You are on page 1of 113

:

:..

:5519

..,

:299

,2010

:5519

32010

..
..

:299/2010

:..,




.

,
,
.

Opera2d, ,
.

.

.

.
2
.

.
3

Opera2d.
4

,
.
4

Abstract
ThisthesiswasproducedinthedepartmentofElectricalEngineeringandComputerScienceat
theUniversityofPatrasandinvolvesthestudyofrotorerrorsinathreephasesynchronousmotor
withsalientpoleswiththehelpoffiniteelementanalysis.
The purpose of this thesis is the monitoring of a threephase synchronous motor with salient
poles during asynchronous starting, with one broken bar, broken ring and in a healthy state for
comparingtheresults.
For the design of the motor we used the machine data of a real motor which is used in a
pumped storage hydroelectric generator. For the creation of the model in two dimensions we
usedthesoftwareOpera2d,whichusesthefiniteelementmethodtosimulatetheoperationof
electricmachines.Forthesuccessofthedesign,anumberofmeasurementsandcalculationswas
takenfromthemachinedatawhicharenotincludedinthethesis.Also,afterthecompletionof
themodel,werunsimulationsinsteadystatetoverifythatthemodelwasrunningaccordingto
designerparameters.
The thesis is divided in five chapters. In the first chapter there is a general description of the
basicknowledgeofelectricenergyandtheprinciplesregardingtheconstructionandoperationof
synchronousmachinesandinparticularthreephasesynchronousmachineswithsalientpoles.
In chapter 2 there is a more detailed description of the operating characteristics of a three
phased synchronous motor and the starting methods, with emphasis at asynchronous starting.
Additionally,thereissomeinformationregardinghydrogeneratorstations.
Chapter3showsthemainstepsfollowedduringthedesignstageofthemodelanditincludes
imagesofthemainpartsofthemotorandthecontrolwindowsofthesoftwareOpera2d.
Chapter 4 starts by showing the main steps and control windows for the analysis parameters
and this is followed by the results of the simulations for the three cases: healthy motor, with
brokenbarandwithbrokenring.
Finally the conclusions for the asynchronous starting of a synchronous motor and how it is
affectedbyabrokenbarandabrokenringattherotor,arepresentedattheendofchapter4.


,..

,
.

.

.
,,
,
.

1.
1.1 ............................................1
1.1.1 ..2
1.1.2 4
1.1.3 ..............................4
1.1.4 6
1.2
1.2.1Faraday..................................7
1.2.2AmperBiotSavat...8
1.2.3Lenz 8
1.2.4.9
1.3
1.3.110
1.3.212
1.3.3 14
1.4
1.4.1.17
1.4.2..18
1.4.3..............................21
1.5. 22

2.
2.1(.)..................................26
2.1.1. 27
2.1.2 28
2.1.3 28

2.1.4..28
2.1.5. 30
2.2 30
2.3. 34
2.4 35

3.

3.1Opera2d
3.1.138
3.1.2 39
3.2
3.2.1 41
3.2.2 41
3.2.3.43
3.2.4.49
3.2.551
3.2.6(ExternalCircuits)54
3.2.7 58

4.
()
4.1 61
4.261
4.3 65
4.3.2
74
4.4. 78

ii

4.4.2
83
4.587
4.5.2
93
4.6.96

97
GorgesEffect..100
103

iii

.

,

.
,
.

,

.

.

1.1[1,2,3,5]
1.1.1

.,
.

.
.

.

1.1

.
.
.
,
. ,
,
.


.

1.2


. ,
,.

1.3
.

1.1.2
.
,
.
.

1.1.3

/
hertz (cycles/sec).

. ,
,
(phasors)
.phasors

.
,
.
.

.
, ,
.
(..)
,
, .
.
.
4

amper ohm,
Watt.
.

,
.

.

,
.
.,
9090.
:
S: S = E * I ,VA
P: P = E * I * cos ,Watt
Q: Q = E * I * sin ,VAR
P.
,
.
.

().

.

1.1.4

.
,,
120 .

.
/.

.

1.4
6

/
.
,
.

(, ..).' ,
,.

1.2

.

,
.

1.2.1Faraday
,:
1.

2.

e =

dt

1.2.2AmperBiotSavart


Faraday. Faraday
,
AmperBiotSavart
.

F = B*l * I

1.2.3Lenz
Faraday AmperBiotSavart
Lenz.Lenz

.

,
, (
Faraday). , ,
, ,
, AmperBiotSavart,
. Lenz

.

(

)

. Lenz
..

1.2.4
,
,
.
,:
,

,
.

WE + WM + WS + WH = 0


,
:
.

,
.

1.3[2,5]
1.3.1

1)
2).

.
. ,
.
() .
5 kVA.
.

,
.,
,
.
( ),
.
, ,
.

10

1.5
.

,
.
.
.
,
!
.
,,,
.
.
.
,
.
,

.
,
,
.
11


,
.o.
.

.
,
.
,
.

1.3.2

,
.

.

.
.

,

. ,

.

12

1.6.
,.

,
/(1.7).

1.721)
2).
13

1.3.3


.
:
1.

2.

.

,


.

.
,

.
.

14

1.8.

,
,.



.

.
,
.

15

1.9



.
,.
, m
2p,s

q=

2 pm

16

1.4

.
, ,


.

.

1.4.1

.. ,

fc =

nm P

120

f c =z
nm=r/min
P=
, 360,
,
.
.
:

e =

P

2 m

em.

1.4.2..

= 2 N c f

17

,

.
IF .
.

1.10)IF)IF()

V.
V:
1.

(
)
2.

3.

4.


().
,

.
,.
R
R.

18

, V
. ,
.

.

s .
stat.

stat.

V=+stat

net=R+s

stat
IA 90 .
statIA

stat=jIA

V=jIA


.
V

V=jsIARAIA

s
(.. ).
.

19

. ,
VT VT = 3V VT = V

1.11
))

20

1.4.3.

.

.
, ,
.
,
.

Pconv = app m d

Pconv = ind m = 3 E A I A cos

Pout = 3VT I L cos


Pout = 3V I A cos

Qout = 3VT IT sin

Qout = 3V I A sin

RA.
sRAs>>RA.

P=

3V E A sin
S

V
90(sin=1).

21

.
1520.

ind =

3V E A sin

m X S

1.5


.
.

1.12
.

,
.
, ,
.
,

22

.
,

.
(sin2).

:
1.
2.
3.
4.

V = A + d + q

d
q
.
90.,

d = jxd I d
q = jxq I q

V = E A jx d I d jxq I q

23

d = d + A

q = q + A

V = E A jxd I d jxq I q RA I A

P=

3V E A
Xd

3V2 X d X q
sin +

2 X d X q

sin 2

ind

3V2 X d X q
sin +
=

2 m X d X q
m X d
3V E A

24

sin 2

1.12
.

25



.
.

2.1
2.1,R
F.
Bs.
!
, , ,
.
.
:
.
.

2.1

26

2.1.1
' .
app
' .

ind = kBR * Bnet

ind = kBR Bnet sin

, ,
.'
.
,
.,"".
R
Bnet.

2.1()()

.
.
27

2.1.2

.
.

ind = kBR Bnet sin


3V E sin
ind = A
m X s
=90

450.
net
.

, .

.
, ,
.

2.1.3
,

.
.
,!

2.1.4
,
. .
,

28

.
V.
,
.
, ,
Q..

V .


..
V
F.V
.

.

2.3V

29

2.1.5

.
,
.
:
1.

.
2.

.
.
3. ,

.

2.2
:
1. ,
.
.
2. ,
.

.
3. .

30

2.4


.

.
.

2.5

31

,
.s
t=0 , 2.6 ,
,,

eind = (v B) I

v=
=
l=

,
. ,
.
w
.
.

ind = kBw Bs

900
.
,,,
.
1800
. ,
. ,

.
3600.

32

2.6

,
.
.

,.
, ,
.,
.,,

33

. ,
. ,
,
.

,.,
, ,

:
1.

.
2.
,.
3.

.
.

2.3

.
,
.

.
,

.
.
34


.

.[10]

2.4
,
().

,
.
:

1. h
2. h
3.


:
1. Pelton(h=1841840m)
2. Francis(h=37490m)
3. Kaplan(h61m)

35

Francis.

2.7

36

3:

M Opera2d
.

.
,
.
,
.


.

.



,
.

37

3.1Opera2d[8,9]
3.1.1
Opera2d
, .

.
:
Poisson
Helmholtz
Diffusion

:

()
()


.
() .
(
).

.
.

,
.
,,,,.
38

3.1.2
Opera2d
3 ,
,.

: Opera2d

.
:

,
,
.
Delaunay.
,
.

.
DRAW EDIT MODIFY.
COPY.

.
BHDATA.

39

:
.
RM (
). , ,
.
.
.

:
, .
(, , ,
) (POINTS),
(CONTOUR PLOTS) .
.

40

3.2
3.2.1
Opera2d,

:
3.1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13

Ssv452/12440NR
500rpm
50Hz
13.00kV
200MVA
0.80
8882.3A
3055.8kNm
1988.5A
167.0V
203000kg
66224kg
445900kgm2

3.2.2

.
.

.
,BH
.
3.1.

41

3.1PreandPostprocessorEnvironment

setview.
.

3.2

42

3.2.3

. construction lines

.
.

3.3


300 300.

43

,
.
.

3.2
Startat
XorR(m)
0
0

Startat
YorZ(m)
0
0

Endat
XorR(m)
2.2
2.2

Endat
YorZ(m)
0
0

Rotation(o)
0
30

3.3
Origin
XorR(m)
0
0
0

Origin
YorZ(m)
0
0
0

Startat
Radius(m)
1.206
1.573
1.943667

Endat
Radius(m)
1.206
1.573
1.943667

Startat
Angle(0)
0
0
0

Startat
Angle(0)
30
30
30



construction lines
.
.
.


(elements)
.

44

3.4

3.5
45

.
.

3.6

3.4

Materiallabel

Permeability

Conductivity

3
4
1

5000
5000
1

0
0
0

Conductor
number

3.5E+07

.


.
.
34
3.7.
46

conductor number
connected conductor symmetry

.

3.7

47

3.8
copy
.

3.9

48

conductor numbers
.500
400,.

3.2.4
180
.
300
15 .

.
2
.

3.5
Startat
XorR(m)
0
0

Startat
YorZ(m)
0
0

Endat
XorR
2.51
2.51

Endat
YorZ(m)
0
0

Rotation(o)
0
30

3.6
Origin
XorR(m)
0
0

Origin
YorZ(m)
0
0

Startat
Radius(m)
1.965
2.51

Endat
Radius(m)
1.965
2.51

49

Startat
Angle(0)
0
0

Startat
Angle(0)
30
30

(4) region
properties permeability (5000)
.
.

3.10


.
conductornumbers1360.

50

3.11

3.2.5

.

. .op2
export command file.

(.comi).

51

3.12

(.op2)
commandsin
.
3.13

3.13

52

3.14



. 3.15.

53

3.15

3.2.6(ExternalCircuits)

,
.
.
.
MontelExternalCircuitsCreate
.

3.16
54

3
2
.

3.7.PeakVoltage
Command file
.turns
29.

3.7

.

55



.
40
3
1200.
.
3.8
.
3.8


.
56

96
3.9
.
3.9


.
Edit Circuits
.

3.19

57

3.2.7

Display Mesh ,
tolerance:5.0E05.

3.20GenerateMesh

,
.
errorswarnings.

(.3.21).

3.21
58


.
.
.


Opera2d

elementsnotes.

3.22

59

,
,3.23.

3.23

60

()

4.1

.,


. :
,,

. ,
,.

4.2


,
.

.
OPERA2dPre
and Post Processor RM analysis {Model Analysis Options
Rotating Machine (RM)}.
.

Linear material analysis .
TimesteppingFixedstep
,
61

1.003 .

.
Output times.

.


.

4.2RMAnalysis(TimeSteppingOutputtimes)

Drive
external circuits . 9
Functional #PHASE1 #PHASE9.
Functional
#VOLTF.
(command input.comi)
. external circuits
defaultDC.
62

4.3RMAnalysis(DriveLogging)

Logging

.
.log.
, ,
, ,
.
Rotation
,
.
(comi)
,

..

63

4.4RMAnalysis(Rotation)
m,
kg/m2 Nm
.

4.5
64

4.3

.

.
,
.

.,,

4.6

65

4.7
11,6 .

4.7

(167V).
4.8

4.8
66

4.9

,
,
.
.

4.10

67

.


.
.
[13]
Gorges
, 5 4.10

.
.
4.11
.

.


.

4.11

68

11.6
,
.

4.1211.6



,

..

4.13
69

,
,
1,6

Gorges5.

4.14


.
4.165.
MATLAB
FastFourierTransformFFT
(db).
Fourier1718
5(250Hz)9(450Hz).

70

4.15

Normalized Amplitude (dB)

-50

-100

-150
0

50

100

150

200
250
300
frequency (Hz)

350

400

450

500

4.16FFT

71

4.17


,3
4 .

(.4.20).

4.183

72

4.194

4.20

73

4.3.2

5,6 7
, A/m2,
4.214.23.
4.36204 m2.
,,

4.215

4.226

74

4.237

4.23
.

.

4.24

75

4.25
,
.

. ,

.

4.257

76


.
.

4.26

77

4.4


3,507 1,
.
.

4.27

.
,
Gorges,

.

.

78

4.28


,
.

4.29

79

4.30

4.31

80

Normalized Amplitude (dB)

-50

-100

-150
0

50

100

150

200
250
300
frequency (Hz)

350

400

450

500

4.32FFT


, 4.33, 4.34, 4.35 .
, 4.33,
.

4.33

81

4.343

4.354
3
5,.,
4.35,
.

82

4.36

4.4.2


,

.

.
.

4.375
83

4.386

4.397

84

4.40267.

4.40


4.41,
5,

6
.

4.40

85



,
6.

4.417

86

4.5

external circuits

4.42 .
,.

4.42externalcircuits

4.43

87


.
4.44
.

4.43

4.44

.
88


,
.

4.45

, ,
,
.FFT,
1718.

4.46

89

Normalized Amplitude (dB)

-20
-40
-60
-80
-100
-120
-140
-160
0

50

100

150

200
250
300
frequency (Hz)

350

400

450

500

4.47FFT

4.482

90

4.493

4.504

91

4.515

4.484.51
.
,
,.

4.52

92

4.5.2

5,67.

4.535

4.546

93

4.557

4.56
5

94

4.577

95

4.6

:
1.
,
.
2.
3.

4.

2
.

.

.

.

[10]
.

96

(comi)
.

HzVolt.

13000
2 = 10615
3

$cons#fs50
$cons#ampl10615

ifelse 2
.120
.
$ifttimele0.04
$cons#PHASE1(ttime*25)*#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(90*pi/180))
$cons#PHASE2(ttime*25)*#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(30*pi/180))
$cons#PHASE3(ttime*25)*#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(150*pi/180))
$cons#PHASE4(ttime*25)*#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(90*pi/180))
$cons#PHASE5(ttime*25)*#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(30*pi/180))
$cons#PHASE6(ttime*25)*#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(150*pi/180))
$cons#PHASE7(ttime*25)*#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(90*pi/180))
$cons#PHASE8(ttime*25)*#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(30*pi/180))
$cons#PHASE9(ttime*25)*#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(150*pi/180))

97

$else
$cons#PHASE1#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(90*pi/180))
$cons#PHASE2#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(30*pi/180))
$cons#PHASE3#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(150*pi/180))
$cons#PHASE4#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(90*pi/180))
$cons#PHASE5#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(30*pi/180))
$cons#PHASE6#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(150*pi/180))
$cons#PHASE7#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(90*pi/180))
$cons#PHASE8#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(30*pi/180))
$cons#PHASE9#ampl*sin((2*pi*#fs*ttime)+(150*pi/180))
$endif

.1

98


1200.

.2


.

. ifelse
#VOLTF.
$ifttimege11.6
$cons#VOLTF167
$else
$cons#VOLTF0
$endif
.
,,
,
,.
.
$cons#TORQUERMTORQUE*RMLENGTH+RMATORQUE
$cons#ACCEL#TORQUE/RMINERTIA
99

GorgesEffect[14,15,17]
1896 H.Gorges

.


d.

.3
Ta
Tp,
.
f Hz
s,
sf.
, Park
, .
, sf

sf.
(1f)s,
(1s)f+sf,

.
100

Ta.
,
(1f)ssf =(12f)s, ,
f(12s)f=2sf.
:

Tm = Ta + Tp cos 2 s t

.4

.5Gorges

101

Ia Ip
. Ia Ip
(12s)f Hz.
:

I = Ia cos( t ) + I p cos(1 2 s) t

.6
, Ta
,,
( .4).
Gorges.

.
.
.

102

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

.,
,.
.,
,.
,,
,
.
..,
..,.
ACDCK.Chapman
AnalysisofelectricMachineryPaulC.Krause
.,
,
.
ManualofOpera2dUserGuidevol.1VectorFields2007.
ManualofOpera2dReferenceManualVectorFields2007.
H.C.KarmakerBrokenDamperBarDetectionStudiesusingFluxProbe
MeasurementsandTimeSteppingFiniteElementAnalysisforSalientPole
SynchronousMachinesAugust2003

[11] ZlatkoMaljkovic,MarijoSundrica,BrankoTomicicAsynchronousStarting
ProcessofHydroGenerator2008IEEE

[12] ArneGruning,StefanKuligTransientPerformanceintheElectromechanical
SystemNetworkGeneratorShaftduringAsynchronousAcceleration2003

[13] JaimeDeLaReeLopez,HowardB.HamiltonTorqueOscillationsof
SynchronousMotorsunderStartingConditionsIEEETransactionson
industryapplications
VolIA23,No.3May/June1987

[14] J.C.Das,JimCaseyCharacteristicsandAnalysisofStartingofLarge
SynchronousMotors

103

[15] J.O.Ojo,V.Ostovic,T.A.Lipo,J.C.WhiteMeasurementandComputationof
StartingTorquePulsationsofSalientPoleSynchronousMotorsIEEE
TransactionsonEnergyConversion,Vol.5,No.1,March1990

[16] HenricusC.J.deJongStartingPerformanceofSynchronousMotorswith
LaminatedSalientPolesIEEETransactionsonPowerApparatusandSystems,
Vol.PAS87,No.4,April1968

[17] K.J.Binns,M.LloydMethodforevaluatingthestartingcharacteristicsof
solidsalientpolesynchronousmotorsIEEEElectricalPowerApplications,
November1978,Vol.1,No.4

[18] M.A.HydeSynchronousMotorwithPhaseConnectedDamperWindingfor
HighTorqueLoadsIEEEAmericaninstituteofElectricalEngineersVol.50,
Issue2,June1931

[19] WangXiaoyuan,RenNaSimulationofAsynchronousStartingprocessof
SynchronousMotorsBasedonMatalab/SimulinkElectricalMachinesand
SystemsVol.2,911November2003

104

You might also like