Professional Documents
Culture Documents
00b49517ff6e558236000000 PDF
00b49517ff6e558236000000 PDF
Abstract
Electrophoretic deposition (EPD) has been used to obtain self-supported alumina substrates
from aqueous slurries. The uniformity of the final deposit is a function of the colloidal properties
of the slurry. In this work, the conductivity and the solid content of the slurries are related to the
deposition kinetics and the characteristics of the green compacts. The solid content is demonstrated
to increase the experimental conductivity margins for suitable deposition. In addition, the more
concentrated the slurry is, the lower the contamination of the deposit when metallic electrodes are
used. 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: A. Ceramics; A. Oxides; A. Interfaces; D. Defects
1. Introduction
A critical aspect in the manufacturing of a ceramic product is the selection of a simple,
low-cost fabrication procedure that allows the obtention of uniform materials of the desired
geometry and shape, with fewer and smaller defects. In recent years, an important effort has
been devoted by ceramists to study in depth the principles of colloidal science. The colloidal
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: rmoreno@icv.csic.es (R. Moreno).
0025-5408/00/$ see front matter 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
PII: S 0 0 2 5 - 5 4 0 8 ( 0 0 ) 0 0 2 8 8 - 9
888
(1)
The electrophoretic mobility of the particles is proportional to the zeta potential () and to
some liquid media properties (dielectric constant and viscosity ), as determined by Eq. (2)
[12]:
ue
1.5
(2)
The electrophoresis phenomenon has been known since 1850 [13]. However, the EPD of
ceramics was first studied by Hamaker in 1940 [11], and only in the 80s did the process
receive attention in the field of advanced ceramics. A literature review revealed that 80% of
the published works on EPD of advanced ceramics [14,15] reported the use of organic
889
2. Experimental
A commercial -Al2O3 powder (Alcoa A16SG, USA) was used. Aqueous slurries with
different solid loadings (5, 10, and 20 wt%) were prepared in water, as described elsewhere
[16]. A commercial carbonic anionic acid based polyelectrolyte (Dolapix CE64, ZschimmerSchwarz, Germany) at different concentrations (0 5 wt% referred to solids) was added to
stabilize the slurries. The effect of colloidal parameters, such as zeta potential, conductivity,
and solid loading, on EPD performance was studied.
To generalize the obtained results, a metallic conductor (Zn) and a semiconductor
(graphite) electrode were used, with surfaces of 7.07 and 6.25 cm2, respectively.
The cell geometry and the electrical conditions were kept constant for each system
suspension/electrode. After checking different experimental conditions for each system, the
following were selected: a current density of 6.4 mA cm2 for 10 min, for a suitable EPD
onto graphite electrodes, and that of 2.8 mA cm2, for a deposition time up to 30 min, when
using Zn as electrode. In all cases, a constant stirring was maintained to avoid powder
sedimentation and bubbling effects. Fig. 1 schematically shows the electrophoretic cell used.
A thermal bath was used for controlled temperature tests. The conductivity was measured
890
Fig. 1. Scheme of the experimental device used for temperature controlled EPD tests.
with a conductivity meter (WTW model LF320), and zeta potential data were obtained on 20
wt% slurries, using a Micromeritics mass transport analyzer.
The deposits obtained were dried at room conditions for 24 h, after which their weight and
thickness were measured. Chemical analysis of some of the dried green deposits was
performed by direct solid-sample analysis, using the inductively coupled plasma atomic
emission spectrometry technique with laser ablation (LA-ICP-AES). This technique is based
on laser irradiation of a solid sample introduced into an ablation chamber, promoting the
fusionvaporizationatomizationionization of the sample. The vapor is carried by an Ar
current and solidifies as micronic and submicronic particles, which are then analyzed by a
plasma spectrometer. A prolonged irradiation makes the penetration, and therefore the
analysis of the sample, to be deeper. The spectrum profiles were obtained taking into account
that 1 pulse corresponds to the analysis of 10 m of sample in depth, assuming that the
packing density is constant within the deposit. A frequency quadrupled Nd:YAG laser
operating at 266 nm (Cetac Technologies, LSX-100) coupled to and ICP-AES instrument
(Perkin-Elmer, Optima 3000DV) were used. The Zn detection with the ICP spectrometer was
performed using the emission line located at 213.856 nm. The in-depth contamination
profiles were determined by irradiating the samples from the face in contact with the
electrode and from the opposite face. The number of applied pulses was high enough to
completely cross the samples. The effect of the variation of the solid content and the slurry
conductivity on the resulting contamination profile was studied.
Green densities were measured by Archimedes method in mercury. Green self-supported
891
samples were sintered at 1550C/2h in air. The microstructure was observed by SEM on
polished and thermally etched surfaces.
(3)
To determine the deposition limits related to the deflocculant system, Al2O3 slurries (5 wt%)
with deflocculant contents up to 5 wt% were tested using Zn working electrodes. The
conductivity of the slurries and the thickness and the mass per unit area of the obtained
deposits are plotted in Fig. 2. There is a minimum below which no deposit is formed (0.3
wt%) due to the lack of stability. The deposited mass decreases when an extremely high
amount of deflocculant is added to the slurry (5 wt%). The deflocculant in excess does not
contribute to the dispersion, but effects an increase in slurry conductivity from 175 S cm1
for an addition of 0.4 wt%, to 1150 S cm1 for an addition of 5 wt%. Hence, the deposition
decreases with the electric field.
This effect is drastic when using graphite electrodes. In this system, the deposition limits
can be experimentally determined. Al2O3 slurries (5 wt%) with 0.2 0.6 wt% deflocculant
892
Fig. 2. Evolution of thickness and weight per unit area of Al2O3 deposits obtained onto Zn substrates as a function
of deflocculant concentration.
concentrations were tested applying a current density of 6.4 mA cm2 for 10 min and keeping
the work temperature constant during the tests. As was demonstrated in a previous work [16],
the increase of voltage during the test is associated with the formation of a homogeneous
growing deposit. An increased voltage also means a higher particle packing of the deposit.
Fig. 3 plots the measured conductivity of 5 and 10 wt% slurries as a function of temperature.
The continuous lines represent the conductivity of two reference suspensions with exact
concentrations of deflocculant (0.3 and 0.4 wt%) for each solid loading. The concentration
of deflocculant can be estimated by measuring its conductivity. Full points represent the
slurry conductivities that produce a uniform coating after EPD, while the void points
correspond to those slurries that did not form an homogeneous deposit onto graphite.
Fig. 3. Conductivity/temperature relationship of 5 and 10 wt% Al2O3 slurries with different amounts of
deflocculant. Full symbols () correspond to EPD tests performed by applying 6.4 mA cm2 for 10 min, which
produced deposit. Void symbols () correspond to EPD test performed under similar conditions where no deposit
could be obtained. The continuous lines represent the conductivity of 5 and 10 wt% slurries with 0.3 and 0.4 wt%
deflocculant each. The dashed lines in the plots of both solid contents limit the regions of successful deposition
onto graphite.
893
Table 1
Green density, thickness, and weight per unit area of the deposits obtained by applying 6.4 mA cm2 for 10
min from 5 and 10 wt% Al2O3 slurries
Green deposit characteristics
Thickness (mm)
Density (g cm3)
Weight per unit area (mg cm2)
Solid content
5 wt%
10 wt%
2.13
2.11 (53.2%)
450
2.23
2.34 (59%)
520
Optimal slurry conditions correspond to a 0.4 wt% deflocculant addition, which has a zeta
potential of 50 mV. From these suspensions, the highest voltage increases were registered
during EPD tests for both solid loadings. Furthermore, a clear region for successful deposition can be plotted, so that deposition does not occur outside of these limits. The minimum
limit is determined by the stability of the slurry and the maximum limit is defined by the
intensity of the electric field able to promote the particle motion and deposition. Al2O3
slurries with 0.2 wt% deflocculant have a zeta potential close to zero [16]; therefore, the
particles do not migrate. Al2O3 slurries with 0.6 wt% deflocculant, on the other hand, have
high enough zeta potentials, but their conductivities are so high that the intensity of the
applied electric field decreases, decreasing the electrophoretic rate and deposition possibilities.
These results demonstrate that slurry conductivity is another important parameter that can
be used for controlling the viability of EPD. This property had not received due attention in
EPD literature, but it is a very simple way to follow slurry behavior. Otherwise, the
deflocculant is the major factor responsible for the measured suspension conductivity and its
control allows determination of the dispersing conditions and a priori knowledge of whether
a deposit will be formed or not.
3.2. The effect of the solid loading
Another important slurry parameter is solid loading. This parameter is usually considered
not to affect EPD, except for the fact that the higher the quantity of solids in the suspension,
the higher the quantity of powder deposited. However, present experimental results demonstrate that the solid content can be a powerful tool for controlling the EPD process and the
characteristics of the shaped materials. As shown in Fig. 3, the region defining the optimal
conductivity/temperature working zone is broader for more concentrated slurries; thus, it
becomes easier to control the deflocculant weight added when solid content increases.
Furthermore, the green characteristics of deposits obtained after applying 6.4 mA cm2 for
10 min largely depend on the solid content of the slurry, as summarized in Table 1. The green
density increased from 53% to 59% theoretical. This means that when all the other processing parameters are maintained constant, the packing density directly increases with the solid
content. Thus, the general consideration that concentration does not affect the characteristics
of the deposit can be discussed. The theoretically predicted linear increase of the deposited
894
Fig. 4. SEM micrograph of a sintered Al2O3 thick film deposited onto a Zn substrate, applying 2.8 mA cm2 for
30 min.
mass was not reached. This suggests that it is necessary to take into consideration the
variation of all colloidal properties of the slurry.
When a metallic electrode was used, the system notably changed and other interesting
variables appeared. Dispersed aqueous Al2O3 slurries (those with 0.4 wt% deflocculant) were
used for deposition onto Zn electrodes. No changes in the potential during the process were
detected in this case. Considering what happened in the case of the graphite electrodes, one
would expect that a deposit would not be formed. However, successive EPD tests produced
deposits. This apparent contradiction suggests that the growing deposit behaves like a
conductive layer. This can only occur if metallic impurities are moving through the deposit.
These metallic impurities must be originated as a consequence of the corrosion of the Zn
electrode when a current is applied.
Direct chemical analysis using laser ablation inductively coupled plasma (LA-ICP-AES)
demonstrated that Zn inclusions were present in the green deposits and diffused from the
surface in contact with the electrode towards the bulk, up to a maximum distance of about
500 m [24]. Fig. 4 shows a general picture of the cross section of a sintered Al2O3 thick
deposit prepared using a Zn electrode. A high heterogeneity with a large residual porosity,
due to metallic contamination, is observed. The contamination profile of Zn across the green
deposit can be drawn. It strongly depends not only on the imposed electrical conditions
(applied current density and deposition time), but also on the slurry characteristics, such as
the conductivity (in other terms, the concentration of deflocculant) and unexpectedly, the
solid content.
Fig. 5 shows the deposited mass per unit area as a function of deposition time for EPD
tests performed applying 2.8 mA cm2 for 1 to 30 min with Al2O3 slurries containing 5 and
20 wt% solids. The slurries were always dispersed with 0.4 wt% deflocculant. The less
concentrated followed linear Hamaker behavior [11], but the concentrated one soon deviated
from this behavior. The total quantity of deposited mass for 20 wt% slurries was about 11%
the total suspended powder. This is too low to be directly responsible for the observed
895
Fig. 5. Weight per unit area deposited onto Zn vs. time, obtained from the 5 and 20 wt% Al2O3 suspensions, with
a 0.4 wt% deflocculant, applying 2.8 mA cm2 for deposition times between 1 and 30 min.
deviation from the linear behavior, since the total loss of mass in the 5 wt% slurry after
consecutive EPD tests was 32% and the kinetics maintained linearity [14].
A uniform deposit as thick as 500 m was obtained from 20 wt% slurries for 5 min
deposition time. For 5 wt% slurries, the packing density was slightly lower and the deposit
growth was slower.
Considering that the major contribution to slurry conductivity is due to the deflocculant,
the conductivity of 20 wt% slurries (600 S cm1) is three times higher than that of 5 wt%
slurries (183 S cm1). Thus, applying the same current density, the electric field generated
on the concentrated slurry is lower. This could be the reason why the deposit formation
cannot maintain for a long time the proportionality predicted by Hamaker equation (Eq. (1))
related to the solid concentration.
The green deposits obtained at 2.8 mA cm2 after 20 min EPD using slurries containing
5 and 20 wt% solids were analyzed by LA-ICP-AES. Fig. 6 shows the indepth profile
Fig. 6. Zn emission intensity profiles vs. the analysis depth of the Al2O3 deposit obtained applying 2.8 mA cm2
for 20 min from 5 and 20 wt% slurries.
896
obtained from analyzing the samples from the surface in contact with the electrode during the
EPD test. An increased solid loading has a noticeable effect on the contamination profile,
strongly reducing the signal intensity, which is nearly constant and very low. High slurry
conductivities developed low electric field intensities, decreasing the oxidation rate of the
electrode and limiting motion of ionic impurities due to the quantity of big particles moving
in the opposite direction. Since, for short times, the deposit growing kinetics is much higher,
migration of impurities is hindered. In this way, metallic contamination is negligible at 20
wt%. In fact, when the concentrated slurry was considered, a voltage increase of 7 V was
measured between electrodes. Thus, the Al2O3 deposit is not conductive. According to these
results, the solid contents of the slurry has much more influence on the obtention of a
contamination-free deposit than was previously suspected.
4. Conclusions
The colloidal properties of the slurry determine both the viability of the EPD process and
the properties of the deposit. The slurry conductivity has been shown to be a critical
parameter capable of predicting whether the deposit will be obtained or not. The solid content
has been proven to affect EPD much more than had been suspected. By controlling this, it
is possible to modify the growing kinetics, to expand the experimental ranging conditions for
successful EPD tests, and even to reduce contamination in the deposit when the coated shape
is a metallic material.
Acknowledgments
The authors thanks to CICYT (Spain) for the concession of a research grant (MAT97-0676).
Dr. J. C. Farinas is greatly acknowledged for analytical tests and helpful discussions.
References
[1]
[2]
[3]
[4]
[5]
[6]
[7]
[8]
[9]
[10]
[11]
[12]
G.D. Parfitt Dispersion of Powders in Liquids, 3rd ed., Elsevier, London, 1986.
J. Israelachvili Intermolecular and Surfaces Forces, 2nd ed., Academic Press, London, 1991.
J.S. Reed Principles of Ceramic Porcessing, 2nd ed., John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1995.
R.J. Pugh, L. Bergstrom Surface and Colloid Chemistry in Advanced Ceramics Processing, Marcel Dekker,
New York, 1994.
R. Moreno, Am Ceram Soc Bull 71 (1992) 1521.
R. Moreno, Am Ceram Soc Bull 71 (1992) 1647.
J.Y. Choudhary, H.S. Ray, K.N. Rai, Trans J Br Ceram Soc 81 (1982) 193.
C.T. Chu, B. Dunn, Appl Phys Lett 55 (1989) 492.
Y. Hirata, A. Nishimoto, Y. Ishihara, J Ceram Soc Jpn Int Ed 99 (1991) 105.
C. Kawai, S. Wakamatsu, J Mater Sci 31 (1996) 2165.
H.C. Hamaker, Trans Faraday Soc 36 (1940) 279.
S. Baudet, LIndustrie Ceramique 754 (1981) 712.
897
[13] F.F. Reuss in: C.A. Hampel (Ed.), The Encyclopedia of Electrochemistry, Reinhold, New York, 1964, p.
540.
[14] P. Sarkar, P.S. Nicholson, J Am Ceram Soc 79 (1996) 1897.
[15] M.S.J. Gani, Ind Ceram 14 (1994) 163.
[16] B. Ferrari, R. Moreno, J Eur Ceram Soc 17 (1997) 549.
[17] G. Fisher, E. Fisher, G. De Portu, E. Roncari, J Mater Sci Lett 14 (1995) 25.
[18] X.M. Ding, N. Merk, B. Ilschner, in B. Ilchner, N. Cherrai (Eds.), Proceedings of the 3rd International
Symposium of Structural and Functionally Gradient Materials (FGM3), Laussanne, Switzerland, 1994, Vol.
1, p. 365.
[19] N. Merk, J Mater Sci Lett 14 (1995) 592.
[20] M. Shirkhanzadeh, J Mater Sci Lett 10 (1991) 1415.
[21] S.N. Sahu, J Mater Sci Lett 8 (1989) 533.
[22] B. Ferrari, R. Moreno, Bol Soc Esp Ceram Vidrio 37 (1998) 369.
[23] H. Vander Poorten, Silicates Ind 41 (1981) 159.
[24] B. Ferrari, J.C. Farinas, R. Moreno, J Am Ceram Soc, in press.