Review
JK - PRACT
rIONER
MANAGEMENT OF HYDROCEPHALUS IN TUBERCULAR MENINGITIS
Gautam Das,M.B..B.S., Basharat Hameed, M.B..B.S., M. Asim Siddiqui M.D., Jamal Ahmad.M.D.,
D.M.. Ph.D
‘The first clinical description of exudate that infiltrates the
tubercular meningitis in the late 18th cortiomeningeal blood vessels and
century is credited to the Scottish causes inflammation and obstruction of
Physiologist Sir Robert Whytt!, even vessels around the interpeduncular and
before Robert Koch isolated pontine cisterns in acute stages and
mycobacterium tuberculosis in 1882°. adhesive leptomeningitis in the chronic
Tuberculosis of the central nervous stages’. This is reported to be more
system is the most dreaded complication common in the paediatric age group as
of tuberculosis and the incidence is ever several case series have reported a 100%
increasing in developing countries and occurence in children4 and is usually
in developed ones. related to the duration of sy
Neurotuberculosis is HYDROCEPHALUSINTUBERCULAR,
encountered in upto 10% of the immuno MENINGITIS
competent patients’ and emergence of Hydrocephalus can be defined as an
HIV (Human immuno deficiency virus) abnormal accumulation of cerebrospinal
epidemic and multidrug resistant fluid (CSF) within the ventricles and/or
(MDR)TB has further compounded the subarachnoid spaces. Exact incidence in
problem as around 5-9% of AIDS patients adults patients with TBM is not known
have pulmonary or extrapulmonary but itis nearly always present in all cases,
tuberculosis'. It is fatal without effective who had the illness for more than 4-6
treatment and is associated with a weeks!"
Authors’ affiliations: significant morbidity rate even after HYDROCEPHALUS IN TBM IS.
Gautam Das,Basharat Hameed, treatment.
M. Asim Siddiqui, Prof. Jamal CNS tuberculosis may take
Ahmad several forms including tubercular
meningitis (TBM), meningoencephalitis,
Department of Endocrinology JN tuberculomas, tubercular abscess,
Medical College. AMU Aligarh, @tachnoiditis and rarely myelo-
ndia radioculopathy. Of these TBM is the
commonest accounting for upto 70-80%
of the cases of neurotuberculosis and 7-
12% of all patients in developing
countries*. Damaging effects to the brain
in TBM occurs due to formation of
granulomatous basal exudates and
periarteritis of the blood vessels
supplying the brain, Blindness, deafness
and cranial nerve palsies (3rd, 4th, 6th and
Professor of Endocrinology & 7th) may be encountered in 25% cases*
Choirman, Department of whereas motor deficits is noted in 40%
Medicine, J.N.Medical College, andseizure in 10-15% casest
ccepted for publication:
March, 2004
Conespondence to:
Jamal Ahmad
A.MU., Aligarh Tubercular meningitis usually
Tel. & Fax: +91-571-2721173 results from the haematogenous spread
‘mail jamalahmad 1@reciifmati com of bacteria to the CNS.from a primary
focus elsewhere in the body usually the
lungs. A caseous lesion is formed in the
cerebral cortex or meninges which
JK-Practi
ruptures to discharge the tubercle bacilli
ner 2004:11(3):161-
USUALLY
a Obstructive or non-obstructive
a Communicating or non-
communicating
a Acute or chronic
a Active or arrested
Excessive accumulation of gelatinous
exudate at the bases of the brain interferes
with the normal flow of cerebro-spinal
fluid (CSP) in TBM leads to a obstructive
hydrocephalus (more common in TBM)
of either a communicating or non-
communicating type
COMMUNICATING
In this type the blockage is outside the
ventricular system ie. within the
subarachnoid space at the base of the
brain or over the cerebral convexity and
is not apparent on routine imaging"
Gelatinous and nodular exudates
comprising of fibrin and inflammatory cells
‘occur in subarachaoid space and cisterns
at the base of brain" and in the region of
optic chaisma and the interpeduncular
and prepontine cisterns"
Encovering of the ependyma and choroid
165 into the subarachnoid space leading to plexus with exudate and scierosis of
the formation of a thick gelatinous arachnoid villi and granulations over
Key words: Meningins, Tuberculosis, Hydrocephalus
161
Vol. 11, No. 3, July-September 2004cerebral convexity with overlying adhesion of leptomeninges
impedes the CSF outflow and leads to hydrocephalus! 5
NON-COMMUNICATING
In this type the blockage is within the ventricular system
itself Le. at the level of the aqueduct of Sylvius or the fourth
.dymitis"", Exudate also block
the foramen of Magendie and Lushka at the fourth ventricular
outlet
SIGNS ANDSYMPTOMS,
The clinical presentation of TBM is quite variable as it
generally progresses insidiously but may be rapid particularly
in infants and young children. The progress of symptoms
occurs over several weeks but not in a smooth continuum.
Alteration in consciousness (79%), fever (66%), focal
neurologic signs (66%) and seizures (53%) are a common
presentation’. TBM complicated with hydrocephalus is very
low in grade I, low in grade fl and maximum in grade IL and
IVI, Common symptoms of hydrocephalus include headache,
vomiting, drowsiness, lethargy, irritability, behavioural
abnormalities. visual blurring and diplopia whereas signs
include tense fomtanelle's, distended scalp veins, frontal
bossing, macrocephaly and sunsetting sign in infants and
papilloe 1 o bilateral lateral recuts palsies,
hyperreflexia, clonus and gait ataxia in older children and
adults". Bradycardia. slow respiration, hypertension,
decetebrate posture, coma and transient and permanent
blindness may occur due to severrise in ICP"
DIAGNOSIS
The diagnosis of tuberculous meningitis may be difficult
because of its non-specific and variable presentation. The
tuberculin skin test is positive in 30%-50% patients and a
pulmonary focus on chest radiograph is detected in 50-87%
cases'”"*, Examination of the CSF and identification or
isolation of mycobacteria on smear or culture is the gold
standaed for diagnosis of TBM, some series have reported
isolation rates as high as 80% after multiple sample
processing". in general the yield is much lower'®™.
Radiometric culture (BACTEC), CSF PCR, ADA levels, ELISA
and other antigen and antibody detection tests have been
reported to be usefial with varying degrees of sensitivity and
specificity
Diagnosis of hydrocephalus in TBM is often difficult as the
signs and symptoms are non-specific, hence a high index of
suspicion is important for its diagnosis. Before the advent of
CT scan in 1976, skull radiograph. cranial ultrasonography,
ventriculography and angiography were used for the
diagnosis'* of limited application today
Neuroimag invaluable in the diagnosis of
hydrocephalus complicating TBM. Completed tomognaply
(CT) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the brain may
be normal during early stages but shows thick basilar
enhancement, parenchymal enhancement, hydrocephalus,
cerebral edema, focal ischaemia and infarcts ata later stage
CT scan of head (plain and contrast) will demonstrate*'*
ventricle and associated eper
lema. unilat
which are
a Hydrocephalus induced ventricular enlargement
(communicating or non-communicating).
A Obliteration of the sulci and subarachnoid spaces
UK - PRACTITIONER
over the cerebral convexity due to raised ICP.
fa Periventricular lucencies (PVL) due to
transependymal absorption of CSF into the white matter'®
a Intense of basal cisterns
(interpeduncular, ambient, prepontine and the chiasmatic
region) due to the presence of exudates. Enhancement may
also extend over the cerebral or cerebellar hemisphe!
enhancement
Meningeal enhancement is more in HIV infected patients (23%
in HIV vs 6% in non-HIV cases)*
Q ——Tuberculomas/Tubercular abscess
Q _ Infarction secondary to vasculitis (most common in
the middle cerebral artery territory).
MRI
Gadolinium (Gd-DTPA) is sensitive for demonstrating
meningeal enhancement and associated infarcts, granuloma
and hydrocephalus’ and MRI is more valuable as a single test
because it also shows ventricular volume and CSF flow
through the foramen of Monro or aqueduct of Sylvius besides
the source of hydrocephalus"
Management
Acute hydrocephalus which evolves over a course of days
or weeks is a neurological emergency which has to be
intervened upon as early as possible whereas chronic
hydrocephalus is usually presented over months or years
and it gets invariably arrested to a non-progressive
hydrocephalus in which compensatory mechanisms comes
into force and the ICP (intracranial pressure) is normal or
mildly elevated withouta shunt 15. The goal of therapy remains
to reduce the ICP and to decrease the size of the ventricle so
as to improve the periventricular perfusion,
MEDICAL THERAPY
Anti-tubercular drugs are the mainstay in managing such
patients supplemented with steroids, frusemide, acetazolamide
and repeated lumbar puncture.
All regimens include isoniazid (H) and rifampicin (R) and a
third drug used is pyrizinamide (Z) and at times Exhambutol
(E) or Steptomycin (S). Recommendations by expert
committees suggested that in managing CNS tuberculosis,
initially four drugs are preferred and a longer duration of
continuation phase is advocated. The World Health
Organization suggest a total of 9 month treatment (2+7
months) whereas the American thoracic Society® recommends,
410 month continuation phase with two drugs. The Indian
Academy of Paediatrics** endorses the WHO recommendation
regarding the initial therapy but includes 3 drugs for 10 months,
inthe continuation phase. However till date there are no studies
to support the superiority ofa three drug regimen over a two-
drug regimen during the continuation phase. Drug resistance
has been reported worldwide and managed with second line
drugs" and the duration of treatment extends to atleast 18-24
months
Steroids have been shown to reduce the neurologic sequelae
especially when administered early in the course of the
disease”. Steroids decrease brain edema and the production
of'inflammatory cytokines and exudates, and minimize damage
to the blood brain barrier. Girsis NI et al” showed that the use
of dexamethasone routinely as an adjunctive treatment for
Vol. L1,No. 3, July-September 2004
162TBM reduces fatality rate (43% vs 59%). Moreover they also
showed that the neurologic complications after initiation of
therapy (4 vs 10) and permanent sequelae were also lower in
the dexamethasone treatment group.
Similarly Schoeman DF et al’ showed that corticosteroid
significantly improves survival rate and intellectual outcome
in TBM as they cause an enhanced resolution of basal
exudates and tuberculomas. Butthey failed to showa dramatic
effect of steroids on the ICP due to hydrocephalus".
Dexamethasone in a dose of 0.2 mg/Kg/day in 3-4 divided
doses via parenteral route or prednisolone in a dose of Img/
Ky/day is given for 4-6 weeks and then gradually tapered
over a equal period of time"
Diuretics such as frusemide may be given in a dose upto
Iing/Kg/ at 6-8 hour interval by the oral, IM or IV route with
an average adult dose of 40 mg at 8 hour interval. Injection
mannitol may be used in life threatening situations or acritical
rise in ICP. Acetazolamide in a dose of 100 mg/Kg/day in 3
divided doses in often required for therapy with an average
adult dose of 250 mg, twice or thricea day. Continued therapy
with frusemide and acetazolamide may decrease
production for few days but do not cause ventriculomegaly
to resolve instead causes a rebound increase in ICP".
SURGICAL THERAPY
Hydrocephalus being a common complication of TBM it is
suggested that once ventriculomegaly sets in, surgical
drainage is the only effective way of reducing raised
intracranial pressure!’
SURGICAL OPTIONS
Q Ventricular tap
Q Ventricular shunt
Q _Endoscopie third ventriculostomy
VENTRICULAR TAP
This procedure is indicated when a shunt cannot be placed
immediately due to poor general condition of patient, lack of
operative facilities and concurrent pyogenic infection.
However, if offers advantages like
a Helps in assessing CSF pressure and defining the
role oF indication of surgery.
a Provides CSF sample for diagnostic study.
a Fastest in reducing intracranial pressure, but it
improves the clinical condition only for 6-8 hours hence,
repeated tapping is therefore needed till the patient is
favourable for shunt surgery. Complications like infection,
intraventricular bleeding, bleeding along the track,
pneumocephalus. poren cephalic cysts along line of
ventricular puneture and localized brain damage may occur.
Endoscopic third Ventriculostomy (ETV)
A percutaneous or stereotactic ETV creates an opening in
the floor of the third ventricle to alleviate hydrocephalus. It
can be used in cases where the CSF is obstructed at the level
of the aqueduct or distal to it'’. A success rate of 40-60% has
been reported in the setting of post tubercular hydrocephalus.
SHUNTSURGERY
Shunt surgery is often needed in patients with TBM who
develop hydrocephalus. While some workers have managed
JK ~ PRACTITIONER
early hydrocephalus with anti-tubercular therapy (ATT)
without surgery, others advocate shunt placements in all
patients with hydrocephalus”
‘TIMING FORSHUNTSURGERY
Kemaloglu S et al” showed that early surgical procedure for
mild/moderate hydrocephalus has a positive effect on the
morbidity and mortality of hydrocephalus in childhood TBM.
Moreover, in severe hydrocephalus, early shunting have a
positive effect on morbidity. However, in several patients
diversion of ventricular CSF doesn’t improve their clinical
condition and may die despite the intervention’. Some
researchers have proposed selection of patients on the basis
of staging of tubercular meningitis. As hydrocephalus rarely
develops in stage I and II TBM indication for shunt surgery
is low here'® whereas a shunt is mandatory for all grade I or
IV patients with attendant hydrocephalus”. From a
prognostic point of view altered sensorium (grade HII) is a
better stage to put the shunt rather than waiting for
decerebration to occur (grade 1V)!"
CRITERIA FORSHUNT SURGERY
1 Clinical"
Symptomatic hydrocephalus with one ormore ofthe following,
signs and symptoms:
Persistent headache and vomiting
Papilloedemaloptic atrophy
Decreased level of consciousness
Gait ataxia or progressive neurological deficit
Decerebration / Decortication
‘Neuro-imaging"”
CT/MRUevidence of active hydrocephalus i.e.
ventriculomegaly with periventricular lucency (PVL) or edema.
3 CSF Criteria!
oxooogg,
Q —_Celleount- CSF polymorph count should be less than
Siem3 irrespective of the number of lymphocytes.
GA protein content of fess than 100 mg/dl is no longer
required or considered mandatory for shunt surgery
4 Ventricular tap eriteria
Q Evidence of raised ICP and a significant fallin the
ICP along with clinical improvement following the ventricular
tap, is a definitive indication for performing a surgery.
METHODS AND RESULTS
CSF shunts divert CSF from the ventricles into the body
cavities. Of the various shunt options available a ventriculo
peritoneal shunt (VP) is the most accepted procedure for
hydrocephalus. Venticulo-atrial shunts (VA) have a higher
‘complication rate and therefore not preferred'™"*, Choice of
shunt is based on cost, availability and intraventricular
pressure. Putting up a low pressure device in high ventricular
pressure hydrocephalus would result in over drainage
syndrome. Similarly a high pressure device will not drain
hydrocephalus with low or moderate intraventricular
pressure'®, Connection is maintained between a burr hole
created behind the ear where the tip is placed in the frontal
hor of the right lateral ventricle and the peritoneal connection
is often placed in the epigastrium or in the tight upper or
Iower quadrant after being tunneled subcutaneously across
the chestwall”
163
Vol. 11, No. 3, July-September 2004Alleviation of increased ICP after shunt may result in
improvement in sensorium within 48-72 hours. A postoperative
CT isadvised in all cases ideally by 1 week after shunt surgery
or earlier ifthere is clinical deterioration or no improvement.
The CSF parameters may take months to normalize”™™. The
CSF glucose returns to normal within 2 months in $0% of the
patients and within 6 months in the majority. The CSF cellular
response tales almost 6 months to normalize in approximately
25% cases. whereas CSF protein remains elevated for more
than 6 months in 40% cases.
COMPLICATIONS
The overall complication rate of shunt surgery is about 20%".
Common complication includes shunt obstruetion and
infection, Others include hematoma, hemiparesis, seizures,
shunt migration/disconnection’ fracture, Peritonitis, Peritubal
leakage/shunt excoriation, overdrainage, endocarditis,
nephritis".
Shunt malfunction may develop within 7 days due to shunt
misplacement or shunt blockage by blood clots and fibrin
debris, Patient have symptoms like headache, vomiting,
drowsiness which may appear, disappear and recur again
with increasing frequency and severity"’. Patency of the
shunt is confirmed by clinical method, transcranial Doppler
(TCD) study and CT and MRI imaging. Delayed onset
malfunctioning occurs afier 7 days'* due to infection, shunt
migration or plugging of the catheter by choroid plexus or
the peritoneal catheter by omental adhesions. 5 to 10% of
shunts are complicated by infection’ caused by S. epidermidis
(60%) and S. aureus (30%) cases. The remainder is caused by
coliform bacteria, streptococci or Hemophilus influenza"
OUTCOME
Although morbidity rates reported may be as high as 88%-
100% despite shunt surgery" but still with effective procedure
‘neurologic improvement following ventricular decompression
may be dramatic particularly in children with improvement in
the level of consciousness and other signs and symptoms".
Daljit Singh et all 1 showed that only 60.3% of patients with
grade II and 34.5% of patients with grade IV showed
improvement following ventriculo-peritoneal shunt surgery
whereas the improvement rate was 100% for group 1 and IT
‘TBM patients! |. Palur R et ab found that the mortality rates
in grade Ill ancl IV were $1.9%and 100% respectively, despite
policy of early shunt surgery ofall patients. John M Mathew
etal" suggested a tial for an external ventricular drainage as,
a preliminary procedure for grade IV patients who has
otherwise a poor prognosis with shunt surgery. They
suggested that all patients of grade 111 should be given the
benefits of shunt surgery without atrial of external ventricular
drainage but poor outcome for grade IV patients (88%
‘mortality) underlines a need for them to undergo a trial with
external ventricular drainage and response to the drainage of
CSF to determine the necessity or otherwise of shunt surgery.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Whytt R. Observation on the nature causes and cure of those
disorders which are commonly called nervous hypochondriae
or hysterie. Significant contribution tothe history of Psychiatry
10,
u
15
16
20,
21
JK - PRACTITIONER
(edited by: Robinson DN), University Publications of America
1978; 551
Koch R. The etiology of tuberculosis, Rev Infect Dis 1982: 4
1270-1274,
RK. Gupta, S. Kumar. Imaging of CNS tuberculosis, Reviews
in tropical Neurology. Editor: Ravindra Kumar Garg, 2002,
Chapter 7: Pe 73-88.
Juan C. Garcia-Monco, Central Nervous System tuberculosis
Central Nervous System infections. Neurology Clinies 1999;
Vol.17; pe.737-759.
K. Prasad, Geetha R Menon, Tubercular Meningitis, JAPI
1997; 45(9): 722-725.
Johan F. Schoeman, Lana E Vanzyl, Jacoba A, Peter R Donald.
Effect of cortiocosteroids on intracranial pressure, computed
tomographic findings and clinieal outcome in young children
‘with tubercular meningitis, Pediatrics 1997; 99(2): 226-23 |
Lorber J Studies of CSF circulation in tubercular meningitis I
review of 100 pneumoencephalograms, Arch Dis Child 1951;
26: 28-48,
Dastur DK, Pandya SK, Rao YC. Etiology of hydrocephalus
in tuberculous meningitis (abstract). Neurology India 1972:
(Supp! 1): 73.
Sinith HV, Vollum RL, Cairns H, Treatment of Tuberculous
meningitis with streptomycin (a report of MRC). Lancet 1948;
i: 627-636,
Tandon PN, Bhatia R, Bhargava S, Tubercular Meningitis. In:
Vinken PJ, Brun GW, Klawans HL, eds, Handbook of Clinical
‘Neurology, Microbial disease Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1988; 58
195-226.
Daljit Singh, Sunil Kumar, Ventriculo peritoneal shunt in post
tubercular hydrocephalus. Indian Pediatrics 1996; 33: 854-855.
Raymond J Fernandez, Martin A Samuels. Intellectual
dysfunction: mental retardation and dementia manual of
neurologic therapeuties. Edited by Martin A Samuels,
Lippincott Williams and Wilkins 1999, Sixth Edition; Ch-3
31-63.
Abigail Zuger. Franklin D Lowy. Tuberculosis of the Brain,
meninges and spinal cord, V. Clinical Aspects; Ch-41: 541-551
John M Mathew, Vedantam Rajshekhar, Mathew J Chandy.
Shunt surgery in poor grade patients with tubercular meningitis
and hydrocephalus. Effects of response to external ventricular
drainage and other variables and long term outcome. J Neurol
‘Neurosurg Psychiatry 1998: 65: 115-118,
A Leland Albright. Hydrocephalus in children, Principles of
Neurosurgery. Edited by Setti S. Rengachary, Robert H.
Wilkins-Mosby-Wolfe 1994, Ch-6: pg, 6.2-6.23
Daljit Singh, V. Gupta, P. Sachdeva, A Goel. S. Sinha, A.K.
Singh, Surgical considerations in CNS tuberculosis. Paediatrics
‘Today 2000: Voll (2): pg. 121-127
Farinha NI, Razali KA, Holzel H. Tuberculosis of central
nervous system in children: a 20-year survey. J Infect 2000:
41-61-68,
Yaranis A, Gurkan P, Elevil M. Central nervous system
tuberculosis in children: a review of 214 cases, Pediatrics 1998;
102: E-49-Abstract.
Kennedy DH, Fallon RJ. Tubercular meningitis. JAMA 1979;
241: 264-268.
Starke IR. Tuberculosis of the central nervous system. Semin
Pediatr Neurol 1999; 6: 318-331
Ozates M, Kemaloglu S. Gurkan F. CT of the brain in
tuberculous meningitis: review of 289 patients. Acta
Radiologica 2000: 41: 13-17.
Vol. 11, No. 3, July-September 2004
164JK_- PRACTITIONER
2
4
2s.
Gupta RK. Gupta S, Singh D. MR imaging and angiography in
tuberculous meningitis. Neuro-radiology 1994; 36: 87-92.
WHO: Treatment of tuberculosis, Guidelines for National
Programme World Health Organisation. WHO TB Geneva
1997, 220
American Thoracic Society: Treatment of tuberculosis and
tuberculosis infection in adults and children. Am J Respir Crit
care Med 1994; 149: 1359-1374
IAP Working Group: Treatment of childhood tuberculosis
Consensus statement of IAP working group. Indian Pediatr
1997; 34: 1093-1096.
‘Steiner P, Portu galeza C: Tuberculos Meningitis in children,
Am Rev Respir Dis 1973; 107: 22-29,
Girgis NI. Farid Z. Kilpatrick ME, Dexamethasone as an adjunct
to treatment of tubercular meningitis. Pediatr Infect Dis J 1991;
10: 179-183,
Palur R. Rajsekhar V, Chandy MJ. Shunt surgery for
hydrocephalus in tubercular meningitis: along term follow up
30.
a1
33,
34.
study. Neurosurgery 1991; 74: 64-69.
Kemaloglu S, Ozkan U, Bukte Y, Ceviz A, Ozates M. Timing of
shunt surgery in childhood tuberculous meningitis with
hydrocephalus. Z Kinder chi 1985, 40 (Suppl 1): 12.
Bhagwati $.N. Ventriculo atrial shunt in tuberculous meningitis
with hydrocephalus. J Neurosurgery 1971; 38: 309-313
Bullock MRR, Ven Dellen JR. The role of cerebrospinal shunting
intuberculous meningitis, Surg Neurol 1982; 18: 274-277.
Peter MC Black, Mit Sunormi Matsumal. Hydrocephalus in
adults Principles of Neurosurgery - Edited by Sett S. Rengachary,
Robert H. Wilkins Mosby - Wolfe 1994: ch 7: 7.2-7.7.
Barett - Conner E. Tuberculous Meningitis in adults. South
Med J 1967; 60: 1061-1067.
Leeper MH, Spies HW. The present status of the treatment of
tuberculosis of the central nervous system, Ann NY Acad Sei
1963; 106: 106-123.
165
Vol. 11, No. 3, July-September 2004