A P. T E Y X .

1 1 9 - 2 0 1 7
. : KTIPION XOH ENIKH AMYNH EION APE 113 62 AHNAI

70

 LAVINIA CORP. LASKARIDIS SHIPPING CO. LTD.

On time... ...cool and dry

A globally integrated shipping company

Transportation (reefer, wet, dry)

Shipyards
Ship agency
Logistics
Terminals
Fuel Supplies at High Seas
Fishing

Head Office
Laskaridis Shipping Co.Ltd.
5, Xenias street & Ch. Trikoupi
Athens, 14562
Greece
Tel: +30.210.6284200
Fax: +30.210.8089710/11/12
Email: athens @ laskaridis.gr


MHNIAIA ENHMEPTIKH EKOH YNEMOY EITEN ENIKH AMYNH ETO 24 AP. TEYX. 119 - 2017
>> K

- ,
, -
, , . ,
, -
. , ,
. , -
- , -
, - .
, , , , -
. -
, .

, -

, , , -
, -
,
. - . -
, , - .
.
, , -
, , - : .
, - . -
. , -
, ( ).

25

1821, - 1821,
, - , -
, -
, . , ,
- , , -
, . ,
- ,
, . -
, - . -
, . - -
, (1714-1779), :
, - .
, .

, , ,
, . -
,
. , - ,
, , - ,
, .
,
www.seetha.org.com PDF

- 2017
4
>>
, - , , .
, ,
70 .
. , - ,
, ..
, - : , ,
(. 107), ;, - ,
, . -
, - . , .. ,
. , : H -
15 2016 - , . , ..
, . , : ; . -
.. . , , , -
, - .
6 - , -
2017, 70 , ,
. , 13
, 70 . ,
. () , -
, , , - ,
, , - . , ()
. , , -
- . .
, - .. ..
, , : . , -
. -
, - . , :
. , ,
, , , , - -
. - , , .
, .
, 120, -
, - 2017. ,
. , ,
, , ,
, . , , -
, . , .. : .

1. , 7. : ,
, , . 11,
, - . - 2000, . 35-42.
1.000 3.000 3. - 8. -
( Arial 12 / - - :
2.500 ). . - . -: : ,
2. . , . -
, - 4. -, , , , -
.. .., - - , , . ..: John Keegan, ,
, , , , , .
- . - - , 1997. : John 9.
, , Keegan, , . 3-12. (CD ),
, , , - . . -: : - -
, 5. , -
. - - , , , - ( - - - ).
- ( , , ..: , * e-mail: seethaee@gmail.com (
, ). Ostpolitik , ).

- 2017
6
PAEIA:
KTIPION XOH
ENIKH AMYNH
EION APE

113 62 AHNAI
TH./FAX: 210-88.11.853
:
E-mail: seethaee@gmail.com
http://www.seetha.org.com
... ...... 3 .
IIOKTHTH:
.E.E.A. ...
;............................... 24
. , ..
:
, , -
..

..
, -
...

E: ............................................ 4
.
,
.. : 70

: 70

..
................................................ 8 , , -
,
.. ...
M . ,
E:

-

..
- ............. 27
.. . : 1. ..
, . .............. 27
.. -
-
-
...
.. ,
-
....
.................. 11 ,
....
: . , -
..
29
Black Sea

.E.E.A. . ............
Constantinople

EAEI , -
E: , , , -
Y 25 - 106 75 A , ,
./Fax.: 210-72.18.223 , 51 , -
E-mail: iliea@otenet.gr

.-
,..
..
- -
- -

....
: o

T
..... 15 13 2017
. H

,
. , , -
70 .. 30


31
.


- .......................................
. , . , ..
:
,
32
31 . 1947:
,
,
, . ...................
, - . - -

630 .
- 2017
 7
-
.
......................................... 33
, , ................ 56
, . . ,

: ........................ 59
- . , .., -

....
................................ 62
: - . . , -
................................ 36

. , () ..
7 1945, .................... 63
, HMS ,
EXMORE. -
: H -
... ..................................................................... 64
& . , ..,

15 2016 : ;............................................... 65
( )............................... 40 . . , ..,
. , .... 71
. ,
-
) 16/4/2017 - &

) - :
-
....
........ 75
, -
................................................... 45
. , (), I -


12 .. - -
, ....
, 1964 -


12 ......

,
............................................................. 80
................................... 51 . , .. /

. , ()

.
.
, , -
..... 81
. ,
, ..,
.... .......................................................... 82
- 2017
 70

70

..
.
A

,
- , , -
, . - -
, .
, -
, .
, -

, ,
-
II. -
-
(-
. - 1947) ,
, , .
, - , -
,
. 14 , -
: 1.

I. ,

,


, : , -
, - , , , , , -
, , , , , , ,
- -
. : . 2.
. -
. , , ,
, - , -
- -
, - -
.
, , -
. 1 14
. ,

. , , -
. :
, 1. , -
.
8 - 2017
 . - --
, , . -
, prima faciae,
- - ,
4 . 2 -
(), - -
. ,
1 14 ,
, , 2 . 4
. . .. ,
2. , , - 11 2001,
-
1 14 ,
, -
, - , ,
. . -
, - , 21
2005-
- :
, -
51, -
(.. -
).
- -
- .
) -
, , a fortiori
, ,

- , -
-

. 51
-
. - -
,
, -
. ,
14 . 2 1974
- ,
, - -

: ,
1. , - ,
14 . 2 - -
, , ,
, , .
(anticipatory self- ,
defence), 1974 - , casus belli
.

. 2.
) , ,
51 , - 1947. :
jus cogens- ) 34, 35 36 -
- 2017 9
 70

- . , ,
(1969) , , : ,
1) - , ,
- - 79
. , , - .
res inter alios acta. 2) -
2) - -
, ,
.
-
, ,
, , -
. -
- , .. 1975 -
A

. .
3) Aide Memoire
, - 3 1975 -
-
, -
, -
- ,
, -
. -
,
, :
. -
) , -
- -
, -


..
1947. , (06 2017) .
-
,

. :
1) - . -
- -
, , , .
-
, ,

. , ,
,
, -
1947, - -
, : ,
, , -
, - -
- . , -
, . , ,
- -
- .
10 - 2017


. , -

- ,
, - , .
. - , -
.
,
. , , - , -
, , , - -
, , (, - , . -
, , ), , .
, , . 30 . 1940,
, - ,
. 1309 -
-
- .... ,
1522, , -

- . -
. - -
- .
,

(1923), 87%
1946,
-
-
. .
- 14
1912, ...
-
,
- ,

, -
- , , ,
. - , , ,
, . , , ,
. 1912, , , ,
!
, , , -
- , -
. -

, 1923, , ,
.
, .
(1919-1920) , -
,
- 2017 11
 70

, , 9.835 -
, , .
, , - ,
, . -
, ,
, 1090 .
,
(1913,1914,1940-41). ,

, , , -
. , - ().
,
. -

A

- -
-
,
- 121
,
MONTEGO BAY,
. 1982,
-

(. -
- )
. -
- -
-
(2.705
, ..), -
- -
- ,
, . ,
, -
, , , ,
(.
, . . , ),
.
, . -
. ( , - .
), - -
393 . ,
, (1.000
..), , - .
.
, -
( 1991), 400 ,
. , ,
, - (
, 1090 ),
. . .
, ,

12 - 2017
 -
. .
14
.... -
,
,
-
.

,
, -
,
51 -
o
, -
. ..
,
, -
, 31 1947: -
, .
.
-
-
, ,
... , -
. -


.

-
. 1928, -
, -
- (
27/8/1928),
.
(
), .. - 7 1948 ()

, , ,
. ,

,
-
, -
-
. , 1990,
CFE (Conventional Forces Europe), -
NATO .. (-
), -

.
, -

.
(. 1947)
- 2017 13
 70

1947, - ,
, 1951, . ( ), -
( ).
, 1952, . 1951 31 ,
, () - 1991 21.
, , ,
,
. (- 1950. -
-), -
1932 ,
. - , .
,
1947, - , -
. ,
A

-
, status quo -
, , -
. , -
, -
,

. - . -
-
1950,
,
-
(31 . 1947)
1955 , - ,
.
1948, - .
., , . 518 ( 7/ 9-1-
1948), ,
51 , -
- ( ),
British Admiralty, 236,872 1546. , .
(. - , -
) ( ),
. .


-
, . . , The Dodecanese Question during the Second
, . War, Greece-Turkey and the Allies, , 2013
., To -
, , - , , 1992
, , . , 1940-91
, , 1995
. . , -
, - (), , 1997
. , - -
.
, 1994
, Institute for Political Studies, The Status Quo in the Aegean,
. Hellenic Institute for Defense and Foreign Policy, Greek-Turkish
. - Relations, 1987

14 - 2017

. , ,

.
-

, , - . , ,
- . , -
. , ,
, ,
, - .4 ,
, , ,
, , - , , ,
.1 13 . .., ,
- . -

-
, 2
- -
, -
-
Ahhiyawa, ,
- -
(-
), -
. (-
800 ..)
-
.5
-
-
,
- .
- (Ahhiyawa).
- -
. - - -
, . (5 . ..)
Ahhiyawa ,
.3 , , -
, , .6

1 . Melas, 283-311. 4 , 2. 653-670. -

, , -
, . Chadwick, 1976. , .
2 5 ,
, . , , , , . ,
150 , 608.
, 10.000 6 , 1.104. -
. (, , ) -
3 . Simpson, 203-237. ,
3.200 , . -
2017! -

- 2017 15
 70

- (521/486 ..),
. , , 490 ..13
, , ,14
. , - .15
.

, -

. ,
- 478 .. -
, , , ( ) -
(). - .16 ,
, -
. , , -
, .
, .
A

.7
.8 (431-404 ..)
-
.9 - .17
-
,
, . , -
(7 . ..). , 411 .., -
.
( ) .18
(- 6 ..).10 , - -
, - , ,
. ,
.19
, - ,
. , -
,
,11 , 13 - -
( ).12 6 . .. , -
, 99 .-
- ,
, . -
, .
490 .. , -
() .
, , , -
, . , 24.
, - 14 , 891
. 15 -
7 , , -
, .
. 16 ,
8 , , , , , ,
. () - , .
. ( ) 17 , 6. 42-43 7. 57
. , - 18 , 8. 35-44.
, - ,
, 2.700 - .
750 .. . 19 5 . .. -
9 , 14.2. , .
10 , 2. 178-182 , .
11 , 7. 57. ,
12 , 14.2. . , 6.7.
16 - 2017
 . , -
.
,
. ,
, -
,
.20 -
,
,
,
.21
,
, . -
, - , , .
, .
, 25 -
.22 401
408 .., .. , -
, . 396 ..
. ,
, .
. -
, .
. - 378 .. -
. 357 .,
. ,
.23 , .
, 366 .., -- .
-
, , .24 . -
355 .. ,
20 . , 1.5. 18-19 , , 6.7.
21 , , 5.6.7 , 6.7, - ,
( -
), , . - ,
.
26

- , 353 .. , .27

. -
- . 333 ..
. - ,
, .28 -
.
22 , -
, .., , - ,
.
23 1 . .. , 14. 2, - .
: 25 , 3.3.16-17. 3.4.14-17.
( ), - 26 . , .
, - , -
, , -
, . - . , -
, - ,
, , .
. - 27 ,
, -
, .. - , .
, . , 171. . -
24 , 15.760 :
- , 480 .. -
. , .
28 , 4.5.9.

- 2017 17
 70

.
.29 (330 ..), - -
, , , -
, , - . , ,
. . -
, -

- (305/304
. ..).
, - -

-
-

A

.
, - .
-
( -
)
- -

,

333 .. -
-
. , 180 ..
, , , ,
.
.30
.
.
1.600

, 323 .., - -, -
-
. .32 , ,
. ,
. , ,
, - -
. -
- ,
, - -
(), ( ), . -
().31 , - .
,
,
29 , 2.20. - ,33
,
, . , 20.81.3. - 32
, , - , . , , 20-22. , 20.81-
, , . - 100. -
, 92. Frazer, 212-214. , ,
30 , ,
, . .
327 . - - 33 , -
, . ( ) -
31 Sartre, 56, 65, 104.
18 - 2017
 - , -
.
-
,
.

.39 -
- , -
.

. -
.34 -
- -

-
, -
.40 ,
.35 . -
, - . 1 . .., ,

. , -
, .
, - . .
- -
. , -
, , - , , -
.36 , ,
- .41 , -
. , , ,
.37 . -
3 . .. - , .

. 227 ..

, -

, , 3 . .. , -
.
38
,
. -
. - - ,
. . , -
34 , ,

. , - .
, - ,
.
35 - -
- - , .
. Berthold, 1984. . , 14.2.
36 , 10. 39 , 5, 88-90.
37 , , , . -
. - , 108-109.
, - 40
. , - , . Sartre, 250-251.
. . , 4.37-38 47-53. .
, 41 , , , -
. , , , ,
, . , - -
. , . ,
38 - -
. - , . , 14.2.

- 2017 19
 70

. .

- .
(200/197 ..). 196 ..,
, -
150.000 .43
.
- . , , -
,
- .
. , , 167 ..,
, -
- , -
- .
A

, ,
(192/188 ..). -


- .44 -
- ,
, -
- -
-
-
.
, 188 .
.., , -

- . -
, -
.

,
, - , - -
. , - 2
( . .. , , ,
) - , .
,
. -
178 .. . (GXII, 3.
: - 173) 105 ..
.
, ,
.42 , -
(171/167 ..) - . ,
, , - 1 . ..
, .45 -
- .
43 , 30, 31.
167 .., 44 , 146 ..,
. -
: 129 .. -
.
42 , 22.5. 45 1 . .. :

20 - 2017
, 78 .. -
27 .., - .51 ,
- , -
,
, - -
Pax Romana - ,
, , , -
, , ,
.46 ..52 , -
, -
-
.
- , -
, ,
.47
, - , -
, , , . -

. ,
.48 - - , 6
- .. ,
.
- .

,
.49 , -

, . -
-
, ,
. 1 . ..,
-
,
, .50
, 3 . .. -
(88-86 ..). (74-67 ..). - ,
(49-48 ..). - .
(43-42 ..). -- -
(32-30 ..). .
42 .., - ,


.
.
46 Pax Romana - . , -
.
2 . . ., , -
, , 103-104, , - .
1-2 , . -
47 , 88 .. , , - .53 , -
, -
. , - :
,
. 51 , , 4.
48 - 52 Barnes, 385.
, 53 , ,
. . ,
49 , - ,
, 30.31. , -
50 , , 4. , , 3. , , . Ling, 733.

- 2017 21
 70

14 .. - .58
, 155 .. -
. - ,
54

- .59 -
. 3 .
. - ..,
- ( ),
, -
-

.55 - -
, , 324 ..,


A

, - -
, - -
,
. . -

-
- -
(Casa Romana). - 16 . , 653
, 1 . .. - . ..
,
.
- , . 900
.60
2 . .., 70 .. -

-
.56 .: . -
, 6, , 2003.
2 . .. Barnes J., Hellenistic Philosophy and Science, 365-385, The Oxford History of
(!) the Classical World, J. Boardman, J. Griffin, O. Murray, Oxford, 1986.
- Berthold R.M., Rhodes in the Hellenistic Age, Berkeley, 1984.
Chadwick J., The Mycenaean World, Cambridge, 1976.
. , Frazer P.M., Cities of Alexander the Great, Oxford, 1996
.57 . ., ,
, 2 . .. , 2015.
Ling R., The Arts of Living, 718-747, The Oxford History of the Classical World,
J. Boardman, J. Griffin, O. Murray, Oxford, 1986.
, . Melas M., Exploration in the Dodecanese: New Prehistoric and Mycenaean
, finds, The Annual of the British School at Athens, 83 (1988), 283-311.
.., , ,
54 , . , 509-519. , -, 1995, . 5-6.
55 , - ., ,
, , 1972.
Sartre M., , (334-31 ..),
. , -
. , . , -
,
, , 2006.
. , -
Simpson R.H., The Dodecanese and the Ahhiyawa Question, The Annual of
. the British School at Athens, 98 (2003), 303-237.
(!) .
56 ,
(81-96 ..), - 58 , , 31.
, . - 59 155 ..
, , . , , -
1 . .. . , .
57 , . . - 60 , . , -
, 5-6. , 20.

22 - 2017
 KATRADIS GLOBAL NETWORK
Africa: Egypt (Alexandria, Port Said, Suez) South Africa (Durban, Cape Town) Asia: Singapore (Singapore) | Korea (Pusan) | China
(Hong Kong, Shanghai, Qingdao, Zhenjiang & other ports) Europe: Belgium (Antwerp, Zeebrugee) | Germany (Hamburg) | Nether-
lands (Rotterdam, Amsterdam) | Spain (Algeciras, Cadiz, Las Palmas) |Turkey (Istanbul) | Bulgaria (Varna) | Cyprus (all ports)
Middle East: U.A.E. (Fujairah, Dubai) North America: Canada (Montreal) | USA (Houston, New Orleans, New York)
Central America: Panama (Panama)

UHMWPE, Aramid & ixed Ropes for LNGs/LPGs and Tankers - Steel Wire Ropes - Sacrificial Anodes
Anchors & Anchor Chains - Port Development Equipment - Vessel Deck Equipment
24

>>

;
. , ..

.
, - -
-
. - .
.
, -
. -
, - .
. .
, , - -
, , , (- -
, ), . -
-
, , . - Maurice Allais: -
-
.
, . -
- -
.
.

- - .
. -
- - -
- -
. :

- - -
.
-
- - .
. - . -

- ,
, -
.
,
. - -
. -
- -
-
- 2017
 25
-
.
-

,
,

-
-
.

, , -


-
-
. ( , , - -

- , -
- , -
- -
). .
- - 1903 1917
. 1960 1972 -
- - ,
, , - . , -
-
, , -
.
.
. , - . -
, - - , 2008
, - - 427.000 ,
15-46 . -
- - , . ,
-
. -
,
- -
, , . : 2013,
, ,
. , , . 2008 -
, , - 100.000 , -
. , . -
2014

. - -
2015.
- .
/ , ,
.
, . -
- - ,
- 2017
26
, :
- , - ,
..
, , - -
. ,
, .

- -
- - , -
.
- , ..
- ,
21 2015 - , - .
117.829 ,
89.881 ! ,
- / , -
, - , . -
, . -
, . -
, , ,
,
; .
New York Times .

2013 : ,
, -
- -
, . , -
-
- - .
,
- -
. - -
, , , -
, . ,
, -
- , - -
, - .
- -
, - - ,
, , -
. , . . -
2013, , -
. .
- , ,
-
2014, : - .. . - , ,
, -
, , -
,
.. -
:
-


, 480-420 .., .
- 2017
 27

08 2017, (), -
, .
. .
. ,
, ,
, , .
.

- , -
,
,
.
. :
- -

, - 91/73
, - -

-

- 2017
28
-
-
-
,
, -
-
.
-
-
-
.

-
-

-


.
-
, - ,
- Plymouth - ,

-
, -
- Plymouth - .
- , -
.
- ,
, - -
- -
.
- -




-
-
,
-

,
.
-

, -

.

- 2017
 29

, , .
.
.

, - ,
, -
. -

,
.
, - , -
. ,
,
-
, -
, - -
. ,
,
- . -
, - .
- , ,
. - ,
-
, -
,
- . : -
- - . , -
, , - , .
- , -
. - , , . -
- , - .
-
, , -
,
, -
-
,
, -
-
.

-
,
, -
, .



- 2017
30

13 2017

70

. - , (..) ..

13 2017,
- - .
,
, : 70
.
, , 70 -
- .
, : -
. , -
.. . , ,
.
. , ,
- .
- 2017
 31

-
. , ..
,
-

, -
- - ,
- , :
. - -
-
- (Montego bay 1982),
- , :
, , ; - . -
.
, - 1947, - ..
- , : -
; - -
- - .
,
, -
.
, - , , :
- . .
- - -
, ,
70 - , -
. - , . -
, - -
, . - -
. ,
, ,
, - - .
- ,
, , -
- -
,
- , -
.. .
-
, ,
-
. . ,
- ,
- - -
, - ,
, . - .

, - 70 -
, -
. - , -
, -
- .
- 2017
32

. -

. ,
-
- -
-
, .
-
- -
-
, ,
-
. , -
.
-
-
- .
, -
,
1821 .
70 -

-
-
. - . -

, - 1943 .
,
, -
, -
,
- - -
, - - , -
, , 1.500.000 -
- - ,

. - .
- , ,
-
, ,
-
. ,
, -

, -
- ,
. - , -
, .
- 2017
 33

, ,

.
-
70 .
- -
, .
-
1945. -
. - -
,
1832, - 1923 1947.

-
. .
, - -
- , ,
.
-
- - .
1912-13. H .1
- -
, -
, ,
, - 1911-12 . -
.
- 1960,
. 1963 -
- , 1963-64, 1967
, , - 1974. ,
- n realpolitik.
, - - 1964 1974
,
. 1923 - .
. -
- -
, - . -
. 1947, ,
- ,
, - -
1914, - ,
. - , , -
- - ,
.
1 ,
, - -
1973-1976, ,
. 2006, . 17-19 1940 , , 1960
- 2017
34
-
. -

-
1932 -
1932
,
, -
-
.
, 1952-53,
, -
. , -
, -

- -
, 1995 1996. -
, - ,
- - -
- , -
, - .5 -
.2 -
,

- -- -
.6
, - 1932, -
, - -
- , 1953
. . - -
, , . 12 .
- , -
,
, - -
- -
1912 -
1923 .3 ,
. -
- 1996, - .
3,5 -
, .4 , -
- , ,
1943, - , - ,
1945. - (casus belli)
-
1947. 12 .
3 ,
,
.
- , - . -
- / , 2002, -
, . 13-29
4 , 5 ,
-, , . 31-33
2 , - / , 6 , -
, . 25-26 1996, . 2 -, . 6
- 2017
 35
,



.
-
-
,
, -

-

. , -
,

-
. - ,
, , . , -
, - .
.7 - , -
.

- , -
, - .
-
, , ,
-
- .
- -
.8 , -
, -
. - ,
. ,
2016, - ,
- . . , -
- -
- -
. , ,
- ,
, - ,
. -
- , -
-
, . ,
. -

. -
- , ; , -
, - -
-
,
7 , -
1996, -
, . 27-41
8 , - -
, , 2015 - .
- 2017
36

:

. , () ..,

,
-
, - .
70 - , 395 . . -
, -
,
- .
10 1947
. , , , -
- , , -
- . 1309 -
-

27 1946, - 1522,
-
-
, .
7 - 1821 -
1948, - .
.
, - -
. . -
, ,
, 26, . -
, , - , 1830
, - , -
80 - , ,
. , .
1908, - 1911 --
, - 1912 -
, , - .
, . , 10 -
, - 1920,
, , .
. , - -
. -
, 305 304 . . ,
. - . . 1922
-
, -
, - . .
- 2017
 37
-
-


-
.

1948.



-

-
, -

.
,
- , .
, - -
, . ,
- , ,
. - , - 1943 -
, -
- -
, , -

.
, -
. , -
- . ,

-
- -
, - -
. . -

-
. - , -
- . , -
, , , .
,

, -
-
, -
. DELFINO . -
- ,
15 1940 , -
. - -
1943 . , -
- -
. - - ,
- , .
- 2017
38
. - -
, - .
Accolade (
) . -

- . ,
. 8 - - Spitfire
, .
- . - 10 17
- -
. -
, ,
, , , , -
. . 13 -
. -
- (
7.500 )
, , -
-
1943, . -
. . 19 ,
-
, - -
.
, - 23
-

8 1943 - , Friedrich Wilhelm Muller, -
. -
3 -
.
, - , 18
, - -
, Eisenhower, Cmpione.
-
, .
-
- ,
. 7.500 362 .
, - 1.500 3.500 -
, - 40.000 . . 3 -
, - - -
, .
- 9 . -
. 11 .
. .
Wilson (Commander in Chief - -
Middle East) - .
, - .
. , - ,
-
, -
Wilson , . -
- 2017
 39

, -
12
. -

-

-
, -
- - .
, 26
. 16 - . - -
. - 71
3.200 5.350 -
. ,
, - .
- 22
. 18 - , -
, - ,
, - , -
, -
.
. 22 , . - 18, 3, 24, -
- -
, .
-
2.500 . . ,
- ,
. , -
- ,
- , ,
, - . -
, CARLISLE - -
- 4 ,
. , .
4.800 -
. , -
28 . R.A.F. 115 ,
- -
, 6 - .
, 10 , 21 -

HUNT, 6 - . 14 - -
45 . - 7 1945, -
- 32 -
, - ,
- - HMS
- , EXMORE.
- , -
-
. -
- ,
. Wagner.
- 2017
40

OITIKO TPATHIKO
E P I K O I O
15 2016
( )
. ,

3. , (5 -
- , 1 ,
2 , 3

AKP , AP, ) -
- -
-
- . .
,
, - ( -
: , , )
) , , -
( -
) - . , )
- 2002, -
, - ,
- - , -
) , -
-
(4/3/1971) ) - .
) - 1990
(17/5/1971) )
, - -
( )
- .... , ,
. (26/3/1972). (
- T.H.K.O. , -
D.H.K.P.-C.)
1971 , , (64,87% 1999!),
-
1980, 12 ,
1971. ... ( 23,5
- . 2002), -
.
- - -
-
, . Margaret .
Krahenbuhl, Political kidnappings in
( Turkey, 1971-1972, RAND Corporation, 20 .
R-2105-005/ARPA, Santa Monica, CA, July
, -
1977. ,
, - ,
[ --
1, ..). - , . - 21 .
. ,
-
:
1 : ) - , , , .
2012, . 94].
- 2017
 41

-
,
-
-

.

(ttihat ve Terakki) -
-
- ,

-
AKP.
AKP -
-
, , AKP, CHP, MHP, HDP/BDP/DEHAP
.
- : Ali arkolu and Kerem Yldrm, Election storm in Turkey: What do the results of June
, and November 2015 elections tell us?, Insight Turkey, Vol. 17, No. 4, Fall 2015, p. 59.
-
. - 71 -
, - , ,
, , -
7 . ,
CHP, ( -
- - , 10-1)
- , -
, AKP ,
, (9/3/2003) .
AKP 34,28% , 2002-2011,
- ( - AKP , ,
2002 ( - ) . -
1987). . , ,
, , -
( -
2009) AKP , - (Jn Trkler).
40%. - , - -
- (3-7/1999) -
5,3%, - .
(18/3/2008), - . , -
- - -
, (
- ).
AKP ( ) , -
. 71 - -
- (-
(2003-2014) - -
-, -
- -, - -). 6 .
. 5, : -
- -
, - AKP -
- 2017
42
- , -
, - ( ) : ,
2 , ) 7. -
, - (
( - ) - )
), , , -
. . , - (ad hoc
: ) -
, ) AKP
( - AKP ( - -
) . - (, -
3) , -, (kara devrim) - ) , , -

, - : - -
/- (
/ (2/2008, 10/2013, 8/2016, 2/2017)
. (- AKP).
(sessiz -
devrim) - - -
2002-2013: ) ) - ,
-
, -
, , , - 63,5% . -
/, - , ,
4 ) (6/2004) , AKP -
- - , -
(TRT 3), (3/2012, , ...
, , , 4+4+4) , :
, ) (1/2009) -
TRT 6/Kurd5 24
7 . [Emine Uaklgil, Bir ehri
2 , , yok etmek: stanbulda kazanmak ya da
- kaybetmek, Can Sanat Yaynlar, stanbul,
Mart 2014, s. 76 -. . . .-] -
/ -
. , - , , -
, CHP. ( -
, , : -
- 6), [. -
- ] , .
-
10 2014, - , (Demokrasi
, (D..B.). bir tramvaydr, gittiimiz yere kadar
(.. , - - gider, orada ineriz. Demokrasi ama deil
- AKP, - aratr). ,
- (Hakka kul
-
2 1993, - da, demokrasiye ball ne olacak? Drt
69,99%). . drtlk. Ama demokrasi ama m, ara m?
3 Reuben Silverman, Dogan versus - Haa burada bizim bir ayrlmz var. Biz
Erdogan: Business and politics in AKP-era diyoruz ki, demokrasi ama deil, aratr)
Turkey, Mediterranean Quarterly, Vol. 25, ( -
No. 2, Spring 2014, pp. 131-151. , , ) ,
4 . H
, . Fuat Dndar, ... - -
, , - , , . -
, 2016, . 61-111. , - [Nilgn Cerraholu, Veliaht Tayyip
5 , - . Erdoana gre RP hepimizin partisi:
- 6 Demokrasi bizim iin aratr, Milliyet,
, , - (yeil kuak). 14/7/1996, s. 20].
- 2017
 43
, -

,

-
(
2013 -
2014).
, -
,

.
-
,
, -
- -
. - , -
10 (trk-islam
15 2016 - sentezi), -
- ,
- - (), -
16 ( , - -
2017 - , ) . , (, -
, , , ,
. - - ).
- ( ) . -
- 13
- sessiz devrim
-/ - ( - , , -
. AKP - .11
). ,
, , - , - 2017 -
- , - 9,5/13 -
, - 73%12 , , -
[]
, - ( 13)
. -
- 9. , , - 10 , , -
MHP ( -
, , - )
- (, . -
momentum, , , -
- ) - . .
11 ,
. , , -
, , , 1998, . 233-253.
, - 12 , -
8. , - , -

, , - , -
8 , - . , - . -
: , -
, . , .
, ., : - 9 , : , , , -
, , , , .
, 2001, . 173. , 2014, . 435. 13 -
- 2017
44
14 - ;] ) - -
. AKP - - 17
- ( - (
: ) . .... -
) 2017, - -
- ), -
) ,
, -
, - - ( ,
[ /16 -
,
] ) (..
, -
, - -
).
) ,
: ) 15
, , , , ). ,

[- -

- - , , -
- , - ( -
15] ) - ( ) ) -
) -
[, . - )
, - ( ). -

, , -
- . - )
status quo [ , -
- -
,
, , 1998, . 234].
, - ,
15 , - -
( -
, )
) .
14 - - 16/4/2017 -
-
, - . , ,
, - )
,
(- -
, -
) 16
- ,
) -
(, ) /
, - .


(, - (, - ,
- ) (
, , - -
(
, , ). -
, ) - -
, - , , ), ,
, , 1998, . 33-34, 177. - -
,
: () - , -
- () . - .
, , , 2011, .
15, 16. sui generis / - 17 ,
15 , : (, ) - :
, - , , ,
, , 2010, . 77. . 2014, . 135.
- 2017
 45

. , (), I

,
- ,
. , -
, - , status quo
. -

, - -
-
....,
. F.I.R. , -
. ,
, -
, ,
-

,
-
,
-
-
.


-
.
,
-
-
, ,
.., .... ..
-

, -
- (
. - -
, - ) -
-
, . . ,
, - -
, - -
- , ,
-
. , - 6 12 .
- ,
, ,
- 2017
46
-
O
, - . ,

- -

, , ,
( , -
,
- , -
) - . ,
. .
. . ,
-
-
,
.



. -

15.020,8 -
72,8 , -
10.942,8 .

. ,
, 50 - (2.463 3.100
- ), -
- . - ,
. , 1973, ,
, , . ,
. .
- -

.

,
94 , -
. , -
,
, , , -
,
, - . -
. - , , -
,
. - - . ,
- . , ,

1947. - :
- . .
, - -
1922. , -
- ; - , -
- .
. .
. 3.000
- 2017
 47
(
).
. -
,
,

.
.


.
. -
-

,
-
.
, , - -
, - - .

90. , , -
, - , ,-
- , , -
, .
, - ,
. , .. -


- ,
, -
-
. - , .
, - -

, - . ,

-
( -
1923 1947) . -
. 1973,

-
, -
-

-
200 .
. , - -
, - - 1974, -
- .
, . , , 1974 1976 -
,
, (-
, 200 - ).
. , -
- - -
- 2017
48

12 .. -
-
, 1964 -

12 ..
,

,
casus belli
. -
-

,
(casus belli) -
2 . 4 -


. ,

FIR 12 ..
,
, -
( ), -
- - .
, -
. . ,
, 10 ..
.
1975 44
-
-

- - 10 ..,
6 .. ,
, . -
, . , -
6 .. , -
- ,
.
- , -
. , 10 6 .., -
, - ,
- 12 .. - 6 ..,
, .. -
, - , -

. - .
, ,
- -
(equity), ,
- ,
. .
- - status quo .
- 2017
 49
FIR

7 1944 -

,
-
-
(ICAO). O ICAO -


(Flight Information
Region-FIR). FIR -
-

1950, 1952 1958. -



. FIR -
.

- -

. - .

ICAO -
, - .
- -
, , - ICAO.
, - H - , -
,
FIR . , -
-
80 , , - ICAO (1952) .
FIR .
, :
- 1. :
, , 1979 - -
, -
(International
, , Maritime Organization-IMO) - ,
( 1985. ,
) -
- 88/1988 - (Gokceada), (Bozcaada)
(Tavcan), -
-
- 1923- -
. , Montreux
, - FIR 1936- , -
, ,
- -
, .



, - ICAO.
- 2017
50
- , , -
. : -
- 1974
2.  - -
, , , , , -
- res inter alios acta , -
, - . .
- -
- -
. - - .
-
, 13 1987
, .

. .

.
, , .

,

- - 1990
-
- . ,
, - - - -
- (), -
. ,
, - ,
- .
. , -
, ,
-
, . ,
. -
, - , -
3.  .. 1923, - .
() 1947 -
1932.
-
- , - -
, , . -
1947. , - , - -
- 1947, 1988 2001
-
: 1995-96. -
- . -

.

- ,
, , 1970 - ,
-
CFE. - .

- ,

-
.
. . 1973
- 2017
 51

,

. , () *

2009, (Strauss 2003, 66),
20% ( 2016; 2013, 20 .
53). 2008-2015, 379.052 , 1990, -
15-54 , ( 2015), 2008-2013,
25-39 , 223.000
( 2016, 73). , - , -
. , 2009-2014, 6.000 - ,
, ( 2014). . ,
, , 46 -
, () -
1.000 , 10,53 2009, 8,48 2015 ( 2015). 9.1
, - -
,
() . (254
, ).
.
.
2016, 5). , - 45.000,

170.000 -

30.000 (EDA 2014; Armed Forces
, 2010).
, - , ,
(....;
(- 2015).
2005, 63; Dawson 1982, 7). ,
Clausewitz (1976, 591), - ,
- - , 21 .
- (Williams 2006, 8). ,
-
,

-
2009-2016
, - -
-
- (Reuters 2017). ( 2016, 49). -
,
20 , - , -
(....). , / , -
, . .
(Karus , ,
* () (LL.M, /, M.S.S., PhD (C) ) .
mikeploumis@uop.gr. , . . -
, .. ( ), () (), .

- 2017
52

- Collins
, (1994),
-
- , ,
- -
-
- ,
. -
/2013. .
, -
- , . -
- .4 -
- . , ,
(Ploumis & Pilalis 2016, , - , , -
89). , , , -
o - , -
, - .
(Deliso 2007, 153). ( 2016, 3) - -
, - ,
- , - .
(Columbis & Dokos 1994, 282). , -
, (Galvin 2014), -
, - :
. - -
, :
40% 1974 ,
, - ,
- , ;
-
(coercive gradualism) .
(Ploumis 2016, 34). - , , / ,
- 95 ,
. .
, . -
(Pierce Robert Gilpin (2007, 32), :
et. al. 2015, 51). - - ( ) -
, - . -
, ; ,
- , ,
, - - , , -
- ;
.2 , - -
, - . ,
- 5 , - ,
, . -
, , - ,
. - ,
(Ploumis 2016, 32; The Economist , - .
2016).3 , (Powell -
1995, 208), -
- . . -
- 2017
 53
, -
- .
, - , -
- :
. , - , /. . -
- :
, , .
-
,
. (1967).
(Hornick et.al. 2016, 42). - ,
- . -
. , Randolph Churchill (2009, 75)
, 2%
. ... , . -
(Stoltenberg 2016; .
. - Cooper 2017). , - , ,
- , , ,
, . ,
, - , -
(Holcomb 2010, 73). , 20% -
( 2016). ,
. -

2009-2016 (. )
-

-
, - (%) , -
,
( .) (. 2641/1998). , -
. , - 2009 7.31 27,7 56,5 0,84 14,8 2017,
-
2010 5.96 17,9 65,0 0,76 16,1
, ( 2017), -
2011 4.93 5,8 76,0 1,26 16,8
:
- 2012 4.38 7,4 73,1 0,79 18,5 .
: 2013 3.99 12,0 74,5 0,63 12,7
, 2014 3.93 8,1 77,1 1,10 13,5 , -
- 2015 4.19 12,7 70,0 0,77 16,4
( ), - 2016 4.15 14,9 69,9 0,49 14,6
- : (2016)
.
,
. , - -
(.., - . -
- , ) - -
, , 559 .. (Graves
1958, 455) 1940
- , . -
-
. - (Ploumis 2016, 36). . ,
, - 2006,
(Fearon 2002, 6). , , -
, , -
- - ,
- 2017
54
- , -
, - , - , 45
C4I - , -
(Cordesman et.al. 2007, 80; Harel & . . , -
Issacharoff 2008). 2017, 2023

, 17 . -

, - , ,
- - ,
. , - . - -
, -
- , ,
.
- , . - .
, -
. , -
-
( 2009, 46), -
. - -
.., . , - -
- , , , . ,
, ,
- (Jackson 2013; Gerras 2010). - . ,
. - ,
. .
, , , ,
- , - , , , ,
17 , , , , -
18 , , . / .. -
- -
- ,
. . - -
, , -
. (.. -
- , , ..).
(..

), - . ,

. -
, -
, (..,
- - . , -
, - ) , -
, - ,
. (Gates 2008). , -
-
,
- .
, , (Lewin 1947; Bruke 2002), -
- - , -
, - (Kotter 1996, 122). , -
, - , ,
, 17 6-
- 2017
 55
- , . .
ADRP 3-0. 2012. U.S. Department of the Army, , . 2013. ,
, , .112.
Unified Land Operations, Washington, 1-3.
- Armed Forces. 2010. Greece:http://www. , . 2005. -
armedforces.co.uk/Europeandefence/ . .
edcountries/countrygreece.htm. Karus, Vahur. 2016. Civil Conscription-Way and

Burke, Warner, 2002. Organization Change: Theory Means to Counter Hybrid Threats?SRP/USAWC.
. and Practice. ThousandOaks. Kotter, John, 1996. Leading Change, Boston, HBRP.
- Churchill, Randolph. 2009. - Lewin, Kurt, 1947. Frontiers of Group
, . . Dynamics,Human Relations, v.1, 5.
Clausewitz, Carl. 1976. On War, Howard-Paret, NATO. 2016. PR 116: Defense Expenditure of NATO
- Princeton. Countries (2009-2016), 4/7/2016.http://www.
Collins, John. 1994. Military Preparedness: nato.int/nato_static_fl2014/assets/pdf/
, - Principles Compared with U.S. Practices, Report pdf_2016_07/20160704_160704-pr2016-116.pdf.
no. 94-48S, CRS, 21/1/1994, 41-49. , . 2008. -
- Cooper, Helene.Defense Secretary Mattis Tells , . -
, - NATO Allies to Spend More, or Else, NY Times, .
15 Feb 2017, , https://www.nytimes. , . 2009. -
com/2017/02/15/world/europe/jim-mattis- : -
. -
nato-trump.html . PhD /,
Cordesman et.al. 2007. Lessons of the 2006 Israeli- http://pandemos.panteion.gr/index.php?op=
- Hezbollah War, CSIS. record&lang=el&pid=iid:3766.
Dawson, David. 1982. The Military Draft: Selected , . 2016. ,
Readings on Conscription, ed. Anderson. ,
Stanford, HIP. , .118.
- Deliso, Christopher. 2007. The Coming Balkan Pierce, Douds & Marra. 2015. Countering Gray-
, 21 . Caliphate, PSI. Zone Wars: Understanding Coercive Gradualism,
.... Parameters, 45, no. 3.
, http://www.eaas.gr/. Ploumis, Michail, 2016. Hellenic National Security:
. 2017. The Turkish Challenge,Army War College
1 9 , 2017, http://www.ert.gr/etos-ethnofylakon- Review, vol. 2, No. 3, Aug. 2016, 21.
ke-efedron-anakirychthike-2017/ Ploumis, Michail & Pilalis, Labros. 2016. A New
12 . EDA. 2014. Defence Data 2014. https://www. Deal for the Middle East and North Africa,
2 eda.europa.eu/info-hub/defence-data-portal/ Mediterranean Quarterly 27:2, June 2016.
Greece/year/2014#1. Powell, Collin. 1995. My American Journey.
. , - . 2016. , - Random House.
: 2016,15/12/2016.
Reuters. 2017. Sweden returns draft amid
. 2015. 2015: -
security worries and soldier shortage, http://
, -
www.reuters.com/article/us-sweden-military-
, - .
idUSKBN1690ND
, (.. ) . 2015. , -
, . 2015. -
( 2008, 361). - 1932-2015.
, 22/1015. http://
Fearon, James. 2002. Selection Effects and
www.iefimerida.gr/news/232160/yparhei-
, , - Deterrence, International Interactions 28, no. 1.
skepsi-sto-pentagono-gia-mikri-ayxisi-tis-
, Galvin, Thomas. 2014. Military Preparedness, FP,
stratiotikis-thiteias.
- USAWC/DCLM, 3.
Gates, Robert, 2008. Remarks to Air War College . 2016. 2015,
(ADRP 3-0 2012).
3 Speech April 21, 2008. AWC. 2/2016.
- Gerras, Stephen, 2010b. Communication The Economist. 2016. Turkeys War on the Kurds,
with External AudiencesA Stakeholder v. 418, no. 8973, (January 23, 2016), 10, 45-46.
. (Schelling 1966, 6). Management Approach. FP, USAWC. . 2016. -
Gilpin, Robert. 2007. - , .118, 2016.
: . . Schelling, Thomas. 1966. Arms and Influence, NH,
Graves, Robert. 1958. , YUP.
, (Clausewitz 1976, 77). . . Stoltenberg. 2016. Remarks by NATO SG at the
4 (complex adaptive Gladwell, Malcolm. 2001. The Mosquito Killer, European Parliament Committee on FASD,
system-CAS) - New Yorker, July 2, 2001. 23/2/2016.
- Harel, Amos & Issacharoff, Avi. 2008. 34 Days. Strauss, Barry. Reflections on the Citizen-Soldier,
PalgraveMacmillan. Parameters, Summer 2003.
( 1999, 254; Gladwell Hastedt, Glenn.2014. American Foreign Policy. Williams, Cindy. 2006. Service to Country:
2001, 42). Rowman&Littlefield. Personnel Policy and the Transformation
5 Holcomb, James. 2010. Managing Strategic Risk, of Western Militaries, eds Gilroy, Curtis and
in USAWC Guide to NSPS, ed. Bartholomees. Williams, Cindy, Cambridge, The MIT Press.
- Hornic et. al. 2016. Rightsizing the Army in Austere , . 2014.
. - Times, Parameters vol. 46, No 3. , 26/10/2014, http://www.
Jackson, Lisa. 2013. The Real Secret of Googles kathimerini.gr/789549/article/epikairothta/
- Corporate Culture, Corporate Culture Pros, 23/7/13. ellada/h-deyterh-megalh-e3odos-twn-
(Hastedt 2014, 35). . 1999. , kalymniwn

- 2017
56

(: )

, ,

, , -
: - -
H , -
- , - 2016
, -
. -
- . , - ,
( ),
-
, , . ,
...
, ,
. , , - .
, . , -
,
, - .
- , ,
. , - -
- .
, - , ,
. , . ,
-
- - -
, . , , -
- ,
. ,
-
- . , .
. -
, - ,
-
,
, . , - -
- - . ,
-
. , . -
-
.
. , , , -
- 2017
 57
- -
-
. -
-
, - -
, -
-
-
-
. -
-
-
.
- -
- -
. ,


, -
- - .
.
, , - -
-
- - , -
, -
. , . 478 -
, ,
-
- , .
.
. ,
, - - -
1994 ,
, -
, - -
. -
, -
- , -

. -
. - .
- -
, - .
, , ,
,
. , - -
, - .
- ,
- - - -
- - , -
. -
. , , .
- 2017
58
, -
- .
. 15
, -

- -
. - . -
,
. -
, , -

.
. , - -
-
- 1980.
. - , -
-

. . 1987, , -
.
-
- 1993,
- , - . 2009,
, ,
. - -
- . , , -
, -
- , -
. -
, - , -
- . ,
- -
- . -
- , -
, ,
. - , -
, - , ,
.
-
. ,
. . - ,
, 1947, - .
- -
- ;
, - ,
. , , ,
-
, - . -
- ,
. -
, -
, -
- 2017
 59
-
- - . -
. .
, -
, -
- -
. 50 , .
, -
-
, . , - . -
. -
- .
, -
1967, - :
. ( - -
- , , , , -
. ), -
-
: -
. , - .

:
. , .., -

16 2017, . . -
- .
.
- .
-
- .
,
. , -
- , ,
: : .
, -
550 600. . , . . -
, . , . . -
25 18 . - - .
, - .
, - , . -
. , . .
, - -
3-11-2019, , , -
. , - - ,
- , , .
- , -
. - : -
, ,
. ,
, - , .
: . - one man
- 2017
60
show . -
, . - ,
. , - -
, - -
, - , . , . . -
: . -
, -
, -
, , -
, , ,
, , , , , . .
. ,
2016 - . . ,
- , , - ,
, - -
2015. . - , -
, - , - , ,
- ,
, , ,
. ,
, - -
. - 15 2016 , . ,
,
- , 248
, 2.193 , -
. . - , -
- --
, - , - -
- . , -
-, -

. -
- , ,
. .
, - , -
, ,
, , , -
-
, ,
. -
, - , ,
. .
, - , - ,
- , , ,
, - -
. -
, ,
- ,
, , : . , -
- . -
, : -
, . . ( 2-3 ). -
- 2017
 61
,



,


2,5
(, ). -
,


, - - :
. . ,
,
- .
(.. , -
, : ). , - .
, , ,
, - . -
. , - ,
- 15 80%, 2016
41,60%. , 40% -
, - , -
20%.
, - .
- , :
. , - -
- . -
, ,
. - - .
, - , -
.. , -
, ,
. , - - .
: -
, , -
- [-
, - ,
, , -
. , -
- ( )] - . -
, : , ,
, -, ,
- .
. .
- -
. , - - , -
, - , .
, -
, -
.
- 2017
62

. . ,

- - -
- , .
,
, - - , -
- -
, -
, ,
- . -
- -
, , . , ,
- -
. , - , -
,

-
-
-
- -
.


, - .
- -
-
-
-
- - ,
- -
, - - -
, - .
. -
- . ,
, - - ,
, , -
- ,
.
, . .
, -
, - , - -
, , , -
, -
, - -
, - . ,
- - -
.
. ,
, - - -
- 2017
 63
, -
, - - -
,
- , - . ,
-
. , ,
, - ,
- . - , , ,
1987 , , -
. , .
-
, , - , -
, - ,
, ,
. - .

, *

. -

-
-
. ,
, -

, , -

. -
,
,

. -
. , ( a priori ,
- ),
. , -
/ -
/, - ,
. , -
- , - -
- - - - ,
. - - . , ,
: ,
. , . ,
, - -
- - -
- - ,
-
- , -

* , , .

- 2017
64
- - - . -
. , ,
YPG- , -
- -
, - (, )
( , -
) - .

: H -
. , ..

. -
, -
.
,
, ,
.
.
. ,
-
- -

- . , (Awdijiwka).
- - - ,
. , -
. -
- - . -
. , -
,
((Donbass). -
. .
. - , -
, . ,
. - - -
, -
12 2015 . , -
, -
- , -
(Debalzewe). 2014 - -
2015 -

. -

, - .
, -

-

. , , -
- -
- , -
. 2014. - . -
, , -
2014, - - ,
- , ,
- , -
- 2017
 65
. -
-
, .
- -
. - -
-
: -
-
, -
,
.
, - -
- . - .

: ;
. . , ..,

, -

- ,
, , 2016,
1990, - , , ,
, - - -
, , , ,
. , - -
, -
, , - , -
, , ,2
, - -
, - - ,
, - - ,
, , - , -
, - , ,
, , - .3 , -
- ( , ,
, - , , - ton-trump-kai-poytin, -
, - Trump . -
,
. , ,
Alexander J. Motyl, www. balkaninsight.
, com/en/ar ticle/soros-foundation-
), - rebuffs-balkan-governments-
. , - attacks-02-09-2017, Soros
Foundation Blames Attacks on Illiberal
, - . 1
Governments,www.balkaninsight.com/
. - en/article/russia-never-went-away-from-
, , , 1 www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/ the-balkans-01-18-2017, Russia
russia-seeking-balkan-chaos-us-expert- Never Went Away from the Balkans,
says-01-26-2017#sthash.NP7seoPL.dpu., Marcus Tanner.
,
Russia Seeking Balkan Chaos, US 2 , -
, - Expert says, www.balkaninsight.com/en/
, - article/russia-aims-to-disrupt-balkans-us- ()
, , - expert-says-02-02-2017#sthash.jJldV5xH. ( ).
dpuf, Turmoils in EU, US Boost 3 w w w . b a l k a n i n s i g h t . c o m / e n /

Russia Influence in Balkans Natalia a r t i c l e / d e m o c rat i c - s t a n d a rd s - i n -
( Zaba, foreignaffairs.gr/articles/71148/ balk ans-replaced-by-a-toxic-mix-
) - alexander-j-motyl/i-theoria-paignion- of-nationalism-02-01-2017,
- 2017
66
, - , -
. ,
, -
4. , (97
, 2 ),
- , , ,
. - , -
, , , - , -
, , , - ,
2015, 5
.
. , -
, SIS - .
, - , -
, 5,7 . - , 14 2017, 18 -
.5 , , , , -
- 15/16 2016, -
, -
, - , 21 ,
-
, - . , -
, - , , -
, . , ,
18 20 , 2 , ,
2017. , - -
, , - .
- , , - /2017/01/16/will-senate-sacrifice-u-s-
, EEMM-MEGA, , - security-for-benefit-of-balkan-mouse-
- montenegro-doesnt-belong-in-nato/,
Dont Add Montenegro To
.6 , -
Obsolete NATO: Senate Shouldnt
- , 29 , Sacrifice U.S. Security For Balkan
, , 22 - - Mouse, Doug Bandow, www.
, 19 2016. nationalinterest.org/feature/does-nato-
need-montenegro-18533, Does
- (27 2017),
NATO Need Montenegro?Montenegro
- isnt a vital component of either European
. , . - or U.S. security Charles V. Pea,
- , - www.politico.eu/article/michael-flynn-
to-recommend-donald-trump-nato-
, ,
membership-montenegro/,
Flynn to recommend Trump back NATO
Freedom House Highlights Threats to , membership for Montenegro Andrew
Balkan Democracies Maja Zivanovic. - Hanna, http://thehill.com/blogs/congress-
Freedom blog/foreign-policy/317247-the-unites-
-
House, , , states-must-ratify-montenegros-nato-
- , membership, The United
, , States must ratify Montenegros NATO
, , , membership Michael Carpenter
, . www.dailyastorian.com/montenegros-
.7
4 www.europarl.europe.eu/sides/getDoc. bid-to-join-nato-faces-us-senate-test-da-
do www.europarl.europe.eu/sides/flu/ ap-webfeeds-news-nation-world127970,
pdf/el/FtU, - 6 http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/ Montenegros bid to join NATO
2016, uk-paper-kremlin-plotted-montenegro- faces US Senate test, http://www.reuters.
17 2016. pm-s-death--02-19-2017-1#sthash. com/article/us-usa-nato-montenegro-
5 http://www.albawabaeg.com/75589,- f0Fa6luh.dpuf, UK Paper: Kremlin idUSKBN16Y2QF?, Montenegro
ISIS money grows on Albanian mafia Plotted Montenegro PMs Death NATO accession clears hurdle in U.S.
marijuana trees. 7 www.forbes.com/sites/dougbandow Senate, Patricia Zengerle
- 2017
 67
, , -

, , .
, -
-
, ,
-
-
, . -
Freedom House -
,
, , -
- -
. -
, - , -
, , , .11
1244 , , -
. , -
, . .
, 11 2016,
. , ,
, , ,
- ,
, .10
- -, - ,
, ,
, - ,
, . , -
, - 2016 - , -
- , ,
, , 9 , , ,
, ,
, - , -
, -
.8 . - , -
, - , -
57 - , . (VMRO-DRMNE:51 , SDSM:49
, , - - , :20 ).
, EULEX,9 2007, , 4 -
- ,
, - , 7 -
-, - 1992-1995. .
-
11 http://www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/
-, , -
serb-member-of-bosnian-presidency-
- , - to-write-to-the-hague-02-24-2017, -
, Bosnian Serb Official Challenges
8 www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/ - Legality of Genocide Appeal Eleanor
kosovo -army-bill-angers-nato -us- Rose, www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/
-
serbia-03-08-2017, NATO Chief political-quarrels-again-block-bosnia-
Rebukes Thaci Over Kosovo Army Plan, . , s-eu-path-02-27-2017, Political
Perparim Isufi. - Quarrels Again Block Bosnias EU Path
9 www. balkaninsight.com / en / article Srecko Latal, Danijel Kovacevic, http://
/ hiding-in-plain-sight-kossovo-s- 10 http://www.balk aninsight.com/en/ www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/rs-
protected-witnesses-02.13.2017, article/kosovo-trapped-by-the-past- on-icj-02-27-2017, Bosnian Serb
Hiding in Plain Sight - Kosovos Protected thaci-03-01-2017, Kosovo Trapped Lawmakers Slam Genocide Lawsuit
Witnesses. by the Past: Thaci Kaltrina Rexhepi. Danijel Kovacevic.
- 2017
68
- , , ,
, -
- . ,
- ,
, - , -

, - -
, , , - -
, - . 15
- ,
1912-1956, 22 . 12 , , ,
- , 8
, MIG 29 -
. BUKE, ,
- , ,
, -
- , S 300.
, ,
, -
, - , -
- (
, - ,
, , - (GERB) , -
, ).
. , , - . ,
- , - , -
, , - ,
, VMRO-
DRMNE, . -
( 6 2017), 47%
, SDSM, . ,
, , 29% , 24%, South Stream,
, , -
, , . .
, - , -
5 .13 - , -
, - ,
Gallup, 2016, 64% - ( 100.000
. , 9% ) -
, .14 -
- , -
12 www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/
, -
macedonia-s-crisis-may-cripple -
, municipalities-03-07-2017#sthash. . ,
xjXKKORD.dpuf, Macedonias , -
. Crisis Could Cripple Local Councils ,
Sinisa Jakov Marusic.
, - , 50-100.000,
13 www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/
, - governments-anti-eu-rhetoric-affects- -
, , - serbian-citizens-02-07-2017, Anti- ,
EU Tide is Rising in Serbia, NGO Warns
Maja Zivanovic 15 www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/putin-
, ,
14 https://regnum.ru/, http://www.echedoros-a. honorary-citizen-in-a-dozen-serbian-
gr/2017/02/70.html, 70% - cities-02-22-2017, Serbian Towns
. Queue to Make Putin Honorary Citizen.
- 2017
 69
. ,
- -
-
- -
, , ,
-
-
. 26

2017, () ( ).
, -
- 0 ( - -
GERB (32,65 %) ) 100 ( ), ,
- .
, , ,

, 90 ,
- , 89, -
BSP (27,20 %) , 11 12 .
: www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/balkans-seen-as-corrupt-transparency-

international-reports-01-24-2017#sthash.kerscKiv.dpuf
- : -
, - - -
[- , ,
(9,07%), -
(MRF) , - -
, - .
, (8,99%) .17 , ,
(Volya) (4,15%)]. - , ,
, -
DOST, , - ,
, -
- .
, 2.86% , ,
. , , -
, , . , ,
, - , -
, , - .
, ,
- , - -
, , , - .
.
, , , , , -
-
Volya, -
MRF, . -
ad hoc - - , ,
. - , , - , (-
, , , - , )
, .
.16 , , , :
- (think tanks),
, . .18

16 http://www.bta.bg/en/c/DF/id/1546584, 17 www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/ 18 https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/

Final Results of Parliamentary romania-2017-russian-shadow-falls-on- bosnia-herzegovina/2016-12-20/
Eelections Show Gerb as Winner with west-s-staunch-ally-01-05-2017#sthash. dysfunction-balkans, : Dysfunction
32.65% of the Votes IEhlkCNA.dpuf, Marian Chiriac. in the Balkans. Can the Post-Yugoslav
- 2017
70
, - . -

, , -
- -
, , -
, - - , -
, : - -
,
, , , -
. -
- - -
, , ,
, , -
. , - ,
, - ,
: - , . , . -
, - ,
.19 , ,
- .21
- , -
.., -
Vision Plus, . -
- , - ,
, - , -
-
, ,
. (, , -
- , ). -
- BREXIT, - -
, : - (, , , )
- , , , -
, -
-- , , -
. - , , . -
- , , -
, ,
- . ,
. , -
, , .

, , . ,
.20 , -
.
Settlement Survive?, Timothy Less ,
19 www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/serbia- - 21 www.mignatiou.com/2017/02/ti-simveni-
kosovo-should-swap-land-ivor-roberts- . - stin-geopolitiki-skakiera-se-diethnes-
says-02-08-2017#sthash.c8OeT0T7.dpuf, epipedo-ti-simfonisan-sto-monacho/.

Serbia, Kosovo Should Swap Land,
Ivor Roberts Says, Marcus Tanner. : -
20 www.balkaninsight.com/en/article/ , . -
balk ans-politicians- dismissing-us- , www.aljazeera.com/news/2017/02/
congressman-proposals-02-08-2017, sergey-lavrov-hope-world-chooses-post-
US Congressman Slammed for congress-rohrabacher-trump-231775, - west-order-170218134909381.html, -
Proposing New Balkan Borders, http:// Putins favorite congressman, Sergey Lavrov: I hope world chooses
www.politico.com/story/2016/11/putin- POLITICO post-West order.
- 2017
 71

. ,

(=) (
- -
, - 5) -
. 6 -
1966-19691, - .
2, - -
, - -
, / (,
( - , ) /- -
), - () (.. , ,
. - ) ,
, - -
, , , - ,-
- (, ,7) 9, -
( - . -
, , ().10 -
) , 8 , ,
, ,
( , , -
5 25 2006
- [Margaret Coffey, Fethullah Gulen, A.B.C. -
19 . ). Radio National, 7/10/2007, goo.gl/aqBxiP]. 11 , ,
, , - , -
9 , , -
3 -
2006, - -
( - -.
- . ,
- 6 Gulen, it turned out, was really not the , . , . ,
ascetic Sufi we were told about, but a micro- ., : -

manager of a global organization based on , , , -
!4) - secrecy and hierarchy. [] There is a sacred 2001, . 103.
/- cause, a single leader with supra-human 10 ,
, wisdom and a cadre of devotees who -
sacrifice their lives and individual minds [ /] -
.
for the utopia. Mustafa Akyol, Cause or [sic]
, - cult? What it means to be a Gulenist, Al- []
- Monitor, 2/8/2016, goo.gl/6GH8oD.
7 . - ,
- . -
1 (1960) - , - , , -
. . . , 6/12/2013, goo.gl/eo6LlD.
2 - . , , , :
170 [al Kasapolu, Baz : , . , 22/11/2013,
lkeler Glen okullarn kapatmaya neden , - goo.gl/AwwxNN.
direniyor?, B.B.C. Trke, 2/8/2016, goo.gl/ , , 2009, . 52, 76. 11 -
lLRoCo], 8 -
( ). ( - . , -
3 Mustafa Akyol, Who was behind the coup ) ( )
attempt in Turkey?, The New York Times, - , -
22/7/2016, goo.gl/44RSo5. - : ) ) ) -
4 , , - ) - [ , :
/ - , ,
. - , - , , 2014, . 329-
- (702-765). Carl W. Ernst, 330]. /
- : , .
. , ,
. , , 2001, . 64. : ,
- 2017
72
. - ( -
.12 1.124.835
. - , , -

), -
- (followers) .
16-22 - , -
() (involved) . -
-
(sympathisants) ,
(- .15 ..,
13). ( 17 [-
27/4/1941
14 - ) - -
- ], --
(, , - 18
19,
, , -
) ( ) ( -
- -
- -
, ).
.
.16
() 20

: . - , -
17 [] the Glen movement seeks the
-
islamization of Turkish identity at home
250.000 - and the Turcification of islam abroad that
, - would yield an Islamic world shaped by
, , 2014, . enlightened Turkish culture. Jeff Jager,
179-180. Understanding the Glen movement,
-
12 , Small Wars Journal, 5/8/2016, goo.
, . , 6/12/2013, gl/3Ljqpu.
goo.gl/eo6LlD. 15 Peter B. Clarke, New religions in global 18 --
13 - perspective: A study of religious change in 2010
, the modern world, Routledge, Abingdon,
( ) 2006, p. 72. , - (
, , , : ). Jana J. Jabbour,
. - , - La Turquie: Linvention dune diplomatie
, - , , 2014, . 177. mergente, C.N.R.S. ditions, Paris, 2017,
- Natalia Mielczarek, David D. Perlmutter, p. 288.
: Big pictures and visual propaganda: 19 , -
The lessons of research on the effects , , -
( ) - of photojournalistic icons, in Carol , , -
- K. Winkler, Cori E. Dauber, eds., Visual . Pnar Doan ve Dani Rodrik,
- propaganda and extremism in the online Fethullah Glen, the Jews, andhypocrisy,
environment, Strategic Studies Institute, Balyozdavasivegercekler.com,
() United States Army War College Press, 5/11/2012, goo.gl/EIG5YF.
Carlisle, PA, July 2014, p. 228. Jeff Jager, 20 [] it appears Glen is not fighting for
() - Understanding the Glen movement, more individual freedoms but to free islam
, ... Small Wars Journal, 5/8/2016, goo. from the confines of the mosque and the
14 When one of us had doubts, they would be gl/3Ljqpu. Jana J. Jabbour, La Turquie: private domain of individuals and to bring
ready with some amazing story of a miracle Linvention dune diplomatie mergente, it to the public arena, to govern every aspect
performed by Gulen. Umar Farooq, Inside C.N.R.S. ditions, Paris, 2017, p. 106. of life in the country. AKP leaders, including
the secretive religious movement that is 16 . , , Gl and Erdoan, have repeatedly expressed
being blamed for Turkeys attempted : their opposition to the imprisonment of
coup, Los Angeles Times, 17/8/2016, goo. islam in the mosque, demanding that it be
gl/fcdYvG. Fethullah Glen dosyas, Milli , , , present everywhere as a lifestyle. Rachel
zm Dergisi, 1/11/2004, goo.gl/QP0oFp. 2009, . 21-22, 32-33. Sharon-Krespin, Fethullah Glens grand
- 2017
 73
- ,
-
,
( - -
- - 24, -
- -
-) . , ()
-
- / ()
- . - ( -
. - - ) ) -
,
, -
. , ( 113 ),
: -
( - 25 .
) -
24 : ) -
. - -
-
.

() -
bras de - ,
fer - , - ,
-
, - -
(),
-
- (
.21 ).23 -
[ -
, - , : ) -
, .
- - ,
, () [
- , ,
, 8, 3-4,
,
2014, . 73-85] ) -
- ] ) -
[] 22. , ()
- 2,5%
ambition: Turkeys islamist danger, Middle
( -
East Quarterly, Vol. 16, No. 1, Winter 2009, (
goo.gl/BkvH. ,
21 ), -,
- -), -
,
-
: , , - -
, - ) ,
- -
, 23 (, .
( ) - 25 -
, - -
[sic] . (25/2/2017),
, . -
, - . -
, - .
, . , 12/12/2013, , -
goo.gl/lVST9d) , , , -
, - , , -
22 . , , - . Markus Bernath, Die
: abgefallenen kinder des herrn Glen,
( Der Standard, 9/4/2011, goo.gl/wsZWq.
, , , ;) Maximilian Popp, Altruistic society or
2009, . 39. . sect? The shadowy world of the Islamic
- 2017
74
, 27 ,
- ( 1970)
( ) - : )
(- -
, , - ( - -
) -- - , -
-
- -
( - 28). - -
) 29 (
. - -
- . , - - 622 ..) ) ,
- -. Yldray , ... -
Our, Adna da Tahiye derler, Trkiye,
, ( -
27/9/2015, goo.gl/hGrSlF.
27 : (5/2010) -
- 30
) - , . . Osman (, -
zgan, Glenin rntgencileri, Yeni afak,
) (,
3/8/2016, goo.gl/ehM028.
. 28 , . -
31 green belt -

,
- , , )
, , , -
, -
, , ,
- . ( ....
15 2016 15 , -
, , . - -
, ( -

) -
- . - -
() -)32 ) ( -
- )
()

, -
- ( -
( ) - )
... . , --
,
- -, -
, . 85-86, -
/ 2016, goo.gl/LP8dVW. - /-
- , --
. - - .
, [*
,
..], 3/9/2016, goo.gl/aYP6mN.
26 29 ... 30 , -
:
Glen movement, Der Spiegel, 8/8/2012, . (2005) , .info,
goo.gl/4OQc7. Safure Cantrk, Glen 13/4/2012, goo.gl/R0snvf.
dorms criticized, Daily Sabah, 13/3/2014, , , 31 Yldray Our, Yirminci yzyln 98 ylnn
goo.gl/AZQiGU. Life in a Gulen dormitory , - hikyesi, Trkiye, 3/5/2015, goo.gl/
in Turkey, Turkish Invitations, sine anno - IckwyF.
et die, goo.gl/Th9bPY. Eileen Barker, C.I.A. 32 , -
The not-so-new religious movements: ... . - -
Changes in the cult scene over the past , - ,
forty years, Temenos, Vol. 50, No. 2, , , -
2014, pp. 235-256. Adam McConnel, My (.. - C.I.A. -
personal knowledge of Fethullah Glens . -
cult (3), Serbestiyet, 24/10/2016, goo.gl/ , / . ) - . Dexter Filkins, Turkeys
mQ1H56. thirty-year coup: Did an exiled cleric try to
26 : (1/2010) 132 (.. - overthrow Erdoans government?, The
, - . ). New Yorker, 17/10/2016, goo.gl/chmqVM.
- 2017
 75

&
:



,

- 1. - -

- -
, -
- ,
.
60
. , - -
, - 2.
,
, , , - -
. - . -
. - - .


, -
, - ,
- . - .
, , ,
- 2 : J. Habermas, ) Il discorso filosofico
, - , della modernita. Laterza 1988. ) -
. -
,
1997. ) .
2003. ) . -
- - 2007. Habermas
. . -
, -
- -
,
state-building, -
- -
, -
.
,
-
(;) - -
. . , -
.
. ,

1 : . .- Habermas
, ,
2017. .
- 2017
76
, - -
3,
(.. ), -
- - .8 -
- . - - ,
. . -
- - -
, , .9 ,

, -
. .10

- 11
. ,
- ,
raisondtat ,
, - , -
, , .7 .
, - -
- -
, - ,
, -
.4
. ,
. ,


(iuscosmopoliticum)
, ( - 8 -
, - )
- - . -
- -
,
. .
5 . - 9 : C.Schmitt,
6 - . 1988. .
, .
3 - 1991. . , ,
- - . . 2005.
, 10 -

( ) .
4 . - .: -
- .
; - . -
MonthlyReview 42. 2008. ( - -
5 - ) , , , -
- , ,,
- --
. , - .
6 - 11 -
- . -
. , 7 , , -
, 1992, . -
- J. Habermas. - -
- : . - .
, ,, 20 21 .
. 1998.. . , , -
- . . 2005. . -
- . : , .2-3. C.
- Preve, . 1998. .
- 2017
 77
- -
, -
-
,
.

. -
- ,
-
-
, ,
- , - -
. - -
- .
. -
.12 , -
- - .
- -
- .
- 17

. - - -
-
-
,
, -
- - (;) -
, - .
, . -


- - ,
- , - -
. - .13 ,
, - .
(
- -
- 13 - , -
. -
, -

. .
) . 2007. 14.
, - .57. - ,

, ,

12 - , ,
, - , ,
- - ( - ,
(.. , ), -
. -
..), - -
. , -
-
. , ,
-
, -
14 R.Nisbet, ,
. . 1995.
- 2017
78
- -
-
. . -


- . -
, -
, - -
- , , - .
,
- -
- -
15. -
- .
, - - -
( - , -
).
, -
() . - . -
- ,
, modus .
vivedi . - -
, , .

. . -
- .
,
15 , - - . -
, - .
,
- .
1650 , -
, -
. - . - . -
, -
, -
. .
,
- -
, : -
- , - , -
,
, . -
-
17,
, , 18,
16.
-
1945 - , -
. Grotius
Kant Mill Hayek -
- 17 .:
- 20 21 .
, 1998. 101 ..
.
, , -
(. , - ( -
, - , )
, -
1776) .,
. - 18 -
, , - 16 R. Cooper, . -
. . 2005, 82. 2005. .
- 2017
 79

-
-
-


.



-

.
, -
, (. -
)
..

20.
-
.
..19 , ,
,
-

, , -
. , -
- 12 2017 -
- - , -
,
: - , 7
- ().
, ,
- -
- ,
, - - , , -
. 21. , ,
- 1.

-
, -
. ,
-
,


, .. -
,
, . -
, 2017,
() -
, -
. 1.
- 22. 2010.
,

- .
-

-

20 . , ,
. . ,
1992. 123.
, -
21 M.Hardt-A.Negri, .
Scripta2002. . 120. , .
19 . , 22 A. Schopenhauer,The World as Will
. and Representation. Dover, N.York, 1
1992. 118. 1966.
- 2017
80
>> ;).
, , -
90,
, , .
. . , ., / : . , -

,
, , ,
. ;
- .
, . 401 - : ,
- - . -
-. (, , : ,
10-15 , . ; ,
, ; - .
.. , ; ( -
( ).
) . ( - ,
, ) , ).
, . , -
. , . , - ;
, , . ,
( , ( ;) - ; , -
), - ; . , ;
, , . ,
- . . . - ,
; - , ;
. . ,
. - ,
. . - , ;
, . .:
34 ( ) . , .
. . , , ,
, ; - , ,
, .. ( .

,

,
:

- 2017
 81

. ,
- , -
, -

-

.

. , ,

. -
, . - ,
.. , -

- - , -
. .
- , -
- , -
, , -
-
- .
- -
. . ,
-
, - ,
- ,
-
-
, , , (
, , -
- - ),
,
. -
, - .
!
. -
, , - ,
, , , ( -
- . 13 15, , 210 36 18
, , - 254), -
, .

Eurobank 0026-0255-30-0101247138
: GR 4202602550000300101247138

- 2017
82

O O , , ,
, , ,
, , -
- 2017 . . 177,
. ,
1. 13 , - .

.
, 3.
.. : 70 .
.... : ,
14 ,
14 , , -
. , -
2400 24 26
22 :
25 1821, .............................. 20
. ........................... 10
23 -
........................................ 5
/ / /.
- ( - ........................... 30
23 -
). .......................... 20

. ...................................... 30
.
1 1 - ............................. 30
.................................... 30
( ) (-
), .................................... 5
, .. .... -
. ....................................... 5
:
3 2 ......................................... 5

. .............................. 50
,
6 ................................. 5

.. 8 - .............................. 20
. ........................................ 10

1 .......................... 10
.
, 2017 ............................... 30
. 2. ........................ 30
T 8 ............................... 10
, . / - ................................... 5
. , , ........................................ 5
12 : - ..................................... 10
, - , , , , .................................. 10
, ..................................... 10
.. . . , , .., - .................................. 10

.

,
,
.

, ,
.

T
.

. 210 38 98 999 www.piraeusbank.gr/ypetha