07.

:
/ ,
, , ,
.

, ,

.

Kuhn

Popper Feyerabend

Lakatos

Laudan

- 2014

7:
:
anoixti-skepsi.tumblr.com
open-thought-blog.tumblr.com

, 2014

-
,
2008-2014.


. , -
,
,
,
.

, ,
.
, , ,
.
, , -
, , ,
.


Popper
23

-
Lakatos
34

Laudan
38

H (Kuhn &
Feyerabend)
42

Kuhn

43

Feyerabend
53

56

67


, -
.

, , , ,
()
, ,
(
). , ,

,
.

( -
), ,
,
, ,
, .

-
( )
:
, , -
, , -

-
( , ).

: (epistemology)

( Cassirer, The Problem of Knowledge:

1
Philosophy, Science and History Since Hegel)

:
(Theory of Knowledge)
,
,
.. . [
(intuition), ,
,
Carnap].

: ( , -
) -
, -
.

: -
(Philosophy of
Science). -
, -

, -
,
,
,
..
-

,

.

. ,
, -
1940-60.
, (-
-). ,
,
.

Anti-spiritual
Pro-science Concerned with
Anti-mysticism distinguishing
Pro-reason
Anti-romanticism science from
Pro-logic non-science
Anti-nationalist

Knowledge Empricism Verifiability Theory of Meaning

Logical Positivism
Logical positivism is a combination of empiricism and rational thought that is not as strict
as empiricism. There are two key concepts within this discipline. These are Knowledge
Empiricism and Verifiabiliry of Meaning.

1920.
:

O -
,

Hilbert, Peano, Frege Russell.

,
. -

3
 Hobbes, Locke Hume.
O Hume, ,
, ,

(- )
( ).
-
(-
- )
. -
Comte (
, Mill, Spencer Durkheim) -

, , -
. ,

. ,
Comte,
-
.
Comte, -

(-
)
-
.

,
.

, -
,
.

,
,

4

. ,
,

.

1920 .

,
Moritz Schlick
, , ,
Rudolf Carnap, Herbert Feigl, Kurt Goedel, Hans Hahn, Karl Menger,
Otto Neurath Friedrich Waismann.

Hans Reichenbach, , ,
Walter Dubislav, Kurt Grelling Carl Hempel.
(Frank).
1930
Erkenntnis Carnap Reichenbach, -
.
,
Ludwig Wittgenstein Karl Popper
-
.

, -

-
Charles Morris, Ernest Nagel
Willard Van Orman Quine.

,
.

5

:

,
.
, -
, .

. , -
, -
.

, , ,

. ,
, ,
.
. , ,
, .
.

6
 , -
, -
.

- -- -
. , :

1. -
, ,

2.
, -
-
.

-
, .

Mach,

, ,

.
, ,
L. Wittgenstein . Russell.
-

,

. , ,
,

.

,
, ,

, ,

7
 , -
.
,
, ,
.
-
.

,

,

.

, , :

a
priori -
.

.
. -
, , , ,

, -
. ,

.

,
,
. -
, -

. ,

8

. -
.

-

, -
.
,
.. : 3 ,
36 C. , , -
: ,
quarks .

,
, -
.
. ,
-
,
, -
. -
.

, , ,
,
,
. -
,
. .. Einstein
Newton -
, .

. ..
Einstein Newton
-, -

9
 , -

.
-
. -
- ,

.

,
(Popper, Lakatos, Putnam),
(Kuhn, Feyerabend)
-
. ,

, -
.

, -
, Kuhn Feyerabend, --
, -
,

. , , -

. -
, Einstein
,
.
, -
, , , ,
, ..
12. , -
Thomas Kuhn
.

10
 -

, Ayer, Carnap, Shclick ..,
, . -
,
. -
,
,

. -
- . -
, ,
,
,
, -
.
. Ayer, -

, ,
. , -
,
.
, ,
, -
-
,
. -

, .
,

.
,

. -

11
, , , .. -
- -

.

-
-

.

, , -
, -
, -
.
- -

. -
. ,
, ,
,
.
-
, .
, , -
.
-
. -
.
-
,
.
,
- -, -
.
- -
, -
, ,

12
, . Popper

, .

,
. ,
.
.

,
: -
.
, -
-
, ,
.
, , ,


.
, -
. -
. Schlick
-


. ,
.
: -
, ,
.



,
.
,

13
 -

.
.

()
. ,
:
, . , -
,
,
-
. , ,
( , )
( -
) ,
,
. , -
( ,
)
( ) -

.

, .
,
-
. , -
60 ,


.

() -

14
 K. Popper, T. Kuhn, I. Lakatos, P. Feyerabend, N. R.
Hanson ..
- -
.

:

) .

, -
. ,
, -
,
-
. , ,

.

, , ,
-
.

: -

-
,



.
, -
- ,

, .
,
,
, , .

15


.

, -
- -
. --

,
. -
-
.

.

,
,
. -

-
.

, , -
.

, ---.
a priori
. -

, .
, ,
-
, . -
a priori . -
-
.
-

16

-
.
-,

. ,
,
. -
: -
,
.
,
.
.

) .

,

.
, , --
,
, , -
.

- -
.
, -
,
(, ,
).
( )
( )
a priori -
.
, , -
.

17
 -
-
, ,
-
. --

, ,
-
Dunhem-Quine (
.

-
, .

:

, ,
.
, , , , .

, ,
, -
:

, -
, ...

-
, ,
,
. -
. -


-
.

18
 . ,
,
,
, , - -
. , , -

( Kuhn). , ,

,


-
. , ,

. -

-
.

( ),
. -

,
- .
Karl Popper, 30, -
.
, Popper
.
, Popper
, -
.
Popper, , -
.
, , -

19
 ,
. , , ,
,
-
-
. , -
( ), Popper
( -
) () ().

,
,
, , -

. , Popper
, -
,
. , , -
, , -
. , Popper
.

- ( 1687)
1900. 1900-20 -
,
, ,
- -
.
-
.

,
.
-
.
, , , -

20
 . ,
, -
. -

/
. -

. - -

() -
-
.
, , ,
, -
, .
-
, -

.

. ,
, -
. -


-
. ,
. -
-
-
-
.
,
( -
), -
- .

21
)

,
. ,
-
.

,


-

.
-

, -

-
, .

, -
-
;
-
, -
. -

, .

,
-
-
.

, -
.
.

22
 Popper

Karl Popper
,
-
.

,

, Popper .
-
-
, Popper -
. ,
Popper, , -
. -
- , ,
,
. Popper, --
,
,
. ,
, ,
, -
. -
-
, .
Popper


. Popper --
. -

.

Popper -

23

(
) .
, Popper
, -
,
.
(Locke, Berkeley
Hume), -
, (, Leibniz
..) a
priori ,
. , Popper
(, , -) -
. ,
(1959,
1934) (1963).

Popper -
.
Popper,

David Hume.

David Hume

David Hume ( -
) -
.
-

.

Hume
, -
, -
. , , , ...

24
 ,
.
, ,
.
; -
,
, -

.

Hume, -

.

. -
,


.
.
( ),
. -
.

,
, -
.
, .
DNA
. . , -

.
.

.

Hume :
-

25
;
-.
() -
(). -
(), -
().

:
-
-
; Hume .
a priori ;

;
.
-
,
. ,
.
, Hume,
.

, -
, ,
. , -
, Hume ,
. -

. .
, .
, Hume,
.
. , -
-
. .
. .
.

26
 .
. -
,
. -
.

.
Hume
a priori
. -
:,
, -
,

.
Hume
, -
.
, -
.
Kant ()

(a priori) . -

, .

H Popper,
-

Popper
, Hume, . ( -
Hume - -
- ).

27
 Hume:
()
.

Popper
{( Hume) + post hoc ergo propter hoc (-
, )} -
.

Hume Popper

(
). .

Popper

, .
( -

). , -
,
.

-

:

28
 modus tollens

-
, Popper
-
.
.

Modus Tolens

If A, then B , .
Not B .

Therefore not A , .

:
-
. -

,
modus tollens ( ).

,
Karl Popper,
, , -
, ,
. , , -
, -
.
, ,
, ...
. , -

, ,
-
.
,

29

.

Popper - -
,
- -
. Popper
, , -
. ,
, -
- -

. Popper -

.

Popper
,
, -
.
,
.
,
-
.
,
, , .., ,
-
,
.
Popper, ,
, -
-- .
Popper
--
,
--.

30
 Popper --
,
,
-
, -
.
-
. -
-
-
(
).
-


.

.
.

, ,
.

.. -
,

-
,
.

Popper,
.
-
,
. , ,
- - -
. ,

31
 . Popper,
-
. -
,

, .
, , -
( )
,
,
.
(
), Popper (
), ()
(). ,
,
, ,
-
. , Popper,
,
(corroboration), -
. Popper,
-
.

, -
.

Popper, , :
) , -
, )
) .

. .

, : -
( , -

32
 ), ,
.

: -
, Popper -
-

.

33
 -
Lakatos

,
Kuhn , , Imre Lakatos Larry
Laudan. Lakatos Laudan
, Kuhn,
-
:
.

Lakatos

Imre Lakatos ( )

Karl Popper. Popper -
.
Popper
Lakatos Kuhn

-
.
Lakatos Popper,
. , Lakatos,
Duhem-Quine ,
.
,
Popper, Lakatos
Kuhn,
. Lakatos,
,
,
-
-

34
 .

Lakatos

Lakatos
, -
. -

-
.
-
.

-
()

()
. Lakatos
-
.

.

Lakatos -
-
.

.
, , -
, . ,
,
,
, -
.

Lakatos
. -

35
 -
, -
.
Lakatos, -
: Lakatos

, -

. Lakatos
-
,
,
-

(Hess 1997, . 28-29).

Lakatos, , -
-

. Kuhn,
, -

. , Lakatos,
(1970, . 93), -

, .

, ,
Lakatos
, -
.
, -
.
,
Lakatos, ,

,

36
 .

, Lakatos,

-
.

37
 Laudan

, Larry
Laudan -
, -
,

, Kuhn Lakatos. Laudan,
,
Popper Kuhn.
Laudan -
, .

, Laudan -
,

. Laudan -
,
.

, Laudan, -
,
.
, -
. ,
, , ,
-
.

-
. , , Laudan

.

Laudan

,

38
 -
,

. , Laudan,
, -
Kuhn. Lakatos.
Laudan,
:

-

: -
.

, , , -
.

( ) -
, (
) ,
, ( -
), (Laudan, 1977,
. 78-79).

Kuhn Lakatos, Laudan

-
. , Laudan
-

. Laudan
-

:

39

-
(Laudan, 1977, . 68).

, Laudan, -
,

.
,
.
Kuhn Lakatos, Laudan
. ,

-
.
-
-
.

, Laudan
-
.


(Laudan, 1977, .
202). -

. , -
,
(1977, . 202-203). , Laudan

(1977, . 202), -
.

(1984), Laudan
.
( ) -

40
 , -
. Laudan,
, -
,
. ,
,
, , , -
, -
(Laudan, 1984, . 5). Laudan
, Kuhn
.
Laudan
. ,
Laudan
(
Giere, 1988, . 44-45).

41
 H
(Kuhn Feyerabend)

Prescience

Paradigm Normal
Change Science

The Kuhn Cycle

Model Model
Revolution Drift

Model
Crisis

, Kuhn Feyerabend, -
,
- . -


.
,
,
,
- .

, -

,
. ,
,
-
. ,
,
,
.

42
 Kuhn

Thomas Kuhn
.
, Kuhn
,

. ,
, Popper
.

-
. -
Kuhn
, Paul Feyerabend, Russell Hanson,
Stephen Toulmin , , Imre Lakatos.
Kuhn
,
, , -
.

Kuhn -
-
, -

. -
,
,
. -
.
, -
. , -
,
,
, .

43

, .
, , , -
, , ,
, Kuhn,
.

, -
,
.
, -
,
.

, , .
, ( )
.
Kuhn Feyerabend
-
-
.
.
,
,
, -
, -
. , , ,
,
, ,
.

44
:

, , ,
,
.

Kuhn,
,

, :
, -
.
. , -
, -
.

Kuhn Feyerabend,
-
,
Einstein.
Kuhn,

Einstein, ,

. ,

, ,
, ..
, -
,
. ,
,

45
 , -
.
. -
: , ,
, ,
. , , ,
Einstein,
Dalton, -
,
,
.

, ,

, ,
, , ,
, -
. ,
,
,
. -

Feyerabend Feyerabend
. , , -
,
Einstein , Kuhn
, Feyerabend
. Feyerabend -
. , ,
,
.

Kuhn, , ,
( -
c)
-

46

. , Einstein
,
, .

Kuhn
. -
,
, . -
, Kuhn,

. -
Kuhn -
, .

Thomas Kuhn

.
Kuhn ,
,
: -
...

, -
, :
-
, - ,
-
. Kuhn

,
.

I. Hacking,
Kuhn
- . -
:

47
, : , ,
-
,
.
. -
.
.

, : -
,
. , ,
-
, ,
. -
, -
, -
Einstein, ,
, ,
Kuhn .

, , -
, -
,
.
-

. , -
.
, Kuhn, .
-
.
,
.

, ,
,
,

48
 . , -

,
.
, .
-
, , ,
, -
. Kuhn
.
,
, -
...

, ,
Kuhn Feyerabend,
,
- . -
,
, , -
. ,
Kuhn,
,
,

.

, , Kuhn
, - -
- ,
, . ,

. ,
. , , -
-

49
. ..
( ). -

. Lavoisier -
.
Maxwell -
, Einstein , ...

, ,


. -
, -
. -
,
, ,
. Kuhn , -
. R. Hanson, -
-
. , ,
- .

, Kuhn,

:

, -
[
] -
. ,
. -
, . -
, .
,

.

, ,

50
 -
.
.
.

, -
Kuhn:
- ,
, , -
-
/. ,
Kuhn .

, , Kuhn
.
, Objectivity, Value Judgement, and Theory Choice

, .

. , ,
, ,
,
. ,
, ,
.

, -

, , -
I. Hacking,
, Kuhn ,

-
. , Objectivity, Value Judgement, and
Theory Choice :

, -
,

51


, , -
,
,

. , , -

.

: -
Kuhn , -
Kuhn
,
, , -

, . , -
Kuhn -
.. ,
, .. ,
.

52
 Feyerabend

Feyerabend -

Feyerabend -
: .
Feyerabend
( -
)

-
. -
. ,

-
. Feyerabend
-
.

Feyerabend
{ : ( ,
) + Wittgenstein + (-
) = ( -
)}. , Feyerabend
-, ,
, (anything goes),
.

. Feyerabend -
, , , -
(.. ) ..

Feyerabend, -
, ,
-

53
 . , ,
Against Method
.
, , -
.
Against Method:

, [ -

] , , -
, . , ,
.

, ,
a priori .
.
, ,
,
, ,
.
, , Feyerabend,
. -
,
-
.

, , -
,

.

Feyerabend -
,
. -
.
,
.

54
 Feyerabend
,
, ,
, -
. , Against Method
Science in a Free Society, Feyerabend
,
J. S. Mill
On Liberty, Mill -
, , ,
.

Feyerabend
,
.

. ,
,
.. , , ,

,
. , , -
,
,
.
, , Science in a Free Society,


,
.

55
 :

: -
;
,
-

; -
.

-
,

,
-
. Carl Popper,
The Logic of Scientific Discovery, -
,
, ,
-
.

-
. -

, -
. ,
. ,
-
, . , Reichenbach
...
.

, -

56

. , -
Braithwhaite,

,
-
.

-
.

, -

:

,

,

.

, -
- -
. ,
,
. Braithwaite ,
:

,
,
.

.
.

. R. Hanson,
,
- , ,

57
 a prior ,

,
. , Hanson, -
,
. , ,
- -
.
:

,

,

.

, Hanson -
,
,
,
- - -
. , Hanson
-
. , ,
.
-

.

C. S. Peirce

Hanson, -
C. S. Peirce,

. Peirce
,
. -

58
 Peirce
-
,
, . -

,
,
, ,
(VII
).

Peirce
,
.
, -
-
. Peirce ,
, , -
.

C. S. Peirce

C. S. Peirce, -
.
Peirce, , -
,

. -
:
, ,
:

. . . ,,
, . . .

, , -
Peirce,
-

59

. ,
, 1867,

.
.

,
,
. , -
-
.

... ,
...
( ) -
...

;
Peirce ,
, :

, ,
.

, ,
.

, , ,
, ,
,
,
.

Hanson
-
. ,
:

60
 . . . , -
,
. . .

, Peirce,
-
.

. . . ,
,
. . .

, , -
.
Peirce ,
Popper :

. . . , -
. . .

.
Hanson,

. -
Peirce,

:

.... ,
[
] .....

Peirce , -

. , -
, .

61
C. S. Peirce,

:
; -

,
;
Peirce -

,
,
.
, .
,
, , -
.

Peirce
:

... , -
...

Peirce , , , -
, . -

, , -
. , ,
. .
-
:

il lumen naturale -
. Kepler, Gilbert Harvey - -
- -
,
,
.

62
 Peirce -
Einstein :

-
, -
.
, ,
, .

, Peirce,
.

(1.46).
-
.
-
,
.
,
. , -

, Peirce,
, -
: ,
, , .
, Peirce


:

,


.
.

63
 Popper

Popper -
Peirce

.
Peirce , ,
, Popper
. -
, , Popper, -
-
. ,
Popper ,
Bergson.
, ,
. Popper
Einstein
:

-
, -
.
, ,
, .

Popper -
,
-
. Novalis
Popper :
: (Hypotheses are
nets: only he who casts will catch).

. Popper

Popper - ,

64
 . ,
Popper, , -
Einstein -
, ,
.
, Einstein
,
Popper.

, ,
-
.

-
, ,
.. ,
. 20
Einstein
.
, ,

. , -
,
Einstein. , ,
, .
,
.
:
, -
; Popper
.
-
.

-
. Popper -
, ,

65
 , , ,
. -
: ,
, ,
-
. , ,
, -
,
(verisimilitude), -

/. , ,
, , -

. ,
, . , -


.
. Popper


.

, -
, , -
,
, Popper,
-
. ,
,
, .
, , -
,
, .

66


, , , :
... , 1993

- , , , ,
.

, , ,
: , 1991

, , ,
, , 1997

Bertrand Russell, , -
: . , (: I. . ),
. 699-700.

Chalmers, A.F, ;
, 2000.

Comte, the Positive Philosophy of Auguste Comte, London 1913

Lakatos, Imre, ;;History of science and its Rational Reconstructions.

Laudan, Larry, A Confutation of Convergent Realism.

Quine, Two Dogmas of Empiricism.

Karl Popper, The Logic of Scientific Discovery (Hutchinson, 1972,

1 . 1959), . 31.

. , Is there a
Logic of Scientific Discovery, , Historical Types of Rationality.
Proceedings of the First Greek-Soviet Symposium on Science
and Society. Athens, October 23-26 1992. National Technical
University of Athens, . 239-50.

Hans Reichenbach, Experience and Prediction (University of

Chicago Press, 1983), . 383.

67
R. . Braithwaite, Scientific Explanation (Cambridge University
Press, 1986, 1 . 1953), . 122.

, . 12.

. . R. Hanson, Is there a Logic of Scientific Discovery?, H.

Feigl G. Maxwell (eds.) Current Issues in the Philosophy of Science
(Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1961), . 20-25, . 28.

R. . Braithwaite, . ., . 20-22.

. R. Hanson, . ., . 31.

. R. Hanson, Patterns of Discovery (Cambridge University Press,

1958, 2 . 1972), . 90.

. .

,
Charles S. Peirce, Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce. Vols.
1-6. (ed. C. Hartshorne and P. Weiss. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard
University Press, 1931), Vols. 7-8. (ed. A. Burks. Cambridge, Mass.:
Harvard University Press, 1958). , , -
5.363, 5 363
.

. R. Hanson, Patterns of Discovery, . ., . 87.

Albert Einsten, Principles of Research (1918), Einstein, Ideas

and Opinions (Bonanza books, 1954), . 226.

Hanson, . . . , Alan Musgrave, Deductive Heuristics

K. Gavroglou et. al. (eds.), Imre Lakatos and Theories of
Scientific Change (Kluwer, 1989) 15-32.

Karl Popper, Objective Knowledge, 1972, . 19.

, . 70.

68