Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The marine environment around the contested Scarborough Shoal and Spratly Islands includes
fish, corals, mangroves, and sea grasses as well as giant clams and sea turtles, some of them
recognized as endangered, according to tribunal findings.
Testimony before the tribunal from Kent Carpenter, a professor of biological sciences at Old
Dominion University in Norfolk, Virginia, describes how the impact of any environmental damage
occurring at Scarborough Shoal and in the Spratly Islands can affect the health and viability of
ecosystems elsewhere in the South China Sea.
All of this is of great importance to the nations surrounding the South China Sea, because of a
growing appetite for fish and the protein they provide even as fish stocks decline in the region.
The coral reefs protect small fish from predators. They also play a role in replenishing depleted fish
stocks.
Experts say that in addition to the Chinese cutter boats destruction of coral reefs, further serious
damage has been caused by Chinese boats engaged in dredging aimed at gathering sand and
gravel to build of Chinas artificial islands in the South China Sea.
The Chinese government has also encouraged Chinese fishing boat incursions deep into the
South China Sea by offering subsidies for petrol and free satellite-navigation systems.
A comprehensive report published on June 1 in Time magazine concludes that the Chinese
governments support for local fishermen has made venturing into contested areas more
economically attractive, exacerbating the overfishing that already plagues the waterway.
Chinas response
Chinese officials have stated on numerous occasions that Chinas island building in the South
China Sea has caused no significant damage to coral reefs.
They say that China has conducted rigorous scientific testing and that once the countrys
construction projects on contested territory that China claims are completed, environmental
protection will be notably enhanced.
But China declined to participate in the proceedings of the international tribunal in The Hague.
Beijing also declined to submit any scientific findings, saying repeatedly that it wouldnt accept the
ruling of the tribunal even before it was announced.
Chinese state media subsequently denounced the ruling as ill-founded and questioned the
tribunals motives, impartiality, and competence.
Chinas top naval officer, Wu Shengli, told the U.S. Chief of Naval Operations John Richardson on
July 25 in a meeting in Beijing that China would not stop building islands in the South China Sea,
according to the official Xinhua news agency.
But in a more conciliatory tone, Chinas State Councilor Yang Jiechi said last week that China was
willing to work with neighboring countries on the joint development of natural resources in the
region.
Most obviously this might include the contested waters surrounding the Scarborough Shoal, where
the Hague-based tribunal found that both China and the Philippines have been fishing for many
years.
But the Associated Press reported on July 21 that Southeast Asian nations involved in disputes
with China over fishing grounds suspect that Beijings calls for negotiations are stalling tactics as
China continues to build airstrips and other infrastructure in the South China Sea.
The AP said that Tran Cong Truc, the former head of Vietnams borders committee, had dismissed
Chinas overtures.
They wanted to secure a placement in the joint development as a first step and then control all of
it, Truc was quoted as saying.There might be some differences in the way they talkbut there is
no change in their nature.
It remains unclear what conditions Beijing would impose on such talks.
None of the players are giving much thought to sustainable exploitation of the fish stocks, says
David Brown, a retired American diplomat, writer, and analyst who focuses mostly on Vietnam.
But at this point only the Chinese, with the advantage of both numbers and technology, are
capable of wiping out those fish stocks, one species after another.
Possible solutions
As a course to calmer waters, John McManus of the University of Miami proposes a freeze on
territorial claims along with joint resource management shared by the countries concerned.
This would include fisheries management.
David Brown said it was important that the tribunal recognized that both the Philippines and China
have traditionally fished over the Scarborough Shoal. They could conceivably share the fish stocks
there, he said.
If there were just a modicum of foresight by these three partiesChina, the Philippines, and
Vietnamits possible to imagine their coast guards and fisheries agencies cooperating in joint,
sustainable management of fishing stocks in the northern two thirds of the South China Sea.
But bringing the parties together over the joint development of fishing grounds might prove difficult
as long as nationalistic passions remain inflamed in all three countries.
This is most evident in Vietnam, where sporadic anti-China protests have been occurring in recent
years. In 2014, Vietnamese rioters attacked factories run by owners from both China and Taiwan.
James Borton, a senior fellow at the U.S. Asia Institute in Washington, D.C., recently visited Ly Son
Island off Vietnams central coast.
There, he found a community of Vietnamese fishermen imbued with nationalistic feelings and in no
mood to back away from clashes with Chinese fishing boats and coast guard vessels.
According to Borton, the Vietnamese government has undertaken a patriotic campaign aimed at
encouraging the population to protect their ancestral lands against outside incursions.
Ly Son Island hosts a national exhibition of historical maps from both Vietnam and China under the
slogan Paracel and Spratly Islands belong to Vietnamthe legal and historical evidence.
Dan Southerland is RFAs executive editor.