....................................................................................................................................................

5
..............................................................................................................................5
................................................................................................5
.........................................................................................................................6
...........................................................................................................................................6
.............................................................................................................6
.....................................................................................................................7
.....................................................................................................................9
.................................................................................................................9
................................................................................................9
..................................................................................11
.............................................................................................................................13
.......................................................................................................14
........................................................................................................14
....................................................................................................................14
................................................................................................................16
....................................................................................................................16
.............................................................................................................................18
............................................................................................................18
............................................................................................................18
............................................................................................................20
............................................................................................................20
1520 ...................................................20
....................................................................................................................21
....................................................................................................................23
.............................................................................................................................24
...................................................................................24
...............................................................................................24
.......................................................................................................25
.....................................................................................................................25
.....................................................................................................................25
.................................................................................................25
.........................................................................................................25
.............................................................................................................26
.......................................................................................................26
............................................................................................................27
....................................................................................................................27
.......................................................................................................27
........................................................................................................27
...........................................................................................28
...........................................................................................29
....................................................................................................................30
..................................................................................................31
........................................................................................................31

1
 ....................................................................................................................33
...............................................................................................33
.......................................................................................................................34
.............................................................................................................................34
........................................................................................................34
.............................................................................................................................35
....................................................................................................................35
........................................................................................................................38
............................................................................................................38
............................................................................................................38
...................................................................................................................38
........................................................................................................................39
........................................................................................................39
..........................................................................................39
.......................................................................................41
...................................................................................................43
....................................................................................................................43
....................................................................................................................43

1
2
3

2
3
4

2
3

2
4

1
2
3
4

1
2
3
4

1520
1
2

1
2

1
2

1
2
3
4
5

10

1
2

3
4

4

5

1
234
5

(1)
23
4

law as it ought to be

law as it is
actual law

Natural Law

Positive Law

1
2

6
34

12
3

12
34

1
2

12

12
3
4

()

()

(
)

()

()

(1)
(2)

9
(3)()

()

(1)
(2)

()

()()

()
(
)

10
()

()

()

2
3
4

11
(1)

(2)

(3)

(4)

(5)

(1)

(2)

(3)

12


20

20

13


14


31

()

()

86

15
(1)

(2)

(3)

----
----

1
2

3
4

16


11
14

17


1
2
3

18
4

12

1
2
3

19

1

21

32

1
12

2
1
2

20
15 20

1
2
AB
382

123

12

1
1997 38238393

21
2
10 273 1997 228

3 2001 74

4
1
2
3
4

12

45

175

22


the prima facie character

23
weight

1
2

subsumptionbalancing

24


25


1
2
3

26


1
2
3

1
2

27


----

----

----

----

19

28


----

----

29


1
2 3

(1) (2)

(3)

(1)
(2)
(3)

30


31


1
2

5
1

32

4
5

33


34
3

126

35


1
2
3

36


2
----

----

----

37


1
2
3
4

S T
R T S
R
TR T R
S=T T
SR S T R

A B
a1a2an b

38
A a1a2anb
B a1a2an

B b

1
2

3
4
5

39


40


----

67 1

----

41

1

1
2
3
4

23

3
4

----

1993 3 3

42
3

----

1
2
3
4 43

43


44