https://engymo.wordpress.

com

5
( 2015)
. ,
, ,
,
,
.
,
, . ,
,
.
,

,
.

. ;

.

. ,
:



.

1
 . , ,
,
.

, , .

.
.

[1]

, ,
.
19 .

.
1
[] . 19

. dictatura
,
.
(
) .

. , ,
2
3.
.

1
The Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences. 15 ,
1930-1967. (...)
2

1789 1795
. 144 48 .
1792 , ,
.
(...)
3
(Convention Nationale) ,
20 1792
. 24 1793 .

,
. (...)

2
 , 4
,

.


5, 6, ,
7 ,
8 .9

4
(Francois Noel Gracchus Babeuf, 1760-1797).
, 19 ,
, , .
.

,
. , ,
, .

( )
,
.
, ,
( ) .
.

. (...)
5
O (Wilhelm Weitling, 1808-1871)
, . ,
, ,
.
. (...)
6
,
(- , , 1760-1825),

.

.
.
,
, .
,
,

. (...)
7
(Louis Jean Joseph Charles Blanc, 1811-1882)
, .
1848
.
, ,
.
1848 . (...)
8
(Filippo Giuseppe Maria Ludovico Buonarrotti, 1761-1837):
, , ,
, .
,
.

3
 , ,
,
,
, .
O [Maurice Donmanget] o [Alan Spitzer]

.
.
,
(Socit des Egaux).
(Analyse de doctrine de Babeuf),
1796, , ,
.
.

. . ,
:
,
,
.
,

(. http://www.rassias.gr/1087BUONAROTTI.html).
.

( )
,
.
, ,
( ) .
.

. 1796
. , ,
, , .
1807,
.
, .
(Carbonari) La Charbonnerie Franaise,
.
1830.
, .
1843
. 16 1837.
18
. : Histoire des socits secrtes de l'arme (1815), Conspiration pour l' Egalite dite de
Babeuf, suivie du procs auquel elle donna lieu (1828), Observations sur Maximilien Robespierre,
Bruxelles,( 1837). (...)
9
- (Louis Auguste Blanqui, 1805-1880)
19 , ,
( 36 75 )


. . . 4, -
. (...)

4
 .
. . [R. W. Postgate], Out of the Past,
. ,
.

, , .
,
,
.

[2]

, 31 1851,
:

! Quelle horreur1011.
.
12 .
New York Tribune13

, .

,
1848 185014.

.

10
! (). (...)
11
Marx-Engels Correspondence, Marx to Engels in Manchester, 31 March 1851,
http://hiaw.org/defcon6/works/1851/letters/51_03_31.html
12
, (Henry John Temple, 3rd Viscount
Palmerston,1784-1865) ,
.
,
. (...)
13
New York Daily Tribune:
1841 1924. -
1851 1862. (...)
14

1848 1850, , , 2012.
(...)

5
 ,
: 15
,
.16


.

, 17

:

,
,
: ,
.18

,
,
. ,
, , ,
. ( ,
).
,
:

. , ,
.19

, .

,
Herrschaft.
, 1845,
15
(Louis Eugene Cavaignac, 1802-1857) .
1848
.
(...)
16
1848 1850, . 76-77, , , 2012.
(...)
17
( Parti de lOrdre)
, ,
. (...)
18
1848 1850, . 153. (...)
19
.., . 140. (...)

6
 ,
.

.

1847 :


.
20
:

, , .21

,
,
.22
,

, ,
.23

,
.

.
1848 , ,
[Neue Rheinische Zeitung] ,

,
.

, ,
, . ,
, -
.
.
.

20
.
. Frederick Engels, The Principles of Communism,
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1847/11/prin-com.htm. (...)
21
Frederick Engels, The Principles of Communism, .. . (...)
22
Karl Marx-Friedrich Engels, , Karl Marx,
1840, . 491, . , , , 2014. (...)
23
.. . 492. (...)

7

.
[ ] ,
. .
,
,
.24

.
;
:
, , mesures de
salut public25.26
.27

, ;

184828. :

,

-
.


. , ,

.29

,

, .

24
Karl Marx,The Crisis and the Counter-Revolution, Neue Rheinische Zeitung, 1848,
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1848/09/12.htm, . (...)
25
(). (...)
26
Karl Marx, The Crisis and the Counter-Revolution, .. (...)
27
.. (...)
28
1851 New York Tribune
1848.
,

. ,
, , ,
.
,
. (...)
29
Fredrick Engels, Revolution and Counter-Revolution in Germany, VII. The Frankfort National
Assembly, https://www.marxists.org.

8
 , ,


.
,
.

. ,
: ,
,
, .30

,
,
31,
.

,
,
,
.

[3]

.
: ) 1850-52, . 1848, ) 1872-75, .
, ) 1890-91 ( ,
, 1875).

.32 ;

30
.. (...)
31
... (...)
32


5), 6, 8, 11, . 4 .
. Ernst
Drahn Karl Marx und Fr. Engels ueber die Diktatur des Proletariats (1920)
. 4, 8 10. Max Beer An Inquiry into Dictatorship
(Labour Monthly, 1922) 1), 1), 4, 6 8. Sherman
H. M. Chang Marxian Theory of the State (1931) . 1),
1), 4, 5), 6 8, .
Stanley W. Moore, The Critique of Capitalist Democracy: Introduction to the
Theory of the State in Marx, Engels and Lenin (1957)
.

9
 1844,
, .
,
,
, ,
.

- .
1850
.

.

1874
.

,
,
.
, , ,
,

.
33 ( . 7)

, .
.

1848 1850,
34 [Neue
Rheinische Zeitung, Politisch-konomische Revue]

33
Frederick Engels, The Program of the Blanquist Fugitives from the Paris Commune,
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1874/06/26.htm, . (...)
34
1849, ,
.
, 1848
1849.
, 1849.
1850 . , ,
1848 1850
. (...)

10
. ( )
.

1848
: !
!.35 [ . 1)].

.
!.
: !.36

; .
,
,
,
.

.

(
)


37. [ . 1)].
,
,
. ,
,

.

35
. , 1848 1850, . 67, , ,
2012. (...)
36
:
! .
. '
.
, ' ' .
,


, .
, ,
,
: ! !. . ,
1848 1850, . 66-67, , , 2012. (...)
37
: ,
,

, ,
. .., . 108. (...)

11
 ( 5-15
) :

, ,
.
, ,
,
,

,
.38 [ . 1)]

:

, .

[4]

.

,
., . , ,
,
.
, , .

.
1850
.
,
,
,
39,

[ ]

38
.., . 148. (...)
39
(George Julian Harvey, 1817-1897)
, ,
, Red Republican (
). (...)

12
( [Arthur Rosemberg]
Democracy and Socialism40).

(Socit Universelle des Communistes Rvolutionnaires)
, 41
, .

, .
:

,

,
.42 [
. 2]

,


,
,


..43.
,
,

40
Arthur Rosemberg, Democracy and Socialism: A Contribution to the Political History of the Past
150 Years. (1938), http://www.unz.org (...)
41
(Johann August Ernst von Willich, 1810-1888)
. ,
1848
.
. (...)
42
The World League of Revolutionary Communists (Societe Universelle des Communistes
Revolutionnaires), https://www.marxists.org/archive/riazanov/1928/xx/blanqui.htm#app1,
. (...)
43
. , , . - , . 33, ,
, 2011. (...)

13

, .

,
,

.

. [Neue
Deutsche Zeitung] [Joseph Weydemeyer]
[Otto Lning] ( ).
1845
.
44.
. ,

, (
).
,
,

.

(Diktatur) ,
(Klassenherrschaft). 4
(Erklrung)45. [
. 3]:

.
: [

].
[
]46. ,

44

1840.
,
. (...)
45
( ). (...)
46
:
.
, , .
, -

. ,
.
.

14
 [
. 1)].47

( )
. .


,
,
,
.

,
.
,
:

. , ,
,
, . ,

.

, ,
.

,
,

,
, .

,
:

, ; .
,
, ,
.
,

, -
. . ,
, . 173-174, . -, ,
, .. (...)
47
Karl Marx, Erklrung, Neue Deutsche Zeitung, 1850,
http://www.mlwerke.de/me/me07/me07_323.htm.
. (...)

15
 , 5 1852.

. ;
.

7
1851. 1
1852 Turn-Zeitung .
.48

1918.

.
.

(die Diktatur des in den grossen Stdten konzentrirten Proletariats)
.49

.
5
.

,

.
. :
, . ,

.

,
, .

.
: )
, )
, )

48
Joseph Weydemeyer, Die Diktatur des Proletariats, Turn-Zeitung, 1 1852. .
Joseph Weydemeyer, The Dictatorship of the Proletariat (1962), Labor History, 3:2, 214-217. (...)
49

:
. Joseph
Weydemeyer, The Dictatorship of the Proletariat, .. . (...)

16

.50 [ . 4]

,
, , ,
1850.

.
.
,
.

[5]

20 ,
, ( ,
).

.
( )
, ,
.

[.
-
...].

,
,
.
. ,
.

,

.51

50
Abstract from Marx to J. Weydemeyer in New York, 5 1852,
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1852/letters/52_03_05-ab.htm,
. (...)
51

' , ,
.
,

17

, .

,
,

.

, ,

: ,
,
, ,
52,
.

53

.54 ,
.

.

.
,
.
:
55
,
, , 56 [Vaillant],
, ,

,
. ,
, . 74, , , 2011. (...)
52
, ,
,
. .., . 70. (...)
53
.., . 74. (...)
54
.., . 80. (...)
55

. (...)
56
(douard Vaillant, 1840-1915) ,
1871 .
.
.
,

. (...)

18
 , ,
57 [Longuet] .

,
,
.
, .
1872
1874 ,
.

, ,
. ,
(1872) :

,

:
-
, ,

,

.58
[ . 5)]

( )
1872,
59.

. ,
1872 ,
(Internationale et Rvolution),
, 18 ,
.

,

(1872),
.60 .

57
(Charles Longuet, 1839-1903)
.
. , , . (...)
58
, , . 116, , , 2012. (...)
59
R. W. Postgate, Out of the Past. (...)
60
1872 Der Volksstaat ,
1869
1876 . (...)

19
 . 5).
:

: 1.
.
,
, ,
.
,
, ,
. ,
, ,

.
,
.61 [ . 5)]

.
:
, .
,
62
,
.

, 1873
,
(LIndifferenza in Materia Politica).
,
, .

. :

,

, . ,

,

61
.., . 119. (...)
62

19 . 1838,
(...).

20

.63 [ . 6]

64, .
, ,

.

1874
[ . 7].

Volksstaat.

,
,

.65
66.

.
.

, .67
,
:

.
,
.68
[ . 8]

63
, , . , , 63,
- 1998. (...)
64
.. (...)
65

, 1875 .
,
, (
),
- ().

.
(1875). (...)
66
. . (...)
67
, , . 33, , , 2007. (...)
68
.., . 34. (...)

21
 .

.69
,
.
.

.

[demokratische Republik],
70 . ,

1880.

[6]

15 ,
,
.

[Conrad Schmidt], 27 1890,

:

.
, . ,
18 71 ,
, ,
.
, .. ,
, , .
( 24 ).
, ;

69
, . , , . 33-36,
, , 2007. (...)
70
, , . 35-36, , , 2007.
(...)
71
, .
(...)

22
(. ) !.72 [ .
9]

15 ;

73.
, , , ,
1875,
( ) .

,
, .
.
.

.
74 [Karl
Grillenberger] :

.


.

.
.

.
( . 7)

. ,
( )
.
75 ,

72
(, 27 1890), . 582, - ,
, , , , .. (...)
73

, 1891 .
. .
. (...)
74
. (...)
75
, , . 22, , , 2011. (...)

23
 ,
.76 :

, 77
: . , , ,
;
. .78 [ . 10]

:
( ). , ,
Vorwrts79:

, ,
80

, . , :

,

.
,
.81 ( . 11)

82, :

76
,
,
! ,
, ,
, ,
, ,
. .., . 22. (...)
77
: , . (...)
78
.., . 22-23. (...)
79
Vorwrts (): ,
(SPD). 1891
.
. (...)
80
, 29 1891, . ,
1891, . 68, -,
, . , , , 1976.
(...)
81
.., . 81. (...)
82

,
, .

24
 ,
.
,
83

,

,
. ,
,


.84

1891, ,
.
, ,
.85

1962

: Hal Draper, Marx and the Dictatorship of the Proletariat

: https://www.marxists.org/archive/draper/1962/xx/dictprolet.html

Hal Draper (1914-1990) , ,

60, a,
,


.

https://engymo.wordpress.com

. ,
. .., . 81-82. (...)
83
.., . 82. (...)
84
: ,

.
, . ,
, . ..., . 81.
(...)
85
(
) . 6 tudes de Marxologie , M.
Rubel , ,
. Labour History ( III, 2)
Weydemeyer ,
.

25