2009 (1)

 (31)      _ 

    
 
Tishreen University Journal for Research and Scientific Studies - Engineering Sciences Series Vol. (31) No. (1) 2009

 

   
  


*
 ! " 

(2009/3/3 !*  +) ( .2008 / 12 / 1  $ %
)

,- 

"  #$ %&  '  : 

  
  
      
      
) 3(  4 54 6    4 -  0 + 2,- ./0 $1 *$ ( ) * +'
#
 94  :4     ;$  ' 8 +
  .    ) /0 4 87   
@ 
 $ @ 1   9
  < /0 *;4  =+  (1 * >- ? 8 )
  
/ 
. )$    B C
 +' D  *; ' @  / E ) F) 
A  + 25 * >-
#  # 7 $ 4  * 8* >- H 9/ % ( ./0 3   :4 +' 
  54 @ *67 
/ * $ I % 4   8 )/ >- )6    
   4 B&
.HE 

.  
   :

"

*
. 05  
 4
" "
"   "     2 /
 0
1

37
 4    / 4 )$ I 
   7  

2009 (1)  (31)      _ 

    
 
Tishreen University Journal for Research and Scientific Studies - Engineering Sciences Series Vol. (31) No. (1) 2009

Criteria for Selection of Vessel's Type and Its Annual

Transport Capacity

Dr. Rami Hawa*

(Received 1 / 12 / 2008. Accepted 3 / 3 / 2009)

ABSTRACT

What is the most appropriate type of Vessels to be purchased? This question is likely
to face any vessel owner, due to he enormous variety of Vessels. It is an extremely
significant question to be dealt with prior to vessel-purchase. Thus, when a maritime
Company or an individual decides to own a maritime unit that accomplishes a certain
mission or provides a service, it will be inevitable to conduct what can be termed as
(executive study), which is a techno-economic study, dealing with the vessel's structural
and technical reliability, its costs, and the net-profit of the whole operation, calculated in
the light of the expected profits and estimated operation costs. The final objective of the
afore-mentioned studies is, then, to reach a decision with regard to taking or leaving these
investment opportunities.
In this research focus will be on operation schemes along with the factors that control
the decision of selecting the most profitable vessel-type to be owned or run. Besides, the
vessel's transporting capability during specific time duration has been measured and the
results have been accordingly compared.

Key Words: Creiteria; ship; M/V Souria

*
Associate Professor at Marine Engineering Department, Mechanical & Electrical Engineering
Faculty, Tishreen University, Latakia, Syria.

38
 Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2009 (1)  (31) /(  ) /
 -  ( /(

: 6
F#- # #  ( 
# @7 + 2  1 5 4  9  'B 8*3  8
/  
.@ I1 ,   5 (   >(
'#0 #/  8 4 @ 7 =4 * 0 ; <4  =+  & 4   '
.#/0 @ 0 ; @'3 @I 
 (  80 ; +) /; 5     I-&  (
.M.......... 6  1 53)(& %/; 0 ; )
5 #( 3#  # & % ;  .N4 =+ =4 * 0 ;   3 (4 ' 
 +
*E #   <  8   )/$ );7 
/ * *E  *  0 =4 * O + 2 
.  E  6 : 4  P *
/ 8 & 5 ./0  * .   @ ( 4 *4  5 4  - 3 =4 * A 
.  5 ( ./0 5E
  +  0 / <   @3 =4 * * @ 
* >#-  /0 @ 7 +'   8 4 @ 7 I-&     =4 * 0 ; I
(M#.....@#7 93 I #$ 
)  4 54 6 8    4 -  0 8

#    #;$  ' 8+
 / $  3 (Q .    %( +E 4 8/I   7 3 (1
#$ @ 1   9
   (1 )/ >- ? 8 )
   4 54/  
 $  :4
.5 * >- @ 

# =4 *  /0 *4 *(  R$&  &  = =+ ; ' 
  
:: 4    ;$ R( 5 3 ;;7 @   .&   @/4
.%   E  * ./0 )$ 5 3
8$/ )6) D
7
8[1] ) ./0 5( 5 I4 )  *  ;  4
8 /   I4  5 3
#4 :# 4 # #)0   ./0 )E  
  ;  0 ;;7 @ - ( N
)   8
/7  (4&   ; @+ 
  5 B T = ( 9 9US  0
.; D4&  ;7 @ -  V B ) ;
=#N R# .#/0    ' @   A) @ 0  @ 0- R(  A 
        + 3/ + 2 ( = B $ . *;  ) E ) F) *B  8 I
.  ;$  
 @ 
8#  $ 8 #) ' ( F#/7 @     )T @ 0-/   ;$ R( F  
= B# # + 7 ?  @   @ /  F  $  ?  8  ;$    8  
. ) 4  %U  F'&  ,6 =+ %E ;
#  7 $ 0  * 8
 * >- 9/ % ( ./0 3    :4 +' 
. )/ >- )6    
   4 B&

39
 4    / 4 )$ I 
   7  

:871  9 71
:/  :4 +' F' ;4
.
   7 5 %  & W&  4 .1
.*&  7 $ <(  * - @ ;  4 .2
.= ;$   
 @  D  BT  .3
# #)/ 
  I  E  (4 '  / 4 5 . 
 * -  0 .4
.4- ( ) /0 . 

::   6

  
  
 21
# 8#  * -   * - 8
 6  46 @ - <(  * -   0  '
:6
 B  1 * - D
.N  46 II7 ./0 *I& 
  3  /0 X1
.*IY *B& (4  4 X2
.
 *641 *B& @ $ X3
.
 @4 ./B / - X4
: +"
 
8*I& 
 *B&  ( X1
 0(      9  
       85 ( 
 II7  0 X2
%#/I   F  :7Z * I * +' " 
   $ %&  '  *B A ) /E&
T @4 *    I  & 7   
   
A & + " *  =4 * ./0
.[2]     3' (     E0
5B *  /(  '  + 2 )/(& @(  * @ 7  I 
/ *B&  7 I
:*B   7 

  21
+#' * 7   S  
  8 4/   (  E 3
 @
; *- '
( *   7  4 
   ./0 D
=+ ' E W  4-   .*0  *- @4
# #4  *  R;   
 . *;/   B    S 
/   B   @
;  
.[ 
 4- *67  4/ *E  ( 4  0 .  1    (4 *B @4

40
 Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2009 (1)  (31) /(  ) /
 -  ( /(

+6
/  22
4#- \# # 0    
   / 0 :& * I 
  B X1
.[ 

0 # # #0  0 @; 
   R  ' : (E 9  
  B X2
.[ 
 4- \  /  
8*7# \# 0  / ;
 @
] / 
 %4 ; / ' : Liner  I7 (@4) @ 4- X3
./4 4 0  
9# # 
   7 W  0 F/7 & * I  (E  
   7 W  
 #4  
/   B   @
;/   ' .I S 6
 B .&  4 
 8[5] =  
  (E
%  *  )  B (T/ 
  / *B R7 *0  0   +7T   B  4  <
.(  5 0)

  
  22
"  :07 (4  7 ' )E- 0 
   <(  /E& ' 4 
0 I @+ 
 7 0 ) *- @ 
 * / . *;   < ( (1X*-) 5,$ 
#4 @+ 
#  @ 
  8*   
 (4 9/ @ 
 +' (4 
A  + 25   / 4
0 I 40000 4 @+ 
  @ 
   =4 * 1000   4 0 I 15000
.[3] ) 
 @/$ / 
 4 @3 / )
   4

   

   
  
  
1000 ( ' 6000 ( ' 22000 ( '
120

100
(( '/)*  )),

80

60

40

20

0
15000 40000 65000 120000
( /  "#$)  



$ *
   <=  >4
?  " +; (1) +"

41
 4    / 4 )$ I 
   7  

& #N \#  D4& 9 0T I 

 (4 . N '         ' 
^ 
WI#> @+ 
# # B \    0    I Draft  >; WI > @+ 

.5 

-. 0#$  

 2 3 
  '#5


140000

120000
  
#$ "*  


100000

80000

60000

40000

20000

0
19 22 27 43 55 73
% 2 3 
  '#5


  A 0  

 @* <=  +  +; (2)+"

\ . 
 *7 9   *)   WI U D0 *I  
/  E  &  +
WI #> #I 16000 #4 @+ 
#  #( (3X *#-)  (2X*-)  @ 0 
)I U )0 )I 3 
 4 @3 / 8  \ N      7 . 9 
. )(4  0 %  )     \ 0 Q   

8 #9 
 2 3 
  '#5


7m-9m 9m-11m 12m-13.5

13.6m-15m 15m-17m 15.3m-16.7m
80
70
% 3 '$  #5)


60
50
40
30
20
10
0
 
 8 :

  CD 0  

 @* <=  +  +;B (3)+"

42
 Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2009 (1)  (31) /(  ) /
 -  ( /(

:8 E  71 23
# /  ? . F) " 7  "  7   (  /0 ' )/ >- 
 ,-  /0 
 + 20# *- )/ /4 9   ' 3 '  8+'  + 
 * >- 5 *I ./0
.4- ( 4  *  *7 R 0 @ / % U *N  ' B  
   U

# *- : 4  4 46 - *0 5 *I *67 
 C7 * /4 9  I
. $      5 0 + 8(T  (   ) /   `+ 
./0 84- @ /0 CE ;7 0 @; ./0 
   *;4 @  +' HE  W  ./0
?#     CE ;7  4 )   B 5I7  8@ / +)  /     R7 @ /
. B 5 , B  9  ;4  ./0 *;4 

 +6 
 F
 24
.# #  5#   ' = *  /0 , B  
 ./0 (* $ I) )  4 (4 
*# 7    C7 '  A  '; . ) ;  0  .  1  8[8] @4 % 4;
.=4
:$6  
/ * $ I %4O

Te ( 1)
Dt = (Q1 + Q2 )
t s + t stop
:: 4
8[ ] 
  B 5 : Te
8[ ] (%  % '+) 54 /4  
  4 3 : ts
8[ ] (%  % '+) 54 /4  
 F$ 3 : tstop
8[I] % '+ /4  
 4 : Q1
8[I] % 1 /4  
 4 : Q2

:$6  Te  B 5 % 4  

Te = Ty Tstop ( 2)

:: 4
.(* @ /0 ) /
  B  
 (   : Te
.(*I&  F$ 7)    
   : Ty
. B  W  =4 * *I  
 (   : Tstop

43
 4    / 4 )$ I 
   7  

:$6  %4 O  /  /4 3 

tv = tx + tld ( 3)

:: 4
.( ) % 1 . % '+  /  /4 3 : tv
.( ) [ 
 * 4 *(  F$ 3 : tld
:$6  %4 

Q Q Q Q
t ld = 1 + 1 + 2 + 2 ( 4)
R1 R2 R1 R2

:: 4

( / I) [ 
 * 4 *A :R1 R2
.% '+  
 * 4  : Cp1
.% 1  
 * 4  : Cp 2
Q1 = Dwt Cp1 :% '+  4
Q2 = DWT Cp 2 :% 1  4
= I  W  (  4) 
/   4 : DWT
.( ) % 1 % '+   41 3 : tv
:$6  %4

2 L
tv = ( 5)
24 K v
:: 4
. T   /4 I7 * &    : L
.(50)   0 :
( 0.95 0.85) 0 9 4 *  : Kv

M/V SOURIA //  </ !

 E 25
 T#  # #  #/4  I7 ./0 / / 
/   (4) * 5$  (  %/I
(2) *(  [7]@ I/  
/7 @  

44
Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2009 (1)  (31) /(  ) /
 -  ( /(

:[4] (1) +  !* ? ()   

G 21

  4
G  ( 1 ) + 

  
 
9274331 IMO No.   $
2004/6/30 ,  M  
 0 E  4- 
 
 138,07 LOA / *I
 21 B D
*- 9
 11
MOULDED DEPTH
*( I 9611 E  *4
*( I 4260  ; *4
 ;4 7200/ @ /  5400 W E 4

    (5)+"

  HG (6)+"

45
 4    / 4 )$ I 
   7  


1 </ F
  !
  ( 2 ) + 

 4
Tstop V D L
 Ty  /I R2  /I R1 Kv Cp2 Cp1
F$  50 I * 

12.5 1200
360 2000 2000 45 0.90 .4 %95 %95 12000 .4 1
16 2500

:
 I4

@#4  /# 5# ;7  
 0 5 3  I   3 
/  / 4 5 
#4  
 0   / 4 5 $60 (6X*-) *B  85 (     $ )/(  +' E 3/
+#' *#B :# 4 8( #   '+)  I7 @   F67  8= I 12000 +'  B  '  B
. * -  I   \  4 @   II7

1200 <  1700 <  2000 <  2500 < 

240000

230000

220000
( ) $-*)

210000

200000

190000

180000

170000

160000
12.5 13 13.5 14 14.5 15 15.5 16
("/"'; 
  );*) ( '


;  !*  / >  H 6 5/ +; (6)+"

*#- 3 
/  / 4 $ I Q 8(I 12000) 4  B  $ 0 < (7X*-)  N46
# $ # #0  >; * 4 $ I   >; 0  $   80 5 3  I
."    N0 * 4 $ I   N0

46
 Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2009 (1)  (31) /(  ) /
 -  ( /(

=#  @ 4 0( P 4 IE  $ (3 @ N 7 . 0  +'
. )    3    
 0 5 3 . '
#I4 /  4 0( 8  A4 
 B )
; ) /0  +' I Q     
 
# 4  ' 7 $/ (3/ N .  1  8PLC  I 4 @ 0( ./0  5
2 #)   0  (  $   0 @ 0   
 @/( @
; +' * IFO 380 cst +'
.(0   =4 * ) 50 16 . )0 *; =

1200 <  1700 <  2000 <  2500 < 

230000

220000

210000
( ) $-*)

200000

190000

180000

170000

160000
0.75 0.8 0.85 0.9 0.95
, - ,  ;'
 B*C (2


;  > / E6 +
 >  H 6 5/ +; (7)+"

.#/0 *;4  < (9X*- 8X*-)  R Q =4 *  0  ' ./0  T
<#
 *-  8
 0 5 3 9 I 0  
/7 @4  
/ )
    / 4 5
#I 216800 '$    / 4 5$ ./0 *;4   I    '+ =4 *  1200   < (
.   
/7 @ 0 
/7 @4
f #& *( +' /  @4    0 @ 0 4  *&  < ( 
// I  % 4
.*I& I$ 0 5 3  )   (  3 
 = 5  @    ( + 2
/  / 4 5 (4  )    = @   
5#;7 # E  @  ' 
S  +'    U * (T @$  + ; 7 (4   /
. B 0 0  41   5 3   / 4 5 D
7 ? (3) *(  $&  9E 

47
4      / 4 )$ I 
   7

 
$ *
 >  H 6  ( 3 ) +
 / 4 5   ) * (=4 (50) 0
261723 500
237952 1000
218140 1500
50 16
201374 2000
187001 2500
174543 3000

)L F-#$  
 /  / -K $C $"0*#E
'- 
12500

12000
 #$
  N' #) / /

11500

11000

10500

10000

9500

9000
12.5 13 13.5 14 14.5 15 15.5 16
"'; 
  );*) ' ( -("/

"K  12000 A

   
/ > 
;  H  J !   A +; (8)+

48
 Tishreen University Journal. Eng. Sciences Series 2009 (1)  (31) /(  ) /
 -  ( /(

#E* $"0 F-#$  

 /  / -K $C )L
'- 
27000
/ / )# ' N  
 #$ 25000

23000

21000

19000

17000

15000

13000

11000

9000
12.5 13 13.5 14 14.5 15 15.5 16
("/ ( '- "'; 
  );*)

K  24000 A
   
/ > 
;  H  J !   A +; (9) +"

:
G

A

:   @ (  C67 O :4 +'  5+

  / /4  
\#  0  . *7  ) ? =+ WI >  (4 @+ 
     *

. 1 $
/ < ( : 4 85   / 4 0 I @+ 
 7 0   *- @ 
 * /  S
.WI > 90  0   +7&   ) 
 @/$ / 
 4 @3
.#/0 #  (  W  +' 4- 
/ D
7 . = (4 5  
 E  4- 
./)
' =  @ 4 0( P 4 IE  $ (3 @ N 7 . 50
. )    3    
 0 5 3 .
+#' # #) /0 /;4  HE  *   +'   ( 1 ' BZ ) =4 *  0
.
:*B 5 (   ;$ @  / :4 +'  ' 7  
     / ( 
#(3/ N# ( .  1  (  \  %75  B . *7 )  ) WI > (4
. )(4 .  5 ( * 4 @    (50 16) ( 5 ( A S 0 )   +' $

49
 4    / 4 )$ I 
   7  

:>

[1] VOLKER; BERTMAN; HERBERT; Schneekluth, Ship Design for Efficiency

and Economy, Butterworth Heineman, , London, 1998, 220.

[2] STOPFORD,M. Maritime Economy, Routledge, London, 2003,780.

[3] BENFORD,H. Principles of Engineering Economy in Ship Design, Transaction of

SNAME, USA, 1963, 194.

[4] EQUASIS, Ship inspection,2008,14 October 2008.

<www.equasis.org/EquasisWeb/restricted/ShipInfo?fs=DetailsPSC&P_IMO=9274331>

[5] BENFORD,H. The Practical Application Of Economics of merchant ship design.

Marine Technology, Society of Naval Architects and Marine Engineers, January
1967.

[6] EDWARD, V . Principles of Naval Architecture , USA, 1988,760.

.2008 8 $+6 8=4 */      8

 * >- 5 8    [7]

 ( 8 E )      )  /   4 ) $ %6I `7   - 84 . [8]
.2008X2007    8 -

50