Name Date

Problem-Solution Essay Writing Workshop

Rubric for Evaluation
Ideas and Content Weak Average Strong
1. Clearly states a problem and explains its significance
2. Explores all aspects of a problem, including its
causes and effects
3. Offers one or more reasonable solutions to the
problem
4. Uses anecdotes, examples, facts, or statistics to
support the proposed solutions
5. Explains how to put the solutions into effect

Structure and Form

6. Uses logical reasoning to persuade the audience
7. Concludes by summing up the proposal

Grammar, Usage, and Mechanics

CHAPTER 23

8. Contains no more than two or three minor errors in

spelling, capitalization, and punctuation
9. Contains no more than two or three minor errors in
grammar and usage

Writing Progress to Date (Writing Portfolio)

The strongest aspect of this writing is __________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________________________________

The final version shows improvement over the rough draft in this way:______________________
Copyright McDougal Littell Inc.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________

A specific improvement over past assignments in your portfolio is__________________________

_____________________________________________________________________________________________

A skill to work on in future assignments is______________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________________________________

Additional comments: ________________________________________________________________

_____________________________________________________________________________________________

94 WRITING AND COMMUNICATION MASTERS For use with Pupils Edition pp. 446451