- versus Civil Case No. 2468 THE CITY COUNCIL OF QUEZON CITY, Defendant. x --------------------------- x COMPLAINT PLAINTIFF, by counsel, respectfully states that:
1. Plaintiff is a Filipino citizen of legal age and resident of Quezon City;
defendant is the City Council of Quezon City, the duly-constituted legislative body for Quezon City, its members may be served with notices at Quezon City Hall.
2. On 1 August 1999, defendant City Council passed Ordinance No.
2345 making it unlawful to operate cellular phone units while inside a moving vehicle and penalizing any violations with a fine of P1,000.00 for each offense in addition to impounding of the cellular phone unit. The relevant portions of the Ordinance are, as follows:
(Quote the relevant portions)
3. The above-quoted portion is ambiguous because it leaves unfettered
discretion to the authorities to stop even urgent and important calls which may be made only while the person is in transit. It fails to consider that, due to the worsening traffic conditions in Metro Manila, majority of business is conducted in transit and over cellular phones. Plaintiff is a lawyer who frequently has to dictate important pleadings over the phone while in transit due to the worsening traffic condition. The Ordinance appears to bar his doing so but plaintiff is unaware of the limits of permissible action under the Ordinance.
4. Unless declaratory relief is granted, plaintiff will suffer grave and
irreparable injury because he is unsure of the instances when he may lawfully use his cellular phone while in a moving vehicle and when such use may lead to confiscation and a fine.
WHEREFORE, plaintiff respectfully prays that this Honorable Court
grant declaratory relief and declare plaintiffs rights and duties under the Ordinance.
The First National Bank of Elkhart, Indiana, of The Estate of Albert Simeri v. R & L Wood Products, Inc., and Peoples Bank of Paint Lick, Kentucky, 917 F.2d 24, 1st Cir. (1990)
MANOTOK BROTHERS, INC., Petitioner, vs. THE HONORABLE COURT OF APPEALS, THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF THE REGIONAL TRIAL COURT OF MANILA (Branch VI), and SALVADOR SALIGUMBA, Respondents.
Hermetic Refrigeration Company, Inc. v. Central Valley National Bank Inc., Robert L. Walker and First Western Bank and Trust Company, Inc., 493 F.2d 476, 1st Cir. (1974)