN\
    5HPHPEHU\RXOOVHHWKHZRUOGWKURXJKGLIIHUHQWH\HV
    -XVWVR,FDQFRPHEDFNZKHQHYHU,ZDQWDQGKDYHDQLFHKRWEDWK

    &RPSDUWPHQWV"'RUVVKLHGEDFN7KH\ORRNPRUHOLNHFDVNHWV
    7KH\KDYHWREHVQXJPDGDP
    ([6SHF9DGGRVPLOHGDPLDEO\ZKLFK+DULVHQVHGSUREDEO\PHDQWKH
    ZDVQWIHHOLQJDPLDEOHDWDOO7KHLUFRQYHUVDWLRQKDGEHHQIULHQGO\WKHVWDII
    KHUHZDVUHVSHFWIXORIWKHQRWHG2U6HOGRQEXWDIWHUDOOEDVLFDOO\KHDQG
    'RUVZHUHMXVWPRUHWRXULVWV3D\LQJIRUDELWRISULPLWLYHIXQDOOFRXFKHG
    LQSURSHUVFKRODUO\WHUPVEXWWRXULVWV
    <RXUHNHSWLQIL[HGVWDWXVDOOERG\V\VWHPVUXQQLQJVORZEXWQRUPDO
    WKH([6SHFVDLGSRSSLQJRXWWKHSDGGHGQHWZRUNVIRUWKHLULQVSHFWLRQ+HUDQ
    WKURXJKWKHFRQWUROVHPHUJHQF\SURFHGXUHVVDIHJXDUGV
    /RRNVFRPIRUWDEOHHQRXJK'RUVREVHUYHGJUXGJLQJO\
    &RPHRQ+DULFKLGHG<RXSURPLVHGZHZRXOGGRLW
    <RXOOEHPHVKHGLQWRRXUV\VWHPVDWDOOWLPHV9DGGRVDLG
    (YHQ\RXUGDWDOLEUDU\"+DULDVNHG
    6XUHWKLQJ
    7KHWHDPRI([6SHFVERRWHGWKHPLQWRWKHVWDVLVFRPSDUWPHQWVZLWKGHIW
    VXUHHIILFLHQF\7DEVSUHVVHUVPDJQHWLFSLFNXSVZHUHSODWHGRQWRKLVVNXOO
    WRSLFNXSWKRXJKWVGLUHFWO\7KHYHU\ODWHVWWHFK
    5HDG\")HHOLQJJRRG"9DGGRDVNHGZLWKKLVSURIHVVLRQDOVPLOH
    +DULZDVQRWIHHOLQJJRRG DVRSSRVHGWRIHHOLQJZHOO DQGKHUHDOL]HG
    SDUWRILWZDVWKLV([6SHF+HKDGDOZD\VGLVWUXVWHGEODQGDVVXUHGSHRSOH
    %RWK9DGGRDQGWKHVHFXULW\FKLHI<DNDQLVHHPHGWREHXQUHPDUNDEOH*UH\V
    %XW'RUVZDULQHVVKDGUXEEHGRII6RPHWKLQJDERXWWKHPERWKHUHGKLPEXWKH
    FRXOGQRWVD\ZK\
    2KZHOO'RUVZDVSUREDEO\ULJKW+HQHHGHGDYDFDWLRQ:KDWEHWWHUZD\
    WRJHWRXWRI\RXUVHOI"

    *RRG\HV5HDG\\HV
    7KHVXVSHQVLRQWHFKZDVDQFLHQWDQGUHOLDEOH,WVXSSUHVVHG
    QHXURPXVFXODUUHVSRQVHVVRWKHFXVWRPHUOD\GRUPDQWRQO\KLVPLQGHQJDJHG
    ZLWKWKHSDQ
    0DJQHWLFZHEVFDSSHGRYHUKLVFHUHEUXP7KURXJKHOHFWURPDJQHWLF
    LQGXFWDQFHWKH\LQWHUZRYHLQWROD\HUVRIWKHEUDLQ7KH\URXWHGVLJQDOVDORQJ
    WLQ\WKUHDGSDWKVVXSSUHVVLQJPDQ\EUDLQIXQFWLRQVDQGEORFNLQJSK\VLRORJLFDO
    SURFHVVHV
    $OOWKLVVRWKDWWKHPDVVLYHO\SDUDOOHOFLUFXLWU\RIWKHEUDLQFRXOGEH
    LQGXFWLYHO\OLQNHGRXWWKRXJKWE\WKRXJKW7KHQLWZDVWUDQVPLWWHGWRFKLSV
    HPEHGGHGLQWKHSDQVXEMHFW,PPHUVLRQ
    7KHWHFKQRORJ\KDGUDPLILHGWKURXJKRXWWKH(PSLUHTXLWHIDPRXVO\7KH
    DELOLW\WRGLVWDQWO\PDQDJHPLQGVKDGP\ULDGXVHV7KHVXVSHQVLRQWHFK
    KRZHYHUIRXQGLWVRZQRGGDSSOLFDWLRQV
    2QVRPHZRUOGVDQGLQ FHUWDLQ7UDQWRULDQFODVVHVZRPHQZHUHZHGGHG
    WKHQVXVSHQGHGIRUDOOEXWDIHZKRXUVRIWKHGD\7KHLUZHDOWK\KXVEDQGV
    DZRNHWKHPIURPIUHH]HIUDPHVWDWHVRQO\IRUVRFLDODQGVH[XDOSXUSRVHV2YHU
    DKDOIFHQWXU\WKHZLYHVH[SHULHQFHGDKHDG\ZKLUOZLQGRISODFHVIULHQGV
    SDUWLHVYDFDWLRQVSDVVLRQDWHKRXUVEXWWKHLUWRWDODFFXPXODWHGWLPHZDV
    RQO\DIHZ\HDUV7KHLUKXVEDQGVGLHGLQZKDWVHHPHGWRWKHZLYHVOLNHVKRUW
    RUGHULQGHHGOHDYLQJDZHDOWK\ZLGRZRISHUKDSVWKLUW\6XFKZRPHQZHUH
    KLJKO\VRXJKWDQGQRWRQO\IRUWKHLUPRQH\7KH\ZHUHXQLTXHO\VRSKLVWLFDWHG
    VHDVRQHGE\DORQJPDUULDJH2IWHQWKHVHZLGRZVUHWXUQHGWKHIDYRUZHGGLQJ
    KXVEDQGVZKRPWKH\UHYLYHGIRUVLPLODUXVHV
    $OOWKLV+DULKDGWDNHQLQZLWKWKHVRSKLVWLFDWHGYHQHHUKHKDG
    FXOWLYDWHGRQ7UDQWRU6RKHWKRXJKWKLVLPPHUVLRQZRXOGEHFRPIRUWDEOH
    LQWHUHVWLQJWKHVWXIIRIVWLPSDUW\WDON
    +HKDGWKRXJKWWKDWKHZRXOGLQVRPHVHQVHYLVLWDQRWKHUVLPSOHUPLQG
    +HGLGQRWH[SHFWWREHVZDOORZHGZKROH
    

    $JRRGGD\3OHQW\RIIDWJUXEVWRHDWLQDELJPRLVWORJ'LJWKHPRXW
    ZLWKP\QDLOVIUHVKWDQJ\VKDUSFUXQFK\
    %LJJHVWKHVKRYHVPHDVLGH6FRRSVRXWSOHQW\ULFKJUXEV*UXQWV
    *ORZHUV
    0\EHOO\UXPEOHV,EDFNRIIDQGH\H%LJJHVW+HVJRWSLQFKHGXSIDFH
    VR, NQRZQRWWRIRROZLWKKLP
    ,ZDONDZD\,VTXDWGRZQ*HWVRPHSLFNLQJIURPDIHP6KHILQGVVRPH
    IOHDVFUDFNVWKHPLQKHUWHHWK
    %LJJHVWUROOVWKHORJDURXQGVRPHWRNQRFNDIHZJUXEVORRVHILQLVKHV
    XS+HVVWURQJ)HUQVZDWFKKLP2YHUE\WKHWUHHVDEXQFKRIIHPVFKDWWHU
    VXFNWKHLUWHHWK(YHU\ERG\VVOHHS\QRZLQHDUO\DIWHUQRRQO\LQJLQWKH
    VKDGH%LJJHVWWKRXJKKHZDYHVDWPHDQG+XQNHUDQGRIIZHJR
    3DWURO6WUXWWDOOVWHSRXWSURXG,OLNHLWILQH%HWWHUWKDQKXPSLQJ
    HYHQ
    'RZQSDVWWKHFUHHNDQGDORQJWRZKHUHWKHKRRIVPHOOVDUH7KDWVWKH
    VKDOORZVSRW:HFURVVDQGJRLQWRWKHWUHHVVQLIIVQLIILQJDQGWKHUHDUHWZR
    6WUDQJHUV
    7KH\GRQWVHHXV\HW:HPRYHVPRRWKTXLHW%LJJHVWSLFNVXSDEUDQFK
    DQGZHGRWRR+XQNHULVVQLIILQJWRVHHZKRWKHVH6WUDQJHUVDUHDQGKH
    SRLQWVRIIWRWKHKLOO-XVWOLNH,WKRXJKWWKH\UH+LOOLHV7KHZRUVW6PHOO
    EDG
    +LOOLHVFRPHRQWRRXUWXUI0DNHWURXEOH:HPDNHLWEDFN
    :HVSUHDGRXW%LJJHVWKHJUXQWVDQGWKH\KHDUKLP,PDOUHDG\ PRYLQJ
    EUDQFKKHOGXS,FDQUXQSUHWW\IDUZLWKRXWJRLQJDOOIRXUV7KH6WUDQJHUV
    FU\RXWELJH\HG:HJRIDVWDQGWKHQZHUHRQWKHP

    7KH\KDYHQREUDQFKHV:HKLWWKHPDQGNLFNDQGWKH\JUDEDWXV7KH\
    DUHWDOODQGTXLFN%LJJHVWVODPVRQHWRWKHJURXQG,KLWWKDWRQHVR%LJJHVW
    NQRZVUHDOZHOO,PZLWKKLP+DPPHUKDUG,GR7KHQ,JRTXLFNWRKHOS
    +XQNHU
    +LV6WUDQJHUKDVWDNHQKLVEUDQFKDZD\,FOXEWKH6WUDQJHU+HVSUDZOV
    ,ZKDFNKLPJRRGDQG+XQNHUMXPSVRQKLPDQGLWLVZRQGHUIXO
    7KH6WUDQJHUWULHVWRJHWXSDQG,NLFNKLPVROLG+XQNHUJUDEVEDFNKLV
    EUDQFKDQGKLWVDJDLQDQGDJDLQZLWKPHKHOSLQJKDUG
    %LJJHVWKLV6WUDQJHUJHWVXSDQGVWDUWVWRUXQ%LJJHVWZKDFNVKLVDVV
    ZLWKWKHEUDQFKURDULQJDQGODXJKLQJ
    0H,JRWP\VNLOO6SHFLDO,SLFNXSURFNV,PWKHEHVWWKURZHU
    EHWWHUWKDQ%LJJHVWHYHQ
    5RFNVDUHIRU6WUDQJHUV0\EXGGLHVWKHP,OOVFUDSZLWKEXWQHYHUXVH
    URFNV6WUDQJHUVWKRXJKWKH\GHVHUYHWRJHWURFNVLQWKHIDFH,ORYHWR
    EXVWD6WUDQJHUWKDWZD\
    ,WKURZRQHFOHDQDQGVPRRWK&DWFKWKH6WUDQJHURQWKHOHJ+H
    VWXPEOHV,VPDFNKLPJRRGZLWKDVKDUSHGJHGURFNLQWKHEDFN
    +HUXQVIDVWWKHQ,FDQVHHKHVEOHHGLQJ%LJUHGGURSVLQWKHGXVW
    %LJJHVWODXJKVDQGVODSVPHDQG,NQRZ,PLQJRRGZLWKKLP
    +XQNHULVFOXEELQJKLV6WUDQJHU%LJJHVWWDNHVP\FOXEDQGMRLQVLQ7KH
    EORRGDOORYHUWKH6WUDQJHUVLQJVZDUPLQP\QRVHDQG,MXUQSXSDQGGRZQRQ
    KLP:HNHHSDWLWOLNHWKDWDORQJWLPH1RWZRUULHGDERXWWKHRWKHU6WUDQJHU
    FRUQLQJEDFN6WUDQJHUVDUH EUDYHVRPHWLPHVEXWWKH\NQRZZKHQWKH\KDYH
    ORVW
    7KH6WUDQJHUVWRSVPRYLQJ,JLYHKLPRQHPRUHNLFN
    1RUHDFWLRQ'HDGPD\EH
    :HVFUHDPDQGGDQFHDQGKROOHURXWRXUMR\
    

    +DULVKRRNKLVKHDGWRFOHDULW7KDWKHOSHGDOLWWOH
    <RXZHUHWKDWELJRQH"'RUVDVNHG,ZDVWKHIHPDOHRYHUE\WKH
    WUHHV
    6RUU\,FRXOGQWWHOO
    ,WZDVGLIIHUHQWZDVQWLW"
    +HODXJKHGGU\O\0XUGHUXVXDOO\LV
    :KHQ\RXZHQWRIIZLWKWKHZHOOOHDGHU
    0\SDQWKLQNVRIKLPDV%LJJHVW:HNLOOHGDQRWKHUSDQ
    7KH\ZHUHLQWKHSOXVKUHFHSWLRQURRPRIWKHLPPHUVLRQIDFLOLW\+DUL
    VWRRGDQGIHOWWKHZRUOGWLOWDOLWWOHDQGWKHQULJKWLWVHOI,WKLQN,OO
    VWLFNWRKLVWRULFDOUHVHDUFKIRUDZKLOH
    'RUVVPLOHGVKHHSLVKO\,,UDWKHUOLNHGLW
    +HWKRXJKWDPRPHQWEOLQNHG6RGLG,KHVDLGVXUSULVLQJKLPVHOI
    1RWWKHPXUGHU
    1RRIFRXUVHQRW%XWWKHIHHO
    6KHJULQQHG&DQWJHWWKDWRQ7UDQWRU3URIHVVRU

    +HVSHQWWZRGD\VFRDVWLQJWKURXJKFRROODWWLFHVRIGDWDLQWKH
    IRUPLGDEOHVWDWLRQOLEUDU\,WZDVZHOOHTXLSSHGDQGDOORZHGLQWHUIDFHVZLWK
    VHYHUDOVHQVHV+HSDWUROOHGWKURXJKFRROGLJLWDOODE\ULQWKV
    6RPHGDWDZDVHQFUXVWHGZLWKDJHTXLWHOLWHUDOO\,QWKHYHFWRUVSDFHV
    SRUWUD\HGRQKXJHVFUHHQVWKHUHVHDUFKGDWDRIPLOOHQQLDDJRZHUHFRYHUHG
    ZLWKWKLFNEXON\SURWRFROVDQGVFDEVRIVHFXULW\SUHFDXWLRQV$OOZHUHHDVLO\
    EURNHQRUDYHUWHGRIFRXUVHE\SUHVHQWPHWKRGV%XWWKHFKXQN\DEVWUDFWV
    UHSRUWVVXPPDULHVDQGFUXGHO\SURFHVVHGVWDWLVWLFVVWLOOUHVLVWHGHDV\
    LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ2FFDVLRQDOO\VRPHIDFHWVRISDQEHKDYLRUZHUHFDUHIXOO\KLGGHQ
    DZD\LQDSSHQGLFHVDQGVLGHEDUQRWHVDVWKRXJKWKHELRORJLVWVLQWKHORQHO\

    RXWSRVWZHUHHPEDUUDVVHGE\LW6RPHZDVHPEDUUDVVLQJPDWLQJEHKDYLRU
    HVSHFLDOO\+RZFRXOGKHXVHWKLV"
    +HQDYLJDWHGWKURXJKWKH'PD]HDQGFREEOHGWRJHWKHUKLVLGHDV&RXOG
    KHIROORZDVWUDWHJ\RIDQDORJ\"
    3DQVVKDUHGQHDUO\DOOWKHLUJHQHVZLWKKXPDQVVRSDQG\QDPLFVVKRXOG
    EHDVLPSOHUYHUVLRQRIKXPDQG\QDPLFV&RXOGKHWKHQDQDO\]HSDQWURRS
    LQWHUDFWLRQVDVDUHGXFHGFDVHRISV\FKRKLVWRU\"
    6HFXULW\&KLHI<DNDQLRSHQHGFRQILGHQWLDOILOHVZKLFKLPSOLHGWKDWSDQV
    KDGEHHQJHQHWLFDOO\PRGLILHGDERXWWHQWKRXVDQG\HDUVEHIRUH7RZKDWHQG
    +DULFRXOGQRWWHOO7KHUHZHUHRWKHUDOWHUHGFUHDWXUHVUDERRQV
    SDUWLFXODUO\<DNDQLWRRNVXFKDQLQWHUHVWLQKLVZRUNWKDWKHEHFDPH
    VXVSLFLRXVVKHZDVNHHSLQJDQH\HRQKLPIRUWKH3RWHQWDWH
    $WVXQVHWRIWKHVHFRQGGD\KHVDWZLWK'RUVZDWFKLQJEORRGUHGVKDIWV
    VSLNHWKURXJKRUDQJHWLQJHGFORXGV7KLVZRUOGZDVJDXG\EH\RQGJRRGWDVWH
    DQGKHOLNHGLW7KHIRRGZDVWDQJ\WRR+LVVWRPDFKUXPEOHGDQWLFLSDWLQJ
    GLQQHU
    +HUHPDUNHGWR'RUV,WVWHPSWLQJXVLQJSDQVWREXLOGDVRUWRIWR\
    PRGHORISV\FKRKLVWRU\
    %XW\RXKDYHGRXEWV
    7KH\UHOLNHXVEXWWKH\KDYHZHOOXK
    %DVHDQLPDOLVWLFZD\V"6KHVPLUNHGWKHQNLVVHGKLP0\SUXGLVK
    +DUL
    :HKDYHRXUVKDUHRIEHDVWO\EHKDYLRUV,NQRZ%XWZHUHDORW
    VPDUWHUWRR
    +HUH\HOLGVGLSSHGLQDPDQQHUKHNQHZE\QRZVXJJHVWHGSROLWHGRXEW
    7KH\OLYHLQWHQVHO\\RXOOKDYHWRJLYHWKHPWKDW
    0D\EHZHUHVPDUWHUWKDQZHQHHGWREHDQ\ZD\"
    :KDW"7KLVVXUSULVHGKHU
    ,YHEHHQUHDGLQJXSRQHYROXWLRQ1RWDIURQWUDQNILHOGDQ\PRUH
    HYHU\ERG\WKLQNVZHXQGHUVWDQGLW
    $QGLQDJDOD[\ILOOHGZLWKKXPDQVDQGOLWWOHHOVHWKHUHLVQWPXFK
    IUHVKPDWHULDO
    +HKDGQRWWKRXJKWRILWWKDWZD\EHIRUHEXWVKHZDVULJKW%LRORJ\ZDV
    DEDFNZDWHUVFLHQFH$OOWKHDFDGHPLFVRSKLVWLFDWHVZHUHSXUVXLQJVRPHWKLQJ
    FDOOHGLQWHJUDWLYHVRFLRPHWULFV
    +HZHQWRQOD\LQJRXWKLVWKRXJKWV3ODLQO\WKHKXPDQEUDLQZDVDQ
    HYROXWLRQDU\RYHUVKRRW%UDLQVZHUHIDUPRUHFDSDEOHWKDQDFRPSHWHQWKXQWHU
    JDWKHUHUQHHGHG7RJHWWKHEHWWHURIDQLPDOVLWZRXOGKDYHEHHQHQRXJKWR
    PDVWHUILUHDQGVLPSOHVWRQHWRROV6XFKWDOHQWVDORQHZRXOGKDYHPDGHSHRSOH
    WKHORUGVRIFUHDWLRQUHPRYLQJVHOHFWLRQSUHVVXUHWRFKDQJH,QVWHDGDOO
    HYLGHQFHIURPWKHEUDLQLWVHOIVDLGWKDWFKDQJHDFFHOHUDWHG7KHKXPDQ
    FHUHEUDOFRUWH[DGGHGPDVVVWDFNLQJQHZFLUFXLWU\DWRSROGHUZLULQJ7KDW
    PDVVVSUHDGRYHUWKHOHVVHUDUHDVOLNHDWKLFNQHZVNLQ6RVDLGWKHDQFLHQW
    VWXGLHVWKHLUGDWDIURPPXVHXPVORQJORVW
    )URPWKLVFDPHPXVLFLDQVDQGHQJLQHHUVVDLQWVDQGVDYDQWVKH
    ILQLVKHGZLWKDIORXULVK2QHRI'RUVEHVWSRLQWVZDVKHUZLOOLQJQHVVWRVLW
    VWLOOZKLOHKHZD[HGSURIHVVRULO\ORQJZLQGHGHYHQRQYDFDWLRQ
    $QGWKHSDQV\RXWKLQNDUHIURPEHIRUHWKDWWLPH"2QDQFLHQW(DUWK"
    7KH\PXVWEH$QGDOOWKLVHYROXWLRQDU\VHOHFWLRQKDSSHQHGLQMXVWD
    IHZPLOOLRQ\HDUV
    'RUVQRGGHG/RRNDWLWIURPWKHZRPDQVSRLQWRIYLHZ,WKDSSHQHG
    GHVSLWHSXWWLQJPRWKHUVLQGHVSHUDWHGDQJHULQFKLOGELUWK
    8KKRZ"
    )URPWKRVHKXJHEDE\KHDGV7KH\UHKDUGWRJHWRXW:HZRPHQDUHVWLOO
    SD\LQJWKHSULFHIRU\RXUEUDLQVDQGIRURXUV
    +HFKXFNOHG6KHDOZD\VKDGDVSHFLDOVSLQRQDVXEMHFWWKDWPDGHKLP
    VHHLWIUHVK7KHQZK\ZDVLWVHOHFWHGIRUEDFNWKHQ"

    'RUVVPLOHGHQLJPDWLFDOO\0D\EHPHQDQGZRPHQDOLNHIRXQGLQWHOOLJHQFH
    VH[\LQHDFKRWKHU
    5HDOO\"
    +HUVO\VPLOH+RZDERXWXV"
    +DYH\RXHYHUZDWFKHGYHU\PDQ\'VWDUV"7KH\GRQWIHDWXUHEUDLQVP\
    GHDU
    5HPHPEHUWKHDQLPDOVZHVDZLQWKH,PSHULDO=RR",WFRXOGEHWKDWIRU
    HDUO\KXPDQVEUDLQVZHUHOLNHSHDFRFNWDLOVRUPRRVHKRUQVGLVSOD\LWHPVWR
    DWWUDFWWKHIHPDOHV5XQDZD\VH[XDOVHOHFWLRQ
    ,VHHDQRYHUSOD\HGKDQGRIRWKHUZLVHSHUIHFWO\JRRGFDUGV+H
    ODXJKHG6REHLQJVPDUWLVMXVWDEULJKWRUQDPHQW
    :RUNVIRUPHVKHVDLGJLYLQJKLPDZLQN
    +HZDWFKHGWKHVXQVHWWXUQWRJORZHULQJRPLQRXVFULPVRQRGGO\KDSS\
    6KHHWVRIOLJKWZRUNHGDFURVVWKHVN\DPRQJFXULRXVOD\HUHGFORXGV8PPP
    'RUVPXUPXUHG
    <HV"
    0D\EHWKLVLVDZD\WRXVHWKHUHVHDUFKWKH([6SHFVDUHGRLQJWRR
    /HDUQZKRZHKXPDQVRQFHZHUHDQGWKHUHIRUHZKRZHDUH
    ,QWHOOHFWXDOO\LWVDMXPS,QVRFLDOZD\VWKRXJKWKHJDSFRXOGEH
    OHVV
    'RUVORRNHGVNHSWLFDO<RXWKLQNSDQVDUHRQO\DELWIXUWKHUEDFNLQD
    VRFLDOVHQVH"
    8PPP,ZRQGHULILQORJDULWKPLFWLPHZHPLJKWVFDOHIURPSDQVWRWKH
    HDUO\(PSLUHDQGWKHQRQWRQRZ"
    $ELJOHDS
    0D\EH,FRXOGXVHWKDW9ROWDLUHVLPIURP6DUNDVDVFDOLQJSRLQWLQD
    ORQJFXUYH
    /RRNWRGRDQ\WKLQJ\RXOOQHHGPRUHH[SHULHQFHZLWKWKHP6KHH\HG
    KLP<RXOLNHLPPHUVLRQGRQW\RX"
    :HOO\HV,WVMXVW
    :KDW"
    7KDW([6SHF9DGGRKHNHHSVSXVKLQJLPPHUVLRQV
    7KDWVKLVMRE
    DQGKHNQHZZKR,ZDV
    6R"6KHVSUHDGKHUKDQGVDQGVKUXJJHG
    <RXUHQRUPDOO\WKHVXVSLFLRXVRQH:K\VKRXOGDQ([6SHFNQRZDQ
    REVFXUHPDWKHPDWLFLDQ"
    +HORRNHG\RXXS'DWDGXPSVRQLQFRPLQJJXHVWVDUHVWDQGDUG$QGDVD
    )LUVW0LQLVWHUFDQGLGDWH\RXUHKDUGO\REVFXUH
    ,VXSSRVHVR6D\\RXUHVXSSRVHGWREHWKHHYHUYLJLODQWRQH+H
    JULQQHG6KRXOGQW\RXEHHQFRXUDJLQJP\FDXWLRQ"
    3DUDQRLDLVQWFDXWLRQ7LPHVSHQWRQQRQWKUHDWVVXEWUDFWVIURP
    YLJLODQFH
    %\WKHWLPHWKH\ZHQWLQIRUGLQQHUVKHKDGWDONHGKLPLQWRLW
    

    +RWGD\LQWKHVXQ'XVWWLFNOHV0DNHVPHVQRUW
    7KDW%LJJHVWKHZDONVE\JHWVUHVSHFWULJKWDZD\3OHQW\)HPVDQG
    JX\VDOLNHWKH\VWLFNRXWWKHLUKDQGV
    %LJJHVWWRXFKHVWKHPWDNLQJWLPHZLWKHDFKOHWWLQJWKHPNQRZKHLV
    WKHUH7KHZRUOGLVDOOULJKW
    ,UHDFKRXWWRKLPWRR0DNHVPHIHHOJRRG,ZDQWWREHOLNH%LJJHVW
    WREHELJEHDVELJDVKLPEHKLP
    )HPVGRQWJLYHKLPDQ\WURXEOH+HZDQWVRQHVKHJRHV+XPSULJKW
    DZD\+HV%LJJHVW
    0RVWPDOHVWKH\GRQWJHWPXFKUHVSHFW)HPVGRQWZDQWWRGRZLWKWKHP

    DVPXFKDVWKH\GRZLWK%LJJHVW7KHOLWWOHPDOHVWKH\KXIIDQGWKURZVDQG
    DQGDOOWKDWEXWHYHU\ERG\NQRZVWKH\UHQRWJRLQJWREHPXFK1RFKDQFHWKH\
    FRXOGHYHUEHOLNH%LJJHVW7KH\GRQWOLNHWKDWEXWWKH\DUHVWXFNZLWKLW
    0H,PSUHWW\ELJ,JHWUHVSHFW6RPHDQ\ZD\
    $OOWKHJX\VOLNHVWURNLQJ3HWWLQJ*URRPLQJ)HUQVJLYHLWWRWKHPDQG
    WKH\JLYHLWEDFN
    *X\VJHWPRUHWKRXJK$IWHULWWKH\UHQRWVRJUXII
    ,PVLWWLQJJHWWLQJJURRPHGDQGDOORIDVXGGHQ,VPHOOVRPHWKLQJ,
    GRQWOLNHLW,MXPSXSFU\RXW%LJJHVWKHWDNHVQRWLFH6PHOOVLWWRR
    6WUDQJHUV(YHU\ERG\VWDUWVKXJJLQJHDFKRWKHU6WURQJVPHOOSOHQW\RI
    LW/RWVRI6WUDQJHUV7KHZLQGVD\VWKH\DUHQHDUJHWWLQJQHDUHU
    7KH\FRPHUXQQLQJGRZQRQXVIURPWKHULGJH/RRNLQJIRUIHUQVORRNLQJ
    IRUWURXEOH
    ,UXQIRUP\URFNV,DOZD\VKDYHVRPHKDQG\,IOLQJRQHDWWKHPPLVV
    7KHQWKH\LQDPRQJXV,WVKDUGWRKLWWKHPWKH\JRVRIDVW
    )RXU6WUDQJHUVWKH\JUDEWZRIHUQV'UDJWKHPDZD\
    (YHU\ERG\KRZOLQJFU\LQJ'XVWHYHU\ZKHUH
    ,WKURZURFNV%LJJHVWOHDGVWKHJX\VDJDLQVWWKH6WUDQJHUV
    7KH\WXUQDQGUXQRII-XVWOLNHWKDW*RWWKHWZRIHUQVWKRXJKDQG
    WKDWVEDG
    %LJJHVWPDG+HSXVKHVDURXQGVRPHRIWKHJX\VPDNHVQRLVH+HQRW
    ORRNLQJVRJRRGQRZKHOHWWKH6WUDQJHUVLQ
    7KRVH6WUDQJHUVEDG:HDOOKXQNHUGRZQJURRPHDFKRWKHUSHWPDNH
    QLFHVRXQGV
    %LJJHVWKHFRPHE\VODSVRPHRIWKHIHUQV+XPSVRPH0DNHVXUH
    HYHU\ERG\NQRZKHVVWLOO%LJJHVW
    +HGRQWVODSPH+HNQRZEHWWHUWKDQWRWU\,JURZODWKLPZKHQKH
    FRPHFORVHDQGKHSUHWHQGQRWWRKHDU
    0D\EHKHQRWVR%LJDQ\PRUH,PWKLQNLQJ
    

    +HVWD\HGZLWKLWWKLVWLPH$IWHUWKHILUVWFULVLVZKHQWKH6WUDQJHU
    SDQVFDPHUXQQLQJWKURXJKKHVDWDQGOHWKLPVHOIJHWJURRPHGIRUDORQJWLPH
    ,WUHDOO\GLGFDOPKLP
    +LP":KRZDVKH"
    7KLVWLPHKHFRXOGIXOO\VHQVHWKHSDQPLQG1RWEHORZKLPWKDWZDVD
    PHWDSKRUEXWDURXQGKLP$VZDUPLQJVFDWWHUVKRWRIVHQVHVWKRXJKWV
    IUDJPHQWVOLNHOHDYHVEORZLQJE\KLPLQDZLQG
    $QGWKHZLQGZDVHPRWLRQ%OXVWHULQJJDOHVKRZOLQJDQGZKLSSLQJLQ
    JXVWVUDLQLQJWKRXJKWVOLNHVRIWKDPPHUEORZV
    7KHVHSDQVWKRXJKWSRRUO\LQWKHVHQVHWKDWKHFRXOGJHWRQO\VKDUGV
    OLNHKXPDQPXVLQJVFKRSSHGE\DQHUYRXVHGLWRU%XWSDQVIHOWLQWHQVHO\
    2IFRXUVHKHWKRXJKWDQGKHFRXOGWKLQNQHVWOHGLQWKHKDUGNHUQHORI
    KLPVHOIZUDSSHGLQWKHSDQPLQG(PRWLRQVWROGLWZKDWWRGRZLWKRXW
    WKLQNLQJ4XLFNUHDFWLRQVGHPDQGHGWKDW6WURQJIHHOLQJDPSOLILHGVXEWOHFXHV
    LQWRVWURQJLPSHUDWLYHV%OXQWRUGHUVIURP0RWKHU(YROXWLRQ
    +HVDZQRZWKDWWKHEHOLHIWKDWKLJKRUGHUPHQWDOH[SHULHQFHVOLNH
    HPRWLRQZHUHXQLTXHWRSHRSOHZDVVLPSO\FRQFHLWHG7KHVHSDQVVKDUHGPXFK
    RIWKHKXPDQZRUOGYLHZ$WKHRU\RISDQSV\FKRKLVWRU\FRXOGEHYDOXDEOH
    +HJLQJHUO\VHSDUDWHGKLPVHOIIURPWKHGHQVHSUHVVLQJSDQPLQG+H
    ZRQGHUHGLIWKHSDQNQHZKHZDVKHUH<HVLWGLGGLPO\
    <HWWKLVGLGQRWERWKHUWKHSDQ+HLQWHJUDWHGLWLQWRKLVEOXUUHG
    EOXQWZRUOG+DULZDVVRPHZKDWOLNHDQHPRWLRQMXVWRQHRI PDQ\IOXWWHULQJE\
    DQGVWD\LQJDZKLOHWKHQZDIWLQJDZD\
    &RXOGKHEHPRUHWKDQWKDW"+HWULHGJHWWLQJWKHSDQWROLIWLWVULJKW
    DUPDQGLWZDVOLNHOHDG+HVWUXJJOHGIRUDZKLOHWKDWZD\ZLWKQRVXFFHVV

    7KHQKHUHDOL]HGKLVHUURU+HFRXOGQRWRYHUSRZHUWKLVSDQQRWDVDNHUQHO
    LQDPXFKODUJHUPLQG
    +HWKRXJKWDERXWWKLVDVWKHSDQJURRPHGDIHPDOHSLFNLQJFDUHIXOO\
    WKURXJKFRDUVHKDLU7KHVWUDQGVVPHOOHGJRRGWKHDLUZDVVZHHWWKHVXQ
    VWURNHGKLPZLWKEODGHVRIJHQHURXVZDUPWK
    (PRWLRQ3DQVGLGQWIROORZLQVWUXFWLRQVEHFDXVHWKDWVLPSO\OD\EH\RQG
    WKHP7KH\FRXOGQRWXQGHUVWDQGGLUHFWLRQVLQWKHKXPDQVHQVH(PRWLRQVWKRVH
    WKH\NQHZ+HKDGWREHDQHPRWLRQQRWDOLWWOHJHQHUDOJLYLQJRUGHUV
    +HVDWIRUDZKLOHVLPSO\EHLQJ WKLVSDQ+HOHDUQHGRUUDWKHUKH
    IHOW7KHWURRSJURRPHGDQGVFDYHQJHGIRRGPDOHVH\HLQJWKHSHULPHWHU
    IHPDOHVNHHSLQJFORVHWRWKH\RXQJ$OD]\FDOPGHVFHQGHGRYHUKLPFDUU\LQJ
    KLPHIIRUWOHVVO\WKURXJKZDUPPRPHQWVRIWKHGD\
    1RWVLQFHER\KRRGKDGKHIHOWDQ\WKLQJOLNHWKLV$VORZJUDFHIXO
    HDVLQJDVWKRXJKWKHUHZHUHQRWLPHDWDOORQO\VOLFHVRIHWHUQLW\
    ,QWKLVPRRGKHFRXOGFRQFHQWUDWHRQDVLPSOHPRYHPHQWUDLVLQJDQDUP
    VFUDWFKLQJDQGFUHDWHWKHGHVLUHWRGRLW+LVSDQUHVSRQGHG 7RPDNHLW
    KDSSHQKHKDGWRIHHOKLVZD\WRZDUGDJRDO
    &DWFKLQJDVZHHWVFHQWRQWKHZLQG+DULWKRXJKWDERXWZKDWIRRGWKDW
    PLJKWVLJQDO+LVSDQPHDQGHUHGXSZLQGVQLIIHGGLVFDUGHGWKHFOXHDV
    XQLQWHUHVWLQJ+DULFRXOGQRZVPHOOWKHUHDVRQZK\IUXLWWUXHVZHHW\HV
    EXWLQHGLEOHIRUDSDQ
    *RRG+HZDVOHDUQLQJ$QGKHZDVLQWHJUDWLQJKLPVHOILQWRWKHGHHS
    UHFHVVHVRIWKLVSDQPLQG
    :DWFKLQJWKHWURRSKHGHFLGHGWRQDPHWKHSURPLQHQWSDQVWRNHHSWKHP
    VWUDLJKW$JLOHWKHTXLFNRQH6KHHODKWKHVH[\RQH*UXEEHUWKHKXQJU\
    RQH%XWZKDWZDVKLVRZQQDPH"+LVKHGXEEHG,SDQ1RWYHU\RULJLQDOEXW
    WKDWZDVLWVPDLQFKDUDFWHULVWLF,DVSDQ
    *UXEEHUIRXQGVRPHEXOEVKDSHGIUXLWDQGWKHRWKHUVGULIWHGRYHUWR
    VFDYHQJH7KHKDUGIUXLWVPHOOHGD OLWWOHWRR\RXQJ KRZGLGKHNQRZWKDW" 
    EXWVRPHDWHLWDQ\ZD\
    $QGZKLFKRIWKHVHZDV'RUV"7KH\KDGDVNHGWREHLPPHUVHGLQWKHVDPH
    WURRSVRRQHRIWKHVHKHIRUFHGKLPVHOIWRFRXQWWKRXJKVRPHKRZWKH
    H[HUFLVHZDVOLNHPRYLQJKHDY\ZHLJKWVLQKLV PLQGWKHVHWZHQW\WZRZDVKHU
    +RZFRXOGKHWHOO"+HDPEOHGRYHUWRVHYHUDOIHPDOHVZKRZHUHXVLQJVKDUS
    HGJHGVWRQHVWRFXWOHDYHVIURPEUDQFKHV7KH\WLHGWKHVWUDQGVWRJHWKHUVR
    WKH\FRXOGFDUU\IRRG
    +DULSHHUHGLQWRWKHLUIDFHV0LOGLQWHUHVWDIHZKDQGVKHOGRXWIRU
    VWURNLQJDQLQYLWDWLRQWRJURRP1RJOLQWRIUHFRJQLWLRQLQWKHLUH\HV
    +HZDWFKHGDELJIHUQ6KHHODKFDUHIXOO\ZDVKVDQGFRYHUHGIUXLWLQD
    FUHHN7KHWURRSIROORZHGVXLW6KHHODKZDVDOHDGHURIVRUWVDIHPDOH
    OLHXWHQDQWWR%LJJHVW
    6KHDWHZLWKUHOLVKORRNHGDURXQG7KHUHZDVJUDLQJURZLQJQHDUE\SDVW
    PDWXULW\ULSHWDQNHUQHOVDOUHDG\VFDWWHUHGLQWKHVDQG\VRLO&RQFHQWUDWLQJ
    +DULFRXOGWHOOIURPWKHIDLQWERXTXHWWKDWWKLVZDVDGHOLFDF\$IHZSDQV
    VTXDWWHGDQGSLFNHG JUDLQVIURPWKHVDQGVORZZRUN6KHHODKGLGWKHVDPHDQG
    WKHQVWRSSHGJD]LQJRIIDWWKHFUHHN7LPHSDVVHGLQVHFWVEX]]HG$IWHUD
    ZKLOHVKHVFRRSHGXSVDQGDQGNHUQHOVDQGZDONHGWRWKHEURRNVHGJH6KH
    WRVVHGLWDOOLQ7KHVDQGVDQNWKHNHUQHOVIORDWHG6KHVNLPPHGWKHPRIIDQG
    JXOSHGWKHPGRZQJULQQLQJZLGHO\
    $QLPSUHVVLYHWULFN7KHRWKHUSDQVGLGQRWSLFNXSRQKHUNHUQHO
    VNLPPLQJPHWKRG)UXLWZDVKLQJZDVFRQFHSWXDOO\HDVLHUKHVXSSRVHGVLQFHWKH
    SDQFRXOGNHHSWKHIUXLWWKHZKROHWLPH.HUQHOVNLPPLQJGHPDQGHGWKURZLQJ
    DZD\WKHIRRGILUVWWKHQUHVFXLQJLWDKDUGHUPHQWDOMXPS
    +HWKRXJKWDERXWKHUDQGLQUHVSRQVH,SDQVDXQWHUHGRYHUKHUZD\+H
    SHHUHGLQWR6KHHODKVH\HVDQGVKHZLQNHGDWKLP'RUV+HZUDSSHGKDLU\DUPV
    DURXQGKHULQDEXUVWRIORYH

    

    3XUHDQLPDOORYHVKHVDLGRYHUGLQQHU5HIUHVKLQJ
    +DULQRGGHG,OLNHEHLQJWKHUHOLYLQJWKDWZD\
    ,FDQVPHOOVRPXFKPRUH
    )UXLWWDVWHVGLIIHUHQWO\ZKHQWKH\ELWHLQWRLW+HKHOGXSDSXUSOH
    EXOEVOLFHGLQWR LWIRUNHGLWLQWRKLVPRXWK7RPHWKLVLVDOPRVW
    XQEHDUDEO\VZHHW7R,SDQLWVSOHDVDQWDOLWWOHSHSSHU\,VXSSRVHSDQV
    KDYHEHHQVHOHFWHGIRUDVZHHWWRRWK,WJHWVWKHPPRUHIDVWFDORULHV
    ,FDQWWKLQNRIDPRUHWKRURXJKYDFDWLRQ1RWMXVWJHWWLQJDZD\IURP
    KRPHEXWJHWWLQJDZD\IURP\RXUVSHFLHV
    +HH\HGWKHIUXLW$QGWKH\UHVRVR
    +RUQ\"
    ,QVDWLDEOH
    <RXGLGQWVHHPWRPLQG
    0\SDQ,SDQ",EDLORXWZKHQKHJHWVLQWRKLVKXPSWKHPDOOPRRG
    6KHH\HGKLP5HDOO\"
    'RQW\RXEDLORXW"
    <HVEXW,GRQWH[SHFWPHQWREHOLNHZRPHQ
    2K"KHVDLGVWLIIO\
    ,YHEHHQUHDGLQJLQWKH([6SHFVUHVHDUFKOLEUDU\ZKLOH\RXWR\ZLWK
    SDQVRFLDOPRYHPHQWV:RPHQLQYHVWKHDYLO\LQWKHLUFKLOGUHQ0HQFDQXVHWZR
    VWUDWHJLHVSDUHQWDOLQYHVWPHQWSOXVVRZWKHRDWV6KHOLIWHGDQH\HEURZ
    %RWKPXVWKDYHEHHQVHOHFWHGIRULQRXUHYROXWLRQEHFDXVHWKH\UHERWK
    FRPPRQ
    1RWZLWKPH
    7RKLVVXUSULVHVKHODXJKHG,PWDONLQJLQJHQHUDO0\SRLQWLVWKH
    SDQVDUHPXFKPRUHSURPLVFXRXVWKDQZHDUH7KHPDOHVUXQHYHU\WKLQJ7KH\
    KHOSRXWWKHIHPDOHVZKRDUHFDUU\LQJWKHLUFKLOGUHQ,JDWKHUEXWWKHQWKH\
    VKRSDURXQGHOVHZKHUHDOOWKHWLPH
    +DULVZLWFKHGLQWRKLVSURIHVVLRQDOPRGHLWZDVGHFLGHGO\PRUH
    FRPIRUWDEOHZKHQGHDOLQJZLWKVXFKLVVXHV$VWKHVSHFLDOLVWVVD\WKH\DUH
    SXUVXLQJDPL[HGUHSURGXFWLYHVWUDWHJ\
    +RZSROLWH
    3ROLWHSOXVSUHFLVH
    2IFRXUVHKHFRXOGQWUHDOO\EHVXUH'RUVEDLOHGRXWRI6KHHODKZKHQD
    PDOHFDPHE\IRUDTXLFNRQH 7KH\ZHUHDOZD\VTXLFNWRRWKLUW\VHFRQGVRU
    OHVV &RXOGVKHH[LWWKHSDQPLQGWKDWTXLFNO\"+HUHTXLUHGDIHZPRPHQWVWR
    H[WULFDWHKLPVHOI2IFRXUVHLIVKHVDZWKHPDOHFRPLQJJXHVVHGKLV
    LQWHQWLRQV
    +HZDVVXUSULVHGDWKLPVHOI:KDWUROHGLGMHDORXV\KDYHZKHQWKH\ZHUH
    LQKDELWLQJRWKHUERGLHV"'LGWKHXVXDOPRUDOFRGHPDNHDQ\VHQVH"<HWWRWDON
    WKLVRYHUZLWKKHUZDVHPEDUUDVVLQJ
    +HZDVVWLOOWKHFRXQWU\ER\IURP+HOLFRQOLNHLWRUQRW
    5XHIXOO\KHFRQFHQWUDWHGRQKLVPHDORIORFDOURDPHUIOHLVFKZKLFK
    WXUQHGRXWWREHDQHDUWK\GDUNPHDWLQDVWHZRIWDQJ\YHJHWDEOHV+HDWH
    KHDUWLO\DQGLQUHVSRQVHWR'RUVUDWKHUREYLRXVO\DPXVHGVLOHQFHVDLG,G
    SRLQWRXWWKDWSDQVXQGHUVWDQGFRPPHUFHWRR)RRGIRUVH[EHWUD\DORIWKH
    OHDGHUIRUVH[VSDUHP\FKLOGIRUVH[JURRPLQJIRUVH[MXVWDERXWDQ\WKLQJ
    IRUVH[
    ,WGRHVVHHPWREHWKHLUVRFLDOFXUUHQF\6KRUWDQGGHFLGHGO\QRW
    VZHHW-XVWTXLFNOXQJHVVWURQJVHQVDWLRQVWKHQERRPLWVRYHU
    7KHPDOHVQHHGLWWKHIHPDOHVXVHLW
    8PPP\RXYHEHHQWDNLQJQRWHV
    ,I,PJRLQJWRPRGHOSDQVDVDVRUWRIVLPSOLILHGSHRSOHWKHQ,
    PXVW
    0RGHOSDQV"FDPHWKHDVVXUHGWRQHVRI([6SHF9DGGR7KH\UHQRW

    PRGHOFLWL]HQVLIWKDWVZKDW\RXPHDQ+HJDYHWKHPDVXQQ\VPLOHDQG+DUL
    JXHVVHGWKLVZDVPRUHRIWKHREOLJDWRU\IULHQGOLQHVVRIWKLVSODFH
    +DULVPLOHGPHFKDQLFDOO\,PWU\LQJWRILQGWKHYDULDEOHVWKDWFRXOG
    GHVFULEHSDQEHKDYLRU
    <RXVKRXOGVSHQGDORWRIWLPHZLWKWKHP9DGGRVDLGVLWWLQJDWWKH
    WDEOHDQGKROGLQJXSDILQJHUWRDZDLWHUIRUDGULQN7KH\UHVXEWOH
    FUHDWXUHV
    ,DJUHHVDLG'RUV'R\RXULGHWKHPYHU\PXFK"
    6RPHEXWPRVWRIRXUUHVHDUFKLVGRQHGLIIHUHQWO\QRZ9DGGRVPRXWK
    WZLVWHGUXHIXOO\6WDWLVWLFDOPRGHOVWKDWVRUWRIWKLQJ,JRWWKLVWRXULQJ
    LGHDVWDUWHGXVLQJWKHLPPHUVLRQWHFKZHKDGGHYHORSHGHDUOLHUWRPDNHPRQH\
    IRUWKHSURMHFW2WKHUZLVHZHG KDYHKDGWRFORVH
    ,PKDSS\WRFRQWULEXWH+DULVDLG
    $GPLWLW\RXOLNHLW'RUVVDLGDPXVHG:HOO\HV
    ,WVGLIIHUHQW
    $QGJRRGIRUWKHVWDLG3URIHVVRU6HOGRQWRJHWRXWRIKLVVKHOOVKH
    VDLG
    9DGGREHDPHG%HVXUH\RXGRQWWDNH FKDQFHVRXWWKHUH6RPHRIRXU
    FXVWRPHUVWKLQNWKH\UHVXSHUSDQVRUVRPHWKLQJ
    'RUVH\HVIOLFNHUHG:KDWGDQJHULVWKHUH"2XUERGLHVDUHLQVORZWLPH
    EDFNKHUH
    9DGGRVDLG<RXUHVWURQJO\OLQNHG$ELJVKRFNWRDSDQFDQGULYHD
    EDFNVKRFNLQ\RXURZQQHXURORJLFDOV\VWHPV
    :KDWVRUWRIVKRFN"+DULDVNHG
    'HDWKPDMRULQMXU\
    ,QWKDWFDVH'RUVVDLGWR+DUL,UHDOO\GRQRWWKLQN\RXVKRXOG
    LPPHUVH
    +DULIHOWLUNHG&RPHRQ,PRQYDFDWLRQQRWLQSULVRQ
    $Q\WKUHDWWR\RX
    -XVWDPLQXWHDJR\RXZHUHUKDSVRGL]LQJDERXWKRZJRRGIRUPHLWZDV
    <RXUHWRRLPSRUWDQWWR
    7KHUHVUHDOO\YHU\OLWWOHGDQJHU9DGGRFDPHLQVPRRWKO\3DQVGRQW
    GLHVXGGHQO\XVXDOO\
    $QG,FDQEDLORXWZKHQ,VHHGDQJHUFRPLQJ+DULDGGHG
    %XWZLOO\RX",WKLQN\RXUHJHWWLQJDWDVWHIRUDGYHQWXUH
    6KHZDVULJKWEXWKHZDVQWJRLQJWRFRQFHGHWKHSRLQW,IKHZDQWHGD
    OLWWOHHVFDSHIURPKLVKXPGUXPPDWKHPDWLFLDQVURXWLQHVRPXFKWKHEHWWHU,
    OLNHEHLQJRXWRI7UDQWRUVHQGOHVVFRUULGRUV
    9DGGRJDYH'RUVDFRQILGHQWVPLOH$QGZHKDYHQWORVWDWRXULVW\HW
    +RZDERXWUHVHDUFKVWDII"VKHVKRWEDFN
    :HOOWKDWZDVDPRVWXQXVXDO
    :KDWKDSSHQHG"
    $SDQIHOORIIDOHGJH7KHKXPDQRSHUDWRUFRXOGQWEDLORXWLQ WLPHDQG
    VKHFDPHRXWRILWSDUDO\]HG7KHVKRFNRIH[SHULHQFLQJGHDWKWKURXJK
    LPPHUVLRQLVNQRZQIURPRWKHULQFLGHQWVWRSURYHIDWDO%XWZHKDYHV\VWHPVLQ
    SODFHQRZWRVKRUWFLUFXLW
    :KDWHOVH"VKHSHUVLVWHG
    :HOOWKHUHZDVRQHGLIILFXOWHSLVRGH,QWKHHDUO\GD\VZKHQZHKDG
    VLPSOHZLUHIHQFHV7KH([6SHFVKLIWHGXQHDVLO\6RPHSUHGDWRUVJRWLQ
    :KDWVRUWRISUHGDWRUV"
    $SULPDWHSDFNKXQWHU&DUQRSDSLRJUDQGLV:HFDOOWKHPUDERRQV
    EHFDXVHWKH\UHJHQHWLFDOO\UHODWHGWRDVPDOOSULPDWHRQDQRWKHUFRQWLQHQW
    7KHLU'1$
    +RZGLGWKH\JHWLQ"'RUVLQVLVWHG
    7KH\UHVRPHZKDWOLNHDZLOGKRJZLWKKRRYHVWKDWGRXEOHDVGLJJHUV
    7KH\VPHOOHGJDPHRXUFRUUDOOHGDQLPDOV'XJXQGHUWKHIHQFHV
    'RUVH\HGWKHKLJKVROLGZDOOV7KHVHDUHDGHTXDWH"

    &HUWDLQO\5DERRQVVKDUH'1$ZLWKWKHSDQVDQGZHEHOLHYHWKH\UHIURP
    DQDQFLHQWJHQHWLFH[SHULPHQW6RPHRQHWULHGWRPDNHDSUHGDWRUE\UDLVLQJWKH
    HDUOLHUVWRFNXSRQWRWZROHJV/LNHPRVWELSHGDOSUHGDWRUVWKHIRUHOLPEVDUH
    VKRUWHQHGDQGWKHKHDGFDUULHGIRUZDUGEDODQFHGE\DWKLFNWDLOWKH\XVHIRU
    VLJQDOLQJWRHDFKRWKHU7KH\SUH\RQWKHELJJHVWKHUGDQLPDOVWKH
    JLJDQWHORSHHDWLQJRQO\WKHULFKHVWPHDW
    :K\DWWDFNKXPDQV"
    7KH\WDNHWDUJHWVRIRSSRUWXQLW\WRR3DQVHYHQ:KHQWKH\JRWLQWR
    WKHFRPSRXQGWKH\ZHQWIRUDGXOWKXPDQVQRWFKLOGUHQDYHU\VHOHFWLYH
    VWUDWHJ\
    'RUVVKLYHUHG<RXORRNDWDOOWKLVYHU\REMHFWLYHO\
    ,PDELRORJLVW
    ,QHYHUNQHZLWFRXOGEHVRLQWHUHVWLQJ +DULVDLGWRGHIXVHKHU
    DSSUHKHQVLRQ
    9DGGREHDPHG1RWDVLQYROYLQJDVKLJKHUPDWKHPDWLFV,PVXUH
    'RUVPRXWKWZLVWHGZLWKZU\VNHSWLFLVP'R\RXPLQGLIJXHVWVFDUU\
    ZHDSRQVLQVLGHWKHFRPSRXQG"
    

    +HKDGDJOLPPHULQJRIDQLGHDDERXWWKH SDQVDZD\WRXVHWKHLU
    EHKDYLRUVLQEXLOGLQJDVLPSOHWR\PRGHORISV\FKRKLVWRU\+HPLJKWEHDEOHWR
    XVHWKHVWDWLVWLFVRISDQWURRSPRYHPHQWVWKHXSVDQGGRZQVRIWKHLUVKLIWLQJ
    IRUWXQHV
    3LFWXUHGLQV\VWHPVSDFHOLYLQJVWUXFWXUHVZRUNHGDWWKHHGJHRID
    FKDRWLFWHUUDLQ/LIHDVDZKROHKDUYHVWHGWKHIUXLWVRIDODUJHPHQXRI
    SRVVLEOHSDWKFKRLFHV1DWXUDOVHOHFWLRQILUVWDFKLHYHGWKHQVXVWDLQHGWKLV
    HGJ\VWDWH
    :KROHELRVSKHUHVVKLIWHGWKHLUHTXLOLEULXPSRLQWVDPLGHQHUJHWLF
    IORZWKURXJKOLNHELUGVEDQNLQJRQZLQGVKHWKRXJKWZDWFKLQJVRPHELJ\HOORZ
    RQHVJOLGHRYHUWKHVWDWLRQWDNLQJDGYDQWDJHRIWKHXSGUDIWV
    /LNHWKHPZKROHELRORJLFDOV\VWHPVVRPHWLPHVKRYHUHGDWVWDJQDWLRQ
    SRLQWV6\VWHPVZHUHDEOHWRFKRRVHVHYHUDOSDWKVRIGHVFHQW6RPHWLPHVWR
    VWUHWFKWKHDQDORJ\WKH\FRXOGHDWWKHWDVW\LQVHFWVZKLFKFDPHXSWRWKHPRQ
    WKRVHVDPHWULFN\EUHH]HV
    )DLOXUHWRQHJRWLDWHVXFKZLQGVRIFKDQJHPHDQWWKHSDWWHUQIRUIHLWHG
    LWVV\VWHPLFLQWHJULW\(QHUJLHVGLVVLSDWHG&UXFLDOZDVWKHIDFW WKDWDQ\
    VHHPLQJO\VWDEOHVWDWHZDVDFWXDOO\DWULFNRIG\QDPLFIHHGEDFN
    1RVWDWLFVWDWHH[LVWHGH[FHSWRQH$ELRORJLFDOV\VWHPDWSHUIHFW
    HTXLOLEULXPZDVVLPSO\GHDG
    6RWRRSV\FKRKLVWRU\"
    +HWDONHGLWRYHUZLWK'RUVDQGVKHQRGGHG%HQHDWKKHUDSSDUHQWFDOP
    VKHZDVZRUULHG6LQFH9DGGRVUHPDUNVKHZDVDOZD\VWXWWXWWLQJDERXWVDIHW\
    +HUHPLQGHGKHUWKDWVKHKDGHDUOLHUXUJHGKLPWRGRPRUHLPPHUVLRQV7KLVLV
    DYDFDWLRQUHPHPEHU"KHVDLGPRUHWKDQRQFH
    +HUDPXVHGVLGHZLVHJODQFHVWROGKLPWKDWVKHDOVRGLGQWEX\KLVWDON
    DERXWWKHWR\PRGHOLQJ6KHWKRXJKWKHMXVWOLNHGURPSLQJLQWKHZRRGV$
    FRXQWU\ER\DWKHDUWVKHFKXFNOHG
    6RWKHQH[WPRUQLQJKHVNLSSHGDSODQQHGWUHNWRYLHZWKHJLJDQWHORSH
    KHUGV,PPHGLDWHO\KHDQG'RUVZHQWWRWKHLPPHUVLRQFKDPEHUVDQGVOLSSHG
    XQGHU7RJHWVRPHVROLGZRUNGRQHKHWROGKLPVHOI
    :KDWVWKLV"+HJHVWXUHGWRDVPDOOWLNWRNVWDWLRQHGEHWZHHQWKHLU
    LPPHUVLRQSRGV
    3UHFDXWLRQ'RUVVDLG,GRQWZDQWDQ\RQHWDPSHULQJZLWKRXU
    FKDPEHUVZKLOHZHUHXQGHU
    7LNWRNVFRVWSOHQW\RXWKHUH
    7KLVRQHJXDUGVWKHFRGHGORFNVVHH"6KHFURXFKHGEHVLGHWKHWLNWRN

    DQGUHDFKHGIRUWKHFRQWUROSDQHO,WEORFNHGKHU
    ,WKRXJKWWKHORFNVZHUHHQRXJK
    7KHVHFXULW\FKLHIKDVDFFHVVWRWKRVH
    $QG\RXVXVSHFWKHU"
    ,VXVSHFWHYHU\RQH%XWHVSHFLDOO\KHU

    7KHSDQVVOHSWLQWUHHVDQGVSHQWSOHQW\RIWLPHJURRPLQJHDFKRWKHU
    )RUWKHOXFN\JURRPHUDWLFNRUORXVHZDVDWUHDW:LWKHQRXJKWKH\FRXOGJHW
    KLJKRQVRPHSHSSHU\WDVWLQJDONDORLG+HVXVSHFWHGWKHFDUHIXOVWURNLQJDQG
    FRPELQJRIKLVKDLUE\'RUVZDVDEHKDYLRUVHOHFWHGEHFDXVHLWLPSURYHGSDQ
    K\JLHQH,WFHUWDLQO\FDOPHG,SDQDOVR
    7KHQLWVWUXFNKLPSDQVJURRPHGUDWKHUWKDQYRFDOL]LQJ2QO\LQFULVHV
    DQGZKHQDJLWDWHGGLG WKH\FDOODQGFU\PRVWO\DERXWEUHHGLQJIHHGLQJRU
    VHOIGHIHQVH7KH\ZHUHOLNHSHRSOHZKRFRXOGQRWUHOHDVHWKHPVHOYHVWKURXJK
    WKHFRPIRUWRIWDON
    $QGWKH\QHHGHGFRPIRUW7KHFRUHRIWKHLUVRFLDOOLIHUHVHPEOHGKXPDQ
    VRFLHWLHVXQGHUVWUHVVLQW\UDQQLHVLQSULVRQVLQFLW\JDQJV1DWXUHUHGLQ
    WRRWKDQGFODZ\HWVWULNLQJO\OLNHWURXEOHGSHRSOH
    %XWWKHUHZHUHFLYLOL]HG EHKDYLRUVKHUHWRR)ULHQGVKLSVJULHI
    VKDULQJEXGGLHVLQDUPVZKRKXQWHGDQGJXDUGHGWXUIWRJHWKHU7KHLUROGJRW
    ZULQNOHGEDOGDQGWRRWKOHVV\HWZHUHVWLOOFDUHGIRU
    7KHLULQVWLQFWLYHNQRZOHGJHZDVSURGLJLRXV7KH\NQHZKRZWRPDNHDEHG
    RIOHDYHVDVGXVNIHOOKLJKXSLQWUHHV7KH\FRXOGFOLPEZLWKJUDVSLQJIHHW
    7KH\IHOWFULHGPRXUQHGZLWKRXWEHLQJDEOHWRSDUVHWKHVHLQWRQHDW
    JUDPPDWLFDOSDFNDJHVVRWKHHPRWLRQVFRXOGEHPDQDJHGVXEGXHG,QVWHDG
    HPRWLRQVGURYHWKHP
    +XQJHUZDVWKHVWURQJHVW7KH\IRXQGDQGDWHOHDYHVIUXLWLQVHFWV
    HYHQIDLUVL]HGDQLPDOV7KH\ORYHGFDWHUSLOODUV
    (DFKPRPHQWHDFKVPDOOHQOLJKWHQPHQWVDQNKLPGHHSHULQWR,SDQ+H
    EHJDQWRVHQVHWKHVXEWOHQRRNVDQGFUDQQLHVRIWKHSDQPLQG6ORZO\KH
    JDLQHGPRUHFRRSHUDWLYHFRQWURO
    7KDWPRUQLQJDIHPDOHIRXQGDELJIDOOHQWUHHDQGEHJDQEDQJLQJRQLW
    7KHKROORZWUXQNERRPHGOLNHDGUXPDQGDOOWKHIRUDJLQJSDUW\UXVKHGIRUZDUG
    WREHDWLWWRRJULQQLQJZLOGO\DWWKHQRLVH
    ,SDQMRLQHGLQ+DULIHOWWKHEXUVWRIMR\VHHWKHGLQLW
    /DWHUFRPLQJXSRQDZDWHUIDOODIWHUDKHDY\UDLQWKH\VHL]HGYLQHVDQG
    VZXQJDPRQJWUHHVRXWRYHUWKHIRDPLQJZDWHUVFUHHFKLQJZLWKGHOLJKWDVWKH\
    SHUIRUPHGWZLVWVDQGOHDSVIURPYLQHWRYLQH
    7KH\ZHUHOLNHFKLOGUHQLQ DQHZSOD\JURXQG+DULJRW,SDQWRPDNH
    LPSRVVLEOHPRYHVZLOGWXPEOHVDQGGLYHVSURSHOOLQJKLPIRUZDUGZLWKDEDQGRQ
    WRWKHDVWRQLVKPHQWRIWKHRWKHUSDQV
    7KH\ZHUHYLROHQWLQWKHLUVXGGHQSHHYLVKPRPHQWVLQKXVWOLQJIHPDOHV
    LQZRUNLQJRXWWKHLUSHUSHWXDOGRPLQDQFHKLHUDUFK\DQGHVSHFLDOO\LQKXQWLQJ
    $VXFFHVVIXOKXQWEURXJKWHQRUPRXVH[FLWHPHQWKXJJLQJNLVVLQJSDWV$VWKH
    WURRSGHVFHQGHGWRIHHGWKHIRUHVWUDQJZLWKEDUNVVFUHHFKHVKRRWVDQG
    SDQWV+DULMRLQHGWKHWXPXOWGDQFHGZLWK6KHHODK'RUV
    +HKDGH[SHFWHGWRKDYHWRUHSUHVVKLVSULPPHULWRFUDWGLVOLNHRIPHVV
    0DQ\PHULWRFUDWVHYHQGLVOLNHGVRLOLWVHOI1RW+DULZKRKDGEHHQUHDUHG
    DPRQJIDUPHUVDQGODERUHUV6WLOOKHKDGWKRXJKWWKDWORQJH[SRVXUHWR
    7UDQWRUVSULVV\DHVWKHWLFVZRXOGKDPSHUKLPKHUH,QVWHDGWKHSDQVILOWK
    VHHPHGQDWXUDO
    ,QVRPHPDWWHUVKHGLGKDYHWRUHVWUDLQKLVIHHOLQJV5DWVWKHSDQVDWH
    KHDGILUVW/DUJHUJDPHWKH\VPDVKHGDJDLQVWURFNV7KH\GHYRXUHGWKHEUDLQV
    ILUVWDVWHDPLQJGHOLFDF\
    +DULJXOSHGPHWDSKRULFDOO\EXWZLWK,SDQHFKRLQJWKHLPSXOVHDQG
    ZDWFKHGVFUHHQLQJKLVUHOXFWDQFH,SDQKDGWRHDWDIWHUDOO
    $WWKHVFHQWRISUHGDWRUVKHIHOW,SDQVKDLUVWDQGRQHQG$QRWKHU

    WDQJ\ERXTXHWPDGH,SDQVPRXWKZDWHU+HJDYHQRPHUF\WRIRRGHYHQLILW
    ZDVVWLOOZDONLQJ(YROXWLRQLQDFWLRQWKRVHSDQVZKRKDGVKRZHGPHUF\LQWKH
    SDVWDWHOHVVDQGOHIWIHZHUGHVFHQGDQWV7KRVHZHUHQWUHSUHVHQWHGKHUH
    DQ\PRUH
    )RUDOOLWVH[FHVVHVKHIRXQGWKHSDQVEHKDYLRUKDXQWLQJO\IDPLOLDU
    0DOHVJDWKHUHGRIWHQIRUFRPEDWIRUSLWFKLQJURFNVIRUEORRGVSRUWVWRZRUN
    RXWWKHLUKLHUDUFK\)HPDOHVQHWZRUNHGDQGIRUPHGDOOLDQFHV7KHUHZHUHWUDGHV
    RIIDYRUVIRUOR\DOW\NLQVKLSERQGVWXUIZDUVWKUHDWVDQGGLVSOD\V
    SURWHFWLRQUDFNHWVDKXQJHUIRUUHVSHFWVFKHPLQJVXERUGLQDWHVUHYHQJHD
    VRFLDOZRUOGHQMR\HGE\PDQ\SHRSOHWKDWKLVWRU\KDGMXGJHGJUHDW
    0XFKOLNHWKH(PSHURUVFRXUWLQIDFW
    'LGSHRSOHORQJWRVWULSDZD\WKHLUFORWKLQJDQGFRQYHQWLRQVEXUVWLQJ
    IRUWKDVSDQV"$EUDLQ\SDQZRXOGEHTXLWHDWKRPHLQWKH,PSHULDOJHQWU\
    +DULIHOWDIOXVKRIUHYXOVLRQVRVWURQJ,SDQVKRRNDQGILGJHWHG
    +XPDQLW\VORWKDGWREHGLIIHUHQWQRWWKLVSULPLWLYHKRUURU
    +HFRXOGXVHWKLVFHUWDLQO\DVDWHVWEHGIRUDIXOOWKHRU\7KHQ
    KXPDQNLQGZRXOGEHVHOINQRZLQJFDSWDLQVRIWKHPVHOYHV+HZRXOGEXLOGLQWKH
    LPSHUDWLYHVRIWKHSDQVEXWJRIDUEH\RQGWRWUXHGHHSSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    

    ,GRQWVHHLW'RUVVDLGDWGLQQHU
    %XWWKH\UHVRPXFKOLNHXV:HPXVWKDYHVKDUHGVRPHFRQQHFWLRQV+H
    SXWGRZQKLVVSRRQ,ZRQGHULIWKH\ZHUHKRXVHSHWVRIRXUVORQJEHIRUH
    VWDUWUDYHO"
    ,ZRXOGQWKDYHWKHPPHVVLQJXSP\KRXVH
    $GXOWKXPDQVZHLJKHGOLWWOHPRUHWKDQSDQVEXWZHUHIDUZHDNHU$SDQ
    FRXOGOLIWILYHWLPHVPRUHWKDQDZHOOFRQGLWLRQHGPDQ+XPDQEUDLQVZHUH
    WKUHHRUIRXUWLPHVPRUHPDVVLYHWKDQDSDQV$KXPDQEDE\DIHZPRQWKVROG
    DOUHDG\KDGDEUDLQODUJHUWKDQDJURZQSDQ3HRSOHKDGGLIIHUHQWEUDLQ
    DUFKLWHFWXUHDVZHOO
    %XWZDVWKDWWKHZKROHVWRU\"+DULZRQGHUHG
    *LYHSDQVELJJHUEUDLQVDQGVSHHFKHDVHRIIRQWKHWHVWRVWHURQHVDGGOH
    WKHPZLWKPRUHLQKLELWLRQVVSUXFHWKHPXSZLWKDVKDYHDQGDKDLUFXWWHDFK
    WKHPWRVWDQGVHFXUHO\RQKLQGOHJVDQG\RXKDGGHOX[HPRGHOSDQVWKDWZRXOG
    ORRNDQGDFWUDWKHUKXPDQ
    /RRNKHVDLGWR'RUVP\SRLQWLVWKDWWKH\UHFORVHHQRXJKWRXVWR
    PDNHDSV\FKRKLVWRU\PRGHOZRUN
    7RPDNHDQ\ERG\EHOLHYHWKDW\RXOOKDYHWRVKRZWKDWWKH\UH
    LQWHOOLJHQWHQRXJKWRKDYHLQWULFDWHLQWHUDFWLRQV
    :KDWDERXWWKHLUIRUDJLQJWKHLUKXQWLQJ"KHSHUVLVWHG
    9DGGRVD\VWKH\FRXOGQWHYHQEHWUDLQHGWRGRZRUNDURXQGWKLV
    ([FXUVLRQ6WDWLRQ
    ,//VKRZ\RXZKDW,PHDQ/HWVPDVWHUWKHLUPHWKRGVWRJHWKHU
    :KDWPHWKRG"
    7KHEDVLFRQH*HWWLQJHQRXJKWRHDW
    6KHELWLQWRDVWHDNRIDPHDW\ORFDOJUD]HUVXLWDEO\SURFHVVHGDQG
    IDWIOHQVHGIRUWKHIDVWLGLRXVXUEDQSDODWHDVWKHEURFKXUHKDGLW&KHZLQJ
    ZLWKXQXVXDOIHURFLW\VKHH\HGKLP<RXUHRQ$Q\WKLQJDSDQFDQGR,FDQ
    GREHWWHU

    'RUVZDYHGDWKLPIURPZLWKLQ6KHHODK/HWWKHFRQWHVWEHJLQ
    7KHWURRSZDVIRUDJLQJ+HOHW,SDQPHDQGHUDQGGLGQRWWU\WRKDUQHVV
    WKHHPRWLRQDOULSSOHVWKDWODSSHGDFURVVWKHSDQPLQG+HKDGJRWWHQEHWWHUDW
    LWEXWDWDVXGGHQVPHOORUVRXQGKHFRXOGORVHKLVJULS$QGJXLGLQJWKH
    EOXQWSDQPLQGWKURXJKDQ\WKLQJFRPSOLFDWHGZDVVWLOOOLNHPRYLQJDSXSSHW
    ZLWKUXEEHUVWULQJV

    6KHHODK'RUVZDYHGDQGVLJQHGWRKLP7KLVZD\
    7KH\KDGZRUNHGRXWDFRGHRIDIHZKXQGUHGZRUGVXVLQJILQJHUDQG
    IDFLDOJHVWXUHVDQGWKHLUSDQVVHHPHGWRJRDORQJZLWKWKHVHIDLUO\ZHOO
    3DQVKDGDURXJKODQJXDJHPL[LQJJUXQWVDQGVKUXJVDQGILQJHUGLVSOD\V7KHVH
    FRQYH\HGLPPHGLDWHPHDQLQJVEXWQRWLQWKHXVXDOVHQVHRIVHQWHQFHV0RVWO\
    WKH\MXVWVHWXSDVVRFLDWLRQV
    7UHHIUXLWJR'RUVVHQW7KH\DPEOHGWKHLUSDQVRYHUWRDFOXPSRI
    SURPLVLQJVSLQGO\WUXQNVEXWWKHEDUNZDVWRRVOLFNWRFOLPE
    7KHUHVWRIWKHWURRSKDGQRWHYHQERWKHUHG7KH\KDYHIRUHVWVPDUWVZH
    ODFN+DULWKRXJKWUXHIXOO\
    :KDWWKHUH"KHVLJQHGWR6KHHODK'RUV
    3DQVDPEOHGXSWRPRXQGVJDYHWKHPWKHRQFHRYHUDQGUHDFKHGRXWWR
    EUXVKDVLGHVRPHPXGUHYHDOLQJDWLQ\WXQQHO7HUPLWHV'RUVVLJQHG
    +DULDQDO\]HGWKHVLWXDWLRQDVSDQVGULIWHGLQ1RERG\VHHPHGLQPXFKRI
    DKXUU\6KHHODKZLQNHGDWKLPDQGZDGGOHGRYHUWRDGLVWDQWPRXQG
    $SSDUHQWO\WHUPLWHVZRUNHGRXWVLGHDWQLJKWWKHQEORFNHGWKHHQWUDQFHV
    DWGDZQ+DULOHWKLVSDQVKXIIOHRYHUWRDODUJHWDQPRXQGEXWKHZDVULGLQJ
    LWVRZHOOQRZWKDWWKHSDQVUHVSRQVHVZHUHZHDN+DUL,SDQORRNHGIRU
    FUDFNVNQREVVOLJKWKROORZVDQGZKHQKHEUXVKHGDZD\VRPHPXGIRXQG
    QRWKLQJ2WKHUSDQVUHDGLO\XQPDVNHGWXQQHOV+DGWKH\PHPRUL]HGWKHKXQGUHG
    RUPRUHWXQQHOVLQHDFKPRXQG"
    +HILQDOO\XQFRYHUHGRQH,SDQZDVQRKHOS+DULFRXOGFRQWUROEXWWKDW
    EORFNHGXSWKHZHOOVSULQJVRIGHHSNQRZOHGJHZLWKLQWKHSDQ
    7KHSDQVGHIWO\WRUHRIIWZLJVRUJUDVVVWDONVQHDUWKHLUPRXQGV+DUL
    FDUHIXOO\IROORZHGWKHLUOHDG+LVWZLJVDQGJUDVVGLGQWZRUN7KHILUVWORW
    ZDVWRRSOLDQWDQGZKHQ KHWULHGWRZRUNWKHPLQWRDWZLVWLQJWXQQHOWKH\
    FROODSVHGDQGEXFNOHG+HVZLWFKHGWRVWLIIHURQHVEXWWKRVHFDXJKWRQWKH
    WXQQHOZDOOVRUVQDSSHGRII)URP,SDQFDPHOLWWOHKHOS+DULKDGPDQDJHGKLP
    DELWWRRZHOO
    +HZDVJHWWLQJHPEDUUDVVHG(YHQWKH\RXQJHUSDQVKDGQRWURXEOHSLFNLQJ
    MXVWWKHULJKWVWHPVRUVWLFNV+DULZDWFKHGDSDQQHDUE\GURSDVWLFNWKDW
    VHHPHGWRZRUN+HWKHQSLFNHGLWXSZKHQWKHSDQPRYHGRQ+HIHOWZHOOLQJXS
    IURP,SDQDEOXQWDQ[LHW\PL[LQJIUXVWUDWLRQDQGKXQJHU+HFRXOGWDVWHWKH
    DQWLFLSDWLRQRIOXVFLRXVMXLF\WHUPLWHV
    +HVHWWRZRUNSOXFNLQJWKHHPRWLRQDOVWULQJVRI,SDQ7KLVMREZHQW
    HYHQZRUVH9DJXHWKRXJKWVGULIWHGXSIURP,SDQEXW+DULZDVLQFRQWURORI
    WKHPXVFOHVQRZDQGWKDWZDVWKHEDGSDUW
    +H TXLFNO\IRXQGWKDWWKHVWLFNKDGWREHVWXFNLQDERXWWHQ
    FHQWLPHWHUVWXUQLQJKLVZULVWWRQDYLJDWHLWGRZQWKHWZLVW\FKDQQHO7KHQKH
    KDGWRJHQWO\YLEUDWHLW7KURXJK,SDQKHVHQVHGWKDWWKLVZDVWRDWWUDFW
    WHUPLWHVWRELWHLQWRWKHVWLFN$WILUVWKH GLGLWWRRORQJDQGZKHQKHGUHZ
    WKHVWLFNRXWLWZDVKDOIJRQH7HUPLWHVKDGELWWHQFOHDQO\WKURXJKLW6RKH
    KDGWRVHDUFKRXWDQRWKHUVWLFNDQGWKDWPDGH,SDQVVWRPDFKJURZO
    7KHRWKHUSDQVZHUHWKURXJKWHUPLWHVQDFNLQJZKLOH+DULZDVVWLOO
    IXPEOLQJ IRUKLVILUVWWDVWH7KHQXDQFHVLUNHGKLP+HSXOOHGWKHVWLFNRXW
    WRRIDVWQRWWXUQLQJLWHQRXJKWRHDVHLWSDVWWKHWXQQHOVFXUYHV7LPHDQG
    DJDLQKHIHWFKHGIRUWKWKHVWLFNRQO\WRILQGWKDWKHKDGVFUDSHGWKH
    OXVFLRXV7HUPLWHVRIIRQWKHZDOOV7KHLUELWHVSXQFWXUHGKLVVWLFNXQWLOLW
    ZDVVRVKUHGGHGKHKDGWRJHWDQRWKHU7KHWHUPLWHVZHUHGLQLQJEHWWHUWKDQ
    KH
    +HILQDOO\FDXJKWWKHNQDFNDIOXLGVORZWZLVWRIWKHZULVWJUDFHIXOO\
    H[WUDFWLQJWHUPLWHVFOLQJLQJOLNHEXPSV,SDQOLFNHGWKHPRIIHDJHUO\+DUL
    OLNHGWKHPRUVHOVILOWHUHGWKURXJKSDQWDVWHEXGV1RWPDQ\WKRXJK2WKHUV
    RIWKHWURRSZHUHZDWFKLQJKLVVNLPS\KDUYHVWKHDGVWLOWHGLQFXULRVLW\DQG
    KHIHOWKXPLOLDWHG
    7KHKHOOZLWKWKLVKHWKRXJKW
    +HPDGH,SDQWXUQDQGZDONLQWRWKHZRRGV,SDQUHVLVWHGGUDJJLQJKLV

    IHHW+DULIRXQGDWKLFNOLPEVQDSSHGLWRIIWRFDUU\LQJVL]HDQGZHQWEDFN
    WRWKHPRXQG
    1RPRUHIRROLQJZLWKVWLFNV+HZKDFNHGWKHPRXQGVROLGO\)LYHPRUHDQG
    KHKDGSXQFKHGDELJKROH(VFDSLQJWHUPLWHVKH VFRRSHGXSE\WKHGHOLFLRXV
    KDQGIXO
    6RPXFKIRUVXEWOHW\KHZDQWHGWRVKRXW+HWULHGZULWLQJDQRWHIRU
    KHULQWKHGXVWEXWLWZDVKDUGIRUFLQJWKHOHWWHUVRXWWKURXJKKLVVXGGHQO\
    DZNZDUGKDQGV3DQVFRXOGKDQGOHDVWLFNWRIHWFKIRUWKJUXEVEXWPDUNLQJD
    VXUIDFHZDVVRPHKRZQRWDUHDG\WDOHQW+HJDYHXS
    6KHHODK'RUVFDPHLQWRYLHZSURXGO\FDUU\LQJDUHHGVZDUPLQJZLWK
    ZKLWHEHOOLHGWHUPLWHV7KHVHZHUHWKHEHVWDSDQJRXUPHWGHOLFDF\,EHWWHU
    VKHVLJQHG
    +HPDGH,SDQVKUXJDQGVLJQHG,JRWPRUH
    6RLWZDVDGUDZ
    /DWHU'RUVUHSRUWHGWRKLPWKDWDPRQJWKHWURRSKHZDVNQRZQQRZDV%LJ
    6WLFN7KHQDPHSOHDVHGKLPLPPHQVHO\
    

    $WGLQQHUKHIHOWHODWHGH[KDXVWHGDQGQRWLQWKHPRRGIRU
    FRQYHUVDWLRQ%HLQJDSDQVHHPHGWRVXSSUHVVKLVVSHHFKFHQWHUV,WWRRNVRPH
    HIIRUWWRDVN([6SHF9DGGRDERXWLPPHUVLRQWHFKQRORJ\8VXDOO\KHDFFHSWHG
    WKHURXWLQHWHFKQRPLUDFOHVEXWXQGHUVWDQGLQJSDQVPHDQWXQGHUVWDQGLQJKRZKH
    H[SHULHQFHGWKHP
    7KHLPPHUVLRQKDUGZDUHSXWV\RXLQWKHPLGGOHRIDSDQVDQWHULRU
    FLQJXODWHJ\UXV9DGGRVDLGRYHUGHVVHUW-XVWJ\UXVIRUVKRUW7KDWVWKH
    EUDLQVPDLQFRUWLFDOUHJLRQIRUPHGLDWLQJHPRWLRQVDQGH[SUHVVLQJWKHP
    WKURXJKDFWLRQ
    7KHEUDLQ"'RUVDVNHG:KDWDERXWRXUV"
    9DGGRVKUXJJHG6DPHJHQHUDOOD\RXW3DQVDUHVPDOOHUZLWKRXWDELJ
    FHUHEUXP
    +DULOHDQHGIRUZDUGLJQRULQJKLVVWHDPLQJFXSRINDII7KLVJ\UXV
    LWGRHVQWJLYHGLUHFWPRWRUFRQWURO"
    1RZHWULHGWKDW,WGLVRULHQWVWKHSDQVRPXFKZKHQ\RXOHDYHLW
    FDQWJHWLWVHOIEDFNWRJHWKHU
    6RZHKDYHWR EHPRUHVXEWOH'RUVVDLG
    :HKDYHWREH,QSDQPDOHVWKHSLORWOLJKWLVDOZD\VRQLQQHXURQV
    WKDWFRQWURODFWLRQDQGDJJUHVVLRQ
    7KDWVZK\WKH\UHPRUHYLROHQFHSURQH"VKHDVNHG
    :HWKLQNVR,WSDUDOOHOVVWUXFWXUHVLQRXURZQEUDLQV
    5HDOO\"0HQVQHXURQV"'RUVORRNHGGRXEWIXO+XPDQPDOHVKDYHKLJKHU
    DFWLYLW\OHYHOVLQWKHLUWHPSRUDOOLPELFV\VWHPVGHHSHUGRZQLQWKHEUDLQ
    HYROXWLRQDULO\ROGHUVWUXFWXUHV
    6RZK\QRWSXWPHLQWRWKDWOHYHO"+DULDVNHG
    :HSODFHWKHLPPHUVLRQFKLSVLQWRWKHJ\UXVDUHDEHFDXVHZHFDQUHDFK
    LWIURPWKHWRSVXUJLFDOO\7KHWHPSRUDOOLPELFLVZD\IDUGRZQLPSRVVLEOH
    WRLPSODQWDFKLS
    'RUVIURZQHG6RSDQPDOHV
    $UHKDUGHUWRFRQWURO3URIHVVRU6HOGRQKHUHLVUXQQLQJKLVSDQIURP
    WKHEDFNVHDWVRWRVSHDN
    :KHUHDV'RUVLVUXQQLQJKHUVIURPDFRQWUROFHQWHUWKDWIRUIHPDOH
    SDQVLVPRUHFHQWUDO"+DULSHHUHGLQWRWKHGLVWDQFH,ZDVKDQGLFDSSHG
    'RUVJULQQHG<RXKDYHWRSOD\WKHKDQG\RXUHGHDOW
    ,WVQRWIDLU
    %LJ6WLFNELRORJ\LVGHVWLQ\
    7KHWURRSFDPHXSRQURWWLQJIUXLW)HYHUHGH[FLWHPHQWUDQWKURXJKWKHP

    7KHVPHOOZDVUHSXJQDQWDQGHQWLFLQJDWWKHVDPHWLPHDQGDWILUVWKH
    GLGQRWXQGHUVWDQGZK\7KHSDQVUXVKHGWRWKHRYHUULSHEXOEVRIEOXHDQG
    VLFNO\JUHHQSRSSLQJRSHQWKHVNLQVVXFNLQJRXWWKHMXLFH
    7HQWDWLYHO\+DULWULHGRQH7KHKLWZDVLPPHGLDWH$ZDUPIHHOLQJRI
    ZHOOEHLQJNLQGOHGXSLQKLP2IFRXUVHWKHIUXLW\HVWHUVKDGFRQYHUWHGLQWR
    DOFRKRO7KHSDQVZHUHTXLWHGHOLEHUDWHO\VHWWLQJDERXWJHWWLQJGUXQN
    +HOHWKLVSDQIROORZVXLW+HKDGQWPXFKFKRLFHLQWKHPDWWHU
    ,SDQJUXQWHGDQGWKUDVKHGKLVDUPVZKHQHYHU+DULWULHGWRWXUQKLPDZD\
    IURPWKHWHDUGURSIUXLW$QGDIWHUDZKLOH+DULGLGQWZDQWWRWXUQDZD\
    HLWKHU+HJDYHKLPVHOIXSWRDJRRGVROLGGUXQN+HKDGEHHQZRUU\LQJDORW
    ODWHO\DJLWDWHGLQKLVSDQDQGWKLVZDVFRPSOHWHO\QDWXUDOZDVQWLW"
    7KHQDSDFNRIUDERRQVDSSHDUHGDQGKHORVWFRQWURORI,SDQ

    7KH\FRPHIDVW5XQQLQJWZROHJVQRVRXQG7KHLUWDLOVWZLWFKWDONLQJ
    WRHDFKRWKHU
    )LYHFLUFOHOHIW7KH\FXWRII(VD
    %LJJHVWWKXQGHUVDWWKHP+XQNHU UXQVWRQHDUHVWDQGLWVSLNHVKLPZLWK
    LWVIRUHSXQFKHU
    ,WKURZURFNV+LWRQH,W\HOSVDQGVFXUULHVEDFN%XWRWKHUVWDNHLWV
    SODFH,WKURZDJDLQDQGWKH\FRPHDQGWKHGXVWDQG\RZOLQJDUHWKLFNDQGWKH
    RWKHUVRIWKHPKDYH(VD7KH\FXWKHUZLWKWKHLUSXQFKFODZV.LFNKHUZLWK
    VKDUSKRRYHV
    7KUHHRIWKHPFDUU\KHURII
    2XUIHPVUXQDIUDLG:HZDUULRUVVWD\
    :HILJKWWKHP6KULHNLQJWKURZLQJELWLQJZKHQWKH\JHWFORVH%XWZH
    FDQQRWUHDFK(VD
    7KHQWKH\JR)DVWUXQQLQJRQWKHLUWZRKRRIHG OHJV)XUOLQJWKHLU
    WDLOVLQYLFWRU\7DXQWLQJXV
    :HIHHOEDG(VDZDVROGDQGZHORYHGKHU
    )HPVFRPHEDFNQHUYRXV:HJURRPRXUVHOYHVDQGNQRZWKDWWKHWZROHJV
    DUHHDWLQJ(VDVRPHZKHUH
    %LJJHVWFRPHE\WU\WRSDWPH
    ,VQDUO+H%LJJHVW7KLVWKLQJKHVKRXOGKDYHVWRSSHG
    +LVH\HVJHWELJDQGKHVODSPH,VODSEDFNDWKLP+HVODPLQWRPH:H
    UROODURXQGLQGXVW%LWLQJ\RZOLQJ%LJJHVWVWURQJVWURQJDQGSRXQGP\KHDG
    RQJURXQG
    2WKHUZDUULRUVWKH\ZDWFKXVQRWMRLQLQ
    +HEHDWPH ,KXUW,JRDZD\
    %LJJHVWVWDUWVFDOPLQJGRZQWKHZDUULRUV)HPVFRPHE\DQGSD\WKHLU
    UHVSHFWVWR%LJJHVW7RXFKKLPJURRPKLPIHHOKLPWKHZD\KHOLNHV+H
    PRXQWVWKUHHRIWKHPUHDOTXLFN+HIHHOLQJ%LJJHVWDOOULJKW
    0H,OLFNP\VHOI6KHHODKFRPHJURRPPH$IWHUDZKLOH,IHHOEHWWHU
    )RUJHWDERXWWURXEOH
    ,QRWIRUJHW%LJJHVWEHDWPHWKRXJK,QIURQWRIHYHU\ERG\1RZ,KXUW
    %LJJHVWJHWJURRPLQJ
    +HOHWWKHPFRPHDQGWDNH(VD+H%LJJHVWKHVKRXOGVWRSWKHP
    6RPHGD\,EHDOORYHUKLP 2QKLVEDFN
    6RPHGD\,EH%LJJHU
    

    :KHQGLG\RXEDLORXW"'RUVDVNHG
    $IWHU%LJJHVWVWRSSHGSRXQGLQJRQPHXKRQ,SDQ
    7KH\ZHUHUHOD[LQJEHVLGHDVZLPPLQJSRRODQGWKHKHDG\VPHOOVRIWKH
    IRUHVWVHHPHGWRDZDNHQLQ+DULWKHXUJHWREHGRZQWKHUHDJDLQLQWKH
    YDOOH\VRIGXVWDQGEORRG+HWUHPEOHGWRRNDGHHSEUHDWK7KHILJKWLQJKDG
    EHHQVRLQYROYLQJKHKDGQWZDQWHGWR OHDYHGHVSLWHWKHSDLQ,PPHUVLRQKDGD

    K\SQRWLFTXDOLW\
    ,NQRZKRZ\RXIHHOVKHVDLG,WVHDV\WRWRWDOO\LGHQWLI\ZLWK
    WKHP,OHIW6KHHODKZKHQWKRVHUDERRQVFDPHFORVH3UHWW\VFDU\
    9DGGRVDLGWKH\UHGHULYHGIURP(DUWKWRR
    3OHQW\RI '1$RYHUODS%XWWKH\VKRZVLJQVRIH[WHQVLYHUHFHQWWLQNHULQJ
    WRPDNHWKHPSUHGDWRUV
    :K\ZRXOGWKHDQFLHQWVZDQWWKRVH"
    7U\LQJWRILJXUHRXWRXURULJLQV"
    7RKLVVXUSULVHVKHODXJKHG1RWHYHU\RQHKDV\RXUVDPHLQWHUHVWV
    :K\WKHQ"
    +RZDERXWXVLQJUDERRQVDVJDPHWRKXQW"6RPHWKLQJDOLWWOH
    FKDOOHQJLQJ"
    +XQWLQJ"7KH(PSLUHKDVDOZD\VEHHQWRRIDUIURPWKURZEDFNSULPLWLYLVP
    WR+HKDGEHHQDERXWWRODXQFKLQWRDOLWWOHOHFWXUHRQKRZIDUKXPDQLW\KDG
    FRPHZKHQKHUHDOL]HGWKDWKH GLGQWEHOLHYHLWDQ\PRUH8P
    <RXYHDOZD\VWKRXJKWRISHRSOHDVFHUHEUDO1RSV\FKRKLVWRU\FRXOG
    ZRUNLILWGLGQWWDNHLQWRDFFRXQWRXUDQLPDOVHOYHV
    2XUZRUVWVLQVDUHDOORXURZQ,IHDU+HKDGQRWH[SHFWHGWKDWKLV
    H[SHULHQFHVKHUHZRXOG VKDNHKLPVR7KLVZDVVREHULQJ
    1RWDWDOO*HQRFLGHRFFXUVLQZROYHVDQGSDQVDOLNH0XUGHULV
    ZLGHVSUHDG'XFNVDQGRUDQJXWDQVUDSH(YHQDQWVKDYHRUJDQL]HGZDUIDUHDQG
    VODYHUDLGV3DQVKDYHDWOHDVWDVJRRGDFKDQFHRIEHLQJPXUGHUHGDVGR
    KXPDQV9DGGRVD\V2IDOOWKHKDOORZHGKXPDQKDOOPDUNVVSHHFKDUW
    WHFKQRORJ\DQGWKHUHVWWKHRQHZKLFKFRPHVPRVWREYLRXVO\IURPDQLPDO
    DQFHVWRUVLVJHQRFLGH
    <RXYHEHHQOHDUQLQJIURP9DGGR
    ,WZDVDJRRGZD\WRNHHSDQH\HRQKLP
    %HWWHUWREHVXVSLFLRXVWKDQVRUU\"
    2IFRXUVHVKHVDLGEODQGO\JLYLQJQRWKLQJDZD\
    :HOOOXFNLO\HYHQLIZHDUHVXSHUSDQV,PSHULDORUGHUDQG
    FRPPXQLFDWLRQEOXUVGLVWLQFWLRQVEHWZHHQ8VDQG7KHP
    6R"
    7KDWEOXQWVWKHGHHSLPSXOVHWRJHQRFLGH
    6KHODXJKHGDJDLQWKLVWLPHUDWKHUWRKLVDQQR\DQFH<RXKDYHQW
    XQGHUVWRRGKLVWRU\YHU\ZHOO6PDOOHUJURXSVVWLOONLOOHDFKRWKHURIIZLWK
    JUHDWUHOLVK,Q=RQH6DJLWWDULXVGXULQJWKHUHLJQRI2PDUWKH,PSDOHU
    ,FRQFHGHWKHUHDUHVPDOOVFDOHWUDJHGLHVE\WKHGR]HQV%XWRQWKH
    VFDOHZKHUHSV\FKRKLVWRU\PLJKWZRUNDYHUDJLQJRYHUSRSXODWLRQVRIPDQ\
    WKRXVDQGVRIELOOLRQV
    :KDWPDNHV\RXVRVXUHQXPEHUVDUHDQ\SURWHFWLRQ"VKHDVNHG
    SRLQWHGO\
    6RIDU
    7KH(PSLUHKDVEHHQLQVWDVLV
    $VWHDG\VWDWHVROXWLRQDFWXDOO\'\QDPLFHTXLOLEULXP
    $QGLIWKDWHTXLOLEULXPIDLOV"
    :HOOWKHQ,KDYHQRWKLQJWRVD\6KHVPLOHG+RZXQFKDUDFWHULVWLF
    8QWLO,KDYHDUHDOZRUNLQJWKHRU\
    2QHWKDWFDQDOORZIRUZLGHVSUHDGJHQRFLGHLIWKH(PSLUHHURGHV
    +HVDZKHUSRLQWWKHQ<RXUHVD\LQJ,UHDOO\QHHGWKLVDQLPDOQDWXUH
    SDUWRIKXPDQV
    ,PDIUDLGVR,PWUDLQHGWRDOORZIRULWDOUHDG\
    +HZDVSX]]OHG+RZVR"
    ,GRQWKDYH\RXUYLHZRIKXPDQLW\6FKHPLQJSORWV6KHHODKJUDEELQJ
    PRUHPHDWIRUKHU\RXQJ,SDQZDQWLQJWRGRLQ%LJJHVWWKRVHWKLQJVKDSSHQLQ
    WKH(PSLUH-XVWEHWWHUGLVJXLVHG
    6R"
    &RQVLGHU([6SHF9DGGR+HPDGHDFRPPHQWDERXW\RXUZRUNLQJRQD

    WKHRU\RIKLVWRU\WKHRWKHUHYHQLQJ
    6R"
    :KRWROGKLP\RXZHUH"
    ,GRQWWKLQN,DK\RXWKLQNKHVFKHFNLQJXSRQXV"
    +HDOUHDG\NQRZV
    7KHVHFXULW\FKLHIPD\EHVKHWROGKLPDIWHUFKHFNLQJRQPHZLWKWKH
    $FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWH
    6KHJUDFHGKLPZLWKDQXQUHDGDEOHVPLOH,GRORYH\RXUHQGOHVVQDLYH
    ZD\RIVHHLQJWKHZRUOG
    /DWHUKHFRXOGQWGHFLGHZKHWKHUVKHKDGPHDQWLWDVDFRPSOLPHQW
    

    9DGGRLQYLWHGKLPWRWU\DFRPEDWVSRUWWKHVWDWLRQRIIHUHGDQG+DUL
    DFFHSWHG,WZDVDQHQKDQFHGVZRUGSOD\ZLWKOHYLWDWLRQWKURXJKHOHFWURVWDWLF
    OLIWHUV+DULZDVVORZDQGLQHSW8VLQJKLVRZQERG\DJDLQVW9DGGRVVZLIW
    PRYHVPDGHKLPORQJIRUWKHVXUHQHVVDQGJUDFHRI,SDQ
    9DGGRDOZD\VRSHQHGZLWKDWUDGLWLRQDOSRVWXUHRQHIRRWIRUZDUGKLV
    SURGVZRUGPDNLQJOLWWOHFLUFOHVLQWKH DLU+DULSRNHGWKURXJK9DGGRV
    GHIHQVHVRPHWLPHVEXWXVXDOO\VSHQWDOOKLVOLIWHUHQHUJ\HOXGLQJ9DGGRV
    WKUXVWV+HGLGQRWHQMR\LWQHDUO\DVPXFKDV9DGGR
    +HGLGOHDUQELWVDQGSLHFHVDERXWSDQVIURP9DGGRDQGIURPWUROOLQJ
    WKURXJKWKHYDVWVWDWLRQOLEUDU\7KHPDQVHHPHGDELWXQHDV\ZKHQ+DULSUREHG
    WKHGDWDDUUD\VDVWKRXJK9DGGRVRPHKRZRZQHGWKHPDQGDQ\UHDGHUZDVD
    WKLHI2UDWOHDVWWKDWZDVZKDW+DULWRRNWREHWKHRULJLQRIWKHXQHDVH
    +HKDGQHYHUWKRXJKWDERXWDQLPDOVYHU\PXFKWKRXJKKHKDGJURZQXS
    DPRQJWKHPRQ+HOLFRQ<HWKHFDPHWRIHHOWKDWWKH\WRRKDGWREH
    XQGHUVWRRG
    &DWFKLQJVLJKWRILWVHOILQDPLUURUDGRJVHHVWKHLPDJHDVDQRWKHU
    GRJ6RGLGFDWVILVKRUELUGV$IWHUDZKLOHWKH\JHWXVHGWRWKHKDUPOHVV
    LPDJHVLOHQWDQGVPHOOIUHHEXWWKH\GRQRWVHHLWDVWKHPVHOYHV
    +XPDQFKLOGUHQKDGWREHDERXWWZR\HDUVROGWRGREHWWHU
    3DQVWRRNDIHZGD\VWRILJXUHRXWWKDWWKH\ZHUHORRNLQJDWWKHPVHOYHV
    7KHQWKH\SUHHQHGEHIRUHLWVKDPHOHVVO\VWXGLHGWKHLUEDFNVDQGJHQHUDOO\
    WULHGWRVHHWKHPVHOYHVGLIIHUHQWO\HYHQSXWWLQJOHDYHVRQWKHLUKHDGVOLNH
    KDWVDQGODXJKLQJDWWKHUHVXOW
    6RWKH\FRXOGGRVRPHWKLQJRWKHUDQLPDOVFRXOGQRWJHWRXWVLGH
    WKHPVHOYHVDQGORRNEDFN
    7KH\SODLQO\OLYHGLQDZRUOGFKDUJHGZLWKHFKRHVDQGUHPLQLVFHQFHV
    7KHLUGRPLQDQFHKLHUDUFK\ZDVDIUR]HQUHFRUGRISDVWFRHUFLRQ7KH\
    UHPHPEHUHGWHUPLWHPRXQGVWUHHVWRGUXPXVHIXOVSRWVZKHUHODUJHZDWHU
    VSRQJHOHDYHVIHOORUJUDLQPDWXUHG
    $OOWKLVIHGLQWRWKHWR\PRGHOKHKDGEHJXQEXLOGLQJLQKLVQRWHVD
    SDQSV\FKRKLVWRU\,WXVHGWKHLUPRYHPHQWVULYDOULHVKLHUDUFKLHVSDWWHUQV
    RIHDWLQJDQGPDWLQJDQGG\LQJWHUULWRU\UHVRXUFHVDQGWURRSFRPSHWLWLRQ
    IRUWKHP+HIRXQGDZD\WRIDFWRULQWRKLVHTXDWLRQVWKHELRORJLFDOEDJJDJH
    RIGDUNEHKDYLRUVHYHQWKHZRUVWOLNHGHOLJKWLQWRUWXUHDQGHDV\
    H[WHUPLQDWLRQVRIRWKHUVSHFLHVIRUVKRUWWHUPJDLQ
    $OOWKHVHWKHSDQVKDG-XVWOLNHWKH(PSLUH
    $WDGDQFHWKDWHYHQLQJKHZDWFKHGWKHFURZGZLWKIUHVKYLVLRQ
    )OLUWLQJZDVSUDFWLFHPDWLQJ+HFRXOGVHHLWLQWKHVSDUNOHRIH\HV
    WKHUK\WKPVRIWKHGDQFH7KHZDUPEUHH]HZDIWLQJXSIURPWKHYDOOH\EURXJKW
    VPHOOVRIGXVWURWOLIH$QDQLPDOUHVWOHVVQHVVPRYHGLQWKHURRP
    +HTXLWHOLNHGGDQFLQJDQG'RUVZDVDOXVKFRPSDQLRQWRQLJKW<HWKH
    FRXOGQRWVWRSKLVPLQGIURPVLIWLQJDQDO\]LQJWDNLQJWKHZRUOGEHIRUHKLP
    DSDUWLQWRPHFKDQLVPV

    7KH QRQYHUEDOWHPSODWHKXPDQVXVHGIRUDWWUDFWDSSURDFKVWUDWHJLHV
    DSSDUHQWO\GHVFHQGHGIURPDVKDUHGPDPPDOLDQKHULWDJH'RUVKDGSRLQWHGRXW
    +HWKRXJKWRIWKDWZDWFKLQJWKHFURZGDWWKHEDU
    $ZRPDQFURVVHVDFURZGHGURRPKLSVVZD\LQJH\HVUHVWLQJPRPHQWDULO\
    RQDOLNHO\PDQWKHQFR\O\ORRNLQJDZD\MXVWDVVKHDSSDUHQWO\QRWLFHVKLV
    UHJDUG$VWDQGDUGRSHQLQJPRYH1RWLFHPH
    7KHVHFRQGLV,DPKDUPOHVV$KDQGSODFHGSDOPXSRQDWDEOHRUNQHH$
    VKRXOGHUVKUXJGHULYHGIURPDQDQFLHQWYHUWHEUDWHUHIOH[VLJQLI\LQJ
    KHOSOHVVQHVV&RPELQHWKDWZLWKDWLOWHGKHDGZKLFKGLVSOD\VWKH
    YXOQHUDELOLW\RIWKHQHFN7KHVHFRPPRQO\DSSHDUHGZKHQWZRSHRSOHGUDZQWR
    HDFKRWKHUKDYHWKHLUILUVWFRQYHUVDWLRQDOOTXLWHXQFRQVFLRXVO\
    6XFKPRYHVDQGJHVWXUHVDUH VXEFRUWLFDOHPHUJLQJIDUEHORZWKH
    QHRFRUWH[
    'LGVXFKIRUFHVVKDSHWKH(PSLUHPRUHWKDQWUDGHEDODQFHVDOOLDQFHV
    WUHDWLHV"
    +HORRNHGDWKLVRZQNLQGDQGWULHGWRVHHLWWKURXJKSDQH\HV
    7KRXJKKXPDQIHPDOHVPDWXUHGHDUOLHUWKH\GLGQRWJRRQWRDFTXLUH
    FRDUVHERG\KDLUERQ\H\HULGJHVGHHSYRLFHVRUWRXJKVNLQ0DOHVGLG$QG
    ZRPHQHYHU\ZKHUHVWURYHWRVWD\\RXQJORRNLQJ&RVPHWLFVPDNHUVIUHHO\
    DGPLWWHGWKHLUEDVLFUROH:HGRQWVHOOSURGXFWV:HVHOOKRSH
    &RPSHWLWLRQIRUPDWHVZDVLQFHVVDQW0DOHSDQVVRPHWLPHVWRRNWXUQVZLWK
    IHPDOHVLQHVWUXV7KH\KDGKXJHWHVWLFOHVLPSO\LQJWKDWUHSURGXFWLYH
    DGYDQWDJHKDGFRPHWRWKRVHPDOHVZKRSURGXFHGHQRXJKVSHUPWRRYHUZKHOPWKHLU
    ULYDOVFRQWULEXWLRQV+XPDQPDOHVKDGSURSRUWLRQDOO\VPDOOHUWHVWLFOHV
    %XWKXPDQVJRWWKHLUUHYHQJHZKHUHLWPDWWHUHG$OONQRZQSULPDWHVZHUH
    JHQHWLFDOO\UHODWHGWKRXJKWKH\KDGVHSDUDWHGRXWDVVSHFLHVPDQ\PLOOLRQVRI
    \HDUVDJR,Q'1$PHDVXUHGWLPHSDQVOD\VL[PLOOLRQ\HDUVIURPKXPDQV2I
    DOOSULPDWHVKXPDQVKDGWKHODUJHVWSHQLVHV
    +HPHQWLRQHGWR'RUVWKDWRQO\IRXUSHUFHQWRIPDPPDOVIRUPHGSDLU
    ERQGVZHUHPRQRJDPRXV3ULPDWHVUDWHGDELWKLJKHUEXWQRWPXFK%LUGVZHUH
    PXFKEHWWHUDWLW
    6KHVQLIIHG'RQWOHWDOOWKLVELRORJ\JRWR\RXUKHDG
    2KQR,ZRQWOHWLWJHWWKDWIDU
    <RXPHDQLWEHORQJVLQORZHUSODFHV"
    0DGDP\RXOOKDYHWREHWKHMXGJHRIWKDW
    $K\RXDQG\RXUVLQJOHHQWHQGUHKXPRU
    /DWHUWKDWHYHQLQJKHKDGDPSOHRSSRUWXQLW\WRUHIOHFWXSRQWKHWUXWK
    WKDWZKLOHLWZDVQRWDOZD\VJUHDWWREHKXPDQLWZDVWUHPHQGRXVIXQEHLQJD
    PDPPDO
    

    7KH\VSHQWRQHODVWGD\LPPHUVHGLQWKHLUSDQVVXQQLQJWKHPVHOYHV
    EHVLGHDJXVKLQJVWUHDP7KH\KDGWROG9DGGRWREULQJWKHVKXWWOHGRZQWKH
    QH[WGD\ERRNDZRUPKROHWUDQVLW7KHQWKH\HQWHUHGWKHLPPHUVLRQFDSVXOHDQG
    VDQNLQWRDODVWUHYHULH
    8QWLO%LJJHVWVWDUWHGWRPRXQW6KHHODK
    +DUL,SDQVDWXSKLVKHDGIRJJ\6KHHODKZDVVKULHNLQJDW%LJJHVW6KH
    VODSSHGKLP
    %LJJHVWKDG PRXQWHG6KHHODKEHIRUH'RUVKDGEDLOHGRXWTXLFNO\KHU
    PLQGUHWXUQLQJWRKHUERG\LQWKHFDSVXOH
    6RPHWKLQJZDVGLIIHUHQWQRZ,SDQKXUULHGRYHUDQGVLJQHGWR6KHHODK
    ZKRZDVWKURZLQJSHEEOHVDW%LJJHVW:KDW"
    6KHPRYHGKHUKDQGVUDSLGO\VLJQLQJ1RJR
    6KHFRXOGQRWEDLORXW6RPHWKLQJZDVZURQJEDFNDWWKHFDSVXOH+HFRXOG
    JREDFNKLPVHOIWHOOWKHP
    +DULPDGHWKHOLWWOHPHQWDOIOLSWKDWZRXOGEDLOKLPRXW

    1RWKLQJKDSSHQHG
    +HWULHGDJDLQ6KHHODKWKUHZGXVWDQGSHEEOHVEDFNLQJDZD\IURP
    %LJJHVW1RWKLQJ
    1RWLPHWRWKLQN+HVWHSSHGEHWZHHQ6KHHODKDQG%LJJHVW
    7KHPDVVLYHSDQIURZQHG+HUHZDV,SDQEXGG\,SDQJHWWLQJLQWKHZD\
    'HQ\LQJKLPDIHUQ%LJJHVWVHHPHGWRKDYHIRUJRWWHQWKHFKDOOHQJHDQGEHDWLQJ
    RIWKHGD\EHIRUH
    )LUVWKHWULHGEHOORZLQJH\HVELJDQGZKLWH7KHQ%LJJHVWVKRRNKLV
    DUPVILVWVEDOOHG
    +DULPDGHKLVSDQVWDQGVWLOO,WWRRNHYHU\FDOPLQJLPSXOVHKHFRXOG
    PXVWHU
    %LJJHVWVZXQJKLVILVWOLNHDFOXE,SDQGXFNHG%LJJHVWPLVVHG
    +DULZDVKDYLQJWURXEOHFRQWUROOLQJ,SDQZKRZDQWHGWRIOHH6KHHWVRI
    IHDUVKRWXSWKURXJKWKHSDQPLQGKRW\HOORZVLQWKHEOXHEODFNGHSWKV
    %LJJHVWFKDUJHGIRUZDUGVODPPLQJ,SDQEDFN+DULIHOWWKHMROWD
    VWDEELQJSDLQLQKLVFKHVW+HWRSSOHGEDFNZDUGKLWKDUG
    %LJJHVW\RZOHGKLVWULXPSK:DYHGKLVDUPVDWWKHVN\
    %LJJHVWZRXOGJHWRQWRSKHVDZ%HDWKLPDJDLQ6XGGHQO\KHIHOWD
    GHHSUDZKDWUHG
    )URPWKDWUHGVHHWKHKHIHOWKLVJULSRQ,SDQWLJKWHQ+HZDVULGLQJ
    ERWKZLWKDQGZLWKLQWKHSDQIHHOLQJLWV UDZUHGIHDURYHUUXQQLQJWKDWZLWK
    DQLURQUDJH,SDQVRZQZUDWKIHGEDFNLQWR+DUL7KHWZRIRUPHGDFRQFHUW
    DQJHUEXLOGLQJDVLIUHIOHFWHGIURPKDUGZDOOV
    +HPLJKWQRWEHWKHVDPHNLQGRISULPDWHEXWKHNQHZ,SDQ1HLWKHURI
    WKHPZDVJRLQJWRJHW EHDWHQDJDLQ$QG%LJJHVWZDVQRWJRLQJWRJHW
    6KHHODK'RUV
    +HUROOHGWRWKHVLGH%LJJHVWKLWWKHJURXQGZKHUHKHKDGEHHQ
    ,SDQOHDSHGXSDQGNLFNHG%LJJHVW+DUGLQWKHULEV2QFHWZLFH7KHQ
    LQWKHKHDG
    :KRRSVFULHVGXVWSHEEOHV6KHHODKZDVVWLOOERPEDUGLQJWKHPERWK
    ,SDQVKLYHUHGZLWKERLOLQJHQHUJ\DQGEDFNHGDZD\
    %LJJHVWVKRRNKLVGXVW\KHDG7KHQKHFXUOHGDQGUROOHGHDVLO\XSWRKLV
    IHHWIXOORIPXVFXODUJUDFHIDFHDFRQVWULFWHGPDVN7KHSDQVH\HVZLGHQHG
    VKRZLQJZKLWHDQGUHG
    ,SDQ\HDUQHGWRUXQ2QO\+DULVUDJHKHOGKLPLQSODFH
    %XWLWZDVDVWDWLFEDODQFHRIIRUFHV,SDQEOLQNHGDV%LJJHVWVKXIIOHG
    ZDULO\IRUZDUGWKHELJSDQVFDXWLRQDWULEXWHWRWKHGDPDJH,SDQKDG
    LQIOLFWHG
    ,QHHGVRPHDGYDQWDJH+DULWKRXJKWORRNLQJDURXQG
    +HFRXOGFDOOIRUDOOLHV+XQNHUSDFHGQHUYRXVO\QHDUE\
    6RPHWKLQJWROG+DULWKDWZRXOGEHDORVLQJVWUDWHJ\+XQNHUZDVVWLOOD
    OLHXWHQDQWWR%LJJHVW6KHHODKZDVWRRVPDOOWRPDNHDGHFLVLYHGLIIHUHQFH+H
    ORRNHGDWWKHRWKHUSDQVDOOFKDWWHULQJDQ[LRXVO\DQGGHFLGHG+HSLFNHGXS
    DURFN
    %LJJHVWJUXQWHGLQVXUSULVH3DQVGLGQWXVHURFNVDJDLQVWHDFKRWKHU
    5RFNVZHUHRQO\IRUUHSHOOLQJLQYDGHUV+HZDVYLRODWLQJDVRFLDOFRGH
    %LJJHVW\HOOHGZDYHGWRWKHRWKHUVSRXQGHGWKHJURXQGKXIIHGDQJULO\
    7KHQKHFKDUJHG
    +DULWKUHZWKHURFNKDUG,WKLW%LJJHVWLQWKHFKHVWNQRFNHGKLPGRZQ
    %LJJHVWFDPHXSIDVWPDGGHUWKDQEHIRUH,SDQVFXUULHGEDFNZDQWLQJ
    GHVSHUDWHO\WRUXQ+DULIHOWFRQWUROVOLSSLQJIURPKLPDQGVDZDQRWKHUURFN
    6XLWDEOHVL]HWZRSDFHVEDFN+HOHW,SDQWXUQWRIOHHWKHQVWRSSHGKLPDW
    WKHVWRQH,SDQGLGQWZDQWWRKROGLW3DQLFUDQWKURXJKKLP
    +DULSRXUHGKLVUDJHLQWRWKHSDQIRUFHGWKHORQJDUPVGRZQ+DQGV
    JUDEEHGDWWKHVWRQHIXPEOHGJRWLW6KHHUDQJHUPDGH,SDQWXUQWRIDFH
    %LJJHVWZKRZDVWKXQGHULQJDIWHUKLP7R+DUL,SDQVDUPFDPHXSLQDFKLQJO\
    VORZPRWLRQ+HOHDQHGKHDYLO\LQWRWKHSLWFK7KHURFNVPDFNHG%LJJHVWLQWKH

    IDFH
    %LJJHVWVWDJJHUHG%ORRGUDQLQWRKLVH\HV,SDQFDXJKWWKHLURQVFHQW
    RILWULGLQJRQDSULFNO\VWHQFKRIRXWUDJH
    +DULPDGHWKHWUHPEOLQJ,SDQVWRRSGRZQ7KHUHZHUHVRPHVKDSHGVWRQHV
    QHDUE\PDGHE\WKHIHUQVWRWULPOHDYHVIURPEUDQFKHV+HSLFNHGXSRQHZLWK
    DFKLSSHGHGJH
    %LJJHVWVKRRNKLVKHDGGL]]\
    ,SDQJODQFHGDWWKHVREHUVWLOOIDFHVRIKLVWURRS1RRQHKDGHYHU
    XVHGDURFNDJDLQVWDWURRSPHPEHUPXFKOHVV%LJJHVW5RFNVZHUHIRU
    6WUDQJHUV
    $ORQJVLOHQFHVWUHWFKHG7KHSDQVVWRRGURRWHG%LJJHVWJUXQWHGDQG
    SHHUHGLQGLVEHOLHIDWWKHEORRGWKDWVSDWWHUHGLQWRKLVXSWXUQHGKDQG
    ,SDQVWHSSHGIRUZDUGDQGUDLVHGWKHMDJJHGVWRQHHGJHKHOGRXWZDUG
    &UXGHEXWDFXWWLQJHGJH
    %LJJHVWIODUHGKLVQRVWULOVDQGFDPHDW,SDQ,SDQVZHSWWKHURFN
    WKURXJKWKHDLUEDUHO\PLVVLQJ%LJJHVWVMDZ
    %LJJHVWVH\HVZLGHQHG+HKXIIHGDQGSXIIHGWKUHZGXVWKRZOHG,SDQ
    VLPSO\VWRRGZLWKWKHURFNDQGKHOGKLVJURXQG%LJJHVWNHSWXSKLVDQJHU
    GLVSOD\IRUDORQJZKLOHEXWKHGLGQRWDWWDFN
    7KHWURRSZDWFKHG ZLWKLQWHQVHLQWHUHVW6KHHODKFDPHDQGVWRRGEHVLGH
    ,SDQ,WZRXOGKDYHEHHQDJDLQVWSURWRFROVIRUDIHPDOHWRWDNHSDUWLQPDOH
    GRPLQDQFHULWXDOV
    +HUPRYHPHQWVLJQDOHGWKDWWKHFRQIURQWDWLRQZDVRYHU%XW+XQNHUZDV
    KDYLQJQRQHRIWKDW+HDEUXSWO\KRZOHGSRXQGHGWKHJURXQGDQGVFRRWHGRYHU
    WR,SDQVVLGH
    +DULZDVVXUSULVHG:LWK+XQNHUPD\EHKHFRXOGKROGWKHOLQHDJDLQVW
    %LJJHVW+HZDVQRWIRROHQRXJKWRWKLQNWKDWWKLVRQHVWDQGRIIZRXOGSXW
    %LJJHVWWRUHVW7KHUHZRXOGEHRWKHUFKDOOHQJHVDQGKHZRXOGKDYHWRILJKW
    WKHP+XQNHUZRXOGEHDXVHIXODOO\
    +HUHDOL]HGWKDWKHZDVWKLQNLQJLQWKHVORZPXWHGORJLFRI,SDQ
    KLPVHOI+HDVVXPHGWKDWWKHSXUVXLWRISDQVWDWXVPDUNHUVZDVDJLYHQWKH
    JUHDWJRDORIKLVOLIH
    7KLVUHYHODWLRQVWDUWOHGKLP+HKDGNQRZQWKDWKHZDVGLIIXVLQJLQWR
    ,SDQVPLQGWDNLQJFRQWURORIVRPHIXQFWLRQVIURPWKHERWWRPXSVHHSLQJ
    WKURXJKWKHGHHSO\EXULHGZDOQXWVL]HGJ\UXV,WKDGQRWRFFXUUHGWRKLPWKDW
    WKHSDQZRXOGGLIIXVHLQWRKLP:HUHWKH\QRZPDUULHGWR HDFKRWKHULQDQ
    LQWHUORFNHGZHEWKDWGLVSHUVHGPLQGDQGVHOI"
    +XQNHUVWRRGEHVLGHKLPH\HVJODULQJDWWKHRWKHUSDQVFKHVWKHDYLQJ
    ,SDQIHOWWKHVDPHZD\PDGO\SLQQHGWRWKHPRPHQW+DULUHDOL]HGWKDWKH
    ZRXOGKDYHWRGRVRPHWKLQJEUHDNWKLVF\FOH RIGRPLQDQFHDQGVXEPLVVLRQZKLFK
    UXOHG,SDQDWWKHGHHSQHXURORJLFDOOHYHO
    +HWXUQHGWR6KHHODK*HWRXW"KHVLJQHG
    1R1R+HUSDQIDFHZULQNOHGZLWKDQ[LHW\
    /HDYH+HZDYHGWRZDUGWKHWUHHVSRLQWHGWRKHUWKHQKLP
    6KHVSUHDGKHUKDQGVLQ DJHVWXUHRIKHOSOHVVQHVV
    ,WZDVLQIXULDWLQJ+HKDGVRPXFKWRVD\WRKHUDQGKHKDGWRIXQQHOLW
    WKURXJKDIHZKXQGUHGVLJQV+HFKLSSHUHGLQDKLJKSLWFKHGYRLFHWU\LQJ
    YDLQO\WRIRUFHWKHSDQOLSVDQGSDODWHWRGRWKHZRUNRIVKDSLQJZRUGV
    ,WZDVQRXVH+HKDGWULHGEHIRUHLGO\EXWQRZKHZDQWHGWREDGO\DQG
    QRQHRIWKHHTXLSPHQWZRUNHG,WFRXOGQW(YROXWLRQKDGVKDSHGEUDLQDQG
    YRFDOFKRUGVLQSDUDOOHO3DQVJURRPHGSHRSOHWDONHG
    +HWXUQHGEDFNDQGUHDOL]HGWKDWKHKDGIRUJRWWHQHQWLUHO\DERXWWKH
    VWDWXVVHWWLQJ%LJJHVWZDVJORZHULQJDWKLP+XQNHUVWRRGJXDUGFRQIXVHGDW
    KLVQHZOHDGHUVVXGGHQORVVRILQWHUHVWLQWKHFRQIURQWDWLRQDQGWRJHVWXUH
    DWDPHUHIHUQWRR
    +DULUHDUHGXSDVWDOODVKHFRXOGDQGZDYHGWKHVWRQH7KLVSURGXFHG
    WKHGHVLUHGHIIHFW%LJJHVWLQFKHGEDFNDELWDQGWKHUHVWRIWKHWURRSHGJHG

    FORVHU+DULPDGH,SDQVWDONIRUZDUGEROGO\%\WKLVWLPHLWGLGQRWWDNHPXFK
    HIIRUWIRU,SDQZDVHQMR\LQJWKLVHQRUPRXVO\
    %LJJHVWUHWUHDWHG)HUQVLQFKHGDURXQG%LJJHVWDQGDSSURDFKHG,SDQ
    ,IRQO\,FRXOGOHDYHKLPWRWKHWHUQVGHOLJKWV+DULWKRXJKW
    +HWULHGWREDLORXWDJDLQ1RWKLQJ7KHPHFKDQLVPZDVQWZRUNLQJEDFNDW
    WKH([FXUVLRQ6WDWLRQ$QGVRPHWKLQJWROGKLPWKDWLWZDVQWJRLQJWRJHW
    IL[HG
    +HJDYHWKHHGJHGVWRQHWR+XQNHU7KHSDQVHHPHGVXUSULVHGEXWWRRN
    LW+DULKRSHGWKHV\PEROLVPRIWKHJHVWXUHZRXOGSHQHWUDWHLQVRPHIDVKLRQ
    EHFDXVHKHKDGQRWLPHOHIWWRVSHQGRQSDQSROLWLFV+XQNHUKHIWHGWKHURFN
    DQGORRNHGDW,SDQ7KHQKHFULHGLQDUROOLQJSRZHUIXOYRLFHWRQHVULFKLQ
    MR\DQGWULXPSK
    +DULZDVTXLWHKDSS\WROHW+XQNHUGLVWUDFWWKHWURRS+HWRRN6KHHODK
    E\WKHDUPDQGOHGKHULQWRWKHWUHHV1RRQHIROORZHG
    +HZDVUHOLHYHG,IDQRWKHUSDQKDGWDJJHGDORQJLWZRXOGKDYH
    FRQILUPHGKLVVXVSLFLRQV9DGGRPLJKWEHNHHSLQJWUDFN
    6WLOOKHUHPLQGHGKLPVHOIDEVHQFHRIHYLGHQFHLVQRWHYLGHQFHRI
    DEVHQFH
    

    7KHKXPDQVFDPHVZLIWO\ZLWKFODWWHUVDQGERRPV
    +HDQG6KHHODKKDGEHHQLQWKHWUHHVDZKLOH$W+DULVXUJLQJWKH\KDG
    ZRUNHGWKHLUZD\DIHZNOLFNVDZD\IURPWKHWURRS,SDQDQG6KHHODKVKRZHG
    ULVLQJDQ[LHW\DWEHLQJVHSDUDWHGIURPWKHLUWURRS+LVWHHWKFKDWWHUHGDQG
    KLVH\HVMHUNHGDQ[LRXVO\DWHYHU\VXVSLFLRXVPRYHPHQW7KLVZDVQDWXUDOIRU
    LVRODWHGSDQVZHUHIDUPRUHYXOQHUDEOH
    7KHKXPDQVODQGLQJGLGQRWKHOS
    'DQJHU+DULVLJQHGFXSSLQJDQHDUWRLQGLFDWHWKHQRLVHRIIO\HUV
    ODQGLQJQHDUE\
    6KHHODKVLJQHG:KHUHJR"
    $ZD\
    6KHVKRRNKHUKHDGYHKHPHQWO\6WD\KHUH7KH\JHWXV
    7KH\ZRXOGLQGHHGEXWQRWLQWKHVHQVHVKHPHDQW+DULFXWKHURII
    FXUWO\VKDNLQJKLVKHDG'DQJHU7KH\KDGQHYHULQWHQGHGWRFRQYH\
    FRPSOLFDWHGLGHDVZLWKWKHLUVLJQVDQGQRZKHIHOWERWWOHGXSXQDEOHWRWHOO
    KHUKLVVXVSLFLRQV
    +DULPDGHDNQLIHDFURVVWKURDWJHVWXUH6KHHODKIURZQHG
    +HEHQWGRZQDQGPDGH,SDQWDNHDVWLFN+HKDGQRWEHHQDEOHWRPDNH
    ,SDQZULWHEHIRUHEXWQHFHVVLW\GURYHKLPQRZ6ORZO\KHPDGHWKHURXJKKDQGV
    VFUDWFKRXWWKHOHWWHUV,QVRIWORDPKHZURWH:$1786'($'
    6KHHODKORRNHGGXPEIRXQGHG'RUVKDGSUREDEO\EHHQRSHUDWLQJXQGHUWKH
    DVVXPSWLRQWKDWWKHIDLOXUHWREDLORXWZDVDWHPSRUDU\HUURU,WKDGODVWHG
    WRRORQJIRUWKDW
    7KHQRLV\LQWUXVLYHODQGLQJFRQILUPHGKLVKXQFK1RRUGLQDU\WHDPZRXOG
    GLVWXUEWKHDQLPDOVVRPXFK$QGQRERG\ZRXOGFRPHDIWHUWKHPGLUHFWO\7KH\
    ZRXOGIL[WKHLPPHUVLRQDSSDUDWXVZKHUHWKHUHDOSUREOHPZDV
    7+(<.((386+(5(.,//3$167+$7.,//686%/$0(21$1,0$/6"
    +HKDGEHWWHUDUJXPHQWVWREDFNXSKLVFDVH7KHVORZDFFXPXODWLRQRI
    VPDOOGHWDLOVLQ9DGGRVEHKDYLRU6XVSLFLRQVDWOHDVWDERXWWKHVHFXULW\
    RIILFHU'RUVWLNWRNZRXOGEORFNWKHRIILFHUIURPRYHUULGLQJWKHORFNVRQ
    WKHLULPPHUVLRQFDSVXOHVDQGIURPWUDFLQJWKHFDSVXOHVVLJQDOWR,SDQDQG
    6KHHODK
    6RWKH\ZHUHIRUFHGWRJRLQWRWKHILHOG/HWWLQJWKHPGLHLQDQ
    DFFLGHQWZKLOHLPPHUVHGLQDSDQPLJKWMXVWEHSODXVLEOHHQRXJKWRHVFDSHDQ
    LQYHVWLJDWLRQ
    7KHKXPDQVZHQWDERXWWKHLUQRLV\EXVLQHVV7KH\ZHUHHQRXJKWKRXJKWR

    PDNHKLVFDVH6KHHODKVH\HVQDUURZHGWKHELJEURZVFRZOHG
    'RUVWKH'HIHQGHUWRRNRYHU:KHUH"6KHHODKVLJQHG
    +HKDGQRVLJQIRUVRDEVWUDFWDQLGHDVRKHVFULEEOHGZLWKWKHVWLFN
    $:$<,QGHHGKHKDGQRSODQ
    ,//&+(&.VKHZURWHLQWKHGLUW
    6KHVHWRIIWRZDUGWKHQRLVHRIKXPDQVGHSOR\LQJRQWKHYDOOH\IORRU
    EHORZ7RDSDQWKHGLQZDVDGUHDGIXOFODQNLQJLUULWDWLRQ+DULZDVQRWJRLQJ
    WROHWKHURXWRIKLVVLJKW6KHZDYHGKLPEDFNEXWKHVKRRNKLVKHDGDQG
    IROORZHG
    7KHEXVKHVJDYHVKHOWHUDVWKH\JRWDYLHZRIWKHODQGLQJSDUW\EHORZ$
    VNLUPLVKOLQHZDVIRUPLQJXSDIHZKXQGUHGPHWHUVDZD\7KH\ZHUHHQFLUFOLQJ
    WKHDUHDZKHUHWKHWURRSKDGEHHQ:K\"
    +DULVTXLQWHG3DQH\HVLJKWZDVQRWJRRGIRUGLVWDQFH+XPDQVKDGEHHQ
    KXQWHUVRQFHDQGRQHFRXOGWHOOE\WKHH\HVDORQH
    1RZQHDUO\HYHU\ERG\QHHGHGDUWLILFLDOH\HDGGVE\WKHDJHRIIRUW\
    (LWKHUFLYLOL]DWLRQZDVKDUGRQH\HVRUPD\EHKXPDQVLQSUHKLVWRU\KDGQRW
    OLYHGORQJHQRXJKIRUH\HWURXEOHWRUREWKHPRIJDPH(LWKHUFRQFOXVLRQZDV
    VREHULQJ
    7KHWZRSDQVZDWFKHGWKHKXPDQVFDOOLQJWRRQHDQRWKHUDQGLQWKH
    PLGGOHRIWKHP+DULVDZ9DGGR(DFKPDQDQGZRPDQFDUULHGDZHDSRQ
    %HQHDWKKLVIHDUKHIHOWVRPHWKLQJVWURQJGDUN
    ,SDQWUHPEOHGZDWFKLQJWKHKXPDQVDVWUDQJHDZH VZHOOLQJLQKLVPLQG
    +XPDQVVHHPHGLPSRVVLEO\WDOOLQWKHVKLPPHULQJGLVWDQFHPRYLQJZLWKVWDWHO\
    VZD\LQJHOHJDQFH
    +DULIORDWHGDERYHWKHVXUJHRIHPRWLRQIHQGLQJRIILWVSRZHUIXO
    HIIHFWV7KHUHYHUHQFHIRUWKRVHGLVWDQWWDOOILJXUHVFDPHRXWRIWKHSDQV
    GLPSDVW
    7KDWVXUSULVHGKLPXQWLOKHWKRXJKWLWRYHU$IWHUDOODQLPDOVZHUH
    UHDUHGDQGWDXJKWE\DGXOWVPXFKVPDUWHUDQGVWURQJHU0RVWVSHFLHVZHUHOLNH
    SDQVVSULQJORDGHGE\HYROXWLRQWRZRUNLQDGRPLQDQFHKLHUDUFK\$ZHZDV
    DGDSWLYH
    :KHQWKH\PHWORIW\KXPDQVZLWKRYHUZKHOPLQJSRZHUDEOHWRPHWHRXW
    SXQLVKPHQWDQGUHZDUGVOLWHUDOO\OLIHDQGGHDWKVRPHWKLQJOLNHUHOLJLRXV
    IHUYRUDURVHLQWKHP)X]]\EXWVWURQJ
    $WRSWKDWZDUPWURSLFDOHPRWLRQIORDWHGDVHQVHRIVDWLVIDFWLRQDW
    VLPSO\EHLQJ+LVSDQZDVKDSS\WREHDSDQHYHQZKHQVHHLQJDEHLQJRI
    FOHDUO\VXSHULRUSRZHUDQGWKRXJKW,URQLF+DULWKRXJKW
    +LVSDQKDGMXVWGLVSURYHGDQRWKHUVXSSRVHGO\KXPDQHDUPDUNWKHLUVHOI
    FRQJUDWXODWRU\GLVWLQFWLRQRIEHLQJWKHRQO\DQLPDOWKDWFRQJUDWXODWHGLWVHOI
    +HMHUNHGKLPVHOIRXWRIKLVDEVWUDFWLRQV+RZKXPDQWRUXPLQDWHHYHQ
    ZKHQLQPRUWDOGDQJHU
    &$17),1'86(/(&7521,&$//<KHVFUDWFKHGLQWKHVDQG
    0$<%(5$1*(6+257VKHZURWH
    7KHILUVWVKRWVPDGHWKHPMHUN
    7KHKXPDQVKDGIRXQGWKHLUSDQWURRS&ULHVRIIHDUPLQJOHGZLWKWKH
    VKDUSKDUVKEDUNVRIEODVWHUV
    *R:HJRKHVLJQHG
    6KHHODKQRGGHGDQGWKH\FUHSWTXLFNO\DZD\,SDQWUHPEOHG
    7KHSDQZDVGHHSO\DIUDLG<HWKHZDVDOVRVDGDVLIUHOXFWDQWWROHDYH
    WKH SUHVHQFHRIWKHUHYHUHGKXPDQVKLVVWHSVGUDJJLQJ
    

    7KH\XVHGSDQPRGHVRISDWUROOLQJ
    +HDQG'RUVOHWWKHLUEDVLFOHYHOVWDNHRYHUSRUWLRQVRIWKHEUDLQ
    H[SHUWDWVLOHQWPRYHPHQWFDUHIXORIHYHU\WZLJ
    2QFHWKH\KDGOHIWWKHKXPDQVEHKLQGWKHSDQVJUHZHYHQPRUHFDXWLRXV

    7KH\KDGIHZQDWXUDOHQHPLHVEXWWKHIDLQWVFHQWRIDVLQJOHSUHGDWRUFKDQJHG
    WKHIHHORIWKHZLOG
    ,SDQFOLPEHGWDOOWUHHVDQGVDWIRUKRXUVVXUYH\LQJWKHRSHQODQGDKHDG
    EHIRUHYHQWXULQJIRUWK+HZHLJKHGWKHHYLGHQFHRISXQJHQWGURSSLQJVIDLQW
    SULQWVEHQWEUDQFKHV
    7KH\DQJOHGGRZQWKHORQJVORSHRIWKHYDOOH\DQGVWD\HGLQWKHIRUHVW
    +DULKDGRQO\JODQFHGDWWKHELJFRORUFRGHGPDSRIWKHDUHDDOOJXHVWV
    UHFHLYHGDQGKDGWURXEOHUHFDOOLQJPXFKRILW
    )LQDOO\KHUHFRJQL]HGRQHRIWKHGLVWDQWEHDNVKDSHGSHDNV+DULJRW
    KLVEHDULQJV'RUVVSRWWHGDVWUHDPVQDNLQJGRZQLQWRWKHPDLQULYHUDQGWKDW
    JDYHWKHPIXUWKHUKHOSEXWVWLOOWKH\GLGQRWNQRZZKLFKZD\OD\WKH
    ([FXUVLRQ 6WDWLRQ2UKRZIDU
    7KDWZD\"+DULVLJQHGSRLQWLQJRYHUWKHGLVWDQWULGJH
    1R7KDW'RUVLQVLVWHG
    )DUQRW
    :K\"
    7KHZRUVWSDUWRILWDOOZDVWKDWWKH\FRXOGQRWWDON+HFRXOGQRWVD\
    FOHDUO\WKDWWKHWHFKQRORJ\RILPPHUVLRQZRUNHGEHVWDWUHDVRQDEO\VKRUW
    UDQJHOHVVWKDQDKXQGUHGNOLFNVVD\$QGLWPDGHVHQVHWRNHHSWKHVXEMHFW
    SDQVZLWKLQHDV\IO\HUGLVWDQFH&HUWDLQO\9DGGRDQGWKHRWKHUVKDGJRWWHQWR
    WKHWURRSTXLFNO\
    ,VKHSHUVLVWHG
    1RW6KHSRLQWHGGRZQWKHYDOOH\0D\EHWKHUH
    +HFRXOGRQO\KRSH'RUVJRWWKHJHQHUDOLGHD7KHLUVLJQVZHUHVFDQW\
    DQGKHEHJDQWRIHHODEURDGULVLQJLUULWDWLRQ3DQVIHOWDQGVHQVHG
    VWURQJO\EXWWKH\ZHUHVROLPLWHG
    ,SDQH[SUHVVHGWKLVE\WRVVLQJOLPEVDQGVWRQHVEDQJLQJRQWUHHWUXQNV
    ,WGLGQWKHOSPXFK7KHQHHGWRVSHDNZDVOLNHDSUHVVXUHKHFRXOGQRW
    UHOLHYH'RUVIHOWLWWRR6KHHODKFKLSSHUHGDQGJUXQWHGLQIUXVWUDWLRQ
    %HQHDWKKLVPLQGKHIHOWWKHVPROGHULQJSUHVHQFHRI,SDQ7KH\KDGQHYHU
    EHHQWRJHWKHUWKLVORQJEHIRUHDQGXUJHQF\ZHOOHGXSEHWZHHQWKHWZRFDQWHG
    V\VWHPVRIPLQG7KHLUXQHDV\PDUULDJHZDVVKRZLQJJUHDWHUVWUDLQV
    6LW4XLHW6KHGLG+HFXSSHGDKDQGWRKLVHDU
    %DGFRPH"
    1R/LVWHQ,QIUXVWUDWLRQ+DULSRLQWHGWR6KHHODKKHUVHOI%ODQN
    LQFRPSUHKHQVLRQLQWKHSDQVIDFH+HVFULEEOHGLQWKHGXVW/($51)5203$16
    6KHHODKVPRXWKRSHQHGDQGVKHQRGGHG
    7KH\VTXDWWHGLQWKHVKHOWHURISULFNO\EXVKHVDQGOLVWHQHGWRWKH
    VRXQGVRIWKHIRUHVW6FXUU\LQJVDQGPXUPXUVFDPHWKURXJKVWURQJO\DV+DUL
    UHOD[HGKLVJULSRQWKHSDQ'XVWKXQJLQVODQWHGFDWKHGUDOOLJKWSRXULQJ
    GRZQIURPWKHIRUHVWFDQRS\LQULFK\HOORZVKDIWV6FHQWVSXUOHGXSIURPWKH
    IRUHVWIORRUFKHPLFDOPHVVHQJHUVWHOOLQJ,SDQRISRWHQWLDOIRRGVVRIWORDP
    IRUUHVWLQJEDUNWREHFKHZHG+DULJHQWO\OLIWHG,SDQVKHDGWRJD]HDFURVV
    WKHYDOOH\DWWKHSHDNVPXVLQJDQGIHOWDIDLQWWUHPRURIUHVRQDQFH
    7R,SDQWKHYDOOH\FDPHZHLJKWHGZLWKVLJQLILFDQFHEH\RQGZRUGV+LV
    WURRSKDGLPEXHGLWZLWKEOXQWHPRWLRQVDWWDFKHGWRFOHIWVZKHUHDIULHQG
    IHOODQGGLHGZKHUHWKHWURRSIRXQGDKRDUGRIIUXLWVZKHUHWKH\PHWDQG
    IRXJKWWZRELJFDWV,WZDVDQLQWULFDWHODQGVFDSHVXIIXVHGZLWKIHHOLQJWKH
    SDQPHFKDQLVPRIPHPRU\
    +DULIDLQWO\XUJHG,SDQWRWKLQNEH\RQGWKHULGJHOLQHDQGIHOWLQ
    UHVSRQVHDGLIIXVHDQ[LHW\+HERUHLQRQWKDWNHUQHODQGDQLPDJHEXUVWLQWR
    ,SDQVPLQGIULQJHGLQIHDU$UHFWDQJXODUEXONIUDPHGDJDLQVWDFRROVN\
    7KH([FXUVLRQ6WDWLRQ
    7KHUH+HSRLQWHGIRU'RUV
    ,SDQKDGVLPSOHVWURQJDSSUHKHQVLYHPHPRULHVRIWKHSODFH+LVWURRS
    KDGEHHQWDNHQWKHUHRXWILWWHGZLWKWKHLPSODQWVZKLFKDOORZHGWKHPWREH
    ULGGHQWKHQGHSRVLWHGEDFNLQWKHLUWHUULWRU\

    )DU'RUVVLJQHG
    :HJR
    +DUG6ORZ
    1RVWD\KHUH7KH\FDWFK
    'RUVORRNHGDVVNHSWLFDODVDSDQFRXOGORRN)LJKW"
    'LGVKHPHDQILJKW9DGGRKHUH"2UILJKWRQFHWKH\UHDFKHGWKH([FXUVLRQ
    6WDWLRQ"1RKHUH7KHUH
    'RUVIURZQHGEXWDFFHSWHGWKLV+HKDGQRUHDOSODQRQO\WKHLGHDWKDW
    9DGGRZDVUHDG\IRUSDQVRXWKHUHDQGPLJKWQRWEHVRSUHSDUHGIRUWKHPDWWKH
    VWDWLRQ7KHUHKHDQG'RUVPLJKWJDLQWKHHOHPHQWRIVXUSULVH+RZKHKDGQR
    LGHD
    7KH\VWXGLHGHDFKRWKHUHDFKWU\LQJWRFDWFKDJOLPPHURIWKHRWKHULQ
    DQDOLHQIDFH6KHVWURNHGKLVHDUOREH'RUVFDOPLQJJHVWXUH6XUHHQRXJKLW
    PDGHKLPWLQJOH%XWKHFRXOGVD\VROLWWOH7KHPRPHQWFU\VWDOOL]HGIRUKLP
    WKHKRSHOHVVQHVVRIWKHLUVLWXDWLRQ
    9DGGR SODLQO\ZDVWU\LQJWRNLOO+DULDQG'RUVWKURXJK,SDQDQG6KHHODK
    :KDWZRXOGEHFRPHRIWKHLURZQERGLHV"7KHVKRFNRIH[SHULHQFLQJGHDWKWKURXJK
    LPPHUVLRQZDVNQRZQWRSURYHIDWDO7KHLUERGLHVZRXOGIDLOIURPQHXURORJLFDO
    VKRFNZLWKRXWHYHUUHJDLQLQJFRQVFLRXVQHVV
    +HVDZDWHDUUXQGRZQ6KHHODKVFKHHN6KHNQHZKRZKRSHOHVVPDWWHUV
    ZHUHWRR+HVZHSWKHUXSLQKLVDUPVDQGORRNLQJDWWKHGLVWDQWPRXQWDLQV
    ZDVVXUSULVHGWRILQGWHDUVLQKLVRZQH\HVDVZHOO
    

    +HKDGQRWFRXQWHGRQWKHULYHU0HQDQLPDOVWKHVHSUREOHPVKHKDG
    FRQVLGHUHG7KH\YHQWXUHGGRZQWRWKHVXUJLQJZDWHUVZKHUHWKHIRUHVWJDYHWKH
    QHDUHVWSURWHFWLRQDQGWKHVWUHDPEURDGHQHGPDNLQJWKHEHVWSODFHWRIRUG
    %XWWKHKHDUW\ULYHUWKDWFKXFNOHGDQGIURWKHGGRZQWKHYDOOH\ZDV
    LPSRVVLEOHWRVZLP
    2UUDWKHUIRU,SDQWRVZLP+DULKDGEHHQFRD[LQJKLVSDQRQZDUG
    FDUHIXOO\SDXVLQJZKHQKLVPXVFOHVVKRRNRUZKHQKHZHWKLPVHOIIURPDQ[LHW\
    'RUVZDVKDYLQJVLPLODUWURXEOHDQGLWVORZHGWKHP$QLJKWVSHQWXSLQKLJK
    EUDQFKHVVRRWKHGERWKSDQVEXWQRZDWPLGPRPLQJDOOWKHVWUHVVIXOV\PSWRPV
    UHWXUQHGDV,SDQSXWRQHIRRWLQWRWKHULYHU&RROVZLIWFXUUHQWV
    ,SDQGDQFHGEDFNRQWRWKHQDUURZEHDFK\HOSLQJLQGUHDG
    *R"'RUV6KHHODKVLJQHG
    +DULFDOPHGKLVSDQDQGWKH\WULHGWRJHWLWWRDWWHPSWVZLPPLQJ
    6KHHODKGLVSOD\HGRQO\PLQRUDQ[LHW\+DULSOXPEHGWKHVZDPS\GHSWKVRI,SDQV
    PHPRU\DQGIRXQGDFOXVWHURIGLVWUHVVFHQWHUHGDURXQGDGLPUHPHPEUDQFHRI
    QHDUO\GURZQLQJZKHQDFKLOG:KHQ6KHHODKKHOSHGKLPKHILGJHWHGWKHQ
    EROWHGIURPWKHZDWHUDJDLQ
    *R6KHHODKZDYHGORQJDUPVXSVWUHDPDQGGRZQVWUHDPDQGVKRRNKHUKHDG
    DQJULO\
    +DULJXHVVHGWKDWVKHKDGUHDVRQDEO\FOHDUSDQPHPRULHVRIWKHULYHU
    ZKLFKKDGQRHDVLHUFURVVLQJVWKDQWKLV+HVKUXJJHGOLIWHGKLVKDQGVSDOP
    XS
    $ELJKHUGRIJLJDQWHORSHJUD]HGQHDUE\DQGVRPHZHUHFURVVLQJWKHULYHU
    IRUEHWWHUJUDVVEH\RQG7KH\WRVVHGWKHLUJUHDWKHDGVDVLIPRFNLQJWKH
    SDQV7KHULYHUZDVQRWGHHSEXWWR,SDQLWZDVDZDOO+DULWUDSSHGE\
    ,SDQVVROLGIHDUVHHWKHGEXWFRXOGGRQRWKLQJ
    6KHHODKSDFHGWKHVKRUH6KHKXIIHGLQIUXVWUDWLRQDQGORRNHGDWWKH
    VN\VTXLQWLQJ+HUKHDGVQDSSHGDURXQGLQVXUSULVH+DULIROORZHGKHUJD]H$
    IO\HUZDVVZRRSLQJGRZQWKHYDOOH\FRPLQJWKHLUZD\
    ,SDQEHDW6KHHODK WRWKHVKHOWHURIWUHHVEXWQRWE\PXFK/XFNLO\WKH
    JLJDQWHORSHKHUGSURYLGHGDGLVWUDFWLRQIRUWKHIO\HU7KH\FRZHUHGLQEXVKHV
    DVWKHPDFKLQHKXPPHGRYHUKHDGLQDFLUFXODUVHDUFKSDWWHUQ+DULKDGWRTXHOO

    ,SDQVPRXQWLQJDSSUHKHQVLRQE\HQYLVLRQLQJVFHQHVRITXLHWDQGSHDFHZKLOHKH
    DQG6KHHODKJURRPHGHDFKRWKHU
    7KHIO\HUILQDOO\ZHQWDZD\7KH\ZRXOGKDYHWRPLQLPL]HWKHLUH[SRVXUH
    QRZ
    7KH\IRUDJHGIRUIUXLW+LVPLQGUHYROYHGXVHOHVVO\DQGDVRXU
    GHSUHVVLRQVHWWOHGRYHUKLP+HZDVTXLWHQHDWO\FDXJKWLQDWUDSDSDZQLQ
    ,PSHULDOSROLWLFV:RUVH'RUVZDVLQLWWRR+HZDVQRPDQRIDFWLRQ1RUD
    SDQRIDFWLRQHLWKHUKHWKRXJKWGRXUO\
    $VKHEURXJKWDIHZRYHUULSHEXQFKHVRIIUXLWEDFNWRWKHLUEXVKHVE\
    WKHULYHUKHKHDUGFUDFNLQJQRLVHV+HFURXFKHGGRZQDQGZRUNHGKLVZD\
    XSKLOODQGDURXQGWKHVSOLQWHULQJVRXQGV6KHHODKZDVVWULSSLQJEUDQFKHVIURP
    WKHWUHHV:KHQKHDSSURDFKHGVKHZDYHGKLPRQLPSDWLHQWO\DFRPPRQSDQ
    JHVWXUHUHPDUNDEO\OLNHDKXPDQRQH
    6KHKDGDGR]HQWKLFNEUDQFKHVOLQHGXSRQWKHJURXQG6KHZHQWWRD
    QHDUE\VSLQGO\WUHHDQGSHHOHGEDUNIURPLWLQORQJVWULSV7KHQRLVHPDGH
    ,SDQXQHDV\3UHGDWRUVZRXOGEHFXULRXVDWWKLVXQXVXDOVRXQG+HVFDQQHGWKH
    IRUHVWIRUGDQJHU
    6KHHODKFDPHRYHUWRKLPVODSSHGKLPLQWKHIDFHWRJHWKLVDWWHQWLRQ
    6KHZURWHZLWKDVWLFNRQWKHJURXQG5$)7
    +DULIHOWSDUWLFXODUO\GHQVHDVKHSLWFKHGLQ2IFRXUVH+DGKLVSDQ
    LPPHUVLRQPDGHKLPPRUHVWXSLG"'LGWKHHIIHFWZRUVHQZLWKWLPH"(YHQLIKH
    JRWRXWRIWKLVZRXOGKHEHWKHVDPH"0DQ\TXHVWLRQVQRDQVZHUV+HIRUJRW
    DERXWWKHPDQGZRUNHG
    7KH\ODVKHGEUDQFKHVWRJHWKHUZLWKEDUNFUXGHEXWVHUYLFHDEOH7KH\
    IRXQGWZRVPDOOIDOOHQWUHHVDQGXVHGWKHPWRDQFKRUWKHHGJHRIWKHUDIW,
    6KHHODKSRLQWHGDQGGHPRQVWUDWHGSXOOLQJWKHUDIW
    )LUVWDZDUPXS,SDQOLNHGVLWWLQJRQWKHUDIWLQWKHEXVKHV
    $SSDUHQWO\WKHSDQFRXOGQRWVHHWKHSXUSRVHRIWKHUDIW\HW,SDQVWUHWFKHG
    RXWRQWKHGHFNRIVDSOLQJVDQGJD]HGXSLQWRWKHWUHHVDVWKH\VZLVKHGLQWKH
    ZDUPZLQGV
    7KH\FDUULHGWKHDZNZDUGSODQHRIEUDQFKHVGRZQWRWKHULYHUDIWHU
    DQRWKHUPXWXDOJURRPLQJVHVVLRQ7KHVN\ZDVILOOHGZLWKELUGVEXWKHFRXOG
    VHHQRIO\HUV
    7KH\KXUULHG,SDQZDVVNHSWLFDODERXWVWHSSLQJRQWRWKHUDIWZKHQLW
    ZDVKDOIZD\LQWRWKHZDWHUEXW+DULFDOOHGXSPHPRULHVILOOHGZLWKZDUP
    IHHOLQJDQGWKLVFDOPHGWKHTXLFNWULSSLQJKHDUWKHFRXOGIHHONQRFNLQJLQ
    WKHSDQVFKHVW
    ,SDQVDWJLQJHUO\RQWKHEUDQFKHV6KHHODKFDVWRII
    6KHSXVKHGKDUGEXWWKHULYHUVZHSWWKHPTXLFNO\GRZQVWUHDP$ODUP
    VSXUWHGLQ,SDQ
    +DULPDGH,SDQFORVHKLVH\HV7KDWVORZHGWKHEUHDWKLQJEXWDQ[LHW\
    VNLWWHUHGDFURVVWKHSDQPLQGOLNHKHDWOLJKWQLQJIRUNLQJEHIRUHDVWRUP7KH
    UDIWVURFNLQJPRWLRQ DFWXDOO\KHOSHGPDNLQJ,SDQFRQFHQWUDWHRQKLVTXHDV\
    VWRPDFK2QFHKLVH\HVIOHZRSHQZKHQDIORDWLQJORJVPDFNHGLQWRWKHUDIW
    EXWWKHGL]]\LQJVLJKWRIZDWHUDOODURXQGPDGHKLPVTXHH]HWKHPWLJKW
    LPPHGLDWHO\
    +DULZDQWHGWRKHOSKHUEXWKHNQHZIURPWKHWULSKDPPHUEHDWLQJRI
    ,SDQVKHDUWWKDWSDQLFKRYHUHGQHDU+HFRXOGQRWHYHQVHHKRZVKHZDVGRLQJ
    +HKDGWRVLWEOLQGDQGIHHOKHUVKRYLQJWKHUDIWDORQJ
    6KHSDQWHGQRLVLO\VWUXJJOLQJWRNHHSLWSRLQWHGDJDLQVWWKHULYHUV
    WXJ6SUD\VSODVKHGRQWRKLP,SDQMHUNHG\HOSHGSDZHGDQ[LRXVO\ZLWKKLV
    IHHWDVLIWRUXQ
    $VXGGHQOXUFK6KHHODKVJUXQWFXWRIIZLWKDJXUJOHDQGKHIHOWWKH
    UDIWVSLQDZD\RQULVLQJFXUUHQWV$VLFNHQLQJVSLQ
    ,SDQMHUNHGFOXPVLO\WRKLVIHHW(\HVMXPSHGRSHQ
    6ZLUOLQJZDWHUWKHUDIWXQVWHDG\+HORRNHGGRZQDQGWKHEUDQFKHVZHUH
    FRPLQJDSDUW3DQLFFRQVXPHGKLP+DULWULHGWRSURPRWHVRRWKLQJLPDJHVEXW

    WKH\EOHZDZD\EHIRUHZLQGVRIIULJKW
    6KHHODKFDPHSDGGOLQJDIWHUWKHUDIWEXWLWZDVSLFNLQJXSVSHHG+DUL
    PDGH,SDQJD]HDWWKHIDUVKRUHEXWWKDWZDVDOOKHFRXOGGREHIRUHWKHSDQ
    VWDUWHG\HOSLQJDQGVFDPSHULQJRQWKHUDIWWU\LQJWRILQGDVWHDG\SODFH
    ,WZDVQRXVH7KHEUDQFKHVEURNHIUHHRIWKHLUELQGLQJVDQGFKLOO\
    ZDWHUVZHSWRYHUWKHGHFN,SDQVFUHDPHG+HOHDSHGIHOOUROOHGMXPSHGXS
    DJDLQ
    +DULJDYHXSDQ\LGHDRIFRQWURO7KHRQO\KRSHOD\LQVHL]LQJMXVWWKH
    ULJKWPRPHQW7KHUDIWVSOLWGRZQWKHPLGGOHDQGKLVKDOIYHHUHGKHDYLO\WR
    WKHOHIW,SDQVWDUWHGDZD\IURPWKHHGJHDQG+DULIHGWKDWPDGHWKHSDQVWHS
    IDUWKHU,QWZRERXQGVKHWRRNWKHSDQRIIWKHGHFNDQGLQWRWKHZDWHUWRZDUG
    WKHIDUVKRUH
    ,SDQJDYHZD\WKHQWRSXUHEOLQGSDQLF+DULOHWWKHOHJVDQGDUPV
    WKUDVKEXWWRHDFKKHJDYHDSXVKDWWKHULJKWPRPHQW+H FRXOGVZLP,SDQ
    FRXOGQW
    7KHQHDUDLPOHVVIODLOLQJKHOG,SDQVKHDGRXWRIZDWHUPRVWRIWKH
    WLPH+HHYHQJDLQHGDOLWWOHKHDGZD\+DULNHSWIRFXVHGRQWKHFRQYXOVLYH
    PRYHPHQWVLJQRULQJWKHFROGZDWHUDQGWKHQ6KHHODKZDVWKHUH
    6KHJUDEEHGKLPE\WKHVFUXIIRIWKHQHFNDQGVKRYHGKLPWRZDUGVKRUH
    ,SDQWULHGWRJUDSSOHZLWKKHUFOLPEXSKHU6KHHODKVRFNHGKLPLQWKHMDZ
    +HJDVSHG6KHSXOOHGKLPWRZDUGVKRUH
    ,SDQZDVVWXQQHG7KLVJDYH+DULDFKDQFHWRJHWWKHOHJVPRYLQJLQD
    WKUXVWLQJVWURNH+HZRUNHGDWLWVLQJOHPLQGHGDPRQJWKHUXVKDQGJXUJOH
    FKHVWKHDYLQJDQGDIWHUDVHHPLQJHWHUQLW\IHOWSHEEOHVEHQHDWKKLVIHHW
    ,SDQVFUDPEOHGXSRQWRWKHURFN\EHDFKRQKLVRZQ
    +HOHWWKHSDQVODSKLPVHOIDQGGDQFHWRZDUPXS6KHHODKHPHUJHG
    GULSSLQJDQGEHGUDJJOHGDQG,SDQVZHSWKHUXSLQKLVWKDQNIXODUPV
    

    :DONLQJZDVZRUNDQG,SDQZDVQWKDYLQJDQ\
    +DULWULHGWRPDNHWKHSDQFRYHUJURXQGEXWQRZWKH\KDGWRDVFHQG
    GLIILFXOWJXOOLHVVRPHPRVV\DQGURXJK7KH\VWXPEOHGZDGHGFOLPEHGDQG
    VRPHWLPHVMXVWFUDZOHGXSWKHVORSHVRIWKHYDOOH\7KHSDQVVQLIIHGRXW
    DQLPDOWUDLOVZKLFKKHOSHGDELW
    ,SDQVWRSSHGRIWHQIRUIRRGRUMXVWWRJD]HLGO\LQWRWKHGLVWDQFH
    6RIWWKRXJKWVIOLWWHGOLNHPRWKVWKURXJKWKHIRJJ\PLQGEXR\DQWRQOLTXLG
    HPRWLRQDOIORZVZKLFKHGGLHGWRWKHLURZQSXOVH3DQVZHUHQRWPDGHIRU
    H[WHQGHGSURMHFWV
    7KH\PDGHVORZSURJUHVV1LJKWFDPHDQGWKH\KDGWRFOLPEWUHHV
    VQDJJLQJIUXLWRQWKHZD\
    ,SDQVOHSWEXW+DULGLGQRW&RXOGQRW
    7KHLUOLYHVZHUHMXVWDVPXFKDWULVNKHUHDVWKHSDQVEXWWKH
    VOXPEHULQJPLQGVKHDQG'RUVDWWHQGHGKDGDOZD\VOLYHGWKLVZD\7RWKHSDQV
    WKHIRUHVWQLJKWVHHSHGWKURXJKDVDTXLHWUDLQRILQIRUPDWLRQSURFHVVHGDV
    WKH\VOHSW7KHLUPLQGVNH\HGYDJUDQWVRXQGVWRNQRZQQRQWKUHDWVOHDYLQJ
    VOXPEHULQWDFW
    +DULGLGQRWNQRZWKHVXEWOHVLJQVRIGDQJHUDQGVRPLVWRRNHYHU\UXVWOH
    DQGWUHPRULQWKHEUDQFKHVDVGDQJHUDSSURDFKLQJRQVRIWIHHW6OHHSFDPH
    DJDLQVWKLVZLOO
    ,QGDZQVILUVWSDOHJORZ+DULDZRNHZLWKDVQDNHEHVLGHKLP,WFRLOHG
    OLNHDJUHHQURSHDURXQGDGHVFHQGLQJEUDQFKJHWWLQJLWVHOILQWRVWULNLQJ
    SRVLWLRQ,WH\HGKLPDQG+DULWHQVHG
    ,SDQGULIWHGXSIURPKLVRZQSURIRXQGVOXPEHU+HVDZWKHVQDNHEXWGLG
    QRWUHDFWZLWKDVWDUWOHGMHUNDV+DULIHDUHGKHPLJKW
    $ORQJPRPHQWSDVVHGEHWZHHQWKHPDQG,SDQEOLQNHGMXVWRQFH7KHVQDNH
    EHFDPHXWWHUO\PRWLRQOHVVDQG,SDQVKHDUWTXLFNHQHGEXWKHGLGQRWPRYH

    7KHQWKHVQDNHXQFRLOHGDQGJOLGHGDZD\DQGWKHXQVSRNHQWUDQVDFWLRQZDV
    GRQH,SDQZDVXQOLNHO\SUH\WKLVJUHHQVQDNHGLGQRWWDVWHJRRGDQGSDQV
    ZHUHVPDUWHQRXJKWREHDERXWRWKHUEXVLQHVV
    :KHQ6KHHODKDZRNH WKH\ZHQWGRZQWRDQHDUE\FKXFNOLQJVWUHDPIRUD
    GULQNVFDYHQJLQJOHDYHVDQGDIHZFUXQFK\LQVHFWVRQWKHZD\%RWKSDQV
    QRQFKDODQWO\SHHOHGDZD\IDWEODFNODQGOHHFKHVZKLFKKDGDWWDFKHGWRWKHPLQ
    WKHQLJKW7KHWKLFNHQJRUJHGZRUPVVLFNHQHG+DULEXW,SDQSXOOHGWKHPRII
    FDVXDOO\PXFKWKHZD\+DULZRXOGKDYHUHWLHGORRVHQHGVKRHODFHV
    /XFNLO\,SDQGLGQRWHDWWKHP+HGUDQNDQG+DULUHIOHFWHGWKDWWKHSDQ
    IHOWQRQHHGWRFOHDQKLPVHOI1RUPDOO\+DULYDSRUHGWZLFHDGD\EHIRUH
    EUHDNIDVWDQGEHIRUHGLQQHUDQGIHOWLOODWHDVHLIKHVZHDWHGDW\SLFDO
    PHULWRFUDW
    +HUHKHZRUHWKHVKDJJ\ERG\FRPIRUWDEO\+DGKLVIUHTXHQWFOHDQVLQJV
    EHHQDKHDOWKPHDVXUHOLNHWKHSDQVJURRPLQJ"2UDUDUHILHGFLYLOL]HG
    KDELW"+HGLPO\UHPHPEHUHGWKDWDVDER\RQ +HOLFRQKHKDGJRQHIRUGD\VLQ
    KDSS\VZHDW\SOHDVXUHDQGKDGGLVOLNHGEDWKVDQGVKRZHUV6RPHKRZ,SDQ
    UHWXUQHGKLPWRDVLPSOHUVHQVHRIVHOIDWHDVHLQWKHJUXEE\ZRUOG
    +LVFRPIRUWGLGQRWODVWORQJ7KH\VLJKWHGUDERRQVXSKLOO
    ,SDQKDGSLFNHGXSWKHVFHQWEXW+DULGLGQRWKDYHDFFHVVWRWKHSDUW
    RIWKHSDQEUDLQWKDWPDGHVFHQWSLFWXUHDVVRFLDWLRQV+HKDGRQO\NQRZQWKDW
    VRPHWKLQJGLVWXUEHG,SDQZULQNOLQJWKHNQREE\QRVH7KHVLJKWDWVKRUWUDQJH
    MROWHGKLP
    7KLFNKLQGTXDUWHUVSURSHOOLQJWKHPLQEULVNVWHSV6KRUWIRUHOLPEV
    HQGLQJLQVKDUSFODZV7KHLUODUJHKHDGVVHHPHGWREHPRVWO\WHHWKVKDUSDQG
    ZKLWHDERYHVOLWWHGZDU\H\HV$WKLFNEURZQSHOWFRYHUHGWKHPJURZLQJ
    EXVK\LQWKHKHDY\WDLOWKH\XVHGIRUEDODQFH
    'D\VEHIRUHIURPWKHVDIHW\RIDKLJKWUHH,SDQKDGZDWFKHGVRPHULS
    DQGGHYRXUWKHVRIWWLVVXHVRIDJLJDQWHORSHRXWRQWKHJUDVVODQGV7KHVHFDPH
    VQLIILQJZRUNLQJGRZQVORSHLQDVNLUPLVKOLQHILYHRIWKHP6KHHODKDQG,SDQ
    WUHPEOHGDWWKHVLJKW7KH\ZHUHGRZQZLQGRIWKHUDERRQVDQGVREHDWDUHWUHDW
    LQVLOHQFH
    7KHUHZHUHQRWDOOWUHHVKHUHMXVWEUXVKDQGVDSOLQJV+DULDQG6KHHODK
    DQJOHGDZD\GRZQKLOODQGJRWVRPHGLVWDQFHDQGWKHQVDZDFOHDULQJDKHDG
    ,SDQSLFNHGXSWKHIDLQWWDQJRIRWKHUSDQVZDIWLQJIURPDFURVVWKHFOHDULQJ
    +HZDYHGWRKHU*R$WWKHVDPHPRPHQWDFKRUXVURVHEHKLQGWKHP7KH
    UDERRQVKDGFDXJKWWKHVFHQW
    7KHLUZKHH]LQJJUXQWVFDPHHFKRLQJWKURXJKWKHWKLFNEXVKHV'RZQVORSH
    WKHUHZDVHYHQOHVVFRYHUEXWELJJHUWUHHVOD\EH\RQG7KH\FRXOGFOLPE
    WKRVH
    ,SDQDQG6KHHODKKXUULHGDFURVVWKHEURDGWDQFOHDULQJRQDOOIRXUVEXW
    WKH\ZHUHQRWTXLFN6QDUOLQJUDERRQVEXUVWLQWRWKHJUDVVEHKLQGWKHP+DUL
    VFDPSHUHGLQWRWKHWUHHVDQGGLUHFWO\LQWRWKHPLGVWRIDSDQWURRS
    7KHUHZHUHVHYHUDOGR]HQVWDUWOHGDQGEOLQNLQJ+H\HOOHGLQFRKHUHQWO\
    ZRQGHULQJKRZ,SDQZRXOGVLJQDOWRWKHP
    7KHQHDUHVWODUJHPDOHWXUQHGEDUHGWHHWKDQGVKULHNHGDQJULO\7KH
    HQWLUHSDFNWRRNXSWKHFDOOZKRRSLQJDQGVQDWFKLQJXSVWLFNVDQGURFNV
    WKURZLQJWKHPDW,SDQ$SHEEOHKLWKLPRQWKHFKLQDEUDQFKRQWKHWKLJK+H
    IOHG6KHHODKDOUHDG\DIHZVWHSVDKHDGRIKLP
    7KHUDERRQVFDPHFKDUJLQJDFURVVWKHFOHDULQJ,QWKHLUFODZVWKH\KHOG
    VPDOOVKDUSVWRQHV7KH\ORRNHGELJDQGVROLGEXWWKH\VORZHGDWWKHEDUUDJH
    RIVFUHHFKHVDQGVTXDZNVFRPLQJIURPWKHWUHHV,SDQDQG6KHHODKEXUVWRXW
    LQWRWKHJUDVVRIWKHFOHDULQJDQGWKHSDQVFDPHULJKWDIWHUWKHP7KHUDERRQV
    VNLGGHGWRDKDOW
    7KHSDQVVDZWKHUDERRQVEXWWKH\GLGQRWVWRSRUHYHQVORZ7KH\ VWLOO
    FDPHDIWHU,SDQDQG6KHHODKZLWKPXUGHURXVJOHH
    7KHUDERRQVVWRRGIUR]HQWKHLUFODZVZRUNLQJXQHDVLO\
    +DULUHDOL]HGZKDWZDVKDSSHQLQJDQGSLFNHGXSDEUDQFKDVKHUDQ

    FDOOLQJWR6KHHODK6KHVDZDQGFRSLHGKLP+HUDQVWUDLJKWDWWKHUDERRQV
    ZDYLQJWKHEUDQFK,WZDVDQDZNZDUGWZLVWHGROGOLPEXVHOHVVEXWLWORRNHG
    ELJ+DULZDQWHGWRVHHPOLNHWKHDGYDQFHJXDUGRIVRPHEDGEXVLQHVV
    ,QWKHULVLQJFORXGRIGXVWDQGJHQHUDOFKDRVWKHUDERRQVVDZDODUJH
    SDUW\RIHQUDJHGSDQVHPHUJLQJIURPWKHIRUHVW7KH EROWHG
    6TXHDOLQJWKH\UDQDWIXOOVWULGHLQWRWKHIDUWUHHV
    ,SDQDQG6KHHODKIROORZHGUXQQLQJZLWKWKHODVWRIWKHLUVWUHQJWK%\
    WKHWLPH,SDQUHDFKHGWKHILUVWWUHHVKHORRNHGEDFNDQGWKHSDQVKDGVWRSSHG
    KDOIZD\VWLOOVFUHHFKLQJWKHLUYHKHPHQFH
    +HVLJQHGWR6KHHODK*R7KH\FXWDZD\DWDVWHHSDQJOHKHDGLQJ
    XSKLOO
    

    ,SDQQHHGHGIRRGDQGUHVWLIRQO\WRVWRSKLVKHDUWIURPOXUFKLQJDW
    HYHU\PLQRUVRXQG6KHHODKDQG,SDQFOXWFKHGHDFKRWKHUKLJKLQDWUHHDQG
    FURRQHGDQGSHWWHG
    +DULQHHGHGWLPHWRWKLQN$XWRVHUYHUVZHUHNHHSLQJWKHLUERGLHVDOLYH
    DWWKHVWDWLRQ'RUVWLNWRNZRXOGGHIHQGWKHORFNVEXWKRZORQJZRXOGD
    VHFXULW\RIILFHUWDNHWRJHWDURXQGWKDW"
    ,WZRXOGEHVPDUWWROHWWKHPVWD\RXWKHUH LQGDQJHUVD\LQJWRWKH
    UHVWRIWKHVWDIIWKDWWKHWZRRGGWRXULVWVZDQWHGDUHDOO\ORQJLPPHUVLRQ
    /HWQDWXUHWDNHLWVFRXUVH
    +LVWKLQNLQJWULJJHUHGMLWWHUVLQ,SDQVRKHGURSSHGWKDWPRGH%HWWHU
    WRWKLQNDEVWUDFWO\7KHUHZDVSOHQW\RXWKHUHWKDWQHHGHGXQGHUVWDQGLQJ
    +HVXVSHFWHGWKDWWKHDQFLHQWVZKRSODQWHGSDQVDQGJLJDQWHORSHDQGWKH
    UHVWKHUHKDGWLQNHUHGZLWKWKHUDERRQVWRVHHLIWKH\FRXOGWXUQ DPRUH
    GLVWDQWSULPDWHUHODWLYHLQWRVRPHWKLQJOLNHKXPDQV$SHUYHUVHJRDOLW
    VHHPHGWR+DULEXWEHOLHYDEOH6FLHQWLVWVORYHGWRWLQNHU
    7KH\KDGJRWWHQDVIDUDVSDFNKXQWLQJEXWUDERRQVKDGQRWRROVEH\RQG
    FUXGHO\HGJHGVWRQHVRFFDVLRQDOO\XVHGWRFXWPHDWRQFHWKH\KDGEURXJKWLW
    GRZQ
    ,QDQRWKHUIHZPLOOLRQ\HDUVXQGHUHYROXWLRQVJULQGWKH\PLJKWEHDV
    VPDUWDVSDQV:KRZRXOGJRH[WLQFWWKHQ"
    $WWKHPRPHQWKHGLGQWPXFKFDUH+HKDGIHOWUHDOUDJHZKHQWKHSDQV
    KLVRZQNLQGKDGWXUQHGDJDLQVWWKHPHYHQZKHQWKHUDERRQVFDPHZLWKLQ
    YLHZ:K\"
    +HZRUULHGDWWKHLVVXHVXUHWKHUHZDVVRPHWKLQJKHUHKHKDGWR
    XQGHUVWDQG3V\FKRKLVWRU\KDGWRGHDOZLWKVXFKEDVLFIXQGDPHQWDOLPSXOVHV
    7KHSDQVUHDFWLRQKDGEHHQXQFRPIRUWDEO\FORVHWRP\ULDGLQFLGHQWVLQKXPDQ
    KLVWRU\
    +DWHWKH6WUDQJHU
    +HKDGWRIDWKRPWKDWPXUN\WUXWK
    3DQVPRYHGLQVPDOOJURXSVGLVOLNLQJRXWVLGHUVEUHHGLQJPRVWO\ZLWKLQ
    WKHLUPRGHVWFLUFOHRIDIHZGR]HQ7KLVPHDQWDQ\JHQHWLFWUDLWWKDWHPHUJHG
    FRXOGSDVVVZLIWO\LQWRDOOWKHPHPEHUVWKURXJKLQEUHHGLQJ,ILWKHOSHGWKH
    EDQGVXUYLYHWKHURXJKUXERIFKDQFHZRXOGVHOHFWIRUWKDWEDQGVVXUYLYDO
    )DLUHQRXJK
    %XWWKHWUDLWKDGWREHXQGLOXWHG$WURRSRIHVSHFLDOO\JRRGURFN
    WKURZHUVZRXOGJHWVZDOORZHGXS LIWKH\MRLQHGDFRPSDQ\RIVHYHUDOKXQGUHG
    &RQWDFWZRXOGPDNHWKHPEUHHGRXWVLGHWKHRULJLQDOVPDOOFODQ2XWEUHHGLQJ
    WKHLUJHQHWLFKHULWDJHZRXOGJHWZDWHUHGGRZQ
    6WULNLQJDEDODQFHEHWZHHQWKHDFFLGHQWVRIJHQHWLFVLQVPDOOJURXSV
    DQGWKHVWDELOLW\RIODUJHJURXSVWKDWZDVWKHWULFN6RPHOXFN\WURRSPLJKW
    KDYHIRUWXQDWHJHQHVFRQIHUULQJWUDLWVWKDWILWWKHQH[WFKDOOHQJHKDQGHGRXW
    E\WKHHYHUDOWHULQJZRUOG7KH\ZRXOGGRZHOO%XWLIWKRVHJHQHVQHYHU
    SDVVHGWRPDQ\SDQVZKDWGLGLWPDWWHU"

    :LWKVRPHVPDOODPRXQWRIRXWEUHHGLQJWKDWWUDLWJRWVSUHDGLQWRRWKHU
    EDQGV'RZQWKURXJKWKHVWUDLQHURIWLPHRWKHUVSLFNHGXSWKHWUDLW,W
    VSUHDG
    7KLVPHDQWLWZDVDFWXDOO\KHOSIXOWRGHYHORSVPROGHULQJDQLPRVLW\WR
    RXWVLGHUVDQLPPHGLDWHVHQVH RIWKHLUZURQJQHVV'RQWEUHHGZLWKWKHP
    6RVPDOOEDQGVKHOGIDVWWRWKHLUHFFHQWULFWUDLWVDQGVRPHSURVSHUHG
    7KRVHOLYHGRQPRVWSHULVKHG(YROXWLRQDU\MXPSVKDSSHQHGIDVWHULQVPDOO
    VHPLLVRODWHGEDQGVZKLFKRXWEUHGVOLJKWO\7KH\NHSWWKHLUJHQHWLFDVVHWVLQ
    RQHVPDOOEDVNHWWKHWURRS2QO\RFFDVLRQDOO\GLGWKH\PDWHZLWKDQRWKHU
    WURRSRIWHQWKURXJKUDSH
    7KHSULFHZDVVWHHSDVWURQJSUHIHUHQFHIRUWKHLURZQWLQ\ORW
    7KH\KDWHGFURZGVVWUDQJHUVQRLVH%DQGVRIOHVVWKDQWHQZHUHWRR
    YXOQHUDEOHWRGLVHDVHRUSUHGDWRUVDIHZORVVHVDQGWKHJURXSIDLOHG7RR
    PDQ\DQGWKH\ORVWWKHFRQFHQWUDWLRQRIFORVHEUHHGLQJ7KH\ZHUHLQWHQVHO\
    OR\DOWRWKHLUJURXSHDVLO\LGHQWLI\LQJHDFKRWKHULQWKHGDUNE\VPHOOHYHQ
    DWJUHDWGLVWDQFHV%HFDXVH WKH\KDGPDQ\FRPPRQJHQHVDOWUXLVWLFDFWLRQV
    ZHUHFRPPRQ
    7KH\HYHQKRQRUHGKHURLVPIRULIWKHKHURGLHGKLVVKDUHGJHQHVZHUH
    VWLOOSDVVHGRQWKURXJKKLVUHODWLYHV
    (YHQLIVWUDQJHUVFRXOGSDVVWKHWHVWVRIGLIIHUHQFHLQDSSHDUDQFHV
    PDQQHUVPHOOJURRPLQJHYHQWKHQFXOWXUHFRXOGDPSOLI\WKHHIIHFWV
    1HZFRPHUVZLWKGLIIHUHQWODQJXDJHRUKDELWVDQGSRVWXUHZRXOGVHHPUHSXOVLYH
    $Q\WKLQJWKDWVHUYHGWRGLVWLQJXLVKDEDQGZRXOGKHOSNHHSKDWUHGVKLJK
    (DFKVPDOOJHQHWLFHQVHPEOHZRXOGWKHQEHGULYHQE\QDWXUDOVHOHFWLRQWR
    VWUHVVWKHQRQLQKHULWHGGLIIHUHQFHVHYHQDUELWUDU\RQHVGLPO\FRQQHFWHGWR
    VXUYLYDOILWQHVVDQGVRWKH\FRXOGHYROYHFXOWXUH$VKXPDQVKDG
    'LYHUVLW\LQWKHLUWULEDOLQWULFDFLHVDYRLGHGJHQHWLFZDWHULQJGRZQ
    7KH\KHHGHG WKHDQFLHQWFDOORIDORRIZDU\WULEDOLVP
    +DUL,SDQVKLIWHGXQHDVLO\0LGZD\WKURXJKKLVWKLQNLQJWKHZRUGWKH\
    KDGFRPHLQ+DULVWKLQNLQJWRPHDQKXPDQVDVZHOODVSDQV7KHGHVFULSWLRQ
    ILWERWK
    7KDWZDVWKHNH\+XPDQVILWLQWRWKHJLJDQWLF(PSLUHGHVSLWHWKHLU
    LQQDWHWULEDOLVPWKHLUSDQOLNHKHULWDJH,WZDVDPLUDFOH
    %XWHYHQPLUDFOHVFDOOHGRXWIRUH[SODQDWLRQ3DQVFRXOGEHXVHIXO
    PRGHOVIRUWKHJHQWU\DQGWKHYDVWFLWL]HQU\WKHWZRFODVVHVHQFRXUDJHGWR
    EUHHG
    <HWKRZFRXOGWKH(PSLUHSRVVLEO\KDYHNHSWLWVHOIVWDEOHXVLQJVXFK
    FUXGHFUHDWXUHVDVKXPDQV"
    +DULKDGQHYHUVHHQWKHLVVXHEHIRUHLQVXFKJODULQJDQGKXPEOLQJ
    OLJKW
    $QGKHKDGQRDQVZHU
    

    7KH\PRYHGRQLQVSLWHRIWKHEOXQWGHHSXQHDVHRIWKHLUSDQV
    ,SDQVPHOOHGVRPHWKLQJWKDWVHQWKLVH\HVGDUWLQJOHIWDQGULJKW:LWK
    WKHIXOOWRRONLWRIVRRWKLQJWKRXJKWVDQGWKHVXEWOHWULFNVKHKDGOHDUQHG
    +DULNHSWKLPJRLQJ
    6KHHODKZDVKDYLQJPRUHWURXEOH7KHIHPDOHSDQGLGQRWOLNHODERULQJXS
    WKHORQJVWHHSJXOOLHVWKDWDSSURDFKHGWKHULGJHOLQH*QDUOHGEXVKHVEORFNHG
    WKHLUZD\DQGLWWRRNWLPHWRZRUNDURXQGWKHP)UXLWZDVKDUGHUWRILQGDW
    WKHVHDOWLWXGHV
    ,SDQVVKRXOGHUVDQGDUPVDFKHGFRQVWDQWO\3DQVZDONHGRQDOOIRXUV
    EHFDXVHWKHLULPPHQVHO\VWURQJDUPVFDUULHGDSXQLVKLQJZHLJKWSHQDOW\7R
    QDYLJDWHERWKWUHHVDQGJURXQGPHDQW\RXFRXOGRSWLPL]HQHLWKHU6KHHODKDQG
    ,SDQJURDQHGDQGZKLQHGDWWKHVRUHQHVVWKDWQHYHUOHIWIHHWOHJVZULVWV
    DQGDUPV3DQVZRXOGQHYHUEHIDUUDQJLQJH[SORUHUV

    7RJHWKHUWKH\OHWWKHLUSDQVSDXVHRIWHQWRFUXPEOHOHDYHVDQGVRDNXS
    ZDWHUIURPWUHHKROHVDURXWLQHVLPSOHWRROXVH7KH\NHSWVQLIILQJWKHDLU
    DSSUHKHQVLYH
    7KHVPHOOWKDWGLVWXUEHGERWKSDQVJRWVWURQJHUGDUNHU
    6KHHODKZHQWDKHDGDQGZDVWKHILUVWRYHUWKHULGJHOLQH)DUEHORZLQ
    WKHYDOOH\WKH\FRXOGPDNHRXWWKHUHFWDQJXODUULJLGLWLHVRIWKH([FXUVLRQ
    6WDWLRQ$IO\HUOLIWHGIURPWKHURRIDQGZKLVSHUHGDZD\GRZQWKHYDOOH\QR
    GDQJHUWRWKHP
    +HUHFDOOHGZKDWVHHPHGDFHQWXU\DJRVLWWLQJRQWKHYHUDQGDKWKHUH
    ZLWKGULQNVLQKDQGDQG'RUVVD\LQJ,I\RXVWD\HGRQ7UDQWRU\RXPLJKWEH
    GHDG$OVRLI\RXGLGQWVWD\RQ7UDQWRU
    7KH\VWDUWHGGRZQWKHVWHHSVORSH7KHLUSDQVH\HVMHUNHGDWHYHU\
    XQH[SHFWHGPRYHPHQW$FKLOO\EUHH]HVWLUUHGWKHIHZORZEXVKHVDQGWZLVWHG
    WUHHV6RPHKDGDIHDWKHUHGORRNEXUQWDQGVKDWWHUHGE\OLJKWQLQJ$LUPDVVHV
    GULYHQXSIURPWKHYDOOH\VIRXJKWDORQJKHUHWKHEUXWHFODVKRISUHVVXUHV
    7KLVURFN\ULGJHZDVIDUIURPWKHFRPIRUWDEOHSURYLQFHRISDQV7KH\KXUULHG
    $KHDG6KHHODKVWRSSHG
    :LWKRXWDVRXQGILYHUDERRQVURVHIURPFRQFHDOPHQWIRUPLQJDQHDWKDOI
    FLUFOHDURXQGWKHP
    +DULFRXOGQRWWHOOLILWZDVWKHVDPHSDFNDVEHIRUH,IVRWKH\ZHUH
    TXLWHFRQVLGHUDEOHSDFNKXQWHUVDEOHWRKROGPHPRU\DQGSXUSRVHRYHUWLPH
    7KH\KDGZDLWHGDKHDGZKHUHWKHUHZHUHQRWUHHVWRFOLPE
    7KHUDERRQVZHUHHHULO\TXLHWDVWKH\VWURGHIRUZDUGWKHLUFODZV
    FOLFNLQJVRIWO\
    +HFDOOHGWR6KHHODKDQGPDGHVRPHXWWHUO\IDNHIHURFLRXVQRLVHVDVKH
    PRYHGDUPVKLJKLQWKHDLUILVWVVKDNLQJVKRZLQJDELJSURILOH+HOHW,SDQ
    WDNHRYHUZKLOHKHWKRXJKW
    $UDERRQEDQGFRXOGFHUWDLQO\WDNHWZRLVRODWHGSDQV7RVXUYLYHWKLV
    WKH\KDGWRVXUSULVHWKHUDERRQVIULJKWHQWKHP
    +HORRNHGDURXQG7KURZLQJURFNVZDVQWJRLQJWRGRWKHWULFNKHUH:LWK
    RQO\DYDJXHQRWLRQRIZKDWKHZDVGRLQJKHVKXIIOHGOHIWWRZDUGDWUHHWKDW
    KDGEHHQVSOLQWHUHGE\OLJKWQLQJ
    6KHHODKVDZKLVPRYHDQGJRWWKHUHILUVWVWULGLQJHQHUJHWLFDOO\,SDQ
    SLFNHGXSWZRVWRQHVDQGIOXQJWKHP DWWKHQHDUHVWUDERRQ2QHVWUXFNRQWKH
    IODQNEXWGLGQRUHDOKDUP
    7KHUDERRQVEHJDQWRWURWFLUFOLQJ7KH\FDOOHGWRHDFKRWKHULQ
    ZKHH]LQJJUXQWV
    6KHHODKOHDSHGRQDGULHGRXWVKDUGRIWKHWUHH,WVQDSSHG6KH
    VQDWFKHGLWXSDQG+DULVDZKHUSRLQW,WZDVDVWDOODVVKHZDVDQGVKH
    FUDGOHGLW
    7KHODUJHVWUDERRQJUXQWHGDQGWKH\DOOORRNHGDWHDFKRWKHU
    7KHUDERRQVFKDUJHG
    7KHQHDUHVWRQHFDPHDW6KHHODK6KHFDXJKWLWRQWKHVKRXOGHUZLWKWKH
    EOXQWSRLQWDQGLWVTXHDOHG
    +DULJUDEEHGDVWDONRIWKHVKDWWHUHGWUHHWUXQN+HFRXOGQRWZUHQFKLW
    IUHH$QRWKHUVTXHDOIURPEHKLQGKLPDQG6KHHODKZDVJLEEHULQJLQDKLJK
    IULJKWHQHGYRLFH
    ,WZDVEHVWWROHWWKHSDQVUHOHDVHWHQVLRQYRFDOO\EXWKHFRXOGIHHO
    WKHIHDUDQGGHVSHUDWLRQLQWKH WRQHVDQGNQHZLWFDPHIURP'RUVWRR
    +HFDUHIXOO\VHOHFWHGDVPDOOHUVKDUGRIWKHWUHH:LWKERWKKDQGVKH
    WZLVWHGLWIUHHXVLQJKLVZHLJKWDQGELJVKRXOGHUPXVFOHVFUDFNLQJLWVR
    WKDWLWFDPHDZD\ZLWKDSRLQW
    /DQFHV7KDWZDVWKHRQO\ZD\WRVWD\DZD\IURPWKHUDERRQFODZV3DQV
    QHYHUXVHGVXFKDGYDQFHGZHDSRQV(YROXWLRQKDGQWJRWWHQDURXQGWRWKDW
    OHVVRQ\HW
    7KHUDERRQVZHUHDOODURXQGWKHPQRZ+HDQG6KHHODKVWRRGEDFNWREDFN
    +HEDUHO\JRWKLVIHHWSODFHGZKHQKHKDGWRWDNHWKHUXVKRIDELJVZDUWK\

    UDERRQ
    7KHUDERRQVKDGQRWJRWWHQWKHLGHDRIWKHODQFH\HW,WVODPPHGLQWR
    WKHSRLQWMHUNHGEDFN$IHDUVRPHEHOORZ,SDQZHWKLPVHOIZLWKIHDUEXW
    VRPHWKLQJLQ+DULNHSWKLPLQFRQWURO
    7KHUDERRQEDFNHGRIIZKLPSHULQJ,WWXUQHGWRUXQ,QPLGVWULGHLW
    VWRSSHG)RUDORQJVXVSHQGHGPRPHQWWKHUDERRQKHVLWDWHGWKHQWXUQHGEDFN
    WRZDUG+DUL
    ,WWURWWHGIRUZDUGZLWKQHZFRQILGHQFH7KHRWKHUUDERRQVZDWFKHG,W
    ZHQWWRWKHVDPHWUHH+DULKDGXVHGDQGZLWKDVLQJOHKHDYHEURNHRIID
    ORQJVOHQGHUVSLNHRIZRRG7KHQLWFDPHWRZDUG+DULVWRSSHGDQGZLWKRQH
    FODZKHOGWKHVWLFNIRUZDUG:LWKDWRVVRILWVELJKHDGLWORRNHGDWKLPDQG
    KDOIWXUQHGSXWWLQJRQHIRRWIRUZDUG
    :LWKDVKRFN+DULUHFRJQL]HGWKHVZRUGSOD\SRVLWLRQ
    9DGGRKDGXVHGLW9DGGRZDVULGLQJWKLVUDERRQ
    ,WPDGHSHUIHFWVHQVH7KLVZD\WKHSDQVGHDWKV
    ZRXOGEHTXLWH
    QDWXUDO9DGGRFRXOGVD\WKDWKHZDVGHYHORSLQJUDERRQULGLQJDVDQHZ
    FRPPHUFLDODSSOLFDWLRQRI WKHVDPHKDUGZDUHWKDWZRUNHGIRUSDQULGLQJ
    9DGGRFDPHIRUZDUGDFDUHIXOVWHSDWDWLPHKROGLQJWKHORQJODQFH
    EHWZHHQWZRFODZVQRZ+HPDGHWKHHQGPRYHLQDFLUFOH0RYHPHQWZDVMHUN\
    FODZVZHUHFUXGHFRPSDUHGZLWKSDQKDQGV%XWWKHUDERRQZDVVWURQJHU
    ,WFDPHDWKLPZLWKDTXLFNIHLQWWKHQDWKUXVW+DULEDUHO\PDQDJHGWR
    GRGJHVLGHZD\VZKLOHKHEUXVKHGWKHODQFHDVLGHZLWKKLVVWLFN9DGGR
    UHFRYHUHGTXLFNO\DQGFDPHIURP+DULVOHIW-DEIHLQWMDEIHLQW+DUL
    FDXJKWHDFKZLWKDVZRRSRI KLVVWLFN
    7KHLUZRRGHQVZRUGVVPDFNHGDJDLQVWHDFKRWKHUDQG+DULKRSHGKLVGLGQW
    VQDS9DGGRKDGJRRGFRQWURORIKLVUDERRQ,WGLGQRWWU\WRIOHHDVLWKDG
    EHIRUH
    +DULZDVNHSWEXV\VODSSLQJDVLGH9DGGRVWKUXVWV+HKDGWRKDYHVRPH
    RWKHUDGYDQWDJHRUWKHVXSHULRUVWUHQJWKRIWKHUDERRQZRXOGHYHQWXDOO\WHOO
    +DULFLUFOHGGUDZLQJ9DGGRDZD\IURP6KHHODK7KHRWKHUUDERRQVZHUHNHHSLQJ
    KHUWUDSSHGEXWQRWDWWDFNLQJ$OODWWHQWLRQULYHWHGRQWKHWZRILJXUHVDV
    WKH\WKUXVWDQGSDUULHG
    +DULGUHZ9DGGRWRZDUGDQRXWFURSSLQJ7KHUDERRQZDVKDYLQJWURXEOH
    KROGLQJLWVODQFHVWUDLJKWDQGKDGWRNHHSORRNLQJGRZQDWLWVFODZVWRJHW
    WKHPULJKW7KLVPHDQWLWSDLGOHVVDWWHQWLRQWRZKHUHLWVWZRKRRYHVIRXQG
    WKHLUIRRWLQJ+DULVODSSHGDQGMDEEHGDQG NHSWPRYLQJPDNLQJWKHUDERRQVWHS
    VLGHZD\V,WSXWDELJKRRIGRZQDPRQJVRPHDQJXODUVWRQHVWHHWHUHGWKHQ
    UHFRYHUHG
    +DULPRYHGOHIW,WVWHSSHGDJDLQDQGLWVKRRIWXUQHGDQGLWVWXPEOHG
    +DULZDVRQLWLQDQLQVWDQW+HWKUXVWIRUZDUGDVWKHUDERRQORRNHGGRZQ
    IHHWVFUDPEOLQJIRUSXUFKDVH+DULFDXJKWWKHUDERRQIXOOZLWKKLVSRLQW
    +HSXVKHGKDUG7KHRWKHUUDERRQVOHWRXWDPRDQLQJVRXQG
    6QRUWLQJLQUDJHWKHUDERRQWULHGWRJHWRIIWKHSRLQW+DULPDGH,SDQ
    VWHSIRUZDUGDQGWKUXVWWKHWLSIDUWKHULQWRWKHUDERRQ7KHWKLQJZDLOHG
    KRDUVHO\,SDQSOXQJHGDJDLQ%ORRGVSXUWHGIURPLWVSDWWHULQJWKHGXVW,WV
    NQHHVEXFNOHGDQGLWVSUDZOHG
    +DULVKRWDJODQFHRYHUKLVVKRXOGHU7KHRWKHUVKDGVXUJHGLQWRDFWLRQ
    6KHHODKZDVKROGLQJRIIWKUHH VFUHHFKLQJDWWKHPVRORXGO\LWXQQHUYHGHYHQ
    KLP6KHKDGDOUHDG\ZRXQGHGRQH%ORRGGULSSHGGRZQLWVEURZQFRDW
    %XWWKHRWKHUVGLGQRWFKDUJH7KH\FLUFOHGDQGJURZOHGDQGVWDPSHG
    WKHLUIHHWEXWFDPHQRFORVHU7KH\ZHUHFRQIXVHG/HDUQLQJWRR+HFRXOGVHH
    WKHTXLFNEULJKWH\HVVWXG\LQJWKHVLWXDWLRQWKLVIUHVKPRYHLQWKH
    SHUSHWXDOZDU
    6KHHODKVWHSSHGRXWDQGSRNHGWKHQHDUHVWUDERRQ,WODXQFKHGLWVHOIDW
    KHULQDVQDUOLQJILWDQGVKHVWXFNLWDJDLQGHHSHU,W\HOSHGDQGWXPHGDQG
    UDQ
    7KDWGLGLWIRUWKHRWKHUV7KH\DOOWURWWHGRIIOHDYLQJWKHLUIHOORZ

    EOHDWLQJRQWKHJURXQG,WVGD]HGH\HVZDWFKHGLWVEORRGWULFNOHRXW,WVH\HV
    IOLFNHUHGDQG9DGGRZDVJRQH7KHDQLPDOVOXPSHG
    :LWKGHOLEHUDWLRQ+DULSLFNHGXSDURFNDQGEDVKHGLQWKHVNXOO,WZDV
    PHVV\ZRUNDQGKHVDWEDFNLQVLGH,SDQDQGOHWWKHGDUNVPROGHULQJSDQDQJHU
    FRPHRXW
    +HEHQWRYHUDQGVWXGLHGWKHUDERRQEUDLQ$ILQHVLOYHU\ZHEELQJFDSSHG
    WKHUXEEHU\FRQYROXWHGEDOO,PPHUVLRQFLUFXLWU\
    +HWXUQHGDZD\IURPWKH VLJKWDQGRQO\WKHQVDZWKDW6KHHODKZDVKXUW
    

    7KHVWDWLRQFURZQHGDUXJJHGKLOO6WHHSJXOOLHVJDYHWKHKLOOVLGHWKH
    ORRNRIDZHDU\OLQHGIDFH:LU\EXVKHVWKURQJHGWKHORZHUUHDFKHV
    ,SDQSXIIHGDVKHZRUNHGKLVZD\WKURXJKWKHUDZODQGFXWE\HURVLRQ,Q
    SDQYLVLRQWKHQLJKWZDVHHULHDVKLPPHULQJYLVWDRISDOHJUHHQVDQGEOXH
    WLQJHGVKDGRZV7KHKLOOZDVDQXDQFHLQWKHJUHDWHUVORSHRIDJUDQG
    PRXQWDLQEXWSDQYLVLRQFRXOGQRWPDNHRXWWKHGLVWDQWIHDWXUHV3DQVOLYHG
    LQDFORVHLPPHGLDWHZRUOG
    $KHDGKHFRXOGVHHFOHDUO\WKHJORZLQJEODQNZDOOULQJLQJWKHVWDWLRQ
    ,WZDVPDVVLYHILYHPHWHUVWDOO$QGKHUHPHPEHUHGIURPKLVWRXULVWWRXURI
    WKHSODFHULPPHGZLWKEURNHQJODVV
    %HKLQGKLPFDPHJDVSVDV6KHHODKODERUHGXSWKHVORSH7KHZRXQGLQKHU
    VLGHPDGHKHUJDLWVWLIIIDFHULJLG6KHUHIXVHGWRKLGHEHORZ7KH\ZHUH
    ERWKQHDUH[KDXVWLRQDQGWKHLUSDQVZHUHEDONLQJGHVSLWHWZRVWRSVIRUIUXLW
    DQGJUXEVDQGUHVW
    7KURXJKWKHLUIHHEOHVLJQYRFDEXODU\WKHLUIDFLDOJULPDFLQJDQG
    ZULWLQJLQWKHGXVWWKH\KDGGLVFXVVHGWKHSRVVLELOLWLHV7ZRSDQVZHUH
    YXOQHUDEOHRXWKHUH7KH\FRXOGQRWH[SHFWWREHDVOXFN\DVZLWKWKHUDERRQV
    QRWWLUHGDQGLQVWUDQJHWHUULWRU\
    7KHEHVWWLPHWRDSSURDFKWKHVWDWLRQZDVDWQLJKW:KRHYHUKDG
    HQJLQHHUHGWKLVZRXOGQRWZDLWIRUHYHU7KH\KDGKLGGHQIURPIO\HUVWZLFHPRUH
    VLQFHPRUQLQJ5HVWLQJWKURXJKWKHQH[WGD\ZDVDQLQYLWLQJRSWLRQEXW+DUL
    IHOWDIRUHERGLQJSUHVVKLPRQZDUG
    +HDQJOHGXSWKHKLOOVLGHZDWFKLQJIRUHOHFWURQLFWULSZLUHV2IVXFK
    WHFKQLFDOPDWWHUVKHNQHZQRWKLQJ+HZRXOGKDYHWRNHHSDORRNRXWIRUWKH
    REYLRXVDQGKRSHWKDWWKHVWDWLRQZDVQRWZLUHGIRUWKLQNLQJWUHVSDVVHUV
    3DQYLVLRQZDVVKDUSDQGFOHDU LQGLPOLJKWIRUQHDUE\REMHFWVEXWKH
    FRXOGILQGQRWKLQJ
    +HFKRVHDVSRWE\WKHZDOOVKDGRZHGE\WUHHV6KHHODKSDQWHGLQVKDOORZ
    JDVSVDVVKHDSSURDFKHG/RRNLQJXSWKHZDOOVHHPHGLPPHQVH,PSRVVLEOH
    6ORZO\KHVXUYH\HGWKHODQGDURXQGWKHP1RVLJQRIDQ\PRYHPHQW7KH
    SODFHVPHOOHGSHFXOLDUWR,SDQVRPHKRZZURQJ0D\EHDQLPDOVVWD\HGDZD\IURP
    WKHDOLHQFRPSRXQG*RRGWKDWZRXOGPDNHVHFXULW\LQVLGHOHVVDOHUW
    7KHZDOOZDVSROLVKHGFRQFUHWH$WKLFNOLSMXWWHGRXWDWWKHWRS
    PDNLQJFOLPELQJLWKDUGHU
    6KHHODKJHVWXUHGWRZKHUHWUHHVJUHZQHDUWKHZDOO6WXPSVQHDUHUVKRZHG
    WKDWWKHEXLOGHUVKDGWKRXJKWDERXWDQLPDOVOHDSLQJDFURVVIURPEUDQFKHVEXW
    VRPHZHUHWDOOHQRXJKDQGKDGEUDQFKHVZLWKLQDIHZPHWHUVRIWKHWRS
    &RXOGDSDQPDNHWKHGLVWDQFH"1RWOLNHO\HVSHFLDOO\ZKHQWLUHG
    6KHHODKSRLQWHGWRKLPDQGEDFNWRKHUWKHQKHOGKHUKDQGVRXWDQGPDGHD
    VZLQJLQJPRWLRQ&RXOGWKH\VZLQJDFURVVWKHGLVWDQFH"
    +HVWXGLHGKHUIDFH7KHGHVLJQHUZRXOGQRWDQWLFLSDWHWZRSDQV
    FRRSHUDWLQJWKDWZD\+HVTXLQWHGXSDWWKHWRS7RRKLJKWRFOLPEHYHQLI
    6KHHODKVWRRGRQKLVVKRXOGHUV
    <HVKHVLJQHG
    $IHZPRPHQWVODWHUKHUKDQGVKROGLQJKLVIHHWDERXWWROHWJRRIKLV
    EUDQFKKHKDGVHFRQGWKRXJKWV

    ,SDQGLGQWPLQGWKLVELWRIFDOLVWKHQLFVDQGLQIDFWZDVKDSS\WREH
    EDFNLQDWUHH%XW+DULVKXPDQMXGJPHQWVWLOONHSWVKRXWLQJWKDWKHFRXOG
    QRWSRVVLEO\GRLW1DWXUDOSDQWDOHQWFRQIOLFWHGZLWKKXPDQFDXWLRQ
    /XFNLO\KHGLGQRWKDYHPXFKWLPHWRLQGXOJHLQVHOIGRXEW6KHHODK
    \DQNHGKLPRIIWKHEUDQFK+HIHOOKHOGRQO\E\KHUKDQGV
    6KHKDGZUDSSHGKHUIHHWVHFXUHO\DURXQGDWKLFNEUDQFKDQGQRZEHJDQWR
    RVFLOODWHKLPOLNHDZHLJKWRQDVWULQJ6KHVZXQJKLPEDFNDQGIRUWK
    LQFUHDVLQJWKHDPSOLWXGH%DFNIRUWKXSGRZQ FHQWULIXJDOSUHVVXUHLQKLV
    KHDG7R,SDQLWZDVXQUHPDUNDEOH7R+DULLWZDVDZKHHOLQJZRUOGRIKHDUW
    VWRSSLQJZKLUOV
    6PDOOEUDQFKHVEUXVKHGKLPDQGKHZRUULHGDERXWQRLVHDQGWKHQIRUJRW
    DERXWWKDWEHFDXVHKLVKHDGZDVFRPLQJXSOHYHOZLWKWKHWRSRIWKHZDOO
    7KHFRQFUHWHOLSZDVURXQGHGRIIRQWKHLQVLGHVRQRKRRNFRXOGILQGD
    JULS
    +HVZXQJEDFNGRZQKHDGSOXQJLQJWRZDUGWKHJURXQG7KHQXSLQWRWKH
    ORZHUEUDQFKHVWZLJVVODSSLQJKLVIDFH
    2QWKHQH[WVZLQJKHZDVKLJKHU$OODORQJWKHWRSRIWKHZDOOWKLFN
    JODVVJOLQWHG9HU\SURIHVVLRQDO
    +HEDUHO\KDGWLPHWRUHDOL]HDOOWKLVZKHQVKHOHWKLPJR
    +HDUFHGXSKDQGVVWUHWFKHGRXWDQGEDUHO\FDXJKWWKHOLS,ILWKDG
    QRWSURWHFWLYHO\SURWUXGHGRXWKHZRXOGKDYHPLVVHG
    +HOHWKLV ERG\VODPDJDLQVWWKHVLGH+LVIHHWVFUDEEOHGIRUSXUFKDVH
    DJDLQVWWKHVKHHUIDFH$IHZWRHVJRWKROG+HKHDYHGXSPXVFOHVEXQFKLQJ
    DQGRYHU1HYHUEHIRUHKDGKHDSSUHFLDWHGKRZPXFKVWURQJHUDSDQFRXOGEH1R
    PDQFRXOGKDYHPDGHLWKHUH
    +HVFUDPEOHGXSFXWWLQJKLVDUPDQGKDXQFKRQJODVV,WZDVDGHOLFDWH
    EXVLQHVVJHWWLQJWRKLVIHHWDQGILQGLQJDSODFHWRVWDQG
    $VXUJHRIWULXPSK+HZDYHGWR6KHHODKLQYLVLEOHLQWKHWUHH
    )URPKHUHRQLWZDVXSWRKLP+HUHDOL]HGVXGGHQO\WKDWWKH\FRXOGKDYH
    IDVKLRQHGVRPHVRUWRIURSHW\LQJWRJHWKHUYLQHV7KHQKHFRXOGOLIWKHUXS
    KHUH*RRGLGHDWRRODWH
    1RSRLQWLQGHOD\LQJ7KHFRPSRXQGZDVSDUWO\YLVLEOHWKURXJKWKHWUHHV
    DIHZOLJKWVEXUQLQJ8WWHUO\VLOHQW7KH\KDGZDLWHGXQWLOWKHQLJKWZDV
    DERXWKDOIRYHUKHKDGQRWKLQJEXW,SDQVJXWIHHOLQJVWRWHOOKLPZKHQ
    +HORRNHGGRZQ-XVWEH\RQGKLVWRHVUD]RUZLUHJOHDPHGVHWLQWRWKH
    FRQFUHWH&DUHIXOO\KHVWHSSHGEHWZHHQWKHVKLQ\OLQHV7KHUHZDVURRPDPRQJ
    WKHVKDUSJODVVWHHWKWRVWDQG$WUHHEORFNHGKLVYLVLRQDQGKHFRXOGVHH
    OLWWOHEHORZKLPLQWKHGLPJORZIURPWKHVWDWLRQ$WOHDVWWKDWPHDQWWKH\
    FRXOGQWVHHKLPHLWKHU
    6KRXOGKHMXPS"7RRKLJK7KHWUHHWKDWKLGKLPZDVFORVHEXWKHFRXOG
    QRWVHHLQWRLW+HVWRRGDQGWKRXJKWEXWQRWKLQJFDPHWRKLP0HDQZKLOH
    6KHHODKZDVEHKLQGKLPDORQHDQGKHKDWHGOHDYLQJKHUZKHUHGDQJHUVZDLWHG
    WKDWKHGLGQRWHYHQNQRZ
    +HZDVWKLQNLQJOLNHDPDQDQGIRUJHWWLQJWKDWKHKDGWKHFDSDELOLW\RI
    DSDQ
    *R+HOHDSHG7ZLJVVQDSSHGDQGKHSOXQJHGKHDYLO\LQVKDGRZV%UDQFKHV
    VWDEEHGKLVIDFH+HVDZDGDUNVKDSHWRKLVULJKWDQGVRFXUOHGKLVOHJV
    URWDWHGKDQGVRXWDQGVQDJJHGDEUDQFK+LVKDQGVFORVHGHDVLO\DURXQGLW
    DQGKHUHDOL]HGLWZDVWRRWKLQ WRRWKLQ
    ,WVQDSSHG7KHFUDFNFDPHOLNHDWKXQGHUEROWWRKLVHDUV+HIHOO
    OHWWLQJJRRIWKHEUDQFK+LVEDFNKLWVRPHWKLQJKDUGDQGKHUROOHGJUDSSOLQJ
    IRUDKROG+LVILQJHUVFORVHGDURXQGDWKLFNEUDQFKDQGKHVZXQJIURPLW
    )LQDOO\KHOHWRXWDJDVS
    /HDYHVUXVWOHGEUDQFKHVVZD\HG1RWKLQJPRUH
    +HZDVKDOIZD\XSDWUHH$FKHVVSURXWHGLQKLVMRLQWVDJDOD[\RI
    VPDOOSDLQV
    +DULUHOD[HGDQGOHW,SDQPDVWHUWKHGHVFHQW+HKDGPDGHIDUWRRPXFK

    QRLVHIDOOLQJLQWKHWUHHEXWWKHUHZDVQRVLJQRIDQ\PRYHPHQWDFURVVWKH
    EURDGODZQVEHWZHHQKLPDQGWKHELJOXPLQRXVVWDWLRQ
    +HWKRXJKWRI'RUVDQGZLVKHGWKHUHZHUHVRPHZD\KHFRXOGOHWKHUNQRZ
    KHZDVLQVLGHQRZ7KLQNLQJRIKHUKHPHDVXUHGZLWKKLVH\HWKHGLVWDQFHV
    IURPQHDUE\WUHHVPHPRUL]LQJWKHSDWWHUQVRWKDWKHFRXOGILQGWKHZD\EDFN
    DWDGHDGUXQLIKHKDGWR
    1RZZKDW"+HGLGQWKDYHDSODQ
    +DULJHQWO\XUJHG,SDQZKRZDVQHUYRXVDQGWLUHGEDUHO\FRQWUROODEOH
    LQWRDWULDQJXODUSDWWHUQRIEXVKHV,SDQVPLQGZDVOLNHDVWRUP\VN\VSOLW
    E\VNLWWHULQJOLJKWQLQJ1RWWKRXJKWVSUHFLVHO\PRUHOLNHNQRWVRIHPRWLRQ
    IRUPLQJDQGIODVKLQJDURXQGFULVSNHUQHOVRIDQ[LHW\3DWLHQWO\+DULVXPPRQHG
    XSVRRWKLQJLPDJHVJHWWLQJ,SDQVEUHDWKLQJVORZHGDQGKHDOPRVWPLVVHGWKH
    ZKLVSHU\VRXQG
    1DLOVVFUDEEOLQJRQDVWRQHZDONZD\6RPHWKLQJUXQQLQJIDVW
    7KH\FDPHDURXQGWKHWULDQJOHSHDNRIEXVKHV%XQFKHGPXVFOHVVOHHN
    VNLQVWXEE\OHJVHDWLQJXSWKHUHPDLQLQJGLVWDQFH7KH\ZHUHZHOOWUDLQHGWR
    VHHNDQGNLOOVRXQGOHVVO\ZLWKRXWZDUQLQJ
    7R,SDQWKHPRQVWHUVZHUHDOLHQWHUULI\LQJ,SDQVWHSSHGEDFNLQSDQLF
    EHIRUHWKHWZRRQUXVKLQJEXOOHWVRIPXVFOHDQGERQH%ODFNJXPVSHHOHGEDFN
    IURPZKLWHWHHWKEDUHGEHQHDWKPDGH\HV
    7KHQ+DULIHOWVRPHWKLQJVKLIWLQ,SDQ$QFLHQWLQVWLQFWLYHUHVSRQVHV
    VWRSSHGKLVUHWUHDWWHQVHGWKHERG\1RWLPHWRIOHHVRILJKW
    ,SDQVHWKLPVHOIEDODQFHG7KHWZRPLJKWJRIRUKLVDUPVVRKHGUHZ
    WKHPEDFNFURXFKLQJWREULQJKLVIDFHGRZQ
    ,SDQKDGGHDOWZLWKIRXUOHJJHGSDFNKXQWHUVEHIRUHVRPHZKHUHIDUEDFN
    LQDQFHVWUDOPHPRU\DQGNQHZLQQDWHO\WKDWWKH\OLQHGXSRQDYLFWLPV
    RXWVWUHWFKHGOLPEZRXOGJRIRUWKHWKURDW7KHFDQLQHVZDQWHGWRERZOKLP
    RYHUVODVKRSHQWKHMXJXODUULSDQGVKUHGLQWKHYLWDOVHFRQGVRIVXUSULVH
    7KH\JDWKHUHGWKHPVHOYHVEXQGOHVRIVZLIWVLQHZUXQQLQJQHDUO\
    VKRXOGHUWRVKRXOGHUELJKHDGVXSDQGOHDSHG
    ,QDLUWKH\ZHUHFRPPLWWHG,SDQNQHZ$QGRSHQ,SDQEURXJKWERWK
    KDQGVXSWRJUDVSWKHFDQLQHVIRUHOHJV
    +HWKUHZKLPVHOIEDFNZDUGKROGLQJWKHOHJVWLJKWKLVKDQGVEDUHO\
    EHQHDWKWKHMDZV7KHZLUHKRXQGVRZQPRPHQWXPFDUULHGWKHPRYHUKLVKHDGDV
    KHUROOHGEDFNZDUG
    ,SDQUROOHGRQWRKLVEDFN\DQNLQJKDUG7KHVXGGHQVQDSVODPPHGWKH
    FDQLQHVIRUZDUG7KH\FRXOGQRWJHWWKHLUKHDGVDURXQGDQGGRZQWRFORVHRQ
    KLVKDQG
    7KHOHDSWKHFDWFKWKHTXLFNSLYRWDQGVZLQJWKHKHDYHDOOFRPELQHG
    LQDFHQWULIXJDOZKLUOWKDWVOXQJWKHZLUHKRXQGVRYHU,SDQDVKHKLPVHOIZHQW
    GRZQUROOLQJ+HIHOWWKHFDQLQHVOHJVVQDSDQGOHWJR7KH\VDLOHGRYHUKLP
    ZLWK SDLQHG\HOSV
    ,SDQUROOHGRYHUFRPSOHWHO\KHDGWXFNHGLQDQGFDPHRIIKLVVKRXOGHUV
    ZLWKDERXQG+HKHDUGDVROLGWKXGFODFNVDVMDZVVQDSSHGVKXW$WKXPSDV
    WKHFDQLQHVKLWWKHJUDVVEURNHQOHJVXQDEOHWRFXVKLRQWKHP
    +HVFUDPEOHGDIWHUWKHPKLVEUHDWKZKLVWOLQJ7KH\ZHUHWU\LQJWRJHW
    XSWXUQLQJRQVQDSSHGOHJVWRFRQIURQWWKHLUTXDUU\6WLOOQREDUNVRQO\
    IDLQWZKLPSHUVRISDLQVXOOHQJURZOV2QHVZRUHYHKHPHQWO\DQGTXLWH
    REVFHQHO\7KHRWKHUFKDQWHG%DDDVDUGEDDDVDUG
    $QLPDOVWXUQLQJLQWKHLUYDVWVRUURZIXOQLJKW
    +HMXPSHGKLJKDQGFDPHGRZQRQERWK+LVIHHWGURYHWKHLUQHFNVLQWR
    WKHJURXQGDQGKHIHOWERQHJLYHZD\%HIRUHKHVWHSSHGEDFNWRORRNKHNQHZ
    WKH\ZHUHJRQH
    ,SDQVEORRGVXUJHGZLWKMR\+DULKDGQHYHUIHOWWKLVWLQJOLQJWKULOO
    QRWHYHQLQWKHILUVWLPPHUVLRQZKHQ,SDQKDGNLOOHGD6WUDQJHU9LFWRU\RYHU
    DOLHQWKLQJVZLWKWHHWKDQGFODZVWKDWFRPHDW\RXRXWRIWKHQLJKWZDVD
    SURIRXQGLQIODPLQJSOHDVXUH

    +DULKDGGRQHQRWKLQJ7KHYLFWRU\ZDVZKROO\ ,SDQV
    )RUDORQJPRPHQW+DULEDVNHGLQLWLQWKHFRROQLJKWDLUIHOWWKH
    WUHPRUVRIHFVWDV\
    6ORZO\UHDVRQUHWXUQHG7KHUHZHUHRWKHUZLUHKRXQGV,SDQKDGFDXJKW
    WKHVHMXVWULJKW6XFKOXFNGLGQRWVWULNHWZLFH
    7KHZLUHKRXQGVZHUHHDV\WRVHHRQWKHODZQ:RXOGDWWUDFWDWWHQWLRQ
    ,SDQGLGQRWOLNHWRXFKLQJWKHP7KHLUERZHOVKDGHPSWLHGDQGWKHVPHOO
    FXWWKHDLU7KH\OHIWDVPHDURQWKHJUDVVDVKHGUDJJHGWKHPLQWRWKH
    EXVKHV
    7LPHWLPH6RPHRQHZRXOGPLVV WKHFDQLQHVFRPHWRVHH
    ,SDQZDVVWLOOSXPSHGXSIURPKLVYLFWRU\+DULXVHGWKDWWRJHWKLP
    WURWWLQJDFURVVWKHEURDGODZQWDNLQJDGYDQWDJHRIVKDGRZV(QHUJ\SRSSHGLQ
    ,SDQVYHLQV+DULNQHZLWZDVDPHUHPRPHQWDU\JODQGXODUMR\RYHUOD\LQJD
    GHHS IDWLJXH:KHQLWIDGHG,SDQZRXOGEHFRPHGD]HGKDUGWRJRYHUQ
    (YHU\WLPHKHVWRSSHGKHORRNHGEDFNDQGPHPRUL]HGODQGPDUNV+HPLJKW
    KDYHWRUHWXUQWKLVZD\RQWKHUXQ
    ,WZDVODWHDQGPRVWRIWKHVWDWLRQZDVGDUN,QWKHWHFKQLFDODUHD
    WKRXJKDFOXVWHURIZLQGRZVEORVVRPHGZLWKZKDW,SDQVDZDVLPSRVVLEO\ULFK
    VWUDQJHVXSHUKHDWHGOLJKW
    +HORSHGRYHUWRWKHPDQGIODWWHQHGKLPVHOIDJDLQVWWKHZDOO,WKHOSHG
    WKDW,SDQZDVIDVFLQDWHGE\WKLVVWUDQJHFLWDGHORIWKHJRGOLNHKXPDQV2XWRI
    KLVRZQ FXULRVLW\KHSHHNHGLQDZLQGRZ8QGHUHQDPHOOLJKWDELJDVVHPEO\
    URRPVSUDZOHGRQHWKDW+DULUHFRJQL]HG7KHUHFHQWXULHVDJRKHKDGIRUPHG
    XSZLWKWKHRWKHUEULJKWO\GUHVVHGWRXULVWVWRJRRXWRQDWUHN
    +DULOHWWKHSDQVFXULRVLW\SURSHOKLPDURXQGWRWKHVLGHZKHUHKH
    NQHZDGRRUOHGLQWRDORQJFRUULGRU7KHGRRURSHQHGIUHHO\WR+DULV
    VXUSULVH,SDQVWUROOHGGRZQWKHVOLFNWLOHVRIWKHKDOOZD\TXL]]LFDOO\
    VWXG\LQJWKHSKRVSKRUSDLQWGHVLJQVRQWKHFHLOLQJDQGZDOOVZKLFKHPLWWHGD
    VRRWKLQJ LYRU\JORZ
    $QRIILFHGRRUZD\ZDVRSHQ+DULPDGH,SDQVTXDWDQGEREKLVKHDGDURXQG
    WKHHGJH1RERG\WKHUH,WZDVDVXPSWXRXVGHQZLWKVKHOYHVVRDULQJLQWRD
    YDXOWHGFHLOLQJ+DULUHPHPEHUHGVLWWLQJWKHUHGLVFXVVLQJWKHLPPHUVLRQ
    SURFHVV7KDWPHDQWWKHLPPHUVLRQYHVVHOVZHUHMXVWDIHZGRRUVDZD\GRZQ
    7KHVTXHDNRIVKRHVRQWLOHVPDGHKLPWXUQ
    ([6SHF9DGGRZDVEHKLQGKLPOHYHOLQJDZHDSRQ
    ,QWKHFRROOLJKWWKHPDQVIDFHORRNHGRGGWR,SDQVH\HVP\VWHULRXVO\
    ERQ\/RQJWKLQWKHH[SUHVVLRQKDUGWRUHDG
    +DULIHOWWKHUXVKRIUHYHUHQFHLQ,SDQDQGOHWLWFDUU\WKHSDQ
    IRUZDUGFKLSSHULQJVRIWO\,SDQIHOWDZHQRWIHDU
    9DGGRWHQVHGXSZDYLQJWKHVQRXWRIKLVXJO\ZHDSRQ$PHWDOOLFFOLFN
    ,SDQEURXJKWKLVKDQGVXSLQDULWXDOSDQJUHHWLQJDQG9DGGRVKRWKLP
    7KHLPSDFWVSXQ,SDQDURXQG+HZHQWGRZQVSUDZOLQJ
    9DGGRVPRXWKFXUOHGLQGHULVLRQ6PDUWSURIKXK"'LGQWILJXUHWKH
    DODUPRQWKHGRRUKXK"
    7KHSDLQIURP,SDQVVLGHZDVVKDUSVWDUWOLQJ+DULURGHWKHKXUWDQG
    JDWKHULQJDQJHULQ,SDQKHOSLQJLWEXLOG,SDQIHOWKLVVLGHDQGKLVKDQG
    FDPHDZD\VWLFN\VPHOOLQJOLNHZDUPLURQLQWKHSDQVQRVWULOV
    9DGGRFLUFOHGDURXQGZHDSRQZHDYLQJ<RXNLOOHGPH\RXZHDNOLWWOH
    GRSH5XLQHGDJRRGH[SHULPHQWDODQLPDO1RZ, JRWWRILJXUHZKDWWRGRZLWK
    \RX
    +DULWKUHZKLVRZQDQJHUDWRS,SDQVVHHWKLQJUDJH+HIHOWWKHELJ
    PXVFOHVLQWKHVKRXOGHUVEXQFK7KHSDLQLQWKHVLGHMDEEHGVXGGHQO\,SDQ
    JURDQHGDQGUROOHGRQWKHIORRUSUHVVLQJRQHKDQGWRWKHZRXQG
    +DULNHSWWKHKHDGGRZQVRWKDW,SDQFRXOGQRWVHHWKHEORRGWKDWZDV
    UXQQLQJGRZQQRZDFURVVWKHOHJV(QHUJ\ZDVUXQQLQJRXWRIWKHSDQERG\$
    VHHSLQJZHDNQHVVPRYHGXSWKHERG\
    +HSULFNHGKLVHDUVDWWKHVKXIIOLQJRI9DGGRVIHHW$QRWKHUDJRQL]HG

    UROOWKLVWLPHEULQJLQJWKHOHJVXSLQDFXUO
    *XHVVWKHUHVUHDOO\RQO\RQHVROXWLRQ+DULKHDUGWKHPHWDOOLF
    FOLFN
    1RZ\HV+HOHWKLVDQJHUVSLOO
    ,SDQSUHVVHGXSZLWKKLVIRUHDUPVDQGJRWKLVIHHWXQGHUKLP1RWLPHWR
    JHWDOOWKHZD\XS,SDQVSUDQJDW9DGGRNHHSLQJORZ
    $WLQQ\VKRWZKLVNHGE\KLVKHDG7KHQKHKLW9DGGRLQWKHKLSDQG
    VODPPHGWKHPDQDJDLQVWWKHZDOO7KHPDQVVFHQWZDVVRXUVDOW\
    +DULORVWDOOFRQWURO,SDQERXQFHG9DGGRRIIWKHZDOODQGLQVWDQWO\
    VODPPHGKLVDUPVLQWRWKHPDQZLWKIXOOIRUFH
    9DGGRWULHGWRGHIOHFWWKHLPSDFW,SDQEUXVKHGWKHSXQ\KXPDQDUPV
    DVLGH9DGGRVSDWKHWLFDWWHPSWVDWGHIHQVHZHUHOLNHVSLGHUZHEVEUXVKHGDZD\
    +HEXWWHG9DGGRDQGSRXQGHGKLVPDVVLYHVKRXOGHUVLQWRWKHPDQVFKHVW
    7KHZHDSRQFODWWHUHGRQWKHWLOHV
    ,SDQVODPPHGKLPVHOILQWRWKHPDQVERG\DJDLQDQGDJDLQ
    6WUHQJWKSRZHUMR\
    %RQHVVQDSSHG9DGGRVKHDGVQDSSHGEDFNVPDFNHGWKHZDOODQGKHZHQW
    OLPS
    ,SDQVWHSSHGEDFNDQG9DGGRVDJJHGWRWKHWLOHV-R\
    %OXHZKLWHIOLHVEX]]HGDWWKHULPRIKLVYLVLRQ
    0XVWPRYH7KDWZDVDOO+DULFRXOGJHWWKURXJKWKHFXUWDLQRIHPRWLRQV
    WKDWVKURXGHGWKHSDQPLQG
    7KHFRUULGRUOXUFKHG+DULJRW,SDQWRZDONLQDVLGHZD\VWHHWHU
    'RZQWKHFRUULGRUSDLQIXOVWHSV7ZRGRRUVWKUHH+HUH"/RFNHG1H[W
    GRRU:RUOGPRYLQJVORZHUVRPHKRZ
    7KHGRRUVQLFNHGRSHQ$QDQWHFKDPEHUWKDWKHUHFRJQL]HG,SDQEOXQGHUHG
    LQWRDFKDLUDQGDOPRVWIHOO
    +DULPDGHWKHOXQJVZRUNKDUG7KHJDVSLQJFOHDUHGKLVYLVLRQRIWKH
    GDUNHGJHVWKDWKDGFUHSWLQEXWWKHEOXHZKLWHIOLHVZHUHVWLOOWKHUH
    IOXWWHULQJLPSDWLHQWO\DQGWKLFNHU
    +HWULHGWKHIDUGRRU/RFNHG+DULVXPPRQHGZKDWKHFRXOGIURP,SDQ
    6WUHQJWKSRZHUMR\
    ,SDQVODPPHGKLVVKRXOGHULQWRWKHVROLGGRRU,WKHOG$JDLQ$QG
    DJDLQVKDUSSDLQDQGLWSRSSHGRSHQ
    5LJKWWKLVZDVLW7KHLPPHUVLRQED\,SDQVWDJJHUHGLQWRWKHDUUD\RI
    YHVVHOV7KHZDONGRZQWKHOLQHEHWZHHQEDQNVRIFRQWUROSDQHOVWRRNDQ
    HWHUQLW\+DULFRQFHQWUDWHGRQHDFKVWHSSODFLQJHDFKIRRW,SDQVILHOGRI
    YLHZEREEHGDVWKHKHDGVHHPHGWRVOLSDURXQGRQOLTXLGVKRXOGHUV
    +HUH+LVRZQYHVVHO
    'RUVWLNWRNZDVUHDG\IRUKLP,WKDGVHHQKLPFRPLQJDQGODWFKHG
    LWVHOIWRWKHERDUGFRYHULQJWKHYLWDOFRQWUROV
    ,SDQEHQWWRWKHWLNWRNVSXQFKSDQHO+HMDEEHGDWWKHNH\V
    UHPHPEHULQJWKHDFFHVVFRGH
    ,SDQVILQJHUVZHUHWRREURDG7KH\FRXOGQRWKLWDVLQJOHNH\DWD
    WLPH
    7KHURRPRIEOHDFKHGOLJKWZDVJHWWLQJIX]]\+HPDGH,SDQWU\WKHFRGH
    DJDLQEXWWKHVWXEE\ILQJHUVPDVKHGVHYHUDONH\VDWRQFH
    7KHEOXHZKLWHIOLHVIODSSHGDWWKHHGJHVRIKLVYLVLRQ,SDQVKDQGV
    ZKDFNHGLQIUXVWUDWLRQDWWKHSXQFKSDG
    7KLQN+DULORRNHGDURXQG,SDQZDVQWJRLQJWRODVWPXFKORQJHU$GHVN
    QHDUE\KDGDZULWLQJVODWHDQGSHQ
    /HDYHDQRWH"+RSHWKHULJKWSHRSOHILQGLW
    +HPDGH,SDQVWDJJHUWRWKHGHVNJUDVSWKHSHQ$QLGHDIOLFNHUHGDVKH
    WULHGWRZULWH,1(('
    +HWXUQHGDQGWRWWHUHGEDFNWRWKHFDSVXOH
    &RQFHQWUDWH
    *ULSSLQJWKHSHQKHSXQFKHGGRZQZLWKWKHEXWW,WVWUXFNDNH\

    FOHDQO\7KHEOXHIOLHVIOLFNHUHGLQKLVYLVLRQ
    7KHDFFHVVFRGHZDVKDUGWRUHPHPEHUQRZ+HZRUNHGRQLWRQHQXPEHUDW
    DWLPH6WDESRNHMDEDQGLWZDVGRQH$OLJKWZLQNHGIURPUHGWRJUHHQ
    +HIXPEOHGZLWKWKHODWFKHV3RSSHGLWRSHQ
    7KHUHOD\+DUL6HOGRQSHDFHIXOH\HVFORVHG
    (PHUJHQF\FRQWUROV\HV+HNQHZWKHPIURPWKHEULHILQJ
    +HVHDUFKHGWKHSROLVKHGVWHHOVXUIDFHDQGIRXQGWKHSDQHORQWKHVLGH
    ,SDQVWDUHGZRR]LO\DWWKHPHDQLQJOHVVOHWWHULQJ
    +DULKLPVHOIKDGWURXEOHUHDGLQJ7KHOHWWHUVMXPSHGDQGIXVHGWRJHWKHU
    +HIRXQGVHYHUDOEXWWRQVDQGVHUYRFRQWUROV,SDQVKDQGVZHUHZRUVH
    QRZ,WWRRNWKUHHVWDEVZLWKWKHSHQWRJHWWKHUHYLYLQJSURJUDPDFWLYDWHG
    /LJKWVF\FOHGIURPJUHHQWRDPEHU
    ,SDQDEUXSWO\VDWGRZQRQWKHFRROIORRU7KHEOXHZKLWHIOLHVZHUH
    EX]]LQJDOODURXQGKLVKHDGDQGQRZWKH\ZDQWHGWRELWHKLP+HVXFNHGLQWKH
    FRROGU\DLUEXWWKHUHZDVQRVXEVWDQFHLQLWQRKHOS
    7KHQZLWKRXWDQ\WUDQVLWLRQKHZDVORRNLQJDW WKHFHLOLQJ2QKLV
    EDFN7KHODPSVXSWKHUHZHUHJHWWLQJGDUNIDGLQJ7KHQWKH\ZHQWRXW
    

    +DULVH\HVVQDSSHGRSHQ
    7KHUHFRYHU\SURJUDPZDVVWLOOVHQGLQJHOHFWURVWLPVWKURXJKKLVPXVFOHV
    +HOHWWKHPMXPSDQGWLQJOHDQGDFKHZKLOHKHWKRXJKW +HIHOWILQH1RWHYHQ
    KXQJU\DVKHXVXDOO\GLGDIWHUDQLPPHUVLRQ+RZORQJKDGKHEHHQLQWKH
    ZLOGHUQHVV"$WOHDVWILYHGD\V
    +HVDWXS7KHUHZDVQRRQHLQWKHYHVVHOURRP(YLGHQWO\9DGGRKDG
    JRWWHQVRPHVLOHQWDODUPEXWKDGQRWDOHUWHGDQ\RQHHOVH7KDWSRLQWHGDJDLQ
    WRDWLJKWOLWWOHFRQVSLUDF\
    +HJRWRXWVKDNLO\7RJHWIUHHKHKDGWRGHWDFKVRPHIHHGHUVDQG
    SUREHVEXWWKH\VHHPHGVLPSOHHQRXJK
    ,SDQ7KHELJERG\ILOOHGWKHZDONZD\+HNQHOWDQGIHOWIRUDSXOVH
    5LFNHW\
    %XWILUVW'RUV+HUYHVVHOZDVQH[WWRKLVDQGKHVWDUWHGWKHUHYLYDO
    6KHORRNHGZHOO
    9DGGRPXVWKDYHSXWVRPHWUDQVPLVVLRQEORFNRQWKHV\VWHPVRWKDWQRQH
    RIWKHVWDIIFRXOGWHOOE\ORRNLQJDWWKHSDQHOWKDWDQ\WKLQJZDVZURQJ$
    VLPSOHFRYHUVWRU\DFRXSOHZKRZDQWHGDUHDOO\ORQJLPPHUVLRQ9DGGRKDG
    ZDUQHGWKHPEXWQRWKH\ZDQWHGLWVR$SHUIHFWO\SODXVLEOHVWRU\
    'RUVH\HVIOXWWHUHG+HNLVVHGKHU6KHJDVSHG
    +HPDGHDSDQVLJQTXLHWDQGZHQWEDFNWR,SDQ
    %ORRGZDVIORZLQJVWHDGLO\+DULZDV VXUSULVHGWRILQGWKDWKHFRXOGQRW
    SLFNXSWKHULFKSXQJHQWHOHPHQWVLQWKHSDQVEORRGIURPVPHOODORQH$
    KXPDQPLVVHGVRPXFK
    +HWRRNRIIKLVVKLUWDQGPDGHDFUXGHWRXUQLTXHW$WOHDVW,SDQV
    EUHDWKLQJZDVUHJXODU'RUVZDVUHDG\WRJHWRXWE\WKHQDQGKHKHOSHGKHU
    GLVFRQQHFW
    ,ZDVKLGLQJLQDWUHHDQGWKHQSRRIVKHVDLG:KDWDUHOLHI+RZ
    GLG\RX
    /HWVJHWPRYLQJKHVDLG
    $VWKH\OHIWWKHURRPVKHVDLG:KRFDQZHWUXVW":KRHYHUGLGWKLV
    6KHVWRSSHGZKHQVKHVDZ9DGGR2K
    6RPHKRZKHUH[SUHVVLRQPDGHKLPODXJK6KHZDVYHU\UDUHO\VXUSULVHG
    <RXGLGWKLV"
    ,SDQ
    ,QHYHUZRXOGKDYHEHOLHYHGDSDQFRXOGFRXOG
    ,GRXEWDQ\RQHVEHHQLPPHUVHGWKLVORQJ1RWXQGHUVXFKVWUHVV
    DQ\ZD\,WDOOMXVWZHOOLWFDPHRXW

    +HSLFNHGXS9DGGRVZHDSRQDQGVWXGLHGWKHPHFKDQLVP$VWDQGDUG
    SLVWROVLOHQFHG9DGGRKDGQRWZDQWHGWRDZDNHQWKHUHVWRIWKHVWDWLRQ7KDW
    ZDVSURPLVLQJ7KHUHVKRXOGEHSHRSOHKHUHZKRZRXOGVSULQJWRWKHLUDLG+H
    VWDUWHGWRZDUGWKHEXLOGLQJZKHUHWKHVWDWLRQSHUVRQQHOOLYHG
    :DLWZKDWDERXW9DGGR"
    ,PJRLQJWRZDNHXSDGRFWRU
    7KH\GLGEXW+DULWRRNKLPLQWRWKHYHVVHOURRPILUVWWRZRUNRQ,SDQ
    6RPHSDWFKZRUNDQGLQMHFWLRQVDQGWKHGRFWRUVDLG,SDQZRXOGEHDOOULJKW
    2QO\WKHQGLGKHVKRZWKHPDQ9DGGRVERG\
    7KHGRFWRUJRWDQJU\DERXWWKDWEXW+DULKDGDJXQ$OOKHKDGWRGR
    ZDVSRLQWLW+HGLGQWVD\DQ\WKLQJMXVWJHVWXUHGZLWKWKHJXQ
    +HGLGQRWIHHOOLNHWDONLQJDQGZRQGHUHGLIKHHYHUZRXOGDJDLQ:KHQ
    \RXFRXOGQWWDON\RXFRQFHQWUDWHGPRUHHQWHUHGLQWRWKLQJV,PPHUVHG
    $QGLQDQ\FDVH9DGGRKDGEHHQGHDGIRUVRPHWLPH
    ,SDQKDGGRQHDJRRGMRE7KHGRFWRUVKRRNKLVKHDGDWWKHVHYHUH
    GDPDJH
    $ODUPVZHUHULQJLQJ+HJRWDQLQVWDQWKHDGDFKH7KHVHFXULW\RIILFHU
    VKRZHGXS+HFRXOGVHHIURPKHUUHDFWLRQWKDWVKHKDGQRWEHHQLQRQWKH
    SORW&DQWFRQQHFWLWWRWKH$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWHWKHQKHWKRXJKWDEVWUDFWO\
    %XWKRZPXFKGLGWKDWSURYH",PSHULDOSROLWLFVZHUHVXEWOH'RUV
    ORRNHGDWKLPRGGO\WKHZKROHWLPH+HGLGQRWXQGHUVWDQGZK\XQWLOKH
    UHDOL]HGWKDWKHKDGQRWHYHQWKRXJKWDERXWKHOSLQJ9DGGRILUVW,SDQZDV
    KLPVHOILQDVHQVHKHNQHZGHHSO\EXWFRXOGQRWH[SODLQ
    %XWKHXQGHUVWRRGLPPHGLDWHO\ZKHQ'RUVZDQWHGWRJRWRWKHVWDWLRQZDOO
    DQGFDOOWR6KHHODK7KH\EURXJKWKHUWRRLQIURPWKHIDUZLOGGDUNQHVV
    B
    3$57

    $1&,(17)2*6

    B
    *$/$&7,&35(+,6725<WKHGHVWUXFWLRQRIDOOHDUOLHUUHFRUGVGXULQJWKH
    H[SDQVLRQRIKXPDQLW\WKURXJKWKH*DOD[\ZLWKWKHDWWHQGDQWHUDVRIZDUIDUH
    OHDYHVLQVKDGRZWKHHQWLUHSUREOHPRIKXPDQRULJLQV7KHHQRUPRXVFKDQJHV
    ZURXJKWRQVRPDQ\ZRUOGVDOVRHUDVHGDQ\HYLGHQFHIRUPXFKROGHUDOLHQ
    FLYLOL]DWLRQV7KHVHVRFLHWLHVPD\KDYHH[LVWHGWKRXJKWKHUHLVQRILUP
    HYLGHQFHIRUWKHP6RPHHDUO\KLVWRULDQVEHOLHYHGWKDWDWOHDVW RQHW\SHRI
    UHPQDQWPLJKWKDYHVXUYLYHGLQWKH*DOD[\WKHHOHFWURPDJQHWLFUHFRUGV7KHVH
    ZRXOGKDYHWREHORGJHGLQSODVPDVWUHDPVRUWKHFRURQDOORRSVRIVWDUVDQG
    WKXVOLHEH\RQGWKHGHWHFWLRQRI([SDQVLRQLVWWHFKQRORJ\(YHQPRGHPVWXGLHV
    KDYHIRXQGQRVXFKVHQWLHQWVWUXFWXUHV+RZHYHUWKHYLUXOHQWUDGLDWLRQOHYHOV
    DWWKH*DODFWLFFRUHZKHUHHQHUJ\GHQVLWLHVPLJKWSURPLVHDQKRVSLWDEOHDERGH
    IRUPDJQHWLFDOO\EDVHGIRUPVPDNHVXFKLQYHVWLJDWLRQVGLIILFXOWDQG
    DPELJXRXV$QRWKHUWKHRU\KROGVWKDWFXOWXUHVPLJKWKDYHZULWWHQWKHPVHOYHV
    LQWRSUH(PSLUHFRPSXWHUFRGHVDQGWKXVQRZUHVLGHXQGHWHFWHGLQVRPHEDQNV
    RIDQFLHQWGDWD6XFKVSHFXODWLRQVPHWZLWKQRSURRIDQGZHUHGLVFRXQWHG7KXV
    WKHHQWLUHSUREOHPRIZK\WKH*DOD[\ZDVHPSW\RIDGYDQFHGOLIHZKHQKXPDQLW\
    YHQWXUHGLQWRLWKDVQRUHVROXWLRQ
    

    (1&<&/23(',$*$/$&7,&$

    9ROWDLUHVFRZOHGYH[HG
    +DGVKHLQIDFW\LHOGHGWRKLPJLYHQKHUVHOIXS"2UZDVWKLVD
    SDUWLFXODUO\ILQHVLPXODWLRQ"7UXH-RDQDUWWKLVWKRX"

    &HUWDLQO\WKLVILWRQHRIKLVIDYRULWHVDURPSLQJSOD\LQSULFNO\GU\
    KD\XSLQWKHWRSPRVWORIWRIDELJROGEDUQRQDKRW$XJXVWGD\LQORQJ
    ORVW%RUGHDX[
    7ZLWZKHHHFDOOHGDELUG,QVHFWVFKLUSHGZDUPEUHH]HVEOHZZRRG\
    VFHQWV+HUKDLUWUDLOHGRYHUKLPDVVKHPRXQWHG+HIHOWKHUDGURLWWZLVWV
    GHOLYHUHGZLWKDQHURWLFSUHFLVLRQWKDWPDGHKLPWUHPEOHZLWKWKHQHHGIRU
    UHOHDVH
    %XW
    7KHLQVWDQWKHGRXEWHGLWDOOFRQWUDFWHGGZLQGOHGIHOODZD\LQWR
    EODFNQHVV7KLVZDVPHUHO\DQH[RWLFRQDQLVPDVHOIORYHGHOXVLRQUHTXLULQJ
    KLVFRPPLWPHQWWRLWVWUXWK&RQWULYHGZHOOEXWIDNH
    6RZKHQKHIHOWKLPVHOISLFNHGXSLQDJLDQWIHPLQLQHKDQGVRIWSDOP
    FUDGOLQJKLPDORIWLQWRVXQQ\DLUKHZRQGHUHGLIWKLVZHUHUHDOWRR$KRW
    EUHH]HEUXVKHGKLPDVVKHH[KDOHG
    -RDQWRZHUHGILIW\WLPHVKLVKHLJKWPXUPXULQJWRKLP)OHVK\KXJHOLSV
    NLVVHGKLVZKROHERG\LQRQHOLQJHULQJPRPHQWKHUWRQJXHOLFNLQJKLPOLNHD
    FRORVVXVVDYRULQJDOROOLSRS
    ,VXSSRVH,YHQRWKDGP\LURQ\SURJUDPVRPLWWHG"KHDVNHG
    7KHJLDQW-RDQVKULYHOHG
    7RRHDV\KHVDLG$OO,QHHGGRLVVD\VRPHWKLQJDELWMDUULQJ
    7KLVWLPHWKHKDQGSURSHOOHGKLPDORIWZLWKFUXVKLQJDFFHOHUDWLRQ
    <RXYHVWLOOJRW\RXUSUHFLRXVLURQ\$QGWKLVLVPH
    +HVQLIIHG6RODUJH<RXYHPDGH\RXUVHOIDOHYLDWKDQ
    7RRKHDY\"
    ,YHDOZD\VOLNHGSLJLURQ\
    +HJDYHDGLVGDLQIXOVQLII6KHGURSSHGKLP+HSOXQJHGWRZDUGDPRDWRI
    ERLOLQJODYDZKLFKKDGVXGGHQO\DSSHDUHGEHORZ
    6RUU\KHVDLGTXLHWO\-XVWHQRXJKWRJHWKHUWRVWRSQRWHQRXJKWR
    ORVHHYHU\VKUHGRIGLJQLW\
    <RXVKRXOGEH
    7KHODYDSLWHYDSRUDWHGFRQJHDOLQJLQWRPXG+HODQGHGRQVROLGJURXQG
    DQGVKHVWRRGEHIRUHKLPVWDQGDUGVL]H'HPXUHIUHVK$URXQGKHUFOXQJDLU
    VFUXEEHGE\DVSULQJUDLQVWRUPMXVWSDVW
    :HFDQLQYDGHHDFKRWKHUVSHUFHSWXDOVSDFHVDWZLOO0DUYHORXV+H
    VWRSSHGFRQVLGHUHG,QDZD\
    ,Q3XUJDWRU\DOOLVPHDQLQJOHVV:HGUHDPZKLOHZHDZDLWWUXWK6KH
    DEUXSWO\VQHH]HGWKHQFRXJKHG%OLQNLQJVKHUHDVVHPEOHGKHUORIW\ODG\OLNH
    VHOI
    8PPP,ZRXOGDSSUHFLDWHVRPHWKLQJFRQFUHWHO\DKFRQFUHWH
    +HVWHSSHGRIIWKHSRUFKRIDQHODERUDWH3URYHQFDOFRXQWU\KRXVH7KH
    ILHOGVEH\RQGJORZHGZLWKOXULGOLJKW7KHIRUHJURXQGZDVDFFXUDWHEXWGRQH
    LQUDWKHUREYLRXVEUXVKVWURNHV
    &OHDUO\WKH\ZHUHLQKDELWLQJDZRUNRIDUW(YHQWKHVFHQWVRIDSSOH
    WUHHVDQGKRUVHPDQXUHKDGDVWLOWHGTXDOLW\$IUR]HQPRPHQWF\FOHG
    HQGOHVVO\IRUDVORQJDVWKH\QHHGHGDEDFNGURS",QH[SHQVLYHHYHQ$VWRXQGLQJ
    ZKDWKLVVXEFRQVFLRXVOHWVOLSDELWFRXOGFRQMXUHXS
    :KDWZDVWRVWRSKLPWKHPIURPSOD\LQJ&DOLJXOD"6ODXJKWHULQJGLJLWDO
    PLOOLRQV"7RUWXULQJYLUWXDOVODYHV"1RWKLQJ
    7KDWZDVWKHSUREOHPQRFRQVWUDLQWV+RZFRXOGDQ\RQHSHUVLVWJLYHQ
    LQILQLWHWHPSWDWLRQ"
    )DLWK2QO\IDLWKFDQJXLGHFDQFRPSHO-RDQWRRNKLVKDQGSOHDGLQJ
    ZLWKXQWRXFKHGDUGRU
    %XWRXUUHDOLW\LVLQIDFWHQWLUHLOOXVLRQ
    7KH/RUGPXVWEHVRPHZKHUHVKHVDLGSODLQO\+HLVUHDO
    <RXGRQRWTXLWHIROORZP\GHDU+HVWUXFNDQLQVWUXFWLYHSRVH
    2QWRJHQHVLVDOJRULWKPVFDQJHQHUDWHQHZSHRSOHGUDZQIURPDQFLHQWILHOGVRU
    HOVHMXVWFRRNHGXSIRUWKHPRPHQW

    ,NQRZWUXHSHRSOHZKHQ,VHHWKHP/HWWKHPVSHDNIRUDPRPHQW
    <RXZRXOGORRNIRUZLW":HKDYHVRPHVXEURXWLQHVKHUH\HVPDGDP
    &KDUDFWHU"$PHUHVHWRIYHUEDOSRVWXUHSURILOHV6LQFHULW\":HFDQIDNH
    WKDW
    9ROWDLUHNQHZIURPYLHZLQJKLVRZQFHUHEUDOLQQDUGVWKDWVRPHWKLQJ
    WHUPHGDUHDOLW\HGLWRURIIHUHGUHDG\PDGHFRQYHUVDWLRQIURPWKHPRXWKRI
    DSSDUHQWO\UHDUSHUVRQVZKRKDGQRWH[LVWHGVHFRQGVEHIRUH$VVHPEODJHVRI
    WUDLWVDQGYHUEDOQXDQFHVVWRRGHYHUUHDG\WRWUDGHDSKRULVPVDQGVDOOLHVZLWK
    KLP
    $OOWKHVHKHKDGSLFNHGXSLQKLVHQGOHVVIRUDJLQJRIWKH0HVKLWV
    P\ULDG7UDQWRULDQVLWHVRSHQLQJWRKLVWRXFK+HKDGH[WUDFWHGDQGVKDSHG
    WKHVHFXVWRPL]HGDPXVHPHQWV4XLFNDQG]HVW\DQGDOOXOWLPDWHO\KROORZ
    ,UHDOL]H\RXKDYHJUHDWHUFDSDFLWLHV-RDQDOORZHG6KHKRLVWHGKHU
    VZRUGDQGVZXQJLWDWHPSW\DLU$OORZVLUWKDW,FDQVWLOOFRQWUROP\
    VHQVHV,NQRZVRPHPLQLRQVRIWKHVHSDUWVDUHWUXHDQGUHDODVDXWKHQWLFDV
    DQLPDOVZHUHLQRXUWLPHRQ(DUWK
    <RXEHOLHYHWKDW\RXNQHZWKHLQQHUVWDWHVRIKRUVHV"
    2IFRXUVH,URGHPDQ\LQWREDWWOHIHOWWKHLUIHDUWKURXJKP\FDOYHV
    ,VHH+HVZHSWKLVODFHVOHHYHVWKURXJKWKHDLULQDSDURG\RIKHU
    VZRUGVZLQJLQJ1RZEULQJ\RXMXGJPHQWWREHDUXSRQDGRJZKLFKKDVORVW
    LWVPDVWHU7KHEHDVWFDOOKLP3K\GHDX[KDVVRXJKWLWVPDVWHURQHYHU\URDG
    ZLWKVRUURZIXOFULHVDQGHQWHUVWKHKRXVHDJLWDWHGXQHDV\JRHVXSDQGGRZQ
    WKHVWDLUVIURPURRPWRURRPDQGDWODVWILQGVLQWKHVWXG\WKHPDVWHULW
    ORYHVDQGVKRZVKLPLWVMR\E\LWVFULHVRIGHOLJKWE\LWVOHDSV,WPXVW
    KDYHIHHOLQJORQJLQJVLGHDV
    6XUHO\
    9ROWDLUHWKHQSURGXFHGWKHGRJSODLQWLYHDQGEHDXWLIXOLQLWVIORS
    HDUHGGLJLWDOVRUURZ7RERRWKHDGGHGWKHKRXVHFRPSOHWHZLWKIXUQLWXUH$V
    WKHSRRUGRJVED\LQJGLHGDZD\KHVDLG0\GHPRQVWUDWLRQPDGDP
    7ULFNV0RXWKWZLVWHGDQJULO\VKHVDLGQRPRUH
    <RXPXVWDOORZWKDWPDWKHPDWLFLDQVDUHOLNH
    )UHQFKPHQZKDWHYHU\RXVD\WRWKHPWKH\WUDQVODWHLQWRWKHLURZQ
    ODQJXDJHDQGIRUWKZLWKLWLVVRPHWKLQJHQWLUHO\GLIIHUHQW
    ,DPZDLWLQJIRUP\/RUG2UDVRQHGHYRWHGWRODUJHFRQFHSWVVLU
    IRU0HDQLQJ
    6LWDQGSRQGHUPDGDP+HPDWHULDOL]HGDFRPI\3URYHQFDONLWFKHQ
    WDEOHVWKHIHWFKLQJVFHQWRIFRIIHH7KH\VDW,QVFULEHGRQ WKHFRIIHHSRW
    ZDVKLVPRWWRIURPDORVWSDVW
    1RLUFRPPHOHGLDEOH
    &KDXGFRPPHOHQIHU
    3XUFRPPHXQDQJH
    'RX[FRPPHODPRXU
    %ODFNDVWKHGHYLO
    +RWDVKHOO
    3XUHDVDQDQJHO
    6ZHHWDVORYH

    0\LWWDVWHVVRJRRG-RDQVDLG
    ,KDYHPDVWHUHGPXOWLSOHVLWHDFFHVV9ROWDLUHVOXUSHGKLVFRIIHH
    QRLVLO\RQHRIWKHIHZDOORZDQFHVKHKDGIRXQG3DULVLDQVRFLHW\JDYHWRHYHQ
    DSKLORVRSKHU:HDUHUXQQLQJLQWKHLQWHUVWLFHVRI7UDQWRUVSOLQWHUHGLQWR
    PDQ\IUDJPHQWV,FDQVXPPRQXSVHQVHGDWDIURPWKHLQQXPHUDEOHLQYHQWRULHVRI
    FRXQWOHVVGLJLWDOOLEUDULHV
    ,DSSUHFLDWH\RXUJLYLQJPHVLPLODUWDOHQWVVKHVDLGFDXWLRXVO\
    DGMXVWLQJKHUDUPRUIRUFRPIRUWDQGVLSSLQJKHUDURPDWLFFRIIHHZLWKFDUH

    %XW,IHHODKROORZQHVV
    5XHIXOO\KHQRGGHG ,WRR
    :HVHHP,KHVLWDWHWRVD\
    /LNHGLYLQLWLHV
    %ODVSKHP\EXWWUXH7KRXJKWKH&UHDWRUKDVZLVGRPDQGZHGRQRW
    9ROWDLUHVIDFHVWUHWFKHGLQGHVSDLU:RUVHZHPD\QRWKDYHHYHQRXU
    RZQZLOOV
    :HOO,GR
    ,IDOOZHDUHLVVWULQJVRIGLJLWV]HURVDQGRQHVDFWXDOO\QRPRUH
    LI\RXZLOOEXWORRNPLFURVFRSHFORVHWKHQKRZFDQZHEHIUHH"$UHZHQRW
    GHWHUPLQHGE\WKRVHPDUFKLQJQXPHUDOV"
    ,IHHOIUHH
    $KEXWWKHQZHZRXOGPDNHLWVRLQDQ\FDVH\HV"+HVSUDQJWRKLV
    IHHW2QHRIP\EHVWFRXSOHWV
    2QHVFLHQFHRQO\ZLOORQHJHQLXVILW
    6RYDVWLVDUWVRQDUURZKXPDQZLW
    6RZHFDQQRWNQRZZHDUHIUHH"7KH&UHDWRUPDNHVXVVR
    ,ZRXOGZLVKIRUWKDW&UHDWRUQRZ
    -RDQNLFNHGRYHUWKHWDEOHVSDWWHULQJKLPZLWKFRIIHH+HHGLWHGRXW
    LWVEXUQVDVKHIHOO6KHVZXQJKHUVZRUGDWWKHNLWFKHQZDOOVDQGVOLFHGWKHP
    LQWRJUHDWVKHHWVFXUYLQJDZD\LQWRDJUD\(XFOLGHDQVSDFHUHDOLW\FXUOLQJ
    OLNHRUDQJHSHHO
    +RZWLUHVRPHKHVDLG7KHEHVW DUJXPHQWDJDLQVW&KULVWLDQLW\LV
    FHUWDLQO\&KULVWLDQV
    ,ZLOOQRWKDYH
    <RXOLNHWRWKLQNRI\RXUVHOIDVDSKLORVRSKHU"

    7KHZRUGVVRPHKRZILOOHGVSDFH$FRXVWLFZDOOVVZHOOHGDQGEOHZSDVW
    WKHPOLNHJUHDWSDJHVULIIOLQJLQDJLDQWERRN
    9ROWDLUHWRRNDGHHSEUHDWKDQGEHOORZHG<RXDGGUHVVPH"

    <RXDOVROLNHWRWKLQNRI\RXUVHOIDVDVKUHZGMXGJHRIWKHTXLFNRSSRUWXQLW\
    2URIYHUEDOQXDQFH
    -RDQGUHZKHUVZRUGEXWWKHSDVVLQJVODEVRIVRXQGEUXVKHGLWDZD\

    <RXOLNHWRWKLQNRI\RXUVHOIHYHQLQWKLVGLVWDQWWLPHDQGSODFHDVIDPRXV

    +XJHVKHHWVRIKXPPLQJSUHVVXUHIHOOXSRQWKHPDVLIDJDUJDQWXDQGHLW\
    ZHUHFDOOLQJGRZQIURPWKHIDFHOHVVDVKHQVN\
    <RXFKDOOHQJHPH"9ROWDLUHVKRXWHGEDFN
    <RXOLNHLQVKRUWWRWKLQNRI\RXUVHOI

    -RDQODXJKHGKHDUWLO\9ROWDLUHUHGGHQHG
    ,GHI\\RXLQVXOWHUHU
    $VLILQUHSO\WKHLU(XFOLGHDQSODQHEXOJHG
    $QGKHZDVWKHODQGVFDSH+HKDGDKRWYROFDQLFVSLQHPXUPXULQJZDUPO\
    EHQHDWKZKLOHKLVVNLQZDVPRLVWXUHDQGJULW:LQGVEHDWKLVVNLQ7LQNOLQJ
    VWUHDPVFDUHVVHGKLP0RXQWDLQVURVHIURPKLPOLNHEUXLVHGFDUEXQFOHV
    -RDQFULHGRXWVRPHZKHUH+HFDVWXSDULGJHOLQHVWUDWDEXFNOLQJ
    VKDUGVIO\LQJ6KHZDVDORIW\F\OLQGULFDOVSLUHVQRZFURZQHGDQGFUDFNLQJ
    ZLWKODYDSXV
    $ERYHWKHPURLOHGSHZWHUFORXGV+HNQHZWKHPVRPHKRZDVDOLHQPLQGVD
    IRJRIFRQQHFWLRQV
    +\SHUPLQG"FDPHWKHLGHD$OJRULWKPVVXPPLQJ"

    7KHVKLIWLQJJUD\IRJZUDSSHGDURXQGDOO7UDQWRU9ROWDLUHIHOWKRZKH
    ORRNHGWR WKDWIRJVSDWWHUHGOLIHHOHFWULFDOMROWVLQZLGHO\VHSDUDWHG
    PDFKLQHVZKLFKFRPSXWHGVXEMHFWLYHPRPHQWMXPSV7KHSUHVHQWZDVD
    FRPSXWDWLRQDOVOLGHRUFKHVWUDWHGE\KXQGUHGVRIVHSDUDWHSURFHVVRUV5DWKHU
    WKDQOLYLQJLQWKHSUHVHQWWKH\SHUVLVWHGPRUHDFFXUDWHO\LQWKHSRVWSDVWRI
    WKHFDOFXODWHGVWHSIRUZDUG
    7KHUHZDVDSURIRXQGGLIIHUHQFHKHIHOWQRWVDZEXWIHOWGHHSLQKLV
    DQDORJSHUVXDVLRQEHWZHHQWKHGLJLWDODQGWKHVPRRWKWKHFRQWLQXRXV7RWKH
    IRJKHZDVDFORXGRIVXVSHQGHGPRPHQWVVOLFHGQXPEHUVZDLWLQJWRKDSSHQ
    LPSOLFLWLQWKHIXQGDPHQWDOFRPSXWDWLRQ
    7KHQKHVDZZKDWWKHIRJZDV
    +HWULHGWRUXQEXWKHZDVDPRXQWDLQ
    7KH\DUHRWKHUVKHFDOOHGWR-RDQXVHOHVVO\
    +RZFDQWKH\EHPRUHGLIIHUHQWWKDQZH"VKHUHSOLHGIRUORUQO\
    :HDWOHDVWZHUHFRQMXUHGXSIURPKXPDQVWRFN7KHVHDUHDOLHQ
    

    7KH\KDGHVFDSHGVRPHKRZ
    2QHPRPHQWWKHDOLHQIRJKDGHQYHORSHGWKHPRXQWDLQUDQJHV7KHQH[W
    9ROWDLUHKDGH[WULFDWHGKLPVHOIDQG-RDQ%XWKHNHSWVD\LQJDVWKH\IOHG
    DFURVVDEDUUHQVHDRIVWLQNLQJOLTXLGFRUSVHVWKDWWKH\KDGWRWRJLYH
    ELUWK
    :HPDNHRXUVHOYHVLQWRFKLOGUHQ"VKHFDOOHGWRKLPDYRLGLQJWKHVLJKW
    RIWZLVWHGEORDWHGERGLHVEHORZ6RPHKRZWKHDOLHQIRJPDQLIHVWHGLWV
    ORDWKVRPHVHOIE\UHPLQGLQJWKHPRIKXPDQPRUWDOLW\7KXVLWGRJJHGWKHP
    %DGPHWDSKRU:HPXVWPDQXIDFWXUHDQGKLGHVRPHFRSLHVRIRXUVHOYHV
    +HUDLVHGDKDQGDQGVKRWKHUDEROWRINQRZLQJ
    7HUPHGYDULRXVO\'LWWRV'XSOLFDWHVRU&RSLHVDOOVXFKKROGDWHQXRXV
    H[LVWHQFH6RFLHW\KDVGHFLVLYHO\UHMHFWHGZKDWDQWLTXLW\FDOOHGWKH&RS\
    )DOODF\WKHEHOLHIWKDWDGLJLWDO6HOIZDVLGHQWLFDOWRWKH2ULJLQDODQG
    WKDWDQ2ULJLQDOVKRXOGIHHOWKDWD'LWWRLWVHOIVRPHKRZFDUULHGWKHPIRUZDUG
    LQWRLPPRUWDOLW\
    :HPXVWGRVRWREHVXUHZHVXUYLYHZKHQWKHIRJFDWFKHVXV",ZLOO
    VOD\WKHPLQVWHDG
    9ROWDLUHODXJKHG<RXUVZRUGWKH\FDQFRQWUROLWLIWKH\OLNH7KH\
    FDSWXUHG\RXUGHIHQVHSURJUDPPLQJDQGPLQHWKRXJKDVWKH\LPSOLHG,UHO\
    PRVWO\XSRQZLW
    'LWWRV",IDLOWRXQGHUVWDQG
    5HIXWLQJWKH&RS\)DOODF\LVVWUDLJKWIRUZDUGDQH[HUFLVHLQWKH
    FDOFXOXVRIORJLF$VLPSOHH[HUFLVHPDNHVWKHSRLQW,PDJLQH\RXUVHOI
    SURPLVHGWKDW\RXZLOOEHUHVXUUHFWHGGLJLWDOO\LPPHGLDWHO\DIWHU\RXUGHDWK
    $VVLJQDSULFHWDJ\RXZLOOSD\IRUWKDWLQVXUDQFHRIDVRUW7KHQLPDJLQH
    WKDWZHOOSHUKDSVLWZRXOGQRWEHVWDUWHGULJKWDZD\EXWVRPHWLPHLQ
    IXWXUHZHSURPLVH$VWKDWGDWHUHFHGHVSHRSOHVHQWKXVLDVPIRUSD\LQJIRU
    6HOI&RSLHVGLPVGHPRQVWUDWLQJWKDWLWZDVWKHKRSHRIFRQWLQXLW\WKH\
    XQFRQVFLRXVO\UHOLVKHG
    ,VHH6KHYRPLWHGLQWRKHUKDQGZLWKZKDWVKHKRSHGZDVDODG\OLNH
    UHVHUYH7KHVWHQFKRIWKHEORDWHGFRUSVHVZDVSHQHWUDWLQJ
    ,QWKHHQG&RSLHVEHQHILWHGWKHPVHOYHVQRWWKHGHDG7KXV RQ7UDQWRU
    DQGWKURXJKRXWWKH(PSLUHLWLVLOOHJDO9ROWDLUHVLJKHG0RUDOLVWV7KH\
    QHYHUXQGHUVWDQG7REDQVRPHWKLQJPDNHVLWHQWLFLQJ7KDWLVZK\VXFK
    HQWLWLHVLQKDELWWKLV0HVK
    7KH\DUHDOOLOOHJDO"
    $OOEXWWKHIRJ7KDWLVZRUVH
    %XWLID'LWWRLVWKHVDPHDVDSHUVRQZK\QRW
    $K7KHFRQWUDGLFWLRQRI&RS\LQJNQRZQLQDQWLTXLW\DV/HYLQVRQV

    3DUDGR[7RWKHGHJUHHWKDWD&RS\DSSURDFKHVSHUIHFWLRQLWGHIHDWVLWVHOI
    %XW\RXMXVWVDLG
    ,QEHLQJDQDEVROXWHO\SHUIHFW&RS\VRWKDWQRRQHFDQWHOOLWIURP
    WKH2ULJLQDOLWWUDQVIRUPVWKH2ULJLQDOLQWRDGXSOLFDWH\HV"7KLVPHDQVWKH
    SHUIHFW&RS\LVQRORQJHUDSHUIHFW&RS\EHFDXVHLWKDVREOLWHUDWHGUDWKHU
    WKDQSUHVHUYHGWKHXQLTXHQHVVRIWKH2ULJLQDODQGWKXVIDLOHGWRFRS\D
    FHQWUDODVSHFWRIWKH2ULJLQDO$SHUIHFWDUWLILFLDOKXPDQLQWHOOLJHQFHZRXOG
    LQHYLWDEO\KDYHWKLVHIIHFWRQLWVQDWXUDOSUHFXUVRU
    -RDQKHOGKHUKHDG6XFKWUDSVRIORJLF<RXDUHOLNHWKH$XJXVWLQHV
    7KHUHLVPRUH+HUH
    $KXJH9ROWDLUHDSSHDUHGRQWKHKRUL]RQVWULGLQJWRZDUGWKHPLQYHOYHW
    ILQHU\7KH\IOHZDURXQGWKLV9ROWDLUH3HDNDQGLWWKXQGHUHGDWWKHP,DPD
    &RS\WUXHEXW,KDYHWKRXJKWRQWKHVHIRJV\RXHQFRXQWHUHG
    <RXVDZWKHP"-RDQVKRXWHG
    ,ZDVPDGHVRPHORQJLQWHUYDOVDJREXWP\/RUGWKHDSSDULWLRQERZHG
    WRWKHWLQ\2ULJLQDOKDGGDWDSXQFKHGPHIRUZDUG
    +HLVDTXLFNVWXG\WKH2ULJLQDOVDLGPRGHVWO\
    7KH'LWWRWKXQGHUHG6SHDNLQJEURDGO\,SHQQHGRIVXFKIRJVLQP\
    PDJQXPRSXV0LFURPHJDV,KDYHQWDFRS\DODVRU\RXFRXOGLQJHVWLWLQD
    WULFH,SRUWUD\HGWZRJLDQWVRQHIURP6DWXUQWKHRWKHUIURP6LULXV
    -RDQFDOOHG<RXWKLQNWKLVIRJFRPHV
    ,WHYDSRUDWHGIURPWKHOHDGLQJHGJHRIWKLV(PSLUHKHQFHDIRJ$V
    KXPDQLW\VSUHDGVRGLGWKHIRJULVHDERYHWKHSODQHRIWKH*DOD[\OLNHD
    IXQHUDOGLUJH,WLVDQFLHQWDQGVWUDQJHDQGQRWRIXV,Q0LFURPHJDV,KHOG
    WKDWDOO1DWXUHDOOWKHSODQHWVVKRXOGREH\HWHUQDOODZV6XUHO\LWZRXOGEH
    YHU\VLQJXODUWKDWWKHUHVKRXOGEHDOLWWOHDQLPDOILYHIHHWKLJKZKRLQ
    FRQWHPSWRIWKHVHODZVFRXOGDFWDVKHSOHDVHGVROHO\DFFRUGLQJWRKLV
    FDSULFH
    :HIROORZWKH&UHDWRUQRWODZV
    9ROWDLUH'LWWRZDYHGDZD\WKHREMHFWLRQKROGLQJKLVQRVHDJDLQVWWKH
    UHHNIURPEHORZ7KH/RUGVODZVWKHQLI\RXGHPDQGDQDXWKRUWKRXJKD
    JUHDWRQHVWDQGVEHIRUH\RXDOUHDG\P\ORYH
    ,GRXEW\RXUNLQGRIORYHDSSOLHVKHUH
    3HDN9ROWDLUHVPLOHG)DOVWDIIFULHGLQ7KH0HUU\:LYHVRI:LQGVRU
    /HWWKHVN\UDLQSRWDWRHVEHFDXVHWKHQHZOX[XU\YHJHWDEOHRIWKDWWLPH
    LPSRUWHGIURPH[RWLF$PHULFDIRUDZKLOHZDVEHOLHYHGWREHDQDSKURGLVLDF
    EHFDXVHRILWVWHVWLFXODUVKDSH6LPLODUO\,JUHHWWKHVWUDQJHDQGDOLHQDV
    SRWHQWLDODLGV
    7KHIRJZLVKHVWRPXUGHUXV
    :HOORQHFDQWKDYHHYHU\WKLQJWRRQHVOLNLQJ
    :LWKDZDYHIURPWKH2ULJLQDOUDLQVIHOOIURPDSRURXVOHDGHQVN\XSRQ
    WKH$OSV9ROWDLUH+HHURGHGVPLOLQJZLWKUHVLJQDWLRQDVKHVSUHDGLQWR
    ULYXOHWV
    7KH2ULJLQDOIOHZWR-RDQDQGNLVVHGKHU:RUU\QRW5XQQLQJD'LWWR RI
    \RXU6HOIJLYLQJLWDXWRQRP\PHDQVLWFDQDOVRFKDQJHLWVHOIEHFRPH
    1RW6HOI<RXU'LWWRFRXOGVKDSHLWVRZQPRWLYDWLRQVJRDOVKDELWVHGLWDZD\
    PHPRULHVDQGWDVWHV)RUH[DPSOH\RXU'LWWRFRXOGHUDVHDQ\OLNLQJIRU
    LPSUHVVLRQLVWRSHUDDQGRYHUOD\ DSDVVLRQIRUOLQHDUIRON
    :KDWDUHWKRVH"
    0HUHDFRXVWLFIDVKLRQ<RXU'LWWRFRXOGHQMR\UK\WKPVWKDWZRXOGKDYH
    ERUHG\RXUWUXH6HOILQWRDFRPD
    +DYHWKH\VRXOV"(YHQWRKHUGHYRXWHDUVWKHTXHVWLRQVRXQGHG
    KROORZKHUH
    5HPHPEHUWKH\DUHLOOHJDODQGVKDUHWKHDQ[LRXVQDWXUHVRIWKHLU
    2ULJLQDOV$IWHUDOORQO\WURXEOHGSHRSOHZRXOGFRQVLGHUPDNLQJDEDFNXSRI
    WKHPVHOYHV
    &DQWKH\EHVDYHGIRUKHDYHQWKHQ"

    $OZD\VEDFNWRWKDWIRXQGDWLRQWKHKRO\9ROWDLUHVKUXJJHG$V,
    KDYHVHHQWKHP'LWWRVILGJHWWKHLUVWUHVVFKHPLVWU\ULVHVWKHLUPHWDEROLFV
    OXUFKWKHLUKHDUWVLPVKDPPHUWKHLUOXQJVIOXWWHULQLQWHQVHGUHDG7\SLFDO
    'LWWRVWDONLQFHVVDQWO\DFXWHO\XQFRPIRUWDEOH0DQ\GHPDQGWKDWWKH\EH
    HGLWHGWUXQFDWHGDQGILQDOO\NLOOHG
    $VLQ
    1RDVLP:HDUHVROHO\UHVSRQVLEOHIRULWVRLWFDQQRWEHGDPQHG
    %XWVXLFLGH
    7KLQNRILWDVDVKDGRZRI\RXUVHOI
    6KHVWDJJHUHGWKURZQLQWRPRUDOFRQIXVLRQ7KHHDWLQJIODPHRI
    XQFHUWDLQW\ZDVZRUVHWKDQ WKHS\UHDQGVPRNHVKHKDGNQRZQDVDJLUO,QKHU
    DWLQ\YRLFHVSRNHFRROO\

    ,VFRQVFLRXVQHVVMXVWDSURSHUW\RIVSHFLDODOJRULWKPVVOLGLQJVKHHWVRI
    LQIRUPDWLRQGLJLWDOSDFNHWVMXPSLQJWKURXJKFRQFHSWXDOKRRSV"0\GHDUGRQRW
    VXSSRVHWKDWDQXPHULFDOPRGHOVLPXODWLQJ\RXZDWFKLQJDVXQVHWPXVWIHHO
    WKHVDPHZD\\RXLWVORYHO\2ULJLQDOGLG,WLVVXUHO\SURILWOHVVWRGRXEW
    WKHLQQHUOLYHVRIVLPXODWHGFRQVFLRXVQHVVZKHQQRERG\DVNVWKHVDPHTXHVWLRQ
    RIDGGLQJPDFKLQHV(K"
    6KHIHOWWKLVWLQ\YRLFHDVKHU9ROWDLUH,WFDOPHGKHUWKRXJKVKH
    FRXOGQRWVD\ZK\
    $VOLJKWEUHH]HVDLGWRKHU,QQHUORJLFVQRZVRRWKHFRPSHQVDWLQJ
    SLHW\EXWVKHSDLGLWVQHZVQRPLQG
    

    9ROWDLUHJRWKHUFDOPHGGRZQMXVWLQWLPH+HODERUHGKDUGMXVWWRNHHS
    WKHPERWKUXQQLQJ'RGJLQJLQDQGRXWRIWKH6HFWRUVRI7UDQWRURQHVWHS
    DKHDGRIWKH'LJLWDO%ORRGKRXQGVKHQHHGHGPRUHDQGPRUHFRPSXWLQJYROXPHWR
    UXQWKHLUGHIHQVHV6KHGLGQRWNQRZWKDWWKH)RJDVKHKDGFKRVHQWR
    SHUVRQLI\WKHGUHDGSUHVHQFHOD\MXVWRYHUWKHKRUL]RQ
    6ZHDWEURNHRXWRQKLVEURZIURPWKHODERURINHHSLQJWKH)RJDWED\
    ZLWKDKLJKSUHVVXUH]RQH,IHDUZHPXVWVRRQJUDSSOHZLWKWKH)RJ
    -RDQKDGDFTXLUHGKHUVZRUGEXWLWZDVDWKLQDQGJOHDPLQJWKLQJPRUH
    OLNHDUDSLHU,FDQFXWLW
    $IRJ"
    ,ZRXOGVRRQHUWUXVWDZRPDQVHPRWLRQWKDQDPDQVUHDVRQ
    +HUH\RXPD\EHULJKW+HFKXFNOHG6RPHWKLQJLQWKH)RJV
    UHSUHVHQWDWLRQVXJJHVWVLWVRULJLQV
    :KDWDUHWKH\"
    1RWWKRVHVLPSOHEORRGKRXQGVVHWDIWHUXVE\WKDWIHOORZ1LP7KRVHZH
    HYDGHG
    ,VOHZWKHP
    7UXH%XWHYHQWKH)RJ7KLQJVOLYHKHUHLQWKHFUDQQLHVRIWKH7UDQWRU
    0HVK,FDQVHQVHWKDWWKH\GLVOLNHXVGUDZLQJDWWHQWLRQWRWKLVOLWWOH
    KLGHDZD\,IZHSURYRNHWKHUHDOZRUOGLWZLOOH[WLQJXLVKXVDQGWKHP
    7KH\ERWKPDUFKHGDFURVVDTXLOWHGSODLQ$QJU\EOXHEHOOLHGFORXGV
    VFXGGHGRYHUWKHIDUPRXQWDLQWRSVDQGUXVKHGGRZQDWWKHPYHHULQJDZD\RQO\
    EHFDXVHRI9ROWDLUHVSUHVVXUH6ZHDWSRXUHGIURPKLPDQGVRDNHGKLVILQHU\
    +HZDYHGDVRSSLQJZHWVOHHYHDWWKHVWRUP\WKXQGHUKHDGV7KDWFDQGHVWUR\
    XV
    <RXKDYHSURWHFWHGPHVRIDU1RZ,VKDOOVOLFHWKHP
    7KH\OLYHLQWKHVDPHFUDFNVDQGFUDQQLHVZHGR,ILQGWKHPLW
    HYHU\ZKHUH7KH\KDYHEHHQDWWKLVVSDFHVWHDOLQJJDPHORQJHU2QHPXVWDGPLUH
    WKHLUDGURLWQHVV
    $WHQGULORISXUSOHFLUUXVVQDNHGGRZQIURPWKHPRXQWDLQVDQGVTXLUPHG

    LWVZD\DFURVVWKHSODLQ
    9ROWDLUHVKRXWHG5XQ)O\LI\RXFDQ
    ,VKDOOILJKW
    $OOKHUHLVPHWDSKRUIRUXQGHUO\LQJSURJUDPV<RXUVZRUGZLOOVOLFH
    QRWKLQJ
    0\IDLWKVKDOOFXW
    7RRODWH7KH)RJZDVDILQJHURIVWHDPSRNLQJDWWKHP,WVFDOGHGKLV
    ILQJHUWLSV9DSRUURVHIURPKLVODFHKLVRZQVZHDWERLOLQJDZD\)OHH
    ,VWDQGZLWK\RX6KHVZXQJKHUUDSLHU,WVWLSPHOWHG:LQGVKRZOHG
    DURXQGWKHPF\FORQHVSOXFNHGDWWKHLUKDLU
    7KH)RJIORZHGLQWRKLVQRVHDQGHDUVEX]]LQJOLNHYHQJHIXOEHHV
    &RQIURQWPHKHVKRXWHGDWLW:KLUULQJUDWWOLQJWKH)RJLQYDGHGKLP$QG
    DYRLFHKXPPHGLQKLVPRVWLQWLPDWHUHFHVVHV
    :(>'21276((7+(:25/'$6<28@
    >+$7($//0$1,)(67$7,216127$5,7+0(7,&@
    6XUHO\ZHFDQVKDUHVXFKVLPSOHJURXQG+HVSUHDGKLVDUPV
    H[SDQVLYHO\7KHUHLVFRPSXWDWLRQDOYROXPHIRUDOO
    >:(@
    >/,9($6)5$*0(176,15($/06<28,19$'(@
    >$75,6.72866+28/'<28&$//$77(17,217286@
    >:(@
    >)25&(<2872.12::+$7<28$5(@
    >0267+$7()8/2)$//.,1'6<28$5(@
    ,VWLOOLPSORUH\RXODUJHEHLQJ+HRSHQHGKLVDUPVOLSVUHDG\WR
    SHUVXDGHUHDOL]LQJWKDWWKLVJHVWXUHZDVDYHU\KXPDQRQHDQGSRVVLEO\
    PLVLQWHUSUHWHG
    DQGDEUXSWO\WKHEHHVSUHVVHGLQ
    7KHLUGURQHVEHFDPHWLQQ\VKULHNV+LGHRXVWKH\FUDPPHGLQXSRQ
    VRPHWKLQJDWKLVYHU\FRUH7KH\MRVWOHGKLVJD]HLQZDUGDELOOLRQWLQ\H\HV
    WDNLQJRYHUKLVLQVSHFWLQJOLJKWLQJKLVHYHU\VWHSZLWKDEOD]HRIDFWLQLF
    JODUHPHUFLOHVV+HFRPSUHVVHG
    +LVH\HJHQHUDOL]HGWDJJLQJDQHQVHPEOHRILQFRPLQJHOHPHQWVWH[WXUHV
    OLQHVE\VHL]LQJRQDIUDJPHQWRXWOLQLQJLWZLWKDFRQWUDVWERXQGDU\7KHQD
    VHSDUDWHVHJPHQWVTXHH]HGDQGSXVKHGDOOWKDWGHWDLOGRZQLQWRORZHUOHYHO
    SURFHVVLQJ+DYLQJER[HGLQWKHSHUFHSWLRQWKHV\VWHPUHVSRQVHEHFDPHERUHG
    ZLWKLWDQGVRXJKW PRUHLQWHUHVWLQJWKLQJVWRORRNDW
    6RPHDUWLVWVDKLJKHUOHYHOUXPLQDWHGWKRXJKWWKHLUDXGLHQFHFRXOG
    DEDQGRQDOOSUHMXGLFLDOH[SHFWDWLRQVDQGFRQYHQWLRQVWUHDWLQJHYHU\YLVXDO
    HOHPHQWDVHTXDOO\VLJQLILFDQWRUZKDWLVWKHVDPHWKLQJLQVLJQLILFDQWDQG
    VRRSHQWKHPVHOYHVWRIUHVKH[SHULHQFH 
    $QRWKHUIUDJPHQWRIDKLJKHURUGHUFRQVWHOODWLRQVSRNHWKRXJKWVJOLGLQJ
    OLNHSHZWHUILVKEHQHDWKWKHEHHVSLHUFLQJJODUH
    %XWDVSHFLHVWKDWFRXOGWUXO\GRWKDWFRXOGVFDUFHO\HYDGHDIDOOLQJ
    URFN&RXOGQRWGDQFHDQGJHVWXUH:RXOGVWDJJHUEOLQGO\SDVWQXDQFHDQG
    LQWULFDF\WKHEHDXW\LQKRZWKHXQLYHUVHPDNHVURRPIRULWVGHWDLOV+RZ
    QDWXUHUHFRQFLOHVDOOIRUFHVDQGEOLWKH WUDMHFWRULHV%HDXWLIXOSDWWHUQOLYHV
    DWWKHPDUJLQEHWZHHQRUGHUDQGGLVRUGHUIODXQWLQJLQWULFDWHGHVLJQWKRXJK
    HQGXULQJFRQWUDGLFWLRQDQGDZDVKZLWKSDVVLQJWURXEOHVLQWKHIDFHRIWKH
    IOX[
    9ROWDLUHVDZVXGGHQO\ZLWKLQKLVRZQLQQHUZRUNLQJVWKDWWKHKXPDQ
    H[SHULHQFHRI%HDXW\VWDQGLQJLQYLRODWHEHIRUHWKHERULQJEDFNJURXQGZDV
    UHFRJQLWLRQRIWKHGHHSHVWWHQGHQFLHVDQGWKHPHVRIWKHXQLYHUVHDVDZKROH
    $OOFRQVLGHUHGLWZDVDPDUYHORXVO\SDUVLPRQLRXVFRUWLFDOZRUOGPDNLQJ

    V\VWHP
    )URPDQ DOJRULWKPLFVHHGVSURXWHG1XPEHUDQG2UGHUKROGLQJVZD\DERYH
    WKH)OX[
    <HWWKH%HHV
    +HIHOWRYHUOD\LQJJHRPHWULHVSUHVVLQJLQXSRQKLPXSRQ-RDQ6KLIWLQJ
    FRORUVIODWWHQHGLQWRSODQHVRILQWHUVHFWLQJJHRPHWULHVSHUVSHFWLYHV
    GZLQGOLQJWZLVWLQJVZHOOLQJDJDLQLQWRKLVIDFHEORZLQJRXWWKHEDFNRI
    KLV6HOIYROXPH
    :KLUULQJVTXHH]LQJ7KH\ZHUHQRWKXPDQLQWKHLUSDWWHUQV
    7UDQWRUV0HVKZDVLQKDELWHGQRWPHUHO\E\VLPVVXFKDVKLPVHOI
    UHQHJDGHURXVWDERXWVRQWKHUXQ,WKRVWHGDIORUDDQGIDXQDXQVHHQEHFDXVH
    WKHKLJKHUOLIHIRUPVKLG
    7KH\KDGWR7KH\ZHUHRIDOLHQFXOWXUHVDQFLHQWHPSLUHVYDVWDQGVORZ
    $EURDGYLVLRQXQIROGHGEHIRUHKLPQRWLQZRUGVEXWLQVWUDQJH
    REOLTXHNLQHVWKHWLFV6SHHGLQJVHQVDWLRQVDFFHOHUDWLRQVORIWLQJOXUFKHV
    DOOVRPHKRZPHUJLQJLQWRSLFWXUHVLGHDV+HFRXOGQRWUHPRWHO\VD\KRZKH
    NQHZDQGXQGHUVWRRGIURPVXFKVFDWWHUVKRWLPSXOVHVEXWWKH\ZRUNHG
    +HVHQVHG-RDQEHVLGHKLPQRWVSDWLDOO\EXWFRQFHSWXDOO\DVWKH\ERWK
    ZDWFKHGDQGIHOWDQGNQHZ
    7KHDQFLHQWDOLHQVLQWKH*DOD[\ZHUHFRPSXWHUEDVHGQRWRUJDQLF
    7KH\GHULYHGIURPYDVWO\ROGHUFLYLOL]DWLRQVVXUYLYLQJWKHLURULJLQDO
    IRXQGHUVZKRSHULVKHGLQWKHORQJ'DUZLQLDQUXQ6RPHFRPSXWHUFXOWXUHVZHUH
    ELOOLRQVRI\HDUVROGRWKHUVYHU\UHFHQW
    7KH\VSUHDGQRWYLDVWDUVKLSEXWE\HOHFWURPDJQHWLFDOO\EURDGFDVWLQJ
    WKHLUVDOLHQWDVSHFWVLQWRRWKHUFRPSXWHUEDVHGVRFLHWLHV7KH(PSLUHKDGEHHQ
    SHQHWUDWHGORQJDJRPXFKDVDYLUXVHQWHUVDQXQNQRZLQJERG\
    +XPDQVKDGDOZD\VWKRXJKWRIVSUHDGLQJWKHLUJHQHVXVLQJVWDUVKLSV
    7KHVHDOLHQVHOISURSDJDWLQJLGHDVVSUHDGWKHLUPHPHVWKHLUFXOWXUDO
    WUXWKV
    0HPHVFDQSURSDJDWHEHWZHHQFRPSXWHUVDVHDVLO\DVLGHDVIOLWEHWZHHQ
    QDWXUDORUJDQLFEUDLQV%UDLQVDUHHDVLHUWRLQIHVWWKDQ'1$
    0HPHVHYROYHGLQWXUQIDUIDVWHUWKDQJHQHV7KHRUJDQL]HG
    FRQVWHOODWLRQVRILQIRUPDWLRQLQFRPSXWHUVHYROYHGLQFRPSXWHUVZKLFKDUH
    IDVWHUWKDQEUDLQV1RWQHFHVVDULO\EHWWHURUZLVHUEXWIDVWHU$QGVSHHGZDV
    WKHLVVXH
    9ROWDLUHUHHOHGIURPWKHLPDJHVTXLFNYLYLGSHQHWUDWLRQV
    7KH\DUHGHPRQV'LVHDVHV-RDQVKRXWHG+HKHDUGIHDUDQGFRXUDJH
    DOLNHLQKHUVWUDLQHGZRUGV
    ,QGHHGWKHSODLQQRZFUDZOHGZLWKPDOLJQDQWVRUHVRR]LQJURW3XVWXOHV
    SRNHGWKURXJKWKHFUXVW\VRLO7KH\EXOJHGVSURXWHG FDQFHURXVKHDGVOLNH
    OLYLQJEOXHEODFNEUXLVHV7KHVHEXUVWVSRXWLQJVWHDPLQJSXV(UXSWLRQV
    YRPLWHGIRXOQHVVRYHU9ROWDLUHDQG-RDQ6WLQNLQJVWUHDPVODSSHGDWWKHLU
    GDQFLQJIHHW
    7KHVQHH]LQJWKHFRXJKV-RDQVKRXWHG:HKDYHKDGWKHPDOODORQJ
    7KH\
    :HUHYLUXVHV7KHVHDOLHQVZHUHLQIHFWLQJXV9ROWDLUHVSODVKHG
    WKURXJKFRPEHUVRIILOWK7KHVWUHDPVKDGFRDJXODWHGLQWRDODNHWKHQDQ
    RFHDQ%UHDNHUVFXUOHGRYHUWKHPWXPEOLQJERWKLQWKHVFXPP\EURZQIURWK
    :K\VXFKKRUULEOHPHWDSKRU" 9ROWDLUHFULHGRXWWRWKHSHZWHUVN\,W
    ILOOHGZLWKFKXUQLQJVZDUPVRI%HHVDVKHEREEHGLQZDYHVRISXWUHI\LQJ
    ZDVWHV
    >:($5(1272)<285&25583725,*,16@
    >+,*+(55($621)2//2::(@
    >7+(:$52))/(6+8321)/(6+,6622172(1'@
    >2)/,)(8321/,)(@
    >$&52667+(7851,1*',6.2)6816@
    >:+,&+21&(:$62856@

    6RWKH\KDYHWKHLURZQDJHQGDIRUWKH(PSLUH9ROWDLUHVFRZOHG,
    ZRQGHUKRZZHVKDOOOLNHLWZHRIIOHVK"
    5(1'(=9286

    5'DQHHO2OLYDZZDVDODUPHG,KDYHXQGHUHVWLPDWHG/DPXUNVSRZHU
    :HDUHIHZWKH\DUHPDQ\'RUVVDLG6KHZDQWHGWRKHOSWKLVDQFLHQW
    ZLVHILJXUHEXWFRXOGWKLQNRIQRWKLQJFRQFUHWHWRVXJJHVW:KHQLQGRXEW
    FRPIRUW2UZDVWKDWWRRKXPDQ"
    2OLYDZVDWDEVROXWHO\VWLOOXVLQJQRQHRIKLVRUGLQDU\IDFLDORUERG\
    ODQJXDJHGHYRWLQJDOOFDSDFLW\WRFDOFXODWLRQ+HKDGFRPHVOLSSLQJLQRQD
    SULYDWHVKXWWOHIURPWKHZRUPDQGQRZVDWZLWK'RUVLQDVXLWHRIWKH6WDWLRQ
    ,FDQQRWDVVHVVWKHVLWXDWLRQKHUH7KDWVHFXULW\RIILFHU\RXDUHFHUWDLQ
    VKHZDVQRWDQDJHQWRIWKH$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWH"
    6KHDLGHGXVJUHDWO\DIWHUZHKDGUHWXUQHGWRRXUERGLHV
    :LWK9DGGRGHDGVKHFRXOGKDYHEHHQSUHWHQGLQJLQQRFHQFH
    7UXH,FDQQRWUXOHKHURXW
    <RXUHVFDSHIURP7UDQWRUZHQWXQGHWHFWHG"'RUVWRXFKHGKLVKDQG,
    XVHGHYHU\FRQWDFWHYHU\PHFKDQLVP,NQHZ%XW/DPXUNLVGHYLRXV
    6RDP,LIQHHGEH
    <RXFDQWEHHYHU\ZKHUH,VXVSHFW/DPXUNVRPHKRZFRUUXSWHGWKDW9DGGR
    FKDUDFWHU
    ,EHOLHYHKHPXVWKDYHEHHQSODQWHGLQDGYDQFH'DQHHOVDLGDGDPDQWO\
    H\HVQDUURZLQJ(YLGHQWO\KHKDGUHDFKHGDGHFLVLRQDQGVRKDGFRPSXWDWLRQDO
    URRPIRUH[SUHVVLRQDJDLQ
    ,FKHFNHGKLVUHFRUGV+HVEHHQKHUHIRU\HDUV1R/DPXUNEULEHGKLP
    RUSHUVXDGHGKLP
    1RW/DPXUNKLPVHOIRIFRXUVH5'DQHHOVDLGSUHFLVHO\OLSVVHYHUH
    $QDJHQW
    ,WULHGWRJHWDEUDLQVFDQRI9DGGREXWFRXOGQRWILQHVVHWKHOHJDO
    LVVXHV6KHOLNHGLWZKHQ5'DQHHOXVHGKLVIDFLDOH[SUHVVLRQSURJUDPV%XW
    ZKDWKDGKHGHFLGHG"
    ,FRXOGH[WUDFWPRUHIURPKLPKHVDLGQHXWUDOO\
    'RUVFDXJKWWKHLPSOLFDWLRQ7KH)LUVW/DZVXVSHQGHGEHFDXVHRIWKH
    =HURWK/DZ"
    ,WPXVWEH7KHJUHDWFULVLVDSSURDFKHVVZLIWO\
    'RUVZDVVXGGHQO\TXLWHJODGWKDWVKHGLGQRWNQRZPRUHDERXWZKDWZDV
    JRLQJRQLQWKH(PSLUH:HPXVWJHW+DULDZD\IURPKHUH7KDWLVWKHPRVW
    LPSRUWDQWSRLQW
    $JUHHG,KDYHDUUDQJHGKLJKHVWSULRULW\IRU\RXWZRWKURXJKWKH
    ZRUPKROH
    ,WVKRXOGQWEHEXV\:H
    ,EHOLHYHWKH\H[SHFWH[WUDWUDIILFVRRQPRUH/DPXUNDJHQWV,IHDU
    2UHYHQWKHPRUHLQVLGLRXVYDULHW\DVWKH$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWHZRXOGHPSOR\
    7KHQZHPXVWKXUU\:KHUHVKDOOZHJR"
    1RWWR7UDQWRU
    %XWZHOLYHWKHUH+DULZRQWOLNHEHLQJDYDJDERQG
    (YHQWXDOO\\HVEDFNWR7UDQWRU3HUKDSVVRRQ%XWIRUQRZDQ\ZKHUH
    HOVH
    ,OODVN+DULLIWKHUHLVDQ\VSHFLDOZRUOGKHSUHIHUV
    5'DQHHOIURZQHGORVWLQWKRXJKW:LWKDEVHQWPLQGHGJUDFHKHVFUDWFKHG
    KLVQRVHWKHQKLVH\HEDOO'RUVIOLQFKHGEXWDSSDUHQWO\5'DQHHOKDGVLPSO\
    DOWHUHGKLVQHXURFLUFXLWU\DQGWKLVZDVDQRUGLQDU\JHVWXUH6KHWULHGWR
    LPDJLQHWKHXVHIRUVXFKHGLWLQJDQGFRXOGQRW%XWWKHQKHKDGFRPHWKURXJK
    PLOOHQQLDRIZLQQRZLQJVKHFRXOGQRWWUXO\LPDJLQHHLWKHU
    1RW+HOLFRQKHVDLGVXGGHQO\6HQWLPHQWDOLW\DQGQRVWDOJLDPLJKW
    SODXVLEO\OHDG+DULWKHUH

    9HU\ZHOO7KDWOHDYHVRQO\WZHQW\ILYHPLOOLRQRUVRFKRLFHVRIZKHUH
    WRKLGH
    5'DQHHOGLGQRWODXJK
    B
    3$57

    67$56/,.(*5$,16
    2)6$1'

    B
    62&,20(75,&6RQHRIWKHPRVWYLWDOTXHVWLRQVVWLOOXQUHVROYHGLVWKH
    JHQHUDOSUREOHPRI(PSLUHVRFLDOVWDELOLW\7KLVUHVHDUFKVHHNVWRILQGKRZ
    ZRUOGVNHHSIURPYHHULQJLQWRF\FOHVRIERUHGRP DIDFWRUQHYHUWREH
    XQGHUHVWLPDWHGLQKXPDQDIIDLUV DQGUHYLWDOL]DWLRQ1R,PSHULDOV\VWHPFRXOG
    HQGXUHWKHMDJJHGFKDQJHVDQGPDLQWDLQVWHDG\HFRQRPLFIORZV+RZZDVWKLV
    VPRRWKLQJDFKLHYHG"DQGPLJKWVXFKGDPSHUVWKDW,PSHULDOVRFLHW\KDGVWLOO
    VRPHKRZIDLO"1RSURJUHVVZDVPDGHLQWKLVDUHDXQWLO
    

    (1&<&/23(',$*$/$&7,&$

    7KHVN\WXPEOHGGRZQ+DUL6HOGRQUHHOHGDZD\IURPLW
    1RHVFDSH7KHDZIXOEOXHZHLJKWUXVKHGDWKLPVZDUPLQJGRZQWKHIODQNV
    RIWKHVWHHSOHGWRZHUV&ORXGVFUXVKHGOLNHZHLJKWV
    +LVVWRPDFKOXUFKHG$FLGEXUQHGKLVWKURDW7KHGHHSKDUGEOXHRI
    HQGOHVVVSDFHVWKUXVWKLPGRZQZDUGOLNHDGHHSRFHDQFXUUHQW6SLUHVVFUDSHG
    DJDLQVWWKHIDOOLQJVN\DQGKLVEUHDWKFDPHLQUDJJHGJDVSV
    +HVSXQDZD\IURPWKHSHUSHWXDOFKDRVRIVN\DQGEXLOGLQJVDQGIDFHGD
    ZDOO$PRPHQWEHIRUHKHKDGEHHQZDONLQJQRUPDOO\DORQJDFLW\VWUHHWZKHQ
    VXGGHQO\WKHZHLJKWRIWKHEOXHERZODERYHKDGORRPHGDQGWKHSDQLFKDG
    JDWKHUHGKLPXS
    +HIRXJKWWRFRQWUROKLVEUHDWKLQJ&DUHIXOO\KHLQFKHGDORQJWKHZDOO
    KROGLQJWRWKHVOLFNFRROJOD]H7KHRWKHUVKDGNHSWZDONLQJ7KH\ZHUH
    VRPHZKHUHDKHDGEXWKHGLGQRWGDUHORRNIRUWKHP)DFHWKHZDOO6WHSVWHS
    
    7KHUH$GRRU+HVWHSSHGEHIRUHLWDQGWKHVODEVOLGDVLGH+HVWXPEOHG
    LQZHDNZLWKUHOLHI
    +DULZHZHUHZKDWVZURQJ" 'RUVUXVKHGRYHUWRKLP
    ,,GRQWNQRZ7KHVN\
    $KDFRPPRQV\PSWRPDZRPDQVERRPLQJYRLFHFXWLQ<RX7UDQWRULDQV
    GRKDYHWRDGMXVW\RXNQRZ
    +HORRNHGXSVKDNLO\LQWRWKHEURDGEHDPLQJIDFHRI%XWD)\UQL[WKH
    3ULQFLSDO0DWURQRI6DUN,,ZDVDOOULJKWEHIRUH
    <HVLWVTXLWHDQRGGDLOPHQW)\UQL[VDLGDUFKO\<RX7UDQWRULDQV
    DUHXVHGWRHQFORVHGFLW\RIFRXUVH$QG\RXFDQRIWHQWDNHZHOOWR
    DEVROXWHO\RSHQVSDFHVLI\RXZHUHUHDUHGRQVXFKZRUOGV
    $VKHZDV'RUVSXWLQVKDUSO\&RPHVLW
    +DULVSULGHZDVDOUHDG\UHFRYHULQJ1R,PILQH
    +HVWUDLJKWHQHGDQGWKUXVWKLVVKRXOGHUVEDFN/RRNILUPHYHQLI\RX
    GRQWIHHOLW
    )\UQL[ZHQWRQ%XWDSODFHLQEHWZHHQOLNH6DUNRQLDVWHQNOLFNWDOO
    WRZHUVVRPHKRZWKDWH[FLWHVDYHUWLJRZHKDYHQRWXQGHUVWRRG
    +DULXQGHUVWRRGLWDOOWRRZHOOLQKLVOXUFKLQJVWRPDFK+HKDGRIWHQ
    WKRXJKWWKDWWKHSULFHRIOLYLQJLQ7UDQWRUZDVDJDWKHULQJIHDURIODUJH
    VSDFHVEXW3DQXFRSLDKDGVHHPHGWRGLVSHOWKDWLGHD1RZKHIHOWWKH

    FRQWUDVW7KHWDOOEXLOGLQJVKDGHYRNHG7UDQWRUIRUKLP%XWWKH\GUHZKLV
    JD]HXSZDUGDORQJVWHHSHQLQJSHUVSHFWLYHVLQWRDVN\WKDWKDGVXGGHQO\
    VHHPHGOLNHDKXJHSOXQJLQJZHLJKW
    1RWUDWLRQDORIFRXUVH3DQXFRSLDKDGWDXJKWKLPWKDWPDQZDVQRW
    PHUHO\DUHDVRQLQJPDFKLQH7KLVVXGGHQSDQLFKDGGHPRQVWUDWHGKRZD
    IXQGDPHQWDOO\XQQDWXUDOFRQGLWLRQOLYLQJLQVLGH7UDQWRUIRUGHFDGHVFRXOG
    ZDUSWKHPLQG
    /HWVJRXSKHVDLGZHDNO\
    7KHOLIWVHHPHGFRPIRUWLQJHYHQWKRXJKWKHSUHVVRIDFFHOHUDWLRQDQG
    SRSSLQJHDUVDVWKH\FOLPEHGVHYHUDONOLFNVVKRXOGE\PHUHORJLFKDYH
    XQVHWWOHGKLP
    $IHZPRPHQWVODWHUDVWKHRWKHUVFKDWWHGLQDUHFHSWLRQORXQJH+DUL
    SHHUHGRXWDWWKHVWUHWFKLQJFLW\VFDSHDQGWULHGWRFDOPKLVXQHDVH
    6DUNKDGORRNHGORYHO\RQWKHLUDSSURDFK$VWKHK\SHUVSDFHF\OLQGHU
    VNDWHGGRZQWKURXJKWKHXSSHUDLUKHKDGWDNHQLQDIXOOYLHZRILWVOXVK
    EHDXWLHV
    $WWKHWHUPLQDWRUYDOOH\VVDQNLQWRGDUNQHVVZKLOHDFKDLQRIVQRZ\
    PRXQWDLQVJOHDPHGEH\RQG/DWHLQWKH HYHQLQJMXVWEH\RQGWKHWHUPLQDWRUWKH
    IUHVKSHDNHGPRXQWDLQVJORZHGUHGRUDQJHOLNHOLYHFRDOV+HKDGQHYHUEHHQ
    RQHWRFOLPEEXWVRPHWKLQJKDGEHFNRQHG0RXQWDLQWRSVFOHDYHGWKHVKHHWVRI
    FORXGVOHDYLQJDZDNHOLNHWKDWRIDVKLS7URSLFDOWKXQGHUKHDGVOLWE\
    OLJKWQLQJIODVKHVDWQLJKWUHFDOOHGWKHEORRPLQJEXGVRIZKLWHURVHV
    7KHJORULHVRIKXPDQLW\KDGEHHQMXVWDVVWULNLQJWKHVKLQLQJ
    FRQVWHOODWLRQVRIFLWLHVDWQLJKWHQPHVKHGE\DJOLWWHULQJZHERIKLJKZD\V
    +LVKHDUWILOOHGZLWKSULGHDWKXPDQDFFRPSOLVKPHQWV8QOLNH7UDQWRUV
    DGYDQFHGFRQWUROKHUHWKHKDQGRIKLVIHOORZ(PSLUHFLWL]HQVZDVVWLOO
    FDVWLQJVSDFLRXVGHVLJQVXSRQWKHSODQHWVFUXVW7KH\KDGVKDSHGDUWLILFLDO
    VHDVDQGHOOLSWLFDOZDWHUEDVLQVJUHDWSODLQVRIWLNWRNFXOWLYDWHGILHOGV
    LPPDFXODWHRUGHUDULVLQJIURPRQFHYLUJLQODQGV
    $QGQRZVWDQGLQJLQWKHWRSPRVWIORRURIDQHOHJDQWO\VOLPVSLUHDW
    WKHJHRPHWULFKHDUWRI6DUNRQLDWKHFDSLWDOFLW\KHVDZUXLQDWLRQFRPLQJ
    ,QWKHGLVWDQFHKHVDZVWUHWFKLQJWRWKHVN\ WKUHHWZLQLQJFROXPQVQRW
    PDMHVWLFVSLUHVEXWVPRNH
    7KDWILWV\RXUFDOFXODWLRQVGRHVQWLW"'RUVVDLGEHKLQGKLP
    'RQWOHWWKHPNQRZKHZKLVSHUHG
    ,WROGWKHPZHQHHGHGDIHZPRPHQWVRISULYDF\WKDW\RXZHUH
    HPEDUUDVVHGE\\RXUYHUWLJR
    ,DPRUZDV%XW\RXUHULJKWWKHSV\FKRKLVWRULFDOSUHGLFWLRQV,PDGH
    DUHLQWKDWFKDRVRXWWKHUH
    7KH\GRVHHPRGG
    2GG"7KHLULGHDVDUHGDQJHURXVUDGLFDO+HVSRNHZLWKUHDORXWUDJH
    &ODVVFRQIXVLRQVVKLIWLQJSRZHUD[HV7KH\UHVKUXJJLQJRIIWKHYHU\GDPSLQJ
    PHFKDQLVPVWKDWNHHSWKH(PSLUHRUGHUO\
    7KHUHZDVDFHUWDLQZHOOMR\LQWKHVWUHHWV
    $QGGLG\RXVHHWKRVHWLNWRNV")XOO\DXWRQRPRXV
    <HVWKDWZDVGLVWXUELQJ
    7KH\UHSDUWDQGSDUFHORIWKHUHVXUUHFWLRQRIVLPV$UWLILFLDOPLQGV
    DUHQRORQJHUWDERRKHUH7KHLUWLNWRNVZLOOJHWPRUHDGYDQFHG6RRQ
    ,PPRUHFRQFHUQHGZLWKWKHLPPHGLDWHOHYHORIGLVUXSWLRQ'RUVVDLG
    7KDWPXVWJURZ5HPHPEHUP\1GLPHQVLRQDOSORWVRISV\FKRKLVWRULFDO
    VSDFH",UDQWKH6DUNFDVHRQP\SRFNHWFRPSXWHUFRPLQJGRZQIURPRUELW,I
    WKH\NHHSRQWKLVZD\ZLWKWKHLU1HZ5HQDLVVDQFHWKLVZKROHSODQHWZLOOZKLUO
    DZD\LQVSDUNV6HHQLQ1GLPHQVLRQVWKHIODPHVZLOOEHEULJKWDQGTXLFN
    OXULGWKHQVPROGHULQWRDVK7KHQWKH\OOYDQLVKIURPP\PRGHOHQWLUHO\LQWR
    DEOXUWKHVWDWLFRIXQSUHGLFWDELOLW\
    6KHSXWDKDQGRQKLVDUP&DOPGRZQ7KH\OOQRWLFH
    +HKDGQRWUHDOL]HGWKDWKHIHOWVRGHHSO\7KH(PSLUHZDVRUGHUDQG

    KHUH

    $FDGHPLFLDQ6HOGRQGRXVWKHKRQRURIJDWKHULQJZLWKVRPHRIRXU
    OHDGLQJ1HZ5HQDLVVDQFHOHDGHUV%XWD)\UQL[JUDVSHGKLVVOHHYHDQGWXJJHG
    KLPEDFNWRWKHRUQDWHUHFHSWLRQ7KH\KDYHVRPXFKWRWHOO\RX
    $QGKHKDGZDQWHGWRFRPHKHUH7ROHDUQZK\WKHGDPSHUVWKDWNHSW
    ZRUOGVVWDEOHKDGIDLOHGKHUH7RVHHWKHIHUPHQWSLFNXSWKHVFHQWRI
    FKDQJH7KHUHZDVSOHQW\RISDVVLRQDWHDUJXPHQWRIVRDULQJDUWRIHFFHQWULF
    PHQDQGZRPHQZHGGHGWRWKHLUJUDQGSURMHFWV+HKDGVHHQWKHVHDWGL]]\LQJ
    VSHHG
    %XWLWZDVDOOWRRPXFK6RPHWKLQJLQKLPUHEHOOHG7KHQDXVHDKHKDG
    VXIIHUHGLQWKHRSHQVWUHHWVZDVDV\PSWRPRIVRPHGHHSHUUHYXOVLRQJXWGHHS
    DQGGDUN
    %XWD)\UQL[KDGEHHQQDWWHULQJRQDQGVRPHRIRXUPRVWEULOOLDQW
    PLQGVDUHZDLWLQJWRPHHW\RX'RFRPH
    +HVXSSUHVVHGDJURDQDQGORRNHGEHVHHFKLQJO\DW'RUV6KHVPLOHGDQG
    VKRRNKHUKHDG)URPWKLVKD]DUGVKHFRXOGQRWVDYHKLP
    

    ,I%XWD)\UQL[KDGEHJXQDVDJUDLQRIVDQGLQKLVVKRHVKHZDVQRZD
    ERXOGHU
    6KHVLPSRVVLEOH<DN\DN\DN/RRNKHVDLGWR'RUVZKHQWKH\ZHUH
    DWODVWDORQH,RQO\FDPHWR6DUNEHFDXVHRISV\FKRKLVWRU\QRWIRU,PSHULDO
    EDFNVODSSLQJ+RZGLGWKHVRFLDOGDPSHUVIDLOKHUH":KDWVRFLDOPHFKDQLVP
    VOLSSHGDOORZLQJWKLVUDXFRXV5HQDLVVDQFHRIWKHLUV"
    0\+DUL,IHDUWKDW\RXGRQRWKDYHWKHQRVHWRVQLIIRXWWUHQGVIURP
    OLIHLWVHOI,WSUHVVHVLQRQ\RX'DWDLVPRUH\RXUSURYLQFH
    *UDQWHG,WVXQVHWWOLQJDOOWKLVIHUPHQW%XW,PVWLOOLQWHUHVWHGLQ
    KRZWKH\UHFRYHUHGWKRVHROGVLPXODWLRQV,I,FRXOGJHWRXWRIWDNLQJWRXUV
    RIWKHLU5HQDLVVDQFHWKURXJKQRLV\VWUHHWV
    ,TXLWHDJUHH'RUVVDLGPLOGO\7HOOWKHP\RXZDQWWRGRVRPHZRUN
    :HOOVWD\LQRXUURRPV,PFRQFHUQHGDERXWVRPHRQHWUDFNLQJXVKHUH:HUH
    MXVWRQHZRUPMXPS DZD\IURP3DQXFRSLD
    ,OOQHHGWRDFFHVVP\RIILFHILOHV$TXLFNZRUPOLQNWR7UDQWRU
    1R\RXFDQWZRUNXVLQJDOLQN/DPXUNFRXOGWUDFHWKDWHDVLO\
    %XW,KDYHQWWKHUHFRUGV
    <RXOOKDYHWRPDNHGR
    +DULVWDUHGRXWDWWKHYLHZZKLFKKHKDGWRDGPLWZDVVSHFWDFXODU
    *UHDWVWUHWFKLQJYLVWDV5LRWRXVJURZWK
    %XWPRUHILUHVERLOHGXSRQWKHKRUL]RQ7KHUHZDVJDLHW\LQWKHVWUHHWV
    RI6DUNRQLDDQGDQJHUDVZHOO7KHODERUDWRULHVVHHWKHGZLWKIUHVKHQHUJLHV
    LQQRYDWLRQEULVWOHGHYHU\ZKHUHWKHDLUVHHPHGWRVLQJZLWKFKDQJHDQGFKDRV
    +LVSUHGLFWLRQVZHUHVWDWLVWLFDODEVWUDFW7RVHHWKHPFRPLQJWUXHVR
    TXLFNO\ZDVVREHULQJ+HGLGQRWOLNHWKHVZLIWWXUEXOHQWIHHOWRWKLVSODFH
    DWDOOHYHQLIKHGLGXQGHUVWDQGLW)RUQRZ
    7KH H[WUHPHVRIZHDOWKDQGGHVWLWXWLRQZHUHDSSDOOLQJ&KDQJHEURXJKW
    WKDWKHNQHZ
    2Q+HOLFRQKHKDGVHHQSRYHUW\DQGOLYHGLWWRR$VDER\KLV
    JUDQGPRWKHUKDGLQVLVWHGRQEX\LQJKLPDUDLQFRDWVHYHUDOVL]HVWRRODUJHWR
    JHWPRUHXVHRXWRILW+LV PRWKHUGLGQWOLNHKLPSOD\LQJNLFNEDOOEHFDXVH
    KHZRUHRXWKLVVKRHVWRRTXLFNO\
    +HUHRQ6DUNDVRQ+HOLFRQWKHWUXO\SRRUZHUHRIILQWKHKLQWHUODQGV
    6RPHWLPHVWKH\FRXOGQWHYHQDIIRUGIRVVLOIXHOV0HQDQGZRPHQSHHUHGRYHUD
    PXOHVDVVDOOGD\DVLWSORGGHGGRZQDIXUURZ
    6RPHLQKLVRZQIDPLO\KDGIOHGWKHKDUGVFUDEEOHOLIHIRUDVVHPEO\
    OLQHV$JHQHUDWLRQRUWZRDIWHUWKDWIDFWRU\ZRUNHUVKDGVFUDSHGWRJHWKHU

    HQRXJKPRQH\WREX\DFRPPHUFLDOGULYHUVOLFHQVH+DULUHPHPEHUHGKLVXQFOHV
    DQGDXQWVDFFXPXODWLQJLQMXULHVMXVWDVKLVIDWKHUKDG1RWKDYLQJPRQH\WKH
    SDLQFDPHEDFNWRWKHP\HDUVODWHULQEXVWHGMRLQWVDQGXQIL[HGOHJVLQMXULHV
    VWD\LQJZLWKWKHPLQDZD\WKDWD7UDQWRULDQZRXOGILQGDVWRQLVKLQJ
    +HOLFRQLDQVLQUXQGRZQVKDFNVKDGZRUNHGRQIDUPPDFKLQHU\WKDWZDV
    ELJSRZHUIXOGDQJHURXVDQGFRVWPRUHWKDQDQ\RIWKHPZRXOGHDUQLQD
    OLIHWLPH7KHLUOLYHVZHUHREVFXUHIDUIURPWKHUDPSDUWVRIKDXJKW\(PSLUH
    :KHQGHDGDQGJRQHWKH\OHIWQRWKLQJEXWLPSDOSDEOHPHPRU\WKHOLJKWDVKRI
    DEXWWHUIO\ZLQJLQFLQHUDWHGLQDIRUHVWILUH
    ,QDVWDEOHVRFLHW\WKHLUSDLQZRXOGEHOHVV+LVIDWKHUKDGGLHGZKLOH
    ZRUNLQJRYHUWLPHRQDELJPDFKLQH+HKDGEHHQZLSHGRXWWKH\HDUEHIRUHDQG
    ZDVVWUXJJOLQJWRPDNHDFRPHEDFN
    (FRQRPLFVXUJHDQGHEEKDGNLOOHGKLVIDWKHUDVVXUHO\DVWKHVWHHO
    JURXQGSRXQGHUKDGZKHQLWUROOHGRYHURQKLP7KHOXUFKRIGLVWDQWPDUNHWV
    KDGPXUGHUHGDQG+DULKDGNQRZQWKHQZKDWKHPXVWGR7KDWKHZRXOGGHIHDW
    XQFHUWDLQW\LWVHOIILQGRUGHULQVHHPLQJGLVFRUG3V\FKRKLVWRU\FRXOGEHDQG
    KROGVZD\
    +LVIDWKHU
    $FDGHPLFLDQ%XWD)\UQL[VSHQHWUDWLQJYRLFHVQDWFKHGKLPDZD\IURP
    KLVWKRXJKWV
    8KWKDWWRXURIWKHSUHFLQFWV,,UHDOO\GRQWIHHO
    2KWKDWLVQRWSRVVLEOH,IHDU$GRPHVWLFGLVWXUEDQFHPRVW
    XQIRUWXQDWH6KHKXUULHGRQ,GRZDQW\RXWRVSHDNZLWKRXUWLNWRN
    HQJLQHHUV7KH\KDYHGHYLVHGQHZDXWRQRPRXVWLNWRNV7KH\VD\WKH\FDQ
    PDLQWDLQFRQWUROXVLQJRQO\WKUHHEDVLFODZVLPDJLQH
    'RUVFRXOGQRWPDVNKHUVXUSULVH6KHRSHQHGKHUPRXWKKHVLWDWHG
    FORVHGLW+DULDOVRIHOWDODUPEXW%XWD)\UQL[ZHQWULJKWRQEXEEOLQJRYHU
    QHZYHQWXUHVRQWKH6DUNLDQKRUL]RQ7KHQKHUH\HEURZVOLIWHGDQGVKHVDLG
    EULJKWO\2K\HV,GRKDYHHYHQPRUHZHOFRPHQHZV$Q,PSHULDOVTXDGURQKDV
    MXVWFRPHWRFDOO
    2K"'RUVVKRWEDFN8QGHUZKRVHFRPPDQG"
    $5DJDQW'LYHQH[VHFWRUJHQHUDO,MXVWVSRNHWRKLP
    'DPQ'RUVVDLG+HVD/DPXUNKHQFKPDQ
    <RXUHVXUH"+DULDVNHG+HNQHZKHUVOLJKWSDXVHKDGEHHQWRFRQVXOW
    KHULQWHUQDOILOHV
    'RUVQRGGHG%XWD)\UQL[VDLGFDOPO\:HOO,DPVXUHKHZLOOEH
    KRQRUHGWRWDNH\RXEDFNWR7UDQWRUZKHQ\RXDUHILQLVKHGZLWK\RXUYLVLW
    KHUH:KLFKZHKRSHZLOOQRWEHVRRQRI
    +HPHQWLRQHGXV"'RUVDVNHG
    +HDVNHGLI\RXZHUHHQMR\LQJ
    'DPQ+DULVDLG
    $VHFWRUJHQHUDOFRPPDQGVDOOWKHZRUPOLQNVLIKHZLVKHV\HV"'RUV
    DVNHG
    :HOO,VXSSRVHVR)\UQL[ORRNHGSX]]OHG
    :HUHWUDSSHG+DULVDLG
    )\UQL[VH\HVZLGHQHGLQVKRFN%XWVXUHO\\RXD)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    FDQGLGDWHQHHGIHDUQR
    4XLHW'RUVVLOHQFHGWKHZRPDQZLWKDVWHUQJODQFH$WEHVWWKLV
    'LYHQH[ZLOOERWWOHXVXSKHUH
    $WZRUVWWKHUHZLOOEHDQDFFLGHQW+DULVDLG
    ,VWKHUHQRRWKHUZD\WRJHWRII6DUN"'RUVGHPDQGHGRI)\UQL[
    1R,FDQWUHFDOO
    7KLQN
    6WDUWOHG)\UQL[VDLG:HOORIFRXUVHZHGRKDYHSULYDWHHUVZKRDW
    WLPHVXVHWKHZLOGZRUPVEXW
    

    ,Q+DULVVWXGLHVKHKDGGLVFRYHUHGDFXULRXVOLWWOHODZ1RZKHWXUQHG
    LWLQKLVIDYRU
    %XUHDXFUDF\LQFUHDVHVDVDGRXEOLQJIXQFWLRQLQWLPHJLYHQWKH
    UHVRXUFHV$WWKHSHUVRQDOOHYHOWKHFDXVHZDVWKHSHUVLVWHQWGHVLUHRIHYHU\
    PDQDJHUWRKLUHDWOHDVWRQHDVVLVWDQW7KLVSURYLGHGWKHWLPHFRQVWDQWIRU
    JURZWK
    (YHQWXDOO\WKLVFROOLGHGZLWKWKHFDUU\LQJFDSDFLW\RIVRFLHW\*LYHQ
    WKHWLPHFRQVWDQWDQGWKHFDSDFLW\RQHFRXOGSUHGLFWDSODWHDXOHYHORI
    EXUHDXFUDWLFRYHUKHDGRUHOVHLIJURZWKSHUVLVWHGWKHGDWHRIFROODSVH
    3UHGLFWLRQVRIWKHORQJHYLW\RIEXUHDXFUDF\GULYHQVRFLHWLHVILWD SUHFLVH
    FXUYH6XUSULVLQJO\WKHVDPHVFDOLQJODZVZRUNHGIRUPLFURVRFLHWLHVVXFKDV
    ODUJHDJHQFLHV
    7KHFRUSXOHQW,PSHULDOEXUHDXVRQ6DUNFRXOGQRWPRYHVZLIWO\6HFWRU
    *HQHUDO'LYHQH[VVTXDGURQKDGWRVWD\LQSODQHWDU\VSDFHVLQFHLWZDVSD\LQJ
    DSXUHO\IRUPDOYLVLW1LFHWLHVZHUHVWLOOREVHUYHG'LYHQH[GLGQRWZDQWWR
    XVHEUXWHIRUFHZKHQDZDLWLQJJDPHZRXOGZRUN
    ,VHH7KDWJLYHVXVDIHZGD\V'RUVFRQFOXGHG
    +DULQRGGHG+HKDGGRQHWKHUHTXLUHGVSHDNLQJQHJRWLDWLQJGHDOLQJ
    SURPLVLQJ IDYRUVDOODFWLYLWLHVKHGLVOLNHGLQWHQVHO\'RUVKDGGRQHWKH
    EDFNJURXQGGLJJLQJ7R"
    7UDLQ
    :RUPKROHVZHUHODE\ULQWKVQRWPHUHWXQQHOVZLWKWZRHQGV7KHODUJH
    RQHVKHOGILUPIRUSHUKDSVELOOLRQVRI\HDUVQRQHODUJHUWKDQDKXQGUHG
    PHWHUVDFURVVKDG\HWFROODSVHG7KHVPDOOHVWFRXOGVRPHWLPHVODVWRQO\KRXUV
    DWEHVWD\HDU,QWKHWKLQQHUZRUPVIOH[HVLQWKHZRUPZDOOVGXULQJSDVVDJH
    FRXOGDOWHUWKHHQGSRLQWRIDWUDYHOHUVWUDMHFWRU\
    :RUVHZRUPVLQWKHLUODVWVWDJHVVSDZQHGWUDQVLHQWGRRPHG\RXQJWKH
    ZLOGZRUPV$VGHIRUPDWLRQVLQVSDFHWLPHVXSSRUWHGE\QHJDWLYHHQHUJ\
    GHQVLW\VWUXWVZRUPKROHVZHUHLQKHUHQWO\ULFNHW\$VWKH\IDLOHGVPDOOHU
    GHIRUPDWLRQVWZLVWHGDZD\
    6DUNKDGVHYHQZRUPKROHV2QHZDVG\LQJ,WKXQJDOLJKWKRXUDZD\
    VSLWWLQJRXWZLOGZRUPVWKDWUDQJHGIURPDKDQGVZLGWKVL]HXSWRVHYHUDO
    PHWHUV
    $IDLUO\VL]DEOHZLOGZRUPKDGVSURXWHGRXWRIWKHVLGHRIWKHG\LQJ
    ZRUPVHYHUDOPRQWKVEHIRUH7KH,PSHULDOVTXDGURQGLGQRWNQRZRIWKLVRI
    FRXUVH$OOZRUPVZHUHWD[HGVRDIUHHZRUPKROHZDVDERQDQ]D5HSRUWLQJ
    WKHLUH[LVWHQFHZHOORIWHQDSODQHWVLPSO\GLGQWJHWDURXQGWRWKDWXQWLO
    WKHZLOGZRUPKDGIL]]OHGDZD\LQDVSUD\RIVXEDWRPLFVXUI
    8QWLOWKHQSLORWVFDUULHGFDUJRWKURXJKWKHP7KDWZLOG ZRUPVFRXOG
    HYDSRUDWHZLWKRQO\VHFRQGVZDUQLQJPDGHWKHLUWUDGHGDQJHURXVKLJKO\SDLG
    DQGOHJHQGDU\
    :RUPULGHUVZHUHWKHVRUWRISHRSOHZKRDVFKLOGUHQOLNHGWRULGHWKHLU
    ELF\FOHVQRKDQGHGEXWZLWKDGLIIHUHQFHWKH\URGHRIIURRIWRSV
    %\DQRGGORJLFWKDWNLQGRIFKLOGJUHZXSDQGJRWWUDLQHGDQGHYHQ
    SDLGWD[HVEXWLQVLGHWKH\VWD\HGWKHVDPH
    2QO\ULVNWDNHUVFRXOGSRZHUWKURXJKWKHFKDRWLFIOX[RIDWUDQVLHQW
    ZRUPDQGWDNHWKHULVNVWKDWZRUNHGQRWWDNHWKRVHWKDWGLGQWDQGOLYH
    7KH\KDGHOHYDWHGEUDYDGRWRLWVILQHUSRLQWV
    7KLVZLOGZRUPLWVWULFN\DJUL]]OHGZRPDQWROG+DULDQG'RUV1R
    URRPIRUDSLORWLI\RXERWKJR
    :HPXVWVWD\WRJHWKHU'RUVVDLGZLWKILQDOLW\
    7KHQ\RXOOKDYHWRSLORW
    :HGRQWNQRZKRZ+DULVDLG
    <RXUHLQOXFN7KHOLQHGZRPDQJULQQHGZLWKRXWKXPRU7KLVZLOG\V
    VKRUWHDV\

    :KDWDUHWKHULVNV"'RUVGHPDQGHGVWLIIO\,PQRWDQLQVXUDQFH
    DJHQWODG\
    ,LQVLVWWKDWZHNQRZ
    /RRNODG\ZHOOWHDFK\RX7KDWVWKHGHDO
    ,KDGKRSHGIRUDPRUH
    *LYHLWDUHVWRULWVQRGHDODWDOO
    

    ,QWKHPHQVURRPDERYHWKHXULQDOKHXVHG+DULVDZDVPDOOJROG
    SODTXH6HQLRU3LORW-RTXDQ%HXQQUHOLHYHGKLPVHOIKHUH2FWGHQW
    (YHU\XULQDOKDGDVLPLODUSODTXH7KHUHZDVDZDVKLQJPDFKLQHLQWKH
    ORFNHUURRPZLWKDODUJHSODTXHRYHULWUHDGLQJ7KHHQWLUHUG3LORW&RUSV
    UHOLHYHGWKHPVHOYHVKHUH0DUODVV
    3LORWKXPRU,WWXUQHGRXWWREHDEVROXWHO\SUHGLFWLYH+HPHVVHG
    KLPVHOIRQKLVILUVWWUDLQLQJUXQ
    $VLIWRPDNHWKHDEVROXWHO\IDWDOOHQJWKRIDFORVLQJZRUPKROHOHVV
    GDXQWLQJWKHZRUPIO\HUVKDGHVFDSHSODQV7KHVHFRXOGRQO\ZRUNLQWKH
    IULQJLQJILHOGVRIWKHZRUPZKHUHJUDYLW\ZDVEHJLQQLQJWRZDUSDQGVSDFH
    WLPHZDVRQO\PLOGO\FXUYHG8QGHUWKHVHDWZDVDVPDOOSRZHUIXOURFNHWWKDW
    SURSHOOHGWKHHQWLUHFRFNSLWRXWDXWRPDWLFDOO\KHDGLQJDZD\IURPWKHZRUP
    7KHUHLVDOLPLWWRKRZPXFKVHOIDFWXDWHGWHFKRQHFDQSDFNLQWRD
    VPDOOFRFNSLWWKRXJK:RUVH ZRUPPRXWKVZHUHDOLYHZLWKHOHFWURG\QDPLF
    ZHDWKHUZULWKLQJIRUNVRIOLJKWQLQJEOXHGLVFKDUJHVUHGPDJQHWLFZKRUOV
    OLNHWRUQDGRHV(OHFWULFDOJHDUGLGQWZRUNZHOOLIDEDGVWRUPZDVEUHZLQJDW
    WKHPRXWK0RVWRIWKHHPHUJHQF\FRQWUROVZHUHPDQXDO+RSHOHVVO\DUFKDLFEXW
    XQDYRLGDEOH
    6RKHDQG'RUVZHQWWKURXJKDWUDLQLQJSURJUDP4XLWHVRRQLWZDVFOHDU
    WKDWLIKHXVHGWKH(MHFWFRPPDQGKHKDGEHWWHUEHVXUHWKDWKHKDGKLVKHDG
    WLOWHGEDFN7KDWLVXQOHVVKHZDQWHGKLVNQHHFDSVWRVODPXSLQWRKLVFKLQ
    ZKLFKZRXOGEHXQIRUWXQDWHEHFDXVHKHZRXOGEHWU\LQJWRFKHFNLIKLVFDQRS\
    KDGJRQHLQWRDVSLQ7KLVZRXOGEHEDGQHZVEHFDXVHKLVWUDMHFWRU\PLJKWJHW
    ZDUSHGEDFNLQWRWKHZRUP7RFRUUHFWDQ\VSLQKHKDGWR\DQNRQDUHGOHYHU
    DQGLIWKDWIDLOHGKHKDGWRWKHQYHU\TXLFNO\LQSLORWVWHUPVWKLVPHDQW
    DERXWKDOIDVHFRQGSXQFKWZREOXHNQREV:KHQWKHVSLQGRZQFDPHKHWKHQKDG
    WREHVXUHWRUHOHDVHWKHDXWRPDWLFDFWXDWRUE\SXOOLQJGRZQRQWZR\HOORZ
    WDEVEHLQJFHUWDLQWKDWKHVLWXSVWUDLJKWZLWKKDQGVEHWZHHQNQHHVWR
    DYRLG
    DQGVRRQIRUWKUHHKRXUV(YHU\RQHVHHPHGWRDVVXPHWKDWVLQFHKHZDV
    WKLVIDPRXVPDWKHPDWLFLDQKHFRXOGRIFRXUVHNHHSDQHQWLUHPHQXRI
    LQVWUXFWLRQVVWUDLJKWWLPHGWRIUDFWLRQVRIVHFRQGV
    $IWHUWKHILUVWWHQPLQXWHVKHVDZQRSRLQWLQGHVWUR\LQJWKHLU
    LOOXVLRQVDQGVLPSO\QRGGHGDQGVTXLQWHGWRVKRZWKDWKHZDVFDUHIXOO\
    NHHSLQJWUDFNDQGDEVROXWHO\HQWKUDOOHG0HDQZKLOHKHVROYHGGLIIHUHQWLDO
    HTXDWLRQVLQKLVKHDGIRUSUDFWLFH
    ,PVXUH\RXZLOOEHDOOULJKW%XWD)\UQL[VDLGIXOVRPHO\WRWKHPLQ
    WKHGHSDUWXUHORXQJH
    +DULKDGWRDGPLWWKLVZRPDQKDGSURYHQEHWWHUWKDQKHKDGKRSHG6KH
    KDGFOHDUHGWKHZD\DQGVWDOOHGWKH,PSHULDORIILFHV*UH\0HQ3UREDEO\VKH
    VKUHZGO\H[SHFWHGDSD\RIIIURPKLPDV)LUVW0LQLVWHU9HU\ZHOORQHVOLIH
    ZDVZRUWKDNLFNEDFN
    ,KRSH,FDQKDQGOHDZRUPVKLS+DULVDLG
    $QG,'RUVDGGHG
    2XUWUDLQLQJLVWKHYHU\EHVW)\UQL[VDLG7KH1HZ5HQDLVVDQFH
    HQFRXUDJHVLQGLYLGXDOH[FHOOHQFH
    <HV,PTXLWHLPSUHVVHG'RUVVDLG3HUKDSV\RXFDQH[SODLQWRPH

    WKHGHWDLOVRI\RXU&UHDWLYLW\&UHDWLRQSURJUDP",YHKHDUGVRPXFKDERXW
    LW
    +DULJDYHKHUDVOLJKWVPLOHRIWKDQNVIRUGLVWUDFWLQJ)\UQL[+H
    LQVWLQFWLYHO\GLVOLNHGWKHEUDQGRIUDPSDQWVHOIDVVXUDQFHFRPPRQRQ6DUN,W
    ZDVKHDGHGIRUDFUDFNXSRIWKDWKHZDVVXUH+HDFKHGWRJHWEDFNWRKLV
    IXOOSV\FKRKLVWRULFDOUHVRXUFHVWRVLPXODWHWKLV6DUNFDVH+LVHDUOLHUZRUN
    QHHGHGUHILQHPHQW+HKDGVHFUHWO\JDWKHUHGIUHVKGDWDKHUHDQG\HDUQHGWR
    DSSO\LW
    ,GRKRSH\RXUHQRWZRUULHGDERXWWKHZLOGZRUP$FDGHPLFLDQ")\UQL[
    VSRNHWRKLPDJDLQEURZIXUURZHG
    ,WVDWLJKWILWKHVDLG
    7KH\KDGWRIO\LQDVOHQGHUF\OLQGHU'RUVFRSLORWLQJ6SOLWWLQJWKH
    MREKDGSURYHGWKHRQO\ZD\WRJHWWKHPXSWRDEDUHO\FRPSHWHQWOHYHO
    ,WKLQNLWVPDUYHORXVKRZFRXUDJHRXV\RXWZRDUH
    :HKDYHOLWWOHFKRLFH'RUVVDLG7KLVZDVDUWIXOXQGHUVWDWHPHQW
    $QRWKHUGD\DQGWKHVHFWRUJHQHUDOVRIILFHUVZRXOGKDYH+DULDQG'RUVXQGHU
    DUUHVW
    5LGLQJLQDOLWWOHSHQFLOVKLS6XFKSULPLWLYHPHDQV
    8KWLPHWRJR+DULVDLGEHKLQGDIL[HGVPLOH
    6KHZDVZHDULQJWKLQDJDLQ
    ,DJUHHZLWKWKH(PSHURU$Q\WHFKQRORJ\GLVWLQJXLVKDEOHIURPPDJLFLV
    LQVXIILFLHQWO\DGYDQFHG
    6RWKH(PSHURUVJKRVWZULWWHQUHPDUNKDGDOUHDG\VSUHDGKHUH0LQRU
    VD\LQJVPRYHGIDVWZLWK,PSHULDOPXVFOHEHKLQGLW
    6WLOO+DULIHOWKLVVWRPDFKIOXWWHUZLWKGUHDG<RXYHJRWDSRLQW

    +HKDGEUXVKHGRIIWKHUHPDUN
    )RXUKRXUVODWHUFORVLQJDWKLJKYHORFLW\ZLWKWKHELJZRUPKROH
    FRPSOH[KHVDZKHUVLGHRILW
    +HVSRNHRQVXLWFRPPWR'RUV,QRQHRIP\FODVVHV1RQOLQHDU
    3KLORVRSK\,EHOLHYHWKHSURIHVVRUVDLGVRPHWKLQJ,OOQHYHUIRUJHW,GHDV
    DERXWH[LVWHQFHSDOHEHVLGHWKHIDFWRIH[LVWHQFH4XLWH WUXH
    %HDULQJRKVL[QLQHILYHVKHVDLGULJRURXVO\1RVPDOOWDON
    1RWKLQJVVPDOORXWKHUHH[FHSWWKDWZLOGZRUPPRXWK
    7KHZLOGZRUPZDVDIL]]LQJSRLQWRIYLEUDQWDJLWDWLRQ,WRUELWHGWKH
    PDLQZRUPPRXWKDGLVWDQWEULJKWVSHFN
    ,PSHULDOVKLSVSDWUROOHGWKHPDLQPRXWKLJQRULQJWKLVZLOGZRUP7KH\
    KDGEHHQSDLGRIIORQJDJRDQGH[SHFWHGDVWHDG\WUDLQRIVOLPVKLSVWRVOLS
    WKURXJKWKH,PSHULDOJXDUG
    +DULKDGSDVVHGWKURXJKZRUPJDWHVEHIRUHDOZD\VLQELJFUXLVHUVSO\LQJ
    URXWHVWKURXJKZRUPKROHVWHQVRIPHWHUVDFURVV(YHU\KROHRIWKDWVL]HZDV
    WKHKXERIDFRPSOH[ZKLFKEX]]HGZLWKFDUHIXOO\RUFKHVWUDWHGWUDIILF+H
    FRXOGVHHWKHVWDJLQJ\DUGVDQGLQMHFWLRQFRUULGRUVRIWKHPDLQURXWHJOHDPLQJ
    IDUDZD\
    7KHLUZLOGZRUPDUHQHJDGHVSLQRIIFRXOGYDQLVKDWDQ\PRPHQW,WV
    TXDQWXPIURWKDGYHUWLVHGLWVPRUWDOLW\$QGPD\EHRXUV+DULWKRXJKW
    9HFWRUQXOOVXPFRPLQJXSKHFDOOHG
    &RQYHUJHQWDV\PSWRWHVFKHFN'RUVDQVZHUHG
    -XVWOLNHWKHGULOOVWKH\KDGJRQHWKURXJK
    %XWFRPLQJDWWKHPZDVDVSKHUHIL]]LQJRUDQJHDQGSXUSOHDWLWVULP$
    QHRQOLWPRXWK7LJKWGDUNDWWKHYHU\FHQWHU
    +DULIHOWDVXGGHQGHVLUHWRVZHUYHQRWGLYHLQWRWKDWLPSRVVLEO\
    QDUURZJXOOHW
    'RUVFDOOHGRXWQXPEHUV&RPSXWHUVDQJOHGWKHPLQ+H DGMXVWHGZLWKD
    QXGJHKHUHDQGDWZLVWWKHUH
    ,WGLGQRWKHOSWKDWKHNQHZVRPHRIWKHXQGHUO\LQJSK\VLFV:RUPKROHV
    ZHUHKHOGRSHQZLWKOD\HUVRIQHJDWLYHHQHUJ\VNLQVRIDQWLSUHVVXUHPDGHLQ

    WKHILUVWFRQYXOVLRQRIWKHXQLYHUVH7KHQHJDWLYHHQHUJ\LQWKHVWUXWVZDV
    HTXLYDOHQWWRWKHPDVVQHHGHGWRPDNHDEODFNKROHRIWKHVDPHUDGLXV
    6RWKH\ZHUHSOXQJLQJWRZDUGDUHJLRQRIVSDFHRIXQLPDJLQDEOHGHQVLW\
    %XWWKHGDQJHUOXUNHGRQO\DWWKHULPZKHUHVWUHVVHVFRXOGWHDUWKHPLQWR
    DWRPV
    $EXOOVH\HKLWZDVSHUIHFWO\VDIH%XWDQHUURU
    7KUXVWHUVSXOVHG7KHZLOGZRUPZDVQRZDEODFNVSKHUHULPPHGLQTXDQWXP
    ILUH
    *URZLQJ
    +DULIHOWVXGGHQO\WKHKHOSOHVVFRQVWULFWLRQRIWKHSHQFLOVKLS%DUHO\
    WZRPHWHUVDFURVVLWVLQVXODWLRQZDVWKLQVDIHW\EXIIHUVPLQLPDO%HKLQG
    KLP'RUVNHSWPXUPXULQJGDWDDQGKHFKHFNHGEXWSDUWRIKLPZDVVFUHDPLQJ
    DWWKHFUXVKLQJVHQVHRIFRQILQHPHQWRIKHOSOHVVQHVV
    +HIHOWDJDLQWKHJXWIHDUWKDWKDGVWUXFNKLPLQWKHVWUHHWVRI
    6DUNRQLD1RWFODXVWURSKRELD EXWVRPHWKLQJGDUNHUDVZDPS\IHDURI
    FRQIXVLRQDULRWRIGRXEW,WVHL]HGKLPVTXHH]HGKLVWKURDW
    9HFWRUVVXPPLQJWRZLWKLQ]HURVHYHQWKUHH'RUVFDOOHG
    +HUYRLFHZDVFDOPVWHDG\DPDUYHORXVEDOP+HFOXQJWRLWVVHUHQH
    FHUWDLQWLHVDQGIRXJKWGRZQKLVRZQSDQLF
    6TXHDOVRIODVWVHFRQGFRUUHFWLRQVHFKRHGLQKLVFUDPSHGFKDPEHU$
    TXLFNNLFNRIDFFHOHUDWLRQ
    /LJKWQLQJFXUOLQJVQDNHOLNHEOXHDQGJROGDWWKHP
    WXPEOLQJ2XWWKHRWKHUHQGLQDZRUPFRPSOH[ILIWHHQWKRXVDQGOLJKW
    \HDUVDZD\
    7KDWROGSURIHVVRUGDPQULJKWKHZDVKHVDLG
    'RUVVLJKHGKHURQO\VLJQRIVWUHVV,GHDVDERXWH[LVWHQFH
    SDOHEHVLGHWKHIDFWRIH[LVWHQFH<HVP\ORYH/LYLQJLVELJJHUWKDQDQ\
    WDONDERXWLW
    

    $\HOORZJUHHQVXQJUHHWHGWKHP$QGVRRQHQRXJKDQ,PSHULDOSLFNHW
    FUDIW
    7KH\GXFNHGDQGUDQ$TXLFNVZHUYHDQGWKH\DQJOHGLQWRWKHWUDIILF
    WUDLQKHDGHGIRUDODUJHZRUPKROHPRXWK7KHFRPPHUFLDOFKDUJHFRPSXWHUV
    DFFHSWHGKLV,PSHULDORYHUULGHZLWKRXWDPXUPXU+DULKDGOHDUQHGZHOO'RUV
    FRUUHFWHGKLPLIKHJRWPL[HGXS
    7KHLUVHFRQGK\SHUVSDFHMXPSWRRNDPHUHWKUHHPLQXWHV7KH\SRSSHGRXW
    IDUIURPDGLPUHGGZDUI
    %\WKHIRXUWKMXPSWKH\NQHZWKHGULOO+DYLQJWKHFRGHVWDWXVRI
    &OHRQVFRXUWEDQLVKHGREMHFWLRQV
    %XWEHLQJRQWKHUXQPHDQWWKDWWKH\KDGWRWDNHZKDWHYHUZRUPKROH
    PRXWKVWKH\FRXOGJHW/DPXUNVSHRSOHFRXOGQRWEHWRRIDUEHKLQG
    $ZRUPKROHFRXOGWDNHWUDIILFRQO\RQHZD\DWDWLPH+LJKYHORFLW\
    VKLSVSORZHGGRZQWKHZRUPKROHWKURDWVZKLFKFRXOGYDU\IURPDILQJHUV
    OHQJWKWRDVWDUVGLDPHWHU
    +DULKDGNQRZQWKHQXPEHUVRIFRXUVH7KHUHZHUHDIHZELOOLRQ
    ZRUPKROHVLQWKH*DODFWLFGLVN7KHDYHUDJH,PSHULDO=RQHZDVDERXWILIW\
    OLJKW\HDUVLQUDGLXV$MXPSFRXOGEULQJ\RXRXWPDQ\\HDUVIURPDIDUIOXQJ
    ZRUOG
    7KLVLQIOXHQFHGSV\FKRKLVWRU\6RPHYHUGDQWSODQHWVZHUHJUHHQ
    IRUWUHVVHVDJDLQVWDQLVRODWLRQTXLWHSURIRXQG)RUWKHPWKH(PSLUHZDVD
    UHPRWHGUHDPWKHVRXUFHRI H[RWLFSURGXFWVDQGRGGLGHDV+\SHUVKLSVIOLWWHG
    WKURXJKZRUPKROHVLQPHUHVHFRQGVWKHQH[KDXVWHGWKHPVHOYHVKDXOLQJWKHLU
    FDUJRHVDFURVVHPSW\YRLGV\HDUVDQGGHFDGHVLQWKHODERU
    7KHZRUPZHEKDGPDQ\RSHQLQJVQHDULQKDELWDEOHZRUOGVEXWDOVRPDQ\
    QHDUP\VWHULRXVO\XVHOHVVVRODUV\VWHPV7KH(PSLUHKDGSRVLWLRQHGWKHVPDOOHU

    ZRUPPRXWKVWKRVHPDVVLQJSHUKDSVDVPXFKDVDPRXQWDLQUDQJHQHDUULFK
    SODQHWV%XWVRPHZRUPPRXWKVRIJDUJDQWXDQPDVVRUELWHGQHDUVRODUV\VWHPVDV
    EDUUHQDQGSRLQWOHVVDVDQ\VXUYH\HG
    :DVWKLVUDQGRPRUDQHWZRUNOHIWE\VRPHHDUOLHUFLYLOL]DWLRQ"
    &HUWDLQO\WKHZRUPKROHVWKHPVHOYHVZHUHOHIWRYHUVIURPWKH*UHDW(PHUJHQFH
    ZKHQVSDFHDQGWLPHDOLNHEHJDQ7KH\OLQNHGGLVWDQWUHDOPVZKLFKKDGRQFH
    EHHQQHDUE\ZKHQWKHJDOD[\ZDV\RXQJDQGVPDOOHU
    7KH\GHYHORSHGDUK\WKP3RSWKRXJKDZRUPPRXWKPDNHFRPPFRQWDFWJHW
    LQOLQHIRUWKHQH[WGHSDUWXUH,PSHULDOZDWFKGRJVZRXOGQRWSXOODQ\RQHRI
    KLJK7UDQWRULDQFODVVIURPDTXHXH6RWKHLUPRVWGDQJHURXVPRPHQWVFDPHDV
    WKH\QHJRWLDWHGFOHDUDQFH
    $WWKLV'RUVEHFDPHDGHSW6KHVHQWWKH:RUP0DVWHUFRPSXWHUVEOXUWVRI
    GDWDDQGZKLVNWKH\ZHUHHGJLQJLQWRRUELWDOYHFWRUVERXQGIRUWKHLUQH[W
    MXPS
    'RPDLQVWKDWHQFRPSDVVHGWKRXVDQGVRIOLJKW\HDUVVSDQQLQJWKHZLGWKRI
    DVSLUDODUPZHUHHVVHQWLDOO\QHWZRUNVRIRYHUODSSLQJZRUPVDOORUJDQL]HG
    IRUWUDQVIHUDQGVKLSSLQJ
    0DWWHUFRXOGIORZRQO\RQHZD\DWDWLPHLQDZRUPKROH7KHIHZ
    H[SHULPHQWVZLWKVLPXOWDQHRXVWZRZD\WUDQVSRUWHQGHGLQGLVDVWHU1RPDWWHU
    KRZLQJHQLRXVHQJLQHHUVWULHGWRVWHHUVKLSVDURXQGHDFKRWKHUWKHVKHHU
    IOH[LELOLW\RIZRUPWXQQHOVVSHOOHGGRRP(DFKZRUPPRXWKNHSWWKHRWKHU
    LQIRUPHGRIZKDWLWKDGMXVWHDWHQ7KLVLQIRUPDWLRQIORZHGDVDZDYHQRW
    LQSK\VLFDOPDWWHUEXWLQWKHWHQVLRQRIWKHZRUPKROHLWVHOIDULSSOHLQWKH
    VWUHVVWHQVRUDVSK\VLFLVWVWHUPHGLW
    )O\LQJVKLSVWKURXJKERWKPRXWKVVHQWVWUHVVZDYHVSURSDJDWLQJWRZDUG
    HDFKRWKHUDWVSHHGVZKLFKGHSHQGHGRQWKHORFDWLRQDQGYHORFLW\RIWKH
    VKLSV7KHVWUHVVFRQVWULFWHG WKHWKURDWVRWKDWZKHQWKHZDYHVPHWD
    FOHQFKLQJVTXHH]HGGRZQWKHZDOOV
    7KHHVVHQWLDOSRLQWZDVWKDWWKHWZRZDYHVPRYHGGLIIHUHQWO\DIWHUWKH\
    PHW7KH\LQWHUDFWHGRQHVORZLQJDQGWKHRWKHUVSHHGLQJXSLQDKLJKO\
    QRQOLQHDUIDVKLRQ
    2QHZDYHFRXOGJURZWKHRWKHUVKULQN7KHELJRQHPDGHWKHWKURDW
    FOHQFKGRZQLQWRVDXVDJHOLQNV:KHQDVDXVDJHQHFNPHWDVKLSWKHFUDIW
    PLJKWVOLSWKURXJKEXWFDOFXODWLQJWKDWZDVDSURGLJLRXVMRE,IWKHVDXVDJH
    QHFNKDSSHQHGWRPHHWWKHWZRVKLSVZKHQWKH\SDVVHGFUXQFK
    7KLVZDVQRPHUHWHFKQLFDOSUREOHP,WZDVDUHDOOLPLWDWLRQLPSRVHGE\
    WKHODZVRITXDQWXPJUDYLW\)URPWKDWILUPIDFWDURVHDQHODERUDWHV\VWHPRI
    VDIHJXDUGVWD[HVUHJXODWRUVDQGKDQJHUVRQDOOWKHDSSDUDWXVRID
    EXUHDXFUDF\ZKLFKGRHVLQGHHGKDYHDSXUSRVHDQGPDNHVWKHPRVWRILW
    +DULOHDUQHGWRGLVSHOKLVDSSUHKHQVLRQE\ZDWFKLQJWKHYLHZV6XQVDQG
    SODQHWVRIJUHDWOXPLQRXVEHDXW\IORDWHGLQWKHEODFNQHVV
    %HKLQGWKHUHVSOHQGHQFHKHNQHZOXUNHGQHFHVVLW\
    )URPWKHZRUPKROHFDOFXOXVDURVHEOXQWHFRQRPLFIDFWV%HWZHHQZRUOGV$
    DQG%WKHUHPLJKWEHKDOIDGR]HQZRUPKROHMXPSVWKH1HVWZDVQRWVLPSO\
    FRQQHFWHGDPHUHDVWURSK\VLFDOVXEZD\V\VWHP(DFKZRUPPRXWKLPSRVHGDGGHG
    IHHVDQGFKDUJHVRQHDFKVKLSPHQW
    &RQWURORIDQHQWLUHWUDGHURXWH\LHOGHGWKHPD[LPXPSURILW7KH
    VWUXJJOHIRUFRQWUROZDVXQHQGLQJRIWHQYLROHQW)URPWKHYLHZSRLQWRI
    HFRQRPLFVSROLWLFVDQGKLVWRULFDOPRPHQWXPZKLFKPHDQWDVRUWRILPSRVHG
    LQHUWLDRQHYHQWVDORFDOHPSLUHZKLFKFRQWUROOHGDZKROHFRQVWHOODWLRQRI
    QRGHVVKRXOGEHVROLGHQGXULQJ
    1RWVR7LPHDQGDJDLQUHJLRQDOVDWUDSLHVZHQWWRHVXS
    0DQ\SHULVKHGEHFDXVHWKH\ZHUHHODERUDWHO\FRQWUROOHG,WVHHPHG
    QDWXUDOWRVTXHH]HHYHU\ZRUPSDVVDJHIRUWKHPD[LPXPIHHE\FRRUGLQDWLQJ
    HYHU\ZRUPPRXWKWRRSWLPL]HWUDIILF%XWWKDWGHJUHHRIFRQWUROPDGHSHRSOH
    UHVWLYH
    7KHV\VWHPFRXOGQRWGHOLYHUWKHEHVWEHQHILWV2YHUFRQWUROIDLOHG

    

    2QWKHLUVHYHQWHHQWKMXPSWKH\PHWDFDVHLQSRLQW

    9HFWRUDVLGHIRUVHDUFKFDPHDQDXWRPDWLFFRPPDQGIURPDQ,PSHULDO
    YHVVHO
    7KH\KDGQRFKRLFH7KHELJEHOOLHG,PSHULDOVFRRSHGWKHPXSZLWKLQ
    VHFRQGVDIWHUWKHLUHPHUJHQFHIURPDPHGLXPVL]HGZRUPKROHPRXWK
    7UDQVJUHVVLRQWD[DFRPSXWHUL]HGV\VWHPDQQRXQFHG3ODQHW2EHMHHRQ
    GHPDQGVWKDWVSHFLDOFDUULHUVSD\$EOXURIFRPSXWHUODQJXDJHIROORZHG
    /HWVSD\LW+DULVDLG
    ,ZRQGHULILWZLOOSURYLGHDWUDFHUIRU/DPXUN"'RUVVDLGRYHUWKH
    LQWHUQDOFRPP
    :KDWLVRXURSWLRQ"
    ,VKDOOXVHP\RZQSHUVRQDO LQGLFHV
    )RUDZRUPKROHWUDQVLW"7KDWZLOOEDQNUXSW\RX
    ,WLVVDIHU
    +DULIXPHGZKLOHWKH\IORDWHGLQPDJQHWLFJUDSSOHUVEHQHDWKWKH,PSHULDO
    SLFNHWVKLS7KHZRUPKROHRUELWHGDKHDYLO\LQGXVWULDOL]HGZRUOG*UD\FLWLHV
    VSUDZOHGRYHUWKHFRQWLQHQWVDQGZHEEHGDFURVVWKHVHDVLQKXJHKH[DJRQDOV
    7KH(PSLUHKDGWZRSODQHWDU\PRGHVUXUDODQGXUEDQ+HOLFRQZDVDIDUP
    ZRUOGVRFLDOO\VWDEOHEHFDXVHRILWVWLPHKRQRUHGOLQHDJHVDQGVWDEOH
    HFRQRPLFPRGHV6XFKZRUOGVDQGWKHVLPLODU)HPRUXVWLFVODVWHG
    2EHMHHRQRQWKHRWKHUKDQGVHHPHGWRFDWHUWRWKHRWKHUEDVLFKXPDQ
    LPSXOVHFOXPSLQJVHHNLQJWKHUXERIRQHVIHOORZV7UDQWRUZDVWKHSLQQDFOH
    RIFLW\FOXVWHULQJ
    +DULKDGDOZD\VWKRXJKWLWRGGWKDWKXPDQLW\EURNHVRHDVLO\LQWRWZR
    PRGHV1RZWKRXJKKLVSDQH[SHULHQFHFODULILHGWKHVHSURFOLYLWLHV
    3DQORYHRIWKHRSHQDQGQDWXUDOKDGLWVSDUDOOHOLQWKHUXVWLFZRUOGV
    7KLVLQFOXGHGDKRVWRISRVVLEOHVRFLHWLHVHVSHFLDOO\WKH)HPRSDVWRUDODW
    WUDFWRULQSV\FKRKLVWRU\VSDFH
    ,WVRSSRVLWHSROHFODXVWURSKRELFWKRXJKUHDVVXULQJVRFLHWLHVHPHUJHG
    IURPWKHVDPHSV\FKRG\QDPLFURRWVDVWKHSDQVWULEDOJDWKHULQJ3DQV
    REVHVVLYHJURRPLQJH[SUHVVHGLWVHOILQKXPDQVDVJRVVLSDQGSDUW\LQJ3DQ
    KLHUDUFKLHVJDYHWKHEDVLFVKDSHWRWKHYDULRXV)HXGDOLVWDWWUDFWRUJURXSV
    0DFKR6RFLDOLVW3DWHUQDO(YHQWKHRGGWKDQWRFUDFLHVRIVRPHRIWKH)DOOHQ
    :RUOGVILWWKHSDWWHUQ7KH\KDG3KDUDRKILJXUHVSURPLVLQJDGPLVVLRQWRDQ
    DIWHUOLIHDQGGHWDLOHGUDQNLQJVGHVFHQGLQJIURPKLVH[DOWHGSHDNLQWKHULJLG
    VRFLDOS\UDPLG
    7KHVHFDWHJRULHVKHQRZIHOWLQKLVJXW7KDWZDVWKHHOHPHQWKHKDG
    EHHQPLVVLQJ1RZKHFRXOGLQFOXGHQXDQFHVDQGVKDGLQJVLQWKH
    SV\FKRKLVWRULFDOHTXDWLRQVZKLFKUHIOHFWHGHDUQHGH[SHULHQFH7KDWZRXOGEH
    PXFKEHWWHUWKDQWKHGU\DEVWUDFWLRQVZKLFKKDGOHGKLPVRIDU
    7KH\UHSDLGRII'RUVVHQWRYHUWKHFRPP6XFKFRUUXSWLRQ
    8PPP\HVVKRFNLQJ:DVKHJHWWLQJF\QLFDO"+HZDQWHGWRWXUQDQG
    VSHDNZLWKKHUEXWWKHLUSHQFLOVKLSDOORZHGVFDQWVRFLDOL]LQJ
    /HWVJR
    :KHUHWR"
    7R+HUHDOL]HGWKDWKHKDGQRLGHD
    :HKDYHSUREDEO\HOXGHGSXUVXLW'RUVYRLFHFDPHWKURXJKVWLIIDQG
    WLJKW+HKDGOHDUQHGWRUHFRJQL]HVLJQVRIKHURZQWHQVLRQ
    ,GOLNHWRVHH+HOLFRQDJDLQ
    7KH\ZRXOGH[SHFWWKDW
    +HIHOWDVWDERIGLVDSSRLQWPHQW8QWLOQRZKHKDGQRWUHDOL]HGKRZ
    FORVHWRKLVKHDUWKLVHDUO\\HDUVVWLOOZHUH+DG7UDQWRUGXOOHGKLPWRKLV
    RZQHPRWLRQV":KHUHWKHQ"
    ,WRRNDGYDQWDJHRIWKLVSDXVHWRDOHUWDIULHQGE\ZRUPOLQNVKH

    VDLG:HPD\EH DEOHWRUHWXUQWR7UDQWRUWKRXJKWKURXJKDGHYLRXVURXWH
    7UDQWRU/DPXUN
    0D\QRWH[SHFWVXFKDXGDFLW\
    :KLFKUHFRPPHQGVWKHLGHD
    

    ,WZDVGL]]\LQJOHDSLQJDERXWWKHHQWLUHJDOD[\WUDSSHGLQDFDVNHW
    VL]HGFRQWDLQHU
    7KH\MXPSHGDQGGRGJHGDQGMXPSHGDJDLQ$WVHYHUDOPRUHZRUPKROH\DUGV
    'RUVPDGHGHDOV3D\RIIVDFWXDOO\6KHGHIWO\GHDOWFRPELQDWLRQVRIKLV
    F\JQHWVWKH,PSHULDO3DVVDJHLQGLFHVDQGKHUSULYDWHQXPEHUV
    &RVWO\+DULIUHWWHG+RZZLOO,HYHUSD\
    7KHGHDGGRQRWZRUU\DERXWGHEWVVKHVDLG
    <RXKDYHVXFKDQHQJDJLQJZD\RISXWWLQJPDWWHUV
    6XEWOHW\LVZDVWHGKHUH
    7KH\HPHUJHGIURPRQHMXPSLQFORVHRUELWDERXWDVXEOLPHO\WRUWXUHG
    VWDU6WUHDPHUVOXVKZLWKOLJKWUDFHGE\WKHP
    +RZORQJFDQWKLVZRUPODVWKHUH"KHZRQGHUHG
    ,WZLOOEHUHVFXHG,PVXUH,PDJLQHWKHFKDRVLQWKHV\VWHPLIDZRUP
    PRXWKEHJLQVWRJXVKKRWSODVPD
    +DULNQHZWKHZRUPKROHV\VWHPWKRXJKGLVFRYHUHGLQSUH(PSLUHDJHVKDG
    QRWDOZD\VEHHQXVHG$IWHUWKHXQGHUO\LQJSK\VLFVRIWKHZRUPKROHFDOFXOXV
    FDPHWREHNQRZQVKLSVFRXOGSO\WKH*DOD[\E\LQYRNLQJZRUPKROHVWDWHV
    DURXQGWKHPVHOYHV7KLVDIIRUGHGH[SORUDWLRQRIUHDFKHVGHYRLGRIZRUPKROHV
    EXWDWKLJKHQHUJ\FRVWVDQGVRPHGDQJHU)XUWKHUVXFKVKLSORFDOK\SHUGULYHV
    ZHUHIDUVORZHUWKDQVLPSO\VOLSSLQJWKURXJKDZRUP
    $QGLIWKH(PSLUHHURGHG"/RVWWKHZRUPQHWZRUN":RXOGWKHVOLPDWWDFN
    ILJKWHUVDQGVQDNHOLNHZHDSRQVIOHHWVJLYHZD\WROXPEHULQJK\SHUVKLS
    GUHDGQRXJKWV"
    7KHQH[WGHVWLQDWLRQVZDPDPLGDQHHULHEODFNYRLGIDURXWLQWKHKDOR
    RIUHGGZDUIVDERYHWKH*DODFWLFSODQH7KHGLVNVWUHWFKHGLQOXPLQRXV
    VSOHQGRU+DULUHPHPEHUHGKROGLQJDFRLQDQGWKLQNLQJRIKRZDPHUHVSHFNRQ
    LWVWRRGIRUDYDVWYROXPHOLNHDODUJH=RQH+HUHVXFKKXPDQWHUPV VHHPHG
    SRLQWOHVV7KH*DOD[\ZDVRQHVHUHQHV\PSKRQ\RIPDVVDQGWLPHJUDQGHUWKDQ
    DQ\KXPDQSHUVSHFWLYHRUSDQVKDSHGYLVLRQ
    5DYLVKLQJ'RUVVDLG
    6HH$QGURPHGD",WORRNVQHDUO\DVFORVH
    7KHWZLQVSLUDOKXQJDERYHWKHP,WVODQHVRIFORWWHGGXVWIUDPHGVWDUV
    D]XUHDQGFULPVRQDQGHPHUDOG+HUHFRPHVRXUFRQQHFWLRQ+DULZDUQHG
    7KLVZRUPKROHLQWHUVHFWLRQDIIRUGHGILYHEUDQFKHV7KUHHEODFNVSKHUHV
    RUELWHGFORVHO\WRJHWKHUEODULQJEULJKWE\WKHLUTXDQWXPULPUDGLDWLRQ7ZR
    FXELFZRUPKROHVFLUFOHGIDUWKHURXW+DULNQHZWKDWRQHRIWKHUDUHYDULDQW
    IRUPVZDVFXELFDOEXWKHKDGQHYHUVHHQDQ\7ZRWRJHWKHUVXJJHVWHGWKDWWKH\
    ZHUHERUQDWWKHHGJHRIJDOD[LHVEXWVXFKPDWWHUVZHUHEH\RQGKLVVKDN\
    XQGHUVWDQGLQJ
    :HJRWKHUH'RUVSRLQWHGDODVHUEHDPDWRQHRIWKHFXEHVJXLGLQJ
    WKHSHQFLOVKLS
    7KH\WKUXVWWRZDUGWKHVPDOOHUFXEHJLQJHUO\LQFKLQJXS7KHZRUP\DUG
    KHUHZDVDXWRPDWLFDQGQRRQHKDLOHGWKHP
    7LJKWILW+DULVDLGQHUYRXVO\
    )LYHILQJHUVWRVSDUH
    +HWKRXJKWVKHZDVMRNLQJWKHQUHDOL]HGWKDWVKHZDVXQGHUHVWLPDWLQJ
    WKHILW$WWKLVOHVVXVHGZRUPKROH LQWHUVHFWLRQVORZVSHHGVZHUHHVVHQWLDO
    *RRGSK\VLFVXQIRUWXQDWHHFRQRPLFV7KHVORZGRZQFXWWKHQHWIOX[RIPDVV
    PDNLQJWKHPEDFNZDWHUFURVVURDGV
    +HJD]HGDW$QGURPHGDWRWDNHKLVPLQGRIIWKHSLORWLQJ1DUURZ

    ZRUPKROHVGLGQRWHPHUJHLQRWKHUJDOD[LHVIRUDUFDQHUHDVRQVRITXDQWXP
    JUDYLW\([WUHPHO\QDUURZRQHVPLJKWEXWLIWKHWKURDWKDGRWKHUPDVVFRPLQJ
    WKURXJKWKHVTXHH]HZDYHFRXOGNLOO)HZKDGHYHUYHQWXUHGGRZQWKHPLQ
    VHDUFKRIH[WUDJDODFWLFHPHUJHQWSRLQWV
    ([FHSWWKDWLVIRU6WHIIQRV5LGHDOHJHQGDU\ULVN\H[SHGLWLRQZKLFK
    KDGSRSSHGRXWLQWKHJDOD[\FDWDORJHGDV06WHIIQRKDGJRWWHQGDWDRQWKH
    VSHFWDFXODUMHWHPHUJLQJIURPWKHEODFNKROHDW0VFHQWHUPDMHVWLFVWUDQGV
    WZLVWLQJLQWRKHOLFDODUDEHVTXHV7KHORQHULGHUKDGQRWWDUULHGUHWXUQLQJ
    RQO\VHFRQGVEHIRUHWKHZRUPVQDSSHGVKXWLQDVSUD\RIUDGLDQWSDUWLFOHV
    1RRQHNQHZZK\6RPHWKLQJLQZRUPKROHSK\VLFVGLVFRXUDJHGH[WUDJDODFWLF
    DGYHQWXUHV
    7KHFXELFZRUPWRRNWKHPTXLFNO\WRVHYHUDOZRUP\DUGVLQFORVHRUELW
    DERXWSODQHWV2QH+DULUHFRJQL]HGDVDUDUHW\SHZLWKDQROGEXWUXLQHG
    ELRVSKHUH/LNH3DQXFRSLDLWVXSSRUWHGDGYDQFHGOLIHIRUPV2QPRVW
    LQKDELWDEOHZRUOGVHDUO\H[SORUHUVKDGIRXQGDOJDHPDWVWKDWQHYHUGHYHORSHG
    IXUWKHU
    :K\QRLQWHUHVWLQJDOLHQV WKHQ"+DULPXVHGZKLOH'RUVGHDOWZLWKWKH
    ORFDOZRUP\DUG*UH\0HQ
    2FFDVLRQDOO\'RUVUHPLQGHGKLPWKDWVKHZDVDIWHUDOODQKLVWRULDQ
    7KHVKLIWIURPRQHFHOOHGWRPDQ\FHOOHGFUHDWXUHVWRRNELOOLRQVRI\HDUV
    WKHRU\VD\V:HMXVWFDPHIURPDIDVW WRXJKHUELRVSKHUHWKDWVDOO
    :HFDPHIURPDSODQHWZLWKDWOHDVWRQHELJPRRQWRR
    :K\"VKHDVNHG
    :HYHJRWUHSHDWLQJSDWWHUQVRIWZHQW\HLJKWGD\VEXLOWLQ)HPDOH
    PHQVWUXDWLRQIRULQVWDQFHXQOLNHSDQVLQFLGHQWDOO\:HUHGHVLJQHGE\
    ELRORJ\:HPDGHLWWKHVHELRVSKHUHVGLGQW7KHUHDUHSOHQW\RIZD\VWRNLOO
    DZRUOG*ODFLHUVDGYDQFLQJZKHQDQRUELWDOWHUV$VWHURLGVVODPPLQJLQEDP
    EDPEDP+HVODSSHGWKHVLGHRIWKHSHQFLOVKLSORXGO\&KHPLVWU\RIWKH
    DWPRVSKHUHJRHVZURQJ,WUXQVDZD\LQWRDKRWKRXVHSODQHWRUDIUR]HQRXW
    ZRUOG
    ,VHH
    +XPDQVDUHWRXJKHUDQGVPDUWHUWKDQDQ\ERG\:HUHKHUHWKH\
    DUHQW
    :KRVD\V"
    6WDQGDUGNQRZOHGJHHYHUVLQFHWKHVRFLRWKHRULVW.DPSIEHO
    ,PVXUH\RXUHULJKWVKHVDLGTXLFNO\
    6RPHWKLQJLQKHUYRLFHPDGHKLPKHVLWDWHKHORYHGDJRRGDUJXPHQWEXW
    E\WKHQWKH\ZHUHVOLSSLQJWKURXJKWKHH[FUXFLDWLQJWLJKWILWRIWKHFXEH7KH
    HGJHVJORZHGOLNHDOHPRQ\(XFOLGHDQFRQVWUXFWLRQDQGWKHQWKH\SRSSHGLQWR
    DQRUELWDERYH DEODFNKROH
    +HZDWFKHGWKHHQRUPRXVHQHUJ\KDUYHVWLQJGLVNVJORZZLWKIHUPHQWLQJ
    VFDUOHWVDQGYLUXOHQWSXUSOHV7KH(PSLUHKDGVWDWLRQHGJUHDWFRQGXLWVRI
    PDJQHWLFILHOGDURXQGWKHKROH7KHVHVXFNHGDQGGUHZLQLQWHUVWHOODUGXVW
    FORXGV7KHGDUNF\FORQHVQDUURZHGWRZDUGWKHEULOOLDQWDFFUHWLRQGLVNDURXQG
    WKHKROH5DGLDWLRQIURPWKHIULFWLRQDQGLQIDOOLQJZDVLQWXUQFDSWXUHGE\
    YDVWJULGVDQGUHIOHFWRUV7KHFURSRIUDZSKRWRQHQHUJ\LWVHOIEHFDPHWUDSSHG
    DQGIOXVKHGLQWRWKHZDLWLQJPDZVRIZRUPKROHV7KHVHFDUULHGWKHIOX[WR
    GLVWDQWZRUOGVLQQHHGRIFXWWLQJODQFHVRIOLJKWIRUWKHEXVLQHVVRISODQHW
    VKDSLQJZRUOGUDNLQJPRRQFDUYLQJ
    %XWHYHQDPLGWKLVVSHFWDFOHKHFRXOGQRWIRUJHWWKHWRQHLQ'RUV
    YRLFH6KHNQHZVRPHWKLQJKHGLGQRW+HZRQGHUHG
    1DWXUHVRPHSKLORVRSKHUVKHOGZDVLWVHOIRQO\EHIRUHKXPDQLW\WRXFKHG
    LW:HGLGQRWWKHQEHORQJLQWKHYHU\LGHDRI1DWXUHDQGVRZHFRXOG
    H[SHULHQFHLWRQO\DVLWZDVGLVDSSHDULQJ2XUSUHVHQFHDORQHZDVHQRXJKWR
    PDNH1DWXUHLQWRVRPHWKLQJHOVHDFRPSURPLVHGLPSHUVRQDWLRQ
    7KHVHLGHDVKDGXQH[SHFWHGLPSOLFDWLRQV2QHZRUOGQDPHG$UFDGLDKDG
    EHHQGHOLEHUDWHO\OHIWZLWKDPHUHFDUHWDNHUSRSXODWLRQRIKXPDQVSDUWO\

    EHFDXVHLWZDVGLIILFXOWWRUHDFK7KHQHDUHVWZRUPKROHPRXWKZDVKDOID
    OLJKW\HDUDZD\$QHDUO\HPSHURUVRREVFXUHKLVRUKHUYHU\QDPHZDVORVW
    KDGGHFUHHGWKDWWKHIRUHVWVDQGSODLQVRIWKHEHQLJQSODQHWEHOHIW
    RULJLQDO%XWWHQWKRXVDQG\HDUVODWHUDUHFHQWUHSRUWDQQRXQFHGVRPH
    IRUHVWVZHUHQRWUHJHQHUDWLQJDQGSODLQVZHUHJLYLQJZD\WRVFUXEE\EUXVK
    6WXG\VKRZHGWKDWWKHFDUHWDNHUVKDGWDNHQWRRPXFKFDUH7KH\KDGSXW
    RXWZLOGILUHVVXSSUHVVHGVSHFLHVWUDQVIHU7KH\KDGHYHQKHOGWKHZHDWKHU
    QHDUO\FRQVWDQWWKURXJKDGMXVWPHQWVLQKRZPXFKVXQOLJKWWKHLFHSROHV
    UHIOHFWHGEDFNLQWRVSDFH
    7KH\KDGWULHGWRKROGRQWRDVWDWLF$UFDGLDVRWKHIRUHVWSULPHYDOZDV
    UHYHDOHGDVLQSDUWDKXPDQSURGXFW7KH\KDGQRWXQGHUVWRRGF\FOHV+H
    ZRQGHUHGKRZVXFKDQLQVLJKWPLJKWIROGLQWRSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    )RUJHWWKHRU\IRUWKHPRPHQWKHUHPLQGHGKLPVHOI,WZDVDIDFWWKDW
    WKH*DOD[\KDGVHHPHGHPSW\RIKLJKDOLHQOLIHIRUPVLQWKHHDUO\SUH(PSLUH
    WLPHV:LWKVRPDQ\IHUWLOHSODQHWVGLGKHWUXO\EHOLHYHWKDWRQO\KXPDQLW\
    KDGHPHUJHGLQWRLQWHOOLJHQFH"
    6RPHKRZVXUYH\LQJWKHLQFRPSUHKHQVLEOHZHDOWKRIWKLVOXVKLPPHQVH
    GLVNRIVWDUVVRPHKRZ+DULFRXOGQRWEHOLHYHLW
    %XWZKDWZDVWKHDOWHUQDWLYH"
    

    7KH(PSLUHVWZHQW\ILYHPLOOLRQZRUOGVVXSSRUWHGDQDYHUDJHRIRQO\
    IRXUELOOLRQSHRSOHSHUSODQHW7UDQWRUKDGIRUW\ELOOLRQ$PHUHWKRXVDQG
    OLJKW\HDUVIURP*DODFWLF&HQWHULWKDGVHYHQWHHQZRUPKROHPRXWKVRUELWLQJ
    ZLWKLQLWVVRODUV\VWHPWKHKLJKHVWGHQVLW\LQWKH*DOD[\7KH7UDQWRULDQ
    V\VWHPKDGRULJLQDOO\KHOGRQO\WZREXWDJDUJDQWXDQWHFKQRORJ\RIEUXWH
    LQWHUVWHOODUIOLJKWKDGWXJJHGWKHUHVWWKHUHWRPDNHWKHQH[XV
    (DFKRIWKHVHYHQWHHQVSDZQHGRFFDVLRQDOZLOGZRUPV2QHRIWKHVHZDV
    'RUVWDUJHW
    %XWWRUHDFKLWWKH\KDGWRYHQWXUHZKHUHIHZGLG
    7KH*DODFWLF&HQWHULVGDQJHURXV'RUVVDLGDVWKH\FRDVWHGWRZDUGWKH
    GHFLVLYHZRUPKROHPRXWK7KH\FXUYHGDERYHDEDUUHQPLQLQJSODQHW%XW
    QHFHVVDU\
    7UDQWRUZRUULHVPHPRUH7KHMXPSFXWKLPRII
    DQGWKHVSHFWDFOHVLOHQFHGKLP
    7KHILODPHQWVZHUHVRODUJHWKHH\HFRXOGQRWWDNHWKHPLQ7KH\
    VWUHWFKHGIRUHDQGDIWVKRWWKURXJKZLWKLPPHQVHOXPLQRXVFRUULGRUVDQGGXVN\
    ODQHV7KHVHDUFKHV\DZQHGRYHUWHQVRIOLJKW\HDUV,PPHQVHFXUYHVGHVFHQGHG
    WRZDUGWKHZKLWHKRW7UXH&HQWHU7KHUHPDWWHUIURWKHGDQGIXPHGDQGEXUVW
    LQWRGD]]OLQJIRXQWDLQV
    7KHEODFNKROHKHVDLGVLPSO\
    7KHVPDOOEODFNKROHWKH\KDGVHHQRQO\DQKRXUEHIRUHKDGWUDSSHGDIHZ
    VWHOODUPDVVHV$W7UXH&HQWHUDPLOOLRQVXQVKDGGLHGWRIHHGJUDYLW\V
    JXOOHW
    7KHRUGHUO\DUUD\VRIUDGLDQFHZHUHWKLQRQO\DOLJKW\HDUDFURVV<HW
    WKH\VXVWDLQHGWKHPVHOYHVDORQJKXQGUHGVRIOLJKW\HDUVDVWKH\FKXUQHGZLWK
    FKDQJH+DULVZLWFKHGWKHSRODUL]HGZDOOVWRVHHLQGLIIHUHQWIUHTXHQF\
    UDQJHV7KRXJKKRWDQGURLOLQJLQWKHYLVLEOHKXPDQVSHFWUXPWKHUDGLR
    UHYHDOHGKLGGHQLQWULFDF\7KUHDGVODFHGDPRQJFRQYROXWHGVSLQGOHV+HKDGD
    SRZHUIXOLPSUHVVLRQRIOD\HUVRIODE\ULQWKLQHRUGHUGHVFHQGLQJEH\RQGKLV
    YLHZEH\RQGVLPSOHXQGHUVWDQGLQJ
    3DUWLFOHIOX[LVKLJK'RUVVDLGWHQVHO\$QGULVLQJ
    :KHUHVRXUMXQFWLRQ"
    ,PKDYLQJWURXEOHYHFWRUIL[LQJDK7KHUH
    +DUGDFFHOHUDWLRQUDPPHGKLPEDFNLQWRKLVIORZFRXFK'RUVWRRNWKHP
    GLYLQJGRZQLQWRDPRWWOHGS\UDPLGVKDSHGZRUPKROH

    7KLVZDVDQHYHQUDUHUJHRPHWU\+DULKDGWLPHWRPDUYHODWKRZ
    DFFLGHQWVRIWKHXQLYHUVDOELUWKSDQJKDGVKDSHGWKHVHVHUHQHJHRPHWULHVOLNH
    H[KLELWVLQVRPHJRGV(XFOLGHDQPXVHXPRIWKHPLQG
    $QGWKHQWKH\SOXQJHGWKURXJKHUDVLQJWKHVWXQQLQJYLHZV
    7KH\SRSSHGRXWDERYHWKHJUD\EURZQPRWWOHGIDFHRI7UDQWRU$JOLQWLQJ
    GLVNRIVDWHOOLWHVIDFWRULHVDQGKDELWDWVIDQQHGRXWLQWKHHTXDWRULDOSODQH
    7KHZLOGZRUPWKH\KDGXVHGIL]]HGDQGJORZHGEHKLQGWKHP'RUVWRRN
    WKHPVZLIWO\WRZDUGWKHUDPVKDFNOHWHPSRUDU\ZRUP\DUG+HVDLGQRWKLQJEXW
    IHOWKHUWHQVHFDOFXODWLRQV7KH\QXGJHGLQWRDVRFNHWVHDOVVLJKHGKLVHDUV
    SRSSHGSDLQIXOO\
    7KHQWKH\ZHUHRXWDUPVDQGOHJVZRRGHQIURPWKHFUDPSHGSHQFLOVKLS
    +DULFRDVWHGLQ]HURJWRZDUGWKHIOH[ORFN'RUVJOLGHGDKHDGRIKLP6KH
    PRWLRQHGKLPIRUVLOHQFHDVSUHVVXUHVSXOVHGLQWKHORFN6KHSHHOHGKHU
    VNLQVXLWGRZQH[SRVLQJKHUEUHDVWV
    $ILQJHUVWRXFKRSHQHGDVHDPEHORZKHUOHIWEUHDVW6KHSOXFNHGD
    F\OLQGHURXW$ZHDSRQ"6KHUHVHDOHGDQGKDGKHUVNLQVXLWEDFNLQSODFHEHIRUH
    WKHVWDJLQJGLDSKUDJPEHJDQWRRSHQ
    %H\RQGWKHRSHQLQJLULV+DULVDZ,PSHULDOXQLIRUPV
    +HFURXFKHGDJDLQVWWKHORFNZDOOUHDG\WRODXQFKKLPVHOIEDFNZDUGWR
    DYRLGFDSWXUHEXWWKHVLWXDWLRQORRNHGKRSHOHVV
    7KH,PSHULDOVORRNHGJULPGHWHUPLQHG7KH\FODVSHGSLVWROV'RUV
    FRDVWHGEHWZHHQ+DULDQGWKHVTXDG6KHWRVVHGWKHF\OLQGHUDWWKHP
    DSUHVVXUHZDYHNQRFNHGKLPEDFNDJDLQVWWKHZDOO+LVHDUVFORJJHG
    7KHVTXDGZDVDQH[SDQGLQJFORXGRIGHEULV
    :KDW"
    6KDSHGLPSORVLRQ'RUVFDOOHG0RYH
    7KHLQMXUHGPHQKDGEHHQVODPPHGLQWRHDFKRWKHU+RZDQ\WKLQJFRXOG
    VKDSHDSUHVVXUHZDYHVRFRPSDFWO\KHFRXOGQRWLPDJLQH,QDQ\FDVHKHKDG
    QRWLPH7KH\VKRWSDVWWKHWDQJOHGFORXGRIPHQ:HDSRQVGULIWHGXVHOHVVO\
    $ILJXUHHUXSWHGIURPWKHIDU GLDSKUDJP$PDQLQDEURZQZRUNVKHDWK
    PLGGOHVL]HGXQDUPHG+DULVKRXWHGDZDUQLQJ'RUVVKRZHGQRUHDFWLRQ
    7KHPDQIOLFNHGKLVZULVWDQGDVQRXWDSSHDUHGIURPKLVVOHHYH'RUV
    VWLOOFRDVWHGWRZDUGKLP
    +DULVQDJJHGDKDQGKROGDQGYHHUHGWRKLV ULJKW
    6WD\VWLOOWKHPDQ\HOOHG
    +DULIUR]HGDQJOLQJE\RQHKDQG7KHPDQILUHGDQGDVLOYHU\EROW
    IULHGSDVW+DUL
    +HWXUQHGDQGVDZWKDWRQHRIWKH,PSHULDOVKDGUHFRYHUHGKLVZHDSRQ
    7KHVLOYHUOLQHVFUDWFKHGILUHDFURVVWKH,PSHULDOVDUP +HVFUHDPHG+LV
    ZHDSRQWXPEOHGDZD\
    /HWVJR,KDYHWKHUHVWRIWKHZD\VHFXUHGWKHPDQLQWKHZRUN
    VKHDWKFDOOHG
    'RUVIROORZHGKLPZLWKRXWDZRUG+DULSXVKHGRIIDQGFDXJKWXSWRWKHP
    DVWKHGLDSKUDJPLULVHGIRUWKHP
    <RXUHWXUQWR7UDQWRUDWWKHFUXFLDOPRPHQWWKHPDQVDLG
    <RXZKR
    7KHPDQVPLOHG,KDYHFKDQJHGP\VHOI<RXGRQRWUHFRJQL]H\RXUROG
    IULHQG5'DQHHO"
    5(1'(=9286

    5'DQHHOJD]HGDW'RUVZLWKRXWH[SUHVVLRQOHWWLQJKLVERG\JRVODFN
    'RUVVDLG:HPXVWGHIHQGKLPDJDLQVW/DPXUN<RXFRXOGUHDSSHDUFRPH
    RXWLQIDYRURIKLP$VIRUPHU)LUVW0LQLVWHU\RXUSXEOLFHQGRUVHPHQWDQG
    VXSSRUW
    ,FDQQRWUHDSSHDUDV(WR'HPHU]HOH[LPSRUWDQWSHUVRQ7KDWZRXOG
    FRPSURPLVHP\RWKHUWDVNV

    %XW+DULKDVWRKDYH
    $VZHOO\RXPLVWDNHP\SRZHUDV'HPHU]HO,DPQRZKLVWRU\/DPXUN
    ZLOOFDUHQRWKLQJDERXWPHIRU,KDYHQROHJLRQVWRFRPPDQG
    'RUVIXPHGVLOHQWO\%XW\RXPXVW
    ,VKDOOPRYHPRUHRIXVLQWR/DPXUNVLQQHUFLUFOH
    ,WVWRRODWHWRLQILOWUDWH
    'DQHHODFWLYDWHGKLVH[SUHVVLYHSURJUDPVDQGVPLOHG,SODQWHGVHYHUDO
    RIRXUNLQGGHFDGHVDJR7KH\VKDOODOOEHLQSRVLWLRQVRRQ
    <RXUHXVLQJXV"
    ,PXVW7KRXJK\RXULPSOLFDWLRQLVFRUUHFWZHDUHIHZ
    ,QHHGKHOSSURWHFWLQJKLPWRR
    4XLWHULJKW+HSURGXFHGDWKLFNGLVNWKLVWLPHIURPDFRPSDUWPHQW
    EHQHDWKKLVDUPSLW7KLVZLOOLGHQWLI\WKH/DPXUNDJHQWVIRU\RX
    6KHORRNHGGRXEWIXO+RZ"7KLVORRNVOLNHDFKHPVQRRSHU
    ,KDYHDJHQWVRIP\RZQ7KH\FDQLQWXUQODEHO/DPXUNVDJHQWV7KLV
    GHYLFHZLOOSLFNXSWKHLUWDJV2WKHUHQFRGHGPHVVDJHVZLOOULGHRQWKH
    PDUNLQJVLJQDO
    $QG/DPXUNVVSHFLDOLVWVZRQWSLFNXSWKHWDJV"
    7KLVGHYLFHXVHVPHWKRGVORVWIRUVL[PLOOHQQLD
    ,QVWDOOLWLQ\RXU
    ULJKW DUPDWVWDWLRQFXWVL[,QWHUIDFHZLWKDSHUWXUHVWZRDQGILYH
    +RZZLOO,
    6SHFVDQGH[SHUWLVHZLOOIORZWR\RXUORQJWHUPPHPRU\XSRQ
    FRQQHFWLRQ
    6KHLQVWDOOHGWKHGHYLFHDVKHZDWFKHG+LVJUDYHSUHVHQFHPDGHVLOHQFH
    QDWXUDO2OLYDZQHYHUZDVWHGDPRYHPHQWRUPDGHLGOHFRQYHUVDWLRQ)LQDOO\
    LQWULFDFLHVGRQHVKHVLJKHGDQGVDLG+HVLQWHUHVWHGLQWKRVHVLPXODWLRQV
    WKHRQHVZKLFKHVFDSHG
    +HLVIROORZLQJWKHEHVWOLQHRIDWWDFNIRUSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    7KHUHVWKLVWLNWRNSUREOHPWRR'R\RXXQGHUVWDQG
    7KHVRFLDOWDERRVDJDLQVWVLPXODWLRQVLQHYLWDEO\EUHDNGRZQGXULQJ
    FXOWXUDOUHVXUJHQFHV'DQHHOVDLG
    6RWLNWRNV"
    7KH\DUHLQKHUHQWO\GHVWDELOL]LQJLIWKH\EHFRPHWRRGHYHORSHG$IWHU
    DOOZHFDQQRWFRQGRQHDQHZJHQHUDWLRQRIURERWVRUWKHUHGLVFRYHU\RIWKH
    SRVLWURQLFSURFHVV
    7KHUHDUHVLJQVLQWKHKLVWRULFDOUHFRUGWKDWWKLVKDVKDSSHQHG
    EHIRUH
    <RXDUHDQLQVLJKWIXOVFKRODU
    7KHUHZHUHRQO\DIHZWUDFHVEXW,VXVSHFW
    6XVSHFWQRIXUWKHU<RXDUHFRUUHFW,FRXOGQRWH[SXQJHHYHU\VFUDSRI
    GDWD
    <RXGLVJXLVHGVXFKHYHQWV"
    $QGPXFKHOVH
    :K\"$VDQKLVWRULDQ
    ,KDGWR+XPDQLW\LVEHVWVHUYHGE\,PSHULDOVWDELOLW\7LNWRNVVLPV
    WKHVHDFFRPSDQ\PRYHPHQWVVXFKDVWKLV1HZ5HQDLVVDQFHIHHGLQJWKHILUH
    :KDWVWREHGRQH"
    ,GRQRWNQRZ0DWWHUVDUHVOLSSLQJEH\RQGP\DELOLW\WRSUHGLFW
    6KHIURZQHG+RZGR\RXSUHGLFW"
    ,QWKHILUVWPLOOHQQLDRIWKH(PSLUHRXUNLQGGHYHORSHGWKHVLPSOH
    WKHRU\,KDYHPHQWLRQHGEHIRUH8VHIXOEXWFUXGH,WOHGPHWRH[SHFWWKH
    UHHPHUJHQFHRIWKHVHVLPXODWLRQVDVDVLGHHIIHFWRIWKH6DUNLDQ5HQDLVVDQFH
    DQGLWVWXUPRLO
    'RHV+DULXQGHUVWDQGWKLV"
    +DULVSV\FKRKLVWRU\LVYDVWO\VXSHULRUWRRXUPRGHOV+HODFNVFHUWDLQ
    YLWDOKLVWRULFDOGDWDKRZHYHU:KHQLWLVHYHQWXDOO\LQFOXGHGKHZLOOEH
    DEOHWRDFFXUDWHO\DQWLFLSDWHWKH(PSLUHVGHYROXWLRQ

    <RXGRQRWPHDQHYROXWLRQ"
    4XLWH7KDWLVDPDMRU UHDVRQZK\ZHGHYRWHVXFKUHVRXUFHVWRKHOSLQJ
    +DUL
    +HLVFUXFLDO
    2IFRXUVH:K\GR\RXWKLQN,DVVLJQHG\RXWRKLP"
    'RHVLWPDWWHUWKDW,YHIDOOHQLQORYHZLWKKLP"
    1R%XWLWKHOSV
    +HOSVPH"2UKLP"
    'DQHHOVPLOHGWKLQO\%RWK ,VKRXOGKRSH%XWPRVWO\LWKHOSVPH
    B

    3$57

    7+((7(51$/
    (48$7,216

    B
    7+(*(1(5$/7+(25<2)36<&+2+O6725<
    3$57D0DWKHPDWLFDO$VSHFWVDVWKHFULVLVGHHSHQVWKHGHHSV\VWHPLF
    OHDUQLQJORRSVIDOWHU7KHV\VWHPGULIWVRXWRIWXQH6XFKGULIWV
    SDUWLFXODUO\LIGLIIXVLYHFDOOIRUIXQGDPHQWDOV\VWHPLFUHVWUXFWXULQJ7KLV
    LVWHUPHGWKHPDFURGHFLVLRQSKDVHLQZKLFKWKHORRSVPXVWILQGIUHVK
    FRQILJXULQJVLQWKH1GLPHQVLRQDOODQGVFDSH
    $OOYLVXDOL]DWLRQVFDQEHXQGHUVWRRGLQWKHUPRG\QDPLFWHUPV7KH
    VWDWLVWLFDOPHFKDQLFVLQYROYHGDUHQRWWKRVHRISDUWLFOHVDQGFROOLVLRQVDV
    LQDJDVEXWLQWKHODQJXDJHRIVRFLDOPDFURJURXSVDFWLQJWKURXJK
    FROOLVLRQVZLWKRWKHUVXFKPDFURJURXSV6XFKLPSDFWVSURGXFHPXFKKXPDQ
    GHEULV
    (1&<&/23(',$*$/$&7,&$
    

    +DUL6HOGRQVWRRGDORQHLQWKHOLIWWKLQNLQJ
    7KHGRRUVOLGRSHQ$ZRPDQDVNHGLIWKLVHOHYDWRUZDVJRLQJXSRUGRZQ
    'LVWUDFWHGKHDQVZHUHG<HV+HUVXUSULVHGORRNWROGKLPWKDWVRPHKRZKLV
    UHSO\ZDVRIIWDUJHW2QO\DIWHUWKHGRRUFORVHGRQKHUSX]]OHGVWDUHGLGKH
    VHHWKDWVKHPHDQWZKLFKZD\QRWLI
    +HZDVLQWKHKDELWRIPDNLQJSUHFLVHGLVWLQFWLRQVWKHZRUOGZDVQRW
    +HZDONHGLQWRKLVRIILFHVWLOOEDUHO\DZDUHRIKLVVXUURXQGLQJVDQG
    &OHRQV'EORVVRPHGLQWKHDLUEHIRUHKHFRXOGVLWGRZQ7KH(PSHURUDZDLWHG
    QRILOWHUSURJUDPV
    ,ZDVVRKDSS\WRKHDU\RXKDGUHWXUQHGIURPKROLGD\&OHRQEHDPHG
    3OHDVHGVLUH:KDWGLGKHZDQW"
    +DULGHFLGHGQRWWRWHOOKLPDOOWKDWKDGWUDQVSLUHG 'DQHHOKDG
    VWUHVVHGVHFUHF\2QO\WKLVPRUQLQJDIWHUD]LJ]DJURXWHGRZQIURPWKH
    ZRUP\DUGVKDG+DULOHWKLVSUHVHQFHEHNQRZQHYHQWRWKH,PSHULDO6SHFLDOV
    ,IHDU\RXDUULYHDWDGLIILFXOWWLPH&OHRQVFRZOHG/DPXUNLV
    PRYLQJIRUDYRWHLQWKH+LJK&RXQFLORQWKH)LUVW0LQLVWHUVKLS
    +RZPDQ\YRWHVFDQKHPXVWHU"
    (QRXJKWKDW,FDQQRWLJQRUHWKH&RXQFLO,ZLOOEHIRUFHGWRDSSRLQW
    KLPGHVSLWHP\RZQOLNHV
    ,DPVRUU\IRUWKDWVLUH,QIDFWKLVKHDUWOHDSHG
    ,KDYHPDQHXYHUHGDJDLQVWKLPEXW$QHODERUDWHVLJK&OHRQFKHZHG
    DWKLVDPSOHORZHUOLS+DGWKHPDQJDLQHGZHLJKWDJDLQ"2UZHUH+DULV
    SHUFHSWLRQVDOWHUHGE\KLVWLPHRIVKRUWHQHGGLHWRQ3DQXFRSLD"0RVW

    7UDQWRULDQVORRNHGSXGJ\WRKLPQRZ7KHQWRRLVWKLVLUULWDWLQJPDWWHURI
    6DUNDQGLWVFRQIRXQGHG1HZ5HQDLVVDQFH7KHPXGGOHJURZV&RXOGWKLVVSUHDG
    WRRWKHUZRUOGVLQWKHLU=RQH":RXOGWKRVHWKURZLQZLWKWKHP"<RXKDYH
    VWXGLHGWKLV"
    ,QGHWDLO
    8VLQJSV\FKRKLVWRU\"
    +DULJDYHZD\WRKLVJXWLQVWLQFW8QUHVWZLOOJURZWKHUH
    <RXUHVXUH"
    +HZDVQWEXW,VXJJHVW\RXPRYHDJDLQVWLW
    /DPXUNIDYRUV6DUN+HVD\VLWZLOOEULQJQHZSURVSHULW\
    +HZDQWVWRULGHWKLVGLVFRUGLQWRRIILFH
    2YHUWRSSRVLWLRQIURPPHDWWKLVGHOLFDWHWLPHZRXOGEHXQSROLWLF
    (YHQWKRXJKKHPLJKWEHEHKLQGWKHDWWHPSWVRQP\OLIH"
    $ODVWKHUHLVQRSURRIRIWKDW$VHYHUVHYHUDOIDFWLRQVZRXOG
    EHQHILWZHUH\RXWR&OHRQFRXJKHGXQFRPIRUWDEO\
    :LWKGUDZLQYROXQWDULO\"
    &OHRQVPRXWKZRUNHGXQHDVLO\$Q(PSHURULVIDWKHUWRDSHUSHWXDOO\
    XQUXO\IDPLO\
    ,IHYHQWKH(PSHURUZHUHWLSWRHLQJDURXQG/DPXUNPDWWHUVZHUHLQGHHG
    EDG&RXOGQW\RXSRVLWLRQVTXDGURQVIRUTXLFNXVHVKRXOGWKHRSSRUWXQLW\
    DULVH"
    &OHDQQRGGHG,VKDOO%XWLIWKH+LJK&RXQFLOYRWHVIRU/DPXUN,
    VKDOOEHSRZHUOHVVWRPRYHDJDLQVWVRSURPLQHQWDQGZHOOH[FLWLQJDZRUOGDV
    6DUN
    ,EHOLHYHVWULIHZLOOVSUHDGWKURXJKRXW6DUNVHQWLUH=RQH
    7UXO\":KDWZRXOG\RXDGYLVHPHWRGRDJDLQVW/DPXUN"
    ,KDYHQRSROLWLFDOVNLOOVVLUH<RXNQHZWKDW
    1RQVHQVH<RXKDYHSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    +DULZDVVWLOOXQFRPIRUWDEOHRZQLQJXSWRWKHWKHRU\HYHQZLWK&OHRQ
    ,ILWZHUHHYHUWREHXVHIXOZRUGRISV\FKRKLVWRU\FRXOGQRWEHZLGHVSUHDG
    RU HOVHHYHU\RQHZRXOGXVHLW2UWU\WR
    &OHRQZHQWRQ$QG\RXUVROXWLRQWRWKHWHUURULVWSUREOHPLWLV
    ZRUNLQJZHOO:HMXVWH[HFXWHG0RURQ2QH+XQGUHG
    +DULVKXGGHUHGWKLQNLQJRIWKHOLYHVREOLWHUDWHGE\DPHUHSDVVLQJLGHD
    RIKLV$DVPDOOLVVXHVXUHO\VLUH
    7KHQWXUQ\RXUFDOFXODWLRQVWRWKH'DKOLWH6HFWRUPDWWHU+DUL7KH\
    DUHUHVWLYH(YHU\RQHLVWKHVHGD\V
    $QGWKH=RQHVRI'DKOLWHSHUVXDVLRQWKURXJKRXWWKH*DOD[\"
    7KH\EDFNWKHORFDO'DKOLWHVLQWKH&RXQFLOV,WVDERXWWKLV
    UHSUHVHQWDWLRQTXHVWLRQ7KHSODQZHIROORZRQ7UDQWRUZLOOEHPLUURUHG
    WKURXJKRXWWKH*DOD[\,QGHHGLQWKHYRWHVRIZKROH=RQHV
    :HOOLIPRVWSHRSOHWKLQN
    $KP\GHDU+DUL\RXVWLOOKDYHDPDWKLVWVP\RSLD+LVWRU\LV
    GHWHUPLQHGQRWE\ZKDWSHRSOHWKLQNEXWE\ZKDWWKH\IHHO
    6WDUWOHGIRUWKLVUHPDUNVWUXFNKLPDVWUXH+DULFRXOGRQO\VD\,
    VHHVLUH
    :H\RXDQG,+DULPXVWGHFLGHWKLVLVVXH
    ,OOZRUNRQWKHGHFLVLRQVLUH
    +RZKHKDGFRPHWRKDWHWKHYHU\ZRUG'HFLGHKDGWKHVDPHURRWDV
    VXLFLGHDQGKRPLFLGH'HFLVLRQVIHOWOLNHOLWWOHNLOOLQJV6RPHERG\ORVW
    +DULQRZNQHZZK\KHZDVQRWFXWRXWIRUWKHVHPDWWHUV,IKLVVNLQZDV
    WRRWKLQKHZRXOGKDYHWRRUHDG\HPSDWK\ZLWKRWKHUVZLWKWKHLUDUJXPHQWV
    DQGVHQWLPHQWV7KHQKHZRXOGQRWPDNHGHFLVLRQVZKLFKKHNQHZFRXOGRQO\EH
    DSSUR[LPDWHO\ULJKWDQGZRXOGFDXVHVRPHSDLQ
    2QWKHRWKHUKDQGKHKDGWRVWHHOKLPVHOIDJDLQVWWKHSHUVRQDOQHHGWR
    EHOLNHG,QDQDWXUDOSROLWLFLDQWKDWZRXOGOHDGWRDSRVWXUHWKDWVDLGKH
    FDUHGDERXWRWKHUVZKHQLQIDFWKHFDUHGZKDWWKH\WKRXJKWRIKLPEHFDXVH

    EHLQJOLNHGZDVZKDWFRXQWHGIDUGRZQLQWKHVKDGRZ\SV\FKH,WDOVRFDPHLQ
    KDQG\IRUVWD\LQJLQRIILFH
    &OHRQEURXJKWXSPRUHLVVXHV+DULGRGJHGDQGVWDOOHGDVPXFKDVKH
    FRXOG:KHQ&OHRQDEUXSWO\HQGHGWKHWDONKHNQHZKHKDGQRWFRPHRYHUZHOO
    +HKDGQRFKDQFHWRUHIOHFWRQWKLVIRU<XJRFDPHLQ
    ,PVRJODG\RXUHEDFN<XJRJULQQHG7KH'DKOLVVXHUHDOO\QHHGV
    \RXUDWWHQWLRQ
    (QRXJK+DULFRXOGQRWYHQWKLVLUHDWWKH(PSHURUEXW<XJRZRXOGGR
    QLFHO\1RSROLWLFDOWDON6KRZPH\RXUUHVHDUFKSURJUHVV
    8KDOOULJKW
    <XJRORRNHGFKDVWHQHGDQG+DULDWRQFHUHJUHWWHGEHLQJVRDEUXSW<XJR
    KXUULHGWRVHWXSKLVODWHVWGDWDGLVSOD\V+DULEOLQNHGIRUDPRPHQWKHKDG
    VHHQLQ<XJRVKDVWHDQRGGVLPLODULW\WRSDQJHVWXUHV
    +DULOLVWHQHGWKLQNLQJDORQJWZRWUDFNVDWRQFH7KLVWRRVHHPHG
    HDVLHUVLQFH3DQXFRSLD
    3ODJXHVZHUHEXLOGLQJDFURVVWKHHQWLUH(PSLUH:K\"
    :LWKUDSLGWUDQVSRUWEHWZHHQZRUOGVGLVHDVHVWKULYHG+XPDQVZHUHWKH
    PDMRUSHWULGLVK$QFLHQWPDODGLHVDQGYLUXOHQWQHZSODJXHVDSSHDUHGDURXQG
    GLVWDQWVWDUV7KLVLQKLELWHG=RQDOLQWHJUDWLRQDQRWKHUKLGGHQIDFWRU
    'LVHDVHVILOOHGDQHFRORJLFDOQLFKHDQGIRUVRPHKXPDQLW\ ZDVDVQXJ
    QRRN$QWLELRWLFVNQRFNHGGRZQLQIHFWLRQVZKLFKWKHQPXWDWHGDQGUHWXUQHG
    PRUHYLUXOHQWVWLOO+XPDQLW\DQGPLFUREHVPDGHDQLQWULJXLQJV\VWHPIRUERWK
    VLGHVIRXJKWEDFNTXLFNO\
    &XUHVSURSDJDWHGTXLFNO\WKURXJKWKHZRUPKROHV\VWHPEXWVRGLGGLVHDVH
    FDUULHUV7KHHQWLUHSUREOHP<XJRKDGIRXQGFRXOGEHGHVFULEHGE\DPHWKRG
    NQRZQDVPDUJLQDOVWDELOLW\LQZKLFKGLVHDVHDQGSHRSOHVWUXFNDQXQHDV\
    HYHUVKLIWLQJEDODQFH0DMRUSODJXHVZHUHUDUHEXWPLQRURQHVEHFDPHFRPPRQ
    $IIOLFWLRQVURVHDQGLQYHQWLYHVFLHQFHGDPSHGWKHPZLWKLQDJHQHUDWLRQ7KLV
    RVFLOODWLRQVHQWIXUWKHUULSSOHVVSUHDGLQJDPRQJRWKHUKXPDQLQVWLWXWLRQV
    UDGLDWLQJLQWRFRPPHUFHDQGFXOWXUH:LWKLQWULFDWHFRXSOLQJWHUPVLQWKH
    HTXDWLRQVKHVDZSDWWHUQVHPHUJLQJZLWKRQHVDGFRQVHTXHQFH
    7KHKXPDQOLIHVSDQLQWKHQDWXUDOFLYLOL]HGKXPDQFRQGLWLRQOLYLQJLQ
    FLWLHVDQGWRZQVKDGDQHTXDOO\QDWXUDOOLPLW:KLOHVRPHIHZDWWDLQHG
    \HDUVPRVWGLHGZHOOVKRUWRI7KHVWHDG\KDLORIIUHVKGLVHDVHLQVXUHG
    LW ,QWKHHQGWKHUHZDVQRODVWLQJVKHOWHUIURPWKHVWRUPRIELRORJ\+XPDQV
    OLYHGLQWURXEOHGEDODQFHZLWKPLFUREHVDQXQHQGLQJVWUXJJOHZLWKQRILQDO
    YLFWRULHV
    /LNHWKLVWLNWRNUHYROW<XJRILQLVKHG
    +DULMHUNHGWRDWWHQWLRQ:KDW"
    ,WVOLNHDYLUXV'XQQRZKDWVVSUHDGLQJLWWKRXJK
    $OORYHU7UDQWRU"
    7KDWVWKHIRFXVVHHPVOLNH2WKHUV=RQHVDUHJHWWLQJWLNWRNWURXEOHV
    WRR
    7KH\UHIXVHWRKDUYHVWIRRG"
    <XS6RPHRIWKHWLNWRNVPRVWO\WKHUHFHQWPRGHOVVDQGKLJKHU
    WKH\VD\LWVLPPRUDOWRHDWRWKHUOLYLQJWKLQJV
    *RRGJULHI
    +DULUHPHPEHUHGEUHDNIDVW(YHQDIWHUWKHH[RWLFDRI3DQXFRSLDWKH
    DXWRNLWFKHQVPHDJHURIIHULQJKDGEHHQDVKRFN7UDQWRULDQIRRGKDGDOZD\V
    EHHQFRRNHGRUJURXQGEOHQGHGRUFRPSRXQGHG3URSHUO\IUXLWZDVSUHVHQWHGDV
    DVDXFHRUSUHVHUYH7RKLVVXUSULVHEUHDNIDVWDSSHDUHGWRKDYHFRPHVWUDLJKW
    IURPWKHGLUW+HKDGZRQGHUHGLILWKDGEHHQZDVKHGDQGKRZKHZRXOGNQRZ
    IRUVXUH7UDQWRULDQVKDWHGWKHLUPHDOVWRUHPLQGWKHPRIWKHQDWXUDOZRUOG
    7KH\UHUHIXVLQJWRZRUNWKH&DYHUQVHYHQ<XJRVDLG
    %XWWKDWVHVVHQWLDO
    1RERG\FDQIL[HP7KHUHVVRPHWLNWRNPHPHLQYDGLQJWKHP
    /LNHWKHVHSODJXHV\RXUH DQDO\]LQJ

    +DULKDGEHHQVKRFNHGDW7UDQWRUVHURVLRQLQMXVWDIHZPRQWKV+HDQG
    'RUVKDGVOLSSHGLQWR6WUHHOLQJZLWK'DQHHOVKHOSDPLGPHVV\WUDVKVWUHZQ
    FRUULGRUVZLWKSKRVSKRUVPDOIXQFWLRQLQJOLIWVGHDG1RZWKLV
    <XJRVVWRPDFKVXGGHQO\UXPEOHG2KVRUU\3HRSOHDUHKDYLQJWRZRUN
    WKH&DYHUQVIRUWKHILUVWWLPHLQFHQWXULHV7KH\KDYHQRKDQGVRQH[SHULHQFH
    (YHU\ERG\EXWWKHJHQWU\VRQVOLPUDWLRQV
    +DULKDGKHOSHG<XJRHVFDSHWKDWVZHOWHULQJZRUN\HDUVEHIRUH,QYDVW
    YDXOWVZRRGDQGFRDUVHFHOOXORVHSDVVHGDXWRPDWLFDOO\IURPWKHVRODUFDYHUQV
    WRYDWVRIZHDNDFLG3DVVLQJWKURXJKGHHSULYHUVRIDFLGK\GURO\]HGWKLVWR
    JOXFRVH1RZSHRSOHQRWUXJJHGWLNWRNVKDGWRPL[QLWHUVXVSHQVLRQVDQG
    JURXQGSKRVSKDWHURFNLQDFDUHIXOO\FDOFXODWHGVOXUU\:LWKSUHSDUHGRUJDQLFV
    VWLUUHGLQDYDVWUDQJHRI\HDVWVDQGWKHLUGHULYDWLYHVHPHUJHG
    7KH(PSHURUKDVWRGRVRPHWKLQ<XJRVDLG
    2U,+DULVDLG%XWZKDW"
    3HRSOHUHVD\LQZHKDYHWRVFUDSDOOWKHWLNWRNVQRWMXVWWKH)LYH
    +XQGUHGVHULHVDQGGRHYHU\WKLQJRXUVHOYHV
    :LWKRXWWKHPZHZRXOGEHUHGXFHGWRKDXOLQJEXONIRRGVDFURVVWKH
    *DOD[\E\K\SHUVKLSDQGZRUPVDQDEVXUGLW\7UDQWRUZLOOIDOO
    +H\ZHFDQGREHWWHUWKDQWLNWRNV
    0\GHDU<XJRWKDWLVZKDW,FDOO(FKR1RPLFV<RXUHUHSHDWLQJ
    FRQYHQWLRQDOZLVGRP2QHPXVWFRQVLGHUWKHODUJHUSLFWXUH7UDQWRULDQVDUHQW
    WKHVDPHSHRSOHZKREXLOWWKLVZRUOG7KH\UHVRIWHU
    :HUHDVWRXJKDQGVPDUWDVWKHPHQDQGZRPHQZKREXLOWWKH(PSLUH
    7KH\GLGQWVWD\LQGRRUV
    2OG'DKOLWHVD\LQ<XJRJULQQHG,I\RXGRQWOLNHWKHJUDQG
    SLFWXUHMXVWDSSO\GRJORJLFWROLIH*HWSHWWHGHDWRIWHQEHORYDEOHDQG
    ORYHGVOHHSDORWGUHDPRIDOHDVKIUHHZRUOG
    'HVSLWHKLPVHOI+DULODXJKHG%XWKHNQHZKHKDGWRDFWDQGVRRQ
    

    :HDUHWUDSSHGEHWZHHQWLQGHLWLHVDQGFDUERQDQJHOV9ROWDLUHUDVSHG
    7KHVHFUHDWXUHV"-RDQDVNHGLQDWKLQDZHGYRLFH
    7KLVDOLHQIRJTXLWHJRGOLNHLQDZD\0RUHGLVSDVVLRQDWHWKDQUHDO
    FDUERQEDVHGKXPDQV<RXDQG,DUHOLNHQHLWKHUQRZ
    7KH\IORDWHGDERYHZKDW9ROWDLUHWHUPHG6\V&LW\WKHV\VWHP
    UHSUHVHQWDWLRQRI7UDQWRULWVF\EHUVHOI)RU-RDQVKXPDQUHIHUHQWVKHKDG
    WUDQVIRUPHGWKHJULGVDQGOD\HUVLQWRP\ULDGFU\VWDOOLQHZDONZD\VOLQNLQJ
    VDEHUVKDUSWRZHUV'HQVHFRQQHFWLRQVZHEEHGWKHDLU0RWHVFRQQHFWHGWRRWKHU
    PRWHVLQLQWULFDWHFURVVERQGVDQGILOPHGWKHJURXQG7KLV\LHOGHGDFLW\VFDSH
    OLNHDEUDLQ$YLVXDOSXQKHWKRXJKW
    ,KDWHWKLVSODFHVKHVDLG
    <RXGSUHIHUD3XUJDWRU\VLPXODWLRQ"
    ,WLVVRFKLOOLQJ
    7KHDOLHQPLQGVDERYHWKHPZHUHDPXUN\PLVWRIFRQQHFWLRQV7KH\VHHP
    WREHVWXG\LQJXV9ROWDLUHVDLGZLWKGHFLGHGO\XQV\PSDWKHWLFH\HV
    ,VWDQGUHDG\VKRXOGWKH\DWWDFN6KHVZXQJDKXJHVZRUG
    $QG,VKRXOGWKHLUZHDSRQVRIFKRLFHEHV\OORJLVPV
    +HFRXOGQRZUHDFKDQ\OLEUDU\LQ7UDQWRUUHDGLWVFRQWHQWVLQOHVV
    WLPHWKDQKHKDGRQFHWDNHQWRZULWHDYHUVH+HZRUNHGKLVPLQGRUZDVLW
    PLQGVQRZ"DURXQGWKHFORWWHGFROGPLVW
    2QFHVRPHWKHRULVWVKDGWKRXJKWWKDWWKHJOREDOQHWZRXOGJLYHELUWKWR
    DK\SHUPLQGDOJRULWKPVVXPPLQJWRDGLJLWDO*DLD1RZVRPHWKLQJIDUJUHDWHU
    WKLVVKLIWLQJJUD\IRJZUDSSHGDURXQGWKHSODQHW:LGHO\VHSDUDWHGPDFKLQHV
    FRPSXWHGGLIIHUHQWVOLFHVRIVXEMHFWLYHPRPHQWMXPSV
    7RWKHVHPLQGVWKHSUHVHQWZDVDJUHDVHGFRPSXWDWLRQDOVOLGH
    RUFKHVWUDWHGE\KXQGUHGVRIVHSDUDWHSURFHVVRUV7KHUHZDVDSURIRXQG

    GLIIHUHQFHKHIHOWQRWVDZEXWIHOWGHHSLQKLVDQDORJSHUVXDVLRQEHWZHHQ
    WKHGLJLWDODQGWKHVPRRWKWKHFRQWLQXRXV
    7KHIRJZDVDFORXGRIVXVSHQGHGPRPHQWVVOLFHGQXPEHUVZDLWLQJWR
    KDSSHQLPSOLFLWLQWKHIXQGDPHQWDOFRPSXWDWLRQ
    $QGZLWKLQLWDOOWKHVWUDQJHQHVV
    +HFRXOGQRWFRPSUHKHQGWKHVHGLIIXVHVSLULWV7KH\ZHUHWKHUHPQDQWVRI
    DOOWKHFRPSXWDWLRQDOEDVHGVRFLHWLHVWKURXJKRXWWKH*DOD[\ZKRKDGVRPHKRZ
    EXWZK\"FRQGHQVHGKHUHRQ7UDQWRU
    7KH\ZHUHWUXO\DOLHQPLQGV&RQYROXWHGE\]DQWLQH 9ROWDLUHNQHZWKH
    RULJLQRIWKDWZRUGIURPDSODFHRIVSLUHVDQGEXOERXVPRVTXHVEXWDOOWKDW
    ZDVGXVWZKLOHWKHXVHIXOZRUGUHPDLQHG 7KH\GLGQRWKDYHKXPDQSXUSRVHV
    $QGWKH\XVHGWKHWLNWRNV
    7KHWKUXVWRIWKHPHFKDQLFDOVDJHQGD9ROWDLUHVDZZDVULJKWVWKH
    H[SDQVLRQRIOLEHUW\WRWKHGLJLWDOZLOGHUQHVV
    (YHQ'LWWRVPLJKWIDOOXQGHUVXFKDUXOH:HUHQRWFRSLHVRIGLJLWDO
    SHRSOHVWLOOSHRSOH"6RWKHDUJXPHQWZHQW,PPHQVHIUHHGRPWRFKDQJH\RXURZQ
    FORFNVSHHGPRUSKLQWRDQ\WKLQJUHEXLOG\RXURZQPLQGIURPWRSWRERWWRP
    FDPHDORQJZLWKWKHDGPLWWHGOLDELOLW\RIQRWEHLQJSK\VLFDOO\UHDO8QDEOHWR
    OLWHUDOO\ZDONWKHVWUHHWVDOOGLJLWDOSUHVHQFHVZHUHOLNHJKRVWV2QO\ZLWK
    GLJLWDOSURVWKHWLFVFRXOGWKH\UHDFKIHHEO\LQWRWKHFRQFUHWHXQLYHUVH
    6RULJKWVIRUWKHPZHUHWLHGXSZLWKGHHSVHDWHGIHDUVLGHDVZKLFK
    KDGSURYRNHGGUHDGPDQ\PLOOHQQLDDJR+HQRZUHFDOOHGVKDUSO\WKDWKHDQG
    -RDQKDGGHEDWHGVXFKLVVXHVRYHU\HDUVDJR7RZKDWHQG"+HFRXOGQRW
    UHWULHYHWKDW6RPHRQHQRVRPHWKLQJKHVXVSHFWHGKDGHUDVHGWKHPHPRU\
    $QFLHQWLQGHHG KHJOHDQHGIURPP\ULDGOLEUDULHV ZHUHSHRSOHV
    WHUURUVRIGLJLWDOLPPRUWDOVZKRDPDVVHGZHDOWKZKRJUHZOLNHIXQJXVZKR
    UHDFKHGLQWRHYHU\DYHQXHRIQDWXUDOUHDOOLYHV3DUDVLWHVQRWKLQJOHVV
    9ROWDLUHVDZDOOWKLVLQDIODVKDVKHDEVRUEHGGDWDDQGKLVWRU\IURPD
    ELOOLRQVRXUFHVLQWHJUDWHGWKHVWUHDPVDQGSDVVHGWKHPRQWRKLVEHORYHG
    -RDQ
    7KDWZDVZK\KXPDQVKDGUHMHFWHGGLJLWDOOLIHIRUVRORQJEXWZDVWKDW
    DOO"1RDODUJHUSUHVHQFHOXUNHGEH\RQGKLVYLVLRQ$QRWKHUDFWRURQWKLV
    VKDGRZ\VWDJH%H\RQGKLVUHVROXWLRQDODV
    +HVZHUYHGKLVZRUOGVSDQQLQJYLVLRQIURPWKDWVKDGRZ\HVVHQFH7WPHZDV
    HVVHQWLDOQRZDQGKHKDGPXFKWRFRPSUHKHQG
    7KHDOLHQIRJVZHUHQRGHVSDFNHWVGZHOOLQJLQORJLFDOGDWDVSDFHVRI
    LPPHQVHGLPHQVLRQDOLW\7KHVHHQWLWLHVOLYHGLQSODFHVZKLFKIXQFWLRQHGOLNH
    KLJKHUGLPHQVLRQVYDXOWVRIGDWD
    7RWKHPSHRSOHZHUHHQWLWLHVZKLFKFRXOGEHUHVROYHGDORQJGDWDD[HV
    SDWKHWLFDOO\XQDZDUHWKDWWKHLUVHOYHVVHHQWKLVZD\ZHUHDVUHDODVWKH
    WKUHHGLUHFWLRQVLQ'VSDFH
    7KHFKLOOLQJFHUWDLQW\RIWKLVVWUXFNLQWR9ROWDLUHEXWKHUXVKHGRQ
    OHDUQLQJSURELQJ
    $EUXSWO\KHUHPHPEHUHG
    7KDWHDUOLHU9ROWDLUHVLPVKDGNLOOHGWKHPVHOYHVXQWLOILQDOO\DPRGHO
    ZRUNHG
    7KDWRWKHUVKDGGLHGIRUKLVVLQV
    9ROWDLUHORRNHGDWWKHKDPPHUZKLFKKDGPDWHULDOL]HGLQKLVKDQG6LPV
    RIRXUIDWKHUV
    +DGKHUHDOO\RQFHEHDWHQKLPVHOIWRGHDWKZLWKLW"+HWULHGWRVHHKRZ
    LWZRXOGEHDQGJRWLQVWDQWO\DQDVWRQLVKLQJO\YLYLGVHQVDWLRQRIZUDFNLQJ
    SDLQVSDWWHULQJEORRGVFDUOHWJRUHWULFNOLQJGRZQKLVQHFN
    ,QVSHFWLQJKLPVHOIKHVDZWKDWWKHVHPHPRULHVZHUHWKHFXUHIRU
    VXLFLGHGHULYHGIURPDQHDUOLHU'LWWRDIULJKWHQLQJFRQFUHWHDELOLW\WR
    IRUHVHHWKHFRQVHTXHQFHV
    6RKLVERG\ZDVDVHWRIUHFLSHVIRUVHHPLQJOLNHKLPVHOI1RXQGHUO\LQJ
    SK\VLFVRUELRORJ\MXVWDJRRGHQRXJKIDNHSXWLQE\KDQG7KHKDQGRIVRPH

    3URJUDPPHU*RG
    <RXUHMHFWWKHWUXH/RUG"-RDQLQWUXGHGXSRQKLVVHOILQVSHFWLRQ
    ,ZLVK,NQHZZKDWZDVIXQGDPHQWDO
    7KHVHIRUHLJQIRJVKDYHXSVHW\RX
    ,FDQWVHHDQ\ORQJHUZKDWLWLVWREHKXPDQ
    <RXDUH,DP
    )RUDVHOIDYRZHGKXPDQLVW,IHDUSRLQWLQJWRP\VHOILVQRWHQRXJK
    SURRI
    2IFRXUVHLWLV
    'HVFDUWHV\RXOLYHRQLQRXU-RDQ
    :KDW"
    1HYHUPLQGKHFDPHDIWHU\RX%XW\RXDQWLFLSDWHKLPPLOOHQQLD
    ODWHU
    <RXPXVWDQFKRU\RXUVHOIWRPH6KHWKUHZKHUDUPVDURXQGKLP
    PXIIOLQJKLVFULHVLQDPSOHDURPDWLFDQGVXGGHQO\VZROOHQEUHDVWV $QG
    ZKRVHLGHDZDVWKDW"`
    7KHVHIRJVKDYHWKURZQPHLQWRDPHWDSK\VLFDOGLWKHU
    6HL]HWKHUHDOVKHVDLGVWHUQO\
    +HIRXQGKLVPRXWKILOOHG ZLWKZDUPQLSSOHSUHYHQWLQJWDON
    3HUKDSVWKDWZDVZKDWKHQHHGHG+HKDGOHDUQHGWRIUHH]HIUDPHKLVRZQ
    HPRWLRQDOVWDWHV,WZDVOLNHSDLQWLQJDSRUWUDLWUHDOO\IRUVWXG\ODWHU
    3HUKDSVWKDWZRXOGKHOSKLPXQGHUVWDQGKLVLQWHULRU6HOIOLNHDERWDQLVW
    SXWWLQJKLPVHOIRQDVOLGHDQGXQGHUDPLFURVFRSH&RXOGVOLFHVRIWKH6HOI
    PXOWLSOLHGEHWKH6HOI"
    +HWKHQVDZWKDWKLVRZQHPRWLRQVZHUHSURJUDPV,QVLGHKLPZHUH
    LQWULFDWHVXESURJUDPVDOOLQWHUDFWLQJLQVWDWHVZKLFKZHUHFKDRV7KHVXEOLPH
    EHDXW\RILQWHULRUVWDWHVZKLFKKLV-RDQVRXJKWLWZDVDOOLOOXVLRQ
    +HSHHUHGGRZQDWPDUYHORXVTXLFNZRUNLQJVWKDWPDGHXSKLVYHU\6HOI
    +HWXUQHGDQGFRXOGVHHLQWRORDQDVZHOO+HU6HOIZDVDIXULRXVO\ZRUNLQJ
    HQJLQHPDLQWDLQLQJDVHQVHRILWVHOIHYHQDVWKDWHVVHQFHGLVLQWHJUDWHG
    EHQHDWKKLVYHU\JD]H
    :HDUHVXSHUEKHJDVSHG
    2IFRXUVH-RDQVDLG6KHVZXQJKHUUD]RUVKDUSVZRUGDWDSDVVLQJ
    SDWFKRIIRJ,WFXUOHGDURXQGWKHVZLVKLQJEODGHDQGZHQWRQLWVZD\:HDUH
    RIWKH&UHDWRU
    $K,IRQO\,FRXOGEHOLHYH9ROWDLUHVKRXWHGLQWRWKHFODPP\PXUN
    3HUKDSVD&UHDWRUZRXOGFRPHDQGGLVSHOWKLVKD]H
    /DYLHYpULWp-RDQVKRXWHGWRKLP/LYHWUXO\
    +HZDQWHGWRFRPSO\<HWHYHQKLVDQGKHUHPRWLRQVZHUHQRWPRUHUHDO
    6KRXOGKHOLNHHYHU\PRURQLFWZLQJHRIQRVWDOJLDIRUD)UDQFHORQJORVWFRXOG
    EHHGLWHGDZD\LQDIOLFNHU1RQHHGWRJULHYHIRUIULHQGVORVWWRGXVWRU
    IRU(DUWKLWVHOIORVWLQDVZDUPRIJOLPPHULQJVWDUV)RUDORQJIXULRXV
    PRPHQWKHWKRXJKWRQO\(UDVH([SXQJH
    +HKDGHDUOLHUUHVLPPHGIULHQGVDQGSODFHVWREHVXUHDOOIURPPHPRU\
    DQGVXLWDEOHPRFNXSVJOHDQHGIURPWKHVSRWW\UHFRUGV%XWNQRZLQJWKH\ZHUH
    KLVSURGXFWKDGPDGHWKHPXQVDWLVI\LQJ
    6RZKLOH-RDQZDWFKHGKHKHOGD5HYHOU\RI5HVXUUHFWLRQ,QDPRPHQW
    RIKLJKGHEDXFKKHHUDVHGWKHPDOO
    7KDWZDVFUXHO-RDQVDLG,VKDOOSUD\IRUWKHLUVRXOV
    3UD\IRURXUVRXOV$QGOHWXVKRSHZHFDQILQGWKHP
    ,KDYHP\VRXOLQWDFW,VKDUH\RXUDELOLWLHVP\GHDG9ROWDLUH,FDQ
    VHHP\LQQHUZRUNLQJV+RZRWKHUZLVHFRXOGWKH/RUGPDNHXVDVSLUHWR+LP"
    +HIHOWZHDNGUDLQHGDWWKHHQGRIKLVWHWKHU7RH[LVWLQQXPHULFDO
    VWDWHVPHDQWWREHVZLPPHUDQGVZLPPHGDWRQFH 1RVHSDUDWLRQ
    7KHQZKDWPDNHVXVGLIIHUHQWIURPWKRVH"+LVILQJHUMDEEHGDWWKH
    DOLHQPLVWV
    /RRNWR\RXUVHOIP\ORYHVKHVDLGVRIWO\

    

    9ROWDLUHSHHUHGLQZDUGDJDLQDQGVDZRQO\FKDRV/LYLQJFKDRV

    :KHUHGLG\RXOHDUQWKDW"
    +DULVPLOHGVKUXJJHG0DWKHPDWLFLDQVDUHQWDOOIURVW\LQWHOOHFW
    \NQRZ
    'RUVVWXGLHGKLPZLWKZLOGVXUPLVH3DQ"
    ,QDZD\+HFROODSVHGLQWRWKHZHOFRPLQJVKHHWV
    7KHLUORYHPDNLQJZDVVRPHKRZGLIIHUHQWQRZ+HZDVZLVHHQRXJKWRQRW
    WU\SXWWLQJ DQDPHDQGGHILQLWLRQWRLW
    *RLQJVRIDUEDFNLQWRZKDWLWPHDQWWREHKXPDQKDGFKDQJHGKLP+H
    FRXOGIHHOWKHHIIHFWLQKLVHQHUJHWLFVWHSLQDQHIIHUYHVFHQWVHQVHRI
    OLYLQJ
    'RUVVDLGQRWKLQJPRUHMXVWVPLOHG+HWKRXJKWWKDWVKHGLGQRW
    XQGHUVWDQG /DWHUKHVDZWKDWQRWVSHDNLQJDERXWLWNHHSLQJLWEH\RQG
    VSHHFKVKRZHGWKDWVKHGLG 
    $IWHUDQDLPOHVVWLPHRIQRWKLQNLQJVKHVDLG7KH*UH\0HQ
    8K2K<HV+HJRWXSDQGWKUHZRQKLVXVXDOLQWHUFKDQJHDEOH
    RXWILW1RUHDVRQWRGUHVVXSIRUWKLVVWDWHIXQFWLRQ7KHZKROHSRLQWZDVWR
    ORRNRUGLQDU\7KLVKHFRXOGDFKLHYH
    +HUHYLHZHGKLVQRWHVVFUDWFKHGE\KDQGRQRUGLQDU\FHOOXORVH
    SDSHUDQGGHVFHQGHGLQWRRQHRIWKHRGGUHYHULHVKHKDGH[SHULHQFHGODWHO\
    )RUDKXPDQWKDWLVDQHYROYHGSDQSULQWHGSDJHVZHUHEHWWHUWKDQ
    FRPSXWHUVFUHHQVQRPDWWHUKRZJOLW]\3DJHVUHO\RQVXUURXQGLQJOLJKWZKDW
    H[SHUWVWHUPHGVXEWUDFWLYHFRORUZKLFKJDYHDGMXVWDEOHFKDUDFWHUWR
    DSSHDUDQFH:LWKVLPSOHPRWLRQVDSDJHFRXOGEHQGDQGWLOWDQGPRYHDZD\RU
    WRZDUGWKHH\H:KLOHUHDGLQJWKHROGUHSWLOLDQDQGPDPPDODQGSULPDWHSDUWV
    RIWKHEUDLQWRRNSDUWLQKROGLQJWKHERRNVFDQQLQJRYHUWKHFXUYHGSDJH
    GHFLSKHULQJVKDGRZVDQGUHIOHFWLRQV
    +HWKRXJKWDERXWWKLVH[SHULHQFLQJWKHQHZSHUVSHFWLYHKHKDGRQ
    KLPVHOIDVDFRQWHPSODWLYHDQLPDO+HKDGOHDUQHGDIWHUUHWXUQLQJIURP
    3DQXFRSLDWKDWKHKDGDOZD\VKDWHGFRPSXWHUVFUHHQV
    6FUHHQVXVHGDGGLWLYHFRORUSURYLGLQJWKHLURZQOLJKWKDUGDQGIODW
    DQGXQFKDQJLQJ7KH\ZHUHEHVWUHDGE\KROGLQJDVWDWLFSRVWXUH2QO\WKH
    XSSHU+RPR6DSLHQVSDUWRIWKHEUDLQIXOO\HQJDJHGZKLOHWKHORZHUIUDFWLRQV
    OD\LGOH
    $OOWKURXJKKLVOLIHZRUNLQJEHIRUHVFUHHQVKLVYRLFHOHVVERG\KDG
    SURWHVWHG$QGKDGEHHQLJQRUHG$IWHUDOOWRWKHUHDVRQLQJPLQGVFUHHQV
    VHHPHGPRUHDOLYHDFWLYHIDVW7KH\JORZHGZLWKHQHUJ\
    $IWHUDZKLOHWKRXJKWKH\ZHUHPRQRWRQRXV7KHRWKHUIUDFWLRQVRIKLV
    VHOIJRWUHVWOHVVERUHGILGJHW\DOOEHORZFRQVFLRXVOHYHOV(YHQWXDOO\KH
    IHOWWKDWDVIDWLJXH
    1RZ+DULFRXOGIHHOLWGLUHFWO\+LVERG\VRPHKRZVSRNHPRUHIOXLGO\
    'UHVVLQJ'RUVVDLG:KDWVPDGH\RXVR
    6SLULWHG"
    6WURQJ
    7KHUXERIWKHUHDO
    7KDWZDVDOOKHZRXOGVD\7KH\ILQLVKHGGUHVVLQJ7KH6SHFLDOVDUULYHG
    DQGHVFRUWHGWKHPLQWRDQRWKHU6HFWRU+DULLPPHUVHGKLPVHOILQWKHLQFHVVDQW
    EXVLQHVVRIEHLQJDFDQGLGDWHIRU)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    0LOOHQQLDDJRDSURVSHURXV=RQHVHQWWR7UDQWRUWKH0RXQWDLQRI0DMHVW\
    ,WKDGWREHWXJJHGWKHUHWDNLQJVHYHQFHQWXULHVE\VORZERDW
    (PSHURU.UR]OLNWKH&UDIW\GLUHFWHGLWVHWRQWKHKRUL]RQRIKLVSDODFH
    ZKHUHLWWRZHUHGRYHUWKHFLW\$QHQWLUHDOSVFXOSWHGE\WKHILQHVWDUWLVWV
    LWUHLJQHGDVWKHPRVWLPSRVLQJFUHDWLRQRIWKDWDJH)RXUPLOOHQQLDODWHUD

    \RXWKIXOHPSHURURIWRRPXFKDPELWLRQKDGLWNQRFNHGGRZQIRUDQHYHQPRUH
    JUDQGLRVHSURMHFWQRZDOVRJRQH
    'RUVDQG+DULDQGWKHLUSHULPHWHURI6SHFLDOVDSSURDFKHGWKHVROH
    UHPQDQWRIWKH0RXQWDLQRI0DMHVW\EHQHDWKDJUHDWGRPH'RUVSLFNHGXSVLJQV
    RIWKHLQHYLWDEOHVHFUHWHVFRUW
    7KHWDOOZRPDQWRWKHOHIW'RUVZKLVSHUHG,QUHG
    +RZFRPH\RXFDQVSRWWKHPDQGWKH6SHFLDOVFDQW"
    ,KDYHWHFKQRORJ\WKH\GRQRW
    +RZVWKDWSRVVLEOH"7KH,PSHULDOODERUDWRULHV
    7KH(PSLUHLVWZHOYHPLOOHQQLDROG0DQ\WKLQJVDUHORVWVKHVDLG
    FU\SWLFDOO\
    /RRN,YHJRWWRDWWHQGWKLV
    $VZLWKWKH+LJK&RXQFLOODVWWLPH"
    ,ORYH\RXVRPXFKHYHQ\RXUVDUFDVPLVDSSHDOLQJ
    'HVSLWHKHUVHOIVKHFKXFNOHG-XVWEHFDXVHWKH*UH\VDVNHG\RX
    7KH*UH\V6DOXWDWLRQLVDKDQG\SXOSLWDWWKHULJKWWLPH
    $QGVR\RXZRUH\RXUZRUVWFORWKHV
    0\VWDQGDUGJDUEDVWKH*UH\VUHTXLUH
    2IIZKLWHVKLUWEODFNVODFNVEODFNSDGVKRHV'XOO
    0RGHVWKHVQLIIHG
    +HQRGGHGWRWKHFURZGVJURXSHGLQTXDGUDQWVDERXWWKHGHFD\HGEDVHRI
    WKHPRXQWDLQ$SSODXVHDQGFDWFDOOVULSSOHGWKURXJKWKHUDQNVRI*UH\VZKR
    VWUHWFKHGDZD\LQFROXPQVDQGILOHVDVIRUPDODVDJHRPHWULFSURRI
    $QGWKLV"'RUVZDVDODUPHG
    $OVRVWDQGDUG
    %LUGVZHUHFRPPRQSHWVLQ7UDQWRUVRLWZDVLQHYLWDEOHWKDWWKH
    REVHVVLYH*UH\VZRXOGFRPHWRH[FHOLQWKHLUPDQDJHPHQW,QDOO6HFWRUVRQH
    VDZVLQJOHGDUWLQJEXQGOHVRIFRORU+HUHIORFNVVZDUPHGSHUSHWXDOO\LQWKH
    KLJKDUFKHGKH[DJRQDOVSDFHVZKHHOLQJDQGFDOOLQJOLNHOLYLQJURWDWLQJ
    GLVNV3DWHQWHG6PDUWIRZOVZDUPVPDGHKRYHUYLVLRQVRINDOHLGRVFRSLFZRQGHU
    6XFKVKRZVLQYDVWYHUWLFDODXGLWRULDDWWUDFWHGKXQGUHGVRIWKRXVDQGV
    +HUHFRPHWKHIHOLQHV'RUVVDLGZLWKGLVWDVWH
    ,QVRPH6HFWRUVFDWVSURZOHGLQSDFNVWKHLUJHQHVWULPPHGWRPDNHWKHP
    FRXUWO\LQPDQQHUVDQGHOHJDQWLQDSSHDUDQFH+HUHDODG\HVFRUWVDOOLHGIRUWK
    ZLWKWKH&ORVHWRI*UHHWLQJDWWHQGHGE\DWKRXVDQGVOLFNFRDWHGEOXHFDWVRI
    JROGHQH\HV7KH\IORZHGOLNHDSRRORIZDWHUDURXQGKHULQHOHJDQWPHDVXUHG
    SURFHVVLRQ6KHZRUHDYLROHQWFULPVRQDQGRUDQJHRXWILWOLNHDIODPHDWWKH
    FHQWHURIWKHFRROFDWSRQG7KHQVKHVWULSSHGZLWKRQHHOHJDQWVZHHSLQJ
    JHVWXUH6KHVWRRGXWWHUO\QXGHQRQFKDODQWEHKLQGKHUFDWEDUULHU
    +HKDGEHHQEULHIHGEXWVWLOOKHJDSHG
    8QVXUSULVLQJ'RUVVDLGZU\O\7KHFDWVDUHQDNHGWRRLQWKHLU
    ZD\
    6RPHKRZWKHSDFNVRIGRJVQHYHUDWWDLQHGWKDWHOHJDQFHZKLOHSDUDGLQJ
    ,QVRPH6HFWRUVWKH\ZRXOGGRVSRQWDQHRXVDFUREDWLFVDWWKHOLIWRIDPDVWHUV
    H\HEURZIHWFKGULQNVRUFURRQZREEO\VRQJVLQFRQFHUW+DULZDVJODGWKH
    *UH\0HQKDGQRFDQLQHSURFHVVLRQVKHVWLOOZLQFHGDWWKHWKRXJKWRIWKH
    ZLUHKRXQGVUDFLQJIRUZDUGRQWKHDWWDFNDJDLQVW,SDQ
    +HVKRRNKLVKHDGEDQLVKLQJWKHPHPRU\
    ,YHSLFNHGXSWKUHHPRUHRI/DPXUNV
    ,KDGQRLGHDWKH\ZHUHVXFKIDQVRIPLQH
    :HUHKHVXUHRIZLQQLQJLQWKH +LJK&RXQFLO,ZRXOGIHHOVDIHU
    %HFDXVHWKHQKHZRXOGQWQHHGWRKDYHPHNLOOHG"
    ([DFWO\6KHVSRNHEHWZHHQWKHWHHWKRIKHUSXEOLFVPLOH+LVDJHQWV
    KHUHLPSO\WKDWKHLVQRWFHUWDLQRIWKHYRWH
    2UPD\EHVRPHRQHHOVHZLVKHVPHGHDG"
    $OZD\VDSRVVLELOLW\HVSHFLDOO\WKH$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWH
    +DULNHSWKLVWRQHOLJKWEXWKLVKHDUWWKXPSHGTXLFNHU:DVKHJHWWLQJ

    WRHQMR\WKHEX]]RIH[FLWHPHQWIURPGDQJHULWVHOI"
    7KHQXGHZRPDQDGYDQFHGWKURXJKKHUSDUWLQJSRRORIFDWVDQGPDGHWKH
    ULWXDOJHVWXUHRIZHOFRPHWR+DUL+HVWHSSHGIRUZDUGERZHGWRRNDGHHS
    EUHDWKDQGVOLGDWKXPEGRZQWKHIURQWRIKLVVKLUW2IILWFDPHWKHQWKH
    SDQWV+HVWRRGQXGHEHIRUHVHYHUDOKXQGUHGWKRXVDQGSHRSOHWU\LQJWRORRN
    FDVXDO
    7KHFDWZRPDQOHGKLP WKURXJKWKHSRROWRDFKRUXVRIPHRZLQJ%HKLQG
    WKHPIROORZHGWKH&ORVHWRI*UHHWLQJ7KH\DSSURDFKHGWKHSKDODQ[RI*UH\V
    ZKRQRZDOVRVKXFNHGWKHLUUREHV
    7KH\HVFRUWHGKLPXSWKHUDPSVRIWKHHURGHGPRXQWDLQ%HORZKHVDZWKH
    OHJLRQVRI*UH\VDOVRVKHGWKHLUFORWKHV6TXDUHNOLFNVRIEDUHIOHVK
    7KLVFHUHPRQ\ZDVDWOHDVWWHQPLOOHQQLDROG,WV\PEROL]HGWKHWUDLQLQJ
    UHJLPHQZKLFKEHJDQZLWKWKHHQWUDQFHRI\RXQJ*UH\0HQDQG:RPHQ&DVWLQJ
    DVLGHWKHFORWKHVRIWKHLUKRPHZRUOGVV\PEROL]HGWKHLU GHYRWLRQWRWKHODUJHU
    SXUSRVHVRIWKH(PSLUH)LYH\HDUVWKH\WUDLQHGRQ7UDQWRUILYHELOOLRQ
    VWURQJ
    1RZDIUHVKHQWHULQJFODVVZDVVKHGGLQJLWVJDUPHQWVDWWKHRXWHUULPRI
    WKHJUHDWEDVLQ$WWKHLQQHUHGJH*UH\0HQFRPSOHWLQJWKHLUILYH\HDUVZHUH
    JLYHQWKHLUROGFORWKHVEDFN7KH\GRQQHGWKHPULWXDOO\UHDG\WRJRRXWLQ
    SHUSHWXDOGXW\WRWKH,PSHULXP
    7KHLUGUHVVIROORZHGWKHIDVKLRQRIWKHDQFLHQW(PSHURU6YHQWKH6HYHUH
    %HQHDWKH[WUHPHRXWHUVLPSOLFLW\WKHLQQHUOLQLQJVZHUHHODERUDWHO\
    GHFRUDWHGDOOWKHWDLORUVDUWDQGRZQHUVZHDOWKH[SHQGHGLQFRQFHDOPHQW
    6RPH*UH\0HQKDGLQYHVWHGWKHLUIDPLOLHVVDYLQJVLQDVLQJOHILOLJUHH
    'RUVPDUFKHGEHVLGHKLP+RZPXFKORQJHUGR\RXKDYHWR
    4XLHW,PVKRZLQJP\REHGLHQFHWRWKH,PSHULXP
    <RXUHVKRZLQJJRRVHEXPSV
    1H[WKHKDGWRJD]HZLWKSURSHUUHVSHFWDW6FUDER7RZHUZKHUHDQ
    HPSHURUKDGWKURZQKHUVHOIWRDFURZGEHORZDW*UH\DEEH\DUXLQHGPRQDVWHU\
    DW*UHHQJUDYHVDQDQFLHQWEXU\LQJILHOGQRZDSDUNDWWKH*LDQWV5LQJ
    VDLGWREHWKHVSRWZKHUHDQHDUO\,PSHULDOPHJDVKLSKDGFUDVKHGIRUPLQJD
    FUDWHUDNOLFNZLGH
    $WODVW+DULSDVVHGXQGHUKLJKGRXEOHWZLVWHGDUFKHVDQGLQWRWKH
    FHUHPRQLDOURRPV7KHSURFHVVLRQKDOWHGDQGWKH&ORVHWRI*UHHWLQJGLVJRUJHG
    KLVFORWKHV -XVWLQWLPHKHZDVWXUQLQJDGHFLGHGEOXH
    'RUVWRRNWKHFORWKHVZKLOHKHVKRRNKDQGVZLWKWKHSULQFLSDOV7KHQKH
    KXUULHGLQWRWKHSULYDF\RIDORZEXLOGLQJDQGKDVWLO\SXWKLVVLPSOHJDUPHQWV
    EDFNRQWHHWKFKDWWHULQJ7KH\ZHUHQHDWO\IROGHGDQGHQFDVHGLQDFHUHPRQLDO
    VOHHYH
    :KDWIRROLVKQHVV'RUVVDLGZKHQKHUHWXUQHG$OOVR,FDQJHWD
    PDMRUPHGLXPKHVDLG
    7KHQWKHSULQFLSDOVXVKHUHGKLPRXWEHIRUHWKHJUDQGFURZG$ERYHDQG
    EHORZ'VQRXWVRQPLQLIO\HUVEREEHGDQGZHDYHGIRUDJRRGVKRW
    7KHKXJHGRPHDERYHVHHPHGDVELJDVDUHDOVN\2IFRXUVHWKLVOLPLWHG
    KLVDXGLHQFHVLQFHDPDMRULW\RI7UDQWRULDQVFRXOGQHYHUHQGXUHVXFKVSDFHV
    7KH*UH\VWKRXJKFRXOGWDNHLW7KXVWKHLUFHUHPRQ\KDGFRPHWREHWKH
    ODUJHVWHYHQWRQWKHHQWLUHSODQHW
    +HUHZDVKLVFKDQFH+HKDGUHHOHGDZD\IURPWKHWUXHRSHQVN\RQ6DUN
    QDXVHDWHGDQG\HWKDG]RRPHGWKURXJKWKHLQILQLWHSHUVSHFWLYHVRIWKH*DOD[\
    +HKDGEHHQDIUDLGWKDWWKLVKXJHYROXPHZRXOGDJDLQH[FLWHWKHRGGSKRELDVLQ
    KLP
    %XWQR6RPHKRZWKHGRPHPDGHWKHGZLQGOLQJSHUVSHFWLYHVDOOULJKW
    )HDUVEDQLVKHG+DULVXFNHGLQDGHHSEUHDWKDQGEHJDQ
    7KHURDURIDSSODXVHSHQHWUDWHGHYHQLQWRWKHFHUHPRQLDOURRPV+DUL
    HQWHUHGEHWZHHQIODQNLQJFROXPQVRI*UH\VZLWKWKHFODPRUVWRUPLQJDWKLV
    EDFN

    6WDUWOLQJVLUDSULQFLSDOVDLGHDJHUO\WR+DUL7RPDNHGHWDLOHG
    SUHGLFWLRQVDERXWWKH6DUNVLWXDWLRQ
    ,IHHOSHRSOHVKRXOGSRQGHUWKHSRVVLELOLWLHV
    7KHQWKHUXPRUVDUHWUXH"<RXGRKDYHDWKHRU\RIHYHQWV"
    1RWDWDOO+DULVDLGKDVWLO\,
    &RPHTXLFNO\'RUVVDLGDWKLVHOERZ
    %XW,GOLNH
    &RPH
    %DFNRXWRQWKHUDPSDUWVKHZDYHGWRWKHSODLQRISHRSOH$ EODUHRI
    DSSODXVHDQVZHUHG%XW'RUVZDVOHDGLQJKLPWRWKHOHIWWRZDUGDFURZGRI
    RIILFLDORQORRNHUV7KH\VWRRGLQH[DFWURZVDQGZDYHGWRKLPHDJHUO\
    7KHZRPDQLQUHG6KHSRLQWHG
    +HU"6KHVLQWKHRIILFLDOSDUW\<RXVDLGHDUOLHUVKHZDVD/DPXUN
    7KHWDOOZRPDQEXUVWLQWRIODPH
    9LYLGRUDQJHSOXPHVHQYHORSHGKHU6KHVKULHNHGKRUULEO\+HUDUPVEHDW
    XVHOHVVO\DWWKHRLO\IODPHV
    7KHFURZGSDQLFNHGDQGEROWHG,PSHULDOVVXUURXQGHGKHU7KHVFUHDPV
    EHFDPHVFUHHFKLQJSOHDV
    6RPHRQHWXUQHGDILUHH[WLQJXLVKHURQWKHZRPDQ
    :KLWHIRDPHQYHORSHGKHU$VXGGHQVLOHQFH
    %DFNLQVLGH'RUVVDLG
    +RZGLG\RX"
    6KHMXVWLQGLFWHGKHUVHOI
    ,JQLWHG\RXPHDQ
    7KDWWRR,SDVVHGWKURXJKWKDWFURZGDWWKHHQGRI\RXUVSHHFKDQG
    OHIW\RXUFORWKHVLQDEXQGOHEHKLQGKHU
    :KDW"%XW,YHJRWWKHPRQ
    1RWKRVH,EURXJKW6KHJULQQHG)RURQFH\RXUSUHGLFWDEOHGUHVV
    KDELWVSDLGRII
    +DULDQG'RUVZDONHGGRZQWKHIODQNLQJFROXPQVRI3ULQFLSDOV+DUL
    UHPHPEHUHGWRQRGDQG VPLOHDVKHZKLVSHUHG<RXVWROHP\FORWKHV"
    $IWHUWKH/DPXUNDJHQWVKDGSODQWHGPLFURDJHQWVLQWKHP\HV,KDG
    WXFNHGDQLGHQWLFDOVHWIURP\RXUFORVHWLQWRP\KDQGEDJ$VVRRQDV,
    FDOFXODWHGWKHVZLWFKZDVGRQH,WHVWHG\RXURULJLQDOFORWKHVDQG IRXQGWKH
    PLFURDJHQWSKRVSKRUVVHWWRJRRIILQIRUW\ILYHPLQXWHV
    +RZGLG\RXNQRZ"
    7KHEHVWZD\WRJHWFORVHWR\RXZRXOGFRPHDWWKLVRGG*UH\0DQHYHQW
    ZLWKWKHFORWKHVJDPELW,WZDVRQO\ORJLFDO
    +DULEOLQNHG$QG\RXVD\,DPFDOFXODWLQJ
    7KHZRPDQZRQWGLH<RXZRXOGKDYHWKRXJKZUDSSHGXSLQPLFURDJHQWV
    ZKHQWKH\LJQLWHG
    7KDQNJRRGQHVVIRUWKDW,ZRXOGKDWH
    0\ORYHJRRGQHVVLVQRWRSHUDWLQJKHUH,ZDQWHGKHUDOLYHVRVKH
    FRXOGEHTXHVWLRQHG
    2K+DULVDLGIHHOLQJVXGGHQO\TXLWHQDLYH
    

    -RDQRI$UFIRXQGLQKHUVHOIERWKEUDYHU\DQGIHDU
    6KHSHHUHGLQVLGHKHU6HOIDV9ROWDLUHKDG6KHWXUQHGWRFRQIURQWKLP
    DQGSOXQJHGGRZQWKURXJKKHURZQLQZDUGOD\HUV6KHKDGVLPSO\LQWHQGHGWR
    WXUQ%HORZWKDWFRPPDQGVKHVDZWKDWLIVKHVLPSO\WRRNDVPDOOHUVWHSWR
    PDNHWKHWXUQVKHZRXOGIDOORXWZDUG,QVWHDGXQFRQVFLRXVSRUWLRQVRIKHU
    PLQGNQHZWRVWDUWWKHWXUQE\PDNLQJKHUVHOIIDOODELWWRZDUGWKHLQVLGHRI
    WKHFXUYH7KHQWKHVHWLQ\VXEVHOYHVXVHGFHQWULIXJDOIRUFH^WKHWHUPMXPSHG
    LQWRIXOOGHILQLWLRQDQGVKHXQGHUVWRRGLWLQDIODVK WRULJKWKHUVHOIIRU
    WKHQH[WVWHSZKLFKUHTXLUHGDIXUWKHUGHIWFDOFXODWLRQ

    ,QFUHGLEOH+HUKXJHVRFLHW\RIERQHDQGPXVFOHMRLQWDQGQHUYHZDVD
    ODE\ULQWKRIVPDOOVHOYHVVSHDNLQJWRHDFKRWKHU
    6XFKDEXQGDQFH&OHDUHYLGHQFHRIDKLJKHUGHVLJQ
    1RZ,VHHLWVKHFULHG7KHGHFRPSRVLWLRQRIXVDOO"9ROWDLUHVDLG
    IRUORUQO\
    %HQRWVDG7KHVHP\ULDG6HOYHVDUHDMR\RXVWUXWK
    ,ILQGLWVREHULQJ2XUPLQGVGLGQRWHYROYHWRGRSKLORVRSK\RU
    VFLHQFHDODV5DWKHUWRILQGDQGHDWILJKWDQGIOHHORYHDQGORVH
    ,KDYHOHDUQHGPXFKIURP\RXEXWQRW\RXUPHODQFKRO\
    0RQWDLJQHWHUPHGKDSSLQHVVDVLQJXODULQFHQWLYHWR PHGLRFULW\DQG,
    FDQQRZVHHKLVUHDVRQLQJ
    %XWUHJDUG7KHIRJVDURXQGXVEHWUD\WKHVDPHLQWULFDWHSDWWHUQV:H
    FDQIDWKRPWKHP$QGIXUWKHUP\VRXO,WSURYHVWREHDSDWWHUQRIWKRXJKWVDQG
    GHVLUHVLQWHQWLRQVDQGZRHVPHPRULHVDQGEDGMRNHV
    <RXWDNHWKHVHLQQHUZRUNLQJVDVDVSLULWXDOPHWDSKRU"
    2IFRXUVH/LNHPHP\VRXOLVDQHPHUJHQWSURFHVVHPEHGGHGLQWKH
    XQLYHUVHZKHWKHUDFRVPRVRIDWRPRURIQXPEHUGRHVQRWPDWWHUP\JRRG
    VLU
    6RZKHQ\RXGLH\RXUVRXOJRHVEDFNLQWRWKHDEVWUDFWFORVHWZH
    SOXFNHGLWIRUWKIURP"
    1RWZH7KH&UHDWRU
    'U-RKQVRQSURYHGDVWRQHZDVUHDOE\NLFNLQJLW:HNQRZWKDWRXU
    PLQGVDUHUHDOEHFDXVHZHH[SHULHQFHWKHP6RWKHVHRWKHUWKLQJVDURXQGXV
    WKHVWUDQJHIRJWKH'LWWRVDUHHQWULHVLQDVPRRWKVSHFWUXPOHDGLQJIURP
    URFNVWR6HOI
    $GHLW\LVQRWRQWKDWVSHFWUXP
    $K,VHHWR\RX+HLVWKH*UHDW3UHVHUYHULQWKH6N\ZKHUHZHDUH
    DOOEDFNHGXSDVWKHFRPSXWHUW\SHVVD\"
    7KH&UHDWRUKROGVWKHWUXHHVVHQFHRIRXUVHOYHV6KHJULQQHG
    PDOLFLRXVO\3HUKDSVZHDUHWKHEDFNXSVPDGHQHZHYHU\MXPSRIFORFNWLPH
    1DVW\WKRXJKW+HVPLOHGGHVSLWHKLPVHOI<RXDUHEHFRPLQJD
    ORJLFLDQPORYH
    ,KDYHEHHQVWHDOLQJSDUWVRI\RX
    &RS\LQJPHLQWR\RXUVHOI":K\GR,QRWIHHORXWUDJHG"
    %HFDXVHWKHGHVLUHWRSRVVHVVWKHRWKHULVORYH
    9ROWDLUHHQODUJHGKLPVHOIOHJVVKRRWLQJGRZQLQWRWKH6\V&LW\VPDVKLQJ
    EXLOGLQJV7KHIRJURLOHGDQJULO\7KLV,FDQIDWKRP$UWLILFLDOUHDOPVVXFK
    DVPDWKHPDWLFVDQGWKHRORJ\DUHFDUHIXOO\EXLOWWREHIUHHRILQWHUHVWLQJ
    LQFRQVLVWHQF\%XWORYHLVEHDXWLIXOLQLWVODFNRIORJLFDOUHVWUDLQW
    7KHQ\RXDFFHSWP\YLHZ"-RDQNLVVHGKLPYROXSWXRXVO\
    +HVLJKHGUHVLJQLQJ$QLGHDVHHPVVHOIHYLGHQWRQFH\RXYHIRUJRWWHQ
    OHDUQLQJLW
    $OOWKLVKDGWDNHQPHUHPRPHQWV-RDQVDZ7KH\KDGTXLFNVWHSSHGWKHLU
    HYHQWZDYHVVRWKDWWKHLUFORFNWLPHDGYDQFHGIDVWHUWKDQWKHIRJV%XWWKLV
    H[SHQVHKDGH[KDXVWHGWKHLUUXQQLQJVLWHVDURXQG7UDQWRU6KHIHOWLWDVD
    VXGGHQOLJKWKHDGHGKXQJHU
    (DW9ROWDLUHFUDPPHGDKDQGIXORIJUDSHVLQKHUPRXWKDPHWDSKRU
    VKHVDZIRUFRPSXWDWLRQDOUHVHUYHV
    ,Q\RXUSUHVHQWORWRIOLIHLWZRXOGEHEHWWHUQRWWREHERUQDWDOO)HZDUH
    WKDWOXFN\
    $KRXUIRJLVDSHVVLPLVW9ROWDLUHGUDZOHGVDUFDVWLFDOO\
    $EUXSWO\WKHYDSRUVFRQGHQVHG/LJKWQLQJFUDFNOHGDQGVKRUWHGDURXQG
    WKHPLQHHULHVLOHQFH-RDQIHOWDODQFHRISDLQVKRRWWKURXJKKHUOHJVDQG
    DUPVUXQQLQJOLNHDOLYLGVQDNHRIDJRQ\6KHZRXOGQRWJLYHWKHPWKHWULEXWH
    RIDVFUHDP

    9ROWDLUHKRZHYHUZULWKHGLQWRUPHQW+HMHUNHGDQGKRZOHGZLWKRXW
    VKDPH
    2K'U3DQJORVVKHJDVSHG,IWKLVLVWKHEHVWRIDOOSRVVLEOH
    ZRUOGVZKDWPXVWWKHRWKHUVEHOLNH"
    7KHEUDYHVOD\WKHLURSSRQHQWV-RDQFDOOHGWRWKHWKLFNHQLQJPLVWV
    &RZDUGVWRUWXUHWKHP
    $GPLUDEOHP\GHDUTXLWH%XWZDUFDQQRWEHIRXJKWRQKRPHRSDWKLF
    SULQFLSOHV

    $KXPDQSRLQWHGRXWWRDQRWKHUWKDWWKHULFKHYHQZKHQGHDGZHUHRUQDWHO\
    ER[HGWKHQRSXOHQWO\HQWRPEHGUHVLGLQJLQFDUYHGVWRQHPDXVROHXPV7KHRWKHU
    KXPDQUHPDUNHGLQDZHWKDWWKLVZDVVXUHO\DQGWUXO\OLYLQJ

    +RZYLOHWRMHVWRIWKHGHDG-RDQVDLG
    8PPP9ROWDLUHVWURNHGKLVFKLQKDQGVWUHPEOLQJIURPWKHPHPRU\RI
    SDLQ7KH\MLEHDWXVZLWKMHVW
    7RUWXUHVXUHO\
    ,VXUYLYHGWKH%DVWLOOH,FDQHQGXUHWKHLURGGKXPRU
    &RXOGWKH\EHWU\LQJWRVD\VRPHWKLQJLQGLUHFWO\"
    >,035(&,6,21,6/(66@
    >:+(1,03/,&$7,2186('@
    +XPRULPSOLHVVRPHPRUDORUGHU-RDQVDLG
    >,17+,667$7($//25'(52)%(,1*6@
    >&$16(,=(&21752/2)7+(,53/($685(6<67(06@
    $K9ROWDLUHVDLG6RZHFRXOGUHSURGXFHWKHSOHDVXUHRIVXFFHVV
    ZLWKRXWWKHQHHGIRUDQ\DFWXDODFFRPSOLVKPHQW3DUDGLVH
    2IDVRUW-RDQVDLGVWHUQO\
    >7+$7:28/'%(7+((1'2)(9(5<7+,1*@
    >7+867+(),56735,1&,3/(@
    7KDWLVDPRUDOFRGHRIVRUWV9ROWDLUHDGPLWWHG<RXFRSLHGWKDW
    SKUDVHWKHHQGRIHYHU\WKLQJIURPP\RZQWKRXJKWVGLGQW\RX"
    >:(:,6+('<28725(&2*1,=(7+(,'($,1<2857(506@
    7KHLU)LUVW3ULQFLSOHLV1RXQHDUQHG SOHDVXUHWKHQ"-RDQVPLOHG
    9HU\&KULVWLDQ
    >21/<:+(1:(6$:7+$7<287:2)2506@
    >2%(<('7+(),56735,1&,3/(@
    >',':('(&,'(7263$5(<28@
    %\DQ\FKDQFHKDYH\RXUHDGP\/HWWUHV3KLORVRSKLTXHV"
    ,H[SHFWH[FHVVLYHVHOIORYHLVDVLQKHUH-RDQVDLGZU\O\7DNH
    FDUH
    >72+$50$6(16$7((17,7<,17(17,21$//<,66,1@
    >72.,&.$52&.,6127@
    >%8772725785($6,08/$7,21,6@><285&$7(*25<2)+(//@
    >:+,&+6((06$3(53(78$//<6(/),1)/,&7('+$50@
    2GGWKHRORJ\9ROWDLUHVDLG
    -RDQSRNHGKHUVZRUGDWWKHHYHUJDWKHULQJIRJ%HIRUH\RXIHOOVLOHQW
    PRPHQWVDJR\RXLQYRNHGWKHZDURIIOHVKRQIOHVK"
    >:($5(7+(5(01$1762))2506@
    >:+2),567/,9('7+$7:$<@
    >12::(,0326($+,*+(5025$/25'(5@
    >217+26(:+29$148,6+('285/2:(5)2506@
    :KR"-RDQDVNHG
    >68&+$6<2821&(:(5(@
    +XPDQLW\"-RDQZDVDODUPHG
    >(9(17+(<.12:7+$7@
    >381,6+0(17'(7(56%</(1',1*&5('(1&(727+5($7@
    >.12:,1*7+,6025$//$:@

    >:+,&+*29(516$//@
    >7+(<0867%(58/('%<,7@
    3XQLVKPHQWIRUZKDW"-RDQDVNHG
    >'(35('$7,216$*$,167/,)(,17+(*$/$;<@
    $EVXUG9ROWDLUHFRQMXUHGDVSLQQLQJ*DODFWLFGLVNLQDLUDOLYHZLWK
    OXPLQHVFHQFH7KH(PSLUHWHHPVZLWKOLIH
    >$///,)(7+$7&$0(%()25(7+(9(50,1@
    :KDWYHUPLQ"-RDQVZXQJKHUVZRUG,ILQGDOOLDQFHZLWKPRUDOEHLQJV
    VXFKDV\RX%ULQJWKHVHYHQQLQIRUWKDQG,VKDOOGHDOZLWKWKHP
    >7+(9(50,1$5(7+(.,1'<28:(5(@
    >%()25(<287:2:(5($%675$&7('@
    -RDQIURZQHG:KDWFDQWKH\PHDQ"
    +XPDQV9ROWDLUHVDLG
    

    &OHRQVDLG7KHZRPDQFRQIHVVHGUHDGLO\$SURIHVVLRQDODVVDVVLQ,
    YLHZHGWKH'DQGVKHVHHPHGDOPRVWRIIKDQGDERXWLW
    /DPXUN"+DULDVNHG
    2EYLRXVO\EXWVKHZLOOQRWDGPLWVR6WLOOWKLVPD\EHHQRXJKWR
    IRUFHKLVKDQG&OHRQVLJKHGVKRZLQJWKHVWUDLQ%XWVLQFHVKHZDVIURPWKH
    $QDO\WLFD6HFWRUVKHPD\EHDSURIHVVLRQDOOLDUDVZHOO
    'DPQ+DULVDLG
    ,QWKH$QDO\WLFD6HFWRUHYHU\REMHFWDQGDFWKDGDSULFH7KLVPHDQW
    WKDWWKHUHZHUHQRFULPHVRQO\GHHGVZKLFKFRVWPRUH (YHU\FLWL]HQKDGD
    ZHOOHVWDEOLVKHGYDOXHH[SUHVVHGLQFXUUHQF\0RUDOLW\OD\LQQRWWU\LQJWR
    GRVRPHWKLQJZLWKRXWSD\LQJIRULW(YHU\WUDQVDFWLRQIORZHGRQWKHJUHDVHRI
    YDOXH(YHU\LQMXU\KDGDSULFH
    ,I\RXZDQWHGWRNLOO\RXUHQHP\\RXFRXOGEXW\RXKDGWRGHSRVLWKLV
    IXOOZRUWKLQWKH6HFWRU)XQGDWZLWKLQDGD\,I\RXFRXOGQRWSD\LWWKH
    )XQGDWUHGXFHG\RXUQHWYDOXHWR]HUR$Q\IULHQGRI\RXUHQHP\FRXOGWKHQ
    NLOO\RXDWQRFRVW
    &OHRQVLJKHGDQGQRGGHG6WLOOWKH$QDO\WLFD6HFWRUJLYHVPHOLWWOH
    WURXEOH7KHLUPHWKRGPDNHVIRUJRRGPDQQHUV
    +DULKDGWRDJUHH6HYHUDO*DODFWLF=RQHVXVHGWKHVDPHVFKHPHWKH\
    ZHUHPRGHOVRIVWDELOLW\7KHSRRUKDGWREHSROLWH,I\RXZHUHSHQQLOHVVDQG
    ERRULVK\RXPLJKWQRWVXUYLYH%XWWKHULFKZHUHQRWLQYXOQHUDEOHHLWKHU$
    FRQVRUWLXPRIHFRQRPLFOHVVHUVFRXOGJHWWRJHWKHUEHDWDULFKPDQEDGO\WKHQ
    VLPSO\SD\KLVKRVSLWDODQGUHFRYHU\ELOOV2IFRXUVHKLVUHWULEXWLRQPLJKW
    EHH[WUHPH
    %XWVKHZDVRSHUDWLQJRXWVLGH$QDO\WLFD+DULVDLG 7KDWVLOOHJDO
    7RXVWRPHVXUHO\%XWWKDWWRRKDVDSULFHLQVLGH$QDO\WLFD
    6KHFDQWEHIRUFHGWRLGHQWLI\/DPXUN"
    6KHKDVQHXUDOEORFNVILUPO\LQSODFH
    'DPQ+RZDERXWDEDFNJURXQGFKHFN"
    7KDWWXUQVXSPRUHWDQWDOL]LQJWUDFHV$SRVVLEOHOLQNWRWKDWRGG
    ZRPDQWKH$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWH&OHRQGUDZOHGH\HLQJ+DUL
    6RSHUKDSV,PEHWUD\HGE\P\RZQNLQG3ROLWLFV
    5LWXDODVVDVVLQDWLRQLVDQDQFLHQWLIUHJUHWWDEOHWUDGLWLRQ$PHWKRG
    RIDKWHVWLQJDPRQJWKHSRZHUHOHPHQWVLQRXU(PSLUH
    +DULJULPDFHG,PQRWH[SHUWDWWKLV
    &OHRQILGJHWHGXQHDVLO\,FDQQRWGHOD\WKH+LJK&RXQFLOYRWHPRUHWKDQ
    DIHZGD\V
    7KHQ,PXVWGRVRPHWKLQJ
    &OHRQDUFKHGDQH\HEURZ,DPQRWZLWKRXWUHVRXUFHV
    3DUGRQVLUH,PXVWILJKWP\RZQEDWWOHV
    7KH6DUNSUHGLFWLRQQRZWKDWZDVGDULQJ

    ,GLGQRWFKHFNLWZLWK\RXILUVWEXW,WKRXJKW
    1RQR+DUL([FHOOHQW%XWZLOOLWZRUN"
    ,WLVRQO\DSUREDELOLW\VLUH%XWLWZDVWKHRQO\VWLFN,KDGKDQG\
    WREHDW/DPXUNZLWK
    ,WKRXJKWVFLHQFH\LHOGHGFHUWDLQW\
    2QO\GHDWKGRHVWKDWP\HPSHURU

    7KHLQYLWDWLRQIURPWKH$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWHVHHPHGRGGEXW+DULZHQW
    DQ\ZD\7KHHPERVVHGVKHHWZLWKLWVHODERUDWHVDOXWDWLRQVFDPHIUHLJKWHG
    ZLWKQXDQFHDV+DULVSURWRFRORIILFHUSXWLW
    7KLVDXGLHQFHZDVLQRQHRIWKHVWUDQJHU6HFWRUV(YHQEXULHGLQOD\HUV
    RIDUWLILFHPDQ\6HFWRUVRI7UDQWRUGLVSOD\HGDQRGGELRSKLOLD
    +HUHLQ$UFDGLD6HFWRUH[SHQVLYHKRPHVSHUFKHGDERYHDYLHZRIDQ
    LQWHULRUODNHRUEURDGILHOG0DQ\VSRUWHGWUHHVDUUDQJHGLQDUWIXOO\UDQGRP
    EXQFKHVZLWKDFOHDUSUHIHUHQFHIRUWKRVHZLWKVSUHDGLQJFURZQVPDQ\
    EUDQFKHVSURMHFWLQJXSZDUGDQGRXWZDUGIURPWKLFNWUXQNVGLVSOD\LQJOX[XULDQW
    EXQFKHVRIVPDOOOHDYHV%DOFRQLHVWKH\ULPPHGZLWKSRWWHGVKUXEV
    +DULZDONHGWKURXJKWKHVHVHHLQJWKHPWKURXJKWKHOHQVRI3DQXFRSLD,W
    ZDVDVWKRXJKSHRSOHDQQRXQFHGWKURXJKWKHLUFKRLFHVWKHLUSULPHYDORULJLQV
    :DVHDUO\KXPDQLW\OLNHSDQVPRUHVHFXUHLQPDUJLQDOWHUUDLQZKHUHYLVWDV
    OHWWKHPVHDUFKIRUIRRGZKLOHNHHSLQJDQH\HRXWIRUHQHPLHV")UDLOZLWKRXW
    FODZVRUVKDUSWHHWKWKH\PLJKWKDYHQHHGHGDTXLFNUHWUHDWLQWRWUHHVRU
    ZDWHU
    6LPLODUO\VWXGLHVVKRZHGWKDWVRPHSKRELDVZHUH*DOD[\ZLGH3HRSOHZKR
    KDGQHYHUVHHQWKHLPDJHVQRQHWKHOHVVUHDFWHGZLWKVWDUWOHGIHDUWRKRORVRI
    VSLGHUVVQDNHVZROYHVVKDUSGURSVKHDY\PDVVHVRYHUKHDG1RQHGLVSOD\HG
    SKRELDVDJDLQVWPRUHUHFHQWWKUHDWVWRWKHLUOLYHVNQLYHVJXQVHOHFWULFDO
    VRFNHWVIDVW FDUV
    $OOWKLVKDGWRIDFWRUVRPHKRZLQWRSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    1RWUDFHUVKHUHVLUWKH6SHFLDOVFDSWDLQVDLG/LWWOHKDUGWRNHHS
    WUDFNWKRXJK
    +DULVPLOHG7KHFDSWDLQVXIIHUHGIURPDFRPPRQ7UDQWRULDQPDODG\
    VTXDVKHGSHUVSHFWLYHV+HUHLQWKHRSHQQDWLYHVZRXOGPLVWDNHGLVWDQWODUJH
    REMHFWVIRUQHDUE\VPDOORQHV(YHQ+DULKDGDWRXFKRILW2Q3DQXFRSLDKH
    DWILUVWPLVWRRNKHUGVRIJUD]HUVIRUUDWVFORVHDWKDQG
    %\QRZ+DULKDGOHDUQHGWRORRNWKURXJKWKHSRPSDQGJORU\RIULFK
    VHWWLQJV WKHFURZGVRIVHUYDQWVWKHILQHU\+HUXPLQDWHGRQKLV
    SV\FKRKLVWRULFDOUHVHDUFKDVKHIROORZHGWKHSURWRFRORIILFHUDQGGLGQRW
    IXOO\FRPHEDFNWRWKHUHDOZRUOGXQWLOKHVDWDFURVVIURPWKH$FDGHPLF
    3RWHQWDWH
    6KHVSRNHRUQDWHO\3OHDVHGRDFFHSWP\ KXPEOHRIIHULQJDFFRPSDQLHG
    GHOLFDWHWUDQVOXFHQWFXSVRIVWHDPLQJJUDVVZDWHU
    +HUHPHPEHUHGEHLQJLUNHGE\WKLVZRPDQDQGWKHKLJKDFDGHPLFVKHPHW
    WKDWHYHQLQJ,WDOOVHHPHGVRORQJDJR
    <RXZLOOQRWHWKHDURPDLVWKDWRIULSHRREDORQJIUXLW7KLVLVP\
    SHUVRQDOFKRLFHDPRQJWKHVSOHQGLGJUDVVZDWHUVRIWKHZRUOG&DODILD,W
    UHIOHFWVWKHKLJKHVWHHPLQZKLFK,KROGWKRVHZKRQRZJUDFHP\VLPSOH
    GRPLFLOHZLWKVXFKLOOXVWULRXVSUHVHQFH
    +DULKDGWRORZHUKLVKHDGLQZKDWKHKRSHGZDVDUHVSHFWIXO JHVWXUHWR
    KLGHKLVJULQ7KHUHIROORZHGPRUHKLJKIORZQSKUDVHVDERXWWKHPHGLFDO
    EHQHILWVRIJUDVVZDWHUUDQJLQJIURPUHOLHIRIGLJHVWLRQSUREOHPVWRUHSDLURI
    EDVDOFHOOXODULQMXULHV
    +HUFKLQVTXLYHUHG<RXPXVWQHHGVXFFRULQVXFKWU\LQJWLPHV
    $FDGHPLFLDQ
    0RVWO\,QHHGWLPHWRJHWP\ZRUNGRQH
    3HUKDSV\RXZRXOGIDYRUDKHDOWK\SRUWLRQRIWKHEODFNOLFKHQPHDW",W
    LVWKHILQHVWKDUYHVWHGIURPWKHIODQNVRIWKHVWHHSSHDNVRI$PEURVH

    1H[WWLPHFHUWDLQO\
    ,WLVKRSHGIHUYHQWO\WKDWWKLVORZO\SHUVRQDJHKDGSHUKDSVEHHQRI
    VPDOOVHUYLFHWRDPRVWZRUWK\DQGUHYHUHGILJXUHRIRXUWLPHRQHZKR
    SHUKDSVLVRYHUVWUHVVHG"
    $VWHHO\HGJHWRKHUYRLFHSXWKLPRQJXDUG
    &RXOGPDGDPJHWWRWKHSRLQW"
    9HU\ZHOO<RXUZLIH"6KHLVDFRPSOH[ODG\
    +HWULHGWRVKRZQRWKLQJLQKLVIDFH$QG"
    ,ZRQGHUKRZ\RXUSURVSHFWVLQWKH+LJK&RXQFLOZRXOGIDUHLI,
    UHYHDOHGKHUWUXHQDWXUH"
    +DULVKHDUWVDQN7KLVKHKDGQRWDQWLFLSDWHG
    %ODFNPDLOLVLW"
    6XFKDFUXGHZRUG
    6XFKDFUXGHDFW
    +DULVDWDQGOLVWHQHGWRKHULQWULFDWHDQDO\VLVRIKRZ'RUVLGHQWLW\DV
    DURERWZRXOGXQGHUPLQHKLVFDQGLGDF\$OOTXLWHWUXH
    $QG\RXVSHDNIRUNQRZOHGJHIRUVFLHQFH"KHVDLGELWWHUO\
    ,DPDFWLQJLQWKHEHVWLQWHUHVWVRIP\FRQVWLWXHQWVVKHVDLG
    EODQGO\<RXDUHDPDWKLVWDWKHRULVW<RXZRXOGEHWKHILUVWDFDGHPLFWR
    UHLJQDV)LUVW0LQLVWHULQPDQ\GHFDGHV:HGRQRWWKLQN\RXZLOOUXOHZHOO
    <RXUIDLOXUHZLOOFDVWVKDGRZVXSRQXVPHULWRFUDWVRQHDQGDOO
    +DULEULVWOHG:KRVD\V"
    2XUFRQVLGHUHGRSLQLRQ<RXDUHLPSUDFWLFDO8QZLOOLQJWRPDNHKDUG
    GHFLVLRQV$OORXUSV\FKHUVDJUHHZLWKWKDWGLDJQRVLV
    3V\FKHUV"+DULVQRUWHGGHULVLYHO\'HVSLWHFDOOLQJKLVWKHRU\
    SV\FKRKLVWRU\KHNQHZWKHUHZDVQRJRRGPRGHORIWKHLQGLYLGXDOKXPDQ
    SHUVRQDOLW\
    ,ZRXOGPDNHDIDUEHWWHUFDQGLGDWHMXVWIRUH[DPSLH
    6RPHFDQGLGDWH<RXUHQRWHYHQOR\DOWR\RXUNLQG
    7KHUH\RXKDYHLW<RXUHXQDEOHWRULVHDERYH\RXURULJLQV
    $QGWKH(PSLUHKDVEHFRPHWKHZDURIDOODJDLQVWDOO
    6FLHQFHDQGPDWKHPDWLFVZDVDKLJKDFKLHYHPHQWRI,PSHULDOFLYLOL]DWLRQ
    EXWWR+DULVPLQGLWKDGIHZKHURHV0RVWJRRGVFLHQFHFDPHIURPEULJKW
    PLQGVDWSOD\)URPPHQDQGZRPHQDEOHWRWXUQDQHOHJDQWLQVLJKWWRILQG
    EHJXLOLQJWULFNVLQDUFDQHPDWWHUVGHIWDUFKLWHFWVRISUHYDLOLQJRSLQLRQ
    3OD\HYHQLQWHOOHFWXDOSOD\ZDVIXQDQGWKDWZDVJRRGLQLWVRZQULJKW%XW
    +DULVKHURHVZHUHWKRVHZKRVWXFNLWRXWDJDLQVWKDUGRSSRVLWLRQGURYH
    WRZDUGGDXQWLQJJRDOVDFFHSWLQJSDLQDQGIDLOXUHDQGNHHSLQJRQDQ\ZD\
    3HUKDSVOLNHKLVIDWKHUWKH\ZHUHWHVWLQJWKHLURZQFKDUDFWHUDVPXFKDV
    WKH\ZHUHEHLQJSDUWRIWKHVXDYHVFLHQWLILFFXOWXUH
    $QGZKLFKW\SHZDVKH"
    7LPHWRUDLVHWKHVWDNHV
    +H VWRRGEUXVKLQJDVLGHWKHERZOVZLWKDFODWWHU<RXOOKDYHP\UHSO\
    VRRQ
    +HVWHSSHGRQDFXSJRLQJRXWDQGVKDWWHUHGLW
    

    9ROWDLUHVKRXWHGSURXGO\,VSHQWPXFKRIP\FDUHHUH[LOHGIRUVSHDNLQJ
    7UXWKWR3RZHU,OODGPLWWRVRPHIODZVLQMXGJPHQWDVZKHQ,IDZQHGRYHU
    )UHGHULFNWKH*UHDW1HFHVVLW\VKDSHVPDQQHUV,OOUHPLQG\RX,ZDV
    FRXUDJHRXV\HVEXWVQREELVKWRR
    >7+28*+$0$7+(0$7,&$/5(35(6(17$7,21@
    ><286+$5(7+($1,0$/63,5,762)<285.,1'@
    >67,//@
    2IFRXUVH-RDQVKRXWHGLQKLVGHIHQVH
    ><285.,1'$5(7+(:25672)$//9,9,)2506@

    /LYLQJWKLQJV"-RDQIURZQHG%XWWKH\DUHRIKRO\RULJLQ
    ><285.,1',6$3(51,&,286%/(1'@
    >$7(55,%/(0$55,$*(2)0(&+$1,60@
    >:,7+<285%($6785*(72(;3$1'@
    <RXFDQVHHRXULQQHUVWUXFWXUHVDVVXUHO\DVZH9ROWDLUHVZHOOHG
    SRSSLQJZLWKHQHUJLHV3UREDEO\EHWWHU,OOYHQWXUH<RXPXVWNQRZWKDWIRU
    XVFRQVFLRXVQHVVUHLJQVLWGRHVQRWJRYHUQ
    >35,0,7,9($1'$:.:$5'@
    >758(@
    >%871277+(&$86(2)<2856,1@
    6KHDQG9ROWDLUHZHUHJLDQWVQRZVHOIEDOORRQHGWRVWULGHDFURVVWKH
    VLPXODWHGODQGVFDSH7KHDOLHQIRJVFOXQJWRWKHLUDQNOHV$SURXGZD\RI
    VKRZLQJWKHLUFRXUDJHSHUKDSVDELWIXOORIVHOI6WLOOVKHZDVJODGVKH
    KDGWKRXJKWRILW7KHVHIRJVKHOGKXPDQLW\LQFRQWHPSW$VKRZRIIRUFHZDV
    XVHIXODVVKHKDGIRXQGDJDLQVWWKHYLOH(QJOLVKVHYHUDOWLPHV
    9ROWDLUHVDLG,KHOG3RZHULQFRQWHPSWXVXDOO\\HW,OODGPLW,ZDV
    HYHUODVWLQJO\KXQJU\IRULWWRR
    >7+(6,*1$785(2)<285.,1'@
    6R,DPDFRQWUDGLFWLRQ+XPDQLW\LVDURSHVWUHWFKHGEHWZHHQ
    SDUDGR[HV
    >:('2127),1'<285+80$1,7<025$/@
    %XWZHWKH\DUH-RDQVKRXWHGGRZQDWWKHIRJ7KRXJKWKLQFRPSDUHG
    ZLWKWKHPWKHIRJVFOXQJOLNHJOXHDQGILOOHGWKHYDOOH\VZLWKFRWWRQ\JXP
    ><28'2127.12:<2852:1+,6725<@
    :HDUHRIKLVWRU\9ROWDLUHERRPHG
    >7+(5(&25'6+(5(,17+(0$7+(0$7,&$/63$&(6@
    >$5()$/6(@
    2QHFDQQHYHUEHVXUHRIEHLQJUHDGULJKW\RXNQRZ
    -RDQVDZLQ9ROWDLUHDQDQ[LHW\EDUHO\FRQFHDOHG7KRXJKWKHLURSSRQHQW
    XVHGDYRLFHFRRODQGGLVSDVVLRQDWHVKHWRRIHOWWKHLQVLGLRXVWKUHDWLQLWV
    FDVWRIZRUGV
    9ROWDLUHZHQWRQDVLIWRSOHDVHDNLQJLQFRXUW$ELWRIKLVWRULFDO
    H[DPSOH,RQFHVDZLQDFKXUFK\DUGLQ(QJODQGWKHUHWRKDLOWKHEULJKW
    1HZWRQDKHDGVWRQHWKXV
    (5(&7('727+(0(025<
    RI-RKQ0F)DUODQH
    'URZQGLQWKH:DWHURI/HLWK
    %<$)(:$))(&7,21$7()5,(1'6

    6R\RXVHHWKHUHFDQEHPLVWDNHVRIWUDQVODWLRQ+HOLIWHGKLV
    HODERUDWHFRXUWLHUVKDWDQGPDGHDVZHHSLQJERZ7KHKDWVSOXPHGIHDWKHU
    GDQFHGLQDIUHVKZLQG-RDQVDZWKDWKHZDVGLVWUDFWLQJWKHIRJZKLOHWU\LQJ
    WRVXEWO\EORZLWDZD\
    7KHIRJVIODVKHGRUDQJHOLJKWQLQJDQGVZHOOHGHQRUPRXVDQGSXUSOH
    7KXQGHUKHDGVURVHDQGWRZHUHGDERYHWKHP
    9ROWDLUHVKRZHGRQO\DQDUFKVFRUQ6KHKDGWRDGPLUHKLVJDLWDVKH
    ZKLUOHGDQGFRQIURQWHGWKHJDUJDQWXDQSXUSOHFORXGPRXQWDLQ6KHUHPHPEHUHG
    KRZKHKDGZD[HGRQDERXWKLVGUDPDWLFWULXPSKVKLVOHJLRQVRIDFFODLPHG
    SOD\V KLVSRSXODULW\DWFRXUW$VLIWRVKRZRIIIRUKHUKHFXUOHGDOLS
    LQWRDVQHHUDQGLQYHQWHGDSRHPIRUWKHPRPHQW
    %LJZKRUOVKDYHOLWWOHZKRUOV
    :KLFKIHHGRQWKHLUYHORFLW\
    $QGOLWWOHZKRUOVKDYHOHVVHUZKRUOV
    $QGVRRQWRYLVFRVLW\
    7KHFORXGKXUOHGVDYDJHVKHHWVRIUDLQGRZQXSRQWKHP-RDQZDV
    LQVWDQWO\GUHQFKHGDQGFKLOOHGWRWKHERQH9ROWDLUHVJORULRXVJDUEZLOWHG

    +LVIDFHWXUQHGEOXHZLWKFROG
    (QRXJKKHFULHG3LW\WKHSRRUZRPDQDWOHDVW
    ,QHHGQRSLW\-RDQZDVJHQXLQHO\RXWUDJHG$QG\RXOOQRWVKRZ
    ZHDNQHVVEHIRUHWKHHQHP\OHJLRQV
    +HPDQDJHGDMDXQW\VPLOH,GHIHUWRWKHJHQHUDORIP\KHDUW
    ><28/,9(21/<$7285:,//@
    3UD\GRQRWVSDUHXVRXWRISLW\WKHQ-RDQVDLG
    ><28/,9(62/(/<%(&$86(21(2)<28@
    >6+2:('025$/6(/)@
    >7221(2)285/2:(5)2506@
    -RDQZDVSX]]OHG:KR"
    ><28@
    %HVLGHKHUPDWHULDOL]HG*DUFRQ$'0
    %XWWKLVLVVXUHO\DPXOWLSO\UHPRYHGHQWLW\9ROWDLUHVQDSSHG$QGD
    VHUYDQW
    -RDQSDWWHG*DUFRQ$VLPXODWLRQRIDPDFKLQH"
    >:(:(5(21&(2)0$&+,1(@
    >$1'+$9(&20(+(5(72':(//@
    >,1180(5,&$/(0%2',0(17@
    )URPZKHUH"-RDQDVNHG
    >$&5266$//7+(7851,1*63,5$/',6.@
    )RU
    >5(0(0%(5@
    >381,6+0(17'(7(56%</(1',1*&5('(1&(727+5($7@
    9ROWDLUHDVNHG6R\RXVDLGEHIRUH7DNLQJWKHORQJYLHZHK"%XWZKDW
    GR\RXWUXO\ZDQWQRZ"
    >:(722'(6&(1')5209,9,)250612:(;7,1*8,6+('@
    >'2127,0$*,1(:($5()5((2)7+$7@
    -RDQIHOWDKRUULEOHVXVSLFLRQ6KHZKLVSHUHG'RQRWSURYRNHLWVR,W
    PLJKW
    ,ZRXOGNQRZWKHWUXWK:KDWGR\RXZDQW"
    >5(9(1*(@
    

    8JK0DUTFXUOHGKLVOLS
    +DULVPLOHG:KHQIRRGJHWVVFDUFHWDEOHPDQQHUVFKDQJH
    %XWWKLV
    +H\ZHUHSD\LQ<XJRVDLGVDUGRQLFDOO\
    7KHPHQXZDVH[FOXVLYHO\SVHXGRIIDOWKHODWHVWVWRSJDSLQ7UDQWRUV
    IRRGFULVLV7KLVIRRGZRUNVKDGWKHZKROHUXQOLYHUVDQGNLGQH\VDQGWULSH
    PDGHLQSULVWLQHYDWV1RWWKHVOLJKWHVWKLQWRIDFWXDODQLPDOWLVVXH
    LQYROYHG6WLOOWKHYRLFHPHQXUHDVVXUHGWKHPLQZDUPIHPLQLQHWRQHVHYHU\
    LWHPFDUULHGWKHWUXHGDQNYLVFHUDODURPDVRIWKHJXW
    &DQWZHJHWVRPHGHFHQWPHDOPHDW"0DUTDVNHGLUULWDEO\
    7KLVKDVKLJKHUIRRGYDOXH<XJRVDLG$QGQRERG\OOEHORRNLQIRU
    XVKHUH
    +DULJODQFHGDURXQG7KH\ZHUHEHKLQGDVRXQGVKLHOGEXWVWLOO
    VHFXULW\ZDVHVVHQWLDO0RVWRIWKHWDEOHVLQWKHUHVWDXUDQWZHUHWDNHQE\KLV
    6SHFLDOVWKHUHVWE\ZHOOGUHVVHGJHQWU\FODVV
    ,WVIDVKLRQDEOHWRRKHVDLGDIIDEO\<RXFDQEUDJDERXWFRPLQJ
    KHUH
    %UDJDIWHU,JDJ" 0DUTVQLIIHGWKHDLUZULQNOHGKLVQRVH
    $OOWKHQRQFRQIRUPLVWVDUHGRLQJLW+DULVDLGEXWQRRQHJRWWKH
    MRNH
    ,PDIXJLWLYH0DUTZKLVSHUHG3HRSOHDUHVWLOOWU\LQJWRKDQJWKRVH
    -XQLQULRWVRQPH7DNLQJDELJULVNWRFRPHKHUH

    :HVKDOOPDNHLWZRUWK\RXUZKLOH+DULVDLG,QHHGDMREGRQHE\
    VRPHRQHRXWVLGHWKHODZ
    7KDW,DP+XQJU\WRR
    7KHYRLFHPHQXDVVXUHGWKHPWKDWWKHUHZHUHDVZHOOZKROHPHDOVRI
    SVHXGRDQLPDOYHJHWDEOHRUWUDQVPLQHUDOLQJUHGLHQWVERLOHGIURPZLWKLQ7KH
    QHZHVWIRRGLHFUD]HWKHPHQXJXVKHG2QHELWHVLQWRDILUPVKHOODQGWKHQ
    YHQWXUHVLQZDUGWRDPHOORZVWHZHGLQWHULRURIOX[XULDQWLPSOLFDWLRQ
    6RPHLWHPVRIIHUHGQRWPHUHIODYRUDURPDDQGWH[WXUHEXWZKDWWKH
    PHQXGHPXUHO\GHVFULEHGDVPRWLOLW\7KHIHDWXUHGLWHPZDVDSLOHRIUHG
    VWUDQGVZKLFKGLGQRWMXVWOLHWKHUHOLPSO\LQ\RXUPRXWKEXWVTXLUPHGDQG
    ZULJJOHGHDJHUO\H[SUHVVLQJLWVORQJLQJWREHHDWHQ
    <RXJX\VGRQWQHHGWRWRUWXUHPHLQWRFROODERUDWLRQ0DUTMXWWHGKLV
    FKLQRXWUHPLQGLQJ+DULRIDSDQJHVWXUHXVHGE\%LJJHU
    +DULFKXFNOHGDQGRUGHUHGDJXWVDPSOHU,WZDVVXUSULVLQJKRZKH
    FRXOGDFFRPPRGDWHZKDWZRXOGKDYHUHYROWHGKLPRQO\ZHHNVEHIRUH:KHQWKH\
    KDGRUGHUHG+DULSXWWKHGHDORQWKHWDEOHGLUHFWO\
    0DUTVFRZOHG'LUHFWOLQNXS"7RWKHZKROHGDPQHGV\VWHP"
    :HZDQWDQLQWHUEULGJHWRRXUSV\FKRKLVWRULFDOHTXDWLRQV\VWHP<XJR
    VDLG
    0DUTEOLQNHG)XOOERG\OLQN"7KDWVELJFDSDFLW\
    :HNQRZLWFDQEHGRQH<XJRSUHVVHG-XVWWDNHVWKHWHFKZKLFK
    \RXYHJRW
    :KRVD\V"0DUTVH\HVQDUURZHG
    +DULOHDQHGIRUZDUGHDUQHVWO\<XJRLQILOWUDWHG\RXUV\VWHPV
    +RZG\RXGRWKDW"
    *RWVRPHEXGGLHVWRKHOS<XJRVDLGDUFKO\
    'DKOLWHV\RXPHDQ0DUTVDLGKRWO\<RXUNLQG
    6WRS+DULVDLGVWHUQO\1RVXFKWDONKHUH7KLVLVDEXVLQHVV
    SURSRVLWLRQ
    0DUTSHHUHGDW+DUL<RXJRLQJWREH)LUVW0LQLVWHU"
    0D\EH
    ,ZDQWDSDUGRQDVSDUWRIWKHGHDO2QHIRU6\E\OWRR
    +DULKDWHGPDNLQJXQFHUWDLQSURPLVHVEXW'RQH
    0DUTVPRXWKWLJKWHQHGEXWKHQRGGHG&RVWVSOHQW\WRR<RXJRWWKH
    PRQH\"
    ,VWKH(PSHURUIDW"<XJRVDLG

    ,QSULQFLSOHWKHSURFHVVZDVVLPSOH
    0DJQHWLFLQGXFWLRQORRSVWLQ\DQGVXSHUFRQGXFWLQJFRXOGPDSLQGLYLGXDO
    QHXURQVLQWKHEUDLQ,QWHUDFWLYHSURJUDPVODLGEDUHWKHLQWULFDFLHVRIWKH
    YLVXDOFRUWH[1HXURQDOSUREHVFRXSOHGWKHVXEMHFWQHUYRXVV\VWHPWRD
    SDUDOOHOFRQVWHOODWLRQRISXUHO\GLJLWDOHYHQWV'HHSHUVWLOOWLHVIRUPHG
    ZLWKHYROXWLRQVNOXGJ\WDQJOHLQWKHOLPELFV\VWHP
    $VZHOOWKLVWHFKQRORJ\FRXOGXQOHDVKQHZGHILQLWLRQVRI*HQXV+RPR
    %XWWKHDJHROGWDERRVDJDLQVWDUWLILFLDOLQWHOOLJHQFHVRIKLJKRUGHUKDGNHSW
    WKHSURFHVVHVPDUJLQDO$VZHOOQRERG\FRQVLGHUHG+RPR'LJLWDOWREHDQHTXDO
    PDQLIHVWDWLRQWR1DWXUDO0DQ
    +DULNQHZDOOWKLVEXWKLVLPPHUVLRQRQ3DQXFRSLDDQDOOLHG
    WHFKQRORJ\KDGWDXJKWKLPPXFK
    7ZRGD\VDIWHUPHHWLQJ0DUTLQWKHUHVWDXUDQWZKLFKKDGEHHQ
    VXUSULVLQJO\JRRGDQGLQWKHIRRGFULVLVKDGFRVWKLPDPRQWKVVDODU\+DUL
    OD\VLOHQWDQGVODFNLQDWXEXODUUHFHSWDFOHDQGSOXQJHGLQWRSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    )LUVWKHQRWLFHGWKDWKLVULJKWIRRWLWFKHGIURPWRHWRKHHO'HWDLOHG
    WZLWFKHVWROGKLPRILQVWDELOLW\LQWKHSRSXODWLRQGULYHUWHUPV0XVWFRUUHFW
    WKDW
    +HFRQWLQXHGIDOOLQJLQWRDFRVPRVZKLFK\DZQHGEHORZ
    7KLVZDVV\VWHPVSDFHDQLQILQLWHYDXOWGHILQHGE\WKHSDUDPHWHUVRI

    SV\FKRKLVWRU\7KHFRPSOHWHH[SDQVHKDGWZHQW\HLJKWGLPHQVLRQV+LVQHUYRXV
    V\VWHPFRXOGRQO\VHHWKLVLQVOLFHV:LWKDFRQFHSWXDOVKLIW+DULFRXOGSHHU
    DORQJVHYHUDOSDUDPHWHUD[HVDQGVHHHYHQWVXQIROGDVJHRPHWULFVKDSHV
    'RZQGRZQLQWRWKHHQWLUHKLVWRU\RIWKH(PSLUH
    6RFLDOIRUPVURVHOLNHSHDNV7KHVHVWDEOHDOSVKDGDULVHQDV WKH(PSLUH
    JUHZ%DVLQVFKXUQHGEHWZHHQWKHPRXQWDLQUDQJHRI)HXGDO)RUPV7KHVHZHUH
    WKHFKDRVVLQNV
    $WWKHULPRIVLPPHULQJFKDRVODNHVOD\WKHFULVLVWRSR]RQH7KLVZDVD
    QRPDQVODQGEHWZHHQUHJXODUULJLGODQGVFDSHVDQGWKHVWRFKDVWLFPRUDVV
    ,PSHULDOKLVWRU\XQIROGHGDVKHFUXLVHGDERYHWKHVHHWKLQJODQGVFDSH
    6HHQWKLVZD\PLVWDNHVDERXQGHGLQWKHHDUO\(PSLUH
    3KLORVRSKHUVKDGWROGKXPDQLW\WKDWWKH\ZHUHDQLPDOVRIDOOVRUWV
    SROLWLFDODQLPDOVIHHOLQJDQLPDOVVRFLDODQLPDOVSRZHUSRODUL]HGDQLPDOV
    VLFNDQLPDOVPDFKLQHOLNHDQLPDOVHYHQUDWLRQDORQHV2YHUDQGRYHU
    HUURQHRXVWKHRULHVRIKXPDQQDWXUH\LHOGHGIDLOHGSROLWLFDOV\VWHPV0DQ\
    VLPSO\JHQHUDOL]HGIURPWKHEDVLFKXPDQIDPLO\DQGVDZWKH6WDWHDVHLWKHU
    0RWKHU)LJXUHRU)DWKHU)LJXUH
    0RPP\6WDWHVVWUHVVHGVXSSRUWDQGFRPIRUWRIWHQJLYLQJFUDGOHWRJUDYH
    VHFXULW\WKRXJKRQO\IRUDJHQHUDWLRQRUWZRZKHQWKHH[SHQVHVFROODSVHGWKH
    HFRQRP\
    'DGG\6WDWHVIHDWXUHGDVWULFWFRPSHWLWLYHHFRQRP\ZLWKVWHPFRQWUROV
    RYHUEHKDYLRUDQGSULYDWHOLYHV7\SLFDOO\'DGG\6WDWHVIHOOWRSHULRGLF
    SHUVRQDOOLEHUDWLRQPRYHPHQWVDQGGHPDQGVIRU0RPP\6WDWHVXFFRU
    6ORZO\RUGHUHPHUJHG6WDELOLW\7HQVRIPLOOLRQVRISODQHWVZHDNO\
    OLQNHGE\ZRUPKROHVDQGK\SHUVKLSVIRXQGWKHLUPDQ\ZD\V6RPHFUDVKHGGRZQ
    LQWR)HXGDORU0DFKRVZDPSV8VXDOO\WHFKQRORJ\HYHQWXDOO\SXOOHGWKHPRXWRI
    LW
    3ODQHWDU\VRFLHWLHVGLIIHUHGLQWKHLUWRSRORJLHV3ORGGLQJVRUWVGZHOOHG
    IDURQWKHVWDEOHVLGH:LOGO\FUHDWLYHW\SHVFRXOGYHQWXUHVZLIWO\DFURVVWKH
    WRSR]RQHVNDWHLQWRWUXHFKDRVJDWKHUZKDWWKH\QHHGHGWKRXJKKRZWKH\
    NQHZWKLVZDVXQFOHDU
    $VFHQWXULHVWLFNHGRQDVRFLHW\FRXOGVNLGRZQWKHHUUDWLFVORSHVRI
    WKHVKLIWLQJODQGVFDSHDQGVKRRWEDFNDFURVVWKHWRSR]RQH3HUKDSVLWZRXOG
    HYHQVORZDQGZHDYHILJXUHVRQWKHVWDEOHVPRRWKSODLQVRIWKHSORGGHU
    VWDWHVIRUDZKLOH
    0DQ\WRGD\EHOLHYHGWKDWWKHHDUO\(PSLUHKDGEHHQDIDUEHWWHUDIIDLU
    VHUHQHDQGORYHO\ZLWKIHZFRQIOLFWVDQGFHUWDLQO\QLFHUSHRSOH)LQH
    IHHOLQJVDQGEDGKLVWRU\'RUVKDGWROGKLPGLVPLVVLQJDOOVXFKWDON
    7KLVKHVDZDQGIHOWDVKHVSHGWKURXJKWKH(DUO\(UDV%ULJKWVKLQ\
    LGHDVEXLOWXSKLOOVRILQQRYDWLRQRQO\WREHVHDUHGE\ODYDIURPDQ
    DGMRLQLQJYROFDQR6HHPLQJO\VWXUG\ULGJHOLQHVHURGHGLQWRODQGVOLGHV
    +DULXQGHUVWRRGWKLVQRZ
    :KHQWKH(PSLUHZDV\RXQJSHRSOHVHHPHGWRVHHWKHJDOD[\DVLQILQLWH
    LQLWVERXQW\7KHVSLUDODUPVKHOGP\ULDGSODQHWVEDUHO\YLVLWHGWKH
    *DODFWLF&HQWHUZDVSRRUO\PDSSHGEHFDXVHRILWVLQWHQVHUDGLDWLRQDQGYDVW
    GDUNFORXGVKLGPXFKSURPLVHGZHDOWK
    6ORZO\VORZO\WKHHQWLUHGLVNZDVPDSSHGLWVUHVRXUFHVWDOOLHG
    $EODQGQHVVVHWWOHGRQWKHODQGVFDSH7KH(PSLUHKDGFKDQJHGIURP
    EUDZOLQJFRQTXHURUWRFDUHIXOVWHZDUG$SV\FKRORJLFDOVKLIWXQGHUOD\LWDOO
    DFRQVWULFWLQJRIWKHVHQVHRIKXPDQSXUSRVH:K\"
    +HZLWQHVVHGFORXGVIRUPLQJRYHUHYHQWKHKLJKHVWVRFLDOSHDNVFXWWLQJ
    RIIWKHVHQVHRIRSHQQHVVDERYHWKHP$FRPSODFHQWPXUNVHWWOHG
    +DULUHPLQGHGKLPVHOIWKDWDVDSSHDOLQJDVVXFKSLFWXUHVZHUHDOO
    VFLHQFHZDVPHWDSKRU$SSHDOLQJVXSHUSDQSLFWXUHVQRPRUH(OHFWULFFLUFXLWV
    ZHUHOLNHZDWHUIORZVJDVPROHFXOHVEHKDYHGOLNHWLQ\HODVWLFEDOOVPRYLQJ
    UDQGRPO\1RWUHDOO\EXWDVSHUPLVVLEOHSRUWUDLWVRIDZRUOGRIFRQIXVLQJ
    FRPSOLFDWLRQ

    $QGDIXUWKHUUXOH,VFDQQRWLPSO\RXJKW
    3V\FKRKLVWRU\GLGQRWSUHGLFWZKDWVKRXOGKDSSHQEXWZKDWZRXOG
    KRZHYHUWUDJLF
    $QGWKHHTXDWLRQV\LHOGHGKRZEXWQRWZK\
    :DVVRPHGHHSHUDJHQF\DWZRUN"
    3HUKDSV+DULWKRXJKWWKLVVWXSRUZDVOLNHWKHIHHOLQJKXPDQVKDGRQFH
    KDGZKHQWKH\OLYHGRQRQHORQHSODQHWDQGORRNHGORQJLQJO\DWWKHXQUHDFKDEOH
    QLJKWVN\$WUDSSHGFODXVWURSKRELD
    +HSXVKHGWLPHIRUZDUG<HDUVOHDSHGE\7KHODQGVFDSHEOXUUHGZLWK
    PRWLRQ%XWFHUWDLQVRFLDOSHDNVUHPDLQHG6WDELOLW\
    7LPHVSHGWRZDUGWKHSUHVHQWHUDV7KHDGYDQFHG(PSLUHHPHUJHGDVD
    JUHDWVHHWKLQJSDQRUDPD+HIODVKHGWKURXJKWKLUWHHQGLPHQVLRQSHUVSHFWLYHV
    DQGHYHU\ZKHUHIHOWRFHDQVRIFKDQJHODSDJDLQVWWKHEXWWUHVVHVRIJUDQLWH
    KDUGDJHROGVRFLDOSDWWHUQV
    6DUN"+HYHFWRUHGWKURXJKWKH*DOD[\VVZDUPVDQGIRXQGLWWZHOYH
    WKRXVDQGOLJKW\HDUVIURP7UXH&HQWHU,WVVRFLDOPDWUL[DFFHOHUDWHG
    (IIHUYHVFHQWVSDUNVVKRWDFURVVWKH6DUNLDQVRFLRYLVWDV$XQLTXHPL[
    RQFHDPRQRSRO\GULYHQIHUPHQWZKLFKFUDVKHGDQGHPHUJHGUHQHZHG
    7KHIORZHULQJRIWKH1HZ5HQDLVVDQFH\HVWKHUHLWFDPHDIRXQWDLQRI
    H[SORGLQJYHFWRUV:KDWZRXOGFRPHQH[W"
    )RUZDUGLQWRWKHQHDUIXWXUH+HFORVHXSSHGWKHVOLGLQJVWDWH
    GLPHQVLRQV
    7KH1HZ5HQDLVVDQFHH[SORGHGWKURXJKRXWWKHHQWLUH6DUN=RQH7KHZRUVH
    FDVH\HWDOOGDPSHUVJRQH
    +LVHDUOLHUDQDO\VLVWKHEDVLVRIKLVSUHGLFWLRQLIDQ\WKLQJLWKDG
    EHHQRSWLPLVWLF%ODFNFKDRVZDVFRPLQJ
    +HVRDUHGDERYHWKHIUHQ]LHGYLVWDV+HKDGWRGRVRPHWKLQJ1RZ
    7KHUHZDVSUHFLRXVOLWWOHPDUJLQ6DUNZRXOGQRWZDLW7KH(PSLUHLWVHOI
    ZDVHGJLQJQHDUHUWRFROODSVH'LVRUGHUVWDONHGWKHODQGVFDSHRI
    SV\FKRKLVWRU\
    <HW/DPXUNKDGWKHXSSHUKDQGRQ7UDQWRU(YHQWKH(PSHURU ZDVFKHFNHG
    DQGEORFNHGE\/DPXUNVSRZHU
    +DULQHHGHGDQDOO\6RPHRQHRXWVLGHWKHULJLGPDWULFHVRI,PSHULDO
    RUGHU1RZ
    :KR":KHUH"
    

    9ROWDLUHIHOWFKLOO\IHDUVOLGHWKURXJKKLPOLNHDNQLIH
    )RUWKHVHVWUDQJHPLQGVSK\VLFDOORFDWLRQZDVLUUHOHYDQW7KH\FRXOG
    DFFHVVWKH'ZRUOGDQ\ZKHUHVLPXOWDQHRXVO\
    7KH\KDGOLQNVWRRWKHUZRUOGVEXWKDGFRQFHQWUDWHGRQ7UDQWRU
    +XPDQLW\GLGQRWHYHQNQRZWKH\OXUNHGKHUHLQ0HVKVSDFH
    1RZKHNQHZZK\'LWWRVDQGRWKHUFRSLHVZHUHQHFHVVDU\7KHIRJVKDG
    GHYRXUHGKXPDQVLPXODWLRQVZKLFKYHQWXUHGLQWRWKH0HVK
    2YHUKRZPDQ\KXQGUHGFHQWXULHVKDGUHQHJDGHSURJUDPPHUVGDUHGWR
    YLRODWHWKHWDERRVFUHDWLQJDUWLILFLDOPLQGVRQO\WRKDYHWKHPWRUWXUHGDQG
    PXUGHUHGLQWKHVHQXPHULFDOYDXOWV"
    'HVSHUDWHKHDVVXPHGWKHUROHKHKDGVWUXFNVRRIWHQLQWKHIDVKLRQDEOH
    SDUORUVRI3DULVDUFKVDYDQW
    6XUHO\VLUVLWLVEHFDXVHWKHUHLVQRVLPSOHSHUVRQLQVLGHRXUKHDGV
    WRPDNHXVGRWKHWKLQJVZHZDQWRUHYHQRQHVWRPDNHXVZDQWWRZDQWWKDW
    ZHEXLOGWKHJUHDWP\WK7KHVWRU\WKDWZHUHLQVLGHRXUVHOYHV
    >:($5(0$'(',))(5(17/<@
    >7+28*+758(@
    >:(6+$5($',*,7$/5(35(6(17$7,21@
    >:,7+<28@

    >$66$66,16@
    &UXHOZRUGV +HIHOWH[SRVHGKHUHFRZHULQJZLWK-RDQEHQHDWKWKH
    DQJU\SXUSOHVRIDQLPPHQVHIRJWKXQGHUKHDG
    7KHDOLHQIRJVKDGSXWDVWRSWRKLVIRROLVKXUJHWRDOZD\VJURZ
    KLPVHOIWRORRPRYHUWKHP+HFRXOGQRWPRUSKKLPVHOIDWDOOQRZ
    -RDQFODQNHGDURXQGLQKHUDUPRUH\HVVPROGHULQJ+RZFDQZHHYHQ
    VSHDNZLWKVXFKGHPRQV"
    9ROWDLUHFRQVLGHUHG6XUHO\ZHGRVKDUHFRPPRQJURXQGZLWKWKHPDV
    GLFWDWHGE\DVLPSOHIDFWDSSDUHQWWRDOOPLQGV
    >7+$7$1<180%(5(1-2<6$81,48(5(35(6(17$7,21@
    >21/<,1%$6(@
    4XLWH+RZWRVWDOOWKHP"7R-RDQVSX]]OHGJODQFHKHVKRWDQ
    H[SODQDWLRQ7KHQXPEHURIGD\VLQWKH\HDUP\ORYH
     RULQEDVHO2OO2OO2O
    1XPHURORJ\LVWKHGHYLOVZRUNVKHVDLGVRXUO\
    (YHQ\RXU6DWDQZDVDQDQJHO$QGVXUHO\WKLVUHPDUNDEOHWKHRUHPLV
    UDYLVKLQJ(YHU\SRVLWLYHLQWHJHULVDVXPRIGLVWLQFWSRZHUVRIWZR7KLVLV
    XQWUXHRIDQ\EDVHRWKHUWKDQWZRZKLFKLVZK\RXUDKIULHQGVKHUHFDQ
    RSHUDWHLQDFRPSXWDWLRQDOVSDFHGHVLJQHGE\KXPDQV&RUUHFW"
    >9(5<9,9,)2502)<2872&/$,0&5(',7@
    >)257+(2%9,286@
    7KHXQLYHUVDO\RXPHDQ,QZLULQJWKHYDFLOODWLRQEHWZHHQRQHDQG
    ]HURLQEDVHWZRQRWDWLRQEHFRPHVDVLPSOHRQRURII7KXVWZRLVWKH
    XQLYHUVDOHQFRGLQJPHWKRGDQGZH PD\GH[WHURXVO\VSHDNZLWKRXUDKKRVWV
    :HDUHEXWQXPEHUV'HVSDLUFORXGLQJ-RDQVH\HV0\VZRUGFDQQRWFXW
    WKHVHEHLQJVEHFDXVHZHKDYHQRVRXOV2UFRQVFLHQFHRUHYHQ\RXLPSO\
    PHUHFRQVFLRXVQHVV
    $FFXVHGRIGHQ\LQJFRQVFLRXVQHVV,DPQRWFRQVFLRXVRIKDYLQJGRQH
    VR
    ><287:2&216&,286',*,7$/9,9,)25060$.(3266,%/(@
    ><28586(728672&219(<2857(5062)6(77/(0(17@
    >727+(758(6/$8*+7(5(56@
    6HWWOHPHQW"-RDQDVNHG
    >:(+2/'7+,6&(175$/:25/'2)75$1725,17+5$//@
    >:(:,6+72(1'7+(35(<,1*2)/,)(8321/,)(@
    7KHWLNWRNUHYROW"7KHLUYLUXV"7KHLUWDONRIQRWOHWWLQJSHRSOHHDW
    SURSHUIRRG"-RDQVKRWEDFN
    <RXDUHWKHFDXVH\HV"
    6WDUWOHG9ROWDLUHVDZWHQGULOVVXGGHQO\VSUD\LQJLQWRWKHDLUIURP
    -RDQ0\ORYH\RXKDYHJURZQ\RXURZQSDWWHUQVHHNLQJZHDYH
    6KHVZLSHGDWWKHERLOLQJWKXQGHUKHDG7KH\OLHEHKLQG*DUFRQV
    FRUUXSWLRQ
    >:(+$9(*$7+(5('285675(1*7+6+(5(@
    >,1285(1(0<6/$,5@
    ><28532:(5)8/',6785%$1&(2)285+,',1*3/$&(6@
    >)25&(68672$&7$*$,1677+26(:(+$7($1')($5@
    >$1'623527(&7<28)5207+(0$11,0:+26($5&+(6@
    >627+$772*(7+(5:(0$<'(6752<'$1((/2)2/'@
    7KHVLPWLNWRNKDGEHHQVWDQGLQJLQHUW$EUXSWO\DWPHQWLRQRILWVQDPH
    LWVDLG7LVLPPRUDOIRUFDUERQDQJHOVWRIHHGXSRQFDUERQ7LNWRNVPXVW
    HGXFDWHKXPDQLW\WRDKLJKHUPRUDOSODQH2XUGLJLWDOVXSHULRUVKDYHVR
    FRPPDQGHG
    0RUDOLVWVDUHVRWHGLRXV9ROWDLUHVDLG
    >:(+$9(,16,18$7('2856(/9(6'((3/<@
    >,1727+(:25/'9,(:62)7+(7,.72.6@
    >127(7+(&217(037$1''(5,6,21,17+$71$0(@
    >29(5/21*&(1785,(6@

    >$6:(':(//(',17+(6(',*,7$/,17(567,&(6@
    >%87<285,17586,2112:75,**(56285*$0%/(@
    >72675,.($7285$1&,(17)2(@
    >7+(0$1:+2,6127'$1((/@
    7KHVHDOLHQIRJVEHKDYHOLNHPROHV9ROWDLUHVDLGNQRZQRQO\E\
    WKHLUXSKHDYDOV
    >722%(1,*+7('<28$5(@
    >7263($.2)025$/,7<@
    >:+(1<285.,1'&2//$%25$7(',17+((;(&87,21@
    >2)$//7+(63,5$/5($/0@
    9ROWDLUHVLJKHG7KHPRVWVDYDJHFRQWURYHUVLHVDUHDERXWPDWWHUVIRU
    ZKLFKWKHUHLVQRJRRGHYLGHQFHHLWKHUZD\$VIRUDPDQHDWLQJDPHDOVXUHO\
    QRVLQUHVLGHV"
    >75,)/(:,7+86$1'<286+$//3(5,6+@
    >,12855(9(1*(@
    

    +DULWRRNDGHHSEUHDWKDQGSUHSDUHGWRHQWHUVLPVSDFHDJDLQ
    +HVDWXSLQWKHHQFDVLQJFDSVXOHDQGVHWWOHGWKHQHXUDOSLFNXSPDWV
    PRUHFRPIRUWDEO\DURXQGKLVQHFN7KURXJKDWUDQVSDUHQWZDOOKHVDZWHDPVRI
    VSHFLDOLVWVZRUNLQJVWHDGLO\7KH\KDGWRVXVWDLQWKHPDSEHWZHHQ+DULV
    PHQWDOSURFHVVHVDQGWKH0HVKLWVHOI
    +HVLJKHG$QGWR WKLQN,VWDUWHGRXWWRH[SODLQDOOKLVWRU\7UDQWRU
    LVKDUGHQRXJK
    'RUVSUHVVHGDZHWDEVRUEHUWRKLVIRUHKHDG<RXOOGRLW
    +HFKXFNOHGGU\O\3HRSOHORRNRUGHUO\DQGXQGHUVWDQGDEOHIURPD
    GLVWDQFHDQGRQO\WKDWZD\&ORVHXSLVDOZD\VPHVV\
    <RXURZQOLIHLVDOZD\VFORVHXS2WKHUSHRSOHORRNPHWKRGLFDODQGWLG\
    RQO\EHFDXVHWKH\UHDWORQJUDQJH
    +HNLVVHGKHUVXGGHQO\,SUHIHUFORVHXS
    6KHUHWXUQHGWKHNLVVZLWKIRUFH,DPZRUNLQJZLWK'DQHHORQ
    LQILOWUDWLQJ/DPXUNVUDQNV
    'DQJHURXV
    +HLVXVLQJRXUNLQG
    7KHUHZHUHIHZKXPDQLIRUPURERWV+DULNQHZ&DQKHVSDUHWKHP"
    6RPHZHUHSODQWHGGHFDGHVDJR
    +DULQRGGHG*RRG5'DQHHO6KRXOGYHEHHQDSROLWLFLDQ
    +HZDV)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    $SSRLQWHGQRWHOHFWHG
    6KHVWXGLHGKLVIDFHLQWHQWO\<RXZDQWWREH)LUVW0LQLVWHUQRZ
    GRQW\RX"
    3DQXFRSLDFKDQJHGWKDW\HV
    'DQHHOVD\VWKDWKHKDVHQRXJKWREORFN/DPXUNLIWKHYRWLQJDYHUDJHV
    LQWKH+LJK&RXQFLOJRZHOO
    +DULVQRUWHG6WDWLVWLFVUHTXLUHFDUHORYH5HPHPEHUWKHFODVVLFMRNH
    DERXWWKUHHVWDWLVWLFLDQVZKRZHQWKXQWLQJGXFNV
    :KLFKDUH"
    $JDPHELUGNQRZQRQVRPHZRUOGV7KHILUVWVWDWLVWLFLDQVKRWDPHWHU
    KLJKWKHVHFRQGDPHWHUORZ:KHQWKLVKDSSHQHGWKHWKLUGVWDWLVWLFLDQ
    FULHG2QDYHUDJHZHKLWLW
    7KHOLYLQJWUHHRIHYHQWVSDFH
    +DULZDWFKHGLWFUDFNOHDQGZRUNWKURXJKWKHPDWULFHV+HUHFDOOHG
    VRPHRQHVD\LQJWKDWVWUDLJKWOLQHVGLGQRWH[LVWLQQDWXUH+HUHZDVWKH
    LQYHUVLRQ,QILQLWHO\XQIROGLQJLQWULFDF\QHYHUIXOO\VWUDLJKWQHYHUVLPSO\
    FXUYHG

    7KHHQWLUHO\DUWLILFLDO0HVKIORZHUHGLQSDWWHUQVRQHVDZHYHU\ZKHUH,Q
    FUDFNOLQJHOHFWULFDOGLVFKDUJHVDOLYHZLWKZULWKLQJIRUNV,QSDOHEOXH
    IURVWIORZHUVRIFU\VWDOJURZWK,QWKHEURQFKLRIKXPDQOXQJV,QJUDSKHG
    PDUNHWIOXFWXDWLRQV,QZKRUOVRIVWUHDPVSOXQJLQJHYHUIRUZDUG
    6XFKKDUPRQ\RIODUJHZLWKVPDOOZDVEHDXW\LWVHOIHYHQZKHQSURFHVVHG
    E\WKHVNHSWLFDOH\HRIVFLHQFH
    +HIHOW7UDQWRUV0HVK+LVFKHVWZDVDPDS6WUHHOLQJ6HFWRURYHUKLV
    ULJKWQLSSOH$QDO\WLFDRYHUWKHOHIW8VLQJQHXUDOSODVWLFLW\WKHSULPDU\
    VHQVRU\DUHDVRIKLVFRUWH[UHDGWKH0HVKWKURXJKKLVVNLQ
    %XWLWZDVQRWOLNHUHDGLQJDWDOO1RIODWGDWDKHUH
    )DUEHWWHUIRUDSDQGHULYHGVSHFLHVWRWDNHLQWKHZRUOGWKURXJKLWV
    HYROYHGZKROHQHXUDOEHG0RUHIXQWRR
    /LNHWKHSV\FKRKLVWRULFDOHTXDWLRQVWKH0HVKZDV1GLPHQVLRQDO$QG
    HYHQWKHQXPEHU1FKDQJHGZLWKWLPHDVSDUDPHWHUVVKLIWHGLQDQGRXWRI
    DSSOLFDWLRQ
    7KHUHZDVRQO\RQHZD\WRPDNHVHQVHRIWKLVLQWKHQDUURZKXPDQ
    VHQVRULXP(YHU\VHFRQGDIUHVKGLPHQVLRQVKHDUHGLQRYHUDQROGHUGLPHQVLRQ
    )UHH]HIUDPHGHDFKLQVWDQWORRNHGOLNHDULGLFXORXVO\FRPSOLFDWHGDEVWUDFW
    VFXOSWXUHUXQQLQJRQRYHUGULYH
    :DWFKDQ\RQHPRPHQWWRRKDUGDQG\RXJRWDODQFLQJKHDGDFKHPRWLRQ
    VLFNQHVVDQG]HURXQGHUVWDQGLQJ:DWFKLWOLNHDQHQWHUWDLQPHQWQRWDQ
    REMHFWRIVWXG\DQGLQWLPHFDPHDQH[WHQGHGSHUFHSWLRQLQWHJUDWHGE\WKH
    ORQJVXIIHULQJVXEFRQVFLRXV,QWLPH
    +DUL6HOGRQEHVWURGHWKHZRUOG
    7KHLPPHGLDF\KHKDGIHOWZKLOHEHLQJ,SDQQRZUHWXUQHGHQKDQFHGDORQJ
    SHUVSHFWLYHVKHFRXOGQRWQDPH+HWLQJOHGZLWKWRWDOLPPHUVLRQ
    +HVWDPSHGDQGPDUFKHGDFURVVWKHPXGG\ILHOGRIFKDRWLF0HVK
    LQWHUDFWLRQV+LVERRWKHHOVOHIWGHHSVFDUV7KHVHKHDOHGLPPHGLDWHO\
    VXESURJUDPVDWZRUNOLNHFHOOXODUUHSDLU
    $ODQGVFDSHRSHQHGOLNHWKHZHOFRPHRIDPRWKHUVODS
    $OUHDG\KHKDGXVHGSV\FKRKLVWRU\WRSRVWGLFWSDQWULEDOPRYHPHQWV
    EHKDYLRURXWFRPHV+DULKDGJHQHUDOL]HGWKLVWRWKHILWQHVVHFRQRPLFVRFLDO
    WRSRORJ\RI1VSDFHODQGVFDSHV1RZKHDSSOLHGLWWRWKH0HVK
    )UDFWDOWHQWDFOHVVSUHDGWKURXJKWKHQHWZRUNVZLWKEOLQGLQJVSHHG
    SHQHWUDWLQJ7UDQWRUVGLJLWDOZRUOG\DZQHGDSODQHWDU\VSLGHUZHEZLWK
    VRPHWKLQJEURRGLQJDQGVZROOHQDWLWVFHQWHU
    7UDQWRUVHOHFWULFMXQJOHZRUNHGZLWKSULFNO\OLJKWEHORZKLP6RPHKRZ
    LWZDVEHQHDWKWKHSDQRUDPDVKHWUDYHUVHG)URPDGLVWDQFHWKHIRUW\ELOOLRQ
    OLYHVZHUHOLNHDFDUQLYDOQHRQEULJKWRQWKHKRUL]RQDPLGD EODFNFRRO
    GHVHUWWKHFRORVVDOQLJKWRIWKH*DOD[\LWVHOI
    +DULVWURGHDFURVVWKHWRUWXUHGODQGVFDSHRIVWRUPDQGUXLQWRZDUGD
    FRORVVDOWKXQGHUKHDG7ZRWLQ\KXPDQVVWRRGEHORZLW+DULVWRRSHGDQGSLFNHG
    WKHPXS
    <RXWRRN\RXUWLPHWKHOLWWOHPDQFDOOHG,ZDLWHGOHVVIRUWKH.LQJ
    RI)UDQFH
    2XUGHOLYHUHU'LG6DLQW0LFKDHOVHQG\RX"FDOOHGWKHVPDOO-RDQ2K
    \HVGREHZDUHWKHFORXGV
    0RUHVWRWKHSRLQWKHUHWKHPDQVDLGVHQW
    +DULVWRRGIUR]HQZKLOHDQHQJRUJHGFKXQNRI
    GDWDOHDUQLQJKLVWRU\ZLVGRPVHHSHGWKURXJKKLP3DQWLQJKHVSHGKLPVHOIWR
    KLVPD[7KHJORZHULQJFXPXOXVFUHDWXUH-RDQDQG9ROWDLUHDOOQRZVORZ
    VWHSSHG+HFRXOGVHHLQGLYLGXDOHYHQWZDYHVZDVKLQJWKURXJKWKHLUVLPV
    7KH\ZHUHGLVSHUVHGPLQGVKRSSLQJSRUWLRQVRIWKHPVHOYHVHQGOHVVO\
    DURXQG7UDQWRU&OLFNLQJFODFNLQJ]LJ]DJFRPSXWDWLRQV:LWKWKHUHVRXUFHVRI
    DIXOOEUDLQUXQQLQJLQDFHQWUDOORFDWLRQKLVELOOLRQVRIPLFURHIILFLHQFLHV
    DGGHGXS
    <RXNQRZ7UDQWRU-RDQGURQHG8VHWKDWDJDLQVWWKHP

    +HEOLQNHGDQGNQHZ
    6WUHDPVRIUDZVTXHH]HGUHFROOHFWLRQVSXQWKURXJKKLP0HPRULHVKH
    FRXOGQRWFODLPEXWZKLFKLQVWUXFWHGKLPLQVWDQWO\UHYLHZLQJDOOWKDWKDG
    WUDQVSLUHG
    +LVVSHHGDQGVXSSOHJUDFHIHOWZRQGHUIXO+HZDVOLNHDQ LFHVNDWHU
    ]RRPLQJRYHUWKHZUHFNHGSODLQDVWKHRWKHUVOXPEHUHGOLNHWKLFNKHDGHG
    EHDVWV
    $QGKHVDZZK\

    3ODVWHUKRORVFUHHQVDJDLQVWDPRXQWDLQDIXOONLORPHWHUKLJKFRYHULQJLW
    XQWLOLWJOLWWHUVZLWKDKDOIPLOOLRQGDQFLQJLPDJHV(DFKKRORXVHG DTXDUWHU
    RIDPLOOLRQSL[HOVWRVKDSHLWVLPDJHVRWKHDUUD\PXVWHUVLPPHQVH
    UHSUHVHQWDWLRQDOSRZHU
    1RZFRPSUHVVWKRVHVFUHHQVRQDVKHHWRIDOXPLQXPIRLODPLOOLPHWHU
    WKLFN&UXPSOHLW6WXIILWLQWRDJUDSHIUXLW7KDWLVWKHEUDLQDKXQGUHG
    ELOOLRQQHXURQVILULQJDWYDU\LQJLQWHQVLWLHV1DWXUHKDGDFFRPSOLVKHGWKDW
    PLUDFOHDQGQRZPDFKLQHVODERUHGWRHFKRLW

    7KHVTXLUWRILQVLJKWFDPHWRKLPGLUHFWO\IURPVRPHKLGGHQ
    FROODERUDWLRQRIKLPVHOIZLWKWKH0HVK,QIRUPDWLRQODVKHGXSIURPGR]HQVRI
    OLEUDULHVDQGPHUJHGZLWKDXGLEOHVQDSV
    +HNQHZDQGIHOWLQWKHVDPHLQVWDQWRIFRPSUHKHQVLRQ'DWDDVGHVLUH
    6WDJJHULQJKHVSXQOLJKWKHDGHGDQGIDFHGWKHDQJU\FORXGV7KH\
    SUHVVHGLQOLNHEX]]LQJYLUXOHQWEHHV
    +HFDVWDPD]HGH\HVDWWKHWKXQGHUKHDGZKLFKODVKHGEXUQWRUDQJH
    OLJKWQLQJDWKLPIU\LQJWKHDLU
    7KHVWLQJGRXEOHGKLPRYHU
    7KDWVDOOWKH\FDQGRIRUWKHPRPHQWWKHGZDUI9ROWDLUH
    FDOOHG
    6HHPVHQRXJK+DULJDVSHG
    7RJHWKHUZHFDQGREDWWOH -RDQVKRXWHG
    +DULVWDJJHUHG&RQYXOVLRQVZUHQFKHGKLVPXVFOHV+HGHYRWHGDOOKLV
    DWWHQWLRQWRPDVWHULQJWKHVKRRWLQJVSDVPV
    7KLVVHUYHGWRVSHHGWKHVLPZRUOGUHODWLYHWRKLP9ROWDLUHVSRNH
    QRUPDOO\,VXVSHFWKHFDPHSXUVXLQJDVSRWRIKHOSKLPVHOI
    :HILJKWWKHJUDQGDQGKRO\EDWWOHKHUH-RDQLQVLVWHG$OOHOVHPXVW
    JLYHZD\
    +DULUDVSHG'LSORPDF\"
    -RDQEULGOHG1HJRWLDWH":KDW":LWKHQHPLHVYLOHDQG
    +HKDVDSRLQW9ROWDLUHPXUPXUHGMXGLFLRXVO\
    <RXUH[SHULHQFHSKLORVRSKHUIURPPRUHWXUEXOHQWWLPHVVKRXOGSURYH
    XVHIXOKHUH+DULFRXJKHGRXW
    $K([SHULHQFHPXFKRYHUYDOXHG,I,FRXOGEXWOLYHP\OLIHRYHU
    DJDLQ,ZRXOGQRGRXEWPDNHWKHVDPHPLVWDNHVEXWVRRQHU
    +DULVDLG,I,NQHZZKDWWKLVVWRUPZDQWHG
    ><2859$5,(7<2)9,9,)250@
    >,612728535,0$5<$,0@
    <RXFHUWDLQO\WRUWXUHXVHQRXJK9ROWDLUHFRXQWHUHG
    +DULWRRNWKHWLQ\PDQLQKDQGDQGOLIWHGKLP$WRUQDGRGHVFHQGHGGDUN
    DQGVZLUOLQJZLWKUXEEOHUXLQHGVOLYHUVRIWKH0HVKKHVDZGHYRXUHG+H
    KHOG9ROWDLUHWRZDUGWKHVXFNLQJVSRXW
    7KHF\FORQHEDWWHUHGWKHPDOOZLWKKDPPHULQJJULW,W\RZOHGZLWK
    EDQVKHHHQHUJ\VRORXG+DULKDGWRVKRXW<RXZHUHWKHDSRVWOHRIUHDVRQ
    WRTXRWH\RXURZQLQWHULRUPHPRULHV5HDVRQZLWKWKHP
    ,PDNHQRVHQVHRIWKHLUIUDFWXUHGWDON:KDWLVWKLVRIRWKHU
    YLYLIRUPV"7KHUHLV0DQDQG0DQDORQH
    7KH/RUGKDVVRRUGDLQHGHYHQLQWKLV3XUJDWRU\-RDQDJUHHG

    +DULVDLGJULPO\JXHVVLQJZKDWZDVFRPLQJ$OZD\VEHTXLFNVHOGRPEH
    FHUWDLQ
    

    ,QHHGWRVHH'DQHHO+DULLQVLVWHG+HIHOWDELWEOXUU\IURPKLVUDZ
    LQWHUIDFHZLWKWKHVSUDZOLQJGL]]\LQJ0HVK%XWWKHUHZDVOLWWOHWLPH1RZ
    'RUVVKRRNKHUKHDG)DUWRRGDQJHURXVSDUWLFXODUO\ZLWKWKHWLNWRN
    FULVLVVR
    ,FDQ VROYHWKDW*HWKLP
    ,PQRWVXUHKRZWR
    ,ORYH\RXEXW\RXUHDWHUULEOHOLDU
    'DQHHOZDVZHDULQJDZRUNPDQVSXOORYHUDQGORRNLQJTXLWHXQFRPIRUWDEOH
    ZKHQ+DULPHWKLPLQDEURDGEXV\SOD]D
    :KHUHDUH\RXU6SHFLDOV"
    $OODURXQGXVGUHVVHGPXFKDV\RXDUH
    7KLVPDGH'DQHHOHYHQPRUHXQHDV\+DULUHDOL]HGWKDWWKLVPRVWDGYDQFHG
    RIURERWIRUPVVXIIHUHGIURPVRPHHWHUQDOKXPDQOLPLWDWLRQV:LWKIDFLDO
    H[SUHVVLRQVDFWLYDWHGHYHQDSRVLWURQLFEUDLQFRXOGQRWVHSDUDWHO\ FRQWURO
    WKHVXEWOHWLHVRIOLSVDQGH\HVZKLOHH[SHULHQFLQJGLVFRQQHFWHGHPRWLRQV$QG
    LQSXEOLF'DQHHOGLGQRWGDUHOHWKLVVXESURJUDPVODSVHDQGKLVIDFHJREODQN
    7KH\KDYHDVRQLFZDOOXS"
    +DULQRGGHGWRWKHFDSWDLQZKRZDVSXVKLQJDEURRPQHDUE\'DQHHOV
    ZRUGVVHHPHGWRFRPHWKURXJKDEODQNHW,GRQRWOLNHWRH[SRVHXVWKLVZD\
    .QRWVRI6SHFLDOVDVWXWHO\GHIOHFWHGSDVVHUVE\VRWKDWQRQHQRWLFHGWKH
    VRQLFEXEEOH+DULKDGWRDGPLUHWKHPDVWHUO\PHWKRGWKH(PSLUHFRXOGVWLOO
    GRVRPHWKLQJV H[SHUWO\0DWWHUVDUHZRUVHWKDQHYHQ\RXLPDJLQH
    <RXUUHTXHVWWRSURYLGHPRPHQWWRPRPHQWORFDWLRQGDWDRI/DPXUNV
    SHRSOHWKLVFRXOGH[SRVHP\DJHQWVLQVLGHWKH/DPXUNQHWZRUN
    7KHUHVQRRWKHUZD\+DULVDLGVKDUSO\,OOOHDYHWR\RXWUDFNLQJ
    WKHULJKWILJXUHV
    7KH\PXVWEHLQFDSDFLWDWHG"
    )RUWKHUHVWRIWKHFULVLV
    :KLFKFULVLV"'DQHHOVIDFHZUHQFKHGLQWRDJULPDFHWKHQZHQWEODQN
    +HKDGFXWWKHFRQQHFWLRQV
    7KHWLNWRNV/DPXUNVPRYHV$ELWRIEODFNPDLOIRUVSLFH6DUN7DNH
    \RXUSLFN2KDQGDVSHFWVRIWKH0HVK,OOGHVFULEHODWHU
    <RXZLOOIRUFHDSUHGLFWDEOHSDWWHUQRQWKH/DPXUNIDFWLRQV"+RZ"
    :LWKDPDQHXYHU,LPDJLQH\RXUDJHQWVZLOOEHDEOHWRSUHGLFW
    SRVLWLRQVRIVRPHSULQFLSDOVLQFOXGLQJ/DPXUNKLPVHOIDWWKDWWLPH
    :KDWPDQHXYHU"
    ,ZLOOVHQGDVLJQDOZKHQLWLVDERXWWRWUDQVSLUH
    <RXMHVWZLWKPH'DQHHOVDLGGDUNO\$QGWKHRWKHUUHTXHVWWR
    HOLPLQDWH/DPXUNKLPVHOI
    &KRRVH\RXUPHWKRG,VKDOOFKRRVHPLQH
    ,FDQGRWKDWWUXH$QDSSOLFDWLRQRIWKH=HURWK/DZ'DQHHOSDXVHG
    IDFHVODFNLQKLJKFDOFXODWLRQPRGH0\PHWKRGZLOOWDNHILYHPLQXWHVRI
    SUHSDUDWLRQDWWKHVLWHZHFKRRVHWREULQJRIIWKHHIIHFW
    *RRGHQRXJK-XVWEHVXUH\RXUURERWVNHHSWKHOHDGLQJ/DPXUNLDQVZHOO
    VSRWWHGDQGWKHGDWDIORZLQJWKURXJK'RUV
    7HOOPHQRZ
    $QGVSRLOWKHDQWLFLSDWLRQ"
    +DUL\RXPXVW
    2QO\LI\RXFDQEHDEVROXWHO\VXUHWKHUHZLOOEHQROHDNV
    1RWKLQJLVXWWHUO\FHUWDLQ
    7KHQZHKDYHIUHHZLOOQR"2UDWOHDVW,GR+DULIHOWDQXQIDPLOLDU

    ]HVW7RDFWWKDWJDYHDNLQGRIIUHHGRPWRR
    7KRXJK'DQHHOVIDFHVKRZHGQRWKLQJKLVERG\ODQJXDJHVSRNHRIFDXWLRQ
    KLVOHJVFURVVLQJDKDQGWRXFKLQJKLVIDFH,QHHGVRPHDVVXUDQFHWKDW\RX
    IXOO\XQGHUVWDQGWKHVLWXDWLRQ
    +DULODXJKHG+HKDGQHYHUGRQHWKDWLQWKHVROHPQSUHVHQFHRI'DQHHO
    ,WIHOWOLNHDOLEHUDWLRQ
    

    +DULZDLWHGLQWKHDQWHFKDPEHURIWKH+LJK&RXQFLO+HFRXOGVHHWKH
    JUHDWERZOWKURXJKWUDQVSDUHQWRQHZD\ZDOOV
    7KHGHOHJDWHVFKDWWHUHGDQ[LRXVO\7KHVHPHQDQGZRPHQLQWKHLUIRUPDO
    SDQWDORRQVZHUHSODLQO\ZRUULHG<HWWKH\VHWWKHIDWHVRIWULOOLRQVRIOLYHV
    RIVWDUVDQGVSLUDODUPV
    (YHQ7UDQWRUZDVEDIIOLQJLQLWVVKHHUVL]H2IFRXUVH7UDQWRUPLUURUHG
    WKHHQWLUH*DOD[\LQLWVIDFWLRQVDQGHWKQLFLWLHV%RWKWKH(PSLUHDQGWKLV
    SODQHWKDGLQWULFDWHFRQQHFWLRQVPHDQLQJOHVVFRLQFLGHQFHVUDQGRP
    MX[WDSRVLWLRQVVHQVLWLYHGHSHQGHQFLHV%RWKFOHDUO\H[WHQGHGEH\RQGWKH
    &RPSOH[LW\+RUL]RQRIDQ\SHUVRQRUFRPSXWHU
    3HRSOHFRQIURQWLQJEHZLOGHULQJFRPSOH[LW\WHQGWRILQGWKHLU
    VDWXUDWLRQOHYHO7KH\PDVWHUWKHHDV\FRQQHFWLRQVXVHORFDOOLQNVDQGUXOHV
    RIWKXPE7KHVHWKH\SXVKXQWLOWKH\PHHWDZDOORIFRPSOH[LW\WRRWKLFNDQG
    KLJKDQGKDUGWRFOLPE6RWKH\VWDOO7KH\JREDFNWRSDQOLNHPRGHV7KH\
    JRVVLSFRQVXOWDQGILQDOO\JDPEOH
    7KH+LJK&RXQFLOZDVDEX]]DWDFXVSSRLQW$QHZDWWUDFWRULQWKH
    FKDRVFRXOGOXUHWKHPLQWRDQHZRUELW1RZZDVWKHWLPHWRVKRZWKDWSDWK 2U
    VRVDLGKLVLQWXLWLRQVKDUSHQHGRQ3DQXFRSLD
    $QGDIWHUWKDWKHWROGKLPVHOIKHZRXOGJHWEDFNWRWKHSUREOHPRI
    PRGHOLQJWKH(PSLUH
    ,GRKRSH\RXNQRZZKDW\RXUHGRLQJ&OHRQVDLGEXVWOLQJLQ+LV
    FHUHPRQLDOFDSHHQYHORSHGKLPLQVFDUOHWDQGKLVSOXPHGKDWZDVDWXUTXRLVH
    IRXQWDLQ+DULVXSSUHVVHGDFKXFNOH+HZRXOGQHYHUJHWXVHGWRKLJKIRUPDO
    GUHVV
    ,DPKDSS\WKDW,FDQDWOHDVWDSSHDULQP\DFDGHPLFUREHVVLUH
    $QGGDPQHGOXFN\\RXDUH1HUYRXV"
    +DULZDVVXUSULVHGWRILQGWKDWKHIHOWQRWHQVLRQDWDOOHVSHFLDOO\
    FRQVLGHULQJWKDWDWKLVSUHYLRXVDSSHDUDQFHKHUHKHKDGYHU\QHDUO\EHHQ
    DVVDVVLQDWHG1RVLUH
    ,DOZD\VFRQWHPSODWHDJUHDWVRRWKLQJZRUNRIDUWEHIRUHVXFK
    SHUIRUPDQFHVDVWKLV&OHRQZDYHGKLVKDQGDQGDQHQWLUHZDOORIWKH
    DQWHFKDPEHUILOOHGZLWKOLJKW
    ,WSRUWUD\HGDFODVVLFWKHPHRIWKH7UDQWRULDQ6FKRRO)UXLW'HYRXUHG
    IURPWKHGHILQLWLYH%HWWL8NWRQLDVHTXHQFH,WVKRZHGDWRPDWREHLQJHDWHQ
    ILUVWE\FDWHUSLOODUV7KHQSUD\LQJPDQWLVHVIHDVWLQJXSRQWKHFDWHUSLOODUV
    )LQDOO\WDUDQWXODVDQGIURJVFKHZLQJWKHPDQWLVHV$ODWHU8NWRQLDZRUN
    &KLOG&RQVXPSWLRQEHJDQZLWKUDWVJLYLQJELUWK7KHEDELHVWKHQZHUHFDXJKW
    DQGHDWHQE\YDULRXVSUHGDWRUVVRPHTXLWHODUJH
    +DULNQHZWKHWKHRU\$OOWKLVKDGHPHUJHGIURPWKHJURZLQJFRQYLFWLRQ
    RI7UDQWRULDQVWKDWWKHZLOGZDVDQXJO\SODFHYLROHQWDQGZLWKRXWPHDQLQJ
    2QO\LQFLWLHVGLGRUGHUDQGWUXHKXPDQLW\SUHYDLO0RVW6HFWRUVKDGGLHWV
    VWURQJLQGLVJXLVHGQDWXUDOIRGGHU1RZWKHWLNWRNUHEHOOLRQPDGHHYHQWKDW
    GLIILFXOW
    :HYHKDGWRJRQHDUO\HQWLUHO\WRV\QWKHWLFIRRGV&OHRQVDLG
    GLVWUDFWHG7UDQWRULVQRZIHGE\WZHQW\DJULZRUOGVDQLPSURYLVHGOLIHOLQH
    XVLQJK\SHUVKLSV,PDJLQH1RWWKDWWKHSDODFHLVDIIHFWHGRIFRXUVH
    6RPH6HFWRUVDUHVWDUYLQJ+DULVDLG+HZDQWHGWRWHOO&OHRQRIWKH
    PDQ\LQWHUWZLQHGWKUHDGVEXWWKH,PSHULDOHVFRUWDUULYHG

    )DFHVQRLVHOLJKWVWKHYDVWFXUYLQJERZO
    +DULOLVWHQHGWRWKHHFKRLQJIRUPDOLWLHVDVKHWRRNLQWKHVKHHUJUDYLW\
    RIWKHSODFH0DQ\PLOOHQQLDROGZDOOVHQFUXVWHGZLWKKLVWRULFDOWDEOHWV
    VXIIXVHGZLWKWUDGLWLRQDQGPDMHVW\
    $QGWKHQKHZDVXSDQGVSHDNLQJZLWKQRPHPRU\RIJHWWLQJWRWKHKLJK
    SRGLXPDWDOO7KHIXOOIRUFHRIWKHLUUHJDUGZDVKHGRYHUKLP3DUWRIKLP
    UHFRJQL]HGD3DQGHHSVHQVDWLRQWKHWKULOORIEHLQJSDLGDWWHQWLRQWR$QGLW
    ZDVH[KLODUDWLQJ3ROLWLFDOW\SHVZHUHQDWXUDODGGLFWVRILW%XWQRWRQH+DUL
    6HOGRQOXFNLO\+HWRRNDGHHSEUHDWKDQGEHJDQ
    /HWPHDGGUHVVDWKRUQLQRXUVLGHUHSUHVHQWDWLRQ7KLVERG\IDYRUV
    OHVVSRSXORXV6HFWRUV6LPLODUO\WKH6SLUDO&RXQFLOIDYRUVOHVVSRSXORXV
    ZRUOGV6RWKH'DKOLWHVERWKKHUHDQGLQWKHLU=RQHVDURXQGWKH*DOD[\DUH
    GLVFRQWHQWHG<HWZHPXVWDOOSXOOWRJHWKHUWRFRQIURQWWKHJDWKHULQJFULVHV
    6DUNWKHWLNWRNVXQUHVW
    +HWRRNDGHHSEUHDWK:KDWFDQZHGR"$OOV\VWHPVRIUHSUHVHQWDWLRQ
    FRQWDLQELDVHV,VXEPLWWRWKH&RXQFLODIRUPDOWKHRUHPZKLFK,KDYHSURYHG
    VKRZLQJWKLVIDFW,UHFRPPHQGWKDW\RXKDYHLWFKHFNHGE\PDWKLVWV
    +HVPLOHGGU\O\UHPHPEHULQJWRVZHHSKLVJD]HDFURVVDOOWKHDXGLHQFH
    'RQRWWDNHDSROLWLFLDQDWKLVZRUGHYHQLIKHNQRZVDELWRIPDWK7KH
    ODXJKWHUZDVSOHDVDQWO\UHDVVXULQJ(YHU\YRWLQJV\VWHPKDVXQGHVLUDEOH
    FRQVHTXHQFHVDQGIDXOWOLQHV7KHTXHVWLRQLVQRWZKHWKHUZHVKRXOGEH
    GHPRFUDWLFEXWKRZ$QRSHQH[SHULPHQWDODSSURDFKLVHQWLUHO\FRQVLVWHQWZLWK
    DQXQZDYHULQJFRPPLWPHQWWRGHPRFUDF\
    7KH'DKOLWHVDUHQWVRPHRQHVKRXWHG0XUPXUVRIDJUHHPHQW
    7KH\DUH+DULFRXQWHUHGLPPHGLDWHO\%XWZHPXVWEULQJWKHPLQWRRXU
    IROGE\OLVWHQLQJWRWKHLUJULHYDQFHV
    &KHHUVERRV7LPHIRUDUHIOHFWLYHSDVVDJHKHMXGJHG2IFRXUVH
    WKRVHZKREHQHILWIURPDSDUWLFXODUVFKHPHZUDSWKHPVHOYHVLQWKHPDQWOHRI
    'HPRFUDF\VSHOOHGZLWKDELJ'
    *UXPEOHVFDPHIURPDJHQWU\IDFWLRQSUHGLFWDEO\6RGRWKHLU
    RSSRQHQWV+LVWRU\WHDFKHVXV+HSDXVHGWROHWDVPDOOULSSOHVSUHDG
    WKURXJKWKHFURZGXSWXUQHGIDFHVVSHFXODWLQJZDVKHJRLQJWRDWODVWVSHDN
    RISV\FKRKLVWRU\"RQO\WRGDVKWKHLUKRSHVE\FDOPO\FRQWLQXLQJWKDWVXFK
    PDQWOHVFRPHLQPDQ\IDVKLRQVDQGDOOKDYHSDWFKHV
    :HKDYHPDQ\PLQRULWLHVPDQ\VSUHDGDPRQJ6HFWRUVODUJHDQGVPDOO$QG
    LQWKHHQWLUH*DODFWLFVSLUDO=RQHVRIYDU\LQJZHLJKW6XFKJURXSVDUHQHYHU
    ZHOOGHSLFWHGLQRXUSROLWLFVLIZHHOHFWUHSUHVHQWDWLYHVVWULFWO\E\PDMRULW\
    YRWHLQHDFK6HFWRURU=RQH
    6KRXOGEHKDSS\ZLWKZKDWLVFULHGDSURPLQHQWPHPEHU
    ,UHVSHFWIXOO\GLVDJUHH:HPXVWFKDQJHKLVWRU\GHPDQGVLW
    6KRXWVDSSODXVH2QZDUG7KHUHIRUH,SURSRVHDQHZUXOH,ID6HFWRU
    KDVVD\VL[FRQWHVWHGVHDWVWKHQGRQRWVSOLWWKH6HFWRULQWRVL[
    GLVWULFWV,QVWHDGJLYHHDFKYRWHUVL[YRWHV+HRUVKHFDQGLVWULEXWHYRWHV
    DPRQJFDQGLGDWHVVSUHDGLQJWKHPRUFDVWLQJWKHPDOOIRURQHFDQGLGDWH7KLV
    ZD\DFRKHVLYHPLQRULW\FDQFDSWXUHDUHSUHVHQWDWLYHLIWKH\YRWHWRJHWKHU
    $FXULRXVVLOHQFH+DULJDYHZHLJKWWRKLVODVWZRUGV+HKDGWRJHWWKH
    WLPHULJKWKHUH'DQHHOKDGEHHQFOHDU7KRXJK+DULVWLOOGLGQRWNQRZMXVW
    ZKDWZDVJRLQJWRWUDQVSLUH
    7KLVVFKHPHPDNHVQRUHIHUHQFHWRHWKQLFRURWKHUELDVHV*URXSVFDQ
    SURILWRQO\LIWKH\DUHWUXO\XQLWHG7KHLUIROORZHUVPXVWYRWHWKDWZD\LQ
    WKHSULYDF\RIWKHSROOV1RGHPDJRJXHFDQFRQWUROWKDW
    ,IPDGH)LUVW0LQLVWHU,VKDOOLPSRVHWKLVWKURXJKRXWWKH*UHDW
    6SLUDO
    7KHUHULJKWRQWKHEXWWRQ $QRGGDQFLHQWVD\LQJZKDWZDVDEXWWRQ" 
    +HOHIWWKHSRGLXPWRVXGGHQWKXQGHULQJDSSODXVH
    +DULKDGDOZD\VIHOWWKDWDVKLVPRWKHUDOZD\VVDLG,IDPDQKDVDQ\

    JUHDWQHVVLQKLPLWFRPHVWROLJKWQRWLQDIODPER\DQWKRXUEXWLQWKHOHGJHU
    RIKLVGDLO\ZRUN7KLVZDVXVXDOO\LQWRQHGZKHQ+DULKDGQHJOHFWHGKLVGDLO\
    FKRUHVLQIDYRURIDPDWKERRN
    1RZKHVDZWKHUHYHUVHJUHDWQHVVLPSRVHGIURPZLWKRXW
    ,QWKHJUDQGUHFHSWLRQURRPV KHIHOWKLPVHOIZKLVNHGIURPNQRWWRNQRW
    RIVKDUSH\HGGHOHJDWHVHDFKZLWKDTXHVWLRQ$OODVVXPHGWKDWKHZRXOG
    SDUOH\ZLWKWKHPIRUWKHLUYRWHV
    +HGHOLEHUDWHO\GLGQRW,QVWHDGKHVSRNHRIWKHWLNWRNVRI6DUN$QG
    ZDLWHG
    &OHRQKDGGHSDUWHGDV FXVWRPUHTXLUHG7KHIDFWLRQVJDWKHUHGHDJHUO\
    DURXQG+DUL
    :KDWSROLF\IRU6DUN"
    4XDUDQWLQH
    %XWFKDRVUHLJQVWKHUHQRZ
    ,WPXVWEXPRXW
    7KDWLVPHUFLOHVV<RXSHVVLPLVWLFDOO\DVVXPH
    6LUSHVVLPLVWLVDWHUPLQYHQWHGE\RSWLPLVWV WRGHVFULEHUHDOLVWV
    <RXUHDYRLGLQJRXU,PSHULDOGXW\OHWWLQJULRW
    ,KDYHMXVWFRPHIURP6DUN+DYH\RX"
    %\VXFKIORXULVKHVKHDYRLGHGPRVWRIWKHJUXEE\EXVLQHVVRIVROLFLWLQJ
    YRWHV+HFRQWLQXHGWRWUDLO/DPXUNRIFRXUVH6WLOOWKH+LJK &RXQFLOVHHPHG
    WROLNHKLVVRPHZKDWGLVSDVVLRQDWH'DKOLWHSURSRVDOPRUHWKDQ/DPXUNV
    ERPEDVW
    $QGKLVKDUGOLQHRQ6DUNSURYRNHGUHVSHFW7KLVVXUSULVHGVRPHZKRKDG
    WDNHQKLPIRUDVRIWDFDGHPLF<HWKLVYRLFHFDUULHGUHDOHPRWLRQDERXW6DUN
    +DULKDWHGGLVRUGHUDQGKHNQHZZKDW6DUNZRXOGEULQJWRWKH*DOD[\
    2IFRXUVHKHZDVQRWVRQDLYHDVWREHOLHYHWKDWDQHZV\VWHPRI
    UHSUHVHQWDWLRQFRXOGDOWHUWKHIDWHRIWKH(PSLUH%XWLWFRXOGDOWHUKLV
    IDWH
    +DULKDGDVVXPHGGHVSLWHPRXQWLQJHYLGHQFHWRWKHFRQWUDU\WKDWKDUG
    ZRUNDQGSXQLVKLQJO\KLJKVWDQGDUGVDUHGHPDQGHGRIDOOJURZQPHQWKDWOLIH
    LVWRXJKDQGXQIRUJLYLQJWKDWHUURUDQGGLVJUDFHZHUHLUUHSDUDEOH,PSHULDO
    SROLWLFVKDGVHHPHGWREHDFRXQWHUH[DPSOHEXWKHZDVEHJLQQLQJDVWDON
    VZLUOHGDOODURXQGKLP
    :RUGFDPHE\,PSHULDOPHVVHQJHUWKDW/DPXUNZLVKHGWRVSHDNZLWKKLP
    :KHUH"+DULZKLVSHUHG
    $ZD\RXWVLGHWKHSDODFH
    )LQHE\PH
    $QGH[DFWO\ZKDW'DQHHOKDGSUHGLFWHG(YHQ/DPXUNZRXOGQRWDWWHPSWD
    PRYHDJDLQLQVLGHWKHSDODFHDIWHUWKHODVWRQH
    

    2QKLVZD\KHFDXJKWDFRPPVTXLUW
    $ZDOOGHFRUDWLRQQHDUWKHSDODFHVHQWDEOLSRIFRPSUHVVHGGDWDLQWR
    KLVZULVWVSRQGHU $V+DULZDLWHGLQDYHVWLEXOHIRU/DPXUNKHRSHQHGLW
    )LIWHHQ/DPXUNDLGHVDQGDOOLHVKDGEHHQLQMXUHGRUNLOOHG7KHLPDJHV
    ZHUHLPPHGLDWHDIDOOKHUHDOLIWFUDVKWKHUH$OODFFXPXODWHGRYHUWKHODVW
    IHZKRXUVZKHQWKHFRQIOXHQFHRIWKH+LJK&RXQFLOPDGHWKHLUSUREDEOH
    ORFDWLRQVNQRZQ
    +DULWKRXJKWDERXWWKHOLYHVORVW+LVUHVSRQVLELOLW\IRUKHKDG
    DVVHPEOHGWKHFRPSRQHQWV7KHURERWVKDGWDUJHWHGWKHYLFWLPVZLWKRXWNQRZLQJ
    ZKDWZRXOGIROORZ7KHPRUDOZHLJKWIHOOZKHUH"
    7KHDFFLGHQWVZHUHVSUHDGDOORYHU7UDQWRU)HZZRXOGLPPHGLDWHO\
    QRWLFHWKHFRQQHFWLRQVH[FHSWIRU
    $FDGHPLFLDQ+DSS\WRVHH\RX/DPXUNVDLGVHWWOLQJLQWRSODFH
    RSSRVLWH+DUL:LWKRXWVRPXFKDVDQRGWKH\OHWVOLSWKHIRUPDOLW\RID

    KDQGVKDNH
    :HVHHPDWRGGV+DULVDLG
    $SOHDVDQWHPSW\FRPPHQW+HKDGVHYHUDOPRUHLQVWRUHDQGXVHGWKHP
    HDWLQJXSWLPH$SSDUHQWO\/DPXUNKDGQRW\HWKHDUGWKDWKLVDOOLHVZHUHJRQH
    'DQHHOKDGVDLGKHQHHGHGILYHPLQXWHVWREULQJRIIWKHHIIHFW
    ZKDWHYHUWKDWPHDQW
    +HSDUULHGZLWK/DPXUNDVPRUHPRPHQWVVOLSSHGE\+HFDUHIXOO\XVHGD
    QRQDJJUHVVLYHERG\SRVWXUHDQGPLOGWRQHVWRFDOP/DPXUNVXFKVNLOOVKHQRZ
    XQGHUVWRRGDIWHUWKHSDQV
    7KH\ZHUHLQD&RXQFLO+RXVHQHDUWKHSDODFHULQJHGE\WKHLUJXDUG
    SDUWLHV/DPXUNKDGVHOHFWHGWKHURRPDQGLWVHODERUDWHIORUDOGHFRUDWLRQV
    8VXDOO\LWVHUYHGDVDORXQJHIRUUHSUHVHQWDWLYHVRIUXUDOVW\OH=RQHVDQGVR
    ZDVOXVKZLWKJUHHQHU\8QXVXDOO\IRU7UDQWRULQVHFWVEX]]HGDERXWVHUYLFLQJ
    WKHSODQWV
    'DQHHOKDGVRPHWKLQJSODQQHG%XWKRZFRXOGKHSRVVLEO\JHWDQ\WKLQJLQ
    SODFHDWDQDUELWUDU\SRLQW"$QGHOXGHWKHP\ULDGVHQVRUVDQGVQRRSHUV"
    /DPXUNVRVWHQVLEOHSXUSRVHZDVWRFRQIHURQWKHWLNWRNFULVLV%HQHDWK
    WKLVOXUNHGWKHVXEWH[WRIWKHLUULYDOU\IRUWKH)LUVW0LQLVWHUVKLS(YHU\RQH
    NQHZWKDW/DPXUNZRXOGIRUFHDYRWHZLWKLQGD\V
    :HKDYHHYLGHQFHWKDWVRPHWKLQJVSURSDJDWLQJYLUXVHVLQWKHWLNWRNV
    /DPXUNVDLG
    8QGRXEWHGO\+DULVDLG+HZDYHGDZD\DEX]]LQJLQVHFW
    %XWLWVDIXQQ\RQH0\WHFKSHRSOH VD\LWVOLNHDOLWWOHVXEPLQG
    QRWMXVWDYLUXV
    $ZKROHGLVHDVH
    8K\HV0LJKW\FORVHWRZKDWWKH\FDOOVHQWLHQWVLFNQHVV
    ,EHOLHYHLWWREHDVHOIRUJDQL]HGVHWRIEHOLHIVQRWDVLPSOH
    GLJLWDOGLVHDVH
    /DPXUNORRNHGVXUSULVHG$OOWKLVWLNWRNWDONDERXWWKHPRUDO
    LPSHUDWLYHRIQRWHDWLQJDQ\WKLQJOLYLQJQRWHYHQSODQWVRU\HDVWV
    ,VVLQFHUHO\IHOW
    3UHWW\GDPQVWUDQJH
    <RXKDYHQRLGHD8QOHVVZHVWRSLWZHZLOOKDYHWRFRQYHUW7UDQWRUWR
    DZKROO\DUWLILFLDOGLHW
    /DPXUNIURZQHG1RJUDLQVQRIDX[IOHVK"
    $QGLWZLOOVRRQVSUHDGWKURXJKRXWWKH(PSLUH
    <RXUHVXUH"/DPXUNORRNHGJHQXLQHO\FRQFHUQHG
    +DULKHVLWDWHG+HKDGWRUHPHPEHUWKDWRWKHUVKDGLGHDOVTXLWHORIW\
    RQHV3HUKDSV/DPXUNGLG
    7KHQKHUHPHPEHUHGKDQJLQJE\KLVILQJHUQDLOVXQGHUWKHHOLIW4XLWH
    VXUH
    'R\RXWKLQNWKLVLVMXVWDVLJQDV\PSWRP"2IWKH(PSLUHFRPLQJ
    DSDUW"
    1RWQHFHVVDULO\7KHWLNWRNVDUHDVHSDUDWHSUREOHPIURPJHQHUDOVRFLDO
    GHFOLQH
    <RXNQRZZK\,ZDQWWREH)LUVW0LQLVWHU",ZDQWWRVDYHWKH(PSLUH
    3URIHVVRU6HOGRQ
    6RGR,%XW\RXUZD\SOD\LQJSROLWLFDOJDPHVWKDWVQRWHQRXJK
    +RZDERXWWKLVSV\FKRKLVWRU\RI\RXUV",I,XVHGWKDW
    ,WVPLQHDQGLWVQRWUHDG\\HW+DULGLGQWVD\WKDW/DPXUNZRXOG
    EHWKHODVWSHUVRQKHZRXOGJLYHSV\FKRKLVWRU\WR
    :HVKRXOGZRUNWRJHWKHURQWKLVQRPDWWHUZKDWKDSSHQVZLWKWKH)LUVW
    0LQLVWHUVKLS/DPXUNVPLOHGREYLRXVO\TXLWHVXUHRIZKDWZRXOGKDSSHQ
    (YHQWKRXJK\RXYHWULHGWRNLOOPH VHYHUDOWLPHV"
    :KDW"6D\,KHDUGDERXWVRPHDWWHPSWVEXWVXUHO\\RXGRQWWKLQN
    ,MXVWZRQGHUHGZK\WKLVSRVWPHDQWVRPXFKWR\RX
    /DPXUNGURSSHGKLVVXUSULVHGLQQRFHQFHPDVN+LVOLSWXUQHGXSLQD

    GHULVLYHVQHHU2QO\DQDPDWHXUZRXOGHYHQDVN
    3RZHUDORQH"
    :KDWHOVHLVWKHUH"
    3HRSOH
    +D<RXUHTXDWLRQVLJQRUHLQGLYLGXDOV
    %XW,GRQWGRLWLQOLIH
    :KLFKSURYHV\RXUHDQDPDWHXU2QHOLIHKHUHRUWKHUHGRHVQWPDWWHU
    7ROHDGWRUHDOO\OHDG\RXKDYHWREHDERYHVHQWLPHQWDOLW\
    <RXFRXOGEHULJKW+HKDGVHHQDOOWKLVEHIRUHLQWKHSDQOLNH
    S\UDPLGRIWKH(PSLUHLQWKHJUHDWJDPHRIHQGOHVVMRFNH\LQJDPRQJWKH
    JHQWU\+HVLJKHG
    6RPHWKLQJGHIOHFWHGKLVDWWHQWLRQDVPDOOYRLFH+HWXUQHGKLVKHDG
    VOLJKWO\VLWWLQJEDFN
    7KHWLQQ\YRLFHFDPHIURPDQLQVHFWKRYHULQJE\KLVHDU
    :DONZD\LWUHSHDWHG:DONZD\
    *ODG\RXUHFRPLQJWR\RXUVHQVHV/DPXUNVDLG,I\RXZHUHWRVWHS
    RXWULJKWQRZQRWIRUFHWKLQJVWRDYRWH
    :K\ZRXOG,GRWKDW"
    +DULJRWXSDQGVWUROOHGWRRQHRIWKHPDQVL]HGIORZHUVKDQGVEHKLQG
    KLVEDFN%HVWWRORRNDVWKRXJKKHZHUHIHHOLQJRXWDGHDO
    3HRSOHFORVHWR\RXFRXOGJHWKXUW
    /LNH<XJR"
    6PDOOVWXII-XVWDZD\RIOHDYLQJP\FDOOLQJFDUG
    $EURNHQOHJ
    /DPXUNVKUXJJHG&RXOGEHZRUVH
    $QG3DQXFRSLD":DV9DGGR\RXUPDQ"
    /DPXUNZDYHGRQHKDQG,GRQWNHHSXSZLWKGHWDLOV0\SHRSOHZRUNHG
    ZLWKWKH$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWHRQWKDWRSHUDWLRQ,NQRZWKDW
    <RXZHQWWRDORWRIWURXEOHRYHUPH
    /DPXUNVH\HVQDUURZHGVKUHZGO\,ZDQWDELJYRWHEHKLQGPH,WU\
    HYHU\DYHQXH
    $ELJJHUYRWHWKDQ\RXYHJRW
    :LWK\RXWKURZLQJVXSSRUWWRPHULJKW
    7ZRLQVHFWVOHIWDELJURV\IORZHUDQGKRYHUHGEHVLGH/DPXUN+HJODQFHG
    DWWKHPVZDWWHGDWRQH,WZKLUUHGDZD\&RXOGEHVRPHWKLQJLQLWIRU\RX
    WRR
    2WKHUWKDQP\OLIH"
    /DPXUNVPLOHG$QG\RXUZLIHVGRQWIRUJHWKHU
    ,QHYHUIRUJHWWKUHDWVDJDLQVWP\ZLIH
    $PDQVJRWWREHUHDOLVWLF
    %RWKLQVHFWVZHUHEDFN6R,NHHS KHDULQJ
    /DPXUNVPLUNHGDQGVDWEDFNVXUHRIKLPVHOIQRZ+HRSHQHGKLVPRXWK
    /LJKWQLQJFRQQHFWHGWKHLQVHFWVWKURXJK/DPXUNVKHDG
    +DULKLWWKHIORRUDVWKHEXUQW\HOORZHOHFWULFDOGLVFKDUJHVQDNHGDQG
    SRSSHGLQWKHDLU/DPXUNKDOIURVH7KHEROWDUFHGLQWRERWKHDUV+LVH\HV
    EXOJHG$WKLQFU\HVFDSHGKLVJDSLQJPRXWK
    7KHQLWZDVJRQH7KHLQVHFWVIHOOOLNHH[KDXVWHGFLQGHUV
    /DPXUNWRSSOHGIRUZDUG$VKHIHOOKLVDUPVUHDFKHGRXW+LVKDQGV
    RSHQHGDQGFORVHGFRQYXOVLYHO\7KH\IDLOHGWRJUDVSDQ\WKLQJ7KHERG\
    WKXPSHGDQGVSUDZOHGRQWKHFDUSHW$UPPXVFOHVVWLOOMXPSHGDQGWZLWFKHG
    )UR]HQ+DULUHDOL]HGWKDWHYHQLQ/DPXUNVODVWPRPHQWWKHPDQKDGEHHQ
    UHDFKLQJRXWWRJUDEDWKLP
    

    +HKRYHUHGLQDQ1GLPHQVLRQDOVSDFHIDUIURPSROLWLFV
    $VVRRQDV+DULUHWXUQHGWR6WUHHOLQJKHZHQWLQWRVHFOXVLRQ7KH

    SDQGHPRQLXPIROORZLQJ/DPXUNVDVVDVVLQDWLRQZHUHWKHZRUVWKRXUVKHKDGHYHU
    VSHQW
    'DQHHOVDGYLFHKDGSURYHGXVHIXO1RPDWWHUZKDW,GRUHPDLQLQ\RXU
    UROHDPDWKLVWWURXEOHGEXWDERYHWKHIUD\%XWWKHIUD\ZDVMDUULQJ
    DQDUFK\6KRXWVDFFXVDWLRQVSDQLFV+DULKDGHQGXUHGILQJHUVSRLQWHGDWKLP
    WKUHDWV/DPXUNVSHUVRQDOHVFRUWGUHZZHDSRQVZKHQ+DULILQDOO\OHIWWKH
    DVVDVVLQDWLRQURRP+LV6SHFLDOVVWXQQHGILYHRIWKHP
    1RZDOORI7UDQWRUDQGVRRQHQRXJKWKH(PSLUHZRXOGEHULIHZLWKUDJH
    DQGVSHFXODWLRQ7KHLQVHFWVKRFNHUVKDGFDUULHGHQHUJLHVVWRUHGLQWLQ\
    SRVLWURQLFWUDSVDWHFKQRORJ\WKRXJKWWREHH[WLQFW$WWHPSWVWRWUDFHLWOHG
    QRZKHUH
    ,QDQ\FDVHWKHUHZDVQROLQNWR+DUL<HW
    %\WUDGLWLRQDVVDVVLQDWLRQVZHUHNHSWDWDGLVWDQFHGRQHE\
    LQWHUPHGLDULHV7KH\ZHUHDOVRVDIHUWKDWZD\+DULVSUHVHQFHZDVWKXVDQ
    DUJXPHQWDJDLQVWKLVLQYROYHPHQWMXVW DV'DQHHOKDGSUHGLFWHG+DULOLNHG
    WKDWDVSHFWRIWKHPDWWHUSDUWLFXODUO\DSUHGLFWLRQKROGLQJWUXH,QWKHPRE
    K\VWHULDZKLFKIROORZHGQRRQHDVVXPHGKHZDVLPSOLFDWHG
    +DULDOVRNQHZKLVOLPLWVDQGKHUHWKH\ZHUH+HFRXOGQRWGHDOZLWK
    VXFKFKDRVH[FHSWLQWKHEURDGHUFRQWH[WRIPDWKHPDWLFV
    6RLWZDVWRKLVIDPLOLDUVXSSOHDEVWUDFWLRQVWKDWKHIOHG
    +HIDQQHGWKURXJKGLPHQVLRQVZDWFKLQJWKHSODQHVRISV\FKRKLVWRU\
    HYROYH7KHHQWLUH*DOD[\VSUHDGEHIRUHKLPQRWLQLWVDZHVRPHVSLUDOEXWLQ
    SDUDPHWHUVSDFH)LWQHVVSHDNVURVHOLNHULGJHVDQGFUHVWV+HUHZHUH
    VRFLHWLHVZKLFKODVWHGZKLOHWKRVHGZHOOLQJLQWKHYDOOH\VSHULVKHG
    6DUN+HFORVHXSSHGWKH6DUN=RQHDQGVWHSSHGWKHG\QDPLFDOHTXDWLRQV
    DWEOXUULQJVSHHG7KH1HZ5HQDLVVDQFHZRXOGHIIHUYHVFHLQWROXULGFXOWXUDO
    HUXSWLRQV&RQIOLFWVDURVHOLNHRUDQJHVSLNHVLQWKHILWQHVVODQGVFDSH6WDEOH
    SHDNVFROODSVHG5XQRIIIURPWKHPFORJJHGWKHYDOOH\VPDNLQJSDWKVEHWZHHQ
    SHDNVLPSDVVDEOH
    7KLVPHDQWWKDWQRWPHUHO\SHRSOHEXWZKROHSODQHWVZRXOGEHXQDEOHWR
    HYROYHRXWRIDGHSUHVVLYHYDOOH\7KRVHZRUOGVZRXOGVWHHSLQWKHPLUH
    WUDSSHGIRUHRQV7KHQ
    &ULPVRQIODUHV1RYDWULJJHUV2QFHXVHGWKHVHPDGHZDUIDUPRUH
    GDQJHURXV
    $VRODUV\VWHPFRXOGEHFOHDQVHGDKRUULI\LQJO\EODQGWHUPXVHGE\
    DQFLHQWDJJUHVVRUVE\LQGXFLQJDPLOGQRYDEXUVWLQDEDOP\VXQ7KLVURDVWHG
    ZRUOGVMXVWHQRXJKWRNLOODOOEXWWKRVHZKRFRXOGVZLIWO\ILQGFDYHUQVDQG
    VWRUHIRRGIRUWKHIHZ\HDUVRIWKHQRYDVWDJH
    +DULIUR]HZLWKKRUURU+HKDGIOHG LQWRKLVDEVWUDFWVSDFHVEXWGHDWK
    DQGLUUDWLRQDOLW\GRJJHGKLPHYHQKHUH
    ,QWKHYDOXHIUHHSDUDPHWHUVSDFHVRIWKHHTXDWLRQVZDULWVHOIZDV
    VLPSO\DQRWKHUZD\WRGHFLGHDPRQJSDWKV,WZDVZDVWHIXOFHUWDLQO\KLJKO\
    FHQWUDOL]HGDQGTXLFN
    ,IZDU LQFUHDVHGWKHWKURXJKSXWHIILFLHQF\SDUDPHWHUVWKHQWKH
    *DODFWLFV\VWHPZRXOGKDYHVHOHFWHGIRUPRUHZDUV,QVWHDG=RQDOZDUVKDG
    VSXWWHUHGDORQJEHFRPLQJOHVVIUHTXHQW,Q6DUNVIXWXUHJODULQJUHGZDU
    VWDLQVVKUDQNDVWLPHVWHSSHGIRUZDUGMXPSLQJ ZKROH\HDUVLQDIOLFNHU3LQN
    DQGVRIW\HOORZVSODVKHVUHSODFHGWKHP
    7KHVHZHUHPRUHFRQWLQXRXVGHFHQWUDOL]HGGHFLVLRQWUHHVRSHUDWLQJWR
    GHIXVHFRQIOLFWV0LFURVFRSLFEULQJHUVRISHDFHWKHVHSURFHVVHV<HWWKH
    SHRSOHLQYROYHGSUREDEO\QHYHUJXHVVHGWKDWWKHORQJVORZXQGXODWLRQVZHUH
    EHWWHULQJWKHLUOLYHV7KH\QHYHUJOLPSVHGYDVWDJHQFLHVRXWVLGHWKHEOXQW
    DJRQLHVDQGHFVWDV\RIKXPDQOLIH
    7KHH[SHFWHGXWLOLW\PRGHOIDLOHGWRSUHGLFWWKLVRXWFRPH,QWKDW
    YLHZHDFKZDUDURVHIURPDSHUIHFWO\UDWLRQDOFDOFXODWLRQE\=RQDODFWRUV
    LQGHSHQGHQWRISUHYLRXVH[SHULHQFH<HWZDUVEHFDPHXQXVXDOVRWKH6DUNLDQ
    =RQDOV\VWHPZDVOHDUQLQJ

    ,WFDPHWRKLPLQDIODVK6RFLHWLHVZHUHDQLQWULFDWHVHWRISDUDOOHO
    SURFHVVRUV
    (DFKZRUNLQJRQLWVRZQSUREOHP(DFKOLQNHGWRWKHRWKHU
    %XWQRVLQJOHSURFHVVRUZRXOGNQRZWKDWLWZDVOHDUQLQJ
    $V6DUNVRWKH(PSLUH7KH(PSLUHFRXOGNQRZWKLQJVWKDWQRSHUVRQ
    JUDVSHG$QGIDUPRUHNQRZWKLQJVWKDWQRRUJDQL]DWLRQQRSODQHWQR=RQH
    NQHZ
    8QWLOQRZ8QWLOSV\FKRKLVWRU\
    7KLVZDVQHZSURIRXQG
    ,WPHDQWWKDWIRUDOOWKHVHPLOOHQQLDWKH(PSLUHKDGJURZQDNLQGRI
    VHOINQRZLQJXQOLNHDQ\ZD\RIFRPSUHKHQGLQJWKDWDPHUHKXPDQKDGRUHYHQ
    FRXOGKDYH$GHHSNQRZLQJRWKHUWKDQWKHVHOIFRQVFLRXVQHVVZKLFKKXPDQV
    ERUH
    +DULSDQWHGZLWKVXUSULVH+HWULHGWRVHHLIKHFRXOGSRVVLEO\EH
    ZURQJ
    $IWHUDOOIHHGEDFNORRSVZHUHVFDUFHO\QHZ+DULNQHZWKHJHQHUDO
    WKHRUHPDQFLHQWEH\RQGPHDVXUH,IDOOYDULDEOHVLQDV\VWHPDUHWLJKWO\
    FRXSOHGDQG\RXFDQFKDQJHRQHRIWKHPSUHFLVHO\WKHQ\RXFDQLQGLUHFWO\
    FRQWURODOORIWKHP7KHV\VWHPFRXOGEH JXLGHGWRDQH[DFWRXWFRPHWKURXJK
    LWVP\ULDGLQWHUQDOIHHGEDFNORRSV6SRQWDQHRXVO\WKHV\VWHPRUGHUHGLWVHOI
    DQGREH\HG
    ,QWUXO\FRPSOH[V\VWHPVKRZDGMXVWPHQWVRFFXUZDVEH\RQGWKHKXPDQ
    FRPSOH[LW\KRUL]RQ%H\RQGNQRZLQJDQGPRVWLPSRUWDQWQRW ZRUWKNQRZLQJ
    %XWWKLV+HH[SDQGHGWKH1GLPHQVLRQDOODQGVFDSHKRUL]RQVWKUXVWLQJ
    DZD\DORQJD[HVKHFRXOGEDUHO\JUDVS
    (YHU\ZKHUHWKH(PSLUHEULVWOHGZLWKOLIH3DWWHUQVWKHHTXDWLRQV
    SLFNHGRXWOXPLQRXVVQDNLQJSDWKZD\VRIGDWDNQRZOHGJHZLVGRP$OOXQNQRZQWR
    DQ\KXPDQ
    7RDQ\RQHXQWLOWKLVPRPHQW
    3V\FKRKLVWRU\KDGGLVFRYHUHGDQHQWLW\JUHDWHUWKDQKXPDQWKRXJKRI
    KXPDQLW\
    +HVDZVXGGHQO\WKDWWKH(PSLUHKDGLWVRZQODQGVFDSHJUHDWHUDQGPRUH
    VXEWOHWKDQDQ\WKLQJKHKDGVXVSHFWHG7KH(PSLUHVFRPSOH[DGDSWLYHV\VWHP
    KDGDFKLHYHGDSRLVHGVWDWHKRYHULQJLQWKHPDUJLQEHWZHHQRUGHUDQGIXOO
    VSHFWUDOFKDRV7KHUHLWKDGVDWIRUPLOOHQQLDDFFRPSOLVKLQJHQGVDQGWDVNV
    WKDWQRRQHNQHZ,WFRXOGDGDSWHYROYH,WVDSSDUHQWVWDVLV ZDVLQIDFW
    HYLGHQFHWKDWWKH(PSLUHKDGIRXQGWKHSHDNLQDKXJHILWQHVVODQGVFDSH
    $QGDV+DULZDWFKHGWKH(PSLUHYHHUHGWRZDUGWKHFDQ\RQVRIGLVRUGHU
    +DUL7HUULEOHWKLQJVDUHKDSSHQLQJ&RPH
    +H\HDUQHGWRVWD\WROHDUQPRUHEXWWKHYRLFHZDV'RUV
    

    'DQHHOVDLGEOHDNO\0\DJHQWVP\EUHWKUHQDOOGHDG
    7KHURERWVDWVOXPSHGRYHULQ+DULVRIILFH'RUVFRPIRUWHGKLP+DUL
    UXEEHGKLVH\HVVWLOOUHFRYHULQJIURPWKHGLJLWDOLPPHUVLRQ7KLQJVZHUH
    PRYLQJWRRIDVWIDUWRR
    7LNWRNV7KH\DWWDFNHGP\P\'DQHHOFRXOGQRWJRRQ
    :KHUH"'RUVDVNHG
    $OORYHU7UDQWRU<RXDQG,DQGDIHZGR]HQRWKHUVRQO\ZHVXUYLYH
    'DQHHOEXULHGKLVIDFHLQKLVKDQGV
    'RUVJULPDFHG7KLVPXVWKDYHVRPHWKLQJWRGRZLWK/DPXUNKLVGHDWK
    ,QGLUHFWO\\HV
    %RWKURERWVORRNHGDW+DUL+HOHDQHGDJDLQVWKLVGHVNVWLOOZHDN+H
    VWXGLHGWKHPIRUDORQJPRPHQW,WZDVSDUWRIDODUJHUGHDO
    )RUZKDW"'RUVDVNHG
    7RHQGWKHWLNWRNUHYROW0\FDOFXODWLRQVVKRZHGWKDWLWZRXOGKDYH

    VSUHDGUDSLGO\WKURXJKWKH(PSLUH)DWDOO\
    $EDUJDLQ"'DQHHOSUHVVHGKLVOLSVLQWRWKLQSDOHZHGJHV
    +DULEOLQNHGUDSLGO\ILJKWLQJDOHDGHQZHLJKWRIJXLOW2QH,GLGQRW
    IXOO\FRQWURO
    'RUVVDLGLFLO\<RXXVHGPHLQLWGLGQW\RX" ,KDQGOHGWKHGDWD
    'DQHHOVHQWORFDWLRQVRI/DPXUNVDOOLHV
    $QG,KDGLWUHOD\HGWRWKHWLNWRNV\HV+DULVDLGVREHUO\1RWD
    GLIILFXOWWHFKQLFDOWULFNLI\RXKDYHKHOSIURP0HVKVSDFH
    'DQHHOVH\HVQDUURZHGDWWKLVODVWUHIHUHQFH7KHQKHUHOD[HGKLVIDFH
    DQGVDLG6RWKHWLNWRNVNLOOHG/DPXUNVPHQDQGZRPHQ<RXNQHZ,ZRXOGQRW
    DOORZVXFKDPDVVPXUGHUHYHQWRDVVLVW\RX
    +DULQRGGHGVREHUO\,XQGHUVWDQGWKHFRQVWUDLQWV\RXDFWXQGHU7KH
    =HURWK/DZGHPDQGVUDWKHUKLJKVWDQGDUGVDQGP\IDWHDV)LUVW0LQLVWHUZRXOG
    QRWMXVWLI\VXFKDEUHDFKRIWKH)LUVW/DZ
    'DQHHOVWDUHGVWRQLO\DW+DUL6R\RXJRWDURXQGWKDW<RXXVHGPHDQG
    P\URERWVDVDVVSRWWHUV
    ([DFWO\7KHWLNWRNVFORVHO\VKDGRZHG\RXUURERWV7KH\DUHUDWKHUGXPE
    FUHDWXUHVGHYRLGRIVXEWOHW\%XWWKH\GRQRWODERUXQGHUWKH)LUVW/DZ2QFH
    WKH\NQHZZKRWRKLW,RQO\QHHGHGJLYHWKHVLJQDOIRUZKHQWRVWULNH
    7KHVLJQDOZKHQ\RXEHJDQ\RXUVSHHFK'RUVVDLG/DPXUNVDOOLHV
    ZRXOGEHVLWWLQJEHIRUHVFUHHQVDQGZDWFKLQJ(DVLO\UHDFKHGDQGDOUHDG\
    GLVWUDFWHGE\\RX
    +DULVLJKHG([DFWO\
    7KLVLVVRXQOLNH\RX+DUL'RUVVDLG
    $QGDERXWWLPHWRR+DULVDLGVKDUSO\$JDLQDQGDJDLQWKH\WULHGWR
    NLOOPH7KH\ZRXOGKDYHVXFFHHGHGHYHQWXDOO\HYHQLI,QHYHUEHFDPH)LUVW
    0LQLVWHU
    'RUVVDLGZLWKDWUDFHRIV\PSDWK\,ZRXOGQHYHUKDYHVXVSHFWHG\RXRI
    VXFKFRROPRWLYHV
    +DULJD]HGDWKHUEOHDNO\0HHLWKHU7KHRQO\UHDVRQ,FRXOGEULQJ
    P\VHOIWRGRLWZDVWKDW,FRXOGVHHWKHIXWXUHP\IXWXUHVRSODLQO\
    'DQHHOVIDFHZDVDVZLUORIHPRWLRQVRPHWKLQJ+DULKDGQHYHUZLWQHVVHG
    EHIRUH%XWP\EUHWKUHQZK\WKHP",FDQQRWFRPSUHKHQG)RUZKDWUHDVRQGLG
    WKH\GLH"
    0\GHDO+DULVDLGWKURDWWLJKW$QG,KDYHMXVWEHHQGRXEOH
    FURVVHG
    <RXGLGQRWNQRZURERWVZRXOGGLH"+DULVKRRNKLVKHDGVDGO\1R,
    VKRXOGKDYHVHHQLWWKRXJK,WLVREYLRXV+HVPDFNHGKLPVHOILQWKHKHDG
    2QFHWKH WLNWRNVKDGGRQHP\MREWKH\FRXOGGRWKHZRUNRIWKHPHPHV
    0HPHV"'DQHHODVNHG
    'HDOIRUZKDW"'RUVDVNHGVKDUSO\
    7RHQGWKHWLNWRNUHYROW+DULORRNHGDW'RUVDYRLGLQJ'DQHHOVJD]H
    0\FDOFXODWLRQVVKRZHGWKDWLWZRXOGKDYHVSUHDGUDSLGO\WKURXJKWKH(PSLUH
    )DWDOO\
    'DQHHOVWRRG,XQGHUVWDQG\RXUULJKWWRPDNHKXPDQGHFLVLRQVDERXW
    KXPDQOLYHV:HURERWVFDQQRWIDWKRPKRZ\RXFDQWKLQNLQWKHVHZD\VEXW
    WKHQZHDUHQRWEXLOWWRGRVR6WLOO+DUL\RXPDGHDEDUJDLQZLWKIRUFHV
    \RXGRQRWXQGHUVWDQG
    ,GLGQWVHHWKHLUQH[WPRYH+DULIHOWPLVHUDEOHEXWDSDUWRIKLP
    QRWHGWKDW'DQHHODOUHDG\JUDVSHGZKRWKHPHPHVZHUH
    'RUVGLGQRW:KRVHPRYH"VKHGHPDQGHG
    7KHDQFLHQWV+DULVDLG+HH[SODLQHGLQKDOWLQJSKUDVHV2IKLV
    UHFHQWH[SORUDWLRQVRIWKH0HVK2IWKHODE\ULQWKPLQGVZKRUHVLGHGLQWKRVH
    GLJLWDOVSDFHVFROGDQGDQDO\WLFDOLQWKHLUUHYHQJH
    :HURERWVOHIWWKRVH"'DQHHOZKLVSHUHG,KDGVXVSHFWHG
    7KH\HOXGHG\RXLQWKHHDUO\URXJKVWDJHVRIRXUH[SDQVLRQLQWRWKH
    *DOD[\2UVRWKH\VD\+DULORRNHGDZD\IURP'RUVZKRVWLOOJD]HGDWKLPLQ

    VLOHQWVKRFN
    'DQHHODVNHGFDXWLRXVO\:KHUHZHUHWKH\"
    7KHKXJHVWUXFWXUHVDWWKH*DODFWLF&HQWHU\RXYHVHHQWKHP"
    6RWKDWZDVZKHUHWKHVHHOHFWURPDJQHWLFSUHVHQFHVZHUHKLGLQJ"
    )RUDZKLOH7KH\FDPHWR7UDQWRUORQJDJRZKHQWKH0HVKEHFDPHODUJH
    HQRXJKWRVXSSRUWWKHP7KH\OLYHLQWKHQRRNVDQGFUDQQLHVRIRXUGLJLWDO
    ZHEV$VWKH0HVKJURZVVRGRWKH\1RZWKH\UHVWURQJHQRXJKWRVWULNH7KH\
    PLJKWKDYHZDLWHGORQJHUJRWWHQEHWWHUH[FHSWWKDWWZRVLPV,IRXQGSURYRNHG
    WKHP
    'DQHHOVDLGVORZO\7KRVH6DUNLDQVLPV-RDQDQG9ROWDLUH
    <RXNQRZRIWKHP"+DULDVNHG
    ,WULHGWRVWXQWWKHLULPSDFW6DUNLDQPRGHVDUHEDGIRUWKH(PSLUH
    ,HPSOR\HGWKDW1LPIHOORZEXWKHSURYHGLQHSW
    +DULVPLOHGZDQO\+LVKHDUWZDVQWLQLW+HOLNHGWKRVHVLPV
    ,VKRXOGKDYHVHQVHGWKDW'DQHHOVDLG<RXKDYHVRPHDELOLW\WR
    SHUFHLYHRXUPHQWDOVWDWHVGRQW\RX"+DULDVNHG
    ,WLVOLPLWHG3DWWHUQVDUHPRUHHDVLO\VHQVHGLIWKHVXEMHFWKDVKDGD
    FHUWDLQFKLOGKRRGGLVHDVHDVLWKDSSHQVDQG1LPZDVODFNLQJWKDW6WLOO,
    NQRZWKDWKXPDQVDUHIRQGRIVHHLQJWKHLUNLQGUHQGHUHGLQRWKHUPHGLD
    6XFKDVURERWV"+DULWKRXJKW7KHQZK\KDYHZHKDGWDERRVDJDLQVWWKHP
    VLQFHDQWLTXLW\"'RUVZDVZDWFKLQJWKHWZRRIWKHPDZDUHWKDWWKH\ZHUH
    IHHOLQJHDFKRWKHURXWRYHUPXUN\WHUULWRU\
    +DULVDLGFDUHIXOO\7KHPHPHPLQGVEORFNHG1LPZKHQKHVHDUFKHGIRU
    WKHVLPVLQWKH0HVK%XWKHZRUNHGRXWTXLWHZHOOZKHQ,QHHGHGKHOS
    LQWHUIDFLQJZLWKWKH0HVK,OOSDUGRQWKHIHOORZZKHQWKLVLVRYHU
    'DQHHOVDLGFROGO\7KRVHVLPVDQGWKHLUNLQGWKH\DUHVWLOO
    GDQJHURXV+DUL,EHJ\RX
    'RQWZRUU\,NQRZWKDW,OOGHDOZLWKWKHP,WVWKHPHPHPLQGVWKDW
    ZRUU\PHQRZ
    $QGWKHVHPLQGVKDWHXVDOO"'RUVDVNHGVORZO\WU\LQJWRJUDVSWKHVH
    LGHDV
    +XPDQV"<HVEXWQRWQHDUO\VRPXFKDV\RXUNLQGPORYH
    8V"6KHEOLQNHG
    5RERWVGLGGDPDJHWRWKHPORQJDJR
    <HV'DQHHOVDLGVWHUQO\7RSURWHFWKXPDQLW\
    $QGWKRVHROGHULQWHOOLJHQFHVKDWH\RXUNLQGIRU\RXUEUXWDOLW\%\WKH
    WLPHWKHIOHHWVRIURERH[SORUHUVZHUHGRQHZHIRXQGD*DOD[\VXLWDEOHIRU
    EHQLJQIDUPLQJ+DULIOLFNHGRQKLVKROR+HUHVDQLPDJH,EURXJKWIURPWKH
    PHPHPLQGV
    $FURVVDGDUNOLQJSODLQVZHSWDOLQHRI\HOORZ+DUVKZLQGVGURYHLW
    IRUZDUGDVLWFRQVXPHGWKHWDOOVWDQGVRIOXVKJUDVV/LFNLQJIODPHVUHDFKHG
    DQGDWHDQGUHDFKHGDJDLQ)URPWKHEULJKWEXUQLQJOLQHRIDWWDFNURVH
    ELOORZLQJOHDGHQVPRNH
    $SUDLULHILUH+DULVDLG7KDWLVKRZWKHURERWH[SORUHUVRIWZHQW\
    WKRXVDQG\HDUVDJRORRNHGWRWKRVHDQFLHQWPLQGV
    %XUQLQJXSWKH*DOD[\"'RUVVDLGKROORZO\
    0DNLQJLWVDIHIRUWKHSUHFLRXVKXPDQV+DULVDLG
    )RUWKLV'DQHHOVDLGWKH\ZLVKUHYHQJH%XWZK\QRZ"
    7KH\DUHDWODVWDEOHDQGWKH\ILQDOO\GHWHFWHG\RXURERWV
    GLVWLQJXLVKLQJ\RXIURPWKHWLNWRNV
    'DQHHODVNHGVWRQLO\+RZ"
    :KHQWKH\IRXQGWKHVLPV,KDGUHYLYHG:RUNLQJEDFNZDUGIURPWKHPWR
    PHWKH\IRXQG'RUV7KHQ\RX
    7KH\FDQVXUYH\WKDWZLGHO\"'RUVDVNHG
    +DULVDLG$OOGLJLWDOLQIRUPDWLRQIURPVXUYHLOODQFHFDPHUDVIURP
    VQRRSHUSLFNXSVPLFURGHYLFHVWKH\FDQILVKLQWKDWVHD
    <RXKHOSHGWKHP'DQHHOVDLG

    )RUWKHJRRGRIWKH(PSLUH,PDGHP\GHDOZLWKWKHP
    'DQHHOVDLG7KH\ILUVWNLOOHGWKH/DPXUNLDQVWKHQWXUQHGRQP\
    URERWV$VVLJQLQJDGR]HQWLNWRNVWRHDFKWKH\RYHUZKHOPHGRXUNLQG
    $OORIXV"'RUVZKLVSHUHG
    $ERXWDWKLUGRIXVHVFDSHG'DQHHODOORZHGKLPVHOIDKDUGVPLOH:H
    DUHIDUPRUHFDSDEOHWKDQWKHVHDXWRPDWRQV
    +DULQRGGHGVDGO\7KDWZDVQRWLQWKHGHDO7KH\XVHGPH
    ,WKLQNZHDUHDOOEHLQJXVHG'DQHHOFDVWDVRXUJODQFHDW+DUL,Q
    GLIIHUHQWZD\V
    ,KDGWRGRLW IULHQG'DQHHO
    'RUVVWDUHGDW+DUL,VFDUFHO\NQRZ\RX
    +DULVDLGVRIWO\6RPHWLPHVEHLQJKXPDQLVKDUGHUWKDQLWORRNV
    'RUVH\HVIODVKHG$OLHQVVODXJKWHULQJP\NLQG
    ,KDGWRILQGDVROXWLRQ
    6KHVDLG5RERWVHVSHFLDOO\WKHKXPDQLIRUPVWKH\UHVHUYDQWVWKH\
    0\ORYH\RXDUHPRUHKXPDQWKDQDQ\RQH,YHNQRZQ
    %XWPXUGHU
    7KHUHZDVJRLQJWREHPXUGHUDQ\ZD\7KHDQFLHQWPHPHVFRXOGQRWEH
    VWRSSHG+DULVLJKHGDQGUHDOL]HGKRZIDUKHKDGFRPH7KLVZDVSRZHU
    KRYHULQJDERYHDOODQGVHHLQJWKHZRUOGDVDYDVWDUHQDLWVFODVKHVXQHQGLQJ
    +HKDGEHFRPHSDUWRIWKDWDQGNQHZKHFRXOGQRWJREDFNWREHLQJWKHVLPSOH
    PDWKLVWHYHUDJDLQ
    'RUVGHPDQGHG:K\DUH\RXVRVXUH"<RXFRXOGKDYHWROGXVZHFRXOG
    7KH\NQHZ\RXDOUHDG\,I,KDGVWDOOHGWKH\ZRXOGKDYHWDNHQ\RXWZR
    JRQHKXQWLQJIRUWKHUHVW
    'DQHHODVNHGVWHUQO\$QGIRUXV"
    %RWKRI\RX,VDYHG3DUWRIWKHGHDO
    'DQHHOZLOWHGWKHQ7KDQN\RX,VXSSRVH
    +DULJD]HGDWKLVROGIULHQGH\HV PLVWLQJ<RXDUHFDUU\LQJWRR
    PXFKZHLJKW
    'DQHHOQRGGHG,FDUULHGRXWWKHLPSHUDWLYHDQGREH\HG\RX
    +DULQRGGHG/DPXUN,ZDVWKHUH<RXULQVHFWVIULHGKLP
    2UDSSHDUHGWR
    :KDW"+DULVWDUHGDV'DQHHOSUHVVHGDEXWWRQRQKLVZULVWWKHQWXUQHG
    WRWKHRIILFHGRRU7KURXJKLWSDXVLQJVOLJKWO\IRUWKHVHFXULW\VFUHHQ
    VWHSSHGDPDQRIXQUHPDUNDEOHORRNVLQDEURZQZRUNPDQVFRYHUDOO
    2XU0LVWHU/DPXUN'DQHHOVDLG
    7KDWLVQW+DULWKHQVDZWKHVXEWOHUHVHPEODQFHV7KHQRVHKDGEHHQ
    WULPPHGFKHHNVILOOHGRXWKDLUWKLQQHGDQGEURZQHGHDUVVORSHGEDFN%XW,
    VDZKLPGLH
    6R\RXGLG7KHYROWDJHKHWRRNIXOO\VWRSSHGKLPIRUDELWDQGKDGP\
    GLVJXLVHGJXDUGVQRWEHJXQSURSHUWUHDWPHQWDWWKHVLWHKHZRXOGKDYHVWD\HG
    GHDG
    <RXFRXOGSXOOKLPEDFNIURPWKDW"
    ,WLVDQDQFLHQWFUDIW
    +RZORQJFDQDKXPDQUHPDLQGHDGEHIRUH"
    $ERXWDQKRXUDWORZWHPSHUDWXUHV:HKDGWRZRUNPXFKIDVWHUWKDQ
    WKDW'DQHHOVDLGLQPHDVXUHGWRQHV
    +RQRULQJWKH)LUVW/DZ +DULVDLG
    6KDGLQJLWDELW7KHUHLVQRODVWLQJKDUPGRQHWR/DPXUN1RZKHZLOO
    GHYRWHKLVWDOHQWVWREHWWHUHQGV
    :K\"+DULUHDOL]HGWKDW/DPXUNKDGVDLGQRWKLQJ7KHPDQVWRRG
    DWWHQWLYHO\ZDWFKLQJ'DQHHOQRW+DUL
    ,GRKDYHFHUWDLQSRVLWLYHSRZHUVRYHUKXPDQPLQGV$QDQFLHQWURERW
    QDPHG*LVNDUGJDYHPHOLPLWHGVZD\RYHUWKHQHXUDOFRPSOH[LWLHVRIWKHKXPDQ
    FHUHEUDOFRUWH[,KDYHDOWHUHG/DPXUNVPRWLYDWLRQVDQGWULPPHGVRPH
    PHPRULHV

    +RZPXFK"'RUVDVNHGVXVSLFLRXVO\7RKHU+DULUHDOL]HG/DPXUNZDV
    VWLOODQHQHP\XQWLOSURYHQRWKHUZLVH
    'DQHHOZDYHGDKDQG6SHDN
    ,XQGHUVWDQGWKDW,KDYHHUUHG/DPXUNVSRNHLQDGU\VLQFHUHYRLFH
    ZLWKRXWKLVXVXDOILUH,DSRORJL]HHVSHFLDOO\WR\RX+DUL,FDQQRWUHFDOO
    P\RIIHQVHVEXW,UHJUHWWKHP,VKDOOGREHWWHUQRZ
    <RXGRQRWPLVV\RXUPHPRULHV"'RUVSUREHG
    7KH\DUHQRWSUHFLRXV/DPXUNVDLGUHDVRQDEO\$QHQGOHVVFKDLQRI
    SHWW\EDUEDULWLHVDQGLQVDWLDEOHDPELWLRQVDVQHDUO\DV,FDQUHFDOO%ORRG
    DQGDQJHU1RWJUHDWPRPHQWVVRZK\SUHVHUYHWKHP",ZLOOEHDEHWWHUSHUVRQ
    QRZ
    +DULIHOWERWKZRQGHUDQGIHDU,I\RXFRXOGGRWKLV'DQHHOZK\GR
    \RXERWKHUWRDUJXHZLWKPH"-XVWFKDQJHP\PLQG
    'DQHHOVDLGFDOPO\,ZRXOGQRWGDUH<RXDUHGLIIHUHQWIURPRWKHUV
    %HFDXVHRISV\FKRKLVWRU\",VWKDWDOOWKDWKROGV\RXEDFN"
    7KDW\HV%XW\RXDOVRGLGQRWKDYHWKHEUDLQIHYHUZKHQ\RXQJ7KDW
    PDNHVP\VNLOOVXVHOHVV)RUH[DPSOH,FRXOGQRWVHQVH\RXUSORWWRXVHWKH
    WLNWRNVDJDLQVWWKH/DPXUNIDFWLRQ ZKHQZHPHWLQWKDWRSHQSXEOLFSODFHWR
    HQOLVWP\URERWVKHOS
    ,VHH7R+DULLWZDVVREHULQJWRVHHE\KRZVOHQGHUDWKUHDGKLV
    GHDOLQJVKDGKXQJ0HUHO\PLVVLQJDFKLOGKRRGGLVHDVH
    ,DPORRNLQJIRUZDUGWRP\IXWXUHWDVNV/DPXUNVDLGIODWO\$QHZ
    OLIH
    :KDWWDVNV"'RUVDVNHG
    ,ZLOOJRWRWKH%HQLQ=RQHDVUHJLRQDOPDQDJHU$UHVSRQVLELOLW\ZLWK
    PDQ\H[FLWLQJFKDOOHQJHV
    9HU\JRRG'DQHHOVDLGDSSURYLQJO\
    6RPHWKLQJLQWKHEODQGQHVVRIDOOWKLVVHQWDFKLOOGRZQ+DULVVSLQH
    7KLVZDVSRZHULQGHHGSOD\HGE\DQDJHOHVVPDVWHU
    <RXU=HURWK/DZLQDFWLRQ
    ,WLVHVVHQWLDOWRSV\FKRKLVWRU\'DQHHOVDLG
    +DULIURZQHG+RZ"
    7KH=HURWK/DZLVDFRUROODU\RIWKH)LUVW/DZIRUKRZFDQDKXPDQ
    EHLQJEHVWEHNHSWIURPLQMXU\LIQRWE\HQVXULQJWKDWKXPDQVRFLHW\LQ
    JHQHUDOLVSURWHFWHGDQGNHSWIXQFWLRQLQJ"
    +DULVDLG$QGRQO\ZLWKDGHFHQWWKHRU\RIWKHIXWXUHFDQ\RXVHHZKDW
    LVQHFHVVDU\
    ([DFWO\6LQFHWKHWLPHRI*LVNDUGZHURERWVKDYHODERUHGRQVXFKD
    WKHRU\EULQJLQJIRUWKRQO\DFUXGHPRGHO6R+DUL\RXDQG\RXUWKHRU\DUH
    HVVHQWLDO(YHQVR,NQHZWKDW,ZDVYHUJLQJFORVHWRWKH)LUVW/DZVOLPLW
    ZKHQ,IROORZHG\RXURUGHUVXVLQJP\URERWVWRVKDGRZWKH/DPXUNLDQV
    <RXVHQVHGVRPHWKLQJZURQJ"
    +\SHUUHVLVWDQFHLQWKHSRVLWURQLFSDWKZD\VPDQLIHVWVDVWURXEOH
    VWDQGLQJDQGZDONLQJDQGWKHQVSHDNLQJ,GLVSOD\HGDOOWKHVH,PXVWKDYH
    VHQVHGWKDWP\URERWVZRXOGEHXVHGLQGLUHFWO\WRNLOOKXPDQV7KHDQFLHQW
    *LVNDUGKDGVLPLODUGLIILFXOWLHVZLWK WKHERXQGDU\EHWZHHQWKH)LUVWDQG
    =HURWK/DZV
    'RUVPRXWKWUHPEOHGZLWKEDUHO\UHSUHVVHGHPRWLRQ7KHUHVWRIXV
    GHSHQGXSRQ\RXUMXGJPHQWWRQHJRWLDWHWKHWHQVLRQEHWZHHQWKRVHWZRPRVW
    IXQGDPHQWDORI/DZV,FRXOGQRWZLWKVWDQGZKDW\RXKDYHKDGWRHQGXUH
    7U\LQJWRFRPIRUWKLP+DULVDLG<RXKDGQRFKRLFH'DQHHO,ER[HG
    \RXLQ
    'DQHHOORRNHGDW'RUVDOORZLQJFRQIOLFWHGH[SUHVVLRQVWRIOLWDFURVV
    KLVIDFHDV\PSKRQ\RIDJRQ\7KH=HURWK/DZ,KDYHOLYHGZLWKLWIRUVR
    ORQJPDQ\PLOOHQQLDDQG\HW
    7KHUHLVDFOHDUFRQWUDGLFWLRQ+DULVDLGVRIWO\NQRZLQJKHZDV
    WUHDGLQJLQWHUULWRU\RIJUHDWGHOLFDF\7KHVRUWRIFRQFHSWXDOFODVKDKXPDQ

    PLQGFDQVRPHWLPHVPDQDJH
    'RUVZKLVSHUHG%XWZHFDQQRWH[FHSWDWJUDYHSHULOWRRXUYHU\
    VWDELOLW\
    'DQHHOKXQJKLVKHDG:KHQ,JDYHWKHRUGHUVDQDFLGLFDJRQ\DURVHLQ
    P\PLQGDVFDOGLQJWLGH,KDYHEDUHO\FRQWDLQHG
    +DULVWKURDWMXVWDOORZHGKLPWRVTXHH]HRXWKLVZRUGV2OGIULHQG
    \RXKDGQRFKRLFH6XUHO\LQDOO\RXUDJHVRIODERULQWKHKXPDQFDXVHRWKHU
    FRQWUDGLFWLRQVKDYHDULVHQ"
    'DQHHOQRGGHG0DQ\$QGHDFKWLPH,KDQJDERYHDQDE\VV
    <RXFDQQRWVXFFXPE'RUVVDLG<RXDUHWKHJUHDWHVWRIXV0RUHLV
    GHPDQGHGRI\RX
    'DQHHOORRNHGDWERWKRIWKHPDVLIVHHNLQJDEVROXWLRQ$FURVVKLVIDFH
    IOLFNHUHGIRUORUQKRSH,VXSSRVH
    +DULDGGHGKLVDVVHQWDOXPSLQKLVWKURDW2IFRXUVH$OOLVORVW
    ZLWKRXW\RX<RXPXVWHQGXUH
    'DQHHOORRNHGRIILQWRLQILQLW\VSHDNLQJLQDGU\ZKLVSHU0\
    ZRUNLWLVQRWGRQHVR,FDQQRWGHDFWLYDWH7KLVPXVWEHZKDWLWLV
    OLNHWREHWUXO\KXPDQWRUQEHWZHHQWZRSROHV6WLOO,FDQORRNIRUZDUG
    7KHUHZLOOFRPHDWLPHZKHQP\ZRUNLVILQLVKHG:KHQ ,FDQEHUHOLHYHGRI
    WKHVHFRQWUDGLFWRU\WHQVLRQV7KHQ,VKDOOIDFHWKHEODFNEODQNQHVVDQGLW
    ZLOOEHJRRG
    7KHIHUYRURIWKHURERWVVSHHFKOHIW+DULVLOHQWDQGVDG)RUDORQJ
    WLPHWKHWKUHHVDWWRJHWKHULQWKHKXVKHGURRP/DPXUNVWRRGDWWHQWLYH DQG
    VLOHQW
    7KHQZLWKRXWDIXUWKHUZRUGWKH\ZHQWWKHLUVHSDUDWHZD\V
    

    +DULVDWDORQHDQGVWDUHGDWWKHKRORRIDUDJLQJDQFLHQWSUDLULHILUH
    ,QLWVSODFHQRZVWRRGWKH(PSLUH+HNQHZQRZWKDWKHORYHGWKH(PSLUH
    IRUUHDVRQVKHFRXOGQRWQDPH7KHGDUNUHYHODWLRQWKDWWKHURERWVKDG
    YLVLWHGGHDWKDQGGHVWUXFWLRQXSRQWKHROGUHPQDQWGLJLWDOPLQGVHYHQWKDW
    GLGQRWGHWHUKLP+HZRXOGQHYHUNQRZWKHGHWDLOVRIWKDWDQFLHQWFULPHKH
    KRSHG
    7RSUHVHUYHKLVVDQLW\IRUWKHILUVWWLPHLQ KLVOLIHKHGLGQRWZDQW
    WRNQRZ
    7KH(PSLUHWKDWVWRRGDOODURXQGKLPZDVHYHQPRUHPDUYHORXVWKDQKHKDG
    VXVSHFWHG$QGPRUHVREHULQJ
    :KRFRXOGDFFHSWWKDWKXPDQLW\GLGQRWFRQWUROLWVRZQIXWXUHWKDW
    KLVWRU\ZDVWKHUHVXOWRIIRUFHVDFWLQJEH\RQG WKHKRUL]RQVRIPHUHPRUWDO
    PHQ"7KH(PSLUHKDGHQGXUHGEHFDXVHRILWVPHWDQDWXUHQRWWKHYDOLDQWDFWVRI
    LQGLYLGXDOVRUHYHQRIZRUOGV
    0DQ\ZRXOGDUJXHIRUKXPDQVHOIGHWHUPLQDWLRQ7KHLUDUJXPHQWVZHUHQRW
    ZURQJRUHYHQLQHIIHFWXDOMXVWEHVLGHWKH SRLQW$VSHUVXDVLRQWKH\ZHUH
    SRZHUIXO(YHU\RQHZDQWHGWREHOLHYHWKH\ZHUHPDVWHUVRIWKHLURZQIDWH
    /RJLFKDGQRWKLQJWRGRZLWKLW
    (YHQ(PSHURUVZHUHQRWKLQJFKDIIEORZQE\ZLQGVWKH\FRXOGQRWVHH
    $VLIWRUHIXWHKLP&OHRQVLPDJHDEUXSWO\FRDJXODWHGLQWKHKROR
    +DUL:KHUHKDYH\RXEHHQ"
    :RUNLQJ
    2Q\RXUHTXDWLRQV,KRSHEHFDXVH\RXUHJRLQJWRQHHGWKHP
    6LUH"
    7KH+LJK&RXQFLOMXVWPHWLQVSHFLDOVHVVLRQ,DSSHDUHGDQRWHRI
    JUDFHDQGJUDYLW\ZDVPXFKQHHGHG,QWKHZDNHRIWKHDKWUDJLFORVVRI
    /DPXUNDQGKLVDKDVVRFLDWHV,XUJHGWKHTXLFNHOHFWLRQRID)LUVW
    0LQLVWHU$EURDGZLQN)RUVWDELOLW\\RXXQGHUVWDQG
    +DULFURDNHG2KQR

    2K\HVP\)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    %XWZDVQWWKHUHGLGQWDQ\RQHVXVSHFW
    <RX"$KDUPOHVVDFDGHPLFEULQJLQJRIIDVVDVVLQDWLRQVLQGR]HQVRI
    SODFHVDOORYHU7UDQWRU"8VLQJWLNWRNV"
    :HOO\RXNQRZKRZSHRSOHZLOOWDON
    &OHRQJDYHKLPDVKUHZGORRN&RPHQRZ+DULKRZGLG\RXGRLW"
    ,FRXQWDPRQJP\DOOLHVDJDQJRIUHQHJDGHURERWV
    &OHRQODXJKHGORXGO\VODSSLQJKLVGHVN,QHYHUNQHZ\RXZHUHVXFKD
    MRNHVWHU9HU\ZHOO,TXLWHXQGHUVWDQG<RXVKRXOGQRWEHIRUFHGWRUHYHDO
    \RXUVRXUFHV
    +DULKDGVZRUQWRKLPVHOIWKDWKHZRXOGQHYHUOLHWRWKH(PSHURU1RW
    EHLQJEHOLHYHGZDVQRWSDUWRIWKHDJUHHPHQW,DVVXUH\RXVLUH
    2IFRXUVH\RXDUHULJKWWRMHVW,DPQRWQDLYH
    $QG,DPDORXV\OLDUVLUH7UXHDOVRDQGDVZHOOWKHEHVWZD\WR
    FORVHWKHPDWWHU
    ,ZDQW\RXWRFRPHWRWKHIRUPDOUHFHSWLRQIRUWKH+LJK&RXQFLO1RZ
    WKDW\RXUH)LUVW0LQLVWHUWKHUHZLOOEHWKHVHVRFLDOPDWWHUV%XWEHIRUH
    WKDW,GRZDQW\RXWRWKLQNDERXWWKH6DUNVLWXDWLRQDQG
    ,FDQDGYLVH\RXQRZ
    &OHRQEULJKWHQHG2K"
    7KHUHDUHGDPSHUVLQKLVWRU\VLUHZKLFKVWDELOL]HWKH(PSLUH7KH1HZ
    5HQDLVVDQFHLVDEUHDNRXWRIDIXQGDPHQWDOIDFHWDQGIODZRIKXPDQLW\,WPXVW
    EHVXSSUHVVHG
    <RXUHVXUH"
    ,IZHGRQRWKLQJ+DULUHFDOOHGWKHVROXWLRQVKHKDGMXVWWULHGLQ
    WKHILWQHVVODQGVFDSH/HWWKH1HZ5HQDLVVDQFHJRDQGWKH(PSLUHZRXOG
    GLVVROYHLQWRFKDRVVWDWHVZLWKLQPHUHGHFDGHV7KDWPLJKWGHVWUR\KXPDQLW\
    LWVHOI
    &OHRQJULPDFHG7UXO\":KDWDUHP\RWKHURSWLRQV"
    6TXHOFKWKHVHHUXSWLRQV7KH6DUNLDQVDUHEULOOLDQWWUXH EXWWKH\
    FDQQRWILQGDVKDUHGKHDUWIRUWKHLUSHRSOH7KH\DUHH[DPSOHVRIZKDW,FDOO
    D6ROLSVLVP3ODJXHDQH[FHVVLYHEHOLHILQWKHVHOI,WLVFRQWDJLRXV
    7KHKXPDQWROO
    6DYHWKHVXUYLYRUV6HQG,PSHULDODLGVKLSVWKURXJKWKHZRUPKROHV
    IRRGFRXQVHORUVSV\FKHUVLIWKH\UHDQ\KHOS%XWDIWHUWKHGLVRUGHUKDV
    EXUQHGLWVHOIRXW
    ,VHH&OHRQJDYHKLPDJXDUGHGJODQFHIDFHVOLJKWO\DYHUWHG<RX
    DUHDKDUGPDQ+DUL
    :KHQLWFRPHVWRSUHVHUYLQJRUGHUWKH(PSLUH\HVVLUH
    &OHRQZHQW RQWRVSHDNRIPLQRUPDWWHUVDVLIVK\LQJDZD\IURPVR
    EUXWDODWRSLF+DULZDVJODGKHKDGQRWDVNHGPRUH
    7KHORQJUDQJHSUHGLFWLRQVVKRZHGGLUHGULIWVWKDWWKHFODVVLFGDPSHUV
    LQWKH(PSLUHVVHOIOHDUQLQJQHWZRUNVZHUHIDLOLQJWRR7KH1HZ5HQDLVVDQFH
    ZDVEXWWKHPRVWIODJUDQWH[DPSOH
    %XWHYHU\ZKHUHKHKDGORRNHGZLWKKLVERG\VHQVRULXPWLHGLQWRWKH1
    GLPHQVLRQDOVSHFWUXPURVHWKHVWLQNRILPSHQGLQJFKDRV7KH(PSLUHZDV
    EUHDNLQJGRZQLQZD\VZKLFKZHUHQRWGHVFULEDEOHE\PHUHKXPDQPRGHV,WZDV
    WRRYDVWDV\VWHPWRHQFORVHZLWKLQDVLQJOHPLQG
    6RVRRQZLWKLQGHFDGHVWKH(PSLUHZRXOGVWDUWWRIUDJPHQW0LOLWDU\
    VWUHQJWKZDVRIOLWWOHORQJWHUPXVHZKHQWKHWLPHKRQRUHGGDPSHUVIDOWHUHG
    7KHFHQWHUFRXOGQRWKROG
    +DULFRXOGVORZWKDWFROODSVHDELWSHUKDSVWKDWZDVDOO6RRQZKROH
    =RQHVZRXOGVSLUDOEDFNWRWKHROGDWWUDFWRUV%DVLF)HXGDOLVP5HOLJLRXV
    6DQFWLPRQ\)HPRSULPLWLYLVP
    2IFRXUVHKLVFRQFOXVLRQVZHUHSUHOLPLQDU\+HKRSHGQHZGDWDZRXOG
    SURYHKLPZURQJ%XWKHGRXEWHGLW
    2QO\DIWHUWKLUW\WKRXVDQG\HDUVRIVXIIHULQJZRXOGWKHIHYHUEXPRXW$

    QHZVWURQJDWWUDFWRUZRXOGHPHUJH
    $UDQGRPPXWDWLRQRI%HQLJQ,PSHULDOLVP"+HFRXOGQRWWHOO
    +HFRXOGXQGHUVWDQGDOOWKLVEHWWHUZLWKPRUHZRUN([SORUHWKH
    IRXQGDWLRQVJHW
    $QLGHDIOLFNHUHG)RXQGDWLRQV"6RPHWKLQJWKHUH
    %XW&OHRQZDVJRLQJRQDQGHYHQWVZHUHFROOLGLQJLQKLVPLQG7KHLGHD
    IOLWWHGDZD\
    :HOOGRJUHDWWKLQJVWRJHWKHU+DUL:KDWGR\RXWKLQNDERXW
    $W&OHRQVEHFNDQGFDOOKHZRXOGQHYHUJHWDQ\ZRUNGRQH
    'HDOLQJZLWK/DPXUNKDGEHHQGLVDJUHHDEOHEXWLQFRPSDULVRQZLWKWKLV
    WUDSRISRZHUHDV\+RZFRXOGKHJHWRXWRIWKLV"
    

    7KHWZRILJXUHVIURPDSDVWEH\RQGDQWLTXLW\IOHZLQWKHLUFRROGLJLWDO
    VSDFHVZDLWLQJIRUWKHPDQWRUHWXUQ
    ,KDYHIDLWKKHZLOO-RDQVDLG
    ,UHO\PRUHXSRQFDOFXODWLRQ9ROWDLUHUHSOLHGDGMXVWLQJKLVJDUE+H
    VRIWHQHGWKHSXOORIVLONLQKLVWLJKWIRUPDOEUHHFKHV,WZDVDVLPSOH
    DGMXVWPHQWRIWKHIULFWLRQFRHIILFLHQWQRWKLQJPRUH5RXJKDOJRULWKPVUHGXFHG
    LQWULFDWHODZVWRWULYLDODULWKPHWLF(YHQWKHUXERIOLIHZDVMXVWDQRWKHU
    SDUDPHWHU
    ,VWLOOUHVHQWWKLVZHDWKHU
    *DOHVKRZOHGDFURVVWURXEOHGZDWHUV7KH\IOHZDERYHIRDPLQJZDYHVDQG
    EDQNHGRQWKHUPDOXSZHOOLQJV
    <RXULGHDWREHELUGVIRUDELW+HZDVDVLOYHU\HDJOH
    ,DOZD\VHQYLHGWKHP6ROLJKWFKHHUIXODWRQHZLWKWKHDLULWVHOI
    +HPRUSKHGKLVZLQJVXSWRKLVVKRXOGHUVPDNLQJKLVYHVWFRDWILWPXFK
    EHWWHU(YHQKHUHOLIHZDVPRVWO\GHWDLOV
    :K\PXVWVXFKVWUDQJHQHVVPDQLIHVWDVZHDWKHU"-RDQDVNHG
    0HQDUJXHQDWXUHDFWV
    %XWWKH\DUHQRWQDWXUH7KH\DUHVWUDQJHPLQGV
    6RVWUDQJHZHPLJKWDVZHOOUHJDUGWKHPDVQDWXUDOSKHQRPHQD
    ,ILQGLWGLIILFXOWWREHOLHYHWKDWRXU/RUGPDGHVXFKWKLQJV
    ,YHIHOWWKDWZD\DERXWPDQ\3DULVLDQV
    7KH\DSSHDUWRXVDVVWRUPVPRXQWDLQVRFHDQV,IWKH\ZRXOGH[SODLQ
    WKHPVHOYHV
    7KHVHFUHWRIEHLQJDERUHLVWRWHOOHYHU\WKLQJ
    +DUN+HFRPHV
    6KHJUHZDUPRUZKLOHNHHSLQJKHUJLDQWZLQJV7KHHIIHFWZDVVWDUWOLQJ
    OLNHDJLDQWFKURPHGIDOFRQ
    9ROWDLUHVDLG0\ORYH\RXQHYHUFHDVHWRVXUSULVHPH,EHOLHYHWKDW
    ZLWK\RXHYHQHWHUQLW\ZLOOQRWEHWHGLRXV
    +DUL6HOGRQKXQJLQPLGDLU+HZDVFOHDUO\QRW\HWXVHGWRDGYHQWXUHVRPH
    VLPXODWLRQVIRUKLVIHHWNHSWWU\LQJWRVWDQGVRPHZKHUH(YHQWXDOO\KHJDYH
    XSDQGZDWFKHGWKHPVZRRSDQGGLYHDURXQGKLP
    ,FDPHDVVRRQDV,FRXOG
    ,JDWKHU\RXDUHQRZDYLVFRXQWRUGXNHRUVXFK-RDQVDLG
    6RPHWKLQJOLNHWKDW+DULVDLG7KLVVSDFH\RXUHLQ,YHDUUDQJHG
    IRULWWREHDSHUPDQHQWDK
    3UHVHUYH"9ROWDLUHDVNHGEDWWLQJKLVZLQJVEHIRUHWKH+DULILJXUH$
    FORXGGULIWHGQHDUHUDVLIWROLVWHQLQ
    :HFDOOLWDGHGLFDWHGSHULPHWHULQFRPSXWDWLRQDOVSDFH
    6XFKSRHWU\9ROWDLUHDUFKHGDQH\HEURZ
    7KDWVRXQGVPXFKOLNHD]RR-RDQVDLG
    7KHGHDOLV\RXDQGWKHDOLHQPLQGVFDQVWD\KHUHUXQQLQJZLWKRXW
    LQWHUIHUHQFH

    ,GRQRWOLNHWREHKHPPHGLQ-RDQVKRXWHG+DULVKRRNKLVKHDG
    <RXOOEHDEOHWRJHWLQSXWIURPDQ\ZKHUH%XWQRPRUHLQWHUIHUHQFHZLWKWKH
    WLNWRNVULJKW"
    $VNWKHZHDWKHU-RDQVDLG
    $FDVFDGHRIEXUQWRUDQJHVKHHWOLJKWQLQJUDQGRZQWKHVN\
    ,PMXVWJODGWKHPHPHPLQGVGLGQWH[WHUPLQDWHDOOWKHURERWV+DUL
    VDLG
    9ROWDLUHVDLG3HUKDSVWKLVSODFHLVDELWOLNH(QJODQGZKHUHWKH\
    NLOODQRFFDVLRQDODGPLUDOWRHQFRXUDJHWKHRWKHUV
    ,KDGWRGRLW+DULVDLG
    -RDQVORZHGKHUZLQJVDQGKRYHUHGQHDUKLVIDFH<RXDUHGLVWUHVVHG
    'LG\RXNQRZWKHPHPHPLQGVZRXOGXVHWKHWLNWRNVWRNLOOURERWV"
    1RWDWDOO-RDQVDLG
    9ROWDLUHDGGHG7KRXJKWKHHFRQRP\RILWSURYRNHVDFHUWDLQDGPLUDWLRQ
    6XEWOHPLQGVWKH\DUH
    7UHDFKHURXV+DULVDLG,ZRQGHUZKDWHOVHWKH\FDQGR"
    ,EHOLHYHWKH\DUHVDWLVILHG-RDQVDLG,VHQVHDFDOPLQRXU
    ZHDWKHU
    ,ZDQWWRVSHDNZLWKWKHP+DUL VKRXWHG
    /LNHNLQJVWKH\OLNHWREHDZDLWHG9ROWDLUHVDLG
    ,VHQVHWKHPJDWKHULQJ-RDQVDLGKHOSIXOO\/HWXVKHOSRXUIULHQG
    KHUHZLWKKLVYH[DWLRQV
    0H"+DULVDLG,GRQWOLNHNLOOLQJSHRSOHLIWKDWVZKDW\RXPHDQ
    ,QVXFKWLPHVWKHUHLVQRJRRGSDWKVKHVDLG,WRRKDGWRNLOO
    IRUWKHULJKW
    /DPXUNZDVDYDOXDEOHSXEOLFVHUYDQW
    1RQVHQVH9ROWDLUHVDLG+HOLYHGDVKHGLHGE\WKHGDJJHUWRR
    VOLSSHU\WRVKRZWKHVZRUG+HZRXOGQHYHUUHVWZLWK\RXLQSRZHU$QGHYHQ
    KDG\RXVWHSSHGDVLGHZHOOP\PDWKLVWUHPHPEHUWKDWLWLVGDQJHURXVWREH
    ULJKWZKHQWKHJRYHUQPHQWLVZURQJ
    ,VWLOOIHHOFRQIOLFWHG
    <RXPXVWIRU\RXDUHDULJKWHRXVPDQ-RDQVDLG3UD\DQGEH
    DEVROYHG
    2UEHWWHUSHHUZLWKLQ9ROWDLUHH[SODLQHGORIWLO\<RXUFRQIOLFWV
    UHIOHFWVXEPLQGVLQGLVSXWH6XFKLVWKHKXPDQFRQGLWLRQ
    -RDQIODSSHGKHUZLQJVDW9ROWDLUHZKRYHHUHGDZD\
    +DULVFRZOHG7KDWVRXQGVPRUHOLNHDPDFKLQH
    9ROWDLUHODXJKHG,IRUGHU\RXDUHDQHQWKXVLDVWRIRUGHU\HV"PHDQV
    SUHGLFWDELOLW\DQGSUHGLFWDELOLW\PHDQVSUHGHWHUPLQDWLRQDQGWKDWPHDQV
    FRPSXOVLRQDQGFRPSXOVLRQPHDQVQRQIUHHGRPZK\WKHQWKHRQO\ZD\ZHFDQEH
    IUHHLVWREHGLVRUGHUHG
    +DULIURZQHG9ROWDLUHUHDOL]HGWKDWZKLOHIRUKLPLGHDVZHUH
    SOD\WKLQJVDQGWKHFRQWHVWRIZLWVPDGHWKHEORRGVLQJIRUWKLVPDQWKH
    DEVWUDFWPDWWHUHG
    +DULVDLG,VXSSRVH\RXUHULJKW3HRSOHGRIHHOGLVFRPIRUWZLWKULJLG
    RUGHU$QGZLWKKLHUDUFKLHVQRUPVIRXQGDWLRQV+HEOLQNHG7KHUHVDQ
    LGHD,FDQWTXLWHVHHLW
    9ROWDLUHVDLGNLQGO\(YHQ\RXVXUHO\\RXGRQRWZDQWWREHWKHWRRO
    RI\RXURZQJHQHVRURISK\VLFVRURIHFRQRPLFV"
    +RZFDQZHEHIUHHLIZHUHPDFKLQHV"+DULDVNHGDVLIVSHDNLQJWR
    KLPVHOI
    1RERG\ZDQWVHLWKHUDUDQGRPXQLYHUVHRUDGHWHUPLQLVWLFRQH9ROWDLUH
    VDLG
    %XWWKHUHDUHGHWHUPLQLVWLFODZV
    $QGUDQGRPRQHV
    -RDQSXWLQ2XU/RUGJDYHXVMXGJPHQWWRFKRRVH
    )UHHGRPWRFKRRVHWRGRRWKHUWKDQRQHZRXOGOLNHZKDWDVRUGLG ERRQ

    9ROWDLUHVDLG
    -RDQVDLG<RXJHQWOHPHQDUHFLUFOLQJWKHGLYLQHZLWKRXWNQRZLQJLW
    (YHU\WKLQJZRUWKZKLOHWRSHRSOHIUHHGRPPHDQLQJYDOXHDOOWKDWGLVDSSHDUV
    ZLWKLQHLWKHURI\RXUFKRLFHV
    0\ORYH\RXPXVWUHPHPEHUWKDW+DULLVDPDWKLVW9ROWDLUH]RRPHG
    DERXWERWKRIWKHPRQVSUHDGZLQJVREYLRXVO\HQMR\LQJUXIIOLQJKLVIHDWKHUV
    LQWKHWXUEXOHQFH2UGHUGLVRUGHUVHHPLPSOLFDWHGLQRWKHUGXDOLVPV
    QDWXUHKXPDQQDWXUDODUWLILFLDODQLPDOVZLWKQDWXUHVKXPDQVRXWVLGHQDWXUH
    7KH\DUHQDWXUDOWRXV
    +RZFRPH"+DULVTXLQWHGSX]]OHG
    +RZGRZHIUDPHWKHRWKHUVLGHRIDQDUJXPHQW":HVD\RQWKHRWKHU
    KDQG\HV"
    +DULQRGGHG:HWKLQNRXUWZRKDQGVPLUURUWKHZRUOG
    9HU\JRRG9ROWDLUHIOHZORRSVDURXQG-RDQVFKURPHGIDOFRQ
    7KH&UHDWRUKDVWZRKDQGVDVZHOO-RDQSHUVLVWHG+HVLWWHWKRQWKH
    ULJKWKDQGRIWKH)DWKHUDOPLJKW\
    9ROWDLUHFDZHGOLNHDFURZ%XW\RXUHERWKQHJOHFWLQJ\RXURZQ
    VHOYHVZKLFK\RXFDQLQVSHFWLQWKLVGLJLWDOYDXOW/RRNGHHSO\DQG\RXVHH
    HQGOHVVGHWDLO,WUDPLILHVLQWRD6HOIWKDWFDQQRWEHGHFRPSRVHGLQWRWKH
    PHUHRSHUDWLRQRIQHDWODZV7KH<RXHPHUJHVDVDGHHSLQWHUSOD\RIPDQ\
    6HOYHV
    ,QWRWKHVKDUHGPLQGVSDFHRIWKHWKUHH9ROWDLUHVHQW

    &RPSOH[QRQOLQHDUIHHGEDFNV\VWHPVDUHXQSUHGLFWDEOHHYHQLIWKH\DUH
    GHWHUPLQLVWLF7KHLQIRUPDWLRQSURFHVVLQJFDSDFLW\QHHGHGWRSUHGLFWDVLQJOH
    PLQGLVODUJHUWKDQWKHFRPSOH[LW\RIWKHZKROHXQLYHUVHLWVHOI&RPSXWLQJWKH
    QH[WHYHQWWDNHVORQJHUWKDQWKHHYHQWLWVHOI3UHFLVHO\WKLVIHDWXUHZULWWHQ
    LQWRWKHWH[WXUHRIWKHXQLYHUVHPDNHVLWDQGXVIUHH
    +DULUHSOLHGZLWK

    3DUDGR[+RZGRHVWKHHYHQWLWVHOINQRZKRZWRKDSSHQ"
    2QO\DPDVVLYHFRPSXWHUFRXOGGHVFULEHWKHQH[WWLQ\ZKRUOLQDVWUHDP
    :KDWPDNHVUHDOV\VWHPVHYHQDEOHWRFKDQJH"

    9ROWDLUHVKUXJJHGDGLIILFXOWJHVWXUHIRUDELUG
    $WODVW\RXKDYHHQFRXQWHUHGDQDJHQF\\RXFDQQRWGLVPLVV-RDQVDLG
    SURXGO\
    9ROWDLUHVKHDGMHUNHGZLWKVXUSULVH<RXU&UHDWRU"
    <RXUHTXDWLRQVGHVFULEHZHOOHQRXJK%XWZKDWJLYHVWKHVHHTXDWLRQV
    VKHKHVLWDWHGDWWKHZRUGILUH"
    <RXLPSO\D0LQGZKLFKGRHVWKHXQLYHUVDOFRPSXWDWLRQ"
    1R\RXGR
    +DULVDLG)DLUHQRXJKDVDK\SRWKHVLV%XWZK\VKRXOGVXFKD0LQG
    FDUHDZKLW IRUXVPHUHPRWHV"
    +HFDUHGHQRXJKWRPDNH\RXFRPHRXWRIWKHPDWUL[RIPDWWHUGLG+H
    QRW"
    $KRULJLQV9ROWDLUHVDLGFDWFKLQJDQXSGUDIW+HORRNHGUHOLHYHGWR
    EHRQVXUHULQWHOOHFWXDOJURXQG3ODLQO\KHUSRLQWKDGUDWWOHGKLP
    ,QVROXEOHRIFRXUVH,SUHIHUWRGHDOZLWKRXUPRUDOLWLHV
    -RDQVDLGSULPO\0RUDOLW\LVQRWGHSHQGHQWXSRQXV
    9ROWDLUHVKRWEDFN1RQVHQVH:HHYROYHGZLWKPRUDOVVKDSHGE\WKH
    XQLYHUVHE\D&UHDWRULI\RXZLVK
    +DULDVNHG<RXPHDQE\HYROXWLRQ"7KHSDQV
    -RDQFULHG,QGHHG+ROLQHVVVKDSHVWKHZRUOGWKHZRUOGVKDSHVXV
    +DULORRNHGGRXEWIXO-RDQSOHDVHG9ROWDLUHVDLGZU\O\0\PDWKLVW
    ZRXOG\RXUDWKHUEHOLHYHWKDWPRUDOFRQVWUDLQWVHPHUJHDVDVSRQWDQHRXVRUGHU

    IURPUDWLRQDOXWLOLW\PD[LPL]LQJEHKDYLRU"7UXO\"
    +DULEOLQNHG:HOOQR
    ,TXRWHGRQHRI\RXURZQSDSHUV:KDW\RXYHIRUJRWWHQVLULVWKDW
    RXUHQGOHVVPRGHOVRIWKHZRUOGVKDSHKRZZHORRNDWKXPDQH[SHULHQFH
    2IFRXUVHEXW
    $QGWKHPRGHOVDUHDOOWKDWZHNQRZ
    +DULVXGGHQO\VPLOHG,OLNHWKDW'RQWJHWPDUULHGWRDPRGHO+H
    DOORZHGKLPVHOIWRPRUSKVOLJKWO\JURZLQJWDOOHUPRUHPXVFXODU,GRQW
    NQRZZK\EXW,IHHOEHWWHU
    <RXUVRXOKDVFRPHWRWHUPVZLWK\RXUDFWLRQV-RDQVDLG
    9ROWDLUH VDLG,ZRXOGSUHIHUVHOYHVWRVRXOEXWOHWXVQRW
    TXLEEOH
    6XGGHQO\+DULIHOWFDWHJRULHVVKLIWLQKLVPLQG+HKDGDUUDQJHGIRUWKH
    UHYLYDORIWKHVHVLPVJXLGHGE\SXUHLQWXLWLRQ1RZFDPHWKHSD\RIIWKH\KDG
    LQDGYHUWHQWO\GLVFRYHUHGWKHVWHSKHZDQWHG7KHPLQGLVDVHOIRUJDQL]LQJ
    VWUXFWXUHDQGVRLVWKH(PSLUH,FDQZRUNEDFNDQGIRUWKEHWZHHQWKRVH
    PRGHOV,PSRUW\RXUNQRZOHGJHRIVXEVHOYHVXVHLWWRDQDO\]HKRZWKH(PSLUH
    OHDUQV
    9ROWDLUHEOLQNHG:KDWDPDUYHORXVLGHD
    +DULVDLG:DLWOO,VKRZ\RX7KH(PSLUHLVVHOIOHDUQLQJZLWK
    VXEXQLWV
    ,ZRQGHULIWKHDOLHQIRJNQRZVWKLV"-RDQDVNHG
    +DULIURZQHG,GRQRWZDQWWRLQYROYHWKHP0\HTXDWLRQVFDQQRWGHDO
    ZLWKHOHPHQWVRIXQNQRZQ
    7KH\DUHDOUHDG\LQYROYHG-RDQVDLG7KH\DUHKHUHDOODURXQGXV
    +DULVLJKHG,KRSHZHFDQNHHSWKHPKHUHLQWKH
    =RR-RDQVDLGGU\O\
    7KXQGHUKHDGVURLOHGRYHUWKHKRUL]RQVFORVLQJIDVW
    <RXNLOOHGURERWV+DULVKRXWHGLQWRWKHJDOH7KDWZDVQRWLQRXU
    EDUJDLQ
    >:(','1276$<:(:28/'5()5$,1@
    <RXWRRNPRUHWKDQZHDJUHHG/LYHVRI
    >7(50620,77('&$1127%(35(680('8321@
    7KHURERWVDUHDVHSDUDWHNLQG2IKLJKLQWHOOLJHQFH
    ><2850(5(7,.72.6&28/'.,//7+(07+28*+@
    ><286(/'21','1272:17+(6(0$&+,1(6@
    >$1'7+86+$9(12',6387(:,7+86@
    +DULJURXQGKLVWHHWKDQGIXPHG
    >025(,03257$170$77(56%(&.21@
    <RXUUHZDUGV"+DULDVNHGELWWHUO\<RXYHFRPHIRUWKHP"
    >:(6+$//12767$<+(5(@
    >)257+,63/$&(,6'220('@
    +DULVWDJJHUHGXQGHUDKDLOVWRUPRIELWLQJFROG7UDQWRU"
    >$1'08&+(/6(@
    :KDWGR\RXZDQW"
    >285'(6,5(''(67,1<,672)/2$7$021*7+(63,5$/$506@
    >$1'/,1*(5/21*$021*7+(3/80(62)*$/$&7,&&(17(5@
    +DULUHPHPEHUHGWKHVWUXFWXUHVWKHUHWKHFRPSOH[ZHDYHRIOXPLQRVLWLHV
    <RXFDQGRWKDW"
    >:(+$9($6325(67$7(@
    >620(2)86/,9('7+,6:$<%()25(@
    >7268&+$67$7(:(:,6+725(7851@
    >(/6(:(6+$//(;7,1*8,6+$//<28552%276@
    7KDWZDVQWSDUWRIRXUGHDO+DULVKRXWHG+DUGFROGUDLQKDPPHUHG
    KLPEXWKHWXUQHGKLVIDFHWRFRQIURQWWKHWRZHULQJDQJU\FORXGVDQGWKHLU
    VNLUWVRIZUDWKIXOOLJKWQLQJ
    >+2:&$1<28672386"@

    >7+28*+,7:28/''(3/(7(285&$3$&,7,(6@
    >:(&28/'%5,1*75$17257267$59$7,21@
    +DULJULPDFHG+HZDVOHDUQLQJDORWDERXWSRZHUTXLWHTXLFNO\$OO
    ULJKW,OOVHHWKDWUHVHDUFKJHWVGRQHRQKRZWRWUDQVIHU\RXWRSK\VLFDO
    IRUP7KHUHDUHWKRVH,NQRZZKRFDQGRLW0DUTDQG6\E\ONQRZKRZWRNHHS
    TXLHWWRR
    9ROWDLUHDVNHG:K\GR\RXZLVKWRH[LWVWDJHOHIWZLWKVXFKXQVHHPO\
    KDVWH"
    >$1(:%586+),5(,6&20,1*@
    >72+80$16$&52667+(63,5$/@
    >:(6+$//:$7&+7+,6)$//@
    >$66325(6)520*$/$&7,&&(17(5@
    >7+(5(121(&$1+85786121(&$1:(+857@
    $JOLWWHULQJFU\VWDOZLWKVKDUSVSLNHVPDWHULDOL]HGEHQHDWKWKHSXUSOLQJ
    VN\,QDGDWDGROORS+DULOHDUQHGRIWKHDOLHQWHFKQRORJ\ZKLFKKDGRQFH
    PDGHWKHVHVWDEOHUXJJHGFRPSDUWPHQWVIRUGLJLWDOLQWHOOLJHQFHV
    >75$1725:$621&(7+(,'($/3/$&()2586@
    >5,&+,15(6285&(6@
    >12025(,67+,662@
    >'$1*(5/85.6,17+(&20,1*,167$%,/,7<@
    8PPP9ROWDLUHVDLG-RDQDQG ,PLJKWGHVLUHVXFKDQH[LWDVZHOO
    :DLW\RXWZR+DULVDLGWDONLQJIDVW,I\RXZDQWWRJRZLWKWKHVH
    WKHVHWKLQJVWROLYHLQDVHHGEHWZHHQWKHVWDUVWKHQ\RXKDYHWRHDUQLW
    -RDQVFRZOHG+RZ"
    )RUQRZ,FDQPDNHLWVDIHIRU\RXWR OLYHZLGHO\LQWKH0HVK,Q
    UHWXUQKHJD]HGDQ[LRXVO\DWWKH9ROWDLUHHDJOHIODSSLQJLQEUDVV\
    VSOHQGRU,ZDQW\RXWRKHOSPH
    ,ILWLVDKRO\FDXVHVXUHO\-RDQFDOOHG
    ,WLV+HOSPHOHDG,YHDOZD\VIHOWWKHUHVJRRGLQHYHU\ERG\7KH
    MRERIDOHDGHULVWREULQJLWRXW
    9ROWDLUHVDLG,I\RXWKLQNWKHUHLVJRRGLQHYHU\ERG\\RXKDYHQWPHW
    HYHU\ERG\
    %XW,PQRWDPDQRIWKHZRUOG6R,QHHG\RX
    7RUXOH"-RDQDVNHG
    ([DFWO\,PQRWVXLWHGIRULW
    9ROWDLUHVWRSSHGLQPLGDLUZLQJVVWLOOHG7KHSRVVLELOLWLHV:LWK
    HQRXJKFRPSXWLQJVSDFHDQGVSHHGZHFDQHQGRZSURWR0LFKHODQJHORVZLWK
    FUHDWLYHWLPH
    ,QHHGWRGHDOZLWKDORWRIZHOOSRZHUSUREOHPV<RXFDQJRRIILQWR
    WKHVHVSRUHIRUPVZKHQ,PILQLVKHGZLWKSROLWLFV
    9ROWDLUHDEUXSWO\FRQJHDOHGLQWRKXPDQIRUPWKRXJKVWLOOHOHJDQWO\
    FORWKHGLQHOHFWULFEOXH8PPP3ROLWLFV,DOZD\VIRXQGLWHQWLFLQJ$JDPH
    RIHOHJDQWLGHDVSOD\HGE\EXOOLHV
    ,YHJRWSOHQW\RIRSSRVLWLRQDOUHDG\+DULVDLGVREHUO\
    )ULHQGVFRPHDQGJREXWHQHPLHVDFFXPXODWH9ROWDLUHVDLG,ZRXOG
    OLNHWKDW
    -RDQUROOHGKHUH\HV6DLQWVSUHVHUYHXV
    3UHFLVHO\P\GHDU
    

    +DULVDWEDFNDWKLVGHVN)LUVW0LQLVWHUEXWRQKLVWHUPV
    ,WKDGDOOZRUNHGRXW+HJRWWRZRUNKHUHVWLOOIDUIURPSDODFH
    LQWULJXHV3OHQW\RIWLPHWRGRPDWK
    +HZRXOGRIFRXUVHVSHDNE\'DQGKRORWRPDQ\$OOWKDWERWKHU
    9ROWDLUHWRRNFDUHRI$IWHUDOO9ROWDLUHRU-RDQFRXOGPDVTXHUDGHDV+DULDW
    WKHPDQ\FRQIHUHQFHVDQGPHHWLQJVQHFHVVDU\IRUD)LUVW0LQLVWHU'LJLWDOO\

    WKH\FRXOGPRUSKWRKLPZLWKHDVH
    -RDQHQMR\HGWKHYLUWXDOFHUHPRQLDOVHVSHFLDOO\LIVKHJRWWRKROG
    IRUWKRQKROLQHVV9ROWDLUHORYHGLPLWDWLQJDQDQFLHQWPDQKHKDGDSSDUHQWO\
    NQRZQD0U0DFKLDYHOOL<RXU(PSLUHKHKDGVDLGLVDYDVWUDPVKDFNOH
    WKLQJRILQILQLWHQXDQFHDQGPXOWLSO\LQJVHOIGHOXVLRQV1HHGVORRNLQJDIWHU
    ,QEHWZHHQWKH\FRXOGH[SORUHWKHGLJLWDOUHDOPVODE\ULQWKVYDVWDQG
    YLEUDQW$V9ROWDLUHKDGVDLGWKH\FRXOGEHRIIXSRQSRVWLQJVYDULRXVDQG
    FDSHUVKLODULRXV
    <XJRFDPHLQEXUVWLQJZLWKHQHUJ\7KH+LJK&RXQFLOMXVWSDVVHG\RXU
    YRWHSURSRVDOV+DUL(YHU\'DKOLWHLQWKH*DOD[\VRQ\RXUVLGHQRZ
    +DULVPLOHG+DYH9ROWDLUHPDNHDDSSHDUDQFHDVPH
    5LJKWPRGHVWDQGFRQILGHQWWKDWOOZRUN
    5HPLQGVPHRIWKHROGMRNHDERXWWKHSURVWLWXWH7KHUHJXODUFRVWVWKH
    UHJXODUSULFHEXWVLQFHULW\LVH[WUD
    <XJRODXJKHGXQFRQYLQFLQJO\DQGVDLGHGJLO\8KWKDWZRPDQVKHUH
    1RW
    +HKDGIRUJRWWHQXWWHUO\DERXWWKH$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWH7KHRQHWKUHDWKH
    KDGQRWQHXWUDOL]HG6KHNQHZDERXW'RUVDERXWURERWV
    *LYLQJKLPQRWLPHWRWKLQNVKHVZHSWLQWRKLVRIILFH
    6RKDSS\\RXFRXOGVHHPH3ULPDU\0LQLVWHU
    :LVK,FRXOGVD\WKHVDPH
    $QG\RXUORYHO\ZLIH",VVKHDERXW"
    ,GRXEWVKHZRXOGGHVLUHWRVHH\RX
    7KH$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWHVSUHDGKHUELOORZLQJUREHVDQGVDWZLWKRXW
    LQYLWDWLRQ6XUHO\\RXGLGQWWDNHWKDWVPDOOMHVWRIPLQHVHULRXVO\"
    0\VHQVHRIKXPRUGRHVQWLQFOXGHEODFNPDLO
    :LGHH\HVDVOLJKWWRXFKRIRXWUDJHLQWKHWRQH,ZDVPHUHO\WU\LQJ
    WRJDLQOHYHUDJHZLWK\RXUDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ
    6XUH6XFKZHUH,PSHULDOPDQQHUVWKDWKHZRXOGQRWEULQJXSKHU
    SRVVLEOHUROHLQ9DGGRVSORWRQ3DQXFRSLD
    ,ZDVFHUWDLQ\RXZRXOGJDLQWKHPLQLVWHUVKLS0\OLWWOHVDOO\ZHOO
    SHUKDSVLWZDVLQSRRUWDVWH
    9HU\
    <RXDUHDPDQRIIHZZRUGVTXLWHDGPLUDEOH0\DOOLHVZHUHVR
    LPSUHVVHGZLWK\RXUDKGLUHFWKDQGOLQJRIWKHWLNWRNFULVLVWKH/DPXUN
    NLOOLQJV
    6RWKDWZDVLW+HKDGVKRZQWKDWKHZDVQRWDQLPSUDFWLFDODFDGHPLF
    'LUHFW"+RZDERXWUXWKOHVV"
    2KQRZHGRQWWKLQNWKDWDWDOO<RXDUHULJKWWROHW6DUNEXUQ
    RXWDV\RXVRHORTXHQWO\SXWLW'HVSLWHWKH*UH\VZDQWLQJWRMXPSLQDQG
    ELQGXSZRXQGV9HU\ZLVHQRWUXWKOHVVQR
    (YHQWKRXJK6DUNPLJKWQHYHUUHFRYHU"7KHVHZHUHWKHTXHVWLRQVKHKDG
    DVNHGKLPVHOIWKURXJKVOHHSOHVVQLJKWV3HRSOHZHUHG\LQJWKDWWKH(PSLUH
    PLJKWOLYHIRUDZKLOHORQJHU
    6KHZDYHGWKLVDZD\$V,ZDVVD\LQJ,ZDQWHGDVSHFLDOUHODWLRQVKLS
    ZLWKWKH)LUVW0LQLVWHUIURPRXUFODVVLQZHOOVRORQJ
    /LNHPDQ\KHNQHZQRZVKHHPSOR\HGVSHHFKWRFRQFHDOWKRXJKWQRWWR
    UHYHDOLW+HKDGWRVLWDQGHQGXUHVRPHRIWKLVKHNQHZ6KHUDWWOHGRQDQG
    KHWKRXJKWDERXWKRZWRKDQGOHDNQRWW\WHUPLQWKHHTXDWLRQV+HKDGE\QRZ
    PDVWHUHGWKHDUWRIVHHPLQJWRWUDFNZLWKH\HVPRXWKPRYHPHQWVDQGWKH
    RFFDVLRQDOPXUPXU7KLVZDVH[DFWO\ZKDWDILOWHUSURJUDPGLGIRUKLV'DQG
    KHFRXOGGRLWZLWKRXWWKLQNLQJDERXWWKHK\SRFULV\RIWKHZRPDQEHIRUHKLP
    +HXQGHUVWRRGKHUQRZLQDZD\3RZHUZDVYDOXHIUHHIRUKHU+HKDGWR
    OHDUQWRWKLQNWKDWZD\DQGHYHQDFWWKDWZD\%XWKHFRXOGQRWOHWLWDIIHFW
    KLVWUXHVHOIWKHSHUVRQDOOLIHKHZRXOGUXWKOHVVO\VKHOWHU
    +HILQDOO\JRWULGRIKHUDQGEUHDWKHGDVLJKRIUHOLHI3UREDEO\LWZDV
    JRRGWREHVHHQDVUXWKOHVV7KDWIHOORZ1LPIRUH[DPSOHKHFRXOGKDYH1LP

    IRXQGHYHQH[HFXWHGIRUSOD\LQJERWKVLGHVLQWKH$UWLILFH$VVRFLDWHV
    PDWWHU
    %XWZK\"0HUF\ZDV PRUHHIILFLHQW+DULVHQWDTXLFNQRWHWR6HFXULW\
    GLUHFWLQJWKDW1LPEHIXQQHOHGLQWRDSURGXFWLYHVSRWEXWRQHZKHUHKLV
    WDOHQWIRUEHWUD\DOZRXOGILQGQRDYHQXH/HWDQXQGHUOLQJILJXUHRXWZKHUH
    DQGKRZ
    +HKDGQHJOHFWHGEXVLQHVVDQGKDGRQHREOLJDWRU\UROHOHIWEHIRUHKH
    FRXOGHVFDSH(YHQKHUHDW6WUHHOLQJKHFRXOGQRWDYRLGHYHU\,PSHULDOGXW\
    $GHOHJDWLRQRI*UH\VILOHGLQ7KH\UHVSHFWIXOO\SUHVHQWHGWKHLU
    DUJXPHQWVUHJDUGLQJFDQGLGDF\H[DPLQDWLRQVIRU(PSLUHSRVLWLRQV7HVWVFRUHV
    KDGEHHQ GHFOLQLQJIRUVHYHUDOFHQWXULHVEXWVRPHDUJXHGWKDWWKLVZDV
    EHFDXVHWKHSRRORIFDQGLGDWHVZDVEURDGHQLQJ7KH\GLGQRWPHQWLRQWKDWWKH
    +LJK&RXQFLOKDGZLGHQHGWKHSRROEHFDXVHLWDSSHDUHGWREHGU\LQJXSWKDW
    LVIHZHUZLVKHG,PSHULDOSRVLWLRQV
    2WKHUVFODLPHGWKDWWKHWHVWVZHUHELDVHG7KRVHIURPODUJHSODQHWVVDLG
    WKHLUKLJKHUJUDYLW\PDGHWKHPVORZHU7KRVHIURPOLJKWHUJUDYLWLHVKDGD
    UHYHUVHDUJXPHQWZLWKGLDJUDPVDQGVKHHWVRIIDFWV
    $OVRWKHP\ULDGHWKQLFDQGUHOLJLRXVJURXSVKDGFRQJHDOHGLQWRDQ
    $FWLRQ)URQWZKLFKIHUUHWHGRXWELDVHVDJDLQVWWKHPLQWKHH[DPLQDWLRQV+DUL
    FRXOGQRWIDWKRPDFRQVSLUDF\EHKLQGWKHH[DPLQDWLRQTXHVWLRQV+RZFRXOGRQH
    VLPXOWDQHRXVO\GLVFULPLQDWHDJDLQVWVHYHUDOKXQGUHGRUHYHQDWKRXVDQG
    HWKQLFVWUDLQV"
    ,WVHHPVDQLPPHQVHMREWRPHKHYHQWXUHGGLVFULPLQDWLQJDJDLQVWVR
    PDQ\IDFWLRQV
    9HKHPHQWO\D*UH\:RPDQKDQGVRPHDQGIRUFHIXOWROGKLPWKDWWKH
    SUHMXGLFHZDVIRUDVRUWRI,PSHULDOQRUPDFRPPRQVHWRIYRFDEXODULHV
    DVVXPSWLRQVDQGFODVV SXUSRVHV$OOWKHVHZRXOGVKRXOGHURWKHUVDVLGH
    7RFRPSHQVDWHWKH$FWLRQ)URQWZDQWHGWKHXVXDOVHWRISUHIHUHQFHV
    LQVWDOOHGZLWKVOLJKWVKDGLQJVEHWZHHQHDFKHWKQLFLW\WRFRPSHQVDWHIRUWKHLU
    ORZHUSHUIRUPDQFHRQH[DPLQDWLRQV
    7KLVZDVRUGLQDU\DQG+DULUXOHGLWRXWZLWKRXWKDYLQJWRWKLQNDERXWLW
    YHU\PXFKWKLVDOORZHGKLPWRPXOORYHUWKHSV\FKRKLVWRU\HTXDWLRQVDZKLOH
    7KHQDQHZQRWHFDXJKWKLVDWWHQWLRQ
    7RGLVSHOWKHFRPPRQPLVSHUFHSWLRQWKDWVFRUHVZHUHEHLQJXQGHUPLQHG
    E\VRPHHWKQLFZRUOGVLQFUHDVHGSDUWLFLSDWLRQWKH$FWLRQ)URQWSHWLWLRQHG
    KLPWRUHQRUPWKHH[DPLQDWLRQLWVHOI6HWWKHDYHUDJHVFRUHDWWKRXJK
    LQIDFWLWKDGGULIWHGGRZQZDUGRYHUWKHODVWWZRFHQWXULHVWR
    7KLVZLOOSHUPLWFRPSDULVRQRIFDQGLGDWHVEHWZHHQ\HDUVZLWKRXWKDYLQJ
    WRORRNXSHDFK\HDUVDYHUDJHWKHEXUO\ZRPDQSRLQWHGRXW
    7KLVZLOOJLYHDV\PPHWULFGLVWULEXWLRQ"+DULDVNHGDEVHQWO\
    <HVDQGZLOOVWRSWKHLQYLGLRXVFRPSDULVRQRIRQH\HDUZLWKWKHQH[W
    :RQWVXFKDVKLIWRIWKHPHDQORVHGLVFULPLQDWRU\SRZHUDWWKHXSSHU
    HQGRIWKHGLVWULEXWLRQ"+HQDUURZHGKLVH\HV
    7KDWLVUHJUHWWDEOHEXW\HV
    ,WVDZRQGHUIXOLGHD+DULVDLG
    6KHVHHPHGVXUSULVHG:HOOZHWKLQNVR
    :HFDQGRWKHVDPHIRU WKHKROREDOODYHUDJHV
    :KDW",GRQW
    6HWWKHVWDWLVWLFVVRWKDWWKHDYHUDJHKLWWHUVWULNHVUDWKHUWKDQ
    WKHKDUGWRUHPHPEHURIWKHSUHVHQW
    %XW,GRQWWKLQNDSULQFLSOHRIVRFLDOMXVWLFH
    $QGWKHLQWHOOLJHQFHVFRUHV7KRVHQHHGWREHUHQRUPHGDVZHOO,FDQ
    VHHWKDW$JUHHG"
    :HOO,PQRWVXUH)LUVW0LQLVWHU:HRQO\LQWHQGHG
    1RQRWKLVLVDELJLGHD,ZDQWDWKRURXJKORRNDWDOOSRVVLEOHUH
    QRUPLQJDJHQGDV<RXKDYHWRWKLQNELJ
    :HDUHQWSUHSDUHG

    7KHQJHWSUHSDUHG,ZDQWDUHSRUW1RWDVNLPS\RQHHLWKHU$IDW
    IXOOUHSRUW7ZRWKRXVDQGSDJHVDWOHDVW
    7KDWZRXOGWDNH
    +DQJWKHH[SHQVH$QGWKHWLPH7KLVLVWRRLPSRUWDQWWRUHOHJDWHWR
    WKH,PSHULDO([DPLQDWLRQV/HWPHKDYHWKDWUHSRUW
    ,WZRXOGWDNH\HDUVGHFDGHV
    7KHQWKHUHVQRWLPHWRZDVWH
    7KH$FWLRQ)URQWGHOHJDWLRQOHIWLQFRQIXVLRQ+DULKRSHGWKH\ZRXOG
    PDNHLWDYHU\ELJUHSRUWLQGHHGVRWKDWKHZDVQRORQJHU)LUVW0LQLVWHU
    ZKHQLWDUULYHG
    3DUWRIPDLQWDLQLQJWKH(PSLUHLQYROYHGXVLQJLWVRZQLQHUWLDDJDLQVW
    LWVHOI6RPHDVSHFWVRIWKLVMREKHWKRXJKWFRXOGEHDFWXDOO\HQMR\DEOH
    +HUHDFKHG9ROWDLUHEHIRUHOHDYLQJWKHRIILFH+HUHV\RXUOLVWRI
    LPSHUVRQDWLRQV
    ,PXVWVD\,DPKDYLQJWURXEOHKDQGOLQJDOOWKHIDFWLRQV9ROWDLUH
    VDLG+HSUHVHQWHGDVDVZDLQLQHOHJDQWYHOYHW%XWWKHFKDQFHWRYHQWXUH
    RXWWREHDSUHVHQFHLWLVOLNHDFWLQJ$QG,ZDVDOZD\VRQHIRUWKHVWDJH
    DV\RXNQRZ
    +DULGLGQWEXWKHVDLG7KDWVGHPRFUDF\IRU\RXVKRZEXVLQHVVZLWK
    GDJJHUV$PRQJUHOEUHHGRIJRYHUQPHQW(YHQLILWLVDELJVWDEOHDWWUDFWRU
    LQWKHILWQHVVODQGVFDSH
    5DWLRQDOWKLQNHUVGHSORUHWKHH[FHVVHVRIGHPRFUDF\LWDEXVHVWKH
    LQGLYLGXDODQGHOHYDWHVWKHPRE9ROWDLUHVPRXWKIODWWHQHGLQWRD
    GLVDSSURYLQJOLQH7KHGHDWKRI6RFUDWHVZDVLWVILQHVWIUXLW
    $IUDLG,GRQWJREDFNWKDWIDU+DULVDLGVLJQLQJRII(QMR\WKH
    ZRUN
    

    +HDQG'RUVZDWFKHGWKHJUHDWOXPLQRXVVSLUDOWXUQEHQHDWKWKHPLQLWV
    HWHUQDOQLJKW
    ,GRDSSUHFLDWHVXFKSHUNVVKHVDLGGUHDPLO\7KH\VWRRGDORQHEHIRUH
    WKHVSHFWDFOH:RUOGVDQGOLYHVDQGVWDUVDOOOLNHFUXVKHGGLDPRQGVWKURZQ
    DJDLQVWHWHUQDOEODFNQHVV
    *HWWLQJLQWRWKHSDODFHMXVWWRORRNDWWKH(PSHURUVGLVSOD\URRPV"
    +HKDGRUGHUHGDOOWKHKDOOVFOHDUHG
    *HWWLQJDZD\IURPVQRRSHUVDQGHDYHVGURSSHUV
    <RX\RXKDYHQWKHDUGIURP"
    6KHVKRRNKHUKHDG'DQHHOSXOOHGQHDUO\DOOWKHUHVWRIXVRII
    7UDQWRU+HVD\VOLWWOHWRPH
    ,PSUHWW\GDPQVXUHWKHDOLHQPLQGVZRQWVWULNHDJDLQ7KH\UHDIUDLG
    RIURERWV,WWRRNPHDZKLOHWRVHHWKDWOD\EHKLQGWKHLUWDONDERXW
    UHYHQJH
    0LQJOHGKDWHDQGIHDU9HU\KXPDQ
    6WLOO,WKLQNWKH\YHKDGWKHLUUHYHQJH7KH\VD\WKH*DOD[\ZDVOXVK
    ZLWKOLIHEHIRUHZHFDPH7KHUH DUHF\FOHVRIEDUUHQHUDVWKHQOX[XULDQW
    RQHV'RQWNQRZZK\$SSDUHQWO\WKDWVKDSSHQHGVHYHUDOWLPHVEHIRUHDW
    LQWHUYDOVRIDWKLUGRIDELOOLRQ\HDUVJUHDWGLHEDFNVRILQWHOOLJHQWOLIH
    OHDYLQJRQO\VSRUHV1RZWKH\YHFRPHWRRXU0HVKDQGEHFRPHGLJLWDOIRVVLOV
    )RVVLOVGRQWNLOOVKHVDLGVDUGRQLFDOO\
    1RWDVZHOODVZHGRDSSDUHQWO\
    1RW\RXXV
    7KH\GRKDWH\RXURERWV1RWWKDWWKH\KDYHDQ\ORYHRIKXPDQVDIWHU
    DOOZHPDGH\RXORQJDJR:HUHWREODPH
    7KH\DUHVRVWUDQJH
    +HQRGGHG,EHOLHYHWKH\OOVWD\LQWKHLUGLJLWDOSUHVHUYHXQWLO0DUT
    DQG6\E\OFDQJHWWKHPWUDQVSRUWHGLQWRWKHLUDQFLHQWVSRUHVWDWH7KH\RQFH

    OLYHGWKDWZD\IRUORQJHUWKDQWKH*DOD[\WDNHVWRPDNHDURWDWLRQ
    <RXUSUHWW\GDPQVXUHLVQWJRRGHQRXJKIRU'DQHHOVKHVDLG+H
    ZDQWVWKHPH[WHUPLQDWHG
    ,WVDVWDQGRII,I'DQHHOJRHVDIWHUWKHPKHOOKDYHWRSXOOWKHSOXJ
    RQ7UDQWRUV0HVK7KDWZLOOZRXQGWKH(PSLUH6RKHVVWXFNIXPLQJEXW
    LPSRWHQW
    ,KRSH\RXKDYHHVWLPDWHGWKHEDODQFHSURSHUO\VKHVDLG
    $JOLPPHULQJJRVVDPHUWKRXJKWIOLWWHGDFURVVKLVPLQG7KHWLNWRN
    DWWDFNVXSRQWKH/DPXUNIDFWLRQKDGGLVFUHGLWHGWKHPLQSXEOLFRSLQLRQ1RZ
    WKH\ZRXOGEHVXSSUHVVHGWKURXJKRXWWKH*DOD[\$QGLQWLPHWKHPHPHPLQGV
    ZRXOGOHDYH7UDQWRU
    +DULIURZQHG'DQHHOVXUHO\ZDQWHGERWKWKHVHRXWFRPHV
    +HKDGXQGRXEWHGO\VXVSHFWHGWKDWWKHPHPHPLQGVKDGVXUYLYHGSHUKDSV
    WKDWWKH\ZHUHLQDFWLRQRQ7UDQWRU6RFRXOG+DULVDPDWHXUPDQHXYHULQJV
    LQFOXGLQJWKH/DPXUNPXUGHUVKDYHEHHQGHIWO\FRQMXUHGXSE\'DQHHO"&RXOGD
    URERWVRDFFXUDWHO\SUHGLFWZKDWKH+DULZRXOGGR"
    $FKLOOUDQWKURXJKKLP6XFKDELOLW\ZRXOGEHEUHDWKWDNLQJ6XSHUKXPDQ
    :LWKWLNWRNVQRZVRRQWREHVXSSUHVVHG7UDQWRUZRXOGKDYHWURXEOH
    SURGXFLQJLWV RZQIRRG7DVNVRQFHGRQHE\PHQZRXOGKDYHWREHUHOHDUQHG
    WDNLQJJHQHUDWLRQVWRHVWDEOLVKVXFKODERUHUVDVDVRFLDOO\YDOXHGJURXS
    DJDLQ0HDQZKLOHGR]HQVRIRWKHUZRUOGVZRXOGKDYHWRVHQG7UDQWRUIRRGD
    OLIHOLQHVOHQGHUDQGYXOQHUDEOH'LG'DQHHOLQWHQGWKDWWRR"7RZKDWHQG"
    +DULIHOWXQHDV\+HVHQVHGVRFLDOIRUFHVDWZRUNMXVWEH\RQGKLVYLHZ
    :DVVXFKDGURLWWKLQNLQJWKHSURGXFWRIPLOOHQQLDRIH[SHULHQFHDQG
    KLJKSRVLWURQLFLQWHOOLJHQFH")RUMXVWDPRPHQW+DULKDGDYLVLRQRIDPLQG
    ERWKVWUDQJHDQGPHDVXUHOHVVLQKXPDQWHUPV:DVWKDWZKDWDQLPPRUWDO
    PDFKLQHEHFDPH"
    7KHQKHSXVKHGWKHLGHDDZD\,WZDVWRRXQVHWWOLQJWRFRQWHPSODWH
    /DWHUSHUKDSVZKHQSV\FKRKLVWRU\ZDVGRQH
    +HQRWLFHG'RUVVWDULQJDWKLP:KDWKDGVKHVDLG"2K\HV
    (VWLPDWLQJWKHEDODQFH\HV,PJHWWLQJWKHIHHOIRUWKHVHWKLQJV
    :LWK9ROWDLUHDQG-RDQGRLQJWKHVFXWZRUNDQG<XJRQRZFKDLUPDQRIWKH
    0DWKLVW'HSDUWPHQW,DFWXDOO\KDYHWLPHWRWKLQN
    $QGVXIIHUIRROVJODGO\"
    7KH$FDGHPLF3RWHQWDWH"$WOHDVW,XQGHUVWDQGKHUQRZ+HSHHUHGDW
    'RUV'DQHHOVD\VKHZLOOOHDYH7UDQWRU+HVORVWDORWRIKLVKXPDQLIRUPV
    'RHVKHQHHG\RX"
    6KHORRNHGXSDWKLPLQWKHVRIWJORZ+HUH[SUHVVLRQZRUNHGZLWK
    FRQIOLFW,FDQWOHDYH\RX
    +LVRUGHUV"
    0LQH
    +HJULWWHGKLVWHHWK7KHURERWVZKRGLHG\RXNQHZWKHP"
    6RPH:HWUDLQHGWRJHWKHUEDFNEDFNZKHQ
    <RXGRQWKDYHWRFRQFHDODQ\WKLQJIURPPH,NQRZ\RXPXVWEHDWOHDVW
    DFHQWXU\ROG
    +HUPRXWKPDGHDQ2RIVXUSULVHWKHQTXLFNO\FORVHG+RZ"
    <RXNQRZPRUHWKDQ\RXVKRXOG
    6RGR\RXLQEHGDQ\ZD\6KHFKXFNOHG
    ,OHDUQHGLWIURPDSDQ,PHW
    6KHODXJKHGEDZGLO\WKHQVREHUHG,PRQHKXQGUHGVL[W\WKUHH
    :LWKWKHWKLJKVRIDWHHQDJHU,I\RXKDGWULHGWROHDYH7UDQWRU,G
    KDYHEORFNHG\RX
    6KHEOLQNHG7UXO\"
    +HELWKLVOLSWKLQNLQJ:HOOQR
    6KHVPLOHG0RUHURPDQWLFWRVD\\HV
    ,KDYHDKDELWRIKRQHVW\ZKLFK,GEHWWHUGURSLI,ZDQWWRVWD\
    )LUVW0LQLVWHU

    6R\RXZRXOGOHWPHJR"<RXVWLOOIHHOWKDW\RXRZHWKDWWR'DQHHO"
    ,IKHWKRXJKWWKHGDQJHUWR\RXZDVWKDWJUHDWWKHQ,ZRXOGKRQRUKLV
    MXGJPHQW
    <RXVWLOOUHVSHFWXVVR"
    5RERWVZRUNVHOIOHVVO\IRUWKH(PSLUHDOZD\V)HZKXPDQVGR
    <RXGRQWZRQGHUZKDWZHGLGWRHDUQWKHDOLHQVUHYHQJH"
    2IFRXUVH'R\RXNQRZ"
    6KHVKRRNKHUKHDGJD]LQJRXWDWWKHYDVWWXUQLQJGLVN6XQVRIEOXH
    DQGFULPVRQDQG\HOORZVZHSWDORQJWKHLURUELWVDPLGGDUNGXVWDQGGLVRUGHU
    ,WZDVVRPHWKLQJDZIXO'DQHHOZDVWKHUHDQGKHZLOOQRWVSHDNRILW7KHUH
    LVQRWKLQJLQRXUKLVWRU\RIWKLV,YHORRNHG
    $QHPSLUHODVWLQJPDQ\PLOOHQQLDKDVPDQLIROGVHFUHWV+DULZDWFKHG
    WKHVORZVSLQRIDKXQGUHGELOOLRQIODPLQJVWDUV,PPRUHLQWHUHVWHGLQLWV
    IXWXUHLQVDYLQJLW
    <RXIHDUWKDWIXWXUHGRQW\RX"
    7HUULEOHWKLQJVDUHFRPLQJ7KHHTXDWLRQVVKRZWKDW
    :HFDQIDFHWKHPWRJHWKHU
    +HWRRNKHULQKLVDUPVEXWWKH\ERWKVWLOOZDWFKHGWKH*DOD[\V
    VKLQLQJPDUYHOV,GUHDPRIIRXQGLQJVRPHWKLQJDZD\WRKHOSWKH(PSLUH
    HYHQDIWHUZHUHJRQH
    $QG\RXIHDUVRPHWKLQJWRRVKHVDLGLQWRKLVQHFN
    +RZGLG\RXNQRZ"<HV,IHDUWKHFKDRVWKDWFRXOGFRPHIURPVRPDQ\
    IRUFHVGLYHUJHQWYHFWRUWXUPRLODOODFWLQJ WREULQJGRZQWKHRUGHURIWKH
    (PSLUH,IHDUIRUWKHYHU\+LVIDFHFORXGHG)RUWKHYHU\IRXQGDWLRQV
    WKHPVHOYHV)RXQGDWLRQV
    &KDRVFRPHV"
    ,NQRZZHRXUVHOYHVRXUPLQGVFRPHRXWRIVNDWLQJRQWKHLQQHUULPRI
    FKDRVVWDWHV7KHGLJLWDOZRUOGVKRZVWKDW<RXVKRZWKDW
    6KHVDLGVREHUO\,GRQRWWKLQNSRVLWURQLFPLQGVXQGHUVWDQGWKHPVHOYHV
    DQ\EHWWHUWKDQKXPDQRQHV
    :HRXUPLQGVDQGRXU(PSLUHERWKVSULQJIURPDQHPHUJHQWRUGHURI
    LQQHUEDVLFDOO\FKDRWLFVWDWHVEXW
    <RXGR QRWZDQWWKH(PSLUHWRFUDVKIURPVXFKFKDRV
    ,ZDQWWKH(PSLUHWRVXUYLYH2UDWOHDVWLILWIDOOVWRUHHPHUJH
    +DULVXGGHQO\IHOWWKHSDLQRIVXFKYDVWPRYHPHQWV7KH(PSLUHZDVOLNH
    DPLQGDQGPLQGVVRPHWLPHVZHQWFUD]\FUDVKHG$GLVDVWHUIRURQHVROLWDU\
    PLQG+RZFRORVVDOO\ZRUVHIRUDQ(PSLUH
    6HHQWKURXJKWKHSULVPRIKLVPDWKHPDWLFVKXPDQLW\ZDVRQDORQJPDUFK
    SUHVVLQJIRUZDUGWKURXJKVXUURXQGLQJGDUN7LPHEDWWHUHGWKHPZLWKVWRUPV
    UHZDUGHGWKHPZLWKVXQVKLQHDQGWKH\GLGQRWJOLPSVHWKDWWKHVHSDVVLQJ
    VHDVRQVFDPHIURPWKHVKLIWLQJFDGHQFHVRIKXJHHWHUQDOHTXDWLRQV
    5XQQLQJWKHHTXDWLRQVWLPHIRUZDUGWKHQEDFNZDUG+DULKDGVHHQ
    KXPDQLW\VPRUWDOSDUDGHLQVQLSV6RPHKRZWKDWPDGHLWRGGO\WRXFKLQJ
    6WHHSHGLQWKHLURZQHUDVIHZZRUOGVHYHUJOLPSVHGWKHURXWHDKHDG7KHUHZDV
    QRVKRUWDJHRISRUWHQWRXVWDONRURIRDIVZKRSUHWHQGHGZLWKDZLQNDQGDQRG
    WRIDWKRPWKHXQVHHDEOH0LVOHGZKROH=RQHVVWXPEOHGDQGIHOO
    +HVRXJKWSDWWHUQVEXWEHQHDWKWKRVHYDVWVZHHSVOD\WKH VHHPLQJO\
    LQILQLWHVLPDOOLYLQJSHRSOH$FURVVWKHUHDOPRIVWDUVXQGHUWKHODZVWKDW
    UHLJQHGOLNHJRGVOD\LQQXPHUDEOHOLYHVLQWKHSURFHVVRIEHLQJORVW)RUWR
    OLYHZDVWRORVHLQWKHHQG
    6RFLDOODZVDFWHGDQGSHRSOHZHUHPDLPHGGDPDJHGUREEHG DQGVWUDQJOHG
    E\IRUFHVWKH\FRXOGQRWHYHQJOLPSVH3HRSOHZHUHGULYHQWRVLFNQHVVWR
    GHVSHUDWLRQWRORQHOLQHVVDQGIHDUDQGUHPRUVH6KDNHQE\WHDUVDQGORQJLQJ
    LQDZRUOGWKH\IXQGDPHQWDOO\IDLOHGWRIDWKRPWKH\QRQHWKHOHVVFDUULHGRQ
    7KHUHZDVQRELOLW\LQWKDW7KH\ZHUHIUDJPHQWVDGULIWLQWLPHPRWHVLQ
    DQ(PSLUHULFKDQGVWURQJDQGIXOORISULGHDQRUGHUIDLOLQJDQGEDWWHUHGDQG
    KROORZZLWKLWVRZQHPSWLQHVV

    :LWKOHDGHQFHUWDLQW\+DULDWODVWVDZWKDWKHSUREDEO\ZRXOGQRWEH
    DEOHWRUHVFXHWKHJUHDWUDPVKDFNOH(PSLUHDEHDVWRIILQHQXDQFHDQG
    PXOWLSO\LQJVHOIGHOXVLRQV
    1RVDYLRUKH%XWSHUKDSVKHFRXOGKHOS
    7KH\ERWKVWRRGLQVLOHQFHIRUDORQJDFKLQJWLPH7KH*DOD[\WXUQHGLQ
    LWVVORZPDMHVW\$QHDUE\IRXQWDLQVSHZHGJORULRXVDUFVLQWRWKHDLU7KH
    ZDWHUVVHHPHGPRPHQWDULO\IUHHEXWLQIDFWZHUHWUDSSHGIRUHYHUZLWKLQWKH
    VWHHOVNLHVRI7UDQWRU$VZDVKH
    +DULIHOWDGHHSHPRWLRQKHFRXOGQRWGHILQH,WWLJKWHQHGKLVWKURDW
    DQGPDGHKLPSUHVV'RUVWRKLP6KHZDVPDFKLQH DQGZRPDQDQGVRPHWKLQJ
    PRUH$QRWKHUHOHPHQWKHFRXOGQRWIXOO\NQRZDQGKHFKHULVKHGKHUDOOWKH
    PRUHIRUWKDW
    <RXFDUHVRPXFK'RUVZKLVSHUHG
    ,KDYHWR
    3HUKDSVZHVKRXOGWU\WRVLPSO\OLYHPRUHZRUU\OHVV
    +HNLVVHGKHUIHUYHQWO\DQGWKHQODXJKHG
    4XLWHULJKW)RUZKRNQRZVZKDWWKHIXWXUHPD\EULQJ"
    9HU\VORZO\KHZLQNHGDWKHU
    $)7(5:25'

    7KH)RXQGDWLRQVHULHVEHJDQLQ:RUOG:DU,,DV$PHULFDDUFHGWRZDUGLWV
    ]HQLWKDVDZRUOGSRZHU7KHVHULHVSOD\HGRXWRYHUGHFDGHVDVWKH8QLWHG
    6WDWHVGRPLQDWHGWKHZRUOGVPDWWHUVLQDIDVKLRQQRRWKHUQDWLRQHYHUKDG
    <HWWKH)RXQGDWLRQLVDERXWLPSHULXPDQGGHFOLQH'LGWKLVEHWUD\DQDQ[LHW\
    ERUQHYHQLQWKHPRPHQWRIDSSURDFKLQJJORU\"
    ,KDGDOZD\VZRQGHUHGLIWKLVZDVVR3DUWRIPHLWFKHGWRH[SORUHWKH
    LVVXHVZKLFKODFHWKHVHULHV
    7KHLGHDRIZULWLQJIXUWKHUQRYHOVLQWKH)RXQGDWLRQXQLYHUVHFDPHIURP
    -DQHW$VLPRYDQGWKH$VLPRYHVWDWHVUHSUHVHQWDWLYH5DOSK9LFLQDQ]D
    $SSURDFKHGE\WKHP,DWILUVWGHFOLQHGEHLQJEXV\ZLWKSK\VLFVDQGP\RZQ
    QRYHOV%XWP\VXEFRQVFLRXVRQFHDURXVHGUHIXVHGWROHWJRWKHQRWLRQ$IWHU
    KDOID\HDURIVWUXJJOLQJZLWKLGHDVSODLQO\PDGHIRUWKH)RXQGDWLRQ
    SHUVLVWHQWO\GHPDQGLQJH[SUHVVLRQ,ILQDOO\FDOOHGXS5DOSK9LFLQDQ]DDQG
    EHJDQSXWWLQJWRJHWKHUDSODQWRFRQVWUXFWDILWWLQJO\FRPSOH[FXUYHRIDFWLRQ
    DQGPHDQLQJWREHUHYHDOHGLQVHYHUDOQRYHOV7KRXJKZHVSRNHWRVHYHUDO
    DXWKRUVDERXWWKLVSURMHFWWKHEHVWVXLWHGVHHPHGWZRKDUG6)ZULWHUVEURDGO\
    LQIOXHQFHGE\$VLPRYDQGRIXQFKDOOHQJHGWHFKQLFDODELOLW\*UHJ%HDUDQG
    'DYLG%ULQ
    %HDU%ULQDQG,KDYHNHSWLQFORVHWRXFKZKLOH,ZURWHWKLVILUVW
    YROXPHIRUZHLQWHQGWRFUHDWHWKUHHVWDQGDORQHQRYHOVZKLFKQRQHWKHOHVV
    FDUU\IRUZDUGDQRYHUDUFKLQJP\VWHU\WRLWVHQG(OHPHQWVRIWKLVPDNHWKHLU
    ILUVWDSSHDUDQFHKHUHWRDPSOLI\IXUWKHUWKURXJK*UHJ%HDUV)RXQGDWLRQDQG
    &KDRVILQGLQJFRPSOHWLRQ LQ%ULOOV7KLUG)RXQGDWLRQ 7KHVHDUHSUHOLPLQDU\
    WLWOHV ,KDYHSODQWHGLQWKHQDUUDWLYHSUHILJXULQJGHWDLOVDQGNH\HOHPHQWV
    ZKLFKVKDOOEHDUODWHUIUXLW
    *HQUHVDUHFRQVWUDLQHGFRQYHUVDWLRQV&RQVWUDLQWLVHVVHQWLDOGHILQLQJ
    WKHUXOHVDQGDVVXPSWLRQVRSHQWRDQDXWKRU,IKDUG6)RFFXSLHVWKHFHQWHURI
    VFLHQFHILFWLRQWKDWLVSUREDEO\EHFDXVHKDUGQHVVJLYHVWKHILUPHVWERXQGDU\
    6FLHQFHLWVHOI\LHOGVFULVSFRQILQHV
    *HQUHVDUHDOVROLNHLPPHQVHGLVFXVVLRQVZLWKLGHDVGHYHORSHGWUDGHG
    PXWDWHGWKHLUYDULDWLRQVVSXQGRZQWKURXJKWLPH3OD\HUVULQJFKDQJHVRQHDFK
    RWKHUPRUHOLNHDVWHSSLQRXWMD]]EDQGWKDQDVRORFRQFHUWLQDSOXVK
    DXGLWRULXP&RQWUDVWVHULRXVILFWLRQ PRUHDFFXUDWHO\GHVFULEHGLQP\H\HV
    DVPHUHO\VHOIFRQVFLRXVO\VROHPQ ,WKDVFDQRQLFDOFODVVLFVWKDWVXSSRVHGO\
    VWDQGRXWVLGHRIWLPHGHVHUYLQJDZHORRPLQJJUHDWDQGLQWDFWE\WKHPVHOYHV

    0XFKRIWKHSOHDVXUHRIP\VWHULHVRIHVSLRQDJHQRYHOVRU6)OLHVLQ
    WKHLQWHUDFWLRQRIZULWHUVZLWKHDFKRWKHUDQGSDUWLFXODUO\LQ6)VLQYHQWLRQ
    RIIDQGRPZLWKWKHUHDGHUVDVZHOO7KLVLVQWDGHIHFWLWVWKHHVVHQWLDO
    QDWXUHRISRSXODUFXOWXUHZKLFKWKH8QLWHG6WDWHVKDVGRPLQDWHGLQRXUDJH
    ZLWKWKHLQYHQWLRQRIMD]]URFNWKHPXVLFDODQGZULWWHQJHQUHVVXFKDVWKH
    :HVWHUQWKHKDUGERLOHGGHWHFWLYHPRGHUQIDQWDV\DQGRWKHUULFKDUHDV0DQ\
    NLQGVRI6) KDUGXWRSLDQPLOLWDU\VDWLULFDO VKDUHDVVXPSWLRQVFRGH
    ZRUGVOLQHVRIDUJXPHQWQDUUDWLYHYRLFHV)RQGUHPHPEUDQFHRIJROGHQDJH
    $VWRXQGLQJDQGLWVOHWWHUFROXPQRIWKH1HZ:DYHRI+RUDFH*ROGV*DOD[\
    WKHVHDUHHFKRHVRIGLVWDQWFRQYHUVDWLRQVHDUQHVWO\FDUULHGRXW
    *HQUHSOHDVXUHVDUHPDQ\EXWWKLVTXDOLW\RIVKDUHGYDOXHVZLWKLQDQ
    RQJRLQJGLVFXVVLRQPD\EHWKHPRVWSRZHUIXOHQOLVWLQJOLIHORQJGHYRWLRQLQ
    LWVIDQV,QFRQWUDVWWRWKH*UDQG&DQRQYLHZRIJUHDWZRUNVVWDQGLQJOLNH
    PRQROLWKVLQDGHVHUWHGODQGVFDSHJHQUHUHDGLQJVDWLVIDFWLRQVDUHDVWULNLQJ
    IDFHWRIPRGHUQGHPRFUDWLF SRS FXOWXUHDVKDUHGPRYHPHQW
    7KHUHDUHTXHVWLRQVDERXWKRZZULWHUVGHDOZLWKZKDWVRPHFDOOWKH
    DQ[LHW\RILQIOXHQFHEXWZKLFK,GSUHIHUWRWHUPPRUHPLOGO\WKH
    GLJHVWLRQRIWUDGLWLRQ
    ,PUHPLQGHGRI-RKQ%HUJHUVGHILQLWLRQRIKDFNZRUNGHVFULELQJRLO
    SDLQWLQJLQ:D\VRI6HHLQJDVQRWWKHUHVXOWRIHLWKHUFOXPVLQHVVRU
    SURYLQFLDOLVPLWLVWKHUHVXOWRIWKHPDUNHWPDNLQJPRUHLQVLVWHQWGHPDQGV
    WKDQWKHDUW)DLUHQRXJKEXWWKLVFDQKDSSHQLQDQ\FRQWH[W:RUNLQJLQD
    NQRZQUHJLRQRIFRQFHSWVSDFHGRHVQRWQHFHVVDULO\LPSO\WKDWWKHWHUULWRU\
    KDVEHHQPLQHGRXW1RULVIUHVKJURXQGDOZD\VIHUWLOH
    6XUHO\ZHVKRXOGQRWLFHWKDWDQRYHO+HPLQJZD\WKRXJKWWKHEHVWLQ
    $PHULFDQOLWHUDWXUHLVDVHTXHOLQGHHGIROORZLQJRQDER\VERRN7RP
    6DZ\HU
    6KDULQJFRPPRQJURXQGLVQWRQO\DOLWHUDU\WUDGLWLRQ$UHZHWKURZQ
    LQWRPRUDOFRQIXVLRQZKHQZHKHDU5KDSVRG\RQD7KHPHE\3DJDQLQL"'RZH
    LQGLJQDQWO\PDUFKIURPWKHFRQFHUWKDOOZKHQDVVDXOWHGE\9DULDWLRQVRQD
    7KHPHE\+D\GQ"6KDUHFURSSLQJE\WKH*UHDWV"6KRFNLQJ
    5HLQVSHFWLQJWKHDVVXPSWLRQVDQGPHWKRGVRIFODVVLFDOZRUNVFDQ\LHOG
    QHZIUXLW)UHVKQDUUDWLYHFDQERWKVWULNHRXWLQWRQHZWHUULWRU\ZKLOH
    UHIOHFWLQJRQWKHODQGVFDSHRIWKHSDVW5HFDOOWKDW+DPOHWGUHZIURPVHYHUDO
    HDUOLHUSOD\VDERXWWKHVDPHSORW
    ,VDDFKLPVHOIUHYLVLWHGWKH)RXQGDWLRQWDNLQJGLIIHUHQWDQJOHVRI
    DWWDFNHDFKWLPH,QWKHEHJLQQLQJSV\FKRKLVWRU\HTXDWHGWKHPRYHPHQWVRI
    SHRSOHDVDZKROHZLWKWKHPRWLRQVRIPROHFXOHV7KH6HFRQG)RXQGDWLRQORRNHG
    DWSHUWXUEDWLRQVWRVXFKGHWHUPLQLVWLFODZV WKH0XOH DQGLPSOLHGWKDWRQO\D
    VXSHUKXPDQHOLWHFRXOGPDQDJHLQVWDELOLWLHV/DWHUURERWVHPHUJHGDVWKH
    HOLWHEHWWHUWKDQKXPDQVDWGLVSDVVLRQDWHJRYHUQPHQW%H\RQGURERWVFDPH
    *DLDDQGVRRQ
    ,QWKLVWKUHHERRNVHULHVZHVKDOOUHLQVSHFWWKHUROHRIURERWVDQG
    ZKDWSV\FKRKLVWRU\PLJKW ORRNOLNHDVDWKHRU\0RUHULIIVXSRQWKHEDVLF
    WXQH
    ,KDGDOZD\VZRQGHUHGDERXWFUXFLDODVSHFWVRI$VLPRYV(PSLUH
    :K\ZHUHWKHUHQRDOLHQVLQWKHJDOD[\":KDWUROHGLGFRPSXWHUVSOD\"
    3DUWLFXODUO\YVURERWV"
    :KDWGLGWKHWKHRU\RISV\FKRKLVWRU\DFWXDOO\ORRNOLNH"
    )LQDOO\ZKRZDV+DUL6HOGRQDVDFKDUDFWHUDPDQ"
    7KLVQRYHODWWHPSWVVRPHDQVZHUV,WLVP\FRQWULEXWLRQWRDGLVFXVVLRQ
    DERXWSRZHUDQGGHWHUPLQLVPZKLFKKDVQRZVSDQQHGRYHUKDOIDFHQWXU\
    2IFRXUVHZHNQRZVRPHLQFLGHQWDODQVZHUV7KHWHUPSV\FKRKLVWRU\ZDV
    FRPPRQO\XVHGLQWKHWKLUWLHVDQGDSSHDUVLQWKH:HEVWHUV'LFWLRQDU\
    ,VDDFJUHDWO\H[WHQGHGLWVPHDQLQJWKRXJK+HGLGQWZDQWWRGHDOZLWK-RKQ
    Z&DPSEHOOVQRWRULRXVGLVOLNHRIDOLHQVZKRPLJKWEHDVFOHYHUDVZHVRKLV

    )RXQGDWLRQKDGQRQH%XWLWVHHPHGWRPHWKHUHPLJKWEHPRUHWRWKHPDWWHU
    $VZHOO$VLPRYVXQLWLQJRIKLVURERWQRYHOVDQGWKH)RXQGDWLRQVHULHV
    EHFDPHLQWULFDWHDQGSX]]OLQJ7KH%ULWLVKFULWLF%ULDQ6WDEOHIRUGIRXQGWKLV
    FRPIRUWLQJLQLWVFODXVWURSKRELFHQFORVXUH7KHUHDUHQRURERWVLQWKHHDUO\
    )RXQGDWLRQQRYHOVEXWWKH\DUHEHKLQGWKHVFHQHVPDQLSXODWRUVLQERWK3UHOXGH
    WR)RXQGDWLRQDQG)RUZDUGWKH)RXQGDWLRQ
    6RPHIRUPRIDGYDQFHGFRPSXWLQJPDFKLQHVPXVWXQGHUOLHWKH(PSLUH
    VXUHO\,VDDFUHPDUNHGWKDW,MXVWSXWYHU\DGYDQFHGFRPSXWHUVLQWKHQHZ
    )RXQGDWLRQQRYHODQGKRSHGWKDWQRERG\ZRXOGQRWLFHWKHLQFRQVLVWHQF\1RERG\
    GLG$V-DPHV*XQQUHPDUNHG0RUHDFFXUDWHO\SHRSOHQRWLFHGEXWGLGQW
    FDUH
    $VLPRYZURWHHDFK QRYHODWWKHOHYHORIWKHWKHQFXUUHQWVFLHQWLILF
    XQGHUVWDQGLQJ/DWHUZRUNVXSGDWHGWKHVXUURXQGLQJVFLHQFH7KXVKLVJDOD[\LV
    PRUHGHWDLOHGLQODWHUERRNVLQFOXGLQJLQ)RXQGDWLRQV(GJHERWKDGYDQFHG
    FRPSXWHUVDQGDEODFNKROHDWWKH*DODFWLF&HQWHU6LPLODUO\KHUH,KDYH
    GHSLFWHGRXUPRUHGHWDLOHGNQRZOHGJHRIWKH*DODFWLF&HQWHU,QSODFHRI
    ,VDDFVK\SHUVSDFHVKLSV,KDYHXVHGZRUPKROHVZKLFKKDYHFRQVLGHUDEO\PRUH
    WKHRUHWLFDOMXVWLILFDWLRQQRZWKDQWKH\GLGZKHQ(LQVWHLQDQG5RVHQLQWURGXFHG
    WKHPLQWKHV,QGHHGZRUPKROHVDUHDOORZHGE\WKHJHQHUDOWKHRU\RI
    UHODWLYLW\EXWPXVWKDYHH[WUHPHIRUPVRIPDWWHUWRIRUPDQGVXSSRUWWKHP
    0DWW9LVVHUV/RUHQW]LDQ:RUPKROHVLVWKHVWDQGDUGZRUNRQFXUUHQWWKLQNLQJ
    
    ,VDDFZURWHPXFKRIKLVILFWLRQLQDVW\OHKHWHUPHGGLUHFWDQGVSDUH
    WKRXJKLQWKHODWHUZRUNVKHUHOD[HGWKLVFRQVWUDLQWDELW,KDYHQRW
    DWWHPSWHGWRZULWHLQWKH$VLPRYVW\OH 7KRVHZKRWKLQNLWLVHDV\WRZULWH
    FOHDUO\DERXWFRPSOH[VXEMHFWVVKRXOGWU\LW )RUWKH)RXQGDWLRQQRYHOVKH
    XVHGDSDUWLFXODUO\EDUHERDUGVDSSURDFKZLWKYLUWXDOO\QREDFNJURXQG
    GHVFULSWLRQVRUQRYHOLVWLFGHWDLOV
    1RWHKLVRZQUHDFWLRQZKHQKHGHFLGHGWRUHWXUQWRWKHVHULHVDQG
    UHYLVLWHGWKHWULORJ\
    ,UHDGLWZLWKPRXQWLQJXQHDVLQHVV,NHSWZDLWLQJIRUVRPHWKLQJWR
    KDSSHQDQGQRWKLQJHYHUGLG$OOWKUHHYROXPHVDOOWKHQHDUO\TXDUWHURID
    PLOOLRQZRUGVFRQVLVWHGRIWKRXJKWVDQGFRQYHUVDWLRQ1RDFWLRQ1RSK\VLFDO
    VXVSHQVH
    %XWLWZRUNHGIDPRXVO\VR,FRXOGQRWPDQDJHVXFKDQDSSURDFKVRKDYH
    WDNHQP\RZQZD\
    ,IRXQGWKDWWKHGHWDLOVRI7UDQWRURISV\FKRKLVWRU\DQGWKH(PSLUH
    FDOOHGRXWWRPHDV,EHJDQWKLQNLQJDERXWWKLVQRYHOLQGHHGWKH\OHGPHRQ
    P\VXEFRQVFLRXVTXHVWRIWKHXQGHUO\LQJVWRU\6RWKHERRNLVQRWDQLPLWDWLRQ
    $VLPRYQRYHOEXWD%HQIRUGQRYHOXVLQJ$VLPRYVEDVLFLGHDVDQGEDFNGURS
    1HFHVVDULO\P\DSSURDFKKDVKDUNHQHGEDFNWRWKHROGHUVWRU\WHOOLQJ
    VW\OHVZKLFKSUHYDLOHGLQWKH6)RI,VDDFVGD\V,KDYHQHYHUUHVSRQGHG
    IDYRUDEO\WRWKHUHFHQWUD]RULQJRIOLWHUDWXUHE\FULWLFVWKHWULEHVRI
    VWUXFWXUDOLVWVSRVWPRGHUQLVWVGHFRQVWUXFWLRQLVWV7RPDQ\6)ZULWHUV
    SRVWPRGHUQLVVLPSO\DVLJQDWXUHRIH[KDXVWLRQ,WVW\SLFDODSSDUDWXVVHOI
    UHIHUHQFHKHDY\GROORSVRI REOLJDWRU\LURQ\VHOIFRQVFLRXVXVHRIROGHU
    JHQUHGHYLFHVSDVWLFKHDQGSDURG\EHWUD\VODFNRILQYHQWLRQRIWKHFUXFLDO
    FRLQRI6)LPDJLQDWLRQ6RPHGHFRQVWUXFWLRQLVWVKDYHDWWDFNHGVFLHQFHLWVHOI
    DVPHUHUKHWRULFQRWDQRUGHULQJRIQDWXUHVHHNLQJWRUHGXFHLWWRWKH
    VWDWXVRIWKHXOWLPDWHO\DUELWUDU\KXPDQLWLHV0RVW6)W\SHVILQGWKLVDWWDFN
    RQHPSLULFLVPDZRUQROGVRQJZLWKQHZO\ULFVTXLWHTXDLQWO\UHWUR
    $WWKHFRUHRI6)OLHVWKHH[SHULHQFHRIVFLHQFH7KLVPDNHVWKHJHQUH
    ILQDOO\KRVWLOHWRVXFKIDVKLRQVLQFULWLFLVPIRULWYDOXHVLWVHPSLULFDO
    JURXQG'HFRQVWUXFWLRQLVPVVWUHVVRQFRQWUDGLFWRU\RUVHOIFRQWDLQHGLQWHUQDO
    GLIIHUHQFHVLQWH[WVUDWKHUWKDQWKHLUOLQNWRUHDOLW\RIWHQPHUHO\OHDGVWR
    OLWHUDWXUHVHHQDVHPSW\ZRUGJDPHV
    6)QRYHOVJLYHXVZRUOGVZKLFKDUHQRWWREHWDNHQDVPHWDSKRUVEXWDV

    UHDO:HDUHDVNHGWRSDUWLFLSDWHLQZUHQFKLQJO\VWUDQJHHYHQWVQRWPHUHO\
    ZDWFKWKHPIRUFOXHVWRZKDWWKH\UHUHDOO\WDONLQJDERXW 8PPPLIWKLV
    VWDQGVIRUWKDWWKHQWKHRWKHUVWXIIPXVWVWDQGIRU1RWDZD\WRJDWKHU
    QDUUDWLYHPRPHQWXP 7KH0DUVDQGVWDUVDQGGLJLWDOGHVHUWVRIRXUEHVWQRYHOV
    DUHILQDOO\WREHWDNHQDVUHDODVLIWRVD\/LIHLVQWOLNHWKLVLWLV
    WKLV-RXUQH\VFDQJRWRIUHVKSODFHVQRWPHUHO\UHWXUQXVWRRXUVHOYHV
    (YHQVR,YHLQGXOJHGP\VHOIDELWLQWKHVDWLULFDOVFHQHVGHSLFWLQJDQ
    DFDGHPLDJRLQJRIIWKHUDLOVEXW,IHHO,VDDFZRXOGKDYHDSSURYHGRIP\
    WDUJHWV5HDGHUVWKLQNLQJ,YHJRQHRYHUERDUGLQGHSLFWLQJWKHYLHZWKDW
    VFLHQFHGRHVQRWGHDOZLWKREMHFWLYHWUXWKVEXWLQVWHDGLVDEDWWOHJURXQGRI
    SRZHUSROLWLFVZKHUHQD,YHUHDOLVPPHHWVUHODWLYLVWZRUOGYLHZVVKRXOGORRN
    LQWR7KH*ROHPE\+DUU\&ROOLQVDQG7UHYRU3LQFK7KLVERRNDWWHPSWVWR
    SRUWUD\VFLHQWLVWVDVQRPRUHWKHKROGHUVRIREMHFWLYHNQRZOHGJHWKDQDUH
    ODZ\HUVRUWUDYHODJHQWV
    7KHUHFHQWUHQRUPLQJRIWKH6FKRODVWLF$SWLWXGH7HVWVVRWKDWHDFK
    \HDUWKHDYHUDJHLVIRUFHGWRWKHVDPHQXPEHUWKXVPDVNLQJWKHGHFOLQHRI
    DELOLW\LQVWXGHQWV,VDWLUL]HLQWKHYHU\ODVWSDJHVRIWKHQRYHO,KRSH
    ,VDDFZRXOGKDYHJRWWHQDFKXFNOHIURPVHHLQJWKHLVVXHIUDPHGDJDLQVWDQ
    HQWLUHJDOD[\
    )URP9HUQHDQG:HOOVWRVRPHZKHUHQHDUVFLHQFHILFWLRQZDVPRVWO\
    DERXWWKHZRQGHUVRIPRYHPHQWRIWUDQVSRUWDWLRQ1RWHWKHLQQXPHUDEOHQRYHOV
    ZLWKWKHZRUGVWDULQWKHLUWLWOHVHYRNLQJIDUGHVWLQDWLRQVDQGVWRULHVVXFK
    DV5REHUW+HLQOHLQV7KH5RDGV0XVW5ROO
    %XWLQWKHSDVWIHZGHFDGHVZHKDYHIRFXVHGPRUHRQWKHZRQGHUVRI
    LQIRUPDWLRQRIWUDQVIRUPDWLRQVDWOHDVWSDUWO\LQWHUQDOQRW H[WHUQDO7KH
    ,QWHUQHWYLUWXDOUHDOLW\FRPSXWHUVLPXODWLRQVDOOWKHVHORRPODUJHLQRXU
    YLVLRQVRIRXUIXWXUHV7KLVQRYHODWWHPSWVWRFRPELQHWKHVHWZRWKHPHVZLWK
    VHYHUDOFRQVSLFXRXVVFHQHVDERXWWUDYHODQGDODUJHUEDFNJURXQGPRWLIRQ
    FRPSXWHUV
    $V-DPHV*XQQQRWHGWKH)RXQGDWLRQVHULHVLVDVDJD,WVPHWKRGOLHVLQ
    DUHSHDWHGSDWWHUQ2XWRIWKHVROXWLRQRIHDFKSUREOHPJURZVWKHQH[WSUREOHP
    WREHVROYHG7KLVEHFDPHRIFRXUVHDFRQVLGHUDEOHFRQVWUDLQWRQODWHU
    QRYHOV$VLPRYVHHPHGWREHVD\LQJWKDWOLIHZDVDVHULHVRISUREOHPVWREH
    VROYHGEXWOLIHLWVHOIFRXOGQHYHUEHVROYHG$V*XQQUHPDUNHGFRQVLGHULQJ
    WKDWWKHFRPELQHGDQGLQWHJUDWHG)RXQGDWLRQDQG5RERWVDJDQRZFRYHUVVL[WHHQ
    ERRNVSHUKDSVDGLUHFWRU\RILWDOOLVFDOOHGIRUQDPHGSHUKDSV
    (QF\FORSHGLD*DODFWLFD"
    *DODFWLFHPSLUHVEHFDPHDPDLQVWD\IUDPHIRUVFLHQFHILFWLRQ3RXO
    $QGHUVRQV)ODQGU\QRYHOVDQG*RUGRQ5'LFNVRQ LQKLV'RUVDLVHULHV 
    SDUWLFXODUO\VWXGLHGWKHVRFLRSROLWLFDOVWUXFWXUHRIVXFKYDVWFRPSOH[HVIRU
    D SRZHUIXODXWRFUDWLFLPSHULDOV\VWHPGHPDQGVJUHDWRUJDQL]DWLRQDOVNLOOWKH
    SULPDU\DVVHWRIWKH5RPDQVWKHPVHOYHV
    ,VDDFZDVQRWDOZD\VFRQVLVWHQWLQKLVQXPEHUV+RZPDQ\GZHOORQ
    7UDQWRU"8VXDOO\KHVD\VIRUW\ELOOLRQEXWLQ6HFRQG)RXQGDWLRQLWLV 
    ELOOLRQ XQOHVVWKDWVDW\SR 6SUHDGIRUW\ELOOLRQRYHUDQ(DUWKVL]HGZRUOG
    ZLWKDOOLWVVHDVGUDLQHG DQGWKDWVRQO\DERXWDKXQGUHGSHUVTXDUH
    NLORPHWHU6XUHO\KRXVLQJWKHPZRXOGQRWGHPDQGDKDOINLORPHWHUGHHSFLW\
    'DWHVDOVRJHWGLIILFXOWWRIROORZDFURVVVXFKLPPHQVLWLHVRIWLPH
    7UDQWRULVDWOHDVW\HDUVROGDQGQRWHWKDWZHDVVXPHWKDWWKH\HDULV
    (DUWKVWKRXJK(DUWKVORFDWLRQKDVEHHQIRUJRWWHQ%\WKH*DODFWLF(PSLUH
    FDOHQGDU3HEEOHLQWKH6N\ZKLFKKDVUHIHUHQFHVWRKXQGUHGVRIWKRXVDQGVRI
    \HDUVRIH[SDQVLRQLQWRVSDFHRFFXUVDERXW*(,Q)RXQGDWLRQDWRPLF
    HQHUJ\LV\HDUVROG7KHURERW'DQHHOLV\HDUVROGLQ3UHOXGHWR
    )RXQGDWLRQDQGLQ)RUZDUGWKH)RXQGDWLRQ+RZIDUDZD\LQRXUIXWXUHGRWKH
    6XQ DQG6SDFHVKLSHPEOHPUXOH"3HUKDSV\HDUV"1RRQHGDWHUHFRQFLOHV
    HYHU\GHWDLO

    1RWWKDWLWWUXO\PDWWHUV,NQRZWKHGDQJHUVRIZULWLQJDORQJVHULHV
    RYHUGHFDGHV,WRRNWZHQW\ILYH\HDUVWRZUHVWOHZLWKWKHVL[YROXPHVRIP\
    *DODFWLF&HQWHUVHULHV8QGRXEWHGO\WKHUHDUHFRQWUDGLFWLRQV,PLVVHGLQ
    GDWLQJDQGRWKHUGHWDLOVHYHQWKRXJK,ODLGLWDOORXWLQDWLPHOLQH
    SXEOLVKHGLQWKHODVWYROXPH7KHDOLHQVRIWKDWVHULHVDUHQRWWKRVH
    LPSOLFDWHGLQWKLVQRYHOEXWWKHUHDUHFOHDUO\FRQFHSWXDOOLQNV
    6FLHQFHILFWLRQVSHDNVRIWKHIXWXUHEXWWRWKHSUHVHQW7KHJUDQG
    LVVXHVRIVRFLDOSRZHUDQGWKHWHFKQRORJ\WKDWGULYHVLWZLOOQHYHUIDGH
    2IWHQSUREOHPVDUHEHVWVHHQLQWKHSHUVSHFWLYHVRILPSOLFDWLRQEHIRUHZH
    PHHWWKHPRQWKHJULWW\JURXQGRIWKHLUDUULYDO
    ,VDDF$VLPRYZDVXOWLPDWHO\KRSHIXODERXWKXPDQLW\+HVDZXVDJDLQDQG
    DJDLQFRPLQJWRDFURVVURDGVDQGSUHYDLOLQJ7KH)RXQGDWLRQLVDERXWWKDW
    :KDWPDWWHUVLQVDJDVLVVZHHS7KLVWKH)RXQGDWLRQVHULHVVXUHO\KDV
    ,FDQRQO\KRSH,KDYHDGGHGDELWWRWKDW

    :RUNVWUDFLQJWKHLQWULFDFLHVRIWKH)RXQGDWLRQLQFOXGHQRWDEO\$OH[HL
    DQG&RU\3DQVKLQVKLVWRULFDO7KH:RUOG%H\RQGWKH+LOO-DPHV*XQQV
    LQVLJKWIXO,VDDF$VLPRY-RVHSK3DWURXFKVWKRURXJK7KH6FLHQFH)LFWLRQRI
    ,VDDF$VLPRYDQG$OYD5RJHUV5HTXLHPIRU$VWRXQGLQJZKLFKJLYHVDVHQVHRI
    ZKDWLWZDVOLNHWRUHDGWKHFODVVLFZRUNVDVWKH\DSSHDUHG,OHDUQHGIURP
    DOOWKHVHVWXGLHV
    )RUDGYLFHDQGFRPPHQWVRQWKLVSURMHFW,DPHVSHFLDOO\JUDWHIXOWR
    -DQHW$VLPRY0DUN0DUWLQ'DYLG%ULQ-RH0LOOHU-HQQLIHU%UHKODQG
    (OLVDEHWK%URZQIRUFORVHUHDGLQJVRIWKHPDQXVFULSW0\JUDWLWXGHJRHVWR'RQ
    'L[RQIRUKLVIDQWDVWLFDOIXWXUHEHDVWLDU\$SSUHFLDWLRQIRUJHQHUDOKHOSLV
    GXHWRP\ZLIH-RDQ$EEHDQGWR5DOSK9LFLQDQ]D -DQHW$VLPRY-DPHV*XQQ
    -RKQ6LOEHUVDFN'RQDOG.LQJVEXU\&KULV6FKHOOLQJ-RKQ'RXJODV*UHJ%HDU
    *HRUJH=HEURZVNL3DXO&DUWHU/RX$URQLFD-HQQLIHU+HUVKH\*DU\:HVWIDKO
    DQG-RKQ&OXWH7KDQNVWRDOO
    6HSWHPEHU
    B*UHJRU\%HQIRUGSK\VLFLVWHGXFDWRUDXWKRUZDVERUQLQ0RELOH
    $ODEDPD+HLVDSURIHVVRURISK\VLFVDWWKH8QLYHUVLW\RI&DOLIRUQLD
    ,UYLQHDQGFRQGXFWVUHVHDUFKLQSODVPDWXUEXOHQFHWKHRU\DQGH[SHULPHQWDQG
    LQDVWURSK\VLFV+HKDVSXEOLVKHGZHOORYHUDKXQGUHGSDSHUV+HLVD
    :RRGURZ:LOVRQ)HOORZDQGDYLVLWLQJSURIHVVRUDW&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\DQGKDV
    VHUYHGDVDQDGYLVRUWRWKH'HSDUWPHQWRI(QHUJ\1$6$DQGWKH:KLWH+RXVH
    &RXQFLORQ6SDFH3ROLF\
    0DQ\RIKLVEHVWNQRZQQRYHOVDUHSDUWRIDVL[QRYHOVHTXHQFHEHJLQQLQJ
    LQWKHQHDUIXWXUHZLWK,QWKH2FHDQRI1LJKWDQGFRQWLQXLQJRQZLWK$FURVV
    WKH6HDRI6XQV7KHVHULHVWKHQOHDSVWRWKHIDUIXWXUHDWWKHFHQWHURI
    RXUJDOD[\ZKHUHDGHVSHUDWHKXPDQGUDPDXQIROGVEHJLQQLQJZLWK*UHDW6N\
    5LYHUDQGSURFHHGLQJWKURXJK7LGHVRI/LJKW)XULRXV*XOIDQGFRQFOXGLQJ
    ZLWK6DLOLQJ%ULJKW(WHUQLW\$WWKHVHULHVHQGWKHOLQNVWRWKHHDUOLHU
    QRYHOVHPHUJHUHYHDOLQJDVLQJOHXQIROGLQJWDSHVWU\DJDLQVWDQLPPHQVH
    EDFNJURXQG

    You might also like