Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Cabezon Jose Ignacio - A Dose of Emptiness PDF

    Uploaded by

    Fernando José
    103 views304 pages

    Original Title

    Cabezon Jose Ignacio - A Dose of Emptiness.pdf

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    103 views304 pages

    Cabezon Jose Ignacio - A Dose of Emptiness PDF

    Uploaded by

    Fernando José

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 304
    tithes Indo-Budica Serer No. 125. A DOSE OF EMPTINESS ‘An Annotated Translation of the ‘Tong thun chen mo of mkhas grub dGe legs dpal bzang José Ignacio Cabensn SRI SATGURU PUBLICATIONS "A DIsiow OF INDIAN BOOKS CENTRE 'DELHLINDIA att Snsagun obits ‘eompentand Oven Phe notin {bys.shabi Naga ane cr ae ner of New Yr 192 ADRighs Rare “TyePustato of hs ok inlay Pein of ‘Bh Ute ew ork Pes Nopansftokmay bed or praia any mat POSEY ESNet oe [PRINTED IN INDIA, Contents* Actnomesgents arson [A Stet Biography of mas gb fe [Preamble] (Hones) [Reson fe Compoion of be Tea) [The Bhe's Dace te Utne Source ‘ol Satin) {Me Preps Nig’ Cong rwoductin] 1. The Reason Why Is Cac 1 Stk ut Rely [it Epis Trg i he Tans) 2: The Beefs of using nthe Pond (Decne ‘of Engin 9: The eel, Thats, he Lise, 9 Whom This Decne Sle Espaned| a aticonceptcn Cancering ies an is ‘Concer [he Characters of the pe Dip) 44 The Ac Doin o Be Exped ‘41 Tying Which Scrue Ae of Define ‘Meaning ees dn) ant Which of Psa Meaning (iron en) 2 » Fs 3 as ne at he ie thi dn tee eng ated my “4.1. THE DOCTRINES OF THE YOOKCARA SCHOOL, tnorcra Mepis td Herne Te Te Nee IR Sg ieee he Hea visha Ctan athe Maye rete Beo he Pits Clie “ag Dy tA Acne 8 Serta,» Ye fs rc tif Soe Sep nine eas oe Ver te a Te tice css Jon se oT Siete reno one ute Axe of he Ee St on cr ay ao a te xa iin ne Sr te Dee nant pl OE oe se "hems 1 nas bin of Ets) Ryn coy ne me ooo ee Nae (Bessy wen York sd ec toes con = U8 Tent nema connie emeea sages Highoing “ie DOCTRINES OF THE MADHYAMARA. SCHOOL [he Sources of the Madhyamaka Sool} 4.12. How te Pater, be Arya Nina a Tis'son Arun, owing Ssh Sia the ‘Meanie Set Fort the Doin of ‘etnies he Proviso 462 How Stop by Step he Tens Nigh an the (Comments eri Pargor ons =) APC 442.1 Eels of te Win th Satpne the Aeye Were Wien 38 422.7 Eatin f Ho Oe i ments oo he Psp! ot Mies ‘emer Aree 1A General Inodution othe Mayra) {nthe Clasieaion of Mayas) {he hesnng ot Cain Tat Panna Accond with ‘ae Won 44.2.3'Seing Fort Engines ty Flowing Those [Mauna Spr 42.31 ning Wht eo Be Rte by the Rewoning Which Anaesth Uline don dam dyed pt rags) 42.57 ity We Necessary wo Hetiy What 10 Be Ref 42.31. Reig te cra Epes of Tae Wo [Proceed nthe] Raton wit etting tbe Once Be Rete 42.511 Refung he On Whe Overetnts Aad ‘hes bs nal Heel i he entiation of What 4251341, Sting What They Bebe 2251212 Reting Teen 12312121 Demnating That They Have Rate the Prcpl ond Spal Qty he Pisa Miva 42ST TTI Lemiping Tt Chet Ouiy {23121213 How Toy Have Rte Ta (Specie “Quality ty The Sytem ft erpetaon] 42312423. Demonartng hse Renan © Be Fay 225121221 Demonaeting Tat Thee "Etamiton of Wht Means or Sorting ‘Wan ot Nt Wit Lop Anais aly 428121222, Denemtring Tot Tht Anat in te Fur Poti, sec Nene, {Su So ft, Fay [The Law of aca Mie i he Questo of Wht he Maya is PMiewpl Ia Ginga of Qt STF 25" Demanaeting That Thi Asi of Inia Mean for Someting Yo Be Estas or Not Eble ya Vd Copii, and The Seseqet o ass ee 88 423121224, Demasaing hat Tei sania. 2 ve Rn Co Be Duel Ect sens) ete Tau Way, Sth a Aig fom Sat ray 4a 21GN228 Demasng That scares 1 en aay Tha We ot Co 42.213 Mow We ee he One Who Doe Nat Go ar Eth ub con Be een of 4231S in tapaton of What Or Owe Spm Tondo Be fe Extent of What so Be Rett “42.01 1 aging Gna Wy he Lot ‘what lo Be Rlace taut nd Pilot Moncton) [ne octaves of THE SeATANTHIKA SCHOOL] [he Logic of he Setanta Critique} 142.312. Te Eastin ofthe Meso the ‘Stitt bjs of Rtuation rie Ann fhe Stan Ot of Refetation used othe sample ofthe sie ime Amc te int Oe Rtn buco Spa See rie Cave lection of fe Svat Objest. ‘of Rett) tric Renn te One an the May [Homie Exam oe Rfecton ne Mor Ts Uoderod) Te Dacnod Grane Resign be Question of ‘ne Quon ote Objet of Reta) ine estore Refuing Aran vin he For Estes {Tbe Renmin Refving te Arsing of he Exe ‘snd Noni [me vocrmes oF THE #RASANGIKA SCHOOL] 1A General Exposition of Prise Tees} 423,133. Explaiing the Extent (shad te Prashga Obj of Refeaton dr Pa) oe Reaiy rly Ext ts Too Met abe 19 He 16 {an Ecos onthe sence Body of he But) [he Argumen Concerning Realty Cones [The Reasoning Used Prove Tht One Pema 1 ‘Empy Ages All Phesomen,ncang Een 1s toes Ney East Empey 2 Mental Label (he Meaning of According wh the Wer in he Prasnpa System] be Scriptura Bass or Nomis) [te Exec th Oppose of Nomina Exist) 2513.4 Reig Moncton sh Reged he TDssinctnetewcen Satna aed Prise} on" Witting Lopes! Anas" 425.135. An Explanation of he ipations of This 225155. 1%keeapaatin of 0) te Too Kiss of Seta to Be Reed snd 2) te Sees That Tete Refton A2RIUSTILA Bt Memon of the Test. ‘Atectel by Other Systems AQ ST SSCL Kote the Set hat he Fern Objet mis alo th late View of Set Ze Ace by Both Busts a Ober 42.21 3502. What a he Ghne Cue Fads in These Views 4201355113 How the Oe Basti Stoo Fost the Sei Ta Ite Det Onect of te To Views of The Sl te ern nd Phenomena] an Hew That [The Hinyiors View on Leraton a Bbood) 2511351148 How the Glsoas Case's Cio 42313512 The Esposito ofthe Systm of the Prsoghas aba Din [Sytem in hs Ov ih) [a Bret spanaton ofthe Diflerences betwen he Silene ft Fenon so Phenom ISroakar and Prayotabuddhar Understand Realty) 425.1352. he Explanation of Whete Sodas 42313531 Hw te Glorious Cana Goes About plain Ths 42.31.3522. Te Retin of he Mion “hat Btw That Expos! to Be Ice the Repose tthe Prceing Cte S552. Tae Eapontion othe Va Seria ‘Evisence Eiplning hat Srinl and Pratabuddas Hine im Untaning oe Seles 0 Pest Son of the Conqueror, Saniceva 423135232 The Explanations of Tis Pint Aso Ingo the Abhisomndanre, the Craton, and 4231352521 How he AbRamayaontna ae ‘Commentaries Explain Tis Pe SI3T35932. Te Eipanton fe Meaning of 42513524 an Esenne Expat of Stipe and Lope essai roving Ta I Crt > sm Tat Star an Pronto ve an Understanding of the Sessa Penonera 423135241 Te Eatin fe Lope 423.35.242. Bringing Sepa Exeesis Bear on the Problem) (on te Hina et Maine Unies of Nr 42313523. The Explamton ofthe Two (Kl of “ications i alan oe Pate on Which Tey ‘he Ata {How he Oteertons Are Emit onthe Various a [he Stas of Infect in the Madhya) 462.32, As Repade he Refeton of That (Objet of Refutato) be Expl of te ieee eee 42.521" Relating What Oters Bee (Do the ‘Matyas Hove Psp Pstos) 442322 Seung For Our wn Poston 42123 8 Tepe Mang Sa «2 SEEE Te apn oe Ro Wy he 4235755" Brpig te Pratmapaid Bear on This [eston and Explaining (hs Messing] a8 a as » [Madhyamsks Lopcal Seatepes and Related Poles) 42.3.3, The Explanation of he Resning Tat Retes the Object of he Retain 4233) The Acta Espanatin of he Resning That Reh the Ont ofthe Reftion 423511 The Rewinng Tt Reiter be Sl of 42.351 Te Eapanatin of he Retain of he Sal 423512114) The ual Expaation of he Reson. 4255.71 48) Tae Reaation of Ain rom Aver £2531 2140 (Te Reftaton of the Aig ror Bot Slander 42331 21(D) [Te Refetation of Arig Caley tnd Cons | {ter Unique Teets ofthe Prisha School) 4233122. apining Oter Faces of he Page “en That Are Nt Common wh te Citas sod ere 42331354, The Rapamtion of be Uncomesn Expoon of he Te Tier 42531 291. The Gon Papantion f he 423512212. Te Eapaatin of he Prot of Why 42551322 The gunn of [Toe Ober Fa ‘Dileetiing [te Pasa rm Otter School (lung and he Acoptance of External Os (pit ow 42531.93.1 Te Eslntio of Hon Even Tough ‘We Bo Not Accept the Funston Cocos he Relation tetween Kata ade til 423512222. Reig the Fat That he Ae [Nisin anda on Ace te Foun Comeiuren 4253122221 The Reason Why They Do Nox ‘Aap [he Fonttion Const 4235122223. Te Redon oe Blt That ie Priests Mami) Ace I 2% am a v6 4233.1.2223. The Eupnaton of How External ‘jess Are PsuedNowstaly Ir Prisyts Interpretation of the Cana Sara) [Some Recaption Acs Wel Spe: The Cane wt We 4251223. The Expat of Why We Do Not 425512231 The Expiation of How We Ree the ‘tn Tat Docs Ace I 42331223111. The Enlnaton ofthe Opponent: tion 42331223.12. The Eastin of Ho wo eft 42331223421 The eluaton ofthe apes) Pra 42351223.1.22. Te Retain of he Bel $25312252 ‘the Epa of Hon We Pst Our ‘Own Sytem, Wich Boos Not Ase [Asean [Tee Two Tats and Thi Corio 4429.32. Te Espana th To Tr, Whe the Ba se Forth Remonag 4235.21 ine tao forthe Bn ot Tao Tate 4233.22. The Meaning of te Met [ia td 532 Coming Wht Thy Are he Same oe Different 4255320 The Nae of fc a the To Ts 423324 Te Dein 4233242 he Danone 42332421 Te Drs of te Unite ah {the Psp neeoe he Tce Ree Try fm oii 425533. Ie Eaplaaton fhe Yad Conon Tat ‘ea he fo Ta Tt A Phenom) 423551 Te etn 223332. he Domne {Concuson) 41238 Having Set Forth pies, How o Mete me @ us as “0 3 18 as us eo m a 42.35, The Expotin of he Rel Ta the Cimiaoe of Median Iconcaing Von? [colo pend 1 The Vrs Ron on Append 2 The Hihen Gres Contactos Giosry Bitsigaphy ‘Wester Scary and Sant Suse a 59 m Acknowledgments ay nity a tn, nh i in, ve males Bit eoning in poral" ALI stem the pion nse the Fepin a te psstlty of ad knowlege (eprom: am) [genera One tings ie pols te dwt of al ne, Ut nting eon be preted hing he, that ty dsc a emp esti, all bang eal ditt om he it; a » oy oe ly we Gnd fr of along sepconhaown a “the ew that hing eater exist sor snes Gd min med min 1” Acsrig oa view the Madham cre be ate at a ‘Reo exstece es, 5008 geal wit edt fn {be gulier alimay a witout soy 10 Gay wha ‘wing reps “aiate' enc oe cal ao eh Te Siew cre from» eral retin era pases the Med "a erate Gat oe te sre mp te Iw of te exhed me ato rong ay mba edhe ar tin hve a een om a RE MaDe pe ws metal inte he tal ee bn tc yal wane a whe ey Sea cl sre wns snp ho 2 rem er exh ter te cal phere a pe wl ring can al 1 ani che he aa anna he ram {ean ang canbe ni oe aging es eat nee vie fname. ing ex en ee te meni, fr Lvl twee fat ea soo ee ad he ming acm eS Fe ay mca el mr appeeint an e Soon ee amesioa htc ee ws hy WL Sim, en 2 pen can ga te sepia cies at ee acca pe tc os ow oie eat seit hve a uc fren a ee ata es encanta ch PO are mac tare Wien ei ws a Fee ne, Urey we finda ponent eid ney cet oy me mene se ce te eens a welrcublie hel oo rine ce ae Pear hat on many choc iKn ah e i a nal runt athe as et pone oe Se ran ede cours ict monte ee re aman eat tak of We TTC # ar Be Oe gig a pers plied eed by ime ene of ew fhe ee on fs tees of th TTC sald ma exe oe sw of wks eb Se pene 1.5 he ea ee ee et oe aed ewig of See ste necro wich te wok a en neta at Naren wc a a Omen ts oman ews He a Seyret matress oer, a eerie of BS 8 Seni ae) oa crf han Mayan Seer ay ns someting |e. None hv Sey aan sin ong eee a et ea SIRE iach nay ined ot ng ners so et ccs Tose ne mde rere 1 ir al Se een ie a sce cms ws Mammen ener opstion tne TE.” Textual Considerations “Te midge of ur tet is The Tae Thar Perfect Elcdates Re ip. The Pn Decne of Empat, Called “Opening the Eye of he rtm mn ot de ho ma rab lB Bed Pa bo eo shal ang mite. ty wen, Anon lg 8 Oe {GreurDiget song cen mo)" 2 The Dig That Opens the Eye of ‘he Porat ing tn sal ean mye. I myth conse tee eet etn of te et 1. That fund ft volume of he Miya Tet Series (MTS), (Sed by Lia mir yogs ‘unin po yal san (New Del wn. 2h found the sue a (Colected Work), ob of the 1897 {inca Zh con persed a meri by the Mtoe Research Frown te Ste Unies of New York a Sno (97, {nde pase Dharmas (198 nd That found ne ump bum, vl a, o te OK sun po ‘nfm th ary of Lethe Rinpoche New Del: Neawang Gl Dom. BS), Fro te ptr fetal an ial er sees lea atthe ATS was ft ey hae o he Lis Zh elton my Ysaon Tv made rere wth page amber of he MTS edn tat tng ot at eae. nnetes o of be at ‘She The TS eon aed with te tonal Ten Foe Simbers (orien ct sn word on the ftund margin fhe fot fh {ny snd wt abe mcs ch fae smb suena = The She me Sw a ma of on = i acct heel Te fet th TTC then 43 pages 235 {os ing nto, eh Se vue ne in te floes ‘tee spends, cpr fom, bt ents eto, the TE tal. Tuco of fing he aul wriings of Khas ares hse ie sales ‘toot ar ses lees gen he an taken wr y neo chit “Stipe hun Bung hoes am rpal Cs hang gr dal {Wotan he ito ie TS. 4-306) ia expnton he ‘tan of arkng vis te or ees a expla a Cas Prosomapaa The seo (MTS, yp. 06-312) a it commeary 08 ‘Tong Kas Ten ‘rel syne poe The lon (MTS. pp. 312-9232 rent on eat poms rting 0 the eaivatoe Sonata and Vinson, Anopheles ex a rele © ech te ad © UTC tat hy dea wh op in Mayan poy a hey ae (Sut work tom the 77 wena by the tat he coe eee an cng TT wept fa he he pend, rh eel cp ee of et Wicd wert ar ou cedar a id with exo sb ceo nee ite cs A ee se vet a an, NO se eh an nthe sonnei tn ut pes Ont os we Sin wr enemy oe ext asic wy ee eed cori a me yt OE ecm whe TEC me The Translation te tanaon was competed ude he eeag o seve eet ane Pe ea alion Gee Aasotedgcs) Oe omy meno ome id ‘cae at tmnt wht 1 ley btw tat Be rsh and hve ed 0 ean he ae cnt. ae tan sera of oe Kind: eae sn pea Hat ts meng © hm Par eons aagonmn or alegancss between mika A et ober Tan os eae NS. a nee met se cre pts he ene ne pesntene me mR wT se ns pvp tat mii ve 2 TH ca tr bcm in Maya ss, ha ‘ola th a escent have some he eo 8 ene ele of Bean yn. Give eae avd ana ane dso wl hve meat» poertin of a ea col easy hve mathe te et i en a mts we wal Ye fund x he being of * see ated ie he eee 1 te oF ai te secondary eae, th be ee Hen Sow ceca ject vs {ve ede eae 1 wooed none rr men wes i tomato sb ero cnn a FTC nd re ees he cs ed Se toe Mat temp oe al othe pages fom te sn a mee tan aki gr ces, cot ha | ae cm 2 eo AD uch hans a tO eye mks pe il tien sea wr wot se Te ne le ch heey We whe ig»). i i bower ae cine ery wort, Most see tne tees [Semin peepee ee Sea eas ares Sober isenienee warren Sania errs Sore Scie eteceseee eit {hen dtr stl fom he 190 cat arate, acta aie eee es heaneaae ree Sa ascites 1989), Monograph Series, Ocasionl Papers, vol. 1. The first leter of prox ce a ee Bee ee eee eed * te tat eter scar nd een seat rnd Salas tae oyna ome sare Sa ‘She the tope if maing th tation rete: ad yet, when as coe =a ocean ee Cae (tape hu scarica gamma ate at es i ‘ol tly as mach hd ee bape comp. She ey ‘Scat ports te wor he ng velo fhe Yokes hy eat eee taeeensameaa {Garces ind woul ce apa erg ener npr Sin engl te ae ota center be i a "pen the ees af the fortune" Ome ‘roe Saeed ERECT eee tte provide with» linge, abe ee 50 sal ev) prod Bion ery empties ” A Short Biography of mKhas grub dGe Legs dpal bzang ‘ote: Ti tography sed on sve i aging was ona ar) encetogmkhas gu The bss fo the reser cous een Tobe Sncog ling Ying ese ea sb (1718-199) Bogapy i be [hong clu Lamy rim pu ama Bray pt ram thar UREN) (Ne ‘athe Ngrvane Geek Den. 1970, pp 77-92) cone werk hat Soom ot of the jr pint n nkae Bb e's ie Ts hse ey ‘toplented by coming wher were sucha he aSang fa wa tar {hry of etm chr eal maha, to be found in mks pr 3 Caled Works, vl 9p. 2-498 have also cose, nthe cop ono he reset grag, he Nam har mis pu ‘pr CCoteced Works a 9p I-23, writen by EN ing an ying die rene (et, hee ra pat a arc the icomple am shar (V7 hy don eho "is me San Po (138-1791) found ine Colle Woks. nS Getan Seng Minyam ‘Gpunte Serie. ol 25 (New Deh pawn Gel Dea 07) pp. "2S also sDe id Sage eps zy o's sy of he de Ts pu Set th Borer po (BS) New Deli: Nsw Gh Demo. 197 pp TEI, May ft at, be ths egy and towpath et nd in sam ht poof i tan sae Seng TE) Too ‘ose Migs dpe stan thang, a.) Ml ga as Bent ge he ede {eng fo he coment an syle of edna Tien hapa ea toe with the os of cite stra perspective Discos tthe ‘arts the dierent gags, diferenees ets, and speementary ‘nr dered fom otto, fr he man prt lated the te ie sry deter OF wha te, Stes inthe Lf and Thoupt of Midas poh Fike ge ‘er Episenmlogal Ooe an He Piolo Remar oa Diggs Proninesmsccoa {° (SK) and "Sass te Lie and Though of ‘Mls Grab eV Mis Grub Reon Regionals and Diet” G1 beth nein Indole San (1) Bad 1 (94S 73-10 Bad Tasi6y 28, respec ” | Sen Bony ofits abe 1 se in he gre of 0m oun, the Taha echigs My mane beny with te neh ed pe aos, Pee a the peo sage tbe ig of eas” sssugpcn enn anon ed ea a SSL oe ene rise ede rion en Oo ose oe Seba ema a ac ea Steet ate craan ar Gene pu vtonecte aaa ou tetera reason Sere te usenet Beetroot so Spe eee ae manasa eet teen Det eS ce rae cee Era een ng tan etn reise was born in a section of Tod tying” in gTsang called Dog oie tae i Soule Sat reas atanaicoae Foe See mae aoa ceremony ata enn sa rt ma ceereneg erat se eres rere ee enced leer bp telapri moe ermine neetn acehna a mils comets Shen enantio Seen mn un Seca mutes a meee ae SE oe Shor Raga of mas rab » npn of Reasoning, 5 wl the Vin At th ne he ao sid toe ried fom Ye ster dpa he ian tte Hear the all sii of ears ech pil ne oc he Te Naam sing aS sya staying st for om ty of sip stots the eso Sd rams al mean nthe pest Na Bb Daring hea wate con o tet, ete o mary othe geet mrss Tag (Wesern ‘Tie to debt wl ate ‘Stoeats a shares tr swn mes faces ugh deta spe ‘on, At oe pit nie he ws ving he owsey of Ne fg Ons Sethe pet cola Bo done Poe ea yl TSS" ted {challenge the ks and he urdersuning spe, He mene 4 Sli pe eu ut ea the Sey Palit comer werk o ge, he Toad ma per 2 ‘ork tat Bo dong character ar emg ae of cal Stade: ‘ion Self te me promt cholo eon Bo Sone ftpunens""The monks nthe wsemby. winesing the dpe of he eet, so atone oi chen do hae sled em" ae sid fo Dive aged mihas gaa nd wp the pt rate tea of the Spa aon even huh ews uta ere seen eof ae the tine No oly ws he af av propery dead ic ew ofS Pgs, bt the sry ger, he mel ticked Bo dang sn iw ‘edi ho accep he asd concn tat "wa ra sh thing 1S am nay (dg pe) tt i re fm 2 cause™™ In gee the Sette std 10 he eens eli the el flog, an a pe Innes pele, wth nthe pry nity ling bates oe Siew dogmatic. Many ofthe pinohcal pnons nfvocated ty Bo Ang ar sal ob ced ia mkhas abs lane wrk ope te De bs ity mun lad ater Bo dog sé have msl pad the young nk a ‘When he ah he pope 2 of wey He tk ll mona imation with Red mh ote abot Then, to eu ate a 1072 iss tht Red a a, realing the temendne Don forthe Wot Inge met he get Tron Hh sot he sen to Seo chs Sainte Tang tha pu na eng a te ine On te way. Ne ‘hag ian gt fa von fn rage sed Matec ‘ery enfant an Tone thn pu Sei manent ef May Arriving at Se cho sig. he aged whe whereas | Tot ha pe tom's monk. Ti simple et 30 pee as BO vhs este, cnc, ad eps for hi ov ne ha when ‘ere that he neste mt geo Tne ta er Rs po es ath ‘woh net fe maser een. “ ® ‘Sin Bega ofthe we oe nen = ecimngeantarageats antes a et sage entre ne ) tame (ming) nip rs) sl na ist wire of thi ow Carat Ite, te imputed aren to be carcterstly sates Becoe they ist ase br dependence on ter eases and condone and arbe eet from thc mares rom tht omm este pede ae Sid te'caualy nul, Because the Uate ad a tease Ick We mtr of the tro Rnd sl, at the mf of peo an ht of lewomens| the al isi Be ‘imately mais Tha hy the Sanainimocone Stas So then wht she cancer messes of pheraens? Ht the carters of the itd And hy ha? Ie hi ‘Beciose I as he character of being Cath! by nae nd sign an eras does ot xt by veo eu cater {Ha ny cal charactor neler en ps) 2 A of gts Wha the aa marl of prem te chat ‘oft dependency pheno And why tha? sie Ih tecme oy arhe unr te iallsece of ter contr a tot by hemes forth eng hat hs pene eon ale eed eawaly manele ™ Meo, wi the charter ofthe el? i 0 Be rt auclecnese. A! why ta Ob Franitsamadeta, the {lene af phenomena (chs ft Ala me sid 1 Be lesen Pat tet, ad ec the tate 5 "ted win hc apm, hat hy el nee eondary explain flit natures a0 eh fort dent mi abo id be tay mate Tha bc ami ‘pun ntith wh mead pnt the eyo Eon tha ety ele {Stteanes phen, pier be barns arp) (i calle ra Beene he dependent Ik the aie eg Sch ae, {5 be wlinaey mln” Aa he Sandhnrmocans ate ‘what oe inate eles of psoas Tow phenmens tha are sterdependeny ta ae eavly tattle aso he tse the nme ht hey eur nates And hy "ha? On Piramthasamudgt, ht bet aoe prema hit ‘pre i ce gh fo be imate Ti reuse the characterise She epee ssc at ape aes, ht 1s sy tat the pt oe a ext by vite of ts on characte ean ht tly exten (hen par med). Ware htt, ol tran athe charcersic ates of the pte} was tanta ‘Ser monetence and if that wee hen, eta the puted oad wa owsbly ett won flow, sary. tha whatever es ga) ‘onl hve be Sst extent (as oh Teer, tough the Sets ain nar, eat teens fst ween he ae, whch de a x ye ‘own raat, andthe pede, wich Soc eat by ie ‘oun curr eau en bah nol ne oe inal exe at Sd yo pe) 2d nt Way ese “Ty clam hat wether somthing est by vee of ts. characterise 's dete by wheter aus bm Bed a) so re (26) Been the fa a expe exiting by vite of sown hari {Et mui flo aby. ht oo wa tected fo) Fen in ft ma). [The Realty ofthe Dependent and the Real. andthe Yoda Critique of the Madhyamasa™” ow des oe cape a a he depen ad he el ti by vit | seo ha! he pi rt si yo a ei sn in mt apd ‘Spee ni are tenga eet aos the gtd, so $e te io wt poses the qi oho ea) fhe in a ya np) to be mate n rear [he depen so em (27) ‘aria the there. The Sahn Sar ye ea (Oh Paramartanaminpt, ew, techni of the depen {ena the hrc ferent hen so sal the ‘Soraceratc fhe pute be Eo eit Th Bese (Serpents the characteris othe eee nd he earacter Sree Gp ee c+ I sh he “The recent fh) ofthe eed wor sgn hes a hig tha eee etl in xe jad med po Mag sd tht teatime cui te crest ey oe de pa ae pons and way us atl nb dese ‘on fo he dactne Ths two ty sol be Uns to Be theater depenerson tis Soils. Ad aun. the Hoda sy: “hs. someone sold bear aching 8 10 he etn ming of (he nian whch are very iio vosod. ih each ne Mayan. wich exh the prod doce of eapine ving beard them i hyo ot cme deste mci sich was explain cacy a ti bt nea consi a “ A Dose gins incest manner ther du 0 the conto tn fom sh ami "hes undoing hey bebe) everyting o Be ot bel ape ipsam, sd ths ety. ho wo ead who wd uy a ach a vcnpit we the ced enpr? Wee tha 0, ‘Sethe would en nites io et te referent labels [al te ltes Deeles could pve and inno way ex Ht Da ‘Tres, Rowell he ey that il oe] 3 mer abel De nd {oust Tee. the [ais nthe ents we tems a i ‘ey ead ol o eile, apd one hold know ta to ‘sing, Yor [Cit fas sai" ing Hm nar fe the wo pot ew" And ao bch he featur as i When on he abet fealty year mesons (dense “That ing om sl ad ter te ert, By tose same reson so] ey ae or ee And thi, bow can your cance of arn te psi" which hs oppose explains a meaning at juste aie wh ete {iin aa te ow eee pits ea ing de ho na yeu). ite same way repute ene even tomy Hence, ey ly hal ‘hoe mo arn. forthe Anvapongordoperpecha Sir es ‘Whatever ies fm cons dos na, Inthe mo ang cen ere dpcdr oon contin i cphied 0 8 Irie undersaning of empineas at oe pe IS) Again, (his one who ovrentende Himself Ref in wha to be seg cam thang cur own pun] # wal oll aby {tte fc thang! cst may ext or wt ey mone Men, and tat nomial eitence imps a exence Ree [ ending tt) albough no psonmeran tly es Wat cont ‘Sceptta aryplenomenon woes 08 the coma. Hs cnet Scop them sb esting Ite (ginal ese accep [os ie We Sotho ch at he Ld shal ve stall gh he opto {te four elanes tron pa ok) wh, nthe nes om he Anna tara Sao, be ae ‘Do nt lyon the perenne dati ‘Do nto the wen rl he meaing ‘Dnt ely om te pons meaning. eyo te dtitve mening. ‘Bu ht ely om colosss, ely eon Sect pv eis eng cme nen ie immense ota # woul fellow bury that wold be texto ely om te define meaning Bt oF the pviseal mesg. Le ‘see exece ef someting nahn he purview of roo coscus fe nates “Iisa! pt mgr) sighs is exitence breathe enesee [of meting) witha the prview of sonra gous Ge Shes mit mr es ot pty Is onesie tha Hw fear ht wou be iting tt ely om on Bo a ‘Suc [The ims hyp fra in prea et nay whereas thes aim ta hey Jo rial exis one as tee ane os} eter ori! ens ines a Jes rt iy exten ‘hey reply that noma exten spin monn exec and dos Bly ulumate xen and f you a the shout ind af xe hat ‘lied by eter “nomal” oc "ake they ep that possible tether ens hd hind exe hat tn tid with he ‘rans tee sing he ston. 1 «6 A ove ines 42.51.22, Refting Ther 42.3.1.2.1.2.1. Demonstrating That They Have Rfid the Principal and Special Quality ofthe Prsagiha Madhyamikas 42.3.12.1.2.1.1, ldenifyng That Chief Quality" oe Msg ss Byte ef sac] maya lags ya hoo ay as The inate gal toward which every Manis sine is he wy o he harmolie (he a) he ysl ty u s).T in es, oe ts elo te spay of ons at ecamalt the vo mates Goon wile i hey doen oe fining erty 1 he on remus yin which th to he ae opt ste cred ‘tote witineexpnon ofthe se Me gs hb Mee, ies one hs ly found ety i eas te woking of dependent “Sane ren re, ey idl Case pve te a oly oy ‘endl ees th accutioe fos as fer wl mtb Someday ad tc heart round etn ht he mas (aril give rset te died fect wil mt hve an Ione ant ou cent as 1 eft halo pilenomenon who ‘er han een te sales som a bere etsens crm sal oe wl thgh one ny dee todo wo. Tischer no way tact te tre mas pois wtbout wnmsenlyscernning Copies. Thee ere ion cnx ind ery i aren (1) het tha ts Ope te cept the ayo al ena an fancy eh wh "atthe exsene ite ep even nora. ae 9 {ht one wil be slo ste te two mane ina Conte le ‘Sty th ae ep the anamton he olmes o at they wal mt heal lo be cere forthe wh prs ht oat fe ptr we cept casaiy whats being temporary expen fete sake of tbs” So ining hs era. we dep Beet m {ie weno ony, ba the recall te mundane ere ow CF erp yan dopa la a an the nikon suerte pees ‘ele the apanandane ore ew ew lt pt ane ag Pe Ia The md mune win hi ites hese sre fos “The muda the sven uh" So bec ts tow eect ‘ced cea at ay ane ah mane 0) nth ear, tes can rome in harmonion may ee est tht Digs ton a that they te ent They Ie at fom mt Rave the sight ov nate one Ro BO) ow eae herb ang et oer er ha agate ove nate So hy ae arch somes do oie ex hey couldnt sia png the mtn of evey since f casa (2) hat an let aes fore iow case t woul have txt fom the objets oh Se ning hat (Pcl be mtg eset tea wm charac an here. foc) a cules irony ol, Mene, becuse bt derision ef fox eth roenonl ad tel thot dig ay wid hse ft (heres the no may OF ein emancipate omen. Thre sno way find peace Outside ve Aya Nig’ path “hoe mb louie he ths he combina! ad ei, ‘ining aen ode tet us, emote ve though he Stata Miya do eve hat heise tajsence een niall they ent ec be at hi hg] ae gy of existing y te of ar ov charac x oral andthe fosliy of tie utoning Hee. ey ase tha oman hg] e 5 star at Wt a th ae ‘etic vehicles Be tha si my tose ho posses he atau, th ase sd ‘sine nb ae cpt the tem Prasad sony Wi eo Jeo (dmg pu) of he appebemien of exec) een ral ‘sway sctng forth the ft ha ee tthe spew nent ‘enc. I th xen tony doy lel one ety at fe tes) 8 not ara 1 the potion ht sft, bt ne a 1S by eof the tt ta gs Fanctin tha they ee een (ang "ond pan hy ea ome Sra hat by ita ec thtthey tk inet esence thats psn fo tees fo onto Ts hen ae a he eto or ny eptinets ncaret, we eal) fr the Pras hs {eaepennc of cause and fe] the chi oie ‘edo expla emptiness vate, Hence nto thy wo coer te two to omay bat meising ros soe a et "aah a a hy my te hts ey de ot the 6 mses ff mit san ta pee By he face fhe wind wpa cea an asl vel he an ‘ue and mrslng ate pr aes ur ow Teacher ae ha ‘seas the of any thr te ng Nes a hee al ake a isn, * | veo Enis sn be ng coins al pn ang i hrs Homage the incompaale Buon “Tato the mae ph tpi ‘And epee asng are soy” 1h his way anientand tat his method of harmonising engines ad de feaden ating the pnp ad special quay of the Praga Mths 423.12 12.12. How They Have Refted That [Special (Ouaty] by Their System fof Iterpretation} ‘wu hee manag ofl ths icp qty [the Pests af Toes As mento ear by vite [l he et ahs] So mt ihren itp nity ft the Pasa system tt You cla tha een time ne emp nbs extent Sl 50 rth do no fist Tere scoring fy te neces clam the even [oe ‘ep pase: ic this reson, depend ring “Ta as hohe exes he of wrong views ** for yo ai hat ca ugh the extensive net of wang ews one ms Fete pend arsiag Whe vig tht the soa des ntl x ing ‘Sassi ianss depended accring youl hee woud be one ‘try per ga pa for yu clam tis whatever ares dept ‘ety loot ey a that waco ty came ae depend, “The reais shi tempi pros oncom. Thy pe asa es on be Mada sac 5S Wea igs ae empty “They Coal ot te me ese ‘And wou fllon tt frou et acting ou, wl Be cor 4 spy ce wih te reais cate Toe Aya Mgr, tomer tendo asecig Wh il ens the oppose game andres te sme sy i: Meshing ws mt ny ro And wo flow tt 8 ‘hare would be no for mb rth ety ning he pene) ox attr prvi ah ies, thor thea Mayan ewer "aster a ph ‘Spor pun tee dns pee one ay oro {yal rie en ch) ach hr 2 Scttay gs me or ein hy sly whe me at {Si ttre oo ow of tar ae sm ch ing Reng inten th ate ye Naa Bsa Whee empties posible “Thee crying sible ™ He saying tht in hater philosophic system ees yess, all Penomena a pose and ohare pbs tem eines foc pn, mo pesamcnon x pons le flows acira oyor, bower thre opponte ew ald bem fos a hatte emies sub ewan posi Toy “vet pose” mcm th eveything evs (The ves] sang tf he Madras system whch ea ht (ie ae gy of erent exten, everyting, ithe far te dw Oe he Prsnnapadis commentary on the vet pet" emg (951 sess poe” sys Whee he that all hips rept finer ete i Prahran pile How [Stecase we cl dependee aring “entiness" Therefore, her tet Ris expires porte, ht pede ciptinn ps A! a tee epee onan @ pose. hee ogc festa te four eet frat ext How so Beate i cgedent rations hat igs et pi, ing spondence eso. Decn a (le Ie sevens is ken be empty ring en, he te Stine ot snerng. te cea Of tating, aa he pak ih Xeatt wth ecu of afeane ae pnb Hen the on Standing of fing tr sunenmen he eee eleaton o ‘Secnudng nt of lrng nen ff ‘Scome bie fect hn ne wh sete fs fe pnt, and tone wo aide mt ruse en, he who {Bie the thre the sore one I te me athe ‘it ten Rly Dar a eo ple. When the Bl A ose a pin ‘Dz nthe ly ah thn te Bust so posible ‘Ms av wel a all ml teins (fon poh ah ‘ecome pole Where eninge ‘em the Prana "Ny A tafe fom te lo four esc" And he at ay Enpy things. sachs etletion et ‘he Brown depen on he lection ot a Lewis wh al phen a ep "Thay om omy Teme ‘So when you ld postin fn onan 10 many sci ae, Sse te realy clan" ae Matyas who 3 ha he ane ‘te Malian 42.3.121.2.2, Demonstrating Those Reasons to Be Faulty" 4.2.3.1.2.1.22.1. Demonsiating That Their Examination of What i Means for Something 19" Withstand or Not Withstand Logical Analysis Is Faulty!" ‘steam 2 phen cet witha clans othe Kl ha sates te la on Smal Yd pt pa ded po) ee fan ha sept es a by the gel esi pa) ht a Ibn te tte Th feet whens pesomenon ol By dCi chaste imate Wat deen ot mam at ch 2 {ah cotinine ht permet Th fll De {se emmeno's nt feng rere y's ran rai oto ees a ‘Sy ta a option pres that pemomene oe nome Topmmeat dont mc he ater cl [Rep ft thn sd, ht und ant Be ec by a sa ae soe be moet ea va ad git es fersive (ul I yo accep hs flown abr that sued frat, teste freed to Be mesint ya val cogent You accept then follows. aby tha the et prepan (to {Ehenlmbe epee aseptic ha evonenn whtve to he appended 3 be usenet 05 a “Teeter avery es lence ees pl etning fa Ine sonshing td fede te snes ‘Wha does itm, te, eng nop aay tat ayes he lite, sd wha cs mean fd id wht Se aay ingT ‘Scpyse ‘ovr ie dst me thi par) ih camserig the ot phenome (ha) and poral (un ap coven he pad Sh ep the ith and no ny, ad Devaar, Yas, td oon ony te Ics smiles min th mya gs pa tam) a oe thew engage in sear fr ow tere esto wie se ane ae abled ext (oy analyzing) wheter he ete) the Same Itunes fo he arts Tcl ene ‘king aba he ence ray bahin sem a la hsp) ni I timate anlsi (on dam dpe po ahaa) eno ptr sh ‘amips someting shoul be ound with he pre ff ed t agen he posses concern the ete Lf ag he et a sheer a th sae ante occa fm prs, for ean "he ths analy! loi ml have gone aa alte mad hh ele that lpe mast econ a mistaken conceses poh te ob ‘estxied fom ts cw ale dam sens ra) a een oan hat (tay gal esis within he prvi of ta mid then ml aly ‘ai wheter stone cal ae nen "hen one egaps covet ening sh 5 the la hat exis logs as bingh devon of Big the same mo rent rom pro ‘cha te such forthe car ine oe tev pees foe as tthe abet dos mt et may of hese ves, al nt he sae ‘x fre [om pre oth hs wh we can ye Finding {eee sucha the pra a when ane tacos fo ty mew of ‘econ that sale the tame." des ten i ead Se is ee fue be momen by vail cognate naan the rat Not nding the po pl, when one sea or 9 eae "bd cognans that alee lite nts he pot dst inte Hw cal t psy be ndtv he ft ht he ot os ot {ener ex “When oe sores for [De pot in this mane, 0 find ht ie does aot ci in ero yl the pes) teat be "inn te ay (Gea ag) he pao "iting eens ane okin™ ting te ‘hima ou dam)" Oe shal io know tthe ft at the eto Jet aed bythe em or des ef ay fo these eet ape ‘hen is eth fr by meas ofthe oil retoing wih alae te irate ining that the pt dct ntti ents he ps ot ‘iting atimaely sido Be the iat don Sop) ae te Ae ence fhe po” and the aly te pu" ipa) 423.12.1.222. Demonstrating That Thelr Analysis into the ‘Four Posibilles, Existence, Nonesistence, and So Forth, Is Faulty: [The Law of Excluded Middle and the Question of Whether the Madhyamaka Has a Viewpoint)” is mneisent an by aoa hts nat onesie one als tha fest Then det cation thar you tve*™ Laie Opponent) These rae tn st onan, fr alto he Svan an aller cho test ya eh) ts sf he av of etlded mule aon pv)” the Praga tom ‘ety sot dst tes fe of excel mile. Hence he ‘eta [Rep] Then woud ft, sb, tt (no ns coal er be 1m det Cicin, tat hey cold csr aly ale ech tar (tamer spo pagar ga Yo (ordng ole uae to rsd! sci a benoit nepting om par Brad a Opponent) {Your ese 5 mot esis Rep Desst tenn your hn teal nero in ers of ela o exe mie, [een ou nah ngs he nn ‘soma rings an undef os onesie, ae hi ey premise Opn) Mery wl 1 ace aii premise that diet conta seo gr mateo pel Rep Ten des in mn] at th rst ees he ei by rsyingom trea conta nae th Tels, ard mJ sew int he i 0 ieee wha ver ete gt tensa wrong oes, ete hy be th et te Prisanghas reins. er shorwver Ta Beate [or ol he pt (x fred emt an ster be dpe) 9a pte a TOppomne The former of he ho eh fou, hat is, eet can he oven By ai opin [ep Then dss (hima a conection sponse "Opponent The late untae st eer can Be poe {neq Ten dest your cla at inert ory wha “Acnngtyou # wl fl shyt xseace and none tee ent conical gmc elo a thd eae bm (phn um pa) ts nh execs no oceitence. Aaa I lows, Gert your stem that ot sre oy an Peonenon ‘Bi cer pokey (nha pg) wor not fo [cereg 10 You] A nt ria sy fay phoren hat efit hr ext dos mest “he wept fr ch argument, what py can the be? If you ace tusscmmuece of our oun, ht no corect to eee myth {ating hen tons th iso cartes act at (1) "a hems are fe of mem person proba) eat (2) "hey are ‘Seay ofthe or [rents ach eet. nonexistent Tha penne lng oi herve ha eter existence nat sone then they mist woul el 8d aerate tat as ‘eter spa or spot, 0 oe that warner acing hr moni ie ny nor sonny. abd So ot iio, Bees of i Sweater po crt be Hd [sou nig). whee by eran ‘trina tt someting sonst be postive Send tobe somthing (Se Tn ence wat you are Bing cla al eres stim isang son he rom aa. etlowing tie of stoning sr he, S10 ape someting] setting eral ew theo ape someting Be a ex (digs poo append be a saan told ei be ‘ene of reat, (which su) A, wha i ght nd what ‘spe by the serps ng) woul ae oe te Sane or a ‘Sut esuece malo meta son exeme, as 8)" Pe {ou sha inprty ae an exe" ‘Who tne ass hing © determine wet i hasan eens it cer acetate of te ffl Sete ht "ert dso aes a ae oe Bu spe tha tid alert ‘eit, hc eer of oe: wee tl ere exami ihe (Shes ot ay [at yee ene enters hat do ‘nal he poste ops coneting the sje) en wal flow ‘Sry, tat wuld mt be the sighs Besos to conde! the ‘nocache po or» pil” ‘Toe tal low, srl, ht fre ald be hobs 08 ich the Pesce Madan sould fx hypteressch the et a al ‘nome ae atertained © be of the Wo WS the Eaton a umn categorie ut ele the potty af «td Is impose lacing pou Teale fll, absurdly, that he wid (ier ra) which undead tnatenes (hon nde ite ew. eae append som ‘tulsa iw facsoing Jou! Opponent We np hat ware aie view [ny Ten el me 900 Mya the ies of which has eer een os A ove of ngs seen tf, wh advocates he loi retition of theses a the fact (hat ayn enon pas pty tes) ssn le what Kn ot Sep i a reer ees? ‘The Arya Nigga has ley tog that elt sede in erm ‘he aw eco mies ht hen eters oe Timp accep he existence of excel the Vpruharoeron fe When one opis etenclesness (Oe wl be easing eaten (rang bhi wi, ‘oe Aocmmenary om this sng): ences worse te (8 ‘Sean ig, hc yw hea omen ‘sings weld ce 0 poses ences, Btu ty Held Poet Ses thy eu a be emp Hc, wien Siu os A ‘sas Nw oe sold pte the peter prton swam a ‘eres "Oneal thruply peeve even he Te Agee o Be Sy) f esc Aad he omc so ye “The though andesaning of pheno a eenset Inthe spree atin fhe perton of miss ‘has. by peng the emits 1" and “ie, “he yop Bom erste We sa eh te se] ha eve a ha ea ‘Scud mide fora ve tn he Matyuna tt he ne Sango the emp face exec an baie eae tov face wit en So Jou lb cls pen ‘on lf these pr that even enn at er em {Qveion} Then ow do you cpt hs sage ‘When hr i 0 ch hing 6 he nme ow coi ete exat = nd a hs psa rom te Rama Ths, the Get Visor oped [athe view of si nd at sess. wl a the Catbiatata passage ht ge: ‘When tee ting ht i ot em ow oul emp be si et {Rey You ae ing he ge al your ese oly he ‘onthe pe Toh at Soa ae on, ae oe = severstanding whatore of he lope ana fhe meaning ofthe Srp (tres tld bem spit one To exp [tbe mesg of hse pa Seni ois wy, ely. oc tht (hey we aang tt) beste thee tae esene there no epee exience, i uly Koil Wie sping"! Bors db ot east cae the ors of fab do at xt” eaplnton of he meng fee {Zar Tectore, when there emo the exnence (er grat mel hee fest ext ule (hn med Jo aed ewe Your evasion (ate ih of ts entence pe tbe nanenstence a he epee et: ‘ene the oponte wha tse ow the meng fl the scr) a lows To cura ht cmp, a hgs ae empty of a exten, be epee ‘reat te Cann] sayng ht empiess rtWly exsten {rcuete not theslptphetemenon ha ely exter, Tere, {meas ofthe en, whch te ervoingcategney ed ye. ha Tevrepton oft eunence In gers the evaed ctr yah tate tv eaence f emptiness). 1 refed, How ld {is ysgol be eacog that by mens fe eso, which te ‘epson of ta eitence, the oct be etd de Da, bles an nhch te very sega Of hat abet, does ment? The Cobia ys ae all “emis ha any so exe by vie foun aure (rant frag ber the tgs Won ao poses ‘Tine Ths reel has ben expand fore por eons (ep arn such este “nen thee sting tht i 8 Tow cold emp be ad x3 Inte abesse of meting How ci sop ext tromediely af thei “hw onl empties ex canes “The Concer: hve emptiness Fert heve twp th thine wi ei emptinss veri poe» Bdpi's Ve as hs 1 0: eis hse taconite eit by verte of hi un me Themen Tha ne ig Neate fem by ve ofthe fat a hey me epee on] Css and codons Toy ht hing ox ex he Prajna (0) Aus pts, ty vio ti gmt i denon ha te mae hea i pti When fel these ty a ‘ce ta cn, Rig yn eg rt momen me ae ahs Sep tlw pat tc ne {eotowing cnet ca yee eta sh ee ‘esi of neste” wiser omc Nae ‘ing oa." e epics “Pe meses ht a SE cc 1, his ample nero, fhe floing eae, ‘et somone Sonam he" myn as thr sm fat as Rocher ar etees ce Remar atewt tts tensa ineah ee Symes meaningless ways, interpret the meaning ofthe definitive serps tat stare Saree ela erage c= me Vag eas Ah me eg coin i aap Sena ety moe re mesma ‘et, and no ultimately neither existe or nonexistent, et the dene at na tas eens syle oma ieee ot Sa eo 8 petal Naan ose and third aerate which is mither does st truly exist" This cases oe Sinn Se ate en Sone noe ae ane brie yee eae eee Se gril Sp eect amaesy coe mars astray indeed." awe oo (Oproeat} Wall ten, what serach beeen tee? [Repl n ener an “exremeor“ege"] ean’ he wold ss any touncary that. een overstepped. cies one ofl ad but ose ‘oe border el sachs peice. me apply the em exteme ewe a the che we apy the term even to aytng Hit when apprehend {uso 0 flit te pit of ae ews and 0 degenerate Ente: ar of two Kd the sateme fenene and the eee of nesitnce The former (a lows Fer example om Bois ake he ‘Si be permanent they aprebendpradhana en ar (Gal be pe tent entsies edna)! The Vaid bel at pac permet | ‘Stun ne sa? i ako ew tat males he flo te eee tela Nonteles, elt [ie he Vass] eter ely sae {ht he sew that gs ney ext 6 tacaou othe ves) at ‘hg ate pont anda ers he way in wc he ins pend iho ereian te att imoles no appeenson of thing 0 be [re Howoer, they have ater othe extee of rain Das Toc inrty ens ther mst Be permanent Opponent Wy must? [Rept fotlon, sry tat te exec of be ots exten ‘term ft on nate iy rn Fin cl gra) case nee IG ee pee at ese of ep roan os exec dn ince [Repl] Then follows, abst, hat posible few ve ‘xg, bovis of hat you hve acpi. Tis llons Beas impo tray prmncnnt0 spent own ae” you acetate oss freer eet then ws bar at at lt ‘et and you acne ha hc tolls bury that permet Sat ty the Point ye cca whatever nee eins teaver amen, pees As fo te later, he etme of itn (med pata), a tows) Acca [ene a Dahat teei memanipaon or Ssmcicce Peso cu sh at eo aig a hg? vem cue In urn system, ht ming Bada cho. gree yagi tht th terete ste bar rl des mot ex > ‘thc view Nor tht The ew exes y the rea hat he ea als mic ew (had ta)” Tee bec spt here ‘xis, eens mathe he pot realy sas) and when et Sf the seco! str, bec eau anising see Mit ie she's nate aon] tenes epaned eter, Mf mehny Sonthing permanent That ey he Paina aye Te my ht wht evil aie os psy exit Reducer one oe say aim 1 ‘These ae all examples of he ways i ne my fl the exes | ‘One der aot come © have an trai view simply by appcheding Iromeing to exit. Likewise, awe does at cone fo hie nie Simpl by aebeding (someting be ence I apt potest at ats hr dst ti hat pce perme ed hat hing desoyed te seid men re ae Eling mathe tenes af eerie an im, then he exten sh cose wold fellow hat spending hat he Boss has alt and hat the ey Madama view dos ot fal foto the ences of sna sn niin te Iba atic ews Berane they bth adecte The Meee Sg) "Te Prasmneade, commenting hein: (Can aver te nonetisen srmanet Wien soething interey exss it een cant oer (dog pal sea asta exh, ws tat oe the ‘xucne of ene nth ya ea ve set fe came daring th ie that ened previo, ml thew cot mow a a in Pe hn te Now bcs the Pama explain thatthe sls, “Bec whicit Inher erst tobe spd he cn of pues hat nln one Such s “To aprcen “esenc’ Yo apprehend erate gate ‘leat hat pases sich “To append) "ase 0 aed ee {tment item exec and to the appteson ta ey aber ‘see an Big sted ha nem a en. ‘ter naiy boca the exten of tips woe ogee ees (1 teed eedions The Pramas os ols he vew ha ings exit “Ten at igs hei in is ay ‘Won have fo Be zeny Jou deve of cases and conan, ”* ‘The adi ference 4 mute of tg. Thr, ty essen o th {ier thng a empy of eens the pom of hewn iy euublahed Thre ae many iano Ie which the Aci (Gai es ety ae a he loa cen ces tt re ame go as med pa) te Prasad be sy: (Oppose I we oss, as you do, that tings have v0 5 sencen fen ths metodo yous ld do sy wt al ate {Es Bhar ph, coring, oe eam i eching ‘in "one matt ef eperience the mpeg of fe arma ich fm ha netfee” Becase Jou ul be ailing kan {Si ie ef, you woul be the met fas med pp) Rep} One sould ety as follows]. We arent minis We eft te postin tha [thing] can be cote no exten toners nl ing done So, we eat he Way tthe i) rscipatin the path of ved. We dont, Monve, sivrle ‘tat te fh karma, proce of arma) res of arn. ‘Why ato? We advocate that ose (ees em ese Orpen} 1 wender wheter ths leds 14 al for when Ita} ve noes: they ant psily futon. ‘epi Even ths ail dees tw oct ws only when ing a snes lato is note take place, ad 6 by en hinge eeneln fa ston ee ec. ™ Toe Cmhinlaya oy: “Theses at advocated 1 be ure agar po med) Rea acted ang pent Opposes Are you then svocting at el ng)" [np No, tease ofthe fc hat me vost ta ares epee, prone) What hen do you vrata? [Rep We advocate we epee. An api, wha i teeing of depend rising? Hees to eens fey tft ht tier] do nt ae inbred er he fing fait whe cara hat eben ani ‘Son; mage a eflton, a airy oy. an eran ce ream, I ‘esto empties an allen ‘in, he Cabs snes {Opponent Does mency that has as oj soneting ast 08 » A Duar Emp Rep} Who ay at dsm xt? We do nt pedi eventing, Tn how arf cu A ow. Tere, what we cal memory mike Ug ps) Sew ars oly wh pes ae og ‘Tis he Acey tHe pote?” Tce, the mete is pas memory spt et ead woke fw om ma cane he mena of hat eject nui hie be pecs a et ‘het the menor) to mol exh y iso Orn name When fn euy ene, wees the mer Tt pres o ‘nce snd forthe ll a es ee ay a ‘tomate dere yne tt eres haf es Senn ne ooh] ma a eee 1s ot hate st nity i wey nner ei sorting te semen an Ec at pce: mr dose ys foe ‘Shue risen lw, sy at sperma sd at el te Step spcknel nor di po) tw ngs vey deed way bernen ter sneence ad cae i of Sols ag, th Cahn os The view of he alist ifs. To the ete tha someting ter oun mae, Hease toe cies mold Ye ty noms tent hey wold resemble he hr of it Hence tease ty have mw toed ani ws ica fre wea of hi ay eb ta hea sy by bering tha an etity ‘smo ex yor o own ete, imo Hf enya ‘la Being egret ht tng ee enya yh ‘inna any atthe Mi fy, nt. ‘he the hpher en The rests and pee Mahe rb ‘Sch er i ha ner of em can eno pendent ating td et tess. Thee ess onl oe lee tee ha the are {pain tote mals’ em thie Madhya teen ei th as Cas wt “Acne ea on std pa yin po) dt ha ing sone med, we ae Seats et, hs reba eas ht» Matyas {Greco ps end foe rr are Spey, heya (fe docs ntact at thy ae toexient Nii sys db mo ‘Sc in cng cag ert i oe Ponto fares fm soe soning tt ot wind, Site wba Hexce fdas aed els) 6 nt semble ch (er Te Pramas er, a opines iy iis w a lows: teem ieee tere + Madama sd «hs a be fomer ares at rome sed novos rma, dot i fee anal ‘or ee of cce. i soy ht et ot ex Tic, cam the oppo, thee tn ence beers Matar want. Bots tS, Midhyamlas noc ‘eendent ising They cam ht bec hing se dense ‘Serine both the rd and he ene yond ne ence, Ne ‘shave read the ure (dgor po me pa of ie ner ‘yond om the satge pt of he fat ta are deen

    You might also like